UNIVERSITÀ DEGLI STUDI DI PADOVA Dipartimento di Scienze Economiche “Marco Fanno”
FROM CONTROLLED TO LOOSE CO-PRODUCTION:
BENEFITS DISTRIBUTION BETWEEN FIRMS AND CONSUMERS
ELEONORA DI MARIA University of Padova
MARCO PAIOLA University of Padova
June 2011
“MARCO FANNO” WORKING PAPER N.135
! "!
!"#$%&#'("#))*+%,#%-##.*%&#/0"#+12(3#'4%5*'*63(.%73.("381(3#'%5*(9**'%
!3"$.%:'+%&#'.1$*".%
!"#$%$&'()*(+'&*'(
#$%&'()%*+!,-!./0,&/!1!2'3*4!,-!56,$,7%6)!/$0!8/$/9'7'$*!
:%/!0';!</$*,!=>?!@A"=@!./0,&/?!B*/;+!
C';4!D!@E!FGE!>=HGFIE!J!K/L4!D@E!FGE>=HG=""!
57/%;M!';',$,(/40%7/(%/NO$%304%*!
% +'&,$(-'*$"'(
#$%&'()%*+!,-!./0,&/!1!2'3*4!,-!56,$,7%6)!/$0!8/$/9'7'$*!
:%/!0';!</$*,!=>?!@A"=@!./0,&/?!B*/;+!
C';4!D!@E!FGE!>=HGFAG!1!K/L4!D@E!FGE>=HG=""!
57/%;M!7/(6,43/%,;/NO$%304%*(
%
! =!
!"#$%&#'("#))*+%,#%-##.*%&#/0"#+12(3#'4%5*'*63(.%73.("381(3#'%5*(9**'%
!3"$.%:'+%&#'.1$*".%
%
%
:8.(";2(%
P%*'(/*O('! ,$! %$$,&/*%,$! /$0! ('6'$*! 7/(Q'*%$9! 6,$*(%RO*%,$)! )*('))'0! *S'!
%$&,;&'7'$*!,-!6,$)O7'()!%$!*S'!6,13(,0O6*%,$!,-!&/;O'?!R+!'73S/)%T%$9!'%*S'(!*S'!
(,;'!,-!/!)%$9;'!6,$)O7'(!,(!*S'!6,77O$%*+!%$!)O6S!3(,6'))4!K'U!)*O0%')!6,O3;'0!
*S'! *U,! %$*'((';/*'0! 0%7'$)%,$)! /$0! /$/;+T'0! *S'%(! %73/6*)! ,$! 6O)*,7'()V!
R'S/&%,(!/$0!-%(7!7/(Q'*%$9!)*(/*'9%')?!)3'6%-%6/;;+!%$!*'(7)!,-!R'$'-%*)!/6S%'&'04!
CS'!3/3'(!/%7)!/*!-%;;%$9!*S%)!*S',('*%6/;!9/3!R+!0%)*%$9O%)S%$9!R'*U''$!%$0%&%0O/;!
/$0! ),6%/;! 6,13(,0O6*%,$?! US'('! 0%--'('$*! ;'&';)! ,-! 6,$)O7'(! '$9/9'7'$*! 6/$! R'!
%0'$*%-%'0!U%*S!0%&'()'!&/;O'!)S/(%$9!,O*6,7')4!!W'!/(9O'!*S/*!$,*!/;;!6O)*,7'()!
/('! %$*'(')*'0! %$! R'%$9! %$&,;&'0! %$! *S'! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! 6,$6'($%$9! /;;! *S'%(!
6,$)O73*%,$!/6*%&%*%')4!2'3'$0%$9!,$!*S'%(!6,77%*7'$*!*,!3/(*%6%3/*'!X6'$*(/;%*+!
,-! *S'! 6,$)O73*%,$! /6*%&%*+! -,(! *S'! 6O)*,7'(Y! /$0! *S'! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! $/*O('!
X%$0%&%0O/;! &)4! ),6%/;Y! -,O(! /;*'($/*%&'! ,3*%,$)! ,-! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! '7'(9'?! U%*S!
0%)*%$6*%&'!7/$/9'(%/;!-'/*O(')4!!
!
<*=9#"+.M! 6,13(,0O6*%,$?! 6,$)O7'(! R'S/&%,(?! 6,77O$%*+?! &/;O'! )S/(%$9?!
%$$,&/*%,$%
! @!
%
>'("#+12(3#'%
Z'6'$*!;%*'(/*O('!,$!%$$,&/*%,$!/$0!7/(Q'*%$9!(')'/(6S!O$0'(;%$')!*S'!%$6('/)%$9!
%73,(*/$6'!,-!6,$)O7'()V!%$&,;&'7'$*!%$!*S'!6,13(,0O6*%,$!,-!&/;O'!X%4'4![,&/!/$0!
2/;;%?! =FFE\! :/(9,?! =FF>\! .(/S/;/0?! =FFG\! .(/S/;/0! /$0! Z/7/)U/7+?! =FF@\!
Z/7]('T?! "EEE\! &,$! ^%33';?! =FFA\! W%Q)*(,7?! "EEI\! _U%6Q! '*! /;4?! =FF>Y4! B*! )S,U)!
*S/*!&/;O'!6,13(,0O6*%,$!%)!/!6,73;'L!6,$)*(O6*!*S/*!'$6,73/))')!0%--'('$*!*+3')!
,-! 6,;;/R,(/*%,$! /$0! %$*'(/6*%,$! %$! *S'! -%$/;! ,O*6,7'! 3(,0O6*%,$4! `;*S,O9S! *S'!
';'7'$*)!,-!*S%)!6,73;'L%*+!S/&'!R''$!/00('))'0!R+!0%--'('$*!(')'/(6S!)*('/7)!1!
)O6S! /)! 6,;;/R,(/*%&'! %$$,&/*%,$?! <'(&%6'12,7%$/$*! ;,9%6?! /$0! 6,77O$%*+!
7/(Q'*%$9! 1! %*! %)! ,O(! ,3%$%,$! *S/*! *S%)! 6,73;'L%*+! S/)! +'*! *,! R'! 6,73;'*';+!
('3(')'$*'04!!
B$!3/(*%6O;/(?!*S'!(')'/(6S!aO')*%,$)!,-!*S%)!3/3'(!/('!/)!-,;;,U)M!US%6S!/('!*S'!
&/(%/R;')! *S/*! /--'6*! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! 3(,6'))')! R'*U''$! *S'! -%(7! /$0! 6,$)O7'()b!
^,U!*S')'!&/(%/R;')!6/$!%73/6*!,$!*S'!7'6S/$%)7)!,-!0%)*(%RO*%,$!6,$6'($%$9!*S'!
R'$'-%*)!,-!6,13(,0O6*%,$b!!
B$!*S%)!3/3'(!U'!*(+!*,!/$)U'(!*S,)'!aO')*%,$)!R+!/0&/$6%$9!*S'!6,73('S'$)%,$!
,-!6,13(,0O6*%,$!3(,6'))')!6,73;'L%*+?!*/Q%$9!%$*,!6,$)%0'(/*%,$!0%--'('$*!/)3'6*)?!
R,*S! 7/*'(%/;! /$0! %77/*'(%/;?! *S/*! 6/$! 3;/+! /! 7/c,(! (,;'! %$! ('/;! 6,13(,0O6*%,$!
3(,6'))')4!P%*'(/*O('!('9/(0%$9!6,13(,0O6*%,$!-,6O)')!'%*S'(!,$!*S'!(,;'!,-!/!)%$9;'!
6,$)O7'(! X%4'4! d%;9(/7! '*4! /;4! =FF>Y! ,(! ,-! *S'! 6,77O$%*+! X%4'4! K(/$Q'! /$0! <S/S?!
=FF@Y! %$! )O6S! 3(,6'))4! C,! ,O(! Q$,U;'09'?! ;%**;'! '--,(*)! S/&'! R''$! O$0'(*/Q'$! %$!
,(0'(! *,! 6,O3;'! *S'! *U,! %$*'((';/*'0! 0%7'$)%,$)! /$0! /$/;+T'! *S'%(! %73/6*)! ,$!
! G!
6O)*,7'()V! R'S/&%,()! /$0! -%(7)V! 7/(Q'*%$9! )*(/*'9%')?! )3'6%-%6/;;+! %$! *'(7)! ,-!
R'$'-%*)!/6S%'&'0!/$0!&/;O'!6/3*O('04!!
CS'! 3/3'(! /00('))')! *S%)! *S',('*%6/;! 9/3! /)! -,;;,U)4! B*! 0%)*%$9O%)S')! R'*U''$!
%$0%&%0O/;! /$0! ),6%/;! 6,13(,0O6*%,$?! '73S/)%T%$9! 0%--'('$6')! /$0! 6,$)'aO'$6')4!
8,(',&'(?!%*!/(9O')!*S/*!$,*!/;;!6O)*,7'()!/('!'aO/;;+!%$*'(')*'0!%$!R'%$9!%$&,;&'0!
%$!6,13(,0O6*%,$!/6*%&%*%')!6,$6'($%$9!/;;!*S'%(!6,$)O73*%,$!/6*%&%*%')4!CS'('-,('?!
*S'! ;'&';! ,-! 6,$)O7'(V)! '$9/9'7'$*! X[';)%! /$0! e;),$?! "E>>Y! /$0?! 6,$)'aO'$*;+?!
6,$)O7'(V)! 6,77%*7'$*! *,! 3/(*%6%3/*'! %$! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! %$-;O'$6'! *S'! U/+! 6,1 3(,0O6*%,$!S/33'$)4!^'$6'?!0%&'()'!&/;O'1)S/(%$9!,O*6,7')!'7'(9'4!!
CS%)! 6%(6O7)*/$6'! %)! -O(*S'(7,('! '&%0'$6'0! R+! *S'! -/6*! *S/*! 3'(),$/;!
%$&,;&'7'$*! 6/$! S'/&%;+! )S/3'! *S'! 3'(6'3*%,$! ,-! *S'! '--,(*)! /$0! *S'! &/;O'! ,-! *S'!
U,(Q!0,$'!%$!6,13(,0O6*%,$!3(,6'))')?!/)!%*!S/)!;,$9!R''$!('6,9$%T'0!R+!(')'/(6S!
,$! 6,$)O7'(! 3/(*%6%3/*%,$! %$! )'(&%6'! '$6,O$*'()! Xd%*$'(! '*! /;4?! "EEH\! f';;'+?!
2,$$';;+! /$0! <Q%$$'(?! "EEFY! /$0! /)! *')*%-%'0! R+! ('6'$*! (')'/(6S! ,$! )'(&%6'!
3(,0O6*%&%*+!Xg,S$)*,$!/$0!g,$')?!=FF@Y4!B77/*'(%/;!/)3'6*!)O6S!/)!%0'$*%-%6/*%,$?!
),6%/;! ('6,9$%*%,$! /$0! ),! ,$! 6/$! %$! -/6*! &/(+! *S'! U%;;%$9$'))! ,-! /! 6,$)O7'(! *,!
3/(*%6%3/*'! %$! *S'! 3(,6'))')?! /$0! *S'! %73,(*/$6'! ,-! /$! '6,$,7%6! ('U/(0! -,(! %*?!
9%&%$9! 6,73/$%')! /! 9('/*! ,33,(*O$%*+! *,! /33(,3(%/*'! *S'! U,(Q! &/;O'! *S/*!
,*S'(U%)'!U,O;0!S/&'!*,!R'!3/%04!CS'!)*/*'!,-!-/%($'))!,-!/0&/$*/9')!0%)*(%RO*%,$!
R'*U''$!)O33;%'(!/$0!6,$)O7'(!%)!*S'('-,('!6,$0%*%,$'0!R+!*S,)'!-/6*,()4!
2'3'$0%$9! ,$! *S'%(! 6,77%*7'$*! *,! 3/(*%6%3/*'! X6'$*(/;%*+! ,-! *S'! 6,$)O73*%,$!
/6*%&%*+! -,(! *S'! 6O)*,7'(Y! /$0! *S'! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! $/*O('! X%$0%&%0O/;! &)4! ),6%/;Y! /!
7/*(%L! %)! 3(,3,)'0! US'('! -,O(! /;*'($/*%&'! ,3*%,$)! ,-! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! '7'(9'4! CS'!
3/3'(! 3(,6''0)! /)! -,;;,U)4! CS'! *S',('*%6/;! R/6Q9(,O$0! %)! 0')6(%R'0! %$! )'6*%,$! =?!
! A!
US'('! *S'! -,6O)! %)! ,$! *S'! (';/*%,$)S%3! R'*U''$! ),6%/;%T/*%,$! 3(,6'))')! /$0! 6,1 3(,0O6*%,$?! /$0! %$! )'6*%,$! @?! 0'&,*'0! *,! 'L3;,('! S,U! 0%--'('$*! 6O)*,7'()V! ;'&';)!
/$0!Q%$0)!,-!'$9/9'7'$*!/--'6*!6,13(,0O6*%,$4!<'6*%,$!G!0')6(%R')!,O(!/33(,/6S!*,!
6,13(,0O6*%,$! 3(,6'))')! /$/;+)%)4! CS'! /(*%6;'! -%$/;;+! 0%)6O))')! %*)! (')'/(6S!
6,$*(%RO*%,$)!/$0!7/$/9'(%/;!%73;%6/*%,$)?!/)!U';;!/)!3(,&%0')!),7'!)O99')*%,$)!
-,(!-O(*S'(!(')'/(6S4!
!
&#/?"#+12(3#'%;'+%.#23;)3@;(3#'4%3'+3A3+1;)%;'+%.#23;)%)*A*)%#6%;';)=.3.%%
:/;O'! 6,16('/*%,$! S/)! R''$! U%0';+! 'L3;,('0! %$! *S'! ;%*'(/*O('! -(,7! 7/$+!
3'()3'6*%&')4! B$! *S'%(! ('6'$*! /(*%6;'! [,&/! /$0! 2/;;%! X=FFEY! S/&'! 3(,3,)'0! /$!
'L*'$0'0!('&%'U!,-!S,U!6,$)O7'()!/('!%$&,;&'0!%$!3(,0O6*%,$?!R+!S%9S;%9S*%$9!*S'!
0%--'('$*!(,;')!/$0!/%7)!,-!6O)*,7'()!/$0!-%(7)!%$!)O6S!3(,6'))4![,13(,0O6*%,$!%)!/!
aO%*'!6,73;'L!3S'$,7'$,$!*S/*!6/$!*/Q'!3;/6'!R'-,('!*S'!3(,0O6*"!;/O$6S!,$!*S'!
7/(Q'*! X%$$,&/*%,$! -(/7'U,(QY! /)! U';;! /)! /! -O$0/7'$*/;! )*'3! ,-! *S'! 3(,0O6*%,$!
3(,6'))! X)'(&%6'! 3(,&%)%,$Y! /$0! ,-! *S'! &/;O'! 6('/*%,$! %$! *S'! 7/(Q'*! X%4'4! R(/$0!
