Integrating BDD-based and SAT-based Symbolic Model Checking
10
0
0
Testo completo
(2) ..
(3)
(4) ! #"%$'&( "*)%+,.- /1032 -* 4 /65870:9; <=?>@A@ABDCFEHGAI*JLKNMOBQPRPRKTSVUFWXCYGAK?Z[I]\ K?^YCFZ`_YK?ab=?KcBbdDUfegBDG`Z1I]h:Kc@iPAIbGA>VSjUfegBDG`Z1I]klIQmb>GRKTSU klIbn>[GRPRI*op>nFBb@qPRKcBDCYKcrDUfBDCFEs<GAMOBDCFEHIOtBbZZ`_Y>[=?=?Bud v]wyx:z {|w~}bxuL b ! [iV`bpjjj xfiADibw|q VApjbf~ uj¡[D¢£Q¤¥£D¢¦Q¤£bV§[¨Q[£b¡[ª©«1b¬©«[ ® wyux°¯!±LVAi²«[ ; ³ ´b¬µA1j DL z ¶u²i ·bf·¸D`¹Q µA1j Dw|q [¤ºV£bVj¢~DQV§1¨·u£V»©|¼bV¡[©T½Vºu[»D¤¾©y[ ¿ ±VRi²«[ ³ ´ufxfi`Qiuu ÀDj ! 1ij`¹bHjV[!xfi`Qiuuw~q [ £b¡¤Áb¨D¡VV¤[ºu¤¾©|½jºu[jºª©y[ Â!þÄ`Å`Æ1ÇpÈÅjÉ QuÊHjË
(5) D´u`bËqÌ`ËqÍDuÎl² lVA«²«¶Ë`ËA`²«²yÏc¶uÏc[i! pVRiÐË· [{ ij*i`ËqÌuNÑQ¶ujpË` [²«²«Ë` %Ê ²«·´*j;Ò [« ® AË`²« ® N [Îq [ ²ÀÓTÒ ®® ²qÔRÕ }X`Ë``QiQ ÖuijÖH²«ip [²i [i²yÐH [Ê¥×Ó|bØ x:Ô i`ËqÌuNÑQ¶u`²!Ìp ·VOÊH``.Öui{ ÖH²«·´! ²
(6) lË` Ö¶uq 1ijp [Ê ²«²Ïc[
(7) ²yb ÊHË: D´uAËqÌ`ËqÍDuÎuD [p´ Öui1V`´ i ÊH [!AÙY`ËAiVL iAi [iVLi Ò ®® {|Êp ²«`´ iAËRÌuÑQ¶`²`Õjw¥ iÌ²Ö ÖHA Ú ²«Ìu1ÚÛÌ·ÚÛÒ ®® {~Ê ²«·´s p´suتx{|Êp ²«`´;i`ËqÌuNÑQ¶u`²Ìp ·VÀÊH`AAÙY`ËAiVA Qi`Îq 1i·´ Ú:iÌiÌuܶpÝÞ²yuÊHjË D´uAFËqÌAËRÍVR·Õ ß. àáXâHãYälåæ çâYèiäXá. e4IHEH>[=:Z`_Y>jZ`épKNCYa.êëuëbURìbíQî
(8) Kc@ B%ïTIuGRMOBD= PR>jZ`_YCYKcð^Y>ïTIbG PR_Y>]mu>[GAKñfZBQPAKNIuCgIDïLñFCYKNPR>O@iP`BQPA> @qòH@qPR>[MO@ó t_Y>s@qòH@qPR>Mn>[K?CYa°BbCFBD=?òpô[>jE°Kc@ GR>õYGR>j@q>CPR>EöBu@÷BgøK?CYKPA>opPABQPA>%egBuZ`_YK?CY> ù ø
(9) oHeûú1Uül_FKN=?> PR_F>÷GA>ð^YK?GR>M>CPA@PAI*nf>@RBDPRKc@iñf>E4BDGA> >1ýHõYGA>@A@R>EK?CPR>[M]õIbG`BD= =NIuabKcZ[@U >bó aFóJLIuM]õY^HPABDPRK?IbCþt GA>[>;ÿªIbabKcZ ù Jtlÿú·UIbGÿK?CY>BbG÷tª>M]õfIuGABb=LÿIuabKcZ ù ÿHtlÿú·óe4IHEH>[= Z`_Y>Z`épK?CYasBb=NauIbGAKPA_YMO@ÀBDGA>nfBb@R>E°IbC°PR_Y>]>1ýH_FBb^F@qPRK?mb>OBDCFBb=NòH@RK?@ IbïXPR_F>*@iP`BQPR>O@RõFBbZ[>]IDï PR_Y>øoYe ó¾t_Y>[òBDGA>÷BDnF=N>÷PRI*õYGAIQmb>!PR_FBDP PR_F> @Ròp@qPR>M @RBDPRKc@iñF>j@lPA_Y>÷GA>ð^YK?GR>M]>[CPUfIbGjU MIuGR>KNM]õIbGRPABbCuPA=NòuUHBDGA>BDnF=N>PRIõYGAIpEY^FZ1> B Z[Ib^YCPR>GR>[ýYBDM]õY=?>bUK~ó >bóHB nf>_FBVmpKNIu^YGLIbïPR_F> øoYe PA_FBQP mpK?Ib=cBQPR>j@ PR_Y>]GA>ð^YK?GR>M]>[CPA@ó¾e4IHEH>[=JL_F>Z`épKNCFa%Kc@ BDC.>1ýpPRGA>[M]>=Nòg> >jZ·PAKNmu> EH>[nY^FababK?CYa PR>jZ`_YCYKcðu^F>bUHBDCFE%Kc@Ln>[K?CYaOBDõFõY=NK?>E%K?Cs@R>[mu>[G`BD=¬BDõYõY=?KcZ[BQPAKNIuC%EHIuMOBDK?CF@[UpG`BDCYa KNCYasïTGAIbM PA_Y>OBDCFBb=NòH@RK?@ IDïLPR>=N>jZ1IbM]M ^YCYKcZ[BQPAKNIuCûõYGAIDPAIHZ1Ib=c@ PRIGR>jBbZ1PRK?mb> Z[IbCPRGAIb=?=?>[G`@PAI _FBDG`EHüBDGA> EH>j@qK?abCf@[ó ï q>1ýHõY=?KcZ1KNP «@iP`BQPR > GRK?abK?CFBD=?=?òbUXM]IHEH>= Z`_Y>jZ`épKNCYaÞüBu@*K?M]õY=N>M]>[CPR>jE npò×M]>BDCf@;Ib PR>Z`_FCYK?ð^Y>j@[UFül_Y>[GA> @qK?CYab=?> @iP`BQPA>@IDïPR_F>!øoYe BbGR> BbCFBD=?òpô[>EsBDCfEs@qPRIuGR>jE¾ó CY> IDïPR_F> MI@iP:CFIDPABbnY=?>l>1ýYBDM]õY=?>@
(10) Ibï>[ýHõY=NKcZ1KNP «@qPABQPA>lM]IpEY>[=fZ`_F>Z`épKNCFa Kc@XoH h
(11) êNë jîyUVPR_fBQPXKc@
(12) mb>GRò > >Z·PAKNmu>:K?CÀPR_Y>XBbCFBD=?òH@qKc@¬IDïYBu@qòpCFZ`_YGAIbCFIb^F@¬@Ròp@qPR>MO@[ó «C ab>[CF>[G`BD=¥U`ïTIbGMOBDCpòÀBDõYõF=NKcZ[BDPRK?IbC EHIbMOBDK?CF@U1PA_Y>:=cBDGAab>:BDM]Iu^YCPªIDïYZ1IuM]õY^HPABDPRK?IbCFBb=DGA>@RIb^YG`Z1>j@¬CY>[>jEH>EÀPAI BDCfBD=?òô>
(13) GR>jBD= y@RK?ô[> EH>@RKNauCF@ ù PR_F>@RI «Z[Bb=N=?>E4@qPABDPR> y>1ýHõY=?Iu@RK?IbC4õYGAIbnY=?>[M*úM]BVòn>B%@qK?abCFKñfZBDCP=?K?MKNPABDPRK?IbCó t_Y>]KNCPRGAIHEH^FZ1PRK?IbC.ID ï "! e4IHEH>=LJL_Y>Z`épK?CYa.êNë #Dî
(14) M]BuEH>]KP!õIu@A@RKNnY=?> PRI>1ýHõY=?IbGA> @iP`BQPR> @RõFBbZ[>@IDï >1ýpPRGA>[M]>[=?ò*=cBDGAab> @qK?ô[>u$ó «Cs@RòpM÷nIb=?K?ZM]IpEY>[=Z`_Y>jZ`éK?CYafUK?CF@qPR>jBbE%IDï MOB CYKNõF^Y=?BDPRK?CYaKNCFEYKNmpKcEH^FBD=¾@qPABDPR>@UuPR_Y> BD=?abIuGRKNPR_FM]@XMOBDCYK?õY^Y=cBQPA& > %('()"%
(15) IDï@iP`BQPR>j@[ópt_Y>j@q>ÀBDGA>.
