III.16.1 Definition
The eponymic designation “Spitz nevus” refers to a benign melanocytic proliferation, which was first described in 1948 by Sophie Spitz as
“melanoma of the childhood” [1]. Along with this original description, we presently consider as “classical” Spitz nevus a rapidly growing, pink or flesh-colored papule or nodule of the lower extremities or the face in childhood or early adulthood [2–6]. Its histopathological hallmark is the presence of large spindle and/or epithelioid cells, usually in the paucity or ab- sence of melanin.
“Reed nevus” is another eponymic designa- tion for a benign melanocytic lesion described by Reed et al. in 1975 as “pigmented spindle cell nevus” [7]. It is mostly found in young adults on the lower extremities as a rapidly growing brownish-black macule or papule [7]. Histo- pathologically, it is described as made up by in- terconnecting junctional fascicles of heavily pigmented spindle cells [4, 7]. The nosological
Chapter III.16
Spitz Nevus and Its Variants
Gerardo Ferrara, Elvira Moscarella, Caterina M. Giorgio,
Giuseppe Argenziano III.16
Contents
III.16.1 Definition . . . .151
III.16.2 Clinical Features . . . .152
III.16.3 Dermoscopic Criteria . . . .153
III.16.4 Relevant Clinical Differential Diagnosis . . . .158
III.16.5 Histopathology . . . .159
III.16.6 Management . . . .160
References . . . 161
autonomy of Reed nevus from Spitz nevus has been questioned since 1978, when Paniago- Pereira et al. [8] underlined the occurrence of cases of spindle and/or epithelioid cell nevi with heavy pigmentation, thereby ascribing Reed ne- vus to the morphological spectrum of Spitz ne- vus. At present, some authors still maintain that Reed nevus is an entity that can be clearly dif- ferentiated from pigmented spindle cell Spitz nevus [9–15]; however, a clinicopathological evaluation of a large case series has recently shown that the histopathological distinction be- tween these two diagnostic categories is often matter of great debate and has no clinical and dermoscopic relevance [16]. We can therefore refer to Spitz nevus by classifying it into two clinical variants, namely, the classical and the pigmented types (the latter also comprising Reed nevus).
Indisputably, some melanomas histopatho- logically resemble Spitz nevi to various extent [4]. When such similarities are striking from both an architectural and a cytological point of view the term “spitzoid melanoma” is justified [17]. A morphological spectrum of melanomas with “spitzoid” features probably exists, in which one end shows lesions with overtly atypi- cal histopathological features, i.e., lesions which are readily identified as malignant on histo- pathological examination At the opposite edge of this spectrum, one can conceivably find (rare) cases which can be diagnosed as malignant only retrospectively, i.e., after the development of metastases [17–19]. These lesions have been first referred to as “spindle cell and epithelioid cell nevi with atypia and metastasis” or “malignant (metastasizing) Spitz nevi” [19], and subse- quently as “atypical Spitz nevi/tumors” [18].
They could be considered as neoplasms with
152 G. Ferrara, E. Moscarella, C.M. Giorgio et al.
III.16
“bland” histopathological features and meta- static potential limited to the regional lymph nodes [18–20]. The common (although not in- variable) absence of further dissemination be- yond the regional lymph nodes has even raised the question about the true malignant nature of the lymph node “implants” from spitzoid neo- plasms [21]. At present, however, we have no convincing scientific data which can allow to really challenge the dogma of the metastasis as an unequivocal sign of malignancy [22, 23].
The concept of an “intermediate” category of spitzoid lesions placed in between benignity and malignancy does not fit with the traditional di- chotomic (“benign vs malignant”) diagnostic approach to histopathology. According to this view, cases of “metastasizing nevi” are simply diagnostic errors, because the distinction be- tween Spitz nevi and melanoma, although sometimes difficult, can – and therefore must – be made [22, 24]. It is obvious, however, that such a “dual” diagnostic approach leads to lowering the diagnostic threshold for melano- ma – and therefore to overdiagnosing melano- ma – in order not to miss the histopathological recognition of metastasizing lesions with subtle histopathological clues to malignancy.
