Supplementary Materials for
Calorie restriction in humans inhibits the PI3K/AKT pathway and induces a younger transcription profile
Evi M. Mercken,
1†Seth D. Crosby,
2†Dudley W. Lamming,
3,4,5Lellean JeBailey,
6Susan Krzysik- Walker,
7Dennis Villareal,
8Miriam Capri,
9,10Claudio Franceschi,
9,10Yongqing Zhang,
11Kevin Becker,
11David M. Sabatini,
3,4,5Rafael de Cabo,
1*Luigi Fontana
8,12,13*†
These authors contributed equally to this research.
*
Corresponding authors: lfontana@dom.wustl.edu (L.F.); decabora@grc.nia.nih.gov (R.D).
This pdf file includes:
Fig. S1
Tables S1 to S5
Table S1. Z-scores of the top 100 pathways significantly changed by either WD or CR.
PathwayName
(Zscore) WD:Y
(Zscore) CR:WD STRIATED_MUSCLE_CONTRACTION -18.83 27.60
IGF_VS_PDGF_UP -18.05 26.23
MYOD_BRG1_UP -14.35 22.87
ELECTRON_TRANSPORT_CHAIN -12.21 17.48
RIBOSOMAL_PROTEINS -10.38 9.08
MOOTHA_VOXPHOS -9.82 15.61
MYOD_NIH3T3_UP -7.99 14.11
HUMAN_MITODB_6_2002 -7.15 15.69
VENTRICLES_UP -6.93 14.27
OXIDATIVE_PHOSPHORYLATION -6.56 10.45
MITOCHONDRIA -6.16 14.19
MUSCLE_MYOSIN -5.95 8.11
ROME_INSULIN_2F_UP -5.06 8.42
GLYCOLYSIS_AND_GLUCONEOGENESIS -4.64 7.43
PGC -3.44 9.33
NADLER_OBESITY_DN 5.16 -7.47
FLECHNER_KIDNEY_TRANSPLANT_WELL_UP 5.19 -8.99
VEGF_MMMEC_ALL_UP 5.39 -7.32
DIAB_NEPH_DN 5.84 -7.71
TAKEDA_NUP8_HOXA9_10D_DN 5.95 -8.11
TNFALPHA_TGZ_ADIP_DN 5.96 -8.58
TGZ_ADIP_UP 6.01 -9.09
ROS_MOUSE_AORTA_DN 6.05 -7.29
JNK_DN 6.16 -7.28
LEE_E2F1_UP 6.26 -8.36
CARIES_PULP_HIGH_UP 6.26 -8.93
MANALO_HYPOXIA_UP 6.34 -8.23
YAO_P4_KO_VS_WT_UP 6.37 -7.32
TAKEDA_NUP8_HOXA9_8D_UP 6.38 -7.71
CMV_HCMV_TIMECOURSE_24HRS_DN 6.39 -8.58
TGFBETA_EARLY_UP 6.40 -7.77
LEE_ACOX1_UP 6.41 -7.27
ZHANG_EFT_EWSFLI1_UP 6.41 -8.94
ADIPOCYTE_PPARG_UP 6.57 -8.97
TNFALPHA_ADIP_DN 6.57 -9.56
TAKEDA_NUP8_HOXA9_8D_DN 6.58 -8.13
VERHAAK_AML_NPM1_MUT_VS_WT_UP 6.64 -8.63
ADIP_VS_PREADIP_UP 6.82 -8.30
ALZHEIMERS_INCIPIENT_UP 6.88 -7.24
RADAEVA_IFNA_UP 6.93 -8.11
HOHENKIRK_MONOCYTE_DEND_UP 7.00 -9.04
HOHENKIRK_MONOCYTE_DEND_DN 7.02 -7.88
YAGI_AML_PROG_FAB 7.07 -7.76
LEE_MYC_E2F1_UP 7.10 -8.54
HTERT_DN 7.15 -8.77
TAKEDA_NUP8_HOXA9_3D_UP 7.16 -7.66
LINDSTEDT_DEND_DN 7.21 -8.14
HSC_LATEPROGENITORS_ADULT 7.24 -5.90
DIAB_NEPH_UP 7.32 -6.81
BYSTRYKH_HSC_TRANS_GLOCUS 7.36 -3.97
SANA_IFNG_ENDOTHELIAL_UP 7.42 -7.41
ADIP_DIFF_UP 7.43 -10.30
REOVIRUS_HEK293_DN 7.46 -4.85
AGEING_BRAIN_UP 7.49 -8.58
PENG_GLUTAMINE_UP 7.52 -3.98
LEE_DENA_UP 7.52 -8.82
HSIAO_LIVER_SPECIFIC_GENES 7.56 -6.97
TARTE_PC 7.59 -7.57
BRCA_ER_POS 7.61 -4.91
