A Discrete-Choice Econometrician's Tale of Monetary Policy Identification and Predictability

Testo completo

(1)A discrete-choice econometrician’s tale of monetary policy identification and predictability. Andrei Sirchenko. Thesis submitted for assessment with a view to obtaining the degree of Doctor of Economics of the European University Institute. Florence, November, 2012.

(2) Sirchenko, Andrei (2012), A Discrete-Choice Econometrician’s Tale of Monetary Policy Identification and Predictability European University Institute DOI: 10.2870/60780.

(3) European University Institute Department of Economics. A discrete-choice econometrician’s tale of monetary policy identification and predictability. Andrei Sirchenko. Thesis submitted for assessment with a view to obtaining the degree of Doctor of Economics of the European University Institute Examining Board Professor Helmut Lütkepohl, DIW Berlin and Freie Universität Berlin (External Supervisor) Professor Peter Hansen, European University Institute Professor Michael Beenstock, Hebrew University of Jerusalem Professor James D. Hamilton, University of California Professor Matthew Neidell, Columbia University. © Andrei Sirchenko, 2012 No part of this thesis may be copied, reproduced or transmitted without prior permission of the author. Sirchenko, Andrei (2012), A Discrete-Choice Econometrician’s Tale of Monetary Policy Identification and Predictability European University Institute DOI: 10.2870/60780.


(5) '*+3(! #)!*0/. "BKLM H? :EE MABL MA>LBL PHNE= GHM A:O> ;>>G PKBMM>G PBMAHNM MA> LI:KD H? <NKBHLBMR @BO>G MH F> ;R FR I:K>GML MA> LMKHG@ BG<>GMBO>L IKHOB=>= ;R FR ?HKF>K LNI>KOBLHK :M MA> 1GBO>KLBMR H? %HP: &HAG #>P>D> :G= MA> BG<K>=B;E> I:MB>G<> :G= LNIIHKM H? FR PB?> +E@: PAH MHHD @K>:M <:K> H? F> :G= HNK <ABE=K>G =NKBG@ MA>L> ?HNK R>:KL % PHNE= EBD> MH MA:GD FR LNI>KOBLHK $>EFNM (mMD>IHAE PAH F:=> FR EB?> :L : ,A LMN=>GM >:LB>K I:MB>GMER K>:= :G= <HFF>GM>= HG :EE H? MA> <A:IM>KL :M =B]>K>GM LM:@>L :G= LNIIHKM>= F> BG F:GR P:RL % PHNE= EBD> MH >LI><B:EER MA:GD FR ?HKF>K :=OBLHK ):LLBFBEB:GH ):K<>EEBGH PAH =B= GHM E>M F> E>:O> MA> ,A IKH@K:F :G= PAH P:L : LHNK<> H? >QMK>F>ER A>EI?NE :=OB<> :G= LNIIHKM MAKHN@AHNM % :F =>>IER BG=>;M>= MH &:F>L $:FBEMHG ?HK F:DBG@ FR

(6) FHGMA LM:R :M MA> 1GBO>KLBMR H? :EB?HKGB: BG /:G B>@H IHLLB;E> :G= ?HK ABL <HGLMKN<MBO> ?>>=;:<D BG MA:M LMBFNE:MBG@ >GOBKHGF>GM % :F :ELH @K:M>?NE MH FR L><HG= :=OBLHK ,>M>K . $:GL>G PAH A:L ;>>G <HGLM:GMER :O:BE:;E> K>LHNK<>?NE :G= @>G>KHNLER A>EI?NE BG IHEBLABG@ MA> MABK= <A:IM>K % :F >JN:EER MA:GD?NE MH ):KD 3RGG> PAH BGMKH=N<>= F> MH MA> EBM>K:MNK> HG FHG>M:KR IHEB<R KNE>L :G= )B<A:>E >>GLMH<D PAH BGMKH=N<>= F> MH MA> EBM>K:MNK> HG S>KH

(7) BGU:MBHG BGLIBK>= FR K>L>:K<A BG MA> MABK= <A:IM>K <:K>?NEER K>:= :G= @>G>KHNLER <HFF>GM>= HG :EE H? MA> <A:IM>KL )R @K:MBMN=> @H>L MH MA> :=FBGBLMK:MBO> LM:] F>F;>KL '>G $NEE>R &>LLB<: /I:M:KH "K:GcHBL> 0A:NOBG &NEB: 2:E>KBH :G= (N<B: 2B@G: PAH A>EI>= F> FN<A FHK> MA:G K>JNBK>= ;R MA>BK CH;L :G= >LI><B:EER MH ):KMBG (>@G>K PAH F:=> FHLM H? MA> A>:OR <HFINM:MBHGL IHLLB;E> ;HMA K>FHM>ER :G= BG I:K:EE>E ):GR MA:GDL @H MH FR :F:SBG@ <E:LLF:M>L PAH F:=> MA>L> ?HNK R>:KL E>LL A><MB< FHK> BGM>K>LMBG@ :G= FHK> PB=>

(8) K:G@BG@ ':KHE BLS>D EH=HFBKH ">KK>BK: HFBGBD )>GGH &:G

(9) ,>M>K /B>=E:K>D ,BHMK /IB>P:GHPLDR KSN 1EN< MH F>GMBHG : ?>P /I><B:E MA:GDL @H MH FR HE= ?KB>G=L +E>@ 0LH=BDHO :G= #>HK@> .N;:G>GDH PAH >G

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irchenko, Andrei (2012), A Discrete-Choice Econometrician’s Tale of Monetary Policy Identification and Predictability European University Institute DOI: 10.2870/60780.

(11) 2:MMHO:GB PAH LNIIHKM>= :G= A>EI>= F> : EHM 0A> K>L>:K<A BG MA> TKLM <A:IM>K P:L LNIIHKM>= TG:G<B:EER ;R MA> #EH;:E >O>EHIF>GM *>MPHKDWL #K:GM *H .

(12) =BLMKB;NM>= OB: MA> @K:GM <HFI>MBMBHGL H? MA> !<HGHFB<L !=

(13) N<:MBHG :G= .>L>:K<A HGLHKMBNF !!. % :F :ELH @K:M>?NE MH !!. >QI>KML

(14) 3HC<A A:K>FS: :G= 2B<MHK ,HEM>KHOB<A

(15) ?HK O:EN:;E> <HFF>GML :G= LNIIHKM ,:MKB<D #K:A:F >:M: %=SBDHPLD: &:KHLk:P &:DN;BD &:DN; &:PHKHPLDB ):KRGB: 'KND 0HF:LS `RSB:D :K

(16) ;:K: /E:=DHPLD: ,BHMK /SING:K ):KD 3RGG> :G= .>NM>KL

(17) 3:KL:P ?HK A>EI PBMA H;M:BGBG@ LM:MBLMB<:E =:M: &H:H /:GMHL /BEO: ?HK ABL NL>?NE LN@@>LMBHGL :G= >QIE:G:MBHGL 0><AGH*%+( ?HK IKHOB=BG@ : <HFINM>K E>QBL >EB:GBG )B<A:k KSHS:

(18) KS>SBG: >:G KHNLAHK> :K

(19) BNLS "BE:K &HAG (>PBL 0BFH )BMS> H; .:L<A> G=KS>C /k:PB^GLDB :G= HMA>K I:KMB<BI:GML H? MA> /IKBG@ )>>MBG@ H? 5HNG@ !<HGHFBLML BG (BEE> %.*+ 3HKDLAHI HG ):<KH><HGHFB< "HK><:LMBG@ :G= ,HEB<R PBMA :M: .>OBLBHG BG )HGMK>:E :G= K>L>:K<A L>FBG:KL :M $B@A>K /<AHHE H? !<HGHFB<L BG )HL<HP :G= *:MBHG:E :GD H? ,HE:G= ?HK NL>?NE <HFF>GML 0A> LMN=R BG MA> L><HG= <A:IM>K P:L TG:G<B:EER LNIIHKM>= ;R MA> ,:=>K>PLDB #K:GM ?KHF MA> *:MHEBG !NKHI>:G >GM>K % PHNE= :ELH EBD> MH MA:GD >:M: B>KNM ):K<BG #K>E: 3BMHE= #KHLM:E *B<HE: $:K@K>:O>L &:KHLk:P &:G><DB RHNG@

(20) 'B 'BF &:<>D 'HMkHPLDB ):k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

(21) ?KHF MA> #EH;:E >O>EHIF>GM *>MPHKD :L P>EE :L MA> #K:GM ?KHF MA> *:MBHG:E :GD H? ,HE:G= % :F :ELH MA:GD?NE MH &dKi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irchenko, Andrei (2012), A Discrete-Choice Econometrician’s Tale of Monetary Policy Identification and Predictability European University Institute DOI: 10.2870/60780.

