Integrating BDD-based and SAT-based Symbolic Model Checking
10
0
0
Testo completo
(2) ..
(3)
(4) ! #"%$'&( "*)%+,.- /1032 -* 4 /65870:9; <=?>@A@ABDCFEHGAI*JLKNMOBQPRPRKTSVUFWXCYGAK?Z[I]\ K?^YCFZ`_YK?ab=?KcBbdDUfegBDG`Z1I]h:Kc@iPAIbGA>VSjUfegBDG`Z1I]klIQmb>GRKTSU klIbn>[GRPRI*op>nFBb@qPRKcBDCYKcrDUfBDCFEs<GAMOBDCFEHIOtBbZZ`_Y>[=?=?Bud v]wyx:z {|w~}bxuL b ! [iV`bpjjj xfiADibw|q VApjbf~ uj¡[D¢£Q¤¥£D¢¦Q¤£bV§[¨Q[£b¡[ª©«1b¬©«[ ® wyux°¯!±LVAi²«[ ; ³ ´b¬µA1j DL z ¶u²i ·bf·¸D`¹Q µA1j Dw|q [¤ºV£bVj¢~DQV§1¨·u£V»©|¼bV¡[©T½Vºu[»D¤¾©y[ ¿ ±VRi²«[ ³ ´ufxfi`Qiuu ÀDj ! 1ij`¹bHjV[!xfi`Qiuuw~q [ £b¡¤Áb¨D¡VV¤[ºu¤¾©|½jºu[jºª©y[ Â!þÄ`Å`Æ1ÇpÈÅjÉ QuÊHjË
(5) D´u`bËqÌ`ËqÍDuÎl² lVA«²«¶Ë`ËA`²«²yÏc¶uÏc[i! pVRiÐË· [{ ij*i`ËqÌuNÑQ¶ujpË` [²«²«Ë` %Ê ²«·´*j;Ò [« ® AË`²« ® N [Îq [ ²ÀÓTÒ ®® ²qÔRÕ }X`Ë``QiQ ÖuijÖH²«ip [²i [i²yÐH [Ê¥×Ó|bØ x:Ô i`ËqÌuNÑQ¶u`²!Ìp ·VOÊH``.Öui{ ÖH²«·´! ²
(6) lË` Ö¶uq 1ijp [Ê ²«²Ïc[
(7) ²yb ÊHË: D´uAËqÌ`ËqÍDuÎuD [p´ Öui1V`´ i ÊH [!AÙY`ËAiVL iAi [iVLi Ò ®® {|Êp ²«`´ iAËRÌuÑQ¶`²`Õjw¥ iÌ²Ö ÖHA Ú ²«Ìu1ÚÛÌ·ÚÛÒ ®® {~Ê ²«·´s p´suتx{|Êp ²«`´;i`ËqÌuNÑQ¶u`²Ìp ·VÀÊH`AAÙY`ËAiVA Qi`Îq 1i·´ Ú:iÌiÌuܶpÝÞ²yuÊHjË D´uAFËqÌAËRÍVR·Õ ß. àáXâHãYälåæ çâYèiäXá. e4IHEH>[=:Z`_Y>jZ`épKNCYa.êëuëbURìbíQî
(8) Kc@ B%ïTIuGRMOBD= PR>jZ`_YCYKcð^Y>ïTIbG PR_Y>]mu>[GAKñfZBQPAKNIuCgIDïLñFCYKNPR>O@iP`BQPA> @qòH@qPR>[MO@ó t_Y>s@qòH@qPR>Mn>[K?CYa°BbCFBD=?òpô[>jE°Kc@ GR>õYGR>j@q>CPR>EöBu@÷BgøK?CYKPA>opPABQPA>%egBuZ`_YK?CY> ù ø
(9) oHeûú1Uül_FKN=?> PR_F>÷GA>ð^YK?GR>M>CPA@PAI*nf>@RBDPRKc@iñf>E4BDGA> >1ýHõYGA>@A@R>EK?CPR>[M]õIbG`BD= =NIuabKcZ[@U >bó aFóJLIuM]õY^HPABDPRK?IbCþt GA>[>;ÿªIbabKcZ ù Jtlÿú·UIbGÿK?CY>BbG÷tª>M]õfIuGABb=LÿIuabKcZ ù ÿHtlÿú·óe4IHEH>[= Z`_Y>Z`épK?CYasBb=NauIbGAKPA_YMO@ÀBDGA>nfBb@R>E°IbC°PR_Y>]>1ýH_FBb^F@qPRK?mb>OBDCFBb=NòH@RK?@ IbïXPR_F>*@iP`BQPR>O@RõFBbZ[>]IDï PR_Y>øoYe ó¾t_Y>[òBDGA>÷BDnF=N>÷PRI*õYGAIQmb>!PR_FBDP PR_F> @Ròp@qPR>M @RBDPRKc@iñF>j@lPA_Y>÷GA>ð^YK?GR>M]>[CPUfIbGjU MIuGR>KNM]õIbGRPABbCuPA=NòuUHBDGA>BDnF=N>PRIõYGAIpEY^FZ1> B Z[Ib^YCPR>GR>[ýYBDM]õY=?>bUK~ó >bóHB nf>_FBVmpKNIu^YGLIbïPR_F> øoYe PA_FBQP mpK?Ib=cBQPR>j@ PR_Y>]GA>ð^YK?GR>M]>[CPA@ó¾e4IHEH>[=JL_F>Z`épKNCFa%Kc@ BDC.>1ýpPRGA>[M]>=Nòg> >jZ·PAKNmu> EH>[nY^FababK?CYa PR>jZ`_YCYKcðu^F>bUHBDCFE%Kc@Ln>[K?CYaOBDõFõY=NK?>E%K?Cs@R>[mu>[G`BD=¬BDõYõY=?KcZ[BQPAKNIuC%EHIuMOBDK?CF@[UpG`BDCYa KNCYasïTGAIbM PA_Y>OBDCFBb=NòH@RK?@ IDïLPR>=N>jZ1IbM]M ^YCYKcZ[BQPAKNIuCûõYGAIDPAIHZ1Ib=c@ PRIGR>jBbZ1PRK?mb> Z[IbCPRGAIb=?=?>[G`@PAI _FBDG`EHüBDGA> EH>j@qK?abCf@[ó ï q>1ýHõY=?KcZ1KNP «@iP`BQPR > GRK?abK?CFBD=?=?òbUXM]IHEH>= Z`_Y>jZ`épKNCYaÞüBu@*K?M]õY=N>M]>[CPR>jE npò×M]>BDCf@;Ib PR>Z`_FCYK?ð^Y>j@[UFül_Y>[GA> @qK?CYab=?> @iP`BQPA>@IDïPR_F>!øoYe BbGR> BbCFBD=?òpô[>EsBDCfEs@qPRIuGR>jE¾ó CY> IDïPR_F> MI@iP:CFIDPABbnY=?>l>1ýYBDM]õY=?>@
(10) Ibï>[ýHõY=NKcZ1KNP «@qPABQPA>lM]IpEY>[=fZ`_F>Z`épKNCFa Kc@XoH h
(11) êNë jîyUVPR_fBQPXKc@
(12) mb>GRò > >Z·PAKNmu>:K?CÀPR_Y>XBbCFBD=?òH@qKc@¬IDïYBu@qòpCFZ`_YGAIbCFIb^F@¬@Ròp@qPR>MO@[ó «C ab>[CF>[G`BD=¥U`ïTIbGMOBDCpòÀBDõYõF=NKcZ[BDPRK?IbC EHIbMOBDK?CF@U1PA_Y>:=cBDGAab>:BDM]Iu^YCPªIDïYZ1IuM]õY^HPABDPRK?IbCFBb=DGA>@RIb^YG`Z1>j@¬CY>[>jEH>EÀPAI BDCfBD=?òô>
(13) GR>jBD= y@RK?ô[> EH>@RKNauCF@ ù PR_F>@RI «Z[Bb=N=?>E4@qPABDPR> y>1ýHõY=?Iu@RK?IbC4õYGAIbnY=?>[M*úM]BVòn>B%@qK?abCFKñfZBDCP=?K?MKNPABDPRK?IbCó t_Y>]KNCPRGAIHEH^FZ1PRK?IbC.ID ï "! e4IHEH>=LJL_Y>Z`épK?CYa.êNë #Dî
(14) M]BuEH>]KP!õIu@A@RKNnY=?> PRI>1ýHõY=?IbGA> @iP`BQPR> @RõFBbZ[>@IDï >1ýpPRGA>[M]>[=?ò*=cBDGAab> @qK?ô[>u$ó «Cs@RòpM÷nIb=?K?ZM]IpEY>[=Z`_Y>jZ`éK?CYafUK?CF@qPR>jBbE%IDï MOB CYKNõF^Y=?BDPRK?CYaKNCFEYKNmpKcEH^FBD=¾@qPABDPR>@UuPR_Y> BD=?abIuGRKNPR_FM]@XMOBDCYK?õY^Y=cBQPA& > %('()"%
(15) IDï@iP`BQPR>j@[ópt_Y>j@q>ÀBDGA>.
