• Non ci sono risultati.

Gruppo Solidarietà

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Condividi "Gruppo Solidarietà"

Copied!
33
0
0

Testo completo

(1)

CAMERA DEI DEPUTATI

Doc. CCXVII n. 1

R E L A Z I O N E

SULLO STATO DI ATTUAZIONE DELLE INI- ZIATIVE PER IL SUPERAMENTO DEGLI

OSPEDALI PSICHIATRICI GIUDIZIARI

(Aggiornata al 30 settembre 2014)

(Articolo 1, comma 2-bis, del decreto-legge 31 marzo 2014, n. 52, convertito, con modificazioni, dalla legge 30 maggio 2014, n. 81)

Presentata dal Ministro della salute (LORENZIN)

e dal Ministro della giustizia (ORLANDO)

Trasmessa alla Presidenza il 30 settembre 2014

STABILIMENTI TIPOGRAFICI CARLO COLOMBO

ATTI PARLAMENTARI

XVII LEGISLATURA

(2)

2UUL =DSMDNHOUDSL * 4DNHSD GHL 5HQVUDUL

ED:: ;68:A;2BC@2 ^ 5:A68=: 5: ;6886 6 @6;2F:>=: ^ 5>4C<6=B: ^ 5>4% 44ED:: =% ,

@LQH[PTSL HQ ?HVQHRLSXT WYQ ?VTNVHRRH KP WYULVHRLSXT KLNQP >WULKHQP ?WPJOPHXVPJP 8PYKP[PHVP# HP WLSWP KLQ KLJVLXT$QLNNL *( RHV[T )'(+# S%,)# JTSZLVXPXT KHQQH QLNNL *'

RHNNPT )'(+ S% /(

@"RZ`^N`N VZ bVT[^R QRX QRP^R`[(XRTTR ., Y N^d[ -+,/' Z)0-' P[ZbR^`V`[' P[Z Y [QVSVPNdV[ZV' QNXXN XRTTR .+ Y NTTV[ -+,/ Z)3,' U N VZ`^[Q[``[ aX`R^V[^V NQ RY \VY RZ`V R _PNQRZdR ^V_\R``[ N ] a N Z `[ TVe \^RbV_`[

QNXXN Z[^Y N`VbN bVTRZ`R VZ Y N`R^VN QV C _\RQNXV D_VPUVN`^VPV = VaQVdVN^V #CD=$)

?Z \N^`VP[XN^R' XR Y [QVSVPUR VZ `^[Q[``R \^R_P^Vb[Z[ PUR VX TVaQVPR Q V_\ [ Z T N ZRV P[ZS^[Z`V QR>"VZSR^Y[ [ QRX _RY VZSR^Y [ QV Y RZ`R X"N\\XVPNdV[ZR QV aZN Y V_a^N QV _VPa^RddN QVbR^_N QNX

^VP[bR^[ VZ CD= [ VZ a Z N PN_N QV Pa^N R QV Pa_`[QVN' NQ RPPRdV[ZR QRV PN_V VZ PaV RY R^T NZ [ RXRY RZ`V QNV ]aNXV ^V_aX`V PUR' [TZV NX`^N Y V_a^N QVbR^_N QNX ^VP[bR^[ VZ [_\RQNXR \_VPUVN`^VP[ T VaQVdVN^V[ Z[Z _VN VQ[ZRN NQ N__VPa^N^R Pa^R NQ RT a N`R R N SN^R S^[Z`R NXXN _aN \R^VP[X[_V`e _[PVNXR' VX PaV NPPR^`NY RZ`[ g RSSR``aN`[ _aXXN ON_R QV ] a N Z `[ _`NOVXV`[ Q NXX"N^`) ,' P[Y Y N / QRX :@ -- QVPRY O^R -+,, Z) -,,' P[ZbR^`V`[ P[Z Y [QVSVPNdV[ZV QNXVN XRTTR ,2 SROO^NV[ -+,-' Z) 4)

,) C ^T N Z V_Y [ QV P[ [ ^Q VZ N Y RZ `[

IZN QRXXR Z[bV`e VZ `^[Q[``[ QNXXN \^R_P^VdV[ZV QRXXN XRTTR .+ Y NTTV[ -+,/ Z)3, g PUR bRZTN V_`V`aV`[

\^R__[ VX A VZV_`R^[ QRXXN _NXa`R aZ C ^TNZV_Y [ QV 9 [[^QVZNY RZ`[ QRX \^[PR__[ QV _a \ R ^N Y RZ `[

QRTXV CD=) HNXR C ^TNZV_Y [ g \^R_VRQa`[' SDULPOH NDUHSLDH$ QNX G[``[_RT^R`N^V[ :[``) JV`[ : R <VXV\\[)

?Z ^RXNdV[ZR N XX"N ^`)X' P[Y Y N - OV_' PUR _`NOVXV_PR PUR RZ `^[ `^RZ`N TV[^ZV QNXXN QN`N QV RZ`^N`N VZ bVT[^R QRXXN XRTTR QV P[ZbR^_V[ZR QRX QRP^R`[ XRTTR ., Y N^d[ -+,/' Z) 0- #R ] a VZ Q V NXXN QN`N QRX , XaTXV[ -+,/$ g N``VbN`[ \^R__[ VX A VZV_`R^[ QRXXN _NXa `R aZ [^TNZV_Y [ QV P[[^Q VZ NY RZ `[ \R^ VX _a\R^NY RZ`[ QRTXV [_\RQNXV \_VPUVN`^VPV TVaQVdVN^V) @ "[^TNZV_Y [ ^V_aX`N V_`V`aV`[' P[Z QRP^R`[ QRX A VZV_`^[ QRXXN _NXa`R' VZ QN`N -1 TVa T Z [ -+,/ #7 XXRTN`[ , ( QRP^R`[ QRX A VZV_`^[$)

7 ^VTaN^Q[' P[Z Z[`R VZ QN`N -1 TVaTZ[ -+,/' Z) 0+2.' 0+2/ R 0+20 N SV^Y N QRXX"C Z)?R A VZV_`^[' VZbVN`R ^V_\R``VbNY RZ`R NX A VZV_`^[ QRXXN TVa_`VdVN' NX D ^R_VQRZ`R QRXXN 9 [ZSR^RZdN QRXXR FRTV[ZV R QRXXR D^[bVZPR 7 a`[Z[Y R R NX A VZV_`^[ \R^ TXV NSSN^V ^RTV[ZNXV R XR Na`[Z[Y VR' _[Z[ _`N`R ^VPUVR_`R XR QR_VTZNdV[ZV QRV ^N\\^R_RZ`NZ`V QRV ^RXN`VbV A VZV_`R^V R QRX ^N\ \ ^R_RZ `NZ `R QRXX"I SSVPV[ QV GRT^R`R^VN QRXXN 9 [ZSR^RZdN \ R^Y NZRZ`R \R^ V ^N\ \ [ ^`V `^N X[ G`N`[' XR FRTV[ZV R XR D^[bVZPR 7 a`[Z[Y R QV H^RZ`[ R 8[XdNZ[ P[_h P[Y R VZQVPN`V ZRX PV`N`[ QRP^R`[ Y VZV_`R^VNXR QgV -1 TVa T Z [ -+,/)

(3)

2UUL =DSMDNHOUDSL

% / (

4DNHSD GHL 5HQVUDUL

ED:: ;68:A;2BC@2 ^ 5:A68=: 5: ;6886 6 @6;2F:>=: ^ 5>4C<6=B: ^ 5>4% 44ED:: =% ,

?X A VZV_`R^[ QRXXN TVa_`VdVN' P[Z Z[`N QRX .+ TVa T Z [ -+,/' Z) -.++2' UN b[Xa`[ Q N ^R XN Y N__VY N

^VXRbNZdN NXXN \^[OXRY N`VPN NT T Va Z T RZ Q [ NV `^R \^RbV_`V aZ _a [ aX`R^V[^R ^N\\^R_RZ`NZ`R5 ,$ JVPR(A VZV_`^[' CZ) ;Z^VP[ 9[_`N6

-$ 9N\[ QV = NOVZR``[ [ _a[ QRXRTN`[6

.$ 9N\[ QRXHISSVPV[ @RTV_XN`Vb[ [ _a[ QRXRTN`[6

/$ JVPR 9 N\[ JVPN^V[ : V\N^`VY RZ`[ QRI "NY Y VZV_`^NdV[ZR \RZV`RZdVN^VN [ _a[ QRXRTN`[)

BRXXN _RQa`N Q R X X"XX _R``RY O^R -+,/ XN 9 [ZSR^RZdN QRXXR ^RTV[ZV R QRXXR \^[bVZPR Na `[ Z [ Y R UN VZQVbVQaN`[ V ^N\ \ ^R_R Z `NZ `V ^RTV[ZNXV VZ _RZ[ NX _a Q Q R ``[ [^TNZV_Y [5 R__V _[Z[ TXV 7 __R__[^V NXXN GNXa`R QRXXR FRTV[ZV ;YVXVN F[Y NTZN' @VTa^VN' DaTXVN' G N^QRTZN R H[_PNZN)

?X ,4 _R``RY O^R -+,/ g _`N`[ Q R_VTZN`[ VX ^N\ \ ^R_R Z `NZ `R QR>"ISSVPV[ QV _RT^R`R^VN QRXXN 9 [ZSR^RZdN DR^Y NZRZ`R \R^ V ^N\ \ [ ^`V `^N X[ G`N`[' XR FRTV[ZV R XR D^[bVZPR Na`[Z[Y R' ZRXXN \ R^_[ZN QRXXN Q[``)__N @Na^N DRXXRT^VZV)

-) @R``R^N NTXV 7 __R__[^V NXXN G NXa `R Q N \ N ^`R QRX G [ ``[ _R T ^R `N^V[ R SN_V _aPPR__VbR

?Z ^RXNdV[ZR NXX"N ^`)X' P[Y Y N , UHS$ QRXXN XRTTR' PUR _`NOVXV_PR PUR V \R^P[^_V `R^N\Ra`VP[(^VNOVXV`N`VbV VZQVbVQaNXV QV QVY V__V[ZR Q V PVN_PaZN QRXXR \R^_[ZR ^VP[bR^N`R ZRTXV [_\RQNXV \_VPUVN`^VPV TVa Q VdVN^V NXXN QN`N QV RZ`^N`N VZ bVT[^R QRXXN XRTTR QV P[ZbR^_V[ZR QRb[Z[ R__R^R [ OOXVTN`[^VNY RZ`R

\^RQV_\[_`V R VZbVN`V NX A VZV_`R^[ QRXXN _NXa`R R NXXN P[ Y \R`RZ`R Na `[ ^V`e T Va Q Vd VN ^VN RZ `^[

RVDSDOUDFLORVH JLPSOL QNXXN Q N`N QV RZ `^N`N VZ bVT[^R QRXXN XRTTR QV P[ZbR^_V[ZR QRX \^R_RZ`R QRP^R`[

#R ]aVZ Q V NXXN Q N`N QRX ,0 XaTXV[ -+,/$) ?X G[``[_RT^R`N^V[ VZ Q N`N - XaTXV[ -+,/ UN VZbVN`[ a Z N Z[`N NTXV 7 __R__[^V NXXN GNZV`e QRXXR ^RTV[ZV R QRXXR DD)77) S[^ZRZQ[ VZQVPNdV[ZV \R^ X"VZbV[ QRV

\^[T^NY Y V #7 XXRTN`[ - ( Z [ `N NTXV N__R__[^V$)

GV g P[ZbRZa`[ #NZPUR VZ _RQR QV 9 [Y V`N`[ \N^V`R`VP[ VZ `R^V_`V`adV[ZNXR \^R__[ XN 9 [ZSR^RZdN IZVSVPN`N$ PUR \R^ VX A VZV_`R^[ QRXXN _NXa`R XN SVZNXV`e Q RXX"NP]aV_VdV[ZR QRV \VNZV VZ Q Vb VQ a NXV \R^

PVN_PaZN \R^_[ZN QVY V__VOVXR \^R_RZ`R VZ CD= NXXN Q N`N QRX , TVaTZ[ QRX P[ ^^RZ`R NZZ[' Q N `N QV RZ`^N`N VZ bVT[^R QRXXN XRTTR' Z[Z \a i PUR R__R^R ]aRXXN QRX _RY \XVPR Y [ZV`[^NTTV[ Q RXX"Nb b RZ a `N

\^RQV_\[_VdV[ZR \R^ XN \^R_N VZ PN^VP[ `R^^V`[^VNXR #SVZNXV`e QVbR^_N QN ]aRXXN PUR VZbRPR P[Y \R`R NXX"7 a`[^V`e TVaQVdVN^VN N PaV \ a ^R VX \R^P[^_[ bN VZbVN`[$)

BRXXN Z[`N N SV^Y N QRX G [``[_RT^R`N^V[ _[Z[ _`N`R ] a VZ Q V R_\XVPV`N`R' NX SVZR QV [ Y [TRZRVddN^R XN _`^a ``a ^N QRTXV VZbVV ^RTV[ZNXV' XR VZS[^Y NdV[ZV ^VPUVR_`R' ^R_R ] a NZ `[ \Vj _RY \XVPV R Y V^N`R \[__VOVXR' R P[Z QN`V ^VT[^[_NY RZ`R NZ[ZVY V \R^ Z[Z P[Z`^NbbRZV^R NXXR QV_\[_VdV[ZV ^RXN`VbR NXXN QSLWDFX&

JN P[Y aZ]aR _[``[XVZRN`[ PUR' bV_`[ PUR XN XRTTR _`NOVXV_PR _[X[ XN P[Y aZVPNdV[ZR VZ Y R^V`[ NXXR

\R^_[ZR \^R_RZ`V VZ CD= NXXpRZ `^N`N VZ bVT[^R QRXXN XRTTR #+,)+1)-+,/$' R Z[Z ^RXN`VbNY RZ`R N ]aNZ`V SN^NZZ[ VZT^R__[ VZ CD= ZRV YR_V _aPPR__VbV' VX Y [ZV`[^NTTV[ QV VZT^R__V R a_PV`R' ^VRZ`^V QN R bR^_[ V :GA QNTXV CD=' P[_h P[Y R N``a NXY RZ `R \^RbV_`[' \ [ `^RO O R Z[Z Q N^R aZ RSSR``Vb[ ] a N Q ^[ QRXXR Rb[XadV[ZV QRXXN _V`aNdV[ZR)

(4)

2UUL =DSMDNHOUDSL

( 0 (

4DNHSD GHL 5HQVUDUL

ED:: ;68:A;2BC@2 ^ 5:A68=: 5: ;6886 6 @6;2F:>=: ^ 5>4C<6=B: ^ 5>4% 44ED:: =% ,

*% 8 QP HWULXXP KP JTR ULXLS[H K K Q!2 R R PS PWXVH[PTS L ?LSPXLS[PHVPH L P KHXP WY QQL U VLWLS[L S LNQP > WULKHQP ?WPJOPHXVPJP 8 PYKP[PHVP

DR^ ]aNZ`[ N``VRZR NTXV N_\R``V QV P[Y \R`RZdN QRXX"7 Y Y VZ V_`^NdV[ Z R DRZV`RZdVN^VN VZ Y R^V`[ NXXR QV^R``VbR RY NZN`R QNXXN @RTTR 3,*-+,/ QV P[ZbR^_V[ZR QRX QRP^R`[ XRTTR ., Y N^d[ -+,/' Z) 0-' _V

^N\\^R_RZ`N PUR _[Z[ _`N`R \^RQ V_\ [ _`R N``VbV`e b[X`R N b NXa`N^R X"VY \ N ``[ QRXXR Z a[bR QV_\[_VdV[ZV _aXXN ^RNX`e QRTXV C _\RQNXV D_VPUVN`^VPV = VaQVdVN^V' N``^NbR^_[ Y [ZV`[^NTTV RQ R_NY R QRV QN`V)

G[Z[ _`N`R ^VXRbN`R XR \^R_RZdR QRTXV VZ`R^ZN`V ZRTXV C _\RQNXV D_VPUVN`^VPV = VaQVdVN^V QRX `R^^V`[^V[

ZNdV[ZNXR' \ R^ bR^VSVPN^R X"NZ Q N Y RZ `[ QRXXR QVY V__V[ZV QRV _[TTR``V _[``[\[_`V NXXN Y V_a^N QV _VPa^RddN Q R`RZ`VbN QRX ^VP[bR^[ VZ [_\RQNXR \_VPUVN`^VP[ T Va Q Vd VN ^V[ R QRXX"N__RT Z NdV[ Z R N PN_N QV Pa^N R Pa_`[QVN N _RTaV`[ Q RXX"RZ `^N`N VZ bVT[^R QRXXN @RTTR 3,*-+,/)

