12 Clinico-Pathological Features of Hepatocellular Carcinoma
Massimo Colombo and Guido Ronchi
M. Colombo, MD; G. Ronchi , MD
Department of Gastroenterology and Endocrinology, IRCCS Maggiore Hospital, University of Milan, Via Pace 9, 20122 Milano, Italy
CONTENTS
12.1 Introduction 169
12.2 The Pathological Classifi cation 169 12.3 Early Detected Tumors 170 12.4 Special Types of Tumors 171 12.5 Diagnosis 171
12.6 Staging 172
12.7 Natural History of the Tumor 173 12.8 Conclusions 174
References 175
12.1
Introduction
Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is a major health problem worldwide due to its high incidence (ap- proximately 600,000 new cases in 2000), and severe natural history. Indeed, the incidence and mortal- ity rates associated with this disease signifi cantly overlap worldwide (Parkin et al. 2001). The identi- fi cation of chronic liver disease as the relevant risk factor for this tumor has made surveillance aimed at early detection of HCC possible and surveillance is now universally recognized to be the practical approach for improving the treatment of HCC pa- tients (Bruix et al. 2001). The few cases (<5%) of HCCs that do not develop with a background of chronic liver disease present late and usually have poor prognosis (Bralet et al. 2000). The under- standing of both the natural history and staging of HCC is hampered by the epidemiologic and clinical variability of the tumor. This, in turn, is infl uenced by the concurrence of multiple co-morbidity fac- tors in the same patient as well as by the presence of multiple distinct cell lines in the liver that may develop into liver cell cancer (Sell 2002).
12.2
The Pathological Classifi cation
HCC is classifi ed as nodular, massive or diffuse. The nodular type occurs as a nodule sharply delineated from the surrounding liver. The massive type occupies a large area and infi ltrates the neighboring hepatic tis- sue with satellite nodules. The diffuse type is charac- terized by the diffuse involvement of the liver (Kojiro 1997). All three forms of HCC occur with a background of chronic liver disease or of an otherwise normal liver.
The growth pattern of HCC may be infi ltrative, expand- ing, multinodular and mixed type. Based on histology, the WHO proposed a classifi cation of HCC into tra- becular, acinar, compact and scirrhous (Gibson and Sobin 1978). In the trabecular type, tumor cells are arranged in cords of variable cell thickness separated by sinusoids, with minimal or no fi brosis (Fig. 12.1).
The acinar (pseudoglandular) type is characterized by cells arranged in gland-like structures, fi lled with cellu- lar debris, exudates and macrophages (Figs. 12.2, 12.3).
The compact type shows tumor cells that are packed in a solid mass with inconspicuous sinusoids (Fig. 12.4).
In the scirrhous type, signifi cant fi brous tissue sepa- rates cords of tumor cells. Each histological type is
Fig. 12.1. Trabecular hepatocellular carcinoma. Trabecular
pattern of well-differentiated neoplastic hepatocytes arranged
in plates which are between three and four cells in thickness
(×30)
further classifi ed according to different grades of cell differentiation. Well differentiated HCC is a trabecular tumor with two- to three-cell thick cords. The anaplas- tic tumor usually shows a solid growth pattern, with pleomorphic and giant syncytial cells (Fig. 12.5).