7/$/9'7'$*Y4!!
CS'! *S',('*%6/;! 6,$*(%RO*%,$)! *S/*! /$/;+T'! S,U! 6,$)O7'()! 3/(*%6%3/*'! %$!
3(,0O6*%,$! /6*%&%*%')! J! R,*S! %$! 7/*'(%/;! /$0! %77/*'(%/;! *'(7)! J! )*('))! '%*S'(! *S'!
%$0%&%0O/;!,(!*S'!6,77O$%*+!0%7'$)%,$!,-!*S%)!3(,6'))4!!
P%*'(/*O('! )*('/7! ,$! 6,;;/R,(/*%&'! %$$,&/*%,$! S/)! '73S/)%T'0! *S'! 3(%7/(+!
6,$*(%RO*%,$! ,-! 'L3'(*! 6O)*,7'()! /$0! ;'/0! O)'()! %$! ,--'(%$9! *S'%(! Q$,U;'09'! -,(!
3(,0O6*! 0'&';,37'$*! X&,$! ^%33';?! "E>I?! =FFAY4! `)! U'! U%;;! )''! ;/*'(! ,$?! )'&'(/;!
('/),$)!'L3;/%$!US+!6O)*,7'()!1!,(!R'**'(!O)'()!J!3(,&%0'!$'U!%0'/)?!6,$6'3*)!/$0!
7'/$%$9)! *,! *S'! -%(7?! /$0! 6,$*(%RO*%$9! %$! )S/3%$9! $'U! 3(,0O6*)! ,(! %73(,&%$9!
! I!
'L%)*%$9! ,$')4! CS,)'! 6,$*(%RO*%,$)! S/&'! )*(,$9;+! %$-;O'$6'0! )*O0%')! ,$! 6,1 3(,0O6*%,$! %0'$*%-+%$9! *S'! %77/*'(%/;! U,(Q! ,-! 6O)*,7'()hO)'()! %$! *S'! -%(7!
%$$,&/*%,$!3(,6'))?!US%6S!R'6,7')!7,('!,3'$!/$0!%$*'(/6*%&'4!!
e$!*S'!,$'!S/$0?!),7'!)*O0%')!S/&'!0'3%6*'0!*S'!3(,-%;'!,-!;'/0!O)'()!X%4'4!eT'(?!
=FFE\! <6S('%'(! /$0! .(i9;?! =FF>Y! *,! 3O*! %$! '&%0'$6'! *S'! )3'6%/;! 6S/(/6*'(%)*%6)! ,-!
*S,)'!6O)*,7'()!-,(!*S'!)O66'))!,-!*S'!6,13(,0O6*%,$!3(,6'))4!d+!'L3;,%*%$9!*S'%(!
%$*'$)'!3(,0O6*!'L3'(%'$6'!/$0!3'(),$/;!/R%;%*+?!;'/0!O)'()!0'&';,3!S%9S!&/;O/R;'!
Q$,U;'09'! /R,O*! $'U! 3(,0O6*! -'/*O(')?! 6,73;'*';+! $'U! 3(,0O6*)! /$0! 7/(Q'*!
*('$0)4!<O6S!)3'6%/;!O)'()!)S,U!%$$,&/*%&'!R'S/&%,()!*S/*!;'/0!*,!S%9S!(/*')!,-!$'U!
3(,0O6*!%0'/)!/)!U';;!/)!3%,$''(!3O(6S/)%$9!3(,6'))4!K%(7)!*S/*!U/$*!*,!9/%$!-(,7!
*S')'! $'U! ),O(6')! ,-! Q$,U;'09'! /('! /)Q'0! *,! 0'&';,3! )3'6%-%6! )*(/*'9%')! ,-! 6,1 3(,0O6*%,$! *,! %$&,;&'! *S,)'! %$0%&%0O/;)! %$*,! *S'%(! %$*'($/;! 3(,6'))')! ,-! $'U!
3(,0O6*!0'&';,37'$*!Xj.2Y!/$0!7/(Q'*%$9!/6*%&%*%')!X2/S;/$0'(!/$0!8/9$O)),$?!
=FF>\!^/((%)!/$0!e9R,$$/?!=FF@Y4!!!
e$!*S'!,*S'(!S/$0?!,*S'(!)6S,;/()!-,6O)'0!,$!*S'!),6%/;!)6/;'!,-!*S'!6,;;/R,(/*%&'!
%$$,&/*%,$?! R+! )*('))%$9! *S'! )*('$9*S! ,-! *S'! 6,77O$%*+! 7'6S/$%)7! -,(! %0'/!
3(,0O6*%,$?! Q$,U;'09'! )';'6*%,$! /$0! )S/(%$9! ,-! 7'/$%$9)! X%4'4! Ki;;'(! '*! /;4! =FFH\!
</US$'+!'*!/;4?!=FFA\!W')*?!=FFEY4!B$!*S%)!3'()3'6*%&'?!*S'!6,77O$%*+!('3(')'$*)!/!
0%--'('$*!/$0?!-,(!7/$+!)6S,;/()?!/!7,('!'--'6*%&'!-(/7'U,(Q!6,73/('0!*,!7/(Q'*!
7'6S/$%)7!XK(/$Q'!/$0!<S/S?!=FF@\!f,T%$'*)!'*!/;4!=FF>\!</US$'+!/$0!.(/$0';;%?!
=FFFY?!U%*S%$!US%6S!*,!0'&';,3!$'U!Q$,U;'09'!/R,O*!3(,0O6*)!/$0!*S'%(!O)')!0O'!
*,! *S'! 0+$/7%6)! ,-! ),6%/;%T/*%,$4! k(,O3! 6('/*%&%*+?! 7O*O/;! '$9/9'7'$*! /$0! ),6%/;!
)O33,(*?! )S/('0! 7'/$%$9)! /$0! 3(/6*%6')?! 7'7R'()V! 0+$/7%6! 'L3'(*%)'M! *S,)'!
! H!
6S/(/6*'(%)*%6)!X/7,$9!7/$+!,*S'()Y!0%)*%$9O%)S!6,77O$%*%')!/)!Q'+!3;/+'()!%$!*S'!
%$$,&/*%,$!3(,6'))4!!
CS'! /$/;+)%)! ,-! 6,;;/R,(/*%&'! %$$,&/*%,$! 6,$*(%RO*%,$)! 0,')! $,*! 6,$6;O0'! *S'!
0%)6O))%,$! ,$! 6O)*,7'()V! (,;')! %$! 6,13(,0O6*%,$?! /)! 6,;;/R,(/*%&'! %$$,&/*%,$!
0%)6,O()'!6/$!R'!%$6;O0'0!%$!*S'!U%0'(!6,$6'3*!,-!6,13(,0O6*%,$4!P%$Q'0!U%*S!*S')'!
*S',('*%6/;! %$3O*)! R/)'0! ,$! *S'! ),6%/;! /33(,/6S! *,! 6O)*,7'(V! %$&,;&'7'$*! %$!
3(,0O6*%,$!*S'('!/('!*S'!)*O0%')!,-!6,$)O7'(!*(%R')!X[,&/?!"EEH\![,&/!/$0![,&/?!
=FF=\![,&/!'*!/;4!=FFHY4!C(%R')!/('!/R;'!*,!0'&';,3!/;*'(/*%&'!,--'(%$9)!/$0!'L*'$0!
*S'! 6O)*,7'(V)! 'L3'(%'$6'M! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! 6/$! ('-'(! *,! R,*S! 3(,0O6*! -'/*O(')! /)!
U';;! /)! %$*/$9%R;'! ';'7'$*)! ,-! *S'! 6,$)O73*%,$! /6*%&%*+4! 5&'$! )*O0%')! ,$! R(/$0!
6,77O$%*%')!X%4'4!8O$%T!/$0!eVkO%$$?!=FF"\!86`;'L/$0'(!'*!/;4?!=FF=\!d/9,TT%!/$0!
2S,;/Q%/?! =FFIY! '73S/)%T'! *S'! (';'&/$6'! ,-! *S'! 6,77O$%*/(%/$! -(/7'U,(Q! -,(!
&/;O'!6('/*%,$!%$!/!)3'6%-%6!6,$*'L*!,-!6,$)O73*%,$4!8,('!3('6%)';+?!6,77O$%*%')!
)O33,(*! /$0! 7/Q'! 3,))%R;'! *S'! )'$)'7/Q%$9! 3(,6'))?! US%6S! %)! *S'! ('/;! &/;O'!
6O)*,7'()! /('! %$*'(')*'0! %$4! CS'! Q'+! 3,%$*! %)! *S/*! *S'! ),6%/;! 0%7'$)%,$! ,-!
6,$)O73*%,$!X%4'4!3/(*%6%3/*%,$Y!%)!0,7%$/$*!U%*S!(')3'6*!*,!*S'!%$0%&%0O/;!)6/;'!%$!
6,13(,0O6*%,$4!C(%R')!/)!U';;!/)!R(/$0!6,77O$%*%')!R'6,7'!*S'!3(%7/(+!('-'('$6'!
-,(! 6O)*,7'()! X7'7R'()Y! %$! *S'! 6,$)O73*%,$! 3(,6'))?! '&'$! %$! ,33,)%*%,$! *,! *S'!
-%(74!!
CS'! %$0%&%0O/;! ;'&';! ,-! /$/;+)%)! %$! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! %)! )*('))'0! %$! *S'! )'(&%6'1 0,7%$/$*!;,9%6!,-!7/(Q'*%$9!X:/(9,!/$0!PO)6S?!=FFG/\!PO)S!/$0!:/(9,?!=FFIY4!B$!
*S'!('6'$*!'&,;O*%,$!,-!*S,)'!)*O0%')?!/;,$9)%0'!-%(7)?!/;),!6,$)O7'()!3;/+!*S'!(,;'!
,-! ('),O(6'! %$*'9(/*,()\! *S'! R,*S! ('3(')'$*! -O$0/7'$*/;! 6,73,$'$*)! ,-! )'(&%6'!
)+)*'7)?! %$! US%6S! &/;O'1%$1O)'! %)! 7/L%7%T'0! X:/(9,?! =FF>Y4! CS'! )ORc'6*%&'!
! >!
3'()3'6*%&'! %$! *S'! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! 3(,6'))! )S%-*! *S'! 3,U'(! *,! *S'! 6O)*,7'(?! US,!
%$-;O'$6')!*S'!)'(&%6'!0'-%$%*%,$!%$!%*)!7/(Q'*!&/;O'!U%*S!S%9S!(/*'!,-!6,$*(,;)!,&'(!
*S'!&/;O'!6('/*'0!X6O)*,7'(!R'$'-%*)Y4!
B$! *S'! )'(&%6'! 7/$/9'7'$*! ;%*'(/*O('?! ,*S'(! )*O0%')! S/&'! )*('))'0! *S'! (,;'! ,-!
6O)*,7'()! /)! 3/(*! ,-! *S'! j'U! <'(&%6'! 2'&';,37'$*! Xj<2Y! /$0! 0';%&'(+! /)!
O$/&,%0/R;'!)*'3!,-!)'(&%6'!6('/*%,$!/$0!-(O%*%,$!X50&/(0)),$!'*!/;4?!=FFIY4!8,('!
3('6%)';+?! 6O)*,7'(V)! &/;O'! %)! (';/*'0! *,! *S%)! 3/(*%6%3/*%,$?! US,! 6,O;0! %$6;O0'!
6O)*,7'()! %$! *S'! -%(7V! ,(9/$%T/*%,$/;! R,O$0/(%')! X/)! '73;,+'')Y4! ! `)! U'! 0%)6O))!
;/*'(!%$!*S%)!/(*%6;'?!U%*S!(')3'6*!*,!*S'!6/)'!,-!;'/0!O)'()!,(!*(%R')?!S'('!6O)*,7'(V)!
%$&,;&'7'$*! %$! *S'! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! %)! $,*! /;U/+)! &,;O$*/(+?! RO*! %*! %)! $'6'))/(+! *,!
,R*/%$!*S'!,O*3O*!,-!*S'!3(,6'))!X2Oc/(%'(?!=FF>Y4!
CS'!7/$+!6%*'0!*S',(%')!*S/*!0%)6O))!6,13(,0O6*%,$!O$0'(!0%--'('$*!3'()3'6*%&')!
3O*!%$!'&%0'$6'!*S'!&/(%'*+!,-!R'$'-%*)!*S'!-%(7!/$0!*S'!6O)*,7'()!6/$!,R*/%$!-(,7!
)O6S! 3(,6'))! X%4'4! [,&/! /$0! 2/;;%?! =FF>\! g'33')'$! /$0! K('0'(%Q)'$?! =FFH\!
Z/7/)U/7+?!=FF>Y4!`$!%73,(*/$*!0%)*%$6*%,$!6/$!R'!7/0'!R'*U''$!7/*'(%/;!/$0!
%77/*'(%/;! R'$'-%*)4! e$! *S'! ,$'! S/$0?! 6,$)O7'(V)! 3/(*%6%3/*%,$! *,! 6,13(,0O6*%,$!
/;;,U)!*S'7!*,!9/%$!*%7'!/$0!)/&'!7,$'+!R+!('6'%&%$9!%$!/0&/$6'0!$'U!&'()%,$)!,-!
*S'!3(,0O6*)!/)!U';;!/)!*/%;,('0!3(,0O6*)4![,13(,0O6*%,$!6/$!('0O6'!)'/(6S!6,)*)!
/$0! %73(,&'! *S'! 3O(6S/)%$9! 3(,6'))! X'$S/$6'0! 3(,0O6*%&%*+! ,-! 6,$)O73*%,$Y4!
K%(7)! %$)*'/0! R'$'-%*! -(,7! /! ('0O6'0! 7/(Q'*! (%)Q?! ;,U'(! 7/(Q'*%$9! 6,)*)! -,(!
6,77O$%6/*%,$! /$0! 3,)*1)/;')! (';/*%,$)S%3! 7/$/9'7'$*! /)! U';;! /)! /! )3''0'(!
%$$,&/*%,$!3(,6'))4!!
e$! *S'! ,*S'(! S/$0?! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! 6/$! ,--'(! 6O)*,7'()! *S'! ,33,(*O$%*+! *,!
%$6('/)'!*S'%(!),6%/;!('3O*/*%,$!/$0!('6,9$%*%,$?!/O97'$*!*S'%(!/7O)'7'$*?!,(!)';-1
! E!
'73;,+/R%;%*+4!B77/*'(%/;!%73/6*)!,-!6,13(,0O6*%,$!-,(!*S'!-%(7!3(%7/(%;+!('-'(!*,!
3(,0O6*! 'L3'(%'$6'! 6('/*%,$! /$0! *S'! R(/$0! 7/$/9'7'$*4! d(/$0)! /('! %$! -/6*!
$/((/*%&')! 0'&';,3'0! /$0! $O(*O('0! R+! 6O)*,7'()! X8/*S'U)! /$0! W/6Q'(?! =FF>Y4!