(22) . 0ABL MA>LBL LMN=B>L MA> ><HGHF>MKB< B=>GMBT<:MBHG :G= IK>=B<M:;BEBMR H? FHG>M:KR IHEB<R %M :==K>LL>L MA> =BL<K>M> :G= <HEE><MBO> G:MNK> H? IHEB<R =><BLBHGL :G= MA> NL> H? MA> K>:E

(23) MBF> O>KLNL <NKK>GMER :O:BE:;E> K>OBL>= =:M: 0A> TKLM <A:IM>K <HF;BG>L MA> HK=>K>= IKH;BM FH=>E GHO>E K>:E

(24) MBF> =:M: L>M :G= IHEB<R

(25) F:DBG@ F>>MBG@L :L : NGBM H? H;L>KO:MBHG MH >LMBF:M> AB@AER LRLM>F:MB< K>:<

(26) MBHG I:MM>KGL ;>MP>>G IHEB<R K:M> =><BLBHGL :G= BG<HFBG@ ><HGHFB< =:M: 0A> I:I>K IKHIHL>L : F>MAH=HEH@R MH F>:LNK> MA> >FIBKB<:E LB@GBT<:G<> H? MA> K:M> =BL<K>M>G>LL :G= =>FHGLMK:M>L MA:M ;HMA MA> =BL<K>M>

(27) <AHB<> :IIKH:<A :G= MA> K>:E

(28) MBF> IHEB<R

(29) F>>MBG@ =:M: =H F:MM>K BG MA> ><HGHF>MKB< B=>GMBT<:MBHG H? FHG>M:KR IHEB<R 0A> >LMBF:M>= KNE>L LNKI:LL MA> F:KD>M :GMB<BI:MBHG F:=> HG> =:R IKBHK MH : IHEB<R F>>M

(30) BG@ ;HMA BG :G= HNM H? L:FIE> 0A> L><HG= <A:IM>K IKHOB=>L >FIBKB<:E >OB=>G<> MA:M : IKHFIM>K K>E>:L> H? IHEB<R

(31) F:D>KLW OHM>L <HNE= BFIKHO> MA> IK>=B<M:;BEBMR H? IHEB<R =><BLBHGL 0A> OHMBG@ I:MM>KGL K>O>:E LMKHG@ :G= KH;NLM IK>=B<MBO> <HGM>GM >O>G :?M>K <HGMKHEEBG@ ?HK IHEB<R ;B:L :G= K>LIHGL>L MH BGU:MBHG K>:E :<MBOBMR >Q<A:G@> K:M>L :G= TG:G<B:E F:KD>M BG=B<:MHKL 0A>R <HGM:BG BG?HKF:MBHG GHM >F;>==>= BG MA> LIK>:=L :G= FHO>L BG MA> F:KD>M BG

(32) M>K>LM K:M>L GHK BG MA> >QIEB<BM ?HK><:LML H? MA> G>QM IHEB<R =><BLBHG F:=> ;R F:KD>M :G:ERLML )HK>HO>K MA> =BK><MBHG H? IHEB<RF:D>KLW =BLL>GM >QIE:BGL MA> =BK><MBHG H? :G:ERLMLW ?HK><:LM ;B:L 0A> MABK= <A:IM>K =>O>EHIL : MPH

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

(34) F:DBG@ I:MAL ?HK MAK>> MRI>L H? S>KH H;L>KO:MBHGL G>NMK:E S>KHL @>G>K:M>= =BK><MER ;R MA> G>NMK:E IHEB<R LM:G<> :G= MPH DBG=L H? H]L>M S>KHL EHHL> :G= MB@AM S>KHL @>G>K:M>= ;R MA> EHHL> HK MB@AM LM:G<> H]L>M :M MA> L><HG= LM:@> 0A> FH=>E BL :IIEB>= MH MA> BG=BOB=N:E IHEB<RF:D>KLW OHM>L ?HK MA> BGM>K>LM K:M> HMA MA> >FIBKB<:E :IIEB<:MBHGL :G= LBFNE:MBHGL =>FHGLMK:M> LNI>KBHKBMR PBMA K>LI><M MH MA> <HGO>GMBHG:E FH=>EL. BBB. Sirchenko, Andrei (2012), A Discrete-Choice Econometrician’s Tale of Monetary Policy Identification and Predictability European University Institute DOI: 10.2870/60780.

(35) BO. Sirchenko, Andrei (2012), A Discrete-Choice Econometrician’s Tale of Monetary Policy Identification and Predictability European University Institute DOI: 10.2870/60780.

(36) ""! . 1642(7'6-21. ,%36)45. . )+ !(%*# )+*!0.5 ,+(%5 %* .!( 0%)! +!/ %/.!0!*!// )0

(37) 0!. %GMKH=N<MBHG . . .>E:M>= EBM>K:MNK> . . :<D@KHNG= H? ,HEBLA FHG>M:KR IHEB<R . . . . :M: :G= FH=>EBG@ ?K:F>PHKD . BL<K>M>G>LL H? IHEB<R K:M>L . . . +K=>K>= IKH;BM FH=>E . . . ,HEB<R F>>MBG@L :L : NGBM H? H;L>KO:MBHG . . . 3A:M =H>L MA> ), P:M<A . . . .>:E

(38) MBF> =:M: . . . 0>LML ?HK LMKN<MNK:E <A:G@> . . !LMBF:MBHG K>LNEML . . . 0>LML ?HK LM:MBHG:KBMR . . . G BGM>KBF R>:K H? . . . 0A> LM:;BEBMR H? IHEB<R K>LIHGL>L . . . ,HEB<R K>:<MBHG IKBHK MH IKBE . . . %GM>K>LM K:M> LFHHMABG@ . . . HFI:KBLHG PBMA F:KD>M :GMB<BI:MBHG . . . ,HEB<R K>:<MBHG :?M>K IKBE . . . +NM

(39) H?

(40) L:FIE> ?HK><:LMBG@ . . . H>L K>:E

(41) MBF> VIHEB<R

(42) F>>MBG@W =:M: F:MM>K . . . H>L =BL<K>M>G>LL F:MM>K . . /NFF:KR :G= <HG<ENLBHGL . . "B@NK>L . . 0:;E>L . . .>?>K>G<>L . . O. Sirchenko, Andrei (2012), A Discrete-Choice Econometrician’s Tale of Monetary Policy Identification and Predictability European University Institute DOI: 10.2870/60780.

(43) ,+(%5)'!./W 2+0!/ *. ,.! %0%(%05 +" )+*!0.5 ,+(%5. %GMKH=N<MBHG 2HM>L :G= =BLL>GM :FHG@ IHEB<RF:D>KL :M: :G= ><HGHF>MKB< FH=>E H OHMBG@ K><HK=L F:MM>K 0A> ><HGHF>MKB< >OB=>G<> H OHMBG@ K><HK=L BG :==BMBHG MH K>E>O:GM ><HGHFB< =:M: A>EI MH IK>

(44) =B<M MA> G>QM IHEB<R K:M> =><BLBHG HNE= OHMBG@ K><HK=L :== BG?HKF:MBHG MH IKBO:M> L><MHK :GMB<BI:MBHG H OHMBG@ K><HK=L >GA:G<> IHEB<R IK>=B<M:;BEBMR ;>RHG= MA> IKBO:M> L><MHK :GMB<BI:MBHG :G MA> =BK><MBHG H? =BLL>GM :G= =BLI>KLBHG H? OHM>L >QIE:BG MA> =BK><

(45) MBHG H? ;B:L :G= NG<>KM:BGMR H? IKBO:M> L><MHK ?HK><:LML HG<ENLBHGL "B@NK>L 0:;E>L .>?>K>G<>L II>G=BQ >L<KBIMBHG H? =:M: . . )+ !( "+. +. %*( .!/,+*/!/ 3%0$ * ,,(%0%+* 0+ ,+(%5 %*0!.!/0 .0! %GMKH=N<MBHG .>E:MBHG MH >QBLMBG@ EBM>K:MNK> 0A> ><HGHF>MKB< ?K:F>PHKD 0A> FB==E>

(46) BGU:M>= HK=>K>= IKH;BM )%+, FH=>E 0A> G>LM>= HK=>K>= IKH;BM *+, FH=>E .>E:QBG@ :LLNFIMBHG H? BG=>I>G=>GM =BLMNK;:G<>L ,:KMB:E >]><ML )H=>E <HFI:KBLHG "BGBM> L:FIE> I>K?HKF:G<> )HGM> :KEH =>LB@G )HGM> :KEH K>LNEML G :IIEB<:MBHG MH IHEB<R BGM>K>LM K:M> :M: !LMBF:MBHG K>LNEML HG<ENLBHGL OB. Sirchenko, Andrei (2012), A Discrete-Choice Econometrician’s Tale of Monetary Policy Identification and Predictability European University Institute DOI: 10.2870/60780.

(47) +*0!*0/ "B@NK>L . 0:;E>L .>?>K>G<>L II>G=BQ >M:BEL H? )HGM> :KEH =>LB@G II>G=BQ /NFF:KR H? )HGM> :KEH K>LNEML II>G=BQ /NIIE>F>GM:E HNMINM ?KHF :IIEB<:MBHG. . OBB. Sirchenko, Andrei (2012), A Discrete-Choice Econometrician’s Tale of Monetary Policy Identification and Predictability European University Institute DOI: 10.2870/60780.

(48) OBBB. Sirchenko, Andrei (2012), A Discrete-Choice Econometrician’s Tale of Monetary Policy Identification and Predictability European University Institute DOI: 10.2870/60780.

(49) %46 1642(7'6-21. . Sirchenko, Andrei (2012), A Discrete-Choice Econometrician’s Tale of Monetary Policy Identification and Predictability European University Institute DOI: 10.2870/60780.


