Aldo Scarpa
ARC-NET Centre for Applied Research on Cancer and Department of Pathology
University of Verona
Patologia molecolare del
carcinoma pancreatico
Ductal
adenocarcinoma Acinar cell
carcinoma
Neuroendocrine tumours
Intraductal papillary mucinous neoplasm
Serous cystic neoplasms
The Spectrum of Pancreatic Tumors
Mucinous cystic neoplasms
Solid pseudopapillary neoplasms
Ductal
adenocarcinoma Acinar cell
carcinoma
Neuroendocrine tumours
Intraductal papillary mucinous neoplasm
Serous cystic neoplasms
The Spectrum of Pancreatic Tumors
Mucinous cystic neoplasms
Solid pseudopapillary neoplasms
Genetics of ductal adenocarcinoma
1. What we know today
2. Information from sequencing
3. What we can do for the patient
Genetics of ductal adenocarcinoma
1. What we know today
2. Information from sequencing
3. What we can do for the patient
Emerging Molecular Taxonomy
The most important mutated genes in pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma and its
variants
Objective : Sub-classify cancers using histopathology and molecules
Methods: Histopathological and molecular characterisation of primary cancers and model systems
Pancreatic Cancer
Genetics of ductal adenocarcinoma
1. What we know today
2. Information from sequencing
3. What we can do for the patient
The mutational landscape of pancreatic cancer
Stable
(<50 events)
Focal
(50-200, 50% on 1 Chr)
Unstable
(>200 widespread)
Scattered
(50 – 200 widespread)
30% 14%
20% 36%
Waddell N, et al – Nature 2015
There are 4 PDAC subtypes
Anatomy Whole genome sequence
of 100 PDAC
Anatomy
• 10 pathways
• 32 recurrently mutated genes
96%
78%
24%
14%
24%
25%
16%
15%
12%
47%
Driver Gene Analysis
Whole genome sequence of 457 PDAC
Bailey et al, Nature 2016
Genetics of ductal adenocarcinoma
1. What we know today
2. Information from sequencing
3. What we can do for the patient
Cancer diagnostics tasks
4 Follow up Diagnosis 1
Prognosis 2
3 Predict drug efficacy
Multigene panels
for pathway based molecular diagnostics
Panel Name
PDAC periampullary
basic
TGFB Pathway SWI/SNF Chromatin Remodelling
WNT non canonical - Spliceosome
DNA DAMAGE REPAIR
GENES
KRAS ACVR1A ARID2 ARHGAP4 BRCA1
BRAF ACVR1B ARID1B PRPF40A BRCA2
NRAS ACVR1C BAP1 PRPF40B PALB2
TP53 ACVR2A DPF1 RBM6 STK11
CDKN2A ACVR2B DPF2 RBM10 RPA1
PIK3CA TGFBR1 DPF3 RNF43 REV3L
APC TGFBR2 HLTF ROBO1 ATM
CTNNB1 SMAD1 KDM5C ROBO2
EGFR SMAD2 KDM6A ROBO3
ERBB2 SMAD3 KMT2C ROBO4
ERBB4 SMAD4 KMT2D SF1
FGFR3 SMAD5 MEF2C SF3A1
FLT3 SMAD9 PBRM1 SF3B1
GNAS SETD2 SLIT2
KDR/VEGFR2 SMARCA1 SRGAP1
FBXW7 SMARCA2 SRGAP2
CDH1 SMARCA4 SRGAP3
U2AF1 U2AF2