(16) Z1IbM]õFBuZ·PA=NòsGR>õYGA>@R>[CPR>jEsBbCFE4>(*OZ[KN>CPR=?òsZ[IbCF@qPRGA^FZ·PA>EnpòsM>jBDCF@ IDï +K?CFBDGAò-,>Z[K?@RKNIuC , KcBDauGABbM]@ê .Qî 0ù /211 @`ú·UQPA_FBQPXBbGR>lZ[BbCYIbCFK?ZBD=ïTIbGAMO@ïTIbG
(17) õYGAIbõIu@RKPAKNIuCFBD=ïTIuGRM ^Y=?Bb>bóbopK?CFZ[> PR_Y>@q>MK?CFBb=üLIuGRé%IDï:egZe4KN=?=cBDC êNë #QîyUf@R>[mu>[G`BD=¾M]>Z`_fBDCYKc@qMO@ïTIuGBOõfBDGRPRKNPRK?IbCY>jE%GA>[õFGR(> @q>CuP`BQPAKNIuC*IDïñfCYKPA> @iP`BQPR> MOBbZ`_YK?CY>j@LBbCFE;EHK >[GA>[CPl>1ýHõY=?IbG`BQPRK?IbC*@qPiòp=N>j@Àê HURìbìYU1ë 3Dî_FBVmu> BD=?=NIQü>EöPAI°K?CFZ[GR>jBb@R>*PR_F>BbõYõY=?K?ZBDnYK?=?KPiò Ib4 ï +5,4,¥nfBb@R>E M]IHEH>=Z`_Y>Z`épK?CYaFókl>Z[>[CPR=?òbU BCY>[ü ïTIbGAMIbï@RòpM÷nIb=?K?Z]M]IHEH>=XZ`_Y>Z`épK?CYaFU Z1IbM]M]IbCF=NògépCYIQülC Bu6 @ +Ib^YCFEY>Eöe4IHEH>[= JL_Y>Z`épK?CYaÞê 7DîyU_FBb@n>[>[CÞKNCPAGRIHEH^FZ[>E¾8 ó +Ib^FCFEH>EÞe4IHEH>[= JL_Y>jZ`épKNCYa°K?@nFBu@q>jE IuC PR_F> >[CFZ[IpEYKNCYasIDïB*M]IHEH>[=
(18) Z`_Y>jZ`éK?CYa%õYGRIunY=?>[M K?CuPAIsB;õYGAIbõIu@RKPAKNIuCFBD=@RBDPRKc@iñBDnYK?=NKNPiò ù oH<
(19) tú õYGRIunY=?>[MUfBbCFEIbC4PA_Y>÷BbõYõY=?K?ZBQPRK?IbC4Ibï:> **Z1K?>[CP oY<
(20) t(@qIu=Nmu>[G`@[óFt_FK?@BDõYõYGAIuBuZ`_UYK?C4PR_F> ïTIb=?=NIQülK?CYa%ZBD=?=N>jEûoH<
(21) 9 t ynFBb@R>EûM]IpEY>[=
(22) Z`_Y>Z`épK?CYaFUGA>[=?KN>j@ IuC4PR_Y>]>CYIbGAM]Ib^F@ õYGRIuabGA>@A@K?C PR_Y>ñF>[=cE*IbïõYGAIbõIu@RKPAKNIuCFBD=¬@RBDPRKc@iñBDnYK?=NKNPiòê ë :Qîyót_Y>ÀBDõFõYGRIBbZ`_OKc@LZ[^YGAGR>CuPA=Nò]>C ;iIQòpKNCYa B @q^Ynf@iP`BDCPRKcBD=
(23) @R^FZ[Z[>@A@K?C @q>mb>GABb= K?CFEH^F@qPRGAKcBD=ñF>[=cEY@ ù @q>>bU¾>bó aFó?U:êNëjìVîyU¬nY^HP!BD=c@RI.ê <VîTú·UBbCFE Ibõ>[CF@^YõCY>üÛGA>@R>BbGAZ`_%EHKNGA>Z1PRK?IbCF@ó +9,2,¥nFBu@q>jE4BDCFE°oH<
(24) 9 t ¥nfBb@R>EM]IHEH>[=Z`_Y>Z`épK?CYa;BbGR> Ibï PR>[C°BDnY=?>!PAI;@qIu=Nmu>÷EHK >GR>CP Z1=cBb@A@q>j@ªIbïfõYGAIbnY=?>[MO@UjBbCFEZ[BDC÷PR_Y>GR>[ïTIbGA>Xn>l@q>>[C]Bb@Z1IbM]õY=?>[M]>CuP`BDGAòÀPR>jZ`_YCYKcðu^F>@óVt_F> > >Z·PAKNmu>;K?CPR>[auGABDPRK?IbC Ib= ï +5,2,>ynFBu@q>jE BDCFEÞoH<
(25) 9 t ¥nfBb@R>EöM]IHEH>[=lZ`_Y>jZ`éK?CYaPA>Z`_YCYKcð^Y>@ K?@smb>GRò6K?M]õfIuGqP`BDCP%PAIÞülKcEH>C PR_F>ö@Rõ>Z·PAGR^FM IDï BbõYõY=?K?ZBDnYK?=NKNPiò×IDï@qòpM÷nIb=?KcZûM]IHEH>[= Z`_Y>Z`éu>[G`@[óf\ IBD= IDï
(26) PR_FK?@õFBDõ>[GK?@ PRI%EH>@AZ1GAKNn>÷_FIQüÛPA_Y? > +5,2,>ynFBu@q>jEgBDCFEgoY<
(27) 9 t ¥nFBu@q>jE BDõYõYGAIuBuZ`_Y>@PAI÷@RòM nfIu=NKcZlM]IHEH>[=¬Z`_Y>jZ`éK?CYa _FBVmu>lnf>>[C;@R^FZZ1>@A@qïT^Y=N=?òKNCPR>abG`BQPA>EülKPA_YK?C PR_Y >
(28) ^foHA e @M]IHEH>= Z`_Y>Z`éu>[GjB ó «C×oH>Z·PAKNIuC6ì.ü>Ib^HPA=NK?CY>PA_YD > C?EBFHGJI3õFGRI ;i>Z·Pj8 ó «C op>Z1PRK?IbK C 3ÞBDCFL E 7ÞüL>.EH>@AZ1GAK?nf>ûPR_Y>°ïT^YCFZ1PRK?IbCFBb=NKNPRK?>@sBDCFE PR_Y>.BDG`Z`_YKNPR>Z1PR^YGA>gIbM ï CNEHO FHGJIOìHP ó «CÞop>jZ·PRK?IbQ C <4ü>%EHKc@RZ[^F@A@÷@RIbM]>*GA>@R^Y=P`@ BbCFE Iu^HPR=?KNCF>%EHK?GR>jZ·PAKNIuCF@ ïTIuG÷ïT^HPA^YGA> EH>[mu>[=?IbõYM]>[CPjó R. SUT>VXW. æZY5[]\. Y_^>`Xa ä_bqèqçK[3älå>VcbedUTVªçgfhVªã. C?EiFjGJI Kc@ B@qòpM÷nIb=?KcZ M]IHEH>=:Z`_Y>Z`éu>[GÀIbGAKNauKNCfBQPR>jE4ïTGAIbM PA_Y>OGA>[>[CFabK?CY>[>GRK?CYaFU¬GA>[K?MN õY=N>M]>[CPABDPRK?IbC]BDCFE >1ýpPR>CF@RKNIuC Ibï_FHGkI êNë#QîyUjPR_Y>lIuGRK?abK?CFBb=l+5,2,>ynFBu@q>jE!M]IHEH>[=FZ`_F>Z`éb>G EH>[mu>[=?Ibõ>EÀnpò eûZ[e4K?=N=cBDC >[PBb=~ójBQPJ e m ù FHGkI ïTGAIbM CYIQüöIbCú·ót_F>_C?EBFHGJIÛõYGAI;i>Z1P BDK?M]@ BQPlPR_F>÷EH>[mu>[=?IbõYM]>CuPIbïBO@qPABDPR(> ¥Ibnï ~PA_Y> «BDGRP@qòpM÷nIb=?KcZÀMIHEH>= Z`_Y>jZ`éb>GUHEH>j@qK?abCY>jE PRIûn>BDõYõY=?KcZ[BDnF=N>*K?C PA>Z`_YCFIb=?IbabòûPRG`BDCF@qïT>[GõYGAI ;i>jZ·PA@ oªKNP Kc@Bgü>[=?=@qPRGA^FZ·PA^YGA>E¾UIbõ>[CU p >1ýHK?nY=N> BDCFEOEYIpZ[^YM]>[CPR>jEOõY=cBQPRïTIbGAM'ïTIuGXM]IHEH>[=Z`_Y>Z`épK?CYaFUBDCFE]Kc@:GAIbnY^f@iPLBbCFEOZ1=?Iu@R>lPAI KNCFEY^F@iPAGRKcBD=@RòH@iPA>[MO@l@qPABDCfEYBDG`EY@ ê #Qîyó t_Y>lñFG`@iPLmb>[G`@RKNIuCIb9 ï CNEiFHGJIsUbZBD=?=N>jq E C?EBFHGJIsëlK?COPR_Y>ïTIb=?=NIQülK?CYaFUunFBb@RKcZ[BD=?=?ò÷K?? M õY=N>M]>[CPA> @ +5,2,>ynFBu@q>jE%@RòpM÷nIb=?K?Z M]IHEH>[=ªZ`_F>Z`épKNCFaFóHt_Y>!@R>Z1IuCFE%mb>[G`@RKNIuC;ID ï CNEiFHGkI ù CNEiFHGJIOì K?C]PR_Y> ïTIb=?=NIQülK?CYapú·UDK?CY_Y>GRKNPA@LBD=?=HPR_Y> ïT^YCFZ1PRK?IbCFBb=NKNPRK?>@LBDCFEPA_Y>K?MõF=N>M>CPAB PRK?IbCg@qPiò=?>!Ibï
(29) PR_Y>!õFGR>mK?Ib^f@mb>GA@RK?IbCgó r IQüL>mb>[GjsU CNEiFHGkI]ì]@RK?abCYKNñfZ[BbCPR=?ò;>1ýpPA>[CFEY@ PR_F> ïT^YCFZ·PAKNIuCFBD=?KNPRK?>@ IDt ï C?EiFjGJIsëbU¬BDCFEûKP`@ KNCPR>GRCfBD=@iPAGR^FZ1PR^YGA>]EH>[õFBbGqP`@ïTGAIbM PA_Y>]IbCY> IDï C?EiFjGJIsëbó
(30) t_Y>MOBDK?CÞCFIQmb>[=NPiòöKNu C CNEiFHGkI]ìgK?@PA_Y>4K?CuPA>[auGABDPRK?IbC IbïM]IHEH>[=Z`_Y>jZ`vé KNCYa PR>jZ`_YCYKcð^Y>@nFBu@q>jE*IbC%õYGAIbõIu@RKPAKNIuCFBD=¬@RBDPRKc@iñBDnYK?=NKNPiòbóHkl>MOBDGAéVBbnY=?òbUPR_Y> K?CuPA>[auGABDPRK?IbC Z1IQmb>GA@PA_Y>:ül_YIu=N>XKNCYõF^HP =cBDCYau^FBDau>IDi ï CNEiFHGkI% ó C?EiFjGJIOìK?@ Z1^YGAGA>[CPR=?òPA_Y>:IbCF=Nò õY^Y$n =NKcZ1=?ò.BVmQBbKN=cBDnY=?>O@qòH@qPR>M PA_FBQP Bb=N=?IQü@ ïTIbG÷nfIbPR_ /Z11 ynFBu@q>jE.BbCFQ E Fw>x4ynFBu@q>jEûM]IHEH>[= Z`_Y>Z`épK?CYaFi ó «CþIuGAEH>G!PAI°K?CPR>[auGABDPR>%oY<
(31) 9 t ¥nFBu@q>jEþBbCFk E +5,4,ynFBb@R>EþMIHEH>=lZ`_Y>Z`épK?CYaFUB M]B ;iIbG BDG`Z`_YKPA>Z1PR^YG`BD=GA>EY>@RKNauC4üBu@ Z[BbGRGAK?>EIb^YPK?y C C?EBFHGJIOìHUfKNCûIbG`EH>[G PRI*MOBDéu> Bu@ M]BbCpòÀïT^YCFZ·PAKNIuCFBD=?KNPRK?>@Bb@ õfI@R@RK?nY=N>K?CFEH>[õ>[CfEH>[CP
(32) IDïYPA_Y>lBbZ1PR^FBb=uM]IHEH>[=HZ`_Y>jZ`épKNCYa>[CYauKNCF>.
