Survey and modeling: from the process to a methodology

%B$""C!>>DEBFD?D9!GH$!<?I>F>DJ(>>DEFD?DK8&<LA8!

M!#N"OP+B#$Q,+!O;R4(:/(&59!/''LSJJ*-:L;.B*(R%.L;R4(:/(&5I('!

! "#$%&'()*'+,*%-.)/ 0 '1#,+'23%'4#,5%!!'2,'('+%23,*,-,/& '

5&%*")&'6**$))"78'9%":*"&)&';&%*-.-3$"778'5"#<&$.'=$::7778'6.+-):-'2>>-."*-7'

T!"-L(%&U-!P&(K%.:('6!1)!+12%!V!+12%9!$'-46!

TTP&(K%.:('6!1)!Q1415&-9!G%L-.'2%&'!1)!N.*/('%*';.%!V!Q1415&-9!$'-46!

TTTP&(K%.:('6!1)!#-4()1.&(-!V!"-&!G(%519!P"N!

(6789:;8'

G1*;2%&'-'(1&!1)!-.*/('%*';.-4!-&0!-.*/-%1415(*-4!/%.('-5%!2;:'!R%!-!2;4'(0(:*(L4(&-.6!-LL.1-*/!'/-'!%&-R4%:!-&-46:(:!-&0!

(&'%.L.%'-'(1&! ).12! 2-&6! )(%40:! 1)! %WL%.'(:%I! C1X-0-6:9! '/%! .%L.%:%&'-'(1&! 1)! '/%! -.*/('%*';.-4J-.*/-%1415(*-4! :;.K%6!

.%L.%:%&':!-!21&;2%&'-4!*/-&5%!(&!*-L-R(4('(%:!'/-&Y:!'1!'/%!-*Z;(:('(1&!-&0!-4(5&2%&'!1)!2-::(K%!:;.K%6!0-'-!0%:*.(R(&5!

'/%!5%12%'.69!-LL%-.-&*%!-&0!*1&'%W'!1)!'/%!'-.5%'!%&K(.1&2%&':I!3/%!*1&:'.;*'(1&!1)!210%4:!(:!'/%!L1(&'!1)!0%L-.';.%!)1.!

%::%&'(-4! -*'(K('(%:! V! ).12! *-'-415;(&5! '1! L.%:%.K-'(1&9! ).12! 0%:(5&! '1! .%:'1.-'(1&! -&0! K-41.(U-'(1&! V! 4(&Y%0! '1! '/%!

Y&1X4%05%! 1)! #;4';.-4! [%.('-5%I! ! 3/%! L.%:%&'%0! .%:%-.*/! )1*;:%:! 1&! '/%! *1&'.14! 1K%.! 0-'-! Z;-4('6! ).12! 2-::(K%! DG!

-*Z;(:('(1&9!(&!'%.2:!1)!2%'.(*!-**;.-*69!R6!*12L-.(&5!DG!(2-5%BR-:%0!-*Z;(:('(1&!2%'/10:!X('/!*1&:14(0-'%0!2%'/10:9!(&!

1.0%.!'1!L.%:%&'!'/%!%&1.21;:!L1'%&'(-4('(%:!(&/%.%&'!(&!210%4:!1R'-(&%0!'/.1;5/!DG!:;.K%6:I!

<=>?@9A7'

#;4';.-4![%.('-5%9!:;.K%6(&59!:;.K%69!DG!2-::(K%!-*Z;(:('(1&9!>GJDG!210%4:!

?@! 2)*%-0A#*"-)'!

N&! %&Z;(.6! (&'1! -! X1.Y! 1)! -.*/('%*';.%!

:(5&()(%:! (&K%:'(5-'(&5! -! L/6:(*-4! :L-*%!

*1&:'.;*'%0! -&0! %WL%.(%&*%0! R6! 2-&! %K%.! :(&*%!

/(:! -LL%-.-&*%! 1&! %-.'/! -:! X%44! -:! -&-46U(&5!

%4%2%&':! '/-'! K-.6! ).12! :'.;*';.%:! 1)! 5.%-'!

0(2%&:(1&:! '1! '/%! :2-44%:'! 1R\%*':I!

#1..%:L1&0(&5! '1! '/(:! 0(2%&:(1&-4! K-.(%'6! (:! -!

:%.(%:! 1)! L.1R4%2:! *1&&%*'%0! X('/! '/%!

(&:'.;2%&':9! X/(*/! %&-R4%! ;:! '1! -*Z;(.%!

Y&1X4%05%! -R1;'! '/%:%! 1R\%*':]! -! Y&1X4%05%!

*1&*%(K%0! (&! '%.2:! 1)! '/%! :6&'/%:(:! 1)! :;.K%6(&5!

-&0! '/%! :;.K%6I! ! 31! '/%! )1.2%.! R%41&5! -44! '/%!

1L%.-'(1&:! (&0(:L%&:-R4%! '1! 0%'%.2(&%! %4%2%&':!

&%*%::-.6! '1! )-:/(1&! '/%! */-.-*'%.(:'(*:! 1)! '/%!

1R\%*'! ;&0%.! :';06]! -:*.(R%0! '1! '/%! 4-''%.! B!

'/.1;5/!210%4!*1&:'.;*'(1&!V!'/%!.%L.%:%&'-'(1&!

1)! -44! '/%! */-.-*'%.(:'(*! )%-';.%:! (0%&'()(%0! (&! '/%!

L.%*%0(&5!:'-5%!1)!:;.K%6(&5I![%&*%!'/%!1L%.-'(1&!

1)! *15&(U(&5! R%*12%:! -! :6&-L:%! =BCDEFGH@!

R%'X%%&!'/%!'/%1.%'(*-4!-:L%*'!-&0!'/%!1L%.-'(K%!

1&%I! HR:%.K(&5! '/%! L.1*%::! 1)! Y&1X4%05%! 1)! '/%!

X1.Y! 1)! -.*/('%*';.%9! X%! *-&&1'! 0(:.%5-.0! '/-'!

(&:'.;2%&':! 1)! 2-::(K%! 0-'-! -*Z;(:('(1&! -&0!

0(5('-4! .%L.%:%&'-'(1&! /-K%! R%*12%! -421:'! '/%!

1&46! (&'%.2%0(-.(%:! )1.! '/%! :';06! -&0! '/%!

*122;&(*-'(1&!1)!'/%!*15&('(K%!L.1*%::I!

$&! '/%! L-:'! '/%! :;R\%*'! 1)! '/%! L.1*%::! 1)!

*15&(U(&5! -&! -.'()-*'! X-:! :'.(*'46! 4(&Y%0! '1! '/%!

L.1R4%2:! (&'.(&:(*! (&! '/%! '.-0('(1&-4! (&:'.;2%&':!

-LL4(%0! -:! X%44! -:! '1! '/%! L.141&5%0! 0;.-'(1&! 1)!

0-'-! -*Z;(:('(1&I! ^1.%1K%.9! '/%! Z;-&'('6! 1)!

(&)1.2-'(1&! -*Z;(.%0! 1)'%&! L.1K%0! '1! R%!

(&:;))(*(%&'!-&0!(&-0%Z;-'%!)1.!:*(%&'()(*!L;.L1:%:!

X/(4%! '/%! /(5/! :;R\%*'(K('6! 1)! .%L.%:%&'-'(1&!

6(%40%0!.%(&'%.L.%'-'(1&:!1)!4(''4%!*1&5.;%&*%!X('/!

'/%! 1R\%*'! :';0(%0I! 3/%! '%*/&1415(*-4!

-0K-&*%2%&'!1)!'/%!4-:'!'X1!'1!'/.%%!0%*-0%:!/-:!

.-0(*-446! */-&5%0! '/%! L.1*%::! 1)! Y&1X4%05%! 0;%!

'1! '/%! 0%K%41L2%&'! 1)! (&:'.;2%&':! '/-'! /-K%!

'.-&:)1.2%0! :;.K%6(&5! 1L%.-'(1&:! (&'1! :%2(B -;'12-'(*!L.1*%::%:!*-L-R4%!1)!5-'/%.(&5!2(44(1&:!

1)! 0-'-! L1(&':! -'! -! K%.6! 41X! ;&*%.'-(&'6! 4%K%4!

=Q(-&*/(&(9! $LL14('19! "%&-'1.%9! Q1.515&(9! #-L(-'19!

#-L1*%)-419! _! #1:%&'(&19! >?<>@I! 3/-&Y:! '1! '/%:%!

-0K-&*%2%&':! X%! -.%! -R4%! '1! *1&:'.;*'! 0%'-(4%0!

210%4:! '/-'! -441X! %W'%&:(K%! *15&('(1&! 1)! '/%!

1R\%*'! R6! .%0;*(&5! '/%! L1::(R(4('6! 1)! :;R\%*'(K%!

(&'%.L.%'-'(1&:I! $'! (:! -4:1! &1X! L1::(R4%! '1! :/-.%!

'/%! .-X! 0-'-! -&0! >G! -&0! DG! 210%4:! )-:'%.! '/-&!

%K%.I! NLL4(*-'(1&! -&0! (&'%5.-'(1&! 1)!

(&:'.;2%&'-'(1&! )1.! 2-::(K%! 0-'-! L1(&'!

-*Z;(:('(1&! /-:! *12L4%'%46! .%K14;'(1&(U%0! -!

L.1*%::!(&!X/(*/!'/%!*1&:'.;*'(1&!1)!-!210%4!X-:!

L.%K(1;:46! '/%! ).;('! 1)! -! 41&5! L.1*%::! X/%.%! '/%!

0(:*1&'(&;('(%:! 1)! 2%-:;.(&5! /-0! R%%&! :%4%*'%0!

R%)1.%! :'-.'(&5! '1! 5-'/%.! 0-'-I! C1X-0-6:9! '/%!

:;.K%69!;&0%.:'110!(&!'%.2:!1)!-!L.1*%::!-(2%0!-'!

A`!

*1&:'.;*'(&5! >G! -&0! DG! 210%4:9! /-:! R%*12%! -!

Z;-4('-'(K%!1L%.-'(1&!1)!L.1)1;&046!*15&(U(&5!'/%!

1R\%*'! 1)! :';06! -&0! -! .%:;4'! 1)! '/%! Z;-&'('-'(K%!

:;.K%6(&5!L.1*%::!1)!2-::(K%!0-'-!-*Z;(:('(1&I!

3/%! L.%:%&'%0! :';06! /-:! R%%&! ;&0%.'-Y%&!

X('/! '/%! 51-4! '1! R%''%.! ;&0%.:'-&0! '/%! );';.%!

0%K%41L2%&':! 1)! '/(:! )(%40! 1)! :';06! X('/(&! '/%!

012-(&!1)!#;4';.-4![%.('-5%9!X/(*/!R%*12%!21.%!

-&0! 21.%! *1&&%*'%0! -&0! 06&-2(*! =N00(:1&! _!

a-(-&(9!>???@I!3/%!2%'/101415(%:!-&0!L.1*%0;.%:!

-LL4(%0! (&! :;.K%6(&5! 1L%&! ;L! -&! 1L%.-'(K%!

L1::(R(4('6! '1! 2-Y%! '/%! *1&'(&;('6! 1)! .%-4('6!

0(:*.%'%!R6!2%-:;.(&5!-!)(&('%!&;2R%.!1)!L1(&':!V -&0!'/-'!2%-&:!'1!*-..6!1;'!-!L.1*%::!1)!:%4%*'(1&!

'/-&Y:! '1! X/(*/! 1&%! *-&! %WL1:%! -&! 1R\%*'! 1)!

(&'%.%:'! =G1**(! _! ^-%:'.(9! >???@I! ";*/! -&!

1L%.-'(1&! .%:;4':! (&! .%0;*(&5! '/%! 5%12%'.(*!

*12L4%W('6! 1)! .%-4! 1R\%*':! '1! L1(&':9! 4(&%:! -&0!

:;.)-*%:!(&*4;0(&5!'/%!-*'!1)!:%4%*'(&59!%W'.-*'(&5!

-&0!(&'%.L.%'(&5!:12%!1)!'/%!(&)(&('%!(&)1.2-'(1&!

-'! 1&%b:! 0(:L1:-4I! c/-'! (:! 21.%9! (:! '/-'! ('! 2-Y%:!

(2L4%2%&'-'(1&! 1)! '/%! :;.K%6! 0())(*;4'! X/%&! '/%!

'/%1.%'(*-4! )1;&0-'(1&:! -'! (':! R-:%! L.1K%! '1! R%!

;&Y&1X&I! [%&*%9! ;&0%.:'-&0(&5! '/%! *1&*%L':! 1)!

:;.K%6(&5!-&0!1)!'/%!:;.K%6!V!%:L%*(-446!(&!K(%X!1)!

'/%! %W'%&:(K%! 0());:(1&! 1)! 2-::(K%! -*Z;(:('(1&!

'%*/&1415(%:^<9! 2;:'! R%! *1&:(0%.%0! );&0-2%&'-4!

)1.! 2-&-5(&5! -&0! *1&'.144(&5! '1! 1;.! R%:'! -R(4('6!

'/%! L.1*%::^>! '/-'! (&*4;0%:! /%'%.15%&%1;:!

(&:'.;2%&':!-&0!0-'-!'6L%:I!=G1**(9!>?<D@I!

N!K-.(%'6!1)!0-'-!-*Z;(:('(1&!210%:!-.%!21.%!

-**%::(R4%! -&0! (&*.%-:(&546! ;:%0! '1! 01*;2%&'!

#;4';.-4![%.('-5%I!

3/%!N.*/('%*';.-4!JN.*/-%1415(*-4!.%L.%:%&'-'(1&!

L.1*%::!(:!&1X!(&!'/%!2(004%!1)!-!'.-&:)1.2-'(1&!

0;%! '1! '/%! -0K-&*%2%&'! 1)! *12L4%W! :;.K%6(&5!

'%*/&1415(%:I! 3/%! ;:%! 1)! '/%:%! &%X! :;.K%6(&5!

'114:! -441X:! ;:! '1! .%*15&(U%! /1X! '/%! 5%12%'.(*!

:;.K%6! L.1*%::! -&0! '/%! 210%4! *1&*%L'! -.%! 21.%!

-&0! 21.%! *1&:14(0-'%0I! $&! '/%! 0(5('-4! -5%9! '/%!

210%4!*1&*%L'!(:!R-:%0!1&!0(5('-4!'%*/&(Z;%:9!&1X!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

<!DG!*-L';.(&5!'%*/&1415(%:!=DG!4-:%.!:*-&&(&59!(2-5%BR-:%09!