VERHAAK_AML_NPM1_MUT_VS_WT_DN 7.72 -6.83
IRITANI_ADPROX_VASC 7.72 -6.89
SERUM_FIBROBLAST_CORE_DN 7.72 -6.14
JECHLINGER_EMT_UP 7.75 -8.41
NFKB_TARGET_REFERENCE 7.80 -8.10
GILDEA_BLADDER_UP 7.91 -8.77
TGFBETA_ALL_UP 7.91 -9.15
EMT_UP 7.93 -8.52
CMV_24HRS_DN 7.94 -10.10
APPEL_IMATINIB_UP 8.04 -7.69
HSC_HSCANDPROGENITORS_FETAL 8.06 -5.47
HSC_HSCANDPROGENITORS_SHARED 8.06 -5.47
CMV_ALL_DN 8.10 -10.42
HSC_HSCANDPROGENITORS_ADULT 8.15 -5.46
ADIPOGENESIS_HMSC_CLASS3_UP 8.22 -9.87
STEMCELL_NEURAL_UP 8.37 -5.22
LI_FETAL_VS_WT_KIDNEY_UP 8.46 -9.91
RUTELLA_HEPATGFSNDCS_UP 8.49 -10.05
DAC_PANC_UP 8.59 -8.66
BAF57_BT549_UP 8.66 -10.73
ELONGINA_KO_UP 8.87 -8.29
SANSOM_APC_5_DN 8.94 -6.79
BROWN_GRAN_MONO_DIFFERENTIATION 8.98 -10.42
NADLER_OBESITY_UP 9.45 -10.67
LEE_TCELLS2_UP 9.52 -8.69
ATRIA_UP 9.55 -10.65
ICHIBA_GVHD 9.82 -10.05
POD1_KO_DN 10.06 -11.80
LEI_MYB_REGULATED_GENES 10.09 -9.18
WIELAND_HEPATITIS_B_INDUCED 10.14 -10.92
FLECHNER_KIDNEY_TRANSPLANT_REJECTION_UP 10.91 -12.93
AGEING_KIDNEY_SPECIFIC_UP 10.92 -11.38
CARIES_PULP_UP 11.47 -14.15
IGLESIAS_E2FMINUS_UP 11.47 -16.27
BRCA_ER_NEG 12.07 -12.19
STEMCELL_HEMATOPOIETIC_UP 12.42 -8.13
RUTELLA_HEMATOGFSNDCS_DIFF 12.98 -14.16
ALZHEIMERS_DISEASE_UP 13.62 -9.64
BOQUEST_CD31PLUS_VS_CD31MINUS_DN 14.72 -18.13 BOQUEST_CD31PLUS_VS_CD31MINUS_UP 16.89 -19.97
AGEING_KIDNEY_UP 18.29 -19.24
Table S2
. RT-qPCR/QuantiGene based assay validation of micro-array dataZ ratio (Array) Fold change (qRT-PCR/quantiGene) CR:WD
HUMAN
CR:AL RAT
CR:WD HUMAN
CR:AL RAT
HSPB6 2.11 6.24 1.32 -1.13
MID1IP1 2.57 6.00 2.24 2.21
TPI1 3.82 4.46 2.21 1.24
ATP5G1 4.64 4.18 3.24 1.06
PKM2 3.94 4.26 3.86 -2.04
NFIX 1.50 4.22 -1.16 1.27
PPARGC1A 3.94 3.83 3.75 2.45
SCN3B 1.51 3.65 2.04 5.29
PTPN3 4.10 3.61 4.10 -
TMEM43 -2.32 -2.64 -2.69 -1.30
DDX39 -1.65 -3.33 -2.08 -2.10
BCAP31 -3.11 -3.44 -4.23 -4.90
SAT1 -4.37 -4.21 -6.99 -1.19
TMEM140 -1.57 -4.83 -2.02 -1.96
LCP1 -3.60 -5.04 -4.54 -2.20
ACSL4 -2.15 -5.60 1.33 -2.12
RUNX1 -1.62 -6.58 -1.08 -2.40
TUBB6 -3.66 -9.66 -8.40 -6.74
RNA from vastus lateralis muscle samples from human on CR versus Western diet (WD) and
vastus lateralis muscle from AL versus 40% CR-fed rat were characterized by Quantigene or
qPCR, respectively. Targets were selected based on the micro-array data which are shown for
comparison. Note that numbers reflect statistical confidence and do not relate directly to fold-
change. The fold changes marked in red did not match the Z-scores of the micro-array data.
