• Non ci sono risultati.

Blame is in the Eye of the Beholder: Beyond an ethics of hubris and shame in the time of COVID-19

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Condividi "Blame is in the Eye of the Beholder: Beyond an ethics of hubris and shame in the time of COVID-19"

Copied!
4
0
0

Testo completo

(1)

The Harvard Kennedy School Misinformation Review1

May 2020, Volume 1, Special Issue on COVID-19 and Misinformation Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)

Reprints and permissions: misinforeview@hks.harvard.edu DOI: https://doi.org/10.37016/mr-2020-022

Website: misinforeview.hks.harvard.edu

Commentary

Blame is in the Eye of the Beholder: Beyond an ethics of hubris and shame in the time of COVID-19

Author: Annalisa Pelizza

Affiliation: University of Bologna and University of Twente

How to cite: Pelizza, Annalisa (2020). Blame Is in the Eye of the Beholder: Beyond an ethics of hubris and shame in the time of COVID-19, The Harvard Kennedy School (HKS) Misinformation Review, Volume 3, Special Issue on COVID-19 and

Misinformation

Received: March 27th, 2020; Accepted: May 27th, 2020; Published: May 28th, 2020

As misinformation and disinformation spread more rapidly and widely than ever before, individuals have been encouraged to be critical consumers of all received information. At the heart of this point of contention is the question of where responsibility and fault should lie. This framing and dynamic have taken a new form during the COVID-19 pandemic: a risk that the narrative of victim blaming may overcome narratives of care and responsibility, at all levels and across national contexts. This begs the question of which ethical assumptions individuals and institutions will build upon in navigating the crisis and developing policies and best practices for everyday life, as well as for what will come next?

Hubristic reactions to the COVID-19 pandemic

Invoking nature’s wrath is an old trope, going back to ancient Greek myths and moral texts where hubris referred to transgressions of the boundaries between gods and humans. The myths of Icarus, Cassiopeia, Tantalus, and Arachne are just a few examples of humans who challenged the gods, pushed their own natural limits, and were punished for their arrogance. It is this meaning of hubris that was inherited by modernity through myths like Faust.

But in ancient Greece there was a second meaning of hubris developed in civil speeches and tractates, something along the lines of what we today might call “victim shaming.” In Against Midias, Demosthenes uses the term hubris to indicate both verbal and physical assault.2 In the Rhetoric, Aristotle refers to hubris as the practice of shaming the victim: “hubris consists in acts and words that cause shame to the victim, not in order to obtain advantage for oneself besides the

1 A publication of the Shorenstein Center on Media, Politics and Public Policy at Harvard University's John F.

Kennedy School of Government.

2http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus%3Atext%3A1999.01.0074%3Aspeech%3D21%3Asection

%3D1

(2)

Pelizza 2

act itself, but simply for the pleasure of it” (Rhetoric 1378b, Author’s translation).3 As in ancient moral systems shame is a form of public dishonor, hubris entails the relationship of public devaluation so that the counterpart can claim their status or be raised higher in comparison.

Rather than transcendental arrogance against the gods, it is this earthly form of hubris, shaming the victim, that characterizes many reactions to the COVID-19 pandemic, even in significantly distinct national and trans-national contexts. And it is with this understanding that I will analyze and contextualize the COVID-19 pandemic.

The politics of shaming the victim

Under the strict locked-down orders of Italy, individuals walking or jogging alone in deserted areas are regularly shamed as Manzonian infectors.4 Videos of Italian mayors condemning citizens who have ventured out of their homes,5 even when respecting physical distancing guidelines, have gone viral and been featured on broadcasts all around the world with little public consideration for whether such stigmatization or enforcement is proportionate or effective. In similar cases, a hubris mechanism is in place: the victim – the locked-in citizen – is to be shamed.

In the Netherlands, the politics of shaming the victim takes subtler but no less insidious forms, where individuals less likely to survive the contagion are encouraged to be role models for the rest of the population and give up their place in intensive care units to those with higher odds of surviving COVID-19.6 In such framings, the weight of important public policy decisions and strategies of how best to manage the pandemic are shifted on to the individual, absolving those in power and the institutions they lead.

Such a rhetorical tactic requires unpacking and some contextualization. The objective problem many countries are now facing is the insufficient ratio of ventilators to the number of individuals infected and in need of ventilation (ventilators/patients < 1). As in algebraic division, the problem can be described as having too low a dividend (i.e., too few ventilators) or too high a divisor (i.e., too many patients in need of ventilators). Choosing to allocate the cause of the problem either to the dividend or to the divisor is not a neutral choice, it is a political framing with ethical implications.

Indeed, framing the insufficient ratio as a problem of too few ventilators puts responsibility on healthcare policy makers and suggests a concrete policy measure: greater investment in acquiring more machines and improving the healthcare system. On the other hand, framing the insufficient ratio as a problem of too many patients shifts responsibility on to individual citizens and suggests individual solutions; as in the case described earlier from the Netherlands, older and immune- compromised patients should give up ventilators to younger, “healthier” patients—shaming those who refuse to conform to this standard.

