• Non ci sono risultati.

Social capital dynamics and collective action: the role of subjective satisfaction in a common pool resource experiment

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Condividi "Social capital dynamics and collective action: the role of subjective satisfaction in a common pool resource experiment"

Copied!
36
0
0

Testo completo

(1)

29 July 2021

AperTO - Archivio Istituzionale Open Access dell'Università di Torino

Original Citation:

Social capital dynamics and collective action: the role of subjective satisfaction in a common pool resource experiment

Published version:

DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S1355770X15000340

Terms of use:

Open Access

(Article begins on next page)

Anyone can freely access the full text of works made available as "Open Access". Works made available under a Creative Commons license can be used according to the terms and conditions of said license. Use of all other works requires consent of the right holder (author or publisher) if not exempted from copyright protection by the applicable law.

Availability:

This is the author's manuscript

(2)

Social capital dynamics and

collective action: the role of

subjective satisfaction

Working papers

Leonardo Becchetti

Stefano Castriota

Pierluigi Conzo

N.29 June 2011

(3)

!"

!"#$%&'#%($)%&'*+,%-$#.'%,*'#"&&/#)$0/'%#)$",1'

)2/'3"&/'"4'.567/#)$0/'.%)$.4%#)$",8'

'

!"#$%&'#()"**+",,-.(/$-0"&1-,2('-(3#4%(5#&(6"&7%,%( 8,"9%$#(:%1,&-#,%.(/$-0"&1-,2('-(;"&<7-%( ;-"&=<-7-(:#$>#.(/$-0"&1-,2('-(3#4%(5#&(6"&7%,%(?(@A@B( ! "#$!%&''! ( 96.)3%#)'

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

' '

:/+;"3*.Q( ,&<1,( 7%4"1.( G<F=-*( 7##'( 7%4"1.( &%$'#4->"'( "RG"&-4"$,.( 1#*-%=( *%G-,%=.( 1<FP"*,-0"(C"==F"-$7H(

<=>',5-6/3.Q(OMN.(:ST.(UMTH(

?",)%#).1' !"#$%&'#( )"**+",,-.( F"**+",,-V"*#$#4-%H<$-&#4%NH-,W( 8,"9%$#( :%1,&-#,%.(

1,"9%$#H*%1,&-#,%V<$-G7H-,W(;-"&=<-7-(:#$>#.(G-"&=<-7-H*#$>#V<$-&#4%NH-,H( '

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

(4)

#"

@A B,)3"*5#)$",'

5+"&"( -1( C-'"1G&"%'( *#$1"$1<1( -$( ,+"( =-,"&%,<&"( %F#<,( ,+"( &#="( %$'( -4G#&,%$*"( #9(

"*#$#4-*( &"=%,-#$1+-G1( #**<&( -$( %( 9&%4"C#&E( #9( %1I44",&-*( -$9#&4%,-#$( %$'( -$*#4G=","( *#$,&%*,1( %$'( %&"( 4%'"( FI( 1"_<"$,-%=( 4#0"1( -$( C+-*+( -$0"1,#&1( 4%E"( ( %$'( K&"-7.(N``a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

)%1"'( #$( C+%,( *#$1-'"&"'( %F#0"( C"( 9#*<1( #$( 1,<'I-$7( ,+"( =%C( #9( 4#,-#$( #9( 1#*-%=( *%G-,%=(-$(,+"(^%-&#F-(1=<4(#9(b-F"&%.(%(G%&,-*<=%&=I(&"="0%$,(*#$,"R,(,#(&<$(,&<1,(%$'( G<F=-*( 7##'( 7%4"1( 7-0"$( ,+"( "R,&"4"( =#*%=( 1*%&*-,I( #9( 1#*-%=( *%G-,%=H( 8<*+( 1*%&*-,I( -1(

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

M( A$( ,+"-&( 1,<'I( #$( ,+"( &#="( #9( 1#*-%=( *%G-,%=( #$( 9-$%$*-%=( '"0"=#G4"$,( K<-1#.( 8%G-"$>%( %$'( U-$7%="1(

JN``cL(G&#0-'"(%$("R*"=="$,("R%4G="(C+"$(&"G#&,-$7(,+%,(Z"C-1+('-%4#$'(4"&*+%$,1(-$(^"C(d#&E(1%0"( %==I(,+"-&("*#$#4-*(,&%$1%*,-#$1H(5+"(G#C"&( '%4%7"(+-1(&"G<,%,-#$(%$'("R*=<'"(+-4(9&#4(9<,<&"(,&%$1%*,-#$1H(

N(5+"(G#1-,-0"("99"*,(#9(,+"(="0"=(#9(,&<1,(#$("*#$#4-*(7&#C,+(%$'(-$1,-,<,-#$1(+%1(F""$('#*<4"$,"'(FI(%(

$<4F"&(#9(1,<'-"1(J1""(%4#$7(#,+"&1.(b$%*E( %$'( b""9"&.(MSSe(%$'(U%E( %$'(b$%*E.(N``M(#$(,+"(9-&1,( G#-$,(%$'(;<,$%4.(MSST(%$'(!%(;#&,%(",(%=H.(MSSe(#$(,+"(1"*#$'LH(5&<1,(%$'(,&<1,C#&,+-$"11(+%0"(F""$( 1+#C$(,#(-4G%*,(G#1-,-0"=I(#$(9-&4(G&#'<*,-0-,I(JB<=="$E%4G(%$'(:+%4-.(N``NLH(5+"(=%*E(#9(,&<1,(%$'( ,&<1,C#&,+-$"11( G&"0"$,1( ,+"( '"0"=#G4"$,( #9( "*#$#4-*( &"=%,-#$1+-G1( %4#$7( -$'-0-'<%=1( F"=#$7-$7( ,#( '-99"&"$,(",+$-*(7&#<G1(%$'(-1(,+"&"9#&"(#$"(#9(,+"(4-*&#"*#$#4-*(*%<1"1(#9(G##&("*#$#4-*(G"&9#&4%$*"( J1"".(%4#$7(#,+"&1.(\="1-$%.()%_-&(%$'(@%1,"&=I.(MSSSW(K&%'1,"-$(%$'(Z<1,4%$.(N``NW(K&%'1,"-$.(N``T( %$'([#$,%=0#(%$'(3"I$%=Df<"&#=.(N``g%(%$'(N``gFLH(O$(,+"(G#1-,-0"(1-'"(4-*&#9-$%$*"(4"4F"&1+-G(%1( %( 1-7$%=( #9( ,&<1,C#&,+-$"11( 4%I( *&"%,"( %( 0-&,<#<1( *-&*="( F",C""$( 1#*-%=( *%G-,%=( %$'( "*#$#4-*( G"&9#&4%$*"(9#&(F#&&#C"&1(J)"**+",,-(%$'(:#$>#.(N`M`LH(

(5)

$"

*#$9-&4"'( FI( &"*"$,( "4G-&-*%=( 9-$'-$71H( :%11%&( %$'( YI'-*E( JN`M`L( 1+#C( -$( %( 4-*&#9-$%$*"(7%4"(*%&&-"'(#$(-$(=#C(-$*#4"(%&"%1(#9(9-0"('-99"&"$,(*#<$,&-"1(J\&4"$-%.( ;+-=-GG-$"1.(A$'-%.(b"$I%(%$'(K<%,"4%=%L(,+%,(,+"(="0"=1(#9(*#$,&-F<,-#$(%&"(=#C"1,(-$( ,+"(\9&-*%$(*#<$,&I(%$'.(4#&"(1G"*-9-*%==I.(-$(^%-&#F-(1=<41H()#+$",(%$'(K&"-7(JN``SL( 9-$'(1-4-=%&(&"1<=,1(-$(%(#$"(1+#,(,&<1,(7%4"TH(

5+"($#0"=,I(#9(#<&("RG"&-4"$,(-1(-$(,+"(-$0"1,-7%,-#$(#9(,+"('I$%4-*1(#9(1#*-%=(*%G-,%=( FI( "0%=<%,-$7( +#C( G<F=-*( 7##'( 7%4"D=-E"(%*,-0-,-"1( %99"*,( *+%$7"1( -$(,&<1,C#&,+-$"11( %4#$7(G=%I"&1(-$(,&<1,(7%4"1H(5

C+-*+( ,+"( -$,&#'<*,-#$( #9( %( 4#'-9-"'( ;<F=-*( K##'1( K%4"( J+"&"#$( ;KKL( ,&"%,4"$,( F",C""$( ,C#( ,&<1,( 7%4"( J+"&"#$( 5KL( &#<$'1( -1( 4"%$,( ,#( %$%=I1"( ,+"( "99"*,1( #9( ,+"( *#44<$-,I( G&#0-1-#$( #9( =#*%=( G<F=-*( 7##'1.( %( ,IG-*%=( G+"$#4"$#$( -$( 1#*-#"*#$#4-*( "$0-&#$4"$,1(#9('"0"=#G-$7(*#<$,&-"1(=-E"(b"$I%.(#$(,&<1,(%$'(,&<1,C#&,+-$"11H(]<"(,#( ,+"(1*%&*-,I(#9(7#0"&$4"$,(&"1#<&*"1(,+"(G&%*,-*"(#9((#)#*+,,(

8C%+-=-L.( ,+%,( -1.( ,+"( =#*%=( *##G"&%,-#$( 9#&( ,+"( &"%=-1%,-#$( #9( 14%==( -$9&%1,&<*,<&"1( -$( ,+"( 1=<41.( -1( %( C"==( E$#C$( 9"%,<&"( -$( ^%-&#F-H( A$( ,+-1( =%&7"( *-,I( *#44<$-,I( 9<$'&%-1-$7(%$'(7&%,<-,#<1("99#&,(G&#0-'"(9<$'%4"$,%=(1<GG#&,(,#(F<-='(1*+##=.(*=-$-*1.( C%,"&(1G#<,1(J)#+$",(%$'(K&"-7.(N``SL.c(-$9&%1,&<*,<&"1(=-E"(&#%'1.(F&-'7"1.(1I1,"41(,#( 7"$"&%,"(%$'(*%&&I("="*,&-*-,I(%$'(*+<&*+"1(JY-=1#$.(MSSNLgH(A$(,+-1(&"1G"*,(C"(C#$'"&( C+",+"&(%$'(<$'"&(C+%,(*-&*<41,%$*"1(,+-1(G&%*,-*"(J%$'.(4#&"(-$(7"$"&%=.(%*,-0-,-"1(

