Frontiers of Law in Chin a
Paper Review Form
Paper’s Title Corporate groups under Italian law: a comparative approach and the brand-new “Crisis Code”.
Author’s Name Anonymity Article’s
Derivation English Original
Reviewer’s Name Reviewer’s
Phone Reviewer’s E-mail
Reviewer’s Postal Address and mobile phone
One hard copy is to be delivered to you free of charge.
Paper Evaluation 5—Excellent 1—Poor
Please mark a tick (√) to indicate a selected grade
Innovative (i.e., theory, calculation, application, data, technology, conclusion)
□ 5 √□ 4 □ 3 □ 2 □ 1
Progressive nature （whether it adheres to or surpasses international and domestic levels of quality.
□ 5 √□ 4 □ 3 □ 2 □ 1
Logical and rational（Establishes and follows a topic; precise reasoning, credible and meaningful conclusions ）
√□ 5 □ 4 □ 3 □ 2 □ 1
Format（appropriate organization, definitive abstract, accurate and comprehensive glossary, references and citations meet format, and conventions, charts and pictures are clear）
√□ 5 □ 4 □ 3 □ 2 □ 1 Overall evaluation
□ 5 √□ 4 □ 3 □ 2 □ 1 Acceptable for publishing?
√□ Yes □Yes, after amendment □No
1
Frontiers of Law in Chin a
Reviewer’s Comments Please drop your objective comments and good opinions as to further revision of this paper in details.
This paper presents an explicit panorama of the law of corporate groups in Italy and gives a detailed introduction of the evolution of the Italian model and its main characteristics. Compared to other systems, the trans-typical Italian legal discipline on direction and coordination is more flexible and more adaptive to the economic reality. This paper explains this model clearly and logically, which provides us with a meaningful reference.
However, the flexibility of regulations is always followed by the uncertainty in application. The paper will provide a more comprehensive view of the Italian model if the experience in judicial practice is also taken into consideration.
In your opinion, what is an important topic being
researched in this field?
How to take full advantage of the form of corporate groups to enhance group interest while protecting the interests of stakeholders, including single corporations in groups and their creditors and minority shareholders, etc.?
What advice or comments would you kindly make to this publication?
The issue in the column of “Focus” can be more specific, it can focus on a specific problem we are faced with at the present time and look for different solutions in different countries.
Reviewer’s Signature:
(Your Registered Name) (Date) Editorial Office
Signature: Date:
Editor-in-Chief
Signature: Date:
PS: The reviewer is expected to read through the referred paper, present your review comments and revision opinions, and then have your (official-registered) full name signed. Technically, have this Review Form fully filled up in a comprehensive way, and have it (Scanned doc., PDF/Word-format are acceptable) returned to the Editorial Office by e-mail within 7 days. Your reviews will be well appreciated.
2