PDAC Periampullary
TGFß Pathway
SWI/SNF Chromatin
WNT
Spliceosome
DNA Damage Repair
ATM BRCA1 BRCA2 PALB2 REV3L STK11 RPA1 BARD1 BRIP1 PTEN RAD51B RAD51C RAD51D MRE11A NBN CHEK1 CHEK2 FAM175A
Molecular Diagnosis
1
Variable No %
Sex
Male 104 52
Female 96 48
Age
Mean 65
Median 67
Range 30 - 88
Overall Stage
IA 1 0.5
IB 2 1
IIA 26 13
IIB 159 80
III 2 1
IV 10 5
T stage
T1 1 0.5
T2 4 2
T3 193 97
T4 2 1
N stage
N0 31 16
N1 169 84
M stage
M0 189 95
M1 11 5
GRADE
1 12 6
2 117 59
3 68 34
X 3 1
Resection Margins
R0 121 60
R1 79 40
Tumour Site
Head 158 79
Body 18 9
Body-Tail 7 3
Tail 13 7
Istmus 2 1
Peri-ampullary 2 1
Cohort of 200 well annotated PDAC
CANCER TYPE SUBTYPE
Ductal adenocaricnoma (PDAC)
Common type 173
Clear cell 3
Adenosquamous 3
Focal squamous 8 IPMN associated 5
Colloid 1
Periampullary 1
Acinar 2
Ampullary 1
Duodenal 2
Neuroendocrine (poor diff.) 1
TOTAL 200
Patient Cohort 200 patients
Multigene panels
for pathway based molecular diagnostics
Panel Name
PDAC periampullary
basic
TGFB Pathway SWI/SNF Chromatin Remodelling
WNT non canonical - Spliceosome
DNA DAMAGE REPAIR
GENES
KRAS ACVR1A ARID2 ARHGAP4 BRCA1
BRAF ACVR1B ARID1B PRPF40A BRCA2
NRAS ACVR1C BAP1 PRPF40B PALB2
TP53 ACVR2A DPF1 RBM6 STK11
CDKN2A ACVR2B DPF2 RBM10 RPA1
PIK3CA TGFBR1 DPF3 RNF43 REV3L
APC TGFBR2 HLTF ROBO1 ATM
CTNNB1 SMAD1 KDM5C ROBO2
EGFR SMAD2 KDM6A ROBO3
ERBB2 SMAD3 KMT2C ROBO4
ERBB4 SMAD4 KMT2D SF1
FGFR3 SMAD5 MEF2C SF3A1
FLT3 SMAD9 PBRM1 SF3B1
GNAS SETD2 SLIT2
KDR/VEGFR2 SMARCA1 SRGAP1
FBXW7 SMARCA2 SRGAP2
CDH1 SMARCA4 SRGAP3
U2AF1 U2AF2
PDAC Periampullary
TGFß Pathway
SWI/SNF Chromatin
WNT
Spliceosome
DNA Damage Repair
ATM BRCA1 BRCA2 PALB2 REV3L STK11 RPA1 BARD1 BRIP1 PTEN RAD51B RAD51C RAD51D MRE11A NBN CHEK1 CHEK2 FAM175A
Molecular Diagnosis
1
PDAC – Periampullary Basic panel
Gene Mutations Proportion
KRAS 188 94%
TP53 123 61%
SMAD4 30 15%
CDKN2A/p16 24 12%
GNAS 4 2%
APC 3 1%
PIK3CA 4 2%
Gene Mutations in 200 Cases
4 Follow up
Personal markers
Multigene panels
for pathway based molecular diagnostics
Panel Name
PDAC periampullary
basic
TGFB Pathway SWI/SNF Chromatin Remodelling
WNT non canonical - Spliceosome
DNA DAMAGE REPAIR
GENES
KRAS ACVR1A ARID2 ARHGAP4 BRCA1
BRAF ACVR1B ARID1B PRPF40A BRCA2
NRAS ACVR1C BAP1 PRPF40B PALB2
TP53 ACVR2A DPF1 RBM6 STK11
CDKN2A ACVR2B DPF2 RBM10 RPA1
PIK3CA TGFBR1 DPF3 RNF43 REV3L
APC TGFBR2 HLTF ROBO1 ATM
CTNNB1 SMAD1 KDM5C ROBO2
EGFR SMAD2 KDM6A ROBO3
ERBB2 SMAD3 KMT2C ROBO4
ERBB4 SMAD4 KMT2D SF1
FGFR3 SMAD5 MEF2C SF3A1
FLT3 SMAD9 PBRM1 SF3B1
GNAS SETD2 SLIT2
KDR/VEGFR2 SMARCA1 SRGAP1
FBXW7 SMARCA2 SRGAP2