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

T( 5+"( &"%1#$1( %&"( F#,+( 1,&<*,<&%=( %$'( &"=%,"'( ,#( 1G"*-9-*( &"*"$,( +-1,#&-*%=( "0"$,1( J,+"( *-0-=( <$&"1,(

9#==#C-$7( ,+"( ]"*"4F"&( N``e( "="*,-#$1LH( \4#$7( 1,&<*,<&%=( "="4"$,1( ,C#( 4%-$( 9%*,#&1( %&"( ,+"( +<7"( '"4#7&%G+-*(G&"11<&"(9&#4(,+"(&<&%=(%&"%1(%$'(,+"(*-&*<=%&(4-7&%,-#$(G%,,"&$1(C+-*+(C"%E"$(,+"(,-"1( %4#$7(1=<4('C"=="&1H(\1('#*<4"$,"'(FI()"7<I.()#*_<-"&(%$'(U<=<(JN`M`L.(,+"(4%P#&-,I(#9(^%-&#F-(1=<4( 'C"=="&1(1G"$'(#$(%0"&%7"(="11(,+%$(T(I"%&1(-$(,+"(%&"%(%$'(%(_<%&,"&(#9(,+"4(1,%I(9#&(="11(,+%$(,C"=0"( 4#$,+1H(

c(B<$'(&%-1-$7(9#&(*#44<$-,I(G&#P"*,1(*%$(F"("-,+"&(G&-0%,"(#&(G<F=-*H(;&-0%,"((#)#*+,,-(,IG-*%==I(&%-1"(

9<$'1( 9&#4( 9%4-=I( %$'( 9&-"$'1( 9#&( 9<$"&%=1( %$'( C"''-$71.( *#=="7"( 9""1( %$'( 4"'-*%=( F-==1H( ;<F=-*(

(#)#*+,,-.( -$1,"%'.( &%-1"( 9<$'1( 9#&( '"0"=#G4"$,( G&#P"*,1( #9( *#44#$( -$,"&"1,( 1<*+( %1( 1*+##=1.( +"%=,+(

*"$,&"1(%$'(C%,"&(G&#P"*,1H((

g(B#&(%$(%$%=I1-1(#9((#)#*+,,(%*,-0-,-"1(*%&&-"'(#$(-$(b"$I%(F",C""$(MSa`(%$'(MSSS(1""(5&%$1G%&"$*I(

(6)

%"

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

5+"( 1G"*-9-*( +IG#,+"1-1( ,"1,"'( -$( #<&( "RG"&-4"$,( -1( ,+"( -4G#&,%$*"( #9( 1<FP"*,-0"( 1%,-19%*,-#$( 0-1D2D0-1( 1,%$'%&'( #FP"*,-0"( 4"%1<&"1( #9( ;KK( 'I$%4-*1( -$( G&#'<*-$7( *+%$7"1(-$(1#*-%=(*%G-,%=Hh(

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

3#<7+=I(1G"%E-$7.(,+"(1%4"(F%1E",(C-,+(,C#(%GG="1(J#&.(-$(#<&(*%1".(,+"(1%4"(#FP"*,-0"( G%I#991(-$(,+"(;KK(7%4"L(4%I(*#&&"1G#$'(,#(*#4G=","=I('-99"&"$,(="0"=1(#9(1%,-19%*,-#$( 9#&( ,+"( -$'-0-'<%=1( C+#( "$P#I( ,+"4H( 8<*+( '-99"&"$*"( 4%I( F"( '","&4-$"'( FI( ,+"(

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

h( 5+"( =-,"&%,<&"( #$( '","&4-$%$,1( #9( =-9"( 1%,-19%*,-#$( +%1( F##4"'( -$( &"*"$,( I"%&1( 9#&( 1"0"&%=( &"%1#$1H(

B-&1,.(-,(+"=G"'("*#$#4-1,1(,#(-$0"1,-7%,"(%,(%77&"7%,"(="0"=(C+I(1<FP"*,-0"(C"==F"-$7('#"1($#,( %=C%I1( *#-$*-'"(C-,+(1,%$'%&'(#FP"*,-0"(4"%1<&"1(%$'.(%,(4-*&#(="0"=.(,#(-'"$,-9I($#$(#FP"*,-0"(9%*,#&1(%99"*,-$7( <,-=-,I(F"I#$'(1,%$'%&'(#FP"*,-0"(4"%1<&"1H((B-$%==I.(=-9"(1%,-19%*,-#$("1,-4%,"1( C-,+(,+"(*#4G"$1%,-$7( 1<&G=<1( %GG&#%*+(G&#0-'"'(&"="0%$,(*#$,&-F<,-#$1(#$(,+"( 4"%1<&"(#9(,+"( 1+%'#C(0%=<"(#9($#$(4%&E",( 7##'1(J9#&(%(1<&0"I(1"".(%4#$7(#,+"&1.(B&"I(%$'(8,<,>"&.(N``N(%$'(N`M`W(:=%&E(",(%=H.(N``hLH(

(7)

&"

*%G%*-,I(#9(,+"(#FP"*,-0"(#<,*#4"(,#(1%,-19Ii$#,(1%,-19I(*#4G="R(G1I*+#=#7-*%=("="4"$,1( #9( -$'-0-'<%=( G&"9"&"$*"1( JG#1-,-#$%=( *#4G",-,-#$.( #,+"&D&"7%&'-$7( G&"9"&"$*"1.( *#$9#&4-,I.(1"%&*+(9#&("R*=<1-0-,I.(E-$'$"11.(",*HL.(+","&#7"$"#<1(7#%=1(%$'(4#,-0%,-#$1( #9( ,+"( %*,-#$.( -,1( '"0"=#G4"$,( %$'( *-&*<41,%$*"1.( G"&*"-0"'( -$,"$,-#$%=-,I( F"I#$'( #,+"&(G"#G="('"*-1-#$1.e(,+"(7%G(F",C""$("RG"*,%,-#$1(%$'(&"%=->%,-#$1(#&(,+"(_<%=-,I(#9( ,+"( &"=%,-#$1+-G1( %4#$7( G"#G="H( [%&E",-$7( 4%$%7"&1( %&"( C"==( %C%&"( ,+%,( ,+"1"( $#$( #FP"*,-0"( 9%*,#&1( %&"( *&<*-%=( 9#&( G&"'-*,-$7( G%,,"&$1( #9( 1<F1"_<"$,( #FP"*,-0"( F"+%0-#&( %$'(,+"I(<1"(*#$1<4"&(1%,-19%*,-#$(1<&0"I1(%1(%(4%-$(-$1,&<4"$,(#9(-$_<-&I.(,#7",+"&( C-,+(%$%=I1-1(#9(#FP"*,-0"("0-'"$*"(#$(%*,<%=(*#$1<4G,-#$(G%,,"&$1H(

B&#4( C+%,( *#$1-'"&"'( %F#0"( C"( <$'"&1,%$'( ,+%,( 4%$I( 9%*,#&1( 4%I( %99"*,( ,+"( 7%G( F",C""$( #FP"*,-0"( #<,*#4"( %$'( 1<FP"*,-0"( 1%,-19%*,-#$H( 5+"( "%1-"1,( %$'( 4#1,( G%&1-4#$-#<1( C%I( ,#(,%E"( ,+"4( -$,#( %**#<$,( -$(#<&( "RG"&-4"$,( -1(FI( %1E-$7( '-&"*,=I(

4%,,"&1(0-1D2D0-1(#FP"*,-0"(*+%&%*,"&-1,-*1(-$(,+"(1"*#$'(,&<1,(7%4"H(

8-$*"( %( 1<FP"*,-0"( "0%=<%,-#$( #9( ,+"( "RG"&-4"$,( ,&"%,4"$,( 1<*+( %1( ;KK( 1%,-19%*,-#$( *%$$#,( #F0-#<1=I( F"( &%$'#4->"'( "R( %$,".( -,( 4%I( F"( %&7<"'( ,+%,( %( ,+-&'( '&-0"&( 4%I( %99"*,(,+"(#F1"&0"'(*#&&"=%,-#$(F",C""$(1%,-19%*,-#$(-,1"=9(%$'(*+%$7"1(-$(1#*-%=(*%G-,%=H( B#&(,+-1(&"%1#$(-$(#<&("RG"&-4"$,(C"(*#$,&#=(9#&( "$'#7"$"-,I(FIQ(J-L(&%$'#4->-$7("RD %$,"( ,+"( G%&,-*-G%,-#$( ,#( ,+"( ;KKi$#( ;KK( ,&"%,4"$,W( J--L( =##E-$7( %,( *+%$7"1( -$( ,&<1,C#&,+-$"11(F",C""$(,+"(,C#(5K(&#<$'1.(,+%,(-1.(FI("=-4-$%,-$7(,+"("99"*,(#9(,-4"( -$0%&-%$,(-'-#1I$*&%,-*(*#4G#$"$,1(FI(<1"(#9(9-&1,('-99"&"$*"1W(J---L(*#$,&#==-$7("RDG#1,(

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

e(

*+#-*"( F<,( %=1#( #$( ,+"( 1",( #9( ,+"( '-1*%&'"'( %=,"&$%,-0"1H( 3"*"$,( "4G-&-*%=( 9-$'-$71( +%0"( 1+#C$( 9#&( -$1,%$*"( -$( 7-9,( "R*+%$7"( 4#'"=1( ,+%,( ,+"( 1%4"( %4#<$,( &"*"-0"'( *%$( ,&-77"&( 4#&"( &"*-G&#*-,I( -$( &"1G#$1"( C+"$( ,+"( &"*"-0"&( E$#C1( ,+%,( ,+"( 1"$'"&( '-'( -,( C-,+#<,( E$#C-$7( ,+"( "R-1,"$*"( #9( %( 1"*#$'( &#<$'(J8,%$*%.(N``aL(H(