(51) ):GR :<:=>FB< ><HGHFBLML :G= <>GMK:E ;:GD IK:<MBMBHG>KL GHP:=:RL L>>F MH :@K>> MA:M MK:GLI:K>GM :G= IK>=B<M:;E> ;>A:OBHK GHM HGER IKHFHM>L MA> <K>=B;BEBMR :G= =>FH<K:MB< :<

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

(53) F:DBG@ F>>M

(54) BG@L H? FHG>M:KR :NMAHKBMR :L : NGBM H? H;L>KO:MBHG OHMBG@ K><HK=L H? BGM>K>LM

(55) K:M>

(56) L>MMBG@ F>>MBG@L :G= K>:E

(57) MBF> =:M: 0A> IKHIHL>= F>MAH=HEH@B<:E ?K:F>PHKD <:K>?NEER FBFB<L MA> :<MN:E IHEB<R

(58) :<MBHG

(59) @>G>

(60) K:MBG@ IKH<>LL LBG<> B FHLM F:CHK <>GMK:E ;:GDL :EM>K BGM>K>LM K:M>L ;R =BL<K>M>

(61) O:EN>= :=CNLMF>GML MRIB<:EER FNEMBIE>L H? ;:LBL IHBGML BB IHEB<R =><BLBHGL :K> G:MNK:EER F:=> NLBG@ BG?HKF:MBHG :O:BE:;E> BG MA> K>:E

(62) MBF> L>MMBG@ BBB MA>R :K> MRIB<:EER F:=>

(63) MBF>L I>K R>:K :M LI><B:E IHEB<RF:DBG@ F>>MBG@L BO MA> O:LM F:CHKBMR H? <>GMK:E ;:GDL >GMKNLM MA> <HG=N<M H? FHG>M:KR IHEB<R MH : <HFFBMM>> <HFIHL>= H? A>M>KH@>G>HNL :G= JNBM> H?M>G =BLL>GMBG@ F>F;>KL :G= O GH

(64) <A:G@> =><BLBHGL <HFFHGER <HGLMBMNM> :G :;LHENM> F:CHKBMR :G= <:G ;> IHM>GMB:EER @>G>K:M>= ;R =B]>K>GM =><BLBHG

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

(66) @>G>K:MBG@ IKH<>LL :G= :IIERBG@ : LBG@E>

(67) >JN:MBHG FH=>E +;OBHNLER LN<A IK:<MB<> E>:=L MH FBLLI><BT<:MBHG H? MA> :<MN:E =:M:

(68) @>G>K:MBG@ IKH<>LL :G= =BLMHKML MA> BG?>K>G<> ;><:NL> B MA> K>@K>LLBHG F>MAH=L ?HK : <HGMBGNHNL =>I>G=>GM O:KB:;E> :K> LAHPG MH ;> BG:=>JN:M> PA>G MA> =>I>G=>GM O:KB:;E> BL =BL<K>M> BB MA> E:M>LM O>KLBHGL H? LM:MBLMB<:E =:M: F:R =B]>K ?KHF MA> K>:E

(69) MBF> HG>L =N> MH MA> K>OBLBHGL BBB MA> MBF> :@@K>@:MBHG H? =:M: FBL:EB@GL MA> MBFBG@ H? IHEB<R =><BLBHGL :G= MA> :O:BE:;BEBMR H? LM:MBLMB<:E =:M: :L P>EE :L K:BL>L MA> IKH;E>F H? LBFNEM:G>BMR BO MA> ?:BENK> MH :==K>LL MA> A>M>KH@>G>BMR H? IHEB<R IK>?>K>G<>L <:G E>:= MH :G BG>\G<R :G= >O>G ;B:L B? MA> FH=>E BL GHG

(70) EBG>:K ;>LB=>L MABL MA> =BLL>GM :FHG@ MA> IHEB<RF:D>KL :M MA> E:LM F>>MBG@ F:R <:KKR : LMKHG@ ABGM :;HNM PA>K> IHEB<R K:M>L FB@AM FHO> BG MA> ?NMNK> :G= O MA> :LLNFIMBHG H? : AHFH@>G>HNL IHINE:MBHG PA>G MA> =:M: :K> :<MN:EER @>G>K:M>= ;R =B]>K>GM IKH<>LL>L. Sirchenko, Andrei (2012), A Discrete-Choice Econometrician’s Tale of Monetary Policy Identification and Predictability European University Institute DOI: 10.2870/60780.

(71) . %*0.+ 10%+*. <:NL>L ;B:L BG >LMBF:M>L L>I:K:M> <HGMKB;NMBHG H? MABL MA>LBL BL : G>P F>MAH=HEH@R ?HK FH=>EBG@ MA> HK=BG:E O:KB:;E>L PAB<A BL EBD>ER MH ;> ?KNBM?NEER :IIEB>= MH MA> HK=>K>= =:M: LN<A :L MA> :MMBMN=>L HIBGBHGL HK =BL<K>M> <A:G@>L MH MA> K:GDBG@ MA:M :K> <A:K:<M>KBS>= ;R MA> :;NG=:GM H;L>K

(72) O:MBHGL BG MA> FB==E> G>NMK:E HK S>KH <:M>@HKR GHMA>K L>I:K:M> <HGMKB;NMBHG BL MA> <HFIBE:MBHG H? GHO>E ,HEBLA K>:E

(73) MBF> =:M: L>M BG

(74) <HKIHK:MBG@ MA> HKB@BG:E MBF> L>KB>L :O:BE:;E> MH IHEB<RF:D>KL :M >:<A IHEB<R

(75) L>MMBG@ F>>MBG@ =NKBG@ MA>

(76) I>KBH= 0A> TKLM <A:IM>K :LL>LL>L L>I:K:M>ER MA> LM:MBLMB<:E >]><ML H? NLBG@ MA> EBG>:K K>@K>LLBHG FH=>E BGLM>:= H? MA> HK=>K>= IKH;BM +, FH=>E :G= MA> E:M>LM K>OBL>= FHGMAER

(77) :O>K:@>= =:M: BGLM>:= H? K>:E

(78) MBF> =:M: PBMA MA> IHEB<R

(79) F:DBG@ F>>MBG@L :L : NGBM H? H;L>KO:MBHG 0A> ?HKF:E <HFI:KBLHG =>FHGLMK:M>L MA:M MA> =BL<K>M>G>LL :G= K>:E

(80) MBF> =:M: BG=>>= F:MM>K BG MA> >FIBKB<:E B=>GMBT<:MBHG H? ,HEBLA FHG>M:KR IHEB<R 0A> LMN=R =>M><ML LMKN<MNK:E ;K>:DL BG IHEB<R PAB<A LPBM<A>= BML ?H<NL ?KHF <NKK>GM MH >QI><M>= BGU:MBHG :G= ?KHF >Q<A:G@> K:M> MH K>:E :<MBOBMR 0A> K>LIHGL> MH BGU:MBHG:KR >QI><M:MBHG BL LAHPG MH ;> AB@AER :LRFF>MKB<:E =>I>G=BG@ HG PA>MA>K MA> >QI><M:MBHG BL :;HO> HK ;>EHP MA> BGU:MBHG M:K@>M 0A> IHEB<R K:M> :II>:KL MH ;> =KBO>G ;R D>R ><HGHFB< BG=B<:MHKL PBMAHNM >OB=>G<> ?HK BGM>GMBHG:E BGM>K>LM

(81) K:M> LFHHMABG@ ;R MA> <>GMK:E ;:GD 0A> >LMBF:M>= KNE>L <HKK><MER >QIE:BG I>K<>GM H? H;L>KO>= IHEB<R :<MBHGL :G= LNKI:LL MA> F:KD>M :GMB<BI:MBHG F:=> HG> =:R IKBHK MH : IHEB<R F>>MBG@ ;HMA BG :G= HNM H? L:FIE> 0A> L><HG= <A:IM>K IKHOB=>L >FIBKB<:E >OB=>G<> :L K>@:K=L PA>MA>K MA> OHMBG@ K><HK=L H? MA> E:LM IHEB<RF:DBG@ F>>MBG@ <HNE= BFIKHO> MA> IK>=B<M:;BEBMR :G= IKBO:M> L><MHK :GMB<

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

(83) F:DBG@ IKH<>LL H? MA> <>GMK:E ;:GD 0ABL PHKD GHM HGER >QM>G=L MA> L<:K<> >FIBKB<:E EBM>K:MNK> ;NM :ELH F:D>L : <HGMKB;NMBHG BG MA> ?HEEHPBG@ =BK><MBHGL "BKLM =H OHMBG@ K><HK=L BG :==BMBHG MH K>E>O:GM ><HGHFB< =:M: A>EI MH ?HK><:LM MA> G>QM IHEB<R K:M> =><BLBHG /><HG= <HNE= =BLL>GMBG@ OHM>L B? MA>R P>K> :O:BE:;E> :== BG?HKF:MBHG MH MA> F:KD>M >QI><M:MBHGL H? NI<HFBG@ IHEB<R =><BLBHGL 0ABK= =H OHMBG@ K><HK=L >GA:G<> IHEB<R IK>=B<M:;BEBMR ;>RHG= MA> IKBO:M> L><MHK :GMB<BI:MBHG G=. Sirchenko, Andrei (2012), A Discrete-Choice Econometrician’s Tale of Monetary Policy Identification and Predictability European University Institute DOI: 10.2870/60780.