(16) Z1IbM]õFBuZ·PA=NòsGR>õYGA>@R>[CPR>jEsBbCFE4>(*OZ[KN>CPR=?òsZ[IbCF@qPRGA^FZ·PA>EnpòsM>jBDCF@ IDï +K?CFBDGAò-,>Z[K?@RKNIuC , KcBDauGABbM]@ê .Qî 0ù /211 @`ú·UQPA_FBQPXBbGR>lZ[BbCYIbCFK?ZBD=ïTIbGAMO@ïTIbG
(17) õYGAIbõIu@RKPAKNIuCFBD=ïTIuGRM ^Y=?Bb>bóbopK?CFZ[> PR_Y>@q>MK?CFBb=üLIuGRé%IDï:egZe4KN=?=cBDC êNë #QîyUf@R>[mu>[G`BD=¾M]>Z`_fBDCYKc@qMO@ïTIuGBOõfBDGRPRKNPRK?IbCY>jE%GA>[õFGR(> @q>CuP`BQPAKNIuC*IDïñfCYKPA> @iP`BQPR> MOBbZ`_YK?CY>j@LBbCFE;EHK >[GA>[CPl>1ýHõY=?IbG`BQPRK?IbC*@qPiòp=N>j@Àê HURìbìYU1ë 3Dî_FBVmu> BD=?=NIQü>EöPAI°K?CFZ[GR>jBb@R>*PR_F>BbõYõY=?K?ZBDnYK?=?KPiò Ib4 ï +5,4,¥nfBb@R>E M]IHEH>=Z`_Y>Z`épK?CYaFókl>Z[>[CPR=?òbU BCY>[ü ïTIbGAMIbï@RòpM÷nIb=?K?Z]M]IHEH>=XZ`_Y>Z`épK?CYaFU Z1IbM]M]IbCF=NògépCYIQülC Bu6 @ +Ib^YCFEY>Eöe4IHEH>[= JL_Y>Z`épK?CYaÞê 7DîyU_FBb@n>[>[CÞKNCPAGRIHEH^FZ[>E¾8 ó +Ib^FCFEH>EÞe4IHEH>[= JL_Y>jZ`épKNCYa°K?@nFBu@q>jE IuC PR_F> >[CFZ[IpEYKNCYasIDïB*M]IHEH>[=
(18) Z`_Y>jZ`éK?CYa%õYGRIunY=?>[M K?CuPAIsB;õYGAIbõIu@RKPAKNIuCFBD=@RBDPRKc@iñBDnYK?=NKNPiò ù oH<
(19) tú õYGRIunY=?>[MUfBbCFEIbC4PA_Y>÷BbõYõY=?K?ZBQPRK?IbC4Ibï:> **Z1K?>[CP oY<
(20) t(@qIu=Nmu>[G`@[óFt_FK?@BDõYõYGAIuBuZ`_UYK?C4PR_F> ïTIb=?=NIQülK?CYa%ZBD=?=N>jEûoH<
(21) 9 t ynFBb@R>EûM]IpEY>[=
(22) Z`_Y>Z`épK?CYaFUGA>[=?KN>j@ IuC4PR_Y>]>CYIbGAM]Ib^F@ õYGRIuabGA>@A@K?C PR_Y>ñF>[=cE*IbïõYGAIbõIu@RKPAKNIuCFBD=¬@RBDPRKc@iñBDnYK?=NKNPiòê ë :Qîyót_Y>ÀBDõFõYGRIBbZ`_OKc@LZ[^YGAGR>CuPA=Nò]>C ;iIQòpKNCYa B @q^Ynf@iP`BDCPRKcBD=
(23) @R^FZ[Z[>@A@K?C @q>mb>GABb= K?CFEH^F@qPRGAKcBD=ñF>[=cEY@ ù @q>>bU¾>bó aFó?U:êNëjìVîyU¬nY^HP!BD=c@RI.ê <VîTú·UBbCFE Ibõ>[CF@^YõCY>üÛGA>@R>BbGAZ`_%EHKNGA>Z1PRK?IbCF@ó +9,2,¥nFBu@q>jE4BDCFE°oH<
(24) 9 t ¥nfBb@R>EM]IHEH>[=Z`_Y>Z`épK?CYa;BbGR> Ibï PR>[C°BDnY=?>!PAI;@qIu=Nmu>÷EHK >GR>CP Z1=cBb@A@q>j@ªIbïfõYGAIbnY=?>[MO@UjBbCFEZ[BDC÷PR_Y>GR>[ïTIbGA>Xn>l@q>>[C]Bb@Z1IbM]õY=?>[M]>CuP`BDGAòÀPR>jZ`_YCYKcðu^F>@óVt_F> > >Z·PAKNmu>;K?CPR>[auGABDPRK?IbC Ib= ï +5,2,>ynFBu@q>jE BDCFEÞoH<
(25) 9 t ¥nfBb@R>EöM]IHEH>[=lZ`_Y>jZ`éK?CYaPA>Z`_YCYKcð^Y>@ K?@smb>GRò6K?M]õfIuGqP`BDCP%PAIÞülKcEH>C PR_F>ö@Rõ>Z·PAGR^FM IDï BbõYõY=?K?ZBDnYK?=NKNPiò×IDï@qòpM÷nIb=?KcZûM]IHEH>[= Z`_Y>Z`éu>[G`@[óf\ IBD= IDï
(26) PR_FK?@õFBDõ>[GK?@ PRI%EH>@AZ1GAKNn>÷_FIQüÛPA_Y? > +5,2,>ynFBu@q>jEgBDCFEgoY<
(27) 9 t ¥nFBu@q>jE BDõYõYGAIuBuZ`_Y>@PAI÷@RòM nfIu=NKcZlM]IHEH>[=¬Z`_Y>jZ`éK?CYa _FBVmu>lnf>>[C;@R^FZZ1>@A@qïT^Y=N=?òKNCPR>abG`BQPA>EülKPA_YK?C PR_Y >
(28) ^foHA e @M]IHEH>= Z`_Y>Z`éu>[GjB ó «C×oH>Z·PAKNIuC6ì.ü>Ib^HPA=NK?CY>PA_YD > C?EBFHGJI3õFGRI ;i>Z·Pj8 ó «C op>Z1PRK?IbK C 3ÞBDCFL E 7ÞüL>.EH>@AZ1GAK?nf>ûPR_Y>°ïT^YCFZ1PRK?IbCFBb=NKNPRK?>@sBDCFE PR_Y>.BDG`Z`_YKNPR>Z1PR^YGA>gIbM ï CNEHO FHGJIOìHP ó «CÞop>jZ·PRK?IbQ C <4ü>%EHKc@RZ[^F@A@÷@RIbM]>*GA>@R^Y=P`@ BbCFE Iu^HPR=?KNCF>%EHK?GR>jZ·PAKNIuCF@ ïTIuG÷ïT^HPA^YGA> EH>[mu>[=?IbõYM]>[CPjó R. SUT>VXW. æZY5[]\. Y_^>`Xa ä_bqèqçK[3älå>VcbedUTVªçgfhVªã. C?EiFjGJI Kc@ B@qòpM÷nIb=?KcZ M]IHEH>=:Z`_Y>Z`éu>[GÀIbGAKNauKNCfBQPR>jE4ïTGAIbM PA_Y>OGA>[>[CFabK?CY>[>GRK?CYaFU¬GA>[K?MN õY=N>M]>[CPABDPRK?IbC]BDCFE >1ýpPR>CF@RKNIuC Ibï_FHGkI êNë#QîyUjPR_Y>lIuGRK?abK?CFBb=l+5,2,>ynFBu@q>jE!M]IHEH>[=FZ`_F>Z`éb>G EH>[mu>[=?Ibõ>EÀnpò eûZ[e4K?=N=cBDC >[PBb=~ójBQPJ e m ù FHGkI ïTGAIbM CYIQüöIbCú·ót_F>_C?EBFHGJIÛõYGAI;i>Z1P BDK?M]@ BQPlPR_F>÷EH>[mu>[=?IbõYM]>CuPIbïBO@qPABDPR(> ¥Ibnï ~PA_Y> «BDGRP@qòpM÷nIb=?KcZÀMIHEH>= Z`_Y>jZ`éb>GUHEH>j@qK?abCY>jE PRIûn>BDõYõY=?KcZ[BDnF=N>*K?C PA>Z`_YCFIb=?IbabòûPRG`BDCF@qïT>[GõYGAI ;i>jZ·PA@ oªKNP Kc@Bgü>[=?=@qPRGA^FZ·PA^YGA>E¾UIbõ>[CU p >1ýHK?nY=N> BDCFEOEYIpZ[^YM]>[CPR>jEOõY=cBQPRïTIbGAM'ïTIuGXM]IHEH>[=Z`_Y>Z`épK?CYaFUBDCFE]Kc@:GAIbnY^f@iPLBbCFEOZ1=?Iu@R>lPAI KNCFEY^F@iPAGRKcBD=@RòH@iPA>[MO@l@qPABDCfEYBDG`EY@ ê #Qîyó t_Y>lñFG`@iPLmb>[G`@RKNIuCIb9 ï CNEiFHGJIsUbZBD=?=N>jq E C?EBFHGJIsëlK?COPR_Y>ïTIb=?=NIQülK?CYaFUunFBb@RKcZ[BD=?=?ò÷K?? M õY=N>M]>[CPA> @ +5,2,>ynFBu@q>jE%@RòpM÷nIb=?K?Z M]IHEH>[=ªZ`_F>Z`épKNCFaFóHt_Y>!@R>Z1IuCFE%mb>[G`@RKNIuC;ID ï CNEiFHGkI ù CNEiFHGJIOì K?C]PR_Y> ïTIb=?=NIQülK?CYapú·UDK?CY_Y>GRKNPA@LBD=?=HPR_Y> ïT^YCFZ1PRK?IbCFBb=NKNPRK?>@LBDCFEPA_Y>K?MõF=N>M>CPAB PRK?IbCg@qPiò=?>!Ibï
(29) PR_Y>!õFGR>mK?Ib^f@mb>GA@RK?IbCgó r IQüL>mb>[GjsU CNEiFHGkI]ì]@RK?abCYKNñfZ[BbCPR=?ò;>1ýpPA>[CFEY@ PR_F> ïT^YCFZ·PAKNIuCFBD=?KNPRK?>@ IDt ï C?EiFjGJIsëbU¬BDCFEûKP`@ KNCPR>GRCfBD=@iPAGR^FZ1PR^YGA>]EH>[õFBbGqP`@ïTGAIbM PA_Y>]IbCY> IDï C?EiFjGJIsëbó
(30) t_Y>MOBDK?CÞCFIQmb>[=NPiòöKNu C CNEiFHGkI]ìgK?@PA_Y>4K?CuPA>[auGABDPRK?IbC IbïM]IHEH>[=Z`_Y>jZ`vé KNCYa PR>jZ`_YCYKcð^Y>@nFBu@q>jE*IbC%õYGAIbõIu@RKPAKNIuCFBD=¬@RBDPRKc@iñBDnYK?=NKNPiòbóHkl>MOBDGAéVBbnY=?òbUPR_Y> K?CuPA>[auGABDPRK?IbC Z1IQmb>GA@PA_Y>:ül_YIu=N>XKNCYõF^HP =cBDCYau^FBDau>IDi ï CNEiFHGkI% ó C?EiFjGJIOìK?@ Z1^YGAGA>[CPR=?òPA_Y>:IbCF=Nò õY^Y$n =NKcZ1=?ò.BVmQBbKN=cBDnY=?>O@qòH@qPR>M PA_FBQP Bb=N=?IQü@ ïTIbG÷nfIbPR_ /Z11 ynFBu@q>jE.BbCFQ E Fw>x4ynFBu@q>jEûM]IHEH>[= Z`_Y>Z`épK?CYaFi ó «CþIuGAEH>G!PAI°K?CPR>[auGABDPR>%oY<
(31) 9 t ¥nFBu@q>jEþBbCFk E +5,4,ynFBb@R>EþMIHEH>=lZ`_Y>Z`épK?CYaFUB M]B ;iIbG BDG`Z`_YKPA>Z1PR^YG`BD=GA>EY>@RKNauC4üBu@ Z[BbGRGAK?>EIb^YPK?y C C?EBFHGJIOìHUfKNCûIbG`EH>[G PRI*MOBDéu> Bu@ M]BbCpòÀïT^YCFZ·PAKNIuCFBD=?KNPRK?>@Bb@ õfI@R@RK?nY=N>K?CFEH>[õ>[CfEH>[CP
(32) IDïYPA_Y>lBbZ1PR^FBb=uM]IHEH>[=HZ`_Y>jZ`épKNCYa>[CYauKNCF>.
