17 The Use of Positron Emission Tomography in Drug Discovery and Development
William C Eckelman
Introduction
To accelerate the drug discovery process and to in- crease the annual number of approved drugs, pharma- ceutical chemists have developed new procedures, such as combinatorial chemistry and parallel synthesis, and biologists have developed high-throughput screening methods that test various properties of the drug candi- date in vitro (Table 17.1). Since the time line for drug discovery and development can be as long as 16 years, these techniques are necessary to expedite the drug discovery process. Currently, discovery and pre- clinical testing can take up to 6 years. Phase I and Phase II studies usually average 2 years each. Phase III takes longer and the final U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approval process takes one year [1]. The goal of this review is to show that studies carried out in vivo using external imaging of all kinds,
but especially Positron Emission Tomography (PET), offer great promise for accelerating the process from pre-clinical discovery to Phase III studies. Although high-throughput, in vitro screening has been useful, the results must be extrapolated to in vivo use. Even though in vivo imaging is first carried out in animals, the drug candidate is being tested in an intact species and this should yield more complete information.
Imaging is especially important in paradigms where animals are studied before and after treatment with the drug candidate. As paired statistics can be carried out in the same animal, fewer animals are needed.
Therefore, in vivo imaging has an advantage over the autoradiographic approaches that are carried out in vivo but require the sacrifice of the animal after each study.
The development of radiolabelled biochemicals and imaging devices to detect the radioactivity by external imaging has expanded the use of nuclear medicine studies in drug development. The common radionu- clides for Single Photon Emission Computed Tomography (SPECT) are
99mTc (half life = 6 hr) and
123
I (half life = 13 hr). For PET, the radionuclides emit a positron that annihilates to give two 511 keV gamma rays at approximately 180 degrees. The positron-emit- ting radionuclides (with their half lives) used most fre- quently are
15O (2.07 min),
11C (20.4 min),
13N (10 min) and
18F (109.7 min). The specific activities (radioactiv- ity per mass unit, usually measured in Ci/mM or TBq/mM) of these radionuclides are high because they are made through a nuclear transformation; that is, one element is converted into another so that, except for trace contaminants, they are carrier free. The actual specific activities for the most-used PET radionuclides,
18
F and
11C, are of the order of 37–185 TBq/mM (1000–5000 Ci/mM) at the end of the cyclotron
327 Table 117.1. High throughput in vitro screening
Physical Properties
pKa, solubility, dissolution rate, crystallinity and chemical stability
Drug Metabolism, Pharmacokinetics (PK), and Pharmacodynamics (PD) Affinity (interaction with membranes, binding proteins, transporters and enzymes)
Organ blood flow, glomerular filtration rate, and tissue uptake
Absorption potential (Caco-2 cell permeability)
Blood Brain Barrier penetration (bovine brain microvessel endothelial cells)
Metabolism (cytochrome P450)
Metabolic stability (hepatocyte metabolites analysed by liquid chro- matography/mass spectrometry)
Source: Ref. 55.
bombardment. Therefore, these radioactive probes are injected at tracer levels (~nM injected). The unique- ness of the nuclear medicine technique based on this tracer principle is in measuring biochemistry in vivo, especially the biochemistry of easily saturated sites such as receptors, by external imaging.
The Tracer Principle
George Charles de Hevesy is usually considered the first to identify the tracer principle [2]. In 1923, he used
212
Pb (half life = 10.6 hr) to study the uptake of solu- tions in bean plants. Although lead is generally consid- ered toxic, he was able to use small, non-toxic amounts because of the sensitivity of the radioactivity tech- niques. The following year he carried out the first ex- periment in animals using
210Bi to label and follow the circulation of bismuth in rabbits after intra-muscular injection of bismuth-containing antisyphilitic drugs.
Martin D. Kamen, in the three editions of his book titled Isotopic Tracers in Biology, chronicled the rapid progress in applying the newly discovered tracer prin- ciple to clinical research [3]. Even today it is the only method of monitoring low concentrations of either re- ceptor or enzymes using external imaging.