@"R_NY R UN RbVQRZdVN`[ P[Y R ZRV YR_V _aPPR__VbV NXX"RZ `^N`N VZ bVT[^R QRXXN XRTTR' ZRX \ R^V[Q[

P[Y \^R_[ `^N Y NTTV[ R _R``RY O^R -+,/ 2QQLNHXT .$' _V g ^VXRbN`N a ZN XRTTR^N Y N P[_`NZ`R QVY VZ a dV[ Z R QRXXR \^R_RZdR' PUR NXXN QN`N QRX 4 _R``RY O^R -+,/ bRQ R 24. ?Z`R^ZN`V \^R_RZ`V N S^[Z`R QRTXV 33+ NXXN QN`N QRX ., TRZZNV[ -+,/ #=^NSVP[ .$)

E aR_`[ QN`[ bN P[Y \N^N`[ P[Z ]aRXX[ QRV SXa__V QRTXV VZT^R__V ZRTXV C _\RQNXV D_VPUVN`^VPV = VaQVdVN^V PUR ZRXX"N^P[ QV aZ `^VY R_`^R _V g b NXa`N`[ N``R_`N^_V Y RQVNY RZ`R VZ `[ Y [ N PV^PN ,+ \NdVRZ`V \ R^

PVN_PaZ CD=' \R^ aZ `[`NXR QV 12 \R^_[ZR N `^VY R_`^R)

BRX \R^V[Q[ PUR bN QNX ,k TVaTZ[ -+,/ NX 4 _R``RY O^R -+,/ _V g Nb a `[ ," VZT^R__[ QV 3/ \R^_[ZR ZRTXV C)D)=)

GV g \ ^[bbRQa`[' NX`^R_h' NQ R_NY VZN^R XR [ ^Q VZ NZ d R RY R__R QNXXN 7 a`[^V`e = VaQVdVN^VN5 ]aRXXR

\R^bRZa`R P[Z`RZT[Z[ TXV RXRY RZ`V ZRPR__N^V N Y [`VbN^R XN \^[_RPadV[ZR QRXXN Y V_a^N QV _VPa^RddN QR`RZ`VbN VZ \^R_RZdN QV aZ"NPPR^`N`N \R^_V_`RZ`R \R^VP[X[_V`e _[PVNXR QRX \ NdVRZ`R VZ`R^ZN`[' [bbR^[

XN `^N_S[^Y NdV[ZR QRXXN Y V_a^N QV _VPa^RddN Q R`RZ`VbN VZ XVOR^`e bVTVXN`N #Y V_a^N QV _VPa^RddN Z[Z QR`RZ`VbN$' [bbR^[ XN ^Rb[PN QRXXN Y V_a^N QV _VPa^RddN \R^ _PRY N`N \R^VP[X[_V`e _[PVNXR QRX \ NdVRZ`R VZ`R^ZN`[)

: NXX"R_NY R QV [TZV _VZT[X[ \^[bbRQVY RZ`[' _V g \[`a `[ ^VXRbN^R P[Y R XR \Vj ^RPRZ`V [^Q VZ NZ dR RY R__R QNX P[Y \R`RZ`R Y NTV_`^N`[ QV _[^bRTXVNZdN P[Z`RZT[Z[ aZ \^RPV_[ R Q R``NTXVN`[ R_NY R QRXXR P[ZQVdV[ZV QRX _[TTR``[' Q N Z Q [ N``[ QRXXN S[^Y aXNdV[ZR QV aZ \ ^[ T ^N Y Y N QV `^N``NY RZ`[

VZ QVbVQaNXVddN`[ ON_N`[ _aV OV_[TZV QRXXN \R^_[ZN' P[Y \^R_[ VX \R^P[^_[ VZ`^N\ ^R_[ NbRZQ[ P[Y R SVZNXV`e XN ^Rb[PN QRXXN Y V_a^N QV _VPa^RddN QR`RZ`VbN)

? `R^Y VZV QRXXN \^[^[TN \R^ VX ^VR_NY R QRXXN \R^VP[X[_V`e N\\NV[Z[ P[ZT^aV R P[R^RZ`V P[Z VX `RY \[

_`^R``NY RZ`R ZRPR__N^V[ NXXN ^VPR^PN R NX \R^SRdV[ZNY RZ`[ QRX \^[ T ^NY Y N `R^N\Ra`VP[(^VNOVXV`N`Vb[

VZQVbVQaNXR' Q R``NZ Q [ NZPUR NQRY \VY RZ`V N PN^VP[ QRV : V\N^`VY RZ`V QV G NXa`R A RZ`NXR [ QV NX`^V [^TNZV_Y V `R^^V`[^VNXY RZ`R P[Y \R`RZ`V5 X"7 Y Y VZV_`^NdV[ZR _`N bR^VSVPNZQ[ X"[__R^bNZdN QRV _a Q Q R ``V NQRY \VY RZ`V QN \ N^`R QRTXV N``[^V VZ`R^R__N`V)

BRXXR [ ^Q VZ NZ dR bVRZR \^R_P^V``[ aZ `R^Y VZR RZ`^[ VX ]aNXR TXV [^TNZV `R^^V`[^VNXY RZ`R P[Y \R`RZ`V QROO[Z[ QRSVZV^R aZ D^[TR``[ H R^N\Ra`VP[ FVNOVXV`N`Vb[ ?ZQVb VQ a NXVddN`[ #DHF?$' [bbR^[ ^VPR^PN^R aZN _[XadV[ZR NX`R^ZN`VbN NXX"N\\XVPNdV[ZR QV aZN Y V_a^N QV _VPa^RddN QR`RZ`VbN' ] a VZ Q V XR NdV[ZV ZRPR__N^VR NXXN ^Rb[PN QRXXN Y V_a^N QV _VPa^RddN Q R`RZ`VbN RQ NX P[Z_RTaRZ`R ^RVZ_R^VY RZ`[ ZRX P[Z`R_`[ _[PVNXR)

?? \R^P[^_[ SVZ ]aV P[Y \Va`[ UN Q R`R^Y VZN`[ XN ^VQadV[ZR QRV `RY \V \R^ VX ^VR_NY R QRXXN \R^VP[X[_V`e _[PVNXR R \R^ XN SV__NdV[ZR QRXXN Z a[bN aQVRZdN #Y RQVNY RZ`R QNV 0 NV 2 YR_V$)

(5)

2UUL =DSMDNHOUDSL

( 1 (

4DNHSD GHL 5HQVUDUL

ED:: ;68:A;2BC@2 ^ 5:A68=: 5: ;6886 6 @6;2F:>=: ^ 5>4C<6=B: ^ 5>4% 44ED:: =% ,

: NXX"R_NY R QRXXR [^QVZNZdR' PUR VZbRPR P[ZSR^Y NZ[ X"N\ \ XVPNdV[ Z R QRXXN Y V_a^N QV _VPa^RddN QR`RZ`VbN' RY R^TR PUR XN \ ^[^[TN g QV_\[_`N _[X[ ZRV PN_V VZ PaV' Z [ Z [ _`N Z `R _VNZ[ _`N`V VZ`^N\^R_V TXV VZ`R^bRZ`V SVZNXVddN`V NXXN N``a NdV[ Z R QV aZ \^[ T ^NY Y N `R^N\Ra`VP[(^VNOVXV`N`Vb[' _V g P[ Z_`N`N`[ VX

\R^_V_`R^R QRXXN \R^VP[X[_V`e _[PVNXR [ VX ^VRY R^TR^R QV a Z [ _P[Y \RZ_[ \_VP[\N`[X[TVP[) s _`N`[' NX`^R_h' NbbVN`N a Z "NZ N XV_V QRV \^[bbRQVY RZ`V RY R__V Q NXX"7 a `[ ^V`e = Va QVdVN^VN VZ N\\XVPNdV[ZR Q RXX"N^`) , ] a N`R^ QRXXN @RTTR 3,*-+,/ #@R Y V_a^R QV _VPa^RddN QR`RZ `Vb R ))) Z[Z \ [__[Z[ Q a ^N ^R [X`^R VX `RY \[ _`NOVXV`[ \ R^ XN \ RZ N QR`RZ`VbN \^RbV_`N \ R^ VX ^RN`[ P[Y Y R__[' Nb a `[ ^VT a N^Q [ NXXN

\ ^RbV_V[ZR RQ V``NXR Y N__VY N$)

: NXX"R_NY R QRXXR _`R__R' _V g P[Z_`N`N`[ P[Y R NXPaZR 7 a`[^V`e = Va QVdVN^VR U NZ Z [ ^V`R Z a `[ PUR' NQ VZ`R^bRZa`N _PNQRZdN QRX `R^Y VZR Y N__VY [ QV Q a ^N `N QRXXN Y V_a^N QV _VPa^RddN VZ [__R]aV[ N ] a NZ `[ \^RbV_`[ QNXX"N^`) , ] a N`R^ @) 3,*-+,/' ZR__a Z N aX`R^V[^R XVY V`NdV[ZR QRXXN XVOR^`e \R^_[ZNXR

\ ai R__R^R Q V_\[_`N N PN^VP[ QRXX"VZ`R^R__N`[ PUR QRb R R__R^R VZSVZR NSSVQN`[ NXXR Pa ^R QRV \^R_VQV _NZV`N^V _\RPVNXV_`VPV P[Y \R`RZ`V \ R ^ `R^^V`[^V[ VZ N__RZdN QV bVZP[XV VY \[_`V Q NXX"7 a `[ ^V`e

= VaQVdVN^VN6 NX`^[ [ ^VRZ`NY RZ`[ UN VZbRPR ^V`RZa`[ PUR' \ a ^ _R _a \ R ^N `[ VX `R^Y VZR Y N__VY [ \^RbV_`[

QNXXN XRTTR' \ R^Y NZ RZ Q [ XN \R^VP[X[_V`e _[PVNXR' XN Y V_a^N QV _VPa^RddN Q R`RZ `Vb N Q ROON R__R^R

`^N_S[^Y N`N VZ Y V_a^N NX`^N Z[Z QR`RZ`VbN' ]aNXR XN XVOR^`e bVTVXN`N)

GV [__R^bNZ[ V \^VY V RSSR``V QV ]aR_`V \^[b b RQ VY RZ `V PUR ZRPR__V`NZ[ QV R__R^R Y [ Z V`[ ^N `V ZRX XaZT[

\R^V[Q[)

7X SVZR \ R^`NZ`[ QV bNXa `N^R X"VY \ N``[ VZ \^[T^R__V[ZR' g _`N`N NbbVN`N' \^Rb V[ R_NY R QRXXR _VZT[XR

\[_VdV[ZV TVa^VQVPUR' aZ N ^VXRbNdV[ZR _aV QN`V ^RXN`VbV NX Z a Y R^[ QV VZ`R^ZN`V PUR _V `^[bVZ[ ZRXXR P[ZQVdV[ZV \^RbV_`R QNXXN XRTTR RSSR``aNZQ[ aZ N \^[VRdV[ZR N `^R #.+ _R ``R Y O ^R -+,/$' _RV #., QVPRY O^R -+,/$ R Z[bR YR_V #., Y N^d[ -+,0$)

9Vi NZPUR NX SVZR QV _RTZNXN^R NV _R^bVdV `R^^V`[^VNXV P[Y \R`RZ`V XN QVY V__V[ZR QV ] a R_`R \ R^_[ Z R R XN bNXa`NdV[ZR QRXXN ZRPR__V`e QRXXN \^R_N VZ PN^VP[ QN \ N^`R QRTXV [^TNZV_Y V _NZV`N^V `R^^V`[^VNXY RZ`R P[Y \R`RZ`V)

?ZSVZR' ZRX ^V_\R``[ QRX ^N\ \ [ ^`[ QV P[XXNO[^NdV[ZR V_`V`adV[ZNXR P[Z_[XVQN`[_V ZRX P[^_[ QRTXV NZZV

`^N X"7 Y Y VZV_`^NdV[ZR \RZV`RZdVN^VN' XR FRTV[ZV' V : V\N^`VY RZ`V QV _N Xa `R Y RZ`NXR R XN A NTV_`^N`a^N QV _[^bRTXVNZdN' XN : V^RdV[ZR = RZR^NXR : R`RZa`V R H ^N``NY RZ`[ UN VZbV`N`[ V : V^R``[^V QRTXV C _\RQNXV D_VPUVN`^VPV = VaQVdVN^V RQ V D^[bbRQV`[^V FRTV[ZNXV N b[XR^ \^R_`N^R XN Y N__VY N P[XXNO[^NdV[ZR NSSVZPUf' VZ [__R]aV[ NXXR Z a [ b R QV_\[_VdV[ZV XRTV_XN`VbR' _VN \ [^`N`[ N P[ Y \ XR`NY RZ `[ VX \^[PR__[ QV _a \ R^NY RZ `[ QRTXV [_\RQNXV \_VPUVN`^VPV TVaQVdVN^V)

; _`N`[' VZ[X`^R' ^Vb[X`[ NV D^[bbRQV`[^V FRTV[ZNXV X"VZbV`[ N Q N^R \VRZN N``a Nd V[ Z R NXX"7 PP[^Q[ QRX ,.

[``[O^R -+,, _NZPV`[ VZ 9 [ZSR^RZdN I ZVSVPN`N' PUR \ ^RbRQR XN ^RNXVddNdV[ZR QRXXR N^`VP[XNdV[ZV QRX _R^bVdV[ _NZV`N^V[ NXX"VZ `R^Z [ QRTXV ?_`V`a`V \ RZV`RZdVN^V [ ^Q VZ N^V \ R^ X"R_\ XR`N Y R Z `[ QRXXR [__R^bNdV[ZV \R^ X"NPPR^`NY RZ`[ QRXXR VZSR^Y V`e \_VPUVPUR QV PaV NXX"N^`) ,,- QRX :DF -.+*-+++' \R^

X"NPP[TXVRZdN QRXXR \R^_[ZR P[ZQNZZN`R P[Z VZSR^Y V`e \_VPUVPN _[ \ ^Nb b R Z a `N ZRX P[^_[ QRXXN Y V_a^N QR`RZ`VbN #N^`) ,/3 P)\)$ R QRXXR \R^_[ZR P[ZQNZZN`R N \RZN Q VY VZ a V`N \R^ bVdV[ \ N^d VNXR QV Y RZ`R

#N^`) ? X V ' P[Y Y N 0 R 2' :DF -.+*-+++' [TTV [_\V`N`V ZRTXV C _\RQNXV D_VPUVN`^VPV = VaQVdVN^V)

? D^[bbRQV`[^V FRTV[ZNXV VZ _VZR^TVN P[Z XR FRTV[ZV R XR 7 dVRZQR GNZV`N^VR @[PNXV _`NZZ[

P[Y \XR`NZQ[ X"VY \XRY RZ`NdV[ZR QRXXN `a`RXN VZ `^N Y a ^N ^VN QRXXN _NXa `R Y RZ`NXR N``^NbR^_[

X"N__RTZNdV[ZR QV \R^_[ZNXR _NZV`N^V[ R \N^N_NZV`N^V[' ZRPR__N^V[ NQ N__VPa^N^R XN Pa ^N R X"N__V_`RZdN NV Q R`RZa`V PUR QROO[Z[ R__R^R [_\V`N`V ZRXXR \ ^RQ R``R _RdV[ZV)

(6)

2UUL =DSMDNHOUDSL

( 2 (

4DNHSD GHL 5HQVUDUL

ED:: ;68:A;2BC@2 ^ 5:A68=: 5: ;6886 6 @6;2F:>=: ^ 5>4C<6=B: ^ 5>4% 44ED:: =% ,

+% 5HXP WYP ULVJTVWP PS KPZPKY HQP

7X SVZR QV T N^NZ `V^R VX ^V_\R``[ QRXXR QV_\[_VdV[ZV QV PaV NXXN XRTTR Z) 3, Q RX -+,/' XN : V^RdV[ZR P[Y \R`RZ`R QRX A VZV_`R^[ QRXXN GNXa`R _V g N``VbN`N \R^ XN P[ _`^adV[ZR QV aZ QN`N(O N_R RXR``^[ZVP[ VZ PaV _[Z[ _`N`V VZ_R^V`V' ZRX P[^_[ QRV Y R_V QV XaTXV[ R NT[_`[' V QN`V \ R^b RZ a `V QNXXR FRTV[ZV)

E aR_`[ P[Z_RZ`R QV QRXVZRN^R a Z \^VY [ ] a N Q ^[ QRXXN _V`aNdV[ZR' ^N\ \ ^R_R Z `N`[ ZRXXR / `NORXXR R ZRV - T^NSVPV NXXRTN`V

?Z _VZ`R_V' _V ^VXRbN PUR _[Z[ _`N`R VZ_R^V`R `a ``R XR _PURQR \ R^bRZa`R' P[Z XR VZS[^Y NdV[ZV ^RXN`VbR N 3-1 _[TTR``V #N S^[Z`R QRV 3/2 PUR ^V_aX`NZ[ \^R_RZ`V VZ CD=$ QV PaV _V Q R``NTXVN _VN X"C D= QV

