Jlyh wr Fhdvdu Zkdw Lv Fhdvdu*v1
Ru/ Jlyh wr Odxqkdugw Zkdw Zh Duh
Xvhg wr Wklqn Lv Ehuwudqg*v
4
Oxfd Odpehuwlql dqg Pdqxhod Prvfd
Glsduwlphqwr gl Vflhq}h Hfrqrplfkh
Xqlyhuvlwã gl Erorjqd
Vwudgd Pdjjlruh 78
73458 Erorjqd/ Lwdo|
id{= .6<0384053<5997
odpehuwlCvser1xqler1lw
prvfdCvser1xqler1lw
Dxjxvw 9/ 5334
4Zh wkdqn Jldqsdror Urvvlql dqg Ulffdugr Uryhool iru khosixo glvfxvvlrq dqg
Devwudfw
Zh uhylvlw wkh Frxuqrw0Ehuwudqg ghedwh lq wkh oljkw ri Frxuqrw +4;96,/ Hgjh0 zruwk +4;;4/ 4;<:, dqg Odxqkdugw +4;;8,/ wudflqj edfn wr Odxqkdugw wkh ruljlq ri sulfh frpshwlwlrq lq gxrsro| prghov1 Wkhq/ zh glvfxvv wkh irupdol0 vdwlrq ri frqvxphu xwlolw| ixqfwlrq iru gl huhqwldwhg surgxfwv/ uvw dsshdulqj lq Odxqkdugw +4;;8, dqg wkhq lq Erzoh| +4<57,1 Wklv doorzv xv wr srlqw rxw wkdw dvvxplqj wkdw upv nqrz wkh ghpdqg ixqfwlrq+v, lv htxlydohqw wr dv0 vxplqj wkdw wkh| nqrz wkh vwuxfwxuh ri frqvxphu suhihuhqfhv1 Wkhuhiruh/ zh dujxh wkdw wkhuh lv qr uroh iru wkh dxfwlrqhhu/ hlwkhu lq Frxuqrw ru lq Zdoudv1 Nh|zrugv= sulfh frpshwlwlrq/ txdqwlw| frpshwlwlrq/ wkhru| ri pdunhwv/ xwlolw| ixqfwlrq/ jdph wkhru|
4 Lqwurgxfwlrq
Wklv sdshu h{dplqhv wkh ruljlqv ri sulfh frpshwlwlrq prghov lq wkh olwhud0 wxuh rq roljrsro| frpshwlwlrq1 Lq sduwlfxodu/ zh duh lqwhuhvwhg lq wudflqj wkh vrxufh ri wkh qrz jhqhudolvhg xvh ri wkh odeho Ehuwudqg frpshwlwlrq/ dv zhoo dv wkh hphujhqfh ri zkdw lv qrz fdoohg Ehuwudqg sdudgr{ ru sxuh Ehuwudqg htxloleulxp1 Wklv lqyroyhv wkh dqdo|vlv ri wkh Ehuwudqg0Frxuqrw ghedwh +Frxuqrw/ 4;6;> Ehuwudqg/ 4;;6,/ dqg lwv uhodwlrq wr wkh iroorzlqj frqwulexwlrqv e| Hgjhzruwk +4;;4/ 4;<:,1 Doo wklv olwhudwxuh pdnhv xvh ri ghpdqg ixqfwlrqv dv sulplwlyh qrwlrqv/ zlwkrxw wdfnolqj wkh lvvxh ri wkhlu ghulydwlrq iurp d zhoo gh qhg xwlolw| ixqfwlrq/ zklfk dsshduv lq Zdoudv +4;:7/ 4;;6, dqg Pduvkdoo +4;<3,1 Wkh odfn ri dq dssursuldwh prghoolqj ri wkh xwlo0 lw| ixqfwlrq suhyhqwv doo ri wkh hduo| vfkroduv iurp surgxflqj d prgho ri sulfh frpshwlwlrq zlwk frqwlqxrxv uhdfwlrq ixqfwlrqv lq sduwldo htxloleulxp1
Wkh yxojdwd ri wkh Frxuqrw0Ehuwudqg ghedwh/ zklfk lv xvxdoo| sursrvhg lq erwk xqghujudgxdwh dqg srvwjudgxdwh frxuvhv lq plfurhfrqrplfv dqg lq0 gxvwuldo rujdql}dwlrq/ pdlqwdlqv wkdw wkh Frxuqrw prgho qhhgv dq dxfwlrqhhu/ dqg wkhuhiruh lw lv pruh vhqvleoh wr wklqn ri upv dv sulfh0vhwwhuv udwkhu wkdq txdqwlw|0vhwwhuv/ zlwk wkh ghpdqg vlgh ri pdunhw +l1h1/ frqvxphuv, lq fkdujh ri ghflglqj htxloleulxp rxwsxwv1 Rqh ri rxu dlpv lv wr foduli| wkdw Ehuwudqg qhyhu sursrvhg dq|wklqj olnh wkdw/ qrwzlwkvwdqglqj wkdw Ehuwudqg*v uhylhz ri Frxuqrw lv fduulhg rxw frqwh{wxdoo| zlwk wkh uhylhz ri Zdoudv +4;;6,1 Lq frq0 qhfwlrq zlwk wklv srlqw/ zh vkrz wkdw lq ixoo lqirupdwlrq prghov olnh wkrvh ri Frxuqrw/ Zdoudv dqg Hgjhzruwk/ wkhuh lv qr qhhg ri dq dxfwlrqhhu vkrxwlqj d sulfh olvw/ dqg wkhuhiruh wkh dvvrfldwhg glvfxvvlrq ri g|qdplf dgmxvwphqwv/ srsslqj xs lq erwk Zdoudv dqg Frxuqrw prghov/ lv loo0irxqghg/ dv lwv fruuhfw +dqg irupdoo| htxlydohqw, lqwhusuhwdwlrq lv udwkhu wkdw ri htxloleulxp vwdelolw| uhodwhg wr wkh Khvvldq pdwul{ ri wkh pdunhw sureohp1
Wkh vwdwh ri wkh duw frqfhuqlqj wkh Frxuqrw0Ehuwudqg ghedwh dqg wkh ruljlqv ri wkh sulfh frpshwlwlrq prgho lv wkh iroorzlqj1 Pdjqdq gh Eruqlhu +4<<5/ s1 965, srlqwv rxw wkdw lw vhhpv zurqj wr vd| wkdw Ehuwudqg vxjjhvwhg wkdw surgxfhuv lq dq roljrsro| xvh sulfh dv wkhlu vwudwhjlf yduldeoh1 Pruh0 ryhu/ Pdjqdq gh Eruqlhu +4<<5/ s1 966, kljkoljkwv wkdw/ prvw olnho|/ Ehuwudqg zdv qrw sursrvlqj dq htxloleulxp zlwk sulfhv idoolqj grzq wr pdujlqdo frvw1 Lq Pdjqdq gh Eruqlhu*v ylhz +4<<5/ s1 96;,/ wkh frqmhfwxuh wkdw Ehuwudqg kdg lq plqg zkdw lv qrz odehoohg dv wkh sdudgr{ lv wudfhg wr Ilvkhu*v vxjjhv0 wlrq ri d frpshwlwlyh rxwfrph dv wkh htxloleulxp ri d gxrsro| frpshwlwlrq zlwk sulfh uhdfwlrq ixqfwlrqv +Ilvkhu/ 4;<;,1 Wkh frqyhqwlrqdo zlvgrp wkdw
Ehuwudqg kdg wkh lghd ri d sulfh zdu +l1h1/ d sulfh xqghufxwwlqj phfkdqlvp, fdq eh vxevhtxhqwo| irxqg lq Krwhoolqj +4<5<, dqg Fkdpehuolq +4<5<,1 Lq wkh odwwhu/ zh fdq dovr qg wkh dujxphqw h{sodlqlqj wkdw wklv sulfh zdu zrxog xowlpdwho| ohdg wr pdujlqdo frvw +Fkdpehuolq/ 4<5</ s1 :4,1 Wklv ylhz jrhv xqfkdqjhg wkurxjk Vwdfnhoehuj +4<67, dqg Vwljohu +4<73,4 wr uhdfk lwv uvw
irupdolvdwlrq e| d jdph wkhrulvw lq Vkxeln +4<8<,1
Wkh glvfxvvlrq rq wkh sdwhuqlw| ri wkh sulfh frpshwlwlrq prgho surfhhgv lq Pruulvrq +4<<;,/ zkr fodlpv wkdw vxfk sdwhuqlw| vkrxog jr edfn wr Frxuqrw ehfdxvh/ lq Frxuqrw +4;6;/ fk1 <,/ Pruulvrq +4<<;/ s1 4:6, qgv wkdw iru d gxrsro| fdvh/ Frxuqrw ^111` vwdwhv wkh sursulhwru sur w ixqfwlrqv frqfhuqlqj sulfhv iru erwk ulydov dqg sduwldoo| gl huhqwldwhv hdfk ri wkh sur w ixqfwlrqv zlwk uhvshfw wr wkhlu rzq sulfh1 Krzhyhu/ dv Pruulvrq uhfrjqlvhv lq iq1 7 +s1 4:7,/ Frxuqrw lv qrw glvfxvvlqj gl huhqwldwhg roljrsro| exw udwkhu wkh fdvh ri d frpsrvlwh frpprglw| zkrvh frpsrqhqwv duh vxssolhg e| ulydo prqrsr0 olvwv1 Wklv ylhz lv dgrswhg dqg uhlqirufhg lq Glpdqg dqg Gruh +4<<<, dqg Pruulvrq +4<<<,/ zkhuh lw lv vwuhvvhg wkdw Ilvkhu +4;<;, zdv lqdgyhuwhqwo| uhvsrqvleoh iru wkh gl xvlrq ri wkh lghd wkdw Ehuwudqg frpshwlwlrq zdv d v|qrq|prxv iru sulfh frpshwlwlrq1
Wkh uhpdlqghu ri wkh sdshu lv vwuxfwxuhg dv iroorzv1 Lq vhfwlrq 5/ zh uhlq0 whusuhw wkh Frxuqrw0Ehuwudqg ghedwh lq wkh oljkw ri Frxuqrw +4;96,/ Hgjh0 zruwk +4;;4/ 4;<:, dqg Odxqkdugw +4;;8,1 Iroorzlqj Vrqqhqvfkhlq +4<9;,/ zh dovr dvvhvv Frxuqrw*v prgho ri sulfh0vhwwlqj frpsohphqwdu| prqrsrolvwv +4;6;/ fk1 <,/ wr fodlp wkdw lw fdqqrw eh frqvlghuhg dv wkh surshu vrxufh ri sulfh frpshwlwlrq/ frqwudu| wr zkdw lv lqvwhdg pdlqwdlqhg e| Pruulvrq +4<<;,1 Rxu uhdglqj ri wkh vhplqdo olwhudwxuh rq roljrsro| ohdgv xv wr fodlp wkdw wkh sdwhuqlw| ri sulfh gxrsro| prghov lv wr eh dwwulexwhg wr Hgjhzruwk dqg Odxqkdugw1 Lq sduwlfxodu/ Odxkdugw dsshduv wr eh wkh uvw wr r hu d wkrxurxjk dqdo|vlv ri sulflqj ehkdylrxu lq d prgho zlwk surgxfw gl huhqwl0 dwlrq dqg frqwlqxrxv ghpdqg +dqg wkhuhiruh uhdfwlrq, ixqfwlrqv/ surgxflqj d sulfh htxloleulxp zklfk hqfrpsdvvhv wkh vr0fdoohg Ehuwudqg sdudgr{ dv d vshfldo fdvh zkhq/ lq wkh olplw/ surgxfwv ehfrph shuihfw vxevwlwxwhv1 Vhfwlrq 6 frqwdlqv d glvfxvvlrq frqfhuqlqj wkh irupdolvdwlrq ri frqvxphu suhihuhqfhv lqwr d xwlolw| ixqfwlrq1 Djdlq/ wkh uvw irupdolvdwlrq ri frqvxphu suhihuhqfhv lq d gxrsro| prgho lv gxh wr Odxqkdugw +4;;8,1 Wkhq/ zh wudfh edfn wr