")^@!X/(*/!2-Y%!('!L1::(R4%!'1!-*Z;(.%!2(44(1&:!1)!L1(&':!1))!

:;.)-*%! 01(&5! -X-6! X('/! '/%! &%*%::('6! '1! L.%K%&'(K%46!

%:'-R4(:/! X/-'! 0(:'-&*%:! '1! 2%-:;.%I! 3/%! .%:;4'! (:!

0())%.%&'(-'%0! Z;-4('-'(K%46! -&0! Z;-&'('-'(K%46! ).12! '/-'!

1R'-(&%0!X('/!'.-0('(1&-4!(&:'.;2%&':!X/(*/!-4X-6:!.%Z;(.%0!

'/%!1L%.-'1.!'1!:%4%*'!:-4(%&'!L1(&':!'1!2%-:;.%!1&!'/%!1R\%*'!

1)!:';06I!

>! $&0%L%&0%&'! 1)! '/%! 2%'/101415(%:! -01L'%0! )1.! 0-'-!

-*Z;(:('(1&! -&0! %W'.-*'(1&! '/%! 1L%.-'(K%! L.1*%0;.%! 1)!

:;.K%6(&5!(:!-.'(*;4-'%0!(&'1!D!0())%.%&'!:'-5%:S!'/%!0%:(5&!1)!

'/%! :;.K%69! 0-'-! -*Z;(:('(1&! -&0! .%-0(&59! -&0! V! )(&-446! V!

210%4!%4-R1.-'(1&!-&0!*1&:'.;*'(1&I!

!

L.%:%&'! (&! -44! -.*/('%*';.-4! .%L.%:%&'-'(1&! '114:9!

'%*/&(Z;%:! X/(*/! /-K%! -4:1! (&K-0%0! '/%! )(%40! 1)!

-.*/('%*';.-4!:;.K%6I!$&!L-.'(*;4-.9!X('/!.%5-.0!'1!

'/%! 210%49! >G! -&0! DG! .%L.%:%&'-'(1&:! /-K%!

*.%-'%0! -! &%X! Y(&0! 1)! 210%4! &1! 41&5%.! :(2L46!

:'-'(*9!R;'!-4:1!06&-2(*I!3/%!210%4!*1&*%L'!2;:'!

'/%.%)1.%! R%! .%)(&%0! -&0! ;L0-'%0I! 3/(:! 210%4! (:!

-R4%! '1! .%L.%:%&'9! *12L.%/%&09! %4-R1.-'%! -&0!

210()6!'/%!:;.K%6]!('!-441X:!1&%!'1!21K%!-.1;&0!

('! -&0! '.-K%4! ).12! 1;':(0%! '1! (&:(0%! '/%! 210%4!

;:(&5!'/%!>G!-&0!DG!%4-R1.-'(1&:!(&!-&!(&'%.-*'(K%!

2-&&%.]!-!*12L4%W!-&0!-R:14;'%!(&'%.-*'(K('6!/-:!

R%%&! *.%-'%0! R%'X%%&! '/%! .%-4! 1R\%*'! =L1(&'!

*41;0:! -&0J1.! L/1'15.-L/:@! -&0! K(.';-4! :6:'%2:!

1)!>G!-&0!DG!0(5('-4!210%4:I!

3/(:! .%:%-.*/! (:! -! *1&'.(R;'(1&! '1! ";.K%69!

*1&:(0%.%0! -:! -! Y&1X4%05%! '114! '1! ;&0%.:'-&0!

2-'%.(-4!%4%2%&':9!(I%I9!'/%!L.1*%::!'/-'!2-'%.(-446!

%&K(:-5%:! '/%! %:'-R4(:/2%&'! 1)! -! :;('-R4%!

Y&1X4%05%! :6:'%2! '1! N*Z;(.%9! "%4%*'9! $&'%.L.%'!

-&0! +%L.%:%&'! d;-&'('-'(K%! R;'! -R1K%! -44!

Z;-4('-'(K%! 0-'-I! 3/%! )1.2%.! 2;:'! R%! L%.)1.2%0!

'1! '/%! 5.%-'%:'! %W'%&'! L1::(R4%! X('/(&! '/%!

R1;&0-.(%:! 1)! -! :'.(*'! :*(%&'()(*! -LL.1-*/9! X/(4%!

1&!'/%!1'/%.!/-&09!'/%!4-''%.!='/%!.%:;4'!1)!*.('(*-4!

1R:%.K-'(1&:@! 0%L%&0:! 1&! '/%! :%&:(R(4('(%:! -&0!

(&'%.L.%'-'(K%! :Y(44:! -::1*(-'%0! X('/! '/%! */1(*%:9!

:%4%*'(1&:! -&0! .%L.%:%&'-'(1&:! 0%*(0%0! R6! -!

:*/14-.I! 3/(:! *1&:(0%.-'(1&! *1&:'(';'%0! R1'/! '/%!

:*1L%!1)!'/(:!:';06!-&0!-4:1!-!L.%'%W'!'1!-&-46U%!

'/%! :'-'%B1)B'/%B-.'! 1)! '/%! X/14%! )(%40! 1)! :;.K%6I!

C1R106! *-&! 0%&6! '/%.%! (:! -! *4%-.B*;'! R1;&0-.6!

R%'X%%&! -*Z;(:('(1&! -&0! .%L.%:%&'-'(1&!

L.1*%0;.%:!V!-44!)1*;:%0!1&!e2-W(2;2!1R\%*'(K('6f!

B! -&0! (&'%.L.%'-'(1&9! X/(*/! (:! (&:'%-0! '/%! L/-:%!

0;.(&5!X/(*/!'/%!:;R\%*'!.%2-(&:!'/%!L.1'-51&(:'I!

[-K(&5!%:'-R4(:/%0!'/(:!R1;&0-.69!:12%!:%52%&':!

1)!'/%!L.1*%::!-LL%-.!*-L-R4%!1)!1K%.*12(&5!'/%!

:'.(&5%&'!.%Z;(.%2%&':!(2L1:%0!R6!'/%!"*(%&'()(*!

^%'/10! '/-'! 1'/%.! 0(:*(L4(&-.6! :%*'1.:! &1.2-446!

;:%!(&!'/%(.!.%:%-.*/!-*'(K('(%:I!N!X%44B:'.;*';.%0!

Y&1X4%05%! :6:'%2! /-:! :%K%.-4! *12L1&%&':S!

/(:'1.69! *;4';.%9! Z;-&'('6! =).12! -&! (&'%5.-'%0!

:;.K%6@! -&0! Z;-4('6I! $)! '/%! )(.:'! 'X1! *-&! =-&0!

:/1;40@! R%! 5-'/%.%0! ;:(&5! -! :'.(*'46! :*(%&'()(*!

-LL.1-*/9! '/%! 4-''%.! (&K14K%! '/%! :%&:('(K('6! -&0!

(&'%.L.%'-'(K%!-R(4('6!1)!'/%!:*/14-.!X/19!-'!'(2%:!

:L1&'-&%1;:46! -&0! (&';('(K%469! (:! *-L-R4%! 1)!

.%-*/(&5! 4%K%4:! 1)! ;&0%.:'-&0(&5! '/-'! 51! R%61&0!

'/%!:(2L4%!-*'!1)!'-Y(&5!2%-:;.%2%&':I!!

3/%! :'.;*';.%! 1)! -! 2%'(*;41;:9! *12L4%'%! -&0!

*1..%*'46!1.5-&(U%0!Y&1X4%05%!:6:'%2!L4-6:!-!Y%6!

.14%! (&! -! *12L4%W! Y&1X4%05%! L.1*%::I! 3/%! G-'-!

AE! ! N*Z;(:('(1&!L/-:%!1RK(1;:46!(&*4;0%:!'/%!*1&*%L'!

1)!2%-:;.%2%&'9!(I%I9!'/%!1L%.-'(1&!'/-'!2-Y%:!('!

L1::(R4%!'1!'.-&:4-'%!'/%!Z;-4('6!1)!-!L/%&12%&1&!

(&'1!-!Z;-&'('6!%WL.%::%0!;:(&5!&;2R%.:!0%.(K%0!

).12! '/%! .%4-'(1&:/(L! R%'X%%&! '/%! Z;-&'('6!

:;.K%6%0! 1&! '/%! 1R\%*'! -&0! '/%! */1:%&! ;&('! 1)!

2%-:;.%I! C1X-0-6:! '/%! :;.K%6(&5! (:! :'.;*';.%0!

-.1;&0! 2-::(K%! 0-'-! -*Z;(:('(1&! =DG! 4-:%.!

:*-&&(&5^D9! "'.;*';.%! ).12! ^1'(1&^F@I! 3/(:! .-(:%:!

'/%! (::;%! 1)! /1X! :;.K%61.:! (&'%.-*'! -&0! 2-&-5%!

'/%:%! '%*/&1415(%:! -&0! 0%K(*%:I! N44! 1L%.-'(1&:!

'/-'!%&K(:-5%!'/%!5-'/%.(&5!1)!Y&1X4%05%!&%%0!'1!

/-K%! -! .%)%.%&*%! ).-2%X1.Y! R1'/! K(:BgBK(:! '/%!

0-'-! -*Z;(:('(1&! 2%'/10! =:;.K%6(&5@! -&0! '/%!

:%4%*'(1&9! L.1*%::(&5! -&0! .%:'(';'(1&! 1)! '/%!

-*Z;(.%0!0-'-!=:;.K%6@I!$&!'/(:!.%5-.09!'/%!:;.K%6!

L.1*%::!(:!*41:%46!4(&Y%0!'1!'/%!*1&*%L'!1)!210%49!

*1&:(0%.%0! -:! '/%! 1;'*12%! 1)! '/%! 1L%.-'(1&!

L%.)1.2%0! R6! -&! -*'1.! 1&! -&! 1R\%*'! '1! %W'.-*'!

:12%!1)!(':!%&04%::!0-'-I!N:!-!.%:;4'!'/%!210%4!(:!

-4X-6:! (&*12L4%'%9! -R:'.-*'! -&0! -R1K%! -44!

:;R\%*'(K%]! 1&46! '/%! %))%*':! -&0! 1;'*12%! 1)!

.%L.%:%&'-'(1&! 2-Y%! ('! -K-(4-R4%! '1! 1'/%.! -*'1.:!

:1! 41&5! -:! '/%6! -.%! -R4%! '1! (&'%.L.%'! '/%!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

D! DG! 4-:%.! :*-&&(&5! (:! L%.)1.2%0! X('/! (&:'.;2%&':! /(5/46!

-0K-&*%0! '%*/&1415(*-446I! 3/%:%! 0%K(*%:! %2('! -&!

%4%*'.12-5&%'(*! (2L;4:%! ='/%! 4-:%.@! -&0! .%*%(K%! '/%! :(5&-4!

.%)4%*'%0!R6!'/%!:;.)-*%!:'.;*YI!3/(:!2%'/10!%&-R4%:!-!'(2%B 1)B)4(5/'!2%-:;.%2%&'!1)!'/%!(&'%.K-4!R%'X%%&!'/%!%2(::(1&!

1)!'/%!.-6!-&0!(':!.%';.&!'1!'/%!(&:'.;2%&'9!(I%I!'/%!0(:'-&*%!

R%'X%%&!'/%!(&:'.;2%&'!-&0!'/%!L1(&'!:;.K%6%0I!N*Z;(:('(1&!

1)!-!/(5/!&;2R%.!1)!0-'-!(&!:/1.'!(&'%.K-4:!1)!'(2%!'-Y%:!'/%!

)1.2!1)!-&!(&)(&('%!:%'!1)!L1(&':!0(:'.(R;'%0!1&!'/%!1R\%*'!'1!

R%!:;.K%6%09!X('/!-!K-.(-R4%!L('*/!(&!);&*'(1&!1)!0%'-(4!0%5.%%!

1&%! X(:/%:! '1! -*/(%K%I! ,-*/! L1(&'! (:! */-.-*'%.(U%0! R6! )(K%!

0-'-S! '/.%%! &;2%.(*-4! 1&%:! *1..%:L1&0(&5! '1! '/%! W9! 69! U!

*11.0(&-'%:! .%4-'%0! '1! '/%! :*-&&%.9! '/%! +aQ! 0-';2! X/(*/!

L1:('(1&:! 1&! '/%! L1(&'! '/%! 0-';2! 1)! '/%! L/1'15.-L/6!

-*Z;(.%0!R6!'/%!0%K(*%]!.%)4%*'-&*%!0-'-!X/(*/!*1..%:L1&0!'1!

'/%!-21;&'!1)!%&%.56!%2(''%0!).12!'/%!(&:'.;2%&'!-!.%';.&:!

(22%0(-'%46! -)'%.! '/%! :;.)-*%! '1! R%! :;.K%6%0! /-:! R%%&!

:'.;*YI!3/;:!X%!1R'-(&!-!'/.%%!0(2%&:(1&-4!&;2%.(*-4!210%4!

L%.)%*'46!*1&5.;%&'!X('/!'/%!.%-4!1R\%*'!;L1&!X/(*/!('!X(44!R%!

L1::(R4%!'1!*-..6!1;'!-&-46:%:!-&0!%4-R1.-'(1&:!&%*%::-.6!'1!

1R'-(&!:;.K%6!0-'-I!

F! "'.;*';.%! ).12! ^1'(1&! =")^@! /-:! R%%&! 0%.(K%0! ).12! '/%!

'/%1.%'(*-4!-::;2L'(1&:!1)!L/1'15.-22%'.6!-&0!%&:;.%:!'/%!

*1&:'.;*'(1&! 1)! '/.%%! 0(2%&:(1&-4! 5.-L/(*! 3-0$.:! R6!

(&'%5.-'(&5! '/%! :'-5%:! 1)! '/%! :;.K%69! 210%4(&5! -&0!

.%L.%:%&'-'(1&! %W'.-*'(&5! *11.0(&-'%:9! 0(:'-&*%:9! K%.'%W%:!

-&0!L.1)(4%:!).12!L/1'15.-L/:I!c/-'!2-Y%:!('!(&&1K-'(K%!(:!

'/%! /(5/! 4%K%4! 1)! -;'12-'(1&! (&! '/%! L.1*%::! -&0! '/%!

L1::(R(4('6!'1!1R'-(&!-!K%.6!4-.5%!-21;&'!1)!(&)1.2-'(1&!(&!-!

:/1.'!:L-&!1)!'(2%I!N4'/1;5/!('!01%:!&1'!1))%.!'/%!L1::(R(4('6!

'1! 2-&-5%! -! :;.K%6! 1&! -&6! :*-4%9! (':! .%:;4'! (:! '/%! 210%4!