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

(85) F:DBG@ IKH<>LL>L >LB=>L MA> IHLBMBO> :G= G>@:MBO> HNM<HF>L <:G ;> =KBO>G ;R =BLMBG<M LHNK<>L %G LN<A : LBMN:MBHG BM PHNE= ;> : FBLLI><BT<:MBHG MH MK>:M :EE MA> H;L>KO:MBHGL :L >F:G:MBG@ ?KHF MA> L:F> IKH<>LL :G= MH :IIER : LM:G=:K= HK=>K>=

(86) K>LIHGL> FH=>E ;:L>= HG : LBG@E> E:M>GM >JN:MBHG 0A> MABK= <A:IM>K =>O>EHIL : FHK> U>QB;E> <KHLL

(87) G>LM>= FH=>E ?HK LN<A MRI>L H? HK=BG:E O:KB:;E>L <HF;BGBG@ MAK>> +, E:M>GM >JN:MBHGL PBMA IHLLB;ER =B]>K>GM L>ML H? <HO:KB:M>L 0A> IKHIHL>= FB==E>

(88) <:M>@HKR

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

(90) <A:G@> HNM<HF> BL BGU:M>= LBG<> MA>K> :K> MA> ?HEEHPBG@ MAK>> MRI>L H? S>KHL MA> :EP:RL HK G>NMK:E S>KHL @>G>K:M>= =BK><MER ;R MA> G>NMK:E IHEB<R K>:<MBHG MH MA> ><HGHFB< =>O>EHIF>GML :G= MPH DBG=L H? GHM

(91) :EP:RL HK H]L>M S>KHL MA> EHHL> :G= MB@AM S>KHL @>G>K:M>= ;R MA> EHHL> HK MB@AM IHEB<R BG<EBG:MBHGL H]L>M ;R MA> BGLMBMNMBHG:E ?:<MHKL 0A> FH=>E :ELH :EEHPL ?HK MA> IHLLB;E> <HKK>E:MBHG :FHG@ MA> MAK>> E:M>GM =><BLBHGL 0A> )HGM> :KEH K>LNEML LN@@>LM @HH= I>K?HKF:G<> H? MA> )%+, FH=>E BG MA> TGBM> L:F

(92) IE>L :G= =>FHGLMK:M> BML LNI>KBHKBMR PBMA K>LI><M MH MA> <HGO>GMBHG:E :G= G>LM>= +, FH=>EL. Sirchenko, Andrei (2012), A Discrete-Choice Econometrician’s Tale of Monetary Policy Identification and Predictability European University Institute DOI: 10.2870/60780.

(93) . %*0.+ 10%+*. 0A> )%+, FH=>E BL MA>G :IIEB>= MH >QIE:BG IHEB<R K:M> =><BLBHGL H? MA> *:MBHG:E :GD H? ,HE:G= NLBG@ MA> I:G>E H? MA> BG=BOB=N:E OHM>L H? IHEB<RF:D>KL :G= K>:E

(94) MBF> F:<KH><H

(95) GHFB< =:M: :O:BE:;E> :M MA> IHEB<R F>>MBG@L 0A> MPH

(96) LM:@> MAK>>

(97) K>@BF> :IIKH:<A :MM>FIML MH :==K>LL MA> PHKE=PB=> LMREBS>= ?:<ML H? BGM>K>LM K:M> L>MMBG@ LN<A :L MA> =BL<K>M>G>LL IK>IHG=>K:G<> H? GH

(98) <A:G@> =><BLBHGL :G= BG>KMB: 0A> OHMBG@ IK>?>K>G<>L :II>:K>= MH ;> P>EE

(99) FH=>E>= ;R LN<A :G :IIKH:<A *HM HGER =H>L BM TM MA> =:M: FN<A ;>MM>K ;NM BM :ELH A:L LHF> BFIHKM:GM :=O:GM:@>L HO>K MA> LBG@E>

(100) :G= MPH

(101) >JN:MBHG FH=>EL LN<A :L MA> LM:G=:K= +, FNEMBGHFB:E IKH;BM :G= S>KH

(102) BGU:M>= +, FH=>EL 0A> >FIBKB<:E :IIEB<:MBHG =>FHG

(103) LMK:M>L MA> :=O:GM:@>L H? MA> )%+, FH=>E BG L>I:K:MBG@ =B]>K>GM =><BLBHG

(104) F:DBG@ I:MAL ?HK MAK>> MRI>L H? S>KHL :G= >LMBF:MBG@ MA> IKHIHKMBHG H? S>KHL @>G>K:M>= ;R >:<A K>@BF>. Sirchenko, Andrei (2012), A Discrete-Choice Econometrician’s Tale of Monetary Policy Identification and Predictability European University Institute DOI: 10.2870/60780.

(105) %46 ,%36)45. . Sirchenko, Andrei (2012), A Discrete-Choice Econometrician’s Tale of Monetary Policy Identification and Predictability European University Institute DOI: 10.2870/60780.


(107) ,%36)4 2()/-1+ 021)6%4; 32/-'; -1 4)%/ 6-0) 2)5 (-5'4)6)1)55 0%66)4 . 1642(7'6-21 X0A> <>GMK:E ;:GD FNLM A:O> : AB@AER K>@NE:K :G= IK>=B<M:;E> IHEB<R KNE> HK K>LIHGL> I:MM>KG MA:M EBGDL IHEB<R :<MBHGL MH MA> LM:M> H? MA> ><HGHFR Y Z 3 ,HHE> MA>G

(108) ,K>LB=>GM H? MA> ">=>K:E .>L>KO> :GD H? /M (HNBL X%M BL GHM IHLLB;E> MH F:D> NL> H? : LBFIE> IHEB<R KNE> PAB<A <HNE= ;> DGHPG >Q :GM> MH F:KD>M I:KMB<BI:GML Y Z )HG>M:KR ,HEB<R HNG<BE *:MBHG:E :GD H? ,HE:G=. 0A> =BL<K>M>G>LL H? IHEB<R K:M>L ;HMA BG F:@GBMN=> MA> :=CNLMF>GML :K> MRIB<:EER F:=> BG FNEMBIE>L H? ;:LBL IHBGML :G= MBFBG@ MA> IHEB<R :<MBHGL M:D> IE:<> NLN:EER

(109) MBF>L : R>:K BL : <HFFHG ?>:MNK> H? <HGM>FIHK:KR FHG>M:KR IHEB<R

(110) F:DBG@ BG F:GR <HNGMKB>L 0ABL LMN=R :IIEB>L :G >FIBKB<:E F>MAH=HEH@R P>EE LNBM>= ?HK F:GR <>GMK:E ;:GDL BG HK=>K MH B=>GMB?R MA> FHG>M:KR IHEB<R ;R <HF;BGBG@ MA> NL> H? =BL<K>M>

(111) <AHB<> :IIKH:<A K>:E

(112) MBF> =:M: :G= IHEB<RF:DBG@ F>>MBG@L H? FHG>M:KR :NMAHKBMR :L : NGBM H? H;L>KO:MBHG 0A> I:I>K >LMBF:M>L AB@AER LRLM>F:MB< K>LIHGL> I:MM>KGL ;>MP>>G MA> BGM>K>LM K:M> =><BLBHGL H? MA> *:MBHG:E :GD H? ,HE:G= *, :G= BG<HFBG@ ><HGHFB< =:M: :O:BE:;E> ;HMA ?HK IHEB<RF:D>KL :G= ?HK IKBO:M> IN;EB< BG MA> K>:E

(113) MBF> L>MMBG@ 0A> LI><BT<:MBHG L>:K<A BL <HG=N<M>= PBMA : PB=> LI><MKNF H? IHM>GMB:E >QIE:G:MHKR O:KB:;E>L :FHG@ MAHL> FHGBMHK>= ;R MA> <>GMK:E . />> ,HHE> />> X)HG>M:KR IHEB<R @NB=>EBG>LY ?HK MA> R>:KL :G= > @ L>> *, I . . Sirchenko, Andrei (2012), A Discrete-Choice Econometrician’s Tale of Monetary Policy Identification and Predictability European University Institute DOI: 10.2870/60780.

(114) . $,0!. . ;:GD :G= BL K>TG>= ;R MA> G=K>PLW M>LML ?HK : LMKN<MNK:E <A:G@> PBMA :G NGDGHPG <A:G@> IHBGM 0ABL I:I>K <HFI:K>L MA> =BL<K>M>

(115) K>LIHGL> O>KLNL <HGO>GMBHG:E <HGMBGNHNL :IIKH:<A MH >LMBF:M> MA> IHEB<R KNE>L :G= :ELH LAHPL MA:M NLBG@ MA> FHGMAER :O>K:@>L H? >Q IHLM K>OBL>= =:M: BGLM>:= H? K>:E

(116) MBF> GHG

(117) :@@K>@:M>= =:M: =BLMHKML HNK NG=>KLM:G=BG@ H? IHEB<R =><BLBHGL L>I:K:M> <HGMKB;NMBHG H? MABL I:I>K BL MA> <HFIBE:MBHG H? ,HEBLA K>:E

