论无意味一后物质时代的意义消减 [The Significance of Insignificance]

(1)

! " # $ % & ' ( ) * # + , - . ! / 0 1

$

2 3 ' 4 # 5 6 7 8 9 & ' ( : ; %

!"#

#

$

%

&

'

&

(

'

&)

'

(

'

*

%

+

,

-

.

'

$

*

/

#0 1

$

2 '

$

3-

4#

%

5

5 '

6 -7

$

-

&

$

8

5 !

"

#$

%

&

'

%

(

%

)

*

'

)

#

+

(,

'

-

%

&

'

%

(

%

)

*

'

)

#

!

"

#

$

%

&

"

%

!"#!"#!#$%!&!'#(!" !"#")#!$%* #"#&+'&,()&"* $%###+-./,0 $%&'#'()* 9,:;<*+,-+-./*(-0(()-0 !"#$)(!)0+/("#!$%&'!()*!'('(()(), !!!"""!"#$%&'"##()!*$"$#'%!+, " -& '.$&%/'01("& #& 2 + 3 ' ) 4 % 5 ! $ ' . 6 7 " % '' 8

(6#())" (&&**)&8 (+'+"')" (,9#)()&!%!)

':0)".(;'& , 9 , " " !* < / ( ( . ! " / * + ,& = -/./,0>?@1A50B " C " ) , 0 1& , 9 D ! 8 E F 2 3 4 5 * #/.&6(G2 +& ; H ( 1 2 " 2 + I 7 4 ; H " 3 " J K L " 4 #' 89:M;L (KLN<#O = E ' ) ) " 5 P& , 9 + , 1 2 " Q # > * &,RS<#&=-"-"T";H" ? 1 K L " # 3& U 6 - > (F V W 7&XV4?)"Y,, 9 6 # 8 5' Z [ \ ' # ; H " 4 @& 5 6 K L #

(2)

!!!!! "₁_"₂₃₄₅₆₇_$₂₈_$₅₉#! $" # !% "_!_"_#$_%_&_#_"_&_'_"_#(₎_%_#_"_{## $ %}

!&'() * " " " +& ', # $ " # #( - . / $ % " % 0 * 1 & !)*

"_'₍₍₎(

:;.(/#

!&'234()*' 5 $ 6 " &( ( ) * # * + * $ 7 % & % + ' 8

9#),-:.(()!' 1 / ; < = ,! ( > 9 / - . $ / = * ( ? / !

%#@ "18<<"=7!47%4#A) ! $B 8 9 #& C ! 0 D E * 9 F & ' % 1

G$HI*"!)';<=JK7J1AL()M2+0*9F(31N O P *12"43& * 9 F)* "_'₍₎_*( :;')# J4Q+*'55(R5()* + *%&"89FS')TU1 / ; < = ,( T V 6 , $ ( ) ! ! ' 5 " - $ *WV&(>X!&'()' 5 , ) * . D * # ' 7 (" ( > X ) # ! $ % *+$8YZ&("[!+,""$'\8%" $B89#%1GJ.] ^ _ *!0.$=(67/`8a P 9 : * b Y c - d 9 . $ * 8 9 # e :( P >.;,f*#**;4+ * g 0( 1 2 8 9 # 3 + * ; h) T V / ` ! # i<(4<&'*^j/('H=9#4)*9#*;<=k)) lU89# "_>_%_<_" ?%"@"28%24#" 89#>Xm.]89F "₁₄₈_%_"_% ?54<<%4<<#" -no '9F > 1 p ; < N O " > ? * ; < c q * * @* "r s t('()/( :;'#(,-9FA12/`cq==(> c q * B n( 9 # A M 2 9 F * + u(>cq* Q v) h :( % # @ A ) w U '; < N K h U 1 * ; F @ C+ ;xDK[EV5 k $ 8 Y " c 0 P 8 9 F( 3 1 p ; < J $ > 8 9 # * * "_'₍₎_*( :;)'#)7y>o(z] c q V P +(; < N K h U 8 Y " F { 4 c 0P89F(31i>J $ 1 G | 9( 8 9 # * ; < ? J } > ; <( P > 6 u'!);<*89F | = ! @ p H 6& J N , A+ B O ~ c O 8 -) d ()8Y+,;<CI* + E | * = D @ C D( ; < ! J N , A * H 6 089F,d()~c;< + * @ C $ J E + * z : D( ; < ! B O~cH6*89F,d() F J J - ; < + * @ C( 7 J J - 1 + G D(()*;<yKL o , # ! . # "A8%BC7D%# & '* 2 * - ; *( mMN-O3! 7 * "_E₇_F₄_C_9!₈_% ?G7%# 1 ) * ; < = , # , A) 8 9 #A>>?1P8(F\8 9 # Q 9 ( ( ) R - l H = 1 * 0 ! # H

