Unit of Investigative Clinical Oncology Istituto di Candiolo (IRCCS)
Terapia adiuvante con inibitori delle Kinasi Cliclina Dipendenti 4/6: quale futuro?
Filippo Montemurro
Direzione Oncologia Clinica Investigativa, IRCC Candiolo
Speaker’s Honoraria
Astra Zeneca
Novartis
Roche
Travel grants
Astra Zeneca
Roche
Disclosures
Direzione Oncologia Clinica Investigativa, IRCC Candiolo
Discussing the rationale
Overview of the most important ongoing Phase III trial evaluating the addition of CDK 4/6
inhibitors to endocrine therapy
Some speculation on what to expect
Conclusions
Presentation outline
Direzione Oncologia Clinica Investigativa, IRCC Candiolo
Long-term prognosis of HR+/PgR- breast cancer
Cortazar et al, Lancet 384; 164, 2014
Direzione Oncologia Clinica Investigativa, IRCC Candiolo
Activity seen in the metastatic setting fully supports studies in operable breast cancer
Study Treatment ORR CBR Median DFS (m) Median OS (m)
PALOMA 2 Letrozole+Placebo 34.7% 70.3% 14.5 N.A.
Letrozole+ Palbociclib 42.1% 84.9% 24.8 N.A.
MONNALEESA 2 Letrozole+Plac 27.5% 72.8% 14.7 33
Letrozole+Ribociclib 40.7% 79.2% 25.3 N.R.*
MONARCH 3 Let. or Ana. + Placebo 34.5% 71.5% 14.7 N.A
Let or Ana + Abemaciclib 48.2% 78.0% N.R. N.A.
0.58 0.56 0.54
Finn et al, NEJM 375;1925, 2016 Hortobagyi et al, NEJM 375;1738, 2017 Di Leo et al, ESMO 2017
Direzione Oncologia Clinica Investigativa, IRCC Candiolo
Randomized, Open-label Phase III Study of Palbociclib + Adjuvant Endocrine Therapy vs. Adjuvant Endocrine Therapy Alone in
HR+/HER2– Early Breast Cancer: PALLAS
1. ClinicalTrials.gov. https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/
NCT02513394 (Accessed April 28 2016)
2. Meyer E, et al. Presented at SABCS 2015; San Antonio, Texas, USA (Oral presentation OT1-03-21)
N=4600
Histologically confirmed
HR+/HER2– early invasive breast cancer
Stage IIA or III
Pre- or postmenopausal women
Men are eligible
≤12 months since initial pathologic diagnosis
Prior chemotherapy allowed
1:1
RANDOMIZATION
Primary endpoint: iDFS Secondary endpoints:
iDFS excluding second primary cancers of non- breast origin; DRFS; LLRFS;
OS; PROs; safety Stratification factors:
Pathologic stage (IIA vs.
IIB/III) or clinical stage (if preoperative therapy was given with the higher stage determining eligibility);
neo/adjuvant chemotherapy (yes vs. no); age (<50 vs.
≥50 years); geographic region (North America vs.
Europe vs. Asia)
Arm B
Endocrine therapy (5–10 years)
Arm A Palbociclib
(2 years) Endocrine therapy+
(5–10 years)
Direzione Oncologia Clinica Investigativa, IRCC Candiolo
Phase III Study of Palbociclib in High-risk Early Breast Cancer: PENELOPE
1. ClinicalTrials.gov NCT01864746
2. Data on file, Pfizer
Early ER+ breast cancer “high risk”
(CPS-EG ≥3*)
Premenopausal/postmenopausal
Completed taxane-based neoadjuvant therapy, surgery, radiotherapy
Primary endpoint: iDFS
Secondary endpoints:
OS, iDFS excluding second non-breast cancer, DDFS, LRFS, iDFS by commercially
available multigene assay subtyping, safety, PROs, biomarkers
Stratification factors:
lymph node status, age, biomarkers
(Ki67, pRb, Cyclin D), and region
N=800
1:1
RANDOMIZATION
PENELOPE
a,1,2Non-study adjuvant endocrine therapies being taken for 5–10 years after surgery were permitted during the study:
tamoxifen (pre- and postmenopausal women)
goserelin agonists (premenopausal)
AIs: anastrozole, letrozole (postmenopausal)
Placebo X 13 cycles (3/1 schedule)
+ SOC Palbociclib X 13
cycles (125 mg QD, 3/1 schedule)
+ SOC
CPS-EG; clinical –patologic stage estrogen/score AKA Neo-Bioscore
Direzione Oncologia Clinica Investigativa, IRCC Candiolo
EarLEE-1: adjuvant therapy for high-risk early breast cancer
8
Endocrine therapya+ Ribociclib
(600 mg/d, 3 weeks on/1 week off
× 26 cycles [24 mo])
•HR+, HER2– EBC
•Men and pre- and
postmenopausal women
•High risk of recurrence
-AJCC 8th ed, Prognostic Stage Group III
-Residual disease in LN(s) and breast tissue after neoadjuvant chemotherapy
Endocrine therapy + Placebo
(3 weeks on/1 week off
×26 cycles [24 mo])
AJCC, American Joint Committee on Cancer; EBC, early breast cancer; DDFS, distant disease-free survival; HER2–, human epidermal growth factor receptor-2–negative; HR+, hormone receptor-positive; iDFS, invasive disease-free survival; LN, lymph node; NACT, neoadjuvant chemotherapy; OS, overall survival;
QoL, quality of life; RFS, recurrence-free survival.
