Mechanisms of action &
pre-clinical activity
Agents used in Metronomics
Mechanisms of action &
pre-clinical activity
Agents used in Metronomics
Marie Sklodowska- Curie Fellowship
Eddy Pasquier, PhD
Marie Curie Fellow – Aix‐Marseille University (France) Honorary Fellow – Children’s Cancer Institute (Australia)
Co‐founder – Metronomics Global Health Initiative
Eddy Pasquier, PhD
Marie Curie Fellow – Aix‐Marseille University (France) Honorary Fellow – Children’s Cancer Institute (Australia)
Co‐founder – Metronomics Global Health Initiative
Clinical Cancer Research 1996
Blood 1999
Journal of Hematotherapy & Stem Cell Research 2003
Anti-angiogenic activity of paclitaxel Anti-angiogenic activity of paclitaxel
[Paclitaxel] (nM) [Paclitaxel] (nM)
% of control% of control
Cytostatic effect Cytotoxic effect
Microtubule dynamic instability Microtubule dynamic instability
Time-lapse videomicroscopy following micro-injection of rhodamine-tubulin in endothelial cells
Interphasic functions of microtubules
Inhibition of cell motility and differentiation
Anti-angiogenic activity Anti-angiogenic activity
ow concentrations
INCREASE INCREASE
Cytotoxic concentrations
SUPPRESSION SUPPRESSION
Microtubule dynamics Microtubule dynamics
slight strong
Mitotic functions of microtubules
Inhibition of cell proliferation
Inhibition of cell proliferation
Apoptosis induction Apoptosis
induction Mitotic
arrest Mitotic
arrest
Inhibition of proliferation and cytotoxicity are not required for the anti-angiogenic activity of MTAs Inhibition of proliferation and cytotoxicity are not
required for the anti-angiogenic activity of MTAs
Pasquier et al., Cancer Res 2005 Pourroy et al., Cancer Res 2006
Nature Reviews Cancer, 2004
Nature Reviews Cancer, 2004
Cancer Research, 2003
Nature Reviews Cancer, 2004
PNAS, 2003
Nature Reviews Cancer, 2004
Adapted from Pasquier et al., Nat Rev Clin Oncol 2010
Galluzzi et al., Nature Reviews Drug Discovery, 2012
Adapted from Pasquier et al., Nat Rev Clin Oncol 2010
Cancer Research 2007
Metronomic chemotherapy decreases cancer cell stemness
Metronomic chemotherapy decreases cancer cell stemness
International Journal of Cancer 2013
PNAS 2009
Cancer Research 2002
2011
Adapted from Pasquier et al., Nat Rev Clin Oncol 2010
Vinblastine
Microtubule-targeting agent
Etoposide
Topoisomerase II inhibitor
Mafosfamide
Alkylating agent
Long-term effects of chemotherapy on vascular endothelial cells
Long-term effects of chemotherapy on vascular endothelial cells
MAXIMUM-TOLERATED DOSE (MTD) versus LOW-DOSE METRONOMIC (LDM) MAXIMUM-TOLERATED DOSE (MTD) versus LOW-DOSE METRONOMIC (LDM)
METRONOMICS Global Health Initiative
LOW-DOSE METRONOMIC (LDM) Treatment 5 days/week with IC1 LOW-DOSE METRONOMIC (LDM)
Treatment 5 days/week with IC1 MAXIMUM-TOLERATED DOSE (MTD)
Treatment every 2 weeks with IC80
MAXIMUM-TOLERATED DOSE (MTD) Treatment every 2 weeks with IC80
Long-term effects of chemotherapy on vascular endothelial cells
Long-term effects of chemotherapy on vascular endothelial cells
METRONOMICS Global Health Initiative
METRONOMICS Global Health Initiative
Metronomic mafosphamide induces senescence in vascular endothelial cells
Metronomic mafosphamide induces senescence in vascular endothelial cells
-galactosidase staining, 3 weeks incubation with MFA
-galactosidase staining, 3 weeks incubation with MFA
BMH29L BMH29L
Long-term effects of chemotherapy on vascular endothelial cells
Long-term effects of chemotherapy on vascular endothelial cells
LOW-DOSE METRONOMIC (LDM) Treatment 5 days/week with IC1 LOW-DOSE METRONOMIC (LDM)
Treatment 5 days/week with IC1 MAXIMUM-TOLERATED DOSE (MTD)
Treatment every 2 weeks with IC80
MAXIMUM-TOLERATED DOSE (MTD) Treatment every 2 weeks with IC80
Long-term effects of chemotherapy on vascular endothelial cells
Long-term effects of chemotherapy on vascular endothelial cells
METRONOMICS Global Health Initiative