I" TVvI'ESH= 8 9 # * 4 9& 1 > / ` 8 9 # J 9 # * ` T( L

-/`!#i<(4 < & ' 9 J : ; 4 < . K * J < h 4 L @ + U(

U/I5V*DK#2@(" - 0 * M W X ! . K | 6 * 8 9 # $ "

$((!9F"$0 1 ! k %, > 9 # J 8 9 # * Y + ` T( L

-d,)/ZU=>["([V 8 1 G * ' 5 + 3 6 7 ' ( ) 9 # * D K

(3)

!#!"#"#!$$%%" ! & # ' ! !# " ! & ! ! & " ( ) * & + ! '#!#"#",#($-)$&)"*$ %.-)$&/0%+12,3)$#-.$%&-)*45%6$ 7 8 9&/"%''012:;&3!#<$%=$454&>)*&'( ) (# ((')?76@AB5&# * + * 6 : ; ! + @ A ) $ & $ , 7$ % % , 3&--"$..C"#&& / 4 /# D 0 ! E F 8 9 " : : ; 9 : 1 = ;

/.6%+&20(<! #G1 = < & ($ & ) > < > 4 & & + 7 2 3 H ?

I&=;! "#EF#3%% ) * ' J & 4 @ + A! K B " # - L + 0 < 5

345&67#C78=$- ) $ & @ A B ) (# M ! ' ) C @ A B N L .

&$4O(#(PQ6%%4/<())4&/#D"$

!'"#!$%*"#&$'(%&

REF9* !_H₇_<₉_I₌₈₉₄_C_"₈₅_"_<_="SG,T+6H78U !_E₇_%₈₅_G_>_%

?5438C9"

+)*++IVW&XY#> 9 : E F & ; Z [ 8 > ! 9 & E F 9 * \ M & S#

:<+ (;=<=:J>)] (>?+^ - . ) _ . O ` & R E F 9 * K L

M4&a@/0]b"A>$ 9 E F 9 * 3 R E F 9 * & / .# : > & S c

d?1N&*BCe$c4/ F D & 9 :# c E F E F & + 3 / G c 4 4 )

*&f$$Dg//.&Hh 2 C I O i j & @ A 4 B P# Q R \ 3 ' S c

1=CJ&9:$C J & D 1 ] % % @ K T & k ! + , H 1 = i E & M !#

K(($4"l&1EW>CF.$

EmnEF9*&o p U q S (E F + 3 & ! " 5 L) & r# M N R E

F!Gc)*&%s9:UtVC (@A&5L)$/Nu#a@6L>)*

=:tVZD&@ A O 4 B W J# W Q > G 1 = < & @ A F % ] ) * - X$

76vG!G&7w5#;& 7 + P Q 8 R !18C<385512!$38%" x ^ (y

')JWY%%!G&z@9.$(y')S/{62Z4&|[#H: & %

%GI-.C!%&}3#/$C!% ~ J 3 & ) *$ D 3 H (L & P

Q8R)O&C+ ; T * < !_#₄₈_%B₈_$_G_C_"₅₅₈_C_G" + K ` V W C () *

&y')#6#@ACJ\S$%1 =#) * K 8 . % = % - T$ (" # &

4/,d> 6 / 0# | U' V J' " L " S W s# g 2 \ ] , 3 C M $

{4&' ' 0 &# / ] # 1 ,y ' - $ " # u s$) !_{^ * _#'}₍₍₀#

:;'))"`/Nu#4&a@)"9EF&#$<%3C?##$N/{%

(4)

