• Non ci sono risultati.

Sulle famiglie di curve con singolarità di prefissato tipo

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Condividi "Sulle famiglie di curve con singolarità di prefissato tipo"

Copied!
82
0
0

Testo completo

(1)

             ! "# $%&'() *+,,- ./012,1- 31 4+56 -478 91827,/51:/; 31 <5-=99/:7 :1<7 >'?@@ABCD( E? FAD%@

(2)

P

Q RST TUVU WXS UYTZ W[\]^ ^_YSR\ZW^ `[ P

U SaaS\S `\UZSVV^V^ RZ\^bZUT^_cSTVS TS_ `Z^TU a[

[T^ W[\]^ WUT aU_Z TUdZe WZUSP`[TVZ dU``Z ^ V^TYSTVZ dZaVZTVSf gV[dZ^\S _S W[\]S ^_YSR\ZWXS

[VZ_Zbb^TdU WUcS `\ZTWZ`^_S cUdS__U [T^ _U\U `\UZSbZUTS `Z^T^ WUT TUdZ P

S [T cSVUdU dZ _^h

]U\U cU_VU [VZ_Zbb^VU d^Y_Z ^[VU\Z W_^aaZWZf iUTaZdS\^TdU V^_Z cUdS__Z `Z^TZej\Z__ S kUSVXS\

dZSdS\U Zc`[_aU ^d [T l_UTS dZ \ZWS\W^ a[__S aS\ZS _ZTS^\Z dZ V^_Z W[\]S S a[__^ _U\U W_^aaZh

lW^bZUTSe WXS ^ V[VVmUYYZ `^\S ^TWU\^ TUT Sa^[\ZVU nWo\f pq\R^\S__UhiU\T^_R^re ps^\ZatZure

pv^X_re pj\[ThwZ\aWXUxZVbrye UVVSTSTdU V\^ _m ^_V\U [T^ dZcUaV\^bZUTS aZTVSVZW^ dS_ VSU\Sc^

dZ zZSc^TThzUWXf {T S|SVVZe _S WUTlY[\^bZUTZ dSZ TUdZ d^TTU cU_VS ZToU\c^bZUTZ aZ^ a[__^

YSUcSV\Z^dS__SW[\]SeaZ^a[ a`^bZ`^\^cSV\Zbb^TVZWUcSY_ZaWXScZdZwZ_RS\VU_S]^\ZSV^PdSZ

cUd[_Zf qd SaSc`ZUe gS]S\Z `STaUPdZ dSd[\\S _mZ\\Zd[WZRZ_ZV^PdS__S ]^\ZSV^PdSZ cUd[_Z d^__^

Z\\Zd[WZRZ_ZV^P dSY_Z a`^bZ `^\^cSV\Zbb^TVZ W[\]S `Z^TS TUd^_Z nWo\f pgS]S\Zrye dSVVZ ^``[TVU

]^\ZSV^P dZ gS]S\Z nZT \S^_V^P[T^ dZcUaV\^bZUTS aUddZao^WSTVS dS__mZ\\Zd[WZRZ_ZV^PdS__S ]^\ZSV^P

dZ gS]S\Z SP aV^V^ UVVST[V^ aU_U dZ \SWSTVS nWo\f pw^\\Zarye cSTV\S }[S__^ dS__^ Z\\Zd[WZRZ_ZV^P

dS__S ]^\ZSV P ^ dSZ cUd[_Z P S TUV^ YZ P ^ d^ VSc`Uyf

{T _SVVS\^V[\^eV^_]U_V^eaZ ZTWUTV\^TU dZcUaV\^bZUTZ a[ W_^aaZlW^bZUTZ dZ W[\]SeWXS `^ah

a^TU `S\ _^ WUTaZdS\^bZUTS dZ cUdS__Z `Z^TZ WUT aZTYU_^\ZV^P `Z[P WUc`_ZW^VS dSZ TUdZ nWo\f

pq

\R^\S__UhiU\T^_R^ryf {T S|SVVZ _^ `UaaZRZ_ZV^P dZ dSoU\c^\S W[\]S _ZaWZS ZT W[\]S ~cU_VU

dSYSTS\Z `\SaSTV^ [T WS\VU ZTVS\SaaS€ aZ `STaZ ^d SaSc`ZU ^_ VSTV^VZ]U W_^aaZWU dZ dSd[\\S

dSY_Z ZT]^\Z^TVZ WUcRZT^VU\Z `S\ _^ W_^aaZlW^bZUTS dS__S W[\]S V\^cZVS dSYSTS\^bZUTZ ^ WUTh

lY[\^bZUTZ dZ \SVVSf {TU_V\S _mSaZaVSTb^ dZ o^cZY_ZS dZ dZ]ZaU\Z aZTYU_^\Z a[ [T^ a[`S\lWZS e

d^P ZToU\c^bZUTZ a[__^ YSUcSV\Z^ dZ  nWo\f p‚^TTSTR^[cryf ƒS\ [_VS\ZU\Z ZToU\c^bZUTZ a[

V^_Z `\UR_Sc^VZWXSe \Zc^TdZ^cU ^ piZ_ZRS\VUrf

„_Za`^bZ`^\^cSV\Zbb^TVZW[\]S^]STVZ[T WS\VUT[cS\UdZTUdZaUTUaV^VZW_^aaZW^cSTVS

aV[dZ^VZ d^ ]^\Z ^[VU\Zf zSWSTVScSTVS [T^ aZaVSc^bZUTS cUdS\T^ dZ V^_S VSU\Z^ P

S UVVST[V^

`S\ SaSc`ZU ZT pv^X_rf …U aWU`U dS_ `\SaSTVS _^]U\U SP WUaV\[Z\S `Z[P ZT YSTS\^_S a`^bZ

`^\^cSV\Zbb^TVZ W[\]S WUT ^aaSYT^VU VZ`U dZ aZTYU_^\ZV P

^ a[ a[`S\lWZ _ZaWZSf ƒS\ dSlTZ\S Z_

~VZ`UdZaZTYU_^\ZV^eP o^WWZ^cU\ZoS\ZcSTVU^__^W_^aaZlW^bZUTS dSRU_S nWo\fpQT\Z}[SahiXZaZTZe

_ZR\U {†re pw^\VaXU\TSe W^`ZVU_U †e `^\^Y\^oU ‡e UaaS\]^bZUTS ‡fˆfurye WXS aScR\^ SaaS\S `Z P

[

[VZ_Se ^_cSTU TS__m ^cRZVU dZ W[Z aU`\^e dS__^ W_^aaZlW^bZUTS `S\ ZaUcU\lacU ^T^_ZVZWU nWo\f

pw^\VaXU\TSe W^`ZVU_U {e `^\^Y\^oU ‰e SaS\WZbZU ‰fŠuryf

{_ `\ZcU `\UR_Sc^ WXS aZ ZTWUTV\^ SP}[S__U dZ V\^VV^\S ZT c^TZS\^VSWTZW^cSTVS c^TSYh

YS]U_S Z ]^\Z ~VZ`Z dZ aZTYU_^\ZV^fP …^ \Za`UaV^ ^ V^_S `\UR_Sc^ SP aV^V^ ZT S|SVVZ d^V^ d^

QT\Z}[Sa ZT pQT\Z}[SahiXZaZTZe _ZR\U {†r€ }[Z aZ V\U]^ [TU aV[dZU ^WW[\^VU dS__^ W_^aaZlh

W^bZUTS dSRU_S dS__S aZTYU_^\ZV^PS ]STYUTU ZTV\UdUVVZ dSZ dZ^Y\^ccZ cU_VU WUT]STZSTVZe WXS

`UaaUTU SaaS\S [VZ_Zbb^VZ `S\ dSlTZ\S Z_ ~VZ`Uf {T }[SaVU d[T}[S Z_ TUaV\U WUc`ZVU SPaV^VU

cU_VU ^YS]U_S€ WZ aZ^cU _ZcZV^VZ ^ \ZoU\c^_Zbb^\S ZT [T _ZTY[^YYZU cUdS\TU _^ dSlTZbZUTS

dSZ dZ^Y\^ccZ dZ QT\Z}[Sae WXS SaaSTbZ^_cSTVS aUTU dSZ Y\^lf ‹[SaVU SP Z_ WUTVST[VU dS_

W^`ZVU_U †e TSWSaa^\ZU `S\ V\^VV^\S WUT U``U\V[T^ `\SWZaZUTS _S dZcUaV\^bZUTZ dSZ W^`ZVU_Z

a[WWSaaZ]Zf

{ `\ZcZ }[^VV\U W^`ZVU_Z aUTU dSdZW^VZ ^__S dSlTZbZUTZ S `\U`\ZSV^P dSZ ~`[TVZ ZTlTZV^h

cSTVS ]ZWZTZe WXS aUTU _U aV\[cSTVU oUTd^cSTV^_S TS__^ WZV^V^ V\^VV^bZUTS dZ pQT\Z}[Sarf

(3)

TUaV\^ Zc`UaV^bZUTS SPaV^V^ }[S__^ dZ dSlTZ\S [T ~`[TVU ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZTU dZ e aSch

`_ZWScSTVS WUcS [T cU\lacU RZ\^bZUT^_S d^ [TU aWXSc^ _UW^_S \SYU_^\S dZ dZcSTaZUTS d[S

^d  n ^ cSTU dZ S}[Z]^_STb^ V\^cZVS ZaUcU\lacZyf ‹[SaVU WZ X^ `S\cSaaU dZ a]U_YS\S d^Z

oUTd^cSTVZ _^VSU\Z^eaWSTdSTdU TSZ dSVV^Y_ZdS__S dZcUaV\^bZUTZeSaV^RZ_STdU ZWU__SY^cSTVZ

dS__^TUaV\^ dSlTZbZUTS dSZ `[TVZ ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZTZ WUT }[S__S WU\\STVZf ‚[VVU WZUPZTU_V\Se

P

S aV^VU o^VVU ZT [T ^cRZVU YSTS\^_S€ }[S__U dSY_Z aWXScZ TUSVXS\Z^TZ ZTVSY\Z dZ dZcSTaZUTS

d[Sf ƒS\ o^\S }[SaVUe aUTU aV^VZ [VZ_Zbb^VZ V\^ _m^_V\Ue TS__^ _U\U `ZST^ YSTS\^_ZV^Pe ^_W[TZ

\Za[_V^VZ ^_YSR\ZWZ dZ s^\ZatZf P

Q ^TWXS Y\^bZS ^ V^_Z \Za[_V^VZ WXS WZ SP aV^VU `UaaZRZ_S d^\S

[T^ dZcUaV\^bZUTS ^YS]U_S dZ ^_W[TS `\U`UaZbZUTZ dU][VS ^d qRXŒ^Tt^\ nWo\f pqRXŒ^Tt^\rye

WXS WUaVZV[ZaWUTU Z_ `\ZTWZ`^_S aV\[cSTVU `S\ aV^RZ_Z\S Z a[ddSVVZ WU__SY^cSTVZ V\^ _S ]^\ZS

dSlTZbZUTZf

{T dSlTZVZ]^e Z `\ZcZ WZT}[S W^`ZVU_Z oU\TZaWUTU [T^ V\^VV^bZUTS YSTS\^_S S cU_VU dSVh

V^Y_Z^V^ nc^ ^__U aVSaaU VSc`U aZTVSVZW^y dS__^ VSU\Z^ dSZ `[TVZ ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZTZe WXS

`\S`^\^ Z_ VS\\STU ZT c^TZS\^ ^dSY[^V^ ^__S dZcUaV\^bZUTZ dSZ W^`ZVU_Z a[WWSaaZ]Ze `Z[PaV\SVh

V^cSTVS^VVZTSTVZ ^__UaWU`U`\SlaaUf {_o^VVUWXS aZ^TUaV^VSa]Z_[``^VS dZcUaV\^bZUTZcU_VU

dSVV^Y_Z^VS dZ o^VVZ ^ ]U_VS S_ScSTV^\Z _U \ZVSTZ^cU WUa^ [VZ_Se `UZWXSe d^V^ _^ YSTS\^_ZV^PZT

W[Z WZ aZ^cU cUaaZe S\^ `UaaZRZ_S WXS _mSa`S\ZSTb^ S _mZTV[ZbZUTS dS\Z]^TVZ d^_ _^]U\^\S WUT

]^\ZSV^P a[ [T W^c`U ^_YSR\ZW^cSTVS WXZ[aUe V\^SaaS V^_]U_V^ ZT ZTY^TTUf

kSZ W^`ZVU_Z a[WWSaaZ]Z ^_ }[ZTVU aZ [VZ_Zbb^ Z_ _^]U\U `\S_ZcZT^\S `S\ WUaV\[Z\S _S ]^\ZSV^P

dSZ dZ]ZaU\ZWUT aZTYU_^\ZV^P^aaSYT^V^ea[ [T^a[`S\lWZS_ZaWZ^f …^aV\^VSYZ^SP}[Z [T `UmdZh

]S\a^d^ }[S__^[VZ_Zbb^V^ ZT pv^X_r€ aZ V\^VV^ZTT^TbZV[VVUdZ dSlTZ\S U``U\V[TZaUVVUaWXScZ

dZ eZT cUdU WXS Zc`U\\S ^d [T dZ]ZaU\S dZ ^]S\S [T ^aaSYT^VUVZ`U dZaZTYU_^\ZV^PS}[Z]^_Y^

^d Zc`U\\S WUTdZbZUTZ dZ ~`^aa^YYZU `S\ V^_Z aUVVUaWXScZf g[WWSaaZ]^cSTVS aZ WUaV\[ZaWS

[T^ o^cZY_Z^ `^\^cSV\Zbb^TVS V[VVZ Z aUVVUaWXScZ dZ  dZ `\Slaa^VU VZ`Uf ‚^_S o^cZY_Z^

TUT P

S [T^ o^cZY_Z^ [TZ]S\a^_Se c^ aSYT^_Z^cUe aSRRSTS }[SaVU TUT aZ^ V\^VV^VU TS__^ VSaZe

WXS [T^ o^cZY_Z^ [TZ]S\a^_S `[UP SaaS\S UVVST[V^ d^ }[SaV^ `S\ }[UbZSTVS dS__U a`^bZU dSZ

`^\^cSV\Z V\^cZVS _m^bZUTS dZ [T U``U\V[TU Y\[``U lTZVU nWU\\Za`UTdSTVS aUaV^TbZ^_cSTVS

^_ Y\[``U dSY_Z ^[VUcU\lacZdS_ dZ^Y\^cc^WXS dSlTZaWS Z_VZ`Uyf …S o^cZY_ZS}[Z WUaV\[ZVS

`UV\SRRS\U V\^ _m ^_V\U SaaS\S [VZ_Z `S\ _U aV[dZU dS__^ aV\[VV[\^ dSY_Z aWXScZ dZ wZ_RS\V dZ

Y\[``Z dZ `[TVZ a[  nWo\f pj\Z^TWUTrŽ e pj\[ThwZ\aWXUxZVbryf

kS__m[_VZcUW^`ZVU_U aZ dZcUaV\^ nWo\f‚SU\Sc^ fyeV\^cZVS_^ WUaV\[bZUTS dS__S ]^\ZSV^P

dZ ZTWZdSTb^ \S_^VZ]S ^ dZ]ZaU\Z S ^__S o^cZY_ZS dZ aUVVUaWXScZ dZ W[Z aU`\^e WXS Z_ _[UYU

dSZ dZ]ZaU\Z dZ [T^ aS\ZS _ZTS^\S WUc`_SV^e WUT `\Slaa^VU VZ`U dZ aZTYU_^\ZV^eP SP [T ZTaZScS

WUaV\[ZRZ_S nTS__U a`^bZU `\UZSVVZ]U `^\^cSV\Zbb^TVS _^ aS\ZS _ZTS^\S aVSaa^yf

{T `\Ua`SVVZ]^e_^ WUaV\[bZUTS dZ V^_Z _[UYXZ`[UPa`S\^RZ_cSTVS `U\V^\S ^d [T^ cZY_ZU\S

WUTUaWSTb^ \ZY[^\dU ]^\ZS }[SaVZUTZ dZ VSU\Z^ dS__S W[\]Se^d SaSc`ZU a[__S o^cZY_ZS dZ W[\]S

dZ YSTS\S `\Slaa^VU a[ a[`S\lWZ \^bZUT^_Zf

†U\\SZ \ZTY\^bZ^\S Z_ `\Uof …[W^ iXZ^TVZTZ `S\ _^ ZTdZa`STa^RZ_S ^aaZaVSTb^ `\SaV^V^cZe

(4)

˜™š›™œ™

ƒS\ c^YYZU\S WXZ^\Sbb^e aV^RZ_Z^cU ZT }[SaVU W^`ZVU_U ^_W[TS dSlTZbZUTZ S WUT]STbZUTZ dZ

R^aSž \ZWXZ^cS\ScU

^_V\SaP

Ÿ

^_W[TZ \Za[_V^VZ WXSe SaaSTdU RST TUVZe TUT dZcUaV\S\ScUf iZ ^Vh

VS\\ScUeWUT `UWXS SWWSbZUTZe ^__SdSlTZbZUTZ dZ pw^\VaXU\TSržd[T}[Se`S\ }[^_aZ^aZ VS\cZTS

TUT Sa`_ZWZV^cSTVS dSlTZVU }[Ze aZ ZTVSTdS\^P ^aa[TV^ _^ dSlTZbZUTS dZ pw^\VaXU\TSrf