EarLEE-1 Clinical Trial Protocol
https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT03078751
a Endocrine therapy can be started up to 12 weeks before randomization and continue for at least 60 months.
N=2000
RANDOMIZATION
Primary endpoint:
iDFS
Secondary End points:
RFSDDFS QSQol
Direzione Oncologia Clinica Investigativa, IRCC Candiolo
EarLEE-2: adjuvant therapy for moderate risk early breast cancer
9
Endocrine therapya+ Ribociclib
(600 mg/d, 3 weeks on/1 week off
× 26 cycles [24 mo])
•HR+, HER2– EBC
•Men and pre- and
postmenopausal women
•Intermediate risk of recurrence
-AJCC 8th ed, Prognostic Stage Group II
-No neoadjuvant chemotherapy and/or endocrine therapy
Endocrine therapy + Placebo
(3 weeks on/1 week off
×26 cycles [24 mo])
AJCC, American Joint Committee on Cancer; EBC, early breast cancer; DDFS, distant disease-free survival; HER2–, human epidermal growth factor receptor-2–negative; HR+, hormone receptor-positive; iDFS, invasive disease-free survival; LN, lymph node; NACT, neoadjuvant chemotherapy; OS, overall survival;
QoL, quality of life; RFS, recurrence-free survival.
EarLEE-1 Clinical Trial Protocol
https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT03078751
a Endocrine therapy can be started up to 12 weeks before randomization and continue for at least 60 months.
N=2000
RANDOMIZATION Primary endpoint:
iDFS
Secondary Endpoints RFSDDFS QSQol
Direzione Oncologia Clinica Investigativa, IRCC Candiolo
monarchE: adjuvant treatment for HR+/HER2-, high risk operable breast cancer
Endocrine therapya+ Abemaciclib
[24 mo]
•HR+, HER2– EBC
•Men and pre- and
postmenopausal women
•N+ and at least one of the following
•≥4 metastatic lymph nodes
•T3
•G3
•Ki67 ≥20% (cohort B)
Endocrine therapy N = 3850
RANDOMIZATION
Primary endpoint:
iDFS
Secondary Endpoints:
IDFS according to Ki67 (cutoff 20%) OSPharmacokinetics Qol
https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT03155997?term=abemaciclib&cond=breast&draw=1&rank=2
Direzione Oncologia Clinica Investigativa, IRCC Candiolo
Trial Population Risk Neo/Adj
chemo CDKi
duration Accrual
target Early results expected*
Completion
PALLAS Pre-Post
menop Women, Men
IIA-III Allowed 2 y 4600 Sep 2020 Sep 2025
PENELOPE-B Pre-Post
menop women
CPS-EG≥3 Neoadj
Mandatory ~1y 800 Dec 2020 Nov 2023
EarLEE1 Pre-Post
menop Women, Men
Group** III or residual
disease after NACT
Allowed ~2y 2000 Sep 2023 Sep 2023
EarLEE2 Pre-Post
menop Women, Men
Group** III None
allowed ~2 y 2000 Sep 2023 Sep 2023
monarchE Pre-Post
menop Women, Men
High-risk N+ Allowed ? 3850 June 2022 Jun 2027
Summary of key points
*Final data collection date for primary outcome measure
*AJCC 8thEdition
Direzione Oncologia Clinica Investigativa, IRCC Candiolo
What to expect
Could we expect increased cure rate due to a sort of "pCR in micrometastatic sites" effect?
Cortazar et al, Lancet 384; 164, 2014
Direzione Oncologia Clinica Investigativa, IRCC Candiolo
Neoadjuvant palbociclib and letrozole vs chemotherapy
Cottu et al., Esmo 2017
Direzione Oncologia Clinica Investigativa, IRCC Candiolo
pCR rates remain globally low, but PEPI scores is better with palbo and letrozole
Cottu et al., Esmo 2017
Ellis, JNCI 2008
Direzione Oncologia Clinica Investigativa, IRCC Candiolo
PEPI score is largely driven by residual Ki67 in surgical specimen
Dowsett et al. JNCI 100; 1380, 2008
Cottu et al., Esmo 2017
Direzione Oncologia Clinica Investigativa, IRCC Candiolo
For short treatment exposures, Ki67 raises sharply upon CDK 4/6 treatment interruption
Neoadjuvant palbociclib and anastrozole (NEOPALANA study).
