Percorsi
di ricerca
Quarantacinque anni di lavoro accademico – ripercorsi in una corposaIntroduzione – sono condensati in questo libro plasmato dall’intreccio di metodi quantitativi e qualitativi che interagiscono tra di loro (mixed methods), guidati da un modello di attore sociale, pensato e progettato da Luciano Gallino negli anni Ottanta.
Il volume è suddiviso in quattro parti. La prima colloca l’ex-voto nella storia dell’arte ed enuncia le teorie, principalmente sociologiche e semio-logiche, che hanno costituito i riferimenti dell’intero lavoro. La seconda affronta il tema del santuario come terreno sacralizzato – per lo più da apparizioni mariane – e luogo d’elezione per la custodia degli ex-voto. La terza parte illustra le scelte di metodo che hanno consentito di osservare e rilevare, analizzare e interpretare l’oggetto ex-voto. La quarta, infine, dà conto di elaborazioni e analisi effettuate su 10.000 ex-voto italiani fotografati e schedati nel lungo periodo di lavoro sul campo.
I dati raccolti ci parlano dello stretto rapporto tra cielo e terra, tra straordinario e quotidiano, tra fede e scienza, rimarcato dagli innumere-voli episodi di pietà che consentono di ripercorrere la Storia e di coglier-ne le trasformazioni, partendo dalla vita vissuta di migliaia di protagoni-sti. Le tavolette votive dipinte si rivelano infatti un eccezionale vettore per riprodurre e trasmettere i valori della comunità: famiglia, patria, lavoro, cura degli animali e del territorio, uso dei mezzi di trasporto e delle vec-chie e nuove tecnologie. Negli ex-voto si snodano i cicli della vita e delle stagioni e l’impatto su di essi di piccole e grandi catastrofi naturali o socia-li che si ripresentano nel tempo con regolarità impressionante, trovando-ci purtroppo ogni volta impreparati. Nell’affrontare rischi e calamità di ogni genere, donne e uomini degli ex-voto rivolgono – con grande dignità – lo sguardo verso l’alto, chiedendo di sopravvivere, persistere e replicarsi quali entità biologiche ed entità culturali. La lunga sequenza di eventi narrati negli ex-voto costituisce una sorta di DNA della nostra nazione, indispensabile per dare forma al futuro del Paese. Anche per questo moti-vo, gli ex-voto dipinti devono essere rilevati, schedati, conservati, protet-ti, valorizzaprotet-ti, studiati e portati all’attenzione del grande pubblico, come questo volume si propone.
Renato Grimaldi è direttore della Scuola di Scienze Umanistiche dell’Università degli Studi di Torino. È stato preside della Facoltà di Scienze della Formazione, direttore del Dipartimento di Scienze dell’Educazione e della Formazione e diret-tore del Dipartimento di Filosofia e Scienze dell’Educazione dello stesso ateneo. E-mail: renato.grimaldi@unito.it.
11
15
2.1
Re
na
to
Gri
m
ald
i
EX-VOTO
D’IT
ALIA
Renato Grimaldi
Ex-voto d’Italia
Strategie di comportamento sociale,
per grazia ricevuta
FrancoAngeli
11152.1_1152.21 22/09/20 11:15 Pagina 1C
OLLANA DIRETTA DAR
ENATOG
RIMALDIComitato scientifico: Roberto Albera – Dipartimento di Scienze Chirurgiche (Torino), Marco Cantamessa – Dipartimento di Ingegneria Gestionale e della Produzione
(Torino), Elena Cattelino – Università della Valle d’Aosta, Marco Devecchi – Dipartimento di Scienze Agrarie, Forestali e Alimentari (Torino), Maria Adelaide Gallina – Dipartimento di Filosofia e Scienze dell’Educazione (Torino), Cristina Ispas – Università
“Eftimie Murgu” din Re¸si¸ta (Romania), Vincenzo Lombardo – Dipartimento di Informatica (Torino), Sergio Margarita – Dipartimento di Management (Torino), Witold
Misiuda-Rewera – Uniwersytet Marii Curie-Sklodowskiej (Lublin), Silvano Montaldo – Dipartimento di Studi Storici (Torino), Giovanni Onore – Departamento de Biologia (Quito), José Emilio Palomero Pescador – Universidad de Zaragoza, Maria Margherita
Satta – Dipartimento di Storia, Scienze dell’Uomo e della Formazione (Sassari), Roberto Trinchero – Dipartimento di Filosofia e Scienze dell’Educazione (Torino),
Christopher Weiss – New York University
Percorsi di ricerca
Le scienze umane e le scienze naturali sono destinate a cooperare nonostante la frattu-ra cognitiva esistente. Questa collana, che nasce con il coinvolgimento di studiosi dei due campi, vede nella ricerca e nell’uso delle nuove tecnologie il luogo sia fisico sia concettuale per la creazione di un insieme di modelli di relazioni di riferimento per la costruzione di teorie e per l’orientamento di scelte rilevanti in campo politico, economico, industriale, tec-nologico, sanitario, educativo, ambientale, storico, sociale.
,OSUHVHQWHYROXPHqSXEEOLFDWRLQRSHQDFFHVVRVVLDLOILOHGHOO¶LQWHURODYRURq OLEHUDPHQWHVFDULFDELOHGDOODSLDWWDIRUPD)UDQFR$QJHOL2SHQ$FFHVV KWWSELWO\IUDQFRDQJHOLRD )UDQFR$QJHOL2SHQ$FFHVVqODSLDWWDIRUPDSHUSXEEOLFDUHDUWLFROLHPRQR JUDILHULVSHWWDQGRJOLVWDQGDUGHWLFLHTXDOLWDWLYLHODPHVVDDGLVSRVL]LRQHGHL FRQWHQXWLDGDFFHVVRDSHUWR2OWUHDJDUDQWLUHLOGHSRVLWRQHLPDJJLRULDUFKLYLH UHSRVLWRU\LQWHUQD]LRQDOL2$ODVXDLQWHJUD]LRQHFRQWXWWRLOULFFRFDWDORJRGL ULYLVWHHFROODQH)UDQFR$QJHOLQHPDVVLPL]]DODYLVLELOLWjHIDYRULVFHODIDFLOLWj GLULFHUFDSHUO¶XWHQWHHODSRVVLELOLWjGLLPSDWWRSHUO¶DXWRUH 3HUVDSHUQHGLSL KWWSZZZIUDQFRDQJHOLLWFRPHBSXEEOLFDUHSXEEOLFDUHBDVS ,OHWWRULFKHGHVLGHUDQRLQIRUPDUVLVXLOLEULHOHULYLVWHGDQRLSXEEOLFDWL SRVVRQRFRQVXOWDUHLOQRVWURVLWR,QWHUQHWwww.francoangeli.itHLVFULYHUVLQHOODKRPHSDJH DOVHUYL]LR³,QIRUPDWHPL´SHUULFHYHUHYLDHPDLOOHVHJQDOD]LRQLGHOOHQRYLWj
COPY 15,5X23 1-02-2016 8:56 Pagina 1
Renato Grimaldi
Ex-voto d’Italia
Strategie di comportamento sociale,
per grazia ricevuta
Percorsi
di ricerca
/¶DWWLYLWj GL ULFHUFD FKH KD SRUWDWR DOOD SXEEOLFD]LRQH GL TXHVWR YROXPH VL q VYROWD QHO /DERUDWRULR GL VLPXOD]LRQH GHO FRPSRUWDPHQWR H URERWLFD HGXFDWLYD ³/XFLDQR *DOOLQR´ QHOO¶DPELWR GHO 3URJHWWR GL (FFHOOHQ]D GHO 'LSDUWLPHQWR GL )LORVRILD H 6FLHQ]H GHOO¶(GXFD]LRQHGHOO¶8QLYHUVLWjGHJOL6WXGLGL7RULQR &RS\ULJKWE\)UDQFR$QJHOLVUO0LODQR,WDO\ /¶RSHUDFRPSUHVHWXWWHOHVXHSDUWLqWXWHODWDGDOODOHJJHVXOGLULWWRG¶DXWRUHHGqSXEEOLFDWDLQYHUVLRQH GLJLWDOHFRQOLFHQ]DCreative Commons Attribuzione-Non Commerciale-Non opere derivate 4.0
Internazionale &&%<1&1'
L’Utente nel momento in cui effettua il download dell’opera accetta tutte le condizioni della licenza d’uso dell’opera previste e comunicate sul sito
KWWSVFUHDWLYHFRPPRQVRUJOLFHQVHVE\QFQGGHHGLW
Indice
,QWURGX]LRQH8QDOHWWXUDVLVWHPLFDGHJOLH[YRWRGLRenato Grimaldi SDJ 3DUWH,±9HUVRXQRVFKHPDFRQFHWWXDOH ([YRWR5LIOHVVLRQLVXOODOHWWHUDWXUDDUWLVWLFDDQWLFDHVXOGLEDW WLWRFULWLFRGDOODVHFRQGDPHWjGHO;,;VHFRORDRJJLGLGianni Carlo Sciolla ª/D FRPSOHVVLWj GHOO¶H[YRWR IRUPH IXQ]LRQL H OLQJXDJJLR GL
Simona Maria Cavagnero
ª
([YRWR H PHPRULD FXOWXUDOH XQD SURVSHWWLYD VHPLRWLFD GL
Jenny Ponzo ª
,O UDFFRQWR LQ XQ¶LPPDJLQH 7HRULD H PRUIRORJLD GHOO¶H[YRWR GLSLQWR GLRenato Grimaldi ª
/D UDSSUHVHQWD]LRQH GHOOD VLWXD]LRQH QHJOL H[YRWR GLSLQWL GL
Maria Adelaide Gallina
ª 3DUWH,,±,VDQWXDULFRPHOXRJRGLJUD]LHULFHYXWH ,VDQWXDULHOHOHJJHQGHGLIRQGD]LRQHGLRenato Grimaldi ª
, VDQWXDUL GHO 3LHPRQWH OH OHJJHQGH GL IRQGD]LRQH GL Simona
Maria Cavagnero ª
, VDQWXDUL GHOOD /LJXULD OH OHJJHQGH GL IRQGD]LRQH GL Renato
Grimaldi, Simona Maria Cavagnero
ª 'LVSRVL]LRQLproanimaHULWXDOLGLSURWH]LRQHWUDFFHVWRULFKHGL DWWLGHYR]LRQDOLWUD*RYRQHH$OED GLAntonella Saracco
ª 3DUWH,,,±8QPRGHOORGLDWWRUHVRFLDOHSHUODULFHUFDVXOFDPSR (*2XQPRGHOORGLDWWRUHVRFLDOHSHUODOHWWXUDGHJOLH[YRWR GLRenato Grimaldi ª
/DULFHUFDVXOFDPSRGLRenato Grimaldi SDJ ,FDUDWWHULVRFLRDQWURSRORJLFLGHLFRPXQLGHO3LHPRQWHHGHOOD 9DOOHG¶$RVWDGLRenato Grimaldi ª 3DUWH,9±*OLH[YRWRUDFFRQWDQRO¶DQDOLVLGHLGDWL ,SLWWRULHLVDQWLGHJOLH[YRWRGLRenato Grimaldi ª
,VFUL]LRQLSDUROHHLPPDJLQLGLMaria Adelaide Gallina ª
/¶RJJHWWRH[YRWRGLSandro Brignone ª ,OWHPSRHORVSD]LRGHOO¶D]LRQHVRFLDOH³VFLRJOLHUHLOYRWR´GL Renato Grimaldi ª
/HFDWHJRULHGHJOLH[YRWRGLSLQWLGLSimona Maria Cavagnero
Maria Adelaide Gallina
ª /DUDSSUHVHQWD]LRQHGHOODVLWXD]LRQHLOULFKLHGHQWHGLMaria Adelaide Gallina ª /DUDSSUHVHQWD]LRQHGHOODVLWXD]LRQHLOPLUDFRODWRGL Simona Maria Cavagnero ª
6ROLGDULHWj GL JHQHUH QHOOH VWUDWHJLH GL LQGLYLGXD]LRQH H GL LGHQWLILFD]LRQHGLRenato Grimaldi ª 0DQWHQHUHLQYLWDODYLWDRGHOVRSUDYYLYHUHGLPaola Borgna ª 7LSRORJLHGLH[YRWR8Q¶DSSOLFD]LRQHGHOO¶DQDOLVL³QRQPHWUL FD´GHOOHFRUULVSRQGHQ]HGLRoberto Trinchero ª *OLH[YRWRHLOWHUULWRULRGLTania Parisi ª /DUDSSUHVHQWD]LRQHSRSRODUHGHOVRSUDYYLYHUHLQ3URYHQ]DH LQ3LHPRQWHXQDFRPSDUD]LRQHGLBenita Delfino ª %LEOLRJUDILDHULIHULPHQWLELEOLRJUDILFLDFXUDGLRenato Grimaldi ª *OLDXWRUL ª
Introduzione.