Ongoing molecular genetic studies on spit- zoid neoplasms seem to be a promising diagnos- tic tool. HRAS mutations/amplifications have been detected in 11.8% of Spitz nevi [25]. B-RAF and N-RAS mutations, which are frequently found in melanoma on skin without chronic sun damage [26], are consistently absent in Spitz nevi [27, 28] and probably expressed in a minor- ity of spitzoid melanomas [28]. These data sug- gest that spitzoid neoplasms probably have a different pathway to tumorigenesis than con- ventional types of nevi and melanomas.
III.16.2 Clinical Features
Spitz nevus is a solitary, round to oval, dome- shaped papule, measuring up to 1 cm in diame- ter. Its surface is smooth or keratotic/verrucous, and occasionally even papillomatous. Although initially described as a non-pigmented lesion [1], recent data underline that Spitz nevi are brown to black in 71.3–92.7% [16, 29] of histo- logically examined cases. Such a high frequency of pigmented variants in surgical series could be the result of a better clinical recognition due to dermoscopy (see below) coupled with a low ex- cision rate of classical “pink” Spitz nevi in chil- dren.
As a rule, a rapidly growing, pink or reddish lesion of the head/neck or (lower) limbs is the clinical presentation of classical Spitz nevus in children. A brown/black papule of the trunk or lower extremities is the common clinical picture of pigmented Spitz nevus in young adults [5, 30, 31]; transitional clinical features are also possi- ble. Large (>1 cm) nodular and/or ulcerated le- sions must be always regarded as worrisome even in childhood [32, 23].
Rare congenital cases have been reported [33, 34]. A halo phenomenon has also been described [35]. Multiple, and sometimes eruptive [36], Spitz nevi can present in a clustered (agminated) [37] or a disseminated pattern [38]. Agminated Spitz nevi can also occur within a background (diffuse) hyperpigmentation [39] or within a speckled lentiginous nevus [40].
Spitz nevi have a low recurrence rate, even
after incomplete excision [41]; however, some
cases of satellitosis [42] and giant nodule forma-
tion [43] have been reported following surgical
procedures. In our opinion, such unusual oc-
currences could be even in keeping with a low
(or very low) malignant potential of some of
these lesions.
Spitz Nevus and Its Variants Chapter III.16 153
III.16.3 Dermoscopic Criteria
Six main dermoscopic patterns can be ascribed to Spitz nevus, namely, vascular, globular, star- burst, reticular, atypical, and homogeneous [44].
Classical Spitz nevus (Fig. III.16.1) is an amelanotic or hypopigmented lesion with a vas- cular pattern composed of dotted vessels [45], which are responsible for its “definitional” pink color. Dotted vessels are monomorphic, regu- larly distributed throughout the lesion, often grouped and surrounded by regularly intersect- ing white lines, the so-called reticular depig- mentation (Fig. III.16.1). A slight pigmentation can be present as a diffuse brownish hue with
widely and regularly spaced gray-brown, small- to medium-sized globules.
In frankly pigmented lesions, globules are brown to black, large and regularly distributed at the periphery (Fig. III.16.2). In most cases of pigmented Spitz nevi, peripheral globules are fused with the central body of the lesion; these regular, “on focus” radial projections (so-called streaks) are responsible for a “starburst” appear- ance (Fig. III.16.3). In a minority of cases, a heavy pigmentation also gives rise to a regular black network, which rests above the lesion and can be removed by tape stripping (“superficial black network”; Fig. III.16.4) [46]. Several of these features can be simultaneously present and/or irregularly distributed within a given le-
Fig. III.16.1. a A pink lesion located on the thigh of a 27-year-old woman. Dermoscopically there is a negative pigment network (reticular depigmentation) with dot- ted vessels especially visible at the periphery. b A large, sharply circumscribed, plaque-like melanocytic lesion.