CS(,O9S! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! -%(7)! /('! /;),! /R;'! *,! 0'&';,3! $'U! /$0! 0''3'(!
(';/*%,$)S%3)!U%*S!6O)*,7'()4!!!
CS'!*S',('*%6/;!6,$*(%RO*%,$)!R(%'-;+!)O77/(%T'0!/R,&'!-,6O)!*S'%(!/**'$*%,$!,$!
S,U! 6O)*,7'()! */Q'! 3/(*! %$! *S'! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! R+! S%9S;%9S*%$9! *S'! %$0%&%0O/;!
0%7'$)%,$!,(!*S'!),6%/;!)6/;'!,-!3/(*%6%3/*%,$4!B$!,O(!&%'U!/!7,('!6,73('S'$)%&'!
-(/7'U,(Q!,-!S,U!6,$)O7'()!6('/*'!&/;O'!%$!*S'!6,13(,0O6*%,$!3(,6'))!/$0?!*S'$?!
S,U!*S%)!&/;O'!%)!)S/('0!R'*U''$!*S'!*U,!)%0')!6/$!R'!,R*/%$'0!R+!6,O3;%$9!*S'!
%$0%&%0O/;! /$0! ),6%/;! 3'()3'6*%&')4! CS'! *U,! 0%7'$)%,$)! /('! R,*S! (';'&/$*! %$! *S'!
&/;O'! 6('/*%,$?! RO*! S/&'! )3'6%-%6! 6S/(/6*'(%)*%6)! %$! *'(7)! ,-! 6O)*,7'(V)!
%$&,;&'7'$*?!*+3')!,-!6O)*,7'(V)!6,$*(%RO*%,$)?!/$0!-%(7V)!7/$/9'7'$*!)*(/*'9%')4!
CS'! /$/;+)%)! ,-! S,U! R'$'-%*)! ,-! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! /('! )S/('0! R'*U''$! *S'! )%$9;'!
6O)*,7'(!/$0!*S'!-%(7!S/&'!*,!*/Q'!%$*,!/66,O$*!*S'!7%00;'!;'&';!,-!6,77O$%*%')4!
j,*!,$;+!*S'!),6%/;!)3S'('!%)!/R;'!*,!'$;/(9'!/$0!'$S/$6'!*S'!6O)*,7'(V)!'--,(*!%$!
*S'! 6,13(,0O6*%,$?! RO*! /;),! R'6,7'! /! $'U! R/(+6'$*'(! %$! *S'! &/;O'! /33(,3(%/*%,$!
0+$/7%6)4! B$! *S%)! 3'()3'6*%&'?! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! )S,O;0! R'! ,R)'(&'0! %$! *'(7)! ,-!
6O)*,7'(1*,16O)*,7'(! 6,$$'6*%,$)?! US'('! *S'! 6,77O$%*+! J! /$0! %$! 9'$'(/;! *S'!
),6%/;! )+)*'7! %$! US%6S! *S'! 6O)*,7'(! %)! '7R'00'0! J! %)! /! $'U! Q'+! )*'3! ,-! *S'!
3(,6'))4!!
!
!
%
! "F!
&#/?"#+12(3#'%;'+%3'A#)A*$*'(4%?;"(323?;(3#'%;'+%2#$$3($*'(%
.#"#/'%,#($0(,$%12345*$%(',5*/*5*#1('%6(,215$3#&71(*%/$"/#3#%5(*%(,$84&$62,5*$%(
5&'$!*S,O9S!%*!%)!aO%*'!'&%0'$*!*S'!(%)'!,-!6,$)O73*%,$!/6*%&%*%')!%$!3',3;'V)!;%-'?!%$!
*'(7)!,-!*%7'!)3'$*!-,(!6,$)O7%$9?!$,*!/;;!*S,)'!/6*%,$)!S/&'!*S'!)/7'!%73,(*/$6'!
-,(!/;;!*S'!6O)*,7'()4!P,*)!,-!)*O0%')!)S'0!;%9S*!,$!*S'!9(,U%$9!&/;O'!%$0%&%0O/;)!
/))%9$! *,! *S'! 6,$)O73*%,$! 3(,6'))?! US'('! *S'! %77/*'(%/;! 0%7'$)%,$! ,-! %*! %)!
)3'6%-%6/;;+! %73,(*/$*! X%4'4! ^%()6S7/$?! ^,;R(,,Q?! "E>=\! ^,;R(,,Q! "E>HY4!
[,$)O73*%,$!S/)!/!),6%/;!0%7'$)%,$!Xd/9,TT%?!=FFFYM!%$!*S%)!)'$)'?!6O)*,7'()!0,!
$,*!3O(6S/)'!3(,0O6*)?!RO*!l;%$Q%$9!,Rc'6*)m!X[,&/?!"EEHY?!US,)'!&/;O'!%)!(';/*'0!*,!
*S'%(! 6/3/6%*+! *,! 6,$$'6*! ,$'! '/6S! ,*S'(?! (/*S'(! *S/$! )/*%)-+%$9! -O$6*%,$/;! $''0)4!
CS'!%$*/$9%R;'!0%7'$)%,$!,-!3(,0O6*)!J!$/7';+!*S'!R(/$0?!RO*!/;),!*S'%(!/')*S'*%6!
/)3'6*)! J! /**(/6*)! 6O)*,7'(! /)! U';;! /)! *S'! 'L3'(%'$6'! *S'+! 6/$! ;%&'! 0O(%$9! *S'%(!
6,$)O73*%,$!/6*%&%*+!X%4'4!.%$'!/$0!k%;7,('?!"EEEY4!!
B$! /00%*%,$! *,! 3(,0O6*)?! 6O)*,7'()! /6S%'&'! &/;O'! *S(,O9S! *S'! 3;/6')?! *S'!
6,$*'L*)!%$!US%6S!*S'!6,$)O73*%,$!,66O()4!K,(!%$)*/$6'?!)*,(')!R'6,7'!7,('!/$0!
7,('! 6,$*'L*)! ,-! %$*'(/6*%,$! /*! 7/$+! ;'&';)M! R'*U''$! *S'! 6O)*,7'(! /$0! *S'!
3(,0O6*?!*S'!6O)*,7'(!/$0!*S'!-%(7?!*S'!6O)*,7'(!/$0!,*S'(!6O)*,7'()!X%4'4!d/0,*?!
/$0! K%;)'(?! =FFHY4! CS'! ,$;%$'! '$&%(,$7'$*! %)! /$,*S'(! Q'+! 6,$*'L*! J! '%*S'(!
6,$)%0'(%$9!*S'!-%(7V!U'R!3/9'!,(!6,77O$%*+!)%*')?!R;,9)!,(!),6%/;!$'*U,(Q)!J!%$!
US%6S!6O)*,7'()!6/$!7''*!/$0!0%)6O))?!9,%$9!R'+,$0!*S'!3(,0O6*!6,$)O73*%,$!,(!
)'(&%6'!-(O%*%,$!X%4'4!g'$Q%$)?!=FFIY4!!
2')3%*'!*S'!S,7,9'$'%*+!*S/*!6,O;0!'7'(9'!R+!,R)'(&%$9!6,$)O73*%,$!*S(,O9S!
*S,)'!3'()3'6*%&')?!7/$+!6,$*(%RO*%,$)!X%4'4!<%;&'()*'%$!/$0!K%)Q'?!=FF@\!<%;&'()*'%$!
/$0! dO*7/$?! =FFIY! '73S/)%T'! /! $'U! &/(%'*+! %$! 6,$)O7'(! R'S/&%,()! /$0! %*)!
! ""!
%73/6*)!,$!6,$)O73*%,$!6S,%6')4!B$!*S'%(!/$/;+)%)!,$!6O)*,7'()?!<%;&'()*'%$!/$0!S%)!
6,;;'/9O')! )*('))! *S/*! ')3'6%/;;+! 7%00;'17/(Q'*! 6O)*,7'()! /('! R'6,7%$9! 7,('!
'L%9'$*!/$0!0'7/$0%$9!3(,0O6*)!*(/0%*%,$/;;+!,O*!,-!*S'%(!%$*'(')*)!X/**'$*%,$!-,(!
*S'!l$'U!;OLO(+m!9,,0)Y4!!CS,)'!6O)*,7'()!/('!,(%'$*'0!*,!3(,0O6*)!*S/*!6/$!,--'(!
*S'7! '7,*%,$/;! '$9/9'7'$*! /$0?! S'$6'?! *S'+! /('! /&/%;/R;'! *,! %$&')*! *%7'! /$0!
7,$'+! -,(! *S/*! )/Q'4! B$! /00%*%,$?! *S'! /**'$*%,$! ,-! *S'! )/7'! 6O)*,7'()! -,(! 6S'/3!
3(,0O6*)!/$0!l;,U!6,)*m!,--'(%$9!)S,U!S,U!%$0%&%0O/;)!6/$!6,7R%$'!3(,0O6*)!U%*S!
0%--'('$*! 7/(Q'*! 3,)%*%,$%$9! 3(,-%;')M! 6O)*,7'()! )*(O6*O('! *S'%(! 6,$)O73*%,$!
/6*%&%*+!/$0!3(,0O6*!R/)Q'*!%$!/!&/(%,O)!U/+!)%7O;*/$',O);+4!!
`66,(0%$9!*,!*S%)!3%6*O('?!U'!/(9O'!*S/*!*S'!;'&';!,-!6O)*,7'(!'$9/9'7'$*!%$!6,1 3(,0O6*%,$!7/+!&/(+?!0'3'$0%$9!,$!*S'!(';'&/$6'!,-!*S'!6,$)O73*%,$!/6*%&%*+!-,(!
*S'!)3'6%-%6!6O)*,7'(!X6'$*(/;%*+!,-!*S'!6,$)O73*%,$Y4!WS'$'&'(!)O6S!/6*%&%*+!S/)!
/!S%9S!%73,(*/$6'!%$!*S'!)3S'('!,-!*S'!6,$)O73*%,$!X/$0!*S'!;%-'Y!-,(!*S/*!3'(),$?!
,$'! )S,O;0! 'L3'6*! /! S%9S'(! 6,$)O7'(V)! '$9/9'7'$*! %$! *S'! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! /$0!
6,77%*7'$*!*,!3/(*%6%3/*'!%$!*S'!3(,6'))4!!
CS'! 6O)*,7'(V)! %$&,;&'7'$*! ('-'()! *,! /! )*/*'! ,-! '$'(9+! /6*%&/*'0! R+! *S'!
6O)*,7'(! ,(%'$*'0! *,! )3'6%-%6! 3O(6S/)%$9! 9,/;! XW%;Q%'?! "EEGY?! /)! U';;! /)! *S'!
%73,(*/$6'! *S/*! )3'6%-%6! 3(,0O6*! /$0! 3O(6S/)%$9! 3(,6'))! ('3(')'$*)! -,(! *S'!
6O)*,7'(!X[';)%!/$0!e;),$?!"E>>Y4!^'$6'?!*S'!6,77%*7'$*!$,*%,$!R(%$9)!%$*,!*S'!
0%)6O))%,$! *S'! (,;'! ,-! 6O)*,7'()V! $''0)! /$0! *S'%(! 7,*%&/*%,$! J! %$! *'(7)! ,-!
6,$)6%,O)! ,(! O$6,$)6%,O)! %73O;)')! *S/*! 7,&'! /$0! /00('))! *,U/(0)!
3O(6S/)%$9h6,$)O7%$9! /! )3'6%-%6! 3(,0O6*4! CS'! 6,77%*7'$*! %)! %$-;O'$6'0! R+! *S'!
7,*%&/*%,$?!US%6S!0'3'$0)!,$!*S'!)+)*'7)!,-!%$6'$*%&')!/$0!*S'!R'$'-%*)!/!)%$9;'!
! "=!
6O)*,7'(! /%7)! /*! ,R*/%$%$9! *S(,O9S! S%)! 6,$)O73*%,$! R'S/&%,(?! /)! U';;! /)! *S'!
6,$*'L*)!%$!US%6S!*S'!6O)*,7'(!%)!'7R'00'04!
CS'!6,77%*7'$*!6,O;0!R'!('-'(('0!R,*S!*,!*S'!3O(6S/)'!/$0!*S'!3(,0O6*!XU%*S!
%*)! O)'Y4! B$! *S'! -(/7'U,(Q! ,-! 6,13(,0O6*%,$?! U'! /('! %$*'(')*'0! %$! )*('))%$9! *S'!
6,$)O7'(V)! 6,77%*7'$*! %$! (';/*%,$! *,! R,*S! *S'! )%*O/*%,$)4! `! S%9S! 0'9(''! ,-!
%$&,;&'7'$*!%$!/!)3'6%-%6!3O(6S/)%$9!R'S/&%,(!,(!6,$)O73*%,$!/6*%&%*+!('-;'6*)!*S'!
(';'&/$6'!,-!*S'!6,$)O73*%,$!-,(!*S'!6,$)O7'(?!US,!6,O;0!R'!-/&,(/R;+!,(%'$*'0!
*,!3/(*%6%3/*'!%$!6,13(,0O6*%,$!XO$;'))!*S%)!3/(*%6%3/*%,$!%)!)*(%6*;+!('aO%('0!R+!*S'!
6,$)O73*%,$!/6*%&%*+!%*)';-?!)''!R';,UY4!B$&,;&'0!6O)*,7'()!/('!7,('!6,77%**'0!/)!
*S'+! 6/$! '&/;O/*'! *S'! 3(,6'))! /$0! %*)! %73;%6/*%,$)! 7,('! 6/('-O;;+M! 6,77%*7'$*!
('0O6')!6,9$%*%&'!R,O$0/(%')!/$0!%$6('/)')!*S'!6,$)O7'(V)!3(,1/6*%&'!(,;'4!!
<*/(*%$9!-(,7!*S%)!3,%$*!,-!&%'U?!U'!6/$!7/Q'!/!0%)*%$6*%,$!R'*U''$!/;*'($/*%&'!
)%*O/*%,$)!X%4'4!2Oc/(%'(?!=FF>Y4!e$!*S'!,$'!S/$0?!6O)*,7'()!7/+!$,*!*/Q'!3/(*!*,!
*S'! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! ,(! 3;/+! /! 3/))%&'! (,;'! %-! %*! %)! ('aO%('0! /! 6'(*/%$! /7,O$*! ,-!
6O)*,7'(V)! %$&,;&'7'$*! %$! *S'! ('/;%T/*%,$! ,-! *S'! ,O*3O*! X%$! 6/)'! ,-! 3(,&%)%,$! ,-!
7/$+! )'(&%6')Y4! e$! *S'! ,*S'(! S/$0?! 6O)*,7'()! 7/+! 6,$)%0'(! /! )3'6%-%6!
6,$)O73*%,$! /6*%&%*+! X%4'4! 3;/+%$9! -,,*R/;;! ,(! &%0',9/7')?! (%0%$9! /! R%Q'?! 6,,Q%$9?!