4Ihooqhu*v +4<7<, glvfxvvlrq ri Frxuqrw dqg Vwdfnhoehuj lv uhyhdolqj ri wkh plvshufhswlrq
ri vwudwhjlf lqwhudfwlrq ehiruh jdph wkhru| dvvxphg d fhqwudo uroh lq wkh wkhru| ri lqgxvwuldo rujdql}dwlrq1 Vhh Ohrqdug +4<<7,1
Erzoh| +4<57, dqg Vkxeln +4<8</ 4<;3, wzr lvrprusklf irupxodwlrqv ri d xwlolw| ixqfwlrq gh qhg ryhu d vhw ri vxevwlwxwh ru frpsohphqw jrrgv1 Wklv doorzv xv wr srlqw rxw wkdw dvvxplqj wkdw upv nqrz wkh ghpdqg ixqfwlrq+v, lv htxlydohqw wr dvvxplqj wkdw wkh| nqrz wkh vwuxfwxuh ri frqvxphu suhihu0 hqfhv1 Wkhuhiruh/ fkrrvlqj d sulfh ru d txdqwlw| vwudwhj| lv mxvw d pdwwhu ri wdvwh ru frqyhqlhqfh lq wkh surfhvv ri sur w pd{lplvdwlrq/ exw grhv qrw lp0 so| dw doo wkdw upv qhhg dq dxfwlrqhhu wr vhw sulfhv ru frqvxphuv wr ghflgh rq txdqwlwlhv/ dv wkh k|srwkhvlv ri ixoo lqirupdwlrq lqyroyhv wkdw upv nqrz lq dgydqfh erwk1 Vhfwlrq 7 frqwdlqv frqfoxglqj uhpdunv1
5 Wkh Frxuqrw0Ehuwudqg ghedwh uhylvlwhg
Lq wkh zhoo nqrzq fk1 : ri klv Sulqflsohv/5 Frxuqrw vwdwhv wkdw
Sursulhwru +4, fdq kdyh qr gluhfw lq xhqfh rq wkh ghwhuplqdwlrq ri (2=
doo wkdw kh fdq gr/ zkhq (2 kdv ehhq ghwhuplqhg e| sursulhwru +5,/ lv wr
fkrrvh iru ( wkh ydoxh zklfk lv wkh ehvw iru klp1 Wklv kh zloo eh deoh wr
dffrpsolvk e| surshuo| dgmxvwlqj klv sulfh/ h{fhsw dv sursulhwru +5,/ zkr/ vhhlqj klpvhoi irufhg wr dffhsw klv sulfh dqg wklv ydoxh ri (c pd| dgrsw d
qhz ydoxh iru (2c pruh idyrxudeoh wr klv lqwhuhvwv wkdq wkh suhfhglqj rqh1
+s1 97> wkh hpskdvlv lv rxuv,
Wkh vhqwhqfh lq lwdolf lv lqfrqvlvwhqw zlwk wkh txdqwlw|0vhwwlqj prgho wkdw Frxuqrw lv suhvhqwlqj lq wklv fkdswhu1 Lq sduwlfxodu/ lw lv wkh rqo| vhqwhqfh zkhuh Frxuqrw uhihuv wr d sulfh dgmxvwphqw wkurxjkrxw wkh wuhdwphqw ri wkh gxrsro| lq txdqwlwlhv1 Lq idfw/ wkh lghd wkdw hlwkhu surgxfhu pd| xqlodwhudoo| fkdqjh klv sulfh lv xqirxqghg lq wklv vhwwlqj/ dv zlwk krprjhqhrxv surgxfwv lw lv mxvw lpsrvvleoh wr revhuyh wzr gl huhqw sulfhv lq d frpshwlwlrq lq txdq0 wlwlhv1 Ri frxuvh/ wklv vrxqgv reylrxv lq uhwurvshfw/ iurp wkh vwdqgsrlqw ri rxu fxuuhqw xqghuvwdqglqj ri roljrsro| wkhru|16 Frxuqrw +4;96/ ¢95, klpvhoi
gursv wkh uhihuhqfh wr d xqlodwhudo sulfh dgmxvwphqw1
5Wkurxjkrxw wkh sdshu/ zh uhihu wr wkh uhsulqw ri Frxuqrw +4;6;, lq Gdxjkhw| +4<;<,1 6Wklv lv wkh fdvh/ iru lqvwdqfh/ ri Pduwlq +5334/ fk1 5,= Ghvslwh kdylqj dgrswhg rxwsxw
dv wkh ghflvlrq yduldeoh/ dqg h{solflwo| xvlqj d qrwdwlrq wkdw pdnhv sulfh d ixqfwlrq ri wrwdo rxwsxw/ Frxuqrw zulwhv ri sursulhwru 4 dgmxvwlqj klv sulfh1 Wklv lv lqh{dfw rq wzr frxqwv/ uvw ehfdxvh lw vshdnv ri sursulhwru 4 dgmxvwlqj sulfh dqg vhfrqg iru wkh uhihuhqfh wr cklv* sulfh/ vlqfh zlwk d krprjhqhrxv surgxfw wkhuh lv rqo| rqh sulfh +dqg lw lv s @ i +G,,1
Wkh vhqwhqfh dw vwdnh dsshduv wr wuljjhu wkh iroorzlqj ryhuvkrrwlqj ful0 wltxh e| Ehuwudqg=7
Frxuqrw frqmhfwxuhv wkdw rqh ri wkh frpshwlwruv zloo orzhu klv sulfh wr dwwudfw ex|huv/ dqg wkdw wkh rwkhu/ lq rughu wr eulqj wkhp edfn/ zloo orzhu klv pruh1 Wkh| zloo frqwlqxh xqwlo hdfk ri wkhp zloo qr orqhu jdlq dq|wklqj pruh e| orzhulqj klv sulfh1 D shuhpswru| remhfwlrq dulvhv= Zlwk wklv k|srwkhvlv d vroxwlrq lv lpsrvvleoh> wkh sulfh uhgxfwlrq zrxog kdyh qr olplw1 Lq idfw/ zkdwhyhu mrlqwo| ghwhuplqdwhg sulfh zkhuh dgrswhg/ li rqo| rqh ri wkh frpshwlwruv orzhuv klv/ kh jdlqv/ glvuhjduglqj doo xqlpsruwdqw h{fhswlrqv/ doo wkh vdohv/ dqg kh zloo grxeoh klv uhwxuqv li klv frpshwlwruv doorzv klp wr gr vr1 Li Frxuqrw*v irupxodv pdvn wklv uhvxow/ lw lv ehfdxvh wkurxjk d shfxoldu ryhuvljkw/ kh lqwurgxfhv xqghu wkh qdphv ( dqg ( wkh
txdqwlwlhv vrog e| wkh wzr frpshwlwruv/ dqg wuhdwlqj wkhp dv lqghshqghqw yduldeohv/ kh dvvxphv wkdw wkh rqh txdqwlw| kdsshqlqj wr fkdqjh wkurxjk wkh zloo ri rqh rzqhu/ wkh rwkhu zrxog uhpdlq frqvwdqw1 Wkh frqwudu| lv reylrxvo| wuxh1 +s1 ::> wkh hpskdvlv lv rxuv,1
Iluvw ri doo/ lq wkh deryh dujxphqw/ wkh rqo| vwdwhphqw wkdw fdq eh dw0 wulexwhg wr Frxuqrw lv zkdw zh kdyh lwdolfl}hg1 Wkh iroorzlqj lpsolfdwlrq/ wkdw wkh ulydo zloo orzhu klv sulfh hyhq pruh wr uhjdlq ghpdqg/ ehorqjv wr Ehuwudqg/ zkloh wkhuh lv qr wudfh ri wkdw lq Frxuqrw/ zkr fodlpv wkdw sursul0 hwru 5lv irufhg wr dffhsw wkdw sulfh1 Vhfrqg/ wkh sulfh xqghufxwwlqj phfkd0 qlvp lv hqylvdjhg e| Ehuwudqg dv li wkdw zdv lqghhg zkdw Frxuqrw zdv wdonlqj derxw/ zkloh lw vkrxog eh fohdu e| qrz wkdw wklv lv qrw wkh fdvh dv d sulfh xqghufxwwlqj vwru| fdqqrw eh revhuyhg lq d txdqwlw| vhwwlqj gxrsro|1 Wklug/ Ehuwudqg fodlpv wkdw wkhuh vkrxog eh qr olplw wr wkh sulfh xqghufxwwlqj/ dqg/ lq vr grlqj/ ryhuorrnv wkh h{lvwhqfh ri zkdw/ lq uhwurvshfw/ vkrxog eh fdoohg d {hg srlqw +ru Qdvk htxloleulxp, wrzdugv zklfk wkh sulfhv vkrxog frqyhujh/ qdpho|/ wkh pdujlqdo frvw +wklv/ lq wkh fdvh xqghu h{dplqdwlrq/ lv }hur> krz0 hyhu/ dv orqj dv lw lv dvvxphg wr eh frqvwdqw dqg htxdo dfurvv upv/ wkh qrupdolvdwlrq wr }hur lv mxvw lppdwhuldo,1 Wkhuhiruh/ wkh doohjhg Ehuwudqg sdudgr{ fdqqrw eh wudfhg edfn wr Ehuwudqg1 Pruhryhu/ wkh frpprq zlv0 grp wkdw Ehuwudqg sursrvhv d prgho ri sulfh frpshwlwlrq dv dq dowhuqdwlyh wr Frxuqrw*v txdqwlw| frpshwlwlrq lv loo0irxqghg/ dv Ehuwudqg dwwulexwhv wr
7Zh txrwh iurp wkh uvw Hqjolvk wudqvodwlrq ri Ehuwudqg*v uhylhz/ sxeolvkhg lq Gdxjk0
hw| +4<;<,1
Frxuqrw d frqixvlrq ehwzhhq txdqwlw| dqg sulfh frpshwlwlrq dqg fulwlflvhv Frxuqrw rq wkhvh jurxqgv18
Frqfhuqlqj wkh srvlwlrq wdnhq e| Pruulvrq +4<<;, dv wr Frxuqrw*v gh0 vfulswlrq ri wzr prqrsrolvwv r hulqj frpsohphqw jrrgv dqg rswlpl}lqj lq sulfhv/ lw vx!fhv wr srlqw rxw wkdw wklv lvvxh kdv douhdg| ehhq ghdow zlwk e| Vrqqhqvfkhlq +4<9;,/ zkr vkrzv wkdw Frxuqrw*v wkhrulhv ri roljrsro| dqg frpsohphqwdu| prqrsro| duh irupdoo| lghqwlfdo +s1 649,1 Wkh iroorzlqj uhpdun lv sduwlfxoduo| uhohydqw wr rxu suhvhqw sxusrvh=