METRONOMICS Global Health Initiative
LDMMTD
Control Vinblastine Etoposide
-20%
N.S
-33%
-39%
MatrigelTM assay – 8h incubation MatrigelTM assay – 8h incubation
LDM and MTD chemotherapy differentially impact on the angiogenic potential of endothelial cells LDM and MTD chemotherapy differentially impact
on the angiogenic potential of endothelial cells
Long-term effects of chemotherapy on vascular endothelial cells
Long-term effects of chemotherapy on vascular endothelial cells
METRONOMICS Global Health Initiative
*
**
***
*
*
**
**
*
*
*
*
Vinblastine Etoposide Paclitaxel
Growth inhibition assay – 72h drug incubation Growth inhibition assay – 72h drug incubation
LDM and MTD chemotherapy differentially impact on the chemosensitivity of endothelial cells
LDM and MTD chemotherapy differentially impact on the chemosensitivity of endothelial cells
*** ***
***
**
**
**
*
* *
*
*
* Vinblastine
(5 nM)
Etoposide (10 μM)
Paclitaxel (10 nM)
MatrigelTM assay – 8h drug incubation MatrigelTM assay – 8h drug incubation
Long-term effects of chemotherapy on vascular endothelial cells
Long-term effects of chemotherapy on vascular endothelial cells
Pasquier et al., Angiogenesis 2013
Adapted from André et al., Nat Rev Clin Oncol 2014 Doxorubicin
Doxorubicin
Vincristine Vincristine
Cyclophosphamid e Temozolomide Cyclophosphamid e Temozolomide Methotrexate Methotrexate
Gemcitabine Gemcitabine
MTAs MTAs
Cyclophosphamid e
Cyclophosphamid eGemcitabine
Gemcitabine Etoposide Etoposide
Cyclophosphamid e
Cyclophosphamid e
Doxorubicin Doxorubicin Topotecan Topotecan Gemcitabine Gemcitabine
DRUG REPOSITIONING
DRUG REPOSITIONING
Adapted from André et al., Lancet Oncol 2013
Nature Reviews Clinical Oncology 2015
June 2008, 358 (24): 2649-51
9 weeks of age
After 4 weeks of corticosteroids
10 weeks of age
After 1 week of propranolol
9 months of age
After 7 months of propranolol
METRONOMICS Global Health Initiative
June 2008, 358 (24): 2649-51
Could β-blockers be
used in cancer treatment
?
Could β-blockers be
used in cancer treatment HYPOTHESIS?
β-blockers may be able to increase the efficacy of chemotherapy through direct effects on cancer
cells or via anti-angiogenic mechanisms
METRONOMICS Global Health Initiative
Potentiation of the anti-angiogenic effects of chemotherapy by
propranolol
Potentiation of the anti-angiogenic effects of chemotherapy by
propranolol
MatrigelTM assay – 8h drug incubation MatrigelTM assay – 8h drug incubation
METRONOMICS Global Health Initiative
No propranolol10 µM propranolol
10 nM paclitaxel 50 nM paclitaxel
-44%
N.S
-71%
-76% -92%
No paclitaxel
Oncotarget, 2011 British J Cancer, 2013
Vehicle – Day 4
VCR – Day 4
VCR – Day 7
**
**
***
***
* *
**
*
Vincristine alone + Propranolol + Carvedilol + Nebivolol
METRONOMICS Global Health Initiative
Spheroid volume (mm3 )
Time (h)
*** ** ***
*
***
***
***
***
Tumour spheroid model
Control
Propranolol
Vinblastine
Combination
-59%
-19%
-20%
EBioMedicine, in press
METRONOMICS Global Health Initiative
EBioMedicine, in press
Diagnosis 3 months 12 months
Diagnosis 8 months
New treatment protocol: propranolol (40 mg; BID) in combination with metronomic vinblastine (6 mg/m2; weekly) and methotrexate (35 mg/m2; weekly)
New treatment protocol: propranolol (40 mg; BID) in combination with metronomic vinblastine (6 mg/m2; weekly) and methotrexate (35 mg/m2; weekly)
100 % response based on RECIST criteria
11+ months median PFS 16+ months median OS
100 % response based on RECIST criteria
11+ months median PFS 16+ months median OS
2 clinical trials starting in 2016, using propranolol in combination with metronomic chemotherapy
2 clinical trials starting in 2016, using propranolol in combination with metronomic chemotherapy
The very concept of “repeated administration of low‐dose chemotherapy over a long period of time” covers numerous possibilities:
• What is a small dose?
