R.D. Griffiths, T. Bongers, and A. McArdle
Introduction
Muscle weakness and muscle wasting are common and debilitating phenomena in intensive care and seen most profoundly in multiple organ failure (MOF) follow- ing severe sepsis and severe burn injuries. Intensive care clinicians recognize that muscle weakness contributes to prolonged mechanical ventilation, a prolonged ICU and hospital stay, and adds considerably to the cost of caring for these pa- tients [1]. This dysfunction goes beyond fatigue and weakness of the muscle, and also includes changes in muscle metabolism, muscle as a nutrient store, and in the inflammatory state of the whole body. The last 25 years has brought a greater appreciation of the mechanisms, structural and metabolic characteristics, the con- sequences, and possible avenues for therapy of muscle dysfunction as a component of MOF.
Contractile Dysfunction
Muscle contraction (force generation) is the final step in a complex chain of com- mand that runs from the higher centers of the central nervous system (CNS) via the spinal cord and peripheral nerves to the muscle. From here an action potential must be generated, calcium released, and cross bridge cycling activated, resulting in muscle force generation via actin and myosin interactions. Loss of strength ob- served clinically can arise secondary to an interruption at any point in this chain, such as a loss of contractile proteins, reduced membrane excitability, or distur- bance in neural signaling. Clinically, it is important not to consider dysfunction of muscle force generation separately from the existing activity level and the en- ergy supply side since the endurance capacity of muscle with repetitive activity is thought to be determined by, at least in part, the number of mitochondria per unit mass of muscle [2]. A trained muscle may contain five times more mitochondria than a healthy sedentary subject and a low mitochondrial content is associated with lower ATP content, increased glycogen breakdown, and lactate production with limitations in performance.
The difficulty in understanding muscle dysfunction in the ICU is the contribu-
tion of disuse-mediated muscle loss to the overall muscle wasting and breakdown.
Inactivity is an abnormal, even ‘diseased’, state of muscle in man, with normal ac- tivity acting as a potent stimulus for metabolism and protein synthesis. The human genome developed over 10,000 years ago when it was associated with a cycle of hunting and rest, feasting and famine, such that muscle was structured as a cyclical organ, highly plastic to synthesis and degradation, storage and utilization. These changes can be very rapid with a 50% decline in peripheral insulin-stimulated glucose utilization after as little as 72 hrs of bed rest [3]. After 20 days of bed rest, maximal muscle blood flow is reduced [4]. Skeletal muscle shows an adaptive reductive remodeling with continued decreased usage (bed rest, spaceflight or old age) [5]. This is associated with a shift in myosin isoforms from slow (fibers that have more oxidative metabolism with more mitochondria) to faster isoforms (fibers that are more glycolytic with fewer mitochondria). This may also result in a shift in fuel metabolism away from lipids and towards glucose. Metabolically, this impacts on fuel utilization and is manifested in marked changes in hepatic metabolism with an increase in gluconeogenisis. Such an adaptive process pro- duces a muscle capable of high-intensity, short duration activity at the expense of endurance, making the tissue easily fatigable. How much of this change is substrate or hormonal driven is unclear but the impairment in peripheral (skeletal muscle) insulin-mediated glucose uptake has become a significant target for management with insulin as shown in the ‘Leuven study’ [6]. During catabolic stress, the gluco- neogenic potential (and hyperglycemia) arises from increased amino acids released by proteolysis but not efficiently reutilized [7]. In skeletal muscle, increased lactate production occurs through exaggerated glycolysis with septic stimulation of Na
+, K
+ATPase activity [8]. Triglyceride accumulation is seen in muscle of ICU patients [9, 10]. The precise mechanisms for the fat accumulation, its lack of utilization, and insulin resistance remain unclear but may involve dysregulation of malonyl CoA and inhibition of carnitine palmitoyl transferase-1 preventing long chain fatty acids from entering mitochondria [11].
Impairment of Muscle Metabolism in Sepsis
The debate of whether there is a primary defect in the microcirculation [12], with shunting [13] compromising oxygen energy substrate delivery, or a cellular mitochondrial dysfunction limiting utilization in muscle during sepsis, either as a result of toxic damage [14] (endotoxin mediated [15] or adaptive [16]), is prob- ably best settled by accepting that both occur. Which of these occurs first and to what extent each contributes to the septic cascade is the challenging question.