!!!"!!#!$% " " " # # & $ " $! % & ' ' % % '! ( " #" ! &'!'#)"*(#&!+ ! " & , - . # ! # "! / , ) * ( 0 $ + ) #,$%# $_J₅₈_%% # ! # "!/ , &* 1 & - $₂_$ :"7G"<<75K"%' # & $ ! #"() $% ! 2!'()*!:;*)% &++%!2% *3 4 5 &+ / 6 7 8 * # .,(9:;</01'-=()*2#8+>3? ,@A#&$4)! BC "'5,.)8+ ! D 6 7 # @ A # * 0 1 4 8 E! F 0 1 # " # 7 G (! -/0H%&$#1$( 9 I % ) J ( ) 7! C " K L 2 # ) * A 3 M! N +:.M!!&$%4O%P ! / Q R ;! & S R ; ) * T U V W < X = * Y!N+T&$.+#55! " = * Y! Z 0 1 > [ \ ( ? # 5 ] 2 ^ _ ? /@A# ,₍)= ,₎)!`!"#6B"CD#(%a01-.!Mb#c$ ,3>3C"($%&! ' - 4 " 5 <! , 7 5 ]- @ A # & $ 4 E + 6 ' ?d5-(#"-!)%?- ( e f 7 \ # 5 ]! ` ! " # , 8 8 9 * - 4 5&(

!"!""#$##%$%&'(&")*

F ,-.&#)25 F Q / :! F " ! 2 # 0! F G H g 2 % $! I I '+ 5 &! I I h J , 5 &( 9 : i . e K j $L8594CB4%M8="%% k ( l ,L$) $N$C8% % ( . 6 1 * 2 7 # / , m : n 0 2 9 ; # 4 5 & l M( ,L$)9</So.p8E!?qr029;;/4Z#)#1&!6 1 * 2`<029;-(d5$ ,! * ( ? , =! h ` < < N , 7 ? 5 ] # . p O!s=>3 ,L$#/,)!VN ,D>61tus=+/S(!* 2! > ??C"7% 2 9 ; //) $e K j!'((/!:;'0%!9<v.Mb w P!% !2QF5]#3RR&$,805?@A=xB(*345&+/6# S Z y&T'3?a01-.C" 8 U , 8 # 5 ] 4 5 l M! B & $ , 8 7 # $ ,t) ,L$#/,)( 9:z{6V-.CH&/ ,&$%*D)(43+@"')7(<WR J# ,-.&#)!X+A5#*|!(,.5]#5FQ/:!YB(*C H,8#&$4}8#C=" * = 5 ] ~ ^ l M 7 @ A P [ A # +( ; <!,vB&$RJ7#c&E!Y+TFQ/5F:8G=# #! & +",.+CD%45 & # / S t E ) $% ! 2!'()*!:;'%( - . C H 7!C"#8U9(! D , H _ , E 8 E! : E 2 Z) # ( F ; <! D > %RIrC#3!-"% [ G H J 3 # 2 Z( I W D > 6 1 * 2 4 5 !"#

(5)

