ContentslistsavailableatScienceDirect
Vaccine
jo u rn al h om ep a g e :w w w . e l s e v i e r . c o m / l o c a t e / v a c c i n e
A
gold
glyco-nanoparticle
carrying
a
listeriolysin
O
peptide
and
formulated
with
Advax
TM
delta
inulin
adjuvant
induces
robust
T-cell
protection
against
listeria
infection
Estela
Rodriguez-Del
Rio
a,
Marco
Marradi
b,c,
Ricardo
Calderon-Gonzalez
a,
Elisabet
Frande-Cabanes
a,
Soledad
Penadés
b,c,
Nikolai
Petrovsky
d,e,1,
Carmen
Alvarez-Dominguez
a,∗,1aGrupodeGenómica,ProteómicayVacunas,InstitutodeInvestigaciónMarquésdeValdecilla(IDIVAL),Santander,Spain bCICbiomaGUNE,P◦deMiramón182,SanSebastian,Gipúzcoa,Spain
cCIBER-BBN,P◦deMiramón182,SanSebastian,Gipúzcoa,Spain
dDepartmentofDiabetesandEndocrinology,FlindersUniversity,Adelaide5042,SA,Australia eVaxinePtyLtd,FlindersMedicalCentre,Adelaide5042,SA,Australia
a
r
t
i
c
l
e
i
n
f
o
Articlehistory:
Received5November2014
Receivedinrevisedform12January2015 Accepted25January2015
Availableonline7February2015
Keywords: Listeriosis Glyconanoparticles Dendriticcells Vaccines Advax
a
b
s
t
r
a
c
t
Inthesearchforaneffectivevaccineagainstthehumanpathogen,Listeriamonocytogenes(Listeria),gold
glyconanoparticles(GNP)loadedwithalisteriolysinOpeptideLLO91–99(GNP-LLO)wereusedtoimmunise
mice,initiallyusingadendriticcell(DC)vaccineapproach,butsubsequentlyusingastandardparenteral
immunisationapproach.Toenhancevaccineimmunogenicityanovelpolysaccharideadjuvantbased
ondeltainulin(AdvaxTM)wasalsoco-formulatedwiththeGNPvaccine.Confirmingpreviousresults,
DCloadedinvitrowithGNP-LLOprovidedbetterprotectionagainstlisteriosisthanDCloadedinvitro
usingfreeLLOpeptide.TheimmunogenicityofGNP-LLOloadedDCvaccineswasfurtherincreasedby
additionofAdvaxTMadjuvant.However,asDCvaccinesareexpensiveandimpracticablefor
prophylac-ticuse,wenextaskedwhetherthesameGNP-LLOantigencouldbeusedtodirectlytargetDCinvivo.
ImmunisationofmicewithGNP-LLOplusAdvaxTMadjuvantinducedLLO-specificT-cellimmunityand
protectionagainstListeriachallenge.ProtectioncorrelatedwithanincreasedfrequencyofsplenicCD4+
andCD8+Tcells,NKcellsandCD8␣+DC,andTh1cytokineproduction(IL-12,IFN-␥,TNF-␣,andMCP-1),
post-challenge.EnhancedT-cellepitoperecruitmentpost-challengewasseeninthegroupsthatreceived
AdvaxTMadjuvant.ImmunisationwithGNP-LLO91–99plusAdvaxTMadjuvantprovidedequallyrobust
Lis-teriaprotectionasthebestDCvaccinestrategybutwithoutthecomplexityandcost,makingthisahighly
promisingstrategyfordevelopmentofaprophylacticvaccineagainstlisteriosis.
©2015TheAuthors.PublishedbyElsevierLtd.ThisisanopenaccessarticleundertheCCBY-NC-ND
license(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
1. Introduction
CandidateprophylacticvaccinesagainstListeriamonocytogenes (Listeria)includeliveattenuatedpathogens[1–4],livevector-based
Abbreviations: APC,antigen-presentingcells;CFU,colonyformingunits;Ctsd, cathepsin-D;DC,dendriticcells;GNP,goldglyconanoparticles;i.p,intra-peritoneal; i.v,intra-venous;LLO,listeriolysinO;MHC,majorhistocompatibilitycomplex;MIIC, MHC-classIIantigenloadingcompartments;MØ,macrophages;LM,Listeria mono-cytogenes.
∗ Correspondingauthorat:GrupodeGenómica,ProteómicayVacunas.Instituto deInvestigaciónMarquésdeValdecilla(IDIVAL),Laboratorio124.EdificioIFIMAV, Avda.CardenalHerreraOria,s/n.39011Santander,Cantabria,Spain.
Tel.:+34942315515x74104;fax:+34942315517.
E-mailaddress:calvarez@humv.es(C.Alvarez-Dominguez).
1 Theseauthorscontributedequallyasseniorauthorsofthispaper.
approaches[5–7]andsubunitvaccines[8,9].However,theuseof livevaccinesinat-riskimmunocompromisedindividualsincluding pregnantwomenposesmajorsafetyrisks,makinganon-living sub-unitvaccineamorepreferableapproach.Unfortunately,subunit vaccinesbythemselvesaregenerallyineffectiveduetooverallpoor immunogenicityandinability,inparticular,togeneratetheT-cell immunityrequiredforprotectionagainstintracellularorganisms suchasListeria.