'*64Y!3/(*%6O;/(;+!%73,(*/$*!-,(!*S'7!J!%$!*'(7)!,-!)/*%)-/6*%,$!,-!7/*'(%/;!$''0)?!
)';-1'L3('))%,$?!),6%/;!%$*'(/6*%,$?!'*64!J!/$0?!S'$6'?!,(%'$*'0!*,!R'!&'(+!/6*%&'!/$0!
6,77%**'0!*,!6,13(,0O6*%,$4!!
!
9#/#"1('%6(:*%61($0(*%/$"/#3#%5(
B$!/00%*%,$!*,!*S'!;'&';!,-!'$9/9'7'$*!,-!6O)*,7'()?!/)!)*/*'0!'/(;%'(!%$!*S'!3/3'(?!
U'!/(9O'!*S/*!/!Q'+!0%)*%$6*%,$!S/)!*,!R'!7/0'!%$!6O)*,7'()V!3/(*%6%3/*%,$!*,!6,1
! "@!
3(,0O6*%,$! 3(,6'))M! %$0%&%0O/;! /#&121! ),6%/;! %$&,;&'7'$*4! CS'! *S',('*%6/;!
6,$*(%RO*%,$)!,$!6,13(,0O6*%,$!)*('))!*S/*!6O)*,7'()!6/$!R'!6,$$'6*'0!*,!*S'!-%(7!
/)!)%$9;')!1!US,!,--'(!!X&,;O$*/(+!,(!$,*Y!*S'%(!7/*'(%/;!/$0!Q$,U;'09'!U,(Q!J!,(!
/)! 7'7R'()! ,-! ),6%/;! '$*%*%')! X*S'! 6,77O$%*%')?! *S'! *(%R')Y4! B$! *S%)! )'6,$0!
0%7'$)%,$?! *S'! '--,(*! /$0! U,(Q! ,-! %$0%&%0O/;)! %)! '$S/$6'0! R+! *S'! /6*%&%*+! ,-!
%$*'(/6*%,$!U%*S!*S'!,*S'(!6O)*,7'()4!CS'!),6%/;!)6/;'!%)!/$!O$/&,%0/R;'!';'7'$*!,-!
*S'!6,13(,0O6*%,$?!US%6S!6,O;0!$,*!$'6'))/(%;+!9'$'(/*'!*S'!)/7'!(')O;*)!,-!)%$9;'!
6O)*,7'()V! %$&,;&'7'$*4! <*O0%')! ,$! 6,77O$%*%')! %0'$*%-%'0! 0%--'('$*! 6,77O$%*+!
7'7R'()V!(,;')!X%4'4!f,T%$'*)?!"EEE\!eOU'();,,*!/$0!e0'Q'(Q'$1<6S(n0'(?!=FF>YM!
6O)*,7'()! %$&,;&'7'$*! /$0! 3/(*%6%3/*%,$! &/(+! 0'3'$0%$9! ,$! *S'%(! ;'/01O)'($'))?!
*S'%(! 'L3'(*%)'! /$0! U%;;! *,! )3'$0! *%7'! /$0! 3'(),$/;! '--,(*! %$! *S'! %$*'(/6*%,$?!
6,$)O73*%,$!0%)6,O()'!/$0!)S/('0!U,(Q!X%4'4!<S/S?!=FFIY4!!
B$!/00%*%,$?!/)!U'!/;('/0+!)/%0?!6,13(,0O6*%,$!%)!/!aO%*'!6,73;'L!3S'$,7'$,$?!
US'('! *S'! 3(,0O6*%,$! X/$0! %*)! R'$'-%*)Y! ('-'()! *,! R,*S! 7/*'(%/;! /$0! %77/*'(%/;!
';'7'$*)4!W'!/(9O'!*S/*!*S'!'&/;O/*%,$!/$0!0%)*(%RO*%,$!,-!*S'!R'$'-%*)!,-!*S'!U,(Q!
0,$'! R+! *S'! 6O)*,7'(! /$0! *S'! 6,73/$+! 6/$! R'! &'(+! 0%--'('$*! %$! 6/)'! ,-! )%73;'!
7/*'(%/;!3/(*%6%3/*%,$!,(!%$!3(')'$6'!,-!6,73;'L!%77/*'(%/;!*/)Q)4!!
W'! )S,O;0! */Q'! %$*,! /66,O$*! *S/*! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! U,(Q! S/)! 9(/0O/;;+! R'6,7'!
7,('!/$0!7,('!R/)'0!,$!%$*/$9%R;'!*/)Q)?!/$0!*S%)!U,(Q!S/)!R'6,7'!-O$0/7'$*/;!
-,(!/0&/$6'0!-%(7)4!B$!*S'%(!('6'$*!/(*%6;'!,$!U,(Q%$9!6,$)O7'()!d'($/(0![,&/!/$0!
2/$%';'!2/;;%!0'-%$'!%77/*'(%/;!;/R,(!/)!*S'(;',5*/*5<(=<(>?*,?('(@&$>*%@(%23=#&($0(
,$%5#34$&'&<(>$&:#&1(,$%5&*=25#(5$(5?#(6#/#"$43#%5($0(4$1580$&6*15(*%6215&<m!X[,&/!
/$0! 2/;;%?! =FFE?! 34! @=>Y4! CU,! 7/%$! -,(7)! ,-! %77/*'(%/;! U,(Q! /('! %$! 3;/6'M! /!
6O;*O(/;! -,(7?! *S/*! ('9/(0)! %$*';;'6*O/;! ,(! ;%$9O%)*%6! */)Q)! U%*S! /$/;+*%6! /$0!
! "G!
)+7R,;%6! 6,$*'$*)?! /$0! /('! (';/*'0! *,! *S'! 3(,0O6*%,$! ,-! '494! %0'/)?! )+7R,;)?! /$0!
%7/9')\!/$!/--'6*%&'!-,(7?!*S/*!%)!(';/*'0!*,!*S'!7'$*/;!/$0!6,(3,(/;!)3S'(')?!/$0!
(';/*')!7/%$;+!U%*S!-'';%$9)!X'494!)/*%)-/6*%,$?!U';;1R'%$9?!3/))%,$Y4!
CS'! 9(,U*S! ,-! 6,$)O7'()V! %77/*'(%/;! U,(Q! 1! *S/*! /66,(0%$9! *,! *S'! /O*S,()! %)!
7/%$;+! O$0'(')*%7/*'0! %-! $,*! '&'$! $,*! ('6,9$%T'0! 1! %)! ,*S'(U%)'! (';/*'0! *,! /!
3(,9('))%&'! %$6('/)'! ,-! 6O)*,7'()V! %$&,;&'7'$*! %$! 6,$)O73*%,$! 3(,6'))')4! `)!
),6%,;,9%6/;! )*O0%')! S%9S;%9S*?! 6,$)O73*%,$! %)! $,U/0/+)! /$! %73,(*/$*! 3/(*! ,-!
3',3;'V)! %0'$*%*+! 6,$)*(O6*%,$! X`SO&%/?! =FFA\!K%(/*! 2S,;/Q%/?! "EE>Y4! B$! *S%)! $'U!
6,$*'L*?!U%;;%$9$'))!*,!3/(*%6%3/*'!%$!7/(Q'*1(';/*'0!/6*%&%*%')!%)!9(,U%$9!/$0!*S%)!
%)!')3'6%/;;+!*(O'!-,(!6('/*%&'!/6*%&%*%')!%$!US%6S!6,$)O7'()!7/$%3O;/*'!)%9$)!/$0!
%$-,(7/*%,$?! %$0%&%0O/;;+! /$0! %$! 6,77O$%*%')! X.'o/;,T/! /$0! :'$Q/*')S?! =FFI\!
<6S,O*'$!/$0!86`;'L/$0'(?!"EEAY4!j'&'(*S';'))?!0O'!*,!/**'$*%,$!6,$)*(/%$*)!/$0!
0%--'('$*!;'&';)!,-!(';'&/$6+!/R,O*!3O(6S/)'!/$0!3(,0O6*)!-,(!6,$)O7'()?!*S%)!;'&';!
,-! 6,77%*7'$*! %)! 0%))%7%;/(! /7,$9! 6O)*,7'()! /$0! %73/6*)! ,$! *S'%(! /R%;%*+! *,!
'--'6*%&';+! 6,$*(%RO*'! *,! *S'! 6,13(,0O6*%,$?! *,! 6,$*(,;! *S'! 3(,6'))! /$0! /6S%'&'!
X6,Y3(,0O6*%,$!R'$'-%*)4!!!
!
&#'("#))*+%A.B%)##.*%2#/?"#+12(3#'4%;%$#+*)%
A$84&$62,5*$%(',5*/*5*#1('%6(&#"#/'%5(,'1#1(
`)! U'! S/&'! )''$! %$! *S'! 3('&%,O)! 3/(/9(/3S)?! *S'! U/+! 6,$)O7'()! %$*'(/6*! U%*S!
-%(7)! %$! ,(0'(! *,! 6,13(,0O6'! &/;O'! %)! /--'6*'0! R+! *S'%(! %$&,;&'7'$*! %$! *S'!
3O(6S/)%$9! h! 6,$)O73*%,$! 3(,6'))! /$0! R+! *S'! *+3'! ,-! (';/*%,$/;! %$*'(/6*%,$! %$!
US%6S!6,13(,0O6*%,$!*/Q')!3;/6'4!
! "A!
B$!,(0'(!*,!)*O0+!US/*!7/+!R'!*S'!6,$)'aO'$6')!,-!*S')'!*S',('*%6/;!3('7%)')!
U'!RO%;*!/!=L=!7/*(%L!O)%$9!*U,!R/)%6!&/(%/R;')!X)''!*/R;'!"YM!;'&';!,-!6O)*,7'(V)!
%$&,;&'7'$*! XS%9S! /$0! ;,UY! /$0! *S'! *+3'! ,-! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! (';/*%,$! X*S/*! %)!
%$0%&%0O/;! ,(! ),6%/;Y4! CS'! -%()*! &/(%/R;'! 6/$! R'! S%9S! ,(! ;,U! 0'3'$0%$9! ,$! *S'!
U%;;%$9$'))! ,-! *S'! 6,$)O7'(! *,! 6,77%*! %$! *S'! 3/(*%6%3/*%,$4! CS'! )'6,$0! &/(%/R;'?!
*S'! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! $/*O('?! 6/$! R'! ('3(')'$*'0! /)! %$0%&%0O/;! J! US'$! *S'! -,(7! ,-!
%$*'(/6*%,$!%)!,$'1*,1,$'!R/)'0!/$0!;%7%*'0!*,!*S'!-%(7!/$0!%*)!6O)*,7'(!1!,(!),6%/;!
J! US'$! *S'! %$*'(/6*%,$! %)! /! 7,('! )3('/01,O*! 3S'$,7'$,$?! /$0! %$&,;&')! ,*S'(!
6,$)O7'()?!$,$16,$)O7'()!/$0!6,77O$%*%')4!
5&'$*O/;;+?! -,O(! /;*'($/*%&'! ,3*%,$)! ,-! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! '7'(9'?! U%*S! 0%)*%$6*%&'!
7/$/9'(%/;! -'/*O(')! X)''! */R;'! "Y4! `! -O(*S'(! 'L3;/$/*%,$! /$0! ),7'! 'L/73;')! X%$!
R(/6Q'*)!%$!*S'!*/R;'Y!U%;;!6;/(%-+!*S'!)'$)'!,-!,O(!0%)6,O()'4!
!
B'="#(C(D(E$,*'"*F'5*$%('%6(,$33*53#%5(*%(,$84&$62,5*$%(',5*/*5*#1(
! ! [,13(,0O6*%,$!(';/*%,$!
! ! B$0%&%0O/;! <,6%/;!
^%9S! @!!
!
"*,"!6,13(,0O6*%,$!
X_,,33/Y!
!
G!
!
[,77O$%*+1R/)'0!6,1 3(,0O6*%,$!
X7/99%,;%$,4%*?!
[,O$*'(1)*(%Q'Y!
!
!
!
!
!
! P'&';!,-!
%$&,;&'7'$*! !
!P,U!
"!
! lK,(6'0m!6,1
3(,0O6*%,$!
X`C8Y!
!
=!!
! KO$6*%,$/;!6,1
3(,0O6*%,$!
X5L3'0%/Y!
!
!
pO/0(/$*! "! %)! *S'! 6/)'! ,-! ;,U! %$&,;&'7'$*! %$! /$! %$0%&%0O/;! 6,13(,0O6*%,$!
(';/*%,$4! CS/*! %)! -('aO'$*;+! *S'! 6/)'! ,-! l-,(6'0m! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! 3O(6S/)%$9! /$0!
! "I!
6,$)O73*%,$!3(,6'))')?!%$!US%6S!7,0'($!3(,0O6*%,$!/$0!0%)*(%RO*%,$!,-!3(,0O6*)!
/$0!)'(&%6')!,--'(!),7'!7/*'(%/;!R'$'-%*)!X*+3%6/;;+!*%7'!/$0!7,$'+!)/&%$9)?!=GLH!
/&/%;/R%;%*+Y!/*!*S'!3(%6'!,-!),7'!6O)*,7'(V)!/6*%&%*%')4!K,(!'L/73;'?!`C8)!)'(&%6')!
9O/(/$*''!6/)S!0%)*(%RO*%,$!/*!/$+!*%7'?!RO*!*S'!6O)*,7'(!S/)!*,!0,!),7'!)%73;'!
U,(Q!*/)Q)!;%Q'!)'/(6S%$9!-,(!*S'!$'/(')*!7/6S%$'?!('/6S!%*!/$0!%$*'(/6*!U%*S!*S'!
/O*,7/*%6!*';;'(4!
<%73;'! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! */)Q)! /('! /;),! 3(')'$*! %$! aO/0(/$*! =?! RO*! %$! *S%)! 6/)'!
%$-,(7/*%,$!/$0!6,77O$%6/*%,$!*'6S$,;,9%')!XB[CY!/$0!%$!3/(*%6O;/(!*S'!U'R?!S/&'!
'$;/(9'0! *S'! )6/;'! ,-! 6,77O$%6/*%,$! /$0! ,3'$'0! $'U! ,33,(*O$%*%')4! CS%)! %)! *S'!
6/)'! ,-! 7,0'($! ';'6*(,$%6! 6,77'(6'! '$9%$')?! )O6S! /)! 5L3'0%/?! %$! US%6S! *S'!
6O)*,7'(! S/)! *S'! 3,))%R%;%*+! ,-! ('*(%'&%$9! *S'! 6,77'$*)! ,-! ,*S'(! 6O)*,7'()! *S/*!
S/&'!3O(6S/)'0!h!6,$)O7'0!*S'!)/7'!3(,0O6*!)S'!%)!%$*'(')*'0!%$!X%4'4!/!)3'6%-%6!
S,*';! aO/;%*+! /))'))7'$*Y4! 2%--'('$*;+! -(,7! *S'! 3('&%,O)! 6/)'?! S'('! *S'! 6,1 3(,0O6*%,$!S/)!/$!%73,(*/$*!),6%/;!0%7'$)%,$M!U%*S,O*!/$+!0%('6*!/$0!%77'0%/*'!