(8)

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a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

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

a5+"( _<%=-9I-$7( '-99"&"$*"( F",C""$( %=,"&$%,-0"( -$,"&G&",%,-#$( #9( #<&( 9-$'-$71( J-$( G&"1"$*"( #&( $#,( #9(

"$'#7"$"-,IL(-1(,+%,.(-9(,+"(#F1"&0"'(1-7$-9-*%$,(*+%$7"(-$(1#*-%=(*%G-,%=(-1(G&#'<*"'(FI(,+"(;KK(7%4".( 1-,<%,-#$1( #9( ,+%,( E-$'( 1-7$-9-*%$,=I( %99"*,( ,+"( *&"%,-#$( #9( 1#*-%=( *%G-,%=( 9#&( ,+"( 1G"*-%=( ,IG"1( #9( J4#&"( 1%,-19-"'L(-$'-0-'<%=1(-'"$,-9-"'(-$(,+"("RG"&-4"$,H(A9.(#$(,+"(*#$,&%&I.(,+"(#F1"&0"'(9-$'-$7('"G"$'1(#$( <$#F1"&0%F="("RD%$,"(-$0%&-%$,(*#4G#$"$,1(J"$'#7"$"-,IL.("R,&%*,-#$(#9(1%,-19%*,-#$(-1(9<$'%4"$,%=(,#( -'"$,-9I(%$'(1"="*,(4#&"(*##G"&%,-0"(1<FP"*,1H((

(9)

("

\$( -$,"&"1,-$7( %GG=-*%,-#$( #9( #<&( &"1<=,1( -1( -$( ,+"( 4%$%7"4"$,( #9( *#44#$( G##=( &"1#<&*"1H(\**#&'-$7(,#("1,%F=-1+"'(,+"#&",-*%=(%$'("4G-&-*%=("0-'"$*"(JO1,&#4.(MSS`( %$'( N```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

IA'=J(/3$-/,)%&'*/.$K,'

@RG"&-4"$,1( C"&"( *#$'<*,"'( -$( Z<=ID\<7<1,( N`M`( -$( b-F"&%( J^%-&#F-.( b"$I%L.( ,+"( 1"*#$'(F-77"1,(1=<4(-$(,+"(C#&='H(B#&(,+-1(G&#P"*,(C"(*&"%,"'(%(1%4G="(#9(c`c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``( -$'-0-'<%=1( G%&,-*-G%,"( #$=I( ,#( ,+"( ,C#( ,&<1,( 7%4"1( C-,+#<,( F"-$7( -$0#=0"'( -$(

(10)

)"

C%I(C

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

&"=%,-#$1+-G1(C-,+(1#4"(G=%I"&1H(( ;=%I"&1(-7$#&"'(F#,+(,+"(1"_<"$*"(#9(,+"(7%4"1(%$'(,+"(G%I#991(#9(,+"(9-&1,(,&<1,(7%4"( JF<,( $#,( ,+%,( #9( ,+"( ;KKL( <$,-=( ,+"( "$'( #9( ,+"( C+#="( "RG"&-4"$,%=( 1"11-#$H( 5+"( 9#==#C-$7(1<F1"*,-#$1("RG=%-$(,+"(7%4"1(-$('",%-=H( ! =>'!!7)2-8!9#*,! O<&(,&<1,(7%4"1(%&"(1,%$'%&'(,C#DG=%I"&(-$0"1,4"$,(7%4"1(J1""()"&7.(]-*E+%<,(%$'( [*:%F".( MSSgL( C+"&"( G=%I"&1( %&"( 4%,*+"'( C-,+( %( *#<$,"&G%&,( #9( <$E$#C$( -'"$,-,IH( ;"#G="(1"="*,"'(,#(F"(,&<1,#&1(&"*"-0"(g`(b"$I%$(1+-==-$71(%,(,+"(F"7-$$-$7(#9("%*+(5K( %$'(+%0"(,#('"*-'"(+#C(4<*+(,#(7-0"(,#(,+"(*#<$,"&G%&,(J,&<1,""L.(E$#C-$7(,+%,(,+-1( 0%=<"(7",1(,&-G="'H(5+#1"(1"="*,"'(,#(F"(,+"(,&<1,""1(&"*"-0"(%$(-$-,-%=("$'#C4"$,(#9(g`( b1+(C"==(%$'(+%0"(,#('"*-'"("RD%$,".(C-,+#<,(E$#C-$7(,+"(%4#<$,(1"$,(FI(,+"(,&<1,#&.( +#C( 4<

(11)

*" #0"&%==(&"1G#$1"(1,&%,"7IHS(@RDG#1,(1<&G&-1"(_<"1,-#$1( *%G,<&"(,+"(1#D*%=="'(9-&1,(%$'(1"*#$'(#&'"&(F"=-"91(J&"1G"*,-0"=I(BO)1(%$'(8O)1LH(( ( =>%!!;2+3.<!4550!4#*,! Y"(&"=I(#$(%(4#'-9-"'(0"&1-#$(#9(,+"(G<F=-*(7##'(7%4"M`(C+"&"(G=%I"&1(9%*"(%(,&%'"D#99( F",C""$( -$'-0-'<%=( %$'( *#=="*,-0"( F"$"9-,1H( 5+-1( 0%&-%$,( -1( <1<%==I( &"9"&&"'( ,#( %1( ?5**5/@;553!A,-52)<,!4#*,MMH(

Y"(&%$'#4=I(*#4G#1"(eh(7&#<G1(#9(9#<&(G"#G="("%*+(JT`c(G"#G="(-$(,#,%=L(C+#(1-,(-$(%( *-&*="(%&#<$'(%(G-="(#9(h``(b8+(

%&"( %==#C"'( ,#( C-,+'&%C( %$I( %4#<$,( F",C""$( >"&#( %$'( Mg`( b8+( 9&#4( ,+"( G-="( %$'( E""G( -,.( ,+"( %4#<$,( ="9,( F"-$7( '#<F="'( %$'( '-0-'"'( "_<%==I( %4#$7( ,+"( 9#<&( G%&,-*-G%$,1H(A$(#&'"&(,#(&"G=-*%,"(%(1-4<=,%$"#<1(1",,-$7("%*+(G=%I"&(C&-,"1('#C$(#$(%( 1+"",( +#C( 4%$I( b8+( +"i1+"( C%$,1( ,#( C-,+'&%CH( 5+"$.( "RG"&-4"$,"&1( 4%E"( ,+"( *%=*<=%,-#$1(%$'(C&-,"('#C$(,+"(-$'-0-'<%=(G%I#991Q(,+%,(-1.(,+"(1<4(#9(,+"(C-,+'&%C$( %4#<$,(%$'(#$"(9#<&,+(#9(,+"(*#44#$(*%G-,%=(J,+"(4#$"I(="9,(FI(%==(G=%I"&1(4<=,-G=-"'( FI(,C#LMNH(5+"(;KK(-1(&"G"%,"'(9-0"(,-4"1(F<,(,+"($<4F"&(#9(&#<$'1(-1(E$#C$(#$=I(,#( """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" S(O$(G&#1(%$'(*#$1(%F#<,(<1-$7(,+"(1,&%,"7I(4",+#'(0-1D2D0-1(%*,<%=(*+#-*"1(1"".(%4#$7(#,+"&1.()&%$',1( %$'(:+%&$"11(JN```LW(:%1#$(%$'([<-(JMSSaL(%$'((:%1%&-(%$'(:%1#$(JN``SLH( M`:%4"&"&(%$'(B"+&(JN``TL(1<44%&->"(1#4"(1,I=->"'(9%*,1Q(-$(#$"DG"&-#'(;KK(4#1,(1<FP"*,1(*#$,&-F<,"( "-,+"&("0"&I,+-$7(#&($#,+-$7.(,+"(%0"&%7"(F"-$7(&#<7+=I(+%=9(,+"("$'#C4"$,.(C+-="(-$(&"G"%,"'(7%4"1( ,+"( %0"&%7"( *#$,&-F 1(%(G&#7&"11-0"( G%,,"&$(-1(&"0"&1"'(JK%*+,"&(%$'(B"+&.(N``MLH(

MM( 8""( j"$&-*+( %$'( 84-,+( JN``cL( 9#&( %( :#44#$( ;##=( 3"1#<&*"( 9-"='( "RG"&-4"$,( %4#$7( ,&-F"1( #9( ,+"(

;"&<0-%$(\4%>#$H((

MN(@RG"&-4"$,"&1("RG=%-$(,+"(7%4"(C-,+(9"C("R%4G="1(+-7+=-7+,-$7('-99"&"$,(G#,"$,-%=(1*"$%&-#1H(Y"('#(

$#,(F"=-"0"(,+%,(1<*+("R%4G="1(4%I("$+%$*"(1,&%,"7-*(="%&$-$7(%4#$7(G=%I"&1(1-$*"(,+"(=%,,"&('#($#,( E$#C( #,+"&( G=%I"& ( 1,&%,"7I( F<,( 1-4G=I( ,+"( G#,"$,-%=( G%I#99( '-1,&-F<,-#$1( -$( 1#4"( #9( ,+"( G#,"$,-%=( 1*"$%&-#1H([#&"#0"&.(1-$*"(,+"(7%4"(4%I(1#<$'(,##(<$9%4-=-%&(,#(,+"4.(C"(+%0"(,#(+"=G(,+"4(%$IC%I(-$( %*+-"0-$7(%(9%-&(="0"=(#9(*#4G&"+"$1-#$($"*"11%&I(,#(G%&,-*-G%,"(-$(,+"(7%4"H(

(12)

!+"

"RG"&-4"$,"&1H( ;=%I"&1( %&"( -$9#&4"'( %,( ,+"( F"7-$$-$7( #9( ,+"( 7%4"( ,+%,( ,+"I( C-==( F"( G%-'(P<1,(9#&(#$"(&%$'#4=ID*+#1"$(&#<$'H(