-&-4151;:! '1! '/-'! 1R'-(&%0! '/.1;5/! 4-:%.! :*-&&(&5! X/(*/!

2-Y%:! ('! L1::(R4%! '1! -*Z;(.%! 5%12%'.(*! -&0! Z;-4('-'(K%!

)%-';.%:!1)!'/%!1R\%*'!-&-46U%0!'/.1;5/!L/1'15.-L/:I!

.%L.%:%&'-'(1&! *10%I! #/11:(&5! '/%! .(5/'! 210%4!

=-&0! /%&*%! '/%! :%'! 1)! 1R\%*'(K%! 0-'-! '1! R%!

:%4%*'%0@!-&0!.%L.%:%&'-'(1&!*10%!0%L%&0:!1&!'/%!

Z;-&'('6! 1)! L1:('(K%46! *122;&(*-'%0! 0-'-I! 3/%!

-0K%&'! 1)! 0(5('-4! :6:'%2:! /-:! -00%0! &%X! DG!

210%4:! '1! '.-0('(1&-4! =(&'.(&:(*-446! >G@! 5.-L/(*!

210%4:I! 3/%:%! &%X! DG! 210%4:! -.%! L;.%46!

&;2%.(*-4! .%L.%:%&'-'(1&:9! X/(*/9! -.%! *-L-R4%! 1)!

%:'-R4(:/(&5! -! K%.6! L.%*(:%! *1..%:L1&0%&*%!

R%'X%%&!L/6:(*-4!-&0!K(.';-4!:L-*%^AI!31!*1..%*'46!

%:'-R4(:/! -&! 1L%.-'(1&-4! L.1'1*14! =Q(-&*/(&(9!

>?<>]! "(1''19! #-44(%.(9! O(&5(9! "*1L(5&19! Q%&-::(9!

O-..(9! h-! ^1&(*-9! _! i%..-.-9! >?<F@ '/%! :;.K%6!

*1&*%L'! /-:! '1! R%! L.1L%.46! (0%&'()(%0! -&0! '/(:!

(&K14K%:! 2%.5(&5! 'X1! :%L-.-'%! Y(&0:! 1)! :;.K%6S!

*.('(*-4!:;.K%69!X/(*/!0%)(&%:!'/%!1R\%*'!;:(&5!(':!

5%12%'.(*! -&0! -.*/('%*';.-4! */-.-*'%.(:'(*:9! -&0!

1R\%*'(K%! :;.K%6! X/(*/! *1&:(:':! 1)! L.1K(0(&5!

;&R(-:%0! 0-'-! '1! -441X! )1.! -&! (&B0%L'/!

(&'%.L.%'-'(1&! R6! -! :L%*(-4(:'! =Q(-&*/(&(! %'! -4I9!

>?<>]!$LL14('19!>?<A@I!!3/%!:;.K%6!X(44!'/%.%)1.%!

0%L%&0! 1&! 'X1! *1&:%Z;%&'(-4! R;'! (&%K('-R4%!

-:L%*':S! *12L4%W! DG! :;.K%6(&5! -&0! *12L4%W! DG!

:;.K%6I! 3/%! *12L4%W! DG! :;.K%6(&5! (&K14K%:!

-*Z;(.(&5! '/%! 0-'-! -&0! *144%*'(&5! -&6! ;:%);4!

(&)1.2-'(1&! -R1;'! '/%! 1R\%*'9! X/(*/! *-&! -4:1! R%!

:';0(%0! '1! -*Z;(.%! 5.%-'%.! ;&0%.:'-&0(&5! -&0!

Y&1X4%05%]! -&! -&-46'(*-4! L/-:%! )1*;:(&5! 1&!

*144%*'(&5! Z;-4('-'(K%! -&0! Z;-&'('-'(K%! 0-'-I! N!

*12R(&-'(1&!1)!2%'/101415(%:!-&0!'114:!-.%!;:%0!

0;.(&5! '/%! -*Z;(:('(1&! L.1*%::! (&*4;0(&5!

'1L15.-L/69! L/1'15.-L/6! -&0! 41&5! -&0! :/1.'!

.-&5%!:*-&&%.:I!3/%!:%*1&0!:'%L9!'/%!*12L4%W!DG!

:;.K%69! (&K14K%:! ';.&(&5! '/%! DG! :;.K%6(&5! (&'1! -!

DG! :;.K%6! R6! *12R(&(&5! '/%! 210%4:9! ';.&(&5!

1R\%*'(K%!0-'-!=:;.K%6(&5@!(&'1!0-'-!*1&'-(&(&5!-44!

'/%! (&)1.2-'(1&! .%Z;(.%0! '1! (&'%.L.%'! -&0! :';06!

'/%! R;(40(&5! =:;.K%6@I! a(K%&! '/%! -R1K%9! :;.K%6:!

-.%!&1'!1&46!.%L1:('1.(%:!;:%0!'1!5-'/%.!(&B0%L'/!

Y&1X4%05%^j! 1)! '/%! -.'()-*':9! R;'! '/%6! -4:1!

.%L.%:%&'! '/%! 2%'/10! .%Z;(.%0! '1! %W'.-*'! '/%!

21:'!:;('-R4%9!*1..%*'!0-'-!).12!.%-4('6I!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

A!,-*/! 2-'%.(-4! L1(&'! L^%' (0%&'()(%0! ;:(&5! (':! *11.0(&-'%:!

M%8J%84%!(&!.%-4!:L-*%9!(22%0(-'%46!)(&0:!(':!K(.';-4!%Z;(K-4%&'!

LI9! -4:1! (0%&'()(%0! R6! -! ;&(K1*-4! '.(L4%'! 1)! #-.'%:(-&!

*11.0(&-'%:!M^I8JI84I!

!j!3/%!-LL.1-*/!'1!Y&1X4%05%!%WL.%::%0!R6!'/%!L/(41:1L/%.!

+%&k! G%:*-.'%:! 0(:'(&5;(:/%:! R%'X%%&! &1.2-4! Y&1X4%05%9!

-*/(%K%0! 1&46! R6! 1;.! :%&:%:9! -&0! L.1)1;&0! Y&1X4%05%9!

-*/(%K%0! R6! :*/14-.:! ;:(&5! 1&46! :';06! 2%'/10:! -&0!

'%*/&(Z;%:! '/-'! *-&! 0%21&:'.-'%! '1! '/%! 2(&09! X/-'! (:!

L.%*4;0%0!'1!'/%!:%&:%:I!

j?!

N@',$#<)-.-/"#&.'0$I$.->3$)*:'")':A%I$J")/'&)0'

%$>%$:$)*")/'9A.*A%&.'=$%"*&/$'

N&6! :';06! )1*;:(&5! 1&! -.*/('%*';.-4! -&0!

-.*/-%1415(*-4! %4%2%&':! V! X/%'/%.! -'! -&! ;.R-&9!

-.*/('%*';.-4!1.!0%'-(4%0!1R\%*'!:*-4%!V!(:!R-:%0!1&!

'/%!*.%-'(1&!1)!-!Y&1X4%05%!:6:'%2!(&K14K(&5!'/%!

*144%*'(1&9! (&'%.L.%'-'(1&! -&0! )(4(&5! 1)! 0-'-I!

N.*/-%1415(*-4!N.*/('%*';.%!=Q(-&*/(&(9!Q1.515&(9!

$LL14('19! _! "%&-'1.%9! >?<F@! (:! *1&:'(';'%0! R6! -!

2-::(K%! &;2R%.! 1)! :;.)-*%:! =L4-&%:9! *1&%:9!

*64(&0%.:9!.1'-'(1&!:;.)-*%:9!L-.-R141(0:9!%'*I@!-&0!

/%&*%!'/%!:%'!1)!L1(&':!%W'.-*'%0!).12!-!DG!:;.K%6!

2;:'! (&%K('-R46! R%! '.-&:)1.2%0! (&'1! *1&'(&;1;:!

:;.)-*%:! R6! '/%! *.%-'(1&! 1)! 2%:/%:! 1.! &;.R:!

:;.)-*%:! :1! .%:%-.*/%.:! 2;:'! R%! *%.'-(&! '1! /-K%!

:;.K%6%0!-44!'/%!*/-.-*'%.(:'(*!L1(&':!1)!'/%!'-.5%'!

:'.;*';.%:I! 3/%! L1'%&'(-4! 1))%.%0! R6! '/%! ;:%! 1)!

&%X! :;.K%6! '114:! )1.! 2-::(K%! 0-'-! -*Z;(:('(1&! 1)!

5%12%'.6! -&0! -LL%-.-&*%! -441X:! ;:! '1! :';06!

-:L%*':! 1)! -.'()-*':! X('/! -! 4%K%4! 1)! 0%'-(4! -&0! -!

/;5%! K-.(%'6! 1)! /%'%.15%&%1;:! 0-'-! '/-'! X-:!

;&(2-5(&-R4%! ;&'(4! -! )%X! 6%-.:! -51! =,4B[-Y(29!

Q%.-40(&9! O(*-.09! _! a10(&9! >??F]! ,&'X(:'4%9!

^**-)).%69! _! NR.-/-2:9! >??E]! Q1;.Y%9! >?<>]!

+%21&0(&19!"L%.-9!C1*%.(&19!^%&&-9!_!C%W9!>?<F]!

[%::9! O%'.1K(*9! l%-5%.9! _! m;%:'%.9! >?<8@I! 3/%!

L/.-:%! n0(5('-4! R;(40(&5! .%*1.0(&5! '%*/&1415(%:o!

2-6!(&)%.!'/%!*144%*'(1&!1)!-**;.-'%!-&0!%))(*(%&'!

0(2%&:(1&-4!0-'-9!R;'!(&!-*';-4('6!-!R;(40(&5f:!:(U%!

(:! 1)'%&! &1'! '/%! 1&46! )1*;:! )1.! '/%! :';069!

L.%:%.K-'(1&9! 1.! *1&:%.K-'(1&! 1)! -! :'.;*';.%I!

#144%*'(&59!(&'%.L.%'(&5!-&0!0(::%2(&-'(&5!-!4-.5%!

-21;&'! 1)! (&)1.2-'(1&! /%4L:! '1! 0%)(&%! -! :6:'%2!

X%! *-&! ;:%! '1! ;&0%.:'-&0! 1;.! #;4';.-4! [%.('-5%I!

3/%!:6:'%2!/-:!'1!R%!R-:%0!1&!:*(%&'()(*!L.1*%::!

;:%0!'1!-*/(%K%!-!0;-4!1R\%*'(K%S!'1!01*;2%&'!'/%!

-*Z;(:('(1&!;:(&5!-!/%'%.15%&%1;:!:%'!1)!0-'-!-&0!

2%'-0-'-! '1! 5;-.-&'%%! .%L%-'-R(4('6! -&0! '1!

%&:;.%! 0-'-! Z;-4('6! 0;.(&5! 0-'-! *-L';.%! -&0!

L.1*%::(&5!1)!>G!-&0!DG!210%4:I!!

G-'-! -*Z;(:('(1&! (:! -&! -.'(*;4-'%0! 1L%.-'(1&!

-(2%0! -'! %W'.-*'(&5! -! :%.(%:! 1)! (&)1.2-'(1&! ).12!

'/%! *12L4%W('6! 1)! '/%! .%-4! 1R\%*'I! ,K%&! '/1;5/! ('!

2-6!:%%2!'1!R%!-&!-;'12-'(*!L.1*%::!'/-'!-LL4(%:!

%W(:'(&5! 2%'/101415(%:9! '1! L%.)1.2! ('! ('! (:!

(&0(:L%&:-R4%! '1! /-K%! -! Y&1X4%05%! 1)! '/%!

'/%1.%'(*-4!*1&*%L':!-&0!L.-*'(*-4!1L%.-'(1&:!'/-'!

2;:'! R%! %W%*;'%0! (&! 1.0%.! '1! X1.Y! X('/! '/%!

(&:'.;2%&':! -&0! 5;-.-&'%%! 1L'(2(U-'(1&! 1)! '/%!

.%:;4':I!3/%!*/1(*%!1)!1&%!1.!21.%!210-4('(%:!)1.!

0-'-!-*Z;(:('(1&!2%-&:!'/-'!:12%!2%'/101415(*-4!

Z;%:'(1&:! /-K%! '1! R%! -00.%::%0S! '/%! :L%*()(*!

*.('(*-4('(%:! 1)! 0())%.%&'! (&:'.;2%&':9! '/%! *1..%*'!

-LL.1-*/! (&! '/%(.! -LL4(*-'(1&9! '/%(.! (&)4;%&*%! 1&!

'/%! '(2(&5! -&0! '/%! Z;-4('6! 1)! '/%! :;.K%6(&5! -&0!

.%L.%:%&'-'(1&! L.1*%::%:! =$LL14('19! >?<j@I!

$&'%5.-'(1&! 1)! K-.(1;:! :;.K%6(&5! 2%'/101415(%:!

'/-'! -441X! 1&%! '1! -*Z;(.%! 0-'-! ).12! '/%! 5%&%.-4!

-&0! '/%! 0%'-(4%0! L1(&'! 1)! K(%X! -:! X%44! -:! '/%(.!

21:'! %W/-;:'(K%! .%*1&:'.;*'(1&! (:! -421:'! -! X%44B

%:'-R4(:/%0! 1L%.-'(1&! =Q(-&*/(&(9! >?<>]!

+%21&0(&1!_!#-2L-&-9!>?<F@I!3%*/&1415(%:!4(Y%!

DG! 4-:%.! :*-&&(&5! -&0! ")^! %&-R4%! :;.K%6(&5! 1)!

*12L4%W! 1R\%*':! -:! X%44! -:! '1! 5-'/%.! -! /(5/!

&;2R%.! 1)! L1(&':! 2-Y(&5! ('! L1::(R4%! '1! :;.K%6!

*1&'%W':! 1)! %W'%&:(K%! 0(2%&:(1&:! -&0! '1! 1R'-(&!

.%:;4':! 1)! 5.%-'! L.%*(:(1&! -:! *1&*%.&:! '/%! 2%'.(*!

-:L%*'! -&0! :;.)-*%! */-.-*'%.(:'(*:! =Q-.'1412%(! _!

$LL14('19! >?<F]! h-2R%.:9! ,(:%&R%(::9! "-;%.R(%.9!

m;L)%.:*/2(0'9! a-(:%*Y%.9! "1'110%/9! _! [-&;:*/9!

>??8@I! 3/%! 0%:*.(L'(1&! 1)! :;.)-*%:! R%*12%:!

L-.'(*;4-.46! 0%'-(4%0! (&! L.1K(0(&5! 2%'.(*9!