Table S3
. Z-scores of common pathways between humans and rats.HUMAN RAT
PathwayName (MSigDB) Zscore
CR:WD
Zscore CR:AL
STRIATED_MUSCLE_CONTRACTION 34.49 23.15
IGF_VS_PDGF_UP 32.43 10.44
HUMAN_MITODB_6_2002 22.23 5.05
ELECTRON_TRANSPORT_CHAIN 21.74 12.50
VENTRICLES_UP 20.26 6.63
MITOCHONDRIA 20.21 4.65
MOOTHA_VOXPHOS 19.38 12.72
PGC 14.34 7.39
RIBOSOMAL_PROTEINS 14.03 3.77
OXIDATIVE_PHOSPHORYLATION 12.96 8.42
GLYCOLYSIS_AND_GLUCONEOGENESIS 9.59 9.44
KREBS_TCA_CYCLE 8.78 7.65
TCA 8.66 6.29
HIPPOCAMPUS_DEVELOPMENT_POSTNATAL 8.47 7.21
UBIQUINONE_BIOSYNTHESIS 8.34 6.71
GAY_YY1_UP 7.75 4.73
ETCPATHWAY 7.65 6.38
KREBPATHWAY 7.50 3.43
PGC1APATHWAY 7.24 3.36
UVB_NHEK1_C1 5.59 3.09
CITRATE_CYCLE_TCA_CYCLE 5.32 5.11
IDX_TSA_UP_CLUSTER5 4.73 3.45
NO2IL12PATHWAY -1.68 -1.79
STAT3PATHWAY -1.74 -1.99
CHEMICALPATHWAY -2.01 -2.42
PLCDPATHWAY -2.10 -1.61
IDX_TSA_DN_CLUSTER6 -2.13 -2.19
NKCELLSPATHWAY -2.70 -1.88
IL22BPPATHWAY -2.75 -2.27
IFNGPATHWAY -3.10 -1.95
AMINOSUGARS_METABOLISM -3.12 -1.83
GOLDRATH_CYTOLYTIC -3.14 -2.71
HOFMANN_MANTEL_LYMPHOMA_VS_LYMPH_NODES_
UP
-3.34 -2.18
SANSOM_APC_LOSS5_UP -3.50 -4.09
ZHAN_MMPC_EARLYVS -3.57 -1.90
TUMOR_SUPRESSOR -3.58 -2.53
BECKER_IFN_INDUCIBLE_SUBSET_1 -3.60 -3.97
IFN_GAMMA_UP -3.64 -2.30
UVC_TTD_ALL_DN -3.67 -2.43
TCYTOTOXICPATHWAY -3.72 -1.65
GALE_FLT3ANDAPL_UP -3.86 -3.21
HIVNEFPATHWAY -3.90 -3.83
UVC_XPCS_8HR_DN -4.00 -3.63
VANTVEER_BREAST_OUTCOME_GOOD_VS_POOR_DN -4.02 -2.45
HSC_MATURE_SHARED -4.05 -2.82
GH_GHRHR_KO_24HRS_UP -4.06 -2.50
UVC_XPCS_ALL_DN -4.06 -3.35
ZHAN_MMPC_SIMAL -4.40 -4.12
TFF2_KO_UP -4.51 -1.84
TPA_SENS_LATE_DN -4.56 -2.64