(33) ^F@q>jE¾óu< C]>1ýYBDM]õY=?>lIDï¬PR_FK?@LBDGA>LPA_Y> @R>[GAmpK?Z[>@õYGAIQmpK?EH>jE÷npò÷PR_Y>M]IHEH^Y=?>@XKNM]õY=?>[M]>CuPAKNCFa PR_Y>]õYGA>[õYGAIHZ1>j@R@RKNCFa;BDCFEûGR>jEH^FZ1PRK?IbCûIbï:PR_F> M]IHEH>[=PAI%n>]BDCFBb=Nòpô[>jE¾ó¾t_YKc@ Bb=N=?IQü>EïTIuG PR_Y> > >Z1PRK?mb> KNCPR>abG`BQPAKNIuC*IDïPA_Y> CY>[üÛoY<
(34) 9 t ¥nFBu@q>jEO>[CFabK?CY>bUHBDCfE*Ibõ>[Cf@X^Yõ;PRIQüBDG`E]PR_F> KNM]õY=?>[M]>[CP`BQPRK?IbCIbï IDPA_Y>[GlM]IHEH>=ªZ`_Y>Z`épK?CYaõYGRIHZ[>EH^YGA>@ó C?EiFjGJIOì!Kc@PR_F>!GR>j@q^F=PlIDï
(35) B]Z1IpIbõ>[G`BQPAKNmu>õFGRI ;i>Z·Pj$ ó ik oHt BDCFE;PR_F6 > mCYK?mb>GA@RKPiò;IDï tªGA>[CPRIZ[BbGRGAKN>jE]Ib^HPPR_F> BuZ·PRK?mpKPAKN>j@XGA>[=cBQPA>E]PAI M]IHEH>=¬Z`_F>Z`épKNCFaFUbül_FKN=?> PA_YZ > mCYK?mb>GA@RKPiò IDïÀ\ >CYIQmQBûõFGRIQmpKcEH>EÞB°õfBbZ`éQBDau>;K?MõF=N>M>CPRK?CYa GR>jEH^FZ[>E nIpIb=?>BbC Z[KNG`Z1^YKNPA@êNë1î BbCFE PR_Y>*@qPABDPR>OIDïLPR_Y>%BDGRP!$o ie oY<
(36) t @RIb=?mb>G]êNë .Dî¥ót_F>;lo ie @qIu=Nmu>[GÀK?@!õFBDGRPRKcZ1^Y=cBDGA=?ò4> >zZ PRK?mb>÷K?CgP`BbZ`ép=?KNCYa;õYGRIunY=?>[MO@BbGRKc@RKNCYa*ïTGRIuM nIb^FCFEH>EûM]IpEY>[=Z`_Y>Z`épK?CYa°êNëjìQî¥Hó C?EiFjGJIOì K?@]õY^FnY=NKcZ1=?òÞBVmQBbKN=cBDnY=?>bU^YCfEH>[G]PA_Y>gZ \
(37) m ÿ>j@R@R>[G*\ >CY>[G`BD=hX^YnY=?K?ZÿKcZ1>CF@R> ù ÿ \ÀhLÿ ú·U BQ= P {$|l|~}5lvH( s9 s| z|B |gYó . Y9^=uâ$Vc`. æ á çâYèqäXá>8bqèiâYè Vc. C?EiFjGJI(Kc@:BDnF=N>PAI õYGRIHZ[>@A@ñF=N>j@
(38) ülGAKPRPR>[C]K?COBDC]>1ýpPR>CF@RKNIuC IbïfPA_Yt > FHGkI(=?BbCYab^fBDab>uó «C PR_YKc@l=cBDCYau^FBDau>bUpKPKc@õIu@A@qK?nY=?>ÀPRIOEH>@AZ1GAK?nf> ñFCYKNPR>!@qPABDPR> MOBbZ`_FKNCY>j@npò*M]>BDCf@IDï
(39) EH>Z[=?B GABDPRK?IbCûBbCFEgK?CF@qPABDCPAK?BDPRK?IbCgM]>Z`_fBDCYKc@qMO@ ïTIbGÀM]IHEH^Y=?>@ÀBDCFEgõYGRIHZ[>@A@q>j@[U¬Z1IuGRGA>@RõfIuCFEHK?CYa PRI%@RòpCFZ`_YGAIbCYIu^F@lBDCfEgBb@RòpCFZ`_YGAIbCYIu^F@lZ1IuMõIu@RKNPRK?IbCUBDCFEsPAI;>1ýHõYGA>@A@B*@R>1P IDï
(40) GA>ð^YK?GR(> M>CPA@
(41) K?C;JtlÿsBbCFEÿHtlÿ:~ó CNEiFHGkI Z[BbC üIbGAé nFBQP`Z`_ IuG
(42) KNCPA>[G`BbZ·PAKNmu>[=?òbUQülKNPR_OBPR>[ýPA^FBD= KNCPR>GABuZ·PAKNIuCs@R_Y>[=?=¥ó <X C FHGkI ñf=N>°K?@%õYGAIpZ[>@A@q>jE KNC @R>[mu>[G`BD=õF_FBb@R>@óLt_Y>ûñFG`@iP;õF_FBb@R>@;GR>jðu^FKNGA>4PR_F> BDCFBb=NòH@RK?@IDïPR_F> K?CYõY^YPñF=?>bUHK?CsIuGAEY>[GPRI*Z[IbCF@qPRGA^FZ·PlBDCK?CPR>[GACFBb=GA>[õFGR>j@q>CuP`BQPAKNIuC;IDïPR_F> @qòH@qPR>[MPRI]n>!BDCFBb=Nòpô[>jE¾ó CNEiFHGJIOì CY>jBQPR=?ò;@R>[õFBbGABDPR>j@XPA_Y>!K?CYõY^HP=cBDCFab^FBbab> KNC4EHK >G >[CP =cBVòb>GA@UYIbï:KNCFZ[GR>jBb@RKNCFa;@qK?M]õY=?K?Z[KPiòuUfPA_FBQP BDGA>!K?CFZ1GA>[M]>CuP`BD=?=Nò>=NK?M]KNCFBDPR>jE¾ó¾t_Y>!ñFG`@qP @iPA>[õUZ[BD=?=?>M E =)0)'( nlDUõ>[GRïTIbGAMO@ PR_Y>;KNCF@qPABbCPRKcBQPRK?IbCöIbïM]IHEH^Y=?>]Piòpõf>j@[UªPR_p^F@!Z[GR>jBQP KNCYaM]IHEH^Y=?>@BDCFE;õYGAIpZ[>@A@q>j@[UpBDCfE*õYGAIHEH^FZ1>j@LB@RòCfZ`_YGRIuCYIb^f@[U p BQPM]IpEY>[=¥Uül_F>[GA>>jBbZ`_ mVBbGRKcBDnF=N>%K?@ abK?mb>CþBDC BDnF@RIb=?^HPR>%CFBDM]>uót_Y>@R>Z1IuCFE @qPR>õU
(43) Z[BD=?=?>K E ' K'(! nlDU M]BbõF@B p BDPMIHEH>=K?CuPAI*BnfIpIb=?>BbC%M]IHEH>=~UHPA_p^F@l>[=?K?MK?CFBDPRK?CYa*@RZBD=cBDGmQBDGAK?BbnY=?>@óYt_YK?@ @q>jZ1IbCfEO@iPA>[õOP`BDéb>j@:K?CPRI÷BuZ[Z1Iu^YCP:PR_F> ül_YIu=N>oYA e @ =cBDCYau^FBDau>bUDK?CFZ[=N^FEYKNCYa÷PR_Y>>[CFZ[IHEHKNCFa IDïLnIb^FCFEH>E°K?CuPA>[au>[G`@[U¾BDCfEgPA_Y>O@q>[P ¥PR_Y>IbGA>1PRKcZBDCFE.BDGAKPA_YM]>1PAK?Z ïT^YCFZ1PRK?IbCF@ BbCFE°õYGR>jEHK Z[BQPA>@ó yP K?@õfI@R@RK?nY=N>!PRI*õYGAK?CuP Ib^HP PR_Y>EHK >[GA>[CP =N>mb>[=c@IbïPR_Y> KNCYõF^HPñf=N>uUFPA_^f@^F@RKNCFa C?EiFjGJIOì;Bu@ B p BQPRPR>[CF>[Gjót_Y>O@RBbM>]GA>EH^fZ·PRK?IbCö@qPR>[õf@ BDGA>BbõYõY=?KN>jEûPAIsPR_Y>]GA>ð^YK?GR(> M>CPA@~ó «CsBbEYEHKNPRK?IbCªUunpò]M]>BDCf@XIbï¾PR_Y> Z1IbCF> IDïK?C p ^F>[CFZ[>GA>EH^fZ·PRK?IbC°ê ìQî¥UKPK?@LõIu@A@qK?nY=?> PRIGR>j@iPAGRKcZ·PLPR_Y>ÀBDCFBb=NòH@RK?@LIDï >BbZ`_;õYGRIuõf>GqPiòPAI÷PA_Y>GA>[=?>[mQBbCuPõFBDGRPA@IbïPR_Y> M]IHEH>[=¥óHt_YK?@ GR>jEH^FZ·PAKNIuCsZBDCsnf> >[ýpPRGA>[M]>[=?ò;> >jZ·PRK?mb>ÀK?CsPABbZ`ép=?KNCFa PA_Y>!@qPABQPA>À>1ýHõY=?Iu@RKNIuC;õYGAIbnY=?>[Mó t_Y>ÀõYGR>õYGAIpZ[>@A@qK?CYa K?@lZBDGAGRK?>EOIu^HPlKNCfEH>[õ>[CFEY>[CPR=?ò*ïTGAIbM8PA_Y>ÀM]IpEY>[=Z`_Y>jZ`éK?CYa>[C$ abK?CY>PAI÷n>^F@R>EOïTIbGXmu>[GAKñZ[BQPAKNIuCóu<ï PR>GLPA_YKc@[UuPR_Y> ^F@R>[GZ[BDC%Z`_YIpIu@R>ül_Y>1PA_Y>[GLPRIBDõYõF=Nò /211 ynFBb@R>EöIue G Fwx4¥nFBu@q>jE.MIHEH>=lZ`_Y>Z`épK?CYaFP ó «C PR_F>%Z[Bu@q>%IDï /211 ynFBb@R>EöM]IHEH>[= Z`_Y>Z`épK?CYaFU¬B /211 ynFBb@R>E4GA>[õFGR>j@q>CuP`BQPAKNIuCgIDï:PA_Y>PR_Y>OøK?CYKPA>*oPABDPR>OegBbZ`_FKNCY>Kc@ Z1IbgC @iPAGR^FZ1PR>jE¾só «CgPR_YKc@@qPR>õU¬EHK >[GA>[CP õFBDGRPRKNPRK?IbCYK?CYa%M>[PR_YIHEY@ BDCfE4@iPAGABDPR>[auKN>j@÷ê ìHë[îZ[BbCgn> ^F@q>jE¾óHt_Y>[CªUpEYK >[GA>[CPïTIbGAM]@LIDïªBbCFBD=?òH@qKc@Z[BDC;nf>ÀBDõYõF=NK?>jE opGA>BuZ`_FBDnYK?=?KPiò]BDCFBb=NòH@RK?@UDï|BbKNG Jtlÿ;M]IHEH>[=YZ`_F>Z`épKNCFaFUVÿHtlÿ;M]IHEH>[=HZ`_Y>jZ`épKNCYampK?BGR>jEH^FZ1PRK?IbC!PAI Jtlÿ%M]IHEH>[=HZ`_Y>jZ`éK?CYafU Z1IbM]õY^YPABQPAKNIuC%Ibïð^FBbCPRKNPABQPAKNmu> Z`_FBDG`BbZ1PR>[GAKc@iPAK?Z@XIbï PA_Y> M]IpEY>[=¥ó. «CgPR_F>ZBb@R>÷IDïoH<
(44) 9 t ¥nfBb@R>EgM]IHEH>=Z`_F>Z`épKNCFaFjU C?EiFjGJIOì*Z[IbCF@qPRGA^FZ·P`@BbCûK?CPR>[GACFBb= GR>õYGR>j@q>CPABQPAKNIuC*IDï PR_Y>ÀM]IHEH>[=¾nfBb@R>E%IbC%k>EH^FZ[>M E +IpIb=?>BDCJLKNG`Z1^YKNP ù > k +Jú1UFB÷GA>[õFGR(> .