Una lettura sistemica degli ex-voto
GLRenato Grimaldi
1. Voci dal passato: per un quadro concettuale degli ex-voto dipinti 2. Il futuro ha un cuore antico
3. Tra metodo standard e metodo non standard (mixed methods): un progetto di ricerca sul campo
4. Un viaggio nell’Italia degli ex-voto 5. Europa del nord e bacino mediterraneo
3RORQLD
%HOJLRH/XVVHPEXUJR 6SDJQD
*UHFLD7XQLVLD0DOWDH&URD]LD )UDQFLD
6. Ecuador (America Latina) 7. Alcune riflessioni
([YRWRLQ,WDOLDHQHOPRQGR
([YRWRLHULHRJJLTXDQGRODSDQGHPLDFLSUHFLSLWDQHOSDVVDWR
8. Un libro, un progetto di ricerca e i risultati 9. Riconoscimenti
9RFLGDOSDVVDWRSHUXQTXDGURFRQFHWWXDOHGHJOLH[YRWRGLSLQWL
1HOOLQJXDJJLRGHOODWHRULDGHLVLVWHPLODFXOWXUDqGHVFULYLELOH©FRPHXQ LQVLHPHGLGHILQL]LRQLLVWUX]LRQLHSURJUDPPLGLFRPSRUWDPHQWRHODERUDWL QHO FRUVR GHOO¶LQWHUD]LRQH XRPRXRPR H XRPRQDWXUD FKH D XQ GDWR PR PHQWRVRQRLQSDUWHPHPRUL]]DWLQHOVLVWHPDSVLFKLFRGHJOLLQGLYLGXLFRP SRQHQWLXQDGDWDSRSROD]LRQHHLQSDUWHVRQRGHSRVLWDWLVXVXSSRUWLPDWHULDOL GLYDULRJHQHUHSUHQGHQGRIRUPDGLWHVWLVFULWWLLGHRJUDPPLSLHWUHVFROSLWH RLQFLVHRVRYUDSSRVWHQDVWULPDJQHWLFLGLVHJQLHPLOOHDOWULPDQXIDWWL$Q FKHJOLHGLILFLVRQRLVWUX]LRQLHSURJUDPPLGLFRPSRUWDPHQWRQHOORVSD]LR LQIDWWLYLQFRODQRLOPRYLPHQWRGLFKLYLWUDQVLWDRYLDELWDDVHJXLUHGHWHUPL QDWLSHUFRUVLª*DOOLQRS7DOLGHILQL]LRQLLVWUX]LRQLHSURJUDPPL RPRGHOOLGLFRPSRUWDPHQWRSRVVRQRHVVHUHFODVVLILFDWL±GDOSXQWRGLYLVWD GHOODWHRULDGHOO¶D]LRQHVRFLDOHDWWRUQRDOODTXDOHUXRWDJUDQSDUWHGHOODSUR EOHPDWLFDVRFLRORJLFD±VXOODEDVHGHOOHIXQ]LRQLFKHWDOLHOHPHQWLFXOWXUDOL KDQQRSHUVRGGLVIDUHELVRJQLXPDQLVLDSULPDULVLDHPHUJHQWLQHOODYLWDDVVR FLDWDFIU*DOOLQRLQSDUWLFRODUHYRFL³FXOWXUD´H³WHFQLFD´ 7DOLSURJUDPPLIDQQRULIHULPHQWRDSRFKHJUDQGLFODVVLDVHFRQGDGHOWLSR GLSUREOHPLXQLYHUVDOLGHOO¶HVLVWHQ]DXPDQDSHUIDUIURQWHDLTXDOLVRQRVWDWL HODERUDWLSUREOHPLGLRUGLQHcognitivoSHUVWDELOLUHLGHQWLWjHGLIIHUHQ]HWUD
VHJQLUHODWLYLDOO¶DPELHQWHQDWXUDOHHVRFLDOHHSRQGHUDUQHLULVFKLGLRUGLQH affettivoULJXDUGDQWLO¶DWWULEX]LRQHGLYDOHQ]HSRVLWLYHHQHJDWLYHDJOLRJJHWWL GLRUGLQHtecnicoUHODWLYLDOODPDQLSROD]LRQHGLPDWHULDOLFRPHIDUHDFXR FHUHXQYDVRGLDUJLOODVHQ]DFKHVLURPSD"GLRUGLQHvalutativoRmorale ULJXDUGDQWLO¶DQWLFLSD]LRQHGHOOHFRQVHJXHQ]HGLXQDGHWHUPLQDWDD]LRQHGHO VLQJRORRGLXQJUXSSRGLorientamento simbolicoLQPHULWRDLVLJQLILFDWLGD DWWULEXLUHDGHYHQWLFUXFLDOLGHOO¶HVLVWHQ]DTXDOLODQDVFLWDODPRUWHODPDODW WLDO¶DPRUHO¶DPLFL]LD©1HVVXQHVVHUHXPDQRqFDSDFHGLYLYHUHHVRSUDY YLYHUHVHQRQULVROYHDOPHQRDOFXQLGHLSUREOHPLSLULFRUUHQWLGLFLDVFXQD FODVVH1HVVXQHVVHUHXPDQRVRSUDYYLYHUHEEHVHGRYHVVHGLYROWDLQYROWD HODERUDUHXQDVROX]LRQHFRQWLQJHQWHDLSUREOHPLFKHLQFRQWUD/DFXOWXUDOD PHPRULDVRFLDOHJOLRIIUHXQLPPHQVRFRUUHGRGLGHILQL]LRQLLVWUX]LRQLH SURJUDPPLWUDFXLVFHJOLHUH(QWURFHUWLOLPLWLJUDQSDUWHGHLSURJUDPPLGL FRPSRUWDPHQWRHGLUDJLRQDPHQWRFKHXQLQGLYLGXRDSSUHQGHVLQGDOODQD VFLWDLQPRGRSUHVVRFKpLUUHYHUVLELOHVRQRLQIDWWLTXHOOLGHOJUXSSRLQFXLJOL FDSLWDGLQDVFHUHªFIUDQFRUD*DOOLQRSS
1HO QRVWUR ODYRUR LQWHJULDPR D TXDQWR DSSHQD YLVWR OD FRQFH]LRQH GHO
mitoVHFRQGR(OLDGHSHULOTXDOHHVVRQDUUDXQDVWRULDVDFUDXQHYHQWRULYH ODWRGD(URLLQFLYLOLWRULFKHGLYHQWDTXLQGLmodello esemplare©/DSULQFLSDOH IXQ]LRQHGHOPLWRTXLQGLq³VWDELOLUH´LPRGHOOLHVHPSODULGLWXWWLLULWLHGL WXWWHOHDWWLYLWjXPDQHVLJQLILFDWLYHDOLPHQWD]LRQHVHVVXDOLWjODYRURHGXFD ]LRQHHFF&RPSRUWDQGRVLFRPHXQHVVHUHXPDQRSLHQDPHQWHUHVSRQVDELOH O¶XRPRLPLWDLJHVWLHVHPSODULGHJOLGqLULSHWHOHORURD]LRQLVLDFKHVLWUDWWLGL XQDVHPSOLFHIXQ]LRQHILVLRORJLFDFRPHO¶DOLPHQWD]LRQHVLD FKH VL WUDWWL GL XQ¶DWWLYLWjVRFLDOHHFRQRPLFDFXOWXUDOHPLOLWDUHHWFª(OLDGHS
6HFRQGR(OLDGHSPHGLDQWHLOULWRO¶XRPRSDVVDVHQ]DSHULFRORGDOWHPSR SURIDQRDOWHPSRVDFUR/RVFULWWRUH&HVDUH3DYHVH±VWXGLRVRGL(OLDGH±VFULYHQHOUDFFRQWREUHYHDel mito, del
simbolo ed altro©8QDSLDQDLQPH]]RDFROOLQHIDWWDGLSUDWLHDOEHULDTXLQWHVXFFHVVLYHH DWWUDYHUVDWHGDODUJKHUDGXUHQHOODPDWWLQDGLVHWWHPEUHTXDQGRXQSR¶GLIRVFKLDOHVSLFFDGD WHUUDW¶LQWHUHVVDSHUO¶HYLGHQWHFDUDWWHUHGLOXRJRVDFURFKHGRYHWWHDVVXPHUHLQSDVVDWR1HOOH UDGXUHIHVWHILRULVDFULILFLVXOO¶RUORGHOPLVWHURFKHDFFHQQDHPLQDFFLDGLWUDOHRPEUHVLOYH VWUL/jVXOFRQILQHWUDFLHORHWURQFRSRWHYDVEXFDUHLOGLR2UDFDUDWWHUHQRQGLFRGHOOD SRHVLDPDGHOODILDEDPLWLFDqODFRQVDFUD]LRQHGHLluoghi uniciOHJDWLDXQIDWWRDXQDJHVWD DXQHYHQWR$XQOXRJRWUDWXWWLVLGjXQVLJQLILFDWRDVVROXWRLVRODQGRORGDOPRQGR&RVu VRQRQDWLLVDQWXDUL,OPLWRqLQVRPPDXQDQRUPDORVFKHPDGLXQIDWWRDYYHQXWRXQD YROWDSHUWXWWHHWUDHLOVXRYDORUHGDTXHVWDXQLFLWjDVVROXWDFKHORVROOHYDIXRULGHOWHPSRH ORFRQVDFUDULYHOD]LRQH3HUTXHVWRDYYLHQHVHPSUHDOOHRULJLQLFRPHQHOO¶LQIDQ]LDqIXRULGHO WHPSR8QXRPRDSSDUVRXQJLRUQRFKLVDTXDQGRVXOOHWXHFROOLQHFKHDYHVVHFKLHVWRGHL VDOLFL HLQWUHFFLDWR XQ FDYDJQRH SRL IRVVH VSDULWR VDUHEEH LO JHQXLQR H SL VHPSOLFH HURH LQFLYLOLWRUH0LWLFDVDUHEEHTXHVWDULYHOD]LRQHGLXQ¶DUWHTXDQGRTXHOJHVWRIRVVHEHQLQWHVR GLXQ¶XQLFLWjDVVROXWDQRQDYHVVHSUHVHQWHHQRQDYHVVHSDVVDWRPDDVVXUJHVVHDXQDVDFUDOH HWHUQLWjFKHIRVVHSDUDGLJPDDRJQLLQWUHFFLDWRUHGLVDOLFL(XQ¶DLDWUDWXWWHGRY¶HJOLVLIRVVH VHGXWRVDUHEEHVDQWXDULRPDTXHVWDDSSDUHJLjXQDFRQFH]LRQHSRVWHULRUHSLPDWHULDOLVWLFD QHOVHQVRGLQDWXUDOLVWLFD*HQXLQDPHQWHPLWLFRqXQHYHQWRFKHFRPHIXRULGHOWHPSRFRVuVL
'DWLTXHVWLSUHVXSSRVWLULWHQLDPRFKHODULFHUFDVXLFRPSRUWDPHQWLGHYR ]LRQDOLLWDOLDQLFKHVWLDPRSHUSUHVHQWDUHSRVVDIRUQLUHSUH]LRVHLQIRUPD]LRQL VXJOLDUFKHWLSLGLPRGHOOLGLFRPSRUWDPHQWRGLIIXVLQHOODSRSROD]LRQHGHOWHU ULWRULR GL ULIHULPHQWR FKH FRQVHQWRQR GL DIIURQWDUH ± FRPH DEELDPR YLVWR VRSUD±DOFXQLJUDQGLSUREOHPLXQLYHUVDOLGHOO¶HVLVWHQ]DXPDQD &RPHPRGHOORIRUPDOHGHOULWXDOHSURSRQLDPRTXHOORHODERUDWRGD'XU NKHLPDXWRUHFKHORVFKHPDWL]]DDWWUDYHUVRLVHJXHQWLHOHPHQWL ODFRSUHVHQ]DILVLFDGLXQJUXSSRODPXWXDFRQVDSHYROH]]DGLXQFRPXQH IRFXVGLDWWHQ]LRQHXQRVWDWRG¶DQLPRHPR]LRQDOHFRQGLYLVR8QDYROWDLQ VWDXUDWHVLJOLHOHPHQWLHKDQQRXQDQGDPHQWRFLUFRODUHHVLLQWHQVLILFDQRD YLFHQGD,ULVXOWDWLVRQRVLPEROLRRJJHWWLVDFULFKHUDSSUHVHQWDQRO¶DSSDUWH QHQ]DDOJUXSSRHQHUJLDHPR]LRQDOHFKHLQYHVWHLSDUWHFLSDQWLJLXVWDUDE ELDQHLFRQIURQWLGHLYLRODWRULGHLVLPEROLVDFUL &LRFFXSHUHPRQHOQRVWURODYRURGLULWXDOLIRUPDOLRLQWHQ]LRQDOLGLWLSR PDFURGDWRFKHHYRFDQRO¶DSSDUWHQHQ]DDLQWHUHFRPXQLWjHGRYHqSUHVHQWH OD VROLGDULHWj PHFFDQLFD FDUDWWHUL]]DWD GD DOWD GHQVLWj ULWXDOH DOWD FRSUH VHQ]DIRUWHIRFXVGLDWWHQ]LRQHHGHPR]LRQHFRPXQHFRQFRQFUHWLVLPEROL GLDSSDUWHQHQ]DUHD]LRQLDOOHYLROD]LRQLVLPEROLFKHHFRQGLIILGHQ]DQHOO¶DW WHJJLDPHQWRYHUVRLQRQPHPEULFIU&ROOLQVSS,QROWUHLO ULWXDOHGHYR]LRQDOHGLFXLFLRFFXSHUHPRDOWHUQDPRPHQWLVDFULDPRPHQWL SURIDQL $OFXQLDXWRULDWWULEXLVFRQRDOULWRXQDIXQ]LRQHLPSRUWDQWHQHOODVRFLHWj FRPHHOHPHQWRFKHFRQWULEXLVFHDFUHDUHXQRUGLQHQHLUDSSRUWLWUDJOLLQGL YLGXLÊLOFDVRGHOPRGHOORGLG¶$TXLOLH/DXJKOLQFKH%UDYR
FRPSLHIXRULGHOORVSD]LR/¶DLDGHOPLRHURHGHY¶HVVHUHWXWWHOHDLHHVXRJQXQDGLHVVHLO FUHGHQWHDVVLVWHDOULFHOHEUDUVLGHOODULYHOD]LRQHª3DYHVHSS©*XDULUH XQ PDODWR q XQ ILQHempirico QHO VHQVR FKH TXDQGR O¶D]LRQH qFRPSOHWDWD