5%12%'.(*! -&0! */.12-'(*! (&)1.2-'(1&I! ^1.%1K%.9!

0(5('-4! :;.K%6(&5! '%*/&1415(%:! L.1K%!

-0K-&'-5%1;:! -'! '/%! :'-5%! 1)! .%*1&:'.;*'(1&9!

1L%&(&5!;L!L1::(R(4('(%:!'1!(&'%5.-'%!&1'!1&46!'/%!

:;.K%6(&5!2%'/101415(%:!R;'!-4:1!0())%.%&'!210%4!

'6L%:I! a%12%'.(*! 0-'-! -441X:! 2%-:;.%2%&'! 1)!

0-2-5%:9! 0%)1.2-'(1&:9! :'.;*';.-4! 0(2%&:(1&:9!

-&0! L.1L1.'(1&:I! NLL%-.-&*%! 5(K%:! -! 21.%!

.%-4(:'(*! K(%X! 1)! '/%! :'.;*';.%! '1! */-.-*'%.(U%! (':!

:'-'%! 1)! *1&:%.K-'(1&! -&0! '/%! :;.)-*%! *1&0('(1&:!

1)! '/%! *1&:'.;*'(1&! 2-'%.(-4:I! #1&'%W'! -441X:! )1.!

(&'%.L.%'-'(1&:! -&0! -&-46:%:! '1! R%! L%.)1.2%0!

R-:%0! 1& '/%! %&K(.1&2%&'-49! ;.R-&9! -&0!

5%15.-L/(*-4! *1&'%W':! =[%::9! O%'.1K(*9! ^%6%.9!

+(::1419! _! m;%:'%.9! >?<A@I! ,-*/! 1)! '/%:%! -:L%*':!

/-K%!'/%(.!1X&!:L%*()(*-'(1&:!-&0!.%Z;(.%2%&':!(&!

1.0%.! '1! L.1K(0%! '/%! -LL.1L.(-'%! -**;.-*6! -&0!

4%K%4! 1)! 0%'-(4! )1.! '/%! (&'%&0%0! ;:%! 1)! '/%! 0-'-I!

"';06(&5! -.*/('%*';.-4! -&0! -.*/-%1415(*-4!

/%.('-5%!).12!'/%!0(5('(U%0!5%12%'.6!.%Z;(.%:!-&!

%W'.%2%46!/(5/!4%K%4!1)!L.%*(:(1&!-&0!-**;.-*6!'1!

2%-:;.%!0%'-(4:!01X&!'1!'/%!1.0%.!1)!-!2(44(2%'%.I!

c/%&! *1&:(0%.(&5! -LL%-.-&*%9! '/%! .%Z;(.%0!

.%:14;'(1&!2-6!R%!%K%&!)(&%.!'/-&!(:!%K%&!L1::(R4%!

X('/!4-:%.!R-:%0!'%*/&(Z;%:]!'/(:!(:!X/%.%!L/1'1!

R-:%0!DG!.%*1&:'.;*'(1&!-&0!a(5-L/1'1!'%W';.(&5!

R%*12%:! %W'.%2%46! ;:%);4I! #1&'%W';-4! -&-46:%:!

1)'%&! .%Z;(.%! 4%::! 5%12%'.(*! L.%*(:(1&! -&0! *-&!

L%.)1.2%0! ).12! *1-.:%.! 0-'-:%':9! R;'! .%Z;(.%! -!

R.1-0%.!%WL-&:%!1)!0-'-!*144%*'(1&!=a-(-&(9!>?<A@I!

3/%!'.-&:('(1&!).12!:;.K%6(&5!'1!:;.K%6!(:!0%)(&%0!

R6!)1.2-4(U(&5!>G!-&0!DG!210%4:!X/(*/!%WL.%::!

'/%! .%4-'(1&! 1)! *1..%:L1&0%&*%! R%'X%%&! '/%! .%-4!

j<! ! -&0!'/%!K(.';-4!-&0!2-Y%!('!L1::(R4%!'1!%:'-R4(:/!-!

*1&'(&;1;:!.%4-'(1&!(*1&(*('6!-&0!'/%!K(:;-4(U-'(1&!

1)! '/%! 1R\%*'! :;.K%6%0I! 310-6! 210%4:! -.%! '/%!

L1(&'!1)!0%L-.';.%!)1.!-44!'/%!-*'(K('(%:!-(2%0!-'!-!

21.%! L.1)1;&0! Y&1X4%05%! -&0! L.1'%*'(1&! 1)! '/%!

1R\%*'I! G())%.%&'! )(%40:! 1)! 1L%.-'(1&:! *1&&%*'%0!

X('/! #;4';.-4! [%.('-5%! B! ).12! *-'-415;(&5! '1!

L.%:%.K-'(1&9! ).12! 0%:(5&! '1! .%:'1.-'(1&! -&0!

K-41.(U-'(1&! B! R%5(&! '1! L.%:%&'! '/%! %&1.21;:!

L1'%&'(-4:! (&/%.%&'! (&! 210%4:! 1R'-(&%0! '/.1;5/!

DG!:;.K%6:I!$&!:12%!*-:%:9!'1!1R:%.K%!-.'()-*':!-'!

K-.(1;:! :*-4%:! -&0! ).12! 0())%.%&'! K(%XL1(&':!

0(5('-446! (:! 21.%! L.10;*'(K%! '/-&! :';06(&5! X1.Y!

(':%4)I!3/%6!2-Y%!('!L1::(R4%!'1!0%:(5&!-&0!L.%L-.%!

.%*1&:'.;*'(1&9! .%(&)1.*%2%&'! -&0! .%:'1.-'(1&!

1L%.-'(1&:!0(.%*'46!(&!'/.%%!0(2%&:(1&:!-:!X%44!-:!

'1! 01*;2%&'! 0())%.%&'! '.-&:)1.2-'(1&:! '/%!

-.'()-*':!;&0%.X%&'!1K%.!'/%!*1;.:%!1)!*%&';.(%:I!

^1.%1K%.9! '/%6! 1L%&! ;L! K-.(1;:! L1::(R(4('(%:!

4(&Y%0! '1! '/%(.! -LL4(*-'(1&! '/.1;5/! 0())%.%&'!

.%L.%:%&'-'(1&!:*-4%:!=).12!<S<!'1!<Sp@9!0())%.%&'!

.%-0(&5! 4%K%4:! )1.! L;.L1:%:! '/-'! 4%-0! ).12!

Y&1X4%05%!'1X-.0:!L1L;4-.(U-'(1&!-&0!.%:%-.*/I!

3/;:9! -! :6:'%2! (:! :'.;*';.%0! 1;'! V! .(5(0! R;'!

06&-2(*!-&0!*12L4%'%!(&!(':!*1&'%&':!B!R-:%0!1&!

'/%! '.-&:('(K%! -LL4(*-'(1&! 1)! 0())%.%&'! 210%4:I!

c/(4%!-'!'/%!:'-5%!1)!0-'-!-*Z;(:('(1&!X%!.%)%..%0!

'1! (&'%5.-'%0! :;.K%6(&5! =(&'%5.-'(1&! 1)!

2%'/101415(%:@9! -'! '/%! :'-5%! 1)! %4-R1.-'(&5! X%!

:/-44!R%!*1&*%.&%0!X('/!(&'%5.-'%0!:;.K%6!=210%4!

(&'%5.-'(1&@I!,-*/!210%4!'6L14156!*122;&(*-'%:!

:12%'/(&5!-!4(''4%!0())%.%&'!(&!-**1.0-&*%!X('/!'/%!

L%*;4(-.! )%-';.%:! 1)! '/%! .%L.%:%&'-'(1&! 210-4('6!

;:%0! -&0! '/%! */-.-*'%.(U-'(1&! 1)! >G! -&0! DG!

210%4:! '/.1;5/! 0())%.%&'! -''.(R;'%:! 2-Y%:! ;L! -!

2;4'(B4%K%4! 01*;2%&'-'(1&! :6:'%2! R-:%0! 1&! '/%!

0%)(&('(1&!1)!'/%!5%12%'.69!'6L14156!-&0!'%W';.%⁸I!

^;4'(4%K%4! -&-46'(*-4! 01*;2%&'-'(1&9! .%L.%:%&'%0!

R6!;&L.1*%::%0!0-'-9!(:!-&!(2L1.'-&'!-:L%*'!X/%&!

0%)(&(&5! >GJDG! 210%4:I! $'! (&*4;0%:! -R:14;'%46!

).%%! 01*;2%&'-'(1&! )1.! -44! :*/14-.:]! DG! 210%4:!

'/-'! *-&! .%-*/! -! <S<! :*-4%! X('/! '/%! L1::(R(4('6! '1!

;:%! '%W';.%! 2-LL(&5! '1! */-.-*'%.(:%! :;.)-*%:!

="'64(-&(9! G1;4-2(:9! N'/-&-:(1;9! $1-&&(0(:9! _!

N20('(:9!>?<j@I!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

8! a%12%'.6! 0%)(&%:! '/%! L1:('(1&! 1)! 1R\%*':! X('/! '/%! M8' J8' 4!

*11.0(&-'%:I!3/%6!(0%&'()6!'/%!L1(&':!1)!1R\%*':!(&!:L-*%!(&!-!

:6:'%2!1)!.%)%.%&*%I!3/(:!*-&!R%!V!-:!&%*%::-.6!V!-R:14;'%!1.!

.%4-'(K%I!31L14156!0%:*.(R%:!'/%!.%4-'(1&:!R%'X%%&!5%12%'.(*!

%&'('(%:! -&0! -&-46U%:! '/%! :;.)-*%:! '/-'! 0%)(&%! '/%! 1R\%*'I!

3%W';.%! *12L4%'%:! '/%! 0%:*.(L'(1&! 1)! '/%! K(.';-4! 1R\%*'!

2-Y(&5!(&!.%*15&(U-R4%!-&0!-''.(R;'-R4%!'1!'/%!.%-4!1R\%*'I!

3/%! L.1*%::! ;:%0! '1! 0%)(&%! '/%! 5%&%.-4! -&0!

0%'-(4%0! DG! 210%4:! (:! 0(K(0%0! (&'1! :%L-.-'%!

L/-:%:! '/-'! )1441X! '/%! .%5(:'.-'(1&! 1)! '/%! L1(&'!

*41;0:! -&0! -441X! -**;.-'%! 0%'%.2(&-'(1&! 1)! '/%!

'1L14156! 1)! '/%! :;.)-*%:I! 3/%:%! 210%4:9! X/%'/%.!

5%12%'.(*9! '%W';.%0! 1.! '/%2-'(*9! X%.%! '/%! R-:(:!

)1.! -! :%.(%:! 1)! *1&:(0%.-'(1&:! -R1;'! '/%! )1.2! 1)!

'/%!:;.)-*%:9!'/%(.!.%5;4-.('6J(..%5;4-.('69!:'-'%!1)!

*1&:%.K-'(1&! -&0! -&-46:(:! 1)! '/%! 2-'%.(-4:I!

i;.'/%.21.%9!0%L%&0(&5!1&!'/%!'6L%!1)!210%4!-&0!

(':! */-.-*'%.(:'(*:! ('! (:! L1::(R4%! '1! *122;&(*-'%!

0())%.%&'! -:L%*':! 1)! '/%! 1R\%*':! (&! Z;%:'(1&I! i1.!

%W-2L4%9! %K%&! ()! '/%! 5%12%'.(*! 210%4! /-:! &1!

*/.12-'(*!1.!2-'%.(-4!0-'-!('!(:!:'(44!K%.6!;:%);4!'1!

:';06! '/%! -..-&5%2%&'! 1)! 2-::%:9! 5%12%'.6! -&0!

L.1L1.'(1&:!-:!X%44!-:!;&0%.:'-&0!'/%!.%*(L.1*-4!

L1:('(1&! -&0! .%4-'(1&:/(L! R%'X%%&! '/%! %4%2%&':!

(&! '/%! -.*/('%*';.-4! *12L1:('(1&I! $&:'%-0! '/%!

'%W';.%0!210%4!/%4L:!'1!0%)(&%!'/%!)1.2-4!-:L%*':!

-&0! :'-'%! 1)! *1&:%.K-'(1&! 1)! '/%! -.'()-*'! R6! )(.:'!

;:(&5! '/%! +aQ! 0-'-! 1R'-(&%0! ).12! '/%! 0(5('-4!

(2-5%:! -*Z;(.%0! R6! '/%! :-2%! (&:'.;2%&'! -'! '/%!

:-2%!'(2%!-:!'/%!4-:%.!:*-&]!'/%!*/.12-'(*!0-'-!(&!

'/%:%!(2-5%:!(:!-**;.-'%46!4(&Y%0!'1!'/%!5%12%'.(*!

L1:('(1&! 1)! '/%! :;.K%6%0! L1(&':I! i(&-4469! '/%!

'/%2-'(*! 210%4! %WL41(':! '/%! :62R14(*! &-';.%! 1)!

*141;.! '1! L.1K(0%! (&)1.2-'(1&! -R1;'! :%K%.-4!

0())%.%&'! -:L%*':I! Q6! ;:(&5! *141;.! '1! %:'-R4(:/!

/1215%&%1;:!-.%-:!(&!'/%!210%4!X%!*-&!/(5/4(5/'!

)1.2:9! '/%! /%'%.15%&%('6! 1)! '/%! 2-'%.(-4:9! '/%(.!

:'-'%! 1)! *1&:%.K-'(1&! -&0! :12%'(2%:! %K%&! '/%(.!

0%5.-0-'(1&!L-'/1415(%:I!!

#.%-'(&5! DG! -&0! >G! 210%4:! 2-Y%:! ('! L1::(R4%! '1!

:/()'! ).12! -! .%-4! 1R\%*'! '1! (':! .%L.%:%&'-'(1&! R6!

:%4%*'(&5!:12%!1)!'/%!%&04%::!0-'-!0%:*.(R(&5!'/%!

1R\%*'I! HRK(1;:469! '/%! 21.%! '/%! K(.';-4! 0-'-!

*1..%:L1&0:!'1!'/%!.%-4!1R\%*'9!'/%!21.%!-**;.-'%!

'/%! -&-46:(:! -&0! (&'%.L.%'-'(1&I! 3X1! (::;%:! /-K%!

'1!R%!'-*Y4%0!X/%&!('!*12%:!'(2%!'1!R;(40!210%4:!

-&0! %W%*;'%! 0.-X(&5:! 1)! *12L4%W! -.'()-*':I! 3/%!

)(.:'! (&K14K%:! '/%! &%%0! '1! ;&0%.:'-&0! -&0!