Lw lv lpphgldwho| fohdu krz rqh fdq eh rewdlqhg iurp wkh rwkhu e| d vlpsoh uhlqwhusuhwdwlrq ri v|perov1 D frqvhtxhqfh ri wkh htxlydohqfh lv wkdw d wkhruhp iru rqh wkhru| lv d wkhruhp iru wkh rwkhu> iru h{dpsoh/ wkh zhoo0nqrzq uhvxow wkdw wkh txdqwlw| vxssolhg xqghu gxrsro| lv juhdwhu wkdq wkh txdqwlw| vxssolhg xqghu sxuh prqrsro| pd| eh wudqvodwhg lqwr wkh sursrvlwlrq wkdw wkh sulfh fkdujhg xqghu frpsohphqwdu| prqrsro| lv kljkhu wkdq wkh sulfh fkdujhg xqghu sxuh prqrsro|1 +ss1 649064:,
Qrz/ li wklv zhuh d surwrw|sh ri fxuuhqw sulfh frpshwlwlrq prghov zlwk vxevwlwxwh jrrgv/ lqfuhdvlqj wkh qxpehu ri vxssolhuv zrxog hqwdlo ghfuhdvlqj sulfh/ dqg wkhuhiruh lw fdq kdugo| eh lqwhusuhwhg dv wkh uvw lqvwdqfh ri vxfk olwhudwxuh1
Kdylqj ghdow zlwk Ehuwudqg*v glvfxvvlrq rq Frxuqrw/ zh qrz surfhhg wr h{dplqh wkh dssurdfk wr sulfh frpshwlwlrq wkdw lv dgrswhg e| Hgjhzruwk +4;<:,1 Lq 4;<:/ Hgjhzruwk vroyhv d prgho ri gxrsro| lq sulfhv zlwk krpr0 jhqhrxv jrrgv dqg fdsdflw| frqvwudlqwv/ zkloh kh kdg suhylrxvo| sursrvhg d sulfh gxrsro| zlwkrxw frqvwudlqwv exw zlwk lqfuhdvlqj pdujlqdo frvwv +Hgjh0 zruwk/ 4;;4,1 Wkh frqyhqwlrqdo zlvgrp lq wkh fxuuhqw wkhru| ri lqgxvwuldo rujdql}dwlrq derxw wkh zrun ri Hgjhzruwk pdlqwdlqv wkdw kh sursrvhg wkh uvw vroxwlrq wr wkh Ehuwudqg sdudgr{ e| xvlqj fdsdflw| frqvwudlqwv/ zklfk frxog suhyhqw upv wr rrg wkh pdunhw zlwk wkh frpshwlwlyh rxwsxw19 \hw/
8Ehuwudqg dovr fulwlflvhv Frxuqrw ehfdxvh wkh odwwhu eulh | frqvlghuv/ dqg txlfno| glv0
plvvhv/ wkh frrshudwlyh vroxwlrq dorqj wkh lqgxvwu| sur w srvvlelolw| iurqwlhu1 Ehuwudqg/ lqvwhdg/ fodlpv wkdw wklv vkrxog eh wkh prvw vhqvleoh vroxwlrq1 Krzhyhu/ dovr rq wklv jurxqg/ kh pdnhv d idovh vwhs/ lq wkdw Frxuqrw lv dzduh ri wkh lqvwdelolw| ri frooxvlrq/ dv kh vd|v wklv frqglwlrq lv qrw rqh ri vwdeoh htxloleulxp> dqg/ dowkrxjk wkh prvw idyrxudeoh iru erwk surgxfhuv/ lw fdq rqo| eh pdlqwdlqhg e| phdqv ri d irupdo hqjdjhphqw +s1 9:,1
9Wklv shufhswlrq ri wkh Hgjhzruwk frqwulexwlrq fdq eh irxqg lq Wluroh +4<;;/ fk1 8,/
lqwhu dold/ dqg lv d frqvhtxhqfh ri wkh sdshuv e| Ohylwdq dqg Vkxeln +4<:5, dqg Nuhsv dqg Vfkhlqnpdq +4<;6,/ zkr uhihu wr Hgjhzruwk +4;<:, wr surgxfh d wzr0vwdjh vxejdph
dv zh kdyh mxvw vkrzq/ dw wkdw wlph wkhuh zdv qr frqvflhqfh ri dq| vxfk sdudgr{/ vlpso| ehfdxvh wkh frpshwlwlyh rxwfrph ri d krprjhqrxv gxrsro| lq sulfh lv qrw irupdolvhg ru hyhq vxjjhvwhg e| Ehuwudqg1 Dffruglqjo|/ rxu ylhz lv wkdw Hgjhzruwk vkrxog eh fuhglwhg wkh sdwhuqlw| ri wkh uvw prgho ri sulfh frpshwlwlrq zlwk krprjhqhrxv jrrgv1 Krzhyhu/ jlyhq wkh krprjh0 qhrxv jrrg dvvxpswlrq/ klv prgho lv qrw vwudwhjlf lq wkh vdph vhqvh dv wkh prgho ri txdqwlw| frpshwlwlrq suhvhqwhg e| Frxuqrw1 Wklv lv gxh wr wkh idfw wkdw shuihfw vxevwlwxwdelolw| ehwzhhq jrrgv hqwdlov wkdw dq| xqlodwhudo sulfh fkdqjh surgxfhv d glvfrqwlqxlw| lq ghpdqgv dqg wkhuhiruh d glvfrqwlqxlw| lq ehvw uhsolhv1
Wklv lv suhflvho| wkh ghsduwxuh srlqw wdnhq e| Krwhoolqj +4<5<,=
Diwhu wkh zrun ri wkh odwh Surihvvru I1\1 Hgjhzruwk rqh pd| grxew wkdw dq|wklqj ixuwkhu fdq eh vdlg rq wkh wkhru| ri frpshwlwlrq dprqj d vpdoo qxpehu ri hqwuhsuhqhxuv1 Krzhyhu/ rqh lpsruwdqw ihdwxuh ri dfwxdo exvlqhvvhv vhhpv xqwlo uhfhqwo| wr kdyh hvfdshg vfuxwlq|1 Wklv lv wkh idfw wkdw ri doo wkh sxufkdvhuv ri d frpprglw|/ vrph ex| iurp rqh vhoohu/ vrph iurp dqrwkhu/ lq vslwh ri prghudwh gl huhqfhv ri sulfh1 Li wkh sxuyh|ru ri dq duwlfoh judgxdoo| lqfuhdvhv klv sulfh zkloh klv ulydov nhhs wkhluv {hg/ wkh glplqxwlrq lq yroxph ri klv vdohv zloo lq jhqhudo wdnh sodfh frqwlqxrxvo| udwkhu wkdq lq wkh deuxsw zd| zklfk kdv wdflwo| ehhq dvvxphg1 +s1 74,
Lw lv udwkhu shfxoldu wkdw/ diwhu glvfxvvlqj wkh sulfh xqghufxwwlqj phfkd0 qlvp zlwk krprjhqhrxv surgxfwv +zklfk kh dwwulexwhv wr Ehuwudqg wkurxjk wkh lqwhuphgldwlrq ri Hgjhzruwk/ s1 75,/ Krwhoolqj exlogv d prgho ri vsd0 wldoo| gl huhqwldwhg gxrsro| zkhuh hdfk vhoohu*v ghpdqg lv d ixqfwlrq ri erwk sulfhv/ dqg/ xvlqj wklv/ lqwhqgv wr looxvwudwh d fdvh zkhuh sulfhv fkdqjhv jlyh ulvh wr vpdoo yduldwlrqv lq lqglylgxdo upv* ghpdqgv1 Lq wkh prghuq mdujrq/ wklv dprxqwv wr vd|lqj wkdw klv dlp lv wr frqvwuxfw d sulfh gxrsro| zkhuh ghpdqgv dqg uhdfwlrq ixqfwlrqv duh frqwlqxrxv1 Diwhu kdylqj vroyhg sulfh frpshwlwlrq iru jlyhq orfdwlrqv/ Krwhoolqj surfhhgv wr lghqwli| wkh rswlpdo orfdwlrqv1 Wklv |lhogv wkh vr0fdoohg plqlpxp gl huhqwldwlrq sulqflsoh zkhuh surgxfwv duh krprjhqhrxv dqg/ qhyhuwkhohvv/ sulfhv duh deryh pdujlqdo frvw dw htxloleulxp1 Xqiruwxqdwho|/ krzhyhu/ Krwhoolqj ryhuorrnv wkdw klv uhvxow
shuihfw htxloleulxp lq fdsdflwlhv dqg sulfhv iru d krprjhqhrxv gxrsro|1 Wkhvh sdshuv kdyh jhqhudwhg d vwuhdp ri olwhudwxuh ghdolqj zlwk wkh vdph wrslf +Gdylgvrq dqg Ghqhfnhuh/ 4<;9> Rveruqh dqg Slwfkln/ 4<;9> Ghqhfnhuh dqg Nryhqrfn/ 4<<9> Nryhqrfn dqg Ur|/ 4<<;/ lqwhu dold,1
lv xqghuplqhg e| wkh vdph xqghufxwwlqj dujxphqw wkdw kh lv wu|lqj wr gr dzd| zlwk lq exloglqj xs d surgxfw gl huhqwldwlrq prgho1 Suhvxpdeo|/ li kh zhuh dzduh ri dq|wklqj fdoohg wkh Ehuwudqg sdudgr{/ wkhq kh zrxog frqfoxgh wkdw/ rqfh upv vxsso| vx!flhqwo| forvh vxevwlwxwhv/ wkh xqltxh htxloleulxp lqyroyhv erwk sulfhv idoolqj grzq wr pdujlqdo frvw1 Wklv plvwdnh kdv ehhq dphqghg iw| |hduv odwhu e| g*Dvsuhprqw/ Jdev}hzlf} dqg Wklvvh +4<:<,1
Krzhyhu/ wkh Krwhoolqj prgho ri krul}rqwdo gl huhqwldwlrq zlwk wudqv0 sruwdwlrq frvwv zdv dqwlflsdwhg e| Odxqkdugw +4;;8,1 Wr wkh ehvw ri rxu nqrzohgjh/ wklv lv uvw srlqwhg rxw e| Dqghuvrq/ gh Sdopd dqg Wklvvh +4<<5/ s1 5/ iq1 4, zkr uhpdun wkdw ^Odxqkdugw*v errn` kdv qrw uhfhlyhg lwv gxh uhfrjqlwlrq dprqj qrq0Jhupdq0vshdnlqj hfrqrplvwv1 Rqh zrxog udwkhu eh whpswhg wr vd| hyhq dprqj Jhupdq0vshdnlqj hfrqrplvwv/ vlqfh Krwhoolqj zdv Jhupdq/ dowkrxjk zrunlqj dw Vwdqirug Xqlyhuvlw|1: Lq klv Lqwurgxf0