(45) @q>CuP`BQPAKNIuC%M]>Z`_fBDCYKc@qM ïTIbGõYGAIbõIu@RKPAKNIuCFBD=ïTIbGAM÷^F=?Bb>bóYt_Y>CUHKPKc@õIu@A@qK?nY=?>PAIOõf>GqïTIuGRM oH<
(46) 9 t ¥nfBb@R>E nIb^FCFEH>E M]IHEH>[=Z`_F>Z`épKNCFaûIDïÀÿHtlÿÛïTIbGAM÷^Y=cBD>uó
(47) \ K?mb>CÞB.nIb^YCFEÞIbCÞPR_F> =N>CYaDPA_ IDïPR_Y>%Z1Ib^FCuPA>[GA>1ýYBDM]õY=?>bU B4ÿHtlÿ×M]IpEY>[=LZ`_F>Z`épKNCFa4õYGRIunY=?>[M K?@ >CFZ1IHEH>jEöKNCPAI BöoY<
(48) tõYGAIbnF=N>Ms ó yïÀB.õYGAIbõIu@RKPAKNIuCFBD=M]IHEH>[= K?@ïTIu^YCFE¾U:KNP;Z1IuGRGA>@RõIbCFEY@ PAIöB Z[Ib^YCg PR>[GA>1ýYBbMõF=N>IDïPA_Y>IuGRK?abK?CFBb=FM]IHEH>[=¾Z`_Y>jZ`éK?CYa!õFGRIunY=N>Mvó ×KNPR_%GR>j@qõ>Z1PLPAI!PA_Y> P`BDnY=?>Bb^ Z1IbCf@iPAGR^FZ1PRK?IbCöK?C ê 7bî¥U>CY_FBbCFZ1>M>CPA@ _FBVmu>]nf>>[C Z[BbGRGAK?>E°Ib^HP!PA_FBQPZ[BDC @RKNauCYKNñfZ[BbCuPA=Nò KNM]õYGAIQmb> PR_F>÷õ>[GRïTIbGAM]BbCFZ1>j@IDïPR_F> oH<
(49) t Z`_Y>Z`éu>[GjóYt_Y>÷@RòH@iPA>[M >[CPR>GA@B]=?IpIbõUfKNCPA>[G =N>jBVmK?CYasõYGAIbnY=?>[Mau>[CY>GABDPRK?IbCûBbCFE.@qIu=N^HPAKNIuC.BDPqPA>[M]õHP!mpK?BBsZ[Bb=N=PAI%PA_Y>;oH<
(50) t @qIu=Nmu>[GjU BDCFEþKPA>[G`BQPR>j@÷^FCuPAKN=B.@RIb=?^HPRK?IbC Kc@ ïTIb^YCfE IbGPA_Y>s@Rõ>Z1KNñF>jE nIb^YCFEÞKc@ GA>BuZ`_Y>Ei ó ,^FBD= PR>Z`_FCYK?ð^Y>j@ïTIbGlK?CpmVBbGRKcBDCPZ`_Y>jZ`éK?CYaê 3Dî Z[BbC%n>!BDõFõY=NK?>E;PRIOK?CpmQBDGAK?BbCuPõYGAIbõ>[GRPRK?>@ó t_Y>]õYGRIuõf>GqPAKN>j@ÀBDGA> _FBbCFEH=?>E.BDCFE.@R_YIQülCgPAI%PA_Y>O^F@R>[GÀnpòûBsõYGAIbõ>[GRPiò4M]BbCFBDau>[GjU PR_FBDPK?@K?CFEH>õf>CFEH>[CPIbï PA_Y>ÀMIHEH>=ªZ`_Y>jZ`éK?CYa>[CYauKNCF> ^f@q>jE*ïTIuGPR_Y> mu>[GAKñfZBQPAKNIuCóHt_YK?@ M>jBDCF@ PA_FBQP
(51) KNPKc@õfI@R@RK?nY=N>LïTIbGPA_Y>^F@q>GPRIÀEH>Z[K?EH>ül_FBDP@RIb=?^HPAKNIuC÷M]>1PA_YIHE!PAI BuEHIbõHPïTIuG >BbZ`_OõFGRIuõf>GqPiòuóbøY^YGRPR_F>[GAMIuGR>uUQPR_F>Z1Iu^YCPR>GR>[ýHBbM]õY=N>PAGABuZ1>j@
(52) nf>KNCFa!ab>CY>[G`BQPA>E]npò nIDPA_ MIHEH>=Z`_F>Z`épKNCFalMIHEH^F=N>j@ BbGR>
(53) õYGA>@R>[CPA>E BDCfE @iPAIbGA>EÀK?CuPAI B^FCYK?ð^Y>:ïTIbGAM]BDPóVopKNM]K?=?BbGR=?òbU PR_Y>^f@q>G:Z[BDCO@RKNM ^Y=cBQPR>PA_Y>ln>[_FBVmpK?Ib^YG
(54) IbïfPA_Y> @Rõf>jZ1KNñF>E]@Ròp@qPR>MUDnpò÷ab>CY>[G`BQPAKNCFaPAGABuZ1>j@ >[KNPR_Y>GK?CPR>[G`BbZ1PRK?mb>=NòsIbGGABbCFEHIbM]=?òbó¾opK?M÷^Y=cBQPAKNIuCûZ[BbCgnf>Z[BbGRGAKN>jEIb^HP nfIbPR_°mKcBe+5,2,> nFBb@R>E%IbG oH<
(55) 9 t ynFBu@q>jE*PA>Z`_YCYKcð^Y>@ó . Y9^=uâ$Vc`. 6ãfçT èiâ$VªçâYæãgV. «CPR_Y>EH>[mu>[=?IbõYM]>[CPIbï2C?EBFHGJIsUYõFBbGqPAK?Z[^Y=cBDG ZBDGA> K?@EHKNGA>Z1PR>jEsPRIOPA_Y> BbGAZ`_YKNPR>jZ·PA^YGABb=. EH>@RKNauCUªK?C IuGAEH>G!PAIgIbnHP`BDK?CþBDC Iuõf>CþBDG`Z`_YKNPR>jZ·PR^FGR>]PA_FBQP]Z[BDCþnf>%KNCPR>abG`BQPA>E.ülKPA_YK?C EHK >[GA>[CPEH>@RKNauCO>[CpmpKNGAIbCFM>CPA@UuBDCfEOZ1^F@qPRIuMK?ô[>jE*EH>õf>CFEHK?CYa÷IuC]PR_Y>ÀBDõYõF=NKcZ[BDPRK?IbC*EHI M]BbKNCªóFt_Y>[GA>1ïTIuGR>uUpPR_Y>!BbGAZ`_FKPA>Z·PA^YGA> Ib4 ï C?EBFHGJIOì÷_FBb@ln>[>C4EH>[>õY=Nò%GR>mpK?@R>EBDCfE%>[lý PR>[CfEH>E ülKNPR_6GR>j@qõ>Z1POPRk I CNEiFHGJIsëuUK?C6IbG`EH>[GPAI BD=?=NIQü8ïTIuG*BöZ1=?>BDC×BbCFEþ> >jZ·PAKNmu> KNCPR>abG`BQPAKNIuCgIDïloH<
(56) 9 t ¥nfBb@R>E4PA>Z`_YCFK?ð^Y>j@ BbCFE4PAIIQmb>[G`Z1IuM]>÷@qIuM]> =?KNM]KNPABDPRK?IbCF@ ID6 ï CNEHO FHGJIsëbó¾< _YK?ab_.=N>mb>=mpK?>[ü IDïXPA_Y>]KNCPA>[GACFBD=
(57) @qPRGA^FZ·PA^YGR>ID6 ï CNEiFHGJIOì;K?@ÀGA>[õIbGRPR>jEgK?C ø K?ab^FGR>]ëbóYt_F>!BDG`Z`_YKPA>Z1PR^YGA>Kc@Z[IbM]õfI@q>jE;IbïªPA_Y>ÀïTIb=?=NIQülK?CYa]MOBDK?C%M]IHEH^Y=?>@ó s~B ¡c¢£ t_Y>;ø=cBQPqPA>[CYK?CYagM]IHEH^Y=?>*K?M]õY=N>M]>[CPA@ÀPA_Y>*õFBbGA@RK?CYaIDïPR_Y>;MIHEH>=~U @qIuM>Z1IuCF@RK?@qPR>CFZ1ò Z`_Y>jZ`ép@ PAI°au^FBDG`BDCPR>>OPR_F>sü>[=?=ïTIb^YCfEH>EHCF>@A@]IDïPA_Y>4EH>1ñFCFKPAKNIuCF@[U BDCFE%>[=?KNM]K?CFBQPA>@õYGAIHZ1>@A@R>@BDCFE;M]IpEY^Y=N>j@[UHõFGRIHEH^FZ[KNCFaB p BDPUY@AZ[BD=cBDGM]IHEH>[=¥UYBDCFEsB@q>[P IDï p BQPlõYGAIbõ>[GRPRK?>@ó ¤4h¥¦l§ ¡c¢H£ t_Y>OW:CfZ1IHEHK?CYa;Kc@ GR>j@qõIbCF@RK?nY=N> ïTIbG MOBDõYõFKNCYa%PR_F> p BQPU¾@AZ[Bb=?BbGM]IHEH>[= KNCPRI BönIpIb=?>BbC M]IHEH>=~óXt_FK?@OGA>ð^YK?GA>@PR_F>gKNCPAGRIHEH^FZ1PRK?IbC6IDï PR_F>g@q^YKNPABbnY=?>gnfIpIu=N>jBDC mVBbGRKcBDnF=N>j@[UbEY>[õ>[CFEHK?CYa IbC]PR_F> G`BDCYau>lIDï¾PR_F> @RZBD=cBDG:mQBbGRKcBDnY=?>@:nf>KNCYa MOBDCYK?õY^Y=cBQPA>E¾ópøYIuG KNCF@qPABbCFZ1>uUQïTIbG:B nIb^YCfEH>EK?CuPA>[au>[G
(58) mQBDGAK?BbnY=?9 > ¨ UDG`BDCYauKNCYaïTGAIbM'í PAI ~ì <<YU #nIpIb=?>BbC mQBDGAK BDnY=?>P @ ¨ S ©(ª(ªª(© ¨s«BDGA>XEH>1ñfCY>E¾óVøY^FGqPA_Y>[GAM]IbGA>bUVBDC >[CfZ1IHEHK?CYaPA_FBQP
(59) Bb@A@qIHZ[K?BDPR>@>BbZ`_÷IDïHPR_F> õYGRIuõfI@qKNPRK?Ib¬ C ¨Mu®;K?CPRI*BOZ[IbGAGR>j@qõIbCFEYKNCYa]Bb@A@RKNauCYM]>[CPPR¯ I ¨ S ©(ªª(ª© ¨s« Kc@Z[IbCF@qPRGA^FZ·PA>E¾ó t_Y>[CUVïTIuG >jBbZ`_BQPRIuM]K?ZXõYGRIuõfI@qKNPRK?IbC KNC÷PR_Y>õYGAIbauGABbMU1PR_F>Z[IbGAGR>j@qõIbCfEHKNCFanfIpIu=N>jBDC÷>[ýl õYGR>j@R@RK?IbC Kc@ Z[IbCF@qPRGA^FZ·PA>E¾óVøYIuGªK?CF@qPABDCfZ1>bUPR_F>BDPRIbM]KcZ
(60) õYGAIbõIu@RKPAKNIuC ù ¨i°&±Y9 ú ²´³üIb^Y=cE n> Bb@A@qIHZ1KcBQPA>E]ülKNPR_;B÷nfIpIu=N>jBDCO>1ýHõYGA>@A@RKNIuCOKNCOPA_Y> nIpIb=?>BbC*mQBDGAK?BbnY=N>j@:Bb@A@RIpZ[K?BDPR>jE]ülKPAq _ ¨ªU ±BbCF E ³Fót_YK?@:Ibõ>[G`BQPRK?IbC]Kc@XZBDGAGRK?>E Ib^HPLnòM]>BbCF@
(61) IDï< =Nau>[nYG`BDKc= Z , >jZ1Kc@qK?Ib¯ C ,K?BbabG`BDMO@U õFBDGRPRKcZ1^Y=cBDGïTIuGRMO@ID8 ï ,>Z1Kc@RKNIu¬ C ,K?BbabG`BDMO@ülKPA_4CYIbgC ¥nIpIb=?>BDC%=N>jBVmb>j@[ó.