A$(#&'"&(,#(*#$,&#=(9#&(G<F=-*(%GG&#0%=i9"%&(#9(G<$-1+4"$,(+%=9(#9(,+"(1%4G=".(Ta(#<,(#9( ,+"(eh(7&#<G1.(G=%I(,+"(7%4"(-$(,+"(%$#$I4#<1iG&-0%,"(0"&1-#$(J;KKD\.(C+"&"("%*+( G"&1#$('#"1($#,(1""(+#C(4<*+(,+"(#,+"&(G=%I"&1(&"*"-0"L.(,+"(&"4%-$-$7(+%=9(G=%I-$7(-$( ,+"( $#$D%$#$I4#<1iG<F=-*( 0"&1-#$( J;KKD^\LH( A$( ,+"( ;KKD\.( ,+"( "RG"&-4"$,"&( *%=*<=%,"1( ,+"( G%I#991( %$'( '-1,&-F<,"1( ,+"( 4#$"I( -$( "$0"=#G"1( C+-="( -$( ,+"( ;KKD^\( "%*+(G=%I"&(+%1(,#(%$$#<$*"(+#C(4<*+(+"i1+"('"*-'"1(,#(C-,+'&%C(%$'(G%I4"$,1(%&"( 0-1-F="( ,#( "0"&IF#'IHMT( 5#( F"( 1<&"( ,+%,( %==( G%&,-*-G%$,1( 9<==I( <$'"&1,%$'( ,+"( #,+"&(

]<&-$7(,+"(9-0"(&#<$'1(G%I4"$,1(%&"(4%'"(C-,+(9-*+"1(%$'(&"G#&,"'(#$(%(1+"",(C-,+( -,1( *#&&"1G#$'-$7( &#<$'( $<4F"&( J9&#4( M( ,#( gLH( \,( ,+"( "$'( #9( ,+"( C+#="( 7%4"( "%*+( G=%I"&( "R,&%*,1( %( $<4F"&( 9&#4( %( F=%*E( F%7( *#$,%-$-$7( $<4F"&1( 9&#4( M( ,#( gH( 5+"(

-$,#(&"%=(4#$"IHMc(

\1( -$( 4#1,( 9-"='( "RG"&-4"$,1( ,+"( 4%R-4<4( G#,"$,-%=( G%I#99( Ja``( b1+( 9&#4( ,+"( ,C#( ,&<1,( 7%4"1.( ,+"( G<F=-*( 7##'( 7%4".( %$'( 1<&0"I( %$'( 1+#C( <G( 9""1L( -1( 0"&I( +-7+( #$( &"=%,-0"(,"&41H(5+"(%4#<$,(%,(1,%E"(-1(&#<7+=I( ,+"(%0"&%7"(C""E=I(C%7"(-$(,+"(%&"%(

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

MT( \( 4%-$( '-99"&"$*"( F",C""$( #<&( *#44#$( G##=( &"1#<&*"( 7%4"( %$'( 1,%$'%&'( ;KK1( -1( ,+%,( C"( '"G%&,(

9&#4( %( 9<==I( %$#$I4#<1( 1",,-$7( %$'( =",( G=%I"&1( 1""( "%*+( #,+"&H( 5+-1( G&#*"'<&"( -1( -$,"$'"'( ,#( 4-4-*( 4#&"(*=#1"=I(,+"(&"%=-,I(#9(*#44#$(G##=(4%$%7"4"$,(-$(%(7-0"$(%&"%(C"&"(-$'-0-'<%=1(E$#C("%*+(#,+"&H( O<&( \i^\( 0%&-%$,( -1( -$,"$'"'( ,#( %==#C( 9#&( ,+"( ,C#( &"%1#$%F="( G#11-F-=-,-"1( ,+%,( G=%I"&1( %&"( #&( $#,( G"&9"*,=I(-$9#&4"'(%F#<,($#$(*##G"&%,-0"(F"+%0-#<&(#9(#,+"&(4"4F"&1('<"(,#(,+"(G&"1"$*"i%F1"$*"(#9(%( 4#$-,#&-$7(G&#*"11H(

McY"('""4(1<*+(*#4G="R-,I($"*"11%&I(-$(#&'"&(,#(4"%1<&"(,+"(*+%$7"(-$(,&<1,C#&,+-$"11('","&4-$"'(FI(

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

%99"*,"'($#,(P<1,(FI(,+"(-4G%*,(#9(,+"(;KK(7%4"("RG"&-"$*"(F<,(%=1#(FI(,+"(#<,*#4"1(#9(,+"(9-&1,(&#<$'( #9(,+"(5K(&"0"%="'(,#(,+"(G=%I"&1H(

(13)

!!" C+-*+.(*#$1-'"&-$7(%=1#(,+"(=#C(=#*%=(1,%$'%&'(#9(=-0-$7.("$1<&"1(,+%,(G=%I"&1(C-==(,%E"( 1"&-#<1=I(4#$",%&I(&"C%&'1(-$(,+"(7%4"HMg( ' LA'M/.#3$()$0/'.)%)$.)$#.' B>'!C,-<).68.5/!5:!8(,!1#).#+3,-!2-,0!#/0!-2**#)$!-8#8.-8.<-!5:!8(,!D(53,!-#*63,!

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j%=9(#9(,+"(1%4G="(0#=<$,""&1(4#&"(,+%$(#$*"(%(4#$,+(%$'i#&(-1(4"4F"&( #9( %( 4-*&#9-$%$*"( -$1,-,<,-#$H( A4G%,-"$*".( &-1E( %$'( F",&%I%=( %0"&1-#$Mh( %&"( 9&"_<"$,( G1I*+#=#7-*%=(%,,-,<'"1H((

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

Mg( \0"&%7"( C""E=I( 1%=%&-"1( %&"( "R,&"4"=I( =#C( %$'( %( &"="0%$,( 1+%&"( #9( ,+"( 1%4G="( -1( <$"4G=#I"'H(

B<&,+"&4#&".(-$(^%-&#F-(1=<41(%&#<$'(g`(G"&*"$,(#9(%'<=,(%$'(*+-='(G#G<=%,-#$(9%*"(+<$7"&(%$'.(4#&"( 7"$"&%==I.( %&#<$'( e`( G"&*"$,( =-0"( F"=#C( ,+"( G#0"&,I( &%,"( JB%I".( )%1*+-"&-.( B%=E-$7+%4( %$'( [<-$'-.( N`M`LH(((

Mh)I( *#=="*,-$7( "RG"&-4"$,%=( 4"%1<&"1( #9( F",&%I%=( %0"&1-#$.( )#+$",( %$'( K&"-7( JN``aL( 1+#C( ,+%,( -$'-0-'<%=1(%&"(7"$"&%==I(="11(C-==-$7(,#(,%E"(&-1E1(C+"$(,+"(<$*"&,%-$,I(-1('<"(,#(%$#,+"&(G"&1#$(&%,+"&( ,+%$($%,<&"H(A$(#&'"&($#,(,#(*#4G=-*%,"(9<&,+"&(,+"(7%4"(%$'("RG#1"(G%&,-*-G%$,1(,#(%$(%''-,-#$%=(J%$'( 1,&"119<=L("RG"&-4"$,%=(%*,-0-,I.(C"(*#=="*,(1<&0"I(4"%1<&"1(#9(F",&%I%=(%0"&1-#$(FI(%1E-$7(_<"1,-#$1(#$( $"7%,-0"( &"*-G&#*-,I( J1""( ,+"( _<"1,-#$$%-&"( -$( ,+"( %GG"$'-RLH( 5+#1"( 4"%1<&"1( 1+#<='( F"( G&#RI( 9#&(

E,8)#$#3! #1,)-.5/! *,#/-! 8(#8! 6,563,! 0.-3.F,! /5/@ 62/.-(./4! /5/@),<.6)5<#3! +,(#1.5)G! #),H! <,8,).-! 6#).+2-H! *5),! 3.F,3$! 85! :,,3! +,8)#$,0! ./! <#-,! 5:! /5/@

="0"=(#9(*#$1"$,(,#(,+"(9#==#C-$7(,C#(_<"1,-#$1Q(-L(I:!I!-2::,)!#!-,).52-!D)5/4H!I!D.33!8#F,!),1,/4,!#-!-55/!

(14)

!#"

5%F="(NF(*#$,%-$1(1<44%&I(1,%,-1,-*1(#9(,+"(0%&-%F="1(&"=%,"'(,#(,+"("RG"&-4"$,H(5+"( %4#<$,( 7-0"$( FI( ,+"( ,&<1,#&( J%&#<$'( Ng( b1+L( -1( &#<7+=I( ,+"( 1%4"( -$( ,+"( 9-&1,( %$'( 1"*#$'( ,&<1,( 7%4"H( j"$*".( ,+"( *+%$7"( 9&#4( ,+"( 9-&1,( ,#( ,+"( 1"*#$'( 1"11-#$( -1( #$( %0"&%7"( >"&#( F<,( &%$7"1( 9&#4( DT`( ,#( kcg.( C-,+( %( 1,%$'%&'( '"0-%,-#$( "_<%=( ,#( aHhMHMe( ]<&-$7(,+"(9-0"(1"11-#$1(#9(,+"(G<F=-*(7##'(7%4"(G=%I"&1(C-,+'&%C(%&#<$'(hS(G"&*"$,( #9(,+"-&(4#$"I(9&#4(,+"(*#44#$(G-=".(&%$7-$7(9&#4(%(4-$-4<4(#9(NT(,#(%(4%R-4<4(#9( Se( G"&*"$,H( 5+"( '-99"&"$*"( F",C""$( ,+"( %4#<$,( C-,+'&%C$( FI( ,+"( G=%I"&( %$'( ,+"( %0"&%7"(#9(+"&i+-1(7&#<G(0%&-"1(1-7$-9-*%$,=I(J1,%$'%&'('"0-%,-#$("_<%=(,#(NhHhT(b1+HLH(( 5+"( '"*=%&"'( ="0"=( #9( 1%,-19%*,-#$( -$( ,+"( G<F=-*( 7##'( 7%4"( *%$( &%$7"( 9&#4( %( 4-$-4<4( #9( #$"( J$#,( %,( %==( 1%,-19-"'L( ,#( %( 4%R-4<4( #9( 9-0"( J,#G( 1%,-19-"'LH( Y"( %77&"7%,"( ,+"( 9-0"( *=%11"1( -$,#( ,+&""( *%,"7#&-"1.( 0"&I( 1%,-19-"'( J1*#&"( 9#<&( #&( 9-0"L.( 9#==#C"'(FI(G&",,I(1%,-19-"'(J1*#&"(,+&""L(%$'($#,(1%,-19-"'(J1*#&"(#$"(#&(,C#LH(5+"(="0"=( #9(1%,-19%*,-#$(%F#<,(,+"(#<,*#4"(#9(,+"(G<F=-*(7##'(7%4"(-1(+-7+.(1-$*"(e`(G"&*"$,(#9( G=%I"&1( '"*=%&"( ,+"41"=0"1( 0"&I( 1%,-19-"'.( MS( G"&*"$,( G&",,I( 1%,-19-"'( %$'( #$=I( MM( G"&*"$,($#,(1%,-19-"'H((

(

B>%!E#3#/<./4!6)56,)8.,-!!