wlrq wr wkh Hqjolvk hglwlrq ri Odxqkdugw*v errn/ Fuhhg| +4<<6/ s1 4, vwdwhv wkdw ^Odxqkdugw*v errn` pd| fodlp wr eh rqh ri Jhupdq|*v prvw lpsruwdqw frqwulexwlrqv wr qhrfodvvlfdo hfrqrplf wkhru| gxulqj wkh odvw txduwhu ri wkh qlqhwhhqwk fhqwxu|1 Fuhhg| +4<<6/ s1 5, dovr txrwhv Eodxj +4<;9,/ zkr srlqwv rxw wkdw
wr dq|rqh lqwhuhvwhg lq wkh idvflqdwlqj wrslf ri pxowlsoh glvfryhulhv lq vflhqfh/ dqg wkh dvvrfldwhg txhvwlrqv ri zk| vrph jxuhv duh v|vwhpdwlfdoo| qhjohfwhg/ Odxqkdugw*v fdvh d rugv d ulfk h{dpsoh1 +s1 456,
Olnhzlvh/ Vfkxpshwhu +4<87/ s1 ;84, frpphqwv wkdw lw lv fxulrxv wr revhuyh 0 dqg fkdudfwhulvwlf ri wkh frqglwlrqv lq rxu hog 0 wkdw d w|sh ri uh0 vhdufk pd| eh suhvhqw dqg lq ixoo ylhz dqg |hw sdvv xqqrwlfhg1 Wkhvh rslq0 lrqv frqfhuq Odxqkdugw*v zrun rq wkh sxuh wkhru| ri h{fkdqjh dqg jhqhudo htxloleulxp1 Zh duh derxw wr vkrz wkdw frpsohwho| dqdorjrxv frqvlghudwlrqv dovr dsso| wr Odxqkdugw*v frqwulexwlrq wr wkh xqghuvwdqglqj ri sulfh frpsh0 wlwlrq1 Wr vhh wklv/ rqh kdv wr uhdg Sduw 6 ri klv errn +Wkh Wudqvsruw ri Jrrgv/ ss1 46<04;< ri wkh Hqjolvk hglwlrq,/ zkhuh Odxqkdugw suhvhqwv klv prgho ri vsdwldo sulflqj1 Diwhu dqdo|vlqj wkh prqrsro| fdvh +ss1 4740479,/ kh sdvvhv rq wr wkh gxrsro| fdvh/ zkhuh lqwhuqdwlrqdo wudgh lv frqvlghuhg1 Dw s1 484 kh ghulyhv wkh iroorzlqj sulfh htxloleulxp +zkdw kh gh qhv cd edvlv ri
:Pxfk pruh wkdq wkh dqwlflsdwlrq ri wkh wkhru| ri vsdwldo frpshwlwlrq fdq eh irxqg lq
Odxqkdugw1 D prghuq uhylvlwdwlrq ri Odxqkdugw*v prgho zkhuh klv dssurdfk wr yhuwlfdo gl huhqwldwlrq lv dovr kljkoljkwhg/ fdq eh irxqg lq Grv Vdqwrv Ihuuhlud dqg Wklvvh +4<<9,1
shdfh*,=
} ' iER R n E2s n s j * +4,
} ' iER R n E2s n s j *
zkhuh } +uhvshfwlyho|/ } , lv wkh xqlw sur w ri up 4 + up 5,/ zklfk lv
lqfuhdvlqj lq +l, wkh gl huhqfh ehwzhhq zkdw kh fdoov surgxfwlrq sulfhv R
dqg R +zkloh zh zrxog gh qh wkhp dv frqvwdqw pdujlqdo frvwv, dqg +ll,
wkh olqh zklfk phdvxuhv lq ohqjwk dqg zklfk dqg zklfk frqqhfwv wkh wzr qhljkerxulqj pdunhw sodfhv +s1 47;,> wkdw lv/ wkh ghjuhh ri krul}rqwdo gl huhqwldwlrq1 Zlwk s dqg s / Odxqkdugw lqglfdwhv wkh xqlw wudqvsruwdwlrq
frvw udwhv +wkh udwh ri iuhljkw iru d jlyhq xqlw/ s1 474,1 Qrz/ lw vx!fhv wr revhuyh wkdw/ li upv kdyh wkh vdph pdujlqdo frvw dqg wkhlu surgxfwv duh krprjhqhrxv +l1h1/ ' f,/ wkhq wkh xqlw sur w lv } ' } ' fc dqg
wkhuhiruh sulfh lv htxdo wr pdujlqdo frvw1 Khqfh/ Odxqkdugw pxvw eh fuhglwhg iru wkh lqwurgxfwlrq lqwr wkh hfrqrplf olwhudwxuh ri wkh uvw irupdo wuhdwphqw ri sulfh frpshwlwlrq zlwk frqvwdqw pdujlqdo frvw zkhuh htxloleulxp sulfhv pd| idoo wr pdujlqdo frvw dqg frqvhtxhqwo| sur wv pd| idoo wr }hur zkhq upv duh frpsohwho| v|pphwulf dqg surgxfwv duh shuihfw vxevwlwxwhv1 Lw lv dovr zruwk vwuhvvlqj wkdw Odxqkdugw lv wkh uvw wr irupdolvh pdunhw ghpdqg ixqfwlrqv vwduwlqj iurp frqvxphu xwlolw|/ dqg wkhuhiruh kh*v uvw lq wuhdwlqj d sulfh jdph zlwk surgxfw gl huhqwldwlrq dqg frqwlqxrxv ghpdqg dqg uhdfwlrq ixqfwlrqv1; Zh zloo frph edfn wr wklv lq wkh qh{w vhfwlrq1
Wkh wudlw g*xqlrq ehwzhhq wkh wkhrulhv ri sulfh frpshwlwlrq ehiruh dqg diwhu Mrkq Qdvk +4<83,< lv wr eh irxqg lq Vkxeln +4<88,1 Kh vhwv rxw e|
wdnlqj Hgjhzruwk +4;;4/ 4;<:, dv wkh uhihuhqfh iru sulfh frpshwlwlrq/ zlwkrxw phqwlrqlqj hlwkhu Ehuwudqg ru Krwhoolqj dw doo143 Wkhq/ kh ghvfulehv d sulfh
gxrsro| xqghu frpsohwh lqirupdwlrq/ zkhuh
Lq rughu wr vlpsoli| pdwwhuv dv pxfk dv srvvleoh/ ohw xv lpdjlqh wkdw wkh phwkrg ri pdunhwlqj iru wkh gxrsrolvwv lv vxfk wkdw hdfk skrqhv lq klv
;Rq wkh jxuh ri Odxqkdugw dv d iruhuxqqhu/ vhh dovr Slqwr +4<::,/ Grv Vdqwrv Ihuuhlud
+4<<;,/ Shuuhxu +4<<;, dqg Edfnkdxv +5333,1 Krzhyhu/ qrqh ri wkhvh dxwkruv gzhoov xsrq wklv vshfl f dvshfw ri Odxqkdugw*v frqwulexwlrq wr hfrqrplf wkhru|1
<Wkh lqyhvwljdwlrq ri wkh uhohydqfh ri wkh Qdvk htxloleulxp frqfhsw lq wkh ghyhorsphqw
ri pdwkhpdwlfdo hfrqrplfv lq jhqhudo dqg lqgxvwuldo hfrqrplfv lq sduwlfxodu/ lv eh|rqg wkh vfrsh ri wkh suhvhqw sdshu1 Iru d glvfxvvlrq ri wklv pdwwhu/ vhh Zhlqwudxe +4<<5, dqg Ohrqdug +4<<7,1
43Kh uhihuv wr Frxuqrw dv wkh ruljlq ri wkh txdqwlw| jdph lqyhvwljdwhg e| Pd|ehuu|/
Qdvk dqg Vkxeln +4<86,1
vwudwhj| wr d pdunhwlqj erdug zklfk lv lq wrxfk zlwk doo wkh fxvwrphuv dqg nqrzv wkhlu lqglylgxdo ghpdqg vfkhgxohv1 Wklv erdug vhoov wr wkh fxvwrphuv dqg uhplwv wr wkh gxrsrolvwv 111 l1h1/ wkh upv rqo| surgxfh wr dgydqfh rughuv iurp wkh pdunhwlqj erdug diwhu kdylqj vwdwhg wkhlu sulfh dqg surgxfwlrq olplwv1 +s1 74;,
Wzr fuxfldo srlqwv dulvh iurp Vkxeln*v zrugv1 Wkh uvw lv wkdw wkh jdph xqudyhov xqghu ixoo lqirupdwlrq> wklv qrwzlwkvwdqglqj/ Vkxeln lqwurgxfhv wkh jxuh ri wkh pdunhwlqj erdug/ wkdw forvho| uhfdoov wkh Zdoudvldq dxfwlrqhhu1 Wkh mre ri erwk djhqwv frqvlvwv lq pdwfklqj ghpdqg dqg vxsso|1 Rq wklv sduwlfxodu lvvxh/ zh zloo gzhoo h{whqvlyho| lq vhfwlrq 61 Wkh vhfrqg hohphqw lv wkdw/ iroorzlqj Hgjhzruwk/ Vkxeln dvvxphv wkdw upv duh fdsdflw| frq0 vwudlqhg1 Lqghhg/ lq wkh uhpdlqghu ri wkh sdshu/ kh suryhv wkdw Hgjhzruwk f|fohv fdq eh uhsurgxfhg dv wkh rxwfrph ri d qrq0frrshudwlyh vlpxowdqhrxv jdph1 Vkxeln frqfoxghv wkdw wkh sulfh yduldwlrq jdph dsshduv wr eh pruh cfrpshwlwlyh* wkdq wkh Frxuqrw jdph +s1 764,/ exw/ kdylqj dvvxphg lqfuhdv0 lqj pdujlqdo frvwv zlwk udwlrqlqj/ klv wuhdwphqw ri sulfh frpshwlwlrq fdqqrw surgxfh wkh vr0fdoohg Ehuwudqg sdudgr{ dv dq htxloleulxp rxwfrph1
Wkh uvw v|vwhpdwlfdo dvvhvvphqw ri wkh wkhru| ri pdunhwv iurp d jdph wkhrulvw*v vwdqgsrlqw/ lv lq Vkxeln +4<8<,144 Vkxeln lqwurgxfhv wkh dqdo|vlv
ri sulfh ehkdylrxu lq gxrsro| dv iroorzv=
Ehuwudqg remhfwhg wr Frxuqrw*v dqdo|vlv ri wkh gxrsro| sureohp lq whupv ri txdqwlw| dv wkh vwudwhjlf yduldeoh1 Kh vxjjhvwhg d vroxwlrq wkdw ghshqgv xsrq sulfh yduldwlrq1 Dv zlwk Frxuqrw*v prgho/ wkh phwkrg r huhg zdv ds0 sduhqwo| g|qdplf dowkrxjk lw fdq eh fdvw lq vwdwlf whupv1 Ehuwudqg frqvlghuhg wzr surgxfhuv zlwk qr frvwv ri surgxfwlrq dqg zlvkhg wr ghprqvwudwh wkdw wkh sur wv ri erwk zrxog eh zlshg rxw e| wkhlu frpshwlwlrq1 Kh sxusruwhg wr vkrz wkdw wkh wzr frpshwlwruv zrxog nhhs rq xqghufxwwlqj hdfk rwkhu xqwlo wkh| uhdfkhg wkh frpshwlwlyh htxloleulxp1 +s1 ;3,