O¶RVVHUYDWRUHLPSDU]LDOHSRWUjGHWHUPLQDUHVHLOSD]LHQWHVWDYLVLELOPHQWHEHQHRqDQFRUDDP PDODWR,OfineTXLqHPSLULFRVLDFKHLPH]]LXVDWLSHUUDJJLXQJHUORDEELDQRRQRQDEELDQR DYXWRHIIHWWR4XDQGRLOILQHGHOO¶D]LRQHqHPSLULFRHLPH]]LVRQRVRYUDQQDWXUDOLWDOHD]LRQH YLHQHGHILQLWDmagica>«@4XHVWHDWWLYLWjHGRFFDVLRQLQHLFDVLWLSLFLKDQQRLQFRPXQHGXH FDUDWWHULVWLFKHVRQRHVWUHPDPHQWHLPSRUWDQWLSHULOPDQWHQLPHQWRGHOVLVWHPDVRFLDOHHLO ULVXOWDWRGHOO¶D]LRQHULYHVWHJUDQGHLQWHUHVVHODEXRQDULXVFLWDQRQVLSXzDVVLFXUDUHFRQLO VRORXVRGHOOHWHFQLFKHUD]LRQDOL6LIDFRVFLHQ]LRVDPHQWHWXWWRLOSRVVLELOHSHURWWHQHUHXQ EXRQUDFFROWRRSUHSDUDUHOHIRU]HSHUODEDWWDJOLDHWXWWDYLDFDSLWDGLQRQULXVFLUHODJUDQGLQH ODVLFFLWjLSDUDVVLWLRODVXSHULRULWjGHOQHPLFRSRVVRQRFRJOLHUHGLVRUSUHVDHSURYRFDUHXQ GLVDVWUR4XDQGRVRQRSUHVHQWLTXHVWHGXHFRQGL]LRQL±SDUWHFLSD]LRQHHPRWLYDQHOULVXOWDWR GHOO¶D]LRQHHLQDGHJXDWH]]DGHOFRQWUROORUD]LRQDOH±SRVVLDPRDVSHWWDUFLGLWURYDUHODPDJLD ,OULWRPDJLFRQRQYLHQHXVDWRal postoGHOOHWHFQLFKHUD]LRQDOLQRWHODPDJLDqin più$SSOL FDQGRODPDJLDJOLXRPLQLKDQQRODFHUWH]]DGLIDUHWXWWRLOSRVVLELOHSHURWWHQHUHXQULVXOWDWR IDYRUHYROHHVSULPRQRVLPEROLFDPHQWHLOORURIRUWHGHVLGHULRHGDQQRQXRYRYLJRUHDOODORUR ILGXFLDª-RKQVRQSS/¶DXWRUHQHOO¶DPELWRGHOOHFUHGHQ]HHULWLUHOLJLRVLID QRWDUHFRPHLOULWRHODIRUPXODPDJLFDSRVVDQRHVVHUHXVDWLDEHQHILFLRGLXQLQGLYLGXRRGL XQJUXSSRSLYDVWRILQRDOO¶LQWHUDVRFLHWj
XWLOL]]DSHUVSLHJDUHODIXQ]LRQHGHOULWRFRPHDWWLYLWjGLUHFXSHURRUJDQL]]D WLYRGHOGLVRUGLQHSURSULRSHUFKpLOULWR©FRRUGLQDULFRVWLWXLVFHFROOHJDPHQWL FRQLOSDVVDWRHFRQXQDFRQFH]LRQHGLIRQGRGHOODYLWDGHOVLQJRORHQHVLQ WRQL]]DOHHVSHULHQ]HFRQTXHOOHGHJOLDOWULSDUWHFLSDQWLªSWHRULDFKH WUDO¶DOWURWHQGHDVSLHJDUHODILRULWXUDULWXDOHFRPHULVSRVWDDO³UXPRUHDP ELHQWDOH´SURGRWWRGDOODFRPSOHVVLWjGHOODVRFLHWjDWWXDOH ,O3URJHWWR$VFOHSLR±TXHVWRqLOQRPHFKHDEELDPRDWWULEXLWRDOQRVWUR SURJUDPPDGLULFHUFD±KDGHILQLWRLSURWRFROOLGLVFKHGDWXUDGHJOLH[YRWR DJOLLQL]LGHJOLDQQL2WWDQWDSDUWHQGRGDYRFLSUHVHQWLQHODizionario di
so-ciologia FKH /XFLDQR *DOOLQR KD SXEEOLFDWR QHO PD q VWDWR GHWHUPL
QDQWHO¶DYHUODYRUDWRDOODYHUVLRQHFRPSXWD]LRQDOHPHGLDQWHWHFQLFKHGLLQ WHOOLJHQ]DDUWLILFLDOHGHOPRGHOORVLVWHPLFRGLDWWRUHVRFLDOH±GHQRPLQDWR (*2YFDS±LGHDWRGD*DOOLQRHYROWRDOODVLPXOD]LRQHGHOODPHQWHGL XQDWWRUHVRFLDOHFRQIURQWDWRGDXQDGHFLVLRQHGLIILFLOH*DOOLQRH %RUJQDH(*2VLqULYHODWRVXELWRPROWRXWLOHSHUUDSSUHVHQWDUH ODVLWXD]LRQHLQFXLVLYHQJRQRDWURYDUHLOULFKLHGHQWHODJUD]LDHLOPLUDFR ODWR,QROWUHFRQVHQWHGLLQGLYLGXDUHFRQVHPSOLFLWjLOUHIHUHQWHPLQDFFLDWR GHOULFKLHGHQWHLOSURSULRFRUSRVLVWHPDGLRULHQWDPHQWRDIILQHELRORJLFRR DIILQHFXOWXUDOHLOUHIHUHQWHPLQDFFLDWRGHOPLUDFRODWRFRUSRHVLVWHPDGL RULHQWDPHQWRHLQSDUWLFRODUHORVFRSRXOWLPRVRSUDYYLYHQ]DSHUVLVWHQ]D UHSOLFD]LRQHFROOHJDWRDOUHIHUHQWHPLQDFFLDWRGHOPLUDFRODWR1HOFDVRLQ FXLLOULFKLHGHQWHODJUD]LDVHQWDFRPHUHIHUHQWHPLQDFFLDWRLOSURSULRFRUSR RVLVWHPDGLRULHQWDPHQWRVLVWHPDGHLYDORULFKHJXLGDQRO¶D]LRQHGHOO¶DWWRUH VRFLDOHO¶H[YRWRUDSSUHVHQWDXQDVWUDWHJLDGLindividuazioneHJRLVWLFDLO ULFKLHGHQWHFKLHGHODJUD]LDSHUVpVWHVVRQHOFDVRLQFXLLOULFKLHGHQWHOD JUD]LDDYYHUWDODPLQDFFLDDXQDIILQHELRORJLFRILJOLRRFRQJLXQWRFKHFRQ GLYLGHLOSDWULPRQLRJHQHWLFRRDXQDIILQHFXOWXUDOHSDUWQHURDSSDUWHQHQWH DPHGHVLPDFRPXQLWjRDVVRFLD]LRQHO¶H[YRWRUDSSUHVHQWDXQDVWUDWHJLDGL identificazioneDOWUXLVWLFDLQIDWWLLOULFKLHGHQWHLQYRFDODJUD]LDSHUXQDOWUR GLYHUVRGDVp1RQVWLDPRTXLDGDSSURIRQGLUHTXHVWRPRGHOOR±FKHWUDWWH UHPRLQVHJXLWRYDQFRUDFDS±PDSRVVLDPRGLUHFKHROWUHODSURJHWWD ]LRQHGHOODVFKHGDGLULOHYD]LRQHKDSURILFXDPHQWHJXLGDWRODIDVHGLHODER UD]LRQHHDQDOLVLGHLGDWL
SopravvivenzaLQWHVDFRPHFDSDFLWjGLXQVLVWHPDGLGXUDUHROWUHOHVLWXD]LRQLFULWLFKH DPPRUWL]]DQGRODFDSDFLWjGHOO¶DPELHQWHHVWHUQRpersistenzaRVVLDODFDSDFLWjGLULFRQRVFHUVL HGLHVVHUHULFRQRVFLXWRGDDOWULFRPHORVWHVVRLQWHPSLGLYHUVLreplicazioneODFDSDFLWjGLXQ VLVWHPDGLSURGXUUHFRSLHGLVp*OREDOPHQWHFRVWLWXLVFRQRODFDSDFLWjGLYLYHUHHFRQWLQXDUH DYLYHUHGLXQVLVWHPD /DULOHYD]LRQHGHLGDWL±SHUTXDQWRDWWLHQHLOULFKLHGHQWHODJUD]LDHLOPLUDFRODWR±DG HVHPSLRVLGHFOLQDFRVuVLSHQVLDGXQDPDGUHFKHFKLHGHODJUD]LDDOOD0DGRQQDSHULOILJOLR DPPDODWRJHQHUH donnaUXROR casalingaHWj adultaDSSDUWHQHQWHDFODVVHVRFLDOH gentesemplice UDSSUHVHQWDWD QHO VLVWHPD famiglia GHO WHUULWRULR GL origine LQYRFD VDQWR YR
WLYR Madonna SHU ULPXRYHUH LO GDQQHJJLDPHQWR malattia GHO PLUDFRODWR FKH q XQ UHIH UHQWH affine biologicoRVVLDXQILJOLRFRQFXLFRQGLYLGHLOGHOSDWULPRQLRJHQHWLFRGL
Foto 1 – Il prof. Luciano Gallino nell’ottobre 1978 a Cossano Belbo (Cuneo), festeggia – con i colleghi dell’Istituto di Sociologia della Facoltà di Magistero dell’Università di Torino – la pubblicazione del 'L]LRQDULRGLVRFLRORJLD [Foto R. Grimaldi, 1978]
JHQHUH maschioHWj giovaneFODVVHVRFLDOH gente sempliceUDSSUHVHQWDWRQHOVLVWHPD
fa-migliaWHUULWRULRGL origineFKHYHGHPLQDFFLDWRLOSURSULRUHIHUHQWH corpoLQSDUWLFRODUHOR
VFRSRXOWLPR sopravvivenza'HOPRGHOORGLDWWRUHVRFLDOH(*2HVLVWHDQFKHXQDYHUVLRQHFKH
SDUODLOOLQJXDJJLRGHOO¶LQWHOOLJHQ]DDUWLILFLDOHODFXLLPSOHPHQWD]LRQHVLSXzFIULQ*ULPDOGL 'XUDQWHO¶LQWHQVLYRFRUVRGLIRUPD]LRQHFKHKDGDWRYLWDDO/DERUDWRULRGL,QWHOOLJHQ]D $UWLILFLDOH/LDGHO&VL3LHPRQWH±VHPSUHVXSURJHWWRGL*DOOLQR±KRSRWXWRVWXGLDUHQHL SULPLDQQL2WWDQWDLIRUPDOLVPLGLUDSSUHVHQWD]LRQHGHOODFRQRVFHQ]DHPRWRULLQIHUHQ]LDOH FKHVRQRLOFXRUHGHLVLVWHPLHVSHUWL7DOLHVSHULHQ]HPLKDQQRSHUPHVVRGLPLQXWDUHSUR JUDPPLLQOLQJXDJJLR/LVSFKHKDQQRUHVR³LQWHOOLJHQWH´ODQRVWUDEDQFDGDWLÊVXIILFLHQWH LQIDWWLVFULYHUHQHOO¶LQWHUIDFFLDLQOLQJXDJJLRQDWXUDOHDGHVHPSLR©([YRWRGLDQLPDOLªSHU YHGHUVLHOHQFDWHOHWDYROHWWHYRWLYHSHUOHTXDOLQHOODGHVFUL]LRQHVRQRLQGLFDWHSDUROHFRPH FDQLFDYDOOLPXOLDVLQLEXRLHWFVLDDOSOXUDOHVLDDOVLQJRODUH*ULPDOGL4XHVWD FRQRVFHQ]DqVWDWDGDWDVXGLXQQXPHURHOHYDWRGLRJJHWWLDQLPDOLSHUVRQHUHQGHQGRSHU O¶DSSXQWR³LQWHOOLJHQWH´LOVLVWHPDGLLQWHUURJD]LRQHGHOODEDQFDGDWL%UXVFKL1LJUD
3RVVLDPR GLUH DO OHWWRUH FKH WUD OH YDULH VFKHGDWXUH GL H[YRWR± DQFKH LQWHUQD]LRQDOL±FKHDEELDPRLQFRQWUDWRLQWDQWLDQQLGLODYRURVXOFDPSRH QHOOHULFHUFKHLQELEOLRWHFKHLQQHVVXQFDVRVLVRQRGLVWLQWHOHILJXUHGHLUL FKLHGHQWLODJUD]LDHGHLPLUDFRODWLPDQFDQGRGXQTXHODSRVVLELOLWjGLLQGL YLGXDUHJOLH[YRWRGRYHLOULFKLHGHQWHFKLHGHODJUD]LDSHUVpRSHUDOWHUH TXHVWRIDWWRGLYHQWDFUXFLDOHTXDQGRVLDQDOL]]DQROHLQIRUPD]LRQLGLULFHUFD (QRLTXHVWDRSSRUWXQLWjFHODVLDPRGDWDHO¶DEELDPRDPSLDPHQWHXWLOL]]DWD ,OIXWXURKDXQFXRUHDQWLFR
Il futuro ha un cuore anticoqLOWLWRORGLXQOLEURGL&DUOR/HYLGHO
O¶KRYROXWRULSUHQGHUHGDWRFKHLQWHQGLDPRVWXGLDUHOHWDYROHWWHYRWLYHGLSLQWH SHURVVHUYDUHFKLVLDPRVWDWLHSRWHUGXQTXHLPPDJLQDUHLOIXWXURFRQJOLH[ YRWRDEELDPRSUHVRXQDULQFRUVDOXQJDFLQTXHVHFROLSHUJXDUGDUHDOGLIILFLOH PRQGRGHOGRPDQL0DSHUFKpSURSULRJOLH[YRWR"4XDUDQWDFLQTXHDQQLID TXDQGRPLVRQRDIIDFFLDWRDOORVWXGLRSURIHVVLRQDOHGHOODVRFLHWjGLFRPH FDPELDHFRPHIXQ]LRQDPLVRQRGHWWRFKHVDUHEEHVWDWRGLHVWUHPRLQWHUHVVH SRWHULQWHUYLVWDUHXRPLQLHGRQQHGLRJQLFODVVHVRFLDOHHGHWjPDVRSUDWWXWWR GLWXWWLLWHPSLHFKLHGHUHORURTXDOHIRVVHVWDWRO¶HYHQWRULWHQXWRSLVLJQLIL FDWLYRGHOODORURYLWDYLVVXWD0LVVLRQHSUDWLFDPHQWHLPSRVVLELOHLQTXDQWR OHSHUVRQHVFRPSDUVHQRQVRQRRYYLDPHQWH³LQWHUYLVWDELOL´/¶LQFRQWURFRQ OHWDYROHWWHYRWLYHGLSLQWH±GDSSULPDDQLPDWRGDXQDPRUHSHULOEHOORSHU ORVSLULWRGLFRQVHUYD]LRQHGHOODFXOWXUDSRSRODUHHGDOODFUHVFHQWHSDVVLRQH SHUODIRWRJUDILDROWUHFKHGHOPHWRGRGLULFHUFD±PLKDIDWWRFDSLUHFKHLQ ILQ GHL FRQWL TXHOOH LQWHUYLVWH HUDQR Ou FXVWRGLWH DWWUDYHUVROD UDSSUHVHQWD ]LRQHLFRQRJUDILFDGHLIDWWLGLIRQGDPHQWDOHLPSRUWDQ]DSHUJOLDWWRULULFKLH GHQWLVRYHQWHDXQSDVVRGDOODPRUWHWDOLGDJLXVWLILFDUHDGGLULWWXUDO¶LQWHU YHQWRGLXQHVVHUHVDFUR6HQ]DTXHVWDIRUPDGLFRPSRUWDPHQWRGHYR]LRQDOH WXWWHTXHVWHWHVWLPRQLDQ]HVLVDUHEEHURGLVVROWHQHOOD6WRULD(GqFRVuFKHD SDUWLUHGDOODPHWjGHJOLDQQL6HWWDQWD±SULPDFRQXQD<DVKLFD[HSRLFRQ OD PLD SULPD UHIOH[ XQD &DQRQ$( FDULFDWD FRQ UXOOLQL SHU GLDSRVLWLYH