c A striking epidermal hyperplasia with junctional mela-
nocytic nests demarcated by half-moon peripheral clefts
(“capping”). d At a higher magnification large Kamino
bodies are seen within the epidermis
154 G. Ferrara, E. Moscarella, C.M. Giorgio et al.
III.16
Fig. III.16.2. a A small pigmented plaque located on
the arm of a 23-year-old man. Dermoscopically this is a
symmetric lesion with striking brown to black globules
especially visible at the periphery and grayish pigmenta-
tion in the center. b A medium-sized, well-demarcated,
plaque-like melanocytic lesion. c An epidermal hyper-
plasia with “capping” of junctional nests. d Same features
at the opposite side of the lesion. e Periadnexal extension
of the melanocytic nests, a microscopic feature which
Spitz nevus shares with congenital nevus as well as with
melanoma
Spitz Nevus and Its Variants Chapter III.16 155
sion, thus giving an atypical or “melanoma-like”
pattern. Dermoscopic atypia can also be in- creased by virtue of the presence of a blue-whit- ish veil as a result of a deep dermal pigmenta- tion with an overlying epidermal hyperplasia (Fig. III.16.5).
The “starburst,” the “globular,” and the
“atypical” patterns are the most common der- moscopic findings in surgical series of Spitz ne- vus [16]; however, most of these different der- moscopic patterns simply correspond to different phases of the natural evolution of Spitz nevi. Pizzichetta et al. [47] clearly demonstrated
that a pigmented Spitz nevus can rapidly evolve from a globular pattern to a “starburst” pattern, and finally to a homogeneous pattern; the latter is characterized by a diffuse brown or dark brown color, which resembles a common der- mal nevus (Fig. III.16.6). Parenthetically, some
“dermal” nevi show that a homogeneous light- brown pattern could be the end phase of classi- cal Spitz nevi. On the other hand, the final stage in the natural evolution of Spitz nevi might also be represented by a complete involution of the lesion (personal observation).
Fig. III.16.3. a A small hyperpigmented plaque located on the thigh of a 43-year-old man. A starburst pattern is clearly visible by dermoscopy. b A small- to medium- sized, sharply circumscribed, plaque-like melanocytic proliferation with a symmetric distribution of the mela-
nin pigment. c A slight epidermal hyperplasia with junc-
tional nests of melanocytes shows no sharp separation
from the nearby keratinocytes. d At a higher magnifica-
tion, the spindle morphology of junctional melanocytes
is evident
156 G. Ferrara, E. Moscarella, C.M. Giorgio et al.
III.16
Fig. III.16.4. a A small black macule dermoscopically typified by a starburst pattern with clearly visible super- ficial black network. b A small melanocytic proliferation with “skip” pigmented parakeratosis. c A slight epidermal hyperplasia with a “plug” of pigmented parakeratosis
above a junctional nest of melanocytes. d At a higher
magnification, junctional melanocytes appear spindle-
shaped. Some melanophages are intermingled within
nests, a microscopic feature which is often observed in
Reed nevus
Spitz Nevus and Its Variants Chapter III.16 157
Fig. III.16.5. a Irregularly pigmented plaque located on
the thigh of a 12-year-old girl. Dermoscopically there
is asymmetry in color and structure, blue-white veil
in the center, and brown globules and dotted vessels at
the periphery. b A medium-sized, dome-shaped, and
symmetric melanocytic proliferation. c, d The lesion is
sharply demarcated at both its edges. e An epidermal
hyperplasia with junctional nests of spindle-shaped
melanocytes. Some focal “capping” is also evident
158 G. Ferrara, E. Moscarella, C.M. Giorgio et al.
III.16
III.16.4 Relevant Clinical Differential Diagnosis
Classical Spitz nevus must be differentiated from viral wart, verrucous epidermal nevus, capillary hemangioma, pyogenic granuloma, angiolymphoid hyperplasia with eosinophilia, and lymphoid infiltration of the skin. It has been underlined that dotted vessels seen on der- moscopy are generally predictive for a melano- cytic lesion and are especially seen in Spitz ne- vus [45]. The uniform shape and distribution of dotted vessels can also help in differentiating classical Spitz nevus from amelanotic melano- ma. It must be emphasized, however, that no
dermoscopic criterion can allow such a differ- ential diagnosis with absolute reliability.