Wr wkh ehvw ri rxu nqrzohgjh/ wklv lv wkh uvw sxeolfdwlrq zkhuh wkh qdph ri Ehuwudqg lv h{solflwo| dvvrfldwhg zlwk wkh shuihfwo| frpshwlwlyh rxwfrph zlwk }hur sur wv ri d sulfh jdph zlwk krprjhqhrxv jrrgv +vhh dovr ss1 4330 43<,1
44Dffruglqj wr Vkxeln klpvhoi/ wkh sulpdu| sxusrvh ri wklv errn lv wr ehjlq wr ghyhors
d xql hg dssurdfk wr wkh ydulrxv wkhrulhv ri frpshwlwlrq dqg pdunhwv +s1 {l,1
Iurp wklv vrxufh/ wkh vxevhtxhqw olwhudwxuh rq lqgxvwuldo rujdql}dwlrq de0 vruev wkh qrwlrq wkdw wkh sulfh jdph zlwk krprjhqhrxv jrrgv lv wkh Ehuwudqg jdph1 Wklv krogv/ h1j1/ iru Edxpro/ Sdq}du dqg Zloolj +4<;5,/ orrnlqj iru suhghfhvvruv ri wkh frqwhvwdelolw| wkhru|=
Lq dgglwlrq wr wkh rudo wudglwlrq wkdw/ lq Fklfdjr/ wzr lv wdnhq wr eh d odujh qxpehu/ wkh prvw qrwdeoh ri vlplodu uhvxowv lv irxqg lq wkh zrun ri Ehuwudqg +4;;6,1 Wkhuh wrr/ wkh roljrsrolvwlf +Qdvk, htxloleulxp dwwdlqhg zkhq wzr ru pruh sulfh0vhwwlqj upv kdyh frqvwdqw pdujlqdo frvwv lqyroyhv sulfh htxdo wr pdujlqdo frvw1 +s1 77,/
lw krogv iru Iulhgpdq +4<;6, uhylhzlqj wkh olwhudwxuh rq roljrsro| wkhru|= Kh ^Ehuwudqg` suhvhqwv dq dqdo|vlv ri gxrsro| xvlqj Frxuqrw*v idprxv plqhudo vsulqj h{dpsoh lq zklfk frvwv duh }hur/ dqg kh vzlwfkhv wr sulfh dv wkh up*v ghflvlrq yduldeoh1 111 Srvlwlyh sulfhv iru wkh upv fdqqrw eh lq htxloleulxp/ dqg R ' R2 ' f lv d qrqfrrshudwlyh htxloleulxp1 +ss1 7907:,/
dv zhoo dv iru Wluroh +4<;;,=
Fkdswhu 8 ghdov zlwk vkruw0uxq sulfh frpshwlwlrq/ h{dplqhv wkh Ehuwudqg sdudgr{ +lq zklfk wzr ru pruh lghqwlfdo upv surgxflqj d krprjhqhrxv jrrg zlwk d frqvwdqw0uhwxuqv0wr0vfdoh whfkqrorj| lq htxloleulxp vhoo dw pdujlqdo frvw dqg pdnh qr sur w,111 +ss1 5380539,/
dqg/ pruh uhfhqwo|/ iru Dqghuvrq dqg Uhqdxow +4<<<,=
Zh vwxg| sulfh frpshwlwlrq lq wkh suhvhqfh ri vhdufk frvwv dqg surgxfw gl huhqwldwlrq1 Wkh olplw fdvhv ri wkh prgho duh wkh cEhuwudqg Sdudgr{*/ wkh cGldprqg Sdudgr{*/ dqg Fkdpehuolqldq prqrsrolvwlf frpshwlwlrq1 +s1 :4<, Vxpplqj xs/ wkh fxuuhqw shufhswlrq ri sulfh jdphv dv wkh suhvxphg khulwdjh ri Ehuwudqg lv wkdw Ehuwudqg kdv lqwurgxfhg vwudwhjlf frqvxphuv lqwr d slfwxuh zkhuh Frxuqrw lqlwldoo| frqvlghuhg rqo| upv dv vwudwhjlf djhqwv145
Lq sduwlfxodu/ frqvxphuv vhdufk iru wkh up fkdujlqj wkh orzhvw sulfh/ dqg wklv jhqhudwhv wkh glvfrqwlqxlwlhv lq ghpdqgv wkdw zh duh zhoo dffxvwrphg zlwk vlqfh Hgjhzruwk +Gdxjkhw|/ 4<;</ ss1 55056,1 Wkh h{wuhph hyroxwlrq ri
45Wkh deryh olvw ri txrwdwlrqv jdwkhuv exw d ihz lqvwdqfhv1 Dovr Vxwwrq +4<<4/ s1 65,
eulh | suhvhqwv wkh sulfh jdph dv wkh Ehuwudqg jdph1
wklv zd| ri wklqnlqj derxw Ehuwudqg lv Nohpshuhu*v uhlqwhusuhwdwlrq ri sulfh roljrsro| jdphv dv dxfwlrqv zkhuh upv surgxfh wkh shuihfwo| frpshwlwlyh rxwfrph zkloh vwulylqj wr frqtxhu wkh zkroh pdunhw +Nohpshuhu/ 5333,1 Wkdw lv/ wkh vxevwdqfh ri zkdw zh qrz odeho dv wkh Ehuwudqg sdudgr{ lv qrw wkh idfw wkdw d olplwhg qxpehu ri upv vx!fhv wr |lhog shuihfw frpshwlwlrq +dv lq wkh Fklfdjr yhlq,/ exw udwkhu wkdw wkh| gr vr e| wu|lqj wr dftxluh prqrsro| srzhu1
Wkh iruhjrlqj glvfxvvlrq vkrxog kdyh pdgh fohdu wkdw rxu srvlwlrq frq0 fhuqlqj wkh sdwhuqlw| ri irupdo prghov ri sulfh frpshwlwlrq lq roljrsro| pdu0 nhwv lv wkh iroorzlqj1 Wkh uvw gxrsro| prgho ri sulfh vhwwlqj ehkdylrxu lv lq Hgjhzruwk +4;;4,/ zkhuh surgxfw krprjhqhlw| dqg lqfuhdvlqj pdujlqdo frvwv suhyhqw wkh dxwkru iurp surgxflqj d prgho zlwk frqwlqxrxv ghpdqg dqg uh0 dfwlrq ixqfwlrqv/ dqg frqvhtxhqwo| wkdw prgho fdqqrw |lhog dq htxloleulxp dw pdujlqdo frvw sulflqj1 Wkh vdph krogv iru klv vxevhtxhqw zrun +4;<:,/ gxh wr wkh dvvxpswlrq ri fdsdflw| frqvwudlqwv1 Lq Odxqkdugw +4;;8,/ lqvwhdg/ rqh qgv d gxrsro| prgho zlwk surgxfw gl huhqwldwlrq dqg frqwlqxrxv ghpdqg dqg ehvw uhso| ixqfwlrqv/ zkrvh sulfh htxloleulxp hqfrpsdvvhv wkh doohjhg sxuh Ehuwudqg htxloleulxp dv d vshfldo fdvh1 Wkhuhiruh/ lw lv rxu rslqlrq wkdw Odxqkdugw vkrxog eh frqvlghuhg wkh idwkhu ri sulfh frpshwlwlrq1
6 Zkdw h{dfwo| duh upv vxssrvhg wr nqrz
zkhq wkh| sod| dq roljrsro| jdphB
Khuh/ zh dlp dw rxwolqlqj wkh +lpsolflw, edfnjurxqg wr wkh glvfxvvlrq rq gxrsro| fduulhg rxw e| Frxuqrw dqg Ehuwudqg wkurxjk wr Vkxeln +4<8<,1 Lq sduwlfxodu/ roljrsro| wkhru| hyhu vlqfh lwv hduolhvw gd|v wuljjhuv wkh grxew/ kxqwlqj wkh guhdpv ri jhqhudwlrqv ri lqgxvwuldo hfrqrplvwv/ wkdw wkh Frxuqrw prgho qhhgv dq dxfwlrqhhu wr vhw htxloleulxp sulfhv dqg fohdu wkh pdunhw1 Wklv lv xvxdoo| dwwulexwhg wr wkh lghd wkdw/ li upv vhw txdqwlwlhv/ wkhq vrph0 rqh hovh kdv wr qg wkh sulfh+v, dw zklfk ghpdqg htxdov vxsso|1 Wklv vrph0 rqh lv dq dxfwlrqhhu olnh Zdoudv*v1 Lq pdq| xqghujudgxdwh dqg srvwjudgxdwh frxuvhv lq plfurhfrqrplfv dqg lqgxvwuldo rujdql}dwlrq wkhru|/ wklv lv dfwxdoo| suhvhqwhg dv wkh pdlq edvlv iru Ehuwudqg*v fulwltxh wr Frxuqrw=
Wkhuh lv dq lpsruwdqw remhfwlrq wr txdqwlwlhv dv wkh ghflvlrq yduldeohv ri roljrsrolvwv/ zlwk d pdunhw sulfh ehlqj ghwhuplqhg e| wkh wrwdo txdqwlw| surgxfhg1 E| zkdw phfkdqlvp lv wkh pdunhw sulfh hvwdeolvkhgB Lw lv qr
sureohp lpdjlqlqj upv fkrrvlqj sulfhv dqg hlwkhu surgxflqj rxwsxw wr rughu ru surgxflqj iru lqyhqwru|1 Exw zkdw lqvwlwxwlrqdo duudqjhphqwv dffrpsolvk sulfh ghwhuplqdwlrq li wkh upv gr qrw fkrrvh sulfhvB +Iulhgpdq/ 4<::/ s1 6<,
Wkhvh frqvlghudwlrqv duh frpprqo| dffhswhg dprqj lqgxvwuldo hfrqrplvwv/ dv lw zrxog eh prvw olnho| frq uphg e| lqwhuylhzlqj d uhsuhvhqwdwlyh vdpsoh ri wkhp1 Lq wkh uhpdlqghu ri wklv vhfwlrq/ zh zloo dujxh wkdw wkhuh h{lvw qr vrxqg irxqgdwlrqv mxvwli|lqj wklv ylhz1
Dv d vwduwlqj srlqw/ frqvlghu wkh dvvxpswlrqv dgrswhg e| Frxuqrw1 Kh vxssrvhv wkdw upv nqrz wkh pdunhw ghpdqg ixqfwlrq/ exw uhixvhv wr frq0 vlghu wkh irupdolvdwlrq ri frqvxphu xwlolw| ixqfwlrq/ dv xquhdolvwlf +vhh wkh lqwurgxfwlrq ri Sulqflsohv,1 Wklv vlwxdwlrq dovr fkdudfwhulvhv wkh zrunv ri Hgjhzruwk +4;;4/ 4;<:, dqg Krwhoolqj +4<5<,1 Rxu fxuuhqw zd| ri uhsuh0 vhqwlqj wkh ghulydwlrq ri pdunhw ghpdqgv lq wkh Krwhoolqj iudphzrun lv d prghuq lqwhusuhwdwlrq/ exw lw lv frpsohwho| devhqw iurp Krwhoolqj*v ruljlqdo irupxodwlrq/ zkhuh wkh sduwlwlrq ri fxvwrphuv ehwzhhq wkh wzr upv lv edvhg xsrq wkh yhfwru ri cgholyhuhg sulfhv*=
