Cross border critical infrastructure: a new approach for the protection evaluation
8
0
0
Testo completo
(2)
(3) 129??B785DD9 # '+"%"&$#%'#%'#%+# '" # "# ' +
(4) ! ##% '' $# ! '. 9?F1>>1$1B389?>>9 # '+"%"&$#%'#%'#%+# '" # "# ' +
(5) ! #)""!% #"" $# ! '. <5>1 E791DD9 # '+"%"&$#%'#%'#%+# '" # "# ' +
(6) ! " ( '' $# ! '. 8B9CD91>=2B?C9 "&' '('#
(7) %' "&" )%& '+# $$ "&" %'&##(' %"* ',% " * ',% "
(8) ! % &' "!%#& &($& . ?B?D1J5BC;9 "&' '('#
(9) %' "&" )%& '+# $$ "&" %'&##(' %"* ',% " * ',% "
(10) ! #%#',%& &($& . 1B=5<1$5<J9 %% '#%+ ". ) %#'' #". %! , % #" #!% '. $%'!"'. #". #!% . ' +.
(11) ! . +85 G?B; @B?@?C5C 1> ?@5B1D9?>1< =?45< 6?B D85 =1>175=5>D ?6 3B?CC2?B45B DB1>C@?BD 3B9D931< 9>6B1CDBE3DEB5C '1BD93E<1B6?3EC9C79F5>D?B?141>4B19<>5DG?B; +85=19>7?1<9CD?45F5<?@1539C9?> *E@@?BD *ICD5= ** 6?B D85 =1>175=5>D ?6 B5<5F1>D 5F5>DC D81D =1I 81F5 9=@13DC ?> D85 DG? 3?E>DB95C +85* D@B?:53D)5C9<95>35?63B?CC2?B45BB9D931< >6B1CDBE3DEB5C9C@1BD?6D85 >D5BB57- D1<I*G9DJ5B<1>4
(12) +85@B?:53D1B519>3<E45C)579?>5#?=21B491 D1<I1>41>D?>+939>? *G9DJ5B<1>41>481C255>49F94549>D?DG?1B51C +85CDE4I1B51G85B5D8581J1B4C5F5>DC?62?D8 1>D8B?@931>4>1DEB1<?B979>1B51>1<IJ54 B9D931<C35>1B9?C?>3B9D931<9>6B1CDBE3DEB51B51<C?5F1<E1D54 +859=@13D1B519C1<1B75B1B519>G8938D8556653DC16D5BD85D?D1<?B@1BD91<9>D5BBE@D9?>C?613B9D931< 9>6B1CDBE3DEB59>D85CDE4I1B511B55F1<E1D54 *@5396931<<ID85G?B;9<<ECDB1D5CD8549665B5>D?@5B1D9?>1< @81C5C?6D85@B?@?C54=?45< +8569BCD?>59CD851>1<IC9C?61>D8B?@931>4>1DEB1<81J1B4CB5<1D54D? D85 CDE4I 1B51 B?14 1>4 B19< 133945>DC B19< 619<EB5C9>D5>C5 B19>61<< 5F5>DC 6<??4C <1>4C<945C 452B9C 6<?G5D3 +85C53?>4@81C53?>35B>CD8545D19<541>1<IC9C19=541D=1>179>7D855F5>DCG9D8@1BD93E<1B B565B5>35D?D8569BCDB5C@?>45BCO9>D5BF5>D9?>=?45<C1>4D855=5B75>3I1>4DB16693=1>175=5>D@<1>C +89C@81C51<C?9>3<E45CD859=@<5=5>D1D9?>?61=?>9D?B9>7>5DG?B;1>41> +@<1D6?B=EC54D?C81B5 41D11>49>6?B=1D9?>12?ED3B9D931<9>6B1CDBE3DEB5C +85D89B4@81C59CD85D5CD1>4F1<941D9?>?6D85 + @<1D6?B=9=@<5=5>D54 -,%'( +B1>C@?BD B5C9<95>35 3B9D931< 9>6B1CDBE3DEB5C B5C9<95>35 3B9D931< 9>6B1CDBE3DEB5C C165DI 5=5B75>3I=1>175=5>DB9C;=1@@9>7DB1>C@?BDFE<>5B129<9DIB?14>5DG?B;B19<>5DG?B;B5C@?>C51>4 B53?F5BI4539C9?>CE@@?BDCICD5=3B?CC2?B45B9>6B1CDBE3DEB5C 619<EB5 E>1F19<129<9DI 133945>D1< ?B =1<939?EC 2B51;4?G>C D81D 3?E<4 75>5B1D5 3?>C5AE5>35C " #" 1>47B51D<I16653DD8553?>?=I851<D8C165DI1>4 &EBC?395DI9CCDB?>7<I45@5>45>D?>D853?BB53D G5<61B5 ?6 39D9J5>C ?6 1> 5>D9B5 3?E>DBI ?B ?6 6E>3D9?>9>7 ?6 9>D5B45@5>45>D 9>6B1CDBE3DEB5 C5F5B1<>59782?B9>73?E>DB95C%1>1>4*1>C1F9>9 CICD5=CCE381CDB1>C@?BD1D9?>B?14B19<19B1>4
(13) +85 49CBE@D9?> ?6 1 3B9D931< DB1>C@?BD C51 5<53DB939DI 1>4 G1D5B >5DG?B;C +85C5 9>6B1CDBE3DEB5B?14?BB19<31>81F5B5@5B3ECC9?>C CICD5=C 1B5 ?6D5> B565BB54 D? 1C 3B9D931< +89C 9C >?D ?><I G85B5 D85 5F5>D ?33EBC 2ED 1<C? 9> 1 2531EC5 D85I 1B5 >535CC1BI 6?B D85 ?B71>9J1D9?> G945B1B51 5@5>49>7?>D85DI@5?65F5>DG8938 6E>3D9?>1<9DI 1>4 CD129<9DI ?6 1 =?45B> =1I 25 ?6 >1DEB1< 5 7 <1>4C<945 ?B 9>4ECDB91<9J54 3?E>DBI ?85>
(14) +85 1>D8B?@?75>93 5 7 B?14 133945>DC ?B979> 9D 9C 9>6B1CDBE3DEB5 CICD5= =1I 25 FE<>5B12<5 D? . Proceedings of the 30th European Safety and Reliability Conference and the 15th Probabilistic Safety Assessment and Management Conference Edited by Piero Baraldi, Francesco Di Maio and Enrico Zio c ESREL2020-PSAM15 Organizers.Published by Research Publishing, Singapore. Copyright ISBN: 978-981-14-8593-0; doi:10.3850/978-981-14-8593-0 4134-cd. 3758.
(15) Proceedings of the 30th European Safety and Reliability Conference and the 15th Probabilistic Safety Assessment and Management Conference. @?CC92<5D?5CD9=1D5D859=@13DC?>D85=?29<9DI?6 @5?@<51>47??4C9>D5B=C?645<1IC1<D5B>1D9F5 B?ED5C 9>3B51C54 DB16693 3?>75CD9?> 1>4 @?CC92<59>3B51C59>133945>DC +85B56?B5 D85 9>D5BBE@D9?> ?6 B?14 1>4 B19< C53D9?>C 31> 81F5 B5@5B3ECC9?>C >?D ?><I ?> DB1>C@?BD2ED1<C??>D85C?39?53?>?=93CICD5= 9> 1 =13B?B579?>1< 3?>D5HD D D85 EB?@51> <5F5< D85 '$( *'%&$ '$(&%') ),%'!81C255>4569>541CD85C5D?6<9>51BB19< B?14 1>4 9><1>4 G1D5BG1I 1>4 @?9>D 9>6B1CDBE3DEB5EB21>>?45C@?BDC9>D5B@?BDC1>4 19B@?BDC3?>C945B54B5<5F1>D1D?==E>9DI<5F5< > ?B45B D? @B?=?D5 D85 3??B49>1D54 9=@<5=5>D1D9?> 1>4 45F5<?@=5>D ?6 D85 +B1>C EB?@51> +B1>C@?BD %5DG?B; 3?BB94?BC ?6 CDB1D5793 9=@?BD1>35 81F5 255> 945>D96954 1C 9<<ECDB1D54 9> 97
(16) EB?@51> ?==9CC9?>
(17) .