(62) P1...Pn. M. SIMULATION. FLATTENING. Pf1...Pfn. TRACE MANIPULATION. Mf. ENCODE. BDD−BASED. SCALARVAR. VERIFICATION. TRACE RECONSTRUCTION. − reachability − model checking − quantitative analysis. BUILD BOOLEAN FUNCTIONS FOR SCALAR PROPOSITIONS. SIM BOUNDED. Mfb. Pfb. MODEL BDD−BASED. CHECKER. MODEL. CONE OF INFLUENCE. SATSOLVER Mfb |=(K) Pfb.cnf DIMACS PRINTER. CONSTRUCTION. Mfb |=(K) Pfb.dimacs. Mfb(Pfb). BDD PACKAGE. RBC ENGINE CNF CONVERSION. µh¶¸· É ¹pÉ. xÌlQiAip [f²y«i¶uËAi¶ui[Ï º>»¼$½¬¾4¿DÕ. À ¦shÁ¦ÂÄÃgÅ&Æi~h¥ $Ç t_YKc@ M]IHEH^Y=?>*KNM]õY=?>[M]>CuP`@ PA_Y>*GAIb^HPAKNCY>j@ PRIgGA>@qPRGAKcZ·P PR_F> DB CFBb=NòH@RK?@:PRI÷B÷GR>jEH^FZ1>jEOø
(63) oHe UHZ1IuCuP`BDK?CYK?CYa!IbCF=Nò PR_Y> GA>[=?>[mQBDCPXmQBDGAKcBDnY=?>@ïTIuGL>jBbZ`_OõYGAIbõg >[GRPiòbóLt_FK?@;GR>jEH^FZ·PAKNIuC6K?@sBDM]>[CfBDnY=?>4nfIbPR_×ïTIuGe+5,4,ynFBb@R>E×BbCFE oH<
(64) t9ynFBb@R>E6M]IHEH>[= Z`_Y>Z`épK?CYaFó > +5,2,>ynFBb@R>EÞM]IHEH>[= Z[IbCF@qPRGA^FZ1PRK?IbC È?ɬɬÊË şÎÍϦl§Hv À ¦sBÌ Ð~Æi¥v ¦s £ t_YA MIHEH^F=N>!K?M]õY=?>[M]>[CPA@PR_Y> ø K?CYKNPR> opPABQPA>÷egBuZ`_YKNCF>!Z1IbGAGA>@RõfIuCFEHK?CYa÷PAIOPR_F>!KNCFõY^HPñF=?>!K?C PR>[GAMO@IDc ï +5,4, @óY<C;>[ýHõY=NKcZ1KNPlEYBQP`B÷@qPRGA^FZ·PA^YGR>ïTIbGø
(65) oHJ e Ñ @K?@õYGAIQmpK?EH>jE¾UuPR_FBDPBb=N=?IQü@
(66) PAI >[CFZBDõF@R^Y=cBQPR> PR_Y>ÀBbZ1PR^FBb=Z[IbCF@qPRGA^FZ1PRK?IbC ÒQõFBDGRPRKNPRK?IbCYK?CYa!M]>[PR_YIHE;BbõYõY=?KN>jE¾ló yPKc@LPR_Y>GR>[ïTIbGA> õfI@R@RKNnF=N> PRIO_fBVmb>ÀEHK >[GA>[CP ø
(67) oHJ e Ñ @Bu@R@RIHZ1KcBQPR>jEOPAI*EHK >[GA>[CPlmb>GRKNñfZBQPRK?IbC%õYGAIbnY=?>[MO@ó > +5,2,>ynFBu@q>jE mu>[GAKñZ[BQPAKNIuC÷GAIb^HPAKNCF>@KNM]õY=?>[M]>CuP È?ɬɬÊË şÔÓ8~Ð ÖÕ&¥ ¦ £ t_F5 GR>jBbZ`_FBbnYKN=?KNPiò;BDCFBb=NòH@RK?@UFÿHtlÿ BbCFEûJtlÿöM]IHEH>[=Z`_Y>Z`épK?CYaFUYBbCFE4ð^FBDCPAKP`BQPRK?mb>!BbCFBD=?òH@qKc@U KNC.PR>GRMO@ÀIbïXPR_F>*øoYe,EFBQPAB@qPRGA^FZ·PA^YGA>@ÀõYGAIQmpK?EH>jEgnpD ò +5,2,>ynFBb@R>E.M]IHEH>[=:Z[IbCF@qPRGA^FZ PRK?IbCóFJtlÿgM]IHEH>=Z`_Y>jZ`épKNCYa K?@LK?MõF=N>M>CPR>E%EHK?GR>jZ·PR=?òbUül_YK?=N>ÀÿHtlÿgM]IHEH>=¬Z`_F>Z`épKNCFa!K?@ GR>jEH^FZ1>jEPRIB JtlÿgM]IHEH>[=¬Z`_Y>jZ`éK?CYa!õFGRIunY=N>MO@:npò M]>jBDCF@XIDïªBÀP`BDnY=?>Bb^;Z1IuCF@iPAGR^fZ·PRK?IbCªU Bb@:EH>j@RZ[GRK?n>E KNCgê :Qîyóbt_Y>BbCFBD=?òH@qKc@IDï¾ð^FBDCPRKNPABDPRK?mb>õYGAIbõ>[GRPRK?>@Ub@R^FZ`_OBb@PR_F> Z1IuMõF^HPAB PRK?IbCIDïPR_Y> =?>Bu@iPEHKc@qPABDCfZ1> n>1Piü>[>[CsPA_Y> IHZ[Z1^FGRGA>[CFZ[>ÀIDïªPiüI]abK?mb>Cs>mb>CuP`@[UHKc@lZ[BbGRGAK?>E nò EH>jEHKcZ[BQPA>E Bb=NauIbGAKPA_YMO@[ó<=?=PR_Y>sIbõ>[G`BQPAKNIuCF@!IuCY=NòöGA>[=?ò°IuC K?M]Bbab>sBDCFE õFGR>KNMOBDau> Z1IbM]õY^YPABQPAKNIuCF@UYBDCFEBDGA> KNCFEY>[õ>[CFEH>CP IDï PR_Y>!BuZ·PR^fBD=¾õFBbGqPAKPAKNIuCYKNCFaM]>jZ`_FBDCYKc@RMsó È?ɬÉØ×ÙH¥~Ú$$¢$£ t_F>°ïT^FCFZ·PAKNIuCFBD=?KPAKN>j@sïTIbGPA_Y> MOBDCYK?õY^Y=cBQPAKNIuC BbCFEÛ@qPRIuGABbab>°IDï +9,2, @%Kc@%õYGRIQmpKcEH>E6npò PR_FU > +5,2,M]IHEH^Y=?>bót_YKc@sMIHEH^F=N>°K?@%nFBb@R>E IbC×PA_Y>.@qPABDPR(> IDnï ¥PR_Y(> yBbGqP%JLIb=?IbG`BbEYÄ I m CYK?mb>[G`@RKPiÛ ò ,>Z[K?@RK?IbL C , KcBDauGABbM ù 9 J m4,4,Àú;õFBbZ`éQBDau>sEY>[mb>=NIuõf>jE.