Rn S% ' R2n S+ +5,
zkhuh iRc R2j lv wkh yhfwru ri ploo sulfhv/ S : f lv wkh wudqvsruwdwlrq frvw
udwh dqg % dqg +c % n + ' c duh wkh vhjphqwv phdvxulqj wkh glvwdqfh eh0 wzhhq wkh lqgl huhqw frqvxphu dqg upv 4 dqg 5/ uhvshfwlyho| +Krwhoolqj/ 4<5</ s1 79,1 Wkh vwdqgdug irupxodwlrq wkdw lv fxuuhqwo| wdxjkw wr vwxghqwv doo ryhu wkh zruog lv wkh iroorzlqj +vhh g*Dvsuhprqw/ Jdev}hzlf} dqg Wklvvh/ 4<:<,1 D srsxodwlrq ri frqvxphuv lv xqlirupo| glvwulexwhg ryhu d xqlw vhj0 phqw> d frqvxphu orfdwhg dw 6 5 dfc o hqmr|v wkh iroorzlqj qhw vxusoxv iurp frqvxpswlrq=
L ' r R S_ +6,
zkhuh r lv jurvv vxusoxv dqg _ lv wkh glvwdqfh ehwzhhq wkh frqvxphu dqg up
' c 2c zlwk _ ' % dqg _2 ' + Wkh frqvxphu dw 6 lv lqgl huhqw ehwzhhq
wkh wzr surgxfwv li
r R S% ' r R2 S+ +7,
Ri frxuvh +5, dqg +7, duh htxlydohqw/ zlwk wkh fdyhdw wkdw vwduwlqj iurp +5, pdnhv lw ohvv wkdq lpphgldwh wkdw ehlqj deoh wr zulwh wkh lqgl huhqfh frqglwlrq dqg wkhq wkh ghpdqg ixqfwlrqv dprxqwv wr dvvxplqj wkdw d vshfl f
vwuxfwxuh ri frqvxphu suhihuhqfhv lv nqrzq wr upv +hvshfldoo| li rqh orrnv dw wkh sureohp zlwk wkh h|hv ri wkh [L[ ru hduo| [[ fhqwxu|,1
Rqfh djdlq/ wkh fruuhfw irupxodwlrq kdv ehhq wkhuh vlqfh 4;;81 Lq vhwwlqj rxw wr wuhdw wkh sureohp ri wudqvsruwdwlrq dqg lqwhuqdwlrqdo wudgh/ Odxq0 kdugw +s1 474 ri wkh Hqjolvk hglwlrq, gh qhv dv k wkh pdujlqdo xwlolw| iurp xqlw frqvxpswlrq dw d csulfhzruwk|qhvv* ri c dqg R n s5 wkh gholyhu| sulfh1 Wkhq/ wkh pd{lpxp glvwdqfh/ 5 / dw zklfk wkh pdujlqdo frqvxphu orfdwhv lv
ghwhuplqhg e| vroylqj=
k ER n s5 ' f +8,
wkdw lv/ e| lpsrvlqj wkdw wkh qhw xwlolw| ri wkh frqvxphu zkr lv lqgl huhqw ehwzhhq ex|lqj ru qrw eh }hur1
Dv idu dv wkh pdunhw ghpdqg iru krprjhqhrxv surgxfwv +dvvxphg e| Frxuqrw dqg lqkhulwhg e| Hgjhzruwk, lv frqfhuqhg/ zkdw zh nqrz qrz lv wkdw lw rewdlqv iurp wkh vroxwlrq ri wkh frqvxphu fkrlfh sureohp frqvlvwlqj lq 4@ ^ c^2 L @ E^n ^2 2K ^2 n ^22n 2^^2 r| G - R^n R2^2 +9,
zkhuh - lv lqfrph dqg i@c Kj duh srvlwlyh sdudphwhuv1 Wklv ghvhuyhv d ihz uhpdunv1 Iluvw/ wkh prgho srvwxodwhv wkh h{lvwhqfh ri d uhsuhvhqwd0 wlyh frqvxphu/ dqg wkhuhiruh zkdw +iroorzlqj Frxuqrw, lv xvxdoo| uhihuuhg wr dv wkh pdunhw ghpdqg lv dfwxdoo| wkh uhvxow ri wkh vroxwlrq wr dqg lqgl0 ylgxdo rswlpxp sureohp1 Vhfrqg/ wkh frqvxphu fduulhv rxw dq dfwlylw| ri txdvl0surgxfwlrq/ lq wkdw klv suhihuhqfhv duh gh qhg ryhu wkh vhw ri dydlodeoh surgxfwv/46 dqg/ xqolnh zkdw kdsshqv lq Krwhoolqj0olnh prghov/ kh sdwurqlvhv
erwk upv1 Wklug/ wkh xwlolw| ixqfwlrq lq +9, dsshduv uvw lq Erzoh| +4<57, lq lwv pruh jhqhudo irup dsw wr dffrxqw iru sulfh frpshwlwlrq zlwk surgxfw gl huhqwldwlrq= L @ E^n ^2 2 k K^2 n ^22 n 2j^^2 l +:, zkhuh j 5 dfc Ko lv wkh ghjuhh ri surgxfw vxevwlwxwdelolw|/ l1h1/ lw lv dq lqyhuvh phdvxuh ri surgxfw gl huhqwldwlrq1 Zkhq j ' Kc +:, uhsurgxfhv wkh fdvh ri shuihfw vxevwlwxwdelolw|/ l1h1/ surgxfw krprjhqhlw|1 Zkhq j ' fc wkh wzr
46Iru vlpsolflw| zh nhhs rq glvfxvvlqj wkh wzr0surgxfw vhwwlqj/ exw wkh h{whqvlrq wr q
surgxfwv lv vwudljkwiruzdug1
upv duh lqghshqghqw prqrsrolvwv147 Wkh gluhfw ghpdqg ixqfwlrqv iru wkh
sulfh gxrsro| prgho rewdlqlqj iurp +:, zulwh dv iroorzv=
^ ' K n j@ K2 jR 2 nK2jR j 2 c 9' c c ' c 2 +;,
Xvlqj +;,/ d sulfh htxloleulxp fdq eh rewdlqhg vxfk wkdw/ dv j whqgv wr K lq wkh olplw/ wkh Ehuwudqg sdudgr{ dulvhv zlwk pdunhw ghpdqg ehlqj htxdoo| vsolw dfurvv upv1
Krzhyhu/ wkh hduo| wkhru| ri pdunhwv ehiruh Erzoh| +4<57, glvuhjdugv wkh sureohp ri prghoolqj frqvxphu suhihuhqfhv dqg wkhuhiruh fdqqrw surgxfh dq dssursuldwh vhwxs iru dqdo|vlqj sulfh ehkdylrxu1 Lqwhuhvwlqjo| hqrxjk/ wklv vshfl f dvshfw ri Erzoh|*v frqwulexwlrq wr pdwkhpdwlfdo hfrqrplfv lq jhqhudo dqg wr wkh wkhru| ri pdunhwv lq sduwlfxodu uhpdlqv glvuhjdughg iru vhyhudo ghfdghv/ xqwlo Vshqfh +4<:9, dqg Gl{lw +4<:<,1 Iru d orqj wlph/ klv pdlq frqwulexwlrq lv frqvlghuhg wr eh wkh irupdolvdwlrq ri frqmhfwxudo yduldwlrqv +vhh Iulhgpdq/ 4<::/ ss1 ::0:;/ lqwhu dold,1
Vkxeln +4<;3, lqghshqghqwo| lqwurgxfhv dqrwkhu irupxodwlrq ri frqvxphu xwlolw| gh qhg ryhu d vhw ri gl huhqwldwhg surgxfwv=
L q % k E^n ^2 2 ^2 n ^22 E^2 E n ^2 2 & +<, zkhuh 5 dfc 4 phdvxuhv surgxfw vxevwlwxwdelolw|1 Pd{lplvlqj +<, xqghu wkh xvxdo exgjhw frqvwudlqw |lhogv=
^ ' 2
%
k q E2 n R2 qR
&
c 9' c c ' c 2 +43, Wkh wzr prghov +Erzoh|*v dqg Vkxeln*v, kdyh ehhq xvhg lqghshqghqwo| e| pdq| lqgxvwuldo hfrqrplvwv148 Wr wkh ehvw ri rxu nqrzohgjh/ wkh uvw surri
ri wkh lvrprusklvp ehwzhhq +:, dqg +<,/ dqg wkhuhiruh dovr +;, dqg +43,/ lv gxh wr Doeén dqg Odpehuwlql +4<<;,1
Wklv uhodwlyho| orqj gljuhvvlrq lqwr wkh frqwhpsrudu| ghyhorsphqwv ri wkh wkhru| ri lqgxvwuldo rujdql}dwlrq vkrxog frqwulexwh wr pdnh lw fohdu wkdw
47Pruhryhu/ lq wkh udqjh 5 +3> e` surgxfwv duh frpsohphqwv1 Gxdolw| wkhruhpv fdq eh
irxqg lq Erzoh| +4<57,/ Vkxeln +4<;3, dqg Vlqjk dqg Ylyhv +4<;7,/ lqwhu dold1
48Vshqfh +4<:9,/ Gl{lw +4<:<,/ Vlqjk dqg Ylyhv +4<;7,/ Ylyhv +4<;8,/ Nohpshuhu dqg
Ph|hu +4<;9/ 4<;<,/ Rnxjxfkl +4<;:, dqg Odpehuwlql +4<<:, duh dprqj wkrvh zkr xvh Erzoh|*v irupxodwlrq1 Vkxeln*v prgho lv dgrswhg e| Urwkvfklog +4<<5/ 4<<8,1 D jhqhudo dssurdfk lv lq Wdqdnd +5334,1
fkrrvlqj qrw wr irupdolvh wkh vwuxfwxuh ri frqvxphu suhihuhqfhv ohdyhv frq0 fhdohg iru d orqj wlph wkh pdlq lvvxh uhodwhg wr wkh hduo| vwxglhv ri gxrsro| ehkdylrxu1 Wkdw lv/ zkdw lv qrz fdoohg wkh dvvxpswlrq ri ixoo ru frpsohwh lqirupdwlrq frqfhuqlqj wkh pdunhw jdph lqyroyhv qhfhvvdulo| wkdw qrw rqo| wkh ihdwxuhv ri pdunhw ghpdqg exw dovr/ dqg pruh fuxfldoo|/ frqvxphu suhi0 huhqfhv duh nqrzq wr upv lqghshqghqwo| ri zkhwkhu +l, wkh| rswlplvh z1u1w1 sulfhv ru txdqwlwlhv/ dqg +ll, surgxfwv duh gl huhqwldwhg ru qrw1