(18)
(19) .
(20) .
(21)
(22) . .
(23) .
(24) .
(25)
(26)
(27)
(28)
(29)
(30)
(31)
(32)
(33)
(34) . %#!,-!.!*/ /%+*+"/$!0-+,! * +--% +-.. . ?<<?G9>7 1 >E=25B ?6 C97>96931>D 5F5>DC 9> D85 EB?@51>9B53D9F5
(35)
(36) ?>D85 945>D96931D9?>1>445C97>1D9?>?6 EB?@51>3B9D931< 9>6B1CDBE3DEB5C1>4D851CC5CC=5>D?6D85>554D? 9=@B?F5 D859B @B?D53D9?> G1C 9CCE54 +85 9B53D9F5 B565BC D? D85 5>5B7I 1>4 DB1>C@?BD C53D?BC =?>7 D85 F1B9?EC 4569>9D9?>C 9>3<E454 9> D85 <579C<1D9?> 9D 9C EC56E< D? C@5396I D85 6?<<?G9>7 •. B9D931< >6B1CDBE3DEB5?B =51>C1>1CC5D CICD5= ?B @1BD D85B5?6 <?31D54 9> $5=25B *D1D5CG89389C5CC5>D91<6?BD85=19>D5>1>35 ?6 F9D1< C?395D1< 6E>3D9?>C 851<D8 C165DI. •. C53EB9DI 53?>?=93 ?B C?391< G5<<259>7 ?6 @5?@<5 +8549CBE@D9?>?B45CDBE3D9?>?6D89C CICD5=G?E<481F51C97>96931>D9=@13D9>1 $5=25B *D1D5 1C 1 B5CE<D ?6 D85 619<EB5 D? =19>D19>D8?C56E>3D9?>C EB?@51> B9D931< >6B1CDBE3DEB5 ?B =51>C 3B9D931< 9>6B1CDBE3DEB5 <?31D54 9> $5=25B*D1D5CD8549CBE@D9?>?B45CDBE3D9?> ?6G8938G?E<481F51C97>96931>D9=@13D?> 1D<51CDDG?$5=25B*D1D5C +85C97>96931>35 ?6 D85 9=@13D C81<< 25 1CC5CC54 9> D5B=C ?6 3B?CC3EDD9>7 3B9D5B91 +89C 9>3<E45C 56653DC B5CE<D9>76B?=3B?CCC53D?B45@5>45>395C?> ?D85BDI@5C?69>6B1CDBE3DEB5C . # "% ! "" ! " !" > ?B45B D? 4569>5 G85D85B 1> 9>6B1CDBE3DEB5 9C 3B9D931< ?B >?D 1C @B5F9?EC<I 4569>54 9D 9C >535CC1BI D? 1CC5CC 9DC FE<>5B129<9DI D? D85 =?CD @B?212<5 5F5>DC 1>4 9DC 9=@?BD1>35 G9D89> D85 >5DG?B; ?3EC9>7?>D8569BCD1C@53D9D1B9C5CD85 >535CC9DID?79F514569>9D9?>D?FE<>5B129<9DIG9D8 B5C@53D D? D85 B9C; B9C; 31> 25 5CD9=1D54 2I 31<3E<1D9>7 D85 @B?2129<9DI ?6 1 79F5> 81J1B4 945>D96I9>7D855<5=5>DC1DB9C;1>41CC5CC9>7D859B FE<>5B129<9DID?D81DC@53969381J1B4?2EB>5D1<
(37) 1>4 #9>;?F 5D 1<
(38) DC 3?==?> 7B?E>4 D81D FE<>5B129<9DI 81C =1>I 4569>9D9?>C 1>4 6?B D85 @EB@?C5 ?6 D89C @B?35CC 9D G1C 3?>C945B54 9=@?BD1>D D? 8978<978D D85 C@539693 4569>9D9?>C?6FE<>5B129<9DI?61DB1>C@?BD>5DG?B; )571B49>7 B?14 DB1>C@?BD1D9?> CICD5=C 6?B 5H1=@<5 D85 ?>5 CE775CD54 9C B5@?BD54 85B5 /+*"$' " )- ((*(&) " )-)% $ $)() ) $ '(*") $ %$( '" '*) %$( $ '% $),%'! ('+ " )-0 $1DDCC?> 1>4 !5>5<9EC
(39) 1>4 5B4931 $?B5?F5B D85B5 1B5 C5F5B1< 3?=@?>5>DC ?6 FE<>5B129<9DI 3?>35B>9>7 DB1>C@?BD >5DG?B; ?B785DD9 1>4 $1<1F1C9
(40) 1 @8IC931< 6E>3D9?>1< ?B71>9J1D9?>1< CICD5=931>4D?@?<?7931< +?79F51>?F5BF95G?6 D8521C933?>35@DC=5>D9?>549>D85@B?:53D9D9C 9=@?BD1>D D? 4569>5 B5C9<95>35 D?? > C395>D9693 <9D5B1DEB5 C5F5B1< 1ED8?BC ?F5B D85 I51BC 81F5 CDE4954D853?>35@D?6B5C9<95>35G9D85=@81C9C?> >5DG?B; CICD5=C CE38 1C 5>5B7I DB1>C@?BD 1>4 3?==E>931D9?>C)57791>9
(41) $1DDCC?>1>4 !5>5<9EC
(42) @?CC92<5 4569>9D9?> ?6 B5C9<95>359C/( " $ () " )-% (-()# )%, ) ()$# %' ('*&) %$, ) $&)" ') %$ &'#)'( $ )% '%+' , ) $ &)") #$%#&%( )%()($' (!(0 B1>39C 1>4 5;5B1
(43) 19=5C D B5CE<DC D81D 1 B5C9<95>D CICD5= 81C D85 6?<<?G9>7 381B13D5B9CD93C B54E354 @B?2129<9DI ?6 619<EB5 =1<6E>3D9?> B54E354 3?>C5AE5>35C ?6 619<EB5C 9> D5B=C ?6 <?CC ?6 <965 41=175 1>4.