(33) ^F@q>jE¾óu< C]>1ýYBDM]õY=?>lIDï¬PR_FK?@LBDGA>LPA_Y> @R>[GAmpK?Z[>@õYGAIQmpK?EH>jE÷npò÷PR_Y>M]IHEH^Y=?>@XKNM]õY=?>[M]>CuPAKNCFa PR_Y>]õYGA>[õYGAIHZ1>j@R@RKNCFa;BDCFEûGR>jEH^FZ1PRK?IbCûIbï:PR_F> M]IHEH>[=PAI%n>]BDCFBb=Nòpô[>jE¾ó¾t_YKc@ Bb=N=?IQü>EïTIuG PR_Y> > >Z1PRK?mb> KNCPR>abG`BQPAKNIuC*IDïPA_Y> CY>[üÛoY<
(34) 9 t ¥nFBu@q>jEO>[CFabK?CY>bUHBDCfE*Ibõ>[Cf@X^Yõ;PRIQüBDG`E]PR_F> KNM]õY=?>[M]>[CP`BQPRK?IbCIbï IDPA_Y>[GlM]IHEH>=ªZ`_Y>Z`épK?CYaõYGRIHZ[>EH^YGA>@ó C?EiFjGJIOì!Kc@PR_F>!GR>j@q^F=PlIDï
(35) B]Z1IpIbõ>[G`BQPAKNmu>õFGRI ;i>Z·Pj$ ó ik oHt BDCFE;PR_F6 > mCYK?mb>GA@RKPiò;IDï tªGA>[CPRIZ[BbGRGAKN>jE]Ib^HPPR_F> BuZ·PRK?mpKPAKN>j@XGA>[=cBQPA>E]PAI M]IHEH>=¬Z`_F>Z`épKNCFaFUbül_FKN=?> PA_YZ > mCYK?mb>GA@RKPiò IDïÀ\ >CYIQmQBûõFGRIQmpKcEH>EÞB°õfBbZ`éQBDau>;K?MõF=N>M>CPRK?CYa GR>jEH^FZ[>E nIpIb=?>BbC Z[KNG`Z1^YKNPA@êNë1î BbCFE PR_Y>*@qPABDPR>OIDïLPR_Y>%BDGRP!$o ie oY<
(36) t @RIb=?mb>G]êNë .Dî¥ót_F>;lo ie @qIu=Nmu>[GÀK?@!õFBDGRPRKcZ1^Y=cBDGA=?ò4> >zZ PRK?mb>÷K?CgP`BbZ`ép=?KNCYa;õYGRIunY=?>[MO@BbGRKc@RKNCYa*ïTGRIuM nIb^FCFEH>EûM]IpEY>[=Z`_Y>Z`épK?CYa°êNëjìQî¥Hó C?EiFjGJIOì K?@]õY^FnY=NKcZ1=?òÞBVmQBbKN=cBDnY=?>bU^YCfEH>[G]PA_Y>gZ \
(37) m ÿ>j@R@R>[G*\ >CY>[G`BD=hX^YnY=?K?ZÿKcZ1>CF@R> ù ÿ \ÀhLÿ ú·U BQ= P {$|l|~}5lvH( s9 s| z|B |gYó . Y9^=uâ$Vc`. æ á çâYèqäXá>8bqèiâYè Vc. C?EiFjGJI(Kc@:BDnF=N>PAI õYGRIHZ[>@A@ñF=N>j@
(38) ülGAKPRPR>[C]K?COBDC]>1ýpPR>CF@RKNIuC IbïfPA_Yt > FHGkI(=?BbCYab^fBDab>uó «C PR_YKc@l=cBDCYau^FBDau>bUpKPKc@õIu@A@qK?nY=?>ÀPRIOEH>@AZ1GAK?nf> ñFCYKNPR>!@qPABDPR> MOBbZ`_FKNCY>j@npò*M]>BDCf@IDï
(39) EH>Z[=?B GABDPRK?IbCûBbCFEgK?CF@qPABDCPAK?BDPRK?IbCgM]>Z`_fBDCYKc@qMO@ ïTIbGÀM]IHEH^Y=?>@ÀBDCFEgõYGRIHZ[>@A@q>j@[U¬Z1IuGRGA>@RõfIuCFEHK?CYa PRI%@RòpCFZ`_YGAIbCYIu^F@lBDCfEgBb@RòpCFZ`_YGAIbCYIu^F@lZ1IuMõIu@RKNPRK?IbCUBDCFEsPAI;>1ýHõYGA>@A@B*@R>1P IDï
(40) GA>ð^YK?GR(> M>CPA@
(41) K?C;JtlÿsBbCFEÿHtlÿ:~ó CNEiFHGkI Z[BbC üIbGAé nFBQP`Z`_ IuG
(42) KNCPA>[G`BbZ·PAKNmu>[=?òbUQülKNPR_OBPR>[ýPA^FBD= KNCPR>GABuZ·PAKNIuCs@R_Y>[=?=¥ó <X C FHGkI ñf=N>°K?@%õYGAIpZ[>@A@q>jE KNC @R>[mu>[G`BD=õF_FBb@R>@óLt_Y>ûñFG`@iP;õF_FBb@R>@;GR>jðu^FKNGA>4PR_F> BDCFBb=NòH@RK?@IDïPR_F> K?CYõY^YPñF=?>bUHK?CsIuGAEY>[GPRI*Z[IbCF@qPRGA^FZ·PlBDCK?CPR>[GACFBb=GA>[õFGR>j@q>CuP`BQPAKNIuC;IDïPR_F> @qòH@qPR>[MPRI]n>!BDCFBb=Nòpô[>jE¾ó CNEiFHGJIOì CY>jBQPR=?ò;@R>[õFBbGABDPR>j@XPA_Y>!K?CYõY^HP=cBDCFab^FBbab> KNC4EHK >G >[CP =cBVòb>GA@UYIbï:KNCFZ[GR>jBb@RKNCFa;@qK?M]õY=?K?Z[KPiòuUfPA_FBQP BDGA>!K?CFZ1GA>[M]>CuP`BD=?=Nò>=NK?M]KNCFBDPR>jE¾ó¾t_Y>!ñFG`@qP @iPA>[õUZ[BD=?=?>M E =)0)'( nlDUõ>[GRïTIbGAMO@ PR_Y>;KNCF@qPABbCPRKcBQPRK?IbCöIbïM]IHEH^Y=?>]Piòpõf>j@[UªPR_p^F@!Z[GR>jBQP KNCYaM]IHEH^Y=?>@BDCFE;õYGAIpZ[>@A@q>j@[UpBDCfE*õYGAIHEH^FZ1>j@LB@RòCfZ`_YGRIuCYIb^f@[U p BQPM]IpEY>[=¥Uül_F>[GA>>jBbZ`_ mVBbGRKcBDnF=N>%K?@ abK?mb>CþBDC BDnF@RIb=?^HPR>%CFBDM]>uót_Y>@R>Z1IuCFE @qPR>õU
(43) Z[BD=?=?>K E ' K'(! nlDU M]BbõF@B p BDPMIHEH>=K?CuPAI*BnfIpIb=?>BbC%M]IHEH>=~UHPA_p^F@l>[=?K?MK?CFBDPRK?CYa*@RZBD=cBDGmQBDGAK?BbnY=?>@óYt_YK?@ @q>jZ1IbCfEO@iPA>[õOP`BDéb>j@:K?CPRI÷BuZ[Z1Iu^YCP:PR_F> ül_YIu=N>oYA e @ =cBDCYau^FBDau>bUDK?CFZ[=N^FEYKNCYa÷PR_Y>>[CFZ[IHEHKNCFa IDïLnIb^FCFEH>E°K?CuPA>[au>[G`@[U¾BDCfEgPA_Y>O@q>[P ¥PR_Y>IbGA>1PRKcZBDCFE.BDGAKPA_YM]>1PAK?Z ïT^YCFZ1PRK?IbCF@ BbCFE°õYGR>jEHK Z[BQPA>@ó yP K?@õfI@R@RK?nY=N>!PRI*õYGAK?CuP Ib^HP PR_Y>EHK >[GA>[CP =N>mb>[=c@IbïPR_Y> KNCYõF^HPñf=N>uUFPA_^f@^F@RKNCFa C?EiFjGJIOì;Bu@ B p BQPRPR>[CF>[Gjót_Y>O@RBbM>]GA>EH^fZ·PRK?IbCö@qPR>[õf@ BDGA>BbõYõY=?KN>jEûPAIsPR_Y>]GA>ð^YK?GR(> M>CPA@~ó «CsBbEYEHKNPRK?IbCªUunpò]M]>BDCf@XIbï¾PR_Y> Z1IbCF> IDïK?C p ^F>[CFZ[>GA>EH^fZ·PRK?IbC°ê ìQî¥UKPK?@LõIu@A@qK?nY=?> PRIGR>j@iPAGRKcZ·PLPR_Y>ÀBDCFBb=NòH@RK?@LIDï >BbZ`_;õYGRIuõf>GqPiòPAI÷PA_Y>GA>[=?>[mQBbCuPõFBDGRPA@IbïPR_Y> M]IHEH>[=¥óHt_YK?@ GR>jEH^FZ·PAKNIuCsZBDCsnf> >[ýpPRGA>[M]>[=?ò;> >jZ·PRK?mb>ÀK?CsPABbZ`ép=?KNCFa PA_Y>!@qPABQPA>À>1ýHõY=?Iu@RKNIuC;õYGAIbnY=?>[Mó t_Y>ÀõYGR>õYGAIpZ[>@A@qK?CYa K?@lZBDGAGRK?>EOIu^HPlKNCfEH>[õ>[CFEY>[CPR=?ò*ïTGAIbM8PA_Y>ÀM]IpEY>[=Z`_Y>jZ`éK?CYa>[C$ abK?CY>PAI÷n>^F@R>EOïTIbGXmu>[GAKñZ[BQPAKNIuCóu<ï PR>GLPA_YKc@[UuPR_Y> ^F@R>[GZ[BDC%Z`_YIpIu@R>ül_Y>1PA_Y>[GLPRIBDõYõF=Nò /211 ynFBb@R>EöIue G Fwx4¥nFBu@q>jE.MIHEH>=lZ`_Y>Z`épK?CYaFP ó «C PR_F>%Z[Bu@q>%IDï /211 ynFBb@R>EöM]IHEH>[= Z`_Y>Z`épK?CYaFU¬B /211 ynFBb@R>E4GA>[õFGR>j@q>CuP`BQPAKNIuCgIDï:PA_Y>PR_Y>OøK?CYKPA>*oPABDPR>OegBbZ`_FKNCY>Kc@ Z1IbgC @iPAGR^FZ1PR>jE¾só «CgPR_YKc@@qPR>õU¬EHK >[GA>[CP õFBDGRPRKNPRK?IbCYK?CYa%M>[PR_YIHEY@ BDCfE4@iPAGABDPR>[auKN>j@÷ê ìHë[îZ[BbCgn> ^F@q>jE¾óHt_Y>[CªUpEYK >[GA>[CPïTIbGAM]@LIDïªBbCFBD=?òH@qKc@Z[BDC;nf>ÀBDõYõF=NK?>jE opGA>BuZ`_FBDnYK?=?KPiò]BDCFBb=NòH@RK?@UDï|BbKNG Jtlÿ;M]IHEH>[=YZ`_F>Z`épKNCFaFUVÿHtlÿ;M]IHEH>[=HZ`_Y>jZ`épKNCYampK?BGR>jEH^FZ1PRK?IbC!PAI Jtlÿ%M]IHEH>[=HZ`_Y>jZ`éK?CYafU Z1IbM]õY^YPABQPAKNIuC%Ibïð^FBbCPRKNPABQPAKNmu> Z`_FBDG`BbZ1PR>[GAKc@iPAK?Z@XIbï PA_Y> M]IpEY>[=¥ó. «CgPR_F>ZBb@R>÷IDïoH<
(44) 9 t ¥nfBb@R>EgM]IHEH>=Z`_F>Z`épKNCFaFjU C?EiFjGJIOì*Z[IbCF@qPRGA^FZ·P`@BbCûK?CPR>[GACFBb= GR>õYGR>j@q>CPABQPAKNIuC*IDï PR_Y>ÀM]IHEH>[=¾nfBb@R>E%IbC%k>EH^FZ[>M E +IpIb=?>BDCJLKNG`Z1^YKNP ù > k +Jú1UFB÷GA>[õFGR(> .