[±qLQL]LDWDODULFHUFDVXOOHWDYROHWWHYRWLYHGLSLQWH,OPLRSDHVHGL RULJLQH±&RVVDQR%HOER&XQHR±KDFRPLQFLDWRD³SDUODUPL´GHOOHVXHWUD VIRUPD]LRQLDWWUDYHUVRJOLH[YRWRGLSLQWLGD)UDQFHVFR%RCichininSUH VHQWLQHO6DQWXDULRGHOOD0DGRQQDGHOOD5RYHUHOXRJRVDFURGLFXLJOLVFULW WRUL3DYHVHH)HQRJOLRKDQQRVFULWWRUHQGHQGROROHWWHUDULDPHQWHPLWLFR*UL PDOGLH /HWHQVLRQLOHJDWHDOOHPDODWWLHGLSHUVRQHRDQLPDOLDOOHJXHUUHDOOH HPLJUD]LRQLDOOHFDODPLWjQDWXUDOLDJOLLQFLGHQWLGRPHVWLFLRVXOODYRURRVX
/DSUH]LRVDLQWHUD]LRQHWUDYHFFKLRHQXRYRqEHQFRQIH]LRQDWDQHOODFLWD]LRQHDWWULEXLWD D2VFDU:LOGH©/DWUDGL]LRQHqXQDLQQRYD]LRQHEHQULXVFLWDªPH]]LGLORFRPR]LRQHDWRUPHQWLGHOODPHQWHPROWHYROWHDWWULEXLWLDSRVVHV VLRQLVDWDQLFKHYHQLYDQRDIILGDWHDVHPSOLFLH[YRWRGLSLQWLFKHDQFRUDRJJL VLWURYDQRGLVVHPLQDWLLQVDQWXDULHFDSSHOOHFDPSHVWULVXWXWWRLOWHUULWRULR QD]LRQDOH5DFFRQWDQGROHYLFHQGHGLXQDSHUVRQDGLXQDIDPLJOLDRGLXQD FRPXQLWjYHLFRODQRPRGHOOLVRFLRFXOWXUDOLFKHWHQGRQRDULSURGXUVLQHOOD VRFLHWjHQHOWHPSR/HWDYROHWWHYRWLYHVRQRGXQTXHXQYHWWRUHFKHFRQVHQWH GLWUDVPHWWHUHHULSURGXUUHQHOWHPSRYDORULHPRGHOOLGLFRPSRUWDPHQWR(D QRLRJJLWRFFDGLFKLDPDUOHDUDFFRQWDUHOHORURPLFURVWRULH /¶H[YRWRqXQ©RJJHWWRRIIHUWRLQGRQRDOODGLYLQLWjLQHWjFULVWLDQDD 'LRDOOD9HUJLQHDXQVDQWRSHUJUD]LDULFHYXWDRLQDGHPSLPHQWRGLXQD SURPHVVDª'HYRWR2OLYDQFKH&DPSXV3DROR7RVFKL±LO OXVWUHIROFORULVWDLWDOLDQRFKHFRQGXVVHQHJOLDQQL6HVVDQWDVXTXHVWRWHPD XQ¶LPSRUWDQWHLQGDJLQHDOLYHOORQD]LRQDOHSURPRVVDGDO&15DYHYDFDOFR ODWRLQJOLH[YRWRGLSLQWLLWDOLDQL,OQRVWURODYRURKDULYLVWRFRPSLX WDPHQWH TXHVWL GDWL ILQR D RJJL LO 3URJHWWR $VFOHSLR QH KD VWLPDWL FLUFD LQ,WDOLDPHQWUHLQ3LHPRQWHVHQHSUHVXPRQRFLUFDGLFXL XQDPHWjqGLVWULEXLWDLQVDQWXDULSHUORSLPDULDQLHO¶DOWUDLQFDSSHOOHFDP SHVWUL6HFRQGR7RVFKLO¶H[YRWRSRVVLHGHLOSLFKLDURVLJQLILFDWRSHUGLPR VWUDUHJOLVWUHWWLFROOHJDPHQWLIUDODVWRULDGHOOHUHOLJLRQLODVWRULDGHOO¶DUWHOD VWRULDGHOOHWUDGL]LRQLSRSRODULHODVRFLRORJLD7RVFKL3HQQDSS ,QQHVVXQ¶DOWUDPDQLIHVWD]LRQHWURYLDPRSURYHFRVuYDOLGHHGHYLGHQWLGHOWUD PDQGDUVLGLIRUPHULWXDOLHGLUHOLJLRVLWjSRSRODUHFROOHWWLYDGDOSDJDQHVLPRDO FULVWLDQHVLPR FRQ XQ WUDSDVVR FKH PDQWLHQH VRVWDQ]LDOPHQWH HJXDOL WXWWH OH HVSUHVVLRQLGHOFRPSOHVVRIHQRPHQRHFRQXQJUDGXDOHDGHJXDPHQWRLOFXLDYYH UDUVLDWWUDYHUVRLOWHPSRqFRVuOHQWRFKHTXDVLQRQORVLDYYHUWH>«@1HOODWDYR OHWWDYRWLYDVRSUDYYLYHRJJLFRQXQDIHGHOWjLPSUHVVLRQDQWHXQDPDQLIHVWD]LRQH ULWXDOHDQWLFKLVVLPDFKHULVDOHDOPHQRDWUHPLODDQQLRUVRQRVHQRQSL0D HVLVWRQR DQFKH DOWUL HOHPHQWL FKH FRQIHUPDQR XQ¶DPSLD HVDWWD YDOXWD]LRQH GHOO¶LPSRUWDQ]DGHOO¶H[YRWR3HUHVHPSLRO¶DSSRUWRFKHGDOOHWDYROHWWHYRWLYHFL YLHQH SHU LQWHJUDUH OD VWRULD GHOO¶DUWH LWDOLDQD >«@ 8Q DOWUR HOHPHQWR FKH YD PHVVRLQULOLHYRqLOYDORUHGRFXPHQWDULRGHOOHWDYROHWWHYRWLYHODYLWDSULYDWD GHOODVRFLHWjLWDOLDQDQRQVRORGHOOHFODVVLSRSRODULPDHGHOODQRELOWjHGHOOD ERUJKHVLD YL q ULIOHVVD H WHVWLPRQLDWD FRQ HVWUHPD HVDWWH]]D LQ TXDVL WXWWL JOL DVSHWWLLFRVWXPLLQWHVLQRQVROWDQWRFRPHIRJJHGLYHVWLUHPDFRPHXVDQ]HH FUHGHQ]H JOL VWUXPHQWL GL ODYRUR GHOOD YLWD DJULFROD H SDVWRUDOH JOL LQWHUQL HG HVWHUQLGHOO¶DUFKLWHWWXUDUXVWLFDHSDHVDQDO¶HVHUFL]LRGHOOHFXUHPHGLFKHHFKL UXUJLFKHODQDYLJD]LRQHHODYLWDPDULQDUDLQWXWWLJOLDVSHWWLFDUDWWHULVWLFLLYDUL PHVWLHULOHGLYHUVHSURIHVVLRQLLPH]]LGLWUDVSRUWRGDLFDUULDJULFROLDOOHFDU UR]]HGHLQRELOLDOOHGLOLJHQ]HDOOHYDSRULHUHDOOHDXWRPRELOLHDLSXOOPDQILQR DLSDOORQLHDJOLDHURSODQLHGLULJLELOLRIIURQRQHOORURLQVLHPHXQDGRFXPHQWD ]LRQHGLHFFH]LRQDOHLQWHUHVVHVWRULFRGHPRORJLFRHVRFLRORJLFR
7RVFKLKDODYRUDWRLQWHQVDPHQWHQHO6DQWXDULRGHOOD0DGRQQDGHOO¶$UFRGL 6$QDVWDVLD1DSROLFKHFRQVHUYDXQRVWUDRUGLQDULRFRUSXVYRWLYRGHYR]LR QDOHGHYRDOVXRUHWWRUHO¶HPR]LRQHGLDYHUSRWXWR±QHOOXJOLR±FRQVXOWDUH OHVFKHGHRULJLQDOLVXFXLKDODYRUDWRWDOHVWXGLRVRGLULOLHYRLQWHUQD]LRQDOHFD SDFHGLFRJOLHUHO¶LPSRUWDQ]DGLTXHVWRRJJHWWRGHOODFXOWXUDSRSRODUH$SSHQD WUHPHVLSULPDGHOQRVWURDUULYR±LODSULOH±qVWDWRSUHVHQWDWRSUHVVRLO VDQWXDULRLOYROXPHVotum. Museo degli ex-voto del Santuario della Madonna
dell’ArcoDGRSHUDGHOPXVLFRORJR5REHUWR'H6LPRQHHGHOO¶DQWURSRORJRFXO
WXUDOH3DROR$SROLWRFKHQHOODVXDUHOD]LRQHGHILQLVFHJOLH[YRWR©FRPHLSQRWLFL JHURJOLILFLDWWLDVROOHFLWDUHXQDIUDWWXUDWUDOLYHOOLVWRULFLDSURGXUUHO¶LQVRUJHUH GHOYLVLRQDULVPRSRSRODUHUHJRODWRGDRUL]]RQWLUHOLJLRVLGHOO¶LPPDJLQDULRFRO OHWWLYRª'H6LPRQHSDUODDQFKHGHOODSURFHVVLRQHGHOOXQHGuLQ$OELVLQFXLWUD O¶DOWUR VL SRUWDQR H[YRWR SHU LO PDQWHQLPHQWR GL SURPHVVH DOOD 0DGRQQD GHOO¶$UFRGRYHVLYHGHODILJXUDGHOVRWWRSUROHWDULDWRGHJOLHPDUJLQDWLGHOODGL VRFFXSD]LRQH GHOOR VIUXWWDPHQWR GHOOD GURJD H SXUH GHOOD FDPRUUD VRWWROL QHDQGRODJUDQGHYLWDOLWjHDWWXDOLWjGHJOLH[YRWRDQFKHGHLSLGDWDWL
Foto 2 – Santuario della Madonna dell’Arco a Sant’Anastasia (Napoli) [Foto R. Grimaldi, 2009]
/DULYLVWD©3DQRUDPDªGHODSULOHWLWRODDSProcessioni di ‘ndrangheta,
UDFFRQWDQGRLQSDUWLFRODUHODVRVSHQVLRQHGHOODIHVWDGHOO¶AffruntataGL6DQW¶2QRIULRSDHVH DOOHSRUWHGL9LER9DOHQWLDLQ&DODEULDSHUEORFFDUHODPDILDFKHYXROHSRUWDUHLQVSDOODOD VWDWXDGHOOD0DGRQQDIDFHQGROHPDJDULIDUHO¶LQFKLQRGDYDQWLDOODFDVDGHOERVVORFDOH
1HJOL H[YRWR GLSLQWL VL WURYDQR DQFKH WUDFFH GHOOD OHWWHUDWXUD FRPH FL ULFRUGD)LFDUDSS
'LSLQWRDROLRVXWHODDQFKHLONarcissusTXHOORGHONigger oh the NarcissusGL &RQUDGFDPSHJJLDVXXQDSDUHWHWUDJOLH[YRWRGHOVDQWXDULR>GL0RQWDOOHJURGL &KLDYDUL*HQRYD@1HOODQRWWHGHOQRYHPEUHDOFRPDQGRGHOFDSLWDQR *LXVHSSH$QVDOGRDIIURQWDYDOHRQGHDOWHFRPHFDVHGL&DSR+RUQLOORURLP SHWRVRYUDQQDWXUDOHHVWDYDSHUVRPPHUJHUVLTXDQGROD0DGRQQDGL0RQWDOOHJUR PLVHULFRUGLRVDPHQWHSODFzOHDFTXH>«@7XWWDYLDLONarcissusDOODILQHQRQVL VDOYzXQJLRUQRVLVIUDFHOOzVXGLXQDFRVWDGHVHUWDGHO%UDVLOHHWXWWLPRULURQR &RQJUDQGHVRGGLVID]LRQHHGHPR]LRQHKRIRWRJUDIDWRQHOODFKLHVDGHOOD Madonetta RGHOOD1HYHQHLSUHVVLGHOSRUWRGL/RDQR6DYRQDO¶H[YRWR
GL XQ PDULQDLR LPEDUFDWR VXONarcissus. 'XUDQWH L ODYRUL GL FDWDORJD]LRQH VYROWLQHOODPHGHVLPDFKLHVDGHOODMadonettaSURWHWWULFHGHLPDULQDLHGHL ORDQHVLJLjLQYRFDWDDSURWH]LRQHGHOODFRPXQLWjSHUODSHVWHGHOF¶q VWDWRXQLPSRUWDQWHULWURYDPHQWR,QXQYHFFKLREDXOHFROORFDWRVXOVRSSDOFR VRSUDO¶LQJUHVVRF¶HUDXQ3DOLRWWRSDUDPHQWRGHVWLQDWRDFRSULUHODSDUWHDQ WHULRUHGHOO¶DOWDUHXQWHORGLVHWDpFUXGLXQPHWURSHUGXHJLjSUHVHQWHQHJOL LQYHQWDULGLILQH2WWRFHQWR0DLOQRVWURLQWHUHVVHGRYXWRDTXHVWRRJJHWWR GHOODGHYR]LRQHSRSRODUHFRQVLVWHQHOIDWWRFKHLOYHOLHURFXFLWRDOFHQWURFRQ ILQHPDQXDOLWjHXQFXRUHG¶DUJHQWRILVVDWRLQDOWRDGHVWUDSRUWDQRDGDIIHU PDUHFKHVLWUDWWLGLXQH[YRWR&RPHVLOHJJHLQ5RQ]LROHYDULH DVVRFLD]LRQLORDQHVLHLFXOWRULGLVWRULDORFDOHVRQRULXVFLWLDULFRVWUXLUHOD ILORJHQHVLGLTXHVWR3DOLRWWRH[YRWR,OYHOLHURULFDPDWRDOFHQWURqXQEUL JDQWLQRDWUHDOEHULEDWWHQWHEDQGLHUDGHO5HJQRGL6DUGHJQDVLFKLDPD$O JHULDHIDSDUWHGHOODIORWWDGHOODIDPLJOLD5RFFDGL/RDQRIXFRPDQGDWRGDO FDSLWDQR6LPRQH5RFFD$OFXQHLQIRUPD]LRQLVXOYHOLHUR$OJHULDVRQRVWDWH WUDWWHGDXQH[YRWRHVSRVWRQHO0XVHRGHO0DUHGHOODVWHVVDFLWWj,O3DOLRWWR qGHGLFDWRFRPHJUD]LDULFHYXWDDOODMadonettaSURWHWWULFHGHLPDULQDLXQD VRUWDGL6LQGRQHFKHODVFLDLQWUDYHGHUH³LQILOLJUDQD´ODGXUDYLWDGHOODPDUL QHULDLWDOLDQD8QDFRSLDGHO3DOLRWWRGL/RDQRqVWDWDFXFLWDD&X]FRLQ3HU HGqVWDWDSUHVHQWDWDDOODSRSROD]LRQHQHOPHQWUHO¶RULJLQDOHqFRQVHU YDWRLQOXRJRVLFXUR2FFRUUHULFRUGDUHFKH/RDQRqOXRJRGLPDUHHKDGDWR LQDWDOLD5RVD5DLPRQGLPRJOLHGL'RPHQLFR*DULEDOGLHPDGUHGL*LX VHSSH'RPHQLFRLPEDUFzD1L]]DQHOLOJLRYDQH*LXVHSSHFRPHPR]]R VXOODWDUWDUDFKHPRVVHYHUVR5RPDSHUSRUWDUHYLQRSHULO*LXELOHR,QTXDO FKHPRGRGD/RDQRSDUWuLOOXQJRYLDJJLRFKHSRUWz*LXVHSSH*DULEDOGLD GLYHQWDUH³HURHGHLGXHPRQGL´