(44) Proceedings of the 30th European Safety and Reliability Conference and the 15th Probabilistic Safety Assessment and Management Conference. @@ >571D9F5 53?>?=93 1>4 C?391< 3?>C5AE5>35C B54E3D9?>?6B53?F5BID9=5BE>51E5D1< 1B<C?>5D1<
(45) ?BD89CB51C?>1DD8545C97> CD1759DG?E<42525DD5BD?3?>C945BD85B5C9<95>35 ?6 D85 9>6B1CDBE3DEB5 >?D :ECD 9DC 5669395>3I >4554CDE495C81F5C8?G>D81D>?D>535CC1B9<I1> 5669395>D 9>6B1CDBE3DEB5 9C 1<C? B5C9<95>D D85 =51CEB5=5>D 9C 31BB954 ?ED EC9>7 D85 1F5B175 45<1I 1C 1 3?=@1B9C?> @1B1=5D5B 25DG55> B5C9<95>351>45669395>3I 1>9>5D1<
(46) > D89CF95GB5C9<95>3531>254569>541C) " )- % $$) )- (()%' $ .) %$%##*$ )- ' %$)%$) &)'( ()(%''(&%$)% &) )% $ '%+' '%# ()*'$ 1B<C?>5D1<
(47) 97 C8?GCD85?@5B1D9>7 CD1DEC ?6 1 D9=545@5>45>D CICD5= 13D9F9DI G9D8 B565B5>35D?1B5<5F1>D5F5>D Performance of the transport system. Event. Equilibrium A. Equilibrium B Trend curve B. Trend curve A. m Ai. e th of. t ec oj r p. Time Preparation Mitigation. Response Recovery. %#!*!- (%.! %.-0,/%+*,-+"%(! * ./ #!."+- /- *.,+-/ .4./!) ,/! "-+) -(.+*!/ ( * !0 (!%*!/ ( . . >1449D9?>D85F1B9?ECB5C9<95>353?=@?>5>DC C8?G> 12?F5 1B5 9<<ECDB1D54 +85 49CBE@D9?> @B?69<5 B5@B5C5>DC D85 5F?<ED9?> 9> D9=5 ?6 D85 @5B6?B=1>35C ?6 D85 CICD5= 1>4 31> 25 1 F1<94 85<@ 6?B D85 =1>175=5>D ?6 2?D8 DB16693 1>4 5=5B75>395C > @1BD93E<1B 6?B DB16693 =1>175=5>D 9D 9C 9=@?BD1>D D? 3?>C945B D85 B54E>41>395C ?6 B?ED5C +85C5 31> ?665B 1<D5B>1D9F5C9>31C5?649CBE@D9?>?33EBB9>7D?1> 5<5=5>D ?6 D85 >5DG?B; +85 B5CE<D 9C D81D D85 CICD5=81C18978B5C9<95>35>?D?><I969D31>B5C9CD D?1>5F5>D2ED1<C?96D85B51B5@B?354EB5C1>4 @<1>C 9> @<135 1C D? =1>175 D85 DB16693 5>CEB9>7 1<D5B>1D9F5B?ED5C #1CD2ED>?D<51CDD851ED8?BC 3?>C945B 9D 5CC5>D91< D? 8978<978D ?>5 1C@53D ?6 B5C9<95>35 D81D 9C 6E>41=5>D1< D8B?E78?ED D85 @B?:53D@B5C5>D549>D89C@B?35549>7133?B49>7D? #9>;?F 5D 1<
(48) D85 1CC5CC=5>D ?6 D85 B5C9<95>35 ?6 D85 DB1>C@?BD >5DG?B; 1>4 9DC =1>175=5>D1B51G1I6?BD85CICD5=D?81>4<5 D85B5C94E1<B9C;D81D9C<56DE>=9D971D54 +85@B5C5>35?612?B45B9C16E>41=5>D1<1C@53D D?253?>C945B54G85>1CC5CC9>7D85B5C9<95>35?6. @ 1 DB1>C@?BD >5DG?B; 5C@5391<<I G85> 9>D5BC53DC =1>I @B9=1BI <9>;C 3?>>53D9>7 49665B5>D 3?E>DB95C +85 9CCE5C D81D >554 D? 25 D1;5> 9>D? 133?E>D 85B5 1B5 D85 49665B5>D 5=5B75>3I =1>175=5>D @B?354EB5C D85 49665B5>D DB16693 =1>175=5>D 1BB1>75=5>DC D85 <1>7E175C D538>931<9CCE5C1C6?B5H1=@<5D85@53E<91B9D95C ?6 >1D9?>1< B19< CICD5=C D81D @B5F5>D 9>D5B?@5B129<9DI +? 25DD5B E>45BCD1>4 D85 @B?2<5=C75>5B1D542I1<?CC?66E>3D9?>1<9DI?61 3B?CC2?B45B3?BB94?BD85)1CD1DD133945>D1>49DC 3?>C5AE5>D 9CCE5C 1B5 @B5C5>D54 25<?G +85 )1CD1DD 5F5>D ?33EBB54 9> D85 )89>5 -1<<5I N 5B=1>I9>
(49) 1<?>7D85"1B<CBE851C5<<9>5 G8938 9C @1BD ?6 D85 )89>5<@9>5 ?BB94?B 9> ?B1>75 9> 97
(50) 1>4 9D 9C ?>5 ?6 D85 EB?@51> 3B9D931< 9>6B1CDBE3DEB5C +85 <9>5 G1C 9>D5BBE@D54 16D5B D85 3?<<1@C5 ?6 D85 DE>>5< E>45B>51D8 D85 B19<G1I 31EC9>7 =?B5 D81> DG? 29<<9?> EB?C 53?>?=9341=1754E5D?1>9>D5BBE@D9?>?6=?B5 D81> 41IC?6D85B19<6B5978DDB166939> EB?@5 +858E751=?E>D?6B19<DB16693D85)89>5<@9>5 3?BB94?B<9>;C D1<ID?D85)E8BB579?>9> 5B=1>I 1>45>5<EH9>1449D9?>D?<9=9D541F19<129<9DI?6 1<D5B>1D9F5 B?ED5C 5H1C@5B1D54 D85 B19< DB16693 @B?2<5= $?B5?F5B C5F5B1< F5893<5C G5B5 >?D CE9D12<5D??@5B1D5?>D85B19<>5DG?B;?614:135>D 3?E>DB95C 1>4 4B9F5BC G9D8 <1>7E175 C;9<<C 1>4 D538>931< 3?=@5D5>35 D? BE> 1 DB19> 9> 1>?D85B 3?E>DBIG5B5>?D5>?E78 6D5BD85)1CD1DD5F5>D G8?C5 B5CE<D9>7 56653DC 9>F?<F54 C5F5B1< 3?E>DB95C D85 >554 D? D1;5 9>D? 133?E>D D85 49665B5>35C 9> D85 B57E<1D?BI 1>4 @B?354EB1< 1C@53DC ?6 D85 =1>175=5>D ?6 D85 5F5>DC 2I D85 3?E>DB95C 9>F?<F54 1B?C5 1<?>7C945 D85 >554 D? @<1>6?BC81B54=1>175=5>D@B13D935C1>4D??<C D?69>4C?<ED9?>CD81D?665B5>81>354B5C9<95>35 " " +85 * D )5C9<95>35 ?6 B?CC2?B45B B9D931< >6B1CDBE3DEB5C@B?:53D9C@1BD?6D85 >D5BB57- D1<I*G9DJ5B<1>4??@5B1D9?>'B?7B1==5
(51) G89383?>DB92ED5CD?13895F9>7D857?1<C?6 D85 EB?@5 *DB1D57I CE==1BIC855DG9D8 D85=19>@B?:53D9>6?B=1D9?>9CC8?G>9> 97 . #.'('#*!# +$!-+.. +-"#--'/'! (*$- ./-0!/0-#. !
(52)
(53)
(54)
(55) 5/ (' *, -/*#-.
(56) 2'.., -/*#-.
(57) '1'(-+/#!/'+*'-#!/+- /# '-#!/+- /#.
(58) + '('/3 *" - *.,+-/ +- /+-3 #, -/)#*/+$ * %#)#*/!+*+)'!. *"*"0./-' (*%'*##-'*%
(59) # "
(60)
(61) *'1#-.'/3+$,,('#" !'#*!#. *"-/.+$ +0/&#-* 2'/4#-( *" #, -/)#*/+$ #--'/+-3 +) -"' *$+-) /'! , +) -"' ! #!#) #- #!#) #- )+*/&.. %# %*%*"+-) /%+*+"/$!/,-+&! /.