Skeletal muscle has a highly variable blood flow depending on the contractile
state. The regulation and distribution of blood flow is disturbed in sepsis, affect-
ing microcirculatory flow. Phase-modulated near-infrared spectroscopy (NIRS) in
septic patients showed that while blood volume was increased, the oxygen con-
tent remained unchanged with reduced microvascular compliance and impaired
re-saturation after ischemia [17]. Reduced muscle oxygen consumption is also con-
firmed during stagnant ischemia [18] and correlates closely to worsening organ failure scoring (sequential organ failure assessment, SOFA). A similar outcome re- lationship was seen with abnormalities in mitochondrial function [19]. However, it appears that muscle mitochondrial structure and function is more protected than in other tissues such as the liver [20] and, therefore, the changes observed in muscle are likely to be more adaptive. Trying to resolve the contribution of the hypotension that arises during sepsis to force generation is clearly a challenge since no septic animal studies examining function appear to have studied this in detail [21]. Nevertheless, various forms of contractile dysfunction occur indepen- dent of the cross-section of muscle [22], some developing early within minutes to hours (possibly related to altered membrane potential and excitability), while others occur later within hours to days (possibly reflecting impairment of calcium activation or energy production). The resting membrane potential of muscle is reduced by 10–50% in the critically ill. This is sufficient to change muscle sodium and potassium content [23, 24] and this will impact on contractility. In critically ill patients [25] and in animal studies [26] there is a major and rapid decrease in activity of several mitochondrial enzymes. Cytochrome C oxidase decreases to very low levels within days after arrival in the ICU, reflecting a rapid decrease in mitochondrial content.
Neuropathy and Myopathy
Early descriptions of muscle pathology in critically ill patients focused on either electrophysiological (critical illness polyneuropathy, CIP [27]) or histological (crit- ical illness myopathy, CIM [28]) manifestations. However, time has shown that both coexist with a spectrum of tissue involvement to various extents [29–32]. The key to appreciating these pathological changes has been the association with inflamma- tory states and the evidence of a vasculopathy with marked endothelial activation in both nerve [33] and muscle [34]. In the ‘Leuven’ study, good nutrition and strict glycemic control in the critically ill improved survival and reduced the incidence of neuropathy [6]. Subsequent investigation suggested that this was manifested through protection of the endothelium with a reduction in endothelial cell acti- vation with lower intercellular adhesion molecule (ICAM)-1 and E-selectin levels, possibly through a more regulated induced nitric oxide (NO) synthase (iNOS) gene expression [35]. The ability to reduce the incidence of the neuropathy is encourag- ing. In the short, term critical illness neuropathy can compromise weaning from mechanical ventilation and prolong hospital stay with increased ICU mortality.
However, once discharge from hospital occurs there is no discernable increased
mortality risk [36]. Although follow-up experience suggests that in very long stay
ICU patients electromyographic (EMG) evidence of chronic denervation may be
detected many years later, the clinical consequences of this are usually minor, and
despite initial profound weakness (probably more due to the myopathy) in these
patients, only a very few show clinical weakness or limitations in the activities of
daily living when followed up 1–2 years later [37]. Recovery of the myopathy with restoration of muscle bulk remains the major determinate of functional recovery.
Muscle Loss
Muscle wasting can be extreme. Over a three week period following either se- vere trauma or sepsis, an average of 16% of total body protein is lost [38]. The total loss of skeletal muscle mass was estimated to be ∼ 3 kg. Such loss of lean body mass (whole body water and protein) ranging from 0.5–1.0% loss per day is far greater than that due to bed rest alone. In the very severely ill patient, the catabolic breakdown of muscle proteins shows losses approaching 2% per day [9], with a daily decrease in the fiber area of 3% to 4% [10]. Muscle biopsies show the greatest atrophy in the contractile myosin filaments with relative preservation of other structural proteins. The septic ICU patient shows increased proteosome pro- teolytic activity [39]. Increased expression of this ubiquitin proteolytic pathway is well characterized in sepsis and is promoted through a number of transcription factors including activator protein-1 (AP-1), nuclear factor-kappa B (NF- κ B) and
CCAAT/enhancer binding protein (C/EBP) [40]. The key proteolytic enzymes are the E3 ubiquitin ligases that act as the substrate recognition component. Increased calcium levels occur in muscle in sepsis [41] and this is likely to influence protein metabolism through the regulation of the calpain-calpastatin system. Increased calpain activity provides an early step in muscle wasting with degradation of Z- band associated proteins, in particular titin and alpha actinin, leading to release of myosin which is ubiquinated and degraded through the proteosome [42]. The targeted loss of mysosin, with the retention of other structural proteins, suggests that these fibers may have the potential to recover. Immobility and absence of the normal stretch and stresses, however, adds to this process, since passive stretching alone in neuromuscularly paralyzed ICU patients has been shown to reduce pro- tein loss and maintain structure [43].