Foto 3 – Santuario della Madonnetta di Loano (Savona). Ex-voto fotografico della nave Nar-cissus raccontata da Conrad. Nell’iscrizione si legge: «Dono fatto dalla Regina NS delle Neve per Grazia Concessa al Marinaro / Martino Giacomo – li 7 Novembre 1899» [Fonte: Chilosi, Collu (2001)]
$QFKHODVFULWWULFH0DWLOGH6HUDRQHIl ventre di NapoliWUDWWDLO WHPDGHOODGHYR]LRQHSRSRODUH
4XDQGRXQELPERqPDODWRORYRWDQRD6DQ)UDQFHVFRTXDQGRULVDQDORYHVWRQR GD PRQDFHOOR FRQ XQD WRQDFD JURVVRODQD FRO FRUGRQH FRQ L SLHGLQL QXGL QHL VDQGDOLFRQODFKLHULFKHWWDUDVD&KLQRQQHKDLQFRQWUDWLQHLTXDUWLHULSRSRODUL" >«@&UHGHWHFKHDOQDSROHWDQREDVWLOD0DGRQQDGHO&DUPLQH",RKRFRQWDWL DSSHOODWLYLGHOOD9HUJLQHHQRQVRQRWXWWL4XDWWURRFLQTXHWHQJRQRLOSULPDWR 4XDQGRXQDQDSROHWDQDqDPPDODWDRFRUUHXQJUDYHSHULFRORXQRGHLVXRLVL YRWDDXQDGLTXHVWH0DGRQQH'RSRVFLRJOLHLOYRWRSRUWDQGRQHOYHVWLWRXQ DELWRQXRYREHQHGHWWRLQFKLHVDFKHQRQVLGHYHVPHWWHUHVHQRQTXDQGRqOR JRUR
/DOHWWHUDWXUDLQWHUQD]LRQDOHVLLQWHUHVVDGLUHWWDPHQWHGLJXDULJLRQLPLUD FRORVH,QWURYLJQHZZZFHVQXURUJWHVWLORXUGHVKWP
*XLGDWL GD ePLOH =ROD ± LO FXL Lourdes GHILQLVFH ILQR DL JLRUQLQRVWULTXHOORFKHXQEXRQDQWLFOHULFDOHGHYHSHQVDUHGL/RXUGHV±SRVLWL YLVWL H PDQJLDSUHWL JULGDQR DOO¶LVWHULD DOOD IURGH FOHULFDOH DOOD PDQLSROD]LRQH PHQWDOHVLVWHPDWLFDGHLSHOOHJULQLGDSDUWHGLPRQDFKHHSUHWL1DVFHXQDXWHQWLFR PRYLPHQWRDQWL/RXUGHVFKHQHLSULPLDQQLGHO1RYHFHQWRVLWUDGXFH±JUD]LH DOODPRELOLWD]LRQHLQXQ¶HSRFDVHJQDWDGDIRUWLSDVVLRQLDQWLFOHULFDOLGHOOHORJJH PDVVRQLFKH±GLPLJOLDLDGLPHGLFLIUDQFHVLLTXDOLFKLHGRQRDOJRYHUQRDQWLFOH ULFDOHGLePLOH&RPEHVGL³FKLXGHUH/RXUGHV´GRSRFKHJOLDVVXQ ]LRQLVWLHUDQRJLjVWDWLHVSXOVLGDOOD)UDQFLDQHOO¶DQQRQRQVRORFHQWURGL GLIIXVLRQHGLLGHHVXSHUVWL]LRQHHUHWULYHPDOXRJRSHULFRORVRSHUODSURVVLPLWj ILVLFDIUDWDQWLPDODWLHFDSDFHDVVHULWDPHQWHGLLQGXUUHPROWLDSRUUHOHORURVSH UDQ]HQHOODIHGHDQ]LFKpQHOOHFXUHGHOPHGLFRYRWDQGRVLFRVuDXQDPRUWHSUH FRFH 2FFRUUHRVVHUYDUHFKHQHOQRVWURODYRURQRQqLPSRUWDQWHDFFHUWDUHODYH ULGLFLWjGHOPLUDFRORGHOO¶LQWHUFHVVLRQHGHOO¶HVVHUHVDFUR$QRLEDVWDLOUDF FRQWRGHOO¶DWWRUHVRFLDOHFKHFRPXQLFDDWXWWRLOPRQGRDQFKHVRORDTXHOOR FKHJOLVWDLQWRUQRQHOODFRPXQLWjGRYHYLYHFKHO¶HYHQWRDFFDGXWRHUDS SUHVHQWDWR QHOOD WDYROHWWD YRWLYD GLSLQWD q TXHOOR SL LPSRUWDQWH GHOOD VXD YLWDHFKHSHUULVROYHUHWDOHVLQJRODULWjF¶qVWDWDDGGLULWWXUDO¶LQWHUFHVVLRQH SUHVVR'LRGLXQHVVHUHVDFUR *OLH[YRWRSRVVRQRHVVHUHIRQWHGLLVSLUD]LRQHSHUXQURPDQ]RSROL]LH VFRWUDOHSLHJKHGHLIDWWLPLQXWLUDFFRQWDWLGDOOHWDYROHWWHYRWLYHGHOVDQWXD ULRGL)RUQR$OSL*UDLH7RULQRLQ9DO*UDQGHGL/DQ]RVRQRFRPSUHVLJOL LQGL]LSHUULVDOLUHDXQDYLFHQGDUDFFRQWDWDGDOFROOHJDHVFULWWRUH$OHVVDQGUR 3HULVVLQRWWRLQL’anno che uccisero RosettaHGLWRGD6HOOHULRQHO
*OLH[YRWRULSUHVLGDO3URJHWWR$VFOHSLRVRQRGLYHQWDWLLPPDJLQLGLFR SHUWLQDGHOODFROODQD©6RFLRORJLDHVRFLHWjLWDOLDQDªGLUHWWDGD/XFLDQR*DO OLQRSUHVVRO¶HGLWRUH5RVHQEHUJ 6HOOLHUGL7RULQR/¶LGHDGLH[YRWRqVWDWD DQFKHLPSLHJDWDGDDUWLVWLLQFDPSDJQHSXEEOLFLWDULHHSHUILQRSHUSURGXUUH ELMRX[PHVVLLQFRPPHUFLR
&HOHEUH q OD IUDVH FKH =ROD SURQXQFLD LURQLFDPHQWH GDYDQWL DJOL H[YRWR GL /RXUGHV
©9HGR PROWL EDVWRQL QRQ YHGRSHUz DOFXQD JDPED GLOHJQRªFRPH SHU GLUH FKH OH JDPEH WDJOLDWHQRQULFUHVFRQRDIIHUPD]LRQHFXLVLRSSRQJRQRTXDQWLVRVWHQJRQRLOUHFXSHURGHOOD JDPED DPSXWDWD D FDXVD GL XQ LQFLGHQWH QHOD 0LJXHO -XDQ 3HOOLFHU YHQWHQQH QDWLYR GL&DODQGDLQ$UDJRQDY0HVVRUL=RODqXQRVFULWWRUHQDWXUDOLVWDFKHQDUUDDWWUDYHUVR
ORVFKHUPRUHDOLVWDGHOSRVLWLYLVPRQHOODULVSRVWDDOODFULWLFDFKHJOLIHFHDOVXRURPDQ]RTe-resa Raquin GHO DIIHUPD GL VFULYHUH GL SHUVRQDJJL SULYL GL OLEHUR DUELWULR IDFHQGR XQ
UHVRFRQWR HVDWWR H PLQX]LRVR GHOOD YLWD FRPH XQ IUHGGR DQDOLVWD FKH SURFHGH FRQ PHWRGR VFLHQWLILFRDXQRVWXGLRGLFDVRFOLQLFR
&IU%X]]DWLI miracoli di Val MorelFRQXQDPrefazioneGL,QGUR0RQWDQHOOL,O
,OODYRURGL*LOOLFRVWLWXLVFHXQDPHWDDQDOLVLGHJOLH[YRWRGLSLQWL ,OVRFLRORJRLQIDWWLSDUWHGDXQFDPSLRQHGLFLUFDFDVLUDFFROWLVXFD WDORJKLWUDOH0DUFKH)ULXOL9HQHWR7UHQWLQR3LHPRQWH/LJXULD5RPDJQD H3XJOLDHFRPSDUDLULVXOWDWLGHOOHVXHHODERUD]LRQLFRQTXHOOLGHLSULQFLSDOL FRUSXVYRWLYLFKHRIIUHODOHWWHUDWXUDFRPSUHVLLOQRVWURHTXHOORGHOOD3UR YHQ]DIUDQFHVHGL%HUQDUG&RXVLQ &LRFFXSLDPRTXLGLH[YRWRGLSLQWLVXWDYROHWWDFRPSHQVDWRFDUWDODWWD IRWRJUDILFLWUDODVFLDQGRPDVRORQHOO¶DQDOLVLVWDWLVWLFDLFXRULG¶DUJHQWRR SDUWLDQDWRPLFKHGHOFRUSRHWXWWHOHDOWUHQXPHURVHIRUPHFKHTXHVWRULWXDOH GHYR]LRQDOHKDDVVXQWRQHOWHPSRULFRUGLDPRDGHVHPSLRFKHqXQH[YRWR O¶DIIUHVFRGHOFKHVLWURYDQHOODFKLHVDPHGLHYDOHGL9LDWRVWRDG$VWL FRVuFRPHODFRUVDGHLFDUULWUDLQDWLGDEXRLFKHVLWLHQHWXWWLJOLDQQLODVH FRQGDGRPHQLFDGLPDJJLRDG$VLJOLDQR9HUFHOOHVHSHUVFLRJOLHUHXQYRWR FRQ6DQ9LWWRUHFKHOLEHUzLOSDHVHGDXQDPLFLGLDOHSHVWHQHO&RPXQH GL$VLJOLDQRqXQH[YRWROD%DVLOLFDGL6XSHUJDGL)LOLSSR-XYDUUD D7RULQRYROXWDGDOUH9LWWRULR$PHGHR,,FRPHULQJUD]LDPHQWRDOOD9HUJLQH 0DULDGRSRDYHUVFRQILWWRLIUDQFHVLFKHDVVHGLDYDQR7RULQRQHOFRVu SXUH±QHOODVWHVVDFLWWj±ODFKLHVDGL6DQ/RUHQ]RqRJJHWWRGLXQDJUD]LD ULFHYXWDÊXQH[YRWRLOSRQWHYRWLYRGL]DWWHUHVXOFDQDOHGHOOD*LXGHFFD D9HQH]LDFKHFRQVHQWHDLIHGHOLGLSDVVDUHGDOODFKLHVDGHOOR6SLULWR6DQWRD TXHOODGHO5HGHQWRUHULFRUGDQGRFRQODWUDGL]LRQDOHIHVWDGHOODWHU]DGRPH QLFDGLOXJOLRODILQHGHOODSHVWHGHO*LRYDQQL/ROOLGL&RVVDQR%HOER
GD&DVFLD/HYLFHQGHVRQRDPELHQWDWHD9DOPRUHOLQSURYLQFLDGL%HOOXQR%X]]DWLLPPDJLQD VpVWHVVRDOODULFHUFDGLXQIDQWRPDWLFRVDQWXDULRGL6DQWD5LWDFKHSHUzQRQULHVFHPDLD WURYDUH6FRSULUjFKHLOOXRJRGLFXOWRQRQqDOWURFKHXQJURVVRPDVVRULFRSHUWRGLOXFFLFDQWL H[YRWR1HOYROXPHLQRJJHWWRJOLH[YRWRVRQRVWDWLGLVHJQDWLGD'LQR%X]]DWLHVRQRSXE EOLFDWLLQVLHPHDOUDFFRQWR &RPHVXJJHULVFH6SHUDRFFRUUHGLVWLQJXHUHWUDfotografie ex-votoLPPDJLQH GHOJUD]LDWRVROLWDPHQWHDPH]]REXVWRHGex-voto fotograficiGRYHO¶HYHQWRqULFRVWUXLWRFRQ XQDIRWRJUDILDPDJDULDQFKHVRORGHOODQDYHFKHKDVXEuWRLOQDXIUDJLRRGHOO¶DXWRLQFLGHQWDWD PROWHYROWHLOJUD]LDWRVLPHWWHQHOODSRVDLQFXLKDDYXWRO¶LQFLGHQWH ©,ODJRVWRLOGXFD(PDQXHOH)LOLEHUWRVFRQILVVHD6DQ4XLQWLQRO¶HVHUFLWRIUDQFHVH SHUPHWWHQGR O¶HJHPRQLD VSDJQROD VXOO¶(XURSD JUD]LH DOODVXFFHVVLYD 3DFH GL &DWHDX &DPEUpVLVHLOSURSULRULWRUQRLQTXHO'XFDWRGL6DYRLDFKHGLOuDSRFRDYUHEEHLQL]LDWR DFDPELDUHSURIRQGDPHQWH(UDLOJLRUQRGL6DQ/RUHQ]RHVLD)HOLSH,,GL6SDJQDVLD(PDQXHOH )LOLEHUWRSURPLVHURODFRVWUX]LRQHGLXQOXRJRGLFXOWRDOXLGHGLFDWR)HOLSHFRVWUXuLO0RQD VWHURGL6DQ/RUHQ]RGHOO¶(VFRULDODSRFKHGHFLQHGLFKLORPHWULGD0DGULGGRYHSRLVLULWLUz QHJOL XOWLPL DQQL GHOOD SURSULD YLWD (PDQXHOH )LOLEHUWR LPSHJQDWR QHOOD FRVWUX]LRQH GHOOD &LWWDGHOODHQHOODULHGLILFD]LRQHGHOOR6WDWRQRQDYHYDOHULVRUVHVXIILFLHQWLSHUXQDQXRYD FKLHVDHGHGLFzDO6DQWRO¶HVLVWHQWHFKLHVDGL6DQWD0DULDDG3UHVHSDH)XTXLFKHWUDO¶DOWUR (PDQXHOH)LOLEHUWRIHFHSRUWDUHOD6DFUD6LQGRQHDIILQFKpIRVVHYHQHUDWDGD6DQ&DUOR%RU URPHR SHU XQ H[YRWR IDWWR GXUDQWH OD SHVWH GL 0LODQRª ZZZVDQORUHQ]RWRULQRLWLQGH[ SKSLWVWRULDHDUWHVWRULDGHOODFKLHVD&XRULG¶DUJHQWRVLWURYDQRQHOODFKLHVDGL6DQ&DUOR %RUURPHRFKHVLDIIDFFLDVXOODFHQWUDOHSLD]]D6DQ&DUORD7RULQR
©/D6WDPSDªGHOO¶DJRVWRULIHULVFHGL0DUFR5ROOHURGL&DVHOOH7RULQRFKHSHU
&XQHR KD PDQWHQXWR LO VXR LPSHJQR FRQ 6DQWD /LEHUD SDUWHFLSDQGR LQ SULPDSHUVRQDHILQDQ]LDQGRODFRVWUX]LRQHGHOSRQWHGLOHJQRFKHKDSHU PHVVRGLULVLVWHPDUHOD©6FDOD6DQWDªVHQWLHURFRQWDGLQRFKHXQLVFHODFDS SHOODGL6DQWD/LEHUDFRQTXHOODGL6DQ%RYR*ULPDOGL*UD]LHUL FHYXWHOHWURYLDPRDQFKH³VFULWWH´VXYDULVXJLRUQDOLFDWWROLFLFRPHLO©%RO OHWWLQRVDOHVLDQRª/DSROHQDSUXDGLXQDQDYHFKHYLHQHFRQVHUYDWDQHO 'XRPRGL%DUFHOORQDLQ6SDJQDqXQH[YRWR ,OOHWWRUHYRUUjSHUGRQDUFLVHTXDQGRSDUOLDPRGLH[YRWRGLSLQWLXVHUHPR DYROWH³WDYROHWWHYRWLYHGLSLQWH´DQFKHVHLQWHQGLDPRULIHULUFLDWXWWLJOLH[
