• Non ci sono risultati.

IL FONDAMENTO ESTETICO DEL PENSIERO DI STANLEY CAVELL. Tesi di: Francesco Frisari. Tutor: Ch. mo Prof. Luigi Russo. Co-tutor: Ch. mo Prof.

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Condividi "IL FONDAMENTO ESTETICO DEL PENSIERO DI STANLEY CAVELL. Tesi di: Francesco Frisari. Tutor: Ch. mo Prof. Luigi Russo. Co-tutor: Ch. mo Prof."

Copied!
367
0
0

Testo completo

(1)

Università degli Studi di Palermo

Dipartimento di Filosofia, Storia e Critica dei Saperi Dottorato di ricerca in Estetica e Teoria delle arti – XXII ciclo

Settore scientifico disciplinare: M-Fil/04 Coordinatore: Prof. Luigi Russo

I

L FONDAMENTO ESTETICO DEL PENSIERO DI

S

TANLEY

C

AVELL

.

Tesi di: Francesco Frisari

Tutor: Ch. mo Prof. Luigi Russo

Co-tutor: Ch. mo Prof. Calì

(2)

!

!

!

!

!

!

"#$%&'(#!)#*+'**',%#!

'%!*&-*.-!/#..#!&%!0,-.-/.#!

)1-!*#*!023!+',-!!

)1-!+-&!4,'((-*.&!+&!/-!/.-//#5!

! 6*.#*&*!6,.'2+7!!"#$%&'()#*+&(*'($%(8!!

!

!

(3)

! "!

!

#$%&'(!

!

!

!"#$%&'()%"*+ ,+

!

-./)#%0%+!!

1$2%3*"#.()%")4+#*5#)+*+/%55)6)0)#7+&*00.+8)0%5%8).+)"+9#."0*:+-.;*00+

!

#$)*+%,-&+$(! ""!

!"#"$%&$'(()*++,*$-./-0'1.$'11'$),21.//,*&.$2,1*/*2,+'#$ "3!

!"#4$5'$+,)+*1'),-6$7.1$-./-*$2,1*/*2,+*$+*8.$+*&7,9,*&.$7.11'$/0'$+*8().&/,*&.$.$

'(.)-0)'#$ 4:!

!4#"$5;.10/,*&.$7.11;')<*8.&-'9,*&.$-)'7,9,*&'1.$,&$=,--<.&/-.,&$.$>'?.11#$ @A!

!4#4$%&;'1-)'$2*)8'$7,$+),-,+'B$),(*)-').$1.$(')*1.$'1$1*)*$,8(,.<*$*)7,&'),*#$ @C!

!4#@$5;')<*8.&-'9,*&.$-)'7,9,*&'1.$.$,$/0*,$),/+D,$/+.--,+,#$ :E!

!@#"$F1$+'8G,*$7,$,88'<,&.$+*8.$&0*?*$8*7.11*$7,$+),-,+'B$1'$),/(*/-'$7,$

=,--<.&/-.,&$'7$H<*/-,&*#$ E@!

!@#4$5;'(().&7,8.&-*$1,&<0,/-,+*$I$,&/+),--*$&.11'$&*/-)'$2*)8'$7,$?,-'#$ 34!

!@#@$J%&;,88'<,&.$+,$-.&.?'$(),<,*&,.),KB$/,'8*$1,8,-'-,$'1$1,&<0'<<,*L$&*&$7'1$

1,&<0'<<,*#$ 3C!

!:#"$F1$-./-*$2,1*/*2,+*$.$,1$(')'7*//*$7.11'$+,)+*1'),-6B$1'$1.--0)'$.$1'$+),-,+'$+*8.$

)./(*&/'G,1,-6$(.)$,1$()*(),*$7,/+*)/*#$ C:!

!:#4$5;./-.-,+'$M,--<.&/-.,&,'&'$7.11;'2*),/8'$.$1;')<*8.&-'9,*&.$2*)8'1.#$ NE!

!:#@$5*$/+*&-)*$.$1'$).1'9,*&.$2)'$1;*)7,&'),*$.$,1$1.--.)'),*#$ O:!

!:#:$5.$P,+.)+D.$Q,1*/*2,+D.$+*8.$*(.)'$7;')-.B$'1G08$.$2)'88.&-*#$ "A"$

!

(4)

! .!

!

!

-./)#%0%+!!!

<5*3/0.$)#74+)33.2)".()%"*+*&+*5/$*55)%"*+

!

#$)*+%,-&+$(! "".!

!"#"$F1$(')'7*//*$/01$/.<0,).$0&'$).<*1'$&.11'$1.--0)'$7,$R),(S.$ ""3!

!"#4$5.$70.$,88'<,&,$7.1$1,&<0'<<,*$)01.T<*?.)&.7#$ "44!

!"#@$F1$<,*+*$1,&<0,/-,+*$+*8.$8.//'$,&$U0./-,*&.$7.11;,7.'$7,$).<*1'#$ "4N!

!4#"$>*/'$/,'8*$7,/(*/-,$'$2').V$5'$),709,*&.$7.1$&*)8'-,?*$'1$$&*)8'1.$ "@C!

!4#4#$5'$/*109,*&.$+*80&,-'),/-'$'1$(')'7*//*$7.1$/.<0,).$0&'$).<*1'#$ ":E!

!4#@$5'$&*/-)'$2*)8'$7,$?,-'$&'-0)'1.$.$+01-0)'1.#$ "EE!

!4#:$JF1$(.)&*$7.1$&*/-)*$).'1.$G,/*<&*KB$1'$2*)8'$7,$?,-'$2)'$).+0(.)*$.$

-)'/2,<0)'9,*&.#$ "3@!

!@#"$F$G,&'),$'11;,&2,&,-*$7.1$1,&<0'<<,*$)01.$<*?.)&.7#$ "CA!

!@#4$5'$2,1*/*2,'$+*8.$,&7'<,&.$+),-.),'1.$/0,$2'--,$8*1-*$<.&.)'1,$7.11'$&*/-)'$

&'-0)'#$ "NA!

!@#@$F$+),-.),$+*8.$'(.)-0)'$'$0&'$).1'9,*&.$&*&$+*&*/+,-,?'L$8'$./().//,?'$.7$

./-.-,+'L$+*&$,1$8*&7*$ "NC!

!@#:$5*$/+.--,+*$.$1'$20<'$7'11;*)7,&'),*$ "OC!

!:#"$F$+1',8$-*$+*880&,-W$.$1.$().-./.$7.11;./().//,*&.#$ 4A4!

!:#4$JX0./-*$I$/.8(1,+.8.&-.$+,Y$+D.$2'++,*KB$1'$7,8.&/,*&.$/*<<.--,?'$'1$2*&7*$

7.11;./'0),8.&-*$7.11.$)'<,*&,#$ 4""!

!:#@$5;'2*),/-,+*$+*8.$,&+*&-)*$2)'$1;./.8(1'),-6$./().//,?'$.$1*$/+.--,+,/8*#$ 4"C$

!

+ +

!

(5)

! /!

-./)#%0%+!!!!

=.+5/*>)8)>)#7+*+0.+$)0*;."(.+*5#*#)>.+&*00.+8)0%5%8).+&)++9#."0*:+-.;*00+

!

#$)*+%,-&+$(! ./"!

!"#"$5'$8'-),+.$S'&-,'&'$7.11;./-.-,+'$7,$>'?.11$ 4@3!

!"#4$$F1$)'((*)-*$2)'$.(,/-.8*1*<,'L$2,1*/*2,'$.7$./-.-,+'$,&$R'&-$.$>'?.11$ 4:A!

!"#@$5.$Z()*(*)9,*&,[$.$1;,88'<,&.$7.11.$).<*1.$,&$R'&-$.$=,--<.&/-.,&$ 4:E!

!"#:$F1$(),&+,(,*$$7.11'$2'+*1-6$7,$<,07,9,*B$,1$/.&/*$+*80&.$.$1'$2*)8'$7,$?,-'$

&'-0)'1.$.$+01-0)'1.$ 4E3!

!4#"$5'$+*&7,?,/,G,1,-6$7.1$/.&-,8.&-*$+*8.$(),&+,(,*$.8,&.&-.8.&-.$./-.-,+*#43@!

!4#4$5'$?*+.$0&,?.)/'1.$$S'&-,'&'$+*8.$8*7.11*$7.1$+1',8$-*$+*880&,-W$

./().//,?*$ 43C!

!@#"$5;./.8(1'),-6$./-.-,+'$2)'$R'&-$.$=,--<.&/-.,&#$ 4C@!

!@#4$\.<0,).$1'$).<*1'$.$/.<0,).$1;./.8(,*B$1'$+*&7,9,*&.$()*70--,?'$7.11;./-.-,+'$

2)'$).<*1.L$./.8(,$.$+),-.),#$ 4CN!

!:#"$F$('//,*&'-.$0--.)'&+./B$,1$+*8(1.-'8.&-*$./-.-,+*$(.)$1'$2,1*/*2,'$7.1$

1,&<0'<<,*$*)7,&'),*$7,$H0/-,&#$ 4O"!

!:#4$H0/-,&$.$,$(.)2*)8'-,?,B$+*&20-').$1;,88'<,&.$7.1$1,&<0'<<,*$/*1*$+*&/-'-,?*$

+*8.$'(.)-0)'$8'&+'-'$'11;./-.-,+*#$ 4O4!

!:#@$]1,$'--,$1,&<0,/-,+,$(.)1*+0-*),$.$,$('//,*&'-.$0--.)'&+./$+*8.$2*&7*$

./().//,?*$.7$./-.-,+*$7.1$1,&<0'<<,*#$ @A3!

!E#"$F$1.<'8,$./.8(1'),$2)'$,1$(.&/,.)*$7,$^D*8'/$R0D&$.$U0.11*$7,$\-'&1.W$>'?.11#

$ @"@!

!E#4$>*80&,-6$.$,&-.)/*<<.--,?,-6$2)'$2,1*/*2,'$7.11'$/+,.&9'$.7$./-.-,+'$ @"E!

!E#@$F1$(')'7,<8'$2)'$./.8(,*$.$).<*1'B$+*80&,-6$.$2*)8'$7,$?,-'$./-.-,+'#$ @43!

$

-%">0'5)%")+!

!"#$%&'$-.*),'$7.11;./().//,*&.#$ @@C!

!#4$5'$+),-,+'$2,1*/*2,+'$.$1'$+),-,+'$7;')-.#$ @:A!

$

(6)

! 0!

$

_F_5F`]PHQFH$ @:C!

+

+

+

+

+

+

+

+

+

+

+

+

+

+

+

+

+

(7)

! 1!

!"#$%&'()%"*+

5'$),/+*(.)-'$7.11;./-.-,+'$,&$\-'&1.W$>'?.11$

+

23+4(*5! '&$6,5$)($$57(! %&! 8)5$7(9! :5;(77! <5! 5;,)+! 75! '545'&)=! %&! 5$%5*(!

+7)*(! &7! >+7+! 5?@&)+! A&7+>+A&'+B! %5! ',&! 4,*(! 4*+;&($(! (! ',&! *&)+*$5! &$! +C$&!

45>>+B!(%!D!>)5)5!7())5!(!*('(4&)5!%5!'*&)&'&!%35*)(B!6,57(!5%!(>(?4&+!E&'<5(7!

F*&(%"B!4+()&!'+?(!G5;&%!H$)&$.!(!:<5*7(>!I(*$>)(&$/B!(!4&J!&$!C($(*57(!%5!