ZHAN_MM_MOLECULAR_CLASSI_DN -4.58 -2.13
LINDSTEDT_DEND_UP -4.59 -3.99
HSC_LATEPROGENITORS_FETAL -4.70 -4.54
DAC_IFN_BLADDER_UP -4.77 -3.27
APOPTOSIS -4.80 -3.30
COMPLEMENT_ACTIVATION_CLASSICAL -4.91 -2.23
ROSS_MLL_FUSION -4.91 -4.54
IFN_ALL_UP -5.01 -3.03
VANASSE_BCL2_TARGETS -5.22 -3.77
HSC_LATEPROGENITORS_SHARED -5.27 -4.84
STEMCELL_HEMATOPOIETIC_UP -5.28 -5.61
BRENTANI_DEATH -5.38 -3.66
IFNALPHA_NL_HCC_UP -5.44 -2.33
UVB_NHEK2_DN -5.44 -3.36
AGED_MOUSE_CEREBELLUM_UP -5.48 -4.21
HSC_MATURE_ADULT -5.48 -3.16
CLASSICPATHWAY -5.50 -2.23
HSC_LATEPROGENITORS_ADULT -5.51 -4.99
CELLCYCLEPATHWAY -5.53 -3.19
YAGI_AML_PROGNOSIS -5.68 -2.15
OKUMURA_MC_LPS -5.75 -3.83
HINATA_NFKB_UP -5.85 -5.31
KNUDSEN_PMNS_DN -5.88 -2.76
IFNALPHA_HCC_UP -6.01 -2.27
GRANDVAUX_IFN_NOT_IRF3_UP -6.10 -2.84
IFNALPHA_NL_UP -6.12 -2.20
CROMER_HYPOPHARYNGEAL_MET_VS_NON_UP -6.54 -2.85
BASSO_GERMINAL_CENTER_CD40_UP -6.56 -3.08
BLEO_HUMAN_LYMPH_HIGH_24HRS_UP -7.09 -3.75
SANSOM_APC_5_DN -7.69 -4.06
SANA_TNFA_ENDOTHELIAL_UP -7.81 -4.13
LEE_TCELLS2_UP -7.92 -2.75
RADAEVA_IFNA_UP -8.34 -2.91
AGEING_BRAIN_UP -8.62 -3.08
SANA_IFNG_ENDOTHELIAL_UP -8.80 -3.03
CARIES_PULP_HIGH_UP -10.97 -4.29
RUTELLA_HEPATGFSNDCS_UP -11.07 -2.86
WIELAND_HEPATITIS_B_INDUCED -11.52 -6.39
ICHIBA_GVHD -11.94 -6.37
BRCA_ER_NEG -12.14 -6.75
FLECHNER_KIDNEY_TRANSPLANT_REJECTION_UP -13.50 -6.30
RUTELLA_HEMATOGFSNDCS_DIFF -14.35 -5.26
CARIES_PULP_UP -15.61 -4.91
Table S4. Z-scores of 3 central pathways altered by CR between humans and rats.
The table lists pathways involved in insulin growth factor 1 (IGF-1) signaling (green), mitochondrial function (braun) and inflammation (blue).