Differential diagnosis of pigmented Spitz ne- vus can include “globular” and “hypermelanot- ic” Clark nevus and melanoma. Brown globules of Clark nevus are usually smaller and regularly distributed throughout the entire surface of the lesion [48, 49]. Hypermelanotic (“black”) nevus is characterized by a central diffuse hyperpig- mentation (black lamella) and dark-brown net- work at the periphery of the lesion. Tape strip- ping removes the black lamella, but not the pigment network, as observed in rare cases of pigmented Spitz nevus [46]. Atypical pigment network, irregular dots and globules, irregular
Fig. III.16.6. a A small black papule located on the arm of a 21-year-old woman. At dermoscopy a homogeneous pattern is seen, with brown to blue-gray structureless pigmentation. b A medium-sized, sharply circumscri bed, and symmetric melanocytic proliferation with dermal melanophages distributed in a band-like fashion.
c A moderate, regular epidermal hyperplasia with regu-
larly distributed junctional nests of melanocytes. d Me-
lanocytes within the junctional nests are spindle-shaped,
often with some dendritic processes, a feature which can
be observed in early Reed nevus
Spitz Nevus and Its Variants Chapter III.16 159
pigmentation, irregular streaks, and blue whit- ish veil are specific dermoscopic criteria of mel- anoma [48, 49]; however, the occurrence of an atypical dermoscopic pattern in Spitz nevus is well recognized [16], as is the occurrence of mel- anomas showing very few or no dermoscopic features suggestive of malignancy but exhibit- ing either the globular or the starburst pattern [50]. Remarkably, melanomas with “spitzoid”
dermoscopic features do not necessarily show
“spitzoid” histopathological features [16]. The substantial lack of reliable differential criteria from melanoma must always be taken into ac- count in the management of Spitz nevus (see below).
III.16.5 Histopathology
Spitz nevus is a neoplastic proliferation of mela- nocytes with large nuclei, prominent nucleoli, and abundant ground-glass cytoplasm with spindle and/or polygonal (epithelioid) outlines.
Its early intraepidermal growth phase is charac- terized by predominance of single melanocytes with some suprabasilar scatter, commonly con- fined to the lower layers of the epidermis (“pag- etoid” Spitz nevus [51] or “baby” Spitz nevus).
There can be a slight asymmetry, but some nest formation is evident even in small lesions.
Junctional, or predominantly junctional, Spitz nevus is a plaque-shaped, sharply demar- cated lesion composed mostly of sharply demar- cated melanocytic nests within a hyperplastic epidermis. Nests are equally sized, shaped, and spaced at the junction. Typically, some of them can undergo a transepidermal elimination. A periadnexal junctional component is very com- mon. Melanocytes are arranged perpendicular and parallel to the skin surface. They are highly cohesive and do not destroy the nearby kerati- nocytes; therefore, a semilunar cleavage is often evident around nests (“capping”) and even around the few single intraepidermal melano- cytes (“micro-capping”). Large and coalescent eosinophilic (Kamino) bodies may be found at the dermo-epidermal junction [52] and telangi- ectatic blood vessels can be seen in the superfi- cial dermis. Melanin pigment is common within spindle cells and dermal melanophages; howev-
er, even epithelioid melanocytes [53], as well as single intraepidermal dendritic melanocytes [54], can be pigmented. Finally, pigmented parakeratosis can be present in an ordered
“skip” fashion [46].
Neoplasms defined as Reed nevus are com- posed of heavily pigmented, monomorphic, small- to medium-sized spindle melanocytes, arranged mainly parallel to the skin surface.
Junctional nests typically show no sharp demar- cation from the overlying epidermis, with the latter showing only little hyperplasia. A band- like dermal infiltration of melanophages is a common ancillary finding [7–15].
Compound Spitz nevus is a dome-shaped le- sion with a dermal component composed of regularly spaced nests and cords of cells. Some maturation is at least focally seen and mitoses may be easily seen, but never as atypical figures and never close to the base of the lesion. Intra- vascular melanocytes can be detected and are not an ominous sign per se [4].