CDH1 SMARCA4 SRGAP3
U2AF1 U2AF2
PDAC Periampullary
TGFß Pathway
SWI/SNF Chromatin
WNT
Spliceosome
DNA Damage Repair
ATM BRCA1 BRCA2 PALB2 REV3L STK11 RPA1 BARD1 BRIP1 PTEN RAD51B RAD51C RAD51D MRE11A NBN CHEK1 CHEK2 FAM175A
Molecular Diagnosis
1
Gene Mutations Pathogenic VUS SN P
ARID1A 12 7 5 -
ARID1B 9 3 3 3
ARID2 11 1 4 6
DPF1 1 - 1 -
DPF3 - - - -
HLTF 4 - 1 3
KDM5C 4 2 1 1
KDM6A 6 5 1 -
KMT2C
(MLL3) 36 9 9 18
KMT2D
(MLL2) 39 5 18 6
SETD2 9 1 5 3
SMARCA2 2 - 2 -
SMARCA4 12 2 7 3
PBRM1 7 3 4 -
BAP1 3
1 2155 39 63 53
Gene Mutations in 200 Cases
Histone Modifiers and Chromatin Remodelling
2 Prognosis
Sausen M et al. Nature Communications. 2015
39/200 (20%)
Multigene panels
for pathway based molecular diagnostics
Panel Name
PDAC periampullary
basic
TGFB Pathway SWI/SNF Chromatin Remodelling
WNT non canonical - Spliceosome
DNA DAMAGE REPAIR
GENES
KRAS ACVR1A ARID2 ARHGAP4 BRCA1
BRAF ACVR1B ARID1B PRPF40A BRCA2
NRAS ACVR1C BAP1 PRPF40B PALB2
TP53 ACVR2A DPF1 RBM6 STK11
CDKN2A ACVR2B DPF2 RBM10 RPA1
PIK3CA TGFBR1 DPF3 RNF43 REV3L
APC TGFBR2 HLTF ROBO1 ATM
CTNNB1 SMAD1 KDM5C ROBO2
EGFR SMAD2 KDM6A ROBO3
ERBB2 SMAD3 KMT2C ROBO4
ERBB4 SMAD4 KMT2D SF1
FGFR3 SMAD5 MEF2C SF3A1
FLT3 SMAD9 PBRM1 SF3B1
GNAS SETD2 SLIT2
KDR/VEGFR2 SMARCA1 SRGAP1
FBXW7 SMARCA2 SRGAP2
CDH1 SMARCA4 SRGAP3
U2AF1 U2AF2
PDAC Periampullary
TGFß Pathway
SWI/SNF Chromatin
WNT
Spliceosome
DNA Damage Repair
ATM BRCA1 BRCA2 PALB2 REV3L STK11 RPA1 BARD1 BRIP1 PTEN RAD51B RAD51C RAD51D MRE11A NBN CHEK1 CHEK2 FAM175A
Molecular Diagnosis
1
BRCA – Homologous Recombination Panel
Gene Mutations in 200 cases
Gene Variants Pathogenic Unknown SNP
ATM 40 3 7 12
BRCA1 24 2 2 11
BRCA2 25 14 3 8
PALB2 8 2 1 5
REV3L 15 2 9 5
STK11 4 2 3 -
RPA1 2 - - 2
BARD1 8 2 1 5
BRIP1 8 - 4 4
PTEN 2 - - 2
RAD51B 4 - - 4
RAD51C 3 - - 3
RAD51D 4 1 - 3
MRE11A 2 1 - 2
NBN 2 1 - 1
CHEK1 2 - 2
CHEK2 7 2 1 4
FAM175A 1 - 1
161 32 34 95
3 Predict drug efficacy
32/200 (16%)
HR gene mutations are associated with BRCA signature and response to platinum
Waddell N, et al – Nature 2015
Anatomy
Physiology
Social Behavior
Beyond anatomical lesions in DNA
• Physiology : RNA-Seq of primaries and xenografts to assess molecular subgroups
• Histopathological revisitation of cancer and its stromal environment
• Devise clinically applicable diagnostic methods for molecular subclassification using DNA panels immunohistochemistry and nanostring assays
• Devise clinical trials based on cancer subtypes
RNAseq of 96 cases
• 4 classes based on transcription factors and downstream targets
• Enriched with specific histological features