\^[bRZVRZdN #HNO) -$ PUR XN FRTV[ZR QV [^VTVZR' PUR _N^e NZPUR ]aRXXN PUR \ ^RZ Q R^e VZ PN^VP[ XN

\R^_[ZN ZRX \R^P[^_[ \[_`(QVY V__V[ZR #HNO) ,$)

G[X`NZ`[ /21 _[TTR``V _[Z[ QVPUVN^N`V QVY V__VOVXV NXXN Q N`N QRX ,*1*-+,/ #HNO) .$' R \R^ XN ] a N_V `[`NXV`e

#/+/ PN_V$ QV R__V VX \R^P[^_[ `R^N\Ra`VP[(^VNOVXV`N`Vb[ \^RbV_`[ g QV `V\[ ^R_VQRZdVNXR #HNO) /$)

?X 4DTH NDODJHS PUR QRb R P[[^QVZN^R X"N\\XVPNdV[ZR QRX \VNZ[ g aZ[ \_VPUVN`^N #12'/!$ [ aZ QV^VTRZ`R Y RQVP[ #--',!$6 ^R_VQaNXR g X"NSSVQNY RZ`[ N SVTa^R QVbR^_R' ]a NXV \ ^VZPV\NXY RZ`R TXV N__V_`RZ`V _[PVNXV #0'1!$ #=^NS) -$)

@N Z[Z QVY V__VOVXV`e QRX _[TTR``[ g N``^VOaV`N N Y [`VbNdV[ZV PXVZVPUR ZRXXN Y NT T V[ ^NZ dN QRV PN_V

#/+'-!$) 7 PPNZ`[ NXXN \R^VP[X[_V`e _[PVNXR #,1'4!$ [ NXXN ZRPR__V`e QV SN^R aX`R^V[^V bNXa`NdV[ZV

#,/'4!$' ^VY NZR a Z P[Z_V_`RZ`R --'0! PUR VZPXaQR XR Y [`VbNdV[ZV \Vj _bN^VN`R' `NXb[X`N Z[Z PUVN^NY RZ`R R_\XVPV`N`R #=^NS) ,$)

7ZPUR NXXN XaPR QRXXN bN^VNOVXV`e ^V_P[Z`^N`N ZRXXN ^N\ \ ^R_R Z `Nd V[ Z R QRV QN`V' _V ^V`VRZR a`VXR _[``[XVZRN^R X"VY \ [ ^`N Z dN QV aZ VY \RTZ[ V_`V`adV[ZNXR b[X`[ N SNb[^V^R a Z Y VTXV[^NY RZ`[ RQ a Z N [Y [TRZRVddNdV[ZR QRXXN ]aNXV`e QRTXV VZ`R^bRZ`V' _VN _aX \VNZ[ QVNTZ[_`VP[ _VN _a X bR^_NZ`R

`R^N\Ra`VP[ ^VNOVXV`N`Vb[) ?X A VZV_`R^[ QRXXN _NXa`R' NQ R_RY \V[' UN SVZNZdVN`[ a Z \^[TR``[ NSSVQN`[

NXX"V_`V`a `[ G a\R^V[^R QV GNZV`e' QNX `V`[X[ J NXa`NdV[ZR QRV \NdVRZ`V ^VP[bR^N`V ZRTXV C _\RQNXV D_VPUVN`^VPV = VaQVdVN^V #CD=$ SVZNXVddN`N N \^[ \ [ _`R QV Y [QVSVPUR QRTXV N__R``V [^TNZVddN`VbV R QV

\^[PR__[ PUR' \ ^[ Y a [ b RZ Q [ ^VPR^PN Y V^N`N' bN NQ NSSVNZPN^_V VZ Y [Q[ _VZR^TVP[ NV \^[ T ^NY Y V QV S[^Y NdV[ZR QRTXV [ \R^N`[^V \^RbV_`V QNXXR _VZT[XR FRTV[ZV)

,% ?VTNVHRRP VLNPTSHQP ULV Q!Y XPQP[[T KLP MTSKP KP UHVXL JTVVLSXL

DR^ ] a NZ `[ ^VT a N^Q N XN bNXa`NdV[ZR QRV \^[T^NY Y V ^RTV[ZNXV ^RXN`VbV NXX"a `VXVdd[ QRV S[ZQV VZ P[Z`[

PN\V`NXR \R^ XN P[_`^adV[ZR QRXXR F;AG R*[ VX \ [ `RZdVNY RZ`[ QRV : V\N^`VY RZ `V Q V _NXa `R Y RZ`NXR

#:GA$' Z[ZPUf \R^ X"a`VXVdd[ QRV SVZNZdVNY RZ`V QV \ N^`R P[^^RZ`R' TXV aSSVPV QRX A VZV_`R^[ UNZZ[

P[XXNO[^N`[ P[_`NZ`RY RZ`R VZ `a``R XR SN_V Q RXX"V_`^a ``[ ^VN QV PVN_PaZ \^[T^NY Y N' \ ^R_`N Z Q [

\N^`VP[XN^R N``RZdV[ZR NTXV N_\R``V PUR \^[Y a [ b [ Z [ N``VbNdV[ZR QV \R^P[^_V _[PVNXY RZ`R VZPXa_VbV _aX

`R^^V`[^V[ R X"NQ R T a N`N S[^Y NdV[ZR Q RX \R^_[ZNXR PUR \ ^RZ Q R VZ PN^VP[ V _[TTR``V N``a NXY RZ `R VZ`R^ZN`V)

?Z \N^`VP[XN^R' _V Qe QV _RTaV`[ Z[`VdVN QRXX[ _`N`[ QRV SVZNZdVNY RZ`V QV \ N^`R P[^^RZ`R QR_`VZN`V NX SaZdV[ZNY RZ`[ QRXXR _`^a ``a ^R ^R_VQRZdVNXV _NZV`N^VR \R^ XpR_RPadV[ZR QRXXN Y V_a^N QV _VPa^RddN

(7)

2UUL =DSMDNHOUDSL

( 3 (

4DNHSD GHL 5HQVUDUL

ED:: ;68:A;2BC@2 ^ 5:A68=: 5: ;6886 6 @6;2F:>=: ^ 5>4C<6=B: ^ 5>4% 44ED:: =% ,

#F;AG$ RQ NXX"N``VbNdV[ZR QV \R^P[^_V `R^N\Ra`VP[ ^VNOVXV`N`VbV `R^^V`[^VNXV \ R^ V _[TTR``V N PaV g N\\XVPN`N aZN Y V_a^N NX`R^ZN`VbN NX ^VP[bR^[ VZ CD= R NXXpN__RTZNdV[ZR N PN_N QV Pa^N R Pa_`[QVN)

=XV N``V Q "VZ `R_N _NZPV`V QNXXN 9 [ZSR^RZdN G`N`[(FRTV[ZV VX 1 QVPRY O^R -+,- R VX 2 SROO^NV[ -+,.' _aX

^V\N^`[ QRV SVZNZdVNY RZ`V QV \ N^`R P[^^RZ`R Q R_`VZN`V NX SaZdV[ZNY RZ`[ QRXXR _`^a ``a ^R ^R_VQRZdVNXV _NZV`N^VR \R^ XpR_RPadV[ZR QRXXN Y V_a^N Q V _VPa^RddN #F;AG$ RQ NXX"N``Vb NdV[ Z R QV \R^P[^_V

`R^N\Ra`VP[(^VNOVXV`N`VbV `R^^V`[^VNXV NX`R^ZN`VbV NXX"C D= ' ^RXN`VbNY RZ`R NTXV NZZV -+,- R -+,.' NSSR^Y NZ[ PUR H ^N``NZQ[_V QRX \^VY [ NZ Z [ QV N\\XVPNdV[ZR' X"R^[TNdV[ZR QRXXR ^V_[^_R _\ R ``N Z `V NXXR

^RTV[ZV g _a O [ ^Q VZ N`N NXX"NQ [ dV[ Z R QRX QRP^R`[ QRX A VZV_`^[ QRXXN _NXa`R' QV P[ZPR^`[ P[Z VX A VZV_`^[

\R^ XN \aOOXVPN NY Y VZV_`^NdV[ZR R XN _RY \XVSVPNdV[ZR R QRX A VZV_`^[ QRXX"RP[Z[Y VN R QRXXR SVZNZdR' QV N\ \^[bNdV[ZR QRV \^[ T ^NY Y V N__V_`RZdVNXV ^RTV[ZNXV \R^ VX P[ Y \XR`NY RZ`[ QRX \^[PR__[ QV _a\ R^NY RZ `[ QRTXV [_\RQNXV \_VPUVN`^VPV TVaQVdVN^V' P[Y \^RZ_VbV QRXXR ^VPUVR_`R QV N__a Z dV[ Z R VZ QR^[TN QRX \R^_[ZNXR ]aNXVSVPN`[ QN QRQVPN^R NZPUR NV \R^P[^_V `R^N\Ra`VP[ ^VNOVXV`N`VbV SVZNXVddN`V NX

^RPa\R^[ R ^RVZ_R^VY RZ`[ _[PVNXR QRV \NdVRZ`V VZ`R^ZN`V \^[bRZVRZ`V QNTXV [_\RQNXV \_VPUVN`^VPV TVaQVdVN^V' P[R^RZ`V P[Z VX \^[ T ^NY Y N QV a`VXVdd[ QRXXR ^V_[^_R \R^ VZbR_`VY RZ`V )

7X SVZR QV NTRb[XN^R XN \^R_RZ`NdV[ZR QRV \ ^[T^NY Y V ^RTV[ZNXV R \R^ b NXa `N^Z R XN P[R^RZdN NTXV [OVR``VbV VZQVPN`V QNX XRTV_XN`[^R' VX A VZV_`R^[ UN `^N_Y R__[ NXXR FRTV[ZV R D^[bVZPR 7 a`[Z[Y R' VZ QN`N -4 [``[O^R -+,.' a Z Q[Pa Y RZ `[ QV VZQV^VddV \R^ XN S[^Y aXNdV[ZR QRX \ ^[ T ^N Y Y N QRTXV VZ`R^bRZ`V QN ^RNXVddN^R)

?Z ON_R NX _a Q Q R ``[ Q[PaY RZ`[' V SVZNZdVNY RZ`V \ [ `^NZ Z [ R__R^R QR_`VZN`V NXX[ _b[XTVY RZ`[ QRXXR _RTaRZ`V N``VbV`e5

,) ?Z`R^bRZ`V \R^ SNb[^V^R XN QVY V__V[ZR R XN \^R_N VZ PN^VP[ QN \ N^`R QRV _R^bVdV QRX Q V\ N ^`VY RZ `[ QV _NXa`R Y RZ`NXR QRV _[TTR``V N PaV g N\\XVPN`N Y V_a^N QV _VPa^RddN QRX ^VP[bR^[ VZ CD= [ QRXX"N__RTZNdV[ZR VZ PN_N QV Pa^N R Pa_`[QVN)

? _[TTR``V QR_`VZN`N^V QV ]aR_`V VZ`R^bRZ`V _[Z[ TXV VZ`R^ZN`V PUR R_P[Z[ QNTXV C D= #R ]aRXXV PUR a_PV^NZZ[ QNXXR F;AG$ \R^ @<; #XVPRZdN SVZNXR QV R_\R^VY RZ`[$ [ @J #XVOR^`e bVTVXN`N$6

-) ?Z`R^bRZ`V \R^ T N^NZ `V^R VX SaZdV[ZNY RZ`[ QRXXR _RdV[ZV \_VPUVN`^VPUR VZ`R^ZR NTXV V_`V`a`V

\RZV`RZdVN^V)

? _[TTR``V QR_`VZN`N^V _[Z[ Q R`RZ a `V P[Z Q V_`a ^O [ Y RZ`NXR' P[Z \N^`VP[XN^R ^VSR^VY RZ`[ NXXR SN``V_\RPVR QV_PV\XVZN`R QNTXV N^`VP[XV ,,, R ,,- QRX :DF -.+*-+++ R NV _[TTR``V QV PaV NXX"N^`VP[X[ ,/3 QRX 9[QVPR DRZNXR' PUR VZ \N__N`[ \[`RbNZ[ R__R^R N__RTZN`V NTXV CD=' R PUR VZ Sa`a^[ _N^NZZ[

N__RTZN`V NXXR _RdV[ZV \_VPUVN`^VPUR QRQVPN`R ZRTXV V_`V`a`V \RZV`RZdVN^V)

.) ?Z`R^bRZ`V \R^ TN^NZ`V^R VX SaZdV[ZNY RZ`[ QRXXR F;AG #_[X[ ^VSR^V`R N F;AG TVe RbRZ `a NXY RZ `R N``VbNOVXV$

? _[TTR``V QR_`VZN`N^V _[Z[ \R^_[ZR PaV _[Z[ N\\XVPN`R XR Y V_a^R QV _VPa^RddN Q R`RZ `Vb N QRX ^VP[bR^[

CD= R QRXX"N__RTZNdV[ZR N PN_N QV Pa^N R Pa_`[QVN)

7XXN QN`N [QVR^ZN' XN _V`aNdV[ZR ^RXN`VbN NXX"V`R^ QV N\ \ ^[ b NdV[ Z R QRV \^[ T ^NY Y V ^RTV[ZNXV QV a`VXVdd[ QRV _aQQR``V SVZNZdVNY RZ`V g VXXa_`^N`N ZRXXN HNORXXN 0)

(8)

2UUL =DSMDNHOUDSL

( 4 (

4DNHSD GHL 5HQVUDUL

ED:: ;68:A;2BC@2 ^ 5:A68=: 5: ;6886 6 @6;2F:>=: ^ 5>4C<6=B: ^ 5>4% 44ED:: =% ,

9[Y R RY R^TR QNXXN `NORXXN' Z[ Z U NZZ[ `^N_Y R__[ aZ \ ^[ T ^NY Y N QV a`VXVdd[ QRV SVZNZdVNY RZ`V XR FRTV[ZV5 <^VaXV JRZRdVN =VaXVN' JNXXR Q"7 [_`N' 9 NY \NZVN' 9 NXNO^VN R GN^QRTZN R XR D^[bVZPR 7 a`[Z[Y R QV H^RZ`[ R QV 8[XdNZ[6

> NZZ[ `^N_Y R__[ aZ \^[ T ^NY Y N QV a`VXVdd[ QRV SVZNZdVNY RZ`V Z [ Z P[ZS[^Y R NXXR VZQVPNdV[ZV Y VZV_`R^VNXV XR FRTV[ZV5 DVRY [Z`R' @[Y ON^QVN' I Y O^VN' A N^PUR' A [XV_R' DaTXVN R GVPVXVN) =XV ISSVPV _[Z[

VZ N``R_N QRXXR VZ`RT^NdV[ZV [ Y [QVSVPUR ^VPUVR_`R)

> NZZ[ `^N_Y R__[ aZ \^[T^NY Y N QV a`VXVdd[ QRV SVZNZdVNY RZ`V P[ZS[^Y R NXXR VZQVPNdV[ZV Y VZV_`R^VNXV XR FRTV[ZV5 @VTa^VN' ;YVXVN F[Y NTZN' H[_PNZN' 7 O^add[' J RZR`[ R @NdV[) DR^ ]a R_`R FRTV[ZV _[Z[ _`N`V

\^RQV_\[_`V TXV _PURY V QV QRP^R`[ VZ`R^Y VZV_`R^VNXR QV N\ \ ^[ b NdV[ Z R QRV \^[T^NY Y V PUR' \R^ XR \^VY R / FRTV[ZV' _[Z[ NXX"R_NY R QRX A VZV_`R^[ QRXX"RP[Z[Y VN R QRXXR SVZNZdR \R^ XN \^RXVY VZN^R P[ZPR^`NdV[ZR

`RPZVPN) @N FRTV[ZR ;YVXVN F [Y NTZN UN ^VPUVR_`[ XN _[_\RZ_V[ZR GHMM LUHS QV N\ \ ^[ b N dV[ Z R QRX QRP^R`[

\R^PUf VZ`RZdV[ZN`N NQ N\ \ [ ^`N ^b V Y [QVSVPUR)

@[ _`N`[ QRXX"V`R^ QV N\\ ^[ b NdV[ Z R QRV \^[TR``V g _VZ`R`VPNY RZ`R VXXa_`^N`[ ZRXXN `NO) 0)

-% @ LHQP[[H[PTSL K LQQL @6<A

@"N^`) , QRXXN XRTTR ., Y NTTV[ -+,/' Z) 3,' Z RXX"N\ \ [ ^`N^R Y [QVSVPNdV[ZV NXXN XRTTR Z) 4*-+,-' \^RbRQR'