Dendriticcell(DC)vaccinesareproducedbyisolationofDCfrom asubject,invitroloadingoftheDCwiththerelevantvaccine anti-gen,andthenintravenousorsubcutaneousinjectionoftheliveDC backintothesubject.Basedontheirimprovedabilitytoinduce T-cellimmunity,DCvaccineshavebeenproposedassolutionsfor inductionofT-cellprotectionagainstintracellularinfections,such asHIV[10].OurgrouppreviouslyreportedaDCvaccineloadedwith a peptidefromtheListeriaprotein, glyceraldehyde3-phosphate http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.vaccine.2015.01.062
dehydrogenase(GAPDH), inducedgenerationof GAPDH-specific CD8+andCD4+TcellsandconferredprotectionagainstListeria[11],
consistentwiththeimportanceofT-cellresponsesagainstGAPDH inListeriaprotection[12–14].OtherListeriaantigensthatcontain CD4+andCD8+T-cellepitopesandthatmightthereforeenhance
theefficacyofaDC-basedListeriavaccineincludelisteriolysin(LLO), ActA,andp60[11,15,16].Todate,onlyT-cellimmunityagainstLLO hasbeenreportedinhumansrecoveringfromlisteriosis[17], sug-gestingapotentialroleofinprotection.Wethereforewishedto testwhetheraT-cellvaccinetargetingLLOcouldprotectagainst listeriosis.Inparticular,wesoughttotestwhethera nanoparticle-conjugatedLLOpeptidecouldincreaseDCvaccineefficacy[10,18] andalsowhetheranovelT-celladjuvantcouldenhanceLLOvaccine immunogenicity[19].Goldglyconanoparticles(GNPs)constitute a nanoscale metallic coreto which self-assembled monolayers ofcarbohydrateligands arecovalentlylinkedbymeansofthiol chemistry[20]. Duetotheirwater dispersibility, biocompatibil-ity,resistancetoenzymaticdegradation,easeofpreparation,and abilitytoincorporatedifferentligands,GNPsarehighlyversatile [21,22].Inthisstudy,therefore,wesoughttotestthepotentialofa glucose-labelledGNPpresentingtheLLO91–99peptide(GNP-LLO)to
protectagainstlisteriosisinamurinemodel.Inthefirstapproach, wesoughttoapplythepreviousapproachofloadingDCinvitro usingtheGNP-LLOcarrierpriortoinjectionoftheDCbackintothe animals.However,giventhelogisticaldifficultiesoftheDCvaccine approach,wealsowishedtotestwhether,ratherthanbeingused forDCvaccineloadinginvitro,theGNP-LLOantigencouldbeused forparenteralimmunisationalongthelinesofatraditionalvaccine. Given the poor T-cell responses induced by subunit vac-cines, we sought to further enhance GNP-LLO immunogenicity by use of AdvaxTM, a novel polysaccharide adjuvant derived
frommicroparticlesofdelta -d-[2-1]poly(fructo-furanosyl)␣-d-glucose(deltainulin) [25].In animalmodelsAdvaxTMhasbeen
showntoenhancecellularplushumoralimmunityagainstabroad spectrumofantigensincludinginfluenza[26],Japanese encephali-tis[27],WestNilevirus[28],hepatitisB[29],andHIV[30]vaccines. AdvaxTMhasalsobeenshowneffectiveandsafeinhumantrialsof
pandemicinfluenza[31]andhepatitisB[29],vaccines. 2. Methods
2.1.1. Peptidesandadjuvants
We used as immunogens, peptides representing known Lis-teriaTcellepitopes,namelyGAPDH1–22,LLO91–99andLLO189–201
[6,11,15].ImmunisationwithfreeLLO189–200andLLO190–201
pep-tideshaspreviouslybeenshowntoinduceCD4+Tcellresponses
inmicebutdidnotconferListeriaprotection[11,32].Allpeptides weresynthesisedatCNB,CSIC,Madridfollowedbyhigh perfor-manceliquidchromatography(HPLC)andmassspectrometryusing aMALDI-TOF ReflexTM IV massspectrometer(Bruker Daltonics,
Bremen,Germany).Peptidepuritywas>95%afterHPLC.AdvaxTM
adjuvant (Adv1) was supplied by Vaxine (Adelaide, Australia) [31,33–35], and was mixed with antigen by simple admixture immediatelybeforeimmunisationofmice.
2.1.2. Bacteria
L.monocytogenes10403Sstrain(LMWT)wasobtainedfromD.A.
Portnoy(UniversityofCalifornia,Berkeley,CA,USA). 2.1.3. PreparationofgoldglyconanoparticlesbearingLLO91–99
peptides(GNP-LLO91–99)
LLO91–99peptidewithaC-terminalcysteamide(LLO91–99C(O)
NHCH2CH2SH,14mg,purity95%)waspurchasedfromGenScript
and5-(mercapto)pentyl--d-glucopyranoside(GlcC5SH)was
pre-paredasreportedintheliterature[36].GNPpreparationisincluded inSupplementalinformation. Averagegolddiameter1.5±0.5nm (thesizehistograminFig.S1,panelAwasobtainedbycounting 600particlesintheTEMimage).
2.1.4. PreparationofDCvaccines
Bone-marrowDCweredifferentiatedwithGM-CSF,andCD11c+
cellsisolatedwithanti-mouseCD11c-coatedmagneticbeadsand MACS separation columns (Miltenyi Biotech Inc., Auburn, CA) [6,11] from 8 to 12 week-old female CD1, Balb/c or C57BL/6 mice.Bonemarrowmacrophages(DM)wereobtainedfromsame femursanddifferentiatedwithM-CSF,asdescribed[11].DCused wereMHC-II+CD11c+CD40+CD11b+/−CD86+/−F4/80−Gr-1− andof
DMwereCD11b+MHC-II+F4/80+/−CD11c−Gr-1−CD40−CD86−.
Cul-turedDCwereexvivoloadedwith50g/mlGAPDH1–22,LLO91–99
orLLO189–201peptidesorwith5g/mlofGNP-LLO91–99for24h.
CellswereanalysedforapoptosisbyFACSanalysisusing annexin-V-APCandH-1770(BD-Biosciences),forcellviabilitywithTrypan bluestaining,andcellsurfacemarkersbyFACS.
2.1.5. T-cellassays
T-cellanalysis,cytotoxicTlymphocytesresponsesanddelayed typehypersensitivity(DTH)analysisaredescribedinSupplemental information.
2.1.6. Preparationofpeptide-coupledGNPvaccines
GNPcarryingapproximately90%glucoseand10%LLO91–99(Fig.
S1,panelA)werepreparedbyreductioninsituofAu(III)saltwith sodiumborohydride,asdescribed[21,37].Theligands(LLO91–99
peptideandglucose)werederivatisedwiththiol-endinglinkersto attachthemtothegoldcore(Fig.S1,panelA).5-Mercaptopentyl -d-glucopyranoside(GlcC5SH) witha shortaliphaticlinker, as
previouslyreported[36]wasusedasaligandpartnertocontrol thedensityofLLO91–99peptideontheGNPs.Glucoseisidealto
con-ferwaterdispersibilityandbiocompatibilitytotheGNPswithout interferingwiththeantigenicpropertiesofLLO91–99peptide[24].
LLOpeptidesandGNP-LLO91–99didnotadverselyaffectDC
viabil-ityorpromoteapoptosis(Fig.S1,panelBandDCcolumninTable S1).Theywerealsowelltoleratedat50g/mlconcentrationsin C57BL/6,CD-1orBalb/cmicestrains,(C57BL/6columninTableS1), whileat500g/mlconcentrationstheycauseddecreasedDC via-bilityandincreasedIL-1concentrationsuggestingpotentialtoxicity (TableS1)[38].
2.1.7. GNPimmunogenicityassessment
Weimmunisedmousefootpadswith0.1gofrecombinantLLO (LLOrec)andthenevaluatedT-cellproliferativerecallresponsesto
invitrostimulationwithLLO91–99,LLO189–201,GNP-LLO91–99,LMWT
lysate(LM-lysate)orLLOrecatdosesrangingfrom0to500g/ml.
T-cellproliferationwasdosedependentpeakingat50g/mlandthen decliningforallantigens(Fig.S1,panelC).GNP-LLO91–99induced
ahighlevelofT-cellproliferationequivalenttoLM-lysate(Fig.S1, panelC).LLO91–99andLLOrecinducedthenextbestT-cell
prolifera-tion,whileLLO189–201waslowest.TotestwhetherthehigherT-cell
recallresponseswithGNP-LLO91–99mightreflectimprovedMHC-I
antigenprocessingbylymphnodeAPC,wecomparedMHC-I pep-tidepresentationafterexvivoloadingofDCorDMwithLLO91–99
orGNP-LLO91–99.MHC-Imoleculeswereimmuno-precipitatedand
levelsofLLOpeptidesboundtoMHC-Iassessedbywestern-blot usingrabbitanti-LLOantibodies,aspreviouslyreportedforMHC-II molecules[5,11].GNP-LLO91–99resultedinhigherefficiency
DM(Fig.S1,panelD),withfarhigherpresentationbyDCthanDM (Fig.S1,panelD).