?+7)&!>),%&+>&!(!)(+*&'&!%(775!7())(*5),*5B!%(7!'&$(?5!(!%(775!?,>&'5B!'<(!&$!

57',$&! '5>&! <5$$+! )($)5)+! %&! %(>,?(*$(! ,$5! ;(*5! (! 4*+4*&+! ?()+%+7+C&5!

'*&)&'5!)57(!%5!4+)(*!%5*!;&)5!5!%(C7&!5,)+$+?&!'5?4&!%3&$%5C&$(0K!#$!5?@&)+!

>)*())5?($)(!A&7+>+A&'+!&!>,+&!75;+*&!<5$$+!5;,)+!57)*())5$)+!>(C,&)+B!>+$+!

&$A5))&! +CC())+! %&! )*5))5-&+$(! (! %&@5))&)+! )5$)+! A*5! C7&! (>4(*)&! %&!

L&))C($>)(&$1B! ;(*+! (! 4*+4*&+! '($)*+! %&! ),))(! 7(! >,(! (75@+*5-&+$&B! 6,5$)+!

$(7735?@&)+! %(775! A&7+>+A&5! ?+*57(MB! %(775! >)+*&5! %(77(! &%((N! (!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

"!F*&(%B!EK!a.b$='11L$=,--<.&/-.,&L$'&7$-D.$c?.)W7'WB!&$!:*&)&'57!#$6,&*9B!O+7K!//P!Q+!/B!.RRNB!

44K!0S1T1.M!!

.!H$)&$B!GK!^D.$\-)'&<.)$'-$-D.$d**)B!U($*(B!"SVN$

/!I(*$>)(&$B!:K!>*&-.&-e/$7).'8B$.//'W/L$"OCET"ON:B!Q+*)<W(>)(*$!X$&;(*>&)9!Y*(>>B!.RR"!!

0!'A*K!G5,@(*B!ZKB![+>)B!LK!\(%>K]!`)7,&')W$5'&<0'<.$>),-,+,/8K!5,-.)')W$^D,&S,&<$'2-.)$>'?.11$

'2-.)$=,--<.&/-.,&!B!Q+*)<W(>)(*$!X$&;(*>&)9!Y*(>>B!^;5$>)+$!.RR/P!_(5%B!_KB!U++%($+,C<B!

[K!\(%>K]!Q,18$H/$fD,1*/*(DW#$c//'W/$,&$>,&.8'$H2-.)$=,--<.&/-.,&$'&7$>'?.11B!Y57C*5;(!

E5'?&775$B!Q(W!`+*a!.RR1K!^$)*5?@&!6,(>)&!)(>)&!'(*'5$+!%&!>)5@&7&*(!(!%(A&$&*(!%(77(!;(*(!

(!4*+4*&(!%&>'&47&$(!b,$5!A+*?5!%&!'*&)&'5!c+*%&$5*&5d!%(775!7())(*5),*5B!'+>e!'+?(!,$5!%&!

5$57&>&!A&7+>+A&'5!%(&!A&7?T!5775!7,'(!4*+4*&+!%(773+4(*5!%&!:5;(77!(!%(775!>,5!7()),*5!%&!

L&))C($>)(&$K!:5;(77B!'<(!4,*(!<5!%&57+C5)+!'+$!)57&!5,)+*&B!$+$!D!?5&!($)*5)+!

(>47&'&)5?($)(!5!A5*!45*)(!%&!)57&!4*+C*5??&!%&!*&'(*'5B!>($-5!4(*!6,(>)+!5;(*7&!4(*f!

>6,57&A&'5)&K!

1!;%K!5%!(>(?4&+!_(5%B!_KB!:*5*9B!HK!\(%>K]!^D.$g.M$=,--<.&/-.,&B!_+,)7(%C(B!2+$%+$!.RRR!

M!O&(A<,(>TI5&7(9B!2K!gK!_.W*&7$-D.$fD,1*/*(D.);/$Q.')B$H$>'?.11,'&$P.'7,&<$*2$].&7.)L$

`),<,&$'&7$P.1,<,*&$,&$h*7.)&$\S.(-,+,/8B!H><C5)(!Y,@7&><&$C!:+?45$9B!I,*7&$C)+$!.RRN!

N!G5;&>B!:K!>),-,+'1$ci+.//#$`?.)).'7,&<$,&$d.)),7'L$d.1.09.L$5.?,&'/L$j,k.S$'&7$>'?.11B!

8)5$A+*%!X$&;(*>&)9!Y*(>>B!8)5$A+*%!.R"R!

(8)

! M!

%(773(4&>)(?+7+C&5VB!A&$+!5!,$!*('($)&>>&?+!&$)(*(>>(!5$'<(!%5!45*)(!%(775!

A&7+>+A&5! 4+7&)&'5SK! Y&J! &$! C($(*57(! >&! >+$+! 5$%5)&! 5AA(*?5$%+! B>+4*5)),))+!

$(C7&!,7)&?&!%,(!%('($$&B!5$'<(!57',$&!;(*&!(!4*+4*&!c:5;(77!>'<+75*>dB!'<(!

<5$$+! %(%&'5)+! %&;(*>(! ?+$+C*5A&(! *&'+>)*,($%+! ;5*&! 5>4())&! %(7! >,+!

4($>&(*+"RK!!

:&f! '<(! %,$6,(! ?&! 4*(?(! >+))+7&$(5*(B! D! '+?(! &$! ,$5! '+>e! 5?4&5! (!

;5*&(C5)5! *&'(-&+$(! %(7! >,+! 4($>&(*+B! >&5! >+>)5$-&57?($)(! 5>>($)(! ,$!

)($)5)&;+! %&! *&'+?4*($%(*(! 73&$)(*(--5! %&! ,$5! ;+'(! '+>e! +*&C&$57(B! (! '+>e!

4+7&A+$&'5B!%(775!A&7+>+A&5!'+$)(?4+*5$(5K!#$!45*)&'+75*(B!>(@@($(!75!C*5$%(!

5))($-&+$(! '<(! D! >)5)5! 4+>)5! 577(! >,(! >&$C+7(! +4(*(! %(%&'5)(! 5775! '*&)&'5!

%35*)(B! &! ;5*&! &$)(*4*()&! $+$! >&! >+$+! ?5&! '+$'($)*5)&! >,775! %&?($>&+$(!

./-.-,+'!%(775!>,5!*&A7(>>&+$(!'+?(!+),-.),*!C($(*57&>>&?+!%&!6,(>)5!>)(>>5B!

(7,%($%+!'+>e!7(!>,(!>)(>>(!5AA(*?5-&+$&!&$!',&!4*(>($)5!4&J!;+7)(!),))+!&7!

>,+! 75;+*+! '+?(! ,$! ,$&'+! )($)5)&;+! %&! %5*! ;&)5! 5! ,$! &$'+$)*+! A*5! 5*)(! (!

A&7+>+A&5""K!!

:&f! '<(! %,$6,(! ?&! 4*+4+$C+! %&! A5*(! &$! 6,(>)5! )(>&! D! %&! (>5?&$5*(! &7! >,+!

?()+%+! (! &7! >,+! >)&7(B! '<(! 5''+?,$5$+! ),))&! &! %&;(*>&! ?+?($)&! %(775! >,5!

(75@+*5-&+$(B! (! %&! &$%5C5*(! 57! '+$)(?4+! 75! >,5! 4*+4+>)5! 4&J!

(?&$($)(?($)(! A&7+>+A&'5B! 4(*! ?+>)*5*(! '+?(! >&5! 4+>>&@&7(! *&$;($&*(! ,$5!

>4('&A&'5! *&A7(>>&+$(! (>)()&'5! '<(! '+>)&),&>'(! 75! *5%&'(B! (! 75! 4+>>&@&7&)=B! %(7!

>,+!>)(>>+!4($>&(*+K!!:+?(!;(%*(?+!:5;(77!$+$!4*+4+$(!&$A5))&!,$5!)(+*&5!

%(7! @(77+! +! ,$5! A&7+>+A&5! %(7735*)(B! ?5! 4&,))+>)+! ,$+! >4('&A&'+! ?+%(77+! %&!

*5-&+$57&)=! '<(! D! 577+! >)(>>+! )(?4+! ,$! ?+%(77+! 5*C+?($)5)&;+! 4(*! 75!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

V!:A*K!5%!(>(?4&+!Y,)$5?B!gK!P.'1,/8*$7'1$?*1-*$08'&*B!#7!E,7&$+B!I+7+C$5!"SS1B!(%K!+*&CB!

#%K!P.'1,/8$M,-D$'$l08'&$Q'+.B!g5*;5*%!X$&;(*>&)9!Y*(>>B!!:5?@*&%C(B!"SSR!

S!Q+**&>B!HK!\(%K]!^D.$>1',8$*2$>*880&,-WB$\-'&1.W$>'?.11$'&7$f*1,-,+'1$fD,1*/*(DWL!8)5$A+*%!

X$&;(*>&)9!Y*(>>B!Y57+!H7)+!.RR1!

"R!'A*K!,&2)'$h0K0B!'54K!##!

""!'A*K!,&2)'$h"K"B!'54K!#!

(9)

! N!

A&7+>+A&5B!(!,$5!*&A7(>>&+$(!(>)()&'5!>,77(!$+>)*(!+*%&$5*&(!(!$5),*57&!'545'&)=!

%&! ./(),8.).! $+&! >)(>>&! (! 75! $+>)*5! ;+'(! %&! (>>(*&! ,?5$&K! ! Y(*! *&5>>,?(*(!

6,(>)&! )*(! ?+?($)&B! 4+>>&5?+! %&*(! '<(! :5;(77! (75@+*5! 4*+4*&+! ,$5! )(+*&5!

%(773(>4*(>>&+$(B! (>4*(>>&+$(! ,?5$5! 6,5$)+! A&7+>+A&'5! (! *5-&+$57(B! (! $(!!

&$%&;&%,5! 7(! '+$%&-&+$&! %&! 4+>>&@&7&)=! $(775! $+>)*5! +*%&$5*&5! '545'&)=! %&!

5;5$-5*(! 4*()(>(! '*&)(*&57&! (%! (>(?475*&B! %&! 4+*'&! (! 4*(>($)5*'&! '+?(!

'*&)(*&+! %&! '+?4*($>&+$(! %&! $+&! >)(>>&B! 45*)($%+! %5775! $+>)*5! %&?($>&+$(!

>+CC())&;5P!7(!>)(>>(!4*()(>(!'<(!5;5$-5!75!A&7+>+A&5!%(7!7&$C,5CC&+!+*%&$5*&+!

%&!L&))C($>)(&$!6,5$%+!4*+;5!5!45*75*(!4(*!>i!(!4(*!$+&B!6,5$%+!5AA(*?5!

'+>5!%&*(??+!&$!,$5!'(*)5!>&),5-&+$(L$($'+>5!&$)($%(*(??+!$(7!%&*7+K!2(!

P,+.)+D.$Q,1*/*2,+D.B!(!75!4(',7&5*(!7()),*5!'<(!$(!+AA*(!:5;(77B$'+>)&),&>'+$+!

&$A5))&!,$+!%(&!7,+C<&!'($)*57&!%&!),))+!&7!$+>)*+!75;+*+P!&7!7+*+!>)(>>+!4+*>&!&$!

,$5!A+*?5!&$)(*?(%&5!A*5!75!7())(*5),*5!(!75!*&A7(>>&+$(!A&7+>+A&'5B!+;;(*+>&5!

75! 7+*+! A+*?5! 5A+*&>)&'5B! *544*(>($)5! &$A5))&! ,$5! %(77(! 4&J! '+$'*()(! (!