FRPXQH,ERUJKLJLDQLGL7DQDUR7ULQFHUH7RUUD]]RGRSRDYHUYLQWRLO3DOLRGL$VWLQHO KDQQRSRUWDWRDSLHGLLOGUDSSRDO6DQWXDULRGL&UHDSHUULVSHWWDUHLOYRWRIDWWR,O3LORQHGL 6DQW¶$JDWDLQIUD]LRQH0H]]DQDWUD3RUWDFRPDURH6FXU]ROHQJR$VWLSUHVVRFXLVLWLHQH XQDVWRULFD)DJLRODWDqXQH[YRWRVLQDUUDLQIDWWLFKHO¶HGLFRODYRWLYDVLDVWDWDIDWWDHGLILFDUH GD XQSURSULHWDULR WHUULHUR GL 6FXU]ROHQJR FRPHULFRQRVFHQ]DDOOD VDQWD SHUODPLUDFRORVD JXDULJLRQHGLXQILJOLRFROSLWRGDOSDOORQHGXUDQWHXQDSDUWLWDDEUDFFLDOHXQPRGRWUDGL]LR QDOHGHOJLRFRGHOODSDOODSXJQRULGXFHQGRORLQFRPD6HFRQGRDOWULODFRVWUX]LRQHULVDOHDG XQH[YRWRGLXQSRUWDFRPDUHVHHPLJUDWRLQ$PHULFDVFDPSDWRGDXQQDXIUDJLRDOULWRUQRLQ ,WDOLDJUD]LHDOO¶LQWHUFHVVLRQHGL6DQW¶$JDWDZZZODVWDPSDLWDVWLQHZVIDJLRODWD GLVDQWDJDWDWUDSRUWDFRPDURHVFXU]ROHQJR©/D6FDOD6DQWDěa scoĜa santaqXQVHQWLHURFRVWUXLWRFRQVFDOLQLGLSLHWUDFKHSHU
PHWWHGLDWWUDYHUVDUHRian ‘d VerseleSDUWHQGRGDOODCesa ‘d Santa LibeĜa HFRQGXFHQGRD 6DQ%RYRLQCà ‘d Bastiàn0ROWRXWLOL]]DWDXQWHPSRVRSUDWWXWWRGDOOHIDPLJOLHGL6DQ%RYR SHUUDJJLXQJHUHLOFRQFHQWULFRFDGGHLQGLVXVRSHUHVVHUHSRLUHFHQWHPHQWHULVLVWHPDWD/XQJR LOSHUFRUVRqSRVVLELOHYLVLWDUHer crutìn ‘d BastiànXQDJURWWDGLPRGHVWHGLPHQVLRQLVFDYDWD QHOODURFFLDGLSURSULHWjGLXQWDOHBastiàn GL6DQ%RYRXWLOL]]DWDFRPHULFRYHURGHJOLDWWUH]]L HFRPHOXRJRSHUFRQVHUYDUHOHGHUUDWHDOLPHQWDUL/DPRWLYD]LRQHGHOO¶DJJHWWLYRsanta QRQq FKLDUDDQFKHVHXQLQIRUPDWRUHLSRWL]]DFKHTXHVWRSRWUHEEHHVVHUHGRYXWRDOIDWWRFKHWUDOH IDPLJOLHFKHSLVLVHUYLYDQRGLTXHVWRVHQWLHURYLIRVVHODIDPLJOLD0LUDQRGL6DQ%RYRFKH DELWDYDLQCà du signùr³FDVDGHO6LJQRUH´FKLDPDWDLQTXHVWRPRGRSRLFKpHUDODFDVFLQD SLORQWDQDGDOFRQFHQWULFRª6DJOLHWWLSS ,O6RPPDULRGLPDJJLRGHO©%ROOHWWLQR6DOHVLDQRªULSRUWDQXPHURVLH[YRWRULYROWL D0DULD66$XVLOLDWULFHHSURYHQLHQWLGDWXWWD,WDOLDPDDQFKHGDOO¶HVWHURULSRUWDWLLQIRUPD WHVWXDOHHQRQGLSLQWDDWHVWLPRQLDQ]DGLFRPHOHIRUPHGHJOLH[YRWRJLjVXOILQLUHGHO DYHVVHURGLYHUVHHVSUHVVLRQL/HJJLDPRVXO©%ROOHWWLQR6DOHVLDQRªGHODSULOHQHOOD UXEULFD ©, QRVWUL VDQWLª ± FXUDWDGDO SRVWXODWRUHJHQHUDOH 3DVTXDOH/LEHUDWRUH ±WUD OH DOWUH VHJQDOD]LRQLGLJUD]LD©0LDPDGUHVLqDPPDODWDGLFDUFLQRPDQHO'RSRYDULHFXUHLQ ,WDOLDHD=XULJRODPHWDVWDVLVLHVWHVHXOWHULRUPHQWH'RSRGRGLFLFLFOLGLFKHPLRWHUDSLDHXQD GHJHQ]DGLXQPHVHDOO¶RVSHGDOHOHPHGLFLQHRUPDLQRQSURGXFHYDQRSLDOFXQHIIHWWR5L YROJHPPRFRQOHLLQWHQVHSUHJKLHUHDO6LJQRUHLQYRFDQGRO¶LQWHUFHVVLRQHGLMamma Mar-gheritaQHOODFDVHWWDHDO7HPSLRGHO&ROOH3HUDOFXQLPHVLLQIDPLJOLDWXWWHOHVHUHHVHWWLPD QDOPHQWHFRQLYLFLQLGLFDVDUHFLWDPPRDVVLHPHLOURVDULRLQYRFDQGRODVXDLQWHUFHVVLRQH 0LDPDGUHFRPLQFLzDVHQWLUVLPHJOLRHSXUFRQFDXWHODSRWpULSUHQGHUHLOODYRURG¶D]LHQGD HO¶DWWLYLWjIDPLOLDUH1HOOXJOLRGRSRYDULHVDPLHUDGLRJUDILHLOPHGLFRFXUDQWHGL FKLDUzµ$VVROXWDPHQWHJXDULWDRVHUHLGLUHFKHQRQKDPDLDYXWRQXOODVHODGRFXPHQWD]LRQH GLGRGLFLDQQLQRQDWWHVWDVVHLOFRQWUDULR4XDOFXQRODVVqLQWHUYHQXWR¶Francesco A.,
To-rinoª&RPHVLSXzRVVHUYDUHTXHVWDVWRULDVLFRQILJXUDFRPHXQH[YRWRHLOJLRUQDOHUHOL
JLRVRVYROJHOHIXQ]LRQLGHOLibro dei miracoliFKHPROWHYROWHYHQLYDWHQXWRQHLVDQWXDULSHU FXVWRGLUHOHWHVWLPRQLDQ]HGLJUD]LHULFHYXWH
YRWRGLSLQWLQRQVRORVXOHJQRPDDQFKHVXWHODODWWDFRPSHQVDWDFDUWDH FDUWRQHFRPSUHQGHQGRWDOYROWDDQFKHTXHOOLIRWRJUDILFL
, PXVHL QDYDOL GHOOH YDULH FLWWj VRQR OXRJKL ODLFL GRYH WURYDUH H[YRWR YROWLSULQFLSDOPHQWHDPLUDFROLFRQQHVVLDOODQDYLJD]LRQHSHQVRDO0XVHR QDYDOHGL,PSHULDPDDQFKHDTXHOORGL%DUFHOORQDHGL0DUVLJOLD8QH[YRWR FRQODIRUPDGLXQFXRUHG¶DUJHQWRSHUODEDWWDJOLDGL6DQ0DUWLQRJLXJQR qHVSRVWRSUHVVRLO0XVHRGHO5LVRUJLPHQWRGL7RULQR /HWDYROHWWHYRWLYHVRQRPROWRSUHVHQWLQHOODFROODQDFKHOD)HUUHURGL$OED KDSXEEOLFDWRWUDODPHWjGHJOLDQQL2WWDQWDHODPHWjGHL1RYDQWDFRQWHVWL GL*LJL0DUVLFRHIRWRJUDILHGL*LDQ3DROR&DYDOOHURFXLGHEERPROWRSHU DYHUPLLQVHJQDWRO¶DSSURFFLRVRFLRORJLFRHDQWURSRORJLFRDOODULSUHVDIRWR JUDILFDSHULWLSLGL2PHJD(GL]LRQLGL7RULQRGHOO¶HGLWRUH*LDFRPR6RQ FLQL /R VWHVVR YROXPH SURPRVVR GDOOD )RQGD]LRQH&DVVD GL 5LVSDUPLRGL &XQHRHGDO&RPXQHGL$OEDVXO5LVRUJLPHQWRLQWHUUDGL/DQJDFRQWLHQH H[YRWRSURYHQLHQWLDQFKHGDOQRVWUR3URJHWWR$VFOHSLR0RQWDOGR ,OSLWWRUHVRYHQWHQRQqXQSURIHVVLRQLVWDPDXQGHFRUDWRUHXQGLOHWWDQWH DQFKHVHVLFRQWDQRSLWWRULHFFHOOHQWLLQIDWWLDOO¶LQL]LRTXHVWDSUDWLFDHUDSUL YLOHJLRGHOOHFODVVLHOHYDWH$GHVHPSLRqXQH[YRWRLOIDPRVR&ULVWRFURFL ILVVRGHO9HOj]TXHVGLSLQWRQHOVXFRPPLVVLRQHGHOUH)LOLSSR,9SHULO FRQYHQWRPDGULOHQRGL6DQ3ODFLGRHFKHRUDVLWURYDDO0XVHRGHO3UDGRGL 0DGULGSDUHFKHLOUHDEELDRUGLQDWRWDOHTXDGURFRPH³HVSLD]LRQH´SHUXQ DPRUHVDFULOHJRFKHDYHYDDYXWRFRQXQDJLRYDQHPRQDFDÊXQH[YRWROD 0DGRQQDGL)ROLJQRGLSLQWDGD5DIIDHOOR6DQ]LRQHOVLWURYDQHL0XVHL 9DWLFDQLGL5RPDHUDFFRQWDODJUD]LDULFHYXWDGDOFRPPLWWHQWHO¶LOOXVWUH XPDQLVWD6LJLVPRQGRGHL&RQWLFKHULFRSUuLPSRUWDQWLLQFDULFKLDOODFRUWH SDSDOHSDUHSHUHVVHUHVWDWRULVSDUPLDWRGDXQPHWHRULWHRIXOPLQHURVVDVWUR FKLDUDPHQWHLQGLFDWRQHOGLSLQWRFDGXWRVXOODFLWWjGL)ROLJQR$O/RXYUHGL 3DULJLVLWURYDO¶H[YRWRGHOGL3KLOLSSHGH&KDPSDLJQHFKHO¶DUWLVWDKD GLSLQWRSHUODJXDULJLRQHPLUDFRORVDGHOODILJOLD&DWKHULQHGH6DLQWH6X]DQQH &KDPSDLJQH UHOLJLRVD GHO FRQYHQWR GL3RUW5R\DO GL 3DULJL UDSSUHVHQWDWD FRQODPDGUHVXSHULRUD&DWKHULQH$JQqV$UQDXOG$QFRUDDO/RXYUHGL3D ULJLODSDODG¶DOWDUH0DGRQQDGHOOD9LWWRULDFRQVHUYDWDHUHDOL]]DWDGD$Q GUHD0DQWHJQDQHOqXQH[YRWRGL)UDQFHVFR,,*RQ]DJDGRSRODYLW WRULDGL)RUQRYR1HOOD*DOOHULDQD]LRQDOHGHOO¶8PEULDD3HUXJLDVRQRPH PRUDELOL©OHSUHGHOOHGL3LHURGHOOD)UDQFHVFDFKHUDIILJXUDLOPLUDFRORGL6 (OLVDEHWWDGL8QJKHULDFKHVDOYDXQEDPELQRFDGXWRQHOSR]]RHGL*HQWLOH GD)DEULDQRFRQ6DQ1LFRODGL%DULFKHVDOYDXQYDVFHOORGDOODWHPSHVWDª %URQ]LQLS7UDIXJDWDGDOODFKLHVDPRGHQHVHGL6DQ9LQFHQ]R QHOHUHFXSHUDWDD&DVDEODQFD0DURFFRQHOqXQH[YRWRODWHOD GHO*XHUFLQRGHOFKHUDIILJXUDOD0DGRQQDLQWURQRFRQLVDQWL*LRYDQQL
HYDQJHOLVWDH*UHJRULRWDXPDWXUJR©-DFRSR3HVDURSUHVHQWDWRD6DQ3LHWUR
GDSDSD$OHVVDQGUR9,ªqXQGLSLQWRDROLRVXWHODGL7L]LDQRGDWDELOHWUDLO HLOFRQVHUYDWRQHO.RQLQNOLMN0XVHXPYRRU6FKRQH.XQVWHQGL $QYHUVD /D SDOD YHQQH FRPPLVVLRQDWD FRPH H[YRWR SHU OD YLWWRULD QHOOD EDWWDJOLDGL6DQWD0DXUDFRQWURL7XUFKL2WWRPDQLGDSDUWHGHOODIORWWDYHQH ]LDQD JLXJQR FRPDQGDWD GD -DFRSR 3HVDUR YHVFRYR GL3DIRD &LSURDOORUDGRPLQLRYHQH]LDQRHGHVSRQHQWHGHOODSRWHQWHIDPLJOLDGHL3H VDUR'XUDQWHODWHUULELOHHSLGHPLDGLSHVWHFKHVFRQYROVHO¶,WDOLDVHWWHQWULR
QDOHQHJOLDQQLWUDLOHGLOVLWUDWWDGHOODSHVWLOHQ]DUHVDIDPRVDGD $OHVVDQGUR 0DQ]RQL QHL Promessi sposi LO WHUULELOH FRQWDJLR ± FKH HEEH FRPHHSLFHQWURLOFDSROXRJRORPEDUGR±VLHUDVSLQWRILQRDO*UDQGXFDWRGL 7RVFDQDHDYHYDLQWHUHVVDWRDQFKHLO0XJHOORGRYHLSULPLFDVLVLYHULILFD URQRQHOJLXJQRGHOHFRQIDVLDOWHUQHULPDVHDWWLYRILQRDOPLH WHQGRYLWWLPHTXDVLRYXQTXH0DOJUDGRODSHVWLOHQ]DGLODJDVVHQHOODYDOODWD PXJHOODQDDOFXQHORFDOLWjQHULPDVHURLPPXQLWUDFXLVLFXUDPHQWH5RQWDLQ SURYLQFLDGL)LUHQ]H1HOO¶HVWDWHGHOJOLRSHUDLGHOO¶RUDWRULRGHOOD0D GRQQDGHL7UH)LXPLFRPPLVVLRQDURQRD/RUHQ]R/LSSLO¶H[YRWRFKHVLWURYD QHOODFKLHVDSDUURFFKLDOHGHL6DQWL3DRORH0LFKHOHUDIILJXUDLQDOWRDVLQL VWUDOD0DGRQQDFRO%DPELQRLQJORULDWUDOHQXELQHUHHWHPSHVWRVHFLUFRQ GDWDGDDQJHOLPHQWUHLQEDVVRVLYHGRQRLVDQWL$QWRQLRGD3DGRYD6HED VWLDQR5RFFR'RQDWRH0LFKHOH$UFDQJHOR/DSDODG¶DOWDUHFRQVHUYDWDQHO 'XRPRG¶(VWH3DGRYDqVWDWDGLSLQWDGD*LDPEDWWLVWD7LHSRORQHOHG qXQH[YRWRFKHUDSSUHVHQWD6DQWD7HFODFKHFKLHGHO¶LQWHUFHVVLRQHSHUOD ILQHGHOODSHVWHGHO