('U/(0?! 6O)*,7'()! /66'3*! *,! )S/('! *S'%(! ,3%$%,$)! U%*S! 5L3'0%/! /$0! *S'! ,*S'(!
&%)%*,()! Q$,U%$9! *S/*! ,*S'(! 6,$)O7'()! 6,O;0! /66'))! )O6S! Q$,U;'09'! /$0! *S'+!
6,O;0! R'$'-%*! -(,7! ,*S'()V! ,$'! %$! *S'! -O*O('?! /)! *S',(%T'0! R+! *S'! ;%*'(/*O('! ,-!
),6%,;,9+!,-!*S'!9%-*!X)''!-,(!'L/73;'!k%');'(?!=FFIY4!!
W%*S,O*!*S,)'!6,77'$*)?!5L3'0%/!U,O;0$V*!R'!/R;'!*,!0%--'('$*%/*'!%*)!)'(&%6')!
-(,7! *S'! 6,73'*%*,()V! ,$')4! B$! /00%*%,$?! 6O)*,7'()! 7/+! R'! /**(/6*%&'! R+! 5L3'0%/!
U'R)%*'! R'6/O)'! ,-! *S'! 3(')'$6'! ,-! 3''()V! '&/;O/*%,$)! /$0! 7,0%-+! *S'%(!
6,$)O73*%,$! 6S,%6')! ,$! *S'! R/)%)! ,-! )O6S! %$3O*)4! j'&'(*S';'))?! *S'! ),;O*%,$! %)!
*'6S$,;,9+10(%&'$! /$0! 6,$)O7'()V! %$&,;&'7'$*! ('7/%$)! ;,U?! S%9S;%9S*%$9! *S'!
! "H!
%73,(*/$6'! ,-! -O$6*%,$/;! R'$'-%*)! 0O'! *,! *S'! 6(%*%6/;! 7/))! ,-! 6,77'$*)! /$0! *S'!
;%7%*'0!),6%/;!%$*'(/6*%,$!/7,$9!6O)*,7'()4!
pO/0(/$*! @! %)! 6S/(/6*'(%T'0! R+! /! S%9S! ;'&';! ,-! %$&,;&'7'$*! %$! /$! %$0%&%0O/;!
X"*,"Y! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! %$*'(/6*%,$4! 8/$+! )*O0%')! ,$! *S'! (,;'! ,-! ;'/01O)'()! %$! *S'!
6,;;/R,(/*%&'! %$$,&/*%,$! 6/$! 3,)%*%,$! *S'%(! /$/;+)')! %$! *S%)! R,L4! CS%)! %)! /;),! *S'!
6/)'!,-!_,,33/?!/!U'R1R/)'0!%$*'(7'0%/(+!)3'6%/;%T'0!%$!)O33,(*%$9!-%(7)!%$!*S'%(!
R(/$0! )*(/*'9+! R+! (';+%$9! ,$! 3',3;'! 3/(*%6%3/*%,$! X_,,33/! 0'-%$')! %*)';-! /)! l*S'!
9;,R/;! ),6%/;! $'*U,(Q! -,(! 6('/*%&'! */;'$*)mY4! B$! /66,(0/$6'! U%*S! *S'! -%(7?! _,,33/!
,--'()! 6('/*%&'! R(%'-! *,! ('9%)*'('0! &%)%*,()?! US,! 6/$! 3/(*%6%3/*'! *,! /$! ,$1;%$'!
6,73'*%*%,$!/$0!U%$!7,$'+4!./(*%6%3/$*)!6/$!R'!$',3S+*')!,(!XO)O/;;+Y!'L3'(*)!%$!
6,77O$%6/*%,$?!0')%9$!,(!/(*)!X6('/*%&'!3',3;'Y!US,!)OR7%*!*S'%(!3(,3,)/;)!*,!*S'!
_,,33/! 3;/*-,(74! CS'! 6,77O$%*+! &,*')! *S'! 3(,3,)/;)! /$0! 9%&')! -''0R/6Q)! /R,O*!
*S'!U,(Q)!O3;,/0'04!8,(',&'(?!'/6S!3/(*%6%3/$*!/)!7'7R'(!6/$!3'()O/0'!&,*'()!*,!
)';'6*!S'(!U,(Q4!^,U'&'(?!*S'!-%$/;!0'6%)%,$!/R,O*!*S'!U%$$'(!%)!O3!*,!*S'!-%(74!B$!
*S%)! 6/)'! *S'! (,;'! ,-! *S'! 6,77O$%*+! %)! $,*! 6'$*(/;! %$! *S'! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! 3(,6'))?!
US%6S! ('7/%$)! %$! *S'! 6,$*'L*! ,-! ,$'1*,1,$'! %$*'(/6*%,$! X*S'! 3/(*%6%3/*%,$! ,-! *S'!
6,77O$%*+!%)!;%7%*'0!*,!*S'!/6*%&%*%')!(';/*'0!*,!*S'!)';'6*%,$!)+)*'7Y4!
`!0''3'(!%$&,;&'7'$*!,-!*S'!6,77O$%*+!%)!*S'!6/)'!,-!aO/0(/$*!G?!%$!US%6S!6,1 3(,0O6*%,$! /6*%&%*%')! /('! ),6%/;;+1R/)'0! /$0! *(%99'(! S%9S! ;'&';)! ,-! 6,$)O7'()!
%$&,;&'7'$*4!<*O0%')!,$!6,77O$%*%')!,-!%$$,&/*%,$)?!R(/$0!6,77O$%*%')!/)!U';;!/)!
*(%R')!'73S/)%T'!*S%)!;'&';!,-!7/$+1*,17/$+!6,13(,0O6*%,$?!)*(,$9!6,77%*7'$*!,-!
3/(*%6%3/$*)! /$0! /R%;%*+! ,-! *S'! 6,77O$%*+! *,! R'6,7'! *S'! $'U! R/(+6'$*'(! %$! *S%)!
3(,6'))4!!
! ">!
CS%)! %)! *S'! 6/)'?! -,(! 'L/73;'?! ,-! *S'! &%$*/9'! 6/()! 6,77O$%*+! 7/99%,;%$,4%*?! %$!
US%6S!7'7R'()!/('!6,77%**'0!%$!)+7R,;%6!/$0!7/*'(%/;!6,13(,0O6*%,$?!-('aO'$*;+!
'$6,73/))%$9! )3'6%-%6! /$0! 3'(),$/;! %$*'(/6*%,$! S%9S! &/;O'! /6*%&%*%')4! e;0! 6/()!
;%7%*'0! ,(! $O;;! 7/(Q'*! &/;O'! %)! *(/$)-,(7'0! %$! &/;O/R;'! 7/(Q'*! *(/$)/6*%,$)! /$0!
3,*'$*%/;! %$*'(')*%$9! R/(9/%$)! *S(,O9S! *S'! 7'/$)! ,-! /$! %$*'$)'! 6%(6O;/*%,$! ,-!
*'6S$%6/;! /$0! )+7R,;%6! %$-,(7/*%,$?! *S/*! 6/$! S/&'! /! ('/;! %73/6*! '&'$! ,$! *S'!
3(,0O6*)! *S'! -%(7! X*S'! k'(7/$! 6/(! 7/$O-/6*O('(! :,;Q)U/9'$! %$! *S%)! 6/)'Y!
6O(('$*;+!0%)*(%RO*')4!!
`$,*S'(!(';'&/$*!'L/73;'!%)!*S'!3,3O;/(!&%0',9/7'![,O$*'(1)*(%Q'?!0'&';,3'0!
R+!*U,!)*O0'$*)!US,!7,0%-%'0!*S'!),O(6'!6,0'!,-!/$,*S'(!U';;1Q$,U$!9/7'?!^/;-1 P%-'4! W%*S! *S'! S';3! ,-! *S'! $'U1R,($! 6,77O$%*+?! *S'+! 6('/*'0! /! 6,73;'*';+! $'U!
3(,0O6*!U%*S!/!;%-'!,$!S%)!,U$!/$0!,O*!,-!*S'!6,$*(,;!,-!*S'!6,73/$+4!d+!RO%;0%$9!
(';/*%,$)S%3)!U%*S!*S'![,O$*'(1)*(%Q'!6,77O$%*+?!:/;&'!),-*U/('!*S'$!U/)!/R;'!*,!
%$6;O0'! J! /)! /! -(''! 7,0O;'! ,-! ^/;-! P%-'! 1! [,O$*'(1)*(%Q'! %$! %*)! 3(,0O6*! 3,(*-,;%,!
/&/%;/R;'!-,(!%$0%&%0O/;!O)'!X7/))!7/(Q'*Y4!
CS'! 6,$*'L*)! S%9S;%9S*'0! R+! *S'! 7/*(%L! S/&'! /;),! %73,(*/$*! 6,$)'aO'$6')! ,$!
*S'! U/+! R'$'-%*)! ,-! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! /('! 0%)*(%RO*'0! R'*U''$! *S'! -%(7! /$0! *S'!
6O)*,7'(?!/)!U'V;;!)''!%$!*S'!$'L*!3/(/9(/3S4!
!
A$84&$62,5*$%('%6(=#%#0*51(6*15&*=25*$%(
`)!0')6(%R'0!%$!3/(/9(/3S!=?!R'$'-%*)!0'(%&%$9!-(,7!6,13(,0O6*%,$!6/$!R'!%$%*%/;;+!
%0'$*%-%'0! /)! 7/*'(%/;! X-O$6*%,$/;Y! /$0! %77/*'(%/;! X)+7R,;%6! /$0! ),6%/;Y4! B$!
/00%*%,$?!S'('!U'!U%;;!6,$)%0'(!/$,*S'(!6%(6O7)*/$6'?!(';/*'0!*,!*S'!-/6*!*S/*!*S'+!
7/+!R'!('-'(('0!*,!*S'!6O)*,7'(!/$0!*,!*S'!-%(74!
! "E!
e$!*S'!,$'!S/$0?!*S'!6,$)O7'(!7/+!'$c,+!7/*'(%/;!R'$'-%*)!0'(%&%$9!-(,7!*S'!
6,13(,0O6*%,$?!-O$6*%,$/;!/0&/$*/9')!)O6S!/)!)3'6%/;!(/*')?!0';%&'(+!/$0!3/+7'$*!
6,$0%*%,$)?!6O)*,7%T'0!),;O*%,$)?!'*64!e*S'(!/0&/$*/9')!/('!7,('!%77/*'(%/;?!)O6S!
/)!3'(),$/;!9(/*%-%6/*%,$?!),6%/;!('6,9$%*%,$?!%0'$*%*+!)';-1('%$-,(6'7'$*?!'*64!!
e$! *S'! ,*S'(! S/$0?! *S'! -%(7! S/)! /! )+77'*(%6! 3,)%*%,$! *S/$! *S'! ,$'! ,-! *S'!
6O)*,7'(X)Y4!B*!6/$!'$c,+!7/*'(%/;!R'$'-%*)!US'$!6,13(,0O6*%,$!3(,6'))')!;'/0!*,!
;,U'(! 3(,0O6*%,$! /$0! 0%)*(%RO*%,$! 6,)*)! X,(9/$%T/*%,$/;! /$0! SO7/$Y?! )O6S! /)!
9('/*'(! '6,$,7%')! ,-! )6/;'?! 6/3%*/;! &)4! ;/R,(! )OR)*%*O*%,$?! 3(,0O6*! 0%--'('$*%/*%,$!
3('7%O7! 3(%6')4! 8,('! %$*/$9%R;'! R'$'-%*)! 0'(%&'! -(,7! *S'! %77/*'(%/;! U,(Q! 0,$'!
R+! 6,$)O7'()! /$0! 6,77O$%*%')?! ')3'6%/;;+! ,$! *S'! 6O;*O(/;! X%$*';;'6*O/;! /$0!
;%$9O%)*%6Y!/$0!/--'6*%&'!X3/))%,$)!/$0!-'';%$9)Y!)%0')4!
[,$)%0'(%$9! *S'! R'$'-%*)! ,-! 6,13(,0O6*%,$?! U'! S/&'! *,! O$0'(;%$'! *S/*! /*! *S'!
-%(7V)!;'&';!J!0%--'('$*;+!-(,7!*S'!6,$)O7'(V)!;'&';!1!6,13(,0O6*%,$!6/$!3,*'$*%/;;+!
3(,0O6'! /! *U,1,(0'(! R'$'-%*4! K%()*;+?! -%(7)! 6/$! R'$'-%*! -(,7! *S'! U,(Q! 0,$'! R+!
6O)*,7'()!0%('6*;+?!/)!/!X0%('6*Y!'--'6*!,-!*S'!/6*%&%*%')!6/((%'0!,$!%$!*S'!6,$*'L*O/;!
%$*'(/6*%,$! ,-! 6,13(,0O6*%,$4! <'6,$0;+?! ('U/(0)! 0%)*(%RO*%,$! /;;,U)! /$,*S'(!
X%$0%('6*Y!-,(7!,-!/33(,3(%/*%,$?!*S/*!%)!*S'!'L3;,%*/*%,$!,-!*S'!6,$*'$*)!(';/*'0!*,!
6,13(,0O6*%,$!%$!/!R(,/0'(!6,$*'L*!*S/*!*S'!,$'!,-!6,13(,0O6*%,$!%$*'(/6*%,$4!K,(!
'L/73;'?!*S'!-%(7!6,O;0!('1O)'!X'L6;O)%&';+Y!6O)*,7'()V!U,(Q!%$!,(0'(!*,!,R*/%$%$9!
$'U!),;O*%,$)!*S/*!6/$!R'!('3;%6/*'0!,(!$'U!3(,0O6*)!*S/*!6/$!R'!)*/$0/(0%T'0!/$0!
0%)*(%RO*'0!*,!*S'!7/))!7/(Q'*!/$0!9'$'(/*'!)%9$%-%6/$*!('&'$O')4!
`!6(O6%/;!3,%$*!%$!*S'!0%)*(%RO*%,$!,-!*S'!R'$'-%*)!(';/*')!*,!*S'!3,))%R%;%*+!-,(!*S'!
-%(7!*,!6,$*(,;!*S'!6,13(,0O6*%,$!3(,6'))!/$0!3(,-%*!-(,7!*S'!/33(,3(%/*%,$!,-!%*)!
&/;O'4! CS'! 3,))%R%;%*+! *,! 6,$*(,;! 6,$)O7'()V! U,(Q! %)! ,-! 6,O()'! 0'3'$0'$*! ,$!
! =F!
)'&'(/;!6%(6O7)*/$6')?!/R,&'!US%6S!U'!S%9S;%9S*!*S'!$/*O('!,-!*S'!U,(Q!X7/*'(%/;?!
%77/*'(%/;Y!/$0!*S'!*+3'!,-!6O)*,7'(!%$&,;&'7'$*4!!
e-! 6,O()'?! '&'(+! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! U,(Q! J! /)! /! SO7/$! /6*%,$! 1! 3(')'$*)! 7/*'(%/;!