2.1.8. ExvivoactivationofDCvaccines
WeexaminedtheeffectofLLOpeptidecarriersonDCvaccine activation[6,10].ActivatedDCshowacharacteristicCD11c+
MHC-II+CD40+CD86+ phenotype[10,18].ToexamineDCactivationby
LLOcarriers,atday5afterGM-CSFdifferentiation,DCwere puri-fiedasCD11c+ cells usingMACSmagneticbeads(Miltenyi)and
loadedex vivo for 24h with 5g/ml of GNP-LLO91–99 in
pres-enceorabsenceofAdvaxTMadjuvant(50g/ml)orwith50g/ml
of LLO91–99, LLO189–201,LM-lysate or left untreated (DC-CONT).
Next, thefrequency of CD11c+MHC-II+ cells positive for CD40+
orCD86+ DCwasassessed asmarkers of matureand activated
DC (Fig.S2, panelA).DC-Listeria lysateinduced thehighest fre-quencyofMHC-IIhighDCfollowedbyGNP-LLO
91–99withorwithout
AdvaxTM,whichwerebothsignificantlyhigherthanLLO
189–201(Fig.
S2,panelB).AsimilarpicturewasseenforCD11c+MHC-II+CD40+
orCD11c+MHC-II+CD86+DC.DifferencesbetweenGNPloadedand
freepeptidewereevenmoremarkedwhenweanalysedthe fre-quencyofCD40+CD86+doublepositiveDC(Fig.S2,panelC).
2.1.9. Immunisation
DCvaccinesloadedinvitrousingeitherfreepeptideor GNP-conjugatedpeptidesareindicatedbyplacementof“DC”infrontof thespecificantigen.Ifthenameofthevaccinedoesnotcontain “GNP”thenthismeansDCloadingorimmunisationwasdonewith freepeptide.VaccinesusedwereeitherDCvaccines(DC-LLO91–99,
DC-LLO189–201,DC-GAPDH1–22,DC-GNP-LLO91–99, allatdoses of
1×106DCperimmunisation),orstandardvaccines(GNP-LLO 91–99
at5gperimmunisation).Standardvaccineswereadministered withor without AdvaxTM adjuvant (250g per immunisation).
Micewereimmunisedintra-peritoneally(i.p)(n=5),intravenously inthetailvein(i.v)(n=5)orleftnon-vaccinated(NV).Sevendays afterimmunisationmicewerechallengedi.pori.vwith5×103CFU
ofListeriamicroorganisms/mouse[2].Serawerestoredat−80◦C
tomeasurecytokinesbyFACSanalysis.Atterminationspleensand liverswerehomogenisedandListeriacolonyformingunits(CFUs) countedinbloodagarplates.
2.1.10. FrequenciesofCD8+-LLO
91–99specificTcells
ToconfirmthefrequencyofIFN-␥producingLLO91–99specific
CD8TcellsweusedrecombinantsolubledimericmouseH-2Kb:Ig
(forC57BL/6mice)orH-2Kd:Ig(forBalb/cmice)fusionproteins
fol-lowingthemanufacturer’sinstructions(DimerXI;BDBioscience) andaspreviouslydescribed[2,11].
2.1.11. Ethicsstatement
Thisstudywascarried outinaccordance withtheGuidefor theCareandUseofLaboratoryAnimalsoftheSpanishMinistry ofScience,ResearchandInnovation.TheCommitteeontheEthics ofAnimalExperimentsoftheUniversityofCantabriaapprovedthe protocol(PermitNumber:2012/06)thatfollowstheSpanish leg-islation(RD1201/2005).Allsurgerywasperformedundersodium pentobarbitalanaesthesia,andalleffortsweremadetominimise suffering.
2.1.12. Statisticalanalysis
For statistical analysis, Student’s t test was applied.ANOVA analysis was applied to cytokine measurements. P≤0.05 was
Fig.1.ExvivoloadingofDCvaccinesandTcellresponses.(A)T-cellproliferationin responsetostimulationinvitrowith50g/mlofLLO91–99inpopliteallymphnode
homogenates7daysafterfootpadinoculationwith1×105cellsofDCvaccinesor
saline(NT)[14].Resultsshowthemean±SDofthestimulationindexcalculated asratioofproliferationinactivewells/proliferationofcontrolsamplesintriplicate (P<0.05).(B)Micewereimmunisedi.pwith5×103CFUofListeria/miceand7days
laterDTHassaysperformed.Resultsareexpressedasthemeandifference±SDof footpadswellingat24and48hinactiveandcontrollimbs,representativeexample ofthreeindependentexperiments(P<0.05).
consideredsignificant.GraphPadsoftwarewasusedforgeneration ofgraphs.
3. Results
3.1. DCvaccinesloadedusingGNP-peptidecarriersinduceT-cell proliferativeresponsesagainstListeria
DendriticcellsstimulatebothCD4+andCD8+Tcellsin
listerio-sis[14].Toevaluatewhetherdendriticcell(DC)vaccinesloaded usingGNP-peptide carriersmight bemore efficientininducing T-cellresponsesthanDC loadedusingfree peptides,micewere immunisedwithDCthathadbeenloadedindifferentways.Seven dayspost-immunisation,popliteallymphnodeswerestimulated invitrowithLLO91–99peptideandantigen-specificT-cell
prolife-rativeresponsesmeasured.ImmunisationwithDCloadedinvitro withGNP-LLO91–99inducedhigherT-cellproliferationresponses
thanimmunisation withDC loadedusingfree LLO91–99 peptide,
indicatingtheimportanceforinductionofT-cellmemoryof attach-mentoftheLLO91–99peptidetotheGNPtoenableefficientloading
an equivalent T-cell proliferative response to a whole Listeria lysate,consistentwithefficientDCloadingandinductionofT-cell responsesbytheGNP-peptidecarrier(Fig.1A).DCloadedwitha CD4+restrictedepitope(LLO
189–201)[11],failedtoinduceaT-cell
proliferativeresponse, suggestingtheDC vaccinespreferentially induceaCD8+T-cellresponse.
3.2. DCvaccinesloadedusingGNP-peptidecarriersinduceDTH responsesinListeria-sensitisedmice
Next,we examinedthe delayedtype hypersensitivity (DTH) responsetotheDCvaccinesinpreviouslyListeria-sensitisedmice asaninvivomeasureoftheabilityofthedifferentDC vaccines toinduceT-cellactivation.TheaimwastoevaluatewhetherDC loadedinvitrowithGNP-LLO91–99 when injected intothe
foot-padofpreviouslysensitisedmicewouldtriggeratypicalTh1-type T-cellresponseasmeasuredbyDTH[7].WeinjectedListeria sensi-tisedmiceinthefootpadwithDCloadedinvitrowithLLO91–99or
LLO189–201freepeptidesorwithGNP-LLO91–99.Infact,DCloaded
withLLO189–201generatedgreaterDTHresponsesinthesensitised
micethanDCloadedwithLLO91–99orGNP-LLO91–99,suggesting
thatLLO189–201isnormallyadominantT-cellepitopeafterListeria
infection(Fig.1B).Interestingly,theDTHresponsetoDCloaded withGNP-LLO91–99inthepresenceofAdvaxTMadjuvantwas
sim-ilarinsizetotheDC-LLO189–201responsesuggestingtheLLO91–99
epitopecouldbeturnedintoadominantepitope,providingitwas presentedbyDCata sufficientlyhighlevel togetherwith suffi-cientco-stimulatorymoleculeexpressioninducedbytheAdvaxTM
adjuvant(Fig.1B).