(118) MBF> =:M: L>M BG<HKIHK:MBG@ MA> HKB@BG:E MBF> L>KB>L PAB<A P>K> :<MN:EER :O:BE:;E> MH IHEB<RF:D>KL :M >:<A IHEB<R

(119) L>MMBG@ F>>MBG@ =NKBG@ MA> I>KBH=

(120) 0H MA> ;>LM H? FR DGHPE>=@> LN<A : =:M: L>M A:L G>O>K ;>>G NL>= BG FH=>EBG@ ,HEBLA FHG>M:KR IHEB<R :G= A:L IKHO>= MH ;> ?KNBM?NE ):GR ><HGHFB< =><BLBHGL K>ER HG BGU:MBHG:KR >QI><M:MBHGL PABE> BGU:MBHG IK>=B<M:;BEBMR =>I>G=L HG MA> <HGLBLM>G<R H? FHG>M:KR IHEB<R )HK> MK:GLI:K>GM :G= IK>=B<M:;E> ;>A:OBHK H? <>GMK:E ;:GD BML>E? BFIKHO>L MA> MK:GLFBLLBHG :G= >]><MBO>G>LL H? FHG>M:KR IHEB<R :L F:GR :<:=>FB< ><HGHFBLML :G= <>GMK:E ;:GDLW IK:<MBMBHG>KL GHP:=:RL L>>F MH :@K>> +O>K MA> I:LM MPH =><:=>L FHLM <>GMK:E ;:GDL BG<EN=BG@ MA> *, A:O> K:=B<:EER BG<K>:L>= MA>BK IN;EB< <HFFNGB<:MBHG :L P>EE :L MA> =BL<EHLNK> H? BGM>KG:E BG?HKF:MBHG :G= F>MAH=HEH@R NL>= BG FHG>M:KR IHEB<R

(121) F:DBG@ G H;OBHNL P:R MH ?:<BEBM:M> MA> IK>=B<M:;BEBMR H? FHG>M:KR IHEB<R BL MH NMBEBS> : XKNE>Y PAB<A BL XGHMABG@ FHK> MA:G : LRLM>F:MB< =><BLBHG

(122) F:DBG@ IKH<>LL MA:M NL>L BG?HKF:MBHG BG : <HGLBLM>GM :G= IK>=B<M:;E> P:RY )>EMS>K /M:KMBG@ :M E>:LM PBMA : <E:LLB< I:I>K ;R 'R=E:G= :G= ,K>L<HMM F:GR ><HGHFBLML <HG<EN=> MA:M IK>

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`RSB:D >M :E HG MA> MK:GLI:K>G<R H? *, FHG>M:KR IHEB<R />> > @ :KKH :G= #HK=HG : ; :KKH :EOH E:KB=: >M :E >GGBL :G= /H=>KLMKHF /O>GLLHG : ; 0:REHK 3HH=?HK= : 0A> XKNE>L O>KLNL =BL<K>MBHGY :<:=>FB< =>;:M> A:L : EHG@ ABLMHKR Z L>> > @ 3B<DL>EE /BFHGL . Sirchenko, Andrei (2012), A Discrete-Choice Econometrician’s Tale of Monetary Policy Identification and Predictability European University Institute DOI: 10.2870/60780.

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

(125) M>KF F:KD>M BGM>K>LM K:M>L "NKMA>KFHK> XB? IK:<MBMBHG>KL BG TG:G<B:E F:KD>ML @:BG : ;>MM>K NG=>KLM:G=BG@ H? AHP IHEB<R BL EBD>ER MH K>LIHG= MH BG<HFBG@ BG?HKF:MBHG :LL>M IKB<>L :G= ;HG= RB>E=L PBEE M>G= MH K>LIHG= MH ><HGHFB< =:M: BG P:RL MA:M ?NKMA>K MA> <>GMK:E ;:GDWL IHEB<R H;C><MBO>LY >KG:GD> %M FNLM ;> MA> <:L> MA:M MA> <>GMK:E ;:GD INKLN>L MA> K>@NE:KBMR H? LHF> LHKM MAHN@A MA>K> BL GH LBFIE> :G= TQ>= IHEB<R KNE> F><A:GB<:EER ?HEEHP>= NG=>K :EE <BK<NFLM:G<>L .:MA>K MA> <>GMK:E ;:GD I:RL :MM>GMBHG MH : O:KB>MR H? LM:MBLMB<:E =:M: :G= HMA>K BG?HKF:MBHG :G= <HGLB=>KL L>O>K:E :EM>KG:MBO> KNE>L NL>= :L IHEB<R @NB=>EBG>L :G= <HF;BG>= PBMA :G><=HM:E >OB=>G<> :G= CN=@F>GM 3> <:G K>:LHG:;ER :LLNF> MA:M MA> IHEB<R

(126) @>G>K:MBG@ IKH<>LL <HG

(127) LBLML H? MPH <HFIHG>GML G:F>ER : K>@NE:K :G= : GHG

(128) K>@NE:K <HFIHG>GM MA> <>GMK:E ;:GD K>:<ML <HGLBLM>GMER MH LHF> BGM>KG:E LHIABLMB<:M>= :LL>LLF>GM H? MA> ><HGHFR ;NM H<<:LBHG

(129) :EER BG MA> <:L> H? MK:GLBMHKR HK :GHF:EHNL LAH<DL MH MA> ><HGHFR LMKBD> TG:G<B:E <KBLBL G:MNK:E =BL:LM>K >M< =>I:KML ?KHF MA> K>@NE:KBMR 0A> LI><BT< <A:K:<M>KBLMB<L H? MA> LRL

(130) M>F:MB< <HFIHG>GM :K> BGLB=> : ;E:<D ;HQ Z MA>R :K> NGH;L>KO:;E> ?HK IN;EB< $HP>O>K P> <:G IKHQR ?HK MA> NG=>KERBG@ =>M>KFBG:GML H? IHEB<R :<MBHGL ;R EHHDBG@ :M MA> <HGL>JN>GMB:E LRLM>F:MB< EBGDL ;>MP>>G :=CNLMF>GML MH IHEB<R K:M>L :G= FHO>F>GML BG O:KBHNL H;L>KO:;E> ?NG=:F>GM:EL 0A> >LMBF:M>= FH=>EL K>IK>L>GMBG@ : LBFIEBT<:MBHG H? MKN> IHEB<R

(131) F:DBG@ IKH<>LL FB@AM >]><MBO>ER K>U><M BML >LL>G<> :G= <HNE= ;> :IIEB>= :L : NL>?NE ;>G<AF:KD ?HK >QIE:BGBG@ I:LM IHEB<R =><BLBHGL :G= IK>=B<MBG@ ?NMNK> HG>L >O>G MAHN@A MA> *, <>KM:BGER =H>L GHM OB>P BML>E? :L BFIE>F>GMBG@ : XLBFIE> IHEB<R KNE>Y >LB=>L DGHPBG@ : <>GMK:E ;:GDWL <HKK><M XK>:<MBHG ?NG<MBHGY BL :ELH : G><>LL:KR >E>F>GM H? F:<KH><HGHFB< FH=>EL NL>= MH ?HK><:LM =>O>EHIF>GML BG MA> ><HGHFR :G= MH >O:EN:M> MA> >]><ML H? ><HGHFB< LAH<DL :G= FHG>M:KR :G= TL<:E IHEB<R :<MBHGL "BG:EER X<E:KBMR :;HNM MA> <>GMK:E ;:GDWL IHEB<R H;C><MBO>L :G= LMK:M>@R F:R A>EI :G<AHK MA> IN;EB<WL EHG@

(132) M>KF BGU:MBHG >QI><M:MBHGL PAB<A <:G LN;LM:G

(133) MB:EER BFIKHO> MA> >\<:<R H? IHEB<R :G= MA> HO>K:EE ?NG<MBHGBG@ H? MA> ><HGHFRY >KG:GD> 0ABL I:I>K =B]>KL ?KHF MA> IK>OBHNL >FIBKB<:E K>L>:K<A HG ,HEBLA FHG>M:KR IHEB<R KNE>L BG MA> ?HEEHPBG@ :LI><ML B BM :<<HNGML ?HK MA> =BL<K>M>G>LL H? IHEB<R K:M>L ;R :IIERBG@ :G. Sirchenko, Andrei (2012), A Discrete-Choice Econometrician’s Tale of Monetary Policy Identification and Predictability European University Institute DOI: 10.2870/60780.

(134) . $,0!. . HK=>K>= IKH;BM FH=>E BB BM FH=>EL MA> IHEB<RF:D>KLW K>LIHGL> MH :G BG?HKF:MBHG L>M :O:BE:;E> :M MA> =><BLBHG

(135) F:DBG@ F>>MBG@L H? FHG>M:KR :NMAHKBMR K:MA>K MA:G MA> K>E:MBHGLABI ;>MP>>G MA> FHGMAER HK JN:KM>KER :O>K:@>L H? IHEB<R K:M> :G= ><HGHFB< BG=B<:MHKL BBB BM :OHB=L MA> =BLMHKMBHG H? BG?HKF:MBHG ;R NLBG@ HGER MA> K>:E

(136) MBF> =:M: B > MA> ABLMHKB<:E MBF> L>KB>L :L MA>R P>K> DGHPG :M :GR IHEB<R

(137) F:DBG@ F>>MBG@ K:MA>K MA:G MA> E:M>LM K>OBL>= O>KLBHGL H? =:M: BO BM :OHB=L MA> IKH;E>F H? LBFNEM:G>BMR PAB<A BL MRIB<:E ?HK MA> MBF>

(138) :@@K>@:M>= =:M: =N> MH IHLLB;E> BGM>K:<MBHGL ;>MP>>G MA> IHEB<R K:M> :G= HMA>K ><HGHFB< O:KB:;E>L MA:M <:G A:II>G =NKBG@ : I>KBH= H? :@@K>@:MBHG O BM <HG=N<ML MAHKHN@A M>LML ?HK LMKN<MNK:E <A:G@>L BG IHEB<R K>@BF> PBMA NGDGHPG <A:G@> IHBGM OB BM =BK><MER FH=>EL MA> :=FBGBLM>K>= IHEB<R K:M> K:MA>K MA:G MA> F:KD>M LAHKM

(139) M>KF BGM>K>LM K:M>L OBB BM :G:ERS>L MA> I>KBH=

(140) PA>G MA> LAHKM

(141) M>KF BGM>K>LM K:M>L A:O> ;>>G : IKBG<BI:E MHHE :G= : LBG@E> F>:LNK> H? FHG>M:KR IHEB<R OBBB BGLM>:= H? MA> E>O>E KNE>L BM >LMBF:M>L MA> =B]>K>G<> KNE>L MA:M :K> FHK> HI>K:MBHG:E :G= MK:GLI:K>GM ?HK IN;EB< BQ BM BL GHM ?H<NL>= HG : EBFBM>= :FHNGM H? LM:MBLMB<:E =:M: ;NM BGLM>:= NL>L BG MA> LI><BT<:MBHG L>:K<A : PB=> LI><MKNF H? ><HGHFB< :G= TG:G<B:E BG=B<:MHKL :G= Q MA> >LMBF:M>= BGM>K>LM K:M> KNE>L A:O> ?:K AB@A>K F>:LNK>L H? TM :G= HNM

(142) H?