©/¶RSHUDIXFRPPLVVLRQDWDQHOGDOGXFD$OIRQVRG¶(VWHFRPHH[YRWRSHUODJXD ULJLRQHGDXQDJUDYHPDODWWLD/DWHODFRVWzO¶HVRUELWDQWHFLIUDSHUO¶HSRFDGLGXFDWRQL G¶DUJHQWRSDJDWLDOSLWWRUHGLUHWWDPHQWHGDOGXFD)UDQFHVFR,ILJOLRGL$OIRQVR,OVRJJHWWR ULFKLDPD XQR GHL PLUDFROL DWWULEXLWL D VDQ *UHJRULR YHVFRYR GL 1HRFHVDUHD YLVVXWR QHO ,,, VHFRORHYHQHUDWRSHUODVXDJUDQGHRSHUDGLHYDQJHOL]]D]LRQHHLWDQWLSURGLJLFRPSLXWLLQ SDUWLFRODUHFRQWURLSHULFROLFDXVDWLGDJOLHYHQWLDWPRVIHULFLHQDWXUDOLGDOOHSHVWLOHQ]HHGDOOH JUDYLPDODWWLHªZZZWXULVPRLWODPRVWUDGHOJLRUQRDUWLFRORDUWODWHODGHOJXHUFLQRUXEDWD WRUQDDPRGHQDLG KWWSVLWZLNLSHGLDRUJZLNL-DFRSRB3HVDURBSUHVHQWDWRBDBVDQB3LHWURBGDBSDSDB$OHVVDQGUR B9, KWWSVFXOWXUDLOILORQHWXQDQWLFRGLSLQWRDURQWDH[YRWRGRSRODSHVWLOHQ]DODPDGRQQDFRQEDPELQRHVDQWLGLORUHQ]ROLSSL 0DUFR 3LQHOOL DSULOH /RUHQ]R /LSSL)LUHQ]HqVWDWRXQRGHLSLVLJQLILFDWLYLHVSRQHQWLGHO6HLFHQWRILRUHQWLQR
KWWSVPHVVDJJHURYHQHWRJHORFDOLWWHPSROLEHURQHZVODVDQWDWHFODGLSLQWD
Foto 4 – Ex-voto dove S. Elisabetta di Ungheria (in alto a destra) intercede per un bambino caduto nel pozzo. Particolare del registro inferiore della predella dipinta da Piero della Fran-cesca, 1468 [Galleria nazionale dell’Umbria, Perugia]
Foto 5 – Jacopo Pesaro presentato a San Pietro da papa Alessandro VI, Tiziano, 1503-1506 circa; ex-voto per la battaglia vinta dalla flotta veneziana contro i Turchi Ottomani [Museum voor Schone Kunsten di Anversa (Belgio)]
/D³JUDPPDWLFD´GHJOLH[YRWRHVSUHVVDQHOODFXOWXUDGHYR]LRQDOHSRSR ODUHSURYLHQHGXQTXHGDXQFRGLFH³DOWR´FKHQXOODDFKHYHGHUHFRQORVWLOH QDLIFKHYLHQHDWWULEXLWRGDDOFXQLDXWRUL7UDOHILJXUHPLQRULPDSHUTXHVWR QRQPHQRLPSRUWDQWLFLSLDFHULFRUGDUHLOGHFRUDWRUHSLWWRUH)UDQFHVFR%R CichininYLVVXWRD&RVVDQR%HOER&XQHRKDSURGRWWRFHQWL QDLDGLQDWXUHPRUWHHGLSLQWRGHFLQHGLH[YRWRSUHVHQWLSULQFLSDOPHQWHQHO 6DQWXDULRGHOOD0DGRQQDGHOOD5RYHUHGHFRUDWRVRIILWWLGLPROWLVVLPHFDVH GHOFRQFHQWULFRHGHOOHSULQFLSDOLFDVFLQHFRQWDGLQH)UDQFHVFR%RKDLQWHU SUHWDWRO¶DQLPDGHOSDHVHPDFRQODVXDDUWHKDVRSUDWWXWWRUDFFRQWDWRPRO WLVVLPH VWRULH GL FRVVDQHVL FKH GLYHUVDPHQWH VDUHEEHUR SDVVDWH QHOO¶REOLR %UDQGRQH1HOLOVLQGDFR%HSSH7RVDKDYROXWRULFRUGDUORH DEELDPRUHDOL]]DWRLOYLGHRCossano Belbo per il 50° della morte di
France-sco Bo, FKHSUHVHQWDCichininVLDFRPHXRPRVLDFRPHDUWLVWDVLDFRPHLQ
WHUSUHWHGHOVXRWHPSR*ULPDOGL56DUDFFR$
Foto 6 – Il pittore-decoratore Francesco Bo &LFKLQLQ (1875-1957) di Cossano Belbo; ha di-pinto numerosi ex-voto [Archivio Comune di Cossano Belbo (Cuneo)]
$CichininO¶DUWLVWD8JR1HVSRORKDGHGLFDWRLOFDSLWRORIl connubio tra arte e vita in
un pittore di LangaSSPHQWUH60&DYDJQHURH0$*DOOLQDKDQQRVFULWWRXQ
$EELDPR DQFKH WUDFFH GL ULFKLHVWH GL JUD]LD QRQ HVDXGLWH DG HVHPSLR QHOOHLettere di condannati a morte della Resistenza italiana. 8 settembre
1943 – 25 aprile 1945DFXUDGL3LHWUR0DOYH]]LH*LRYDQQL3LUHOOL,OSDU WLJLDQRTito)RUWXQDWR&DFFDPRDQQLGL6DQ*UHJRULRSURYLQFLDGL5HJ JLR&DODEULDVFULYH©+RSURPHVVRD6DQWD5LWDGLDQGDUHDULQJUD]LDUODDO VXRVDQWXDULRVHDYUzODJUD]LDHVHOD]LD(VWHUFKHOHqWDQWRGHYRWDYXRO YHQLUHFLDQGLDPRDVVLHPH/HVFDUSHSHUDGHVVRQRQPDQGDWHPHOHª4XHVWR H[YRWRQRQIX ,OILOPµFXOW¶GHJOLDQQL&LQTXDQWDVacanze romaneFRQ$XGUH\+HSEXUQ H*UHJRU\3HFNKDXVDWRJOLH[YRWRFRPHPHWDGLXQRGHLJLULLQ9HVSDSHU LO FHQWUR GL 5RPD TXDQGR L GXH SURWDJRQLVWL YDQQR D YHGHUH OH WDUJKH LQ PDUPRDSSRVWHGDJOLVFDPSDWLDOERPEDUGDPHQWRGL6DQ/RUHQ]R0DQRQq LOVRORPer grazia ricevutaILOPGHOLQWHUSUHWDWRHGLUHWWRGD1LQR0DQ IUHGLKDQHOODVXDVWRULDXQVXSSRVWRPLUDFRORDFFDGXWRD%HQHGHWWRLOSUR WDJRQLVWDFKHYHVWLWRGLXQVDLRLQRQRUHD6DQW¶(XVHELRYLHQHFRQGRWWRLQ SURFHVVLRQHIUDOHSRSRODQHFKHJOLFKLHGRQRJUD]LH
Foto 7 – Audrey Hepburn e Gregory Peck in 9DFDQ]HURPDQH e sullo sfondo le targhe ex-voto
6WLDPRGXQTXHSDUODQGRGLTXDUDQWDFLQTXHDQQLGLULFHUFDFKHKDQQRSRU WDWR D XWLOL]]DUH GLIIHUHQWL WHFQRORJLH GHOO¶LQIRUPD]LRQH H GHOOD FRPXQLFD ]LRQH6LDPRLQIDWWLSDVVDWLGDPDLQIUDPHV,EPFRQVFKHGHSHUIR UDWHHXQLWjDQDVWURHSURJUDPPLFRPHLO.ZRF.H\:RUG2XW&RQWH[W QHJOLDQQL6HWWDQWDSHUSDVVDUHDLSULPL3FFRPHO¶2OLYHWWL0FRQG%DVH ,,,QHJOLDQQL2WWDQWDILQRDOO¶XWLOL]]RGLPRGHUQLVLVWHPLRSHUDWLYLtoolsGL
&RPHPLKDIDWWRQRWDUHLOFROOHJD(Q]R&DPSHOOL8QLYHUVLWjGL5RPD³/D6DSLHQ]D´ qUDURWURYDUHULFHUFKHLQFDPSRVRFLDOHGRYHODSHUPDQHQ]DVXOO¶RJJHWWRG¶LQGDJLQHVLDFRVu OXQJDHDSSURIRQGLWDLQWHOOLJHQ]D DUWLILFLDOH .DSSD GHOOD ,QWHOOLFRUS H GHO :HE QHJOL DQQL 1R YDQWDSURVHJXHQGRSRLLOODYRURQHLSULPLGHFHQQLGHO'XHPLODLQWXWWRTXH VWRSHUFRUVRFLKDDFFRPSDJQDWRO¶XVRGL6SVVStatistical Package for the
Social SciencesFKHSXUFDPELDQGRQXPHURVHYHUVLRQLHLQWHUIDFFHDEELDPR LQL]LDWRFRQOHVFKHGHSHUIRUDWHHXQLWjDQDVWURVLqVHPSUHPDQWHQXWRFRPH IRQGDPHQWRLQIRUPDWLFRGHOOHQRVWUHDQDOLVLPDQPDQRFKHO¶DUFKLYLRGLH[ YRWRFUHVFHYD/HVWDWLVWLFKHSUHVHQWDWHLQTXHVWRYROXPHVRQRHODERUDWHFRQ WDOHpackage8QDOWURPRPHQWRLPSRUWDQWHqVWDWRLODQQRLQFXLVLDPR SDVVDWLDOODIRWRJUDILDGLJLWDOHGRYHqRYYLDPHQWHFDPELDWRLOPRGRGLIRWRJUD IDUHPDDQFKHGLVFKHGDUHHDUFKLYLDUHLGDWLDOO¶LQL]LROHIRWRDYHYDQRXQD VFDUVDULVROX]LRQHVXL.EULVSHWWRDL0EDWWXDOL/DIRWRJUDILDGLJLWDOH OLEHUDQGRLOULFHUFDWRUHGDOODVSHVDGHOODSHOOLFRODVYLOXSSRHVWDPSDPDDQ FKHGDOWHPSRLPSLHJDWRSHUVYROJHUHWDOLRSHUD]LRQLKDDVVXQWRDQFKHLOYD ORUHGLXQ³GLDULRGLERUGR´LQTXDQWRLOULFHUFDWRUHSXzULSUHQGHUHOHWDUJKH HVSRVLWLYHLOFRQWHVWRHXVDUHLQROWUHLPHWDGDWLFRQVHUYDWLQHOOHPRGHUQHLP PDJLQLGLJLWDOLSHUDYHUHODSUHFLVDJHRORFDOL]]D]LRQHGDWDHWF /DPDJJLRUSDUWHGHJOLH[YRWRFKHIDQQRSDUWHGHO3URJHWWR$VFOHSLRIR WRJUDIDWLVFKHGDWLHLQVHULWLLQXQDEDQFDGDWLGLJLWDOHSURYHQJRQRGDO3LH PRQWHH9DOOHG¶$RVWDDEELDPRSHUzYROXWRFRPSDUDUHLGDWLGLTXHVWDUH JLRQHFRQLFRUSXVYRWLYLGLDOFXQLWUDLSULQFLSDOLVDQWXDULLWDOLDQL6LVRQR TXLQGLVFKHGDWRJOLH[YRWRGLSLQWLGHO6DQWXDULRGL0RQWHQHURGL/LYRUQR &KLDUOHVDQWXDULRULYLVWRQHOGL&HVHQD&KLDUHOODVDQ WXDULRULYLVWRQHODFFRPSDJQDWLGDOFROOHJDVRFLRORJR6WHIDQR0DUWHOOL HGDOODFDPSLRQHVVDROLPSLRQLFDGLVFLGLIRQGR6WHIDQLD%HOPRQGRLQRF FDVLRQHGLXQFRQYHJQRVXLYDORULGHOORVSRUWYDQFKH*ULPDOGLGHOOD 0DGRQQDGHOOD4XHUFLDGL9LWHUER3LQ]XWLULYLVWRQHOGL6DQ 1LFROD GL 7ROHQWLQR LQ SURYLQFLD GL 0DFHUDWD 'DLQHOOL ULYLVWR QHO O¶DQWURSRORJR$QWRQLQR%XWWLWWDPLKDIDWWRFRQRVFHUHJOLH[YRWRGHO 6DQWXDULRGL$OWDYLOOD0LOLFLDSUHVVR3DOHUPRYDQFRUD'DLQHOOLULYL VWRQHO7XWWLTXHVWLODYRULKDQQRSHUPHVVR±FRPHYHGUHPRPHJOLRLQ VHJXLWR±GLFRQRVFHUHOHVLQJRODULWjFRQOHRYYLHYDULDQWLGHOFDVRSUHVHQWL QHLFRPSRUWDPHQWLGHYR]LRQDOLQD]LRQDOLQHJOLXOWLPLFLQTXHVHFROL 7UDTXDQWLVRQRYHQXWLDFRQRVFHQ]DGHOQRVWURODYRURKRULFHYXWRULFKLH VWHGLLPPDJLQLWUDOHSLGLVSDUDWHGDFKLHUDLQWHUHVVDWRDOOHGLYLVHGHOO¶HVHU FLWRULVRUJLPHQWDOHGDFKLVLRFFXSDYDGLFRUVLG¶DFTXDGLSURWH]LRQHPD JLFRUHOLJLRVDGDLIXOPLQL%DURQWLGLULFRVWUXLUHLQFLGHQWLQDYDOLGL
3ULPDGHOHTXLQGLGHOO¶XVRGHOOHULSUHVHLQGLJLWDOHOHIRWRYHQLYDQRVWDPSDWH VXFDUWDLQIRUPDWR[DSDUWLUHGDOOHGLDSRVLWLYH[HLQFROODWHVXOODVFKHGDULSURGRWWD LQ)LJGHOFDS ,OQRVWURDUFKLYLRGLH[YRWRqVWDWRXWLOL]]DWRGDOFROOHJD*LDQFDUOR%DURQWLSHUODPRVWUD ©«QpSRUFKHULHQpDFTXHULH«)RUPHGLSURWH]LRQHPDJLFRUHOLJLRVDFRQWURLOIXOPLQHHODJUDQ GLQHGDOODFROOH]LRQHGLDPXOHWL³*LXVHSSH%HOOXFFL´ªFKHKDDYXWRFRPHHVLWRXQYROXPHFKHPDSSDUHOHYDODQJKHGHOOHQRVWUHPRQWDJQHGLFHQVLUHOHDOOXYLRQLILQRDOOH ULFKLHVWHGLXQ³FDFFLDWRUHGLWHUUHPRWL´FRVuVLHUDGHILQLWR,PPDJLQLGHO QRVWURDUFKLYLRVRQRVWDWHULFKLHVWHGDOODUHGD]LRQHGHOO¶(QFLFORSHGLD7UHF FDQLSHULOOXVWUDUHODYRFH³H[YRWR´ 1RQGLPHQWLFKLDPRFKHQHJOLH[YRWRGLSLQWLVRQRFXVWRGLWHLPPDJLQLGL DUFKLWHWWXUDXUEDQDHLQGXVWULDOHGHOWHUULWRULRFKHPHVVHDFRQIURQWRFRQ IRWRJUDILH DWWXDOL SRVVRQR WHVWLPRQLDUH OH WUDVIRUPD]LRQL DYYHQXWH H FRVWL WXLUHXQGDWRGLFRQIURQWRGLXQSDUWLFRODUHPRPHQWRVWRULFR/¶H[YRWRGL SLQWRFLULFRUGDRJQLYROWDFKHORVLJXDUGDODIUDJLOLWjGHOSDHVDJJLRFRQ IUDQHWHUUHPRWLHUX]LRQLHFLSDUODDQFKHGLWHUULWRULGLPHQWLFDWLDEEDQGR QDWL/DWDYROHWWDGLSLQWLFLFRQVHJQD±VHODOHJJLDPRFRQLOPRGHOORSURSRVWR GD$QWRQHOOD7DUSLQRQHOVXRYROXPHIl paesaggio fragile. L’Italia
