REGIONAL BRAIN METABOLISM OF FOUR SPONTANEOUS MURINE
MUTATIONS WITH DEGENERATION OF THE CEREBELLAR CORTEX
Robert Lalonde
Universit´e de Rouen, Facult´e de M´edecine et de Pharmacie, INSERM U614, 76183 Rouen, Cedex France and CHUM/St-Luc, Neuroscience Research Center, Montreal, Canada
Catherine Strazielle
Universit´e Henri Poincar´e, Nancy I, Laboratoire de Pathologie Mol´eculaire et Cellulaire en Nutrition, INSERM U724, and Service de Microscopie Electronique, Facult´e de M´edecine, 54500 Vandoeuvre-les-Nancy France
Abstract
Four spontaneous mutations with cerebellar atrophy exhibit ataxia and deficits in motor coordination tasks requiring balance and equilibrium. These mutants were compared to their respective controls for regional brain metabolism assessed by histochemical staining of the mitochondrial enzyme, cytochrome oxidase (CO).
The enzymatic activity of Grid2
Lc, Grid2
ho, Rora
sg, and Reln
r lmutants was altered in cerebellum and cerebellar-related pathways at brainstem, midbrain, and telencephalic levels. The CO activity changes in cerebellar cortex and deep cerebellar nuclei as well as some cerebellar-related regions were linearly corre- lated with motor performance in stationary beam and rotorod tasks of Grid2
Lc, Rora
sg, and Reln
r lmutants.
These results indicate that in addition to its relation to neural activity, CO staining can be used as a predictor of motor capacity.
Keywords: cerebellum, motor control, equilibrium, cytochrome oxidase
1. Introduction
Spontaneous murine mutations with developmental defects causing degeneration of the cerebellar cor- tex have been known for many years (Lalonde and Strazielle 1999). But only recently have genes been identified, namely Grid2
Lc(Lurcher), Grid2
ho(hot- foot), Rora
sg(staggerer), and Reln
r l(reeler). The cere- bellar mutants exhibit cerebellar ataxia (wide-spread gait) and motor coordination deficits in tasks requir- ing balance and equilibrium.
2. Neuropathology in Cerebellar Mutant Mice
The neuropathology of the semi-dominant Lurcher (allele symbol: Lc) mutation (Grid2
Lc) is caused by a gain-in-malfunction of Grid2 located on chromo- some 6. This gene encodes an ionotropic glutamate receptor (GluRδ2) functionally related with AMPA receptors (Landsend et al. 1997) and predominantly expressed in cerebellar Purkinje cells (Zuo et al. 1997).
115
While homozygous (Grid2
Lc/Grid2
Lc) mutants cannot survive beyond the first postnatal day because of defective suckling caused by brainstem damage (Cheng and Heintz 1997; Resibois et al. 1997), het- erozygous (Grid2
Lc/-) mutants have been tested for motor control and shown to be deficient during de- velopmental (Thullier et al. 1997) and adult (Lalonde and Strazielle 1999) periods. The increased perme- ability of the mutated GluRδ2 channel to calcium (Wollmuth et al. 2000) may be responsible for the nearly complete degeneration of Purkinje cells occur- ring from the second to the fourth postnatal week (Caddy and Biscoe 1979). The massive degeneration of granule cells is attributed to the loss of the trophic influence exerted by Purkinje cells (Vogel et al. 1991).
In a similar fashion, the 60 to 75% decrease in the number of inferior olive cells (Caddy and Biscoe 1979;
Heckroth and Eisenman 1991) and the 30% decrease in the number of deep cerebellar nuclei (Heckroth 1994) appear to be secondary consequences of Purk- inje cell atrophy.
Two recessive hot-foot (allele symbol: ho) mutations (4-J and Nancy) cause different deletions of the cod- ing sequences of the Grid2 gene (Lalouette et al. 1998, 2001). At least for the 4-J allele, the truncated GluRδ2 protein was expressed in the soma of Purkinje cells but without transport to the cell surface (Matsuda and Yuzaki 2002). In an opposite manner to Grid2
Lc, the encoded protein appears non-functional, as the neu- ropathological and behavioral phenotypes of Grid2
homutants were similar to those of targeted Grid2 null mutants (Kashiwabuchi et al. 1995). The Grid2
homutants are characterized by defective innervation of Purkinje cells by parallel fibers and by a mild loss of cerebellar granule cells (Guastavino et al. 1990).
The Grid2
homodel has been bred with Grid2
Lcto obtain the double Grid2
ho/Lcmutant (Selimi et al. 2003). The type of cerebellar atrophy seen in Grid2
ho/Lcdouble mutants is more similar to Grid2
Lc/+than Grid2
ho/ho, but during development, Purkinje cell number was lower in the double mutant than in the single Grid2
Lc/+mutant.