(143) L:FIE> ?HK><:LMBG@ I>K?HKF:G<> 0A> I:I>K IKH<>>=L :L ?HEEHPL /><MBHG IKHOB=>L K>OB>P H? MA> K>E:M>= EBM>K:MNK> /><MBHG =BL<NLL>L MA> ;:<D@KHNG= H? MA> FHG>M:KR IHEB<R BG ,HE:G= /><MBHG =>L<KB;>L MA> =:M: :G= F>MAH=HEH@R /HF> ><HGHF>MKB< K>LNEML :K> IK>L>GM>= BG /><MBHG /><MBHG =>FHGLMK:M>L MA:M ;HMA MA> K>:E

(144) MBF> IHEB<R

(145) F>>MBG@ =:M: =H F:MM>K BG MA> ><HGHF>MKB< B=>GMBT<:MBHG H? ,HEBLA FHG>M:KR IHEB<R /><MBHG ?H<NL>L HG MA> <HFI:KBLHG H? MA> =BL<K>M>

(146) K>LIHGL> O>KLNL <HGO>GMBHG:E <HGMBGNHNL :IIKH:<A MH >LMBF:M> MA> IHEB<R KNE>L 0A> E:LM L><MBHG IKHOB=>L MA> LNFF:KR :G= <HG<EN=>L. . )/%6)( /-6)4%674). 0A> EBM>K:MNK> HG ,HEBLA FHG>M:KR IHEB<R KNE>L BL LNFF:KBS>= BG 0:;E> 0A>L> LMN=B>L >LMBF:M> MA> BGM>K>LM K:M> KNE>L ?HK MA> I>KBH= ?KHF

(147) MAKHN@A

(148) $HP>O>K IKBHK MH MA> ,HEBLA FHG>M:KR IHEB<R P:L K:MA>K ><E><MB< PBMA MA> F:G:@>= >Q<A:G@> K:M> K>@BF> :G= <A:G@BG@ IHEB<R BGLMKNF>GML MA> =BK><M BGU:MBHG M:K@>MBG@ PBMA MA> LAHKM

(149) M>KF BGM>K>LM K:M>L :L : IKBG<BI:E MHHE H? FHG>M:KR IHEB<R P:L HGER ?NEER BFIE>F>GM>= BG />O>K:E LMN=B>L >LMBF:M> *, K>:<MBHG ?NG<MBHGL BG MA> <HGM>QM H? O><MHK :NMHK>@K>LLBHG 2. FH=>EBG@ H? MA> ,HEBLA ><HGHFR #HEBG>EEB :G= .HO>EEB $KBLMHO 'kHL :G= />> +KIA:GB=>L :G= 3BEEB:FL ?HK : <HFI:KBLHG H? MA> E>O>E :G= =B]>K>G<> KNE> :IIKH:<A>L NG=>K MA> ?K:F>PHKD H? BFI>K?><M DGHPE>=@>. Sirchenko, Andrei (2012), A Discrete-Choice Econometrician’s Tale of Monetary Policy Identification and Predictability European University Institute DOI: 10.2870/60780.

(150) .!(0!. (%0!.01.!. . 3Kh;>E 'HDHLS<SR^GLDB >M :E ):EBLS>PLDB 3Kh;>E :G= ,:PkHPLD: $HP>O>K MA> 2.L :K> ?H<NL>= HG B=>GMB?RBG@ MA> FHG>M:KR IHEB<R LAH<DL :G= K>LIHGL>L H? D>R ><HGHFB< BG=B<:MHKL MH MA>F K:MA>K MA:G HG B=>GMB?RBG@ MA> BGM>K>LM K:M> K>:<MBHG ?NG<MBHGL 0A> IHEB<R KNE>L >LMBF:M>= NLBG@ MA> 2. FH=>EL MRIB<:EER A:O> IHHK BG

(151) :G= HNM

(152) H?

(153) L:FIE> ?HK><:LMBG@ I>K?HKF:G<> <HFI:K>= MH MA> GHG

(154) 2. FH=>EL L>> .N=>;NL<A : ; .N=>;NL<A IHBGML HNM MA> ?HEEHPBG@ LAHKM<HFBG@L H? MA> LM:G=:K= 2. BGM>K>LM K:M> KNE>L : MBF>

(155) BGO:KB:GM :G= EBG>:K LMKN<MNK> ; : EBFBM>= BG?HKF:MBHG L>M PAB<A E>:=L MH HFBMMBG@ MA> K>E>O:GM >QIE:G:MHKR O:KB:;E>L :G= < EHG@ =BLMKB;NM>= E:@L K>LNEMBG@ BG LINKBHNL BG

(156) L:FIE> TMMBG@ KSHSHPLDB :G= )HA:GMR :G= 'E:N >LMBF:M> MA> GHG

(157) 2. IHEB<R KNE>L HMA LMN=B>L NL> JN:KM>KER =:M: :O>K:@>L MA> E:MM>K :ELH MKB>L MA> FHGMAER :O>K:@>L LAHKM

(158) M>KF F:KD>M BGM>K>LM K:M>L :L : =>I>G=>GM O:KB:;E> :G= MA> 0:REHK

(159) KNE> LI><BT<:MBHG +GER : ?>P I:I>KL BG MA> >FIBKB<:E EBM>K:MNK> HG FHG>M:KR IHEB<R KNE>L :IIER MA> =BL<K>M> K>@K>LLBHG M><AGBJN>L MH :==K>LL MA> =BL<K>M>G>LL H? IHEB<R K:M>L /MN=B>L ;R NIHK >M :E $N :G= ,ABEBIL (:II >M :E :G= ,B:SS>LB NL> MA> HK=>K>= IKH;BM MH FH=>E MAK>> IHLLB;E> IHEB<R <AHB<>L MH =><K>:L> E>:O> NG<A:G@>= HK BG<K>:L> MA> BGM>K>LM K:M> H? MA> 1/ ">=>K:E .>L>KO> ">= PABE> N>D>K :G= $:FBEMHG :G= &HK=: >FIEHR MA> HK=>K>= IKH;BM PBMA TO> <:M>@HKB>L <HKK>LIHG=BG@ MH

(160) :G=

(161) ;:LBL IHBGM <A:G@>L !B<A>G@K>>G >M :E :G= :ONMR:G :G= ,:KD> :IIER MA> =RG:FB< HK=>K>= IKH;BM PBMA MAK>> :G= TO> <:M>@HKB>L K>LI><MBO>ER MH FH=>E MA> :GD H? !G@E:G=WL IHEB<R BGM>K>LM K:M> <A:G@>L HE:=H >M :E >LMBF:M> MA> BGM>K>LM K:M>

(162) L>MMBG@ ;>A:OBHK H? MA> :GJN> => "K:G<> MA> NG=>L;:GD MA> :G<H => !LI:g: :G= MA> ">=>K:E .>L>KO> NLBG@ MA> HK=>K>= IKH;BM FH=>E PBMA TO> <:M>@HKB>L ,H=IB>K: <HF;BG>L MA> HK=>K>= IKH;BM :G= <>GLHK>= K>@K>LLBHGL MH >LMBF:M> MA> BGM>K>LM K:M> KNE>L H? MA> ">= :G= MA> S><A *:MBHG:E :GD 'HMkHPLDB >LMBF:M>L : MKBIE>

(163) <AHB<> HK=>K>= EH@BM FH=>EBG@ MA> =BK><MBHG H? <A:G@> BG MA> K>LMKB<MBO>G>LL H? FHG>M:KR IHEB<R IKHIHL>= ;R : @BO>G F>F;>K H? MA> )HG>M:KR ,HEB<R HNG<BE BG ,HE:G= 0A> K>LMKB<MBO>G>LL BL F>:LNK>= ;R MA> IKHIHL>= <A:G@> H? IHEB<R ;B:L :G=HK <A:G@> MH MA> K>?>K>G<> K:M> 1G?HKMNG:M>ER MA> L:FIE> BG<EN=>L HGER FHGMAER H;L>KO:MBHGL ?HK MA> I>KBH= Z GHM >GHN@A ?HK : K>EB:;E> EBD>EBAHH= >LMBF:MBHG @KHPBG@ GNF;>K H? K><>GM PHKDL >FIEHR K>:E

(164) MBF> =:M: MH :==K>LL MA> LN;L>JN>GM K>

(165) 0:REHK IKHIHL>= : FHG>M:KR IHEB<R KNE> PA>K> MA> 1/ ">=>K:E .>L>KO> :EM>KL MA> ?>=>K:E ?NG=L K:M> :<<HK=BG@ MH

(166) PA>K>

(167) MA> X>JNBEB;KBNFY K>:E BGM>K>LM K:M>

(168) MA> EHG@

(169) KNG BGU:MBHG M:K@>M Z MA> BGU:MBHG K:M> HO>K : R>:K :L : IKHQR ?HK MA> >QI><M>= BGU:MBHG Z MA> HNMINM @:I MA> I>K<>GM =>OB:MBHG H? K>:E # , ?KHF MA> IHM>GMB:E HG> 0:REHK :LLNF>= :G= 0A> 0:REHK KNE> <HGMKB;NM>= MH : ;>MM>K NG=>KLM:G=BG@ H? FHG>M:KR IHEB<R :G= P:L PB=>ER FH=BT>= :G= >QM>G=>= BG : GNF;>K H? P:RL BG MA> LN;L>JN>GM EBM>K:MNK>. Sirchenko, Andrei (2012), A Discrete-Choice Econometrician’s Tale of Monetary Policy Identification and Predictability European University Institute DOI: 10.2870/60780.