(45) @q>CuP`BQPAKNIuC%M]>Z`_fBDCYKc@qM ïTIbGõYGAIbõIu@RKPAKNIuCFBD=ïTIbGAM÷^F=?Bb>bóYt_Y>CUHKPKc@õIu@A@qK?nY=?>PAIOõf>GqïTIuGRM oH<
(46) 9 t ¥nfBb@R>E nIb^FCFEH>E M]IHEH>[=Z`_F>Z`épKNCFaûIDïÀÿHtlÿÛïTIbGAM÷^Y=cBD>uó
(47) \ K?mb>CÞB.nIb^YCFEÞIbCÞPR_F> =N>CYaDPA_ IDïPR_Y>%Z1Ib^FCuPA>[GA>1ýYBDM]õY=?>bU B4ÿHtlÿ×M]IpEY>[=LZ`_F>Z`épKNCFa4õYGRIunY=?>[M K?@ >CFZ1IHEH>jEöKNCPAI BöoY<
(48) tõYGAIbnF=N>Ms ó yïÀB.õYGAIbõIu@RKPAKNIuCFBD=M]IHEH>[= K?@ïTIu^YCFE¾U:KNP;Z1IuGRGA>@RõIbCFEY@ PAIöB Z[Ib^YCg PR>[GA>1ýYBbMõF=N>IDïPA_Y>IuGRK?abK?CFBb=FM]IHEH>[=¾Z`_Y>jZ`éK?CYa!õFGRIunY=N>Mvó ×KNPR_%GR>j@qõ>Z1PLPAI!PA_Y> P`BDnY=?>Bb^ Z1IbCf@iPAGR^FZ1PRK?IbCöK?C ê 7bî¥U>CY_FBbCFZ1>M>CPA@ _FBVmu>]nf>>[C Z[BbGRGAK?>E°Ib^HP!PA_FBQPZ[BDC @RKNauCYKNñfZ[BbCuPA=Nò KNM]õYGAIQmb> PR_F>÷õ>[GRïTIbGAM]BbCFZ1>j@IDïPR_F> oH<
(49) t Z`_Y>Z`éu>[GjóYt_Y>÷@RòH@iPA>[M >[CPR>GA@B]=?IpIbõUfKNCPA>[G =N>jBVmK?CYasõYGAIbnY=?>[Mau>[CY>GABDPRK?IbCûBbCFE.@qIu=N^HPAKNIuC.BDPqPA>[M]õHP!mpK?BBsZ[Bb=N=PAI%PA_Y>;oH<
(50) t @qIu=Nmu>[GjU BDCFEþKPA>[G`BQPR>j@÷^FCuPAKN=B.@RIb=?^HPRK?IbC Kc@ ïTIb^YCfE IbGPA_Y>s@Rõ>Z1KNñF>jE nIb^YCFEÞKc@ GA>BuZ`_Y>Ei ó ,^FBD= PR>Z`_FCYK?ð^Y>j@ïTIbGlK?CpmVBbGRKcBDCPZ`_Y>jZ`éK?CYaê 3Dî Z[BbC%n>!BDõFõY=NK?>E;PRIOK?CpmQBDGAK?BbCuPõYGAIbõ>[GRPRK?>@ó t_Y>]õYGRIuõf>GqPAKN>j@ÀBDGA> _FBbCFEH=?>E.BDCFE.@R_YIQülCgPAI%PA_Y>O^F@R>[GÀnpòûBsõYGAIbõ>[GRPiò4M]BbCFBDau>[GjU PR_FBDPK?@K?CFEH>õf>CFEH>[CPIbï PA_Y>ÀMIHEH>=ªZ`_Y>jZ`éK?CYa>[CYauKNCF> ^f@q>jE*ïTIuGPR_Y> mu>[GAKñfZBQPAKNIuCóHt_YK?@ M>jBDCF@ PA_FBQP
(51) KNPKc@õfI@R@RK?nY=N>LïTIbGPA_Y>^F@q>GPRIÀEH>Z[K?EH>ül_FBDP@RIb=?^HPAKNIuC÷M]>1PA_YIHE!PAI BuEHIbõHPïTIuG >BbZ`_OõFGRIuõf>GqPiòuóbøY^YGRPR_F>[GAMIuGR>uUQPR_F>Z1Iu^YCPR>GR>[ýHBbM]õY=N>PAGABuZ1>j@
(52) nf>KNCFa!ab>CY>[G`BQPA>E]npò nIDPA_ MIHEH>=Z`_F>Z`épKNCFalMIHEH^F=N>j@ BbGR>
(53) õYGA>@R>[CPA>E BDCfE @iPAIbGA>EÀK?CuPAI B^FCYK?ð^Y>:ïTIbGAM]BDPóVopKNM]K?=?BbGR=?òbU PR_Y>^f@q>G:Z[BDCO@RKNM ^Y=cBQPR>PA_Y>ln>[_FBVmpK?Ib^YG
(54) IbïfPA_Y> @Rõf>jZ1KNñF>E]@Ròp@qPR>MUDnpò÷ab>CY>[G`BQPAKNCFaPAGABuZ1>j@ >[KNPR_Y>GK?CPR>[G`BbZ1PRK?mb>=NòsIbGGABbCFEHIbM]=?òbó¾opK?M÷^Y=cBQPAKNIuCûZ[BbCgnf>Z[BbGRGAKN>jEIb^HP nfIbPR_°mKcBe+5,2,> nFBb@R>E%IbG oH<
(55) 9 t ynFBu@q>jE*PA>Z`_YCYKcð^Y>@ó . Y9^=uâ$Vc`. 6ãfçT èiâ$VªçâYæãgV. «CPR_Y>EH>[mu>[=?IbõYM]>[CPIbï2C?EBFHGJIsUYõFBbGqPAK?Z[^Y=cBDG ZBDGA> K?@EHKNGA>Z1PR>jEsPRIOPA_Y> BbGAZ`_YKNPR>jZ·PA^YGABb=. EH>@RKNauCUªK?C IuGAEH>G!PAIgIbnHP`BDK?CþBDC Iuõf>CþBDG`Z`_YKNPR>jZ·PR^FGR>]PA_FBQP]Z[BDCþnf>%KNCPR>abG`BQPA>E.ülKPA_YK?C EHK >[GA>[CPEH>@RKNauCO>[CpmpKNGAIbCFM>CPA@UuBDCfEOZ1^F@qPRIuMK?ô[>jE*EH>õf>CFEHK?CYa÷IuC]PR_Y>ÀBDõYõF=NKcZ[BDPRK?IbC*EHI M]BbKNCªóFt_Y>[GA>1ïTIuGR>uUpPR_Y>!BbGAZ`_FKPA>Z·PA^YGA> Ib4 ï C?EBFHGJIOì÷_FBb@ln>[>C4EH>[>õY=Nò%GR>mpK?@R>EBDCfE%>[lý PR>[CfEH>E ülKNPR_6GR>j@qõ>Z1POPRk I CNEiFHGJIsëuUK?C6IbG`EH>[GPAI BD=?=NIQü8ïTIuG*BöZ1=?>BDC×BbCFEþ> >jZ·PAKNmu> KNCPR>abG`BQPAKNIuCgIDïloH<
(56) 9 t ¥nfBb@R>E4PA>Z`_YCFK?ð^Y>j@ BbCFE4PAIIQmb>[G`Z1IuM]>÷@qIuM]> =?KNM]KNPABDPRK?IbCF@ ID6 ï CNEHO FHGJIsëbó¾< _YK?ab_.=N>mb>=mpK?>[ü IDïXPA_Y>]KNCPA>[GACFBD=
(57) @qPRGA^FZ·PA^YGR>ID6 ï CNEiFHGJIOì;K?@ÀGA>[õIbGRPR>jEgK?C ø K?ab^FGR>]ëbóYt_F>!BDG`Z`_YKPA>Z1PR^YGA>Kc@Z[IbM]õfI@q>jE;IbïªPA_Y>ÀïTIb=?=NIQülK?CYa]MOBDK?C%M]IHEH^Y=?>@ó s~B ¡c¢£ t_Y>;ø=cBQPqPA>[CYK?CYagM]IHEH^Y=?>*K?M]õY=N>M]>[CPA@ÀPA_Y>*õFBbGA@RK?CYaIDïPR_Y>;MIHEH>=~U @qIuM>Z1IuCF@RK?@qPR>CFZ1ò Z`_Y>jZ`ép@ PAI°au^FBDG`BDCPR>>OPR_F>sü>[=?=ïTIb^YCfEH>EHCF>@A@]IDïPA_Y>4EH>1ñFCFKPAKNIuCF@[U BDCFE%>[=?KNM]K?CFBQPA>@õYGAIHZ1>@A@R>@BDCFE;M]IpEY^Y=N>j@[UHõFGRIHEH^FZ[KNCFaB p BDPUY@AZ[BD=cBDGM]IHEH>[=¥UYBDCFEsB@q>[P IDï p BQPlõYGAIbõ>[GRPRK?>@ó ¤4h¥¦l§ ¡c¢H£ t_Y>OW:CfZ1IHEHK?CYa;Kc@ GR>j@qõIbCF@RK?nY=N> ïTIbG MOBDõYõFKNCYa%PR_F> p BQPU¾@AZ[Bb=?BbGM]IHEH>[= KNCPRI BönIpIb=?>BbC M]IHEH>=~óXt_FK?@OGA>ð^YK?GA>@PR_F>gKNCPAGRIHEH^FZ1PRK?IbC6IDï PR_F>g@q^YKNPABbnY=?>gnfIpIu=N>jBDC mVBbGRKcBDnF=N>j@[UbEY>[õ>[CFEHK?CYa IbC]PR_F> G`BDCYau>lIDï¾PR_F> @RZBD=cBDG:mQBbGRKcBDnY=?>@:nf>KNCYa MOBDCYK?õY^Y=cBQPA>E¾ópøYIuG KNCF@qPABbCFZ1>uUQïTIbG:B nIb^YCfEH>EK?CuPA>[au>[G
(58) mQBDGAK?BbnY=?9 > ¨ UDG`BDCYauKNCYaïTGAIbM'í PAI ~ì <<YU #nIpIb=?>BbC mQBDGAK BDnY=?>P @ ¨ S ©(ª(ªª(© ¨s«BDGA>XEH>1ñfCY>E¾óVøY^FGqPA_Y>[GAM]IbGA>bUVBDC >[CfZ1IHEHK?CYaPA_FBQP
(59) Bb@A@qIHZ[K?BDPR>@>BbZ`_÷IDïHPR_F> õYGRIuõfI@qKNPRK?Ib¬ C ¨Mu®;K?CPRI*BOZ[IbGAGR>j@qõIbCFEYKNCYa]Bb@A@RKNauCYM]>[CPPR¯ I ¨ S ©(ªª(ª© ¨s« Kc@Z[IbCF@qPRGA^FZ·PA>E¾ó t_Y>[CUVïTIuG >jBbZ`_BQPRIuM]K?ZXõYGRIuõfI@qKNPRK?IbC KNC÷PR_Y>õYGAIbauGABbMU1PR_F>Z[IbGAGR>j@qõIbCfEHKNCFanfIpIu=N>jBDC÷>[ýl õYGR>j@R@RK?IbC Kc@ Z[IbCF@qPRGA^FZ·PA>E¾óVøYIuGªK?CF@qPABDCfZ1>bUPR_F>BDPRIbM]KcZ
(60) õYGAIbõIu@RKPAKNIuC ù ¨i°&±Y9 ú ²´³üIb^Y=cE n> Bb@A@qIHZ1KcBQPA>E]ülKNPR_;B÷nfIpIu=N>jBDCO>1ýHõYGA>@A@RKNIuCOKNCOPA_Y> nIpIb=?>BbC*mQBDGAK?BbnY=N>j@:Bb@A@RIpZ[K?BDPR>jE]ülKPAq _ ¨ªU ±BbCF E ³Fót_YK?@:Ibõ>[G`BQPRK?IbC]Kc@XZBDGAGRK?>E Ib^HPLnòM]>BbCF@
(61) IDï< =Nau>[nYG`BDKc= Z , >jZ1Kc@qK?Ib¯ C ,K?BbabG`BDMO@U õFBDGRPRKcZ1^Y=cBDGïTIuGRMO@ID8 ï ,>Z1Kc@RKNIu¬ C ,K?BbabG`BDMO@ülKPA_4CYIbgC ¥nIpIb=?>BDC%=N>jBVmb>j@[ó.