Y"(,"1,($#$(G%&%4",&-*%==I(C+",+"&(,+"&"(%&"(1-7$-9-*%$,('-99"&"$*"1(%4#$7(,+"(,+&""( 7&#<G1( J5%F="( T%LH( Y+"$( *#4G%&-$7( 0"&I( 1%,-19-"'( 0"&1<1( ,+"( &"1,( #9( ,+"( 1%4G="( C"( 9-$'( ,+%,( ,+"( 9#&4"&( %&"( I#<$7"&( %$'( 4%&&-"'( -$( +-7+"&( G&#G#&,-#$( JGD0%=<"( %&#<$'(

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

Me5+-1(9-&1,('"1*&-G,-0"(&"1<=,1(1<77"1,(1#4"(-$1-7+,1(9#&(,+"('"F%,"(#$(,+"(G"&1-1,"$*"(#9(1#*-%=(*%G-,%=H(

\**#&'-$7( ,#( 1#4"( %<,+#&1( 1#*-%=( *%G-,%=( '#"1( $#,( 0%&I( 4<*+( -$( ,+"( 1+#&,( &<$( %$'( -,1( 7"#7&%G+-*%=( '-1,&-F<,-#$(-1(%99"*,"'(FI(=#$7(&<$(+-1,#&-*%=(G+"$#4"$%(JK<-1#(",(%=H.(N``aLH(j#C"0"&((#<&('"1*&-G,-0"( "0-'"$*"(1+#C1(,+%,(1+#&,(&<$(%77&"7%,"((-$0%&-%$*"(J*#$9-&4"'(FI(#<&(9-$'-$71L(4%I(*#$*"%=((&"="0%$,( *+%$7"1(%,(-$'-0-'<%=(="0"=(C+#1"('","&4-$%$,1('"1"&0"(9<&,+"&(-$_<-&IH((

(15)

!$"

H`TL.(C+-="(F",&%I%=(%0"&1"Ma(-$(=#C"&(G&#G#&,-#$H(Y+"$(*#4G%&-$7(0"&I(1%,-19-"'(%$'( G&",,I(1%,-19-"'(0"&1<1($#$(1%,-19-"'(C"(9-$'(,+%,(,+"(=%,,"&(%&"(4#&"(&-1E(%0"&1".(="11( F",&%I%=(%0"&1".(+%0"(+-7+"&(G&#G"$1-,I(,#(0#=<$,""&(%$'(+-7+"&(9##'("RG"$'-,<&"(G"&( '%I( JGD0%=<"1( F",C""$( H`M( %$'( H`gLH( ^#,"( +#C"0"&( ,+%,.( C+"$( C"( *#4G%&"( 0"&I( 1%,-19-"'(0"&1<1($#$(1%,-19-"'(J"R*=<'-$7(G&",,I(1%,-19-"'(9&#4(,+"(1%4G="L.(,+"($<==(#9( $#('-99"&"$*"(#$(,+"(#F1"&0"'(*+%&%*,"&-1,-*1(-1($"0"&(&"P"*,"'(%,(g(G"&*"$,(="0"=H(

A$(5%F="(TF(C"(=##E(%,(F%=%$*-$7(G&#G"&,-"1(-$(,+"(&%$'#4->%,-#$(#9(G%&,-*-G%$,1(,#(,+"( ;KK( %$'( ,+"( *#$,&#=( 7&#<G( %$'( '#( $#,( 9-$'( 1-7$-9-*%$,( '-99"&"$*"1( 9#&( %$I( #9( ,+"( *#$1-'"&"'((0%&-%F="1H(

'

B>=!7(,!;99!+,(#1.5)!

5+"( 'I$%4-*( F"+%0-#<&( #9( %==( 1<FP"*,1( -$( ,+"( ;KK( '#*<4"$,1( ,+%,( *##G"&%,-#$( '"*&"%1"1(#0"&( &#<$'1.(C-,+(*##G"&%,-#$(F"-$7(4"%1<&"'(-$("%*+(&#<$'(%,( -$'-0-'<%=( D-$D ,+"DG#,( &%,-#( Jl( ="9,( FI( ,+"( 7&#<Gih``LH( 5+"( '"*&"%1"( -1( +#C"0"&( 4<*+( 14%=="&( ,+%$( C+%,(<1<%==I(#F1"&0"'.(*#$1-1,"$,=I(C-,+(,+"(9%*,(,+%,(C"('#($#,(-$9#&4(G%&,-*-G%$,1( %F#<,( ,+"( $<4F"&( #9( ;KK( &#<$'1( -$( #&'"&( ,#( %0#-'( ;KK( "$'( 7%4"( "99"*,1( #$( 1#*-%=( *%G-,%=( 9#&4%,-#$HMS( 5+"( 4"%$( C-,+'&%C%=( &%,-#( -1( #$( %0"&%7"( haHh( G"&*"$,.( 4#0-$7( 9&#4(hgHN(-$(,+"(9-&1,(,#(e`He(G"&*"$,(-$(,+"(9-9,+(&#<$'H(;%&,-*-G%$,1(1""4(,#(#F1"&0"( ,+"(F"+%0-#<&(#9(,+"(7&#<G(4"4F"&1(%$'(&"%*,(1,&%,"7-*%==I(,#(-,Q(-9(#$"(#&(4#&"(,+%$( #$"('"9"*,(-$(%(&#<$'.(#,+"&1(%=1#('#(-$(,+"(9#==#C-$7(&#<$'H(5+"(#0"&%==(1*%&*"('"7&""( """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" MaB#&('",%-=1(#$(+#C(,+"(F",&%I%=(%0"&1"(0%&-%F="(-1('"9-$"'(1""(9##,$#,"(MhH( ( MS(Y"(,%E"(,+-1('"*-1-#$(1-$*".(*#$1-1,"$,=I(C-,+(,+"(7#%=((#9(4-4-*E-$7(,+"("99"*,(#9(#$7#-$7(;KKD=-E"( %*,-0-,-"1(#$(1#*-%=(*%G-,%=(9#&4%,-#$.(C"(G&"9"&(($#,(,#(-$,&#'<*"(,+"(-$9=<"$*"(#$(,+"(=%,,"&(#9(;KK("$'( 7%4"("99"*,1H(

(16)

!%"

#9(*##G"&%,-#$(-$(#<&(1%4G="(-1(*#$1-1,"$,(C-,+(,+"(#$"(9#<$'(FI(:%11%&(%$'(YI'-*E( JN`MMLH((

Y+"$(*#4G%&-$7(,+"(,C#(;KK(,&"%,4"$,1.(C"(9-$'(,+%,(,+"('"*&"%1"(-$(*##G"&%,-#$(-1( =%&7"&( C+"$( ,+"( %$#$I4-,I( *#$'-,-#$( -1( &"4#0"'H( Y-,+'&%C%=( &%,-#1( -$( 9%*,( -$*&"%1"( -#$1( %$'( G%I#991(-$("%*+(&#<$'W(1-4-=%&=I.(,+"(%4#<$,(="9,(-$(,+"(G#,('"*&"%1"1(4#&"(#0"&(&#<$'1( -$(,+"($#$D%$#$I4#<1(;KK(,+%$(#0"&(&#<$'1(-$(%$#$I4-,IH(

B>B!L$658(,-.-!8,-8./4!!