/$0! %77/*'(%/;! ';'7'$*)M! 6,$)O7'()V! %77/*'(%/;! U,(Q! %)! %$! 3;/6'! '&'$! %-! *S'!
6,$)O7'(! 0,')$V*! U/$*! /$0h,(! Q$,U! XW'%6Q?! "EEAY4! j'&'(*S';'))?! ),7'! 6,1 3(,0O6*%,$!/6*%&%*%')!%73;%'0!%$!*S'!aO/0(/$*)!,-!*S'!7/*(%L!/('!3('&/;'$*;+!,-!,$'!
,(! ,-! *S'! ,*S'(! *+3'! X)''! */R;'! =Y4! CSO)?! /*! *S'! 'L*('7')! ,-! *S%)! )%*O/*%,$! U'! 6/$!
0%)*%$9O%)S!R'*U''$!;,U1%$&,;&'7'$*!7/*'(%/;!U,(Q?!*S/*!/('!'/)%;+!/))'))'0!/$0!
aO%*'!-/%(;+!0%)*(%RO*'0!X'494!*S'!6/)'!,-!`*7?!,(!*S'!6/)'!,-!*S'!O)'!,-!'16,77'(6'!
)S,3R,*)Y?!/$0!S%9S!%$&,;&'7'$*!%77/*'(%/;!U,(Q?!*S/*!%)!0%--%6O;*!*,!('U/(0!/$0!
'&'$!*,!7'/)O('!X'494!%$!*S'!6/)'!,-!*S'!6,$)*(O6*%,$!,-!/!R(/$0!%$!/!&%(/;!6,$*'L*!
*S(,O9S!*S'!/6*%,$!,-!/!6,77O$%*+!,-!/0,3*'()Y4!
!
B'="#(G(D(H#%#0*51(6*15&*=25*$%I(='"'%,*%@(,$%5&$""#6('%6("$$1#(,$84&$62,5*$%(
! ! [,13(,0O6*%,$!(';/*%,$!
! ! B$0%&%0O/;! <,6%/;!
^%9S!
X`('/!,-!!
%$*/$9%R;'!
'L3;,%*/*%,$Y!
@!!
9$$1#(,$84&$62,5*$%(
2,OR;'!'L3;,%*/*%,$!&)4!
6O)*,7'(!
'73,U'(7'$*!!
!
G!
9$$1#(*%5#&3#6*'5*$%!
*S'!6,77O$%*+!%)!/!
-,(7/;!%$*'(-/6'!
!
!
!
! P'&';!,-!
%$&,;&'7'$*!!
!
! P,U!
X`('/!,-!-O$6*%,$/;!
R/(*'(Y!
"!!
J$&,#6(,$84&$62,5*$%(
[,13(,0O6*%,$!U,(Q!%)!
'/)+!*,!'&/;O/*'!/$0!
R'$'-%*)!/('!'/)%;+!
0%)*(%RO*'0!!
!
=!
A$%5&$""#6(,$8 4&$62,5*$%(
.('7%O7!3(%6')!/('!
'L6S/$9'0!-,(!),7'!
0%--'('$*%/;!R'$'-%*)!
0'(%&%$9!-(,7!6,1 3(,0O6*%,$!
!
!
B$! 3/(*%6O;/(?! aO/0(/$*)! "! /$0! =! /('! *S'! /('/)! %$! US%6S! 7/*'(%/;! R'$'-%*)! /('!
3('&/;'$*4!^'('!*S'!-%(7!S/)!7,('!3,))%R%;%*%')!*,!)*(%6*;+!6,$*(,;!*S'!6,13(,0O6*%,$!
! ="!
3(,6'))?!,(9/$%T%$9!*+3'!/$0!)6,3'!,-!*S'!U,(Q!*S/*!*S'!6,$)O7'(!%)!)O33,)'0!*,!
0,4!WS'$!6,13(,0O6*%,$!*/)Q)!/('!0'-%$%*'!/$0!)%73;'!XaO/0(/$*!"Y?!*S'!-%(7!/$0!
*S'! 6O)*,7'(! /9(''! ,$! /! ('6%3(,6/;! -O$6*%,$/;! R/(*'(! *S/*! ;'/0)! *,! /! (/*S'(! -/%(!
0%)*(%RO*%,$!,-!R'$'-%*)4!
8,('! 6,73;'L! )%*O/*%,$)! 1! ;%Q'! *S'! ,$'! ('3(')'$*'0! %$! aO/0(/$*! =! J! 6/;;! -,(! /!
0%--'('$*! 6,$*(,;! R+! *S'! -%(74! ^'('! *S'! )*/Q'! %)! *S'! /33(,3(%/*%,$! ,-! *S'! 6,1 3(,0O6*%,$! &/;O'! %$! *'(7)! ,-! 0%--'('$*%/*%,$?! 3(,-%*%$9! -(,7! *S'! /)),6%/*'0!
3('7%O713(%6'4!K,(!'L/73;'?!%$!*S'!6/)'!,-!5L3'0%/!J!7'$*%,$'0!%$!*S'!3('&%,O)!
3/(/9(/3S! J! *S'! -%(7! 6,O;0! 'L6;O)%&';+! O)'! *S'! -,(1-(''! 6,77'$*)! 3,)*'0! R+! *S'!
O)'()! %$! ,(0'(! *,! '$S/$6'! %*)! )'(&%6'! ;'&';! /$0! /)Q! -,(! R'**'(! 6,77%))%,$)! -(,7!
/0&'(*%)'()!/$0!-(,7!*(/&';!,3'(/*,()4!
#33'(!/('/)!%$!aO/0(/$*!@!/$0!G!/('!'&'$!7,('!3(,R;'7/*%6?!)%$6'!*S'+!3(')'$*!
7,('!)OR*;'!-,(7)!,-!U,(Q4!^'('?!*S'!3,)%*%,$!,-!*S'!6,$)O7'(!%)!6,$0%*%,$'0!R+!%*)!
%$&,;&'7'$*!%$!*S'!3(,6'))4!<%$6'!*S'!3'(6'3*%,$!,-!*S'!U,(Q!0,$'!6/$!&/(+!/!;,*!
/7,$9! 6,$)O7'()?! *S%)! 7/+! %$-;O'$6'! *S'! R'$'-%*)! *S'! -%(7! 6/$! 3,*'$*%/;;+!
/33(,3(%/*'4! e-! 6,O()'! *S%)! /('/! %)! /;),! /! &'(+! %$*'(')*%$9! ,$'! -,(! -%(7)?! R'6/O)'!
S'('! *S'! ,Rc'6*! ,-! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! %)! (';/*'0! *,! *S'! %$*/$9%R;'! &/;O'! ,-! -%(7)V!
3(,0O6*)?! ,-! 3,*'$*%/;! )*(/*'9%6! %73,(*/$6'4! `)! /! (')O;*?! -%(7V)! 7,*%&/*%,$! *,! */Q'!
6,$*(,;! ,-! *S'! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! 3(,6'))! %)! S%9S4! j'&'(*S';'))?! -%(7)! 7O)*! /;),!
6,$)%0'(!*S/*!7,('!6,73;'L!-,(7)!,-!6,13(,0O6*%,$!6/;;!-,(!(%6S'(!/33(,/6S')!*,!
6O)*,7'(! '$9/9'7'$*?! aO')*%,$%$9! *S'! 0,7%$/$*! -%(716'$*'('0! 3'()3'6*%&'! ,$!
R'$'-%*!6,$*(,;!X.(/S/;/0?!=FFG\!./+$'!'*!/;4?!=FF>Y4!
[,$*(,;! %$%*%/*%&')! ,&'(! 0%)*(%RO*%,$! 7'6S/$%)7)! 0'3'$0! /;),! ,$! *S'!
6S/(/6*'(%)*%6)! ,-! *S'! 6,$)O7'()4! B$! 3/(*%6O;/(?! ('6'$*;+! *S'! ;%*'(/*O('! S/)!
! ==!
('6,9$%T'0! *S'! 3'6O;%/(%*+! ,-! /! 3/(*%6O;/(! 6/*'9,(+! ,-! 'L%9'$*! l'73,U'('0m!
6,$)O7'()4! CS')'! 6O)*,7'()! /('! )O(';+! %$6('/)%$9;+! -O;;+! (')3,$)%R;'! -,(! *S'%(!
6,$)O73*%,$! 6S,%6')! X<S/$Q/(! '*! /;4?! =FFIY\! ),7'*%7')! *S'+! '&'$! 6,$)*(O6*! X%$!
7/*'(%/;?!%$*';;'6*O/;!/$0!/--'6*%&'!*'(7)Y!*S'%(!,U$!6,$)O73*%,$!3(,0O6*)!Xf'/*!
'*! /;4?! "EEGY4! 573,U'('0! 6,$)O7'()! 6/$! 6,$*(,;! ),7'! 7/(Q'*%$9! &/(%/R;')?!
')3'6%/;;+!*S,)'!(';/*'0!*,!6,77O$%6/*%,$)!';'7'$*)!,-!7/(Q'*%$9!7%L4!CS/*!U/+!
*S'+! 6/$! %$-;O'$6'! S,U! ,*S'(! 6,$)O7'()! 9'*! %$! *,O6S! U%*S! *S'! ,--'(%$9?! /--'6*%$9!
*S'! -%$/;! 3'(6'3*%,$! ,-! *S'! 3(,0O6*?! *S'! R(/$0?! *S'! 6,73/$+! /$0! *S'! /)),6%/*'0!
7'/$%$9)4! WS'$'&'(! *S'! (,;'! ,-! *S'! 6,77O$%*+! %$! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! J! /)! %$! *S'!
'L/73;'!,-![,O$*'(1)*(%Q'!J!%)!)*(,$9'(!/$0!%*!R'6,7')!*S'!$'U!%$*'(;,6O*,(!,-!*S'!
-%(7?!(/*S'(!*S/$!*S'!)%$9;'!6O)*,7'(!XaO/0(/$*!GY!Xg'33')'$!/$0!8,;%$?!=FF@Y?!*S'!
-%(7V)!'--,(*!*,!6,$*(,;!*S'!&/;O'!6('/*'0!%$6('/)'!/$0!)3'6%-%6!%$6'$*%&')!S/&'!*,!R'!
0'&';,3'0!*,!)S/('!*S'!6,13(,0O6*%,$!,O*6,7')4!!
CS'! 3%6*O('! %)! 6,73;%6/*'0! R+! *S'! -/6*! *S/*! lA$%123#&1( >$&:( *33'5#&*'""<( '%6(
4&$62,#(*33'5#&*'"(4&$62,51('1('(4&#,$%6*5*$%(5?'5(6$#1(%$5(*34"<('%<(*%5#&',5*$%(
>*5?(5?#($&@'%*F'5*$%($0(4&$62,5*$%m!X[,&/!/$0!2/;;%?!=FFE?!34!@@FY4!CS/*!7'/$)!*S/*!
*S'!-%(7!7/+!R'!;/(9';+!O$/U/('!,-!%73,(*/$*!3/(*!,-!*S'!%77/*'(%/;!U,(Q!0,$'!R+!
6,$)O7'()!X6O)*,7'()!/$0!$,$16O)*,7'()Y!O$*%;!),7'*S%$9!7/Q')!*S'7!%$*'(/6*!
%$!),7'!U/+4!!
CS'! /(9O7'$*)! 0%)6O))'0! /R,&'! )S,U! *S/*! *S'! -%(716'$*'('0! 3'()3'6*%&'! ,$!
S,U!*,!'$9/9'!*S'!6O)*,7'(!-,(!R'$'-%*!/33(,3(%/*%,$!%)!%$!aO')*%,$4!B$!3/(*%6O;/(?!
U'! R';%'&'! *S/*! /! R/;/$6'! R'*U''$! *%9S*;+! 6,$*(,;;'0! /$0! ;,,)'! 6,13(,0O6*%,$!
(';/*%,$)! 7O)*! R'! ('/6S'0?! /$0! *S%)! %)! /;),! %$! ;%$'! U%*S! 3('&%,O)! (')'/(6S!
X2/$$'';)?! =FF@Y4! <*(,$9! 7O*O/;! 0'3'$0'$6+! /$0! 3/(*%/;! 7O*O/;! 0'*'(7%$/*%,$!
! =@!
/7,$9! ';'7'$*)! /('! %$! -/6*! 6S/(/6*'()! ,-! *%9S*! /$0! ;,,)'! 6,O3;%$9! Xe(*,$! /$0!
W'%6Q?!"EEFYM!*S'+!7O)*!R'!7/$/9'0!%$!,(0'(!*,!/&,%0!0'*(%7'$*/;!6,$)'aO'$6')?!
)O6S!/)!(')*(%6*'0!)*(/*'9%6!&%)%,$!/$0!S,)*%;'!('/6*%,$)!R+!*S'!7/(Q'*4!!
B$!-/6*?!)*(%6*!-,(7)!,-!6,$*(,;!6/$!;'/0!*,!*S'!6$2="#(#K4"$*5'5*$%!0')6(%R'0!R+!
[,&/!/$0!./6'!X=FFIY4!CS'!-%()*!;'&';!%)!%$!*S'!-,(7!,-!O)%$9!*S'!6,$)O7'()V!U,(Q!%$!
,(0'(! *,! %$6('/)'! *S'! R(/$0V)! ;%$Q%$9! &/;O'! X-,(! 'L/73;'?! S,)*%$9! 6,$)O7'()V!
6,77O$%*%')! 7'7R'()! 3'(),$/;! 6,$*'$*)! ;%Q'! 3,)*)! /$0! 7/*'(%/;)! *S/*! S,;0!
)3'6%-%6!&/;O'Y\!*S'!)'6,$0!%)!0,$'!R+!('1/33(,3(%/*%$9!*S'!6,$)O7'()V!3(,0O6*%,$!
3,)%$9! 6,3+(%9S*! 6,$0%*%,$)! ,$! *S'! /R,&'! 7'$*%,$'0! U,(Q! %$! ,(0'(! *,! O)'! %*!
'L6;O)%&';+!%$!%*)!R(/$0%$9!)*(/*'9+4!B-!*S'!-%(7!6,$*(,;)!*,,!7O6S!*S'!6,13(,0O6*%,$!
3(,6'))!7/+!$,*!R'!/R;'!*,!'L3;,('!*S'!3,*'$*%/;%*%')!,-!6O)*,7'()V!6,$*(%RO*%,$)!
X%4'4!7/$/9%$9!/!6,77O$%*+!0%('6*;+Y4!`*!*S'!)/7'!*%7'?!S,U'&'(?!/!;,,)'!(';/*%,$!
U%*S! 6O)*,7'()! 6/$! ('0O6'! -%(7V)! 6/3/6%*+! *,! ,R*/%$! 7/*'(%/;! /$0! %77/*'(%/;!