Dermal Spitz nevus is a dome-shaped or flat lesion which is often characterized by extensive desmoplasia encircling single melanocytes. Its overall picture can closely resemble dermatofi- broma [55]. The neoplasm described as “desmo- plastic nevus” [56] is probably related to desmo- plastic Spitz nevus. A plexiform arrangement of bundles and lobules of melanocytes has been described (plexiform Spitz nevus [4]). A promi- nent vasculature may also be seen (angiomatoid Spitz nevus [57]).
At present, an unequivocal and reproducible definition for “atypical Spitz nevus” and “atypi- cal Spitz(oid) tumor” is probably lacking [22, 24]. In general, these diagnostic categories can be used for lesions showing some distinctly ab- normal characteristics commonly absent in
“conventional spitzoid” lesions [17]. In a meta-
analysis based on 19 papers reporting 62 metas-
tasizing spitzoid neoplasms, an aggressive bio-
logical behavior was recorded even for lesions
showing only one of the following nine “atypi-
cal” features: (a) nodular dermal growth (solid
cellular sheets within the dermis); (b) deep ex-
tension with absent or impaired maturation; (c)
deep dermal mitoses; (d) marked nuclear/nucle-
olar pleomorphism; (e) heavy melanization in
depth; (f) asymmetry; (g) cellular necrosis; (h)
160 G. Ferrara, E. Moscarella, C.M. Giorgio et al.
III.16
epithelioid epidermal melanocytes below para- keratosis and/or epidermal ulceration; and (i) neoplastic cells within the lymph vessels [58].
One can therefore conclude that even the pres- ence of one of the above-listed features is prob- ably enough for ascribing a given spitzoid lesion to an “intermediate” diagnostic category. We prefer to use the term “atypical spitzoid tumor”
for lesions which show a large nodular (“tumor- al”) dermal component, while leaving the term
“atypical Spitz nevus” to the remaining cases.
III.16.6 Management
The management of Spitz nevus must be decid- ed by considering the following issues:
1. Melanoma in childhood is exceedingly rare [59]; however, amelanotic melanoma surprisingly shows higher prevalence in children than in adults. Moreover, very large (>1 cm) and/or ulcerated spitzoid neoplasms of childhood can show sentinel lymph node metastases [23].
2. There are no reliable differential criteria between Spitz nevus and melanoma on dermoscopy [49, 50]. Actually, melano- mas showing Spitz nevus-like features on dermoscopy are not necessarily “spitzoid”
on histopathology [16].
Based on these considerations, a classical or pig- mented Spitz nevus appearing up to the age of 12 years [60] can be easily diagnosed and man- aged conservatively if it is relatively small (up to 1 cm) and shows no atypical clinical and der- moscopic features. Under these circumstances, a follow-up can be scheduled with controls ev- ery 6 months [60]. In the absence of dramatic changes in color, shape, or size, such a follow-up protocol can be held until the appearance of a homogeneous pattern. Afterward, a 1-year fol- low-up can be employed.
Large (>1 cm), ulcerated, rapidly changing, or otherwise atypical Spitz nevi of childhood must be excised. Surgical excision is also recom- mended when Spitz nevi appear in adulthood, regardless of the presence of atypical clinical/
dermoscopic features.
Every surgical excision must be carried out with a narrow (0.1 cm) margin. Diagnosis of atypical Spitz nevus/tumor requires further surgical procedures as suggested for melanoma [59].
Left: The lesion is mostly nested, mostly at the junction, with some irregular epidermal atrophy. Right: At the cen- ter of the lesion the epidermis is atrophic; the melanocyt- ic proliferation becomes more diffuse, with large sheets of cells separated by small amonts of collagen fibers
The lesion is a brownish, dome shaped papule with
smooth surface and regular borders. Dermoscopically
the lesion shows a central irregular grayish hyperpig-
mentation, and brown to black globules/dots irregularly
distributed throughout the lesion. Histopathogically, a
dome-shaped, sharply demarcated and symmetric mela-
nocytic proliferation is seen
Spitz Nevus and Its Variants Chapter III.16 161
C