)*5>45*($)&!(>(?47&A&'5-&+$&!%&!)57(!)(+*&5!(>4*(>>&;5K!

Q(7! 4*&?+! '54&)+7+! '&! '+$'($)*(*(?+! 4*+4*&+! >,773&$&-&+! )(>),57(! %(77(!

P,+.)+D.B! >,7! 7+*+! >4('&A&'+! ?()+%+! 5*C+?($)5)&;+! (! >,77(! *(75-&+$&! '<(!

)*5''&5$+! '+$! 57)*&! )(>)&B! *&'+>)*,($%+! 75! '+?47(>>5! (! *5?&A&'5)5!

&$)(*4*()5-&+$(! '<(! $(! +AA*(! :5;(77K! _&,>'&*(?+! '+>e! ! 5! '+?4*($%(*(!

73&$&-&+B! 75! '+$%&-&+$(! %&! 4+>>&@&7&)=B! %(775! A&7+>+A&5! >)(>>5! %&! :5;(77B!

&$%&;&%,5$%+!7(!'+$%&-&+$&!7())(*5*&(!(!5,)+*&57&B!&$!,$5!45*+75!c(>)()&'<(dB!

'<(! *(57&--5$+! 75! >,5! A+*?5! %&! '*&)&'5B! %&! 7()),*5B! '+?4*($>&+$(! (!

'+$A,)5-&+$(!%(&!)(>)&B!'<(!>&!%&>)5''5!(>47&'&)5?($)(!%5773544*+''&+!7+C&'+T A+*?57(K! Q(7! >('+$%+! '54&)+7+! (>47&'&)(*(?+! %,$6,(! 4*+4*&+! )57&!

'+$%&-&+$&! (! 7(! A5'+7)=! '<(! '<&5?5$+! &$! '5,>5B! 5*)&'+75$%+! (!

&**(CC&?($)5$%+!75!;(*5!(!4*+4*&5!)(+*&5!%(773(>4*(>>&+$(!%&!:5;(77K!H$'<(!

6,&!&7!*&A(*&?($)+!5!L&))C($>)(&$!D!'($)*57(B!4(*!'<&5*&*(!&$A5))&!75!>4('&A&'5!

;57($-5!*5-&+$57(!%(775!4*+4+>)5!%&!:5;(77B!$(!4*+4+$C+!,$5!*&'+>)*,-&+$(!

5775! 7,'(! %(7! %&@5))&)+! >,7! c>(C,&*(! ,$5! *(C+75dB! '+$A*+$)5$%+! 75! >,5!

(10)

! V!

4+>&-&+$(! '+$! 6,(775! %&! 85,7! Z*&4a(! (! :*&>4&$! L*&C<)K! #7! )(*-+! (! ,7)&?+!

'54&)+7+! *&'+$)(>),57&--5! 4+&! )57(! ?+%(77+! (>4*(>>&;+! $(775! >)+*&5!

%(773(>)()&'5B! (>5?&$5$%+! C7&! (>47&'&)&! (! %&*())&! *&A(*&?($)&! 5773(>)()&'5!

a5$)&5$5!'<(!*&)*+;&5?+!$(C7&!>'*&))&!%&!:5;(77B!?+>)*5$%+!'+?(!7(!4*()(>(!

(>4*(>>&;(! >,! ',&! (C7&! &$>&>)(B! 5@@&5$+! '+?(! 4*('&>+! ?+%(77+! &7! C&,%&-&+!

(>)()&'+!%(775!>),-,+'$7.11'$2'+*1-6$7,$<,07,9,*K!H**&;(*(?+!5!%(7&$(5*(!&7!)&4+!

%&! (>(?475*&)=! '<(! &$;+'5! :5;(77! 4*+4*&+! 5))*5;(*>+! )57(! '+$A*+$)+B!

?+>)*5$%+! '+?(! 73c(>(?4&+! '*&)(*&57(d! '<(! (C7&! <5! *&)*+;5)+! &$!

L&))C($>)(&$B! ;5%5! +7)*(! 73&%(5! %&! Z5$)! %&! ,$! *544+*)+! ;&;&A&'5$)(! A*5!

(>(?4&+!(!*(C+75B!$+$!>&!%=!&$A5))&!>,77+!>A+$%+!%&!,$!'+?47(>>+!(!%&!*(C+7(!

5!4*&+*&B!?5!(>&@&>'(!&$!>i!75!4*+4*&5!$+*?5)&;&)=K!!

Q(775! 45*)(! A&$57(! %(7! )(*-+! '54&)+7+! (>5?&$(*(?+! %,$6,(! %,(! ;(*(! (!

4*+4*&(! ).'1,99'9,*&,B! (! 577+! >)(>>+! )(?4+! +*&2.)8.B! %&! )57(! ?+%(77+! %&!

(>(?475*&)=j!%544*&?5!?+>)*(*(?+!'+?(!(>>+!%&!A5))+!>&!%&5!(!>&5!'($)*57(!

$(775! 4(*A+*?5)&;&)=! %(7! $+>)*+! 7&$C,5CC&+B! $(7! $+>)*+! cA5*(! '+>(! +*&$ 7(!

45*+7(dB!'+?(!(;&%($-&5!,$3&$)(C*5-&+$(!(>)()&'5!'<(!:5;(77!4*+4+$(!4(*!75!

)(+*&5! %(C7&! 5))&! 7&$C,&>)&'&! %&! [K2K! H,>)&$K! _&'+>)*,&*(?+! 4+&! 7(! >4('&A&'<(!

'+$>+$5$-(!A*5!7(!c4*()(>(!(>4*(>>&;(d!!&$%&;&%,5)(!%5!:5;(77B!(!75!$+-&+$(!

%&! c45*5%&C?5d! '<(! &7! A&7+>+A+! (! >)+*&'+! %(775! >'&($-5! k<+?5>! Z,<$! <5!

(75@+*5)+! 4(*! %5*! '+$)+! %(775! >)*,)),*5-&+$(! %(7! >54(*(! >'&($)&A&'+! (! %(&!

>,+&! '5?@&5?($)&B! 5! *&4*+;5! %(775! *(57(! ;57($-5! *5-&+$57(! (%!

(4&>)(?+7+C&'5!%(775!>,5!4*+4+>)5K!

Q+$!?&!%&AA+$%+!6,&!+7)*(!>,7735*)&'+75-&+$(!%(&!'54&)+7&B!+C$,$+!%(&!6,57&!

<5!,$5!>,5!'+$'&>5!&$)*+%,-&+$(!'<(!$(!&77,>)*5!C7&!>$+%&!5*C+?($)5)&;&!(!

$(!'<&5*&>'(!7(!*(75-&+$&!'+$!C7&!57)*&K!Y(*!'+$'7,%(*(!6,(>)5!&$)*+%,-&+$(!

;+**(&! &$;('(! @*(;(?($)(! ?($-&+$5*(! ,$! ,7)(*&+*(! '*&)(*&+! %&!

*&'+?4*($>&+$(!4(*!6,(>)5!)(>&!>)(>>5B!,$!)(?5!'<(!(?(*C(!4&J!;+7)(!$(7!

>,+! >;+7C&?($)+B! >($-5! 4(*f! (>>(*(! ?5&! '+$>&%(*5)+! '+?(! 6,(77+! '<(! $(!

(11)

! S!

7(C5!&!%&;(*>&!5>4())&K!k*5?&)(!75!7()),*5!6,&!4*+4+>)5!%&!:5;(77!(!%(775!>,5!

&$)(*4*()5-&+$(! %&! L&))C($>)(&$B! (! 75! '+$>(C,($)(! (75@+*5-&+$(! %&! ,$5!

)(+*&5! %(773(>4*(>>&+$(B! 5**&;&5?+! &$A5))&! 5! ?+>)*5*(! '+?(! 4+>>&5?+!

*&$;($&*(! 75! $+>)*5! *)7,&'),'$ .$ &'-0)'1.$ 7,8.&/,*&.$ ./-.-,+'B! *&>'+4*&*(! (!

*&'+$A&C,*5*(!75!$+>)*5!2*)8'$7,$?,-'$./-.-,+'!%&!45*75$)&B!>+7+!>,4(*5$%+B!&7!

'<(! ;,+7! %&*(! 5$'<(! *&'+?4*($%($%+$(! 73+*&C&$(B! 57',$(! &??5C&$&! '<(! '&!

>3&?4+$C+$+!$(7!$+>)*+!A&7+>+A5*(!>,7!7&$C,5CC&+K!X$!%&;(*>+!?+%+!%,$6,(!

4(*!*&7(CC(*(!(!>'5$%&*(!&7!4(*'+*>+!%&!6,(>)5!)(>&B!+7)*(!5!6,(77+!'<(!4+$(!

5))($-&+$(! 57! >,+! 75)+! 4&J! >4('&A&'5)5?($)(! (>(C()&'+! (! )(+*&'+B! D! 4*+4*&+!

$(&! )(*?&$&! %&! ,$! )($)5)&;+! %&! >,4(*5?($)+! %&! 6,(>)(! )*(! &??5C&$&B! ,$!

4*+;5*(! 5B! '+?(! >'*&;(! L&))C($>)(&$! 57! h"RS! %(77(! P,+.)+D.! l4($()*5*(!

73+4(*5*(!%(7!$+>)*+!7&$C,5CC&+!&$!?+%+!%5!*&'+$+>'(*7+j!+*&-)*$,$5!A+*)(!

)($%($-5! 5! A*5&$)($%(*7+mK! Q(7! *&'+>)*,&*(! &7! 4($>&(*+! %&! L&))C($>)(&$! (!

:5;(77! '&! )*+;(*(?+! &$A5))&! 5%! 5AA*+$)5*(! %544*&?5! 73&??5C&$(!

%(773544*($%&?($)+! +>)($>&;+! %(7! 7&$C,5CC&+B! 4+&! 6,(775! %(7! 7&$C,5CC&+!

c*,7(! C+;(*$(%dB! (! &$A&$(! 6,(775! %(7! 7&$C,5CC&+! '+?(! >+7+! *&),57?($)(!

4(*A+*?5)&;+K!Q+$!4+)($%+!6,&!*&5>>,?(*(!7(!>4('&A&'<(!5$57&>&!%&!+C$,$5!

%&!6,(>)(!'<(!;($C+$+!>;+7)(!$(&!;5*&!'54&)+7&!b!$+$!5!'5>+!5!+C$&!&??5C&$(!

$(!'+**&>4+$%(!,$+B!(''())+!75!>('+$%5B!'<(!'+$'(*$(!7(!*(C+7(!7&$C,&>)&'<(B!

(! '<(! %5)5! 75! >,5! '($)*57&)=! *&)*+;&5?+! 5$'<(! $(7! '+$A*+$)+! a5$)&5$+! %(7!

)(*-+!'54&)+7+TB!?&!7&?&)+!6,&!5!(;&%($-&5*(!'<(!&7!75;+*+!%&!*(',4(*+!%(775!

%&?($>&+$(!(>)()&'5!7,!(!,&!:5;(77!'+&$'&%(!'+$B!(!4,f!(>>(*(!7())+!'+?(B!,$!

45*577(7+! *(',4(*+! %(7! $+>)*+! 7&$C,5CC&+B! (! %(775! >,5! c(>)()&'&)=dB! %577(!

$+>)*(!)($)5-&+$&!%&!)*5>'($%(*$(!&!'+$'*()&!(!+*%&$5*&!&?4(C$&!7&$C,&>)&'&B!