;&0%.:*1.%!'/%!;&(Z;%!-:L%*':!1)!'/%!*1&'%W':!(&!

Z;%:'(1&! B! 4-.5%9! :L.-X4(&5! -.%-:! -&0!

5%12%'.(*-446! (..%5;4-.! -.*/('%*';.-4! -&0!

-.*/-%1415(*-4! -.'%)-*':! B! :(&*%! '/%! 4-''%.!

%))%*'(K%46! :'1L! '/%! 1L%.-'1.! ).12! (0%&'()6(&5!

:/-.L! %05%:! 1.! L.%*(:%! )1.2:I! 3/%! :%*1&0! (::;%!

(&K14K%:! '/%! .%L.%:%&'-'(1&! :*-4%9! (&! '/%! *-:%! 1)!

>G!210%4:9!-&0!'/%!4%K%4!1)!0%'-(4!)1.!DG!210%4:I!!

j>!

O@';A".0")/'NPQOP'3-0$.:'+%-3'3&::"I$'OP'0&*&'

&#RA":"*"-)'

3/%! (..%5;4-.('6! -&0! 0(:'(&*'(K%! '.-(':! 1)!

-.'()-*':! 2-Y%:! ('! &%*%::-.6! '1! 01*;2%&'! '/%(.!

21.L/14156! R-:%0! 1&! -! L4-&! X/(*/9! 0;.(&5!

-*Z;(:('(1&! -&0! .%:'(';'(1&9! .-&5%:! ).12! 5%&%.-4!

'1!0%'-(4%0!-.%-:I!$'f:!(2L1.'-&'!'1!;&0%.:'-&0!'/%!

e*1&'-*'! L1(&'f! R%'X%%&! L.10;*':! *.%-'%0! R6!

'.-0('(1&-4! :;.K%6! -*'(K('(%:! -&0! '/1:%! 5%&%.-'%0!

R6! &%X! 2-::(K%! 0-'-! -*Z;(:('(1&! '%*/&1415(%:I! $'!

(&K14K%:! &1'! 1&46! '/%! 1L%.-'(1&-4! -:L%*':!

-::1*(-'%0!X('/!'/%!.%L.%:%&'-'(1&9!R;'!'/%!21.%!

5%&%.-4!(::;%!1)!/1X!*15&('(K%!L.1*%::%:!X1.Y!(&!

'/%! X1.40! -'! 4-.5%I! c('/! '/%! *1&'(&;1;:!

-0K-&*%2%&'!1)!'%*/&141569!0-'-!-*Z;(:('(1&!-&0!

%4-R1.-'(1&! 1L%.-'(1&:! -.%! R%*12(&5! %K%.! 21.%!

0(5('(U%0! =Q.;&%'-;09! G%! h;*-9! q-&K(%.BQ-01:-9!

Q%*Y9! _! N4B^;Y/'-.9! >?<>]! ^(&'1! _! +%21&0(&19!

>?<F@I! $'! (:! (&K-.(-R46! '/%! *-:%! '/-'! 1&46! R6!

(&'%5.-'(&5!0())%.%&'!2%'/101415(%:!*-&!X%!1R'-(&!

.%:;4':! 21.%! *12L4%'%! -&0! R%''%.! (&! '/%!

L%.:L%*'(K%! 1)! *15&('(1&I! [1X%K%.9! ('! (:!

(&0(:L%&:-R4%!'/-'!L.-*'(*-4B1L%.-'(K%!L.1*%0;.%:!

-.%!*.('(*-446!-&0!(&'%44%*';-446!:;LL1.'%0I!3/(:!(:!

'/%!R-:(:!)1.!-!);44!-&0!(&)1.2%0!0%K%41L2%&'!'/-'!

L.12L':!);';.%!L.15.%::I!!

3/%.%!-.%!'/.%%!L.(&*(L-4!)(%40:!1)!-LL4(*-'(1&!

*1&*%.&%0! (&! 210%4! *1&:'.;*'(1&! -&0!

0%K%41L2%&'I! 3/%! )(.:'! *-&! R%! (0%&'()(%0! (&!

*-'-415;(&5! -&0! *4-::()6(&5! 210%4:! X/(*/! -441X!

1&%! '1! *1&:'.;*'! -! b/(:'1.(*-4b! 2%21.6! :&-L:/1'9!

%K%.! 21.%! ;&:'-R4%! '10-6! 0;%! '1! ;&L.%0(*'-R4%!

%K%&':!X/%'/%.!&-';.-4!1.!2-&2-0%]!'/%!:%*1&0!

:L/%.%! 1)! -LL4(*-'(1&! (:! 4(&Y%0! '1! '/%! :';06! 1)!

-&'(Z;%! 1R\%*':! %K%&! ()! 1&46! L-.'(-446! L.%:%.K%0!

X/%.%! (&'%5.-'(1&! 1)! 0())%.%&'! 2%'/101415(%:!

-441X:! 1&%! '1! .%*1&:'.;*'! '/%! 1R\%*'! (&! (':!

*12L4%'%&%::]!'/%!'/(.0!)(%40!*1&*%.&:!0%:(5&(&59!

.%:'1.-'(1&9! -&0! *1&:14(0-'(1&! V! X/%.%! '/%!

0%:(5&(&5! :'-&*%! *-&! 0(.%*'46! ';.&! '1! '/%! '/.%%!

0(2%&:(1&-4! 1R\%*'I! i;.'/%.21.%9! '/%!

*1&:'.;*'(1&! 1)! 210%4:! X('/(&! '/%! -R1K%B 2%&'(1&%0!)(%40:!1) %&Z;(.69!2-Y%:!('!L1::(R4%!'1!

K-41.(U%! 1R\%*':! 1)! *;4';.-4! /%.('-5%9! 1))%.(&5! -'!

'/%!:-2%!'(2%!-!*/-&*%!'1!5%'!'1!Y&1X!'/%2!21.%!

%W'%&:(K%46! '/-&Y:! '1! '/%! L1::(R(4('(%:! 1)!

L1L;4-.(U(&5!Y&1X4%05%!:1!2;*/!(&*.%-:%0!R6!'/%!

;:%!1)!'/%!$&'%.&%'I!!

3/%!)1441X(&5!*-:%!:';0(%:!2-6!)-44!;&0%.!'/%!

)(.:'! -&0! :%*1&0! )(%40I! $&! R1'/! *-:%:! '/%! 'X1!

L.(2-.6! '%*/&(Z;%:! ;'(4(U%0! )1.! 0(5('-4!

01*;2%&'-'(1&! -.%! 4-:%.! :*-&&(&5! -&0!

L/1'15.-22%'.6I! h-:%.! :*-&&(&5! L.1K(0%:!

'.;:'%0! -**;.-*6! -&0! L.%*(:(1&9! R;'! %-*/!

(&:'.;2%&'!/-:!(':!1X&!4(2('-'(1&:!-&0!)(W%0!:%'!1)!

.%:14;'(1&! *-L-R(4('(%:I! O/1'15.-22%'.6!

'%*/&(Z;%:! -.%! %W'.%2%46! )4%W(R4%! '1! L.1K(0%!

.%:14;'(1&:! .-&5(&5! ).12! Y(412%'%.:! '1!

2(*.12%'%.:!=^(*/%4%''(9!#/-&04%.9!_!h-&%9!>?<A@I!!

$&!-00('(1&!'1!'/%!.%4-'(K%!5%12%'.6!5%&%.-'%0!R6!

L/1'15.-22%'.(*! '%*/&(Z;%:9! '/%! (2-5%:!

'/%2:%4K%:! *-&! R%! ;:%0! '1! L.1K(0%! /(5/B .%:14;'(1&! L/1'1.%-4(:'(*! '%W';.%:! '1! '/%! '-.5%'!

R%(&5! :';0(%0I! $&'%5.-'(1&! 1)! (2-5(&5! '%*/&(Z;%:!

*-&!6(%40!-!:;L%.(1.!%&0!L.10;*'!()!'/%!(&'%5.-'(1&!

2%'/1014156! (:! X%44! 01*;2%&'%0! -&0! 1L'(2(U%0!

)1.! -**;.-'%! -4(5&2%&'! 1)! 210-4('(%:I! 3/%! /(5/!

)(0%4('6!5%12%'.(*!0-'-!L.1K(0%0!R6!4-:%.!:*-&&(&5!

*-&! R%! *12L4%2%&'%0! R6! '/%! /(5/! .%:14;'(1&!

(2-5%:! ).12! L/1'15.-22%'.(*! .%*1&:'.;*'(1&:I!

3/%! &%*%::('6! 1)! %4-R1.-'(&5! DG! 210%4:! -:! -!

:;**%::(K%! :'-5%! 2-0%! ('! L1::(R4%! '1! -LL46! /(5/!

0%)(&('(1&! (2-5%:! '1! '/%! :;.K%6%0! 1R\%*'I! 3/%!

2;4'(210-4! 0-'-! '15%'/%.! :/1;40! &1'! 1&46! :%.K%!

-:!K(:;-4!-(0:9!R;'!:/1;40!R%!;:%0!'1!'/%(.!);44%:'!

%W'%&'! )1.! *144-R1.-'(K%! -&-46:(:! -21&5! -!

2;4'(0(:*(L4(&-.6! '%-2I! N&1'/%.! );&0-2%&'-4!

-:L%*'9! :'.(*'46! *1&&%*'%0! X('/! '/%! -R1K%9! :%%2:!

'1!R%!'/%!*12L.%/%&:(1&!1)!Z;-4('6!4%K%4!'/-'!'/%!

210%4:!1R'-(&%0!X('/!'/%!0(K%.:%!2%'/101415(%:!

=4-:%.!:*-&&%.!-&0!"i^@!-*/(%K%!-:!X%44!-:!'/%(.!

L1::(R(4('6!'1!L%.)1.2!1&!4-.5%.!1.!:2-44%.!:*-4%I!

H&!L.%*(:%46!:;*/!210%4:!X%!*-&!*-..6!1;'!(&('(-4!

-&-46:%:! 1)! '/%! :'-'%! 1)! L.%:%.K-'(1&! 1)! :;.)-*%:9!

2-L! 1;'! '/%! 0%5.%%! 1)! '/%(.! 0%5.-0-'(1&! -&0!

(0%&'()6!*/-&5%:!(&!'/%!X-44!'%W';.%!X/(4%!(&!*-:%!

1)!0%*1.-'(K%!*1K%.(&5:!5-L:!*-&!R%!0(:*1K%.%0I!

S@'T"..&';-%/<$:$'&%#<"*$#*A%$:'

3/%! )(.:'! -LL4(*-'(1&9! 1&! 7(44-! Q1.5/%:%!

-.*/('%*';.%:^`! =i(5I<@9! /-:! R%%&! ;&0%.'-Y%&! X('/!

K-.(1;:!!!!1R\%*'(K%:!!!!(&!!!!K(%XI!!!$'!!!!.%:':!!!1&!!!'/%!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

`! 3/%! 7(44-! Q1.5/%:%! L-.Y! (&! +12%! *1K%.:! '/%! -.%-! 1)!

-LL.1W(2-'%46! `?! /-! -&0! (:! :(';-'%0! (&! '/%! K%.6! *%&'%.! 1)!

+12%I!3/%!*1&:'.;*'(1&!1)!'/%!K(44-!-:!-!:;R;.R-&!.%:(0%&*%!

:'-.'%0! -.1;&0! '/%! 6%-.! <j?j! R;'! '/%&9! (&! *1&:%Z;%&*%! 1)!

/(:'1.(*-4! %K%&':! -&0! ;.R-&! '.-&:)1.2-'(1&:! *1&*%.&(&5!

+12%! -&0! '/%! X/14%! 1)! $'-469! '/%! ! L-.Y! X-:! '1! /-K%! R%%&!

L-.*%4%0! 1;'! -&0! '/%! X/14%! :('%! *1;40! /-K%! R%%&!

0(:2%2R%.%0I! i1.! '/(:! .%-:1&! (&! <E?<9! '/%! "'-'%! 1)! $'-46!

R1;5/'!'/%!X/14%!21&;2%&'-4!*12L4%W!-&0!(&!<E?D!'/%!L-.Y!

X-:! /-&0%0! 1K%.! '1! '/%! #122;&%! 1)! +12%! -&0! 1L%&%0! '1!

'/%! L;R4(*I! 310-6! ('! (:! -&! 1L%&B-(.! 2;:%;2! *1&'-(&(&5!

R;(40(&5:9! -.*/('%*';.-4! *12L4%W%:9! 21&;2%&':! -&0!

)1;&'-(&:9!-44!X1.Y:!1)!1;':'-&0(&5!R-.1Z;%9!&%1*4-::(*-4!-&0!

%*4%*'(*!-.'(:':I!

jD! !

!

!

1BCD'ES!7(44-!Q1.5/%:%!(&!+12%!

L.1)1;&0! Y&1X4%05%! 1)! -&! (2L1.'-&'! *12L4%W9!! 01''%0! X('/! %4%2%&':! .%L.%:%&'(&5! K-.(1;:!

-.*/('%*';.-4! '6L1415(%:! 1)! /;5%9! 2%0(;2! -&0!

:2-44! :*-4%! =i(5I>@I! 3/%! 2-\1.('6! 1)! R;(40(&5:!

%.%*'%0! )1.! '/%! L;.L1:%! 1)! .%L.%:%&'-'(1&!

);&*'(1&! '10-6! -:! K%&;%:! 1)! *;4';.-4! %K%&':! -&0!

(&'%44%*';-4! -*'(K('6S! -.'! 5-44%.(%:9! 2;:%;2! -&0!

-*-0%2(%:I! H'/%.:9! *1&*%(K%0! -:! )1.2:! 1)!

%2R%44(:/(&5!'/%!5-.0%&:9!/-K%!&1'!*/-&5%0!'/%(.!

1.(5(&-4! );&*'(1&! -&0! -.%! ;:%0! )1.! (0%&'()6(&5!

(2L1.'-&'! L4-*%:! (&! '/%! L-.Y! 4(Y%9! )1.! %W-2L4%9!

%&'.-&*%:!1.!(&'%.:%*'(1&:!R%'X%%&!2-(&!-44%6:I!!

3/%! *12L4%W('6! 1)! '/%! -.*/('%*';.%! (&! '/%!

X/14%! L-.Y! X(44! R%! %&/-&*%0! (&! '/%! L.1*%::! 1)!

:6&'/%:(U-'(1&! '/.1;5/! 0(5('-4! 210%4:! -&0! (&! -!

*1..%*'! (&'%.L.%'-'(1&! -&0! 2-&-5%2%&'! 1)!