12.3
Early Detected Tumors
Surveillance of patients with cirrhosis has led to an in- creasing number of cancers detected early in the form of small nodules that fi rst appear as well-differentiated tumors and proliferate along with gradual dediffer- entiation (Kojiro 1998). A sizable number of tumors arising in cirrhotic livers seem to occur in a multi- centric distribution and a certain proportion of them may arise from dysplastic nodules (International Working Party 1995). HCCs ranging from 1–2 cm in size may present with a fi brous capsule and/or fi - brous septa in contrast to other indistinct nodular small cancers that have indistinct margins despite such tumors being clearly detected as hypoechoic or hyperechoic focal lesions on ultrasound (US) exami- nation. The latter have been considered carcinoma in situ of the liver due to the absence of invasion into the portal vein branches and intrahepatic metastases (Kojiro 2002). Minute HCCs of the indistinct nodu- lar type are diffi cult to differentiate from high grade dysplastic nodules. The majority of small (less than 1.5 cm) HCCs of the indistinct nodular type are not detected as hypervascular tumors by contrast imaging, whereas distinct nodular type tumors almost invari- ably show hypervascular features during the arterial phase of contrast imaging (Kojiro 2002). A combina- tion of the lack of fi brotic capsule and reduced num- ber of unpaired arteries per square millimeter in less than 1.5 cm tumors accounts for many false negative diagnoses of HCC with contrast imaging. Since well- differentiated tumors in the early stages proliferate along with the occurrence of gradual dedifferentiation (Kojiro 1998), more histological grades are seen in tu- mors greater than 1 cm in size. A “nodule-in-nodule”
Fig. 12.3. Acinar clear-cell hepatocellular carcinoma. Clear-cell hepatocytes are arranged in glands with lumen fi lled by bili- ary plugs (×120)
Fig. 12.4. Solid hepatocellular carcinoma. Nodular growth of neoplastic hepatocytes with prominent nucleoli. The cells grow in solid sheets with few vascular channels (×120)
Fig. 12.5. Undifferentiated hepatocellular carcinoma.
Pleomorphic liver cells growing in solid pattern with evidence of many syncytial giant cells (×75)
Fig. 12.2. Acinar hepatocellular carcinoma. Prevalence of
acinar pattern of well-differentiated hepatocytes arranged in
acini with dilated lumen (×30)
appearance has been documented in less differenti- ated tumors expanding with a clear boundary within a well-differentiated tumor.
Biopsy examination of 1–2 cm nodules in patients with cirrhosis often implies differential diagnosis between a well-differentiated HCC and a large regen- erative nodule. Histological changes seen in a biop- sied nodule are best evaluated in comparison with those of control extranodular tissue from the same liver (Table 12.1) (Borzio et al. 1994). Moderately differentiated HCC has a typical trabecular pattern, whereas poorly differentiated HCC may show a tra- becular, solid or sarcomatous like pattern.
12.4
Special Types of Tumors
Special types of HCC have distinct histologic pat- terns and natural history: fi brolamellar carcinoma, clear cell HCC and pedunculated HCC. Fibrolamellar carcinoma is composed of large eosinophilic cells arranged in thin or thick trabeculae that are sur- rounded by fi brous bounds with lamellar stranding
makes fi brolamellar carcinoma more often suitable for resection than the usual HCC (Craig 1997).
12.5 Diagnosis
Both cytohistologic criteria and non-invasive crite- ria allow diagnosis of HCC (Table 12.2). In patients with chronic liver disease, large tumors are easily diagnosed by combining clinical and radiological procedures. Arterial hypervascularization by tripha- sic spiral CT or MR of a liver mass identifi ed by abdominal US, is diagnostic for HCC (Bruix et al.
2001). Diagnosis is further confi rmed by greater than 400 ng/ml serum levels of AFP. During the arterial phase of spiral CT highly vascularized HCCs appear against a background of relatively unenhanced liver that is primarily contrasted during the late portal vein phase. In patients not fulfi lling these diagnostic criteria, the diagnosis of HCC is made by echo-guided aspiration cytology or microhistology (Bruix et al.
2001). The histological diagnosis of HCC is needed in the absence of contraindications and when a defi nite diagnosis may infl uence the choice of treatment. The diagnosis of small HCCs (1–2 cm in diameter) identi- fi ed by chance or during surveillance, may be diffi - cult. In principle, a lesion seen as either a hypoechoic or hyperechoic nodule in the liver of a patient with chronic liver disease should be presumed to be a pre- neoplastic lesion, like a macroregenerative nodule, or an HCC, and should be investigated accordingly.