(62) P1...Pn. M. SIMULATION. FLATTENING. Pf1...Pfn. TRACE MANIPULATION. Mf. ENCODE. BDD−BASED. SCALARVAR. VERIFICATION. TRACE RECONSTRUCTION. − reachability − model checking − quantitative analysis. BUILD BOOLEAN FUNCTIONS FOR SCALAR PROPOSITIONS. SIM BOUNDED. Mfb. Pfb. MODEL BDD−BASED. CHECKER. MODEL. CONE OF INFLUENCE. SATSOLVER Mfb |=(K) Pfb.cnf DIMACS PRINTER. CONSTRUCTION. Mfb |=(K) Pfb.dimacs. Mfb(Pfb). BDD PACKAGE. RBC ENGINE CNF CONVERSION. µh¶¸· É ¹pÉ. xÌlQiAip [f²y«i¶uËAi¶ui[Ï º>»¼$½¬¾4¿DÕ. À ¦shÁ¦ÂÄÃgÅ&Æi~h¥ $Ç t_YKc@ M]IHEH^Y=?>*KNM]õY=?>[M]>CuP`@ PA_Y>*GAIb^HPAKNCY>j@ PRIgGA>@qPRGAKcZ·P PR_F> DB CFBb=NòH@RK?@:PRI÷B÷GR>jEH^FZ1>jEOø
(63) oHe UHZ1IuCuP`BDK?CYK?CYa!IbCF=Nò PR_Y> GA>[=?>[mQBDCPXmQBDGAKcBDnY=?>@ïTIuGL>jBbZ`_OõYGAIbõg >[GRPiòbóLt_FK?@;GR>jEH^FZ·PAKNIuC6K?@sBDM]>[CfBDnY=?>4nfIbPR_×ïTIuGe+5,4,ynFBb@R>E×BbCFE oH<
(64) t9ynFBb@R>E6M]IHEH>[= Z`_Y>Z`épK?CYaFó > +5,2,>ynFBb@R>EÞM]IHEH>[= Z[IbCF@qPRGA^FZ1PRK?IbC È?ɬɬÊË şÎÍϦl§Hv À ¦sBÌ Ð~Æi¥v ¦s £ t_YA MIHEH^F=N>!K?M]õY=?>[M]>[CPA@PR_Y> ø K?CYKNPR> opPABQPA>÷egBuZ`_YKNCF>!Z1IbGAGA>@RõfIuCFEHK?CYa÷PAIOPR_F>!KNCFõY^HPñF=?>!K?C PR>[GAMO@IDc ï +5,4, @óY<C;>[ýHõY=NKcZ1KNPlEYBQP`B÷@qPRGA^FZ·PA^YGR>ïTIbGø
(65) oHJ e Ñ @K?@õYGAIQmpK?EH>jE¾UuPR_FBDPBb=N=?IQü@
(66) PAI >[CFZBDõF@R^Y=cBQPR> PR_Y>ÀBbZ1PR^FBb=Z[IbCF@qPRGA^FZ1PRK?IbC ÒQõFBDGRPRKNPRK?IbCYK?CYa!M]>[PR_YIHE;BbõYõY=?KN>jE¾ló yPKc@LPR_Y>GR>[ïTIbGA> õfI@R@RKNnF=N> PRIO_fBVmb>ÀEHK >[GA>[CP ø
(67) oHJ e Ñ @Bu@R@RIHZ1KcBQPR>jEOPAI*EHK >[GA>[CPlmb>GRKNñfZBQPRK?IbC%õYGAIbnY=?>[MO@ó > +5,2,>ynFBu@q>jE mu>[GAKñZ[BQPAKNIuC÷GAIb^HPAKNCF>@KNM]õY=?>[M]>CuP È?ɬɬÊË şÔÓ8~Ð ÖÕ&¥ ¦ £ t_F5 GR>jBbZ`_FBbnYKN=?KNPiò;BDCFBb=NòH@RK?@UFÿHtlÿ BbCFEûJtlÿöM]IHEH>[=Z`_Y>Z`épK?CYaFUYBbCFE4ð^FBDCPAKP`BQPRK?mb>!BbCFBD=?òH@qKc@U KNC.PR>GRMO@ÀIbïXPR_F>*øoYe,EFBQPAB@qPRGA^FZ·PA^YGA>@ÀõYGAIQmpK?EH>jEgnpD ò +5,2,>ynFBb@R>E.M]IHEH>[=:Z[IbCF@qPRGA^FZ PRK?IbCóFJtlÿgM]IHEH>=Z`_Y>jZ`épKNCYa K?@LK?MõF=N>M>CPR>E%EHK?GR>jZ·PR=?òbUül_YK?=N>ÀÿHtlÿgM]IHEH>=¬Z`_F>Z`épKNCFa!K?@ GR>jEH^FZ1>jEPRIB JtlÿgM]IHEH>[=¬Z`_Y>jZ`éK?CYa!õFGRIunY=N>MO@:npò M]>jBDCF@XIDïªBÀP`BDnY=?>Bb^;Z1IuCF@iPAGR^fZ·PRK?IbCªU Bb@:EH>j@RZ[GRK?n>E KNCgê :Qîyóbt_Y>BbCFBD=?òH@qKc@IDï¾ð^FBDCPRKNPABDPRK?mb>õYGAIbõ>[GRPRK?>@Ub@R^FZ`_OBb@PR_F> Z1IuMõF^HPAB PRK?IbCIDïPR_Y> =?>Bu@iPEHKc@qPABDCfZ1> n>1Piü>[>[CsPA_Y> IHZ[Z1^FGRGA>[CFZ[>ÀIDïªPiüI]abK?mb>Cs>mb>CuP`@[UHKc@lZ[BbGRGAK?>E nò EH>jEHKcZ[BQPA>E Bb=NauIbGAKPA_YMO@[ó<=?=PR_Y>sIbõ>[G`BQPAKNIuCF@!IuCY=NòöGA>[=?ò°IuC K?M]Bbab>sBDCFE õFGR>KNMOBDau> Z1IbM]õY^YPABQPAKNIuCF@UYBDCFEBDGA> KNCFEY>[õ>[CFEH>CP IDï PR_Y>!BuZ·PR^fBD=¾õFBbGqPAKPAKNIuCYKNCFaM]>jZ`_FBDCYKc@RMsó È?ɬÉØ×ÙH¥~Ú$$¢$£ t_F>°ïT^FCFZ·PAKNIuCFBD=?KPAKN>j@sïTIbGPA_Y> MOBDCYK?õY^Y=cBQPAKNIuC BbCFEÛ@qPRIuGABbab>°IDï +9,2, @%Kc@%õYGRIQmpKcEH>E6npò PR_FU > +5,2,M]IHEH^Y=?>bót_YKc@sMIHEH^F=N>°K?@%nFBb@R>E IbC×PA_Y>.@qPABDPR(> IDnï ¥PR_Y(> yBbGqP%JLIb=?IbG`BbEYÄ I m CYK?mb>[G`@RKPiÛ ò ,>Z[K?@RK?IbL C , KcBDauGABbM ù 9 J m4,4,Àú;õFBbZ`éQBDau>sEY>[mb>=NIuõf>jE.