(&)1.2-'(1&I! "L%*()(*-4469! '/%! %&Z;(.6! X(44! R%!

1.(%&'%0!'1X-.0:!-&!-&-46:(:!1)!'/%!Z;-4('6!1)!'/%!

0-'-!-*Z;(.%0!2-::(K%469!.-&5(&5!).12!'/%!;.R-&!

:*-4%!'1!'/-'!1)!'/%!0%'-(4I!3/%!1'/%.!);&0-2%&'-4!

-:L%*'! 1)! '/%! :';06! (:! '1! -&-46U%! '/%! .%:;4':! 1)!

;:(&5! 41X! *1:'! -*Z;(:('(1&! (&:'.;2%&':! =X('/! '/%!

;:%! 1)! 1L%&! :1;.*%! 1.! 41X! *1:'! :1)'X-.%! -'! '/%!

:'-5%!1)!%4-R1.-'(1&!.-'/%.!'/-&!'/%!L-(0!K-.(%'69!

1.! '/1:%! X/1:%! L.(*%! (:! 2;*/! 21.%! .%-:1&-R4%!

'/-&! '/-'! 1)! 1'/%.! ;:-R4%! L.15.-2:@! (&! 1.0%.! '1!

'%:'!'/%!0%'-(4!4%K%4!L1::(R4%!'1!-*/(%K%!(&!'%.2:!1)!

2%'.(*!-**;.-*6!-:!X%44!-:!2%'.(*9!*/.12-'(*!-&0!

:;.)-*%! (&)1.2-'(1&I! ,K%&! '/1;5/! &1X-0-6:! '/%!

:;.K%6(&5! -&0! :;.K%6! 1L%.-'(1&:! -.%! *-..(%0! 1;'!

-421:'!%W*4;:(K%46!X('/!0(5('-4!2%-&:!)1441X(&5!-!

L.%B%:'-R4(:/%0! :%Z;%&*%9! X/-'! (:! 1)'%&! 2(::(&5!

).12! '/%! 1L%.-'(K%! L.-*'(*%! (:! '/%! *12L4%'%! -&0!

.%-:1&%0!1;'!:'-&0-.0(U-'(1&!1)!L.1*%::%:!X/(*/!

X1;40! 2-Y%! (2L1::(R4%! '1! )(W! Z;-&'('-'(K%! -&0!

Z;-4('-'(K%!)%-';.%:!1)!1R\%*':!-&-46U%0!(&!.%4-'(1&!

'1!'/%!2%'/1014156!-LL4(%0!-:!X%44!-:!'1!'/%!:*-4%!

1)!210%4:I!!

3/%!:';06!1)!'/%!-.*/('%*';.%!1)!7(44-!Q1.5/%:%!

:'-.'%0!X('/!-!*-.%);4!-&0!0%'-(4%0!*-'-415;(&5!1)!

%W(:'(&5! :'.;*';.%:I! 3/%! L.%:%&'! .%:%-.*/!

*1&*%.&:! 1&46! 1R\%*':! 1)! '/%! 2%0(;2! :*-4%9! 4(Y%!

%&'.-&*%:!1.!-.*/('%*';.-4!0%*1.9!-&0!1&!'/%!:2-44!

:*-4%9!4(Y%!)1;&'-(&:!)%-';.(&5!K-.(1;:!:*;4L';.%:I!

3/%!*/1(*%!(:!.%4-'%0!'1!'/%!%WL%.(2%&'-4!-:L%*'!1)!

'/%! :;.K%6(&5! 2%'/1014156! -01L'%09! *1&:(0%.%0!

%:L%*(-446!:;('-R4%!)1.!-.'()-*':!1)!'/(:!'6L%I!!

!

!

1BCD'FS!#-'-415(&5!1)!7(44-!Q1.5/%:%!N.*/('%*';.%S!/;5%9!

2%0(;2!-&0!:2-44!:*-4%!

!3/%! :';06! %&-R4%0! -&-46:(:! 1)! '/%!

L1'%&'(-4('(%:! -:! X%44! -:! '/%! 4(2('-'(1&:! 1)! -&!

-LL.1-*/! '/-'! ;:%:! 41XB*1:'! 2%'/101415(%:! )1.!

-*Z;(.(&5! -&0! *1&:'.;*'(&5! 210%4:! X1.Y%0! 1;'!

)1.!'/%!L;.L1:%!1)!01*;2%&'-'(1&!-&0!*-'-415(&5I!

#-:%!:';0(%:!-&-46U%09!/%'%.15%&%1;:!:'64(:'(*-446!

jF!

-&0!)1.2-4469!/-K%!*1221&!)%-';.%:!4(&Y%0!'1!'/%!

.%*15&(U-R(4('6! -&0! .%L%-'-R(4('6! 1)! -.*/('%*';.-4!

-&0! 0%*1.-'(K%! %4%2%&':! -:! X%44! -:! 1)! '/%!

0(2%&:(1&:I!3/%!4-''%.!)%-';.%!/-:!R%%&!)1;&0!'1!

0%'%.2(&%!'/%!*/1(*%!1)!:;.K%6(&5!2%'/101415(%:!

-LL4(%0! -&0! '/%! -&-46:(:! 1)! '/%! .%:;4':! 1R'-(&%0I!!

$&!)-*'!'/%!"i^!'%*/&(Z;%9!'%:'%0!1&!K-.(1;:!*-:%:!

1)!2%0(;2!-&0!:2-44!:*-4%9!:%%2:!'1!R%!%))%*'(K%!

(&!0%:*.(R(&5!1)!5%12%'.(*9!0(2%&:(1&-49!2-'%.(-4!

-&0! */.12-'(*! )%-';.%:I! #1&:'.;*'(&5! :;*/! -!

:6:'%2! /-:! '1! 1K%.*12%! *%.'-(&! );&0-2%&'-4!

L.1R4%2S!/1X!'1!1R'-(&!DG!.%-4('6!R-:%0!210%4:!

1)! 1R\%*':! X/(*/! -.%! 0())%.%&'! R;'! /1215%&%1;:!

-:! '1! '/%(.! :*-4%9! ;&*%.'-(&'6! 4%K%4! -&0!

K(:;-4(U-'(1&! '6L14156I! 3/%! 0%)(&('(1&! -&0!

2-&-5(&5! 1)! '/%! DG! 210%4! R%*12%! '/%! *.;*(-4!

L1(&'!1)!'/%!L.1R4%2!)1.!'/%!:14;'(1&!1)!X/(*/!('!(:!

);&0-2%&'-4!'1!0%)(&%!-&!1L%.-'(K%!2%'/1014156!

'/-'! *1;40! R%! .%)%..%0! '1! (&! -! :'-&0-.0(U%0!

2-&&%.I!!

3/%! :;.K%6(&5! 1L%.-'(1&:! /-K%! R%%&! *-..(%0!

1;'!)1441X(&5!'/%!L.1\%*'!1)!-!;&('-.6!:;.K%6I!H&%!

1)! '/%! &10-4! L1(&':! (&! '/(:! .%:%-.*/! (:! '/%!

0%)(&('(1&! 1)! 210%4! '6L1415(%:! X%! *-&! *1&:'.;*'!

X('/! '/%! :6:'%2:! 1)! 2-::(K%! 0-'-! -*Z;(:('(1&! (&!

.%4-'(1&!'1!'/%!(&)1.2-'(1&9!X/(*/!'/%!K%.6!:-2%!

210%4:! '.-&:2('! (&! .%L.%:%&'-'(1&! :*-4%! )(W%0! -'!

'/%! L1(&'! 1)! 0%L-.';.%I! 3/%! *1&*%L':! 1)! 0-'-!

Z;-4('6! -&0! :*(%&'()(*('6! -41&5:(0%! '/-'! 1)!

;&*%.'-(&'6!*1&'.14!';.&!1;'!'1!R%!);&0-2%&'-4!(&!

'/%! L.1*%::%:! 1)! -*Z;(:('(1&! -&0! %4-R1.-'(1&I!

3/%.%)1.%9! 0())%.%&'! *-:%! :';0(%:! X%.%! -&-46U%09!

(&!1.0%.!'1!%W%*;'%!-!L.1\%*'!1)!L4-*%2%&'!:;.K%69!

(&0%L%&0%&'46!1)!1&%!-&1'/%.I!G;.(&5!L.%4(2(&-.6!

L4-&&(&5! V! (&0(:L%&:-R4%! )1.! *-..6(&5! 1;'! '/%!

:;.K%6! :*(%&'()(*-446! -:! X%44! -:! )1.! :L%%0(&5! ;L!

)(%40! -*'(K('(%:9! L.1R4%2:! 1)! 2%'/101415(*-4!

&-';.%! /-K%! R%%&! -00.%::%0! -&0! B! )1441X(&5! '/%!

-421:'! X%44B%:'-R4(:/%0! L.-*'(*%! B! '/%! 0%*(:(1&!

X-:! '-Y%&! '1! (&'%5.-'%! K-.(1;:! 2%'/10:! -&0!

(&:'.;2%&':!=Q(-&*/(&(9!$&54%:%9!_!$LL14('1!>?<j@I!

G-'-! -*Z;(:('(1&! *-..(%0! 1;'! '/.1;5/! (&'%5.-'%0!

(&:'.;2%&'! :;.K%6(&5^E! -K-(4%0! (':%4)! 1)! K-.(1;:!

&1&B*1&'-*'! :;.K%6(&5! 2%'/101415(%:9! '/%! L/1'1!

.%*'()(*-'(1&! X('/! '/%! K(%X! '1! 1R'-(&(&5! 541R-4!

.%L.%:%&'-'(1&9!0%'-(4!.%L.%:%&'-'(1&!1.!-!:L%*()(*!

-&-46:(:! 1)! 2-'%.(-4! -:L%*':! 1)! :;.)-*%:I! 3/%!

(&)1.2-'(1&! -*Z;(.%0! /-K%! '/%&! R%%&! 1.5-&(U%0!

(&'1! -! :6:'%2! (&! 1.0%.! '1! 2-Y%! :;.%! '/-'! '/%!

*15&('(K%! L(*';.%! 1)! '/%! 1R\%*'! ;&0%.! -&-46:(:! R%!

-:!*12L4%'%!-&0!2;4'(B4%K%4!-:!L1::(R4%!:1!'/-'!('!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

E! N! *-2%.-! +%)4%W! C(Y1&! GE?! -&0! -! L/1'1! *-2%.-! +%)4%W!

#-&1&!FA?G!X%.%!'/%!(&:'.;2%&':!;:%0I!

*-&! R%! :';0(%0! (&B0%L'/! (&! (':! 0())%.%&'! -:L%*':!

-&0! (&'%.L.%'-'(1&! Y%6:! =2%'.(*9! */.12-'(*9!

/(:'1.(*-4!-&0!'/-'!1)!L.%:%.K-'(1&@!X/(*/!*-&!'/%!

R%!*12L-.%0!'1!1&%!-&1'/%.I!

3/%!%WL%.(2%&'!:%%Y:!'1!(&'%5.-'%!'/%!L.1*%::!

1)!:;.K%6(&5!X('/!'/-'!1)!*-'-415(&5!R6!:'.;*';.(&5!

210%4:! 1R'-(&%0! '/.1;5/! 0(5('-4! L/1'15.-L/(*!

(2-5%:! X('/! '/%! -(2! '1! *.%-'%! -! 01*;2%&'-.6!

-.*/(K%I! N*Z;(:('(1&! 1L%.-'(1&:! -.%! 4(&Y%0! '1! '/%!

*1..%*'&%::!1)!'/%!L.1*%::%:!)1441X%0!-&0!'1!'/%!

*1&*%L'! 1)! 2%'.(*! -**;.-*6! =#(L.(-&(! _! i-&'(&(9!

>?<A@I!

!

1BCD'G0'+%L%-'-R4%!2%'/1014156!)1.!DG!0-'-!*-L';.%!-&0!DG!

0-'-I!#-:%!:';06S!i1&'-&-!0%44%!L(.-2(0('

!3/;:9! -! 2%'.1415(*-4! :%''(&5! (:! Z;-4('-'(K%46!

0%:*.(R%0! R6! -&! -55.%5-'%! 1)! L-.-2%'%.:! '/-'!

0%)(&%!'/%!*/-.-*'%.(:'(*!1)!2%-:;.%S!;&*%.'-(&'69!

.%L%-'-R(4('6! -&0! -**;.-*6@I! 3/%! :'-5%! 1)! 0-'-!

-*Z;(:('(1&! :/1;40! -4X-6:! R%! *1&:(0%.%0! -:! -&!

-LL4(*-'(1&! 1)! -! :*(%&'()(*! 2%'/10! R-:%0! 1&! -!

*144%*'(1&! 1)! %2L(.(*-446! 1R:%.K-R4%! -&0!

2%-:;.-R4%! 0-'-9! X/(*/! *-&! R%! -.*/(K%0! -&0!

:;R\%*'%0!'1!%W'%.&-4!K%.()(*-'(1&!'1!R%!K-4(0-'%0I!

3/%! -LL4(%0! L.1*%0;.%! =i(5ID@! :/1;40! R%!

.%L4(*-R4%!(&!1.0%.!'1!-*Z;(.%!-!&%X!-55.%5-'%!1)!

0-'-!*12L-.-R4%!'1!'/%!L.%*%0(&5!1&%I!

3/%! 0-'-! *-L';.(&5! :'-5%! =i(5IF@! /-:! R%%&!

*1&0;*'%0! X('/! '/%! -(2! '1! '%:'! '/%! K-4(0('6! 1)! -!

jA! ! L.1*%0;.%! '/-'! -::;2%0! '/-'! 1&46! 41XB*1:'!

(&:'.;2%&':! X(44! R%! ;:%0! )1.! :;.K%6(&5! -&0!

R;(40(&5!DG!210%4:9!*1&'.-:'(&5!0(K%.:%!:6:'%2:I!

3/%! %WL%.(2%&'%0! L.1*%0;.%! X-:! -(2%0! -'!

*1&:'.;*'(&5!Z;-4('-'(K%46!*1&'.144-R4%!DG!-&0!>G!

210%4:! X/%.%! ('! (:! %::%&'(-4! '1! 0%)(&%! '/%!

;&*%.'-(&'6! 4%K%4! 1)! '/%! 210%4:! 4(&Y(&5! ('! '1! '/%!

210%4!:*-4%^<?I!N&!!-''%2L'!!'1!!0%)(&%!!-!!L.(1.(!!'/%!

:*-4%!1)!'/%!210%4!.%Z;(.%:!'/%!Y&1X4%05%!1)!'/%!