(170) . $,0!. . OBLBHGL H? LM:MBLMB<:E =:M: :G= HO>KPA>EFBG@ER LAHP MA:M =B]>K>GM OBGM:@>L H? 1/ &:I:G>L> !NKH :K>: #>KF:G /PBLL :G= *HKP>@B:G =:M: E>:= MH LB@GBT<:GMER =B]>K>GM K>LNEML 0A>K>

(171) ?HK> MA> >LMBF:MBHG H? IHEB<R KNE>L ;:L>= HG >Q IHLM K>OBL>= =:M: =BLMHKML HNK NG=>KLM:G=BG@ H? I:LM FHG>M:KR IHEB<R Z :G H;OBHNL IHBGM ;NM HG> MA:M BL KHNMBG>ER G>@E><M>= ;R FHLM LMN=B>L 1LBG@ MA> =><BLBHG

(172) F:DBG@ F>>MBG@L H? FHG>M:KR :NMAHKBMB>L :L : NGBM H? H;L>KO:MBHG K>IK>L>GML :G :IIKH:<A MA:M <:K>?NEER FBFB<L MA> :<MN:E =><BLBHG

(173) F:DBG@ IKH<>LL ;NM L>>FL MH ;> <HFFHGER B@GHK>= BG MA> EBM>K:MNK> %GLM>:= K>L>:K<A>KL A:;BMN:EER >LMBF:M> MA> LRL

(174) M>F:MB< K>E:MBHGLABI ;>MP>>G MA> FHGMAER HK JN:KM>KER :O>K:@>L H? IHEB<R K:M>L :G= ><HGHFB< O:KB:;E>L. . %'.+4271( 2* 2/-5, 021)6%4; 32/-';. %G MA>

(175) I>KBH= MA> *, <HG=N<M>= BML FHG>M:KR IHEB<R ;R <HGMKHEEBG@ MA> FHG>R LNIIER @KHPMA :G= M:K@>MBG@ MA> >Q<A:G@> K:M> 0A> >Q<A:G@> K:M> K>@BF> P:L @K:=N:EER MK:GL?HKF>= ?KHF : F:G:@>= MH : ?K>>

(176) UH:MBG@ K>@BF> =NKBG@ MA> L 0A> FHGMAER K:M> H? <K:PE P:L IKH@K>LLBO>ER K>=N<>= ?KHF I>K<>GM BG MH I>K<>GM BG 0A> IK>

(177) :GGHNG<>= <K:PEBG@ I>@ LRLM>F P:L LNI>KL>=>= ;R MA> <K:PEBG@ ;:G= K>@BF> BG ):R 0A> <K:PEBG@ ;:G= PB=MA P:L PB=>G>= ?KHF I>K<>GM BG MH I>K<>GM BG :G= P:L TG:EER :;:G=HG>= Z BG IKBE MA> SEHMR H\<B:EER ;>@:G MH UH:M <MN:EER MA> *, LNLI>G=>= ?HK>B@G >Q<A:G@> BGM>KO>GMBHGL :EK>:=R BG FB=

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

(179) F:DBG@ ;H=R 0A> ), P:L ?HNG=>= BG ">;KN:KR LHHG :?M>K MA> BG=>I>G=>G<> H? MA> *, A:= ;>>G LMK>G@MA>G>= ;R MA> G>P HGLMBMNMBHG :G= MA> G>P <M HG MA> *, 0A> HNG<BE <HGLBLML H? MA> ,K>LB=>GM H? MA> *, :G= GBG> HMA>K F>F;>KL :IIHBGM>= BG >JN:E IKHIHKMBHGL ;R MA> />> > @ >KGA:K=L>G >M :E KHNLAHK> :G= /M:KD E:NL>G :G= )>B>K #>K;>K=BG@ #>K=>LF>B>K :G= .H\: #ARL>EL >M :E ':F:=: 'N@E>K >M :E (:GLBG@ +KIA:GB=>L >M :E +KIA:GB=>L : ; ,>K>S .NGDE> /M>KD>G 0>MEHP :G= %KHGLB=> />> *, . Sirchenko, Andrei (2012), A Discrete-Choice Econometrician’s Tale of Monetary Policy Identification and Predictability European University Institute DOI: 10.2870/60780.

(180) . 0 *. )+ !(%*# ".)!3+.'. . ,K>LB=>GM H? ,HE:G= MA> />CF :G= MA> />G:M> H? MA> ,:KEB:F>GM ?HK : M>KF H? LBQ R>:KL 0A> ), BFF>=B:M>ER LMHII>= MA> EHG@

(181) M>KF BGM>K>LM K:M> HI>K:MBHGL ;R LAHKM>GBG@ MA> F:QBFNF F:MNKBMR H? *,WL FHG>R ;BEEL ?KHF MH =:RL :;:G=HG>= MA> FHG>M:KR ;:L> M:K@>MBG@ >QI:G=>= MA> >Q<A:G@> K:M> U>QB;BEBMR MHP:K= MA> ?K>> UH:MBG@ LRLM>F BG<K>:L>= MA> KHE> H? LAHKM

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

(183) M>KF BGM>K>LM K:M>L F:R NG=HN;M>=ER ;> MK>:M>= :L : IKBG

(184) <BI:E BGLMKNF>GM :G= : LBG@E> F>:LNK> H? ,HEBLA FHG>M:KR IHEB<R /BG<> MA> IHEB<R K:M>L A:O> ;>>G :EP:RL L>M :=FBGBLMK:MBO>ER ;R MA> FHG>M:KR :NMAHKBMB>L :G= A:O> G>O>K ;>>G MA> HNM

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

(186) =>;M L><NKBMB>L Z A>EI MH ;:E:G<> MA> =>F:G= :G= LNIIER H? ?NG=L A>E= ;R MA> <HFF>K<B:E ;:GDL :M MA> <>GMK:E ;:GD :G= A:O> ;>>G NL>= MH F:G:@> MA> LAHKM

(187) M>KF BGM>K>LM K:M>L HG MA> BGM>K;:GD F:KD>M LBG<> .

(188)

(189) . %6% %1( 02()/-1+ *4%0)924. -5'4)6)1)55 2* 32/-'; 4%6)5. 0A> =>I>G=>GM O:KB:;E> BL : <A:G@> BG<EN=BG@ GHG

(190) S>KH HG>L MH MA> K>?>K>G<> K:M> F:=> ;R MA> ), :M : =><BLBHG

(191) F:DBG@ F>>MBG@ 0A> *, A:L :EP:RL :EM>K>= MA> E>O>EL H? IHEB<R "HK MA> K>E:M>= :IIEB<:MBHGL H? :G HK=>K>= IKH;BM FH=>E PBMA LN<A : MKBIE> <E:LLBT<:MBHG MH LMN=R ?HK >Q:FIE> MA> 1/ ">=>K:E ?NG=L K:M> M:K@>M L>> > @ NIHK >M :E $N :G= ,ABEBIL (:II >M :E 0A> K:M> HG

(192) =:R ?KHF MH

(193) =:R ?KHF MH :G=

(194) =:R LBG<> MH IK>L>GM *, FHG>R F:KD>M ;BEEL. Sirchenko, Andrei (2012), A Discrete-Choice Econometrician’s Tale of Monetary Policy Identification and Predictability European University Institute DOI: 10.2870/60780.