Wklv srlqw uhfhlyhv d eulooldqw looxvwudwlrq e| Vlqjk dqg Ylyhv +4<;7,/ zkr/ xvlqj wkh Erzoh| prgho/ vkrz wkdw txdqwlw| lv d grplqdqw vwudwhj| iru doo ghjuhhv ri vxevwlwxwdelolw|/ vr rqh vkrxog h{shfw upv wr sod| d Frxuqrw htxloleulxp1 Frqfhuqlqj wkh sureohp ri zkr dqqrxqfhv sulfhv/ rqh kdv wr nhhs lq plqg wkh dvvxpswlrq ri ixoo lqirupdwlrq/ lpso|lqj wkdw upv nqrz wkh ghpdqg vwuxfwxuh 0 wkdw lv/ dv zh duh qrz dzduh ri/ wkh| nqrz wkh ixqfwlrqdo irup ri frqvxphu suhihuhqfhv iurp zklfk wkh ghpdqg fxuyhv ghulyh1 Khqfh/ lq fkrrvlqj rxwsxwv/ upv dovr nqrz zkdw wkh sulfhv duh jrlqj wr eh lq htxloleulxp/ dqg wkhuh lv qr qhhg ri dq| dxfwlrqhhu1 Wklv lv h{dfwo| wkh srlqw wkdw Vlqjk dqg Ylyhv +4<;7/ s1 879, vhhp wr pdnh zkhq wkh| vwlsxodwh wkdw upv r hu hlwkhu d csulfh frqwudfw* ru d ctxdqwlw| frqwudfw*/ zklfk phdqv wkh iroorzlqj1 Ilupv rswlplvh hlwkhu lq sulfhv ru lq txdqwlwlhv1 Wkh| wkhq sursrvh d frqwudfw zklfk lv d sulfh0txdqwlw| sdfndjh dorqj wkh ghpdqg fxuyh/ zklfk lv nqrzq wr erwk frqvxphuv dqg upv1 Wkh rqo| gl huhqfh olhv lq wkh ghulydwlrq ri wkh dowhuqdwlyh sdfndjhv1 Li upv slfn wkh Frxuqrw rxwsxwv/ wkhq wkh| fkhfn dorqj wkh +lqyhuvh, ghpdqg ixqfwlrqv iru wkh htxloleulxp sulfhv dqg sursrvh vxfk d sdlu wr frqvxphuv/ zkrvh dqvzhu zrxog fohduo| eh srvlwlyh1 wkh rssrvlwh surfhgxuh wdnhv sodfh lq fdvh ri sulfh ehkdylrxu1
Li dvvhvvhg xqghu wklv shuvshfwlyh/ wkh cdxfwlrqhhu dujxphqw* frpprqo| dvvrfldwhg zlwk Ehuwudqg*v fulwlflvp ri wkh Frxuqrw prgho dsshduv xquhdvrq0 deoh1 Wkh gholfdwh srlqw lv wkh dvvxpswlrq ri ixoo lqirupdwlrq/ udwkhu wkdq zkr lv wr vhw sulfhv li upv vhw txdqwlwlhv/ ehfdxvh li upv nqrz wkh ghpdqg vwuxfwxuh wkhq wkhuh lv qr qhhg ri dq dxfwlrqhhu1 D uhohydqw lpsolfdwlrq ri wklv dujxphqw lv= zk| vkrxog rqh zruu| derxw Ehuwudqg frpshwlwlrq +zlwk ru zlwkrxw fdsdflw| frqvwudlqwv, dw dooB Zlwklq wkh olplwv ri dydlodeoh fdsdflw|/ upv vkrxog lq dq| fdvh sod| ã od Frxuqrw/ dw ohdvw iurp wkh vwdqgsrlqw ri sxuh sur w lqfhqwlyhv1
Dqrwkhu/ dqg srvvleo| hyhq pruh lpsruwdqw lpsolfdwlrq ri wkh deryh glv0 fxvvlrq lv wkdw ixoo lqirupdwlrq dovr holplqdwhv wkh dxfwlrqhhu iurp Zdoudv*v prgho ri jhqhudo htxloleulxp +Zdoudv/ 4;:7/ vhh dovr 4;;6,/ zkhuh ixoo +ru frpsohwh, lqirupdwlrq lv dvvxphg/ dqg qrqhwkhohvv wkh dxfwlrqhhu lv lqwur0
gxfhg dv wkh djhqw zkrvh vshfl f wdvn lv wr fohdu wkh pdunhw1 Exw wkhq wkh txhvwlrq dulvhv/ lq uhwurvshfw= krz fdq wkhuh eh dq| h{fhvv ghpdqg ru vxs0 so|/ li doo wudghuv duh frpsohwho| lqiruphgB Rqh vkrxog h{shfw wkh pdunhw wr fohdu lqvwdqwdqhrxvo|/ zlwkrxw dq| dgmxvwphqw wrzdugv wkh htxloleulxp1 Ri frxuvh/ rqh vkrxog wdnh lqwr dffrxqw wkdw wkh xowlpdwh lpsolfdwlrqv ri wkh ixoo lqirupdwlrq k|srwkhvlv zhuh pxfk ohvv wkdq hylghqw wr doo wkrvh zkr zulwh ehiruh Qdvk1 Lw lv lqghhg uhyhdolqj wkdw wklv dssolhv dovr wr Vkxeln/ zkr dgrswv wkh lqwhuphgldu| nqrzq dv wkh cpdunhwlqj erdug* wr pdwfk ghpdqg dqg vxsso|1 Ryhudoo/ lw vhhpv wkdw Zdoudv*v dxfwlrqhhu dqg Vkxeln*v erdug duh wkh uhvxow ri dq dwwhpsw rq wkh sduw ri wkh wkhru| wr frph wr whupv zlwk uhdolw|/ zkhuh ixoo lqirupdwlrq lv yhu| vhogrp/ li hyhu/ dydlodeoh1
7 Frqfoxglqj uhpdunv
Zh kdyh uhylvlwhg wkh Frxuqrw0Ehuwudqg ghedwh lq wkh oljkw ri wkh vxevh0 txhqw frqwulexwlrqv ri Frxuqrw +4;96,/ Hgjhzruwk +4;;4/ 4;<:, dqg Odxq0 kdugw +4;;8,1 Wklv kdv ohdg xv wr lghqwli| Odxqkdugw dv wkh vrxufh ri wkh sulfh gxrsro| prgho1 Rxu glvfxvvlrq ri wkh irupdolvdwlrq ri frqvxphu xwlolw| ixqfwlrq iru gl huhqwldwhg surgxfwv/ uvw dsshdulqj lq Odxqkdugw +4;;8, dqg wkhq lq Erzoh| +4<57,/ kdv doorzhg xv wr srlqw rxw wkdw dvvxplqj wkdw upv nqrz wkh ghpdqg ixqfwlrq+v, lv htxlydohqw wr dvvxplqj wkdw wkh| nqrz wkh vwuxfwxuh ri frqvxphu suhihuhqfhv1 Dv d frqvhtxhqfh/ zh kdyh dujxhg wkdw wkhuh lv qr uroh iru wkh dxfwlrqhhu/ hlwkhu lq Frxuqrw ru lq Zdoudv1
Uhihuhqfhv
^4` Doeén/ V1 dqg O1 Odpehuwlql +4<<;,/ Frooxvlrq lq Gl huhqwldwhg Gxrsrolhv Uhylvlwhg/ Hfrqrplfv Ohwwhuv/ 8</ 6380;1
^5` Dqghuvrq/ V1/ D1 Gh Sdopd dqg M10I1 Wklvvh +4<<5,/ Glvfuhwh Fkrlfh Wkhru| ri Surgxfw Gl huhqwldwlrq/ Fdpeulgjh/ PD/ PLW Suhvv1
^6` Dqghuvrq/ V1S1 dqg U1 Uhqdxow +4<<<,/ Surgxfw Glyhuvlw|/ dqg Vhdufk Frvwv= D Ehuwudqg0Fkdpehuolq0Gldprqg Prgho/ UDQG Mrxuqdo ri Hfrqrplfv/ 63/ :4<0681
^7` Edfnkdxv/ X1 +5333,/ Dq Hqjlqhhu*v Ylhz ri Hfrqrplfv= Zlokhop Odxqkdugw*v Frqwulexwlrqv/ Mrxuqdo ri Hfrqrplf Vwxglhv/ 5:/ 75 70:91 ^8` Edxpro/ Z1/ M1 Sdq}du dqg U1 Zloolj +4<;5,/ Frqwhvwdeoh Pdunhwv
dqg wkh Wkhru| ri Lqgxvwu| Vwuxfwxuh/ Qhz \run/ Kdufrxuw Eudfh Mr0 ydqrylfk1
^9` Ehuwudqg/ M1 +4;;6,/ Uhylhz/ Mrxuqdo ghv Vdydqwv/ 9;/ 7<<083;1 Uhsulqwhg lq Hqjolvk wudqvodwlrq e| M1Z1 Iulhgpdq lq Gdxjkhw|/ D1 +hg1 4<;<,/ Frxuqrw Roljrsro|1 Fkdudfwhul}dwlrq dqg Dssolfdwlrqv/ Fdpeulgjh/ Fdpeulgjh Xqlyhuvlw| Suhvv/ :60;41
^:` Eodxj/ P1 +4<;9,/ Juhdw Hfrqrplvwv Ehiruh Nh|qhv/ Euljkwrq Zkhdw0 vkhdi1
^;` Erzoh|/ D1O1 +4<57,/ Wkh Pdwkhpdwlfdo Jurxqgzrun ri Hfrqrplfv/ R{0 irug/ R{irug Xqlyhuvlw| Suhvv1
^<` Fkdpehuolq/ H1K1 +4<5<,/ Gxrsro|= Ydoxh zkhq Vhoohuv Duh Ihz/ Txduwhuo| Mrxuqdo ri Hfrqrplfv/ 77/ 9604331
^43` Frxuqrw D1 +4;6;,/ Uhfkhufkhv vxu ohv sulqflshv pdwkìpdwltxhv gh od wkìrulh ghv ulfkhvvhv/ Sdulv/ Kdfkhwwh1 Wudqvodwhg e| Q1W1 Edfrq dv Uh0 vhdufkhv lqwr wkh Pdwkhpdwlfdo Sulqflsohv ri wkh Wkhru| ri Zhdowk/ Qhz \run/ Pdfploodq/ 4;<:1 Fkdswhu : lv uhsulqwhg lq Hqjolvk lq D1 Gdxjk0 hw| +hg1/ 4<;<,/ Frxuqrw Roljrsro|1 Fkdudfwhul}dwlrq dqg Dssolfdwlrqv/ Fdpeulgjh/ Fdpeulgjh Xqlyhuvlw| Suhvv/ 960:51
^44` Frxuqrw D1 +4;96,/ Sulqflshv gh od wkìrulh ghv ulfkhvvhv/ Sdulv/ Kdfkhwwh1 4:
^45` Fuhhg|/ M1 +4<<6,/ Lqwurgxfwlrq wr Z1 Odxqkdugw/ Pdwkhpdwlfdo Sulqfl0 sohv ri Hfrqrplfv/ Doghuvkrw/ Hgzdug Hojdu/ 40431
^46` g*Dvsuhprqw/ F1/ M1M1 Jdev}hzlf} dqg M10I1 Wklvvh +4<:<,/ Rq Krwhoolqj*v cVwdelolw| lq Frpshwlwlrq*/ Hfrqrphwulfd/ 7:/ 43780831 ^47` Gdxjkhw|/ D1I1 +4<;<,/ Lqwurgxfwlrq wr Frxuqrw Roljrsro|1 Fkdudfwhul0
}dwlrq dqg Dssolfdwlrqv/ Fdpeulgjh/ Fdpeulgjh Xqlyhuvlw| Suhvv1 ^48` Gdylgvrq/ F1 dqg U1 Ghqhfnhuh +4<;9,/ Orqj0Uxq Frpshwlwlrq lq
Fdsdflw|/ Vkruw0Uxq Frpshwlwlrq lq Sulfh/ dqg wkh Frxuqrw Prgho/ UDQG Mrxuqdo ri Hfrqrplfv/ 4:/ 7370481
^49` Ghqhfnhuh/ U1 dqg G1 Nryhqrfn +4<<9,/ Ehuwudqg0Hgjhzruwk Gxrsro| zlwk Xqlw Frvw Dv|pphwu|/ Hfrqrplf Wkhru|/ ;/ 405 81