(68) nò*øfBDnYK?IOopIbM]>[CFô[K:ê ì 7DîyóH<CBbEYEYKPAKNIuCFBD=¬=cBVòb>[G>[CfZ[BDõf@q^Y=cBQPA>@XPR_Y>÷9 J m4,4, ïT^FCFZ·PAKNIuCFBD=?ÖK PRK?>@K?C;IbG`EH>GLPAI õFGRIQmpKcEH>B^YCYKNïTIbGAM8K?CuPA>[GRï|BbZ[> PA_FBQPl_YKcEH>@=?IQü5¥=?>[mu>[=K?@A@R^Y>@GA>[=cBQPR>jEOPAI auBDGAnFBbab>Z[Ib=?=N>jZ·PAKNIuC%IbB ï +5,2,@ó > +Ib^YCFEY>E4e4IHEH>=JL_Y>Z`éu>[GlM]IHEH^Y=?> õYGAIQmKcEH>j@ ȦsÆch§H§´ÍX¦l§Hv À4Ü ¥~Úg~Ðl£ t_Y6 PR_Y>loH<
(69) t9ynFBb@R>EÀM]IHEH>[=HZ`_Y>jZ`épKNCYaïT^YCFZ·PAKNIuCFBD=?KNPRK?>@ó yPKNCPA>[G`BbZ·P`@ülKNPR_÷PR_Y>k>+J.õFBbZ`éQBbab> PRIab>CY>[G`BQPA>Bs> k + J ¥nfBb@R>E°MIHEH>=
(70) GR>õYGA>@R>[CPABDPRK?IbCó¬<P PR_Y>]=?IQüL>j@iPÀ=?>[mb>=~UBbC°Bu@R@RIHZ1K BQPRK?IbCön>1Piü>[>C @iP`BQPR>OmQBbGRKcBDnY=?>@÷BQP÷EHK >GR>CP!PRK?M]>*KNCf@iP`BDCPA@!BbCFE.PR_F>;Z1IuGRGA>@RõfIuCFEHK?CYa k +JÞmVBbGRKcBDnF=N>j@:Kc@LEH>[ñFCY>jE¾óHt_Y>Z[IbCF@qPRGA^FZ·PAKNIuCOK?@LIbõYPRK?MK?ô[>jE*npò]M]>BDCf@:IDïM]>MIuKNôKNCFa > PR>Z`_FCYK?ð^Y>j@[U¬K?CûIuGAEH>G PAIsBVmuIbKcEPR_F> GA>Z[IbM]õY^HP`BQPRK?IbCûIDï:ïTGA>ð^Y>CuPA=Nò4^f@q>jEû> k +J@ó¬t_F> mVBbGRKcBDnF=N>Bb@A@qIHZ[K?BDPRK?IbC!@AZ`_Y>[MOBK?@K?M]õY=N>M]>[CPR>jE÷K?C @R^FZ`_]B üBVò PR_FBDPïT^F=N=HnY=?IQülC÷õfBDG`BD=?=N>= @q^Ynf@iPAKPA^HPRK?IbCþZBDC n>;GA>[õY=cBbZ[>E.npò Bg@q_FKï PAKNCYaûIbõ>[G`BQPRK?IbCªó CFZ[>OPR_Y>%KNCPA>[GACFBD=:GA>[õFGR(> @q>CuP`BQPAKNIuC.IbïLPA_Y>*M]IHEH>[=XK?@ Z1IbM]õY=?>1PA>bU¾PA_Ye > +Ib^FCFEH>Eöe4IHEH>=JL_Y>jZ`éb>[G!ZBDCöab>CY>[G`BQPA> PR_Y>;oH<
(71) t õYGAIbnF=N>M]@ Z[IbGAGR>j@qõIbCfEHKNCFa;PAIgB%auKNmu>[C.ïTIbGAM÷^F=?BFU¾ülKPA_öB4Z[IbCF@qPRGA^FZ1PRK?IbC°PR_FBDP >1ýpPR>CFEY@PA_Y> IbCY>ÀK?C ê 7bî¥gó «CõFBbGqPAK?Z[^Y=cBDGjUuPA_Y>!Z1IuCF@qPRGA^FZ·PAKNIuC;P`BDéb>j@KNCPAI]BuZ[Z[Ib^YCPBD=?=¾PR_F> Z1IbM]õIbCY>CPA@IDï:PA_Y> M]IHEH>= ù >bó aFó?UFï|BbKNGACY>j@R@ Z1IuCF@iPAGABbKNCP`@[UfKNCpmQBDGAK?BbCPA@`ú·ó¾op>[mu>[G`BD=ª>CFZ1IHEl KNCYa@ IDïPA_Y>*õYGAIbõ>[GRPiòûBDGA>OõIu@A@qK?nY=?>bUªEH>õf>CFEHK?CYagKNïlüL>*BbGR>OZ`_Y>jZ`éK?CYaïTIuG÷BmpKNIu=?BDPRK?IbC IpZZ1^YGAGAKNCYa >1ýYBbZ1PR=?ò*BQPl@iPA>[A õ ÝOIuGBDPlB@qPR>[y õ ²ÁݾUpBbCFE%ülKPA_%EHK >GR>CP=?IpIb$õ ynFBuZ`é]@qPRGA^FZ PR^YGA>@:ïTIbG:PA_Y> Z[Ib^YCPR>GR>[ýYBDM]õY=?>bóbt_Y>õYGAIbnY=?>[M K?@Xab>CY>[G`BQPA>E]Bb@:BbC*> k +JUbPA_FBQPLK?@:PR_Y>C Z1IbCpmu>[GRPR>EgKNC 9 J
(72) ø ïTIbGAM]BDPÀBbCFE°õYGRIQmpKcEH>EgKNC.KNCFõY^HP PRIsPA_Y>*lo ie @RIb=?mb>Gó yïBsM]IHEH>[= K?@ïTIu^YCFE¾UYPR_Y>CsKNPKc@lGR>[PR^YGACY>jE*PAI]PR_Y6 > +Ib^FCFEH>Ee4IHEH>=JL_Y>jZ`éb>[GjUpül_YIu@R> ñFCFBb=ª@iPA>[õKNP PRI÷BuZ·PRK?mQBQPA>lPR_Y>PRG`BbZ1> GR>jZ1IbCf@iPAGR^FZ1PRK?IbCIDï¾PA_Y> Z1Iu^YCPR>GR>[ýHBbM]õY=N>uóbt_Y>õFGRIHEH^FZ[>E]M]IHEH>[= Z`_Y>Z`épK?CYa õYGAIbnF=N>M]@ZBDC Bb=?@RI n>õYGAKNCPR>jE÷Iu^HPKNC PR_Y>@qPABDCfEYBDG`& E ,4 ieg< Jo!ïTIbGAM]BDPUjPR_p^F@ BD=?=NIQülK?CYa ïTIbGPR_F>!@iP`BDCFlE «BD=?IbCF> ^f@q>ÀIDïIDPA_Y>[G oY<
(73) tÛ@RIb=?mb>GA@ó k +J×õFBuZ`éQBDab>ÀK?M]õY=N>M]>[CPA@BO@RK?? M Þ?§ÆB¥ §Qȯ¦l¦ s À ¡Ð ¥~Æc qßÞqÈ À9à £ t_Y> > õY=NKNñF>jEÀmb>[G`@RKNIuC IbïpPR_Y>Xk+lJ°EYBDPABl@qPRGA^FZ·PA^YGA>XBDCFEPA_Y>LBu@R@RIHZ1KcBQPR>jE õFGRK?M]KPAKNmu>@¾ïTIuGª@qPRIbGAK?CYa BDCFE;M]BbCYK?õY^Y=cBQPRK?CYaõYGAIbõIu@RKPAKNIuCFBD=fïTIbGAM÷^Y=cBb@Up@q>> êNë1îyópt_F> > k +J õfBbZ`éQBDau>Z1IuM]>@LülKPA_ B EH>[õHPA$_ ¥ñFGA@qP
(74) PRG`BVmb>GA@ABD=pGAIb^HPAKNCF>bUDül_YKcZ`_OBD=?=NIQü@PAI!@q>jBDG`Z`_!PA_Y> > k +JUbBbõYõY=?òK?CYa!BÀauKNmu>[C ïT^YCFZ·PAKNIuC ù õfBb@A@q>jE*Bb@LB õFBDG`BDM]>[PR>[G·úPAI!>BuZ`_OCYIHEH> n>[K?CYa÷mpKc@qKNPR>jEO>[KNPR_F>[GXK?$C yIbG`EH>[GjUbõFGR(> IbG`EH>[GjUªIuG÷õIu@qP yIbG`EH>[Gjó t_YKc@÷ïT^YCFZ·PAKNIuCþKc@ BDP PA_Y>;nfBb@RK?@ IDïlPA_Y>49 J
(75) ø(Z1IuCmu>[GRPR>Góªt_F> J
(76) ø Z[IbCpmb>GqPA>[Gab>[CF>[G`BQPR>j@BDC;>jð^YÖK «@ABQPRKc@qñfBDnY=?>ïTIbGAM÷^Y=cB÷IunHPABbKNCF>E;ïTGRIuM PR_Y> > 9 k +J6npò BDõYõY=?òpKNCFa*BO@iPAGR^FZ1PR^YGA> yõYGA>@R>[GAmpKNCYa÷PRG`BDCF@qïTIbGAMOBQPAKNIuCóYt_Y> 9 J
(77) ø Z1IuCpmb>[GRPR>GlBD=c@qI]MOBDGAéH@ PR_Y> mQBDGAKcBDnY=?>@IHZ[Z[^YGAGRK?CYaKNCPA_Y>!> k +JóFt_Y>!BbnYKN=?KNPiò*PRIOEHKc@qPRK?CYab^YKc@R_sn>1Piü>[>CsPR_Y > RKNgC EH>[õ>[CFEY>[CáP .mQBDGAK?BbnY=?>@ ù K¥ó >uóNUPA_Y>IbCY>j@÷IHZ[Z[^YGAGRK?CYaûK?CÞPR_Y>sïTIbGAM÷^F=?B°nf>[ïTIbGA>;PA_Y>û9 J
(78) ø Z1IbCpmu>[G`@qK?IbCfúLBDCfE*PA_YA > REH>õf>CFEH>Cu P ]mQBDGAK?BbnY=N>j@ ù K¥ó >uóNUFPR_Y> IuCY>@K?CPRGAIpEY^FZ1>jE%EH^FGRK?CYa]PR_F> J
(79) øþZ[IbCpmb>GA@RK?IbCfúLZ[BbC%n> >1ýpPRGA>[M]>=Nò*^f@q>[ïT^Y=K?CEYGRK?mpKNCYaPA_Y>!@qIu=Nmu>[G êN(ë 7FU[ ë <HUAì 3YU·ëVìVîyó 9 o ie K?@4BbCÛ(> *OZ[KN>CP°oH<
(80) t @RIb=?mb>GsnfBb@R>E IuC PA_Yk > , BVmKc@ â ÃÍ âPã¬äåâ ¦sçæg~Ðl£ l ÿIbau>[MOBDCFC$yÿªIQmb>=?BbCFE õYGAIHZ1>jEH^YGA>bótüI BbGR>öPA_Y>ÞEHKc@qPRK?CYab^YKc@R_YKNCFa×ïT>BDPR^YGA>@ûIDï%ol ie ó ø K?G`@iPjUYKP Z[BDC=?KNM]KNPPR_F> nYGABbCFZ`_YK?CYaPRI*BO@R^YnF@R>1PIbï PA_Y>!mQBDGAK?BbnY=?>@UYBb@A@q^YM]K?CYaPR_FBDPPR_F> IDPR_F>[G`@ZBDCnf>Bu@R@RK?abCY>jE!npò!^YCYKNP:õYGAIbõFBbauBDPRK?IbCóQop>Z[IbCFEUQKPXBb=N=?IQü@ ïTIbG
(81) GA>[=?>[mQBDCFZ[>L=?>BbGRgC KNCYafU:BDCFEÞnYG`BDCFZ`_FKNCYa._Y>^YGRKc@qPRKcZ[@]nFBu@q>jE IbC nIIu=N>jBDC6Z1IuCF@iPAGABbKNCP]õYGAIbõFBbauBQPAKNIuC ül_YKcZ`_ BDCFBb=Nòpô[>PA_Y> ül_FIb=?>@q>[PLIDï ù GR>=N>mVBbCP`úmQBDGAKcBDnY=?>@ób< @ê ì 3YU1ëVìVîf@R_YIQü UbPR_Y>j@q>lïT>jBQPA^YGR>j@:Z[BbC õYGRIHEH^fZ1>lEHG`BDMOBQPAK?Z@Rõf>>lE y^YõF@
(82) K?CPR_Y>lIQmu>[G`BD=?=uõ>[GRïTIbGAMOBDCFZ[>@IDïPR_F> oH<
(83) tÞZ`_F>Z`éb>GUQBbCFE PR_p^F@ IDïPR_Y>%ül_YIb=?>;@RòH@iPA>[Mólo ie BD=c@qIïT>jBQPR^FGR>j@!MOBDCpò.IDPR_F>[G÷nFGABbCFZ`_YK?CYa4_Y>[^FGRKc@iPAK?Z@[U BDCFEs@qK?ô[> =?>BbGRCFKNCYa ù @R>[>*êNë .Dî ú1ó.