(195) . $,0!. . K:M>L BG =BL<K>M> :=CNLMF>GML Z MA> FNEMBIE>L H? ;:LBL IHBGML : JN:KM>K H? HG> I>K<>GM 0:;E> LAHPL MA> ABLMHKR H? MA> K>?>K>G<> K:M> ?HK MA> I>KBH=

(196) 0A> ?K>JN>G<R =BLMKB;NMBHG H? MA> K>?>K>G<> K:M> :=CNLMF>GML BL K>IHKM>= BG 0:;E> :EE ABLMHKB<:E K:M> <A:G@>L MHHD HGER >E>O>G O:EN>L ;>MP>>G

(197) :G= ;:LBL IHBGML 0:;E> :G= "B@NK> >QAB;BM MPH =BLMBG<M IA:L>L BG MA> ABLMHKB<:E ;>A:OBHK H? MA> K>?>K>G<> K:M> MA> AB@A

(198) OHE:MBEBMR I>KBH= IKBHK MH IKBE PA>G :EE <A:G@>L >Q<>IM MA> TKLM HG> BG ">;KN:KR P>K> ;R :;LHENM> O:EN> ;>MP>>G :G= ;:LBL IHBGML :G= MA> EHP

(199) OHE:MBEBMR I>KBH= LBG<> IKBE PA>G :EE <A:G@>L P>K> ;R :;LHENM> O:EN> >BMA>K HK ;:LBL IHBGML 0A> K>?>K>G<> K:M> :=CNLMF>GML :K> =BLMKB;NM>= A>M>KH@>G>HNLER HNM H? <A:G@>L ?:EE BGMH HNM H? H;L>KO>= =BL<K>M> <:L>L 0A>K> :K> MAK>> HK E>LL H;L>KO:MBHGL BG LBQ <:M>@HKB>L H? =>I>G=>GM O:KB:;E> 0ABL BL GHM LN\GM ?HK : K>EB:;E> F:QBFNF EBD>EBAHH= >LMBF:MBHG NLN:E :IIKH:<A NG=>K LN<A <BK<NFLM:G<>L BL MH <HGLHEB=:M> LHF> :=C:<>GM <:M>@HKB>L PBMA : LF:EE GNF;>K H? H;L>KO:MBHGL "HK >Q:FIE> P> <HNE= F>K@> :EE H;L>KO>= <A:G@>L BGMH ?HNK <:M>@HKB>L X=><K>:L>L H? HK FHK>Y X=><K>:L>L H? HK Y XGH <A:G@>Y :G= XBG<K>:L>LY PBMA :G= H;L>KO:MBHGL K>LI><MBO>ER $HP>O>K =N> MH MA> MPH :?HK>F>GMBHG>= I>KBH=L PBMA =B]>K>GM OHE:MBEBMR H? MA> K>?>K>G<> K:M> LN<A : JN:=KNIE> <E:LLBT<:MBHG =H>L GHM :EEHP ?HK MA> <HG=N<MBG@ H? MA> M>LML ?HK LMKN<MNK:E <A:G@> %G=>>= =NKBG@ MA> AB@A

(200) OHE:MBEBMR I>KBH=

(201) :EE K:M> <A:G@>L ?:EE BGMH ?HEEHPBG@ MAK>> <:M>@HKB>L X=><K>:L>L H? HK FHK>Y XGH <A:G@>Y HK XBG<K>:L>LY PABE> =NKBG@ MA> EHP

(202) OHE:MBEBMR I>KBH=

(203) MA> HGER MAK>> K>:EBS>= <:L>L :K> X=><K>:L> H? HK Y XGH <A:G@>Y HK XBG<K>:L>LY L>> 0:;E> ?M>K LIEBMMBG@ MA> L:FIE> :M :GR IHBGM IKBHK MH ):K<A HK :?M>K IKBE MA> =>I>G=>GM O:KB:;E> PBEE A:O> : =B]>K>GM GNF;>K H? <:M>@HKB>L MAK>> :G= ?HNK BG MA> MPH LN;

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

(205) P:L :G:ERS>= NLBG@ MA> TG>K JN:=KNIE> <E:LLBT<:MBHG X=HPG Y X=HPG Y XGH <A:G@>Y :G= XNIY Z PBMA :G= H;L>KO:MBHGL K>LI><MBO>ER L>> 0:;E> 0ABL <E:LLBT<:MBHG <EHL>ER <HKK>LIHG=L MH MA> ABLMHKB<:E IHEB<R K:M> :=CNLMF>GML BG MABL I>KBH= HGER MPH H;L>KO>= :=C:<>GM <:M>@HKB>L Z MA> XNI Y :G= XNI Y PBMA HG> :G= MPH H;L>KO:MBHGL K>LI><MBO>ER Z A:O> ;>>G <HGLHEB=:M>=. Sirchenko, Andrei (2012), A Discrete-Choice Econometrician’s Tale of Monetary Policy Identification and Predictability European University Institute DOI: 10.2870/60780.

(206) . 0 *.

(207) . )+ !(%*# ".)!3+.'. . 4()4)( 342&-6 02()/. 0H :==K>LL MA> =BL<K>M>G>LL H? =>I>G=>GM O:KB:;E> MABL I:I>K >FIEHRL :G HK=>K>= IKH;BM :IIKH:<A PAB<A ?HKFL : IKH;:;BEBLMB< ?HK><:LM H? =BL<K>M> :=CNLMF>GML MH MA> IHEB<R K:M> :L : GHGEBG>:K ?NG<MBHG H? >QIE:G:MHKR O:KB:;E>L 0ABL :IIKH:<A :LLNF>L :G NG=>KERBG@ E>O>E H? MA> K>?>K>G<> K:M> && MA:M PHNE= A:O> ;>>G H;L>KO>= A:= MA> *, ;>>G PBEEBG@ MH F:D> MA> <HGMBGNHNL K:MA>K MA:G =BL<K>M> <A:G@>L MH MA> K:M> M >O>KR IHEB<R

(208) K:M>

(209) L>MMBG@ F>>MBG@ ? MA> *, =>M>KFBG>L MA> <A:G@> && && && BG MABL E:M>GM K:M> :<<HK=BG@ MH MA> ?HEEHPBG@ ?HKFNE: && . . PA>K> ,,' 14/$.

(210) :G= BL : F:MKBQ MA:M F:R BG<HKIHK:M> :GR =:M: K>E>O:GM ?HK MA> IHEB<RF:D>KL :G= :O:BE:;E> :M =:M> ? ):MKBQ F:R BG<EN=> MA> O:KB:;E>L BG :GR ?HKF E>O>EL TKLM :G= L><HG= =B]>K>G<>L :G= :M :GR HKB@BG:E =:M: ?K>JN>G<R EMAHN@A && BL NGH;L>KO>= MA> *, :GGHNG<>L MA> H\<B:E B > H;L>KO>= :=CNLMF>GML MH MA> K>?>K>G<> K:M> && :<<HK=BG@ MH MA> ?HEEHPBG@ KNE> 6 B? && && 6 B? && :G= 5 6 B? && . . PA>K> 6 6 6 6 Z H;L>KO>= =BL<K>M>

(211) O:EN>= <A:G@>L MH MA> IHEB<R K:M> FNEMBIE>L H? MA> ;:LBL IHBGML BL : GNF;>K H? H;L>KO>= =BL<K>M> <:L>L :G=

(212)

(213) :K> NGDGHPG MAK>LAHE=L MH ;> >LMBF:M>= LLNFBG@ : #:NLLB:G <NFNE:MBO> =BLMKB;NMBHG ?NG<MBHG H? BM ?HEEHPL MA:M MA> IKH;

(214) :;BEBMB>L H? H;L>KOBG@ >:<A IHLLB;E> HNM<HF> H? && :K> B? 5 && 6 B? 5 B? 5 . . 0A> >LMBF:M>L H? :G= <:G ;> H;M:BG>= ;R F:DBG@ B=>GMB?RBG@ :LLNFIMBHGL MRIB<:EER MA:M ( -= :G= MA> BGM>K<>IM :G= F:QBFBSBG@ MA> EH@ EBD>EBAHH= ?NG<MBHG . . .

(215)

(216) . 0 . . PA>K> " BL MA> L:FIE> LBS> :G= 0 B? && 6 :G= HMA>KPBL>. Sirchenko, Andrei (2012), A Discrete-Choice Econometrician’s Tale of Monetary Policy Identification and Predictability European University Institute DOI: 10.2870/60780.

(217) .

(218) . $,0!. . 2/-'; 0))6-1+5 %5 % 71-6 2* 2&5)48%6-21. 0A> I:I>K =>I:KML ?KHF : <HFFHG IK:<MB<> H? >FIEHRBG@ MA> JN:KM>KER HK FHGMAER =:M: :O>K:@>L :G= BGLM>:= NL>L FHK> :=>JN:M> L:FIE> <HGLMKN<MBHG 0A> L:FIE> H;L>KO:MBHGL :K> :EE ), F>>MBG@L PA>G MA> =><BLBHGL HG MA> IHEB<R K:M> A:O> ;>>G F:=> 0A> ), A:L :EP:RL M:D>G LN<A =><BLBHGL HG<> : FHGMA =NKBG@ MA> L><HG= A:E? H? MA> FHGMA 0A> =>I>G=>GM O:KB:;E> BL : K>?>K>G<> K:M> <A:G@> F:=> :M : @BO>G ), F>>MBG@ 0A> =:M: HG MA> KB@AM

(219) A:G=

(220) LB=> O:KB:;E>L BL M:D>G :L BM P:L H;L>KO>= :M : =:M> H? F:DBG@ IHEB<R =><BLBHG LH BM <HGLBLML H? :EK>:=R IK>=>M>KFBG>= O:KB:;E>L PAB<A :K> BG=>I>G=>GM H? MA> K:M> L>MMBG@ :M MA:M ), F>>MBG@ 0A> K:P =:M: BL NL>= BG :EE MRI>L H? HKB@BG:E ?K>JN>G<R =:BER FHGMAER :G= JN:KM>KER 0A> :;HO> =:M: <HGLMKN<MBHG :OHB=L MA> LBFNEM:G>BMR IKH;E>F PAB<A <:G H<<NK BG FH=