3.3. ImmunisationwithGNP-loadedDCvaccinesprovides protectionofmiceagainstlisteriosis
We next assessed protection against listeriosis using the different DC vaccine vectors, DC-LLO91–99, DC-LLO189–201,
DC-GAPDH1–22,DC-Listerialysate,DC-GNP-LLO91–99,andemptyDCs
(DC-CONTROL)whencomparedtoimmunisationwithfree GNP-LLO91–99.DC-GAPDH1–22wasincludedasapositivecontrolsinceit
previouslyshowedgoodListeriaprotection[11].Micewere immu-nisedi.vwithasingledoseofvaccine.Althoughi.visanunusual immunisation route for standard vaccines, it is a typical route foradministration ofcellularDC vaccines [6].Seven days post-immunisationthemicewereadministeredaliveListeriachallenge. Fivedayspost-challenge,allmiceweresacrificedandliversand spleensrecoveredtocountListeriacolonyformingunits(CFU)and analysetheimmunecellpopulations.DC-GAPDH1–22and
DC-GNP-LLO91–99providedthegreatestListeriaprotection(∼97and99%CFU
reduction,respectively),followedbyDC-LLO91–99(∼94%)(Fig.2A).
DC-LLO189–201 conferred nosignificantprotection(5%).Notably,
immunisationofmicewithfreeGNP-LLO91–99(asopposedtoDC
pre-loadedinvitrowithGNP-LLO91–99)conferredintermediate
pro-tection(∼60%CFUreduction).Controlnon-vaccinatedmice(NV) werenotprotectedandasexpectedhadenlargedspleensand gran-ulomatousliverspost-challenge(Fig.2A,righthandfigure). 3.4. ImmunisationwithGNP-loadedDCsincreasesthefrequency ofDCandCD8Tcellsinthespleenpost-challenge
Protectioninlisteriosisistypicallyreflectedbyincreasesinthe frequencyofsplenicmacrophages(MØ),naturalkillercells(NK), matureDC and activatedTcells post Listeriachallenge[14,39]. We therefore examined the cell populations in the spleens of immunisedmice5dayspost-challenge.Miceimmunisedwith DC-LLO91–99,DC-GAPDH1–22,DC-GNP-LLO91–99orfreeGNP-LLO91–99
particlesshowed anincreased frequencyof matureDC (70% of positivecells),CD8+Tcells(∼32%ofpositivecells),MØ(18–19%
Table1
FrequenciesofLLO91–99-CD8+TcellsinducedbyDCvaccines.Splenocytesof
vacci-natedmiceincubatedwithrecombinantdimericH-2Kb:Igfusionproteinloaded
withLLO91–99peptide.FrequenciesofCD8+-LLO91–99andIFN-␥producerswere
performedasdescribedinSection2.1.10.Resultsareexpressedasthemean±SD (P<0.05).
Vaccinationtype %Total dimer-CD8/LLO91–99 %Gated dimer-CD8/LLO91–99 DC-LM-lysate 0.05±0.01 0.48±0.01 DC-LLO91–99 0.06±0.01 1.22±0.02 DC-GNP-LLO91–99 0.17±0.02 3.42±0.02 GNP-LLO91–99 0.05±0.01 0.35±0.01 GNP-LLO91–99+Advax 0.20±0.01 3.21±0.02
ofpositivecells)and NK(10%ofpositive cells)intheirspleens,
post-challenge.OnlyDC-LLO189–201andDC-GAPDH1–22immunised
miceshowedanincreasedfrequencyofCD4+Tcellspost-challenge
(Fig.2B).
3.5. ListeriaprotectionbyGNP-loadedDCisassociatedwithan enhancedTh1T-cellresponse
WenextevaluatedwhetherListeriaprotectionofimmunised mice was associated with enhanced Th1 cytokine production, as would be predicted for protection against an intracellular bacterium.ImmunisationwithDC-LLO91–99,DC-GAPDH1–22,
DC-GNP-LLO1–99 and, to a lesser extent, free GNP-LLO91–99 was
associatedwithhighlevelsofMCP-1, TNF-␣andIFN-␥ produc-tion,consistentwitha strongTh1response (Fig.2C).However, onlyDC-GAPDH1–22andDC-GNP-LLO1–99immunisationwas
asso-ciatedwithmeasurableIL-12production,post-challenge,(Fig.2C), which correlated withthesegroupshaving thegreatestListeria protection(Fig.2A)[6,11].Next,wecomparedtheabilityofthe differentvaccinestoinduceLLO-specificT-cellimmunity. DC-GNP-LLO91–99inducedahigherfrequencyofLLO-specificIFN-␥+CD8+
Tcells (3.42%), than inducedby DC-LLO91–99 (1.22%), (Table1).
The response induced by DC-GNP-LLO91–99 thereby compared
favourably to the 4.2% frequency of LLO-specific CD8+ T cells
obtainedwiththemostprotectiveListeriavaccinewehadidentified todate,DC-GAPDH1–22,[11].
3.6. AdvaxTMadjuvantenhancesListeriaprotectionby
GNP-LLO91–99
DC vaccines are expensive and impracticable. However, standard immunisation with free GNP-LLO91–99 vaccine only
provided intermediate levels of Listeria protection, (∼60% CFU reduction,Fig.2),thatwasinferiortotheprotectionobtainedwith theDCvaccines.Wewishedtotest,therefore,whether formula-tionofGNP-LLO91–99 withAdvaxTMadjuvant mightenhanceits
abilitytoprotectwhenadministeredthroughatraditionalvaccine approach.Miceimmunisedi.pwithasingledoseofGNP-LLO91–99
plusAdvaxTMdidindeedexhibitenhancedprotection(84%)when
compared to mice immunised with GNP-LLO91–99 alone (60%)
(Fig.3A).ThistherebyachievedcomparablelevelsofListeria pro-tection to those previously only achieved withthe DC vaccine approach.
Analysisofspleenpopulations5dayspost-challengeconfirmed thati.pimmunisationwithGNP-LLO91–99plusAdvaxTMadjuvant,
inducedasimilarfrequencyofmatureDC,CD8+TcellsandNKcells
andahigherfrequencyofCD4+TcellswhencomparedtotheDC
vaccine,DC-GNP-LLO91–99 (Fig.3B).Thissuggeststhatproviding
it wasformulated withAdvaxTM adjuvant, standard
immunisa-tionwithGNP-LLO91–99wasasgoodorbetteratinducingT-cell
responsesandprotectionagainstListeriathanthemuchmore com-plexDCvaccineapproach.