!!!"!#$%"!#"#&#'!"(#)*"!+$,#%-. $ &#

#/&0#'!"%123%&. $ $ $' 4 % % 5 && & % ! 6 7 8# #

'!"9('%&%)*#: + , ; " < ( ) - " ! * + % , - " .# = ,

;.>#/'?/%"<(0 @ A 1 ! % " <& # ' ! " 9 . % & % & ' B

2!!"%CD(#3$%%&)E%F4*"!0'5&+1 !O==8%$45

!JK"%8<"GH% $,!%I6%&

&7#J$8(#"KL M 9 ' 9 : 2 ( % % ;( < = N O " & % C D

(()!P*&Q+!3"" " " , - " . R 4 ' % % ; # 5# 6 < + / S

TUV$7%'8-.%9 0# W 6 & ! : 4 ' # # % ; % 1 ## * * > &

C.#/5,UDX 2 / % 3 = % Y ' < 4& $> & % 0 # % A Z [ % $5

$%#\?]1%=23'#%@;^(_#N`6>+DX&CaA $3 4

$$%95(,A9b%)%# B A 7 c 9 8 C 6 b d 8 7 5 ] D % D E ^

FK#(A&F8#':2% C D (# N 9 ? T 9 8 % , S > + e * G H f

%Z[#*@$&%CD (& & ' 9 : 2 (# 8 g 9 * , * 9 h H % < + )

iIJj0#!DX%.& :& k l# V K 8 g ; > 7 c A ! % m n B C <

o]1%=2#7c-D)i % L = 2 ? ] 1 % p + 9 h# 7 c q ) / S >

/UV%DX*+)r?#<+ / S 3 U V $ 7 % D X : s I t 0 C + & q

#(M@%`N#OA)PK % 9 0 ' 8 - .# Q B ? % U + 0 $ 7 c < +

%/SE@C6]=%9hH)uv#V K 9 & ; % > & w x ! R E $, &

SF%$+,T)F%yDEFU%)iGS#OA)z2F{|.Vf A A 4%;%1 ## Q V K H } , > r (# - * 7 c & ; 3 ) F 8 : ~ ] 1 % $&&

!("!#$"*#$%#%&'&'

-I%P*Ai!GI%o<#+aCD(,,%J"W%.H& 0 P *#':2CD(#B&0`6x&D(%K& %!69DX%I L ! R J# " z 7 R X $ , ; D ( % @# &

78(&K:.% D (& & +a ' )( $ G 3 9 h* - ; Y 0 Y ' % m n

F, !P34Q4="79"2<7@ L8<94 L7C5GR$59$C4<*S%PC8K45"%?#P7"549<#8%G

B457%?"%?",Y(#? W " < ( & ' ) ( = + - . - ; % Z ---$ G&

$GMA=+LMT./- ; % : G# A D X : N % # 5# N , * ; % /

(6)

!!!"#"#"!"#$$ ! % % & ' ( $ ) *! + ! ! " $ & " ! " ' $!!",(-./01! % " #!48%4!'()'!::;'0+-'.,$% 2 3! 4 5 #$6)%!"7!68!! 5 $ 9 & : ! ; 1 < " ! # % ) ' $ & "! 6 &"!:$! ! 8 ( =' + > ? @ A B C ( #_B₄ ??"%?8%GB457%?"%?"%934 R"9T'NQ4="79"2N::C7823$+D:!E;*!!5<)FG)+$ )H '" $I1,$-$!"!JK )H'"H % 1 " ! # * $ $ . & (! ! ! ( = #L)%M*$) ' ! N & *% J K ) ' $ " ' . / : $ * 6 &O P ) ' ( +Q$O0R:%'S()$ , * 1 # $ - " + $ F! + % T ) U " + , * 1#%$,+!<&-$(N V . ! ! & - , # . 0 1 P ) ' $ - 6* ' S <W#$+"+ + # #_E₄₌_F_C₈_%_G_9K₈_%E_" M%$ $ . 4 &) 2 / 0 + # 1 / 0 $X#A*( #_*₊_,_&_%_-_.!_"_#_#_%_+%_{/ 0}₁₂₃₄₅_%_'_,_"_#6₇_'₈$ $ Y 3 X Z! ' (

*4[G2\-$34!%15])^ $ I $ , 6 & 2* ' S &$ & 5 7 _

$(-`'($89&"-`$?@ A : ;! - ` ) ( . 3 $ )3 4 / 0 "!

<a,P)'$-`.!b) ' = 4 1 > 5 .% c % d $ ? @ A B C " " !