Y+"$( C"( =##E( %,( ="0"=1( #9( ,&<1,C#&,+-$"11( -$( ,+"( ,C#( '-99"&"$,( 5K( &#<$'1( %$'( ,+"( *+%$7"( -$( ,&<1,C#&,+-$"11( F",C""$( ,+"( ,C#( 5K1( JF"9#&"( %$'( %9,"&( ,+"( ;KKL( C"( 9-$'( ,+%,(;KK(1%,-19%*,-#$(1-7$-9-*%$,=I(%99"*,1(,+"(*+%$7".("0"$(,+#<7+(-,('#"1($#,(G&#'<*"( ,+"( 1%4"( "99"*,( #$( ,&<1,C#&,+-$"11( ="0"=1( J5%F="( c%LH( 5+-1( -1( F"*%<1"( ;KK( 0"&I( 1%,-19-"'( 1,%&,( C-,+( =#C"&( ,&<1,C#&,+-$"11( ="0"=1( -$( ,+"( 9-&1,( &#<$'( %$'( "$'( <G( C-,+( +-7+"&( ="0"=1( -$( ,+"( 1"*#$'( &#<$'( 0-1D2D0-1( ,+"( &"1,( #9( ,+"( 1%4G="H( [#&"( 1G"*-9-*%==I.( C+"$(C"(*#4G%&"(0"&I(1%,-19-"'(0"&1<1(&"1,(#9(,+"(1%4G="(C"(9-$'(,+%,(,+"(9#&4"&(+%0"( %( *+%$7"( #9( HTT( b1+( %7%-$1,( %( DgHag( #9( ,+"( =%,,"&( C-,+( ,+"( '-99"&"$*"( F"-$7( +-7+=I( 1-7$-9-*%$,(JGD0%=<"(H``cLH(5+"(,C#(0%=<"1(%&"(DM`HaM(%7%-$1,(DH``N(JGD0%=<"(H``cL.(-9(C"( *#4G%&"($#$(1%,-19-"'(C-,+(&"1,(#9(,+"(1%4G=".(HTT(%7%-$1,(DM`HTc(JGD0%=<"(H``TL(-9(C"( *#4G%&"( 0"&I( 1%,-19-"'( 0"&1<1( $#$( 1%,-19-"'( J"R*=<'-$7( G&",,I( 1%,-19-"'( 9&#4( ,+"( 1%4G="L( %$'.( *#$1"_<"$,=I.( DM`HTc( %7%-$1,( DH`N( JGD0%=<"(H``cL( C+"$( C"( *#4G%&"( 0"&I( %$'(G&",,I(1%,-19-"'(0"&1<1(,+"(&"1,(#9(,+"(1%4G="H(^#,"(,+%,(,+"(4%R-4<4('-99"&"$*"( F",C""$(,C#(7&#<G1(#9('-99"&"$,=I(;KK(0"&I(1%,-19-"'(G=%I"&1(-1(%&#<$'(M`(b1+.(,+%,(-1.( %F#<,( Ng( G"&*"$,( #9( ,+"( JG&"D;KKL( 9-&1,( 5K( ="0"=( #9( ,&<1,C#&,+-$"11( -$( ,+"( #0"&%==( 1%4G="H(8-$*"(C"(<1"(,+"(1,&%,"7I(4",+#'(-$(,+"(5K(,#("R,&%*,(,&<1,""1 (*#$,&-F<,-#$1.(

(17)

!&"

&"1<=,1( &"G#&,"'( %F#0"( &"9"&( ,#( %0"&%7"1( #9( &"1G#$1"1( *#$'-,-#$%=( ,#( ,+"( M`( G#11-F="( 1(J9&#4(g(,#(g`(b1+LH(Y+"$(C"(&"G"%,(,+"($#$(G%&%4",&-*(,"1,1(#$(

'-99"&"$*"( 9#&( ,&<1,#&1( *#$,&-F<,-#$1( F",C""$( M`( %$'( T`( JC-,+( GD0%=<"1( F"=#C( `H`ML( J5%F="(cFLH((

(

NA'=#","-/)3$#'4$,*$,K.'",')2/'*/)/3-$,%,).'"4')35.);"3)2$,/..'*+,%-$#.' %#3"..'DF'3"5,*.'

A$(G&"1"$*"(#9(%(C"==D1,&<*,<&"'(&%$'#4->%,-#$(G&#*"11(G%&%4",&-*(%$'($#$(G%&%4",&-*( ,"1,1( %&"( <1<%==I( *#$1-'"&"'( %1( 1<99-*-"$,( "4G-&-*%=( "0-'"$*"( FI( "RG"&-4"$,%=-1,1H( ^"0"&,+"="11.( C"( '"*-'"( ,#( G"&9#&4( "*#$#4",&-*( "1,-4%,"1( F"*%<1"( C"( C%$,( ,#( "0%=<%,"(,+"(4%7$-,<'"(#9(#<&("99"*,1.(-1#=%,"(,+"4(9&#4(#,+"&(*#$9#<$'-$7(9%*,#&1(%$'( *#$,&#=(9#&(,+"(%$#$I4-,Ii$#$(%$#$I4-,I(9"%,<&"(#9(,+"(;KKH(A$(5%F="(g%(C"(&"G#&,(%( F%1"=-$"( &"7&"11-#$( -$( C+-*+( C"( ,"1,( ,+"( "99"*,( #9( ,+&""( 4%-$( 0%&-%F="1( J,+"( 9-&1,( 5K( *#$,&-F<,-#$.(%$#$I4-,I(#9(,+"(;KK(,&"%,4"$,(%$'(*#$,&#=('<44IL(#$(,+"(*+%$7"(-$( ,&<1,C#&,+-$"11(F",C""$(,+"(,C#(;KK(&#<$'1(C-,+(-$*=<1-#$i#4-11-#$(#9(%==(,+"(1#*-#D '"4#7&%G+-*( 0%&-%F="1( =-1,"'( -$( 5%F="( M%H( 5+"( $"7%,-0"( *#"99-*-"$,( #9( ,+"( 9-&1,( &#<$'( *#$,&-F<,-#$( 1<77"1,1( ,+"( "R-1,"$*"( #9( %( *#$0"&7"$*"( 4"*+%$-14( C+-*+( 4%E"1( ,+"(

"_<%=.( $#,( +%0-$7( G%&,-*-G%,"'( ,#( ,+"( ;KK( $"7%,-0"=I( %99"*,1( ,+"( *+%$7"( -$( *#$,&-F<,-#$(9&#4(,+"(9-&1,(,#(,+"(1"*#$'(,&<1,(7%4"H(5+-1(1<77"1,1(%(G#1-,-0"("99"*,(#9( ,+"( ;KK( #$( ,+"( G&#*"11( #9( *&"%,-#$( #9( 1#*-%=( *%G-,%=H( 5+"( #$=I( 1-7$-9-*%$,( J$"7%,-0"L( 0%&-%F="( %4#$7( 1#*-#D'"4#7&%G+-*( *#$,&#=1( -1( '%-=I( 9##'( "RG"$'-,<&".( G&#F%F=I( '#*<4"$,-$7( ,+%,( ,+"( 4%&7-$%=( <,-=-,I( #9( 4#$"I( -1( =#C"&( 9#&( ="11( G##&( G=%I"&1H( ( A$(

(18)

!'"

5%F="(gF(C"(&"1,&-*,(,+"(1%4G="(,#(,+"(,&"%,4"$,(7&#<G(%$'(-$,&#'<*"(1<FP"*,-0"(J0"&I( 1%,-19-"'( %$'( G&",,I( 1%,-19-"'( '<44-"1L( %$'( #FP"*,-0"( J-$'-0-'<%=( %$'( 7&#<G( C-,+'&%C%=( &%,-#1.( -$'-0-'<%=( G%I#991L( ;KK( -$'-*%,#&1( *#$,&#==-$7( %1( C"==( 9#&( ",+$-*( %$'( 7"$'"&( 9&%74"$,%,-#$( C-,+( %$'( C-,+#<,( ,+"( -$*=<1-#$( #9( 1#*-#D'"4#7&%G+-*( 0%&-%F="1HN`( Y"( 9-$'( ,+%,( 1<FP"*,-0"( -$'-*%,#&1( %&"( 1-7$-9-*%$,( JG#1-,-0"( "99"*,( #9( ;KK( 1%,-19%*,-#$( ( C-,+( %( 4%7$-,<'"( #9( 4#&"( ,+%$( ab1+.( &#<7+=I( "_<%=( ,#( ,+"( 0%&-%F=" ( 1,%$'%&'( '"0-%,-#$L( C+-="( #FP"*,-0"( -$'-*%,#&1( %&"( $#,H( \4#$7( #,+"&( &"7&"11#&1( $#,"( ,+%,( 7"$'"&( 9&%74"$,%,-#$( +%1( %( 1,&#$7( "*#$#4-*( -4G%*,( J-$( =-$"( C-,+( )#+$",( %$'( K&"-7.(N``SL.("0"$(,+#<7+(-,(-1(1-7$-9-*%$,(#$=I(%,(M`(G"&*"$,(="0"=LH((

5%F="(g*(G&#0-'"1(%(&#F<1,$"11(*+"*E(#9(#<&(4%-$(&"1<=,1(FI(<1-$7(%=,"&$%,-0"(),3#8.1,! #FP"*,-0"( -$'-*%,#&1( %1( *#$,&#=1( J&%$E-$7( -$( C-,+'&%C%=( &%,-#1.( %0"&%7"( %$'( 1G"*-9-*( &#<$'('-99"&"$*"1(F",C""$(-$'-0-'<%=(%$'(7&#<G(*#$,&-F<,-#$1(%$'(G%I#991LH(OFP"*,-0"( -$'-*%,#&1( &"4%-$( $#,( 1-7$-9-*%$,( C+-="( ,+"( 1-7$-9-*%$*"( #9( 1<FP"*,-0"( -$'-*%,#&1( -1( <$%=,"&"'HNM(

5%F="1(h%(%$'(hF(-==<1,&%,"(

,C#( #9( ,+"( 1G"*-9-*%,-#$1( %'#G,"'(-$("1,-4%,"1(&"G#&,"'(J5%F="1(gF.(*#=<4$1(c(%$'(gLH(5+"(%&"%(#9(,+"(1,&#$7"1,( 1-7$-9-*%$*"( #9( ,+"( ;KK( 0"&I( 1%,-19-"'( '<44I( JGD0%=<"( F"=#C( H``ML( -1( 9#&( ,&<1,#&1( *#$,&-F<,-#$1( F",C""$( g%$'( Tgb1+.( *#$1-1,"$,=I( C-,+( "0-'"$*"( 9&#4( $#$( G%&%4",&-*( ,"1,1( J,+"( +-7+"1,( 4%7$-,<'"( -1( %&#<$'( MNb1+( -$( *#&&"1G#$'"$*"( #9( ,&<1,#&( *#$,&-F<,-#$(#9(T`(b1+LH(5+"(1-7$-9-*%$*"(#9(,+"(G&",,I(1%,-19-"'('<44I(-1(C"%E"&(%$'( ,+"( 4%7$-,<'"( -1( 14%=="&( JC-,+( ,+"( "R*"G,-#$( #9( ,+"( &-7+,( "$'( "1,-4%,"1( C+"&"( ,+"(