Fig.2. GNP-LLO91–99vaccineprotectsagainstlisteriosis.DCvaccinesweretestedforabilitytoprotectagainstlisteriosis.(A)C57BL/6micewerevaccinatedoncei.vwith
variousDCvaccinevectors(1×106cells)(DC-CONT,DC-LMlysate,DC-GAPDH
1–22,DC-LLO91–99,DC-LLO189–201,DC-GNP-LLO91–99),solubleGNP-LLO91–99(5g/ml)ornot
vaccinated(NV)(n=5mice/group)and7dayslaterchallengedi.vwith5×103CFUofListeria.ListeriacountsinspleenhomogenatesexpressedasCFU(mean±SD)obtained
fromtriplicatesamplesofthreeindependentexperiments(P<0.01).Imagescorrespondingtospleensandliversofnon-vaccinated(NV)versusGNP-LLO91–99vaccinated
mice(GNP-LLO91–99).(B)Percentagesofdifferentspleencellpopulationsareshown:MØs,Bcells,NK,CD4Tcells,CD8Tcells,DCi,DCmquantifiedinspleenhomogenates
byFACS.Resultsexpressedasthemean±SDofthepercentageofpositivecells(P<0.05).(C)Levelsofpro-inflammatorycytokines(MCP-1,TNF-␣,IFN-␥,IL-6,IL-10,IL-12) wereanalysedinmouseserabyCBA.Resultsexpressedascytokineconcentration(pg/ml)ofmean±SD,P<0.05.
Fig.3. EffectofAdvaxTMadjuvantonGNP-LLO
91–99vaccineprotection.(A)C57BL/6micewerevaccinatedi.pwithDC-LLO91–99orDC-GNP-LLO91–99(1×106cells),orsoluble
GNP-LLO91–99(5g/ml)withorwithoutAdvaxadjuvant(1g/ml)ornotvaccinated(NV)(n=5mice/vaccinevector).Sevendayspost-immunisationtheywerechallenged
i.pwith5×103ofListeria(LMWT).Listeriacountsinspleenhomogenates5dayspost-challenge(CFUmean±SD)ofthreeindependentexperiments(P<0.01).(B)Spleen
homogenates5dayspost-challengewereanalysedbyFACS(mean±SDofpercentagesofpositivecells,P<0.05).(C)SplenicDCfrommicevaccinatedasinAwereanalysed toquantitateCD11c+MHC-II+CD8␣+DC(percentagesofMHC-II+CD8␣+positivecells(mean±SD)ofthreedifferentexperiments,P<0.05).(D)Serumcytokinelevels5days
3.7. Advax-adjuvantedGNP-LLO91–99increasessplenicIL-12+
CD8˛+DCpost-challenge
CD8␣+DCsplayacriticalroleinpresentationofListeria
anti-gens toprotective CD4+ and CD8+ Tcells and, in particular, in
IL-12productionthatcorrelateswithprotection[39,40].We there-foreanalysedsplenicDC content,post-challenge. Thefrequency ofsplenicCD8␣+DCwasalmostdoubledfrom10%to18%when
GNP-LLO91–99 wasformulated withAdvaxTM adjuvant (Fig.3C).
Thiscontrastedwithalowfrequency(2–3%)ofCD8␣+DCinthe
spleenofnon-vaccinatedmicepost-challenge.Notably, immun-isationwithfreeGNP-LLO91–99plusAdvaxTMadjuvantgenerated
a higher frequency of splenic CD8␣+ DC than theDC vaccines
(DC-GNP-LLO91–99 orDC-LLO91–99)(10%)(Fig.3C).Hence,when
formulatedwithAdvaxTMadjuvant,standardimmunisationwith
GNP-LLO91–99 wasasgoodorbetterthanthemorecomplexDC
vaccineapproachatinducingsplenicCD8␣+DCthatplayacritical
roleinlisteriaprotection
3.8. FormulationofGNP-LLO91–99vaccinewithAdvaxTM
adjuvantenhancesTh1cytokineresponses
SinceformulationofvaccineswithAdvaxTMincreasedthe
fre-quencyofbothCD8+TcellsandCD8␣+DCinthespleenpost-Listeria
challenge,wenextexaminedserumcytokinelevelspost-challenge insplenocytesofmiceimmunisedwithorwithoutAdvaxTM
adju-vant.MiceimmunisedwithGNP-LLO91–99plusAdvaxTMexhibited
significantly greaterMCP-1, TNF-␣and IFN-␥ production when comparedtomiceimmunisedwithGNP-LLO91–99alone,
consis-tent with AdvaxTM driving an enhanced Th1-response against
Listeria. Cytokinelevels in mice immunised withGNP-LLO91–99
plus AdvaxTM were equivalentto those seen withthe DC
vac-cine,DC-GNP-LLO91–99(Fig.3D,upperpanel).Immunisationwith
GNP-LLO91–99plusAdvaxTMwasalsoassociatedwithsignificantly
greatersplenocyteIL-12and IL-10production andreduced IL-6 productionwhencomparedtoimmunisationwithGNP-LLO91–99
alone(Fig.3D,lowerpanel),consistentwiththeAdvaxTMadjuvant
enhancingtheTh1responseagainstListeria.
3.9. FormulationofGNP-LLO91–99withAdvaxTMadjuvant
enhancesIFN-producingListeria-specificCD4+andCD8+Tcells
Next, we evaluated the effect of AdvaxTM on the ability of
standardimmunisationswithGNP-LLO91–99toinduceLLO-specific
CD8+ andCD4+TcellsusingIFN-␥asaTh1subsetmarker.Five
dayspostListeriachallenge,miceimmunisedwithGNP-LLO91–99
alonehadadetectablefrequency(0.59%)ofLLO91–99specific
IFN-␥+CD8+Tcells,butasexpectedhadnoresponsesagainsttheCD4+
Tcellepitopenotcontainedinthevaccine(Fig.3E,upperpanel). ImmunisationwithGNP-LLO91–99plusAdvaxTMnotonlyresulted
inasignificantincreaseinthefrequencyofLLO91–99specific
IFN-␥+CD8+ Tcells(0.89%) butalsoresultedintheappearanceofa
significantnumberofIFN-␥+CD4+TcellsrecognisingtheCD4
epi-tope,LLO189–201,notpresentinthevaccine(Fig.3E,lowerpanel).
ThustheAdvaxadjuvantenhancedtheabilityoftheListeria vac-cinetoprimeforaprocessofT-cellepitopespreadinginresponse toListeriainfection.
Toconfirm theabove findings,theability of AdvaxTM when
addedtoeitherDCvaccinesorfreeGNP-LLO91–99vaccinetoinduce
LLO91–99-specific CD8+ cells was tested using H2-Kb-LLO91–99
dimerstolabelandidentifytheantigen-specificTcells (H2-Kd
-LLO91–99dimerswereusedwithsimilarresults,datanotshown).