(62) Proceedings of the 30th European Safety and Reliability Conference and the 15th Probabilistic Safety Assessment and Management Conference. . . . +85@B?:53D9CCDBE3DEB549>.?B;'13;175C .' 1>4 9DC @B?:53D 1B51 9>3<E45C )579?>5 #?=21B491 9> D1<I 1>4 1>D?> +939>? 9> *G9DJ5B<1>41C9<<ECDB1D549> 97 . . . . %# -! +"/$!*/!--!#/,-+&! / $! -! %* (0 !., -/ +" /$! */+* % %*+ %* 2%/5!-( * * , -/ +" !#%+*! +) - % %*/ (4. C1<B514I=5>D9?>549>D85@B5F9?EC@1B17B1@8C D85B51B5C5F5B1<9CCE5CB5<1D54D?D85@B5C5>35?6 D852?B45BD81D31>=1;5D85DB1>C@?BD>5DG?B;C =?B5 FE<>5B12<5 =?>7 D85C5 ?>5 ?6 D85 =?CD 6B5AE5>D 9C D85 49665B5>D ?669391< <1>7E175 1 @B?2<5= D81D 81C >?D 255> 144B5CC54 G9D89> D85 * D@B?:53D2531EC51<<@B?:53D@1BD>5BC2?D89> 1>D?>+939>?9>*G9DJ5B<1>41>4?63?EBC59> D1<IC@51; D1<91> %5F5BD85<5CC9D9C9=@?BD1>D D81D D85B5 9C E>1=297E?EC 1>4 @B539C5 D5B=9>?<?7I C81B54 2I 2?D8 >1D9?>C 9> ?B45B D? 6139<9D1D5 3?==E>931D9?> 25DG55> D85= ?G5F5B D85B5 1B5 CD9<< @B?2<5=C B5<1D54 D? 49665B5>D5=5B75>3I1>4DB16693=1>175=5>D<9;5 >?D ?G>9>7 C81B54 @<1>C 6?B :?9>D 5=5B75>3I =1>175=5>DG85B5@?CC92<5:?9>D9>D5BF5>D9?>2I D85@?<935?B?D85B1B=546?B35C6?B5H1=@<59C >?D@?CC92<5 >D89C3?>D5HDD85* D@B?:53D9C 19=541D9>3B51C9>7D85C81B9>7?6;>?G<54751>4 9>6?B=1D9?> ?> 3B?CC2?B45B 3B9D931< 9>6B1CDBE3DEB5C +89C 9C 9=@?BD1>D 9> =1>I C9DE1D9?>C5 7 9>D855F5>D?6@B?<?>7543<?CEB5 ?61=1:?BB?149>?>5?6D85DG?3?E>DB95CG8938 1<C? 16653DC D85 ?D85B +85 13895F5=5>D ?6 D85 ?2:53D9F5C 6?B5C55C D85 B51<9J1D9?> ?6 :?9>D =?>9D?B9>7 CICD5=C 1>4 3?==E>931D9?> @B?354EB5C25DG55>49665B5>DCE2:53DC9>381B75?6 D859B=1>175=5>D2?D89>?B49>1BI3?>49D9?>C1>4 6?<<?G9>7 B5<5F1>D 5F5>DC +85 =19> 5H@53D54 381>75 3?>35B>C D85 CDB5>7D85>9>7 ?6 :?9>D B9C; 7?F5B>1>3531@129<9D95CB5<1D54D?5F5>DCD81D=1I @1BD91<<I ?B D?D1<<I 41=175 D85 3?>D9>E9DI ?6 C5BF935 ?6 3B9D931< 3B?CC2?B45B DB1>C@?BD 9>6B1CDBE3DEB5C '1BD93E<1B1DD5>D9?>9C@194D?B?14 1>4 B19< 9>6B1CDBE3DEB5C +85C5 9> 613D B5@B5C5>D 9=@?BD1>D1>4CDB1D57933?BB94?BC6?BD85DB1>C@?BD ?6@5?@<51>47??4C +85D8B55=19>7?1<C31>25 CE==1B9J541C6?<<?GC •. >3B51C9>7 D85 3??@5B1D9?> ?6 D85 3B?CC 2?B45B 7?F5B>1>35 ?6 5F5>DC 2?D8 ?6 1>D8B?@93 1>4 >1DEB1< ?B979> G8938 16653D 3B9D931< 9>6B1CDBE3DEB5C +89C 9C 13895F54 2I. •. •. CDB5>7D85>9>7 D85 =?>9D?B9>7 31@139D95C 1>4 D85 9>6?B=1D9?> 6<?GC 25DG55> D85 CE2:53DC 9>F?<F54 *DB5>7D85>9>7 D85 :?9>D 31@129<9D95C D? =1>175 D85 3?>C5AE5>35C 9=@13DC ?6 D85 9>D5BBE@D9?> ?6 3B?CC2?B45B 3B9D931< 9>6B1CDBE3DEB5C -5B96I9>71>49=@B?F9>7D8556653D9F5>5CC?6 D85 3??@5B1D9?> CICD5= 6?B D85 =?>9D?B9>7 1>4 =1>175=5>D ?6 B5<5F1>D 5F5>DC 9> D85 3B?CC2?B45B1B51 . " +85CDBE3DEB5?6D85* D@B?:53D9C49F94549> @81C5C 1C C8?G> 9> 97 1>1<IC9C 9=@<5=5>D1D9?> 1>4 F1<941D9?> ?B 5138 @81C5 D85B5 1B5 49665B5>D 13D9F9D95C D81D 1<<?G D? ?2D19> D85?ED@EDC1>4B5CE<DC5H@53D54 .
(63)
(64) .
(65) . !
(66)
(67) .
(68)
(69) . # $.
(70)
(71)
(72) ! . ! . . # " $.
(73) % %# /-0 /0-!+"/$!/,-+&! /. ! >@81C5
(74) D85CDE4I1B511>4D859=@13D1B51?6 D85@B?:53D9<<ECDB1D549> 97 G5B54569>54 +85CDE4I1B519CD851B519>G8938D8581J1B4C D81D 31> 31EC5 @1BD91< ?B D?D1< 9>D5BBE@D9?> ?6 1 C53D9?>1B53?>C945B541>45F1<E1D54 >1449D9?> D85 CDE4I 1B51 3?>C945BC D85 3?>C5AE5>35C 9=@13DC?>D85>5DG?B;?681J1B4C .