vista dai margini ± O¶RUGLQH ³YLVLELOH´ LO JLRFR VHGLPHQWDWR GHJOL VSD]L H
TXHOOR³LQYLVLELOH´ODPHPRULDSURIRQGDGHLJUXSSLQHOWHPSR/¶H[YRWRFL DLXWDDYHGHUHO¶LPSURQWDGHOO¶DELWDUHHGHOODYRUDUHPHPRULDFKHULVFKLDDO WULPHQWLGLHQWUDUHLQXQFRQRG¶RPEUD
Foto 8 – Santuario della Madonna di Altavilla Milicia (Palermo). Ex-voto del 1861 che raffigura un’incidente accaduto a un gruppo che esce da una chiesa; l’anno ricorda sia l’Unità d’Italia sia la data in cui ricade all’incirca la media degli ex-voto italiani [Fonte: Buttitta (1983)]
FRQWLHQHXQ¶LQWHUHVVDQWHHGRFXPHQWDWDLQWURGX]LRQHGL7XOOLR6HSSLOOLGLUHWWRUHGHOO¶,VWLWXWRGL HWQRORJLDHDQWURSRORJLDFXOWXUDOHGHOO¶8QLYHUVLWjGHJOL6WXGLGL3HUXJLDY%DURQWL $OFXQLDQQLIDPLVRQRVWDWHFKLHVWHIRWRJUDILHGLH[YRWRGD*LDFRPR&KLDULIXQ]LR QDULRGHO3DXO*HWW\0XVHXPGL/RV$QJHOHV8VDGDSRUWDUHDOPXVHRVWHVVR
6HGLJLWLDPRODSDUROD³H[YRWR´LQXQPRWRUHGLULFHUFDFRPH*RRJOH RWWHQLDPRFLUFDPLOLRQLGLULIHULPHQWLGDWRWUDO¶DOWURLQIRUWHFUHVFLWDH LQJUDQSDUWHSHUWLQHQWHDGLPRVWUD]LRQHGHOJUDQGHLQWHUHVVHYHUVRTXHVWD IRUPDGLGHYR]LRQHSRSRODUHLQ,WDOLDHQHOPRQGR6RQRDQQLFKHULFHYR RJQLJLRUQRHVHQ]DVROX]LRQHGLFRQWLQXLWjWUDPLWHODIXQ]LRQHGoogle Alert, VHJQDOD]LRQLVXTXHVWRRJJHWWRDUWLFROLGLJLRUQDOHQRWL]LHGLHVSRVL]LRQLH PRVWUHDQFKHDQQXQFLGLYHQGLWHsic!QRQXOWLPRQRWL]LHGLIXUWLHDYROWH GLULWURYDPHQWLGHOODUHIXUWLYDLQTXHVWRFDVRVLULYHODQRLPSRUWDQWLOHVFKH GDWXUHIRWRJUDILFKHGHJOLH[YRWR/HPLJOLDLDGLVHJQDOD]LRQLULFHYXWHVXO ZHEWHVWLPRQLDQRODYLWDOLWjHO¶LQWHQVLWjGLTXHVWDIRUPDGLUHOLJLRVLWjSRSR ODUHHSRWUHEEHUREHQLVVLPRGLYHQWDUHLGDWLGLXQDWHVLGLODXUHD 1HLSULPLDQQL2WWDQWDKRLQL]LDWRXQDULFHUFDFRQTXHVWLRQDULRULYROWRDL UHWWRULGHLVDQWXDULSLHPRQWHVLHOLJXULLQWDOHRFFDVLRQHqVWDWRULOHYDWRROWUH RYYLDPHQWHDLQIRUPD]LRQLVXOODSUHVHQ]DGLH[YRWRPDWHULDOHLPSRUWDQWH VXOO¶RULJLQHGHOVDQWXDULRLQSDUWLFRODUPRGRVLVRQRUDFFROWHOHOHJJHQGHGL IRQGD]LRQHFKHWHVWLPRQLDQRODVDFUDOL]]D]LRQHGHOOXRJRPHGLDQWHXQ¶DSSD UL]LRQHVROLWDPHQWHPDULDQDULFHUFDFKHKDFRQWULEXLWRDOODVWHVXUDGLDOFXQL FDSLWROLSUHVHQWLLQTXHVWRYROXPH&RQ)UDQFR%ROJLDQLKRDYXWRRFFDVLRQH GLGLVFXWHUHGHO6DQWXDULRGHOOD&RQVRODWDHGHOORVWUDRUGLQDULRFRUSXVYRWLYR LQHVVRFXVWRGLWRVXFXLLOFROOHJDKDUHGDWWRXQLPSRUWDQWHFRQWULEXWRLQXQ YROXPHSURPRVVRGDOOD3URYLQFLDGL7RULQR%ROJLDQLDOPHGHVLPR OLEURKDSDUWHFLSDWR/DXUD%RUHOORHVSHUWDGLH[YRWRHGLLPPDJLQLGHYR ]LRQDOL$OFXQLVDQWXDULVRQRGLYHQWDWLULIHULPHQWRSHUJUXSSLVRFLDOLVLSHQVL
$QFKHVHLQTXHVWRYROXPHSDUOLDPRGLOHJJHQGHGLIRQGD]LRQHGLOXRJKLVDFULLWDOLDQLY 3DUWH ,, QH HVLVWRQR RYYLDPHQWH DQFKH DO GL IXRUL GHL QRVWUL FRQILQL FRPH WHVWLPRQLD TXDQWRVHJXH©'DOODSDUWHRULHQWDOHGHOFROOHQHOTXDOHVLHUJHOD%DVLOLFDGHOOD1DWLYLWjVL WURYDOD*URWWDGHO/DWWHGHWWDLQDUDER³0DJKDUHW6LWWL0DULDP´ODJURWWDGHOOD6LJQRUD0D ULDSUHVVR%HWOHPPH6HFRQGRXQDOHJJHQGDGHO9,VHFOD0DGRQQDVLQDVFRVHTXLGXUDQWH ODVWUDJHGHJOL,QQRFHQWLDOORQWDQDQGRVLGDOODPDQJLDWRLDGRYHDYHYDPHVVRDOULSDURLO%DP ELQRGDLSHUVHFXWRULPDQGDWLGD(URGH4XHVWDOHJJHQGDVFRPSDUYHSUHVWRHIXVRVWLWXLWDGD XQ¶DOWUD6*LXVHSSHDYYHUWLWRGDXQDQJHORGHOSHULFRORFKHLQFRPEHYDVXO%DPELQRHGHOOD QHFHVVLWjGLWUDVIHULUVLLQ(JLWWRVLPLVHVXELWRDIDUHLSUHSDUDWLYLSHULOYLDJJLRHVROOHFLWzOD 9HUJLQHFKHVWDYDDOODWWDQGR$OFXQHJRFFHQHOODIUHWWDFDGGHURDWHUUDHODURFFLDGDURVD GLYHQQHELDQFD,O6DQWXDULRqVHPSUHPROWRYHQHUDWRHODFUHGHQ]DSRSRODUHQRQVLqPDL VSHQWDWXWWRUDGRSRVHFROLOHGRQQHLQGLJHQHVLDFULVWLDQHFKHPDRPHWWDQHSUHJDQRTXL OD9HUJLQH0DULDSHURWWHQHUHODWWHDEERQGDQWHSHUOHORURFUHDWXUHª1HOOD*URWWDVRQRSUHVHQWL QXPHURVLH[YRWRFKHWHVWLPRQLDQROHULFKLHVWHGLJUD]LHULFHYXWHGLPDWHUQLWjZZZHUHPR VDQWDOEHULFRLWSDJHSKS" %ROJLDQLLQTXHVWRFRQWULEXWRVRWWROLQHDFKH©XQVDQWXDULRVHQ]DH[YRWRQRQqXQVDQ WXDULRRQRQORqSLHQDPHQWHªHIDQRWDUHFRPHO¶H[YRWRDSSDLDSULPDFRPHSURGRWWR³DOWR´ HVSUHVVLRQHGLFODVVLHOHYDWHHSRLYLVLDVWDWDXQJUDGXDOHWUDVIHULPHQWRYHUVROHFODVVLSL XPLOLVRWWRIRUPDGLDUWHSRYHUDOXRJRGHOOD³PLVHULDFRQILGHQWH´ /DXUD%RUHOORFLULFRUGDFKHQHOSDHVHGL9HUGXQRLQSURYLQFLDGL&XQHRVLWURYDQR H[YRWRGHGLFDWLDO%HDWR6HEDVWLDQR9DOIUpFROORFDWLQHOVDQWXDULRFKHLQJOREDODFDVDQDWLYD GHOSUHWHRUDWRULDQRGHOOD&RQJUHJD]LRQH)LOLSSLQDGL7RULQRLPSRUWDQWHGDWRFKHKDSUHFRUVR LWHPSLGHLJUDQGL³VDQWLVRFLDOL´SLHPRQWHVL%RUHOORLQ©/¶$OWUR3LHPRQWHªPDU]R
DOOD 0DGRQQD GHO 6DQWXDULR GL &DVWHOOD]]R %RUPLGD $OHVVDQGULD HOHWWD SURWHWWULFHGHLFHQWDXULPRWRFLFOLVWLRDOOD0DGRQQDGHO6DQWXDULRGHL&DIIL $VWLSURWHWWULFHGHJOLDOSLQL 'XUDQWHXQDFRQIHUHQ]DWHQXWDSHU8QL7UHGL&DQHOOL$VWLQHOVRQR ULXVFLWRDYHQLUHDFDSRGHOFRQWHQXWRGLXQH[YRWRFKHDYHYDFRQVHUYDWR SHUPHLOVXRPLVWHURSHUSLGLWUHQW¶DQQL7DOHGLSLQWRGHVFULYHXQWUHQR FKH GHUDJOLD FRQ O¶LVFUL]LRQH Chenney le Grain / “Francia” 6-8-1943
“Banda Bedin”8QDIRWRWHVVHUDGLXQJLRYDQHHXQDIRWRGLXQJUXSSRGL JLRYDQRWWLLQSRVDVRQRFROORFDWHLQDOWRDGHVWUD/DVWXGLRVDGLVWRULD ORFDOH±*LDQQD0HQDEUHD]SUHVHQWHLQVDOD±KDUDFFRQWDWRFKHXQRGLTXHVWL q)HUUXFFLR*DLGL&DQHOOLFKHKDWHVWLPRQLDWRGLHVVHUHVWDWRSDUWHGLTXHO JUXSSRUDJD]]LGHOODOHYDGHOFKLDPDWLDULQIRU]DUHOD,9$UPDWDGL VWDQ]DQHOOD3URYHQ]DIUDQFHVHHFKHVLVRQRGDWLLOQRPHGL³%DQGD%HGLQ´ FKHILQRDOO¶VHWWHPEUHJLRFDYDDFDOFLRFRQJOLDOOHDWLWHGHVFKLHFKHGRSR ODGDWDGHOQRWR$UPLVWL]LRVLWURYzSULJLRQLHURGLTXHOOLFKHHUDQRGLYHQWDWL QHPLFL)XURQRFDULFDWLVXGLXQWUHQRGLUHWWRDLFDPSLGLODYRURLQ*HUPD QLDHGXUDQWHTXHVWRYLDJJLRVLYHULILFzXQGHYDVWDQWHVFRQWURIHUURYLDULRD FDXVDIRUVHGLXQVDERWDJJLRGLSDUWLJLDQLIUDQFHVL*LDQQD0HQDEUHD]±LQ XQYROXPHFKHPLKDIDWWRFRQRVFHUHHLQFXLULFRVWUXLVFHTXHVWDHQXPHURVH DOWUHYLFHQGHGLFDQHOOHVLGHSRUWDWLHLQWHUQDWLLQODJHUQD]LVWL±VFULYH©6HE EHQHLSULJLRQLHULDYHVVHURODQFLDWRJULGDGLVSHUDWHQHVVXQRVLFXUzGLVRF FRUUHUOL/RURVFRUDJJLDWLDYHYDQRGHFLVRGLLQYRFDUHOD0DGRQQDGHL&DIIL OHDYHYDQRULYROWRXQDVHQWLWDSUHJKLHUDHIDWWRYRWRFKHVHIRVVHURXVFLWL YLYLGDOGLVDVWUROHDYUHEEHURGHGLFDWRXQTXDGURUDIILJXUDQWHODORURWUD JHGLDH/HLOLDYHYDHVDXGLWLª0HQDEUHD]S&LUFRQGDWLGDOOD :HKUPDFKWIXURQRWUDVSRUWDWLQHOODJHUWHGHVFKLGL9LOOLQJHQH:XWRVFKLQ JHQGRYHODYRUDURQRFRPHPHFFDQLFLSHUPHVLQHOODFRVWUX]LRQHGLSDUWL GHLIDPLJHUDWLPLVVLOL9H9/LEHUDWLLODSULOHWRUQDURQRD&D QHOOLGRSRPHVLGLSHULSH]LHHILQDOPHQWHLVXSHUVWLWLSRWHURQRVFLRJOLHUHLO YRWRDOOD0DGRQQDGHL&DIILGL&DVVLQDVFR$VWL3HU*DLODSDVVLRQHSHU
ULSRUWDXQ¶LQWHUHVVDQWHLQWHUYLVWDD*XLGR*DMHWWLFRUUHGDWDGDIRWRXQRGHJOLXOWLPLSLWWRUL WRULQHVLFKHJUDYLWDYDDWWRUQRDOOD&RQVRODWD 1HO6DQWXDULRGHOOD0DGRQQDGHOOD&UHWDGL&DVWHOOD]]R%RUPLGD$OHVVDQGULDqFROOR FDWRO¶H[YRWRGL9LWWRULR/DXWLHUFKHLORWWREUHVLWURYDYDVXOWUDQVDWODQWLFR0DIDOGD FKHDIIRQGzDSRFKHPLJOLDGHOOHFRVWHGHO%UDVLOHSURYRFDQGRODPRUWHGLSHUVRQH9LW WRULR/DXWLHUVLVDOYzGDOQDXIUDJLRQRQRVWDQWHODVFLDOXSSDVXFXLHUDVFHVRLQPDUHVLIRVVH URYHVFLDWDO¶H[YRWRqULSURGRWWRLQ*ULPDOGLS /DFLWWjGL&DQHOOLULFFDGLLPSUHVHYLQLFROH*DQFLD5LFFDGRQQD&RQWUDWWR%RVFD HWFKDYLVWRQHOGRSRJXHUUDODQDVFLWDGLQXPHURVHD]LHQGHHQRPHFFDQLFKHSUREDELOPHQWH DQFKHOHHVSHULHQ]HYLVVXWHQHOODFRVWUX]LRQHGL9H9KDQQRSRUWDWRFRQRVFHQ]HLQTXHVWR FHQWURGHO0RQIHUUDWR/D QRWWH WUD LO H O¶ GLFHPEUH IX O¶XOWLPD SULPD GHOOD GHSRUWD]LRQH SHU
UDJD]]LUHFOXVLQHOODFKLHVDFDQHOOHVHGL6DQ5RFFR'DOUDFFRQWRGL)HUUXFFLR%UDQGDUDF FROWRGDOOHQLSRWL%LDQFDH6HUHQD©,OGLFHPEUHPHQWUHOR]LRHUDGDOIRUQDLRSHU IDUFXRFHUHLOSDQHYLGLDUULYDUHGDOODVWUDGDGL5RQFRJHQQDURGHLPLOLWDULGHOOD5HSXEEOLFD