 ¡¢£¤¥¦¦£¦¥¡§¥¨ ©ª«¬­«®¯ª«­ °±²± ³´µ ^TS__U ¶¥ ¥§·´§¸´µ£¹¶´º»µ´ ¼§ £§´¤¤¡ ¢¡ºº¼·£·¥½¡ ¼§¥·£µ¥¡¨ ¾¥£¿ ¼§ £§´¤¤¡ ´  ¼§£»£µ·´ º¡¤·¥»¤¥¢£·¥½£ ¸¥ ¿¨ À§¸¥¢Á´µ´º¡ ¢¡§ ÂÃ¿Ä ¤Å£§´¤¤¡ ¸´¤¤´Æµ£¦¥¡§¥ ¸¥¿ µ¥¶»´··¡ £¸Ä ¢¡¶¹ Ç ¢¡º´ ´¹¸´È§¥·¡¥§ pqVZŒ^XhÉ^WdUT^_deW^`ZVU_U{{{r¨¾´Ê ´¹¼§ ¥¸´£¤´ »µ¥º¡ ¸¥¿Ä ¤Å£§´¤¤¡¿Ë Ì n¿ ÍÊyÂÿ ¶£µ£¹¸´··¡ ¤¡¢£¤¥¦¦£¦¥¡§´ ¸¥¿ ¥§ ʨ  Å¡º¡º¡µÈ¶º¡ § £·¼µ£¤´ ¿ Î  Âÿ Á£ ¼ §£ »µ¡»µ¥´·¹ £ ¼ §¥½ ´µ¶£¤´ ϢƵ ¨ pq VZŒ^XhÉ^WdUT^_de W^`ZVU_U {{{e `\U`UaZbZUTS ‡fŠrÐÑ ¡ Ò §¥ ¡º¡º¡µÈ¶º¡ ¿ Î Ó ¶£µ£¹¸´··¡ UcUcU\lacU dZ _UW^_Zbb^bZUTS µ¥¶»´··¡ £ Ê Ä ¶ ´ Á£ ·£¤´ »µ¡»µ¥´·¹ £ ¼ § ¥½´µ¶£¤´ Ï¢¡§  Ì ¿ Í ÊÐ Ô ·£¤½¡¤·£ ¤ Å¡º¡º¡µÈ ¶ º ¡ ¶ £µ¹ £ ¶¡··¥§·´¶¡Ä ¥§ »£µ·¥¢¡¤£µ´ ¶´ ¿ Õ ÓÄ ´¶¶¡ ¶£µ£¹¤Å¥§¢¤¼¶¥¡§´¨ Ö ¥µ´º ¡ ¢Á´ ¼ § ¢£º» ¡ × ¹ ´ W^c`U dSZ }[UbZSTVZ ¸¥ ¼ § ¸¡º ¥§¥¡ ¸¥ ¥§· ´ Ò µ ¥· ¹ £¿Ä ·µ£º ¥· ´ ¼§ ¡º¡º¡µÈ¶º¡Ä ¶´ ·£¤´ ¡º¡º¡µÈ¶º¡ ´¹¼§ ¡º¡º¡µÈ¶º¡ ¸¥¤¡¢£¤¥¦¦£¦¥¡§´µ¥¶»´··¡ £¤¤Å¥¸´Ø £¤´ § ¼ ¤¤¡¨ ¾´ Ù € ¿ Î Ó ´ Ú € ¿Û Î ÓÛ ¶¡§¡ ¡º¡º¡µÈ¶º¥ ¸¥ £§´¤¤¥Ä ¸¥µ´º¡ ¢Á´ Ù WU\\Za`UTdS £ Ú ·µ£º¥·´ Ò ¤¥ ¥¶¡º ¡µÈ ¶º¥ Ü €¿ Î ¿Û ´ Ý € Ó Î ÓÛ ¶´ Ý ÞÙ Ì Ú Þܨ

ßàà­á¬â®¯ª«­ °±ã± gZ ]S\ZlW^ a[RZVUe [VZ_Zbb^TdU _^ `\U`\ZSV^P [TZ]S\a^_Se WXS ]^_YUTU Z

aSY[STVZ o^VVZf

n ^y ‘[S UcUcU\lacZ dZ _UW^_Zbb^bZUTS dZ ¿ \Za`SVVU ^d [T a[U ZdS^_S `\ZcU Êe dZoh

oS\ZaWUTU `S\ [TmZaUcU\lacUžWZU P S dSVVZ Ù € ¿ Î Ó S ÙÛ €¿ Î ÓÛ Z d[SUcUcU\lacZeSaZaVS [T ZaUcU\lacU Ý €Ó Î ÓÛ V^_S WXS ÙÛ Ì Ý ÞÙf

nRy gS [T UcUcU\lacU Ù €¿ Î Ó WU\\Za`UTdS ^d [T UcUcU\lacU dZ _UW^_Zbb^bZUTS

¿Û Î ÓÛ \Za`SVVU ^d [T ZdS^_S `\ZcUÊ dZ ¿ÛeV\^cZVS ZaUcU\lacZ Ü €¿ Î ¿Û S Ý €Ó Î ÓÛe

^__U\^ Ù SP[T UcUcU\lacU dZ _UW^_Zbb^bZUTS \Za`SVVU ^d ÜÂÃnÊyf

¾¡··¡¶¢Á´º¥ £»´µ·¥¨ ©ª«¬­«®¯ª«­ °±ä± ¾¥£  ¼§¡ ¶¢Á´º£Ä å ¼§ £»´µ·¡ ¸¥  ´ æç € å Î  ¤Å¥§¢¤¼¶¥¡§´¨ è Ò §¥Æ£¶¢¥¡ éç ¥¶¡º¡µÆ¡ £ éêëç Ì æ Âà ç néêy ¸´È§¥¶¢´ ¼§£ ¶·µ¼··¼µ£ ¸¥ ¶¢Á´º£ ¶¼ å ¢Á´ µ´§¸´ å ¼§ ¶¡··¡¶¢Á´º£ £»´µ·¡ ¸¥ Ä ´ æç Ϥ£ Ƽ§¦¥¡§´ ¶¼¥ ¶¡¶·´ Ò §¥ ¸¥Ð ¼§ º ¡µÈ ¶º¡ ¸¥ ¶¢Á´º¥¨ ¾·£ì¥¤¥£º¡ ¢Á´ ¥¤Æ£¶¢¥¡ éç ¶¥£ ¸£·¡ ¸£ éçníy Ì éêníy »´µ ¡ Ò §¥ £»´µ·¡ í ¸¥ åÄ ´ ¸£ Ò ¤¥ ¡º¡º ¡µÈ ¶º¥ ¸¥ µ´¶·µ¥¦¥¡§´ îï𠸥 éêÄ ¸¡½´ ñ Õ í Õ å¨  £ º£»»£ æò ç ¹ ´ ¸£·£ ¸£ æò ç níy Ì îï ïóçÄ »´µ ¡ Ò §¥ £»´µ·¡ í ¸¥ ¨

ßàà­á¬â®¯ª«­ °±ô± gS õ €  Î ö SP [T cU\lacU dZ aWXScZe S aS í SP [T ^`S\VU dZ ö

(5)

ò nõëç÷ ïy ò nñ y Ì îøùúûð ü øùúûð üóç Þõ ò

nñye `S\ UYTZ ^`S\VU ñ dZ í f {TU_V\Se _^ \SaV\ZbZUTS

õëç÷ ï SPV^_S WXS õÞæç Ì æï Þõ ëç÷ ï edU]S æç S æï aUTU _S ZTW_[aZUTZ\Za`SVVZ]^cSTVS dZ å SdZ

í eSd SP_m[TZWU cU\lacU^]S\ZlW^\SV^_SWUTdZbZUTS nd^VUWXSWZUPSP]S\UZTaZScZaVZW^cSTVSyf

ßàà­á¬â®¯ª«­ °±ý± gS õ €þ Î  SP[T cU\lacU dZ aWXScZeS aS å SP[T ^`S\VU dZ e ^__U\^

õ o^VVU\Zbb^ V\^cZVS _mZTW_[aZUTS æç aS S aU_U aS _mZcc^YZTS ZTaZScZaVZW^ õnþy SP WUTVST[V^

ZT åe ZTU_V\S _^ o^VVU\Zbb^bZUTSe aS SaZaVSe SP [TZW^f {_ ~aU_U aS SP U]]ZUe Z_ ~aS S _m[TZWZV^P

dZaWSTdUTU a[RZVU d^ }[^TVU dSVVU TS__mUaaS\]^bZUTS ÿfu€ ZTo^VVZ õ Þæ Ì æç Þ õë ÷ç e S æ Ì Zd f  ¼ ¥½ £¤´§ ¦£ ·µ£ ¶¢Á ´º ¥ £ §¥ ´¸ £§ ´¤¤¥¨ ©ª«¬­«®¯ª«­ °±± ¾´ Ù € ¿ Î Ó ´¹¼§ ¡º¡º¡µÈ¶º¡ ¸¥ £§´¤¤¥Ä ¥¤ º¡µÈ¶º¡ g`SW Ó Î g`SW ¿Ä ¢¡¶¹ Ç

¢¡º´ ´¹¸´È§¥·¡ ¥§ pw^\VaXU\TSe W^`ZVU_U {{e `\U`UaZbZUTS ’f‡rÄ ¶£µ£¹¥§¸¥¢£·¡

¢¡§ g`SW Ù¨

ßàà­á¬â®¯ª«­ °±± …^WUT]STbZUTS ÿfSPYZ[aVZlW^V^d^_o^VVUWXS _S`UaZbZUTZ¿ Î g`SW ¿e

Ù

Î g`SW Ù

edSlTZaWUTU [T o[TVU\S WUTV\U]^\Z^TVS d^__^ W^VSYU\Z^dSY_Z ^TS__Z WUcc[V^VZ]Z

[TZV^\Z ^__^ W^VSYU\Z^ dSY_Z aWXScZ ^TZ nWo\f p„\UVXSTdZSWth‘ZS[dUTTSe W^`ZVU_U {e Šf f ‰ryf

\^

\ZWU\dZ^cU [T o^VVU oUTd^cSTV^_S ZT VSU\Z^ dSY_Z aWXScZ€ Z_ o[TVU\S g`SW S }[S__U

d^VU d^__S aSbZUTZ Y_UR^_Z nþ Î é nþye nõ €þ Î y Î nõ

ò

ny € é n y Î é nþyy n yy

ZTd[WUTU [TmS}[Z]^_STb^ V\^ _^ W^VSYU\Z^ dSY_Z aWXScZ ^TZ S _^ W^VSYU\Z^ U``UaV^ dZ }[S__^

dSY_Z ^TS__Z WUcc[V^VZ]Z [TZV^\Zf T \ZoS\ZcSTVU `S\ }[SaVU \Za[_V^VU SP p„\UVXSTdZSWth

‘ZS[dUTTSe W^`ZVU_U Še Šf f‰rf kUZ d^\ScU [T WSTTU dZ dZcUaV\^bZUTSe WXS cUaV\^ WUcS

WZUP aZ^ aUaV^TbZ^_cSTVS WUTVST[VU TS__S `\U`UaZbZUTZ dZ pw^\VaXU\TSe W^`ZVU_U {{re ZT `^\h

VZWU_^\S pZRZdfe `\U`UaZbZUTS ’f‡r S a[^ dZcUaV\^bZUTSf ƒS\ dZcUaV\^\S d[T}[S WXS Z d[S

o[TVU\Z ZTd[WUTU [TmS}[Z]^_STb^ dZ W^VSYU\ZS nWo\f pÉ^W …^TSe W^`ZVU_U {e `^\^Y\^oU ur

`S\ _^ dSlTZbZUTS dZ S}[Z]^_STb^ dZ W^VSYU\ZSye dURRZ^cU dZcUaV\^\S _mSaZaVSTb^e `S\ UYTZ

^TS__U ¿ S `S\ UYTZ aWXSc^ ^TS þe dZ ZaUcU\lacZ T^V[\^_Z  €¿ÍÎ é ng`SW ¿y S

 €þÍÎ g`SW é nþyf ᪪௮¯ª«­ °±± ³´µ ¡ Ò §¥ £§´¤¤¡ ¢¡ºº¼·£·¥½¡ ¼§¥·£µ¥¡ ¿ ´¶¥¶·´ ¼§ ¥¶¡º ¡µÈ ¶º¡  € ¿ÍÎ é ng`SW ¿yÄ ·£¤´ ¢Á´¶¥ £ì쥣 ng`SW Ùy ò ng`SW ¿yÞ Ì ÞÙ »´µ ¡ Ò §¥ ¡º¡º¡µØ È ¶º¡Ù €¿ Î Ó¨ ³´µ ¡ Ò §¥¶¢Á´º£ £ §´þ ´¶¥¶·´¼§ ¥¶¡º ¡µÈ ¶º¡  €þÍÎ g`SW é nþy ·£¤´ ¢Á´»´µ ¡ Ò §¥ º¡µÈ¶º¡ ¸¥ ¶¢Á´º¥ £§¥ õ €þ Î ¶¥ £ì쥣g`SW õ ò n yÞ  Ì  Þõ¨ À§¡¤·µ´ ¶¥ Á£  ò ng`SW é nþyy Ì  Âà  û ü ´ g`SW  Ì  Âà   ¨

 ! !"#$ %&'!( ƒS\ pw^\VaXU\TSe W^`ZVU_U {{e `\U`UaZbZUTS

’

f ‡ S \S_^VZ]^ dZh

cUaV\^bZUTSre g`SW SP [T o[TVU\S `ZSTU S oSdS_Sž ZTU_V\S UYTZ aWXSc^ ^TS SP ZaUcU\oU `S\

dSlTZbZUTS ^d [TU a`SVV\U dZ [T ^TS__Uf ‹[SaVZ o^VVZ dZcUaV\^TU WXS SPaUddZao^VV^ _^ WUTh

dZbZUTS nWydZ pÉ^W …^TSeW^`ZVU_U {†e`^\^Y\^oUueVSU\Sc^ Šrf ‘SVVU ) _mU]]ZUo[TVU\S d^__^

W^VSYU\Z^dSY_ZaWXScZ^TZ ^__^a[^ U``UaV^eZ_VSU\Sc^^aaZW[\^ WXSSaZaVS [T o[TVU\S }[^aZ

(6)

TS__^ dZcUaV\^bZUTS dS_ WZV^VU VSU\Sc^e aZ `[UP aWSY_ZS\S _^ WUc`UaZbZUTS dS_ o[TVU\S dS__S

aSbZUTZ Y_UR^_Z WUT _mZT]S\aU dZ)eSeWUcS ZaUcU\lacU T^V[\^_S  €¿ÍÎ é ng`SW ¿ye

`\U`\ZU }[S__U aV^RZ_ZVU TS__^ dZcUaV\^bZUTS dZ pw^\VaXU\TSe W^`ZVU_U {{e`\U`UaZbZUTS

’ f’Wrf

zZa[_V^ ^__U\^ ZTdZ]Zd[^VU ^TWXS _mZaUcU\lacU T^V[\^_S



€ þÍÎ g`SW é nþy nTS__^

W^VSYU\Z^ U``UaV^ _^ o\SWWZ^ \Za[_V^ ZT]S\VZV^yf ‚^_S

 P

S dSVS\cZT^VU d^__^ WUTdZbZUTS

dZ SaaS\S _m[TZWU ZaUcU\lacU WXS aUddZao^ _^ \S_^bZUTS

 ò n g`SW é nþyy Ì  Âà  û ü f ‚^_S

\S_^bZUTS aZ WXZ^c^ \S_^bZUTS V\Z^TYU_^\S nWo\f pÉ^W …^TSe W^`ZVU_U {†e `^\^Y\^oU Šryž ]^_S

ZTU_V\S ^TWXS _m^_V\^ \S_^bZUTS V\Z^TYU_^\S g`SW  Ì

 ÂÃ

 

f +

,

ßàà­á¬â®¯ª«­ °±-± gS aZ ][U_S [T^ dSlTZbZUTS WUTW\SV^ dZ



e aZ `[UP `\STdS\S [T ZaUh

cU\lacU õ € g`SW ¿ÍÎ þ S UaaS\]^\S WXS _^ `\Zc^ \S_^bZUTS V\Z^TYU_^\S S _^ T^V[\^_ZV^P

dZ  Zc`_ZW^TU WXS  Ì g`SW õ ò n g`SW ¿y Þg`SW  ÂÃ  ÞõÂÃe Z_ }[^_S d[T}[S \Za[_V^ ZTh

dZ`STdSTVS d^__^ aWS_V^ dZ õf T^ dZcUaV\^bZUTS ^_VS\T^VZ]^ dS__^ `\U`UaZbZUTS ÿf aZ `[UP

UVVSTS\S dSlTSTdU dZ\SVV^cSTVS  S



TS__^ c^TZS\^ YZ^PdSaW\ZVV^e S ]S\ZlW^TdUe ^ `^\h

VZ\S d^__S WZV^VS `\U`UaZbZUTZ dZ pw^\VaXU\TSe W^`ZVU_U {{e `^\^Y\^oU ’re WXS _^ dSlTZbZUTS dZ

 P

S ZTdZ`STdSTVS d^ õe S WXS V^_Z ZaUcU\lacZ aUTU T^V[\^_Zf

Ö¥½¥¶¡µ¥¨

.

­/«¯®¯ª«­ °±²°±

gZ^ [TUaWXSc^TUSVXS\Z^TUeZTVSY\UeaS`^\^VUS\SYU_^\Sf T ¸¥½¥¶ ¡µ´

»µ¥º¡ dZ  SP [T WXZ[aU Z\\Zd[WZRZ_S dZ WUdZcSTaZUTS [TUž [T ¸¥½¥¶¡µ´ dZ  SP[T S_ScSTVU

dS_ Y\[``U ^RS_Z^TU _ZRS\U a[__mZTaZScS dSZ dZ]ZaU\Z `\ZcZe }[ZTdZ `[ P

U SaaS\S aW\ZVVU WUcS

aUcc^ oU\c^_S lTZV^ 0 1232e WUT Y_Z 12 ZTVS\Z S Z 32 dZ]ZaU\Z `\ZcZf T dZ]ZaU\S 0 1232

aZ dZWS ´4 ´··¥½¡ aS 12 5 ÿ `S\ UYTZ æf ©ª«¬­«®¯ª«­ °±²²± ¾¥£ ¼§¡¶¢Á´º£ ¥§·´ Ò µ¡¨ 6§»¼§·¡ Ò ´§´µ¥¢¡¸¥¼§¡¶»£¦¥¡·¡»¡¤¡ Ò ¥¢¡ ¹ ´ ¼§ »¼§ ·¡ ¤£ ¢¼¥ ¢Á¥¼¶¼µ£Ä ¢Á ´ ¶ £µ¹ £ § ´¢´¶¶£µ¥£º´§ · ´ ¥µµ¥¸¼¢¥ì¥¤´Ä ¢¡¥§¢¥¸£ ¢¡§ ·¼·· ¡ ¤¡ ¶»£¦¥¡¨ ¹  Æ£¢¥¤´ ¸¥º¡¶·µ£µ´ ¢Á´ ¥§ ¼§¡ ¶¢Á´º£ ¡ Ò §¥ ¢Á¥¼¶¡ ¥µµ¥¸¼¢¥ì¥¤´ Á£ ¼§ ¼§¥¢¡ »¼§·¡ Ò ´§´µ¥¢¡¨ ¾¥ Á£ ¸¼§¼´ ¢Á´ Á£¼§ ¼§¥¢¡»¼§·¡ Ò ´§´µ¥¢¡7 Ï¢¥¡´¹879Ì ÐÄ ¢Á´ ´¹¢¡§·´§¼·¡ ¥§ ¡ Ò §¥ £»´µ·¡ §¡§ ½¼¡·¡ å¨ :¤¥ ¡º¡º¡µÈ¶º¥ îç; € énåy Î é< ¶¡§¡ ¥§¥´··¥½¥Ä ¸¼§¼´ ¥¸´§ ·¥È ¢Á´µ´º¡ éç ¢¡§ ¤£ ¶¼£ ¥ºº£ Ò ¥§´ ¥§ é< ´ Ò ¤¥ ¡º¡º ¡µÈ ¶º¥ îç; ¢¡§ ¤´ ¥§¢¤¼¶¥¡§¥¨  ¡ ¶·´¶¶¡ ½£¤´»´µ Ò ¤¥ £§´¤¤¥ ¤¡¢£¤¥ é=¨

.­/«¯®¯ª«­ °±²ã± gZ^  [TU aWXSc^ TUSVXS\Z^TUe ZTVSY\Ue aS`^\^VU S \SYU_^\Se 7 Z_ a[U

`[TVU YSTS\ZWUe 829 _mZTaZScS dSZ dZ]ZaU\Z `\ZcZe S aZ^TU 7 > Z `[TVZ YSTS\ZWZ dSY_Z 2f „_Z

éê÷<?