(75) Proceedings of the 30th European Safety and Reliability Conference and the 15th Probabilistic Safety Assessment and Management Conference. @@ +859=@13D1B51<1B75BD81>D85CDE4I1B519C D85 ?>5 G85B5 D85 9=@13DC ?6 9>D5BBE@D9?>C 1B5 1>1<IJ54 +85 G?B;9>7 7B?E@ 81C :?9>D<I 945>D96954 D85 B?14 1>4 B19< 9>6B1CDBE3DEB5 61<<9>7 G9D89> D85 @B?:53D 1B51 EC9>7 &$)')& 31BD?7B1@8I 1>4
(76)
(77) % '& $ %'#) %$ -()# D??<C 6?B 41D1 1>1<IC9C 97 C8?GC 9> B54 D85 B?14 >5DG?B;3?>C945B549>D85* D@B?:53D9>2<E5D85 B19<G1I>5DG?B;1>48978<978DCD85CDE4I1B519> ?B1>751>4D859=@13D1B519>F9?<5D +85B?14 >5DG?B; 9>3<E45C 49665B5>D <5F5<C =19><I 8978G1IC1>4CD1D5B?14C2EDD85B51B51<C?C?=5 @B?F9>391<1>4=E>939@1<B?14C . . %#
(78) *-! %.-!,-!.!*/! /$!-+ *!/2+-' +*.% !-! %*/$! /,-+&! /%* (0!/$!- %(2 4*!/2+-' $!,-+ !..%*# / 2 .) !0.%*#/++(.. +85 5HD5>D ?6 D85 9=@13D 1B51 9C >?D CI==5DB931<G9D8B5C@53DD?D85CDE4I1B51G8938 9C <?31D54 >51B D85 2?B45B 25DG55> D1<I 1>4 *G9DJ5B<1>4 +859=@13D1B515HD5>4C>?BD8D?D85 39DI?60EB9381>4C?ED8D?$9<1> +89C9C4E5D? D85@B5C5>35?6D85<@CG8938=1;5CD85*G9CC B?141>4B19<>5DG?B;<5CC45>C5D81>D85 D1<91> ?>5 C B5CE<D ?6 C5F5B1< 49C3ECC9?>C 1=?>7 D85 @B?:53D@1BD>5BC$9<1>1>40EB9381B5C55>1CDG? 4539C9?>1<@?9>DCG85B59D9C@?CC92<5D?E>45BD1;5 1>4 9=@<5=5>D =1>175=5>D CDB1D5795C 6?B 1<D5B>1D9F5B?ED5C @1D8C EBD85B=?B5D85G?B;9>77B?E@945>D96954D85 3B9D931< C53D9?>C ?6 D85 B?14 1>4 B19< >5DG?B; B5@B5C5>D549> 97 +85 )"%$"-( ( 9C 1 D538>9AE5 D81D 1<<?GC D? 1>1<IJ5 D85 2581F9?B?61G8?<5>5DG?B;6?<<?G9>71>5F5>D D81D =1I 3?>35B> ?>5 ?B =?B5 >?45C ?6 D85 >5DG?B; '5DB5>: 1>4 +BE33?
(79) +85 ?ED@ED ?6 D85 1<<?GC D? 945>D96I D85 =?CD 3B9D931< C53D9?>C9>D5B=C?6CICD5=93FE<>5B129<9DI?6D85 >5DG?B; ?> G8938 D? @5B6?B= =?B5 45D19<54 1>1<IC5C 1>4 5F1<E1D9?>C +85 CICD5=93. @ FE<>5B129<9DI B5@B5C5>DC D85 7<?21< 56653DC ?> 1 DB1>C@?BD >5DG?B; 31EC54 2I 1 B5<5F1>D 5F5>D 3?>C945B9>7 D85 9>D5B45@5>45>395C G9D89> D85 5<5=5>DC?6D85>5DG?B; +85<1CD13D9F9DI?6@81C5
(80) 9CD851>1<IC9C1>4 945>D96931D9?> ?6 81J1B4C D81D =1I 16653D D85 @B?:53D B?14 1>4 B19< >5DG?B; +85 81J1B4C 1>1<IJ549>D85CDE4I1B51=1I81F531EC5C9>C945 ?B ?EDC945 D85 DB1>C@?BD CICD5= > D85 69BCD 31C5 D85I 451< G9D8 D538>931< 619<EB5C 1>4 133945>DC 1>D8B?@93 ?B979> 9> D85 C53?>4 D85I 3?>35B> 14F5BC5 G51D85B 3?>49D9?>C ?B >1DEB1< 49C1CD5BC $1DDCC?> 1>4 !5>5<9EC
(81) +89C 13D9F9DI 6?B5C55C D81D D85 45D19<54 1>1<IC9C 9C 31BB954 ?ED 5H3<EC9F5<I?>D853B9D931<C53D9?>C945>D96954G9D8 D85133?B49>7D?D85CICD5=93FE<>5B129<9DI &>35 D85 5<5=5>DC D81D G?E<4 CD?@ D85 >?B=1< ?@5B1D9?> ?6 D85 >5DG?B; 1B5 945>D96954 9D 9C >535CC1BID?1>1<IJ5D853?>>53D5481J1B4C2?D8 1>D8B?@931>4>1DEB1< *DE4I9>7 D85 133945>DC 9> D85 <1CD I51BC G1C >535CC1BID?5F1<E1D5D851>D8B?@9381J1B49>B?14 DB1>C@?BD9>?B45BD?4569>5D85=?CD6B5AE5>DDI@5 ?6133945>D1>4D8561D1<?>5C +89C9CD8569BCDCD5@ D? 4569>5 D85 B5<5F1>D 5F5>DC 1>4 1>1<IJ5 D85 3?>C5AE5>35C <??;9>7 1D 2?D8 5=5B75>3I 1>4 DB16693 =1>175=5>D *?=5 1ED8?BC 81F5 CDE4954 D85 9CCE5 ?6 FE<>5B129<9DI 9> B?14 DB1>C@?BD <9;5 09?5D1< >D85C5G?B;CD851ED8?BCCD1D5 D81D D85 FE<>5B129<9DI ?6 1 B?14 C53D9?> 31> 25 5CD9=1D54 EC9>7 C?=5 9>4931D?BC 45@5>49>7 ?> B?14133945>DC1>4?D85B:1==9>731EC5CD85B?14 <9>;C1B53?>C5AE5>D<IB1>;54133?B49>7D?D859B 3?>DB92ED9?>D?D85<?CC?6C165DI?6D855>D9B5B?14 >5DG?B; > 97 D85B59C1>5H1=@<5?61
(82) B?143B1C8=1@9>D851B51?6D85 D1<I*G9DJ5B<1>4 3ECD?=C>51BD8539D95C?6?=?1>4891CC? +85 41D1G5B5@B?F94542I *++ . . %# 3/- /+" - .$) ,%*/$!./0 4 -! *! -/$! +- !-*4!((+2/$! -! .2%/$/$!(+2!-*0) !-+"-+ - .$!. #- 0 ((4 -'!*%*# . /$! *0) !- +" -+ - .$!. %* -! .!.. +89C DI@5 ?6 1>1<IC9C 9C EC56E< D? 945>D96I D85 2<13;C@?DC1>46?B5H1=@<5D?E>45BCD1>496D85 C@1D91<49CDB92ED9?>?6D85B?14133945>DC31>31EC5 @B?2<5=C 9> DB16693 6<?G ?B 5=5B75>3I =1>175=5>D9>2?D83?E>DB95C D9C9=@?BD1>DD?.