'+?(! >(! 75! 4+>>&@&7&)=! %&! *&>'+4*&*(! (! *(',4(*5*(! 73(>)()&'5! A+>>(! 75!

4+>>&@&7&)=!%&!*&>'+4*&*(!(!*(',4(*5*(!$+&!>)(>>&K!!

(12)

! "R!

(13)

! ""!

Alcuni filosofi sono capaci di trasformare qualsiasi cosa in un testo filosofico, come per un sacerdote il primo pianto del bambino è occasione di discorsi edificanti;

mentre altre persone non sarebbero capaci di intavolare una discussione neppure con Dio.

Stanley Cavell, La riscoperta dell’ordinario

-./)#%0%+!++

1$2%3*"#.()%")4+#*5#)+*+/%55)6)0)#7+&*00.+

8)0%5%8).+)"+9#."0*:+-.;*00++

+

Introduzione

#$!6,(>)+!4*&?+!'54&)+7+!;+C7&+!*&A7())(*(!4*(7&?&$5*?($)(!>,775!>)*,)),*5!

5*C+?($)5)&;5B!>,&!?+%&!(!7+!>)&7(!%&!*5C&+$5?($)+!A&7+>+A&'+!%&!:5;(77B!4(*!

4*+;5*(! 5! ($)*5*(! $(775! >,5! 45*)&'+75*(! (! +*&C&$57(! 4*+4+>)5! A&7+>+A&'5B!

(>5?&$5$%+!7(!)($>&+$&!(!7(!A&))&>>&?(!*(75-&+$&!A*5!,$5!%&?($>&+$(!7+C&'5T

*5-&+$57(! (! ,$5! 5*)&>)&'+T7())(*5*&5! %(7! >,+! 4($>&(*+B! 7(C5?(! %&! ',&! (C7&!

>)(>>+!>&!D!4&J!;+7)(!%&?+>)*5)+!'+$>54(;+7(K!:5;(77!<5!&$A5))&!4*(>($)5)+!&$!

?+7)&! >,+&! )(>)&! >(! >)(>>+! $(&! )(*?&$&! %&! ,$+! /+),--*).B! &$>(*($%+! 75! >,5!

5))&;&)=! A&7+>+A&'5! &$! 6,(>)5! 45*)&'+75*(! '+*$&'(B! '<(! +7)*(! 5! *&?5$%5*(!

5773+*%&$5*&()=! %&! '&f! '<(! (C7&! A5! (! <5! A5))+B! 4*+%,**(! (! 4,@@7&'5*(! )(>)&B!

>(?@*5! &$(;&)5@&7?($)(! ;+7(*! ?())(*(! &$! (;&%($-5! ,$5! 4*+>4())&;5!

5*)&>)&'5! (! >)&7&>)&'5B! +! 4(*7+?($+! ,$5! >,5! *&'(*'5B! $+$! %&>>+'&5@&7(! %5!

6,(775!A&7+>+A&'5K!#7!*&A(*&?($)+!%,$6,(!57!c)(>)+d!(!5775!c)(>),57&)=d!&$!),))+!

&7!>,+!4($>&(*+!;57(!&$A5))&!4*&$'&457?($)(!'+?(!,$!*&A(*&?($)+!57!)(>)+!&$!

6,5$)+! +4(*5! %35*)(! 7())(*5*&5B! (! 57! *&C,5*%+! (C7&! $+$! <5! ?5&! $5>'+>)+! 7(!

4*+4*&(!&$)($-&+$&j!!

(14)

! ".!

ho sem pre tentato di trovare un registro m edio di pensiero e di scrittura che fosse com e una m em brana tra il passato della letteratura ed il presente della scienza -quella che personalm ente chiam o una filosofia di scam bio12.

_&A7())(*(! >,7! >,+! ?+%+! %&! '+$'(4&*(! (! A5*! ,>+! %(7735*C+?($)5-&+$(! &$!

A&7+>+A&5B! >,7! >,+! >)(>>+! ?+%+! %&! >'*&;(*(! '+>e! '+?(! >,! 6,(77+! %(&! >,+&!

?5(>)*&! (! ?5>>&?&! *(A(*($)&B! '+?4+*)5! %,$6,(! &7! >+AA(*?5*>&! >,775!

>'*&)),*5B! >,775! $5),*5! )(>),57(! %(7! 4($>&(*+! A&7+>+A&'+! '+?(! 7,+C+! %(77+!

>'5?@&+!A*5!*5-&+$57&)=!(%!(>)()&'5K!n,(>)5!)(>&!;,+7(!&$%5C5*(!4*+4*&+!)57(!

7(C5?(B!4*+;5$%+!5!)*5''&5*(!&7!45*)&'+75*(!*544+*)+!'&'1*<,+*!A*5!A&7+>+A&5!

(! 5*)(! '<(! :5;(77! *&(>'(! 5! (;&%($-&5*(! (! ?())(*(! &$! 5))+! '+$! &7! >,+! >)(>>+!

?+%+! %&! A5*! A&7+>+A&5K! oC$&! 45>>+! %&! 6,(>)+! 75;+*+! >5*=! %,$6,(! ,$5!

*&'+>)*,-&+$(! %(7! >,+! ?()+%+! &$! 6,5$)+! (>>+! '+>)&),&>'(! 75! >,5! >)(>>5!

(>)()&'5K! Q(&! 4*+>>&?&! '54&)+7&! 5AA*+$)(*(?+! 4+&! 57)*&! '+$'())&! '<&5;(! %(7!

>,+!4($>&(*+B!(!5$'<(!&$!6,(>)&!'5>&!&7!'+$A*+$)+!'+$!7(!>,(!&%((!'&!*&4+*)(*=!

&$! ?5$&(*5! 4*+A+$%5! (! '+>)5$)(! 5! %5*! '+$)+! %(775! >,5! +*&C&$57(! ;+'(!

(>4*(>>&;5! (! *&A7(>>&;5B! ?5! 75! %&?($>&+$(! )(>),57(! '*(%+! *544*(>($)&! ,$5!

>+*)5!%&!(),808B!+!%&!4+>>&@&7(!&$&-&+B!4+&'<i!4+*)5!&$!(;&%($-5!>&5!75!>)(>>5!

6,(>)&+$(!%(773&$&-&+!%(775!(75@+*5-&+$(!%&!:5;(77!6,5$)+!&7!>,+!A+$%+B!75!>,5!

&**&%,'&@&7&)=! (>)()&'5K! 8+7+! 4+$($%+! 5))($-&+$(! 57! )(>)+! '+?(! 7,+C+!

4*&$'&4(!%(775!A&7+>+A&5!>)(>>5B!+*&C&$(!(!'($)*+!%(7!>,+!&$)(*(>>(!A&7+>+A&'+B!

>&! 4+)*=! '+?4*($%(*(! '+?(! :5;(77B! '<(! 4,*(! (>47&'&)5?($)(! (>4*&?(! 4&J!

;+7)(!&7!>,+!%&>)5''+!%5775!)*5%&-&+$(!5$57&)&'5!(!%5775!>,5!+*&+.9,*&.$2*)-.!

%(7735*C+?($)5-&+$(!(!%(7!>,+!*,+7+!$(7!*5C&+$5?($)+!A&7+>+A&'+B!4($>5)+!(!

?+%(77&--5)+! >,77(! 4*+;(! A+*?57&! %(775! 7+C&'5! (! %(775! ?5)(?5)&'5B! $+$!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

12!:5;(77B!8K!F1$),(07,*$7.1$/'(.).B$1*$/+.--,+,/8*$&.1$-.'-)*$7,$\D'S./(.').L!^&$5,%&B!k+*&$+!

.RR0B!4K!."R!!

(15)

! "/!

?5$'<&!%&!+AA*&*(!,$5!>,5!+*&C&$57(!4*+4+>)5!57!*&C,5*%+B!'<(!4&J!'<(!7.G*1.!

+! ,))'9,*&'1,/-'"@! '*(%+! >&5! &$$5$-&),))+! (,m$ 2*&7'8.&-'1.! (! 6,&$%&! &$!

*(75-&+$(! '+$! 75! '+>&%%())5! +*&+.9,*&.$ 2*)-.K! ^C7&! *&'+$+>'(! &$A5))&! 75!

%&?($>&+$(! 7+C&'5T*5-&+$57(! %(7735*C+?($)5-&+$(B! >($-5! $(C5*75! $i!

+44+*>&!5!(>>5B!?5!$(!'(*'5!4&,))+>)+!,$!(),&+,(,*$7,$(*//,G,1,-6!&$!5?@&)+!

,?5$+!(%!(>)()&'+B!$+$!?($+!>57%+!5$'<(!>(!54(*)+!577+!>'())&'&>?+!'+>e!

'+?(!5&!>,+&!>,4(*5?($)&K!

Y(*!A5*(!'&f!(C7&B!4&J!'<(!%&>)5''5*>&!%5775!)*5%&-&+$(!5$57&)&'5B!*&4*($%(!(%!

(>45$%(! ,$+! %(&! >,+&! A&7+$&! +*&C&$5*&B! '<(! 4,*! $(C7&! 5$$&! D! >)5)+!

c%&?($)&'5)+d! 5! A5;+*(! %&! 6,(77+! 7+C&'+T4+>&)&;&>)5B! +;;(*+! 6,(77+! %(775!

2,1*/*2,'$7.1$1,&<0'<<,*$*)7,&'),*!%(&!>,+&!?5(>)*&!L&))C($>)(&$!(%!H,>)&$K!

_&A(*($%+'&! &$! 45*)&'+75*(! 57! 4*&?+B! 57! >,+! +*&C&$57(! 544*+''&+! 5775!

6,(>)&+$(! 7&$C,&>)&'5B! 4+)*(?+! '+?4*($%(*(! 7+! >)5),)+! %(77(! >)(>>(!

5*C+?($)5-&+$&! %&! :5;(77B! +! ?(C7&+! 5$'+*5! '+?4*($%(*(! 6,5$%+! (! '+?(!

(C7&! >)&5! 5*C+?($)5$%+B! (%! (;&%($-&5*(! '+?(! 5775! @5>(! %&! )57&!

5*C+?($)5-&+$&!'&!>&5!75!),+D,./-'!%&!),+*&*/+.)+,!&$!6,5$)+!'&!4*+4+$(B!,$5!

*&'<&(>)5! '<(! >&! @5>5! >,! A5'+7)=! (! %&?($>&+$&! %(773(>4(*&($-5! ,?5$5! '<(!

>+$+! 4*+4*&5?($)(! (>)()&'<(B! 6,57&! &7! *&'+**(*(! 5! 45*)&'+75*&! C&+'<&!

7&$C,&>)&'&! 4(*! 5AA*+$)5*7&! +),-,+'8.&-.$ (%$ ./.8(1')8.&-.B! ,88'<,&'&7*! (!

6,&$%&! '*(5$%+! 45*)&'+75*&! >&),5-&+$&! &$! ',&! 7')$ ?*+.! (%! ./(),8.).$ $+&!

>)(>>&K! 8+7+! )($($%+! &$! ?($)(! 6,(>)5! 45*)&'+75*(! 7&$(5! %&! c5;&d! &$! ',&! (C7&!

>)(>>+! <5! %('&>+! %&! &$>(*&*(! &7! >,+! 4($>&(*+! T,$5! 7&$(5! '<(! (C7&! >)(>>+! <5!

*&'+$A&C,*5)+! &$>(*($%+;&! $,+;&! 45*($)&! (! 4*+C($&)+*&B! A&7+>+A&! (! 5*)&>)&B!

*&$;($($%+! &$)(*(>>5$)&>>&?(! >+?&C7&5$-(! %&! A5?&C7&5T! >5*=! 4+>>&@&7(!