(84) â ¡èUÆP ¦jé ä Ð H¥AÍÏsB n×iÆi ¦s £ t_Y>!@RKNM ^Y=?BDPRK?IbCõFBuZ`éVBbab>ÀBD=?=NIQü@ïTIuGlPR_F> KNCPR>GABuZ·PAKNmu>:BDCFEÀG`BDCFEYIbMÛ@RK?M÷^Y=cBQPAKNIuC IbïpPR_Y>:n>[_fBVmK?Ib^FGIDïpPR_F>:M]IpEY>[=bn>[K?CYaõFGRIHZ1>j@R@R>Eó. yP!K?@ Z[IbM]õFBQPAKNnF=N>]nIDPR_öülKNPR_.PR_Fq > +9,2,¥nFBu@q>jE°BbCFE°PR_Y>;oY<
(85) 9 t ¥nFBu@q>jEûGA>[õFGR>j@q>CuP`BQPAKNIuCU BDCFE]>CFZ[BbõF@q^F=?BDPR>@XB ^YCYKNïTIbGAM'PAGABuZ1>_fBDCFEH=?K?CYa!M]>Z`_FBbCYKc@qM PR_YGAIb^Fab_]ül_YKcZ`_]PR_Y> @iPAIbGA>E PRG`BbZ1>j@lZ[BbC%n> KNCf@qõ>Z1PR>EBbCFE;GA>[GA^YCó ê. d°äLá çjbqæ4pèiäXá4. C?EiFjGJI Kc@ BsGRIunY^F@qPU¾ü>[=?=X@iPAGR^fZ·PR^FGR>jE°BbCFE p >1ýHKNnF=N>OõY=cBQPRïTIbGAM ïTIbG!@RòpM÷nIb=?K?ZM]IHEH>[= `Z _Y>Z`épK?CYaFUVEH>@RK?abCY>jEÀPRI nf>lBbõYõY=?K?ZBDnY=?>XK?C!PA>Z`_YCYIu=NIuabò PRG`BDCf@iïT>G õYGAI;i>jZ·P`@[ó «C!PA_YK?@õFBbõf>GU üL> _FBVmb>@q_YIQülCû_YIQüÏ+5,4,¥nfBb@R>EgBbCFE°oH<
(86) t9ynFBu@q>jE4M]IpEY>[=
(87) Z`_Y>Z`épK?CYa;BbGR> KNCPR>abG`BQPA>E KNC4PA_Y>÷CF>[ü(mb>GA@RK?IbCID2 ï CNEiFHGkIsUYPR_fBQP @RK?abCYKNñfZ[BbCPR=?ò;>1ýpPA>[CFEY@ PR_F>÷õYGA>[mpK?Ib^F@lmu>[G`@qK?IbCªó. «CsõfBDGRPRKcZ1^Y=cBDGjUpüL> _FBVmu> EYK?@AZ1^F@A@R>E%PR_Y>ÀïT^FCFZ·PAKNIuCFBD=?KPAKN>j@BDCfE*PA_Y>!BDG`Z`_YKNPR>Z1PR^YGA>ÀID ï CNEHO FHGJIOìHUXPR_FBDP;K?CuPA>[auGABDPR>@%oH<
(88) 9 t ¥nfBb@R>E×@qPABQPA>gIDï PA_Y>ûBbGqP;mu>[GAKñZ[BQPAKNIuC PR>Z`_FCYK?ð^Y>j@[ULK?@ BDnY=?>lPRI÷üLIuGRépK?CYa!Bb@LB õYGAIbnY=?>[M p BQPRPR>CY>[GLKNe C ,4 ieg< JoïTIuGRMOBDPUuBbCFEPABuZ`ép=N>j@PR_Y> @iP`BQPA> >1ýHõY=?Iu@RKNIuC%ülKNPR_4Z1IuCY>ÀIDïKNC p ^Y>[CFZ[> GR>jEH^FZ1PRK?IbCó C?EiFjGJIOìKc@:Z[^YGRGA>[CPA=Nò!n>[K?CYa ^F@R>E]Bu@PR_Y>lmu>[GAKñZ[BQPAKNIuC éu>[GACY>[=HIbï¬B÷J4 < ,6PRIpIu=FEH> mb>[=?Ibõ>E÷KNCBPA>Z`_YCFIb=?Ibabò PAGABbCF@iïT>G õFGRI ;i>Z·PjUVül_Y>[GA>BbC÷K?M]õf>GABDPRK?mb>L@qPiòp=N>õYGAIbauGABbMM]K?CYa =?BbCYab^FBbab>:Kc@ ^F@q>jE PAIEH>j@RZ[GRK?nf>L>[M nf>jEYEH>E Z1IuCuPAGRIu=N=?>[G`@ót_Y>LKNCPR>abG`BQPAKNIuC IDïfEH>jZ1IuMõIu@RK PRK?IbC*PA>Z`_YCFK?ð^Y>j@ ù >bó aFó?UBbnF@iPAGABuZ·PAKNIuC*BDCFE*Z[IbM]õIu@RKPAKNIuCFBD=mb>GRKNñfZ[BDPRK?IbCfú
(89) K?@L^YCFEH>GlEH>[mu>[= IbõYM]>[CPjó «C!PR_F>LïT^YPR^YGA>bUQü>õY=?BbC!PAIK?Cpmb>@qPRK?auBDPR>BPAKNau_PR>[GK?CPR>[auGABDPRK?IbC!n>1Piü>[>N C +5,2,> nFBb@R>E*BbCFE%oY<
(90) 9 t ¥nFBu@q>jE]PR>jZ`_YCYIu=NIuabK?>@ót_Y> CY>ü KNCPA>[GACFBD=¬BDG`Z`_YKNPR>Z1PR^YGA> Bb=?@RI÷Iuõf>CF@^Yõ PR_Y>OõIu@A@qK?nYK?=NKNPiò4PAI4KNCPR>abG`BQPA>EHK >[GA>[CP!nfIpIu=N>jBDC.>[CFZ[IpEYKNCYa@OêëjíQîXBbCFE°EYK >[GA>[CP ù >uó afóNU CYIbCsnfIpIu=N>jBDCfúmu>[GAKñfZBQPAKNIuC;>[CFabK?CY>@ó ë. VcìáVªãgVªá çHVP. jÕ>í¾ 1ij²«ÌûØ_îAÖî ØLÊY´b¶ bHí¬A Òsï¥`²«²«j ´ÜÍD ²Zð`ñ FÕ%Db ÊHË i· [ËRÌ Ê¥g [p [D{ ²«² Ê ²«·´gj.uتx{|²«jVAi²`Õgw~öD¶²i uµLq [Ï [p´ûÝËRÌ `bËqÌQÚ
(91) 1« î`Êp [ËRÌF·´uii²`. òBó¡ôzõöÙ÷$ôzô ø ù_úûlü=ý_ø þôóÿ4ùáôó
(92) côûvù nó~õnÿôûeúûlü=ý û$úø ù ÿçù_ô (ù 4ù÷ý ý óáø ÿç û ó Zú. û pjj¶ j Ï!" # ÕHDÖuiÎA«{| Ai [Îul¿ jbÕ ¿DÕ HÕ:ÒAiá`î fLYÕ:z ÖHj²`X [p´k
(93) ð ÕLÝ%ÕLzN 1iÍVjÕ'z ÖHj²«ij li· ²«Îû D´u` ËqÌAËRÍDÎbÕw¥ òBó¡ôzõ$ ö &%!'N ò %$ F)(*(* DÕ bÕØÕDÒAijbØÕbz! [«i
(94) ð Õbz [iÍVjÝ%Õ+u¶yï q Db p´-,Õ/.YÌD¶FÕfDb ÊHËÝD´u`FzÌu`ËqÍbuÎ ±L²«ÎûuتxÏí iQËA·´u¶bi`²²yi` j´öÏÒ ®® ²`Õ×w¥ òBó¡ôzõ1 ö 0234 cô5û ) ó û$õ ¬ô(7 û 6 ù ÿÖþû ý "ô8Z8ú nÿôû )(*(*(DÕ ¹uÕØÕfÒAijØÕ¬z! 1«iTH: ð Õ¬z [iÍV¾ ´9, Õ:.HÌb¶FÕ Db ÊHË D´u`ËqÌ`ËqÍDuÎÚ:i̶u Ò ®® ²`Õ]w~ òBó¡ôzõ ü(ÿçûþù?ô - -;Pÿ 9<û óûl8ú nÿôûlú = ø cô)û 5 ó ûlõ Nôû´÷$ôzô ø ù6úûlüý_ø þ8ô > óÿ 4? ù ô= ó @ côû~ù nó~õ nÿôû¬úû$ü2ý û$úø ù ÿçù>Aô 1 ù 4C ù B÷ ý ý ED FGFH f5(8(*(bÕ DÕØÕ·Ò[ I HÕDØJ+¶uØL¶ui! [i·´lØXÖÖbiV ËqÌÏc[j¾í i1buÎb [Ï?A¥>¾í ijÖHR«iA²¬ w~QiAiQËRÍQ{ uÎ!b[Ï?¥Ú [i±²«uÎ ØL¶bij! [iËxÌu`i`À{ ¾í i1buÎuÕªw¥]YÕpµ`²« p´ ® Õ K [iA DH·´u{ i[i²` òBó¡ôzõ ü(ÿçûþùBô ! !L õ ôûl ü <. û óû$8ú nÿô(û$ú 8ø M!NO <P'RQNôPó S(Pù ô T&ôO û ;sôó Zú 8ø 'U ~ôzü(ù í ²i bw~q Q Xj¶*5(8(G QÕ áô ó <û$3ü ù nóÿú V ø jóÿ nÿnõúW ø ( ù 2ù $ ¸bÕl}Õ
(95) ð ÕÒª«D Q·Õ!Qb ÊHjËÒQj· [4! Öu¶ [ij*Ú:iÌs[q´uAi·´;Êp 1«D{¥´b`Ë`²«js´u [{ Î[q ²`Õ ý 'Y c8ô TZnÿçûC þ ó [8 (ù [¿ ¹uÓTVÔ\ 8¿ (1¯Qb·Db`Öbi` ÊHA5(*( D¿ Õ DÕOXbÕ}Õ¬Ò ¶uiËqÌf: ð Õ¬Ý%Õz [iÍjj:]ÀÕKªÕ¬ÝË1ÝN [f ® Õ:KÕ ® ¾ [p´^KÕ:XuÕ_LÚ ÎbÕDbÀ{ ÊHË]ÝD´u`XzÌu`ËqÍbuÎ\
(96) · ` Dq 1i`²À [p´gÒAVjp´YÕ <)û ôó t8ú nÿô(ûÄúûla ü c8ô TZ"ú8nÿôû (uÓ" ¿ Ô\A¹`¿ ¯p [bWXj¶u )(*(Q¿ Õ.