(83) Proceedings of the 30th European Safety and Reliability Conference and the 15th Probabilistic Safety Assessment and Management Conference. 4569>5D85D9=5?63<?CEB5?B<?G?@5B1D9?><5F5< ?6 D85 >5DG?B; C53D9?> 31EC54 2I D85 49665B5>D 5F5>DC9>?B45BD?@<1>D8525CDB5C@?>C5 $?B5?F5BD851ED8?BC3?>C945B549D9=@?BD1>D D?144B5CCD85@B?2<5=CD81D1B9C56B?=5=5B75>3I =1>175=5>DCE381CD859>D5BF5>D9?>?6B5C3E59> 31C5 ?6 >554 .9D8 B565B5>35 D? D85 5=5B75>3I =1>175=5>DC5F5B1<CDE495C81F5451<DG9D8D85 <?31D9?> ?6 B5C3E5 6139<9D95C *?=5 G?B;C 1B181>95D1<
(84) &G5>1>41C;9>
(85) Q189> 1>4 *KB1< 81F5 1@@B?13854 D85 @B?2<5= 1>4 @B?@?C54 =5D8?4C ?6 ?@D9=9C1D9?> 6?BD85<?31D9?>?6CDBE3DEB5C &D85BG?B;C5F5> =?B5 C@539693 1>1<IC5 D85 1335CC929<9DI ?6 D85 B19<G1I >5DG?B; 2I B5C3E5BC EC9>7 D85 B?14 >5DG?B; 9> 31C5 ?6 1 B5<5F1>D 5F5>D 3?>C945B9>7 C@539693 1335CC @?9>DC?B785DD9 1>4 $1<1F1C9
(86) 11>4?B785DD91>4$1<1F1C9
(87) 2 *9=9<1B<ID?D851>D8B?@9381J1B4CD851>1<IC9C ?6D857B1F9D1D9?>1<>1DEB1<81J1B4C 5DJ>5B5D1<
(88) 5 7 <1>4C<945CB?3;61<<C452B9C6<?GC1>4 6<??4C D81D 9=@13D ?> D85 B19<G1I 1>4 B?14 >5DG?B;C 9C =19><I 21C54 ?> D85 <1>4C<945C 9>F5>D?BI1>481J1B4=1@C?62?D81>D?>+939>? 1>4)579?>5#?=21B491 ?G5F5B9D1<C?4B1GC 9>6?B=1D9?> 6B?= D85 89CD?B931< 41D1 CE38 1C D85 >E=25B?65F5>DC?33EBB54?>1@1BD93E<1BC53D9?> D859BC5F5B9DI1>4D851CC?391D54B5DEB>@5B9?4 97 C8?GC 1> 5HDB13D ?6 1 * =1@ ?6 D85 CDE4I 1B51 9>3<E49>7 D85 <1>4C<945 9>F5>D?BI 41D1C5D 6?B G8938 5138 @?9>D B5@B5C5>DC 1> 89CD?B931< 5F5>D ?B 1 6EBD85B 1>1<IC9C ?6 D85 C35>1B9?G51CCE=5D81DD85=?B5C5F5B51>5F5>D 9C4E5D?>1DEB1<81J1B4CD8529775BD859=@13D?> D85>5DG?B;G9<<251>4<?>75BD85B5CE<D9>7D9=5 ?6B53?F5BI . %#3/- /+" ) ,%*/$!./0 4 -! !/2!!*!(% ! * 0# *+ */+* % %*+2%/5!-( * $! -! %. ""! /! 4-+ '" ((.! $,+%*/ +--!.,+* ./+ *$%./+-% (!1!*//$ / $ *%), /+*/$!/- *.,+-/*!/2+-'. . +85<1>4C<945C9>F5>D?BI=1@C1B5D85B5CE<D?6 45D19<54CDE495C@5B6?B=54?F5B1<?>7@5B9?4?6 D9=5 $?B5B535>D<ID8541D1G5B59=@<5=5>D54 EC9>7 9>>?F1D9F5 =5D8?4C 6?B 75?=?B@8?<?7931< 1>4>1DEB1<81J1B4=1@@9>7 +85C51B54979D1< CD5B5?C3?@93 @8?D?7B1==5DBI 1>4 1>1<IC9C ?6 $ )"" ) -$) ) &')*' ' $)' '%#)'- 41D1 9> ?B45B D? AE1>D96I D85 49C@<135=5>DC F5<?39D95C ?6 7B?E>4 C@1D91< 5<5=5>DC =2B?C9 1>4 *31@?JJ1
(89) +85 <1CD=5>D9?>54 =5D8?4 G9<< 1<C? 25 EC56E< D? @5B6?B= D85 49B53D =?>9D?B9>7 ?6 D85 CD129<9DI ?6 D85 9>6B1CDBE3DEB5C D85=C5<F5C 1>4 G9<< 25 1@@<9312<5 6?B D85 6EBD85B 9=@B?F9>7 ?6 D85 =?>9D?B9>7>5DG?B; +85 1>1<IC9C ?6 ?D85B >1DEB1< 81J1B4C CE38 1C 6?B5CD 69B5C 9C 21C54 ?> D85 3141CD5B ?6 D85 1B51C 16653D542I@1CD5F5>DC1CG5<<1C5>F9B?>=5>D1< 1>4D?@?7B1@8931<@1B1=5D5BC5 7 5H@?CEB5C?9< =?9CDEB5 DI@5 ?6 F575D1D9?> 5<5F1D9?> 5D3 ?>545B1 5D 1<
(90) .85B51C D85 1>1<IC9C ?6 D85 =5D5?B?<?7931< 81J1B4C 3?>C945BC CD1D9CD93C 9CCE546B?=89CD?B931<B579?>1<41D1C5DC?65HDB5=5 G51D85B5F5>DC5 7 CD?B=C5HDB5=5B19>61<<5D3 &D85BCDE495C81F5144B5CC54D852581F9?B?61 DB1>C@?BD>5DG?B;2I3?>C945B9>7D85@5B6?B=1>35 ?62B9475C6?<<?G9>751BD8AE1;5C9?>49>95D1< +85 9>D57B1D9?> ?6 D85 5<12?B1D54 41D1 6?B 1>D8B?@93 1>4 >1DEB1< 81J1B4C G9<< 5>12<5 D? 5F1<E1D5D85FE<>5B129<9DI?6D85CDE4954>5DG?B; +85 19= 1D D85 5>4 ?6 D85 1>1<IC9C @81C5 9C D? 4569>5 C35>1B9?C B5<1D54 D? D85 D?D1< ?B @1BD91< 9>D5BBE@D9?>?61>9>6B1CDBE3DEB5C53D9?>1>4D?9DC FE<>5B129<9DI 138 C35>1B9? 9C 1CC?391D54 D? 1 C@53969381J1B41>431>25381B13D5B9J549>D5B=C ?6B5C?EB35C>55454?BB5C@?>C531@139DI +85C53?>4@81C5?6D85@B?:53D9>F?<F5C69BCD?6 1<<D851>1<IC9C?6D85C35>1B9?C945>D969549>@81C5
(91) G9D8 B565B5>35 D? D85 3B9D931< C53D9?>C ?6 D85 >5DG?B; >@1BD93E<1B9D9C9>D5>454D?1CC5CCD85 3?@9>7 31@139DI 9> C35>1B9? =1>175=5>D 3?>C945B9>7 D1<91> 1>4 *G9CC B5C?EB35C > D89C C5>C55=5B75>3I@<1>C<?79CD931>41335CC929<9DI ?6 B5C3E5 1>4 DB16693 =1>175=5>D @<1>C 5 7 B5B?ED9>7 1B5 5F1<E1D54 C 61B 1C 5=5B75>3I @<1>C 1B5 3?>35B>54 D85 13D9F9DI 6?B5C55C D85 =1@@9>7 ?> D85 D5BB9D?BI ?6 D85 B5C?EB35C >535CC1BI 6?B C35>1B9? =1>175=5>D +85 B5C?EB35C3?>35B>F5893<5C=5>1>45AE9@=5>D ?B 5H1=@<5 9> D85 31C5 ?6 1> 133945>D G9D8 41>75B?EC 7??4C 9D 9C >535CC1BI D? =1@ D85 C@5391<9J54 D51=C 12<5 D? 9>D5BF5>5 1>4 B5C?<F5 D85 5F5>D )% 85=931< 9?<?7931< )149?<?7931<%E3<51B,>9D +85>5HDCD5@9CD? 1>1<IJ5D851335CC929<9DI?6B5C3E5BC?>D85C53D9?> G85B5 D85 C35>1B9? ?33EBC ?B785DD9 5D 1< 9> @B5CC .9D8 B565B5>35 D? DB16693 =1>175=5>D @<1>C =1>175=5>D =51CEB5C 1B5 945>D96954 1>4.