2-W(2;2! 0%'-(4! 4%K%4! :;*/! 210%4:! *-&! .%-*/I! $&!

1.0%.!'1!K%.()6!'/%!-**;.-*6!1)!'/%!:;.K%6!0-'-!-:!

X%44! -:! '1! *1&'.14! '/%! 4%K%4! 1)! ;&*%.'-(&'6! 1)! '/%!

210%4!:*-4%9!('!(:!);&0-2%&'-4!'1!*1&).1&'!'/%!0-'-!

1R'-(&%0! R6! 2-Y(&5! L/1'1! (2-5%:! X('/! '/1:%!

1R'-(&%0! R6! 0(.%*'! :;.K%6(&5I! 3/%! .%)4%W! C$mHC!

GE?!*-2%.-!X('/!#^H"!:%&:1.!1)!<>!^%5-L(W%4:!

X('/! -;'12-'(*! )1*;:(&5' -&0! 2-&;-4! U112!

L.1*%0;.%:! (:! ;:%0! (&! '/%! :;.K%6(&5! *-2L-(5&I!

3/%! :;.K%6(&5! L.1\%*'^<<! /-0! 0%)(&%0! (&! 1.0%.! '1!

5;-.-&'%%! *1K%.! 1)! '/%! X/14%! 1R\%*'! -&0! %-*/!

L/1'15.-L/! 1K%.4-LL%0! X('/! '/%! :;**%::(K%! 1&%!

(&!-'!4%-:'!D?BF?!rI!

3/%!)(&-4!.%L.%:%&'-'(1&!:*-4%!1)!'/%!0-'-!X-:!

)(W%0!(&!-0K-&*%!-'!<SA?!X/(4%!V!(&!1.0%.!'1!5%'!-44!

'/%! %4%2%&':! 1)! '/%! 1R\%*'! L.%*(:%46! (&! '/%!

:%4%*'%0!:*-4%9!'/%!0(:'-&*%!X-:!*-4*;4-'%0!R-:%0!

1&! '/%! 4%&:! )1*;:! -&0! '/%! */-.-*'%.(:'(*:! 1)! '/%!

*-2%.-! ;:%0I! #1&:(0%.(&5! '/-'! (&! -&6! :;.K%6(&5!

1L%.-'(1&!('!(:!&%*%::-.6!'1!0%'%.2(&%!'/%!4%K%4!1)!

;&*%.'-(&'6!-4:1!(&!.%4-'(1&!'1!'/%!.%L.%:%&'-'(1&!

:*-4%! L.%K%&'(K%46! )(W%09! '/%! 0())%.%&*%! X1;40!

-21;&'! '1! D! 2(44(2%'%.:9! -! K-4;%! L%.)%*'46!

-**%L'-R4%! R%*-;:%! ('! )-44:! X('/(&! '/%! 5.-L/(*:!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

<?! G(5('-4! .%L.%:%&'-'(1&! .%'.(%K%:! '/%! '/.%%! 0(2%&:(1&-4!

*/-.-*'%.!1)!'/%!1R\%*'!:;.K%6%0I!$&!'/%!.%-42!1)!'/%!K(.';-4!

'/%!5.-L/(*!210%4!*-&!R%!.%L.%:%&'%0!X('/1;'!R%(&5!.%0;*%0!

(&! :*-4%! (&! .%4-'(1&! '1! .%-4('6I! $'! *-&! R%! :-(0! '/%.%)1.%9! '/-'!

-4:1!X('/!0(5('-4!210%4:!('!(:!L1::(R4%!'1!-''.(R;'%!.%)%.%&*%!'1!

:*-4%!(&!1.0%.!'1!(0%&'()6!(':!*-L-*('6!'1!.%L.10;*%!.%-4('6!1&!

'/%!R-:(:!1)!'/%!4%K%4!1)!0%'-(4!-&0!'/%!;&*%.'-(&'6!L1::(R4%!'1!

-*/(%K%I!

<<"(&*%! %-*/! -.*/('%*';.-4! 1R\%*'! /-:! (':! L%*;4(-.('(%:9! (:!

(2L1::(R4%!'1!%:'-R4(:/!-&!-R:14;'%!.;4%!.%5-.0(&5!'/%!X-6!-!

:;.K%6! :/1;40! R%! L%.)1.2%0I! C%K%.'/%4%::9! -44! '/%!

2%'/101415(*-4! 1L'(1&:! -.%! -&-46U%0! -&0! 0%K%41L%0! 0;.(&5!

'/%!:;.K%6!L.1\%*'!(&!1.0%.!'1!1L'(2(U%!'/%!1L%.-'(1&:!K(:BgB K(:! '/%! 1R\%*'(K%I! 3/%! :;.K%6! L.1\%*'! (:! -! Y%6! :'-5%! (&! '/%!

X/14%! L.1*%::I! $'! %:'-R4(:/! '/%! (&:'.;2%&':9! '/%! >G! 210%4!

:*-4%9!-&0!'/%!&;2R%.!-&0!L1:('(1&!1)!'/%!K-.(1;:!:'-'(1&:I!N!

*1..%*'!:;.K%6!L.1\%*'!=L-.'46@!5;-.-&'%%:!'/%!Z;-4('6!1)!'/%!

0-'-! 4-'%.! ;:%0! '1! L.10;*%! '/%! :;.K%6! 0.-X(&5:]! ('! -4:1!

%&:;.%:! '/%! -**;.-'%! 5-'/%.(&5! 1)! &;2%.(*-4! 0-'-! 1R'-(&%0!

1&46! ).12! '/%! 2%-:;.%2%&'! 1L%.-'(1&:! -&0! :'(44! &1'!

L.1*%::%0I! 3/%! 1L%.-'(K%! L/-:%! *12%:! -)'%.! '/%! :;.K%6!

L.1\%*']!'/(:!(:!'/%!212%&'!X/%&!-44!'/%!L4-&&%0!1L%.-'(1&:9!

-&0!-&6!;&)1.%:%%&!1L%.-'(1&:9!-.%!)1.2-4(U%0!(&!:(';I!

%..1.I! ! ,W'.-! *1&)(.2-'(1&! /-:! R%%&! 1R'-(&%0! R6!

*-4*;4-'(&5! '/%! 0%K(-&*%! K-4;%! X('/! #41;0!

#12L-.%9! -&! 1L%&! :1;.*%! :1)'X-.%! ;:%0! )1.!

%4-R1.-'(&5!-&0!*12L-.(&5!DG!*41;0!L1(&':S!-4:1!

(&!'/(:!*-:%!'/%!K-4;%!1R'-(&%0!).12!'/%!:%*'(1&!1)!

'/%! :;.)-*%:! '/-'! 2-Y%! ;L! '/%! 210%4! (&! '/%! 'X1!

0(2%&:(1&-4! L4-&%9! L.1K%:! '1! )-44! X('/(&!

2(44(2%'%.:I!

!

!

1BCD'HS!+%L%-'-R4%!2%'/1014156!)1.!DG!0-'-!*-L';.%!-&0!DG!

0-'-I!#-:%!:';06S!7(44-!Q1.5/%:%!)1;&'-(&:

!3/%!4%K%4!1)!;&*%.'-(&'6!/-:!R%%&!2-&-5%0!R6!

*1..%*'(&5! '/%! 1L'(*-4! -R%..-'(1&:! 1)! (&0(K(0;-4!

L/1'15.-2:! -&0! '/(:! :'-5%! 0(.%*'46! L.%*%0%0! '/%!

*.%-'(1&!1)!'/%!DG!210%4!=i(5IA@!-&0!;:(&5!:12%!

2-.Y%.:! 1&! '/%! 1R'-(&%0! L1(&'! *41;0! )1;&0! '/%!

*1..%:L1&0%&*%! 1)! '/%! :-4(%&'! L1(&':! 2%-:;.%0!

X('/!'/%!2%'/101415(%:!)1.!0(.%*'!:;.K%6(&5I!3/%!

210%4! 1R'-(&%0! '/.1;5/! '/(:! L.1*%0;.%9!

*12L-.%0! R6! 2%-&:! 1)! 1L%&! :1;.*%! #41;0!

#12L-.%! :1)'X-.%! X('/! '/%! 0-'-! %W'.-*'%0! ).12!

0(.%*'!:;.K%6(&59!.%K%-4%0!-&!-K%.-5%!0%K(-'(1&!1)!

D!2(44(2%'%.:^<>I!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

<>!3/%!2%-:;.%2%&'!(:!-!:%'!1)!'/.%%!0-'-S!&;2R%.9!2%-:;.%!

;&('!-&0!;&*%.'-(&'6I!3/%!4-''%.!*-&!R%!-::%::%0!X('/!L.1L%.!

2-'/%2-'(*-4!L.1*%0;.%:I!3/%!:'-&0-.0!0%K(-'(1&!1.!-K%.-5%!

%..1.! *-&! R%! .%)%..%0! '1! -:! '/%! ;&*%.'-(&'6! 1)! '/%!

2%-:;.%2%&'I! "'-&0-.0! 0%K(-'(1&! (:! -&! (&0%W! 1)! :'-'(:'(*!

jj!

' !

1BCD'IS!G%)(&('(1&!1)!DG!210%4S!DG!&;2%.(*-4!210%49!DG!2%:/!

210%4!-&0!DG!'%W';.(U%0!210%4I!#-:%!:';06S!i1&'-&-!

0%44f-*Z;-!)%4(W!-&0!i1&'-&-!0%44%!'-.'-.;5/%!

!

1BCD'JS!>G!'%W';.(U%0!-&0!-.*/('%*';.-4!210%4!).12!DG!210%4I!!

#-:%!:';06S!,0(*14-!0%44-!^;:-!

^%:/h-R!K(:;-4(U%.!X-:!;:%0!'1!*4%-&!'/%!0-'-!

5-(&%0! ).12! '/%! :;.K%6I! 3/%&! '/%! &;2%.(*-4!

210%4! 1R'-(&%0! R6! L.1*%::(&5! L/1'15.-L/:! X-:!

)(.:'! L1:('(1&%0! -&0! L.1L%.46! :*-4%0! (&! #NG!

%&K(.1&2%&'! 1&! '/%! R-:(:! 1)! '/%! 2%-:;.%2%&':!

-*Z;(.%0!0;.(&5!'/%!*-2L-(5&!1)!0(.%*'!:;.K%6(&5I!

3/%! DG! '%W';.%0! 210%4:! X%.%! '/%&! '-Y%&! -:! '/%!

L1(&'! 1)! 0%L-.';.%! )1.! *1&:'.;*'(&5! >G! 210%4:I!

";*/!-&!1L%.-'(1&!(:!-44!R;'!-;'12-'(*S!-!/(5/!4%K%4!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

0(:L%.:(1&9!'/-'!(:9!'/%!%:'(2-'(1&!1)!0-';2!K-.(-'(1&I!3/(:!(:!

X/-'!(:!1)'%&!.%)%..%0!'1!-:!'/%!2%-:;.%2%&'!%..1.I!

1)! Y&1X4%05%! 1)! '/%! :;R\%*'! -&0! '/%! .;4%:! 1)! '/%!

:*(%&*%! 1)! .%L.%:%&'-'(1&! -.%! (&0(:L%&:-R4%! (&!

1.0%.! '1! R;(40! >G! 210%4:! -R4%! '1! %))%*'(K%46!

0%:*.(R%!'/%!1R\%*'!-&-46U%0!=i(5I!j9!i(5I!8@I!

U@'VMW")*-W'6%#<&$-.-/"#&.'("*$K'(&*A):&*' X&YJ%")*<'

3/.%%B0(2%&:(1&-4! 01*;2%&'-'(1&! (:!

R%*12(&5!(&*.%-:(&546!L1L;4-.!(&!'/%!-.*/('%*';.%!

-&0! %&5(&%%.(&5! *122;&('(%:! -:! X%44! -:! 1'/%.!

-LL4(*-'(1&!012-(&:!(&*4;0(&5!-.*/-%14156I!!

a(K%&! '/%! */-44%&5(&5! *1&0('(1&:! '6L(*-446!

-::1*(-'%0! X('/! '/%! L.-*'(*%! 1)! 0(5('-4!

01*;2%&'-'(1&! 1)! *;4';.-4! /%.('-5%! B! '1;.(:'!

(&'%.)%.%&*%9! -**%::! L%.2(::(1&:9! 4(2('%0! '(2%9!

5%12%'.(*! *12L4%W('6! B! %:'-R4(:/(&5! -! .%4(-R4%!

2%'/1014156! )1.! 2-::(K%! 0-'-! -*Z;(:('(1&! (:!

%::%&'(-4! )1.! L%.)1.2(&5! %))(*(%&'! :;.K%6:! =[%::!

%'I!-4I9!>?<8@I!!

!

!

1BCD'KS!>G!'%W';.(U%0!-&0!-.*/('%*';.-4!210%4!).12!DG!210%4I!

#-:%!:';06S!O1.'-4%!i4-2(&(1!O1&U(1!

!31! %&:;.%! '/-'! '/%! )(&-4! L.10;*':! 5%&%.-'%0!

).12! DG! :;.K%6:! -.%! -LL.1L.(-'%! )1.! ;:%! R6!

K-.6(&5! 012-(&! %WL%.':9! '/%! 0(5('-4!

01*;2%&'-'(1&! :'.-'%56! 2;:'! R%! R;(4'! )1.!

.%L%-'-R4%!*12L.%/%&:(K%!210%4!*.%-'(1&I!!

c('/!'/(:!(&!2(&09!-!:;.K%61.!2;:'!R%!-.2%0!X('/!

%&1;5/!Y&1X4%05%!1)!'/%!:;.K%6(&5!'%*/&14156!'1!

R%! -R4%! '1! 1K%.*12%! '/%! 4(2('-'(1&:! 1)! %-*/!

'%*/&(Z;%!-:!X%44!-:!4%K%.-5%!'/%(.!:'.%&5'/:I!

3/%! )1*;:! 1)! '/(:! *-:%! :';06! (:! 1&!

(2L4%2%&'(&5! 3%..%:'.(-4! h-:%.! "*-&&(&5! =3h"@!

)1.! *12L.%/%&:(K%! 01*;2%&'-'(1&! 1)! -! *12L4%W!

-.*/-%1415(*-4!:'.;*';.%I!!!

3/%! h-R6.(&'/! 1)! HWY(&'1Y9! -4:1! Y&1X&! -'!

"-';&:-'! =i(5I`@9! (:! -&! %W'.%2%46! )-:*(&-'(&5!

-&*(%&'!:'.;*';.%!(&!'/%!&1.'/%.&!^-6-!41X4-&0:I!!

!

j8! !

' !