(68) nò*øfBDnYK?IOopIbM]>[CFô[K:ê ì 7DîyóH<CBbEYEYKPAKNIuCFBD=¬=cBVòb>[G>[CfZ[BDõf@q^Y=cBQPA>@XPR_Y>÷9 J m4,4, ïT^FCFZ·PAKNIuCFBD=?ÖK PRK?>@K?C;IbG`EH>GLPAI õFGRIQmpKcEH>B^YCYKNïTIbGAM8K?CuPA>[GRï|BbZ[> PA_FBQPl_YKcEH>@=?IQü5¥=?>[mu>[=K?@A@R^Y>@GA>[=cBQPR>jEOPAI auBDGAnFBbab>Z[Ib=?=N>jZ·PAKNIuC%IbB ï +5,2,@ó > +Ib^YCFEY>E4e4IHEH>=JL_Y>Z`éu>[GlM]IHEH^Y=?> õYGAIQmKcEH>j@ ȦsÆch§H§´ÍX¦l§Hv À4Ü ¥~Úg~Ðl£ t_Y6 PR_Y>loH<
(69) t9ynFBb@R>EÀM]IHEH>[=HZ`_Y>jZ`épKNCYaïT^YCFZ·PAKNIuCFBD=?KNPRK?>@ó yPKNCPA>[G`BbZ·P`@ülKNPR_÷PR_Y>k>+J.õFBbZ`éQBbab> PRIab>CY>[G`BQPA>Bs> k + J ¥nfBb@R>E°MIHEH>=
(70) GR>õYGA>@R>[CPABDPRK?IbCó¬<P PR_Y>]=?IQüL>j@iPÀ=?>[mb>=~UBbC°Bu@R@RIHZ1K BQPRK?IbCön>1Piü>[>C @iP`BQPR>OmQBbGRKcBDnY=?>@÷BQP÷EHK >GR>CP!PRK?M]>*KNCf@iP`BDCPA@!BbCFE.PR_F>;Z1IuGRGA>@RõfIuCFEHK?CYa k +JÞmVBbGRKcBDnF=N>j@:Kc@LEH>[ñFCY>jE¾óHt_Y>Z[IbCF@qPRGA^FZ·PAKNIuCOK?@LIbõYPRK?MK?ô[>jE*npò]M]>BDCf@:IDïM]>MIuKNôKNCFa > PR>Z`_FCYK?ð^Y>j@[U¬K?CûIuGAEH>G PAIsBVmuIbKcEPR_F> GA>Z[IbM]õY^HP`BQPRK?IbCûIDï:ïTGA>ð^Y>CuPA=Nò4^f@q>jEû> k +J@ó¬t_F> mVBbGRKcBDnF=N>Bb@A@qIHZ[K?BDPRK?IbC!@AZ`_Y>[MOBK?@K?M]õY=N>M]>[CPR>jE÷K?C @R^FZ`_]B üBVò PR_FBDPïT^F=N=HnY=?IQülC÷õfBDG`BD=?=N>= @q^Ynf@iPAKPA^HPRK?IbCþZBDC n>;GA>[õY=cBbZ[>E.npò Bg@q_FKï PAKNCYaûIbõ>[G`BQPRK?IbCªó CFZ[>OPR_Y>%KNCPA>[GACFBD=:GA>[õFGR(> @q>CuP`BQPAKNIuC.IbïLPA_Y>*M]IHEH>[=XK?@ Z1IbM]õY=?>1PA>bU¾PA_Ye > +Ib^FCFEH>Eöe4IHEH>=JL_Y>jZ`éb>[G!ZBDCöab>CY>[G`BQPA> PR_Y>;oH<
(71) t õYGAIbnF=N>M]@ Z[IbGAGR>j@qõIbCfEHKNCFa;PAIgB%auKNmu>[C.ïTIbGAM÷^F=?BFU¾ülKPA_öB4Z[IbCF@qPRGA^FZ1PRK?IbC°PR_FBDP >1ýpPR>CFEY@PA_Y> IbCY>ÀK?C ê 7bî¥gó «CõFBbGqPAK?Z[^Y=cBDGjUuPA_Y>!Z1IuCF@qPRGA^FZ·PAKNIuC;P`BDéb>j@KNCPAI]BuZ[Z[Ib^YCPBD=?=¾PR_F> Z1IbM]õIbCY>CPA@IDï:PA_Y> M]IHEH>= ù >bó aFó?UFï|BbKNGACY>j@R@ Z1IuCF@iPAGABbKNCP`@[UfKNCpmQBDGAK?BbCPA@`ú·ó¾op>[mu>[G`BD=ª>CFZ1IHEl KNCYa@ IDïPA_Y>*õYGAIbõ>[GRPiòûBDGA>OõIu@A@qK?nY=?>bUªEH>õf>CFEHK?CYagKNïlüL>*BbGR>OZ`_Y>jZ`éK?CYaïTIuG÷BmpKNIu=?BDPRK?IbC IpZZ1^YGAGAKNCYa >1ýYBbZ1PR=?ò*BQPl@iPA>[A õ ÝOIuGBDPlB@qPR>[y õ ²ÁݾUpBbCFE%ülKPA_%EHK >GR>CP=?IpIb$õ ynFBuZ`é]@qPRGA^FZ PR^YGA>@:ïTIbG:PA_Y> Z[Ib^YCPR>GR>[ýYBDM]õY=?>bóbt_Y>õYGAIbnY=?>[M K?@Xab>CY>[G`BQPA>E]Bb@:BbC*> k +JUbPA_FBQPLK?@:PR_Y>C Z1IbCpmu>[GRPR>EgKNC 9 J
(72) ø ïTIbGAM]BDPÀBbCFE°õYGRIQmpKcEH>EgKNC.KNCFõY^HP PRIsPA_Y>*lo ie @RIb=?mb>Gó yïBsM]IHEH>[= K?@ïTIu^YCFE¾UYPR_Y>CsKNPKc@lGR>[PR^YGACY>jE*PAI]PR_Y6 > +Ib^FCFEH>Ee4IHEH>=JL_Y>jZ`éb>[GjUpül_YIu@R> ñFCFBb=ª@iPA>[õKNP PRI÷BuZ·PRK?mQBQPA>lPR_Y>PRG`BbZ1> GR>jZ1IbCf@iPAGR^FZ1PRK?IbCIDï¾PA_Y> Z1Iu^YCPR>GR>[ýHBbM]õY=N>uóbt_Y>õFGRIHEH^FZ[>E]M]IHEH>[= Z`_Y>Z`épK?CYa õYGAIbnF=N>M]@ZBDC Bb=?@RI n>õYGAKNCPR>jE÷Iu^HPKNC PR_Y>@qPABDCfEYBDG`& E ,4 ieg< Jo!ïTIbGAM]BDPUjPR_p^F@ BD=?=NIQülK?CYa ïTIbGPR_F>!@iP`BDCFlE «BD=?IbCF> ^f@q>ÀIDïIDPA_Y>[G oY<
(73) tÛ@RIb=?mb>GA@ó k +J×õFBuZ`éQBDab>ÀK?M]õY=N>M]>[CPA@BO@RK?? M Þ?§ÆB¥ §Qȯ¦l¦ s À ¡Ð ¥~Æc qßÞqÈ À9à £ t_Y> > õY=NKNñF>jEÀmb>[G`@RKNIuC IbïpPR_Y>Xk+lJ°EYBDPABl@qPRGA^FZ·PA^YGA>XBDCFEPA_Y>LBu@R@RIHZ1KcBQPR>jE õFGRK?M]KPAKNmu>@¾ïTIuGª@qPRIbGAK?CYa BDCFE;M]BbCYK?õY^Y=cBQPRK?CYaõYGAIbõIu@RKPAKNIuCFBD=fïTIbGAM÷^Y=cBb@Up@q>> êNë1îyópt_F> > k +J õfBbZ`éQBDau>Z1IuM]>@LülKPA_ B EH>[õHPA$_ ¥ñFGA@qP
(74) PRG`BVmb>GA@ABD=pGAIb^HPAKNCF>bUDül_YKcZ`_OBD=?=NIQü@PAI!@q>jBDG`Z`_!PA_Y> > k +JUbBbõYõY=?òK?CYa!BÀauKNmu>[C ïT^YCFZ·PAKNIuC ù õfBb@A@q>jE*Bb@LB õFBDG`BDM]>[PR>[G·úPAI!>BuZ`_OCYIHEH> n>[K?CYa÷mpKc@qKNPR>jEO>[KNPR_F>[GXK?$C yIbG`EH>[GjUbõFGR(> IbG`EH>[GjUªIuG÷õIu@qP yIbG`EH>[Gjó t_YKc@÷ïT^YCFZ·PAKNIuCþKc@ BDP PA_Y>;nfBb@RK?@ IDïlPA_Y>49 J
(75) ø(Z1IuCmu>[GRPR>Góªt_F> J
(76) ø Z[IbCpmb>GqPA>[Gab>[CF>[G`BQPR>j@BDC;>jð^YÖK «@ABQPRKc@qñfBDnY=?>ïTIbGAM÷^Y=cB÷IunHPABbKNCF>E;ïTGRIuM PR_Y> > 9 k +J6npò BDõYõY=?òpKNCFa*BO@iPAGR^FZ1PR^YGA> yõYGA>@R>[GAmpKNCYa÷PRG`BDCF@qïTIbGAMOBQPAKNIuCóYt_Y> 9 J
(77) ø Z1IuCpmb>[GRPR>GlBD=c@qI]MOBDGAéH@ PR_Y> mQBDGAKcBDnY=?>@IHZ[Z[^YGAGRK?CYaKNCPA_Y>!> k +JóFt_Y>!BbnYKN=?KNPiò*PRIOEHKc@qPRK?CYab^YKc@R_sn>1Piü>[>CsPR_Y > RKNgC EH>[õ>[CFEY>[CáP .mQBDGAK?BbnY=?>@ ù K¥ó >uóNUPA_Y>IbCY>j@÷IHZ[Z[^YGAGRK?CYaûK?CÞPR_Y>sïTIbGAM÷^F=?B°nf>[ïTIbGA>;PA_Y>û9 J
(78) ø Z1IbCpmu>[G`@qK?IbCfúLBDCfE*PA_YA > REH>õf>CFEH>Cu P ]mQBDGAK?BbnY=N>j@ ù K¥ó >uóNUFPR_Y> IuCY>@K?CPRGAIpEY^FZ1>jE%EH^FGRK?CYa]PR_F> J
(79) øþZ[IbCpmb>GA@RK?IbCfúLZ[BbC%n> >1ýpPRGA>[M]>=Nò*^f@q>[ïT^Y=K?CEYGRK?mpKNCYaPA_Y>!@qIu=Nmu>[G êN(ë 7FU[ ë <HUAì 3YU·ëVìVîyó 9 o ie K?@4BbCÛ(> *OZ[KN>CP°oH<
(80) t @RIb=?mb>GsnfBb@R>E IuC PA_Yk > , BVmKc@ â ÃÍ âPã¬äåâ ¦sçæg~Ðl£ l ÿIbau>[MOBDCFC$yÿªIQmb>=?BbCFE õYGAIHZ1>jEH^YGA>bótüI BbGR>öPA_Y>ÞEHKc@qPRK?CYab^YKc@R_YKNCFa×ïT>BDPR^YGA>@ûIDï%ol ie ó ø K?G`@iPjUYKP Z[BDC=?KNM]KNPPR_F> nYGABbCFZ`_YK?CYaPRI*BO@R^YnF@R>1PIbï PA_Y>!mQBDGAK?BbnY=?>@UYBb@A@q^YM]K?CYaPR_FBDPPR_F> IDPR_F>[G`@ZBDCnf>Bu@R@RK?abCY>jE!npò!^YCYKNP:õYGAIbõFBbauBDPRK?IbCóQop>Z[IbCFEUQKPXBb=N=?IQü@ ïTIbG
(81) GA>[=?>[mQBDCFZ[>L=?>BbGRgC KNCYafU:BDCFEÞnYG`BDCFZ`_FKNCYa._Y>^YGRKc@qPRKcZ[@]nFBu@q>jE IbC nIIu=N>jBDC6Z1IuCF@iPAGABbKNCP]õYGAIbõFBbauBQPAKNIuC ül_YKcZ`_ BDCFBb=Nòpô[>PA_Y> ül_FIb=?>@q>[PLIDï ù GR>=N>mVBbCP`úmQBDGAKcBDnY=?>@ób< @ê ì 3YU1ëVìVîf@R_YIQü UbPR_Y>j@q>lïT>jBQPA^YGR>j@:Z[BbC õYGRIHEH^fZ1>lEHG`BDMOBQPAK?Z@Rõf>>lE y^YõF@
(82) K?CPR_Y>lIQmu>[G`BD=?=uõ>[GRïTIbGAMOBDCFZ[>@IDïPR_F> oH<
(83) tÞZ`_F>Z`éb>GUQBbCFE PR_p^F@ IDïPR_Y>%ül_YIb=?>;@RòH@iPA>[Mólo ie BD=c@qIïT>jBQPR^FGR>j@!MOBDCpò.IDPR_F>[G÷nFGABbCFZ`_YK?CYa4_Y>[^FGRKc@iPAK?Z@[U BDCFEs@qK?ô[> =?>BbGRCFKNCYa ù @R>[>*êNë .Dî ú1ó.