•What is a repeated administration?
• What is a long period of time?
Computational oncology &
metronomics
Computational oncology &
metronomics
Computational oncology &
metronomics
Computational oncology &
metronomics
Examples of oral vinorelbine protocols used in the clinic
Different PK profile
Similar toxicity profile
Higher efficacy
Briasoulis et al. Model-driven
PK
Tox
Eff
Mathematical modeling suggests that a D1-D2-D4 protocol at 60-30-60mg would be more efficient than the D1-D3-D5 protocol at 50-50-50mg recommended by Briasoulis et al. (BMC Cancer 2013)
Computational oncology &
metronomics
Computational oncology &
metronomics
TAKE HOME MESSAGES TAKE HOME MESSAGES
Metronomic chemotherapy is a form of multi-targeted therapy
Metronomic chemotherapy is a form of multi-targeted therapy
Mathematical modeling can help optimize metronomic chemotherapy protocols
Mathematical modeling can help optimize metronomic chemotherapy protocols
Every drug has its own unique properties and must be rationally selected
Every drug has its own unique properties and must be rationally selected
Drug repositioning provides a unique opportunity to further increase the efficacy of metronomic chemotherapy
Drug repositioning provides a unique opportunity to further increase the efficacy of metronomic chemotherapy
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Sydney Pr Maria Kavallaris Janine Street
Charlotte Pouchy Maria-Pia Tuset Snega Sinnappan Jayne Murray
Dr Karen MacKenzie
Marseille Pr Diane Braguer Dr Nicolas André Dr Manon Carré Dr Joseph Ciccolini Seimia Chebbi
Arnaud Mansour
Mumbai
Dr Shripad Banavali
METRONOMICS Global Health Initiative
Mathematical modeling can help identify an optimal solution among numerous combinations
Once built and validated, the model can generate an infinity of simulations until a solution to a given problem is found
This strategy is based upon the use of any data made available which are likely to help build a mathematical model and identify its parameters
+
Computational oncology &
metronomics
Computational oncology &
metronomics
• Doses: 1, 2, 3.3, 5, 10, 30 mg/kg…
• Schedule: daily, 1-day on / 2-days off, 3-weeks on / 1-week off …
• Duration: 3 weeks, 4 weeks, continuous…
Metronomic gemcitabine Metronomic gemcitabine
PK modeling
Effects on:
cancer cells
endothelial cells Tumour growth (Gompertz)
Anti-angiogenic effect
Mathematical modeling Mathematical modeling
Can metronomic scheduling improve the efficacy of gemcitabine against resistant
neuroblastoma ?
GMZR
100 mg/kg i.p.
QW for 4 weeks
VS.
METROGEM
1 mg/kg or 0.5 mg/kg Continuous for 4 weeks
Standard Model-driven
MetroGEM study MetroGEM study
• Drug Monitoring (LC-MS/MS)
While MTDGem led to a Cmax of 80 µg/ml, 0.1 µg/ml steady state concentrations were observed with MetroGem
MTDGem MetroGem1 MetroGem1
GEM dFdU
MetroGEM study MetroGEM study
MTDGem
Vascular Density-1(AngioSense 780)
MetroGem led to reduced vascular density
Control 100 mg/kg MetroGem1 MetroGem0.5
MetroGEM study MetroGEM study
MTD showed little efficacy, while MetroGem induced a significant reduction in tumour growth (p<0.05 ANOVA). Disease stabilization was maintained at least 40 days after stopping treatment.
MetroGEM study MetroGEM study
0,00E+00 1,00E+02 2,00E+02 3,00E+02 4,00E+02 5,00E+02 6,00E+02 7,00E+02 8,00E+02
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Tumor growth (106 p/sec)
MTDGem (100 mg/kg)
MetroGEM (0.5 mg/kg) MetroGEM (0.5 mg/kg)