R'$'-%*)! ,(?! '&'$! U,()*?! *,! 7%)%$*'(3('*! *S'! '--'6*%&'! (')O;*)! ,-! US/*! *S'! 6,1 3(,0O6*%,$!S/)!3(,0O6'04!!!!
%
&#'2)1.3#'.4%3$?)32;(3#'.%;'+%61(1"*%"*.*;"2C%
#)%$9! *S'! &/(%/R;')! S%9S;%9S*'0! %$! *S'! 3('&%,O)! 3/(/9(/3S)?! U'! %0'$*%-+! /!
6,73;'7'$*/(%*+! R'*U''$! 0%--'('$*! ;%*'(/*O('! )*('/7)! %$! S';3%$9! 'L3;/%$%$9! *S'!
$/*O('!,-!6,13(,0O6*%,$!3(,6'))')!/$0!U'!6/$!0(/U!/!6,73('S'$)%&'!/33(,/6S!*,!
6,13(,0O6*%,$4!K%()*?!U'!0%)*%$9O%)S'0!R'*U''$!%$0%&%0O/;!/$0!),6%/;!3/(*%6%3/*%,$!
*,!6,13(,0O6*%,$?!R+!S%9S;%9S*%$9!S,U!*,!%$*'9(/*'!*S'!*U,!3'()3'6*%&')!/$0!S,U!
*S'+!/--'6*!6,13(,0O6*%,$!)*(O6*O('!/$0!R'$'-%*!0%)*(%RO*%,$4!<'6,$0?!U'!'$(%6S!*S'!
3%6*O('!3(,&%0'0!R+!*S'!;%*'(/*O('!%$6;O0%$9!%$!*S%)!-(/7'U,(Q!/$,*S'(!%73,(*/$*!
! =G!
&/(%/R;'M! *S'! ;'&';! ,-! 6O)*,7'(V)! %$&,;&'7'$*4! W'! /(9O'! *S/*! *S'! %$*'$)%*+! ,-!
6,$)O7'()V!3/(*%6%3/*%,$!6/$!&/(+!/!;,*!0'3'$0%$9!,$!*S'!6,77%*7'$*!*S'+!S/&'!%$!
*S'! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! 3(,6'))')4! CS%)! ';'7'$*! 9'$'(/*')! 6,$)'aO'$6')! ,$! *S'! 6,1 3(,0O6*%,$! /$0! )3'6%-%6/;;+! ,$! S,U! 6O)*,7'()! /$0! -%(7)! 6/$! */Q'! 6,$*(,;! *S'!
,O*6,7')!/$0!*S'!R'$'-%*)4!!
CS'! 7/*(%L! U'! 3(,3,)'! /;;,U)! 3,)%*%,$%$9! *S'! 0%--'('$*! )%*O/*%,$! ,-! 6,1 3(,0O6*%,$! /$0! *S'! R/;/$6'! ,-! R'$'-%*)! R'*U''$! -%(7)! /$0! 6O)*,7'()4! d+!
O$0'()*/$0%$9! *S'! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! $/*O('! /)! U';;! /)! *S'! ;'&';! ,-! %$&,;&'7'$*! ,-!
6O)*,7'()! *S'! -%(7! 6/$! ,O*;%$'! /$! /33(,3(%/*'! 7/(Q'*%$9! )*(/*'9+4! B$! 6,73;'L!
)+7R,;%6!/$0!),6%/;!6,13(,0O6*%,$!)'**%$9)?!*S'!;,,)'(!*S'!(';/*%,$)S%3)!XR'*U''$!
*S'! -%(7! /$0! *S'! 6,$)O7'(! )3S'('Y! *S'! )*(,$9'(! *S'! -%(7V)! '--,(*! %$! /6S%'&%$9!
R'$'-%*)!-(,7!6,13(,0O6*%,$4!!
CS'!'7'(9%$9!6/*'9,(+!,-!q'L%9'$*!'73,U'('0!6,$)O7'()V!%)!6S/;;'$9%$9!-%(7)V!
7/(Q'*%$9! /$0! 3(,0O6*%,$! 6/3/R%;%*%')?! RO*! %)! $,*! $'6'))/(%;+! ,$;+! 6(%*%6/;4! CS'+!
U,(Q!-,(!*S'%(!R'$'-%*?!RO*!(/*S'(!*S/$!6S/;;'$9%$9!-%(7V)!/O*S,(%*+?!*S'+!6/;;!-,(!/!
$'U! (,;'! ,-! *S'! -%(7?!/;),! 6('/*%$9! $'U! 7/(Q'*! ,33,(*O$%*%')4! CS,)'! 6,77%**'0!
6O)*,7'()!/('!/R;'!*,!%$0'3'$0'$*;+!0'&';,3!3(,0O6*)!/$0!7'/$%$9)!Xd/;0U%$!'*!
/;4!=FFI\!KO';;'(!/$0!&,$!^%33';?!=FF>Y!*S/*!6/$!'&'$!R'!3(,3,)'0!*,!*S'!7/(Q'*!R+!
0%)%$*'(7'0%/*%$9! *S'! (,;'! ,-! -%(74! B$! *S%)! 6/)'?! -(,7! 3/))%&'! /$0! )OR,(0%$/*'0!
3;/+'()?! 6O)*,7'()! X/$0! 6,77O$%*+Y! R'6,7'! 3,*'$*%/;! -%(7V)! 3/(*$'(! X%4'4! .%)/$,!
/$0!:'(9/$*%?!=FF>Y4!!
CS'!3/3'(!S/)!/;),!;%7%*/*%,$)?!)%$6'!),7'!%73,(*/$*!*,3%6)!S/&'!R''$!'L6;O0'0!
-(,7!*S'!3(')'$*!&'()%,$4!W'!R';%'&'!*S/*!-O(*S'(!(')'/(6S!'--,(*)!7/+!R'!0'&,*'0!
*,!*S'!/$/;+)%)!,-!*S'!(,;'!,-!6,$)O7'()!/)!('),O(6'!%$*'9(/*,()!XPO)6S!/$0!:/(9,?!
! =A!
=FFI?!34!=>@\!d/(,$!/$0!^/((%)?!=FF>Y?!U%*S!3/(*%6O;/(!/**'$*%,$!*,!*S'!,$')!US,!
/6*!/)!9/*'Q''3'()!%$!(';/*%,$!*,!%73,(*/$*!3S+)%6/;?!),6%/;!/$0!6O;*O(/;!('),O(6')!
-,(!*S'!-%(7!X`($,O;0!'*!/;4?!=FFIY4!B$!-/6*?!*S'!;/**'(!R(%09'!3(%7/(+!/$0!)'6,$0/(+!
;'&';)!,-!),6%/;%*+!%$*,!*S'!6,13(,0O6*%,$!/$0!O$;,6Q!*,!*S'!-%(7!*S'%(!$'*U,(Q)!,-!
(';/*%,$)S%3)! U%*S! ,*S'(! 6O)*,7'()! /$0! J! 7,)*! %73,(*/$*! J! $,$16O)*,7'()! X%4'4!
K%6S*'(?!=FFEY4!!
KO(*S'(7,('?!6O)*,7'()!7/+!(';+!,$!*S'%(!3'(),$/;!$'*U,(Q)!*,!('%$-,(6'!*S'%(!
6,$*(%RO*%,$)!*,!*S'!6,13(,0O6*%,$!R,*S!%$!*'(7)!,-!,O*3O*)!/$0!R'$'-%*)4!^,U'&'(?!
;%*'(/*O('!S/)!$,*!-O;;+!6,$)%0'('0!*S'!(';'&/$6'!,-!$,$16,$)O7'()!%$!*S'!,&'(/;;!
6,13(,0O6*%,$! 3(,6'))')! +'*4! Z'6'$*! 6,$)%0'(/*%,$! ,-! *S'! %73,(*/$6'! ,-! ),6%/;!
$'*U,(Q)!6,$)O7'()!-,(!*S'!,O*6,7')!,-!6,13(,0O6*%,$!3(,6'))')!O$0'(;%$'!1!,$!
*S'! 6,$*(/(+! 1! *S'! %73,(*/$6'! ,-! $,$16,$)O7'()! *S/*! /('! %$! 6,$*/6*! U%*S!
6,$)O7'()!,-!/!3/(*%6O;/(!3(,0O6*!,(!)'(&%6'4!`*!*S%)!('9/(0?!*S'!(,;'!,-!6,$)O7'()!
/)!('),O(6')!%$*'9(/*,()!,-!X$,$1Y!6,$)O7'()!%)!/!6(%*%6/;!*,3%6!%$!('6'$*!;%*'(/*O('!
/$0!)S,O;0!R'!-O(*S'(!/$/;+T'04!
K%$/;;+?! *S'! %73,(*/$6'! ,-! '$*('3('$'O(%/;! (%)Q! X-(,7! *S'! 7/(Q'*! /$0!
*'6S$,;,9%6/;! )%0')Y! %$! &/;O/*%$9! *S'! 0%)*(%RO*%,$! ,-! 6,13(,0O6*%,$! R'$'-%*)! 1!
')3'6%/;;+!-,(!6,;;/R,(/*%&'!%$$,&/*%,$!1!%)!*,!R'!-O(*S'(!%$&')*%9/*'04!
% D#(*.%
"% 5&'$! *S,O9S! *S'('! %)! /! ;/(9'! 0'R/*'! %$! 7/(Q'*%$9! )*O0%')! 6,$6'($%$9! *S'!
7/$/9'(%/;! 0%)*%$6*%,$! R'*U''$! 3(,0O6*! /$0! )'(&%6'! X-,(! /$! ,&'(&%'U! )''! :/(9,!
/$0!PO)6S?!=FFG/!/$0!=FFGR!/$0!*S'!8/(Q'*%$9!CS',(+!)3'6%/;!%))O'!,$!)'(&%6'1 0,7%$/$*!;,9%6!&,;O7'!IX@Y\!-,(!/$!/;*'($/*%&'!&%'U!)''!<*/O))?!=FFAY?!%$!*S'!3/3'(!
! =I!
U'! U%;;! O)'! *S'! *'(7! l3(,0O6*m! R+! %$6;O0%$9! R,*S! *S'! 7/*'(%/;! /$0! %77/*'(%/;!
0%7'$)%,$)!,-!-%(7V)!,O*3O*)!X[,&/?!"EEH\!^,;R(,,Q?!"E>HY4%
%
E*6*"*'2*.%
`SO&%/?! `4! [4! X=FFAY! qd'+,$0! *S'! 'L*'$0'0! )';-M! P,&'0! ,Rc'6*)! /$0! 6,$)O7'()V!
%0'$*%*+!$/((/*%&')V?!L$2&%'"($0(A$%123#&(.#1#'&,?!@=M!"H"1">G4!
`($,O;0?!54g4?!.(%6'!P4P4!/$0!8/;)6S'?!`4!X=FFIY!qC,U/(0!/!6O;*O(/;!('),O(6'1R/)'0!
*S',(+!,-!*S'!6O)*,7'(V?!%$!PO)6S?!Z4K4!/$0!:/(9,?!<4P4!X'0)Y?!B?#(1#&/*,#86$3*%'%5(
"$@*,($0(3'&:#5*%@I(6*'"$@M(6#='5#('%6(6*&#,5*$%1?!334!@=F1@@@4!
d/0,*?! e4! /$0! K%;)'(?! 84! X=FFHY! qZ'1'$6S/$*7'$*! ,-! ('*/%;%$94! C,U/(0! O*,3%/$!
%);/$0)V?!%$![/(r!`4?![,&/!d4!X'0)4Y!X=FFHY?!334!"II1">"4!
d/9,TT%?! Z4.4! X=FFFY! qe$! *S'! 6,$6'3*! ,-! %$*'$*%,$/;! ),6%/;! /6*%,$! %$! 6,$)O7'(!
R'S/&%,(V?!L$2&%'"($0(A$%123#&(.#1#'&,?!=HM!@>>1@EI4!
d/9,TT%?!Z4.4!/$0!2S,;/Q%/?!#484!X=FFIY!q`$*'6'0'$*)!/$0!3O(6S/)'!6,$)'aO'$6')!
,-!6O)*,7'(!3/(*%6%3/*%,$!%$!)7/;;!9(,O3!R(/$0!6,77O$%*%')V?!N%5#&%'5*$%'"(L$2&%'"(
$0(.#1#'&,?(*%(+'&:#5*%@!=@M!GA1I"!
d/;0U%$?![4?!^%'($'*S?![4!/$0!&,$!^%33';?!54!X=FFIY!q^,U!O)'(!%$$,&/*%,$)!R'6,7'!
6,77'(6%/;! 3(,0O6*)M! /! *S',('*%6/;! %$&')*%9/*%,$! /$0! 6/)'! )*O0+V?! .#1#'&,?( 4$"*,<!
@AM!"=E"1"@"@4!
d/(,$?! <4! /$0! ^/((%)?! f4! X=FF>Y! q[,$)O7'()! /)! ('),O(6'! %$*'9(/*,()V?! L$2&%'"( $0(
+'&:#5*%@(+'%'@#3#%5!=GX"1=YM!""@1"@F4!!
d%;9(/7?!:4?!d('7?!`4!/$0!:,%9*?!f4!X=FF>Y!q#)'(16'$*(%6!%$$,&/*%,$)!%$!$'U!3(,0O6*!
0'&';,37'$*!s!)+)*'7/*%6!%0'$*%-%6/*%,$!,-!;'/0!O)'()!S/($'))%$9!%$*'(/6*%&'!/$0!
! =H!
6,;;/R,(/*%&'!,$;%$'1*,,;)V?!N%5#&%'5*$%'"(L$2&%'"($0(N%%$/'5*$%(+'%'@#3#%5!"=X@YM!
G"E1GA>4!
d%*$'(?! 84g4?! K/(/$0/?! W4C4?! ^ORR'(*?! `4Z4! /$0! _'%*S/7;?! :4`4! X"EEHY! q[O)*,7'(!
6,$*(%RO*%,$)! /$0! (,;')! %$! )'(&%6'! 0';%&'(+V?! N%5#&%'5*$%'"( L$2&%'"( $0( E#&/*,#(
N%6215&<(+'%'@#3#%5!>X@YM"E@1=FA4!
[/(r?!`4!/$0![,&/?!d4!X'0)Y!X=FFHY!A$%123*%@ !K4#&*#%,#4!eL,$M!Z,O*;'09'4!
[';)%?! Z4P4! /$0! e;),$?! g4[4! X"E>>Y! qCS'! (,;'! ,-! %$&,;&'7'$*! %$! /**'$*%,$! /$0!
6,73('S'$)%,$!3(,6'))')V?(L$2&%'"($0(A$%123#&(.#1#'&,?!"AX<'3*'7R'(YM!="F1==G4!
[,&/?!d4!X"EEHY!q[,77O$%*+!/$0!6,$)O73*%,$4!C,U/(0)!/!0'-%$%*%,$!,-!*S'!;%$Q%$9!
&/;O'!,-!3(,0O6*!,(!)'(&%6')V?!!2&$4#'%(L$2&%'"($0(+'&:#5*%@!@"X@hGYM!=EH1@"I4!