(84) â ¡èUÆP ¦jé ä Ð H¥AÍÏsB n×iÆi ¦s £ t_Y>!@RKNM ^Y=?BDPRK?IbCõFBuZ`éVBbab>ÀBD=?=NIQü@ïTIuGlPR_F> KNCPR>GABuZ·PAKNmu>:BDCFEÀG`BDCFEYIbMÛ@RK?M÷^Y=cBQPAKNIuC IbïpPR_Y>:n>[_fBVmK?Ib^FGIDïpPR_F>:M]IpEY>[=bn>[K?CYaõFGRIHZ1>j@R@R>Eó. yP!K?@ Z[IbM]õFBQPAKNnF=N>]nIDPR_öülKNPR_.PR_Fq > +9,2,¥nFBu@q>jE°BbCFE°PR_Y>;oY<
(85) 9 t ¥nFBu@q>jEûGA>[õFGR>j@q>CuP`BQPAKNIuCU BDCFE]>CFZ[BbõF@q^F=?BDPR>@XB ^YCYKNïTIbGAM'PAGABuZ1>_fBDCFEH=?K?CYa!M]>Z`_FBbCYKc@qM PR_YGAIb^Fab_]ül_YKcZ`_]PR_Y> @iPAIbGA>E PRG`BbZ1>j@lZ[BbC%n> KNCf@qõ>Z1PR>EBbCFE;GA>[GA^YCó ê. d°äLá çjbqæ4pèiäXá4. C?EiFjGJI Kc@ BsGRIunY^F@qPU¾ü>[=?=X@iPAGR^fZ·PR^FGR>jE°BbCFE p >1ýHKNnF=N>OõY=cBQPRïTIbGAM ïTIbG!@RòpM÷nIb=?K?ZM]IHEH>[= `Z _Y>Z`épK?CYaFUVEH>@RK?abCY>jEÀPRI nf>lBbõYõY=?K?ZBDnY=?>XK?C!PA>Z`_YCYIu=NIuabò PRG`BDCf@iïT>G õYGAI;i>jZ·P`@[ó «C!PA_YK?@õFBbõf>GU üL> _FBVmb>@q_YIQülCû_YIQüÏ+5,4,¥nfBb@R>EgBbCFE°oH<
(86) t9ynFBu@q>jE4M]IpEY>[=
(87) Z`_Y>Z`épK?CYa;BbGR> KNCPR>abG`BQPA>E KNC4PA_Y>÷CF>[ü(mb>GA@RK?IbCID2 ï CNEiFHGkIsUYPR_fBQP @RK?abCYKNñfZ[BbCPR=?ò;>1ýpPA>[CFEY@ PR_F>÷õYGA>[mpK?Ib^F@lmu>[G`@qK?IbCªó. «CsõfBDGRPRKcZ1^Y=cBDGjUpüL> _FBVmu> EYK?@AZ1^F@A@R>E%PR_Y>ÀïT^FCFZ·PAKNIuCFBD=?KPAKN>j@BDCfE*PA_Y>!BDG`Z`_YKNPR>Z1PR^YGA>ÀID ï CNEHO FHGJIOìHUXPR_FBDP;K?CuPA>[auGABDPR>@%oH<
(88) 9 t ¥nfBb@R>E×@qPABQPA>gIDï PA_Y>ûBbGqP;mu>[GAKñZ[BQPAKNIuC PR>Z`_FCYK?ð^Y>j@[ULK?@ BDnY=?>lPRI÷üLIuGRépK?CYa!Bb@LB õYGAIbnY=?>[M p BQPRPR>CY>[GLKNe C ,4 ieg< JoïTIuGRMOBDPUuBbCFEPABuZ`ép=N>j@PR_Y> @iP`BQPA> >1ýHõY=?Iu@RKNIuC%ülKNPR_4Z1IuCY>ÀIDïKNC p ^Y>[CFZ[> GR>jEH^FZ1PRK?IbCó C?EiFjGJIOìKc@:Z[^YGRGA>[CPA=Nò!n>[K?CYa ^F@R>E]Bu@PR_Y>lmu>[GAKñZ[BQPAKNIuC éu>[GACY>[=HIbï¬B÷J4 < ,6PRIpIu=FEH> mb>[=?Ibõ>E÷KNCBPA>Z`_YCFIb=?Ibabò PAGABbCF@iïT>G õFGRI ;i>Z·PjUVül_Y>[GA>BbC÷K?M]õf>GABDPRK?mb>L@qPiòp=N>õYGAIbauGABbMM]K?CYa =?BbCYab^FBbab>:Kc@ ^F@q>jE PAIEH>j@RZ[GRK?nf>L>[M nf>jEYEH>E Z1IuCuPAGRIu=N=?>[G`@ót_Y>LKNCPR>abG`BQPAKNIuC IDïfEH>jZ1IuMõIu@RK PRK?IbC*PA>Z`_YCFK?ð^Y>j@ ù >bó aFó?UBbnF@iPAGABuZ·PAKNIuC*BDCFE*Z[IbM]õIu@RKPAKNIuCFBD=mb>GRKNñfZ[BDPRK?IbCfú
(89) K?@L^YCFEH>GlEH>[mu>[= IbõYM]>[CPjó «C!PR_F>LïT^YPR^YGA>bUQü>õY=?BbC!PAIK?Cpmb>@qPRK?auBDPR>BPAKNau_PR>[GK?CPR>[auGABDPRK?IbC!n>1Piü>[>N C +5,2,> nFBb@R>E*BbCFE%oY<
(90) 9 t ¥nFBu@q>jE]PR>jZ`_YCYIu=NIuabK?>@ót_Y> CY>ü KNCPA>[GACFBD=¬BDG`Z`_YKNPR>Z1PR^YGA> Bb=?@RI÷Iuõf>CF@^Yõ PR_Y>OõIu@A@qK?nYK?=NKNPiò4PAI4KNCPR>abG`BQPA>EHK >[GA>[CP!nfIpIu=N>jBDC.>[CFZ[IpEYKNCYa@OêëjíQîXBbCFE°EYK >[GA>[CP ù >uó afóNU CYIbCsnfIpIu=N>jBDCfúmu>[GAKñfZBQPAKNIuC;>[CFabK?CY>@ó ë. VcìáVªãgVªá çHVP. jÕ>í¾ 1ij²«ÌûØ_îAÖî ØLÊY´b¶ bHí¬A Òsï¥`²«²«j ´ÜÍD ²Zð`ñ FÕ%Db ÊHË i· [ËRÌ Ê¥g [p [D{ ²«² Ê ²«·´gj.uتx{|²«jVAi²`Õgw~öD¶²i uµLq [Ï [p´ûÝËRÌ `bËqÌQÚ
(91) 1« î`Êp [ËRÌF·´uii²`. òBó¡ôzõöÙ÷$ôzô ø ù_úûlü=ý_ø þôóÿ4ùáôó
(92) côûvù nó~õnÿôûeúûlü=ý û$úø ù ÿçù_ô (ù 4ù÷ý ý óáø ÿç û ó Zú. û pjj¶ j Ï!" # ÕHDÖuiÎA«{| Ai [Îul¿ jbÕ ¿DÕ HÕ:ÒAiá`î fLYÕ:z ÖHj²`X [p´k
(93) ð ÕLÝ%ÕLzN 1iÍVjÕ'z ÖHj²«ij li· ²«Îû D´u` ËqÌAËRÍDÎbÕw¥ òBó¡ôzõ$ ö &%!'N ò %$ F)(*(* DÕ bÕØÕDÒAijbØÕbz! [«i
(94) ð Õbz [iÍVjÝ%Õ+u¶yï q Db p´-,Õ/.YÌD¶FÕfDb ÊHËÝD´u`FzÌu`ËqÍbuÎ ±L²«ÎûuتxÏí iQËA·´u¶bi`²²yi` j´öÏÒ ®® ²`Õ×w¥ òBó¡ôzõ1 ö 0234 cô5û ) ó û$õ ¬ô(7 û 6 ù ÿÖþû ý "ô8Z8ú nÿôû )(*(*(DÕ ¹uÕØÕfÒAijØÕ¬z! 1«iTH: ð Õ¬z [iÍV¾ ´9, Õ:.HÌb¶FÕ Db ÊHË D´u`ËqÌ`ËqÍDuÎÚ:i̶u Ò ®® ²`Õ]w~ òBó¡ôzõ ü(ÿçûþù?ô - -;Pÿ 9<û óûl8ú nÿôûlú = ø cô)û 5 ó ûlõ Nôû´÷$ôzô ø ù6úûlüý_ø þ8ô > óÿ 4? ù ô= ó @ côû~ù nó~õ nÿôû¬úû$ü2ý û$úø ù ÿçù>Aô 1 ù 4C ù B÷ ý ý ED FGFH f5(8(*(bÕ DÕØÕ·Ò[ I HÕDØJ+¶uØL¶ui! [i·´lØXÖÖbiV ËqÌÏc[j¾í i1buÎb [Ï?A¥>¾í ijÖHR«iA²¬ w~QiAiQËRÍQ{ uÎ!b[Ï?¥Ú [i±²«uÎ ØL¶bij! [iËxÌu`i`À{ ¾í i1buÎuÕªw¥]YÕpµ`²« p´ ® Õ K [iA DH·´u{ i[i²` òBó¡ôzõ ü(ÿçûþùBô ! !L õ ôûl ü <. û óû$8ú nÿô(û$ú 8ø M!NO <P'RQNôPó S(Pù ô T&ôO û ;sôó Zú 8ø 'U ~ôzü(ù í ²i bw~q Q Xj¶*5(8(G QÕ áô ó <û$3ü ù nóÿú V ø jóÿ nÿnõúW ø ( ù 2ù $ ¸bÕl}Õ
(95) ð ÕÒª«D Q·Õ!Qb ÊHjËÒQj· [4! Öu¶ [ij*Ú:iÌs[q´uAi·´;Êp 1«D{¥´b`Ë`²«js´u [{ Î[q ²`Õ ý 'Y c8ô TZnÿçûC þ ó [8 (ù [¿ ¹uÓTVÔ\ 8¿ (1¯Qb·Db`Öbi` ÊHA5(*( D¿ Õ DÕOXbÕ}Õ¬Ò ¶uiËqÌf: ð Õ¬Ý%Õz [iÍjj:]ÀÕKªÕ¬ÝË1ÝN [f ® Õ:KÕ ® ¾ [p´^KÕ:XuÕ_LÚ ÎbÕDbÀ{ ÊHË]ÝD´u`XzÌu`ËqÍbuÎ\
(96) · ` Dq 1i`²À [p´gÒAVjp´YÕ <)û ôó t8ú nÿô(ûÄúûla ü c8ô TZ"ú8nÿôû (uÓ" ¿ Ô\A¹`¿ ¯p [bWXj¶u )(*(Q¿ Õ.