(97) bÕØÕQz! 1«iTð:Õ Ý%Õbz 1iÍVj+ÕQµ¶uËqÌÎj bQ p´ÀÝ%ÕQ}L1VRiTÕlº>»¼$½¬¾-\j AÚöDbÊHjË ÝD´b`Y RiÐA·Õfw¥÷ÜÕ _ [ÊDÚ Ëq̲: [p´ ® Õ í¬`·´Yu`´uii²` òBó¡ôzõ ü(ÿçûþùM8øb [8 û 9 côû > Kf`ËAi¶biÜ[i`² ) ó û$õ ôûJ cô8=T / ó>çý5ÿüG üJc óÿ diõ ú8nÿôûeB ýOcD FGFH uD¶ ÊHR·¸j f ]zj Ö¶biALbËAAË`juÖp [Îj`²XG¹ (j·¯VG¹ (*(DFxfi`Qiubw|q QZ X¶*5 (*(8(bÕFDÖuiÎA«{| RiN [ÎuÕ (b> Õ ð
(98) Õuz [iÍV gÕuµLi¶ ÊHRiÎuD [pC ´ ]ÀhÕ _ [! ζËqÌ ÕfØL[iÌA$ KfQÍ! [ Kb& x K;ÝD´u`fzÌAËRÍQ{ uÎuÕ ;ôótúøi'U ~ôzü(ù=ÿçûj (ù k6 ùÿ þû F·uÓy·Ô \ * ·¯ D +u`Êui¶ [«O5 (8(G QÕ `b> Õ ð
(99) ÕpzN 1iÍV f ´ lZÕ .YÌ b! Õ m [qn ´ KfAV`¾Qb ÊHjËÝD´b`¾zÌu`ËRÍD/Î \HØþÜAÚ ØLÖuÖuiV [ËRÌ Ï? LAiÏ?bÎ;ØXiiÌu AiË]ziË`¶ui²`Õ4x`ËqÌË· [
(100) }LAÖH«Àz
(101) ݱL{¥z
(102) D{ (V·{i·¸bbËqÌQj
(103) [Ï z Ö¶biAXbËAAË`jpz [iu`ÎjÝ`j]±LVAi²«~Qv í«i²«Ê¶biÎjÌf~ íYØ · ¿Q·[{~* (bY±lbØ Ý] `*5 (8(VQÕ j> Õ ð
(104) ÕÝ%Õz [iÍV ´ ð
(105) Õ[Ø zÕ ðª Ai²«fÕbQbDiÌu`²«²[ϲybËqÌui î· 1i²«Íj`Aiju²Ïc[¾Êuq [ËqÌu{ uÎ!i li`'ÖHq [¾ÎjËjÕlw~9 ô þÿõtô9ò8óô þó¡ú84ù)o
(106) QNôóPS(ù~ôT ÕbÖbiÎjRªAi ÎufÝ] ` (jDjp ) Õ Kf`ËAi¶biÜ[i`²:*zj Öu¶uiALDË``Ë`ÜuÕF·DjÕ z¿DO Õ + j´b!zjÖu~Q/ Kf & +¬r qY ðuiË`Àµ¶uËqÌÎj bpµ
(107) ] Ìu bØXi! ´ux¬ [Ë`ËqÌ` b ´ ݲ«Ì] [q´b Õ.Ò `AÐui²ÀÏÊHj¶up´u`´û D´b`
(108) ËRÌu`ËqÍbuÎs 1! °´u¶u²y«iN [:²«A«iÎuÕ°w¥ ¿bÕ òBó¡ôzõ ¡üÿçûþùôs ý1c^t/uGuGv pÖp [Îj`²:¹jj¸1¯V¹Q[bs `bÕl}L U +uq A·¬µf ] ÌuTfÒ 1i¶ÍDJ Ì .HH¬Ý²«Ì ,Õf [q´b ¬ [pU ´ KF +¬w qY6 Õ íi[i{ i î``´*«q ·VAi²i [x \ð#y Ë``Qli· [ËRÌ Êu¥% [p b²«²Ïc[VAiÐpË· 1ij [p´OÏ [²«ÐË· [ijFÕ w¥ òBó¡ôzõ ¡üÿçûþù>ô=
(109) v3tGs<û óû$ú8nÿnôû$ú øV côû5) ó û$õ >ôûJ cô8TZ ó9ý ÿüh ¡üUc óÿ dPõ ú8nÿôû Ö Î`²Xj* (·¯Q¹j ¿DÕfDÖuiÎA· Xj¶N ¿jbÕ A¹u> Õ ð
(110) Õ¬µ¶uËqÌÎj b¾Ø Õ¬Ý] ²«²i [i[«iu [p´s}Õ¬b`Ê ²yi uTÕØLËR·¬ [p´%iÌuÀi`²yÚ:ªÏcj·1 Ú \ ð#qbÖjiÎÀ´uAiAi u²« Ö uÎ ²X²i [i²yÐH [Ê~QÕªw¥ òBó¡ôzõösý ý_ý < Y5 (*(bÕ ·D> Õ ð
(111) ÕYµ¶uËqÌÎj ! p´ } ÕHb`Ê ²yi uTÕ
(112) ØLÖÖuuuÎ iÌ ® ·D²y{ íª¶bip (ÖbiQË`·´b¶uili u{ ËAN [¶²i [Ï?i¶ ²`Õ'w¥Û ðV`pa K ! g [pk ´ í¾ N öÝ`b`´uii²` òBó¡ôzõ ü(ÿçûþùMô ý <hz<¡ýnD FGFhogýhü8[(úûlõ ù=ÿ¸ûNý ónÿ dPõáÿú øL<û áøçø ÿÖþh ûlõ Ö ÎjA²[¹[¯ ([¹uÕFDÖuiÎA:ªAi Îuf5 (8(*(bÕ `¸b> Õ ðuiË`Oµ¶uËqÌÎj b¾Ý] [iË`;Ý] 1q [i· DØXi! [p´bx¬ [Ë`ËqÌ` b [p´ ® ·b´b@ .F [ ÊHjufÕ ð ¶p 1iuÎ ²«· 1iËRÌÌ`¶bi²yiË`²X [p´ Öui î· [i i`ËqÌuNÑQ¶u`²
(113) ÖuiÖHj²«ij ²i 1i²yÐH [{ Êu~QÕw~À}z ïyA` µ[ jñ QØX q [p´bA! Kf`i²«ËqÌfQ [p´ÀxfjÊ [² ÜLÖuÍV·Úlj`´uii²` òBó¡ôzõ ¡üÿçûþù ¿j[LÏ õxóP " ô3 ùiÿçûn cô3=TZ ó&$õáÿ} û$õ [Öp Î`²G¹ ·¯Qj¸jDÕ ôAV<{Z ýN|t/uGuGv jj¶ P DÖuiÎA·l ¿jDjÕ 5 DÕ µ Õ XuÕ _Ö îA! FÕxÌl D´b`YËRÌu`ËqÍVAXDÖfÕ <MVM!MK÷vó¡úû~ùáöcôûjlôx~PúóP M8ûþÿçûi óÿçûþ ¿[uÓ|Ô \ ¿8 8(·¯ ¿8(jDÝ] `*5 (*(* DÕbÖH`ËAN [²«²«¶lj +[i! fÝAiÌD´b²:ObÏN¥Ú [i íq [ËAiË`jÕ `b1 Õ ]ÀÕ KÕHÝË1Ý FÕ 8-ôø ÿõ1'-ôzüG áøV ¡õS(ÿçûþ V Õ ]l¶QÚALØLË· ´u` = Ë í¶ÊuTÕF5 (8(jbÕ )(bÕ Ý] 1«iÌAJ Ú m ÕQݲ«ÍVAÚ: Ë îjQzj[! +ÕVÝ] ´uÎV [f8 , Î .YÌ u8 KFQq [O .YÌ uÎu ´ÀbÌ [q ´ Ý] [ÍHÕzÌp 1#Ù \ðÎju`AiÎ yÀË``Q²i [²«jVA·ÕFw~ ò8óôzõ ¡üÿçûþù=ô 0G*-6 ù ÿÖþû ¿[jbÕ ý "ô8Zú8nÿôûe côû)5 ó ûlõ HÖp [Îj`²L1¯DVQÕFØXz
(114) Ý%$ ¿[bO Õ XbÕ í¬LÕ ¶` pf ´ XuÕYDÏc ÍD²`Õ
(115) DÖH`Ë`ÐpË` [ijO [p´jAiÐpË· 1i]ÏËAjËA¶u«i`QX²yb²yi` ²
Documenti correlati
I Strong cyclic solutions: SA is a strong cyclic solution to the planning problem if from any state in Q some terminal state of K is reachable and all the terminal states of K are in
diverse acque sotterranee emergenti dai quattro acquiferi, me- diante i quali è suddivisibilc la struttura idrogeologica in esame, sono state condotte analisi fisico- chimiche
Le pratiche e gli strumenti di accertamento del prior learning sperimentati nei PLA/ PLAR Centers canadesi, pur con i dovuti adattamenti, possono trovare
D413 - in the C-linker – and in position R297 – in the intracellular portion of S5 – are cross-linked (Fig. 2 ), mutant channels R297C_D413C channels are locked in the open
This notion, based on the concept of strongly connected component, allows to partition the nodes of a graph and to guide the computation of the bisimulation algorithm. In this work
limited sensitivity: one good setting, does not require expert users much higher capacity (more variables) than BDD based techniques Various techniques: Bounded Model
all but one literals in η are as “old” as possible Learning: in future branches, when all-but-one literals in η are assigned, the remaining literal is assigned to false
The role of metabotropic glutamate receptors for the generation of calcium oscillations in rat hippocampal astrocytes