AdditionofAdvaxTMtoGNP-LLO
91–99resultedina4-foldincrease
in the frequency of LLO91–99-specific CD8+ cells versus
GNP-LLO91–99vaccinealone,andwassuperiortoallothervaccine
for-mulationsincludingtheDCvaccine,DC-GNP-LLO91–99(Table1,left
handcolumn).TheeffectsofAdvaxTMwereevenmorepronounced
whenH2-Kb-LLO
91–99positivecellsweregatedforIFN-␥,with
∼10-foldhigherfrequencyofIFN-␥expressingH2-Kb-LLO
91–99positive
cellsinmicevaccinatedwithGNP-LLO91–99plusAdvaxversusmice
vaccinatedwithfreeGNP-LLO91–99alone(Table1,righthand
col-umn).ThisconfirmedthatprovidingthevaccineincludedAdvaxTM
adjuvant,standardimmunisationwithGNP-LLO91–99wassuperior
toallothervaccineapproaches, includinguseofthebest GNP-loadedDCvaccine,atinducingListeria-specificIFN-␥+CD8+Tcells,
thecriticalcellsinvolvedinprotection. 4. Discussion
The objective of this study wasto identify an optimal vac-cineformulationtoprotectagainstlisterosis.Listeriaprotectionis largelydependentonCD4+andCD8+Tcellsratherthan
antibody-mediated immunity[14,17].Livevector vaccinesare inherently unsuitableforListeriavaccinesgiventheirriskofcausingserious infectioninimmune-compromisedindividuals.Asanalternative, cellularDC-basedvaccineswhereDCareloadedwithListeria anti-gensexvivo[6,11,19]andinjectedbackintothehosthavebeen proposedforinductionof protectivecellularimmunity.We ini-tiallydesignedaDCvaccinebasedonloadingofDCwithLLO91–99
peptideusingconjugatedGNP(GNP-LLO91–99)andshowedthat
thisprovidedahighefficiencyofDCloading,invitro[22,23]. DC-GNP-LLO91–99 inducedCD8+Tcellimmunityinimmunisedmice
thattranslatedintoprotectionagainstListeriachallenge.However DCvaccinesareimpracticalandexpensivetomake,necessitating thatwefindanalternativestrategyfordeliveryofourGNP-based vaccine. To overcometheseproblems, we next tested whether standardimmunisationwithGNP-LLO91–99ratherthanusingitto
loadDCinvitro,couldtargetandloadDCinvivo.However,only par-tialprotectionwasobtainedbystandardimmunisationwithfree GNP-LLO91–99vaccine,inferiortothatobtainedwiththeDCvaccine.
To overcome this problem, we next formulated the free GNP-LLO91–99antigenwithAdvaxTM,apolysaccharideadjuvantshown
effectiveandsafeinabroadrangeofanimalmodelsandhuman trials[25–31,33–35].Inadditiontoastronghumansafetyrecord, AdvaxTMwasselectedbasedonitsabilitytoinducerobustCD4+
andCD8+Tcellresponses[30,35].Asaproofofprinciplewefirst
showedthatAdvaxTMenhancedtheimmunogenicityoftheDC
vac-cine,GNP-LLO91–99.ThisfindingsuggestsAdvaxadjuvantmayoffer
benefitsforDCvaccinesforotherindicationssuchascancer,where thecostandcomplexityofDCvaccinesislessanissue.However, givenourdesiretomoveawayfromtheDCvaccineapproachfor Listeria,themostimportantfindingwasthatAdvaxTMsignificantly
enhanced the immunogenicityof GNP-LLO91–99 when
adminis-teredasastandardvaccine.Notably,thistranslatedintoimproved Listeriaprotectiontoalevelwehadpreviouslyonlyachievedusing DCvaccines.Theenhancedprotectionobtainedwiththe Advax-adjuvantedGNP-LLO91–99vaccinewasassociatedwithanincreased
frequencyofsplenicCD4+ andCD8+ Tcells,NKcellsandCD8␣+
DC.ThelatterhavebeenreportedtoplayacriticalroleinListeria protectionviaabilitytoproduceIL-12andactivateIFN-␥ produc-ingCD4+ and CD8+ Tcells [39,40]. Notably,immunisation with
Advax-adjuvantedGNP-LLO91–99enhancedproductionoftheTh1
cytokines,IL-12,IFN-␥,TNF-␣,andMCP-1,whilereducingtheTh2 cytokine,IL-6.Interestingly,immunisationwithAdvax-adjuvanted
werestimulatedfor5hwithLLO91–99orLLO189–201peptidesthenintracellularcytokinestainingperformed.HistogramsshowthefrequencyofLLO189–201-specificCD4+Tcells
andfrequencyofthesemakingIFN-␥producers(leftplots)andthefrequencyofLLO91–99-specificCD8+TcellsandfrequencyofthesemakingIFN-␥(rightplots).Experiments
Fig.4.HypotheticalmodeltoexplaintheeffectofAdvaxTMadjuvantonGNP-LLO
91–99protectionagainstlisteriosis.Diagramdepictingpredictedeventswhenmicearevaccinated
withsolubleGNP-LLO91–99carriersinthepresenceorabsenceofAdvaxTMadjuvant(step1)andthenchallengedwithliveListeria(step2).Explanationofthemodelis
describedintextoftheSection4.
GNP-LLO91–99 wasalsoassociated withincreasedproduction of
theanti-inflammatorycytokine,IL-10,butunlikeotherstudiesthis increasedIL-10wasnotassociatedwithenhancedListeria suscep-tibility[32].IL-10maynormallyactasaninversemarkerofIFN-␥ productionasIL-10isdownregulatedbyIL-12andIFN-␥andvice versa.BecauseIL-12andIFN-␥aredominantindeterminingListeria protectionandwerebothmarkedlyincreasedbyAdvax-adjuvanted GNP-LLO91–99,theIL-10 evenalthough increased wouldnot be
expected to block IFN-␥-mediated protection in this situation, butmayactuallyhavebeenbeneficialbyreducinginflammatory damageinresponsetoListeriainfection.Immunisationwith Advax-adjuvanted GNP-LLO91–99 resultedin an increasedfrequency of
LLO91–99specificIFN-␥+CD8+Tcells,post-challenge.More
surpris-ingwastheincreasedfrequencyofLLO189–201specificIFN-␥+CD4+
Tcells, asthisCD4+epitope wasnotpresent inthevaccinethe
micereceivedsotheseCD4+Tcellsmusthavebeengeneratedin
responsetotheListeriaitself.Thissuggeststhatmiceimmunised withAdvaxTMadjuvanthaveagreatercapacityforT-cellepitope
spreadingafterListeriachallenge,therebyexplainingthebroader T-cellrecognitionofListeriaepitopesinthemicethatreceivedthe Advax-adjuvantedGNP-LLO91–99vaccine.