Ma et al, Clin Cancer Res, epub 2017 ER+ (Allred 6-8)
HER2-
Surgery
AnastrozoleC0D1 +/-Goserelin
Ana. + Pal.C1D1 +/-Goserelin
4 weeks
(PIK3CA mutational analysis)
C1D15 Ana. + Pal.
+/-Goserelin
2 weeks
B
Ana. + Pal.C2D1 +/-Goserelin
B B
If ki67 >10% patients go off study
4 cycles
(5 in 8 patients)
PIK3CAwt 32 PIK3CAmut 16
Direzione Oncologia Clinica Investigativa, IRCC Candiolo
CDK 4/6 inhibition and prolonged G1 arrest may induce cancer cell senescence
Kovatcheva et al, Oncotarget 6;8226, 2015 Evidence that this occurs in: Vemurafenib-resistant melanoma (PMID 26988987), Sarcoma (PMID 26528855), Neuroblastoma (PIMD 24045179 ), Breast (PIMD 28813415), Glioblastoma multiforme (PMID 20354191), Hepatocellular carcinoma (PIMD 27849562), Leukemia (PMID 28286417) and others
Direzione Oncologia Clinica Investigativa, IRCC Candiolo
Senescence is capable of stimulating clearance by the immune system
Experimentally impaired immune surveillance
Wong-Kang et al, Nature 479; 547, 2011
Direzione Oncologia Clinica Investigativa, IRCC Candiolo
Changes occurring in the tumor bed in the neoadjuvant setting with abemaciclib
C1D15
T Regulatory cells (FOXP3) Total T cells
(CD3)
C5D28 Baseline
H&E
Moderately Differentiated
Ki67: 20%
DifferentiatedWell Ki67: 3.4%
DifferentiatedWell Ki67: 0.2%
(Abemaciclib monotherapy)
(Abemaciclib & Anastrozole)
Suppressor/ Cytotoxic T cells
(CD8)
Hurvitz SABCS 2016
Direzione Oncologia Clinica Investigativa, IRCC Candiolo
CDK 4/6 inhibition triggers anti-tumour immunity
Collectively, these results establish that CDK4/6 inhibitors induce breast cancer cell cytostasis without directly causing their apoptosis, and enhance their capacity to present antigen and stimulate cytotoxic T cells
Goel et al, Nature; epub 2017
Direzione Oncologia Clinica Investigativa, IRCC Candiolo
Adding CDK 4/6 inhibitors to adjuvant endocrine in high- risk, ER+/HER2- breast cancer patients has a strong
rationale
Biology suggests a potential eradicating effect based on induction of senescence and clearance by the immune system
Safety in patients who have been recently exposed to cytotoxic chemotherapy needs to be addressed
Potential effects of senescence on normal cells need to be clarified
Which type of tumors will be faced with upon progression?
Conclusions
Direzione Oncologia Clinica Investigativa, IRCC Candiolo
Development in the Neoadjuvant setting
Criscitiello et al, Curr Opin Oncol, epub 2017
Direzione Oncologia Clinica Investigativa, IRCC Candiolo
Toxicity, dose adjustments and discontinuation without progression
Paloma 2 Monnaleesa 2* Monarch 3
Item (% any grade/% G3-4) Palbociclib Placebo Ribociclib Placebo Abemaciclib Placebo
Any 99/76 96/24 98/81 97/33 98/55 90/22
Neutropenia 80/66 6/1 74/59 5/1 41/21 2/1
Febrile Neutropenia 1.8 0 1.5 0 - -
Anemia 24/24 11/1 19/1 4/1 28/6 5/1
Diarrhea 26/1 19/1 35/1 22/1 81/37 30/1
Nausea 35/0 26/2 52/3 28/1 38/12 20/2
Vomiting 16/1 17/1 29/4 16/1 28/9 12/4
Alopecia 33/0 16/0 33/0 16/0 27/0 11/0
Need for dose interruption 67% 41% 77% 41% 43% 6%
Need for dose adjustment 36 1 54 7 43 6
Discontinuation for adv. ev. 10 6 8 2 20 2
Direzione Oncologia Clinica Investigativa, IRCC Candiolo
Rationale for using CDK 4/6 in the adjuvant treatment of HR positive breast cancer
Cossetti et al. J Clin Oncol 33; 65, 2017
1986-1992 2004-2008
Direzione Oncologia Clinica Investigativa, IRCC Candiolo
SWOG 8814: Disease-free survival according to Recurrence Score and treatment arm
Albain et al, Lancet Oncol 11;55, 2016