Bailey et al, Nature 2016
Physiology : Identification of PDAC Subtypes
Immunogenic Subtype
c a b
CD4+ve regulatory T cells
1 0 -1
GP6 GP7 GP8
1 0 -1
ADEX Immunogenic
Squamous Pancreatic Progenitor
APC co-stimulation APC co-inhibition Macrophages
T cell co-stim ulation
T cell co-inhibition B cells
CD8+ve T cells
Cytolytic activity
6.7 15.5 2.8 4.8 2.8 3.4 2.9 2.8 9.7 7.6 10.4 15.3 7.7 17.8 20.8 12 6.1 25.7 15.2 15.4 20.8 10 3 19.5 8.4 4.7
d
MACROPHAGE SIGNATUREe
T CELL CO-INHIBITION SIGNATURE SignatureScore
Correlation
●●●
● ●
●
●
●
●
GP6 GP7 GP8
Pval = 6.75E-11 Pval = 0.00625 Pval = 0.00945
-0.2 0 0.2 0.4
GP association (ME)
A I S P A I S P A I S P
REACTOME_PD1_SIGNALING BIOCARTA_CTLA4_PATHWAY P.value = 0.01
0 0.5
Signature Score -0.5
P.value = 0.00843
A I S P A I S P
Bailey et al, Nature 2016
PDAC subtypes using colorectal cancer assinger
Scarpa, unpublished
Cancer is a tissue
Pancreas Cancer
Cancer Normal
Pancreas Cancer
Pancreas Cancer
Inter- and Intra- Patient Heterogeneity
Multigene panels
for pathway based molecular diagnostics
Panel Name
PDAC periampullary
basic
TGFB Pathway SWI/SNF Chromatin Remodelling
WNT non canonical - Spliceosome
DNA DAMAGE REPAIR
GENES
KRAS ACVR1A ARID2 ARHGAP4 BRCA1
BRAF ACVR1B ARID1B PRPF40A BRCA2
NRAS ACVR1C BAP1 PRPF40B PALB2
TP53 ACVR2A DPF1 RBM6 STK11
CDKN2A ACVR2B DPF2 RBM10 RPA1
PIK3CA TGFBR1 DPF3 RNF43 REV3L
APC TGFBR2 HLTF ROBO1 ATM
CTNNB1 SMAD1 KDM5C ROBO2
EGFR SMAD2 KDM6A ROBO3
ERBB2 SMAD3 KMT2C ROBO4
ERBB4 SMAD4 KMT2D SF1
FGFR3 SMAD5 MEF2C SF3A1
FLT3 SMAD9 PBRM1 SF3B1
GNAS SETD2 SLIT2
KDR/VEGFR2 SMARCA1 SRGAP1
FBXW7 SMARCA2 SRGAP2
CDH1 SMARCA4 SRGAP3
U2AF1 U2AF2
PDAC Periampullary
TGFß Pathway
SWI/SNF Chromatin
WNT
Spliceosome
DNA Damage Repair
ATM BRCA1 BRCA2 PALB2 REV3L STK11 RPA1 BARD1 BRIP1 PTEN RAD51B RAD51C RAD51D MRE11A NBN CHEK1 CHEK2 FAM175A
Molecular Diagnosis
1
Gene Mutations in 200 Cases
TGFß pathway
Gene Mutations Pathogenic VUS SNP
SMAD2 1 1 - -
SMAD3 12 4 1 7
SMAD4 46 30 8 8
SMAD5 2 - - 1
SMAD9 5 - 3 2
ACVR1 2 - - 2
ACVR1C 3 - 1 2
ACVR2A 8 5 3 -
ACVR1B 3 1 2
ACVR2B 4 1 2 1
TGFBR2 10 7 3 1
86 49 21 24
49/200 (25%)
Stroma is composite and variable
Pancreas Cancer and its environment
Dissecting the Stroma
Keratin Vimentin Fusion
VIM+
KER+
Stromal Cells
Tumor Cells
EMT
KRAS G12R 22%
TP53 R273H 39%
SMAD4 R361H 32%
DEP-ARRAY Silicon Biosystems
Dissecting the Stroma
TUMOR EMT
Recovery of homogeneous pools of cells
STROMAL
DEP-ARRAY
40% Tumor Cells: CNV assessment
Unsorted cells
Low-Pass Whole-Genome sequencing for CNV assessment confirm separation of S/T
DEPArray™ sorted Tumor cells