'54&*(!7(!>,(!*5%&'57&!%&>)5$-(!%5!?+7)5!(>)()&'5!5$57&)&'5P!%(%&)5!6,(>)5!5%!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

13!Y(*!)57&!'75>>&A&'5-&+$&!%(775!4+>&-&+$(!%&!:5;(77B!'<(!$(7!?+$%+!5$57&)&'+T5$C7+>5>>+$(!

>+$+!&$!45*)(!5$'<(!%(77(!>6,57&A&'<(B!'A*K!U7+'aB!gK![K!=D'-$,/$H&'1W-,+$fD,1*/*(DWVB!

:5?@*&%C(!X$&;(*>&)9!Y*(>>B!:5?@*&%C(!.RRVB!&$!45*)&'+75*(!4K!S/B!44KS1TSVK!

(16)

! "0!

&$%5C&$&! (! %+?5$%(! '<(! ?+7)+! &$;('(! %(;+$+! 5775! )*5%&-&+$(! 7+C&'+T 4+>&)&;&>)&'5B!6,57(!6,(775!%(!c75!7.2,&,9,*&.!%(7735*)(dB!+!!%(!c75!$5),*5!%(&!

().7,+'-,!(!%(77(!()*(),.-6!%(7!C&,%&-&+!(>)()&'+d"0K!8(!&$A5))&!75!?5CC&+*5-5!

%&! 6,(>)&! 5,)+*&! <5$$+B! 4(*! %&*75! &$! @*(;(B! 5447&'5)+! ,$5! ?()+%+7+C&5! (!

>($>&@&7&)=!7+C&'+T(4&>)(?+7+C&'5!577(!%&>'&47&$(!5*)&>)&'<(!+!5773(>)()&'5!4&J!

&$!C($(*57(B!75!%&?($>&+$(!(>)()&'5B!75!*&A7(>>&+$(!>,7735*)(!&$!:5;(77!D!(>>5!

>)(>>5!C($(*5)*&'(!%&!>($>+B!%&!?()+%&B!%&!>)&7&!5*C+?($)5)&;&B!D!,$!?+%(77+!

%&!*5-&+$57&)=!$+$'<i!7,+C+!%&!6,(>)&+$&!(%!&$)(**+C5)&;&!'($)*57&K!

Q(&!45*5C*5A&!>,''(>>&;&!(>5?&$(*f!%,$6,(!7(!5AA(*?5-&+$&!%&!:5;(77!'<(!5!

;+7)(!>(?@*5$+!$(C5*(!6,57>&5>&!*,+7+!577(!5*C+?($)5-&+$&!&$!A&7+>+A&5B!(!7(!

'+$>&%(*(*f!5773&$)(*$+!%(7!>,+!4&J!(75@+*5)+!4($>&(*+!*&C,5*%+!&!?()+%&!(!

7(! 4+>>&@&7&)=! %(7! *5C&+$5?($)+! A&7+>+A&'+P! ;+C7&+! '+>e! 4*+;5*(! 5! ?+>)*5*(!

C&=! &$! 6,(>)+! 4*&?+! '54&)+7+! '+?(! *&A7())($%+! &$! ?+7)&! %(&! >,+&! >'*&))&! >,!

)57(! 6,(>)&+$(! :5;(77! C&,$C5! 5! *&A+*?,75*(! (! 5AA*+$)5*(! )57(! 4*+@7(?5! &$!

)(*?&$&! (>)()&'&K! Q+$! 4*+4+$($%+! +! >+))+>'*&;($%+! 4(*f! ,$5! >4('&A&'5!

)(+*&5!%(7!@(77+!+!,$5!A&7+>+A&5!%(7735*)(B!?5!4&,))+>)+B!&$!'+$)&$,5!)($>&+$(!

(!>'5?@&+!A*5!>'&($-5!(!7())(*5),*5B!&$%&;&%,5$%+!,$5!>4('&A&'5!*5-&+$57&)=!

%(773(>)()&'5! '<(! *&'+?4*($%(! (! *($%(! 4+>>&@&7(! 75! *5-&+$57&)=! &$! 6,5$)+!

)57(K!G+4+!5;(*!&$%&;&%,5)+!&$!4*&?5!&>)5$-5!6,(>)+!?+%(77+!%&!*5-&+$57&)=B!

'<(!&$!),))5!6,(>)5!)(>&!4*($%(!&7!$+?(!%&!(>(?475*&)=B!(!'<(!'+?(!;(%*(?+!

'+&$;+7C(! (>>($-&57?($)(! 73&??5C&$5-&+$(! (! 73(>4*(>>&+$(B! >+>)(**f! '<(!

(>>+!)*+;&!,$5!4*+4*&5!*&>4+$%($-5B!,$5!4*+4*&5!*),<,&.!(!).'1,99'9,*&.!&$!

,$5! 4*('&>5! ./-.-,+'B! &$! ,$5! A+*?5! (>4*(>>&;5! (! %&! >'*&)),*5B! '<(! ;(%*(?+!

(>>(*(!'($)*57(!4(*!),))+!&7!$+>)*+!%&>'+*>+B!+;;(*+!6,(775!%(7735A+*&>?5B!%(7!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

"0!:A*K!!8<,>)(*?5$B!_K!H&'1W/,&<$H&'1W-,+$H./-D.-,+/B!&$!8<,>)(*?5$B!_K!\5!',*5!%&]!H&'1W-,+$

H./-D.-,+/B!I5>&7!I75'aW(77B!opA+*%!"SVSB!44K!"T"SK!Y(*!,$35$)+7+C&5!&$!&)57&5$+!%&!57',$&!

>5CC&!'<(!<5$$+!A5))+!75!>)+*&5!%&!6,(>)5!%&>'&47&$5!;%K!!Z+@5,B!YK!O(7+))&B!8K!E5))(,''&B!UK!\5!

',*5!%&]!c/-.-,+'$.$Q,1*/*2,'$H&'1,-,+'B!!#7!E,7&$+B!I+7+C$5!.RRVK!

(17)

! "1!

A*5??($)+B! '<(! $+$! 5! '5>+! &$! L&))C($>)(&$! >)(>>+! )*+;5! ,$+! %(&! >,+&!

?5>>&?&!(>4+$($)&!A&7+>+A&'&K!

Y(*!*&5>>,?(*(!>'<(?5)&'5?($)(!6,5$)+!>(C,(!4+>>&5?+!%&*(!'<(!4+*'&!75!

6,(>)&+$(!%(77(!5*C+?($)5-&+$&B!%&!'+>5!>&C$&A&'<&!4(*!:5;(77!5*C+?($)5*(!

\&]!'&!4+*)(*=!%5!>,@&)+B!&$!,$3+44+>&-&+$(!'<(!4+&!>,4(*(*(?+B!5!*&A7())(*(!

>,775!6,(>)&+$(!%(&!)(>)&B!&$!,$!&$)*(''&+!7+C&'+T(>)()&'+!'<(!&$!),))5!75!)(>&!>&!

4*+;(*=!5!>;+7C(*(!$(775!>,5!&$)(*(--5!4&J!'<(!5!%&45$5*(P!75!%&?($>&+$(!

)(>),57(!%(775!A&7+>+A&5!\&&]!'&!4+*)5!5!*&A7())(*(!5$'<(!>,775!6,(>)&+$(!%&!'<(!

'+>5! >&5! >'*&;(*(! (! 7(CC(*(! ,$! )(>)+! A&7+>+A&'+! \&&&]B! (>4*&?(*>&!

A&7+>+A&'5?($)(B! (! 5! ,$! )(?5! %('&>5?($)(! 544*+4*&5)+! 4(*! 6,(>)(! 4*&?(!

45C&$(B! &7! )(?5! %(773&$&-&+! (! %(775! 4+>>&@&7&)=! %(775! A&7+>+A&5K! n,(77+! '<(! ?&!

4*+4+$C+! &$! 6,(>)+! 4*&?+! '54&)+7+! D! 4*+4*&+! %&! ?())(*(! 5! '+$A*+$)+!

73&$&-&+!)(>),57(!%(775!A&7+>+A&5!%&!:5;(77B!%(7!>,+!)(>)+!'($)*57(!^D.$>1',8$*2$

P.'/*&B!'+$!73&$&-&+!%(775!\>('+$%5]!A&7+>+A&5!%&!L&))C($>)(&$!(!'+$!735$57&>&!

'<(!7+!>)(>>+!:5;(77!$(!<5!A+*$&)+K!23&$&-&+!%(77(!P,+.)+D.$Q,1*/*2,+D.$&$A5))&!

&77,?&$5! (! *($%(! '+?4*($>&@&7(! 73&$&-&+! %&! :5;(77B! &7! A+$%5?($)+! ! (! 75!

4+>>&@&7&)=! %&! &$)*54*($%(*(! ,$5! >)*5)(C&5! A&7+>+A&'5! '+>e! 4(',7&5*(! (!

%&>)&$)&;5B!57)*&?($)&!5!A+*)(!*&>'<&+!%&!A*5&$)($%&?($)+K!

#7!)(?5!%(775!4+>>&@&7&)=!A&7+>+A&5B!+!?(C7&+!%&!,$5!A&7+>+A&5!'+>e!&$)(>>,)5!%&!

7())(*5*&()=! 6,57(! D! 75! >,5B! D! %,$6,(! '($)*57(! $(77(! >,(! >)*())&>>&?(!

*(75-&+$&! '+$! &! 4*('(%($)&! %,(P! &! )*(! ?+?($)&! %(7! >,+! 4($>&(*+! b 5*C+?($)5-&+$(B! )(>),57&)=! (! 4+>>&@&7&)=q&$&-&+! %(775! A&7+>+A&5T! *&?5$%5$+!

&$A5))&! +,)+*1')8.&-.! 73,$+! 577357)*+K! 25! A&7+>+A&5! %&! L&))C($>)(&$! >&! 54*(!

&$A5))&B! '+?(! ;(%*(?+B! 4*+4+$($%+'&! ,$! $,+;+! ?+%+! %&! 5*C+?($)5*(! (!

*5C&+$5*(B!6,(775!%&!:5;(77!&$;('(!'+$'($)*5$%+>&!>,775!%&?($>&+$(!(>)()&'5!

(!7())(*5*&5!%&!6,(>)35?@&)+!%(7!4($>&(*+!,?5$+P!&$!),))5!6,(>)5!)(>&!4*+;+!

5!7(C5*(!6,(>)&!%,(!?+?($)&B!!5!>+>)($(*(!'<(!)57(!?+%+!%&!5*C+?($)5*(B!%&!

?5)*&'(! W&))C($>)(&$&5$5! (! >;&7,445)+! (! 544*+A+$%&)+! 4+&! %5! :5;(77B! D!

(18)

! "M!

(?&$($)(?($)(! (>)()&'+B! (! >&! 4*+4+$(! '+?(! ,$! %&;(*>+! &$&-&+! (! ?+%+! %&!

'+$'(4&*(! 75! A&7+>+A&5B! '<(! ;(%(! 4*+4*&+! $(773(>)()&'5! $+$! ,$5! %(77(! >,5!

@*5$'<(!?5!75!>,5!'+$%&-&+$(!%&!4+>>&@&7&)=K!!

8+7+! )*5''&5$%+! 7(! &$)(*(>>5$)&! *(75-&+$&! A*5! 6,(>)&! )*(! %&;(*>&! )(?&!!

4+>>&5?+! &$A5))&! '+?4*($%(*(! 75! >)*,)),*5! 5*C+?($)5)&;5! %&! :5;(77B! (!