HUMAN RAT
PathwayName (MSigDB) Zscore CR:WD Zscore CR:AL
IGF_VS_PDGF_UP 32.43 10.44
GH_GHRHR_KO_24HRS_UP -4.06 -2.50
ELECTRON_TRANSPORT_CHAIN 21.74 12.50
MITOCHONDRIA 20.21 4.65
MOOTHA_VOXPHOS 19.38 12.72
HUMAN_MITODB_6_2002 22.23 5.04
PGC 14.34 7.39
OXIDATIVE_PHOSPHORYLATION 12.96 8.42
GLYCOLYSIS_AND_GLUCONEOGENESIS 9.59 9.44
KREBS_TCA_CYCLE 8.78 7.65
TCA 8.66 6.29
UBIQUINONE_BIOSYNTHESIS 8.34 6.71
ETCPATHWAY 7.65 6.38
KREBPATHWAY 7.50 3.43
PGC1APATHWAY 7.24 3.36
CITRATE_CYCLE_TCA_CYCLE 5.32 5.11
IFNALPHA_NL_UP -6.12 -2.20
IFNALPHA_HCC_UP -6.01 -2.27
CLASSICPATHWAY -5.50 -2.23
IFNALPHA_NL_HCC_UP -5.44 -2.33
IFN_ALL_UP -5.01 -3.03
IFN_GAMMA_UP -3.64 -2.30
IFNGPATHWAY -3.10 -1.95
IL22BPPATHWAY -2.75 -2.27
STAT3PATHWAY -1.74 -1.99
NKCELLSPATHWAY -2.70 -1.88
LEE_TCELLS2_UP -7.92 -2.75
Table S5. Primer sequences and probe set region used for quantitative PCR analysis or Quantigene based assays
Rats Humans
Gene Accession number Sense - Antisense Probe Set Region HSPB6 NM_144617 CGTGCTTCAGCTCCTTTACC
CATCCAGCAGCACAGAAAAA
287-792
MID1IP1 NM_021242 CCCCTCTCTTTCCTCCAAAC TTCCCACCAACAGAGTAGGC
854-1356
TPI1 NM_000365 CCTGCATTGGGGAGAAGTTA GTACTTCCTGGGCCTGTTGA
280-790
ATP5G1 NM_005175 AAAAATGCAGACCACGAAGG ACTTGGCTGCTGTGTCAATG
146-620
PKM2 NM_182470 CCTATCCATTAGGCCAGCAA TTTCCAATCCTGCATTCCTC
1828-2419
NFIX NM_002501 CGACGACAGTGAGATGGAGA GCAGAAGTCCAGCTTTCCTG
728-1171
PPARGC1A NM_013261 ATGTGTCGCCTTCTTGCTCT ATCTACTGCCTGGGGACCTT
379-826
SCN3B NM_001040151 CTGAAGGACCTCCTGTGAGC CCGTAAGCGATTTCTGAAGC
416-818
PTPN3 NM_002829 ACCTGCCTGTTTACCCACTG CAGTGACCAGCATCTCTGGA
1739-2303
TMEM43 NM_024334 GAAAGCCTTTGCCTTCTGTG GCTTCACTCCAGCTTTTTGG
395-897
DDX39 NM_005804 TGAGCGCTTCTCGAAGTACA GCTGTTCCAGCATCTTGTCA
910-1348
BCAP31 NM_005745 TTTTCCTTGCTGCTGTCCTT ACTCCCAACATCCAACTTGC
654-1103
SAT1 NM_002970 AAAGGCACTGTCTTGCCACT GTGGCTGGACGGATCTTAAA
221-807
TMEM140 NM_018295 CAGCAGACAGAACCCACTGA TGACACTTTGCCAAGACAGC
535-1162
LCP1 NM_002298 ATACCCTGCCTTGCACAAAC AGCTTGGGGTATGGAGGTCT
282-736
ACSL4 NM_203436 CAAACTGAAGGCGGCATTAT GCTTGAGTTTTCTGGCTTGG
534-1067
RUNX1 NM_001754 ACTAAGCGGCCAGTTGCTAA GGACTCGGATCTTCTGCAAG
399-909
TUBB6 NM_032525 AATAGGGGCCGTAAGATGCT TGTATGGCCCCGTACTTAGC
1250-1784
GAPDH NM_008084.2 AGACAGCCGCATCTTCTT TGATGGCAACAATGTCCACT
-
HPRT1 NM_000194 - 102-646
ACTB NM_001101 - 1164-1762