3http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus%3Atext%3A1999.01.0060%3Abekker+page%3D1378b#no te-link3

4 https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/35155

5 https://edition.cnn.com/2020/03/23/world/italian-mayors-scolding-residents-coronavirus-lockdown-trnd/index.html

6 https://www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2020/03/20/als-je-overlevingskans-klein-is-beland-je-in-nederland-niet-op-de-intensive- care-a3994450

(3)

Blame is in the Eye of the Beholder: Beyond an ethics of hubris and shame in the time of COVID-19 3

Hubris in COVID-19-informed international relations

This kind of hubris is not limited to national governments and its citizenry but is extended to international relations, as well. On March 25, former president of the European Central Bank Mario Draghi specified that “the loss of income is not the fault of any of those who suffer from it.”7 A claim that certainly needed to be restated, particularly with respect to negotiations taking place between members of the European Council.8 On the one hand, nine European countries severely affected by the virus had asked for immediate shared financial tools, backed by European institutions, to mitigate COVID-19 disruptions, even recognizing how such tools might further bind together these states and potentially relinquish some of their financial sovereignty.9 On the other hand, some ministers of finance had called for an investigation into past fiscal management of the countries seeking support from the European Union and refused the criteria for loans to be relaxed.10 Financially conservative countries indeed argue that the current inability to cope with the pandemic is a consequence of past financial dysfunctions. Whatever the outcome of the debate for the future of Europe, it is evident that it revolves around the hubristic behavior that pushes the victim to face not only the violence of the pandemic, but also the violence of shame.

Against currently resurgent feelings of nationalism, these examples show that hubris is not a national trait, but an attitude in the face of disasters. Confronting such catastrophe, a hubristic response can see humans either invoke gods’ wrath or identify the root cause in other humans (i.e., the plague is a god’s response to human arrogance vs. the resulting hardship of a plague is based on specific individual failures). This latter form of hubris is an attitude of the powerful for power’s sake. And, where the former understanding of hubris does not leave much room to maneuver, as it is rooted in supernatural deeds beyond human control, more possibilities of action can be devised within this latter form of hubris. This shame indeed requires two things: a distinction between

“Us” and “Them” as well as framing the situation as a zero-sum game.

Two recommendations for scholars, policy makers, and journalists

Regarding the distinction, we might want to ask how “them” became “Them” and “us” became

“Us,” that is, which criteria are mobilized to create and reproduce these distinctions. How are well worn narratives of the unruly citizen and other bigoted stereotypes resurrected to find fault and validate austerity and other such grave decisions? What are the alternative narratives that might instead lead to policies of care and mutual aid?

As for the zero-sum game, it corresponds to Aristotle’s definition of hubris as a relationship in which a rise in status for the perpetrator is only obtained by publicly shaming the victim. By

7 https://www.ft.com/content/c6d2de3a-6ec5-11ea-89df-41bea055720b

8 https://www.faz.net/aktuell/politik/inland/oekonomische-pandemie-folgen-eu-einigt-sich-auf-weiteres-vorgehen- in-corona-krise-16698750.html ; https://www.lemonde.fr/economie/article/2020/03/27/coronavirus-au-conseil- europeen-les-vingt-sept-ebauchent-la-suite_6034628_3234.html ;

https://www.repubblica.it/economia/2020/03/26/news/conte_alla_ue_se_aiuti_gli_saranno_come_in_passato_faccia mo_da_soli_-252410637/?ref=RHPPTP-BH-I252410466-C12-P8-S1.8-T1 ; https://elpais.com/economia/2020-03- 26/el-plan-de-reactivacion-enfrenta-a-la-ue-en-su-mayor-crisis-sanitaria.html

9 http://www.governo.it/it/articolo/coronavirus-la-lettera-al-presidente-del-consiglio-europeo-charles-michel/14378

10 https://www.volkskrant.nl/nieuws-achtergrond/hoekstra-stribbelt-tegen-bij-steunpakket-eu-een-nederlandse- middelvinger-naar-het-zuiden~b94cd15b/

(4)

Pelizza 4

shaming Italian runners, the credibility of those mayors is strengthened. By shaming the elderly, the efficiency of the Dutch healthcare system is reaffirmed. By shaming China or Spain, the superiority of the United States and Northern Europe is proven. Or, at least, so some believe. We should instead question this zero-sum game on which hubris and its ethics of shame are based.

As scholars, policy makers, and journalists, in these gloomy days we need an ethics beyond shame, an ethics that is able a) to account for how old tropes are resurrected and utilized to push for current goals, and make those tropes known to the public; b) to avoid building policies on assumptions of zero-sum games. Such an ethics is urgent and necessary to rebut the re-emerging narratives around biological and financial infectors. A better future cannot be built on the ruins of a social fabric where officers despise their citizens and the young sacrifice the elderly.

Riferimenti

Documenti correlati

In general the computation of the connection coefficients seems to be a difficult task for at least two reasons: first, the most known (and used) wavelets are not functionally

agricultural region models population energy area Topic 05 data analysis (indexes, indicators, maps).. farmers basin under over potential indicators Topic 06 society

A mathematical model of an innovative solid oxide fuel cell (IDEAL-Cell), made of the combining of the cathodic compartment of a conventional anionic-conducting SOFC with

One can easily verify that every element of ~ is a right tail of 5 preordered withrespect to relation defined 1n (j).. A CHARACTERIZATION DF V-PRIME ANO 5TRONGLY V-PRIME ELHlrtHS OF

Eine solche Kette alles Seins wird im Dickicht der Silvae weder gesucht noch gefunden, die einzelnen Entdeckungen werden eben nicht sofort in einen klar gegliederten Kosmos

The survey described in part I.A provides the dependent variables used in our analyses. The independent variables came from matching a variety of data sources to these surveys’..

Sakai and myself [33], [34] determined (1) all the biharmonic hypersurfaces in irreducible symmetric spaces of compact type which are regular orbits of commutative Hermann actions

Wojtaszczyk, Banach Spaces for Analysts, Cambridge University Press,