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

N`(3"1<=,1(#$(1#*-#D'"4#7&%G+-*(0%&-%F="1(%&"(#4-,,"'(9#&(&"%1#$1(#9(1G%*"H(B<==('",%-=1(#$(,+"1"(&"1<=,1(

%&"(%0%-=%F="(<G#$(&"_<"1,H(

NM(Y"(%=1#(*+"*E('-&"*,=I(-$(%(1"G%&%,"("1,-4%,"(C+",+"&(;KK(1%,-19%*,-#$( -1(%99"*,"'(FI('"4#7&%G+-*1(

%$'( #FP"*,-0"( #<,*#4"1( #9( ,+"( 7%4"( %$'( 9-$'( ,+%,( -,( -1( $#,H( 5+"( -$,"&G&",%,-#$( F"-$7( %7%-$( ,+%,( 1<FP"*,-0"( 1%,-19%*,-#$( 4%I( F"( -'-#1I$*&%,-*( #&( -,( 4%I( '"G"$'( 9&#4( 4%$I( $#$( #FP"*,-0"( 9%*,#&1( J1""( 1"*,-#$(NL(8-$*"($#$"(#9(,+"(&"7&"11#&1(-1(1-7$-9-*%$,(&"1<=,1(%&"(#4-,,"'(%$'(%0%-=%F="(<G#$(&"_<"1,H(

(19)

!("

4%7$-,<'"( -1( +-7+"&( F<,( 1-7$-9-*%$*"( '"*=-$"1LH( 3"1<=,1( #$( ,&<1,""1( *#$'-,-#$%=( *#$,&-F<,-#$1(9#&('-99"&"$,(1G"*-9-*%,-#$1(%&"(#4-,,"'(9#&(&"%1#$1(#9(1G%*"(%$'(%0%-=%F="( <G#$(&"_<"1,H(

\( G#,"$,-%=( 1#<&*"( #9( F-%1( -$( ,+"( G&"0-#<1( "1,-4%,"1( 4%I( *#4"( 9&#4( 1"="*,-#$H( B#&( "R%4G=".(-$'-0-'<%=1(C-,+(F",,"&(G&#D1#*-%=(%,,-,<'"1(4%I(F"(4#&"(=-E"=I(,#('"*=%&"(%( +-7+"&(1%,-19%*,-#$(="0"=(%F#<,(,+"(;KK(C-,+(&"1G"*,(,#(-$'-0-'<%=1(C-,+(C#&1"(#$"1H(A$( #&'"&(,#(*#$,&#=(9#&(,+-1(%$'(1-4-=%&(1#<&*"1(#9(F-%1.(C"(&"D"1,-4%,"(,+"(4#'"=1(MM(%$'( MN(#9(5%F="(gF(C-,+(Y"-7+"'(!"%1,(8_<%&"1(JY!8L(C+"&"(,+"(C"-7+,1(%&"(,+"(-$0"&1"( #9(,+"(-$'-0-'<%=1m(G&#G"$1-,I(1*#&"(#9(;KK(1%,-19%*,-#$HNN([#&"(1G"*-9-*%==I.(-$(%(9-&1,( 1G"*-9-*%,-#$( C"( "R*=<'"( ;KK( G&",,I( 1%,-19-"'( -$'-0-'<%=1( %$'( "1,-4%,"( #$( ,+"( &"4%-$-$7( 1%4G="( ,+"( G&#G"$1-,I( 1*#&"( J;8L( #9( &"G#&,-$7( %( +-7+( 1%,-19%*,-#$( ="0"=( J0%&-%F="( ;99! 1,)$! -#8.-:.,0LNTW( ,+"$( C"( <1"( ,+"( ;8( 4"%1<&"( ,#( C"-7+,( ,+"( #<,*#4"( &"7&"11-#$( #9( ;KK( 0"&I( 1%,-19-"'( #$( ,+"( *+%$7"( -$( ,&<1,""m1( %0"&%7"( ,&<1,C#&,+-$"11( F",C""$( ,+"( ,C#( 5K( &#<$'1( J 79LH( \1( %( 1"*#$'( 1G"*-9-*%,-#$( C"( *#4G<,"( ,+"( G&#G"$1-,I( 1*#&"( 4"%1<&"( <1-$7( %1( '"G"$'"$,( 0%&-%F="( %( '<44I( "_<%=( ,#( #$"( -9( -$'-0-'<%=1(C"&"(G&",,I(#&(0"&I(1%,-19-"'(J-#8.-:.,0L(%$'(,+"$(C"(*#4G<,"(,+"(#<,*#4"( (3"1<=,1(-$(5%F="(e(+-7+=-7+,(,C#(-4G#&,%$,(9%*,1.( -H"H( -L( 0%&-%F="1( G&#RI( 9#&( G&#D1#*-%=( *+%&%*,"&-1,-*1( '#( $#,( +%0"( G&"'-*,-0"( G#C"&( #$( '"*=%&"'( 1%,-19%*,-#$.( %$'( --L( ,+"( G#1-,-0"("99"*,( #9( ;KK( 1%,-19%*,-#$(#$(,+"( *+%$7"(-$( ,&<1,C#&,+-$"11( -1( *#$9-&4"'( "-,+"&( F#,+( C+"$( "R*=<'-$7( ;KK( G&",,I( 1%,-19-"'(

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

NNA$( G%&,-*<=%&.( 9#&( "%*+( -$'-0-'<%=.( ,+"( C"-7+,1( %&"Q( ! "#$%&' ! () (

* !

* "#$%&' !.( C+"&"( 6-<5),( -1( %( $#$D G%&%4",&-*( "1,-4%,"( #9( ,+"( G&#G"$1-,I( 1*#&"( %$'( M( -1( ,+"( 1%,-19%*,-#$( '<44I( J;KK( 0"&I( 1%,-19-"'( #&( 1%,-19-"'LH( B#&( '",%-=1( #$( ,+-1( 1,&%,"7I( 1"".( %4#$7( #,+"&1.( )=%,,4%$( %$'( \$$%$( JN`M`L( %$'( j-&%$#.( A4F"$1(%$'(3-''"&(JN``TLH((

NT(^#,"(,+%,(9#&(,+"(*#4G<,%,-#$(#9(,+"(G&#G"$1-,I(1*#&"(C"(<1"(%=1#(0%&-%F="1(,+%,(*%$(F"(G&#RI(#9(,+"(

-$'-0-'<%=1m( G&#D1#*-%=( *+%&%*,"&-1,-*1( 1<*+( %1( %( ,&<1,( -$'"R( J*#$1,&<*,"'( <1-$7( ,+"( K88( _<"1,-#$1( #$( ,&<1,L(%$'(%(1#*-%F-=-,I('<44I(J1""(B"+&.(N`M`LH(B<&,+"&('",%-=1(%F#<,(,+"1"(0%&-%F="1(%&"(&"G#&,"'(-$( ,+"(0%&-%F="(="7"$'(J5%F="(MLH

(20)

!)"

J*#=<4$1( MDNL( %$'( C+"$( G&",,I( %$'( 0"&I( 1%,-19-"'( %&"( P#-$,=I( 1<44%&->"'( -$( ,+"( F&#%'"&('"9-$"'(-#8.-:.,0(0%&-%F="(J*#=<4$1(TDcLH(5+"1"(&"1<=,1(1<GG#&,(<1(-$(*=%-4-$7( ,+"(&#F<1,$"11(#9(#<&(F%1"=-$"("1,-4%,"1(,#(1"="*,-#$H(

(

OA'?",#&5.$",.''

-$( 1#*-%=( *%G-,%=( -$( ,+"( ^%-&#F-( 1=<4( #9( b-F"&%.( #$"( #9( ,+"( G##&"1,( 1#*-#"*#$#4-*( *#$,"R,1( -$( C+-*+( G&"0-#<1( &"1"%&*+( '#*<4"$,"'( ,+%,( 1#*-%=( *%G-,%=( -1( %,( -,1( =#C"1,( ="0"=1(%&#<$'(,+"(C#&='H((3"1<=,1(#9(#<&("RG"&-4"$,('#*<4"$,(,+%,(=-4-,-$7(#$"1"=9(,#( ,+"(<1"(#9(#FP"*,-0"(;KK(&"1<=,1(,#(G&"'-*,(9<,<&"(#FP"*,-0"(#<,*#4"1(-$(,"&41(#9(1#*-%=( *%G-,%=( *&"%,-#$( -1( "R,&"4"=I( G##&( 1-$*"( -,( &<="1( #<,( "11"$,-%=( -$0-1-F="( $#$( #FP"*,-0"( 9%*,#&1(C+-*+(*&<*-%==I('&-0"(9<,<&"(,&<1,(7%4"(F"+%0-#&H((

5+"( *#$,&-F<,-#$( #9( ,+"( G%G"&( -1( ,C#9#='H( B-&1,.( 9&#4( %$( "RG"&-4"$,%=( "*#$#4-*1( 0-"CG#-$,(-,('#*<4"$,1(,+"(1,&#$7("RG=%$%,#&I(G#C"&(#9( 1<FP"*,-0"(1%,-19%*,-#$(C+"$( 4"%1<&-$7(,+"("99"*,(#9(;KK(%*,-0-,-"1(#$(*+%$7"1(-$(1#*-%=(*%G-,%=H(8"*#$'.(-,(1<77"1,1( 9&#4( %( $#&4%,-0"( G#-$,( #9( 0-"C( ,+%,( 1%,-19%*,-#$( 4"%1<&"1( 4%I( +"=G( ,#( 1"="*,( -$'-0-'<%=1(C+#1"(G%&,-*-G%,-#$(,#(G<F=-*(7##'(%*,-0-,-"1(4%I(4%R-4-1"("99"*,1(-$(,"&41( #9(1#*-%=(*%G-,%=(*&"%,-#$H(