Pathogenetic Factors in Myopathy of Critical Illness
From the above one can see that a number of factors may come together to result in
muscle dysfunction. These factors include a combination of inflammatory catabolic
or even toxic triggers and physiological adaptive mechanisms. During sepsis, the
upregulation of several hormones and numerous pro- and anti-inflammatory me-
diators makes the identification of any single factor clinically worthless. Neverthe-
less, excess prostaglandins, tumor necrosis factor (TNF)- α , reactive oxygen species
(ROS), such as NO, have all been implicated [21]. Hypercortisolemia is responsible
for a significant catabolic effect on muscle after trauma or in sepsis [44] which
is amplified by inactivity. In normal subjects, protein breakdown is not increased
any more than during starvation. However, if cortisol is given after 14 days of bed
rest, the net catabolic state is similar to a patient with 70% burn injury [45]. The effect of steroids may combine with locally produced cytokines, such as TNF- α
and interleukin (IL)-6 [46], to produce a potent stimulus. It has been suggested that there is a more generalized systemic process with the identification of a low molecular weight neurotoxic factor in the serum from patients who have a neu- romyopathy [47] that appears to block intracellular Ca
2+release channels and depolarize the resting membrane potential. This combination leads to impaired force development and membrane hypoexcitability with impaired recovery from repetitive action potentials [48].
In the wear and tear of normal exercise activity and following ischemic injury, neutrophils and macrophages dominate the basic inflammatory response [49].
Superoxide-dependent mechanisms appear to be involved, though probably medi- ated through conversion of hydrogen peroxide to highly reactive radicals, a mecha- nism involving myeloperoxidase. Neutrophils, however, are also involved in repair through the eventual phagocytosis of debris. Clinically, however, the invasion of neutrophils into skeletal muscle in the critically ill patient is less apparent than occurs following exercise-related muscle damage and is seen only in the extreme necrotic stages that occur in severe MOF [28]. In vitro, muscle-derived NO reduces neutrophil-mediated lysis of muscle cells [50] and the leukocyte interaction with the vascular endothelium [51]. Removal of normal muscle loading by inactivity causes a decrease in the expression and activity of neuronal NO synthase (nNOS) in muscle [52]. The same authors subsequently suggested a link with muscle wast- ing with disuse through studies of dystrophies [53]. NO appears to modify the active site of calpains that initially cleave myosin in degradation. Reduction in NO through reduced nNOS production could contribute to muscle wasting through the loss of a regulatory role for NO on calpain-mediated proteolysis.
While the systemic inflammatory process may impact on skeletal muscle, it is also important to realize that activation of systemically released mediators from within skeletal muscle tissue can lead to disturbances in distant organ systems.
During infrarenal aortic abdominal aneurysm repair, an ischemia/reperfusion in- jury response occurs in the lower limbs. After 30 mins of clamping, increased expression of genes for angiotensinogen, angiotensin converting enzyme (ACE) and IL-6 occur in muscle. Increased IL-6 levels were detectable systemically for 12 hours after reperfusion and were associated with impaired pulmonary func- tion [54].
Failed Protective Responses in Skeletal Muscle During Sepsis: A Role for Heat Shock Proteins and Glutamine in Mediating Muscle Function
The rapid increased expression of stress or heat shock proteins (HSPs) is one
of the most highly conserved mechanisms of cellular protection. HSPs may be
central to protect muscle against the assault from systemic inflammation and are
critical for cell survival. Increased HSP expression has been reported following is-
chemia/reperfusion and shock. Further, enhanced HSP expression has been shown to be associated with cyto-protection in a wide variety of experimental injury models. These include models of experimental sepsis, lung injury, transplantation injury, and cardiac ischemia/reperfusion injury.
Skeletal muscle normally adapts following stress, such that it is protected against subsequent damage [55]. This adaptation occurs following a variety of insults, including exercise. The mechanism of activation of the stress response is not fully understood, but increased ROS generation has been implicated as a major signal. The adaptive responses of muscle to exercise stress are by far the most studied. In this instance, increased ROS are produced and these in turn lead to activation of redox-sensitive transcription factors, such as NF- κ B, AP-1 and heat shock factor-1 (HSF1), and subsequent increases in the activity of protective enzymes, such as superoxide dismutase and catalase, and an increase in the cellular content of HSPs [57]. Only once the increased ROS production becomes excessive or chronic does failure in adaptation and subsequent damage occur. A putative model of how sepsis can affect the cellular adaptive and protective mechanisms of muscle from young and older patients is illustrated in Fig. 1.
The increase in protective enzymes and HSPs protects the tissue against sub- sequent exposure to damage [56]. The HSP70 family of proteins has been most studied in skeletal muscle. Major components of this family are a constitutively expressed but inducible HSP, known as HSC70, and a highly inducible HSP (HSP70
Fig. 1. A putative model of how sepsis can affect the cellular adaptive and protective mechanisms