>(44,*(! 5@@&5?+! A&$! 6,&! %(A&$&)+! )57(! 544*+A+$%&?($)+! '+?(!

,$3+4(*5-&+$(!4*(7&?&$5*(!57!;(*+!(!4*+4*&+!5%%($)*5*>&!$(77+!>;+7C&?($)+!

%&!6,(>)5!)(>&B!4*+4*&+!4(*'<i!>&!A+'57&--5!>,!,$5!%&?($>&+$(!?()+%+7+C&'5B!

'*(%+!'<(!C&=!%5!>,@&)+B!5!6,(>)+!7&;(77+!%(7!%&>'+*>+B!4+>>&5?+!5$)&'&45*(!

C7&! (7(?($)&! '($)*57&! %(775! 8XH! A&7+>+A&5B! (! &$&-&5*(! 5! %(A&$&*(! '+>e! 75! >,5!

4*+4+>)5K! Q+$! 4(*'<i! ;&! >&5! 6,&B! &$! 6,(>)(! ?()5T*&A7(>>&+$&B! C&=! -0--*! &$!

$,'(B!'+>e!'+?(!+C$&!>+))&C7&(--5!(!&$)(*(>>(!'<(!>+>)5$-&5$+!&!>,+&!>'*&))&!(!

75!>,5!+*&C&$57(!;+'(!A&7+>+A&'5B!?5!4&,))+>)+!'+?(!>(!6,(>)5!>,5!?(>>5!&$!

6,(>)&+$(! %(7! )(?5! %(773&$&-&+! (! %(&! )(>)&B! %(775! *5-&+$57&)=! %(77(! >,(!

4*+4+>)(B!./.8(1,2,+'//.!C&=!75!45*)&'+75*&)=!(!75!$5),*5!%(77(!>,(!&%((B!%(7!

>,+!4($>5*(K!n,(>)+!4*&?+!'54&)+7+!D!%,$6,(!,$5!>+*)5!%&!(>4+>&-&+$(!%(&!

)(?&!(>>($-&57&!%(7!4($>&(*+!%&!:5;(77B!,$5!4*&?5!%&?+>)*5-&+$(!%&!'+?(!>&5!

4+>>&@&7(! (! $('(>>5*&+! 7(C5*7&! A*5! 7+*+! (! ?())(*7&! &$! *(75-&+$(! 5! 45*)&*(! %5!

,$5! >4('&A&'5! *&A7(>>&+$(! (! *(57&--5-&+$(! (>)()&'5! \735A+*&>?5]B! 4(*! 4+&!

4+)(*7&! '+>e! 5AA*+$)5*(! 4&J! $(7! 4*+A+$%+! $(&! >,''(>>&;&! '54&)+7&! C&=!

5773&$)(*$+!%&!,$+!>'<(?5!'<(!'(!$(!A5!'+?4*($%(*(!&!*544+*)&K!

?@A@+B"+.//$%>>)%+#*5#'.0*+.00.+$)80*55)%"*+8)0%5%8)>.A+

+

25! A&7+>+A&5! %&! :5;(77! >&! >+>)5$-&5! (! >&! ?,+;(! >,773+$%5! %&! ,$5! 45*)&'+75*(!

'&*'+75*&)=!'<(!&$!6,(>)5!)(>&!4*+;+!5!>;+7C(*(!(!>'5$%&*(!$(&!>,+&!%&;(*>&!

?+?($)&B!%+;(!%&>)&$C,(*(!&7!+D.!%57!+*8.!D!>'+**())+!$+$!4(*'<i!)*5%&>'5!

(19)

! "N!

C7&! >)(>>&! ?+$&)&! %(7735,)+*(B! ?5! 4(*'<i! &7! *,+7+! %(773(>(?47&A&'5-&+$(! D!

'($)*57(j! :5;(77! (>&@&>'(! '&f! '<(! 4*+4+$(B! ?())(! &$! 5))+! (! 5%+4(*5! 7(! >,(!

>)(>>(! '+$'(-&+$&! *&C,5*%+! '+>5! >&5! 5*C+?($)5*(! (! *5C&+$5*(B! (! 4+$(!

%,$6,(! &7! >,+! >)(>>+! >'*&;(*(B! 75! >,5! A&7+>+A&5! (! 75! 4+>>&@&7&)=! %&!

'+?4*($%(*75!'+?(!'*&)(*&+!4(*!;57,)5*(!7(!>,(!&%((K!r!%,$6,(!&$!6,(>)+!

>($>+!(>(?47&A&'5)+*&+!'<(!(?(*C(*5$$+B!>(44,*!&$!@*(;(!&$!6,(>)+!4*&?+!

'54&)+7+B! ?+7)(! 6,(>)&+$&! '($)*57&! %(7! >,+! 4($>&(*+B! '<(! $(7! >(C,&)+!

;(**5$$+!4+&!5$57&--5)(!5775!7,'(!%(773&?4&5$)+!C($(*57(!%(775!)(>&!'<(!)*+;5!

4*+4*&+! $(773(>(?475*&)=! &7! >,+! '($)*+K! k(?&! 6,57&! 7+! >'())&'&>?+B! &7!

*544+*)+! A*5! >+CC())+! (! '+?,$&)=B! (! &$! 45*)&'+75*(! 75! *&'+?4*($>&+$(!

%(773+*%&$5*&5!%&?($>&+$(!%(7!>+CC())+!(!%(775!A&7+>+A&5!&$!)(*?&$&!(>)()&'&K!

O+C7&+! '<&5*&*(! (! 5$)&'&45*(! &$$5$-&),))+! '<(! 73(>)()&'5! &$! 6,(>)5! )(>&! >&!

'+$A&C,*5! '+?(! 73&$%5C&$(! '*&)&'5! '<(! )($)5B! &$! >($>+! a5$)&5$+T W&))C($>)(&$&5$+"1B! %&! ),/'1,).$ 577(! '+$%&-&+$&! %(775! $+>)*5! (>4(*&($-5!

,?5$5B!577(!'+$%&-&+$&!%(77(!$+>)*(!4+>>&@&7&)=!%&!./(),8.).!$+&!>)(>>&!(!75!

$+>)*5! ;+'(! %&! (>>(*&! ,?5$&B! '+$'($)*5$%+>&! >,7735*)(B! >,77(! +4(*(B! '+?(!

7,+C+! A+$%5?($)57(! '<(! (>&@&>'(! 75! 4+>>&@&7&)=! %&! *&)*+;5*(! 6,(>)(!

'+$%&-&+$&! (! %(7&$(5*(! 7(! $+>)*(! A5'+7)=! (>4*(>>&;(! (! &??5C&$5)&;(K! k57(!

c(>)()&'5d!$+$!*&>,7)(*=!%,$6,(!>+7+!,$!544*+%+!%(7!4($>&(*+!%&!:5;(77B!,$5!

)(>&!'<(!(C7&!;,+7(!4*+4+**(B!?5!4&,))+>)+!D!&7!>,+!>)(>>+!?+%+!%&!A&7+>+A5*(!

(!%&!>'*&;(*(B!75!*(>4+$>5@&7&)=B!75!%&*(-&+$(!(!75!4+>>&@&7&)=!*5-&+$57(!%(775!

>,5!A&7+>+A&5B!&7!+*8.!)5$)+!&7!>,+!+D.K!23+4(*5!%&!:5;(77B!'&f!'<(!(C7&!;,+7(!

()*(*)).$ .$ ),+D,.7.).! 5! >(! >)(>>+B! '+?(! 5! $+&! 7())+*&B! D! &$! 6,(>)+! >($>+!

?+7)+!'+$>+$5$)(!577(!P,+.)+D.$Q,1*/*2,+D.$%&!2,%W&C!L&))C($>)(&$B!&7!)(>)+!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

"1!X$+!%(C7&!>'+4&!%&!6,(>)5!)(>&B!D!4*+4*&+!&!7(C5?&!A*5!Z5$)B!(!75!>,5!(>)()&'5B!(!

L&))C($>)(&$B!4*+4*&+!5))*5;(*>+!75!*&A7(>>&+$(!%&!:5;(77B!5',)+!7())+*(!%&!($)*5?@&K!k57&!

7(C5?&!%357)*+$%(!>+$+!'<&5*5?($)(!%(7&$(5)&B!>(44,*!4(*!57)*&!&$)($)&B!&$!?+7)5!

7())(*5),*5B!&$!45*)&'+75*(!6,&!<+!5;,)+!'+?(!*&A(*&?($)+!!U5**+$&B!^K!c/-.-,+'L$0&*$/<0')7*$

'--)'?.)/*B!U5*-5$)&B!E&75$+!"SS.!'+>e!'+?(!U5**+$&B!^K!$\.&/*$.$(')'7*//*L$!25)(*-5B!

_+?5TI5*&!"SS1!K!:A*K!,&2)'$!hh"K"T"K/B!'54K!###K!!

(20)

! "V!

%5!7,&!>'(7)+!'+?(!*&A(*&?($)+B!6,(77+!'<(!4&J!7+!<5!'<&5?5)+!5775!A&7+>+A&5B!(!

4(*!&!>,+&!>'*&))&!'*(%+!;57C5!%,$6,(!4*+4*&+!75!>,5!>)(>>5!'+$>&%(*5-&+$(!

57!*&C,5*%+B!+;;(*+!'<(!!

il m odo in cui quest’opera è scritta è interno a ciò che essa insegna, il che significa che non possiam o com prendere il m odo (chiam iam olo il m etodo) prim a di aver com preso l’opera16.

Q(773&$'&4&)!%&!6,(77+!'<(!D!&7!)(>)+!'($)*57(!%(775!>,5!4*+%,-&+$(!A&7+>+A&'5B!

^D.$ >1',8$ *2$ P.'/*&B! A*,))+! %(775! >,5! )(>&! %+))+*57("N! *&(75@+*5)5! (!

*&4($>5)5!4(*!4&J!%&!%,(!%('($$&!A&$+!5775!4,@@7&'5-&+$(!5775!A&$(!%(C7&!5$$&!

>())5$)5B!)*+;&5?+!:5;(77!5775!*&'(*'5!%&!,$!4+>>&@&7(!&$&-&+B!5775!*&'(*'5!%&!

,$!?+%+!544*+4*&5)+!4(*!5''+>)5*>&!4*+4*&+!577(!P,+.)+D.$Q,1*/*2,+D.K!^C7&!D!

?+>>+!%5775!4*(>>5$)(!%+?5$%5j!l'+?(!4+)*(?+!A5*!>e!'<(!6,(>)+!7&@*+!'&!

&$>(C$&!6,57'+>5smK!25!4*&?5!5AA(*?5-&+$(!57!*&C,5*%+!D!75!>(C,($)(j!

Innanzitutto –per presentare m e stesso e per spiegare perché insista sulle R icerche in quanto testo filosofico- dirò che ho voluto intendere la filosofia non com e un insiem e di problem i m a com e un insiem e di testi18.

O+**(&!%,$6,(!45*)&*(!4*+4*&5?($)(!%5!6,(>)5!>,5!%&'<&5*5-&+$(!&$&-&57(B!(!

6,5>&! 754&%5*&5B! &$! ',&! :5;(77! 5AA*+$)5! &7! )(?5! %&! +*/'$ >&5! 75! A&7+>+A&5B! +!

?(C7&+!%(77(!>,(!,&-.&9,*&,!57!*&C,5*%+K!:&f!'<(!?&!4*(?(!D!73+44+>&-&+$(!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

16!:5;(77B!8K!5'$),/+*(.)-'$7.11;*)7,&'),*#$5'$2,1*/*2,'L$1*$/+.--,+,/8*L$,1$-)'<,+*K!:5*+''&B!_+?5!