>

e WUTaZdS\^VZ WUcS aUVVU^TS__Z dZ é<e aUTU ^TS__Z dZ ]^_[V^bZUTS dZaW\SV^e S aZ^ @ >

V^_S ]^_[V^bZUTSf ‘SlTZ^cU Z_ ¸¥½¥¶¡µ´ nõy dZ õ A é< Í 8ÿ9e WUcS 0

2

@ >nõy2 nWXS SP [T^

aUcc^ lTZV^yf T dZ]ZaU\S dZ  aZ dZWS »µ¥§¢¥»£¤´ aS SP dS_ VZ`U nõye WUT õ A é< Í 8ÿ9f

‘[S dZ]ZaU\Z aZ dZWUTU ¤¥§´£µº´§·´ ´¼¥½£¤´§·¥aS _^ _U\U dZ|S\STb^ SP[T dZ]ZaU\S `\ZTWZ`^_Sf

gS 3 SP[T dZ]ZaU\S dZ e _mZTaZScS dSZ dZ]ZaU\Z S|SVVZ]Z _ZTS^\cSTVS S}[Z]^_STVZ ^ 3 aZ dZWS

¶´µ¥´ ¤¥§´£µ´ ¢¡º»¤´·£ ¸¥3e S aZ ZTdZW^ WUT ë3ëf gS å SP[T ^`S\VU dZ  S 3 Ì 0

2

1232 SP[T

dZ]ZaU\S dZ eWUT å B3 ZTVSTdS\ScU Z_ dZ]ZaU\S dZ å dSlTZVU d^__^ aUcc^ dSY_Z 12n32Båy

V^_Z WXS 32 B å ÌC Df ‘^VU [T dZ]ZaU\S 3 dZ e aS `S\ UYTZ ^`S\VU å dZ  aZ dSlTZaWS Enåy

(7)

ZTW_[aZUTZye WXS aZ dZ\^PÆ£¶¢¥¡ £¶¶¡¢¥£·¡^ 3f ‘Z\ScU WXS [T dZ]ZaU\S S|SVVZ]U 3 dZ  »£¶¶£

`S\ [T aUVVUaWXSc^WXZ[aU þ dZ e dSlTZVU d^ [T o^aWZU dZ ZdS^_ZGe aS `S\ UYTZ ^`S\VU å ZT

W[Z 3 Bå Ì nõy aZ X^ õ AG nåy€ SPS}[Z]^_STVS ^ \ZWXZSdS\S WXS _mZccS\aZUTS dZ þ o^VVU\ZbbZ

V\^cZVS _mZccS\aZUTS dS_ aUVVUaWXSc^ nZT YSTS\^_S TUT \ZdUVVUy dSlTZVU d^ 3e d[T}[S [T

dZ]ZaU\S S|SVVZ]U `^aa^ `S\ [T `[TVU WXZ[aU aS S aU_U aS Z_ a[``U\VU dS_ dZ]ZaU\S WUTVZSTS

V^_S `[TVUf

ßàà­á¬â®¯ª«­ °±²ä± gZ^  [TU aWXSc^ TUSVXS\Z^TUe ZTVSY\Ue aS`^\^VU S \SYU_^\Se 3 [T

dZ]ZaU\SeE Z_o^aWZU^aaUWZ^VU ^3eþ [T aUVVUaWXSc^WXZ[aUeæ €þ Î  [T^a[^ZccS\aZUTSf

iUTaZdS\Z^cU Z_ cU\lacU Ù UVVST[VU d^__^ WUc`UaZbZUTS

EÍÎ E H I éêJKLM 2N ÍÎ E H æ é O

dU]S éê S é aUTU Z o^aWZ aV\[VV[\^_Zf T S_ScSTVU õ A Eny Í 8ÿ9 SP V^_S WXS n õy F 3

`^aaZ `S\ þ aS S aU_U aS Ù

nynõy Ì ÿf

P¥ìµ£·¥ ¥§ ¶»£¦¥»µ¡¥´··¥½¥¨

.­/«¯®¯ª«­ °±²ô± gZ^  [TU aWXSc^ TUSVXS\Z^TUe Q [T o^aWZU }[^aZhWUS\STVS dZ éêh

^_YSR\S Y\^d[^VS V^_S WXSe ZTdZW^TdU WUT n

R

yS _^ WUc`UTSTVS UcUYSTS^ dZ Y\^dU Te aZ

^RRZ^Q

* U Ì

éê nWUcS éêh^_YSR\^yeQ

Ã

aZ^ WUS\STVS SYSTS\Z _UW^_cSTVSQ WUcS éêh^_YSR\^f

QaZaVS ^__U\^ [TU aWXSc^ WXS WXZ^cS\ScU »µ¡¥´··¥½¥¦¦£·¡ ¸¥ Q S ZTdZWXS\ScU WUT áªV Qe

[T cU\lacU W € áªV Q Î  S [T o^aWZU énŠy a[ áªV Q V^_Z WXS `S\ UYTZ ^`S\VU ^TS

å dZ  _^ \SaV\ZbZUTS dZ W ^ WÂÃnåy Sd å WU\\Za`UTd^ V\^cZVS ZaUcU\lacZ ^_ cU\lacU

ZTdUVVU ƒ\UX Qnåy Î g`SW éênåy

U Ì

åe S énŠye \ZaV\SVVU ^ WÂÃnåye WU\\Za`UTd^ V\^cZVS

_mZaUcU\lacU ƒ\UX Qnåy

U Ì

WÂÃnåy ^_ o^aWZU énŠy a[ ƒ\UX Qnåyf ‚^_S aWXSc^ SPUVVST[VU

`S\ ZTWU__^cSTVU dSZ ƒ\UX Qnåyf gS í SP[TU a`^bZU ]SVVU\Z^_S a[ [T W^c`U YeZTdZWXS\ScU

WUT níy _mZTaZScS dS__S W_^aaZ dZ S}[Z]^_STb^ dZ í Í 8ÿ9 cUd[_U _^ `\U`U\bZUT^_ZV^Pf gS Z

P

S [T o^aWZU _UW^_cSTVS _ZRS\U a[ e ^__U\^ dSlTZ^cU Èìµ£·¡ ¥§ ¶»£¦¥ »µ¡¥´··¥½¥ £¶¶¡¢¥£·¡ £¸

Z S _U ZTdZWXZ^cU WUT nZye _U aWXSc^ áªV gŒcnZ[ye dU]S Z[SPZ_ d[^_S dZ Z S gŒc ZTdZW^

_m^_YSR\^ aZccSV\ZW^ nWXS SP[T o^aWZU dZ éêh^_YSR\Syf gS þ SP[T aUVVUaWXSc^ WXZ[aU dZ  S

G P

S Z_ \S_^VZ]U o^aWZU dZ ZdS^_Ze ^__U\^ \ € Ì  áªV n]S^ * G S y aZ dZWS ¶ ¢¡»»¥£º´§ ·¡dZ  _[TYU þ S Z_ cU\lacU W €\Î  aZ WXZ^cS\^P º¡µÈ¶º¡ ¸¥ ¶¢¡»»¥£º´§·¡f {_ WXZ[aU WÂÃnþyaZ dZ\^P ¸¥½¥¶¡µ´ ´¢¢´¦¥¡§£¤´f gS  SP[T^ a[`S\lWZS _ZaWZ^ a[ [T W^c`U ^_YSR\ZW^cSTVS WXZ[aU Y S _ P

S [T `[TVU WXZ[aU dZ e Z_ cU\lacU dZ aWU``Z^cSTVU dZ  _[TYU _ aZ dZ\^P ·µ£¶Æ¡µº£¦¥¡§´

º¡§¡¥¸£¤´f

ßàà­á¬â®¯ª«­ °±²ý±

…^ TUaV\^ dSlTZbZUTS dZ lR\^VU ZT a`^bZ `\UZSVVZ]Z ^aaUWZ^VU dZ|S\ZaWS

d^ }[S__^ dZ pw^\VaXU\TSrf gS Y SP[T W^c`U ^_YSR\ZW^cSTVS WXZ[aUe S ` SP[T o^aWZU WUS\STVS

a[ g`SW Y n}[ZTdZ_ZRS\UdZ\^TYUlTZVUyWmPS[Tm ^``_ZW^bZUTST^V[\^_Sn`ng`SW YyyÎ n`ye

WXS SP [T^ RZSbZUTS a[Z `[TVZ WXZ[aZ dZ n`ye S WXS WUTaZaVS TS__m^aaUWZ^\S ^d [T^ W_^aaS

põr Z_ `[TVU dZ áªV gŒc `[

U Ì

ƒ\UX gŒc n`n g`SW Yy

[

y _mZdS^_S nUcUYSTSUhc^aaZc^_Sy dZ

gŒc n`ng`SW Yy

[

y YSTS\^VU d^Z WU\\Za`UTdSTVZ dS__S aSbZUTZ dZ `n g`SW Yy

[

WXS aZ ^TT[__^TU

(8)

abcd™ ™cec™dœfcdf g™š™c™h šicj™kflœm™ic™ ™cdlikbdd™gf

‹[SaVU W^`ZVU_U X^ _UaWU`U dZ Z__[aV\^\S ^_W[TZ WUTWSVVZ dZ R^aS S dZZTV\Ud[\\S ^_ _^]U\U WXS

a^\^P a]U_VU TSZ a[WWSaaZ]Z W^`ZVU_Zf …S ^|S\c^bZUTZ a^\^TTU d[T}[S YZ[aVZlW^VS ZT c^TZS\^

cSTU dSVV^Y_Z^V^ dZ }[^TVU aZ o^\^P TSZ W^`ZVU_Z dZ WUTVST[VU `Z[P VSWTZWUf gZ o^\^P ^_V\SaP

Ÿ

\ZoS\ZcSTVU ^d ^_W[TS TUbZUTZ dZ R^aSe WUcS ^d SaSc`ZU }[S__^ dZ cU_VS`_ZWZV^P dZ [T `[TVU

`S\[T^ W[\]^eWXSWUc[T}[S \ZdSlTZ\ScUZT c^TZS\^ ^``\UoUTdZV^TS__m ^cRZVUdS__^ TUaV\^

Zc`UaV^bZUTS oU\c^_Sf

…^ V\^VV^bZUTS dZ QT\Z}[Sa dS__S aZTYU_^\ZV^PdS__S W[\]S o^ ^c`ZU [aU dS__^ TUbZUTS dZ

~`[TVU ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZTUe ^TbZ SY_Z ^|S\c^ WXS ~Z_ WUTWSVVU dS__^ WUc`UaZbZUTS dS__^

aZTYU_^\ZV^P cSdZ^TVS `[TVZ c[_VZ`_Z ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZTZ pnnnr `[UP \ZVSTS\aZ WUcS _m ^W}[ZaVU

`Z[P Zc`U\V^TVS TS__^ VSU\Z^ dS__S aZTYU_^\ZV^P nWo\f pQT\Z}[SahiXZaZTZe _ZR\U {†e `^\^Y\^oU

’ˆe`^Yf ‰uÿryf qTWXS ZT VSc`Z `Z[P\SWSTVZ aZ SPWUTVZT[^VU ^o^\ [aU dZ V^_S TUbZUTSe_^ }[^_S

WUc`^\S ^d SaSc`ZU ZT ps^\ZatZr S pw^\VaXU\TSrž]SdZ^cU d[T}[S dZ WXS aZ V\^VV^f

o¡§¶¥¸´µ£¦¥¡§¥ ¥§·¼¥·¥½´¨

P

Q WS\V^cSTVS cU_VU ZTV[ZVZ]U dZ\S WXS [T^ W[\]^ S [T^ a[^ V^TYSTVS X^TTU ZT WUc[TS d[S

`[TVZ ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZTZe WUaP

Ÿ

WUcS SPZTV[ZVZ]U dZ\S WXS d[S \SVVS `^\^__S_S aZ ZTWUTV\^TU ZT

[T `[TVU ^__mZTlTZVUž U ^TWU\^elaa^VU [T `[TVU _ a[ [T^ \SVV^eZcc^YZTZ^cUWXS SaZaV^ [T

`[TVU _

Ã

a[__^ \SVV^e ^ dZaV^Tb^ ZTlTZVSaZc^ d^ _ n[T V^_S `[TVU S|SVVZ]^cSTVS SaZaVSe aS

WUTaZdS\Z^cU [T cUdS__U dZ ^T^_ZaZ TUT aV^Td^\deS dm^_V\^ `^\VS V^_S _ZTY[^YYZU S\^ cU_VU

WUc[TS ^__S U\ZYZTZ dS_ W^_WU_U ZTlTZVSaZc^_Sy€ SP T^V[\^_S `STa^\S WXS _S W[\]S \SYU_^\Z

`^aa^TVZ `S\ _ S _

Ã

aZ^TU W[\]S `^aa^TVZ `S\ _ S Z]Z V^TYSTVZ ^__^ \SVV^f ƒUV\SccU `STa^\S

}[ZTdZ ^d [T^ lY[\^ dZ }[SaVU YSTS\S€

C

C

r

r

P

P

1

1:

pZY[\^ Šf

oU\aSe `S\ WUTaS\]^\S _^ TUbZUTS WXS [T V\^VVU ZTlTZVSaZcU dZ W[\]^ WUZTWZdS ^ cSTU

(9)

`UaaUTU `STa^\S ZTW_ZT^VS dZ [T ^TYU_U ZTlTZVSaZcUyf

C

C

C

r

r

r

P

P

P

r

C

r

C

1

pZY[\^ ’f

gSRRSTS V^_Z lY[\S `Uaa^TU ^aa[cS\S [T aZYTZlW^VU `\SWZaU WUT _m ^Z[VU dS__m ^T^_ZaZ TUT

aV^Td^\de YSTS\^_cSTVS aZ `\SoS\ZaWS Z__[aV\^\S }[SaVS aZV[^bZUTZ WUT dZaWU\aZ dZ ~`^aa^YYZU

^_ _ZcZVS nWXS dm ^_V\^ `^\VS `S\dUTU ^TWXmSaaZ [T aZYTZlW^VU `\SWZaUe }[^TdU aZ _^]U\Z a[

[T W^c`U }[^_aZ^aZye^TWXS `S\WXSe `S\ ^_V\Z ]S\aZe `UaaUTU V\^\\S ZT ZTY^TTU€ `S\ SaSc`ZUe

TS__^ VS\cZTU_UYZ^ dSZ `[TVZ ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZTZ aZ [a^ dZ\S WXS d[S W[\]S V^TYSTVZ X^TTU

ZT WUc[TS [T `[TVU U\dZT^\ZU S [TU ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZTUe cSTV\S TS__S lY[\S Š S

’ TUT

aScR\^ SaaS\WZ TZSTVS WXS YZ[aVZlWXZ _^ dZaVZTbZUTS V\^`[TVUU\dZT^\ZU S`[TVUZTlTZV^cSTVS

]ZWZTUf ‚^_SdZaVZTbZUTSX^ [T^WS\V^ Zc`U\V^Tb^žaSYT^_Z^cUZTo^VVZ WXSe[T^]U_V^ aV^RZ_ZVS

_S U``U\V[TS dSlTZbZUTZe aZ ^]\^P WXS [T^ W[\]^ WXS `^aaZ `S\ [T `[TVU _

Ã

e ZTlTZV^cSTVS

]ZWZTU ^d [T `[TVU U\dZT^\ZU _e SP URR_ZY^V^ ^ `^aa^\S `S\ _f {T \S^_V^eP `S\ WUcUdZV^P

dZ TUV^bZUTSe WUT]ZSTS ZTW_[dS\S Z `[TVZ U\dZT^\Z TS__mZTaZScS dZ }[S__Z WXS WXZ^cS\ScU

`[TVZ ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZTZe S _^ aZV[^bZUTS U\^ aSYT^_^V^ aZ Sa`\ZcS\^P dZWSTdU WXS Z_ `[TVU

ZTlTZV^cSTVS]ZWZTU_

Ã

(10)

^]^TVZ ZT }[SaVU W^`ZVU_Už S WUT _^ WUTaZdS\^bZUTS dZ V^_Z `[TVZ aU\YUTU T[U]Z `\UR_ScZ dZ

\^``\SaSTV^bZUTS ZTV[ZVZ]^f

gSRRSTS d[T}[S aZ dSRR^ o^\S ^VVSTbZUTS ^ o^\ V\U``U \ZoS\ZcSTVU ^__mZTV[ZbZUTSe SP

ZTd[RRZU WXS Z `[TVZ ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZTZe [T^ ]U_V^ dSlTZVZ \ZYU\Ua^cSTVSeoU\TZaW^TU dS__S

ZTVS\`\SV^bZUTZ cU_VU T^V[\^_Z dS__^ TUbZUTS dZ cU_VS`_ZWZV^P dZ ZTVS\aSbZUTSe S WUTaSTV^TU

dZ Sa`\ZcS\S ZT c^TZS\^ aSc`_ZWS Zc`U\V^TVZ o^VVZe WUcS Z_ VSU\Sc^ dZ jSbU[V e Z_ W^_WU_U

dS_ YSTS\S YSUcSV\ZWU dZ [T^ W[\]^ dZ d^VU Y\^dU S aZTYU_^\ZV^Pe _mSaVSTaZUTS dS__S oU\c[_S

dZ ƒ_[qWtS\e S Z_ W^_WU_U dS_ T[cS\U dZ WUTdZbZUTZ _ZTS^\cSTVS ZTdZ`STdSTVZ WXS dS\Z]^TU

d^__mZc`U\\S ^__S W[\]S Z_ `^aa^YYZU `S\ `[TVZ WUT d^V^ cU_VS`_ZWZV^P S d^VS WUTdZbZUTZ dZ

V^TYSTb^ dSZ \^cZ nWo\f ^TWU\^ pQT\Z}[SahiXZaZTZe _ZR\U {†e `^\^Y\^oU ’ˆre Se `S\ ^_W[TS

WUTaZdS\^bZUTZ ZTVS\Saa^TVZ pZRZdfe _ZR\U {e W^`ZVU_U {{e a`SWZ^_cSTVS Z `^\^Y\^l Šÿ S Šryf

ִȧ¥¦¥¡§´ º´¸¥£§·´ ¥§¶¥´º¥ ¸¥ ¢¼µ½´¨

{TWUcZTWZ^cU ^ ]SdS\S WUcS aZ `Uaa^ d^\S [T^ dSlTZbZUTS \ZYU\Ua^ dS_ WUTWSVVU dZ `[TVU

ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZTUf ƒS\ U\^ WZ _ZcZVZ^cU ^ WUTaZdS\^\S WUa^ a[WWSdS TS_ `Z^TUe aSRRSTS

`^\VS dZ WZUP WXS aVZ^cU `S\ dZ\S ]^_Y^ `S\ a[`S\lWZ _ZaWS }[^_aZ^aZe S ^TWXS ZT dZcSTaZUTS

c^YYZU\S dZ d[S nWo\f pQT\Z}[SahiXZaZTZe _ZR\U {†e W^`ZVU_U {†ryf

iUaP

Ÿ

WUcS [T `[TVU Zc`\U`\ZU^__mZTlTZVU`[UPSaaS\S dSlTZVU WUcS_mZTaZScS dS__S\SVVS

^]STVZ [T^ dSVS\cZT^V^ dZ\SbZUTSe `UaaZ^cU dSlTZ\S [T `[TVU ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZTU ^d [T

laa^VU `[TVU _ WUcS _mZTaZScS dS__S W[\]S ^_YSR\ZWXS `^aa^TVZ `S\ _ S ZT SaaU V^TYSTVZ ^d

[T^ \SVV^ d^V^f ‹[SaV^ ]Z^ PS a[YYS\ZV^e ZT [T^ oU\c^ `Z[P YSTS\^_Se ZT pQT\Z}[SahiXZaZTZe

_ZR\U {†e `^\^Y\^oU e `^Yf ‡urf

P

Q ZTVS\Saa^TVS TUV^\S WXSe aS WUTaZdS\Z^cU ^d SaSc`ZU _mZTaZScS dSZ `U_ZTUcZ ZT d[S

]^\Z^RZ_Z ^ WUSWZSTVZ ZT [T W^c`U Y WXS dSlTZaWUTU W[\]S dZ rs

t

e `^aa^TVZ `S\ _mU\ZYZTS S

Z]Z V^TYSTVZ ^__m ^aaS ue }[SaVU SP Sa^VV^cSTVS _mZdS^_S n

v Ou Í v sy TS__m^TS__U Yp v Oure `[\WXS

WUTaZdS\Z^cU WUcS V^TYSTVZ ^TWXS V[VVS _S W[\]S WUT cU_VS`_ZWZV P

^ c^YYZU\S dZ [TU TS__mUh

\ZYZTS nV^_Z W[\]Se ZT YSTS\^_Se aUTU V^TYSTVZ aU_U Zc`\U`\Z^cSTVS ^__S \SVVS `S\ _mU\ZYZTSž

Wo\f pQT\Z}[SahiXZaZTZe_ZR\U {e`^\^Y\^oU Šÿe`^Yf‰ryf ‚^_S ZdS^_S dSlTZaWS [T aUVVUaWXSc^

ÿhdZcSTaZUT^_S TUT \ZdUVVU dZ rs

t

e WXS `UV\SRRS SaaS\S [a^VU ^TWXmSaaU WUcS dSlTZbZUTS

dS_ `[TVU w

Ã

e ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZTU ^__mU\ZYZTS w _[TYU _^ dZ\SbZUTS dS__m ^aaS uf iZUP TUT

P

S Sa^VV^cSTVS }[S__U WXS o^\ScUe `S\UP }[SaVU aUVVUaWXSc^ SP }[S__U WXS TUZ WXZ^cS\ScU

~aUVVUaWXSc^ ^aaUWZ^VU ^ 8wO w à 9f ִȧ¥¦¥¡§´ º´¸¥£§·´ ·µ£¶Æ¡µº£¦¥¡§¥ ¼£¸µ£·¥¢Á´¨

…^ dSlTZbZUTS cSdZ^TVS ZTaZScZ dZ W[\]S TUT SP_m[TZW^ WXS aZ V\U]^ ZT _SVVS\^V[\^f q

TWU\^

ZT pQT\Z}[SahiXZaZTZe _ZR\U {†e `^\^Y\^oU Їe`^Yf uÿreaZ V\U]^ [T^ dSlTZbZUTS ^_VS\T^VZ]^e

WXS o^ [aU dS__S V\^aoU\c^bZUTZ }[^d\^VZWXSf ƒS\ Z__[aV\^\S }[SaVU ^``\UWWZU \Z`\STdZ^cU

_mSaSc`ZU dSZ `[TVZ ^__mZTlTZVUf iUTaZdS\Z^cU d[S \SVVS `^\^__S_S TS_ `Z^TUe `S\ SaSc`ZU

x

dZ S}[^bZUTS

v

Ì ÿ Sd y dZ S}[^bZUTS

v

Ì Šž WUTaZdS\Z^cU `UZ _^ V\^aoU\c^bZUTS

 dZ S}[^bZUTS z { | v Û Ì v u uÛ Ì Š u O

(11)

WZUSP _m ^``_ZW^bZUTS dZ rs t Í n ^aaS }y ZT aSe d^V^ d^ n v Ouy Î n~  O  yf …mZT]S\a^ dZ  P S d^V^e

WUT o^WZ_Z WUTVZe d^ z

€ { € | v Ì v Û uÛ u Ì Š uÛ O d[T}[S P S  aVSaa^f †SdZ^cU ZT WXZ aZ V\^aoU\c^TU x

Sd yf ƒS\ aUaVZV[bZUTS dS__S S}[^bZUTZ

dZ  ZT }[S__S dZ x aZ X^ WXS  n x Í 8n ÿOÿy9y X^ S}[^bZUTS ~   Ì ÿe S `S\WZUP SP ^TWU\^ x Í 8nÿOÿy9ecSTV\S 

n y Í8nŠOÿy9y X^ S}[^bZUTS ~

  Ì Še S `S\WZUPSP_^ \SVV^ v Û Ì uÛ `\Z]^V^ ^TWXmSaa^ dS__mU\ZYZTSf P

Q T^V[\^_S ^__U\^ `STa^\S WXS _mU\ZYZTS aZ^ _mZcc^YZTS dS_ `[TVU

^__mZTlTZVU WUc[TS ^d

x

Sd ye S WXS _mU\ZYZTS S Z_ `[TVU nŠOÿy ^RRZ^TU WUcS Zcc^YZTS `[TVZ

^__mZTlTZVUž S ^d [_VS\ZU\S WUToS\c^ dZ }[SaV^ ZdS^e ]ZSTS Z_ o^VVU WXS



V\^aoU\c^ Z_ o^aWZU

dS__S \SVVS `^\^__S_S ^d

x

Sd y TS_ o^aWZU dS__S \SVVS `S\ _mU\ZYZTSe cSTV\S Z o^aWZ dZ WSTV\U

_mU\ZYZTS S nŠOÿy aUTU V\^aoU\c^VZ ZT o^aWZ dZ \SVVS `^\^__S_Sf iUTUaWSTdU _^ dSlTZbZUTS

dS__m ^c`_Z^cSTVU `\UZSVVZ]Ue V^_S dZaWU\aU dZ]STV^ WUc`_SV^cSTVS \ZYU\UaUf {To^VVZ

 P S

_^ \SaV\ZbZUTS dZ [T^ `\UZSVVZ]ZV^P WXS S|SVVZ]^cSTVS aZ WUc`U\V^ a[Z `[TVZ Zc`\U`\Z TS__^

c^TZS\^ dSaW\ZVV^f ‚[VVU WZUPa[YYS\ZaWS [T^ c^TZS\^ ^_VS\T^VZ]^ dZ dSlTZ\S _m ^c`_Z^cSTVU

`\UZSVVZ]Uf gZ `UV\SRRS\U WZU P

S dSlTZ\S Z `[TVZ Zc`\U`\Z WUcS WU``ZS dS_ VZ`U n

 O

_y nU

cSY_ZUWUcSU``U\V[TSW_^aaZ dZS}[Z]^_STb^ dZ }[SaVS WU``ZSyedU]S

 P

S [T^V\^aoU\c^bZUTS

\^bZUT^_S dZ `\ZcU Y\^dU S _ [T `[TVUf

{T c^TZS\^ aZcZ_Se WUTaZdS\Z^cU _^ V\^aoU\c^bZUTS }[^d\^VZW^ dS_ `Z^TU s

t

ZT aSe dZ

S}[^bZUTS nZT WUU\dZT^VS UcUYSTSSy

z { | v Û * Ì v à v s v Û Ã Ì v * v s v Û s Ì v * v à ‚

‚^_S V\^aoU\c^bZUTS RZ\^bZUT^_S SP[T ZaUcU\lacU a[ s

t

`\Z]^VU dS__S V\S \SVVS WUU\dZT^VS

v

2 Ì ÿ næ A 8ÿOŠO

’

9yeS _^ V\^aoU\c^bZUTS ZT]S\a^e WUcS aZ ]S\ZlW^ o^WZ_cSTVSe SPd^V^ d^

nƒy z { | v * Ì v Û Ã v Û s v Ã Ì v Û * v Û s v s Ì v Û * v Û Ã ‚

iUTaZdS\Z^cU [T^ }[^_aZ^aZ W[\]^ WXS `^aaZ aSc`_ZWScSTVS `S\ nŠOÿOÿy S aZ^ V^TYSTVS ^__^

\SVV^ v Ã Ì v s

f ‹[SaVS W[\]S aUTU V[VVS S aU_S }[S__S d^VS d^ [TmS}[^bZUTS dS_ VZ`U

v S * v Ã Í v S * v s F„n v * O v à O v s y Ì ÿO

WUT „ `U_ZTUcZU UcUYSTSU dZ Y\^dU TF Še TUT dZ]ZaZRZ_S `S\

v S

*

f gUaVZV[STdU _S nƒy TS__mSh

}[^bZUTS dZ V^_S W[\]^e UVVSTZ^cU _mS}[^bZUTS dS__^ a[^ V\^aoU\c^V^ WXSe ^_ dZ o[U\Z dS__S

V\S \SVVS WUU\dZT^VSea^\^PdS_ VZ`U v Û Ã S v Û s S… à v Û * Í v Û Ã S… à v Û s S v Û * F„ Û n v Û * O v Û Ã O v Û s y Ì ÿO

(12)

WUT „Û `U_ZTUcZU UcUYSTSU dZ Y\^dU ’TF’e dZ]ZaZRZ_S `S\ v Û * f ‘Z]ZdSTdU `S\ v Û * UVVSTZ^cU

^TWU\^ [T^ S}[^bZUTS dS__^ TUaV\^ V\^aoU\c^V^ n`S\WXSaZ^cU ^_ dZ o[U\Z dZ

v Û * Ì ÿye dZ VZ`U v Û Ã S v Û s S… Ã Í v Û Ã S… à v Û s S F„ ÛÛ n v Û * O v Û Ã O v Û s y Ì ÿO WUT „ÛÛ dZ]ZaZRZ_S `S\ v Û *

f ‚^_S S}[^bZUTS SPaSc`\S aUddZao^VV^ d^ n ÿOŠOŠyf

gU\YS ^ }[SaVU `[TVU Z_ aUa`SVVU WXS Z_ `[TVU nÿOŠOŠye ZTaZScS ^__^ V\^aoU\c^bZUTS

}[^d\^VZW^e ZTdZ]Zd[Z Z_ `[TVU ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZTU ^__mU\ZYZTS _[TYU _^ \SVV^ v Ã Ì v s f gZ

`UV\SRRS `\U]^\Se ^d [_VS\ZU\S WUToS\c^ dZ }[SaV^ ZdS^e WXS UYTZ W[\]^ ^]STVS TS__mU\ZYZTS

[T `[TVU dZ cU_VS`_ZWZV^P† ‡ ÿ S V^_S WXS _^ \SVV^ v Ã Ì v s aZ^ [T^ V^TYSTVS `\ZTWZ`^_Se aZ

V\^aoU\c^ ZT [T^ W[\]^ WXS `^aa^ `S\ n ÿOŠOŠye `\Z]^V^ dSZ `[TVZ dS__S V\S \SVVS WUU\dZT^VS

nV\^ W[Z T^V[\^_cSTVS WmPS ^TWXS n ÿOŠOŠyye S ]ZWS]S\a^f gSYT^_Z^cU ZTU_V\S WXS aS `^\VZ^cU

d^ [TmS}[^bZUTS \ZdUVV^ nWZUSP V^_S WXS UYTZ o^VVU\S Z\\Zd[WZRZ_S dS__^ aWUc`UaZbZUTS ^RRZ^

Sa`UTSTVS Šye _^ c^aaZc^ `UVSTb^ dZ

v Û

*

WXS dZ]ZdS _mS}[^bZUTSV\^aoU\c^V^ `S\ aUaVZV[bZUTS

P S v Û *ˆ f ‚[VVU WZUP ]^_S ^TWXS aUaVZV[STdU v Ã Ì v s

WUT [T^ }[^_aZ^aZ \SVV^ `S\ _mU\ZYZTSe

`[\WXSaZ o^WWZ^ ^VVSTbZUTS ^ TUT `\STdS\S [T \ZoS\ZcSTVU ZT W[Z Saa^ aZ^ \SVV^ WUU\dZT^V^ž

d[T}[S _S V\^aoU\c^bZUTZ }[^d\^VZWXSe ^ cSTU dZ W^cRZ dZ \ZoS\ZcSTVUe oU\TZaWUTU [T^ ]Z^

dZ dSlTZbZUTS dSZ `[TVZ ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZTZf

‹[SaV^ SP_mZc`UaV^bZUTS dZ kUSVXS\e WXS SP^c`Z^cSTVS V\^VV^V^ ZT pQT\Z}[SahiXZaZTZe

_ZR\U {†e W^`ZVU_U {{re ^ W[Z \Zc^TdZ^cU `S\ [_VS\ZU\Z ^c`_Z^cSTVZ S ZToU\c^bZUTZf

ִȧ¥¦¥¡§´ º´¸¥£§·´ ¶¢¡»»¥£º´§·¥¨

ƒ^aa^TdU ^d [T `[TVU dZ ]ZaV^ `Z[P cUdS\TUe WUcZTWZ^cU ^d UaaS\]^\S WXS _^ V\^aoU\h

c^bZUTS }[^d\^VZW^eWUcS UYTZV\^aoU\c^bZUTSRZ\^bZUT^_S dZ a[`S\lWZeaZ o^VVU\Zbb^ V\^cZVS

V\^aoU\c^bZUTZ cUTUZd^_Z nWo\f pw^\VaXU\TSe W^`ZVU_U †e ‚SU\Sc^ ‰f‰ryf …S V\^aoU\c^bZUTZ

cUTUZd^_Z aUTU aWU``Z^cSTVZ ZT [T `[TVU dZ [T^ a[`S\lWZS nWo\f dSlTZbZUTS ÿfŠuye S TUT

P

S dZWZ_S ]SdS\S WXS _^ V\^aoU\c^bZUTS }[^d\^VZW^ aZ UVVZSTS cSdZ^TVS aWU``Z^cSTVU dSZ

V\S `[TVZ WUU\dZT^VZ dS_ \ZoS\ZcSTVU nnŠOÿOÿyOnÿOŠOÿyOn ÿOÿOŠyye S a[WWSaaZ]^ ~Zc`_UaZUTS

nR_UxZTY dUxTe ZT]S\a^ dS_ R_UxZTYh[`y dS__S \SVVS WU\\Za`UTdSTVZ ^__S V\S \SVVS WUU\dZT^VS

n`S\c^YYZU\ZdSVV^Y_Z\Zc^TdZ^cU^d pw^\VaXU\TSeW^`ZVU_U†euf’f‡ryf P

Q T^V[\^_S^__U\^WXS

Z_ dZaWU\aU o^VVU `S\ _^ V\^aoU\c^bZUTS }[^d\^VZW^ `Uaa^ SaaS\S \Z`SV[VU a[__S V\^aoU\c^bZUTZ

cUTUZd^_Z WXS _^ WUc`UTYUTUeSd ^TbZ WZ aZ `[UP_ZcZV^\S^__U aWU``Z^cSTVUdZ nŠOÿOÿyf ‚^_S

V\^aoU\c^bZUTS SP `Z[P WUcUd^ dS__^ V\^aoU\c^bZUTS }[^d\^VZW^e ZT }[^TVU S]ZV^ Z `\UR_ScZ

WXS aZ ZTWUTV\^TU WUTaZdS\^TdU W[\]S V^TYSTVZ ^__S \SVVS WUU\dZT^VS ndm ^_V\UTdS TUT P

S [T

W^aU WXS _S V\^aoU\c^bZUTZ cUTUZd^_Z aZ^TU V^_]U_V^ WXZ^c^VS ~V\^aoU\c^bZUTZ _UW^_cSTVS

}[^d\^VZWXSyf q_V\U Y\UaaU ]^TV^YYZU dS__^ V\^aoU\c^bZUTS cUTUZd^_S SP WXS Saa^ aZ `[UP

o^\S a[ [T^ }[^_aZ^aZ a[`S\lWZSf

{T dSlTZVZ]^e^T^_UY^cSTVS^}[^TVU o^VVUZT `\SWSdSTb^ `S\ _^V\^aoU\c^bZUTS}[^d\^h

VZW^e aZ `UV\SRRS UaaS\]^\S WXS W[\]S a[ [T^ }[^_aZ^aZ a[`S\lWZSe ^]STVZ [T^ d^V^ V^TYSTVS

`\ZTWZ`^_S ZT [T `[TVU _e aUTU V[VVS S aU_S }[S__S Z_ W[Z V\^aoU\c^VU aV\SVVU cSdZ^TVS

aWU``Z^cSTVU ZT _e `^aa^TU `S\ [T WS\VU `[TVU _Û dS_ dZ]ZaU\S SWWSbZUT^_Sf QaSc`Z WXS

Z__[aV\^TU RSTS _^ aZV[^bZUTS aZ `UaaUTU V\U]^\S ZT pw^\VaXU\TSe W^`ZVU_U {e `^\^Y\^oU ue

`^YYf ’h‡ÿrf …^ dSlTZbZUTS WXS V\U]Z^cU ZT pw^\VaXU\TSe W^`ZVU_U †e `^\^Y\^oU ‡e `^Yf

(13)

WZV^V^ dSlTZbZUTSe WUcS dm ^_V\UTdS }[S__S a[YYS\ZVS ZT pQT\Z}[SahiXZaZTZre SP `Z[P YSTS\^_Se

`S\WXSWUc`\STdS _^ TUbZUTS dZ ~`[TVZ ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZTZ a[WWSaaZ]Ze WXS U\^ ^TdZ^cU