`^N X"NX`^[' aZ Za[b[ `R^Y VZR ( ., Y N^d[ -+,0 ( \R^ XN PUVa_a^N QRTXV CD=' Z[ZPUf XN \[__VOVXV`e \ R^ XR FRTV[ZV QV Y [QVSVPN^R RZ`^[ VX ,0 TVaTZ[ -+,/ V \ ^[T^NY Y V \^R_RZ`N`V VZ \^RPRQRZdN ( TVe N\ \ ^[ b N`V QNX A VZV_`R^[ P[Z _\RPVSVP[ :)A) ( NX SVZR QV \^[ b b RQ R^R NXXN ^V]aNXVSVPNdV[ZR QRV Q V\ N ^`VY RZ `V QV _NXa`R Y RZ`NXR R QV P[Z`RZR^R VX ZaY R^[ P[Y \XR__Vb[ QV \[_`V XR``[ QN ^RNXVddN^R ZRXXR _`^a ``a ^R _NZV`N^VR)

4SLUHSL QHS MD WDMVUDYLPOH GHL QSPJSDNNL SHJLPODML

9VN_PaZ \^[T^NY Y N QRbR P[Z`RZR^R XN QR_P^VdV[ZR P[Y \XR__VbN QRTXV VZ`R^bRZ`V \ ^[ T R``a NXV P[Z X"VZQVPNdV[ZR QRX ZaY R^[' Q RXX"aOVPNdV[ZR TR[T^NSVPN R QRXXR PN^N``R^V_`VPUR TRZR^NXV QRXXR _`^a ``a ^R QN

^RNXVddN^R' ZRX ^V_\R``[ QRV ^R]aV_V`V SV__N`V QNX QRP^R`[ QRX A VZV_`^[ QRXXN _NXa`R' QV P[ZPR^`[ P[Z VX A VZV_`^[ QRXXN TVa_`VdVN QRX ,k [``[O^R -+,-' \^RbV_`[ Q NXX"N^`VP[X[ . UHS$ P[Y Y N -' QRX QRP^R`[(XRTTR -- QVPRY O^R -+,,' Z) -,, P[ZbR^`V`[' P[Z Y [QVSVPNdV[ZV' QNXXN XRTTR ,2 SROO^NV[ -+,-' Z) 4) :RbR P[Z`RZR^R' NX`^R_h' aZN b NXa`NdV[ZR _aXXN QVY RZ_V[ZR R P[Y \[_VdV[ZR QRXXR ^V_[^_R aY NZR' R QRXXR _\RPVSVPUR P[Y \R`RZdR ZRPR__N^VR NXXN \VRZN SaZdV[ZNXV`e QRV _R^bVdV _NZV`N^V [\R^N`VbV Q[\[

X"VZ`R^bRZ`[6 Z[ZPUf S[^ZV^R VZS[^Y NdV[ZV PV^PN XR Y [QNXV`e PUR _V VZ `RZ Q [ Z [ N Q [ ``N^R \ R^ VX

^R\R^VY RZ`[ QRXXR ^V_[^_R aY NZR)

CTZV _VZT[X[ \^[TR``[ QRbR P[Z`RZR^R5 VX _[TTR``[ N``aN`[^R' X"aOVPNdV[ZR' XN \[\[XNdV[ZR _R^bV`N' XN

`V\[X[TVN QV VZ`R^bRZ`[ #^V_`^a ``a ^NdV[ Z R [ Za[bN P[_`^adV[ZR$' VX Z a Y R^[ QRV \[_`V XR``[' VX XVbRXX[ QV

\^[TR``NdV[ZR' XN _a\R^SVPVR X[^QN \VNZN \R^ \[_`[ XR``[' V P[_`V _`VY N`V \R^ XR N``VbV`e _NZV`N^VR R \R^ XR Y V_a^R QV _VPa^RddN' XN _`VY N QRV `RY \V QV \^[TR``NdV[ZR' QV N\ \NX`NOVXV`e R XN _`VY N QRV `RY \V QV

^RNXVddNdV[ZR QRXX"[\R^N)

(9)

2UUL =DSMDNHOUDSL

( ,+ (

4DNHSD GHL 5HQVUDUL

ED:: ;68:A;2BC@2 ^ 5:A68=: 5: ;6886 6 @6;2F:>=: ^ 5>4C<6=B: ^ 5>4% 44ED:: =% ,

?X \ ^[T^NY Y N QRbR P[Y \^RZQR^R XN QRSVZVdV[ZR QV a Z _V_`RY N QV VZQVPN`[^V' PN\NPR QV S[^ZV^R VZS[^Y NdV[ZV _aX ^NTTVaZTVY RZ`[ QRTXV [OVR``VbV' _VN P[ZPR^ZRZ`V XN ^RNXVddNdV[ZR R*[ X"NQ R T a NY R Z `[

QRXXR _`^a ``a ^R PUR X"N``VbNdV[ZR R XN P[ ZQadV[ZR Q RV \ ^[ T ^NY Y V `R^N\Ra`VP[(^VNOVXV`N`VbV)

G[Z[ \R^b RZ a `V NTXV ISSVPV P[Y \R`RZ`V' RZ`^[ VX `R^Y VZR _`NOVXV`[ QRX ,0 Y NTTV[ -+,.' V \^[ T ^NY Y V QV

`a ``R XR FRTV[ZV `^NZ Z R ]aRXX[ QRXXN FRTV[ZR JRZR`[)

DR^`NZ`[' ZRX ^V_\R``[ QRXXR QV_\[_VdV[ZV bVTRZ`V' _[ \ ^N _VZ`R`VddN`R' g _`N`N N``VbN`N XN \ ^[ PRQ a ^N QV P[Y Y V__N^VNY RZ`[' P[Z X"VZbV[ QN \ N^`R QRXX"C Z) XR A VZV_`^[' VZ QN`N -+ TVa T Z [ a)_)' NX D ^R_VQ RZ `R QRX 9[Z_VTXV[ QRV A VZV_`^V QRXXN \^[\[_`N QV QVSSVQN NX D ^R_VQRZ`R QRXXN F RTV[ZR JRZR`[) : [\[ NbR^

NP]aV_V`[ VX P[ZPR^`[ QN \ N^`R QRX A VZV_`^[ QRXXN TVa_`VdVN VZ QN`N ,, [ ``[O^R -+,.' VX \^[ PRQ VY RZ `[ g _`N`[ N__RTZN`[ \R^ P[Y \R`RZdN NX A VZV_`^[ \R^ TXV NSSN^V ^RTV[ZNXV R XR Na`[Z[Y VR' PUR VZ Q N`N -3 Z[bRY O^R -+,. UN S[^Y NXY RZ`R QVSSVQN`[ VX D ^R_VQRZ`R QRXXN F RTV[ZR J RZR`[ NQ N Q R Y \ VR ^R NTXV [OOXVTUV QV XRTTR ZRX `R^Y VZR QV ,0 TV[^ZV)

@N bNXa`NdV[ZR QRV \^[T^NY Y V g _`N`N RSSR``aN`N P[ Z T Va Z `NY RZ `R QNTXV ISSVPV P[ Y \R`RZ`V QRXXN : V^RdV[ZR = RZR^NXR QRXXN \ ^[ T^NY Y NdV[ZR _NZ V`N^VN R QRXXN : V^RdV[ZR = RZR^NXR QRXXN \^RbRZdV[ZR QRX A VZV_`R^[ QRXXN _NXa`R)

E aR_`N P[XXNO[^NdV[ZR UN P[Z_RZ`V`[ QV NZNXVddN^R' VZ \N^`VP[XN^R6 XN ^V_\ [ Z Q RZ d N QRV \^[ T ^NY Y V

^RTV[ZNXV NXXR QV_\[_VdV[ZV Z[^Y N`VbR VZ [TTR``[' VZ Y R^V`[ NXXN \^RQ V_\ [ _VdV[ Z R QV \VNZV PUR

\^RbRQR__R^[ "M PEEMLJP QHS MH DYLHOGH TDOLUDSLH MPFDML GL QSHTD LO FDSLFP DMM LOUHSOP GL QSPJHUUL UHSDQHVULFP%

SLDELMLUDULWL LOGLWLGVDML FKH DTTLFVSLOP LM GLSLUUP DMMH FVSH H LM SHLOTHSLNHOUP TPFLDMH$ OPOFKZ D IDWPSLSH M HTHFVYLPOH GL NLTVSH GL TLFVSHYYD DMUHSODULWH DM SLFPWHSP LO <=7 P DMM DTTHJODYLPOH D FDTH GL FVSD H FVTUPGLD"&

H a``R XR FRTV[ZV U NZ Z [ `RZa`[ P[Z`[ QV ]aR_`[ N_\R``[' NZPUR _R XR N^`VP[XNdV[ZV QV Q R``NTXV[ Y [_`^NZ[

XVbRXXV QVbR^_V QV N\\^[S[ZQVY RZ`[' P[_N \ R^NX`^[ \^RbRQVOVXR Z[Z R__RZQ[ VZ Q Vb VQ a N`[ QNXXN Z[^Y N`VbN aZ[ _PURY N QV ^VSR^VY RZ`[)

GV \^RPV_N PUR' NV _RZ_V QRXX"N^`) . QRX QRP^R`[ VZ`R^Y VZV_`R^VNXR -3 QVPRY O^R -+,-' XR FRTV[ZV

@[Y ON^QVN R JNXXR : "7 [_`N' 7 O^add[ R A[XV_R' H[_PNZN R I Y O^VN U NZ Z [ \^[ \ [ _`[ aZ \^[ T ^NY Y N aZV`N^V[) @"NPP[^Q[ `^N ]aR_`R FRTV[ZV \^Rb RQ R PUR TXV VZ`R^ZN`V ^R_VQRZ`V VZ JNXXR Q"7 [_`N' I Y O^VN R A [XV_R _VNZ[ [ _\V`N`V ZRXXR F;AG' ^V_\R``VbNY RZ`R' QRXXR FRTV[ZV @ [Y ON^QVN' H[_PNZN R 7 O^add[' SR^Y [ ^R_`NZQ[ X"VY \ RT Z [ N \^RZQR^XV VZ PN^VP[ ZRV \ ^[\^V _R^bVdV `R^^V`[^VNXV' ] a NZ Q [ ^V`RZa`V QVY V__VOVXV)

7 _RTaV`[ Q RXX"V_`^a ``[ ^VN RSSR``aN`N QNTXV ISSVPV P[Y \R`RZ`V QRX A VZV_`R^[ QRXXN GNXa`R' _aXXN ON_R QRV

^R]aV_V`V _`NOVXV`V Q NX QRP^R`[ VZ`R^Y VZV_`R^VNXR ,k [ ``[O^R -+,-' Q NX QRP^R`[ VZ`R^Y VZV_`R^VNXR -3 QVPRY O^R -+,- R QV ] a NZ `[ \^RbV_`[ Q NX QRP^R`[(XRTTR -- SROO^NV[ -+,,' Z) -,,' P[ZbR^`V`[' P[Z Y [QVSVPNdV[ZV' QNXXN XRTTR ,2 SROO^NV[ -+,-' Z)4 R _)Y)' P[Z \N^`VP[XN^R ^VSR^VY RZ`[ NXX"N^`VP[X[ .%UHS$

\Vj b[X`R PV`N`[ #\R^P[^_V `R^N\Ra`VP[(^VNOVXV`N`VbV$' XR : V^RdV[ZV VZ`R^R__N`R U NZ Z [ R_\^R__[ \N^R^R SNb[^Rb[XR _aV \^[T^NY Y V \^R_RZ`N`V' SN``N R_PXa_V[ZR QRX JRZR`[' QNXXR FRTV[ZV5 DVRY [Z`R'

@[Y ON^QVN(J NXXR : "7 [_`N' <^VaXV JRZRdVN = VaXVN' @VTa^VN' ;YVXVN F [Y NTZN' H[_PNZN(I Y O^VN' A N^PUR' @NdV[' 7 O^add[(A [XV_R' 9 NY \NZVN' DaTXVN' 8N_VXVPN`N' 9 NXNO^VN' GVPVXVN R GN^QRTZN)

DR^ QR``R FRTV[ZV _V g \ ^[PRQa`[ N ^VPUVRQR^R NX A VZV_`R^[ QRXX"RP[Z[Y VN R QRXXR SVZNZdR VX P[ZPR^`[

`RPZVP[ SVZNZdVN^V[ \ ^[\RQRa`VP[ NXX"NQ [ dV[ Z R QRX : RP^R`[ QRX A VZV_`^[ QRXXN _N Xa `R QV N__RTZNdV[ZR QRXXR ^V_[^_R)

(10)

2UUL =DSMDNHOUDSL

( ,, (

4DNHSD GHL 5HQVUDUL

ED:: ;68:A;2BC@2 ^ 5:A68=: 5: ;6886 6 @6;2F:>=: ^ 5>4C<6=B: ^ 5>4% 44ED:: =% ,

7XXN QN`N QRX .+ NT[_`[ -+,/' N _RTaV`[ QRXX"NP]aV_VdV[ZR QRX P[ZPR^`[ `RPZVP[ SVZNZdVN^V[ QRX A VZV_`R^[ QRXX"RP[Z[Y VN R QRXXR SVZNZdR' _[Z[ _`N`V _[``[_P^V``V' QNX G [``[_RT^R`N^V[ QV G`N`[ QRXRTN`[ V QRP^R`V QRXXR FRTV[ZV5 DVRY [Z`R' @[Y ON^QVN(J NXXR : "7 [_`N' <^VaXV J RZRdVN =VaXVN' @VTa^VN' ;YVXVN F[Y NTZN' H[_PNZN(I Y O^VN' A N^PUR' @NdV[' 7 O^add[(A [XV_R' 9 NY \NZVN' DaTXVN' 8N_VXVPN`N' 9 NXNO^VN R GN^QRTZN) : R``V QRP^R`V' NP]aV_V`[ VX bV_`[ QV P[Z`^[XX[ Q N \ N^`R QRTXV [^TNZV P[Y \R`RZ`V' _[Z[ _`N`V

\aOOXVPN`V _aXXN = NddR``N ISSVPVNXR)

BRXXN `NORXXN 1 _[Z[ R_\XVPV`N`V V `V`[XV QV PVN_PaZ VZ`R^bRZ`[ \ R^ _VZT[XN FRTV[ZR' VX P[_`[ P[Y \XR__Vb[

QV R__[' VX ZaY R^[ Q V \)X) QN ^RNXVddN^R' XR _[Y Y R PUR _N ^N Z Z [ [TTR``[ QV _aPPR__VbV \ ^[ T ^NY Y V

^RXN`VbV NX \[`RZdVNY RZ`[ QRV \R^P[^_V `R^N\Ra`VP[(^VNOVXV`N`VbV) @N `NORXXN 2 ^V\[^`N XN _`VY N QRV `RY \V QV \^[TR``NdV[ZR' N\\NX`NOVXV`e R QV ^RNXVddNdV[ZR)

?X ZaY R^[ P[Y \XR__Vb[ QRV \[_`V XR``[ ZRXXR _`^a ``a ^R VZ R_NY R PUR _V \ ^Rb RQ R QV ^RNXVddN^R _[Z[ 44+' P[Z aZ N N^`VP[XNdV[ZR QV _`^a ``a ^R ^R_VQRZdVNXV N QVSSR^RZ`R XVbRXX[ Q V VZ`RZ_V`e N__V_`RZdVNXR) HNXR Z a Y R^[ g VZSR^V[^R NX Z a Y R^[ QRV _[TTR``V Q R_`VZN`N^V QRXXR Y V_a^R QV _VPa^RddN NX .,*,-*-+,,) @N

^VQadV[ZR' P[Y R TVe QR``[' g Q [ b a `N NXXN \^[T^R__VbN N``VbNdV[ZR QRV \^[ T ^NY Y V QV QVY V__V[ZR' PUR U NZ Z [ P[Z_RZ`V`[ X"a_PV`N QNTXV CD= QRV _[TTR``V QVY V__VOVXV )

GV ^V`VRZR' \R^`NZ`[' PUR VX Z a Y R ^[ QV 44+ \[_`V ?R``[ _VN P[R^RZ`R P[Z V P[Z`RZa`V QRV \^[T^NY Y V

\^R_RZ`N`V QNXXR FRTV[ZV R N\\^[bN`V' SR^Y [ ^R_`NZQ[ PUR `NXR Q [ `NdV[ Z R \ [ `^e _aOV^R' ZRX Sa`a^[' aZN

^VQadV[ZR' VZ ^N\ \ [ ^`[ NXX"VY \?RY RZ`NdV[ZR Q RXX"N\\XVPNdV[ZR QV Y V_a^R QV _VPa^RddN NX`R^ZN`VbR'