.RR"B!)*5%,-&+$(!&)57&5$5!%&!I5*@5*5!HC$(>(B!4K!.1K!^%&-&+$(!!+*&C&$57(j!:5;(77B!8K!^D.$>1',8$

*2$P.'/*&K!=,--<.&/-.,&L$\S.(-,+,/8L$h*)'1,-W$'&7$^)'<.7WK!opA+*%!X$&;(*>&)9!Y*(>>B!opA+*%!

"SNS$!

17!25!fD#d#$7,//.)-'-,*&$;($$(!4*(>($)5)5!$(7!"SM"!4*(>>+!&7!%&45*)&?($)+!%&!A&7+>+A&5!!

%(773,$&;(*>&)=!%&!g5*;5*%B!'+$!&7!)&)+7+!%&!^D.$>1',8$-*$P'-,*&'1,-W#$

18!:5;(77B!8K!5'$),/+*(.)-'$7.11;*)7,&'),*#$\'&)K]!4K!.1$!

(21)

! "S!

'<(!)*5''&5!A*5!6,57'+>5!%&!'+$)($,)&>)&'+!(!>+>)5$)&;+B!+>>&5!&!c4*+@7(?&dB!

5*C+?($)&! >4('&A&'&! '<(! +C$&! %&>'&47&$5! >(?@*(*(@@(! 4+*)5*(! '+$! >iB! (!

6,57'+>5!&$;('(!'<(!+>'&775!A*5!&7!A+*?57(!(%!,$5!'(*)5!;5C<(--5!+%!+;;&()=B!

+;;(*+!%(&!c)(>)&dK!r!&$A5))&!4*+4*&+!&$!6,(>)5!5AA(*?5-&+$(!'<(!(?(*C+$+!7(!

*(75-&+$&! A*5! &! )*(! )(?&! >+4*5! (;&%($-&5)&j! 75! 6,(>)&+$(! %&! '+>5! >&5! 75!

A&7+>+A&5B!%&!'+?(!%5*7(!,&,9,*!b>&5?+!&$!5?@&)+!%&!4*(>($)5-&+$(T!>&!>&),5!

$(775! >'(7)5B! (>'7,>&;5! 5! 6,5$)+! 45*(B! A*5! 57',$&! ()*G1.8,! '+?(! '+$)($,)&!!

>4('&A&'&!%(775!A&7+>+A&5!(!75!%&?($>&+$(!)(>),57(!>)(>>5K!!

:5;(77! >(?@*5! &$A5))&! 4*($%(*(! %5! >,@&)+! 4+>&-&+$(! 5! A5;+*(! %&!

6,(>)3,7)&?5B! ?5! 4(*! '+?4*($%(*(! )57(! >'(7)5! %+@@&5?+! '<&(%(*'&! '+>5!

;+**(@@(!%&*(!7(CC(*(B!'+?(!&!4+'<&!'<(!;&!'&!>+$+!>+AA(*?5)&!<5$$+!A5))+B!

6,(>)5!A*5>(!'+?(!,$5!>+*)5!%&!)(>&!?()5TA&7+>+A&'5!'<(!>;57,)5!&!4*+@7(?&!

%(775! A&7+>+A&5! &$! A5;+*(! %(&! >,+&! )(>)&K! #$! '<(! '+>5! '+$>&>)(*(@@(! ,$5! )57(!

4*+4+>)5s!8(?@*(*(@@(!,$5!4+>&-&+$(!57!'+$A&$(!)*5!75!@5$57&)=!b),))&!$+&!

5''(%&5?+!5775!A&7+>+A&5!)*5?&)(!&!>,+&!)(>)&!(!75!A&7+>+A&5!>)(>>5!>&!>+>)5$-&5!

&$!(>>&T!(!&7!4*&?+!45>>+!%&!,$!*5C&+$5?($)+!)(>+!5!&$%&;&%,5*(!'<(!)&4+!%&!

)(>)+!>&5!6,(77+!A&7+>+A&'+B!',&!6,&$%&!>5*(@@(!5!>,5!;+7)5!45*5%+>>57?($)(!

*&'<&(>)+!%&!A+*$&*(!5*C+?($)&!(!&%($)&A&'5*(!()*G1.8,!(!'+$)($,)&!b4*+4*&+!

6,(77&!'<(!>(?@*5;5!>;57,)5*(T!4(*!?+>)*5*(!&$;('(!'<(!)&4+!%&!()*(),.-6!

%(@@5!4+>>(%(*(!&7!)(>)+!A&7+>+A&'+!4(*!(>>(*(!*&'+$+>'&,)+!)57(K!Q+$!D!,$!

'5>+! +! ,$5! )*5>',*5)(--5! '<(! 6,(>)+! )&4+! %&! 5*C+?($)5-&+$&! 57! *&C,5*%+!

%(77(! '5*5))(*&>)&'<(! 4*+4*&(! %(&! )(>)&! A&7+>+A&'&! >&5$+! &$;('(! 5>>($)&! $(7!

4*+>&(C,+! %(7! )(>)+! %&! :5;(77B! (! '<(! 75! >,5! 5AA(*?5-&+$(! *&?5$C5! 6,5>&!

&>+75)5B!,$5!*54&%5!$+)5-&+$(!'<(!5!;+7)(!D!>)5)5!)*5>',*5)5B!+!'<(!&$!57)*&!

'5>&!<5!A5))+!>e!'<(!>&!>&5$+!7(;5)(!'*&)&'<(!?+7)+!$())(!'+$)*+!6,(>)5!&%(5!

(22)

! .R!

*&)($,)5!@&--5**5!+!$+$!>+>)5$-&5)5!5%(C,5)5?($)("SB!+!4*(>5!'+?(!'<&5*+!

>(C$57(!%(775!'+$A,>&+$(!(!'5+>!%&!,$!)(>)+!(!%&!,$!4($>&(*+!4,*!*&)($,)+!

?+7)+! +*&C&$57(.RK! Q(7! 7(CC(*(! &$! 6,(>)+! ?+%+! 75! >,5! 5AA(*?5-&+$(! >&! D! 5!

?&+! 45*(*(! >+))+;57,)+! &7! '+?47(>>+B! >(44,*! @*(;(B! %&>'+*>+! '<(! $(77(!

4*&?&>>&?(!45C&$(!%(7!7&@*+!;&($(!>;+7)+!57!*&C,5*%+B!>,!',&!>&!D!>+AA(*?5)+!

8)(4<($!E,7<577!$(7!>,+!5*)&'+7+!`&$P.20/,&$-*$_.<,&4"B!'+>e!'+?(!7(!57)*(!

*&A7(>>&+$&! )5$C($-&57&! 5! 6,(>)+! )(?5! '<(! >&! )*+;5$+! &$! 57)*(! >,(! +4(*(K!

E,7<577! &$%&;&%,5! $(775! 6,(>)&+$(! %(773&$&-&+! %(775! A&7+>+A&5! (! %(7! )(>)+!

A&7+>+A&'+!,$+!%(C7&!>$+%&!%(7!4($>&(*+!%&!:5;(77B!4*+4*&+!4(*'<i!D!'+$!(>>5!

'<(!:5;(77!>&!4*(>($)5B!D!73(>4*(>>&+$(!%&!,$!>,+!%(>&%(*&+!'<(!7+!&$)*+%,'(B!

?5!,$!%(>&%(*&+!57!45>>5)+!'+?(!'<&5*&>'(!&7!)(?4+!%(7!;(*@+!,>5)+!$(775!

A*5>(!%&!c<+!;+7,)+!&$)($%(*(!75!A&7+>+A&5dB!(!'+?(!$+)5!E,7<577j!!

Il tem po passato im plica fortem ente che non sia più posseduto da tale desiderio, o alm eno che non è più a proprio agio al riguardo, che quindi è qualcosa da cui

ha ottenuto, o desidera ottenere, una certa

prospettiva; senza voler screditare questa sua idea, fa nascere un sospetto al riguardo, conferm ato dalla sua descrizione di sé com e qualcuno che “insiste” sulle R icerche com e testo filosofico.22

235AA(*?5-&+$(!%&!:5;(77!c5!A5;+*(d!%(&!)(>)&!)*+;5!%,$6,(!&7!>,+!>&C$&A&'5)+!

>+7+!$(775!4*+>4())&;5!'<(!<5!\C&=]!C($(*5)+!(!'+$)&$,5!5!C($(*5*(B!(!'<(!C7&!

<5!+))($,)+!*&C,5*%+!&7!>,+!>)(>>+!>)&7(!%&!4($>&(*+!(!>'*&)),*5!T!C*5-&(!5775!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

19!:A*K!F7(?&$CB!_K!^D.$\-'-.$*2$fD,1*/*(DWB$H&$F&?,-'-,*&$-*$'$P.'7,&<$,&$^D)..$f')-/$*2$

\-'&1.W$>'?.11;/$^D.$>1',8$*2$P.'/*&!B!I,'a$(77!X$&;(*>&)9!Y*(>>B!2(W&>@,*C!"SS/B!4K!.0K!

20!H&-D*&W$R.&&WL!k&?(>!2&)(*5*9!8,447(?($)B!"V!54*&7(!"SVRB!4K!00K!

21!E,7<577B!8K!`&$P.20/,&$^*$_.<,&B!&$!U++%?5$B!_K!\(%K]!>*&-.&7,&<$=,-D$\-'&1.W$>'?.11B!!

opA+*%!X$&;(*>&)9!Y*(>>B!Q(W!`+*a!.RR1B!44K!..T/NK!

22!&@&%(?!4K!.M!

(23)

! ."!

'545'&)=! '<(! <5$$+! &! $+>)*&! %(>&%(*&! %&! *&7(;5*'&! $+&! >)(>>&K! :<&5?(*f! )57(!

4*+>4())&;5!75!c4*+>4())&;5!)(>),57(d!$(&!'+$A*+$)&!%(775!A&7+>+A&5B!'<(!'+?(!

;(%*(?+!'+$)&($(!&$!>i!C&=!,$!>,4(*5?($)+!*&>4())+!5773+44+>&-&+$(!%5!',&!

>(?@*5! +*&C&$5*>&B! 4+&'<i! 54*(! (! *&'+$A&C,*5! 75! 6,(>)&+$(! %(77(!

5*C+?($)5-&+$&! ',&! 4,*(! >(?@*5! +44+*>&K! Y(*! &$&-&5*(! 5! %(7&$(5*75! $+$!

%+@@&5?+!A5*!57)*+!'<(!5$%5*(!+7)*(!6,(>)5!4*&?5!&%(5!%&!:5;(77B!(!)*+;5*(!

'+$A(*?5)+!&7!>+>4())+!%&!E,7<577!4+'+!+7)*(!$(7!)(>)+P!$+)&5?+!&$A5))&!'<(!

6,(>)5! 4*&?5! '+$)*544+>&-&+$(! A*5! 4*+@7(?&! (! )(>)&! D! '+?(! >(! ;($&>>(!

?($+B! +! ?(C7&+B! 6,(77(! '<(! >(?@*5;5$+! %,(! 57)(*$5)&;(! (>'7,>&;(! >,7!

$+>)*+! ?+%+! %&! &$)($%(*(! 75! A&7+>+A&5B! >(?@*5$+! 7(C5*>&! &$! ?5$&(*5!

5>>+7,)5?($)(!+*&C&$57(j!!