R\S]ScSTVS ^d Sa^cZT^\Sf ³¼§·¥ ¥§È§¥·£º´§·´ ½¥¢¥§¥ ¶¼¢¢´¶¶¥½¥¨ kS_ `Z^TU ^TSe _S W[RZWXS dS_ o^aWZU dZ S}[^bZUTS u Ì v‰ Í Y v s

aUTU V[VVS V^TYSTVZ ^__m ^aaS

v

TS__mU\ZYZTSe }[ZTdZe ZTV[ZVZ]^cSTVSe `^aa^TU `S\ _mU\ZYZTS w

S `S\ Z_ a[U `[TVU ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZTU w

Ã

dS__m ^aaS

v

f QaaS X^TTU WUcS [_VS\ZU\S `[TVU dZ

ZTVS\aSbZUTSZ_ `[TVU nYOÿy€ SPT^V[\^_SdZ\S ^__U\^WXS`S\ Y Ì ÿ _^ VS\b^ZTVS\aSbZUTS dZ]STV^

ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZT^ ^ w S w

Ã

f ƒZ[P ZT YSTS\^_Se `UaaZ^cU `STa^\S WXS d[S W[\]S WUT [T

WUTV^VVU V\Z`[TVUe WZUSP WXS ZT [T d^VU `[TVU _ aZ^TU V^TYSTVZ S WUT _^ aVSaa^ W[\]^V[\^e

^RRZ^TU ZT WUc[TS _e [T `[TVU ZTlTZV^cSTVS]ZWZTU _ Ã _[TYU _^ \SVV^V^TYSTVSe S [T VS\bU `[TVU _ ÃÃ e ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZTU ^ _ Ã S ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZTU ^ _ ~TS__mZTVU\TU dS_ aSWUTdU

U\dZTSf …^aZV[^bZUTS WUcZTWZ^U\^^dZ]STV^\ScSTUZTV[ZVZ]^€ SPZTo^VVZo[U\]Z^TVS`STa^\S

^ V\S `[TVZ _e _

à e _

ÃÃ

^ dZaV^Tb^ ZTlTZVSaZc^ V\^ dZ _U\U€ [T^ W[\]^ `^aa^TVS `S\ }[SaVZ

V\S `[TVZ dU]\SRRS SaaS\S V^TYSTVS _[TYU V[VVS S V\S _S dZ\SbZUTZ __

à e __ Ãà e _ à _ Ãà e WXS ZT

YSTS\^_S aUTU dZaVZTVS n[T^ V^_S ZTVS\`\SV^bZUTS `UV\SRRS ZT]SWS SaaS\S [VZ_S `S\ dSaW\Z]S\S

[T `[TVUdU``ZUyf ƒZ[PWU\\SVVUa^\SRRSZcc^YZT^\aZV\S`[TVZZTlTZV^cSTVS]ZWZTZe^__ZTS^VZ

^_ `\ZcmU\dZTS c^ TUT ^_ aSWUTdU n]SdZ lY[\^ ‡ye c^ ^TWXS WUaP

Ÿ

TUT aZ ao[YYS ^Z `\UR_ScZ

^ W[Z ^RRZ^cU ^WWSTT^VU ZT `\SWSdSTb^f

P P P

1

P

11

11

pZY[\^ ‡f

…S dSlTZbZUTZdZ W[Z^RRZ^cU YZ^PV\^VV^VU aZ SaVSTdUTU ^YS]U_cSTVS^_ W^aUdZ `Z[P`[TVZ

ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZTZ a[WWSaaZ]Zf T^ c^TZS\^ SP }[S__^ dZ dSlTZ\S Z_ `[TVU ZTlTZV^cSTVS

]ZWZTU TS__mZTVU\TU dZ U\dZTS 1 dZ _e _[TYU [T^ W[\]^ Š nUe WUcS a[YYS\ZaWS pQT\Z}[Sah

iXZaZTZre _[TYU [T \^cU dZ W[\]^ye aSc`_ZWS ZT _e WUcS _mZTaZScS dS__S W[\]S WXS X^TTU ZT

(14)

dSaW\Z]S\S Z `[TVZ ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZTZ TSY_Z ZTVU\TZ a[WWSaaZ]Zf gZ X^ ZTo^VVZ WXS _S W[\]S`^ah

a^TVZ aSc`_ZWScSTVS `S\ [T `[TVU _ dZ [T^ W[\]^ Še ^TWXmSaa^ aSc`_ZWS ZT _e S ^]STVZ WUT

Saa^[T WUTV^VVU V\Z`[TVUeaZ V\^aoU\c^TUeV\^cZVS [TmU``U\V[T^V\^aoU\c^bZUTS}[^d\^VZW^

U V\^cZVS aWU``Z^cSTVU ZT _e ZT W[\]S V[VVS V^TYSTVZ _[TYU [T^ dSVS\cZT^V^ dZ\SbZUTS ^_

WU\\Za`UTdSTVS dS_ `[TVU ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZTU ^ _ TS_ `\ZcU ZTVU\TU n`S\ _S W[\]S aZTYU_^\Z

ZT _ _^ aZV[^bZUTS SP_^ aVSaa^eWUT }[^_WXS `\SWZa^bZUTSyf Q|SVV[^TdU [T^ [_VS\ZU\S V\^aoU\h

c^bZUTSe ^RRZ^cU ^__U\^ WXS _S TUaV\S W[\]S `^aa^TU V[VVS `S\ [T `[TVU U\dZT^\ZUž aZ `[UP

d[T}[S dSlTZ\S [T `[TVU ZTlTZV^cSTVS]ZWZTU TS__mZTVU\TU dZ U\dZTS 1 WUcS [T `[TVU U\dZh

T^\ZU a[__mU``U\V[TU dZ]ZaU\S SWWSbZUT^_S dS__^ a[`S\lWZS UVVST[V^V\^cZVS1 V\^aoU\c^bZUTZ

a[WWSaaZ]Sf

³µ¡ì¤´º¥ ·´¢§¥¢¥¨

q

}[SaVU `[TVU `UaaZ^cU ZTWUcZTWZ^\S ^ WUTaZdS\^\S Z_ `\UR_Sc^ dS__^ dSlTZbZUTS VSWTZW^

dSZ `[TVZ ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZTZf kS__mUVVZW^ cUdS\T^e [T^ dSlTZbZUTS VSWTZW^ dS]S SaaS\S

d^V^ ZT cUdU WXS aZ^ V\^d[WZRZ_S ZT VS\cZTZ dZ _UYZW^ oU\c^_Se YSTS\^_cSTVS TS__m ^cRZVU

dS__^VSU\Z^ dSY_Z ZTaZScZeS T^V[\^_cSTVS Z_ V\^VV^VU pQT\Z}[SahiXZaZTZreaZ^`S\ Z_ `S\ZUdUZT

W[Z aZ WU__UW^e aZ^ `S\ aWS_V^ WUTa^`S]U_S nWo\f pQT\Z}[SahiXZaZTZe `\So^bZUTSrye TUT aSc`\S

aZ ^VVZSTS ^ aV^Td^\d dZ \ZYU\S oU\c^_S o^WZ_cSTVS \ZWUTd[WZRZ_Z ^ }[S__Z cUdS\TZf ‚^_S

`\UR_Sc^aZ ^WWSTV[^TS_ W^aU dSZ`[TVZZTlTZV^cSTVS]ZWZTZeZT }[^TVU_S\S_^VZ]SdSlTZbZUTZ

aUTU a[YYS\ZVS `Z[P WXS aV^RZ_ZVSf

ƒUZWXSZT }[SaVU_^]U\UWZaScR\^U``U\V[TUaV^RZ_Z\S_mS}[Z]^_STb^dS__S]^\ZSdSlTZbZUh

TZ WXS aZ V\U]^TU ZT _SVVS\^V[\^e ]SdZ^cU WUcS WZUP `[UP SaaS\S o^VVUf

…^ c^TZS\^ dZ `\UWSdS\S `Z[P T^V[\^_S a^\SRRS }[S__^ dZ \Z`U\V^\S ZT oU\c^ VSWTZW^ _S

]^\ZS dSlTZbZUTZ S dZcUaV\^\TS ZT c^TZS\^ oU\c^_S _mS}[Z]^_STb^f iUaP

Ÿ

`\UWSdSTdU `S\UPe TS_

W^aU dZ aZV[^bZUTZ WUcS }[S__^ dS_ V\^VV^VU pQT\Z}[SahiXZaZTZre dU]\SccU WUc[T}[S d^\S

Sa^[\ZSTVZ YZ[aVZlW^bZUTZ `S\ _^ ~V\^d[bZUTS ZT oU\c^ VSWTZW^ dS__mZc`UaV^bZUTS U\ZYZT^\Z^f

É^V^_S`\UR_Sc^a[aaZaVS ^TWXS `S\ Z V\^VV^VZcUdS\TZeZTo^VVZTUT aSc`\S_^ dZcUaV\^bZUTS

dS__mS}[Z]^_STb^ dZ dSlTZbZUTZ oU\c^_Z SP[T o^VVU oU\c^_Se c^ a`SaaU ^VVZSTS ^TWXmSaaU ^__^

~V\^d[bZUTS d^_ _ZTY[^YYZU U\dZT^\ZU ^ }[S__U oU\c^_Sf

gV^TdU WUaP

Ÿ

_S WUaSe V^TVU ]^_S d^\S [Tm[TZW^ dSlTZbZUTS oU\c^_Se S a[WWSaaZ]^cSTVS

dZcUaV\^\S `\U`UaZbZUTZ WXS Z__[aV\ZTU ZT c^TZS\^ aUddZao^WSTVS WUcS }[SaV^ dSlTZbZUTS aZ

WU__SYXZ ^__S ^_V\Sf

Qa^cZTZ^cU U\^ `Z[P ZT dSVV^Y_ZU _^ dSlTZbZUTS cSdZ^TVS aWU``Z^cSTVZ WXS V\U]Z^cU

ZT pw^\VaXU\TSe W^`ZVU_U †e`^\^Y\^oU ‡e`^Yf ‡ˆ’re]^_Zd^ `S\ [T^ }[^_aZ^aZ a[`S\lWZS _ZaWZ^

S WXS U\^ \Z`U\VZ^cU ZTVS\^cSTVS nT^V[\^_cSTVS V^_S dSlTZbZUTS SP d^V^ TS__m ^cRZVU dS__^

VSU\Z^ dSY_Z aWXScZž `S\ W[Z ~a[`S\lWZS _ZaWZ^ oU\c^_cSTVS aV^ `S\ ~aWXSc^ \SYU_^\Se aS`h

^\^VUe ZTVSY\Ue dZ VZ`U lTZVU a[ [T W^c`U ^_YSR\ZW^cSTVS WXZ[aU Y S }[^TdU aZ `^\_^ dZ

`[TVZ aZ aUVVZTVSTdS WXS aZ^TU WXZ[aZyf

.­/«¯®¯ª«­ ²±²± gZ^ þ [T^ a[`S\lWZS _ZaWZ^f q

__U\^ UYTZ `[TVU a[ UYTZ a[`S\lWZS þÛe

UVVST[V^d^ þ V\^cZVS [T^a[WWSaaZUTSlTZV^ dZV\^aoU\c^bZUTZcUTUZd^_ZeSPWXZ^c^VU»¼§·¡

¥§È§¥·£º´§·´ ½¥¢¥§¡ dZ þf gS „ € þÛÛ Î þÛ SP [Tm[_VS\ZU\S a[WWSaaZUTS dZ V\^aoU\c^bZUTZ

cUTUZd^_Ze S aS ‹ÛÛ A þÛÛ SP[T `[TVU TS__m^`S\VU dU]S „ SP[T ZaUcU\lacUe ^__U\^ ZdSTVZlh

(15)

]]S\VZ^cU WXS TS_ `\SaSTVS _^]U\U TUT ^aa[cS\ScU }[SaV^ dSlTZbZUTS c^ [Tm^_V\^e

WXS dZcUaV\S\ScU SaaS\S S}[Z]^_STVS ^ }[SaV^e TS_ aSTaU `\SWZa^VU ZT `\SWSdSTb^f

iUcZTWZ^cU ^d UaaS\]^\S WXS ^TWXS }[SaV^ dSlTZbZUTS TUT SP d^V^ ZT VS\cZTZ aV\SVh

V^cSTVS oU\c^_Ze S WXS _^ V\^d[bZUTS ZT V^_Z VS\cZTZ SPcSTU ZccSdZ^V^ dZ }[^TVU aScR\Zf

†SdZ^cU R\S]ScSTVS }[^_Z `\UR_ScZ `UaaUTU aU\YS\Sf

iZ aUTU d[S c^TZS\S dZ ZTVS\`\SV^\S _^ dSlTZbZUTS ŠfŠf iZUP dZ`STdS d^_ o^VVU WXS `S\

V\^aoU\c^bZUTS cUTUZd^_S aZ `[UPZTVSTdS\S aZ^ [T cU\lacU dZ aWU``Z^cSTVU ZT [T `[TVUe

TS_ aSTaU dS__S dSlTZbZUTZ dZ pw^\VaXU\TSeW^`ZVU_U {{e`^\^Y\^oU reaZ^ [T^ }[^_aZ^aZ V\^aoU\h

c^bZUTS S}[Z]^_STVS ^ }[SaV^ ^ cSTU dZ ZaUcU\lacZf qT^_ZbbZ^cU _^ `\Zc^ Zc`UaV^bZUTSf

pU\c^_cSTVSe^ TU\c^ dS__S dSlTZbZUTZe [T^ V\^aoU\c^bZUTS cUTUZd^_S SP[T cU\lacU

W € þÛ Î þe dU]S þÛ P

S Z_ `\UZSVVZ]Zbb^VU dS_ o^aWZU dZ é h^_YSR\S Y\^d[^VS Q Ì ]S^

* G

S

e

dU]SG SPZ_ o^aWZUdZ ZdS^_ZdZ[T `[TVUdZ þf ƒUZWXSZ_`\UZSVVZ]Zbb^VUaZUVVZSTS ZTWU__^TdU Y_Z

aWXScZ áªVnQnåyy ^_ ]^\Z^\S dZ å V\^ V[VVZ Y_Z ^`S\VZ ^TZ dZ þ e[T `[TVU dZ þÛ a^\^P[T^

U``U\V[T^ W_^aaS dZ S}[Z]^_STb^ dZ ZdS^_Z `\ZcZ UcUYSTSZ dS__S ]^\ZS ^_YSR\S Qnåyf kUT WZ

aU|S\cZ^cU ^d Sa^cZT^\S WUa^ aZ^ oU\c^_cSTVS [T `[TVU a[ [T^ a[`S\lWZS UVVST[V^ d^ þ

V\^cZVS TUT [T^e c^ `Z[PV\^aoU\c^bZUTZ cUTUZd^_ZžWZ ZTVS\Saa^ UaaS\]^\S WXSe ZT V^_ cUdUe

[T `[TVU ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZTU oU\c^_cSTVS \Za[_V^ SaaS\S [T^ W_^aaSe\Za`SVVU ^__^ \S_^bZUTS

dZ S}[Z]^_STb^ YSTS\^V^ d^__mZdSTVZlW^bZUTS aV^RZ_ZV^ TS__^ dSlTZbZUTS ŠfŠedZ }[SaVZ UYYSVVZ

`Z[VVUaVU WUc`_ZW^VZf iZ aZ \STdS a[RZVU WUTVU WXS dZcUaV\^bZUTZ aV\SVV^cSTVS oU\c^_Z WUT

[T^ V^_S dSlTZbZUTS \Za[_V^TU cU_VU`UWU ^YS]U_Zf É^ }[SaV^ Zc`UaV^bZUTSWUc`U\V^^TWXS

[T ^_V\U `\UR_Sc^ WXS U\^ Sa^cZTZ^cUf

iUTaZdS\Z^cU a[ þ d[S `[TVZ dZaVZTVZ _ S ‹e S aZ^ þ= _U aWU``Z^cSTVU dZ þ ZT _e

þŒ _U aWU``Z^cSTVU dZ þ ZT ‹e nþ=yŒ _U aWU``Z^cSTVU dZ þ= TS_ WU\\Za`UTdSTVS dZ ‹ S

nþŒy= _U aWU``Z^cSTVU dZ þŒ TS_ WU\\Za`UTdSTVS dZ _f …S a[`S\lWZ nþ=yŒ S nþŒy= aUTU

ZaUcU\oS ZT c^TZS\^ T^V[\^_Sf iUTaZdS\Z^cU [T `[TVU _

à a[_ dZ]ZaU\S SWWSbZUT^_S dZ _ ZT nþŒy= S Z_ a[U WU\\Za`UTdSTVS T^V[\^_S _Û Ã ZT nþ=yŒ€ aSRRSTS _ à S _Û Ã dSRR^TU dSlTZ\S

_U aVSaaU `[TVU ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZTUe TUT SP`S\ TZSTVS WXZ^\U aS ZTaZScZaVZW^cSTVS aZ^TU _U

aVSaaU UYYSVVUe TSaS aZ^TU S}[Z]^_STVZ V\^cZVS [T^ a[WWSaaZUTS dZ ZdSTVZlW^bZUTZ dS_ VZ`U

aV^RZ_ZVU TS__^ dSlTZbZUTS ŠfŠ nS ^TbZ WZ aUTU UVVZcZ cUVZ]Z `S\ \ZVSTS\S WXS WZ P

U aZ^ o^_aUyf

P

Q `UaaZRZ_S ^__U\^ WXS _^ dSlTZbZUTS ŠfŠ dSRR^ SaaS\S ZTVS\`\SV^V^ oU\c^_cSTVS ZT

c^TZS\^dZ]S\a^f P

Q T^V[\^_SZTo^VVZ dSlTZ\S ~aWU``Z^cSTVU dZ þ ZT _ TUT aU_U Z_ cU\lacU

W € þ Û

Î þ dZ W[Z ^RRZ^cU lTU\^ `^\_^VUe c^ }[^_aZ^aZ cU\lacU WÛ

€ þ ÛÛ

Î þ V^_S WXS

SaZaV^ [T ZaUcU\lacU õ € þÛÛ Î þÛe V^_S WXS WÛ Ì W Þõf ‹[SaV^ ZTVS\`\SV^bZUTS SPWUToU\h

V^V^ d^_ o^VVU WXS _U aWU``Z^cSTVU X^ [T^ `\U`\ZSV P

^ [TZ]S\a^_S nWo\f pw^\VaXU\TSe W^`ZVU_U

{{e `\U`UaZbZUTS fŠurye S d[T}[S `[UP SaaS\S dSlTZVU o[TVU\Z^_cSTVSe `S\WZUP^ cSTU dZ ZaUh

cU\lacZf q

_V\U o^VVU WXS WUToU\V^ V^_S Zc`UaV^bZUTS SP WXS TS_ YZ^P WZV^VU VSU\Sc^ a[__^

o^VVU\Zbb^bZUTS dS__S V\^aoU\c^bZUTZ RZ\^bZUT^_Z dZ a[`S\lWZSe _S V\^aoU\c^bZUTZ cUTUZd^_Z

aUTU aZW[\^cSTVS ZTVSaS ^ cSTU dZ ZaUcU\lacZf

{T }[SaVmUVVZW^e[T `[TVU ZTlTZV^cSTVS]ZWZTU\Za[_V^SaaS\S [T^W_^aaS dZ S}[Z]^_STb^dZ