1BCD'LS!#1&'%W';-4!K(%X!1)!'/%!3h"!0-'-!1)!"-';&:-'!

!c/-'! -LL%-.:! ).12! '/%! 1;':(0%! -:! -&!

;&2%21.-R4%! '%..-*%0! R;(40(&5! L4-')1.2! (:9! 1&!

'/%! (&'%.(1.! 1)! '/%! :'.;*';.%9! -! *12L4%W! :%.(%:! 1)!

(&'%.*1&&%*'%0! K-;4'%0! L-::-5%X-6:! :L-&&(&5!

'/.%%!4%K%4:I!!

3/%:%!L-::-5%X-6:!;'(4(U%!(..%5;4-.9!*1.R%44%0!

K-;4':! -&0! .%4-'(K%46! &-..1X! :L(&%! X-44:! '1!

:;LL1.'! '/%! -R1K%! :'.;*';.%9! X/(*/! 0())%.:!

:(5&()(*-&'46! ).12! '/%! K%&%%.! -&0! *1&*.%'%! *1.%!

'%*/&(Z;%! */-.-*'%.(:'(*! 1)! 4-'%.! O;;*! K-;4'%0!

-.*/('%*';.%I!!

3/%! .%4-'(1&:/(L! R%'X%%&! '/%! L4-U-9! '/%!

:'.;*';.%f:!2-:1&.6!*12L1&%&':9!-&0!(':!R%0.1*Y!

)1;&0-'(1&! (:! -&1'/%.! -:L%*'! '/-'! *-&! R%!

01*;2%&'%09! K(:;-4(U%0! -&0! :';0(%0! ).12! 0(5('-4!

01*;2%&'-'(1&!.%*1.0:I!

3/%! 51-4! 1)! '/(:! :%*'(1&! (:! '1! 1;'4(&%! -!

L.-*'(*-49! )(%40B.%-06! -LL.1-*/! '/-'! %&:;.%:! '/%!

5%&%.-'(1&! 1)! Z;-4('6! 0-'-! ).12! X/(*/! 0%'-(4%0!

-&-46:%:! *-&! R%! 2-0%! R6! 0())%.%&'! 012-(&!

%WL%.':I! 3/%! (&'%5.-'(K%! 2%'/1014156! =i(5IE@!

*1&*%&'.-'%:! 1&! %:'-R4(:/(&5! .%L%-'-R4%!

-*Z;(:('(1&! X1.Y)41X:! (&! 1.0%.! '1! 5;-.-&'%%!

.%4(-R(4('6!-&0!;:-R(4('6!1)!'/%!0-'-!5%&%.-'%0I!!

N:! '/%! 51-4! (:! '1! *1&0;*'! '/%:%! *;4';.-4!

/%.('-5%! :;.K%6:! 5(K%&! '/%! *1&:'.-(&':! 1)! .%-4!

X1.40!L.-*'(*%9!'/%.%!-.%!(&)1.2%0!0%*(:(1&:!'/-'!

2;:'!R%!2-0%!(&!'/%!)(%40I!N!2-\1.!)1*;:!1)!'/%:%!

-*Z;(:('(1&! X1.Y)41X:! (:! 1&! '/%! :;.K%61.! 1.!

%Z;(L2%&'!1L%.-'1.!R%!(&)1.2%0!1)!'/%!:'.%&5'/:!

-&0! X%-Y&%::%:! 1)! '/%! '%*/&14156! (&! 1.0%.! '1!

.%-4(:'(*-446!L4-&!'!/%!:;.K%6(&5!%))1.':!;&0%.!'/%!

5(K%&!*1&:'.-(&':I!

3/%!*-:%!:';06!L.%:%&'%0!/%.%!(:!-&!%W*%44%&'!

%W-2L4%!1)!/1X!'/(:!-*Z;(:('(1&!2%'/1014156!*-&!

R%! (2L4%2%&'%0! (&! '/%! )(%40! '1! 6(%40!

*12L.%/%&:(K%! :;.K%6:! '1! R%! ;:%0! R6! -! X(0%!

.-&5%! 1)! %WL%.':I! 3/%! DG! 01*;2%&'-'(1&! 1)!

"-';&:-'!!%&-R4%:!!.%:%-.*/%.:!!'1!!R%''%.!!%W-2(&%!

!

1BCD'MS!+%L%-'-R4%!2%'/1014156!)1.!'/%!*12L.%/%&:(K%!

-*Z;(:('(1&!1)!3h"!0-'-

'/%!*12L4%W!21.L/14156!1)!'/%!-&*(%&'!4-R6.(&'/!! X/(4%! -4:1! 2-Y(&5! ('! L1::(R4%! '1! *1&0;*'! -! 21.%!

-**;.-'%! :'.;*';.-4! /%-4'/! -::%::2%&'! 1)! '/%!

:'.;*';.%! -:! -! X/14%I! 3/%! :'.;*';.%! (:! X('/(&! -!

4-.5%.!*12L4%W!'/-'!(:!1L%&!'1!'/%!L;R4(*9!R;'!'/%!

(&:(0%!1)!'/%!4-R6.(&'/!(:!&1'!-**%::(R4%!'1!K(:('1.:I!

3/%! (&:(0%! L-::-5%X-6:! -.%! /;2(09! /1'! -&0! (&!

&%-.!'1'-4!0-.Y&%::!X('/!R-':!)46(&5!-.1;&0!%K%.6!

*1.&%.I!H&%!51-4!1)!'/%!:;.K%6!X-:!'1!(0%&'()6!'/%!

4-61;'! 1)! '/%! (&'%.*1&&%*'%0! L-::-5%X-6:9! -&0!

X('/1;'! '/%! 4-61;'! 0%)(&%0! -/%-0! 1)! '(2%9! -&!

-**;.-'%! 4-:%.! :*-&&(&5! *-2L-(5&! *1;40! &1'! R%!

*.-)'%0I! 3/(:! (:! -! 0%21&:'.-'(1&! 1)! X/6! '/%!

2%'/1014156! R%5(&:! X('/! -! K(:;-4! (&:L%*'(1&! 1)!

'/%! :L-*%:! '1! R%! :;.K%6%0I! G;.(&5! '/(:! (&('(-4!

X-4Y'/.1;5/!1)!'/%!:L-*%9!'/%!:;.K%61.!X(44!2-Y%!

(&)1.2%0! %:'(2-'%:! 1)! (&:'.;2%&'! L1:('(1&(&5! (&!

1.0%.! '1! -*/(%K%! 1K%.4-LL(&5! .%5(1&:! '/-'! -.%!

-LL.1L.(-'%! )1.! -**;.-'%! .%5(:'.-'(1&! -&0!

*12R(&-'(1&!1)!(&0(K(0;-4!:*-&:!X('/!%-*/!1'/%.I!

3/.1;5/! '/%:%! %:'(2-'%:9! '/%! 1K%.-44! &;2R%.! 1)!

:*-&:!X(44!R%!0%'%.2(&%0!-&0!-!0%*(:(1&!1)!X/%.%!

'1!:'-.'!X(44!R%!2-0%!(&!'%.2:!1)!L.(1.('(U-'(1&I!

3/%! %W%*;'(1&! 1)! '/%! 3h"! :;.K%6! X(44! '/%&!

0%L%&0!1&!'/%!5(K%&!1L%.-'(&5!*1&:'.-(&':!:;*/!-:!

-**%::9!'(2%9!L/6:(*-4!L4-*%2%&'!1)!'/%!'.(L109!%'*I!

i1.! '/(:! *-2L-(5&9! '/%! '1'-4! -441''%0! '(2%! X-:! D!

j`!

0-6:!1&!:('%!X('/!2;4'(L4%!%Z;(L2%&'!1L%.-'1.:!(&!

'/%! :L-*%! :(2;4'-&%1;:46I! G1! '1! '/%! 2;4'(L4%!

1**;L-&':! (&! '/%! :L-*%9! '/%.%! X-:! &1'! 1&46!

*11.0(&-'(1&!)1.!'/%!3h"!1L%.-'1.!-41&%9!R;'!-4:1!

*122;&(*-'(1&! X('/! '/%! .%:'! 1)! '/%! L-.'(%:!

(&K14K%0! 1&! :('%! )1.! '/%! :;.K%6I! $&! '/%! %&09! ('!

.%Z;(.%0! -! '1'-4! 1)! <?D! :*-&:! '1! 01*;2%&'! '/%!

(&'%.(1.!-&0!%W'%.(1.!1)!'/%!:'.;*';.%!=8F!-&0!>E!

.%:L%*'(K%46@! -&0! -! '1'-4! 1)! 1K%.! )(K%! R(44(1&! 0-'-!

L1(&':!*-L';.%0I!3/%!4%K%4!1)!0%'-(4!*-L';.%0!X-:!

1&!'/%!1.0%.!1)!-!2(44(2%'%.!1&!'/%!(&'%.(1.!-&0!DB A!2(44(2%'%.:!1&!'/%!%W'%.(1.!1)!'/%!:'.;*';.%I!3/(:!

0%&:%! 01*;2%&'-'(1&! .%*1.0! &1X! L.1K(0%:! -&!

%W*%44%&'! 0%L-.';.%! L1(&'! )1.! -44! );';.%! -&-46:(:!

-&0!(&'%.L.%'-'(1&!R6!012-(&!%WL%.':I!

c('/! '/%! DG! L1(&'! *41;0! -**%::(R4%! ).12! '/%!

).;(':! 1)! '/(:! :;.K%6(&5! *-2L-(5&9! '/%! 4-R6.(&'/!

-&0!(':!L-::-5%X-6:!*-&!&1X!R%!:';0(%0!(&!-!X-6!

'/-'! X-:! &1'! L1::(R4%! R%)1.%I! i(K%! R(44(1&! L1(&'!

0-'-:%'! *-&! R%! 2-&(L;4-'%0! (&! -! X-6! '1! %W'.-*'!

'/(&!:4(*%:!1)!L1(&':!'/-'!.%&0%.!X/-'!-21;&':!'1!

:%*'(1&!*;':!1)!'/%!:'.;*';.%I!!

c('/! '/%:%! :%*'(1&! *;':9! %WL%.':! *-&! )(&-446!

:';06! '/%! .%4-'(1&:/(L:! 1)! '/%! X(&0(&5!

L-::-5%X-6:!-&0!K(:;-4(U%!'/.1;5/!'/%!0-'-!/1X!

%-*/! 4%K%4! 1)! '/%! :'.;*';.%! (:! :(';-'%0! -'1L! '/%!

)411.:!R%41XI!3/%!L4-&!K(%X!1)!'/%!)(.:'!)411.!1)!'/%!

4-R6.(&'/!'/-'!X-:!%W'.-*'%0!).12!'/%!L1(&'!*41;0!

(&!1.0%.!'1!*-L';.%!-&0!2%-:;.%!'/%!4-61;'!1)!'/(:!

-&*(%&'! 2-U%I! 3/%! 5.(0! L-''%.&! =i(5I<?@! K(:(R4%!

0%21&:'.-'%:!'/-'!'/%!L-''%.&!1)!'/%!L-::-5%X-6:!

(:! &1'! 1&46! K(:;-4(U%0! '/.1;5/! '/%! 0-'-9! R;'! *-&!

-4:1! R%! 2%-:;.%0! 01X&! '1! 2(44(2%'%.! -**;.-*6!

5(K%&! '/%! 4%K%4! 1)! 0%'-(4! 1)! 3h"! '%*/&14156!

=i(5I<<@I!!

!

' !

1BCD'ENS!O4-&!K(%X!1)!'/%!3h"!0-'-!:/1X(&5!'/%!4-61;'!1)!'/%!

4-R6.(&'/f:!)(.:'!)411.!

!!

' !

1BCD'EES!"%*'(1&!*;'!1)!'/%!3h"!0-'-!).12!'/%!L4-U-!411Y(&5!

'1X-.0:!'/%!R-*Y!1)!'/%!:'.;*';.%!-&0!:%*'(1&!*;'!1)!'/%!3h"!

0-'-!411Y(&5!).12!'/%!:(0%!1)!'/%!:'.;*';.%!

Z@''9-)#.A:"-)'

$&'%5.-'(1&! 1)! 2-::(K%! -*Z;(:('(1&!

(&:'.;2%&':9! .%)1.2;4-'(&5! '/%! '.-0('(1&-4!

L.1*%::! 1)! 0%)(&(&5! *4-::(*-4! >G! %4-R1.-'(1&:9!

(&'%5.-'(1&! 1)! 0(5('-4! .%L.%:%&'-'(1&! '%*/&(Z;%:9!

'/%! L1::(R(4('6! '1! *122;&(*-'%! '/.1;5/!

(&&1K-'(K%! 1;'L;'! V! '/%6! -44! /-K%! L.1K(0%0! '/%!

R-:(:! )1.! (&K%:'(5-'(&5! -44! '/%! 2-'%.(-4! -&0! &1&B 2-'%.(-4! -:L%*':! );&0-2%&'-4! )1.! ;&0%.:'-&0(&5!

'/%!-.*/('%*'1&(*!*12L4%W!-&-46U%0I!

3/%! L.%:%&'! :';06! 2-0%! ('! L1::(R4%! '1! *4-.()6!

*%.'-(&!L.1R4%2:!*1&&%*'%0!X('/!'/%!L1::(R(4('(%:!

'1! *12L-.%! -&0! :;L%.(2L1:%! -! :%.(%:! 1)!

(&)1.2-'(1&! 1&! .%-4('6! R6! -LL46(&5! 2;4'(L4%!

:;.K%6(&5! 2%'/101415(%:I! $'! /-:! -5-(&!

0%21&:'.-'%0! '/%! %))(*(%&*6! 1)! '/%! (&'%5.-'%0!

-LL.1-*/I!

NK-(4(&5! 1;.:%4K%:! 1)! -! :%.(%:! 1)! '/%2-'(*!

210%4:!-&0!'/%!-&-46:(:!1)!*1&:'(';'(K%!%4%2%&':!

1)! '/%! 1R\%*':! ;&0%.! :';06! 0%.(K%0! ).12! K-.(1;:!

.%-0(&5!210%:9!X%!X%.%!-R4%!'1!-..(K%!-'!-!*4%-.!

;&0%.:'-&0(&5! 1)! '/%! :(5&()(*-'(1&:! '/-'! '/%!

-''%&'(K%! :;.K%61.! /-:! '1! R%! -R4%! '1! 5.-:L! -&0!

*122;&(*-'%9! -44! '/%! '(2%! /-K(&5! (&! 2(&0! '/%!

*.('(*-4!:'-&*%!'1X-.0:!'/%!X/14%!L.1*%::I!