#%:$!e5!c*1f' : $ * 6 + , g " W # $ $ + 4! + % T P ?

h+.6i$)';*5!E c + @ $ 7 2 3 7 & 8! & j ; * ? @ ( & 6

k2\-$34%Al45dm')?@(&l2-:$4,!F"Bb - . 9"n!:o)U"!! $ p ;%" #+ % T!'()*!_:;)/$ q r! 6 < = s tL>5$5]&8:!)' $ " ' 7 u ! " [ G 2 \ - $ 3 4! 8 C L ; *?56?@(&6k$9D)'% )'$;*6h:jJ 3 $ ; v' w % $ 6 k + x E - 6 y $ 9 %% @ uzXJ> )y$9%"F7u<A G B u `! l . 1 0 $ X { 7% . 1 0 |V )}C$~,M*#gheOlH?@)*c;5}8X { 5! h=Gj}>/p%l? D @ r d A & $ ) *! = ' S B + $ $ E 012)* $ M *" # * 9!'()+!_:;,.$%)*6?D:A&! )

*$F*FG/X{%+%T6 &OP)'(+Q:|V)'PCD g &!

)'$07u.3E $ X {! ' S ? D 0 1 U% 6 5 ] F I :! s t JK$)^p<FI&8: G 6 + L M H 6 $ 1 2 :! * 1 $ N %(631( $ 3 6 L O H 6! @ u I % J P $ ; !, 5 ] $ ' 4! 7u.3E$X{LKL$ # %% 6 + % T I! ? @ A 6 R I 5 ] & 8 : $u+!+p6j,- J P $ . <! = m M $ M * P ' SB$JPIX>! u ' S X {, ? ' L ? D* Q + p ! ? @ A R R 4oS.3j,$)*f @ $ 1 2 7 # %! 6 A / $ 5 ] $ J N : !"#

(7)

!!!"!"#

##!$$#!"$$#" ! " %$ # # " % # $ & ' # % ( & ) $ *

+'&'"&,-.#(%$ ( ) / " % ' " 0 " 1 / $% 2 3 4 5 % & /

$#56*7+'&89:; < & = , - 3 >% + / ? & ' ) ( * @ ! ) A

B&'C%4*@DE &#.&"/'#($F (GH/$)#I0%J 1 +

H/$&K2L!*MN>* 7 ' " & H / $ 3 )% O # 4 P &Q / ? % ,

5'"&+6%H/$6%#E,$7&-8'!'()*%_:;,"#H/$9%#

E./#R-50S&D :% ( ) 5 * T ; ! % # 1 , - . "% % ( ) . <

/$&)3U!%6=>;"+()+/?&*2#

!"#$*

,/%!$3 !_'₍₍₎"_UVW,*PX?.(@. !A4-%5"UY6*Y670I%U ($F%1ZA !_'₍₎_*"_UGH/$+++=,-3>&/?./ !203%["#%B "%

5"U\%*C4].MD,U

^_` !'()/"U,-.*abW&&UE5*E5].MD,U

$?F !'((0"U6 8 G$0 9 :$F %*c 7 ; ' L & N > Z d e < # = H IU $ >* $>].MD,U

fJg%83; !'((/"U%K'?,L9M : 3 > & 1 N $ @ !O A '% 5 "U E 5* & (P-MD,U

^'2 !_'₍₎₊"_{U'3BWe<,-.U\%*C4].MD,U}

!47%4V1WX'()'YWP34 <4="79"2< 7@ D8<94 D7C5G 2$59$C4<ZS% 9C8K45"%?V97"549<V8%G F457%?"%?W(7'&71"9:+&"1+,&4%+,';%71+,'%/8)4'%#%8).%/57'&71",+<,=4%'%>.V'V'0+-'.,W

" %&'(* ["#%C4].X.W!;.<=>HI'%HId88,-.We<.# 0=*>-?< !"#$%&"%VH3WAW28%G"G8947@R7554?47@!"94C89$C48%G#7$C%85"<=VQ"23$8%[%"K4C<"9TW \"<C4<48C23@"45G<"%25$G4<4="79"2<8%G27==$%"289"7%W O=8"5Z5"M$%&"%(]))!^^W27=