WU``ZS dS_ VZ`U n_OWyedU]SW €þÛ Î þ SPWUc`UaV^dZV\^aoU\c^bZUTZcUTUZd^_Ze_ A þÛ nUe

aS]UY_Z^cUedZWU``ZS dS_VZ`U n_OnW

à O

‚‚‚

OWyyedU]S_S W2 aUTU_S V\^aoU\c^bZUTZ cUTUZd^_Z

WUc`UTSTVZ Wye S dU]S _mS}[Z]^_STb^ SP dSlTZV^ VSTSTdU WUTVU dSY_Z ZaUcU\lacZ T^V[\^_Z S

(16)

 £ §¥¦¥¡§´ º´¸¥£§·´ £§´¤¤¥ ¸¥Æ¼§¦¥¡§¥ µ£¦¥¡§£¤¥¨

gSRRSTS _mZc`UaV^bZUTS U\^ Sa`UaV^ aZ^ ^RR^aV^Tb^ aUddZao^WSTVSe SP U``U\V[TU aSYT^_^\S

[Tm ^_V\^ dSlTZbZUTS oU\c^_S dSZ `[TVZ ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZTZe WXS SP }[S__^ WXS aZ V\U]^ ZT

ps^\ZatZe ^``STdZWS ^_ W^`ZVU_U {{e dZ Žf …Z`c^Trf

kUVZ^cU WXS [T^ }[^_aZ^aZ WUc`UaZbZUTS dZ V\^aoU\c^bZUTZ cUTUZd^_Z dZ a[`S\lWZe W €

Û Î e SPRZ\^bZUT^_Se S }[ZTdZ ZTd[WS [T ZaUcU\lacU dSZ W^c`Z dS__S o[TbZUTZ \^bZUT^_Z

×ny S ×nÛyf {TU_V\Se [T `[TVU _ A Ûe WXS TS__^ dSlTZbZUTS ŠfŠ P

S [a^VU `S\ ZTdZ]Zd[^\S

[T `[TVU ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZTU dZ e X^ ^TS__U _UW^_S éê



÷=e WXS `[UP SaaS\S \ZY[^\d^VU

WUcS aUVVU^TS__U dZ ×ny

U Ì

×nÛye S V^_S aUVVU^TS__U WUTVZSTS _m ^TS__U _UW^_S dZ [T [TZWU

`[TVU dZ e WXS `UZ SP _m[TZWU `[TVU dZ  ZT W[Z SP TSWSaa^\ZU aWU``Z^\S `S\ `UVS\ dSlTZ\S

_ nV[VVU WZUP a^\^P \ZoU\c[_^VU ZT dSVV^Y_ZU TS_ W^`ZVU_U {{{yf É^e Y\^bZS ^d [T \Za[_V^VU dZ

qRXŒ^Tt^\ nWo\f pqRXŒ^Tt^\e VSU\Sc^ ‡e `^Yf ‡u‡rye a^``Z^cU WXS UYTZ aUVVU^TS__U _UW^_S

\SYU_^\S dZ dZcSTaZUTS d[S dZ ×nyeWUTVSTSTVS _m ^TS__U _UW^_S dZ [T `[TVU nWXZ[aUy dZ e SP

UVVST[VU TS__^ c^TZS\^ ^``ST^ dSaW\ZVV^f ‘[T}[S V^_S aUVVU^TS__U`[UPSaaS\S ^aa[TVU WUcS

dSlTZbZUTS oU\c^_S dS_ `[TVU ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZTUf …^ \S_^bZUTS V\^ Z `[TVZ ZTlTZV^cSTVS

]ZWZTZ S V^_Z aUVVU^TS__Z SP^TWXS ^RR^aV^Tb^ ZTV[ZVZ]^€ `S\ SaSc`ZUe Z_ aUVVU^TS__U dZ ×n sy

^aaUWZ^VU ^_ `[TVU ZTlTZV^cSTVS ]ZWZTU ^d [T `[TVU _ _[TYU [T^ \SVV^

x

]ZSTS ^d SaaS\S

_mZTaZScS dS__S o[TbZUTZ \^bZUT^_Z _^ W[Z \SaV\ZbZUTS ^ }[^_aZ^aZ W[\]^ aSc`_ZWS ZT _e S Z]Z

V^TYSTVS ^

x

\Za[_V^ dSlTZV^ ZT _f

‚^_S Zc`UaV^bZUTSeU_V\S ^d SaaS\S cU_VU WUcUd^ d^_ `[TVU dZ ]ZaV^ oU\c^_Se X^ ^TWXS

[T ^_V\U `\SYZU€ }[S__U dZ \ZWU\d^\S cU_VU d^ ]ZWZTU _^ WUaV\[bZUTS ^_YSR\ZW^ dS__^ dSaZTh

YU_^\Zbb^bZUTS dZ [T^ W[\]^e o^VV^ WUT Z aUVVU^TS__Z dZ ‘SdStZTd dS_ W^c`U dS__S o[TbZUTZ

\^bZUT^_Z nWo\f pw^\VaXU\TSe W^`ZVU_U {e `^\^Y\^oU ryf {T S|SVVZ TS_ _ZR\U ps^\ZatZhg^c[S_r SP

^WWSTT^V^e`S\ _S a[`S\lWZe[T^ WUaV\[bZUTS ^T^_UY^eV\^cZVS`\U`\ZU aUVVU^TS__ZdZ W^c`ZdZ

Y\^dU dZ V\^aWSTdSTb^ d[Sf k^V[\^_cSTVSe`UZWXS_^ aZV[^bZUTS SPTUVS]U_cSTVS WUc`_ZW^V^e

TUT aZ X^TTU \Za[_V^VZ WUaP

Ÿ

WUc`_SVZ WUcS TS_ W^aU dS__S W[\]Sf

…^dSlTZbZUTS cSdZ^TVS^TS__ZdZo[TbZUTZ \^bZUT^_Z`\SaSTV^`S\UP^TWXS [TU a]^TV^YYZU€

Z_ \Za[_V^VU dZ qRXŒ^Tt^\ ]^_S `S\ _S a[`S\lWZe c^e `S\ SaVSTdS\_U ZT dZcSTaZUTS c^YYZU\S

dZ d[Se U `S\ d^\TS [T^ ]S\aZUTS ~\S_^VZ]^e WZUSP ]^_Zd^ `S\ _S o^cZY_ZSe TUT R^aV^TU _S

Z`UVSaZ [VZ_Zbb^VS ZT dZcSTaZUTS d[S nWo\f ^TWXS ps^\ZatZh g^c[S_e ^``STdZWS ‰e `^Yf ‡’re

`S\ [T ^WWSTTU `Z[P YSTS\^_S ^ dZWU_V^P dZ }[SaVU VZ`Uyf {T]SWS _^ dSlTZbZUTS ŠfŠ SP `Z[P

dZ\SVV^cSTVS SaVSTaZRZ_S nWUT }[^_WXS W^[VS_^ TS_ W^aU dS__S W[\]Syf

À§·µ¡¸¼¦¥¡§´ £¥ ¢£»¥·¡¤¥ ¶¼¢¢´¶¶¥½¥¨

kSZ `\UaaZcZ d[S W^`ZVU_Z aV^RZ_Z\ScU ZT c^TZS\^ dSVV^Y_Z^V^ _S TSWSaa^\ZS dSlTZbZUTZ S

`\U`UaZbZUTZeWXS Z__[aV\^TU Z WU__SY^cSTVZ V\^ _S ]^\ZS dSlTZbZUTZ ^ W[Z ^RRZ^cU ^WWSTT^VUe

S WXS WUaVZV[ZaWUTU`^\VSdS__m ^``^\^VUVSWTZWU WXS[VZ_ZbbS\ScUTS__^ V\^VV^bZUTSa[WWSaaZ]^f

gV^RZ_Z\ScU [T^ dSlTZbZUTS ~ZTVS\cSdZ^ V\^ }[S__S dZ pw^\VaXU\TSr S ps^\ZatZre WXS

WUTaZaVS SaaSTbZ^_cSTVS TS_ WUTaZdS\^\S Z cU\lacZ dZ aWXScZ ZTdUVVZ d^__S ZTW_[aZUTZ dSZ

aUVVU^TS__Z dZ W[Z ^RRZ^cU `^\_^VUe TS_ W^c`U ×nyf q

RRZ^cU \ZVST[VU dZ `\UWSdS\S ZT

}[SaVU cUdUe `UZWXSWUaP

Ÿ

Z WU__SY^cSTVZ WUT _S dSlTZbZUTZ S}[Z]^_STVZ aUTU ^RR^aV^Tb^ \^h

`ZdZf {TU_V\SeWUT }[SaV^Zc`UaV^bZUTS]STYUTU ^d SaaS\S Z__[aV\^VZ ZT c^TZS\^ ~YSUcSV\ZW^

^_W[TZ o^VVZ WUTWS\TSTVZ _^ aV\[VV[\^ ~RZ\^bZUT^_S dSY_Z aWXScZe ZT `^\VZWU_^\S Z_ o^VVU WXS

(17)

WUcS ~YS\cZ dZ dSaZTYU_^\Zbb^bZUTS dS__U aWXSc^ aVSaaUf k^V[\^_cSTVS V^_S o^VVU TUT SP

TSWSaa^\ZU `S\ Y_Z a]Z_[``Z a[WWSaaZ]Z dS_ _^]U\Ue S WS\V^cSTVS TUT WUaVZV[ZaWS [TU a]Z_[``U

TS__^ VSU\Z^ dS__^ dSaZTYU_^\Zbb^bZUTS dS__S a[`S\lWZžV[VV^]Z^ ^RRZ^cU \ZVST[VU U``U\V[TUe

ZT [T _^]U\U dZ VSaZ WUcS Z_ `\SaSTVSe dZ ^WWSTT^\S ^ V^_S ^a`SVVU TS_ cUcSTVU ZT W[Z WZ aZ

(18)

ilej™ šœcic™š™ lfœd™g™ œ ‘bcd™ f ilej™ ’™lœm™icœ™

{TWUcZTWZ^cU }[SaVU W^`ZVU_U aV^RZ_STdU ^_V\Z \Za[_V^VZ S_ScSTV^\Zž V[VV^]Z^e aZWWUcS TS__^

oU\c^ ZT W[Z WZ aS\]UTUe TUT aUTU o^VVZ _^\Y^cSTVS [VZ_Zbb^VZ ZT _SVVS\^V[\^ WUcS }[S__Z dS_

W^`ZVU_U ÿea]Z_[``S\ScU `Z[PZT dSVV^Y_ZU_S dZcUaV\^bZUTZf g[WWSaaZ]^cSTVSe[VZ_Zbb^TdU dSZ

\Za[_V^VZ dZ ps^\ZatZhg^c[S_redZcUaV\S\ScU dSZ o^VVZ YSTS\^_Z WXS WZ a^\^TTU [VZ_Z ZT aSY[ZVUf

ִȧ¥¦¥¡§´ ´ ¸´¶¢µ¥¦¥¡§´ ¸´¥ º¡µÈ¶º¥ ¢£§¡§¥¢¥ µ´¤£·¥½¥ £ »¼§·¥¨

ƒS\ UYTZ `[TVU _ dZ [TU aWXSc^ eaZ `[ P

U WUTaZdS\^\S [T cU\lacUedSVVU º¡µÈ

¶ º

¡ ¢£§ ¡Ø

§¥¢¡eZ_ W[Z dUcZTZU SP_U a`SVV\U dS__m ^TS__U _UW^_S éê÷= dZ _ ZT f …^ dSlTZbZUTS dZ }[SaVU

cU\lacUSPR^aZ_^\SZT VSU\Z^dSY_ZaWXScZ€ SPTSWSaa^\Z^`S\dSlTZ\S _SZccS\aZUTZYn_y Î e

S }[ZTdZ _S lR\S dSZ cU\lacZ nWo\f pw^\VaXU\TSe W^`ZVU_U {{e `^Yf ˆ Sd SaS\WZbZU

’ f ryf

T^ dSlTZbZUTS dS_ cU\lacU W^TUTZWU \S_^VZ]U ^ _ aZ V\U]^ ZT

p„\UVX

STdZSWth‘ZS[dUTTSe

W^`ZVU_U {e

’

f‰fŠrž V[VV^]Z^ UaaS\]Z^cU }[Ze `S\WXS WZ SP WUcUdU `S\ Z_ aSY[ZVUe WXS V^_S

cU\lacU `[UP SaaS\S dSlTZVU WUcS Z_ _ZcZVS ZT]S\aU dS__S ZccS\aZUTZ dSY_Z ZTVU\TZ ^`S\VZ dZ

_f  ᪪௮¯ª«­ ã±²± ¾¥£ ¼ §¡ ¶¢Á ´º £ ´8å “ Oæç”ç• 9 ¥¤¶¥¶· ´º £¥§½ ´µ ¶¡ ¸¥ ¶¢Á ´º ¥ ¢¡¶ ·¥·¼¥·¡ ¸£ Ò ¤¥ ¥§·¡µ§¥ £»´µ·¥ ¸¥ _ ¥§  ´ ¸£¤¤´ ¥ºº´µ¶¥¡§¥ æç”ç• € å“ Î å–¨ —¤¤¡µ£ g`SW éê÷= ´¹ ¤¥º¥·´ ¥§½ ´µ ¶¡ ¸¥ ·£¤´ ¶¥¶· ´º £Ä ¢¥¡ ¹ ´ ´¶ ¥¶·¡§¡ º¡µÈ ¶ º ¥ æ = ç” € g`SW éê ÷= Î å“ ·£¤¥ ¢Á ´ æç”ç• Þ æ=ç” Ì æ=ç•Ä ´ ¶´ þ ´¹ ¼§¡ ¶¢Á´º£ ´ æ“ € þ Î å“ ¶¡§¡ º¡µÈ¶º¥ ·£¤¥ ¢Á´ æç”ç• Þæ“ Ì æ– Ä £¤ ¤¡µ£ ´¶ ¥¶ ·´ ¼ § ¼§ ¥¢¡ º¡µÈ ¶ º ¡õ € þ Î g`SW éê ÷= ·£¤´ ¢Á ´æ“ Ì æ=ç”Þ õ¨

˜!"#$ %&'!( ƒUZWXSY_Z ^`S\VZ ^TZ oU\c^TU [T^ R^aS `S\ _^ VU`U_UYZ^e Z_ aUVVUaZaVSh

c^ dZ 8å“Oæç”ç•9 WUaVZV[ZVU d^Y_Z ZTVU\TZ ^TZ X^ _U aVSaaU _ZcZVS ZT]S\aU naS SaZaVSy dZ

8å“Oæç”ç•9f ƒUaaZ^cU ^__U\^ a[``U\\S WXS Z_ aZaVSc^ ZT]S\aU 8å“Oæç”ç•9aZ^ WUaVZV[ZVUd^Z

aU_Z ZTVU\TZ ^TZf

{T }[SaV^ Z`UVSaZe 8å“Oæç”ç•9 SP V\^aoU\c^VU V\^cZVS Z_ o[TVU\S dS__S aSbZUTZ Y_UR^_Z

TS_ aZaVSc^ dZ\SVVU dZ ^TS__Z néênå“y Oîç•ç” ye Z_ W[Z _ZcZVS dZ\SVVU P S `S\ dSlTZbZUTS éê ÷= f

‘[T}[Se `UZWXSZ_ o[TVU\S dS__S aSbZUTZ Y_UR^_Z SP WUTV\U]^\Z^TVS S ZTd[WS ZTaZScS ^ g`SW

[TmS}[Z]^_STb^ dZ W^VSYU\ZSe P S ZccSdZ^VU ]S\ZlW^\S WXS g`SW éê ÷= P S [T _ZcZVS ZT]S\aU dZ 8å“O擖9eaS ZcU\lacZ æ=ç” € g`SW éê÷= Î å“ aUTU dSlTZVZ d^  ÂÃ ç” Þg`SW îç”=edU]S  ç” P S _mZaUcU\lacUT^V[\^_SS îç” = P S _mUcUcU\lacU éênå“yÎ éê ÷= eSaZaVSTVS `S\ dSlTZbZUTS dZ _ZcZVS dZ\SVVU dZ ^TS__Zf + , .­/«¯®¯ª«­ ã±ã± gZ^ _ [T `[TVU dZ [TU aWXSc^ e 8þOæç” €þ Î å“9 [T _ZcZVS ZT]S\aU

dS_ aZaVSc^ 8å“Oæç”ç•9 WUaVZV[ZVU d^Y_Z ZTVU\TZ ^`S\VZ dZ _ ZT f q

__U\^ æê nV^_S TUV^bZUTS

X^ aSTaU `S\WXS SP[TU dSY_Z å“y a^\^PdSVVU [T º¡µÈ¶º¡ ¢£§¡§¥¢¡\S_^VZ]U ^ _f

©ª«¬­«®¯ª«­ ã±ä± ¾¥£  ¼§¡ ¶¢Á´º£ ´ å ¼§ ¶¼¡ £»´µ·¡¨ ™´¤ ¶´ Ò ¼¥·¡ ¼¶´µ´º¡ ¶»´¶¶¡ ¤£ §¡·£¦¥¡§´ îç= »´µ ¤Å¡º¡º¡µÈ¶º¡ éênåy Î éê÷=¨ À§¡¤·µ´ µ¥¶´µ½´µ´º¡ ¤£ §¡·£¦¥¡§´ æ=ê »´µ ¥¤ º¡µÈ¶º¡ ¢£§¡§¥¢¡ g`SW éê÷= Î  Æ£¢´§·´ »£µ·´ ¸´¤ ¶¥¶·´º£ ¥§½´µ¶¡ ¸´È§¥·¡ §´¤¤£ ¸¥º¡¶·µ£¦¥¡§´ ¸´¤¤£ »µ¡»¡¶¥¦¥¡§´ š¨›¨

(19)

ßàà­á¬â®¯ª«­ ã±ô± gSWUTdU _^ dSlTZbZUTS dZ STdZSWth‘ZS[dUTTSe W^`ZVU_U {e ’f‰fŠre

aU_U æ=ê aZ WXZ^c^ cU\lacU W^TUTZWUf kS__^ TUaV\^ Zc`UaV^bZUTS ZT]SWS aZ ]S\ZlW^ a[RZVUe

WUT _^ `\U`\ZSV^P [TZ]S\a^_S dS_ _ZcZVSe WXS Z cU\lacZ W^TUTZWZ æ € þ Î  aUTU V[VVZ S aU_Z