(92) Proceedings of the 30th European Safety and Reliability Conference and the 15th Probabilistic Safety Assessment and Management Conference. @@ 1>1<IJ54 +85C531>25D85CD?B175?6851FI7??4C F5893<5C 1<?>7 D85 31BB9175G1I ?B 9> C@539693 B5CD @1B;1B51C1>4F912<51<D5B>1D9F5B?ED5C 97 C8?GC 1 DB1>C@?BD >5DG?B; G85B5 D85 3<?C54 3B9D931< C53D9?> 9C 8978<978D54 9> B54 $?B5?F5B G5?2C5BF5D85=1@@9>7?6D8B556139<9D95C12<5D? 9>D5BF5>5 D? 6135 D85 C35>1B9? ?> D85 3B9D931< C53D9?> ?B51386139<9DID85B?ED5C381B13D5B9J54 2ID85=9>9=E=DB1F5<D9=5D?B5138D85C53D9?> 1B5 45D5B=9>54 > 97 DG? 1<D5B>1D9F5 B?ED5C D81D31>25EC549>31C5?61>5F5>DD81D9>D5BBE@DC D853B9D931<C53D9?>1B51<C?C8?G> . @ CDB1D5795CB571B49>79>D5BF5>D9?>=5D8?4C 97
(93) 9<<ECDB1D5C D85 6E>3D9?>1< 1B389D53DEB5 ?6 D85 + '<1D6?B= . .
(94) .
(95) .
(96)
(97)
(98)
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
(100) >D89CG1I9D9C@?CC92<5D?=?>9D?BD85 5F?<ED9?> ?6 1 3B9D931< C9DE1D9?> D81D 3?E<4 3?=@B?=9C5 D85 @B?@5B ?@5B1D9?> ?6 1 3B?CC 2?B45BB?14?BB19<9>6B1CDBE3DEB5 +85 +@<1D6?B=81CD85=19>7?1<?6C81B9>7 9>6?B=1D9?> 1>4 41D1 25DG55> 3B9D931< 9>6B1CDBE3DEB5?@5B1D?BC1>469BCDB5C@?>45BC +85 @<1D6?B= 9C 3?>697EB54 1C 1 ( %$ *&&%') -()# 12<5 D? @B?35CC 1>4 49C@<1I 9>6?B=1D9?>?>D85B51<D9=5?@5B1D9?>?6D85B?14 1>4B19<>5DG?B;9>D85CDE4I1B51 >D89CG1I9D 9C@?CC92<5D?7E1B1>D553?==E>931D9?>25DG55> D1<91>1>4*G9CCCE2:53DC9>?B45BD?14?@DC81B54. .
(101) .
(102)
(103)
(104)
(105)
(106)
(107)
(108)
(109)
(110)
(111) . . .
(112) .
(113) . %#0* /%+* ( - $%/! /0-!+"/$! ( /"+-).
(114) +856?3EC?6@81C59C1D5CD?6D85 +@<1D6?B= D1;9>79>D?133?E>D1B5<5F1>D5F5>DD81D9>F?<F5C 2?D8 D1<I1>4*G9DJ5B<1>4 6D5B D85 945>D96931D9?> ?6 D85 3B9D931< 9>6B1CDBE3DEB5C ?@5B1D?BC 69BCD B5C@?>45BC 1>4 CD1;58?<45BC D85 13D9F9DI 9C D? 8978<978D D85 CDB5>7D8C1>4G51;>5CC5C?6D85CICD5=9>?B45B D? 9=@B?F5 D85 3?<<12?B1D9?> 1>4 3??@5B1D9?> 1=?>7D859>F?<F54CE2:53D6B?=2?D83?E>DB95C #! ! +89C@1@5B9<<ECDB1D5C1>445C3B925CD851@@B?138 ?6D85* D@B?:53DD81D9C@1BD?6D85 >D5BB57- D1<I*G9DJ5B<1>4
(115) +85=19>7?1<?6 D85@B?:53D9CD?45F5<?@1>?@5B1D9?>1<=?45<6?B D85 =1>175=5>D ?6 3B?CC2?B45B 3B9D931< 9>6B1CDBE3DEB5C G9D8 @1BD93E<1B 6?3EC D? B?14 1>4 B19< >5DG?B;C > 9=@?BD1>D 1C@53D 3?>35B>C D85 496693E<DI ?6 3?<<53D9>7 81B=?>9J9>7 1>4 @B?35CC9>741D125DG55>D85DG?3?E>DB95C EBD85B=?B5 D85 >554 D? 4569>5 E>96?B= 1>4 C81B54 =5D8?4C 6?B D85 6?<<?GE@ ?6 D85 @B?:53D 13D9F9D95C9C8978<978D54 +85@B?@?C54=?45<31> 25 3?>C945B54 1 ( %$ *&&%') -()# 6?B D85 =1>175=5>D ?6 B5<5F1>D 5F5>DC D81D =1I 81F59=@13DC?>D85DG?3?E>DB95C $ " +85G?B;@B5C5>D549>D89C@1@5BG1C45F5<?@54 G9D89> D85 * D 'B?:53D 1> >D5BB57 'B?:53D 3? 6E>454 2I EB?@51> )579?>1< 5F5<?@=5>D E>4 +89C 69>1>391< CE@@?BD 9C 7B1D56E<<I 13;>?G<54754 >1449D9?>D851ED8?BCD81>;D85 @B?:53DD51=5C@5391<<ID85+5BB9D?BI5@1BD=5>D ?61>D?>+939>?'?<9J911>D?>1<5?6+939>?1>4 )579?>5#?=21B4916?B@B?F949>7D8541D1 .
(116) Proceedings of the 30th European Safety and Reliability Conference and the 15th Probabilistic Safety Assessment and Management Conference.