For tumors of 1–2 cm in diameter the risk of false negative diagnoses with contrast imaging technique could be as high as 50% due to immature arterial vascularization of the nodule (Kojiro 2002). The highest diagnostic accuracy (85%) for these nodules was provided by the combined use of fi ne needle as- piration cytology plus intranodular and extranodu- lar fi ne needle microhistology (Table 12.1) (Borzio et al. 1994). Complications in patients subjected to
Fig. 12.6. Fibrolamellar hepatocellular carcinoma. Cords of neoplastic liver cells are separated by lamellar fi brous strands (×75)
Table 12.1. Diagnostic accuracy of fi ne-needle aspiration (A) and biopsy (B) of 36 ≤2-cm nodules developing in patients with compensated cirrhosis
Liver sampling Accuracy
Intra- + extranodular A+B 85%
Intranodular A+B 78%
Intra- + extranodular B 67%
Intranodular B 54%
Intranodular A 31%
(Fig. 12.6). The tumor occurs primarily in non-cir-
rhotic livers of young adults with equal frequency
in males and females. In the USA the incidence of
this tumor is approximately 1% of all HCCs. Serum
α-fetoprotein (AFP) is elevated in a minority of the
patients. In half the patients, an abdominal X-ray
reveals minute calcifi cations within the tumor that
are uncommon in HCC. The fact that the tumor is
sharply demarcated and arises in non-cirrhotic livers
fi ne-needle biopsy are hemoperitoneum (<0.5%) and tumor seeding along the needle track (3%–5%) (Takamori et al. 2000; Kim et al. 2000). Recently, 3D image reconstruction techniques by MR was proven to be superior to spiral CT in the diagnosis of HCC nodules of 1–2 cm in size (84% vs 47% detection rates). As expected both imaging techniques failed to recognize tumors of less than 1 cm in diameter (32%
vs 10% detection rates) as a consequence of poor arterialization of small nodules (Table 12.3) (Burrel
et al. 2003). Cases not resolved by imaging or liver biopsy should be followed up with imaging tech- niques performed at 3-month intervals (enhanced follow-up), until diagnosis is obtained (Fig. 12.7). The differential diagnosis of HCC or fi brolamellar carci- noma includes focal nodular hyperplasia, metastatic carcinomas, neuroendocrine carcinoma and cholan- giocarcinoma (Craig 1997).
12.6 Staging
Staging is a crucial variable in treatment outcome since many therapeutic failures have resulted from incorrect patient selection. Tumor dedifferentiation and vascular invasion by tumor cells have constantly emerged as independent predictors of shortened survival in patients undergoing hepatic resection or transplantation for HCC. Although, tumor size and number appear to be clinical surrogates predicting tumor dedifferentiation and vascular invasion, tu- mor-related criteria like the tumor, node and me- tastases (TNM) classifi cation do not accurately pre- dict patient survival. The latter is better predicted by criteria combining tumor characteristics, func- tional status and liver function. Triphasic spiral CT and dynamic MR are currently used for assessing the number, size and vascular invasiveness of the tumor.
In the Barcelona Clinic Liver Cancer staging classi- fi cation the functional status of the patient and the liver status are measured by the Performance Status and Child-Pugh score system, respectively (Llovet et al. 1999). The Barcelona classifi cation comprises four stages that select the best candidates for the best therapies available, i.e. from early tumor stage (Stage
Fig. 12.7. Surveillance of patients with compensated cirrhosis as suggested by the Conference of the European Association for the Study of the Liver
Table 12.2. Diagnostic criteria for hepatocellular carcinoma as proposed during the Conference of the European Association for the Study of the Liver in Barcelona
• Cytohistologic criteria
• Non-invasive criteria (cirrhotic patients) 1. Radiological criteria:
Two coincident imaging techniquesa
Focal lesion >2 cm with arterial hypervascularization 2. Combined criteria:
One imaging technique associated to AFP
Focal lesion >2 cm with arterial hypervascularization AFP levels >400 ng/ml
a