\^RbV_`R QNXXN XRTTR' VQ[ZRR NQ N__VPa^N^R NXXN \R^_[ZN VZSR^Y N QV Y RZ`R Pa^R NQRTaN`R' P[Z NSSVQNY RZ`[ NV _R^bVdV _NZV`N^V `R^^V`[^VNXV) ? \^[T^NY Y V ^RTV[ZNXV' P[Y R g Z[`[' _[Z[ SVZNXVddN`V Z[Z

`NZ`[ NX Y NZ`RZVY RZ`[ QRV _[TTR``V VZ ]aR_`V[ZR \^R__[ TXV CD= [ XR _`^a ``a ^R NX`R^ZN`VbR' ORZ_h NXX"N``VbNdV[ZR QV \ ^[T^NY Y V `R^N\Ra`VP[(^VNOVXV`N`VbV' T^NdVR NX \ [ `R Z dVN Y R Z `[ QRV _R^bVdV `R^^V`[^VNXV QV _NXa`R Y RZ`NXR)

?Z `a``V V \^[T^NY Y V ^RTV[ZNXV' N\ \ ^[ b N`V NV _RZ_V QRX \ Vj b[X`R PV`N`[ QRP^R`[ VZ`R^Y VZV_`R^VNXR -3*,-*-+,-' _[Z[ \^RbV_`V VZ`R^bRZ`V SVZNXVddN`V NX _a \ \ [ ^`[ R NX \ [ `RZdVNY RZ`[ QRV \R^P[^_V

`R^N\Ra`VP[(^VNOVXV`N`VbV R' \Vj VZ TRZR^NXR' NXXN ^V]aNXVSVPNdV[ZR QRXX"N__V_`RZ dN `R^^V`[^VNXR \_VPUVN`^VPN) GV VXXa_`^NZ[ QV _RTaV`[' V \ ^[T^NY Y V QV PVN_PaZN FRTV[ZR' P[Y R _VZ[``VPNY RZ`R ^N\ \ ^R_R Z `N`V ZRXXR

`NORXXR 1 R 2 NXXRTN`R5

m F RTV[ZR D VRY [ Z `R ( VX \^[ T ^NY Y N \^RbRQR XN ^RNXVddNdV[ZR QV Z) - _`^a ``a ^R ^R_VQRZdVNXV _V`a N`R VZ

\^[bVZPVN QV 8VRXXN R 7 XR__NZQ^VN' \ R^ aZ P[_`[ `[`NXR QV ,-'1 Y VXV[ZV QV Ra^[) ;" \^RbV_`N XN

^RNXVddNdV[ZR QV Z) 2+ \[_`V XR``[' QV PaV Z) /+ ZRXXN _`^a ``a ^N VZ \^[bVZPVN QV 8VRXXN) ?Z 4 YR_V g

\^RbV_`[ VX `RY \[ QV \ ^[TR``NdV[ZR R N\\NX`NOVXV`e R VZ -/ YR_V g _`VY N`N XN ^RNXVddNdV[ZR QRXXR [\R^R) @N FRTV[ZR UN \ ^RNZZaZPVN`[ XN `^N_Y V__V[ZR QV aZ Z a [ b [ \^[ T ^NY Y N ^V_\R``[ N ]aRXX[ TVe N\ \ ^[ b N`[ P[Z :)A) QRX ,4 QVPRY O^R -+,.)

m F RTV[ZR @ [Y ON^QVN ( VX \^[ T ^NY Y N \^RbRQR XN ^RNXVddNdV[ZR QV Z) / _`^a ``a ^R ^R_VQRZdVNXV \R^ aZ P[_`[ P[Y \XR__Vb[ QV ./ Y VXV[ZV QV Ra^[) ;" \^RbV_`N XN ^RNXVddNdV[ZR QV Z) -/+ \[_`V XR``[' QV PaV Z) ,-+ ZRXXN _`^a ``a ^N ^V]aNXVSVPN`N QRXX"C D= QV 9 N_`VTXV[ZR QRXXR G`VbVR^R) @R NX`^R . _`^a ``a ^R U NZZ[

aZN Q[`NdV[ZR QV Z) /+ \[_`V XR``[ R _[Z[ aOVPN`R ZRXXR \^[bVZPVR QV 9[Y [' 8^R_PVN R A VXNZ[) ?

`RY \V QV ^RNXVddNdV[ZR _[Z[ _`VY N`V QNV -+ NV .- YR_V) @N F RTV[ZR UN \^R_RZ`N`[' VZ Q N `N ,, XaTXV[

-+,/' aZ Za[b[ \^[T^NY Y N ^V_\R``[ N ]aRXX[ TVe N\ \ ^[ b N`[ QNX A VZV_`R^[ P[Z :)A) ,/ TRZZNV[

-+,/)

(11)

2UUL =DSMDNHOUDSL

( ,- (

4DNHSD GHL 5HQVUDUL

ED:: ;68:A;2BC@2 ^ 5:A68=: 5: ;6886 6 @6;2F:>=: ^ 5>4C<6=B: ^ 5>4% 44ED:: =% ,

m F RTV[ZR J RZR`[ ( 7 _RTaV`[ QRXXN \^R_RZ`NdV[ZR QN \ N ^`R QRXXN ^RTV[ZR J RZR`[ QV a Z \^[TR``[

PUR g _`N`[ b NXa `N`[ Q N \ N^`R QRTXV aSSVPV QRX A VZV_`R^[ QRXXN _NXa`R PN^RZ`R QRV ^R]aV_V`V \^R_P^V``V QNXXN XRTTR' VX A VZV_`^[ Q RXXN _NXa`R QS\ UHNQPSH P[Z Z[`N ,. SROO^NV[ -+,/ ^N\ \ ^R_RZ `Nb N NX A VZV_`^[ QRXXN TVa_`VdVN R NX A VZV_`^[ QRTXV NSSN^V ^RTV[ZNXV PUR _R Y O ^N b NZ [ ^RNXVddN`R XR P[ZQVdV[ZV \ R^ ^V\ ^R Z Q R^R XN \ ^[ PRQ a ^N QV P[Y Y V__N^VNY RZ`[) 7 _R T a V`[ QV aX`R^V[^V _[XXRPV`NdV[ZV QN \ N^`R QRX A VZV_`R^[ XN FRTV[ZR J RZR`[ \^R_RZ`NbN a X`R^V[^V VZ`RT^NdV[ZV) @N FRTV[ZR UN QN`[' ZRX Y R_R QV N\^VXR -+,/' QRSVZVdV[ZR NX \^[ T ^NY Y N TVe \^R_RZ`N`[' Y N _[X`NZ`[

\R^ XN \N^`R ^RXN`VbN NXXN ^RNXVddNdV[ZR QRXXN F;AG' Nb RZ Q [ NPPNZ`[ZN`[ NX Y [Y RZ`[ a Z N ] a[`N

\R^ VX \ [`RZdVNY RZ`[ QRV _R^bVdV `R^^V`[^VNXV \_VPUVN`^VPV ^RTV[ZNXV N _a \ \ [ ^`[ QRX _a \ R ^N Y RZ `[

QRTXV CD=) G[X[ ZRV \^VY V TV[^ZV QV _R``RY O^R -+,/ XN FRTV[ZR J RZR`[ UN S[^ZV`[ `a``V TXV RXRY RZ`V \^R_P^V``V PUR _[Z[ N``a NXY RZ `R NXXN bNXa`NdV[ZR QRTXV aSSVPV P[Y \R`RZ`V QRX A VZV_`R^[)

m F RTV[ZR < ^VaXV J RZRdVN = Va XVN ( XN FRTV[ZR \^RbRQR' ZRX \^VY [ \ ^[ T ^N Y Y N \^R_RZ`N`[' XN

^RNXVddNdV[ZR QV , ^R_VQRZdN VZ \^[bVZPVN QV D [^QRZ[ZR Q [ `N`N QV Z),+ \[_`V XR``[' \R^ a Z P[_`[

P[Y \XR__Vb[ QV ,'01 Y VXV[ZV QV Ra^[) ? `RY \V QV \^[TR``NdV[ZR R N\\NX`NO VXV`e _[Z[ _`VY N`V VZ /-0 TT) R ]aRXXV QV ^RNXVddNdV[ZR VZ /++ TT)) @N FRTV[ZR' Z RXX"NY O V`[ QRX SVZNZdVNY RZ`[

P[Y \XR__VbNY RZ`R N__RTZN`[' UN VZ Q Vb VQ a N`[ aZ N _[Y Y N \N^V N ,'+/ Y VXV[ZV QV Ra ^[ QN QR_`VZN^R' P[Z _aPPR__Vb[ \^[T^NY Y N' N VZ`R^bRZ`V SVZNXVddN`V NX _a \ \ [ ^`[ R \ [ `RZ dVNY RZ `[ QRV \R^P[^_V

`R^N\Ra`VP[(^VNOVXV`N`VbV' N``^NbR^_[ VZ`R^bRZ`V QV ^V]aNXVSVPNdV[ZR _`^a ``a ^N XR QRV _R^bVdV `R^^V`[^VNXV)

@N FRTV[ZR UN \ ^R_RZ`N`[ X "V X N\^VXR -+,/ a Z Za[b[ \^[ T ^NY Y N ^V_\ R``[ N ]aRXX[ TVe N\ \ ^[ b N `[

QNX A VZV_`R^[ P[Z :)A) -- [``[O^R -+,.)

m F RTV[ZR @ VT a ^VN ( XN F RTV[ZR \^RbRQR' ZRX \^VY [ \ ^[ T ^N Y Y N \^R_RZ`N`[' XN ^RNXVddNdV[ZR QV ,

^R_VQRZdN Q [ `N`N QV Z) -+ \[_`V XR``[ VZ \^[bVZPVN QV @N G\RdVN' \R^ a Z P[_`[ P[Y \XR__Vb[ QV /', Y VXV[ZV QV Ra^[) ? `RY \V QV \^[TR``NdV[ZR \ R ^ N\ \ NX`NOVXV`e _[Z[ _`VY N`V VZ 4+ TT) ? `RY \V QV

^RNXVddNdV[ZR _[Z[ _`VY N`V VZ 1,+ TT) @N FRTV[ZR' ZRXX"NY OV`[ QR@ SVZNZdVNY RZ`[

P[Y \XR__VbNY RZ`R N__RTZN`[' UN VZ Q Vb VQ a N`[ aZ N _[Y Y N \ N^V N ,'21 Y VXV[ZV QV Ra ^[ Q N QR_`VZN^R' P[Z _aPPR__Vb[ \^[T^NY Y N' N VZ`R^bRZ`V SVZNXVddN`V NX _a \ \ [ ^`[ R \ [ `R Z dVN Y R Z `[ QRV \R^P[^_V

`R^N\Ra`VP[(^VNOVXV`N`VbV' N``^NbR^_[ VZ`R^bRZ`V QV ^V]aNXVSVPNdV[ZR _`^a ``a ^N XR QRV _R^bVdV `R^^V`[^VNXV) 7 `NX SVZR UN \ ^R_RZ`N`[ a Z [ _\RPVSVP[ \^[ T ^NY Y N VZ QN`N 4 TRZZNV[ -+,/)

m F RTV[ZR ; Y VXVN F [Y NTZN ( XN FRTV[ZR \^RbRQR' ZRX \^VY [ \ ^[ T ^N Y Y N \^R_RZ`N`[' XN

^RNXVddNdV[ZR QV , ^R_VQRZdN Q[`N`N QV Z) /+ \[_`V XR``[ VZ \^[bVZPVN QV FRTTV[ ;YVXVN' \R^ aZ P[_`[

P[Y \XR__Vb[ QV 2'.0 Y VXV[ZV QV Ra^[) ? `RY \V QV \ ^[TR``NdV[ZR R N\ \ NX`NOVXV`e _[Z[ _`VY N`V VZ ,- YR_V) ? `RY \V QV ^RNXVddNdV[ZR _[Z[ _`VY N`V VZ ,2 YR_V) @N FRTV[ZR' ZRXX"NY O V`[ QRX SVZNZdVNY RZ`[

P[Y \XR__VbNY RZ`R N__RTZN`[' UN VZ Q Vb VQ a N`[ a Z N _[Y Y N \N^V N -'44 Y VXV[ZV QV Ra ^[ QN QR_`VZN^R' P[Z _aPPR__Vb[ \^[T^NY Y N' N VZ`R^bRZ`V SVZNXVddN`V NX _a \ \ [ ^`[ R \ [ `RZ dVNY RZ `[ QRV \R^P[^_V

`R^N\Ra`VP[(^VNOVXV`N`VbV' N``^NbR^_[ VZ`R^bRZ`V QV ^V]aNXVSVPNdV[ZR _`^a ``a ^N XR QRV _R^bVdV `R^^V`[^VNXV) 7 `NX SVZR UN \ ^R_RZ`N`[ a Z [ _\RPVSVP[ \^[ T ^NY Y N VZ QN`N ,3 Z[bRY O^R -+,.)

m F RTV[ZV H [_PNZN(I Y O^VN ( X"NPP[^Q[ VZ`R^^RTV[ZNXR _`V\ a XN`[ `^N H[_PNZN R I Y O^VN UN QRSVZV`[ aZ

\^[T^NY Y N a Z V`N^V[ \R^ XN ^RNXVddNdV[ZR QV ^R_VQRZdR P[Y aZV VZ PaV [ _\ V`N^R V _[TTR``V VZ`R^ZN`V

(12)

2UUL =DSMDNHOUDSL

( ,. (

4DNHSD GHL 5HQVUDUL

ED:: ;68:A;2BC@2 ^ 5:A68=: 5: ;6886 6 @6;2F:>=: ^ 5>4C<6=B: ^ 5>4% 44ED:: =% ,

\^[bRZVRZ`V QNXXR FRTV[ZV _`R__R) ;" \^RbV_`N XN ^RNXVddNdV[ZR QV Z) 2- \[_`V XR``[' P[Z Q Vb R^_N VZ`RZ_V`e QV Pa^N' VZ 0 _`^a ``a ^R ZRXXR \^[bVZPVR QV <V^RZdR' 7 ^Rdd[ R A N__N 9 N^^N^N \ R^ aZ P[_`[

P[Y \XR__Vb[ QV ,,'1 Y VXV[ZV QV Ra^[) ? `RY \V QV ^RNXVddNdV[ZR _[ Z [ _`VY N`V Q N 4 N .+ YR_V' P[Z_VQR^N`[ PUR / QRV 0 VZ`R^bRZ`V P[Z_V_`[Z[ VZ ^V]aNXVSVPNdV[ZV [ ^V_`^a ``a ^Nd V[ Z V QV RQVSVPV TVe R_V_`RZ`V)

m F RTV[ZR @NdV[ ( VX \^[ T ^NY Y N QRXXN FRTV[ZR @NdV[ \ ^Rb R Q R VX ^R_`Na ^[ R VX ^V_NZ N Y R Z `[ QV - _`^a ``a ^R _V`a N`R ZRXXN PV``e QV F[YN6 R XN ^V_`^a ``a ^Nd V[ Z R QV aZ [_\RQNXR Q V_Y R__[ VZ \ ^[bVZPVN QV F[YN) ? \[_`V XR``[ \^RbV_`V _[Z[ Z) 40 \R^ aZ P[_`[ P[Y \XR__Vb[ QV ,2'2 Y VXV[ZV QV Ra ^[ ) ? `RY \V QV

\^[TR``NdV[ZR R N\ \ NX`NOVXV`e bN^VNZ[ Q N 4+ N .,+ TT) R ]aRXXV QV ^RNXVddNdV[ZR QN ,3+ N 2-+ TT) I Z[

QRTXV VZ`R^bRZ`V QV ^R_`Na^[ R ^V_NZNY RZ`[' ]aRXX[ _V`[ ZRXXN 7G@ F[Y N 7' \ ^Rb RQ R' [X`^R NXXN

^R_VQRZdN \R^ X"R_RPadV[ZR QRXXR Y V_a^R QV _VPa^RddN #F;AG$' XN ^V_`^a ``a ^Nd V[ Z R QRXXN ^R_`NZ`R

\ N^`R QRXX"RQVSVPV[ #PV^PN -+++ Y]$ Q N Q R_`VZ N ^R NQ N``VbV`e _[PVNXV R \ ^[ Q a ``Vb R P[^^RXN`R NXXN

^VNOVXV`NdV[ZR R N \R^P[^_V Q "VZ `R T ^N dV[ Z R RQ VZPXa_V[ZR _[PVNXR)

m F RTV[ZV 7 O^a dd[ (A [ XV_R ( VX \^[ T ^NY Y N VZ`R^^RTV[ZNXR QRXXR FRTV[ZV 7 O ^a dd[ R A [XV_R \^RbRQR'