[,&/?!d4!/$0![,&/?!:4!X=FF=Y!qC(%R/;!8/(Q'*%$9M!CS'!C(%R/;%)/*%,$!,-!<,6%'*+!/$0!B*)!
B73/6*! ,$! *S'! [,$0O6*! ,-! 8/(Q'*%$9V?! !2&$4#'% L$2&%'" $0 +'&:#5*%@! @IXAhIYM!
AEAJ!I=F4!!
[,&/?! d4! /$0! 2/;;%?! 24! X=FF>Y! qW,(Q%$9! 6,$)O7'()M! *S'! $'L*! )*'3! %$! 7/(Q'*%$9!
*S',(+bV?!+'&:#5*%@(5?#$&<!EX@YM!@"A1@@E4!
[,&/?! d4?! f,T%$'*)?! Z4:4! /$0! <S/$Q/(?! `4! X=FFHY! A$%123#&( B&*=#14! dO(;%$9*,$?! 8`M!
dO**'(U,(*S1^'%$'7/$$4!
[,&/?! d4! /$0! ./6'?! <4! X=FFIY! qd(/$0! 6,77O$%*+! ,-! 6,$&'$%'$6'! 3(,0O6*)M! $'U!
-,(7)! ,-! 6O)*,7'(! '73,U'(7'$*! 1! *S'! 6/)'! t7+! jO*';;/! CS'! [,77O$%*+tV?!
!2&$4#'%(L$2&%'"($0(+'&:#5*%@!GF!XEh"FYM!"F>H1""FA4!
2/S;/$0'(?!P4!/$0!8/9$O)),$?!84!X=FF>Y!q^,U!0,!-%(7)!7/Q'!O)'!,-!,3'$!),O(6'!
6,77O$%*%')bV?!9$%@(.'%@#(-"'%%*%@!G"MI=E1IGE4!
2Oc/(%'(?!84`4!X=FF>Y!9# 5&'/'*" 62 ,$%1$33'5#2&O()# +,)$ P #H'<I A$33#%5
%$21 (,$4&$62*1$%1 ,# Q2# %$21 ',?#5$%14!./(%)M!P/!2u6,O&'(*'4!!
! =>!
50&/(0)),$?!d4?!kO)*/-)),$?!`4?!f(%)*'$)),$?!.4?!8/9$O)),$?!.4!/$0!8/**S%$9?!g4!X'0)4Y!
X=FFIY! N%/$"/*%@( A215$3#&1( *%( R#>( E#&/*,#( )#/#"$43#%5?! <'(%')! ,$! C'6S$,;,9+!
8/$/9'7'$*!1!&,;4!""?!B73'(%/;![,;;'9'!.('))?!P,$0,$4!
K%6S*'(?!f4!X=FFEY!qB$$,&/*%,$![,77O$%*%')M!*S'!(,;'!,-!$'*U,(Q)!,-!3(,7,*,()!%$!
e3'$!B$$,&/*%,$V?!.S)(+'%'@#3#%5!@EXGYM!@AH1@H"4!
K(/$Q'?! j4! /$0! <S/S?! <4! X=FF@Y! q^,U! [,77O$%*%')! <O33,(*! B$$,&/*%&'! `6*%&%*%')M!
`$! 5L3;,(/*%,$! ,-! `))%)*/$6'! /$0! <S/(%$9! /7,$9! 5$01O)'()V?! .#1#'&,? -$"*,<!
@=X"YM!"AHJ!H>4!
KO';;'(?! g4! /$0! &,$! ^%33';?! 54! X=FF>Y! q[,)*;'))! [('/*%,$! ,-! <*(,$9! d(/$0)! R+! #)'(!
[,77O$%*%')M! B73;%6/*%,$)! -,(! .(,0O6'(1eU$'0! d(/$0)V?! +NB( E"$'%( E,?$$"( $0(
+'%'@#3#%5(T$&:*%@(-'4#&(GH">1F>?!<'3*'7R'(4(
Ki;;'(?! g4?! g/U'6Q%?! k4! /$0! 8iS;R/6S'(?! ^4! X=FFHY! qB$$,&/*%,$! 6('/*%,$! R+! ,$;%$'!
R/)Q'*R/;;!6,77O$%*%')V?!L$2&%'"($0(H21*%#11(.#1#'&,?!IFMIF1H"4!!
k%');'(?! 84! X=FFIY! q[,$)O7'(! k%-*! <+)*'7)V?! L$2&%'"( $0( A$%123#&( .#1#'&,?!
@@X=YM=>@1=EF4!
k(/$0%$'**%?! Z4! /$0! ./%,;/?! 84! X=FFGY! qB73'9$,?! /33('$0%7'$*,! '! &,6'! 0'%!
6,$)O7/*,(%! $'%! 3(,6'))%! 0%! /6aO%)*,V?! +*,&$S+',&$( +'&:#5*%@! @X2%6'7R('YMG>H1 AF=4!
k(n$(,,)?! [4! X=FF>Y! q<'(&%6'! P,9%6! Z'&%)%*'0M! WS,! [('/*')! :/;O'b! `$0! WS,! [,1 6('/*')bV?!!2&$4#'% H21*%#11 .#/*#>!=FXGYM!=E>J@"G4 !
^/((%)?! P4[4! /$0! e9R,$$/?! 54! X=FF@Y! qCS'! ,(9/$%T/*%,$! ,-! 7/(Q'*%$9M! `! )*O0+! ,-!
2'6'$*(/;%T'0?!2'&,;&'0?!/$0!2%)3'()'0!8/(Q'*%$9!/6*%&%*+V?!L$2&%'"($0(+'%'@#3#%5(
E526*#1!GFX=YM!G>@1A"=4!!
! =E!
^%()6S7/$?! 54! [4! /$0! ^,;R(,,Q?! 84! d4! X"E>=Y! q^'0,$%6! 6,$)O73*%,$M! '7'(9%$9!
6,$6'3*)?!7'*S,0)!/$0!3(,3,)%*%,$)V?!L$2&%'"($0(+'&:#5*%@!GIM!E=1"F"4!!
^,;R(,,Q?!84d4!X"E>HY!qWS/*!%)!6,$)O7'(!(')'/(6SbV?!L$2&%'"($0(A$%123#&(.#1#'&,?!
"GX"YM"=>1"@=4!
g'$Q%$)?!^4!X=FFIY!J'%1M(="$@@#&1('%6(@'3#&1O(!K4"$&*%@(4'&5*,*4'5$&<(,2"52!j'U!
v,(QM!j'U!v,(Q!#$%&'()%*+!.('))4!
g'33')'$?!P4d4!/$0!K('0'(%Q)'$?!P4!X=FFIY!qWS+!2,!#)'()![,$*(%RO*'!*,!K%(71S,)*'0!
#)'(! [,77O$%*%')b! CS'! [/)'! ,-! [,73O*'(16,$*(,;;'0! 8O)%6! B$)*(O7'$*)V?!
U&@'%*F'5*$%(E,*#%,#!"HX"YM!GAJI@4!
g'33')'$?!P4d4!/$0!8,;%$?!84g4!X=FF@Y!q[,$)O7'()!/)![,10'&';,3'()M!P'/($%$9!/$0!
B$$,&/*%,$!eO*)%0'!*S'!K%(7V?!B#,?%$"$@<(V%'"<1*1(S(E5&'5#@*,(+'%'@#3#%5!"AX@YM!
@I@1>G4!
g,S$)*,$?!Z4!/$0!g,$')?!.4!X=FF@Y?!q<'(&%6'!3(,0O6*%&%*+M!*,U/(0)!O$0'()*/$0%$9!*S'!
(';/*%,$)S%3!R'*U''$!,3'(/*%,$/;!/$0!6O)*,7'(!3(,0O6*%&%*+V?!N%5#&%'5*$%'"(L$2&%'"(
$0(-&$62,5*/*5<('%6(-#&0$&3'%,#(+'%'@#3#%5!A@X@YM!=F"1="@4!
f'/*?! Z4?! `R'(6(,7R%'?! j4! /$0! WS%*';'+?! j4! X'0)4Y! X"EEGY?! B?# V25?$&*5< $0 5?#
A$%123#&?!P,$0,$M!Z,O*;'09'4!
f';;'+?! <4W4?! 2,$$';;+! g(4?! g4^4! /$0! <Q%$$'(?! <4g4! X"EEFY! q[O)*,7'(! 3/(*%6%3/*%,$! %$!
)'(&%6'!3(,0O6*%,$!/$0!0';%&'(+V?!L$2&%'"($0(.#5'*"*%@!IIX@YM@"A1@@A4!
f,T%$'*)?!Z4:4!X"EEEY!q51C(%R/;%T'0!8/(Q'*%$9b!CS'!<*(/*'9%6!B73;%6/*%,$)!,-!:%(*O/;!
[,77O$%*%')!,-![,$)O73*%,$V?!!2&$4#'%(+'%'@#3#%5(L$2&%'"!"HX@YM!=A=1=IG4!
f,T%$'*)?! Z4:4?! ^'7'*)R'(9'(?! `4! /$0! g'$)'$! <6S/O?! ^4! X=FF>Y! qCS'! W%)0,7! ,-!
[,$)O7'(! [(,U0)M! [,;;'6*%&'! B$$,&/*%,$! %$! *S'! `9'! ,-! j'*U,(Q'0! 8/(Q'*%$9V?!
L$2&%'"($0(+',&$3'&:#5*%@!=>XGYM!@@E1@AG4!
! @F!
PO)6S?!Z4K4!/$0!:/(9,?!<4P4!X=FFIY!q<'(&%6'10,7%$/$*!P,9%6M!Z'/6*%,$)?!Z'-;'6*%,$)!
/$0!Z'-%$'7'$*)V?!+'&:#5*%@(B?#$&<!IX@YM!=>"J=>>4!
8/*S'U)?! Z4! /$0! W/6Q'(?! W4! X=FF>Y! T?'571( <$2&( 15$&<W( E5$&<5#""*%@( 5$( 3$/#(
3'&:#51M('26*#%,#M(4#$4"#M('%6(=&'%614!j'U!v,(QM!KC!.('))4!
86`;'L/$0'(?! g4^4?! <6S,O*'$?! g4W4! /$0! f,'$%9?! ^4K4! X=FF=Y! qdO%;0%$9! R(/$0!
6,77O$%*+V?!L$2&%'"($0(+'&:#5*%@!IIM!@>1AG4!
8O$%T?! `4! 84! /$0! ewkO%$$?! C4! X=FF"Y! qd(/$0! 6,77O$%*+V?! L$2&%'"( $0( A$%123#&(
.#1#'&,?(=HM!G"=1G@=4!
e(*,$?!g424!/$0!W'%6Q?!f454!X"EEFY!qP,,)';+!6,O3;'0!)+)*'7)M!/!('6,$6'3*O/;%T/*%,$V?!
V,'6#3<($0(+'%'@#3#%5(.#/*#>!"AX=YM!=F@!J!==@4!!
eOU'();,,*?! ^4! /$0! e0'Q'(Q'$1<6S(n0'(?! k4! X=FF>Y! qWS,V)! US,! %$! R(/$0!
6,77O$%*%')!J!/$0!US+bV?!!2&$4#'%(L$2&%'"($0(+'&:#5*%@!G=XAhIYM!AH"1A>A4!
eT'(?! 84! X=FFEY! qCS'! (,;')! ,-! 3(,0O6*! ;'/01O)'()! /$0! 3(,0O6*! 'L3'(*)! %$! $'U!
3(,0O6*!'&/;O/*%,$V?!.#1#'&,?(-$"*,<!@>M"@GF1"@GE4!
./+$'?!`4K4?!<*,(R/6Q/?!f4?!/$0!K(,U?!.4!X=FF>Y!q8/$/9%$9!*S'!6,16('/*%,$!,-!&/;O'V?!
L$2&%'"($0(5?#(V,'6#3<($0(+'&:#5*%@(E,*#%,#!@IM>@1EI4!
.'o/;,T/?!P4!/$0!:'$Q/*')S?!`4!X=FFIY!qKO(*S'(!'&,;&%$9!*S'!$'U!0,7%$/$*!;,9%6!,-!
7/(Q'*%$9M!-(,7!)'(&%6')!*,!*S'!),6%/;!6,$)*(O6*%,$!,-!7/(Q'*)V?!+'&:#5*%@(B?#$&<!
IX@YM!=EE1@"I4!
.%$'?! d4g4! /$0! k%;7,('?! g4^4! X"EEEY! B?# !K4#&*#%,# !,$%$3<I T$&: *1 B?#'5&#
'%6 !/#&< H21*%#11 ' E5'@#4!d,)*,$?!8`M!^/(&/(0!dO)%$'))!<6S,,;!.('))4!!
.%)/$,?!k4.4!/$0!:'(9/$*%?!Z4!X=FF>Y!qWS%6S!Q%$0!,-!6,;;/R,(/*%,$!%)!(%9S*!-,(!+,ObV?!
X'&/'&6(H21*%#11(.#/*#>!!2'6'7R'(M!H>1>I4!
! @"!
.(/S/;/0?![4!f4!X=FFGY!qCS'!6,16('/*%,$!,-!&/;O'!J!B$&%*'0!6,77'$*/(+V?!L$2&%'"($0(
+'&:#5*%@?!I>X"YM!=@4!
.(/S/;/0?! [4! f4! /$0! Z/7/)U/7+?! :4! X=FF@Y! qCS'! $'U! -(,$*%'(! ,-! 'L3'(%'$6'!
%$$,&/*%,$V?!+NB(E"$'%(+'%'@#3#%5(.#/*#>!GGM!"=1">4!
Z/7/)U/7+?! :4! X=FF>Y?! q[,16('/*%$9! &/;O'! *S(,O9S! 6O)*,7'()V! 'L3'(%'$6')M! *S'!
j%Q'!6/)'V?!E5&'5#@<(S(9#'6#&1?*4!@IXAYM!E1"G4!
Z/7]('T?!Z4!X"EEEY?!q:/;O'!6,13(,0O6*%,$M!%$*';;'6*O/;!,(%9%$)!/$0!%73;%6/*%,$)!-,(!
3(/6*%6'!/$0!(')'/(6SV?!E5&'5#@*,(+'%'@#3#%5(L$2&%'"!=FMGE1IA4!
</US$'+?! 84! /$0! .(/$0';;%?! 54! X=FFFY! q[,77O$%*%')! ,-! [('/*%,$M! 8/$/9%$9!
2%)*(%RO*'0! B$$,&/*%,$! %$! CO(RO;'$*! 8/(Q'*)V! A'"*0$&%*'( +'%'@#3#%5( .#/*#>!
G=X=YM!=G1AG4!
</US$'+?! 84?! :'(,$/?! k4! /$0! .(/$0';;%?! 54! X=FFAY! q[,;;/R,(/*%$9! *,! [('/*'M! CS'!
B$*'($'*!/)!/!.;/*-,(7!-,(