}[S__Z dS_ VZ`U æ=ê ÞÜe dU]S Ü SP[T ZaUcU\lacU þÍÎ g`SW éê÷=f

iUT]ZSTS `S\WZUP dSaW\Z]S\S Sa`_ZWZV^cSTVS æ=êe nWZUSeP \ZVU\T^TdU ^__^ dZcUaV\^bZUTS

dS__^ `\U`UaZbZUTS ’fŠe dURRZ^cU \ZWXZ^c^\S WUcS aZ UVVSTY^TU Z cU\lacZ WXS dSlTZaWUh

TU Z_ _ZcZVS ZT]S\aU ^ `^\VZ\S d^ }[S__Z dZ [T aUVVUaZaVSc^yf ƒ\SaZ d[S }[^_aZ^aZ ZTVU\TZ

^TZ dZ _e å“ S å–e S [T ZTVU\TU ^TS åœ Õ å“ B å–e S WXZ^c^TdU æç”êe æç•ê _S ZccS\aZUTZe aZ X^ æç”ê Þæ=ç” Ì æç”ê Þæçç” Þæ=ç Ì æçê Þæ=ç S ^T^_UY^cSTVS ^TWXS æç•ê Þæ=ç• Ì æçê Þæ=çf ‹[ZTdZ æç”ê Þæ=ç” Ì æç”ê Þ  ÂÃ ç” Þg`SW îç”=e dU]S  ç” SPWUcS

^_ aU_ZVU _mZaUcU\lacU T^V[\^_Se P

S ZTdZ`STdSTVS d^__^ aWS_V^ dZ že S dSlTZaWS Z_ cU\lacU

W^TUTZWU æ=ê €g`SW éê÷= Î f

‘^__mUaaS\]^bZUTS ÿf‰ S d^__^ dSlTZbZUTS

’

f’ aSY[S a[RZVU WXS Z cU\lacZ W^TUTZWZ aUTU

W^\^VVS\Zbb^VZ d^__^ aSY[STVS `\U`\ZSV^P[TZ]S\a^_Sf

᪪௮¯ª«­ ã±ý± ¾¥£ æ € þ Î  ¼§ º¡µÈ¶º¡ ¢£§¡§¥¢¡ µ´¤£·¥½¡ £¸ ¼§ »¼§·¡ _ ¸¥ ¼§¡ ¶¢Á´º£ ¨ —¤¤¡µ£ æ Æ£··¡µ¥¦¦£ ·µ£º¥·´ ¡ Ò §¥ ¥ºº´µ¶¥¡§´ ¸¥ ¥§·¡µ§¥ £»´µ·¥ ¸¥ _Ä ´ ¶´ õ € Î  ´¹¼§ º¡µÈ¶º¡ ·£¤´ ¢Á´Æ£··¡µ¥¦¦¥ ·µ£º¥·´ ¡ Ò §¥¥ºº´µ¶¥¡§´ ¸¥¥§·¡µ§¥ £»´µ·¥ ¸¥_Ä ¡ ´¼¥½£¤´§·´º´§·´ ´¹·£¤´ ¢Á´õn y ´¹¢¡§·´§¼·¡¥§ ¡ Ò §¥ ¥§·¡µ§¡¸¥_ ϢƵ¨¡¶¶´µ½£¦¥¡§´Ÿ¨ ÐÄ £¤¤¡µ£ ´¶¥¶·´ ¼§ ¼§¥¢¡ º¡µÈ¶º¡ õ= € Î þ ·£¤´ ¢Á´ õ Ì æ Þ õ=¨ À§¡¤·µ´Ä ¡ Ò §¥ º¡µÈ¶º¡ ¢Á´ ¶¡¸¸¥¶È ·£¤¥ ¢¡§¸¥¦¥¡§¥ ´¹¼§ º¡µÈ¶º¡ ¢£§¡§¥¢¡ µ´¤£·¥½¡ £ _ ¨ ¡­¢¢â ã±± ¾¥£ å ¼§¡ ¶¢Á´º£ £§´Ä _ ¼§ »¼§·¡ ¸¥ åÄ ¿ ¤Å£§´¤¤¡ ¸´¤¤´ ¶´¦¥¡§¥ Ò ¤¡Ø 죤¥ é ç nåyÄ  ç € åÍÎ g`SW ¿ ¤Å¥¶ ¡º¡µÈ¶º ¡ § £·¼µ£¤´Ä ´ ¶¥£ ¥§È § ´ Ê Ì  ç n_y¨ —¤ ¤¡µ £ ¤Å¡º¡º¡µÈ¶º¡ îç= ´¹¼§ ¡º¡º¡µÈ¶º¡ ¸¥ ¤¡¢£¤¥¦¦£¦¥¡§´ ¸¥ — µ¥¶»´··¡ £ ʨ ˜ !"#$ %&'!(

iUTaZdS\Z^cU Y_Z ZaUcU\lacZ

Ù €¿ÍÎ é

g`SW 

ng`SW ¿y S Ú €é  ËÍÎ ¿ËO

WXS aZ V\U]^TU dSlTZVZ TS__^ dZcUaV\^bZUTS dZ pw^\VaXU\TSe W^`ZVU_U {{e `\U`UaZbZUTS ’f’r

nZdSTVZlWXZ^cU ¿ WUT ¿ ø

e dU]S õ Ì Šy€ d^__S dSlTZbZUTZ dZaWSTdS dZ\SVV^cSTVS WXS Ú Þ

î  Ë ÞÙe SPZ_ cU\lacU dZ _UW^_Zbb^bZUTS £ €¿ Î ¿Ëf ƒUaVU „ Ì

 Âà ç aZ X^ „ò Ë Þîç= Ì î  Ë Þ„ ò

nåyf …mZaUcU\lacU Ù SPSa^VV^cSTVS _mZaUcU\lacU T^V[\^_S  nWo\f Z_ WSTTU

dZ dZcUaV\^bZUTS dS__^ `\U`UaZbZUTS ÿf yf \^ `UTZ^cU Ù Ì Ù Âà  ބ ò nåy S Ú Ì Ú ބò Ë f …^ WUcc[V^VZ]ZV^PdS_ dZ^Y\^cc^ éçnåy ¤ÍÎ¥¦ éç÷= § ¨© § ¨ª ¿ ÍΫ ¿Ë dZcUaV\^ _m^aaS\VUf + ,

(20)

SaS\WZbZU ‡fАWr U p„\UVXSTdZSWth‘ZS[dUTTSe W^`ZVU_U ÿe

’ fŠfŠryf

.­/«¯®¯ª«­ ã±± gS _ S ‹ aUTU `[TVZ dZ [TU aWXSc^ e ^__U\^ dZ\ScU WXS _ SP ¶»´¢¥£¤¥¦Ø

¦£¦¥¡§´dZ ‹ S ‹ SP Ò ´§´µ¥¦¦£¦¥¡§´dZ _e aS _ A 8‹9f ᪪௮¯ª«­ ã±± 6§ º¡µÈ¶º¡ ¢£§¡§¥¢¡ æ € þ Î Ä µ´¤£·¥½¡ £¸ ¼§ »¼§·¡ _ ¸¥ ¼§¡ ¶¢Á´º£ Ä ´¹¼§ ¡º´¡º¡µÈ¶º¡ ¶¼¤¤Å¥ºº£ Ò ¥§´Ä ¤£ ¼£¤´ ´¹¤Å¥§¶¥´º´ ¸´¤¤´ Ò ´§´µ¥¦¦£¦¥¡§¥ ¸¥ _ ¨ À§¡¤·µ´Ä ¶´ ¿ ´¹¼§ £§´¤¤¡Ä Ê ´¹¼§ ¥¸´£¤´ »µ¥º¡ ¸¥ ¿Ä ´¸ £ € ¿ Î Ó ´¹¼§ ¡º¡º¡µÈ¶º¡ ¸¥ ¤¡¢£¤¥¦¦£¦¥¡§´ ¸¥ ¿ ¥§ ÊÄ £¤¤¡µ£ g`SW £ ´¹¼§ º¡µÈ¶º¡ ¢£§¡§¥¢¡ µ´¤£·¥½¡ £ Ê ¥§ g`SW ¿¨

˜!"#$ %&'!( ƒUZWXSZ cU\lacZ W^TUTZWZ dZ|S\ZaWUTU `S\ ZaUcU\lacZ dSZ dUcZTZeR^aV^

dZcUaV\^\S _m ^aaS\VU `S\ æ=êf iUTaZdS\Z^cU [T ZTVU\TU ^`S\VU ^TS å dZ _e S UaaS\]Z^cU

WXS æ=êe `S\ WUcS SP aV^VU dSlTZVUe o^VVU\Zbb^ `S\ _mZccS\aZUTS æç € å Î e WXS SP [T

UcSUcU\lacU a[__mZcc^YZTSf j^aV^ d[T}[S `\U]^\S _m ^aaS\VU `S\ æ = ç f ‘^VU WXS æ=ç P

S d^VU d^__^ WUc`UaZbZUTS dS__mZaUcU\lacU T^V[\^_S „ Ì

 ÂÃ ç € g`SW éçnåyÍÎ å WUT g`SW îç

=e R^aV^ `\U]^\S _m ^aaS\VU `S\ g`SW îç

=e S `S\ Z_ `[TVU

 ç

n_yf

ƒS\ Z_ _Scc^ ’f S a[^ dZcUaV\^bZUTSe SaZaVUTU [T ^TS__U ¿e [T ZdS^_S `\ZcU Ê dZ ¿ S

d[S ZaUcU\lacZ Ù € éênåyÍÎ ¿ S Ú €éê÷=ÍÎ ¿Ë V^_Z WXS aZ^ WUcc[V^VZ]U Z_ dZ^Y\^cc^

éênåy ¤ÍÎ¥¦ éê÷= § ¨© § ¨ª ¿ ÍΫ ¿Ë O dU]S £ P

S _mUcUcU\lacU dZ _UW^_Zbb^bZUTS dZ ¿ ZT Ê

f q

``_ZW^TdU Z_ o[TVU\S g`SWe UVVSTZ^cU

Z_ dZ^Y\^cc^ WUcc[V^VZ]U

g`SW ¿Ë  « ÍÎ g`SW ¿ § ¨  ª § ¨  © g`SW éê÷=  ¤¥¦ ÍÎ g`SW éênåy ‚ É^ Ù Ì Ù Âà  Þ „ ò nåy Ì  Âà  Þ „ ò

nåye d[T}[Se `S\ _^ \S_^bZUTS V\Z^TYU_^\S nWo\f `\U`Uh

aZbZUTS ÿfye g`SW Ù Ì  ç ބ Ì Zdn¿ Ì éênåyy S }[ZTdZ ng`SW ÙynÊy Ì  çn_yf ‘[T}[S WZ \Zd[WZ^cU ^ `\U]^\S _m ^aaS\VU `S\ Ê S g`SW £f

…mUcUcU\lacU£e SaaSTdU [T^ _UW^_Zbb^bZUTSeZTd[WS [T^ RZSbZUTS nÊ Î £ÂÃnÊyyV\^ Y_Z

ZdS^_Z `\ZcZ dZ ¿Ë S Y_Z ZdS^_Z `\ZcZ WUTVST[VZ ZT Ê

nWo\f pq

VZŒ^XhÉ^WdUT^_de W^`ZVU_U {{{e

`\U`UaZbZUTS ‡fŠŠnZ]yrye `S\WZUP g`SW £ SP [T UcSUcU\lacU a[__mZcc^YZTSe _^ }[^_Se `UZWXS

_^ \S_^bZUTS Ê A 8¬9 S}[Z]^_S ^ ¬ Õ Êe SP`\U`\ZU _mZTaZScS dS__S YSTS\Zbb^bZUTZ dZ Êe WUcS

]U_S]^cUf

ƒS\ dZcUaV\^\S _m[_VZc^ ^|S\c^bZUTSe UaaS\]Z^cU WXSe d^VU WXS Y_Z UcUcU\lacZ dZ

_UW^_Zbb^bZUTS dZ|S\ZaWUTU `S\ ZaUcU\lacZ dSZ dUcZTZ S Z cU\lacZ W^TUTZWZ dZ|S\ZaWUTU

(21)

aU`\^e aS å Ì g`SW ¿e „ Ì Zd e aZ X^ g`SW Ù Ì   e S }[ZTdZ g`SW £ Ì    Þ g`SW î  Ë Þg`SW Ú Ì æË   Þg`SW Úe S d[T}[S SP[T cU\lacU W^TUTZWUf + , o¡º »¡µ·£º´§·¡ ¸´¥ º ¡µÈ ¶º¥ ¢£§¡§¥¢¥ µ¥¶»´··¡ £¤¤´ ¶»´¢¥£¤¥¦¦£¦¥¡§¥¨ ᪪௮¯ª«­ ã±-± ¾¥£§¡ _O7 A Ä ¢¡§ _ ¶»´¢¥£¤¥¦¦£¦¥¡§´ ¸¥ 7¨ —¤¤¡µ£ ´¶¥¶·´ ¼§ ¼§¥¢¡ º¡µÈ¶º¡æ<= €þ< Î þ= ·£¤´ ¢Á´æ< Ì æ=Þæ<=Ä ¢¥¡´¹·£¤´ ¢Á´ ¶¥£ ¢¡ºº¼·£·¥½¡¥¤ ¸¥£ Ò µ£ºº£ þ< § ¨ 2; ¦ 2; ­ þ= 2 ¦ ÍÎ  ‚

˜!"#$ %&'!( ƒUZWXS_ A 879e UYTZ ZTVU\TU dZ _ SP ^TWXS ZTVU\TU dZ 7e `S\WZUPe `\SaU

[T cU\lacU W^TUTZWU \S_^VZ]U ^ _e æ= € þ= Î e S [TU \S_^VZ]U ^d 7e æ< € þ< Î e æ <

o^VVU\Zbb^ `S\ UYTZ ZTVU\TU ^`S\VU dZ _e S d[T}[S `S\ _^ `\U`\ZSV^P [TZ]S\a^_S dZ æ= nWo\f

`\U`UaZbZUTS ’f ‰y aZ X^ _m^aaS\VUf +

,

ßàà­á¬â®¯ª«­ ã±²°± kUVZ^cU WXSe aSc`\S `S\WXS Z_ aZaVSc^ dSY_Z ZTVU\TZ dZ _ SP [T

aUVVUaZaVSc^dZ }[S__UWUaVZV[ZVU d^Y_Z ZTVU\TZdZ 7eWmSP[T^c^``^T^V[\^_SV\^Z_ZcZVZdZ\SVVZ

éê÷= S éê÷< nUVVST[V^ [VZ_Zbb^TdU _^ `\U`\ZSV^P [TZ]S\a^_S dS_ _ZcZVS dZ\SVVUe ZT c^TZS\^

^T^_UY^ ^ }[^TVU U\^ o^VVU `S\ Y_Z aWXScZye WXS WXZ^cS\ScU c^``^ dZ _UW^_Zbb^bZUTS î=<f

qTWXS }[SaV^ TUV^bZUTS a^\^P \Z[VZ_Zbb^V^ ZT W^aZ aZcZ_Zf {_ TUcS dZ c^``^ dZ _UW^_Zbb^bZUTS

P

S ^TWXS }[Z YZ[aVZlW^VU d^_ o^VVU WXS î=< WU\\Za`UTdS ^d [T^ c^``^ dZ _UW^_Zbb^bZUTS o\^

^TS__Z ¿Ë Î ¿®edU]S ¿ SP[T ^TS__US Ê S ¬ aUTU ZdS^_Z dZ ¿ WUT ¬ Õ Ê n ^]U_S\ SaaS\S `ZYTU_Ze

^TWXS }[SaV^ SP [T UcUcU\lacU dZ _UW^_Zbb^bZUTS aU_U ^ cSTU dS__mZaUcU\lacU T^V[\^_S

V\^ ¿® S _^ _UW^_Zbb^bZUTS dZ ¿Ë \Za`SVVU ^_ WU\\Za`UTdSTVS dZ ¬yf

᪪௮¯ª«­ ã±²²± ™´¤¤£ ¶¥·¼£¦¥¡§´ ¸´¤¤£ »µ¡»¡¶¥¦¥¡§´ š¨¯Ä ¶´ þ= Ì g`SW éê÷=Ä þ< Ì g`SW éê ÷< Ä æ= Ì æ= êÄ æ < Ì æ< êÄ ¶¥ Á£ æ <= Ì g`SW î= <¨

˜!"#$ %&'!( gS å SP[T }[^_aZ^aZ ZTVU\TU ^TS dZ _ nS }[ZTdZ dZ 7ye ^__U\^SPWUcc[V^VZ]U

Z_ dZ^Y\^cc^ éênåy ¤ÍÎ¥¦ éê÷= ¤¥ ; ­ § ¨¤¦ ; éê÷< ‚

q``_ZW^TdU Z_ o[TVU\S g`SW S WUc`UTSTdU WUT _mZaUcU\lacU T^V[\^_S

 ÂÃ ç € g`SW éênåy Ì g`SW éçnåyÍÎ å aZ X^ Z_ dZ^Y\^cc^ g`SW éê ÷< § ¨  ¤¦ ; 2; ¥ ­ g`SW éê ÷= 2 ¦¥ ÍÎ å ‚

(22)

aZbZUTS

’

fˆe WUT g`SW î=< ^_ `UaVU dZ æ<= nVSTSTdU WUTVU WXS aVZ^cU a[``UTSTdU þ Ì

g`SW éê÷=e SWWfyf ƒS\ _m[TZWZV^eP aZ X^ g`SW î=< Ì æ<=e WUcS ]U_S]^cUf +

,

ßàà­á¬â®¯ª«­ 㱲㱠qT^_UY^cSTVS ^ }[^TVU o^VVU ZT `\SWSdSTb^e TUT SPdZWZ_S `\U]^\S

WXS aS ¿ P S [T ^TS__Ue aS ÊO¬ A g`SW ¿e WUT ¬ Õ Ê

e S aS ZTlTS WUTaZdS\Z^cU Z cU\lacZ

W^TUTZWZ d^VZ d^Y_Z a`SVV\Z dSY_Z UcUcU\lacZ dZ _UW^_Zbb^bZUTSe ^__U\^ æË® Ì g`SW £e dU]S £

P S _mUcUcU\lacU dZ _UW^_Zbb^bZUTS ¿Ë Î ¿®f ᪪௮¯ª«­ ã±²ä± ™´¤¤£ ¶¥·¼£¦¥¡§´ ¸´¤¤£ »µ¡»¡¶¥¦¥¡§´ š¨¯Ä ¥¤ º¡µÈ¶º¡ æ<= €þ< Î þ= ¹ ´ ¼§ º¡µÈ¶º¡ ¢£§¡§¥¢¡ µ´¤£·¥½¡ £¤¤Å¼§¥¢¡ ¢¡µµ¥¶»¡§¸´§·´æ Âà = n7y ¸¥ 7 ¥§ þ=¨