\ R^ aZ P[_`[ P[Y \XR__Vb[ QV /'3 Y VXV[ZV QV Ra^[' XN ^RNXVddNdV[ZR QV Z) -+ \[_`V XR``[ VZ aZ N Z a[bN _`^a ``a ^N _V`aN`N VZ \^[bVZPVN QV 9UVR`V) ? `RY \V QV ^RNXVddNdV[ZR _[Z[ _`VY N`V VZ - NZZV R 4 YR_V)

m F RTV[ZR 9 N Y \ N Z VN ( XN FRTV[ZR 9 NY \NZVN UN \^R_RZ `N`[ aZ \ ^[ T ^N Y Y N PUR \ ^Rb R Q R XN

^RNXVddNdV[ZR QV 3 F;AG _V`a N`R ZRXXR \^[bVZPR QV 7bRXXVZ[' 8RZRbRZ`[' 9 N_R^`N' B N\[XV R GNXR^Z[) C TZV _`^a ``a ^N g Q[`N`N QV Z) -+ \[_`V XR``[' \R^ a Z `[`NXR QV Z) ,1+' P[Z aZ P[_`[ P[Y \XR__Vb[

\^RbV_`[ QV ,4'. Y VXV[ZV QV Ra^[) @N _`VY N QRV `RY \V QV \ ^[TR``NdV[ZR R N\\NX`NO VXV`e bN^VN Q N - N ,+

YR_V' Y RZ`^R ]aRXXV QV ^RNXVddNdV[ZR `^N - R ,0 YR_V)

m F RTV[ZR D aT XVN ( XN FRTV[ZR DaTXVN UN \ ^R_RZ`N`[ a Z \ ^[ T ^N Y Y N QRX P[_`[ P[Y \XR__Vb[ QV ,+', Y VXV[ZV QV Ra ^[ \R^ P[Y \XR__VbV Z) 03 \[_`V XR``[' QN ^RNXVddN^_V VZ . \^R_VQV [_\RQNXVR^V QV_Y R__V R

^V]aNXVSVPN`V' _V`V VZ \^[bVZPVN QV 8^VZQV_V' H N^NZ`[ R <[TTVN) ? `RY \V Q V \^[TR``NdV[ZR R N\ \ NX`NOVXV`e bN^VNZ[ Q N ,3+ N -2+ TT)' ]aRXXV QV ^RNXVddNdV[ZR _[Z[ \ ^RbV_`V ?Z ,- YR_V) @N FRTV[ZR' ZRXX"NY O V`[

QRX SVZNZdVNY RZ`[ P[Y \XR__VbNY RZ`R N__RTZN`[' UN VZ Q Vb VQ a N`[ a Z N _[Y Y N \N^V N ,'13 Y VXV[ZV QV Ra^[ QN QR_`VZN^R' P[Z _aPPR__Vb[ \^[T^NY Y N' N VZ`R^bRZ`V SVZNXVddN`V NX _a \ \ [ ^`[ R

\ [`RZdVNY RZ`[ QRV \R^P[^_V `R^N\Ra`VP[(^VNOVXV`N`VbV' N``^Nb R^_[ VZ `R^bRZ`V QV ^V]aNXVSVPNdV[ZR _`^a ``a ^N XR QRV _R^bVdV `R^^V`[^VNXV)

m F RTV[ZR 8N_VXVPN`N ( XN F RTV[ZR 8N_VXVPN`N UN \^R_RZ `N`[ a Z \^[ T ^NY Y N PUR \ ^Rb RQ R X"a`VXVdd[ QV

\ N^`R QRXXN _[Y Y N N__RTZN`N \R^ XN ^RNXVddNdV[ZR' VZ \^[bVZPVN QV D[`RZdN' QV , _ `^a ``a ^N _NZV`N^VN NX`R^ZN`VbN NXX"C D= Q[`N`N QV Z) 0 \[_`V XR``[) ?X P[_`[ P[Y \XR__Vb[ g PV^PN 02,)+++ Ra^[) ? `RY \V QV

\^[TR``NdV[ZR R QV N\\NX`NOVXV`e _[Z[ SV__N`V VZ 1 YR_V6 _RY \ ^R VZ 1 YR_V _[Z[ \^RbV_`V V `RY \V QV

^RNXVddNdV[ZR) @N FRTV[ZR' ZRXX"NY OV`[ QRX SVZNZdVNY RZ`[ P[Y \XR__VbNY RZ`R N__RTZN`[' UN VZ Q VbVQaN`[ aZN _[Y Y N \ N ^V N 2+4)+++ Ra^[ QN QR_`VZN^R' P[Z _aPPR__Vb[ \ ^[ T ^NY Y N' N VZ`R^bRZ`V SVZNXVddN`V NX _a \ \ [ ^`[ R \[`RZdVNY RZ`[ QRV \R^P[^_V `R^N\Ra`VP[( ^VNOVXV`N`VbV N``^Nb R^_[ VZ`R^bRZ`V QV ^V]aNXVSVPNdV[ZR _`^a ``a ^N XR QRV _R^bVdV `R^^V`[^VNXV)

(13)

2UUL =DSMDNHOUDSL

( ,/ (

4DNHSD GHL 5HQVUDUL

ED:: ;68:A;2BC@2 ^ 5:A68=: 5: ;6886 6 @6;2F:>=: ^ 5>4C<6=B: ^ 5>4% 44ED:: =% ,

m F RTV[ZR 9 N XN O ^VN ( XN FRTV[ZR 9NXNO^VN UN QR_`VZN`[ VX SVZNZdVNY RZ`[ N__RTZN`[ NXXN ^RNXVddNdV[ZR R ^V]aNXVSVPNdV[ZR QV - _`^a ``a ^R ^R_VQRZdVNXV _V`R VZ \^[bVZPVN QV 9 N`NZ dN^[ R 9[_RZdN' \R^

P[Y \XR__VbV Z) 1+ \[_`V XR``[ R aZ P[_`[ P[Y \XR__Vb[ QV 1'4 Y VXV[ZV QV Ra^[) G[Z[ \^RbV_`V `RY \V QV

\^[TR``NdV[ZR R N\\NX`NOVXV`e Q N . N 2 YR_V Y RZ`^R ]aRXXV Q V ^RNXVddNdV[ZR _[Z[ VZQVPN`V VZ . ( ,/

YR_V)

m F RTV[ZR G N^Q RT Z N ( VX \ ^[T^NY Y N \^R_RZ`N`[ \^Rb RQ R XN ^RNXVddNdV[ZR QV , ^R_VQRZdN \R^

X"R_RPadV[ZR QRXXR Y V_a^R QV _VPa^RddN _V`aN`N VZ \^[bVZPVN QV GN__N^V' P[Z a ZN Q[`NdV[ZR P[Y \XR__VbN QV Z) /+ \[_`V XR``[ R aZ P[_`[ P[Y \XR__Vb[ QV 1 Y VXV[ZV QV Ra^[) ? `RY \V QV

\^[TR``NdV[ZR R N\\NX`NOVXV`e _[Z[ SV__N`V VZ ,3 YR_V6 ]aRXXV QV ^RNXVddNdV[ZR _[Z[ QRSVZV`V VZ -/

YR_V)

@N bN^VNOVXV`e QRV P[_`V QV PaV NXXN `NO) 1' Q V\ R Z Q R QNXXR bN^VR ^RNX`e ZRXXR ] aNXV _V \ ^Rb R Q R QV ^RNXVddN^R XN _`^a ``a ^N' QNXXN `V\[X[TVN QRXXR _`R__R R QNX `V\[ Q"VZ `R^b RZ `[ 5 Z a [ b N P[_`^adV[ZR' ^V_`^a ``a ^Nd V[ Z R [

^V]aNXVSVPNdV[ZR)

2) @N _V`a N d V[ Z R Z RXXN F RTV[ZR G VPVXVN

@N FRTV[ZR GVPVXVN UN \^R_RZ`N`[ aZ \^[T^NY Y N PUR \^Rb RQ R a Z P[_`[ P[Y \XR__Vb[ QV ,3',, Y VXV[ZV QV Ra ^[ N^`VP[XN`[ ZRXXN ^V_`^a ``a ^NdV[ Z R R NQ R T a NY RZ `[ SaZdV[ZNXR Q V . \^R_VQV [_\RQNXVR^V QV_Y R__V \R^ P[Y \XR__VbV Z) 3+ \[_`V XR``[' Q V_`^VOaV`V VZ / _`^a ``a ^R _V`a N`R ZRXXR \^[bVZPVR QV 9N`NZVN' 9 NX`NZV__R``N R A R__VZN) ? `RY \V QV \ ^[TR``NdV[ZR R N\ \ NX`NOVXV`e _[Z[ VZQVPN`V VZ 4 YR_V6 Y RZ`^R QN ,/ N -+ YR_V _[Z[ QR`R^Y VZN`V V `RY \V QV ^RNXVddNdV[ZR QRXXR _`^a ``a ^R ) ? \^[TR``V QV SN``VOVXV`e \^RbRQ[Z[' [X`^R NXXR F;AG' XN ^RNXVddNdV[ZR QV T ^a \ \ V QV N\ \ N ^`NY R Z `V QSHGLNLTTLPOL R

\R^P[^_V QV ^VNOVXV`NdV[ZR \R^ V _[TTR``V ^VP[bR^N`V) ?Z[X`^R' XN FRTV[ZR' ZRXX"NY OV`[ QRX SVZNZdVNY RZ`[ P[Y \XR__VbNY RZ`R N__RTZN`[' UN VZ Q Vb VQ a N`[ aZN _[Y Y N \N^V N ,'01 Y VXV[ZV QV Ra^[ QN QR_`VZN^R' P[Z _aPPR__Vb[ \^[T^NY Y N' N VZ`R^bRZ`V SVZNXVddN`V NX _a \ \ [ ^`[ R

\ [`RZdVNY RZ`[ QRV \R^P[^_V `R^N\Ra`VP[(^VNOVXV`N`VbV' N``^NbR^_[ VZ`R^bRZ`V QV ^V]aNXVSVPNdV[ZR _`^a ``a ^N XR QRV _R^bVdV `R^^V`[^VNXV)

=XV _`N`a`V QV Na`[Z[Y VN QRXXR ^RTV[ZV NQ Na`[Z[Y VN _\RPVNXR' N\ \ ^[ b N `V P[Z XRTTV P[_`V`adV[ZNXV'

\ ^RbRQ[Z[ PUR XR ^RXN`VbR Z[^Y R QV N``aNdV[ZR _VNZ[ Q R``N`R P[Z N\\ [ _V`V QRP^R`V XRTV_XN`VbV' RY NZN`V _a \^[\[_`N QV aZN 9 [Y Y V__V[ZR \N^V`R`VPN #_V bRQN' \R^ ] a NZ `[ P[ZPR^ZR XN ^RTV[ZR GVPVXVNZN' X"N^`VP[X[ /. QRXX[ G `N`a`[ _\RPVNXR N\ \ ^[ b N `[ P[Z F):)@) ,0 Y NTTV[ ,4/1' Z) /00' P[ZbR^`V`[ VZ XRTTR P[_`V`adV[ZNXR -1 SROO^NV[ ,4/3' Z) - $)

HNXR \^VZPV\V[ QV Na`[Z[Y VN g _`N`[ SN``[ _NXb[ R_\^R__NY RZ`R _VZ Q NXX"Nb b V[ QRX \^[PR__[

Z[^Y N`Vb[ QV ^V[^QVZ[ QRXXR Y RQVPVZN \RZV`RZdVN^VN) ?X QRP^R`[ XRTV_XN`Vb[ Z) -.+*,444' NXX"N^`VP[X[

4' QV_\[ZRbN PUR \ R ^ VX `^N_SR^VY RZ`[ QRXXR SaZdV[ZV QV PaV NX \^R_RZ`R QRP^R`[ XRTV_XN`Vb[ _V

\^[bbRQR' \R^ XR FRTV[ZV N _`N`a `[ _\RPVNXR R \R^ XR \^[bVZPR Na `[ Z [ Y R QV H ^RZ`[ R QV 8[XdNZ[' P[Z Z[^Y R QV N``aNdV[ZR NV _RZ_V QRV ^V_\R``VbV _`N`a`V )

CPP[^^R RbVQRZdVN^R PUR' \R^ ] a NZ `[ P[ZPR^ZR' _\RPVSVPNY RZ`R' XN ^RTV[ZR GVPVXVNZN' VZ Y N`R^VN QV _NZV`e \RZV`RZdVN^VN g _`N`[ RY NZN`[ R_PXa_VbNY RZ`R VX QRP^R`[ XRTV_XN`Vb[ -+ T VaTZ[ -++0' Z) ,-0'

^RPNZ`R B [^Y R QV N``aNdV[ZR QRXX[ G`N`a`[ _\RPVNXR QRXXN ^RTV[ZR _VPVXVNZN' P[ZPR^ZRZ`V VX

`^N_SR^VY RZ`[ QV SaZdV[ZV VZ Y N`R^VN QV Y RQVPVZN \RZV`RZdVN^VN ' NV _RZ_V QRX ]a NXR _[Z[ _`N`R

(14)

2UUL =DSMDNHOUDSL

( ,0 (

4DNHSD GHL 5HQVUDUL

ED:: ;68:A;2BC@2 ^ 5:A68=: 5: ;6886 6 @6;2F:>=: ^ 5>4C<6=B: ^ 5>4% 44ED:: =% ,

`^N_SR^V`R NXXN ^RTV[ZR XR SaZdV[ZV _NZV`N^VR QV PaV NXX"N^`VP[X[ 3 QRX ^VPUVNY N`[ Q)XT_) Z) -.+*,444 P[Z

^VSR^VY RZ`[ NV _[XV _R``[^V QRXXN \^RbRZdV[ZR R Q RXX"N__V_`RZdN NV Q R`RZ a `V R NTXV VZ`RY N`V

`[__VP[QV\RZQRZ`V )

7 `a``"[TTV' VZbRPR' Z[Z ^V_aX`N NZP[^N RY NZN`[ NXPaZ QRP^R`[ XRTV_XN`Vb[ \ R^ VX `^N_SR^VY RZ`[' VZ

\N^`VP[XN^R' QRXXR SaZdV[ZV ^RXN`VbR NTXV [_\RQNXV \_VPUVN`^VPV TVaQVdVN^V)

GV QRbR [__R^bN^R PUR VX `^N_SR^VY RZ`[ QRXXR \^RQ R``R SaZdV[ZV' N``VZRZ`V NTXV [_\RQNXV \_VPUVN`^VPV TVaQVdVN^V' _V P[ZSVTa^N ]aNXR \^R_a \ \ [ _`[ R P[ZQVdV[ZR ZRPR__N^VN \R^ \ [`R^ \^[PRQR^R NXXN P[ZP^R`N N__RTZNdV[ZR QRXXR _`^aY RZ`NXV ^V_[^_R SVZNZdVN^VR' P[Y \^R_R ]aRXXR Q R_`VZ N `R NXXN

^RNXVddNdV[ZR R ^VP[ZbR^_V[ZR QRXXR _`^a ``a ^R ' QV PaV NXX"N^`VP[X[ .(`R^ QRX Q)XT_) Z) -,,*-+,,) B [Z

\a i P[Z_VQR^N^_V VZ NXPaZ Y [Q[ NY Y V__VOVXR X"N__RTZNdV[ZR QV `NXV ^V_[^_R SVZNZdVN^VR \R^

X"R_R^PVdV[ QV SaZdV[ZV PUR NX Y [Y RZ`[ Z[Z ^VRZ`^NZ[ ZRXXN `V`[XN^V`e QRXXN ^RTV[ZR GVPVXVN' VZ ] a NZ `[

Z[Z NZP[^N `^N_SR^V`R _RP[ZQ[ XR \ ^[PRQa^R _`NOVXV`R QNXXN Z[^Y N`VbN bVTRZ`R)

/% ?VTWULXXPZL

B [Z[_`NZ`R VX QVSSR^VY RZ`[ NX ., Y N^d[ -+,0 QRX `R^Y VZR \R^ XN PU Va _a ^N QRTXV CD=' _aXXN ON_R QRV QN`V VZ \[__R__[ QRX A VZV_`R^[ QRXXN _NXa`R N\ \ N ^R Z[Z ^RNXV_`VP[ PUR XR FRTV[ZV ^VR_PNZ[ N

^RNXVddN^R R ^VP[ZbR^`V^R XR _`^a ``a ^R RZ `^[ XN \ ^RQ R ``N QN`N) ?Z PN_[ QV Y NZPN`[ ^V_\R``[

Q RXX"NZ dVQ R``N QN`N' [bbR^[ VZ PN_[ QV Y NZPN`[ P[ Y \XR`NY RZ`[ QRXXR _`^a ``a ^R ZRX `R^Y VZR

\^RbV_`[ QNV \^[T^NY Y V ^RTV[ZNXV' g SR^Y N VZ`RZdV[ZR QRV A VZV_`^V N``VbN^R XN \ ^[ PRQ a ^N QV PaV NXX"N^`VP[X[ ,' P[Y Y N -' QRXXN XRTTR .+ Y NTTV[ -+,/' Z) 3,' \ ^[PRQa^N PUR P[Z_RZ`R NX = [bR^Z[ QV