Compared with other external imaging modalities, the radiotracer approach requires injection of the least amount of mass to obtain the necessary biochemical information. The high specific activity of the radioli- gands allows detection of very low density sites. For example, for
11C or
18F-labelled radiopharmaceuticals, the specific activity at the time of injection is usually greater than 37TBq/mM (1000 Ci/mM). Since the ra- diopharmaceutical is injected in amounts approximat- ing 370MBq, the associated mass injected is 10 nM in a 70 kg human. This amount is minimal compared with
Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI), which requires concentrations of 10 to100 μM/kg (~700 to 7000 μM) for iodinated contrast media where a concentration of
>100 μM (~7 mM) is required. The advantage of using smaller amounts can be seen from the Scatchard trans- formation of the equilibrium binding constant. At high specific activity, the bound-to-free ratio (B/F) reaches a maximum in that (B
max– B) / K
Dapproaches B
max/K
Dwhere B
maxrepresents the free receptor concentration and K
Dis the dissociation equilibrium constant. At lower specific activity, the ratio is decreased, or in the extreme case the receptor will be saturated [3]. In general, these saturating concentrations using radioli- gands will still be orders of magnitude less concen- trated than those required for MRI and CT. However, the higher instrument resolution of MRI and CT is a driving force to apply these tracer principles to MRI contrast media and iodinated contrast media. An example of the effect of injected dose can be seen from data showing binding of the muscarinic M2 subtype- specific ligand FP-TZTP [(1,2,5-thiadiazol-4-yl)- tetrahydro-1-methylpyridine]. As the dose of injected material increases, the percent injected dose (%ID) decreases (Fig. 17.1). A saturating amount of drug can be estimated from such studies. In this particular example, the receptor is easily saturated at 140 μM/kg, a much lower amount than the 700 to 7000 μM/kg re- quired for standard MRI studies.
Case Method Analysis of the Drug Discovery Process Using External Imaging
The Society of Noninvasive Imaging in Drug Development (SNIDD) was formed in 1990 by a small
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6
NCA 5 nmol 50 nmol 500 nmol
Blood Ctx Hippo Striat Thal Pons Medu Cb
%ID/g
Figure 117.1. The percent injected dose per gram
(%ID/g) in rat brain for [
18F]-FP-TZTP as a function
of the co-injected dose of P-TZTP. Tissues assayed
are cortex (Ctx), hippocampus (Hippo), striatum
(Striat), thalamus (Thal), pons, medulla (Medu) and
cerebrum (Cb).
group of researchers from academia, government labo- ratories and the pharmaceutical industry. This group believed that non-invasive imaging technologies such as PET and SPECT can be powerful research tools for the drug industry and that these tools can help reduce the time and cost of discovering and bringing new drugs to the marketplace by improving the efficiency of both pre-clinical and clinical research on new drug candidates and identifying drug candidates that will ultimately fail. SNIDD has held two meetings to illus- trate the use of imaging in drug development. The first of these symposia was held on September 11–13, 1998 at the National Institutes of Health (NIH). The sympo- sium was organized using the case method technique, popularized by the Harvard Business School as a
framework for analyzing examples of actual business decisions and, from that, obtaining insight into the process [4]. Several conferences have addressed the use of imaging in drug research and development, but none, in our experience, had analyzed decisions made during the drug development process based on colla- borative imaging studies. Nuclear Medicine imaging techniques were used in the eleven case method presen- tations. The special issue reporting on this conference contains descriptions of pre-clinical studies in knock- out mice, pre-clinical PET studies in non-human pri- mates, a series of Phase I studies (dosing studies, pharmacokinetics [unique delivery systems], dose, dose interval, drug interactions), Phase I/II (dose response, response duration, pharmacokinetic/pharmacodynamic
Figure 117.2. Representative planar images of
wild-type and knockout mice obtained 10 minutes
(upper panels) and 150 minutes (lower panels)
post-injection. Both [
99mTc]-sestamibi and [
99mTc]-
Q58 show Pgp-mediated hepatobiliary clearance in
wild-type mice. However, in knockout mice,
Tc-99m sestamibi lacked hepatobiliary clearance
but [
99mTc]-Q58 did not.
[PK/PD] relationship), Phase III “surrogate markers” or mechanistic intermediates [5], and marketing studies.
Use of Knockout Mice in Drug Discovery
Imaging can save considerable time in pre-clinical studies. Multi-drug resistance (MDR) in cancer chemotherapy is mediated by P-glycoprotein.
Monitoring the effectiveness of modulators is an im- portant area of imaging. Piwnica-Worms and Marmion presented a case study that used knockout mice to decide whether [
99mTc]-Q complexes would be effective as probes for P-glycoprotein. The [
99mTc]-Q complexes tested in MDR 1a/ab knockout mice showed enhance- ment of initial brain uptake but no significant delay in liver clearance (Fig. 17.2). These agents were deemed to have cross-reactivity for another organic cation trans- porter expressed in mouse liver and were not advanced to clinical studies [6].
Drug Distribution Studies
Two studies were carried out to evaluate drug distribu- tion in the gut and in the lung. Producing a true tracer situation is important to these studies. In the analysis of modified-release formulations, drugs such as dilti- azem are formulated with small amounts of stable [
152Sm]-samarium oxide. The tablets can then be acti- vated by neutron activation to produce radioactive
153