OurmodelforhowvaccinationwithAdvax-adjuvanted
GNP-LLO91–99 provides enhanced protection against listeriosis is
depictedinFig.4.Inbrief,injectionofsolubleGNP-LLO91–99
carri-ers(step1)targetstheconjugatedpeptidetoconventionalsplenic DCthatarestimulatedtoamaturephenotypeandcanthenprime LLO91–99-specificCD8+Tcells(step3).UponexposuretoListeria
(step2),theseCD8+ Tcellsbecomeactivatedandproduce
IFN-␥thatinturnenhancesDCIL-12productionandconsequentNK cellactivation.ATh1feedbackloopisgenerated,whichassiststhe inductionofinflammatoryandactivatedDCandMØthat phago-cytoseandkill thebacteria(step4).AdvaxTM adjuvant recruits
andinteractswithDCresultinginanincreaseinmatureDCand, inparticular,CD8␣+DC,whichafterloadingwithGNP-conjugated
LLO91–99,migratetothesplenicwhitezoneswheretheybecome
activatedand induce expansionof LLO-specific CD4+ and CD8+
T cells (step 5). Upon exposure to Listeria, these LLO-specific
CD8+ Tcells becomeactivatedandinducehighlevelsof IFN-␥,
IL-12, MCP-1, and TNF-␣.These Th1cytokinesenhance Listeria phagocytosisanddestruction,whileincreasedIL-10mayhelp pre-ventexcessinflammation(step6).CD8+Tcellsgeneratedbythe
Advax-adjuvantedvaccineenhanceepitopespreadingbyinducing DCtoexpressadditionalListeriaepitopes,therebyallowing recruit-mentofadditionalCD4+ TcellsableinresponsetotheseMHC-II
epitopes.Thispromotesfurtherexpansionandactivationof LLO-specificTcellsincludingIFN-␥producingLLO189–201-specificCD4+
Tcells(step7)thatsynergisewithIFN-␥-producingCD8+Tcellsin
Listeriacontrol.
Overall, these results support further development of GNP-peptide carriers together with AdvaxTM adjuvant as a vaccine
platformwithpotentialapplicabilitytoprophylacticimmunisation againstListeria,plusotherbroaderuses.
Acknowledgements
This study was supported in part by grants founded by MINECO, SAF2009-08695 and SAF2012-34203 and by IDIVAL grants:API2012/03/SAF2009-08695andAIP2014/SAF2012-34203 (toC. A-D)and grantCTQ 2011-27268(to S.P).Developmentof AdvaxadjuvantwassupportedbycontractHHSN272200800039C from the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, NationalInstitutesofHealth(toN.P).Thispaper’s contentsare solely the responsibility of the authorsand do not necessarily representtheofficialviewsofthefunders.Weacknowledgethe laboratory technical assistance of L. Vazquez-Rioja and IDIVAL institutionalassistanceofC.Santacruz-LlatawithFACSanalysis.
AppendixA. Supplementarydata
Supplementarydataassociatedwiththisarticlecanbefound, intheonlineversion,athttp://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.vaccine.2015. 01.062.
References
[1]BrockstedtDG,BahjatKS,GiedlinMA,LiuW,LeongM,LuckettW,etal.Killed butmetabolicallyactivemicrobes:anewvaccineparadigmforelicitingeffector T-cellresponsesandprotectiveimmunity.NatMed2005;11(8):853–60.
[2]LauerP,HansonB,LemmensEE,LiuW,LuckettWS,LeongML,etal.Constitutive activationofthePrfAregulonenhancesthepotencyofvaccinesbasedon live-attenuatedandkilledbutmetabolicallyactiveListeriamonocytogenesstrains. InfectImmun2008;76(8):3742–53.
[3]StarksH,BruhnKW,ShenH,BarryRA,DubenskyTW,BrockstedtD,etal. Listeriamonocytogenesasavaccinevector:virulenceattenuationor exist-ingantivectorimmunitydoesnotdiminishtherapeuticefficiency.JImmunol 2004;173:420–37.
[4]Quispe-TintayaW,ChandraD,JahangirA,HarrisM,CasadevallA,Dadachova E,etal.NontoxicradioactiveListeriaat isahighlyeffectivetherapyagainst
metastaticpancreaticcancer.ProcNatlAcadSciUSA2013;110:8668–73.
[5]Carrasco-MarinE,Rodriguez-DelRioE,Frande-CabanesE,TobesR,ParejaE, Lecea-CuelloMJ,etal.Phagosomesinducedbycytokinesfunctionas anti-Listeriavaccines:anovelroleforfunctionalcompartmentalizationofStat-1 andcathepsin-D.JBiolChem2012;287:14310–24.
[6]KonoM,NakamuraY,SudaT,Uchijima M,Tsujimura K,NagataT,etal. Enhancementofprotectiveimmunityagainstintracellularbacteriausing type-1polarizeddendriticcell(DC)vaccine.Vaccine2012;30:2633–9.
[7]Mohamed W,SethiS,TchatalbachevS,Darji A,ChakrabortyT.Protective immunitytoListeriamonocytogenesinfectionmediatedbyrecombinantListeria innocuaharboringtheVGClocus.PLoSONE2012;7(4):e35503.
[8]Rodriguez-DelRioE,Frande-CabanesE,TobesR,ParejaE,Lecea-CuelloMJ, Ruiz-SaezM,etal.TheintactstructuralformofLLOinendosomescannotprotect againstlisteriosis.IntJBiochemMolBiol2011;2(3):207–18.
[9]AnsariMA,ZubairS,TufailS,AhmadE,KhanMR,QuadriZ,etal.Etherlipid vesicle-basedantigensimpartprotectionagainstexperimentallisteriosis.IntJ Nanomed2012;7:2433–47.
[10]Vacas-CordobaE,PionM,RasinesB,FilippiniD,KomberH,IonovM,etal. Glycodendrimersasnewtoolsinthesearchforeffectiveanti-HIVDC-based immunotherapies.Nanomed:Nanotechnol,BiolMed2013;9(7):972–84.
[11]Calderon-GonzalezR,Frande-CabanesE,Bronchalo-VicenteL,Lecea-Cuello MJ,ParejaE,Bosch-Martinez A,etal. Cellularvaccinesinlisteriosis:role oftheListeriaantigenGAPDH.FrontCellInfectMicrobiol2014;4(22):1–11,
http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fcimb.2014.00022(eCollection2014).
[12]NagataT,KoideY.InductionofspecificCD8Tcellsagainstintracellular bacte-riabyCD8Tcell-orientedimmunizationapproaches.JBiomedBiotechnol 2010;2010:764542.
[13]LeeSH,CarreroJA,UppaluriR,WhiteJM,ArchambaultJM,LaiKS,etal. Identify-ingtheinitiatingeventsofanti-Listeriaresponsesusingmicewithconditional lossofIFN-␥receptorsubunit1(IFNGR1).JImmunol2013;191(8):4223–34.
[14]PamerEG.ImmuneresponsestoListeriamonocytogenes.NatRevImmunol 2004;4:812–23.
[15]GeginatG,SchenkS,SkoberneM,GoebelW,HofH.Anovelapproachofdirect exvivoepitopemappingidentifiesdominantandsubdominantCD4andCD8T cellepitopesfromListeriamonocytogenes.JImmunol2001;166:1877–84.
[16]SkoberneM,GeginatG.EfficientinvivopresentationofListeria monocyto-genesderivedCD4andCD8cellepitopesintheabsenceofIFN-␥.JImmunol 2002;168:1854–60.