(97) bÕØÕQz! 1«iTð:Õ Ý%Õbz 1iÍVj+ÕQµ¶uËqÌÎj bQ p´ÀÝ%ÕQ}L1VRiTÕlº>»¼$½¬¾-\j AÚöDbÊHjË ÝD´b`Y RiÐA·Õfw¥÷ÜÕ _ [ÊDÚ Ëq̲: [p´ ® Õ í¬`·´Yu`´uii²` òBó¡ôzõ ü(ÿçûþùM8øb [8 û 9 côû > Kf`ËAi¶biÜ[i`² ) ó û$õ ôûJ cô8=T / ó>çý5ÿüG üJc óÿ diõ ú8nÿôûeB ýOcD FGFH uD¶ ÊHR·¸j f ]zj Ö¶biALbËAAË`juÖp [Îj`²XG¹ (j·¯VG¹ (*(DFxfi`Qiubw|q QZ X¶*5 (*(8(bÕFDÖuiÎA«{| RiN [ÎuÕ (b> Õ ð
(98) Õuz [iÍV gÕuµLi¶ ÊHRiÎuD [pC ´ ]ÀhÕ _ [! ζËqÌ ÕfØL[iÌA$ KfQÍ! [ Kb& x K;ÝD´u`fzÌAËRÍQ{ uÎuÕ ;ôótúøi'U ~ôzü(ù=ÿçûj (ù k6 ùÿ þû F·uÓy·Ô \ * ·¯ D +u`Êui¶ [«O5 (8(G QÕ `b> Õ ð
(99) ÕpzN 1iÍV f ´ lZÕ .YÌ b! Õ m [qn ´ KfAV`¾Qb ÊHjËÝD´b`¾zÌu`ËRÍD/Î \HØþÜAÚ ØLÖuÖuiV [ËRÌ Ï? LAiÏ?bÎ;ØXiiÌu AiË]ziË`¶ui²`Õ4x`ËqÌË· [
(100) }LAÖH«Àz
(101) ݱL{¥z
(102) D{ (V·{i·¸bbËqÌQj
(103) [Ï z Ö¶biAXbËAAË`jpz [iu`ÎjÝ`j]±LVAi²«~Qv í«i²«Ê¶biÎjÌf~ íYØ · ¿Q·[{~* (bY±lbØ Ý] `*5 (8(VQÕ j> Õ ð
(104) ÕÝ%Õz [iÍV ´ ð
(105) Õ[Ø zÕ ðª Ai²«fÕbQbDiÌu`²«²[ϲybËqÌui î· 1i²«Íj`Aiju²Ïc[¾Êuq [ËqÌu{ uÎ!i li`'ÖHq [¾ÎjËjÕlw~9 ô þÿõtô9ò8óô þó¡ú84ù)o
(106) QNôóPS(ù~ôT ÕbÖbiÎjRªAi ÎufÝ] ` (jDjp ) Õ Kf`ËAi¶biÜ[i`²:*zj Öu¶uiALDË``Ë`ÜuÕF·DjÕ z¿DO Õ + j´b!zjÖu~Q/ Kf & +¬r qY ðuiË`Àµ¶uËqÌÎj bpµ
(107) ] Ìu bØXi! ´ux¬ [Ë`ËqÌ` b ´ ݲ«Ì] [q´b Õ.Ò `AÐui²ÀÏÊHj¶up´u`´û D´b`
(108) ËRÌu`ËqÍbuÎs 1! °´u¶u²y«iN [:²«A«iÎuÕ°w¥ ¿bÕ òBó¡ôzõ ¡üÿçûþùôs ý1c^t/uGuGv pÖp [Îj`²:¹jj¸1¯V¹Q[bs `bÕl}L U +uq A·¬µf ] ÌuTfÒ 1i¶ÍDJ Ì .HH¬Ý²«Ì ,Õf [q´b ¬ [pU ´ KF +¬w qY6 Õ íi[i{ i î``´*«q ·VAi²i [x \ð#y Ë``Qli· [ËRÌ Êu¥% [p b²«²Ïc[VAiÐpË· 1ij [p´OÏ [²«ÐË· [ijFÕ w¥ òBó¡ôzõ ¡üÿçûþù>ô=
(109) v3tGs<û óû$ú8nÿnôû$ú øV côû5) ó û$õ >ôûJ cô8TZ ó9ý ÿüh ¡üUc óÿ dPõ ú8nÿôû Ö Î`²Xj* (·¯Q¹j ¿DÕfDÖuiÎA· Xj¶N ¿jbÕ A¹u> Õ ð
(110) Õ¬µ¶uËqÌÎj b¾Ø Õ¬Ý] ²«²i [i[«iu [p´s}Õ¬b`Ê ²yi uTÕØLËR·¬ [p´%iÌuÀi`²yÚ:ªÏcj·1 Ú \ ð#qbÖjiÎÀ´uAiAi u²« Ö uÎ ²X²i [i²yÐH [Ê~QÕªw¥ òBó¡ôzõösý ý_ý < Y5 (*(bÕ ·D> Õ ð
(111) ÕYµ¶uËqÌÎj ! p´ } ÕHb`Ê ²yi uTÕ
(112) ØLÖÖuuuÎ iÌ ® ·D²y{ íª¶bip (ÖbiQË`·´b¶uili u{ ËAN [¶²i [Ï?i¶ ²`Õ'w¥Û ðV`pa K ! g [pk ´ í¾ N öÝ`b`´uii²` òBó¡ôzõ ü(ÿçûþùMô ý <hz<¡ýnD FGFhogýhü8[(úûlõ ù=ÿ¸ûNý ónÿ dPõáÿú øL<û áøçø ÿÖþh ûlõ Ö ÎjA²[¹[¯ ([¹uÕFDÖuiÎA:ªAi Îuf5 (8(*(bÕ `¸b> Õ ðuiË`Oµ¶uËqÌÎj b¾Ý] [iË`;Ý] 1q [i· DØXi! [p´bx¬ [Ë`ËqÌ` b [p´ ® ·b´b@ .F [ ÊHjufÕ ð ¶p 1iuÎ ²«· 1iËRÌÌ`¶bi²yiË`²X [p´ Öui î· [i i`ËqÌuNÑQ¶u`²
(113) ÖuiÖHj²«ij ²i 1i²yÐH [{ Êu~QÕw~À}z ïyA` µ[ jñ QØX q [p´bA! Kf`i²«ËqÌfQ [p´ÀxfjÊ [² ÜLÖuÍV·Úlj`´uii²` òBó¡ôzõ ¡üÿçûþù ¿j[LÏ õxóP " ô3 ùiÿçûn cô3=TZ ó&$õáÿ} û$õ [Öp Î`²G¹ ·¯Qj¸jDÕ ôAV<{Z ýN|t/uGuGv jj¶ P DÖuiÎA·l ¿jDjÕ 5 DÕ µ Õ XuÕ _Ö îA! FÕxÌl D´b`YËRÌu`ËqÍVAXDÖfÕ <MVM!MK÷vó¡úû~ùáöcôûjlôx~PúóP M8ûþÿçûi óÿçûþ ¿[uÓ|Ô \ ¿8 8(·¯ ¿8(jDÝ] `*5 (*(* DÕbÖH`ËAN [²«²«¶lj +[i! fÝAiÌD´b²:ObÏN¥Ú [i íq [ËAiË`jÕ `b1 Õ ]ÀÕ KÕHÝË1Ý FÕ 8-ôø ÿõ1'-ôzüG áøV ¡õS(ÿçûþ V Õ ]l¶QÚALØLË· ´u` = Ë í¶ÊuTÕF5 (8(jbÕ )(bÕ Ý] 1«iÌAJ Ú m ÕQݲ«ÍVAÚ: Ë îjQzj[! +ÕVÝ] ´uÎV [f8 , Î .YÌ u8 KFQq [O .YÌ uÎu ´ÀbÌ [q ´ Ý] [ÍHÕzÌp 1#Ù \ðÎju`AiÎ yÀË``Q²i [²«jVA·ÕFw~ ò8óôzõ ¡üÿçûþù=ô 0G*-6 ù ÿÖþû ¿[jbÕ ý "ô8Zú8nÿôûe côû)5 ó ûlõ HÖp [Îj`²L1¯DVQÕFØXz
(114) Ý%$ ¿[bO Õ XbÕ í¬LÕ ¶` pf ´ XuÕYDÏc ÍD²`Õ
(115) DÖH`Ë`ÐpË` [ijO [p´jAiÐpË· 1i]ÏËAjËA¶u«i`QX²yb²yi` ²
Documenti correlati
D413 - in the C-linker – and in position R297 – in the intracellular portion of S5 – are cross-linked (Fig. 2 ), mutant channels R297C_D413C channels are locked in the open
This notion, based on the concept of strongly connected component, allows to partition the nodes of a graph and to guide the computation of the bisimulation algorithm. In this work
I Strong cyclic solutions: SA is a strong cyclic solution to the planning problem if from any state in Q some terminal state of K is reachable and all the terminal states of K are in
limited sensitivity: one good setting, does not require expert users much higher capacity (more variables) than BDD based techniques Various techniques: Bounded Model
all but one literals in η are as “old” as possible Learning: in future branches, when all-but-one literals in η are assigned, the remaining literal is assigned to false
The role of metabotropic glutamate receptors for the generation of calcium oscillations in rat hippocampal astrocytes
diverse acque sotterranee emergenti dai quattro acquiferi, me- diante i quali è suddivisibilc la struttura idrogeologica in esame, sono state condotte analisi fisico- chimiche
Le pratiche e gli strumenti di accertamento del prior learning sperimentati nei PLA/ PLAR Centers canadesi, pur con i dovuti adattamenti, possono trovare