(117) ! =2B?C9 *31@?JJ1
(118) =@B?F5=5>DC 9>4979D1<=1@@9>76?B75?=?B@8?<?7931< 1>4 (E1D5B>1BI 75?<?7931< 31BD?7B1@8I 5?7B1@8931 5<F5D931
(119)
(120)
(121) 5B4931 " > 9>DB?4E3D9?> D? B?14 FE<>5B129<9DI.81D81C255>4?>59C4?>51>4 C8?E<4254?>5 +B1>C@?BD'?<93I
(122)
(123)
(124) ?B785DD9 '5DB5>: +BE33?' 1<12B5C5- '?>D9 $ $1B389?>>9 9> @B5CC $E<D9 <5F5<@@B?138D?CC5CC9>7D85)5C9<95>35?6 )?14 %5DG?B; >6B1CDBE3DEB5 >D5B>1D9?>1< !?EB>1<?6B9D931< >6B1CDBE3DEB5C ?B785DD9 $1<1F1C9
(125) 1 )?14 1335CC929<9DI =?45< D? D85 B19< >5DG?B; 9> 5=5B75>3I 3?>49D9?>C !?EB>1< ?6 )19< +B1>C@?BD '<1>>9>7 1>4 $1>175=5>D ?B785DD9 $1<1F1C9
(126) 2 -E<>5B129<9DI 1>4 1335CC929<9DI ?6 ?@5> B19< B?ED5C 6?B 5=5B75>3IB5C3E5 >757>5B91 5BB?F91B91 BE>51E$ 81>7* 7E389) + #55 &)?EB;5+ )59>8?B> $ -?> .9>D5B65<4D 6B1=5G?B; D? AE1>D9D1D9F5<I1CC5CC1>45>81>35D85C59C=93 B5C9<95>35 ?6 3?==E>9D95C 1BD8AE1;5 *@53DB1 1@1339 # 9?>49>9 +9D9 #965D9=5 C59C=93 B5C9<95>35 ?6 179>7 2B9475C 1>4 B?14 >5DG?B;C *DBE3DEB5 1>4 >6B1CDBE3DEB5 >79>55B9>7
(127) 1B<C?> # 1665>45> ! 1CC5DD ) E58B9>7 ?<<9>C. ! ?<71$ * '5D9D '89<<9@C ! -5B>5B ) .89D695<4 )
(128) )5C9<95>35 +85?BI 1>4 @@<931D9?> B7?>>5 %1D9?>1< #12?B1D?BI ?2EB> . *@5>35) ! * '?=?>9C
(129) -E<>5B129<9DI 1>4 )9C; CC5CC=5>D C53?>4 54 ,%' 9C1CD5B $1>175=5>D +B19>9>7 'B?7B1==5 ?85>
(130) .81D =1;5C 3B9D931< 9>6B1CDBE3DEB5C 3B9D931< >D5B>1D9?>1< !?EB>1< ?6B9D931< >6B1CDBE3DEB5'B?D53D9?> ?>545B1 $ "B52C ' -1<5C5 ?331 *38E>; $5>J5< -139; 1>5 !1@5<: $EB9 )93?DD1 &<9F5B9 * '5JJ1DD9
(131) 81B13D5B9J9>7 <@9>5 @IB?75?7B1@8I 6B?= 69B5 CD1D9CD93C @@<954 5?7B1@8I 5E2<59> $ )?D8 .9<<9 >1CD1CC914?E " 5B75B81EC5>,
(132) #9>;9>7C395>35 D? @B13D935 1 @B17=1D93 1@@B?138 6?B D85 1CC5CC=5>D ?6 =51CEB5C D? 9=@B?F5 D85 B5C9<95>35 ?6 DB1>C@?BD1D9?> 9>6B1CDBE3DEB5 CICD5=C 'B?35549>7C ?6 D85 D8 EB?@51> *165DI1>4)5<9129<9DI?>65B5>35
(133)
(134)
(135) EB?@51> ?==9CC9?>
(136) )57E<1D9?> , %?
(137)
(138)
(139) ?6D85 EB?@51>'1B<91=5>D1>4 ?6D85?E>39<?6
(140)
(141) 535=25B
(142) ?>,>9?>. 7E945<9>5C 6?B D85 45F5<?@=5>D ?6 D85 DB1>C EB?@51> DB1>C@?BD >5DG?B; 1>4 B5@51<9>7 539C9?> %?
(143)
(144) , +5HD G9D8 B5<5F1>35 1B181>9 ) 0 *D51495*5969 $ C71B9 %
(145) $E<D9@<5 3B9D5B91 6139<9DI <?31D9?> @B?2<5=C CEBF5I @@<954 $1D85=1D931< $?45<<9>7
(146)
(147) B1>39C ) 5;5B1
(148) =5DB93 1>4 6B1=5G?B;C 6?B B5C9<95>35 1>1<IC9C ?6 5>79>55B54 1>4 9>6B1CDBE3DEB5 CICD5=C )5<9129<9DI >79>55B9>7 1>4 *ICD5= *165DI
(149) 1>9> "9DC1;$ $1B385C5 "59C<5B! $ *5175B+ #9>;?F
(150) )5C9<95>35 1>4 5669395>3I 9> DB1>C@?BD1D9?> >5DG?B;C *395>354F1>35C
(151) 5DJ>5B $ ED859<">?@@"9B38G1<4 "B59=5B "9B38=59B E25B$
(152) B1F9D1D9?>1< >1DEB1< 81J1B4C -1<E9>7 D85 @B?D53D9F5 6E>3D9?> ?6 <@9>5 6?B5CDC ?B5CD '?<93I1>4 3?>?=93C
(153)
(154) 19=5C / / &> D85 4569>9D9?> ?6 B5C9<95>359>CICD5=C )9C;>1<IC9C
(155) #9>;?F ?H#5>D )514 # <<5> ) B>?DD ! 5<<9>9 .??4C
(156) +95B541@@B?138D?B5C9<95>351CC5CC=5>D )9C; >1<IC9C
(157)
(158) $1DDCC?># !5>5<9EC
(159) -E<>5B129<9DI1>4 B5C9<95>35?6DB1>C@?BDCICD5=C49C3ECC9?> ?6 B535>D B5C51B38 +B1>C@?BD1D9?> )5C51B38 '1BD'?<93I1>4'B13D935
(160) %1> *1>C1F9>9
(161) AE1>D9D1D9F5 =5D8?4 6?B 1CC5CC9>7 B5C9<95>35 ?6 9>D5B45@5>45>D 9>6B1CDBE3DEB5C )5<9129<9DI >79>55B9>7*ICD5=*165DI &G5> * 1C;9> $ *
(162) *DB1D5793 6139<9DI<?31D9?>B5F95G EB?@51>!?EB>1< ?6&@5B1D9?>1<)5C51B38 '5DB5>: +BE33? '
(163) *9=E<1D9?>21C54 381B13D5B9J1D9?> ?6 3B9D931< 9>6B1CDBE3DEB5 CICD5= B5C9<95>35 >D5B>1D9?>1< !?EB>1< ?6 B9D931< >6B1CDBE3DEB5C )57791>9
(164) %5DG?B; B5C9<95>35 6?B DB1>C@?BD C53EB9DI *?=5 =5D8?4?<?7931< 3?>C945B1D9?>C +B1>C@?BD'?<93I Q189> *KB1< B5F95G ?6 895B1B38931< 6139<9DI <?31D9?> =?45<C ?=@ED5BC 1>4 &@5B1D9?>C )5C51B38
(165)
(166) 09? *1>C1F9>9 $1:1) $1B389?>>9 >1>1<ID931<1@@B?138D?D85C165DI?6 B?14 >5DG?B;C >D5B>1D9?>1< !?EB>1< ?6 )5<9129<9DI (E1<9DI 1>4 *165DI >79>55B9>7 .
(167)
Documenti correlati
The model provides support to the engineer for: identifying homogeneous portions of a linear of levees, to evaluate the performance of structures for different failure mechanisms and
Hence, in the present study, the pharmacokinetic dispo- sition, faecal excretion and anthelmintic efficacy of two different formulations (paste and granule) of PYR pamoate are
Peptide- functionalized liposomes show a clear advantage in compari- son to pure DOPC liposomes with regard to drug internaliza- tion in both HT29 and TE671 tumor cells: FACS
Effects of addition of flaxseed to diets of laying hens on some production characteristics, levels of yolk and serum cholesterol, and fatty acid composition of yolk..
With the help of Tables 2 and 3 and Figures 1 and 2, we summarize the results for the different discount factors. For 0 < δ < 1/3 the sum of the incumbent’s capacity and of
In this study, two years of field spectroscopy measure- ments acquired with an automatic spectral system (Meroni et al., 2011) on a subalpine grassland equipped with an EC tower
In particular, there are five subontologies for the stratigraphic unit catalogue record: “registry” (which contains identifiers and formal issues concerning the location, the
In altre parole, un ente ecclesiastico civilmente riconosciuto potrebbe fiscalmente transitare di volta in volta dalla qualifica di “non commercialità” a quella