˜!"#$ %&'!( …^ WUTV\UZcc^YZTS æ ÂÃ

=

n7y SP WUaVZV[ZV^ d^ [T [TZWU `[TVU `S\WXS æ= SP

[T UcSUcU\lacU a[__mZcc^YZTSf ƒS\ dZcUaV\^\S WXS æ<= SP [T cU\lacU W^TUTZWUe R^aV^

dZcUaV\^\S_^`\U`\ZSV^P[TZ]S\a^_S ’f‰f gS õ €ö Î þ= SP[T cU\lacU WXS o^VVU\Zbb^ V\^cZVS

UYTZ ZTVU\TU dZ æ ÂÃ

=

n7ye æ= Þ õ €ö Î  o^VVU\Zbb^ V\^cZVS UYTZ ZTVU\TU dZ 7f ‘[T}[S SaZaVS

[T [TZWU õ< €ö Î þ< V^_S WXS æ< Þõ< Ì æ= Þõe WUaP Ÿ d^ ^]S\S Z_ dZ^Y\^cc^ ö ø; ÍÎ þ< ã ø ­ § ¨ 2; ¦ ² 2; ­ þ= 2 ¦ ÍÎ  O

dU]S _^ `^\VS ² S Z_ `S\ZcSV\U SaVS\TU aUTU WUcc[V^VZ]Zf gS cSVVZ^cU æ<= Þõ< ^_ `UaVU dZ

õe `UZWXS² SPWUcc[V^VZ]Ue Z_ `S\ZcSV\U SaVS\TU \SaV^ WUcc[V^VZ]Uf É^ `S\ _^ `\U`\ZSV^P

[TZ]S\a^_S dZ æ=e õ SP_m[TZWU WXS WUc`UaVU WUT æ= d^Pæ= Þõe `S\WZUPõ Ì æ<= Þõ<e WZUSP^TWXS

_^ `^\VS ã dS]S SaaS\S WUcc[V^VZ]^f ‘m^_V\UTdSe V\^ Z cU\lacZ ö Î þ<e õ< SP_m[TZWU WXS

\STdS WUcc[V^VZ]^ _^ `^\VS ã `S\WXSSP _m[TZWU WXS \STdS WUc[V^VZ]U Z_ `S\ZcSV\U SaVS\TUf

‘[T}[S æ<= X^ _^ ]U_[V^ `\U`\ZSV^P [TZ]S\a^_S S `S\WZUP SP [T cU\lacU W^TUTZWU \S_^VZ]U ^

æ Âà = n7yf o¡º »¡µ·£º´§·¡ ¸´¥ º ¡µÈ ¶º¥ ¢£§¡§¥¢¥ µ¥¶»´··¡ £¥ º ¡µÈ ¶º¥ ¸¥ ¶¢Á´º¥¨ ᪪௮¯ª«­ ã±²ô± ¾¥£ õ €  Î ö ¼§ º¡µÈ¶º¡ ¸¥ ¶¢Á´º¥Ä ´ ¶¥£ _ A Ä ‹ Ì õn_y¨ ¾´ æ € þ Î  ´¹¼§ º ¡µÈ ¶º¡ ¢£§¡§¥¢¡ µ´¤£·¥½¡ £ _ ´° € Î ‹ ´¹¼§ º ¡µÈ ¶º¡ ¢£§¡§¥¢¡ µ´¤£·¥½¡ £ ‹Ä ´¶¥¶·´ ¼§ ¼§¥¢¡ º¡µÈ¶º¡ õ=Œ ·£¤´ ¢Á´ ¶¥£ ¢¡ºº¼·£·¥½¡ ¥¤ ¸¥£ Ò µ£ºº£ nƒy þ 2 ÍÎ  § ¨ ø ¦± § ¨ ø Íβ ö ‚ À§ ¡¤·µ´Ä § ´¤ ¢£¶¡ þ Ì g`SW éê ÷= Ä Ì g`SW é³ ÷Œ Ä æ Ì æ= êÄ ° Ì æŒ ³Ä ¸´½´ £½ ´µ¶ ¥ õ=Œ Ì g`SW õò = ¨

(23)

˜ iUTaZdS\Z^cU õ Þ æ € þ Î öf ƒUZWXS æ o^VVU\Zbb^ V\^cZVS UYTZ ZTVU\TU

^`S\VU dZ _e õ Þæ o^VVU\Zbb^ V\^cZVS UYTZ ZTVU\TU ^`S\VU dZ ‹e S d[T}[Se `S\ _^ `\U`\ZSV^P

[TZ]S\a^_S dZ °e SaZaVS [T [TZWU cU\lacU õ=Œ V^_S WXS aZ^ WUcc[V^VZ]U nƒyf

gS í SP[T ZTVU\TU ^TS dZ ‹ S å SP[T ZTVU\TU ^TS dZ _ WUTVST[VU ZT õÂÃn íye aZ X^

Z_ dZ^Y\^cc^ WUcc[V^VZ]U

é³ní y ¤´± ÍÎ é³÷Œ § ¨© § ¨ øN ¦ éênåy ¤ÍÎ¥¦ éê÷= O dU]S Ù Ì îøùúûïüç Þõ ò n í yf q

``_ZW^TdU Z_ o[TVU\S g`SW S WUc`UTSTdU WUT Y_Z ZaUcU\lacZ

T^V[\^_Z g`SW é³níy Ì g`SW éï n íy U Ì í S g`SW éênåy Ì g`SW éçnåy U Ì åe aZ X^ Z_

dZ^Y\^cc^ WUcc[V^VZ]U

g`SW éê÷= 2 ¦¥ ÍÎ å § ¨  øN ¦ § ¨ øµ ¥¶´ g`SW é³÷Œ 2 ±´ ÍÎ í ‚

iUc`UTSTdU ^TWU\^ WUT _S ZccS\aZUTZ ^`S\VS dZ å S dZ í e UVVSTZ^cU Sa^VV^cSTVS Z_ dZ^h

Y\^cc^ nƒy WUT g`SW õò = ^_ `UaVU dZ õ=Œf ƒS\ _m[TZWZV^Pe g`SW õò = Ì õ=Œe WUcS ]U_S]^cUf + ,

ßàà­á¬â®¯ª«­ ã±²ý± iUTaS\]^TdU _S TUV^bZUTZ dS__^ `\SWSdSTVS dZcUaV\^bZUTSe aZ^TU U\^

õ €  Î ö S „ € ö Î í d[S cU\lacZ S aZ^ _ A e ‹ Ì õn_ye · Ì „n ‹yf gZ dZcUaV\^

a[RZVU WXS n õ ބy=¸ Ì õ=Œ ބŒ¸f {To^VVZed^VU WXS õ=Œ WXZ[dS Z_ dZ^Y\^cc^ nƒy S „Œ¸ TS

WXZ[dS [TU ^T^_UYU nWZUPS nƒye WUT ö ^_ `UaVU dZ e í ^_ `UaVU dZ öe SWWfye ^__U\^ õ=Œ ބŒ¸

WXZ[dS Z_ dZ^Y\^cc^ WXS dSlTZaWS nõ ބy=¸ nWZUSPe c[V^VZa c[V^TdZae aSc`\S nƒyyf

gZ X^ `UZ WXS aS õ € Î ö SP[T ZaUcU\lacU S õn_y Ì ‹ ^__U\^ õ=Œ SP[T ZaUcU\lacUf

{To^VVZ nZdêy== Ì Zd n`S\WXSSTV\^cRZ WXZ[dUTU Z_ aU_ZVU dZ^Y\^cc^y S ^T^_UY^cSTVS

nZd³yŒŒ Ì Zd f ‘[T}[S õ=Œ ÞõŒ= Ì nZdêy== Ì Zd S õŒ= Þõ=Œ Ì nZd³yŒŒ Ì Zd e WZUSP

õŒ= SP _mZT]S\a^ dZ õ=Œf ©ªáª¹¹âᯪ ã±²± ¾¥£ õ €  Î ö ¼§ º¡µÈ¶º¡ ¸¥ ¶¢Á´º¥Ä ¶¥£ í ¼§ £»´µ·¡ ¸¥ ö ´ å Ì õÂÃn íyÄ ·£¤´ ¢Á´ õ ëç÷ï ¶¥£ ¼§ ¥¶¡º ¡µÈ ¶º¡Ä ¶¥£ _ A å ´ ‹ Ì õn_yÄ ´ ¶¥£ ¥§È §´ æ €þ Î  ¼§ º¡µÈ¶º¡ ¢£§¡§¥¢¡ µ´¤£·¥½¡ £_¨ —¤¤¡µ£ õ Þæ ´¹¼§ º¡µÈ¶º¡ ¢£§¡§¥¢¡ µ´¤£·¥½¡ £ ‹¨

˜!"#$ %&'!( gZ^TU æç S æï _S ZccS\aZUTZ S ° € Î í [T cU\lacU W^TUTZWU \S_^VZ]U

^ ‹f ƒUZWXS_ A å S ‹ A í e S d^VU WXS Z cU\lacZ W^TUTZWZ o^VVU\Zbb^TU `S\ _S ZTW_[aZUTZ

dZ ZTVU\TZ ^`S\VZe SaZaVUTU æÛ € þ“ Î å S °Û € “ Î í V^_Z WXS æ Ì æç ÞæÛ S ° Ì æï Þ°Ûf gZ

]S\ZlW^ o^WZ_cSTVSe WUT _^ `\U`\ZSV^P [TZ]S\a^_Se WXS æÛ S °Û aUTU cU\lacZ W^TUTZWZ \S_^VZ]Z

\Za`SVVZ]^cSTVS ^ _ S ‹f ‘[T}[S õ Þæ Ì õ Þæç ÞæÛ Ì æï Þnõëç÷ ïyÞæÛ Ì æï Þ°ÛÞnõëç÷ ïy=Œ Ì

° Þ n õëç÷ïy=Œf ƒUZWXS° SP [T cU\lacU W^TUTZWU \S_^VZ]U ^ ‹e S `UZWXS nõëç÷ ïy=Œ SP [T

ZaUcU\lacUeZT }[^TVU õëç÷ ï SP[T ZaUcU\lacUe _m^aaS\VU SP`\U]^VUf +

(24)

º ¶º¥ 쥵£¦¥¡§£¤¥ ¸¥ ¶¢Á´º¥¨

†SdZ^cU U\^ WUcS ^_W[TZ cU\lacZ W^TUTZWZ aZ^TU [VZ_Z `S\ dSlTZ\S Z cU\lacZ RZ\^bZUT^_Z

dZ aWXScZf ƒS\ aV^RZ_Z\S V^_S dSlTZbZUTSe aZ `UV\SRRS `STa^\S dZ aSY[Z\S _^ o^_a^\ZY^ dS__^

dSlTZbZUTS ]^_Zd^ `S\ _S ]^\ZSV^P nWo\f pw^\VaXU\TSe W^`ZVU_U {e `^\^Y\^oU urye V[VV^]Z^ ZT

p„\UVXSTdZSWth‘ZS[dUTTSe W^`ZVU_U {e ’f‡fur SP d^V^ [T^ dSlTZbZUTS `Z[P dSRU_Se _^ }[^_S ^d

SaSc`ZU TUT Zc`_ZW^ WXS [T cU\lacU RZ\^bZUT^_S ZTd[W^ [T ZaUcU\lacU a[ [T ^`S\VUe

T P

S WXS SaaU ^RRZ^ [T ZT]S\aUf kUZ WZ ^VVS\\ScU ^ V^_S dSlTZbZUTSe WXS U\^ ^TdZ^cU ^d

Sa^cZT^\Sf .­/«¯®¯ª«­ ã±²± iXZ^cS\ScU »¼§·¥ Ò ´§´µ¥¢¥ º£¶¶¥º£¤¥ Z `[TVZ YSTS\ZWZ dSZ WXZ[aZ Z\h \Zd[WZRZ_Z c^aaZc^_Z dZ [TU aWXSc^f ᪪௮¯ª«­ ã±²± ¾¥£ õ €  Î ö ¼§ º¡µÈ¶º¡ ¸¥ ¶¢Á´º¥Ä ´ ¶¼»»¡§¥£º¡ ¢Á´ ¤£ µ´Ø ¶·µ¥¦¥¡§´ ¸¥ õ £¤¤Å¥§¶¥´º´ 8»“9“¼½ ¸´¥ »¼§·¥ Ò ´§´µ¥¢¥ º£¶¶¥º£¤¥ ¸¥ Ä ¶¥£ ¼§£ 쥴¦¥¡§´ ·µ£ ·£¤´ ¥§¶¥´º´ ´ ¤Å¥§¶¥´º´ ¸´¥»¼§·¥ Ò ´§´µ¥¢¥ º£¶¶¥º£¤¥ ¸¥ö ¨ —¤¤¡µ£Ä »¡¶·¡7“ Ì õn»“yÄ ¶¡§¡ ´¼¥½£¤´§·¥ ¤´ ¶´ Ò ¼´§·¥»µ¡»¡¶¥¦¥¡§¥¨ n ^y :¤¥ ¡º¡º¡µÈ¶º¥ õò ¾ ” € é³÷<” Î éê÷ ¾ ” ¶¡§¡ ¥¶¡º¡µÈ¶º¥¨ nRy ¶¥¶·¡§¡ ¶¢Á´º¥ þ“ ´ º¡µÈ¶º¥ æ“ € þ“ Î Ä°“ €þ“ Î öÄ ·£¤¥ ¢Á´ »´µ ¡ Ò §¥ žÄ æ“ ´°“ ¶¥£§¡ º¡µÈ¶º¥ ¢£§¡§¥¢¥ µ´¤£·¥½¥ µ¥¶»´··¥½£º´§·´ £ »“ ´¸ 7“Ä ´ ·£¤¥ ¢Á´°“ Ì õ Þæ“Ä ¢¥¡´¹¶¥£ ¢¡ºº¼·£·¥½¡ ¥¤ ¸¥£ Ò µ£ºº£  2”¿ þ“ § ¨ ø ² ” ­ ö ‚ ˜ !"#$ %&'!(

n ^y À nRyf pZaa^VU že R^aV^ WUTaZdS\^\S Z_ dZ^Y\^cc^ WUcc[V^VZ]U

g`SW éê÷ ¾ ” 2Á ” I ÍÎ  § ¨  øN Á” § ¨ ø g`SW é³÷<” 2; ” ÍÎ ö ‚ ƒUZWXSg`SW õò ¾ ” P S [T ZaUcU\lacUe æ<”³ Þg`SW õò ¾ ” P

S [T cU\lacU W^TUTZWU \S_^VZ]U ^d 7“e

S d[T}[S R^aV^ `U\\S þ“ Ì g`SW éê÷ ¾ ”e æ“ Ì æ ¾ ”ê S °“ Ì æ<”³ Þg`SW õò ¾ ” f

nRy À n^yf pZaa^VU že`UZWXSæ“ S°“ aUTU cU\lacZ W^TUTZWZ \S_^VZ]Z ^ »“ S 7“e SaZaVUTU

ZaUcU\lacZ Ü € þ“ÍÎ g`SW éê÷

¾

(25)

þ“ § ¨Ã ² 2” ­ g`SW éê÷ ¾ ” 2Á ” I ÍÎ  § ¨  øN Á ” ä § ¨ ø g`SW é³÷<” 2; ” ÍÎ ö ÄÅ § ã ² ” ¿ þ“ ‚

ƒUZWXS^TWXS _^ `^\VS ä SPWUcc[V^VZ]^ea^\^PWUcc[V^VZ]U Z_ `S\ZcSV\U SaVS\TU

þ“ 2” ÍÎ  § ¨Æ § ¨ ø þ“ ² ” ÍÎ ö O dU]S „ Ì ÝÂÃÞ ng`SW õò ¾ ” yÞÜf É^ `S\ Z`UVSaZ ^TWXS þ“ 2” ÍÎ  § ¨JK  ” § ¨ ø þ“ ² ” ÍÎ ö P

S WUcc[V^VZ]Uf ƒS\ _m[TZWZV^PdS_ cU\lacU WXS WXZ[dS ^ aZTZaV\^ }[SaVZ [_VZcZ d[S dZ^Y\^ch

cZ nWo\f }[^TVU dSVVU `\Zc^ a[_ WUc`U\V^cSTVU dSZ cU\lacZ W^TUTZWZ \Za`SVVU ^Z cU\lacZ

dZ aWXScZye aZ X^ ÝÂÃÞng`SW õò ¾ ” yÞÜ Ì Zd ”e d[T}[S g`SW õò ¾ ” Ì ÝÞÜÂà S }[ZTdZ g`SW õò ¾ ” P

S [T ZaUcU\lacUž S WUaP

Ÿ ^TWXS õò ¾ ” f + ,

.­/«¯®¯ª«­ ã±²-± T cU\lacU WXS aUddZal _S WUTdZbZUTZ S}[Z]^_STVZ n^ye nRydS__^ `\U`Uh

aZbZUTS ’fŠ aZ dZWS 쥵£¦¥¡§£¤´f

ßàà­á¬â®¯ª«­ ã±ã°± gZ^ õ €  Î ö [T cU\lacU dZ aWXScZ ZTVSY\Zf TU aWXSc^ ZTVSY\Ue

SaaSTdU Z\\Zd[WZRZ_Se X^ [T [TZWU `[TVU YSTS\ZWU c^aaZc^_Sf gZ^TU ^__U\^ 7ê Sd 7³ Z `[TVZ

YSTS\ZWZ c^aaZc^_Z \Za`SVVZ]^cSTVS dZ  S dZ öf …^ RZ\^bZUT^_ZV^P dZ õ S}[Z]^_S ^__U\^ ^

\ZWXZSdS\S WXS õn7êy Ì 7³ S WXS õ ò < I € é³÷<  Πéê÷< I aZ^ [T ZaUcU\lacUf É^ õn7êy Ì 7³ S}[Z]^_S ^ dZ\S WXS õ SP dUcZT^TVSe WZUSP õny Ì öž ZTo^VVZ õn7êy Ì 7³ À ö Ç õny Ç

Riferimenti

Documenti correlati

ciò che genericamente si dice e si pensa di noi), quanto più ci denudiamo delle maschere e ci mostriamo nella nostra fragilità, la fragilità della nostra nuda esistenza, povera

Abbiamo già accennato alla nozione Abbiamo già accennato alla nozione di di curva curva o arco di curva continua... D’ora in avanti useremo la lettera D’ora in avanti useremo

ESERCIZI DI ANALISI MATEMATICA 1 SETTIMANA

[r]

Il numero di intersezione ` e simmetrico rispetto alle curve di cui si calcola, per cui si pu` o determinare anche come ordine della serie ottenuta sostituendo la

This meta-analysis of randomized trials evaluating (physiological or surgical) postmenopausal women suffering from daily hot flushes and sleep disturbances showed that

relativi all’indirizzario del Ministero della Salute che tiene traccia dell’elenco delle strutture di ricovero: tra il 2014 e la fine del 2016, il numero degli erogatori accreditati

balanced budget clause since January 2014 has never been invoked as a standard for the constitutional review of austerity measures to accomplish a balance between this clause, on