\^[bbRQR^R VZ bVN _[_`V`a`VbN NV _RZ_V QRXX"N^`VP[X[ *%UHS$ P[Y Y N 4' QRX QRP^R`[(XRTTR -- QVPRY O^R -+,,' Z) -,,' P[ZbR^`V`[ P[Z Y [QVSVPNdV[ZV ZRXXN XRTTR ,2 SROO^NV[ -+,-' Z) 4)

GaXXN ON_R QRXXR bNXa`NdV[ZV ^R_R g ]aVZ Q V QV Za[b[ Na_\VPNOVXR a Z aX`R^V[^R QVSSR^VY RZ`[ QRX

`R^Y VZR QV PUVa_a^N QRTXV CD=)

@ "NZdVQR``N \^[^[TN' `a``NbVN' Q[b^ROOR R__R^R NPP[Y \NTZN`N QNXXN \^RbV_V[ZR QV Y V_a^R Z[^Y N`VbR SVZNXVddN`R N P[Z_RZ`V^R XN ^RNXVddNdV[ZR R ^VP[ZbR^_V[ZR QRXXR NZ d VQ R ``R _`^a ``a ^R RZ`^[

`RY \V PR^`V6 N `NX SVZR _V ^V`RZT[Z[ `a``[^N bNXVQR XR \^[ \ [ _`R S[^Y aXN`R ZRXXN \ ^RP RQ RZ `R FRXNdV[ZR VZbVN`N NX DN^XNY RZ`[5 Y V_a^R Z [^Y N`VbR b[X`R N _RY \XVSVPN^R R ^NdV[ZNXVddN^R XR \^[ PRQ a ^R NY Y VZV_`^N`VbR6 \[__VOVXV`e QV NbbNXR^_V QRX _VXRZdV[(N__RZ_[ \R^ XR Na`[^VddNdV[ZV NY Y VZV_`^N`VbR

^VPUVR_`R N XVbRXX[ X[PNXR)

@R Y V_a^R Z[^Y N`VbR QV _RY \XVSVPNdV[ZR N\ \ N V[ Z [ ZRPR__N^VR VZ ] a NZ `[ X"V`R^ \ ^[PRQa^NXR

^VPUVR_`[ \R^ XN \^[TR``NdV[ZR R XN ^RNXVddNdV[ZR QRXXR _`^a ``a ^R #P[YR ^V_aX`N Rb VQ RZ `R QNV QN`V

^V\[^`N`V ZRXXR `NORXXR$ _V Q V_`NZdVN Z[`Rb[XY RZ`R QNV `R^Y VZV \^RbV_`V QNXXR \ ^RPRQRZ`V \^[^[TUR)

<R^YV ^R_`NZQ[ V \^[SVXV QV _VPa^RddN' VX \^R_a \ \ [ _`[ _[_`NZdVNXR \R^PUf ]a R_`[ \R^P[^_[ \[XV`VP[ R NY Y VZV_`^N`Vb[ \^[_RTaN g XN Y N`a^NdV[ZR QV aZ N Z a [ b N PaX`a^N' a Z Z a [b[ Y [Q[ QV T a N^Q N ^R NXXN PUVa_a^N QRTXV CD= R QRXXR \^[OXRY N`VPUR P[ZZR__R' a ZN N``RZdV[ZR ]aNXVSVPN`N QRTXV N``[^V

\[XV`VPV R QRV Y RddV QV VZS[^Y NdV[ZR) GV PR^PUR^e QV XNb[^N^R P[Z VZ`R^bRZ`V b[X`V N P[ Z `^N_`N^R VX

\^RTVaQVdV[ ZRV P[ZS^[Z`V QRV _[TTR``V NSSR``V Q N Y NXN``VN Y RZ`NXR' \ a ^ _R Na `[ ^V QV SN``V P[_`V`aRZ`V T^NbV ^RN`V)

(15)

2UUL =DSMDNHOUDSL

( ,1 (

4DNHSD GHL 5HQVUDUL

ED:: ;68:A;2BC@2 ^ 5:A68=: 5: ;6886 6 @6;2F:>=: ^ 5>4C<6=B: ^ 5>4% 44ED:: =% ,

%=15 8! "!' ;?7A1B7;:7!34881!:;:!3797>>72787?C!347

<1B74:?7

$ ) ' %

' #+ $ * ) ' " ! & " ' #! % $ % ( #) - .!( % ! # $"

(+'0 ! (- '0 !

(16)

2UUL =DSMDNHOUDSL

( ,2 (

4DNHSD GHL 5HQVUDUL

ED:: ;68:A;2BC@2 ^ 5:A68=: 5: ;6886 6 @6;2F:>=: ^ 5>4C<6=B: ^ 5>4% 44ED:: =% ,

(17)

2UUL =DSMDNHOUDSL

( ,3 (

4DNHSD GHL 5HQVUDUL

ED:: ;68:A;2BC@2 ^ 5:A68=: 5: ;6886 6 @6;2F:>=: ^ 5>4C<6=B: ^ 5>4% 44ED:: =% ,

8@27:4 > *

?BH;FB7H? DF;G;BH? B;=@? CD= ?B 7DD@?97L?CB; :;@@7 A?GIF7 :? G?9IF;LL7 :;H;BH?J7 :;<?B?H?J7 ;*C DFCJJ?GCF?7 ( :;@ F?9CJ;FC ?B CGD;:7@; DG?9>?7HF?9C =?I:?L?7F?C ; :;@@"7GG;=B7L?CB; 2 97G7 :? 9IF7 ; 9IGHC:?7 ( *( =;BB 7?C ( *( 7=CGHC 2==> )'(+

*,'

NLSSHPT MLIIVHPT RHV[T HUVPQL RHNNPT NPYNST QYNQPT HNTWXT

(18)

2UUL =DSMDNHOUDSL

( ,4 (

4DNHSD GHL 5HQVUDUL

ED:: ;68:A;2BC@2 ^ 5:A68=: 5: ;6886 6 @6;2F:>=: ^ 5>4C<6=B: ^ 5>4% 44ED:: =% ,

-12 !!! "!#&,-+&"./&)($!#$&!,)%%$--&!*$+!,$,,)

@68:>=6

<2A49: 76<<:=6 B>B2;:

D?;ACBH; 00 / 04

@CA87F:?7 % ,/1 -- ,13

DFC J) 7 IHCB) 8C@L7BC , , -

J;B;HC .1 3 //

<F?I@? J;B;L?7 =?I@?7 4 - ??

@?=IF?7 ,4 + ,4

;A?@?7 FCA7=B7 ., / .0

HCG97B7 .- , ..

IA8F?7 0 . 3

A7F9>; ,- + ,-

@7L?C 40 ,+ ,+0

78FILLC ,/ , ,0

97AD7B?7 ,,. 0 ,,3

DI=@?7 ., , .-

87G?@?97H7 0 + 0

97@78F?7 -4 - .,

G?9?@?7 42 . ,++

G7F:;=B7 -+ + -+

:B2;:2 .,' -. /(.

% QHS 0 TPJJHUUL OPO [ TUDUP SLMHWDUP LM THTTP& 8M OVNHSP UPUDMH G L TPJJHUUL SLMHWDUL [ Q D SL D /(.# 01 /)-

(19)

2UUL =DSMDNHOUDSL

( -+ (

4DNHSD GHL 5HQVUDUL

ED:: ;68:A;2BC@2 ^ 5:A68=: 5: ;6886 6 @6;2F:>=: ^ 5>4C<6=B: ^ 5>4% 44ED:: =% ,

@DE&) % 58?@>83AB8<;6 568 ?<776@@8 =6> <=7

CD= QXYV__VSNVXR

7J;FG7 ,,4

87F9;@@CB7 DCLLC :? =CHHC ,1,

97GH?=@?CB; :;@@; GH?J?;F; -.2

ACBH;@IDC <?CF;BH?BC 3+

B7DC@? 4-

F;==?C ;A?@?7 44

BCB ?B:?97HC .3

?H7@?7 3-1

@DE&* % 58?@>83AB8<;6 568 ?<776@@8 ?64<;5< 92 4<;58B8<;6 58 58:8??83898@2

F;=?CB;

#8ZQ__VOVXR O [ O QYV__VO>R [Z[N

?ZQVPN`[

D?;ACBH; ., -0 .

@CA87F:?7 2/K 23 -0

DFC J) 7 IHCB) 8C@L7 BC , ? +

J;B;HC -, -. +

<F?I@? J;B;L?7 =?I@?7 3 + .

@?=IF?7 ,/ 0 +

;A?@?7 FCA7=B7 -. ?? ,

HCG97B7 ,3 ,0 +

IA8F?7 - 1 +

A7F9>; . 4 +

@7L?C /1 03 ,

78FILLC ,- . +

97AD7B?7 3, ./ .

DI=@?7 -. 4 +

87G?@?97H7 - . +

97@78F?7 -1 0 +

G?9?@?7 20 -0 +

G7F:;=B7 ,1 / +

?H7@?7 /21 .,/ .1

(20)

2UUL =DSMDNHOUDSL

( -, (

4DNHSD GHL 5HQVUDUL

ED:: ;68:A;2BC@2 ^ 5:A68=: 5: ;6886 6 @6;2F:>=: ^ 5>4C<6=B: ^ 5>4% 44ED:: =% ,

@VE&+ % 58?@>83AB8<;6 5 68 ?<776@@8 5 8: 8??83898 =6> @8=<9<782 =><7>2::2 @6>2=6

F;=?CB;

H?DC@C=?7 DFC=F7AA7 H;F7D;IH?9C F?78?@?H7H?JC

NYOaXN`[^VNXR _RYV^R_VQRZdVN`R ^R_VQRZdVNXR NX`^[ [ Z[Z VZQVPN`[

D?;ACBH; . + -3 +

@CA87F:?7 0 / 1- .

DFCJ) 7 IHCB)8C@L7BC + +" , +

J;B;HC X , , ,1 .

<F?I@? J;B;L?7 =?I@?7 + + 3 +

@?=IF?7 + + ,/ +

;A?@?7 FCA7=B7 , + -+ -

HCG97B7 , + ,1 ,

IA8F?7 + + - +

A7F9>; + + . +

@7L?C 0 + .4 -

78FILLC + + ,, ,

97AD7B?7 1 / 02 ,/

DI=@?7 + , -- +

87G?@?97H7 , + , +

97@78F?7 , , -/ +

G?9?@?7 / / 11 ,

G7F:;=B7 + , ,/ ,

^H7@?7 -3 ,1 /+/ -3

(21)

2UUL =DSMDNHOUDSL

( -- (

4DNHSD GHL 5HQVUDUL

ED:: ;68:A;2BC@2 ^ 5:A68=: 5: ;6886 6 @6;2F:>=: ^ 5>4C<6=B: ^ 5>4% 44ED:: =% ,

B H I LQQH , A PXY H [ PT S L Z H QY XH [ PT S L U VT N VH R R P V L N PT S H QP ULV Q!Y XPQP[[T KLP MTS K P KP UHVXL JTVVLSXL

@68:>=:

7TSKP )'() 5LQPILVH 4:?6 )( KPL%

)'()!

7TSKP )'(*

VPKLXLVRPSHXP KTUT @ )* RHNNPT )'(*# S% ,.

BTXHQL APXYH[PTSL ZHQYXH[PTSL UVTNVHRRP HQ (' WLXXLRIVL )'(+

D?;A CBH; -)1,.),13'++ .)/2-)20-'+1 1)+30)4-+'+1

VZ N``R_N Y [ Q VSVPU R R P U VN ^VY R Z `V Q N XXN F RTV[ZR

J :"7CGH7 23)041'++ ,+/)/0+'/4 ,3.)+/1'/4 SLWWYS \^[T^NYYN

@CA87F:?7 1)432)0/4'++ 4)-31)+30'0- ,1)-2.)1./'0-

))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) VZ N``R_N Y [ Q VSVPU R R P U VN^VY RZ `V Q N XXN F RTV[ZR

DFCJ) 7IH)

8C @L7BC 43)11+'0. 1-3)0/,'0. SLWWYS \^[T^NYYN

DFCJ) 7IH)

HF;BHC 0-4)33,'++ 1+0)0,4'3- 1+0)0,4'3- SLWWYS UVTNVHRRH

J;B;HC -)0..)./4'++ .).11)132',2 0)4++)+.1',2 \ ^R Q V_\ [ _`[ Q RP^R`[

<F?I@? 00.)2.3'++ 2.0)333'24 ,)-34)1-1'24 SLWWYS UVTNVHRRH

@?=IF?7 ,)-.1)/24'++ ,)1/.)-,0'2+ -)324)14/'2+ Q R P^R `[ `^N_Y R__[ NX A;<

;)FCA 7=B7 -),3-)344'++ -)4++)402'02 0)+3.)301'02 Q R P^R `[ `^N_Y R__[ NX A;<

HC G97 B 7 ,)413)42/'++ -)1,1)11-'31 /)030)1.1'31 Q R P ^R `[ `^N_Y R__[ NX A;<

IA8F?7 /.2)2,2'++ 03,)2,1'-1 ,)+,4)/..'-1

VZ N``R_N Y [QVSVPUR R PU VN^VY RZ `V QNXXN F RTV[ZR

A 7F9>; 2+3)--.'++ 4/,),4,'.- ,)1/4)/,/'.-

VZ N``R_N PU VN^VY RZ `V Q NXXN F RTV[ZR

@7L?C .)122)/-,'++ /)332)+43'3/ 3)01/)0,4'3/ \ ^R Q V_\ [ _`[ Q RP^R`[

)78FILLC 3+/)233'++ ,)+14)0-,'/1 Q R P^R `[ `^N_Y R__[ NX A;<

(22)

2UUL =DSMDNHOUDSL

( -. (

4DNHSD GHL 5HQVUDUL

ED:: ;68:A;2BC@2 ^ 5:A68=: 5: ;6886 6 @6;2F:>=: ^ 5>4C<6=B: ^ 5>4% 44ED:: =% ,

F ; = ?C B ?

< [ Z Q V -+,-

#: R XVO R ^N 9?D; -, QVR) -+,-$

< [ Z Q V -+,.