[17]AngelakopoulosH,LoockK,SisulDM,JensenER,MillerJF,HohmannEL.Safety andsheddingofanattenuatedstrainofListeriamonocytogeneswithadeletion ofactA/plcBinadultvolunteers:adoseescalationstudyoforalinoculation. InfectImmun2002;70(7):3592–601.
[18]PionM,SerramiaMJ,DiazL,BryszewskaM,GallartT,GarciaF,etal.Phenotype andfunctionalanalysisofhumanmonocytes-deriveddendriticcellsloaded withacarbosilanedendrimer.Biomaterials2010;31:8749–58.
[19]LebelME,DaudelinJF,ChartrandK,TarrabE,KalineU,SavardP,etal. Nanopar-ticleadjuvantsensingbyTLR7enhancesCD8+Tcell-mediatedprotectionfrom Listeriamonocytogenesinfection.JImmunol2014;192:1071–8.
[20]delaFuenteJM,BarrientosAG,RojasTC,RojoJ,Ca ˜nadaJ,FernándezA,etal.Gold glyconanoparticlesaswater-solublepolyvalentmodelstostudycarbohydrate interactions.AngewChemIntEd2001;40(12):2257–61.
[21]delaFuenteJM,PenadésS.Glyconanoparticles:types,synthesisand applica-tionsinglycoscience,biomedicineandmaterialscience.BiochimBiophysActa 2006;1760:636–51.
[22]MarradiM,ChiodoF,GarcíaI,PenadésS.Glyconanoparticlesasmultifunctional andmultimodalcarbohydratesystems.ChemSocRev2013;42:4728.
[23]SafariD,MarradiM,ChiodoF,ThDekkerHA,ShanY,AdamoR,etal.Gold nanoparticlesascarriersforasyntheticStreptococcuspneumoniaetype14 con-jugatevaccine.Nanomedicine2012;7:651–62.
[24]ChiodoF,MarradiM,ParkJ,RamAF,PenadésS,vanDieI,etal. Galactofuranose-coated gold nanoparticles elicit a pro-inflammatory response in human monocyte-deriveddendriticcellsandarerecognizedbyDC-SIGN.ACSChem Biol2014;9(2):383–9.
[25]CooperPD,BarclayTG,Ginic-MarkovicM,PetrovskyN.Thepolysaccharide inulinischaracterizedbyanextensiveseriesofperiodicisoformswithvarying biologicalactions.Glycobiology2013;23(10):1164–74.
[26]Honda-OkuboY,KolpeA,LiL,PetrovskyN.Asingleimmunizationwith inactiv-atedH1N1influenzavaccineformulatedwithdeltainulinadjuvant(AdvaxTM)
overcomespregnancy-associatedimmunesuppressionandenhancespassive neonatalprotection.Vaccine2014;32(Aug(36)):4651–9.
[27]LarenaM,ProwNA,HallRA,PetrovskyN,LobigsM.JE-ADVAXvaccine pro-tectionagainstJapaneseencephalitisvirusmediatedbymemoryBcellsin theabsenceofCD8(+)Tcellsandpre-exposureneutralizingantibody.JVirol 2013;8:4395–402.
[28]PetrovskyN,LarenaM,SiddharthanV,ProwNA,HallRA,LobigsM,etal.An inactivatedcellcultureJapaneseencephalitisvaccine(JE-ADVAX)formulated withdeltainulinadjuvantprovidesrobustheterologousprotectionagainst WestNileencephalitisviacross-protectivememoryBcellsandneutralizing antibody.JVirol2013;18:b10324–33.
[29]GordonD,KelleyP,HeinzelS,CooperP,PetrovskyN.Immunogenicityand safetyofAdvaxTM,anovelpolysaccharideadjuvantbasedondeltainulin,when
formulatedwithhepatitisBsurfaceantigen:arandomizedcontrolledPhase1 study.Vaccine2014Sep,http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.vaccine.2014.09.034(pii: S0264-410X(14)01293-6).
[30]CristilloAD, FerrariMG, HudacikL, Lewis B, Galmin L, Bowen B, et al. InductionofmucosalandsystemicantibodyandT-cellresponsesfollowing prime-boostimmunizationwithnoveladjuvantedhumanimmunodeficiency virus-1-vaccineformulations.JGenVirol2011;92(Pt1):128–40.
[31]GordonDL,SajkovD,WoodmanRJ,Honda-OkuboY,CoxMJ,HeinzelS,etal. Randomizedclinicaltrialofimmunogenicityandsafetyofarecombinant H1N1/2009pandemicinfluenzavaccinecontainingAdvaxTMpolysaccharide
adjuvant.Vaccine2012;30:5047–416.
[32]CarreroJA,UnanueER.Mechanismsandimmunologicaleffectsofapoptosis causedbyListeriamonocytogenes.AdvImmunol2012;113:157–74.
[33]Lobgis M, Pavy M, Hall RA, Lobgis P, Cooper P, Komiya T, et al. An inactivatedVerocell-grownJapaneseencephalitisvaccineformulatedwith Advax,anovelinulin-basedadjuvant,inducesprotectiveneutralizing anti-bodyagainsthomologousandheterologousflaviviruses.JGenVirol2010;91: 1407–17.
[34]Layton RC, Petrovsky N, Gigliotti AP, Pollock Z, Knight J, Donart N, etal. Delta inulinpolysaccharideadjuvant enhances theability of split-virionH5N1vaccinetoprotectagainstlethalchallengeinferrets.Vaccine 2011;29(37):6242–51.
[35]Honda-OkuboY,SaadeF,PetrovskyN.AdvaxTM,apolysaccharideadjuvant derivedfromdeltainulin,providesimprovedinfluenzavaccineprotection throughbroad-basedenhancementofadaptiveimmuneresponses.Vaccine 2012;30:5373–81.
[36]Martínez-ÁvilaO,HijaziK,MarradiM,ClavelC,CampionC,KellyC,etal.Gold manno-glyconanoparticles:multivalentsystemstoblockHIV-1gp120binding tothelectinDC-SIGN.ChemEurJ2009;15:9874–88.
[37]OjedaR,DePazJL,BarrientosAG,Martin-LomasM,PenadésS.Preparationof multifunctionalglyconanoparticlesasaplatformforpotential carbohydrate-basedanticancervaccines.CarbohydrRes2007;342:448–59.
[38]UchiyamaR,YoneharaS,TsutsuiH.Fas-mediatedinflammatoryresponsein Listeriamonocytogenesinfection.JImmunol2013;190(8):4245–54.
[39]MitchellLM,Brzoza-LewisKL,HenryCJ,GraysonJM,WestcottMM,Hitbold EM.DistintresponsesofsplenicdendriticcellsubsetstoinfectionwithListeria monocytogenes:maturationphenotype,levelofinfection,andTcellpriming capacityexvivo.CellImmunol2011;268:79–86.
[40]EdelsonBT,BradstreetTR,HildnerK,CarreroJA,FrederickKE,WumeshKC, etal.CD8␣+dendrititccellsareanobligatecellularentrypointforproductive