Y"( F"=-"0"( ,+%,( -$,"&"1,-$7( -4G=-*%,-#$1( 4%I( F"( '&%C$( 9&#4( #<&( G#=-*I( "RG"&-4"$,( 1-$*"( ,+"&"( %&"( 1"0"&%=( &"%1#$1( C+I( #<&( ;KK( ,&"%,4"$,( 4-4-*1( 9"%,<&"1( C+-*+( %&"( -4G#&,%$,( 9#&( ,+"( =#*%=( 1#*-#"*#$#4-*( "$0-&#$4"$,H( 3#%'1.( C%,"&( %$'( 1%$-,%,-#$( %&"( G&#0-'"'( -$( ,+"1"( 1=<41( FI( =#*%=( -$9&%1,&<*,<&"( *#44<$-,I( '"0"=#G4"$,( G&#P"*,1( -$( ;KKD=-E"(1-,<%,-#$1(-$(C+-*+(C+"&"(G"#G="(9&#4(=#*%=(*#44<$-,I('#$%,"(4#$"I(%$'i#&( =%F#<&(-$(#&'"&(,#(F<-='(,+"(G<F=-*(7##'H(8"*#$'.(%==(-$'-0-'<%=1(-$(b"$I%("RG"&-"$*"(

(21)

!*"

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c.(^#H(c.(GGH(MNcTDMNacH( NH \&&#C.(bH(ZH(JMSecL. .((^#&,#$Q(^"C(d#&EH(

TH )%1*+-"&-.( \H.( B%=E-$7+%4( ZH.( [<-$'-.( bH(JN`M`L.( j<$7"&(%$'( B##'( A$1"*<&-,I( .(:@;8(C#&E-$7(G%G"&(TT( Y#&E-$7(;%G"&(^#H(N`M`DTTH(

cH @$+%$*-$7( *%G%F-=-,-"1( ,+&#<7+( *&"'-,(

%**"11Q( :&"'-,C#&,+-$"11( %1( %( 1-7$%=( #9( ,&<1,C#&,+-$"11( <$'"&( %1I44",&-*( O52)/#3!5:!;2+3.<!P<5/5*.<-.(6#=H(Sg.(^#H(TDc.(GGH(NhgDNeaH(

(22)

#+"

gH )"**+",,-( !H( %$'( ;%*"( ^H( JN``hLH(

:#&G#&%,-#$ ]"G%&,4"$,%=( Y#&E-$7( ;%G"&( ^#H( NTT.( 5#&( 6"&7%,%( /$-0"&1-,I.( 3#4"H(

hH )"7<I.( ]H.( )#*_<-"&.( ;H( %$'( [1-I%G+%>-(

H! C,*54)#6(.<! A,-,#)<(.(6#=H(NT.(\&,H(N`.(GGH(gcSDgahH(( eH 5&<1,.( 3"*-G&#*-,I.( %$'( 8#*-%=( j-1,#&I 9#*,-!#/0!P<5/5*.<!E,(#1.5).(6#=H(M`.(^#H(M.(GGH(MNNDMcNH( aH )#+$",.( AH( %$'( K&"-7 P<5/5*.<!I/Q2.)$.(6#=H(ch.(^#H(M.(GGH(eeD aTH( SH )#+$",.(AH(%$'(K&"-7.(BH( @RG=#&-$7(7"$'"&"'(F"+%0-#&(-$(,+"(9-"='(C-,+( "RG"&-4"$,1Q( Y+I( G<F=-*( 7##'1( %&"( G&#0-'"'( FI( C#4"$( -$( %( ^%-&#F-( 1=<4 O52)/#3!5:!P<5/5*.<!E,(#1.5)!#/0!R)4#/.S#8.5/.(6#=H(e`.(GGH(MDSH(

M`H

PT6,).*,/8#3!P<5/5*.<-.(6#=H(N.(GGH( NNeDNTaH(

MMH :%4"&"&.(:H(%$'(B"+&.(@H( ["%1<&-$7(1#*-%=($#&41(%$'(G&"9"&"$*"1(<1-$7( "RG"&-4"$,%=( 7%4"1Q( \( 7<-'"( 9#&( 1#*-%=( 1*-"$,-1,1 .( !"0-$"m1( Y#&E-$7( ;%G"&( \&*+-0"(.(]%0-'(bH(!"0-$"H(

MNH 5+"( 1,&%,"7I( 4",+#'( =#C"&1( 4"%1<&"'( (P<5/5*.<-!U,88,)-.(6#=H(M`T.(^#H(T.(GGH(MgeDMgSH( MTH :%11%&.(\H(%$'(YI'-*E.()H(JN`M`GH B-0"D ( RT:5)0! P<5/5*.<! ;#6,)-H! 6#=H( hN.( ^#H(c.(GGH(eMgDeTSH( McH :=%&E.( \H@H.( B&-P,"&1.( ;H( %$'( 8+-"='1.( [H\H( @0-'"$*".( @RG=%$%,-#$1( %$'( @*#$#4-_<"1.(C#&E-$7(G%G"&(N``hDNcH( MgH B"+&.(@H.(B-1*+F%*+"&.(/H(%$'((Kn*+,"&.(8H(JN``NL.( 8,&#$7(3"*-G&#*-,I.(j<4%$( :##G"&%,-#$( .(L2*#/!V#82),.(6#=H(MT.(^#H( M.(GGH(MDNgH( MhH (O52)/#3!5:!P<5/5*.<!U.8,)#82),.(6#=H(c`.(GGH(c`NDcTgH(

(23)

#!"

MeH B&"I.( )H8H( %$'( 8,<,>"&.( \H( JN`M`L.( 3"*"$,( \'0%$*"1( -$( ,+"( @*#$#4-*1( #9( A$'-0-'<%=(8<FP"*,-0"(Y"==D)"-$7 (AU\(]-1*<11-#$(;%G"&1(cag`.(A$1,-,<,"(9#&(,+"( 8,<'I(#9(!%F#&(JAU\LH(( MaH O52)/#3! 5:! E#/F./4!#/0!W./#/<,.(6#=H(Nh.(^#H(S.(GGH(MeagDMa`SH( MSH @'<*%,-#$.( 1#*-%=( *#+"1-#$.( %$'( "*#$#4-*(7&#C,+ (X*,).<#/!P<5/5*.<!A,1.,D.(6#=H(SN.(^#H(c.(GGH(MMSNDMN`cH( N`H X*,).<#/! P<5/5*.<! A,1.,D.( 6#=H( Sc.( ^#H( T.( GGH( gNhD ggeH( NMH K<-1#.( !H.( 8%G-"$>%.( ;H( %$'( U-$7%="1.( !H( JN``aL :+-*%7#(K8)(3"1"%&*+(;%G"&(^#H(`aDMM( NNH \(:&#11D 7(,!N2#)8,)3$!O52)/#3!5:!P<5/5*.<-.(6#=H(MMN.( ^#H(c.(GGH(MNgMDMNaaH( NTH O52)/#3! 5:! W./#/<,.( 6#=H( !AA.( ^#H( T.( GGH( MMTMDMMg`H( NcH [#$,%=0#.( KH( %$'( 3"I$%=Df<&#=.( [H( JN``g% ]"0"=#G4"$, .(O52)/#3!5:!C,1,356*,/8!P<5/5*.<-H!6#=H(eh.(GGH(NSTDTNT>! NgH [#$,%=0#.( KH( %$'( 3"I$%=Df<&#=.( [H( JN``gFL.( X*,).<#/!P<5/5*.<!A,1.,D.(6#=H(Sg.(^#H(T.(GGH(eShD aMhH! NhH :#=="*,-0"( \*,-#$( Q' 7(,! O52)/#3!5:!P<5/5*.<!;,)-6,<8.1,-.(6#=H(Mc.(^#H(TH.(GGH(MTeDMgaH(

NeH O1,&#4.( @H( J Q( ,+"( "0#=<,-#$( #9( -$1,-,<,-#$1( 9#&( Q(:%4F&-'7"(/$-0"&1-,I(;&"11H!

NaH ;<,$%4.( 3H( ]H( JMSSTL.( [%E-$7( ]"4#*&%*I( Y#&EH( :-0-*( ,&%'-,-#$1( -$( 4#'"&$( .(;&-$*",#$Q(;&-$*",#$(/$-0"&1-,I(;&"11H!

NSH j#C(,#(F"(E-$'o(O<,*#4"1(0"&1<1(A$,"$,-#$1(%1(]","&4-$%$,1( #9(B%-&$"11 Y#&E-$7(;%G"&(^#H(Mcg.(/$-0"&1-,I(#9([-=%$#D)-*#**%H(

(24)

##" T`H D 9-="1iF<"&#1iE"$-%i`MTScHG'9(H( TMH 7(,!P<5/5*.<!O52)/#3.(6#=H( MMM.(^#H(ce`.(GGH(NSgDTNMH( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( !"#$%&'()'*+&'&,-&%".&/0'1&2"#/' ' ' !"#$%&'()#&*#+# !""#$#%&# " ,--#(./01%)# '()*'#"&+,# !"#$%"&' ,--#(./01%)# '()*'#"&+,# !-+(./01%)# " '()*'# "&+,# # # # # # *)(-,.# !-+#(./01%)# " '()*'# "&+,# " !"#$%&'()#&*#+# !""#$#&#

Riferimenti

Documenti correlati

The big advantage of the numerical analysis with Surface Evolver [84, 85] is that the minimal area surface is obtained without going through this procedure of finding the

Cette agglomération comporte diverses cabanes implantées soit à l’extérieur du nuraghe (dans la zone face à l’entrée, au sud-est du monument), soit à l'intérieur du

Moreover it is influenced by other factors, such as the morphology of the hot spots, the relative orientation of the molecule with respect to the SERS surface (which results

Among the principal outcomes is an empirical multiple correlation between the travel time of the nitrate fertilizer pollutant, water table depth, and equivalent saturated

Purpose: The aim of this study was to investigate the role of S-phase kinase associated protein (Skp2) in the development of nodal metastasis and to assess its influence on

This, however, does not apply to Hans: his profoundly social atti- tude added to the fact that he applied the critical method to many areas of intellectual life (including theology:

In this study, we systematically investigated the effects of MRI acquisition and tractography parameters on the diffusion-based tractography reconstruction of the AR using