The recessive Rora
sgmutation causes a deletion of the Rora gene situated on chromosome 9, encoding the retinoid-like nuclear receptor involved in neuronal differentiation and maturation, particularly expressed in Purkinje cells (Hamilton et al. 1996; Nakagawa et al. 1997). The retinoid-like protein appears non- functional, as the neuropathological and behavioral phenotypes of Rora
sgwere similar to those of Rora null mutants (Steinmayr et al. 1998). The Purkinje cell number of Rora
sgmutants declined on embry- onic day 14 and reached 25% of normal values at the end of the first postnatal month (Herrup and Mullen
1979). Thus, the Purkinje cell loss begins at an earlier stage of development but is less complete than Grid2
Lc(Caddy and Biscoe 1979). The remaining Purkinje cells in Rora
sgmutants were reduced in size, ectopically positioned, and lacked the tertiary dendritic spines re- ceiving synaptic contacts from parallel fibers (Sotelo 1975). The secondary degeneration of granule cells oc- curred soon after their migration (Herrup 1983) and was nearly complete by the end of the first postnatal month (Landis and Sidman, 1978). Unlike Grid2
Lcand Grid2
homutants, the massive degeneration of the cerebellar cortex makes the molecular and granule cell layers difficult to distinguish. Although deep cerebellar nuclei were present in normal numbers, their volume was reduced in Rora
sgmutants (Roffler-Tarlov and Herrup 1981). Presumably because of Purkinje cell loss, the number of inferior olive neurons decreased by 60% on postnatal day 24 (Shojaeian et al. 1985a) and remained lower than normal in adults (Blatt and Eisenman 1985a).
The autosomal recessive Reln
r lmutation causes a disruption of the Reln gene, located on chromosome 5 (Beckers et al. 1994; D’Arcangelo et al. 1995). This gene encodes an extracellular matrix protein involved in neural adhesion and migration at critical stages of development (Beckers et al. 1994; D’Arcangelo et al. 1995, 1999; Hack et al. 2002; Trommsdorff et al. 1999). The Reln
r lmutant displays abnormal ar- chitectonic organization and cell ectopias, but with preserved anatomical connections in cerebellum, in- ferior olive, hippocampus, and neocortex (Mariani et al. 1977; Stanfield and Cowan 1979; Goffinet 1983; Blatt and Eisenman 1988; Heckroth et al. 1989;
Terashima et al. 1986). The principal cerebellar cell type depleted by the mutation is the granule cell pop- ulation. The Purkinje cell loss reached approximately 50%, the remaining Purkinje cells being malposi- tionned and grouped in a central mass (Heckroth et al.
1989). Presumably as a consequence of the Purkinje cell deficit, the number of inferior olive cells dimin- ished by 20% (Blatt and Eisenman 1985b; Shojaeian et al. 1985b). Despite ectopic positioning, the zonal pattern of climbing fiber projections was maintained (Blatt and Eisenman 1988), but with Purkinje cells abnormally innervated by more than one climbing fiber, as found with other dysgranular cerebellar mu- tants such as Rora
sg(Mariani 1982; Mariani et al.
1977).
3. Motor Coordination Deficits of Cerebellar Mutant Mice
The main measure used for testing motor coordina-
tion in mice is the time elapsed before falling from
TABLE 1. Regional brain variations of cytochrome oxidase activity in cerebellum of Grid2
Lc(Lc), Grid2
ho(ho), Rora
sg(sg), and Reln
r l(rl ) mutants
Brain region Lc ho sg rl
Cortex
-molecular nc ↑ nc nc
-Purkinje depl nc depl ↑
-granular nc nc depl nc
Deep nuclei
-fastigial ↑ nc ↑ nc
-interpositus ↑ nc ↑ ↓*
-dentate ↑ nc ↑ ↓*
↓ decreased, ↑ increased, nc not changed, depl = too severily depleted or not disso- ciable from other layers, *measured as a single region designated “roof nuclei”
TABLE 2. Variations of cytochrome oxidase activity in
cerebellar-related pathways of Grid2
Lc(Lc), Grid2
ho(ho), Rora
sg(sg), and Reln
r l(rl ) mutants
Brain regions Lc ho sg rl
Neocortex
-primary motor nc nc nc ↑↓*
-eye field nc ↑ nc nc
Thalamus
-ventrolateral ↑ ↑ nc nc
-ventromedial nc nc nc nc
-dorsomedial nc nc ↓ nc
-lateral geniculate nc nc ↓ ↑
-midline nc ↑ ↓ nc
Red nucleus ↑ nc ↑ nc
Interpeduncular ↑ nc ↑ nc
Dorsal raphe ↑ nc nc nc
Vestibular nuclei
-medial nc nc ↑ nc
-lateral ↑ nc ↑ nc
Pontine nuclei
-medial nc nc nc ↑
-lateral nc nc nc nc
Inferior olive ↓ nc nc nc
↓ decreased, ↑ increased, nc not changed, *dependent on cell layer