^ VQ R `R ^Y VZ N `V

H [ `N XR Q [ \ [ @ -. Y NT T V[

-+,.' Z) 02

G V`a N d V[ Z R b N Xa `N d V[ Z R

\ ^[ T ^N Y Y V NX ,+ _R ``R Y O ^R -+,/

,)32/).+4'/1

AC@?G; ,34)3/+'++ -0-)-32'13 //-),-2'13

VZ N``R _N Y [ Q VSVPU R R P U VN ^VY R Z `V Q N XXN F RTV[ZR

9 7 A D7 B ?7 /)+,2)2-,'++ 0)..4)./+'+- 4).02)+1,'+- Z R __a Z \ ^[ T ^N Y Y N

DI=@?7 -)/2-)33.'++ .)-31)..,'+4 0)204)-,/'+4

VZ N``R_N Y [ Q VSVPU R R PU VN^VY RZ `V Q NXXN FRTV[ZR

87G?@?97H7 -2.)2/4'++ .1.)241',+ 1.2)0/0',+ Z R __a Z \ ^[ T ^N Y Y N

97@78F?7 ,)/.1)411'++ ,)4+4)10-'3- .)./1)1,3'3- Z R __a Z \ ^[ T ^N Y Y N

G?9?@?7 /),+0)--/'++ 0)/00)1-1'41 4)01+)30+'41

VZ N``R_N Y [ Q VSVPU R R P U VN^VY RZ `V Q NXXN F RTV[ZR

G7F:;=B7 ,),4+)3.0'++ ,)03-)001'4. -)22.).4,'4. Z R __a Z \ ^[ T ^N Y Y N

HCH7@; .3)+++)+++ 0+)0++)+++'++ //%,''%'''#''

(23)

2UUL =DSMDNHOUDSL

( -/ (

4DNHSD GHL 5HQVUDUL

ED:: ;68:A;2BC@2 ^ 5:A68=: 5: ;6886 6 @6;2F:>=: ^ 5>4C<6=B: ^ 5>4% 44ED:: =% ,

BHILQQH -% AXVYXXYVL @6<A UVLZPWXL S LQQL WPS N T QL @ LNPTSP

F ; = ?C B ? ?Y \ [ ^`[

N __R T Z N `[ QNX :VA -3*,-*-+,-

H V`[ X[ VZ `R ^b R Z `[ 9 [_`[

VZ `R ^b R Z `[

N PN^VP[

Q R XX[ _`N`[

9 [ _`[

P [ Y \ XR __Vb [

#G `N`[ & F RT V[ Z R$

?Y \ [ ^`[

^R _VQ a [

B a Y R ^[

\ [ _`V XR ``[

D?;ACBH; q,,)40-)001',/ F V]aNXVSVPNdV[ZR QRXX"RQ VSVPV[ Rc FG7 A NQ[ZZN : [ ^[ `RN QV 8V[TXV[ #8?$

q

0)130)20+'++

q 0)430)+++'++ q,)4.1',/ /+ \V

F RNXVddNdV[ZR QV a Z N _`^a ``a ^N R c `^N[ _\ RQ NXVR^N

\^R__[ X[PNXV`e 9 N_PVZN G \ N Z Q [ Z N ^N ( 7 XR__NZQ^VN

q

1)-1/)32+'++

q 1)04/)1++'++ .+ \V

@CA87F:?7 J7@@;

:"7CGH7

q.,)41+)-1-'-2 q.04)/4,',1

X$F V] a NXVSVPNdV[ Z R Q R XX"C _\ R Q N XR D_VPUVN`^VP[

q

,0)4-3)01.'4 ,

q ,1)211)4+4'.3 ************ ,-+\X

q.-).,4)20.'/. = Va Q VdVN ^V[ QV 9 N_`VT XV[ Z R QRXXR G`VbVR^R (7)C) 9) D[Y N (A NZ`[bN -$F V]aNXVSVPNdV[ZR QV QRXX"RQ VSVPV[

A (B QRX D ^R_VQV[ A aX`V(

_\RPVNXV_`VP[ QV A N^VNZ[

9 [ Y RZ _R ( 7)C) QV 9 [Y [

q

0)./.)344'/0

q 0)1-0),02'.- /+\X

, .$F RNXVddNdV[ZR QV a Z N _`^a ``a ^N _NZ V`N^VN Rc `^N[ _\ RQ NXVR^N

\^R__[ H C _\RQNXR QV @ RZ[ ( 7)C) QV : R_RZ dNZ [ QRX

= N^Q N

q

0)./.)344'/0

q 0)1-0),02'.- /+\X

(24)

2UUL =DSMDNHOUDSL

( -0 (

4DNHSD GHL 5HQVUDUL

ED:: ;68:A;2BC@2 ^ 5:A68=: 5: ;6886 6 @6;2F:>=: ^ 5>4C<6=B: ^ 5>4% 44ED:: =% ,

F ; = ?C B ? ?Y \ [ ^`[

N __R T Z N `[ QNX : A -3*,-*-+,-

H V`[ X[ VZ `R ^b R Z `[ 9 [ _`[

VZ `R ^b R Z `[

N PN^VP[

Q R XX[ _`N `[

9 [_`[

P [ Y \ XR __Vb [

#G `N`[ & F RT V[ Z R$

?Y \ [ ^`[

^R _ VQ a [

B a Y R ^[

\ [ _`V XR ``[

/$F RPa\R^[ QRV

\NQVTXV[ZV < [^XNZVZV R F [Zd[ZV NI "VZ`R^Z[ QRXX"Rc C _\ RQ NXR D_VPUVN`^VP[ QV

@ VY OVN`R (7)C)

=) GNXbVZV QV

= N^O NT Z N`R A VXNZR_R

q

0)./.)344'/0

q0)1-0),02'.- /+\X

0$ A VTXV[^NY RZ`[

] a N XV(] a NZ `V`N `Vb [ QRTXV N_\R``V

^RXN`VbV NXXN _VPa^RddN QRXXR _ `^a ``a ^R _NZ V`N^VR Rc `^N[ _\ RQ NXVR^R

\R^ VX _a \ R ^NY R Z `[

QRTXV CD= PUR b R^^NZ Z [

^RNXVddN`R VZ

^RTV[ZR

@ [Y ON^QVN

q.04)/4,',1 q.23)/,,'20

J;B;HC q ,,)032)-01'21 \ ^[ T ^NY Y N VZ P[^_[ QV b NXa `NdV[ Z R

<F?I@?

J;B;L?7

=?I@?7

q-)0.-)2.2'/- F R_VQRZdN \R^

X"NPP[TXVY RZ`[ R X"N__V_`RZ dN QV

\NdVRZ`V

\_VPUVN`^VPV P[Z Y V_a ^R QV _VPa ^RddN QV A NZVNT[ #DB $ '

q

,)/3/)20,'-+

q,)01-)341'++ V q

,)+/2)431'-- ,+ \V

(25)

2UUL =DSMDNHOUDSL

( -1 (

4DNHSD GHL 5HQVUDUL

ED:: ;68:A;2BC@2 ^ 5:A68=: 5: ;6886 6 @6;2F:>=: ^ 5>4C<6=B: ^ 5>4% 44ED:: =% ,

@68:>=: \ :RUTVXT P BPXTQT PSXLVZLSXT HWWLNSHXT KHQ

\ 5< )/&()&)'()

4TWXT 4TWXT PSXLVZLSXT JTR UQLWWPZT H JHVPJT 1 AXHXT"@LNPTSL!

KLQQT WXHXT

:RUTVXT =YRLVT VLWPKYT UTWXP

QLXXT

@?=IF?7 q 0)100)0,0'.3 F RNXVddNdV[ZR _`^a ``a ^N _NZ V`N^VN Rc`^N [ _\ RQ NXVR^N

\R^ VX _a \ R ^NY R Z `[

QRTXV [_\RQNXV

\_VPUVN`^VPV T Va Q Vd VN^V ( 9NXVPR NX 9 [^Z [ b VT XV[

#GD$

_

.)34.),++'++

6 q/)+43)+++'++ q -+ \V

,)21-)/,0'.3

;A?@?7 FCA 7=B 7

q4)43/)..3'+- F RNXVddNdV[ZR QV

^R_VQ RZ dR \R^

X"R_RPa dV[ Z R QRXVR Y V_a ^R QV _VPa ^RddN ( 7 dVRZ Q N IG@ QV FRTTV[ ;YVXVN

_

1)434)+.1'1,

q 2).01)33+'1/ _

-)440).+,'/, /+ \V

HC G97 B7 IA8F?7

_ 4)++0)313'+- q-)++-),,0'/1

_ ,,)++2)43/'.0

,$ G `^a ``a ^N

\_VPUVN`^VPN

^R_VQ RZ dVNXR @R E aR^PR ( 9 [ Y a Z R QV

<V^RZdR ( 7IG@

,+ QV <V^RZdR

_ .3+)+++'++ _ /++)+++'++ &&&&&&&&&&&& 3 \V

-$ 7 ^RN JN_`N GaQ

;_` ( ^R_VQRZdN _NZ V`N^VN \ R^ XN _NXa `R Y RZ `NXR ( 9 [ Y a Z R QV 8VOOVRZN #7F$ ( 7IG@ 3 QV 7 ^Rdd[

_

,)-0+).12',2

q,).,1),20'42 ,- \V

.$ F R_VQRZdN _NZV`N^VN VZ `R^Y RQ VN pH VdVNZ [ ( 9 [ Y a Z R QV 7aXXN

#AG$ ( 7 dVRZQN IG@ , QV A N__N R 9 N^^N^N

q 21+)+++'++ q 3++)+++'++ ,+ \V

/$ F R_VQRZdN _NZV`N^VN VZ `R^Y RQ VN 7 J 9 RZ`^[ (

@N_`^N N GVTZN #<?$

( 7 dVRZ Q N IG@ ,+

QV <V^RZdR

q

,)-0+'.12',2

q,).,1),20'42 ,+ \V

(26)

2UUL =DSMDNHOUDSL

( -2 (

4DNHSD GHL 5HQVUDUL

ED:: ;68:A;2BC@2 ^ 5:A68=: 5: ;6886 6 @6;2F:>=: ^ 5>4C<6=B: ^ 5>4% 44ED:: =% ,

F ; = ?C B ? ?Y \ [ ^`[

N__R T Z N`[ Q NX 5< )/&()&)'()

H V`[ X[ VZ `R ^b R Z `[ 9 [_`[

VZ `R ^b R Z `[

N PN^VP[

Q R XX[ _`N `[

9 [_`[

P [ Y \ XR __Vb [

#G `N`[& F RTV[ZR$

?Y \ [ ^`[

^R _VQ a [

B a Y R ^[

\ [ _`V XR ``[

0 F RNXVddNdV[ZR

^R_VQ RZ dN _N Z V`N ^VN \R^

R_RPa dV[ Z R Y V_a ^R QV _VPa ^RddN Q R `R Z `Vb N ( 9 [ Y \ XR__[ @N 8NQVN ( GNZ A VZVN`[ #D?$

7IG@ ,, ;Y \[XV q

2).12)-0+'++

q 2)200)+++'++ .- \V

A 7 F9>; q .)-.4)..0',1 F RNXVddNdV[ZR QV a Z N _ `^a ``a ^N NV _RZ_V Q RXXN @RTTR Z) 4*,- N^`) .(`R^

P[ Y Y N - ( 9 [ Y a Z R QV

<[__[ Y O ^[ Z R ( 7 ^RN JN_`N , 7GIF

q

.)-.4)..0',1

q .)/+4)3-1'/3 ************ -+ \V

@7L?C q,1)3-+),,+'+2 X$F R _ `N a ^[ R

^V_N Z NY RZ `[

P [ Z _R^b N`Vb [ Q R> "VY Y [OVXR QV bVN 8 N^`[X[Y R[

9 N \ V`N Z V[ GB 9 QN Q R _`VZ N ^R N F;AG5 Q a R Y [ Q a XV Y N_PUVXV R

\ R^P[ ^_[

^VNO VXV`N`Vb [ o 7G@

FA 7

q

,+)2/+).++'+

2

q ,,).+0)024'+-

#q2)/++)+++'++$

************ /+ \V

- $ F V_`^a ``a ^N dV[

ZR RQVXVdVN QRV X[PNXV N``a N XY RZ `R Q R _`VZ N `V N GD:9

Q R XX"[ _ \ R Q N XR QV G aOVNP[ Q N Q R _`VZ N ^R N F;AG5

Q a R Y [ Q a XV Y N_PUVXV 7G@

FA =

q

/)./2)-++'++

q /)021)+++'++ /+ \V ,

(27)

2UUL =DSMDNHOUDSL

( -3 (

4DNHSD GHL 5HQVUDUL

ED:: ;68:A;2BC@2 ^ 5:A68=: 5: ;6886 6 @6;2F:>=: ^ 5>4C<6=B: ^ 5>4% 44ED:: =% ,

F ; = ?C B ? ?Y \ [ ^`[

N __R T Z N`[ Q NX 5< )/&()&)'()

H V`[ X[ VZ `R ^b R Z `[ 9 [_`[

VZ `R ^b R Z `[

N PN^VP[

Q R XX[ _`N `[

9 [ _`[

P [ Y \ XR __Vb [

#G `N`[ & F RT V[ Z R$

?Y \ [ ^`[

^R _VQ a [

B a Y R ^[

\ [ _`V XR ``[

.$F R_`Na^[ R

^V_N Z NY RZ `[

P[Z _R^b N`Vb [ Q R XX"VY Y [ O VXR QV bVN 9 XN^VPR H N^`a SN^V QN Q R _`VZ N ^R N F;AG ( Y [ Q a X[

SRY Y VZ VXR ( 7G@

F A 9

q

,)2.-)1,+'++

q ,)3-.)3++'++ ,0 \V

78FILLC AC@?G;

q.)13,)+,-'-, q 313).+2'44

q /)0/4).-+'-+

F RNXVddNdV[ZR QV a Z N _`^a ``a ^N Rc `^N [ _\ R Q NXVR^N QV -+ \[_`V ?R``[ VZ P[ Y a Z R QV FV\N HRN`VZN ( 7G@

@ NY PVNZ[(J N_`[(

9 UVR`V

q

/)0/4).-+'-+

q /)233)203',+ ************ -+ \V

9 7 A D7 B ?7 q ,3).21)1+.'03 X$@ Nb [ ^V QV

^VP[ Z b R^_V[ Z R RQ N Q R T a N Y R Z `[ N _ `^a ``a ^N _NZ V`N^VN R c `^N [ _\ R Q NXVR^N Q V -+ \ [_`V XR``[

QRXXN FG7 QV GNZ BVP[XN 8N^[ZVN

#7J$ ( 7G@ 7J q

,)+2+)++,'.3

q ,),-1).,2'-/ ************ -+ \V

-$@Nb[^V QV

^V_`^a ``a ^N d V[ Z R R N Q RT a N Y R Z `[ QV a Z RQVSVPV[ _V`[

ZRX P[ Y a Z R QV 7 ^\ N V_R #8B$' TVe N Q VO V`[ N G?F' QN Q R _`VZ N ^R N _ `^a ``a ^N _NZ V`N^VN Rc `^N [ _\ R Q NXVR^N QV -+ \[_`V XR``[ ( 7G@ 8B

q

,)---)444'1+

q ,)-32).13'++ -+ \V

(28)

2UUL =DSMDNHOUDSL

( -4 (

4DNHSD GHL 5HQVUDUL

ED:: ;68:A;2BC@2 ^ 5:A68=: 5: ;6886 6 @6;2F:>=: ^ 5>4C<6=B: ^ 5>4% 44ED:: =% ,

F ; = ?C B ? ?Y \ [ ^`[

N __R T Z N `[ QNX 5< )/&()&)'()

H V`[ X[ VZ `R ^b R Z `[ 9 [_`[

VZ `R ^b R Z `[

N PN^VP[

Q R XX[ _`N`[

9 [_`[

P [ Y \ XR __Vb [

#G`N`[& F RTV[ZR$

?Y \ [ ^`[

^R _ VQ a [

B a Y R ^[

\ [ _`V XR ``[

.$@Nb[^V QV

^V_`^a ``a ^N dV[ Z R R N Q RT a N Y R Z `[ QV aZ RQVSVPV[ _V`[

ZRX P [ Y a Z R QV 9NXbV FV_[^`N

#9;$' Q N Q R_`VZ N^R N _`^a ``a ^N _NZV`N^VN Rc `^N[ _\ RQ NXVR^N QV -+ \[_`V XR``[ ( 7 G @ 9 ;

q

,).13)+0-'-0

q ,)//+)+00'++ -+ \V

/$ @Nb[^V Q V P [ _`^a dV[ Z R' ZRX P[ Y a Z R QV

<^NZP[XV_R #9;$

QV a Z RQVSVPV[ QN Q R _`VZ N ^R N _`^a ``a ^N

^R_VQ RZ dVNXR Rc `^N[ _\ RQ NXVR^N QV -+ \[_`V XR``[ ( 7G@ 9;

L

.)3/-)0/4'00

q /)+//)234'++ -+ \V

0$@Nb[^V QV

^V_`^a ``a ^N dV[ Z R' N Q RT a N Y R Z `[ R P[ Z _[ XVQ NY RZ `[

_`^a ``a ^N XR QRXX"RQVSVPV[ _V`[

VZ B N\[XV Q R Z [ Y VZ N `[

=R_j R A N^VN

\ R^ XN

^RNXVddNdV[ Z R QV a Z N _`^a ``a ^N

^R_VQ RZ dVNXR QV -+

\[_`V XR``[ ( 7G@

B N\[XV , 9 RZ `^[

L

.).++)+++'20

q.)/2.)130'++ -+ \V

Riferimenti

Documenti correlati

Il programma assistenziale della regione, sottoposto al vaglio e al decreto del Ministro della Salute, deve contenere i progetti terapeutico riabilitativi individuali, a

A decorrere dall'anno 2009, il Comitato interministeriale per la programmazione economica (CIPE), su proposta del Ministro del lavoro, della salute e delle politiche sociali,

Il 1° agosto 2007 la Conferenza Stato-Regioni ha ratificato in via definitiva il provvedimento con il quale il Ministro della Salute Livia Turco ha destinato 10 milioni

Potrebbe apparire come il &#34;paradosso della Giustizia&#34; quello del diritto universale alla salute, che ancora oggi a distanza di più di otto anni dalla norma che disciplina

Il decreto 12 agosto 2021 del Ministro della salute, preceduto da una Intesa con la Conferenza Stato-regioni, ha definito le funzioni assistenziali correlate all'emergenza

Per la Missione 6 SALUTE sono confermate le risorse già assegnate con la precedente versione del PNRR: si tratta di 15,63 miliardi di RRF a cui, per dichiarazione ufficiale del

Per questo rinnoviamo al Ministro della salute, Roberto Speranza, la proposta di organizzare un tavolo di confronto con le organizzazioni che rappresentano questi giovani medici

La richiesta al Ministro della salute avanzata dall’Assessore Icardi è giusta ma incompleta: non deve ridursi ad una «revisione temporanea delle percentuali di compartecipazione