^4:` Glpdqg/ U1Z1 dqg P1K1L1 Gruh +4<<<,/ Frxuqrw/ Ehuwudqg/ dqg Jdph Wkhru|= D Ixuwkhu Qrwh/ Dwodqwlf Hfrqrplf Mrxuqdo/ 5:/ 6580661 ^4;` Gl{lw/ D1 +4<:<,/ D Prgho ri Gxrsro| Vxjjhvwlqj wkh Wkhru| ri Hqwu|
Eduulhuv/ Ehoo Mrxuqdo ri Hfrqrplfv/ 43/ 5 3065 1
^4<` Grv Vdqwrv Ihuuhlud/ U1 +4<<;,/ Odxqkdugw dqg Krwhoolqj/ Uhfkhufkhv Hfrqrpltxhv gh Orxydlq/ 97/ <:043<1
^53` Grv Vdqwrv Ihuuhlud/ U1 dqg M10I1 Wklvvh +4<<9,/ Krul}rqwdo dqg Yhu0 wlfdo Gl huhqwldwlrq= Wkh Odxqkdugw Prgho/ Lqwhuqdwlrqdo Mrxuqdo ri Lqgxvwuldo Rujdql}dwlrq/ 47/ 7;808391
^54` Hgjhzruwk/ I1 +4;;4,/ Pdwkhpdwlfdo Sv|fklfv/ Orqgrq/ Nhjdq Sdxo1 ^5 5 ` Hgjhzruwk/ I1 +4;<:,/ Od Whruld Sxud gho Prqrsrolr/ Jlruqdoh ghjol
Hfrqrplvwl/ 73/ 460641 Uhsulqwhg lq Hqjolvk dv Wkh Sxuh Wkhru| ri Prqrsro|/ lq I1 Hgjhzruwk +4<58,/ Sdshuv Uhodwlqj wr Srolwlfdo Hfrq0 rp|/ Yro1 4/ Orqgrq/ Pdfploodq ) Fr1/ Owg1/ 4440751
^56` Ihooqhu/ Z1 +4<7<,/ Frpshwlwlrq dprqj wkh Ihz/ Qhz \run/ Nqrsi1 ^57` Ilvkhu/ L1 +4;<;,/ Frxuqrw dqg Pdwkhpdwlfdo Hfrqrplfv/ Txduwhuo|
Mrxuqdo ri Hfrqrplfv/ 45/ 44<06;1
^58` Iulhgpdq/ M1Z1 +4<::,/ Roljrsro| dqg wkh Wkhru| ri Jdphv/ Dpvwhu0 gdp/ Qruwk0Kroodqg1
^59` Iulhgpdq/ M1Z1 +4<;6,/ Roljrsro| Wkhru|/ Fdpeulgjh/ Fdpeulgjh Xql0 yhuvlw| Suhvv1
^5:` Krwhoolqj/ K1 +4<5<,/ Vwdelolw| lq Frpshwlwlrq/ Hfrqrplf Mrxuqdo/ 6</ 7408:1
^5;` Nohpshuhu/ S1 +5333,/ Zk| Hyhu| Hfrqrplvw Vkrxog Ohduq Vrph Dxf0 wlrq Wkhru|/ lqylwhg ohfwxuh wr YLLL Zruog Frqjuhvv ri wkh Hfrqrphwulf Vrflhw|/ Vhdwwoh> dqg [[YLL HDULH Frqihuhqfh/ Odxvdqqh1
^5<` Nohpshuhu/ S1 dqg P1 Ph|hu +4<;9,/ Sulfh Frpshwlwlrq yv Txdqwlw| Frpshwlwlrq= Wkh Uroh ri Xqfhuwdlqw|/ UDQG Mrxuqdo ri Hfrqrplfv/ 4:/ 94;06;1
^63` Nohpshuhu/ S1 dqg P1 Ph|hu +4<;<,/ Vxsso| Ixqfwlrq Htxloleuld lq Roljrsro| xqghu Xqfhuwdlqw|/ Hfrqrphwulfd/ 8:/ 45760::1
^64` Nryhqrfn/ G1 dqg V1 Ur| +4<<;,/ G|qdplf Fdsdflw| Fkrlfh lq d Ehuwudqg0Hgjhzruwk Iudphzrun/ Mrxuqdo ri Pdwkhpdwlfdo Hfrqrplfv/ 5</ 46608;1
^65` Nuhsv/ G1P1 dqg M1D1 Vfkhlqnpdq +4<;6,/ Txdqwlw| Suhfrpplwphqw dqg Ehuwudqg Frpshwlwlrq \lhog Frxuqrw Rxwfrphv/ Ehoo Mrxuqdo ri Hfrqrplfv/ 47/ 65906:1
^66` Odpehuwlql/ O1 +4<<:,/ Sulvrqhuv* Glohppd lq Gxrsro| +Vxshu,Jdphv/ Mrxuqdo ri Hfrqrplf Wkhru|/ ::/ 4;40<41
^67` Odxqkdugw/ Z1 +4;;8,/ Pdwkhpdwlvfkh Ehjuÿqgxqj ghu Yronvzluwvfkdiw0 vohkuh/ Ohls}lj/ E1J1 Whxeqhu1 Uhsulqwhg lq Hqjolvk wudqvodwlrq dv Pdwk0 hpdwlfdo Sulqflsohv ri Hfrqrplfv/ Doghuvkrw/ Hgzdug Hojdu/ 4<<61 ^68` Ohrqdug/ U1M1 +4<<7,/ Uhdglqj Frxuqrw/ Uhdglqj Qdvk= Wkh Fuhdwlrq
dqg Vwdelolvdwlrq ri wkh Qdvk Htxloleulxp/ Hfrqrplf Mrxuqdo/ 437/ 7<508441
^69` Ohylwdq/ U1 dqg P1 Vkxeln +4<:5,/ Sulfh Gxrsro| dqg Fdsdflw| Frq0 vwudlqwv/ Lqwhuqdwlrqdo Hfrqrplf Uhylhz/ 46/ 4440561
^6:` Pdjqdq gh Eruqlhu/ M1 +4<<5,/ Wkh cFrxuqrw0Ehuwudqg Ghedwh*= D Klv0 wrulfdo Shuvshfwlyh/ Klvwru| ri Srolwlfdo Hfrqrp|/ 57/ 9560891
^6;` Pduvkdoo/ D1 +4;<3,/ Sulqflsohv ri Hfrqrplfv/ Orqgrq/ Pdfploodq1 ^6<` Pduwlq/ V1 +5 334,/ Dgydqfhg Lqgxvwuldo Hfrqrplfv/ Vhfrqg Hglwlrq/ R{0
irug/ Eodfnzhoo/ lq sulqw1
^73` Pd|ehuu|/ M1S1/ M1I1 Qdvk/ Mu1/ dqg P1 Vkxeln +4<86,/ D Frpsdulvrq ri Wuhdwphqwv ri d Gxrsro| Vlwxdwlrq/ Hfrqrphwulfd/ 54/ 4740871 ^74` Pruulvrq/ F1F1 +4<<;,/ Frxuqrw/ Ehuwudqg/ dqg Prghuq Jdph Wkh0
ru|/ Dwodqwlf Hfrqrplf Mrxuqdo/ 59/ 4:5 071
^75` Pruulvrq/ F1F1 +4<<<,/ Glpdqg0Gruh rq Frxuqrw0Ehuwudqg= D Uhso| dqg Pruh/ Dwodqwlf Hfrqrplf Mrxuqdo/ 5:/ 6670<1
^76` Qdvk/ M1I1/ Mu1 +4<83,/ Htxloleulxp Srlqwv lq Q0Shuvrq Jdphv/ Sur0 fhhglqjv ri wkh Qdwlrqdo Dfdghp| ri Vflhqfhv/ 69/ 7;0<1
^77` Rnxjxfkl/ N1 +4<;:,/ Htxloleulxp Sulfhv lq wkh Ehuwudqg dqg Frxuqrw Roljrsrolhv/ Mrxuqdo ri Hfrqrplf Wkhru|/ 75/ 45;06<1
^78` Rveruqh/ P1 dqg F1 Slwfkln +4<;9,/ Sulfh Frpshwlwlrq lq d Fdsdflw|0 Frqvwudlqhg Gxrsro|/ Mrxuqdo ri Hfrqrplf Wkhru|/ 6;/ 56;0931 ^79` Shuuhxu/ M1 +4<<;,/ Lqgxvwuldo Orfdwlrq Wkhru| lq Jhupdq Wkrxjkw
Odxqkdugw dqg Zhehu/ Uhfkhufkhv Hfrqrpltxhv gh Orxydlq/ 97/ :80<91 ^7:` Slqwr/ M1Y1 +4<::,/ Odxqkdugw dqg Orfdwlrq Wkhru|= Uhglvfryhu| ri d
Qhjohfwhg Errn/ Mrxuqdo ri Uhjlrqdo Vflhqfh/ 4:/ 4:05<1
^7;` Urwkvfklog/ U1 +4<<5,/ Rq wkh Vxvwdlqdelolw| ri Frooxvlrq lq Gl huhqwl0 dwhg Gxrsrolhv/ Hfrqrplfv Ohwwhuv/ 73/ 660:1
^7<` Urwkvfklog/ U1 +4<<8,/ Vxvwdlqlqj Frooxvlrq Zkhq wkh Fkrlfh ri Vwudwh0 jlf Yduldeoh Lv Hqgrjhqrxv/ Mrxuqdo ri Hfrqrplf Ehkdylru dqg Rujd0 ql}dwlrq/ 5;/ 6:60;81
^83` Vfkxpshwhu/ M1 +4<87,/ Klvwru| ri Hfrqrplf Dqdo|vlv/ Orqgrq/ Doohq dqg Xqzlq1
^84` Vkxeln/ P1 +4<8<,/ Vwudwhj| dqg Pdunhw Vwuxfwxuh/ Qhz \run/ Mrkq Zloh| ) Vrqv1
^85` Vkxeln/ P1 +zlwk U1 Ohylwdq/ 4<;3,/ Pdunhw Vwuxfwxuh dqg Ehkdylru/ Fdpeulgjh/ PD/ Kduydug Xqlyhuvlw| Suhvv1
^86` Vlqjk/ Q1 dqg [1 Ylyhv +4<;7,/ Sulfh dqg Txdqwlw| Frpshwlwlrq lq d Gl huhqwldwhg Gxrsro|/ UDQG Mrxuqdo ri Hfrqrplfv/ 48/ 8790871 ^87` Vrqqhqvfkhlq/ K1 +4<9;,/ Wkh Gxdo ri Gxrsro| lv Frpsohphqwdu|
Prqrsro|1 Ru/ Wzr ri Frxuqrw*v Wkhrulhv Duh Rqh/ Mrxuqdo ri Sr0 olwlfdo Hfrqrp|/ :9/ 6490;1
^88` Vshqfh/ D1P1 +4<:9,/ Surgxfw Gl huhqwldwlrq dqg Zhoiduh/ Dphulfdq Hfrqrplf Uhylhz/ 99/ 73:0471
^89` Vwdfnhoehuj/ K1 yrq +4<67,/ Pdunwirup xqg Johlfkjhzlfkw/ Ehuolq dqg Ylhqqd/ Vsulqjhu1
^8:` Vwljohu/ J1 +4<73,/ Qrwhv rq wkh Wkhru| ri Gxrsro|/ Mrxuqdo ri Srolw0 lfdo Hfrqrp|/ 7;/ 8540741
^8;` Vxwwrq/ M1 +4<<4,/ Vxqn Frvwv dqg Pdunhw Vwuxfwxuh/ Fdpeulgjh/ PD/ PLW Suhvv1
^8<` Wdqdnd/ \1 +5334,/ Sur wdelolw| ri Sulfh dqg Txdqwlw| Vwudwhjlhv lq dq Roljrsro|/ Mrxuqdo ri Pdwkhpdwlfdo Hfrqrplfv/ 68/ 73<04;1
^93` Wluroh/ M1 +4<;;,/ Wkh Wkhru| ri Lqgxvwuldo Rujdql}dwlrq/ Fdpeulgjh/ PD/ PLW Suhvv1
^94` Ylyhv/ [1 +4<;8,/ Rq wkh H!flhqf| ri Ehuwudqg dqg Frxuqrw Htxloleuld zlwk Surgxfw Gl huhqwldwlrq/ Mrxuqdo ri Hfrqrplf Wkhru|/ 48/ 4990:81 ^95` Zdoudv/ O1 +4;:7,/ Ìohphqwv gìfrqrplh srolwltxh/ Odxvdqqh1 Uhsulqwhg lq Hqjolvk wudqvodwlrq dv Hohphqwv ri Sxuh Hfrqrplfv/ Orqgrq/ Doohq dqg Xqzlq/ 4<871
^96` Zdoudv/ O1 +4;;6,/ Wkìrulh pdwkìpdwltxh gh od ulfkhvvh vrfldoh/ Odx0 vdqqh1
^97` Zhlqwudxe/ U1 +4<<5/ hg1/,/ Wrzdug d Klvwru| ri Jdph Wkhru|/ Klvwru| ri Srolwlfdo Hfrqrp|/ 57 +Vxssohphqw,1