Q uesto [la “prospettiva tesuale”] per m e significa che il contributo di un filosofo (o com unque di un pensatore originale) in m ateria di filosofia non è da intendersi com e l’apporto, o il contributo a un insiem e di problem i dati, benché tanto gli storici quanto i non- storici siano inclini a credere il contrario23.

#7! >,+! )($)5)&;+q%(>&%(*&+! %&! 5%+))5*(! 75! c4*+>4())&;5! )(>),57(d! 4(*! %5*!

'+$)+! %(775! A&7+>+A&5! $+$! ;,+7(! %,$6,(! %&>'+>)5*>&! %5773&%(5! '<(! (>>5! >&5!

'+>)&),&)5! %5! '(*)(! )(?5)&'<(B! ?5! 4&,))+>)+! >&! +44+$(! 5773&%(5! '<(! (>>(!

>&5$+!7'-.B!'<(!'+>)&),&>'5$+!,$!&$>&(?(!%(A&$&)+!(!%(A&$&@&7(!,$5!;+7)5!4(*!

),))(! %&! 6,(>)&+$&! '<(! %(?5*'5$+! $())5?($)(! '+>5! '+$)&! '+?(! A&7+>+A&5K!

:5;(77!>(?@*5!6,&!5AA(*?5*(!'<(!c'<(!'+>5!>&5d!,$!4*+@7(?5!A&7+>+A&'+!D!5!

>,5! ;+7)5! ,$! 4*+@7(?5! A&7+>+A&'+B! ,$! 4*+@7(?5! '(.)-*B! 6,(7! )&4+! %&!

4*+@7(?5! '<(! +C$&! )(>)+! A&7+>+A&'+! &$! >(! >)(>>+! (75@+*5! (%! (>(?47&A&'5K!

G+@@&5?+! 577+*5! '+?4*($%(*(! '+?(! 75! c4*+>4())&;5! )(>),57(d! 4+*)&! 5!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

23!:5;(77B!8B!5'$),/+*(.)-'$7.11;*)7,&'),*$\'&)K]!4K.1B!&7!'+*>&;+!D!%&!:5;(77!>)(>>+K!

(24)

! ..!

6,(775!'<(!'<&5?&5?+!,$5!c4*+>4())&;5!%(77354(*),*5dB!'+?4*($%(*(!'+?(!

75!%&?($>&+$(!'<(!>+4*5!5;(;5?+!%(A&$&)+!cA+*?57(dCD!%(775!A&7+>+A&5!T&!)(>)&!

&$! 5$)&)(>&! 5! '+$)($,)&! %&>)&$)&;&! +! 4*+@7(?&T! >&! )*5>A&C,*&B! %&! ?+%+! '<(! &!

)(>)&! $+$! >&5$+! 4&J! ,$5! >+75! A+*?5B! @($>e! &7! ?(--+! (! &7! 7,+C+! &$! ',&! +C$&!

5,)+*(! '+$)*&@,&>'(! 5! %()(*?&$5*(! '<(! '+>5! >&5! 75! A&7+>+A&5! (! &! >,+&!

4*+@7(?&K! Y(*! A5*! '&f! %+@@&5?+! &$%5C5*(! '<(! )&4+! %&! )(>)&! >&5$+! 6,(77&!

A&7+>+A&'&B!'+?(!(>>&!&$)(*5C&>'5$+!(!'+$)*&@,&>'5$+!5775!7+*+!'+?4*($>&+$(!

(! 5775! 7+*+! '*&)&'5B! 5! >,''(>>&;(! %()(*?&$5-&+$&! %(&! 7+*+! >)(>>&! )(?&K! 25!

c4*+>4())&;5! )(>),57(dB! &$! 5445*($-5! +44+>)5! 577(! 5*C+?($)5-&+$&! (! 5&!

4*+@7(?&B! '&! *&4+*)5! %,$6,(! 5! 6,(>)&B! >(44,*! 544,$)+! 5773&$)(*$+! %&! ,$5!

%&;(*>5! *(75-&+$(! b! %+@@&5?+! &$)*54*($%(*(! )57(! 4*+>4())&;5B! '+>e! %5!

4+)(*75!>,4(*5*(B!(''+!75!>4&(C5-&+$(!%(7!)(?4+!45>>5)+!'+$!',&!:5;(77!>&!

7(C5!5!(>>5K!

23&$(>)*&'5@&7&)=! A*5! 4*+@7(?&! A&7+>+A&'&B! &! )(>)&! '<(! 7&! (>4*&?+$+! (! '&f! '<(!

4+>>&5?+! &?45*5*(! %5! (>>&! >&! (*5! C&=! &?4+>)5! 4+'+! 4*&?5! *&>4())+! 577(!

4*('(%($)&!'&)5-&+$&B!$(7!4*&?+!45*5C*5A+!%&!^D.$>1',8$*2$P.'/*&L$6,5$%+!

45*75$%+! %(! 7(! P,+.)+D.! :5;(77! 5AA(*?5B! '+?(! 5@@&5?+! ;&>)+! 4+'+! >+4*5B!

'<(!!

il m odo in cui quest’opera è scritta è interno a ciò che essa insegna, il che significa che non possiam o com prendere il m odo (chiam iam olo il m etodo) prim a di aver com preso l’opera25.

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

.0!n,&!4(*!tA+*?5d!<+!&$!?($)(!6,57'+>5!'<(!5$)&'&45!C&=!,$35))($-&+$(!57!?+%+!%&!

>'*&)),*5B!577(!>,5!6,57&)=!>)&7&>)&'<(!(!6,&$%&!(>)()&'<(P!)57(!$+-&+$(!%&!A+*?5!'*(%+!'<(!

)*+;&!,$!&$'+$)*+!(>)*(?5?($)(!+*&C&$57(!&$!:5;(77!'+$!6,(775!%&!A+*?5!%&?+>)*5)&;5B!%&!

4*+;(!cA+*?57&dK!O%K!+7)*(!!

25!:5;(77B!8K!5'$),/+*(.)-'$7.11;*)7,&'),*$\'&)K]!4K!.1!

(25)

! ./!

n,(>)5! &%(5! '<(! >+7+! &7! )(>)+! &$! 6,5$)+! )57(B! 73+4(*5! 4*(>5! $(775! >,5!

&$)(*(--5! %&! A+*?5! (! '+$)($,)+B! 4+>>5! (>>(*(! '+?4*(>5B! >(?@*5! 4*+4*&+!

,$5! *&>4+>)5! 5773+@&(-&+$(B! 5! ',&! :5;(77! >)(>>+! %=! ;+'(B! '<(! 4+)*(@@(!

5'',>5*7+! %&! $+$! 4+)(*! %&>)&$C,(*(! &! )(>)&! A&7+>+A&'&! \%5! 6,(77&! '<(! $+$! 7+!

>+$+]B!>(!$+$!'+$'($)*5$%+>&!>,77(!6,(>)&+$&!'<(!(>>&!%&>',)+$+K!^C7&!>)(>>+!

A5! &$)(*;($&*(! ,$! &4+)()&'+! &$)(*7+',)+*(B! '<(! %+4+! 7(! >,(! 5AA(*?5-&+$&! 5!

A5;+*(!%(775!A&7+>+A&5!'+?(!&$>&(?(!%&!)(>)&B!>+))+7&$(5!'<(!l+;;&5?($)(!$+$!

),))&!&!)(>)&!>+$+!A&7+>+A&'&B!?5!>+7)5$)+!6,(77&!'<(!4*('&>5?($)(!'+$)($C+$+!

4*+@7(?&! %&! ,$! '(*)+! C($(*(um.MK! k57(! +@&(-&+$(! '+>e! 475,>&@&7(! >(?@*5!

&$>&>)(*(! $,+;5?($)(! >,773+44+>&-&+$(! '<(! :5;(77! >)(>>+! <5! 5%+4(*5)+B!

'+$)(>)5$%+C7&! (! &?4,)5$%+C7&! 73&$>($>5)(--5! %(773544*+''&+! %&! ,$5!

c4*+>4())&;5! )(>),57(dB! '<(! >(?@*5! &$%&'5*(! ,$5! 2*)8'$ ;,+)5B! &7! 4,*+! (!

>(?47&'(! )(>)+B! '<(! &$;('(! $('(>>&)5! %&! +*&-.&0-,! 4(*! (>>(*(! *&'+$+>'&,)+!

$(775! >,5! A&7+>+A&'&)=P! ?5! :5;(77! $(7! 7(C5*($ 8*7*$ (%$ *(.)'! $(775!

'+?4*($>&+$(! %(77(! P,+.)+D.$ Q,1*/*2,+D.! 5>>,$)(! '+?(! (>(?475*(!

*544*(>($)5)&;+! %(&! )(>)&! A&7+>+A&'&B! $(773&$>&>)(*(! >,&! *544+*)&! %&! $('(>>&)=!

A*5!?()+%+!(!&$>(C$5?($)+!%&!,$3+4(*5B!>(?@*5!*&A&,)5*(!75!%&>)&$-&+$(!A*5!

&7!A&7+>+A&'+!(!&7!$+$!A&7+>+A&'+!'+>e!'+?(!D!A+*?,75)5!&$!6,(>)5!+@&(-&+$(!'<(!

C7&! ;&($(! *&;+7)5K! ^>>5! &$A5))&! 5%+4(*5! (! &?4&(C5! 4*+4*&+! 73+44+>&-&+$(! A*5!

,$!)(>)+!A&7+>+A&'+!(!&!)(?&!'<(!(>>+!5AA*+$)5B!)*5''&5$%+75!4(*f!%57!75)+!%(&!

4*+@7(?&B!%(&!)(?&B!'+$>&%(*5)&!&!;(*&!(7(?($)&!%&>)&$)&;&!4(*!&%($)&A&'5*(!75!

A&7+>+A&5K!n,(>)5!+44+>&-&+$(!)(>)&T)(?&!5!4*&?5!;&>)5!>(?@*5!75!>)(>>5!'<(!

)*5''&5! :5;(77B! ?5! 75! %&AA(*($-5! 5*C+?($)5)&;5! D! '<(! (C7&! 75! 7(CC(! &$;('(!

%5$%+! 75! 4*&+*&)=! 5&! )(>)&B! %57! 75)+! (! %57! ;(*>+! %(775! )(>),57&)=K! #7! >,+!

5>>,?(*(!75!c4*+>4())&;5!)(>),57(d!D!&$A5))&!,$!?+%+!4(*!>,4(*5*(!6,(>)5!

'+$)*544+>&-&+$(B! '+?(! >(! >+7+! 45*)($%+! %57! )(>)+! A&7+>+A&'+! &$! 6,5$)+!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

26!&@&%(?!4K.M!

(26)

! .0!

)(>)+B! %57! >,+! (>>(*(! ,$3+4(*5B! &7! '<(! ;(%*(?+! ;,+7! %&*(! (>>(*(!

(>>($-&57?($)(! (>>(*(! %&! ,$! 5,)+*(! (! %&! ,$5! >+CC())&;&)=B! 4+)(>>&?+!

C,5%5C$5*(!75!4+>>&@&7&)=!%&!>,4(*5*(!6,(>)5!A*5)),*5!A*5!>)&7(!(!'+$)($,)+B!

A*5!(>)()&'5!(!4*+@7(?&K!!

!

?@AC+=.+>)$>%0.$)#7+&*0+#*5#%+8)0%5%8)>%+>%3*+>%"&)()%"*+

&*00.+5'.+>%3/$*"5)%"*+*+./*$#'$.A++

Y(*! (>47&'&)5*(! %,$6,(! &7! 45>>5CC&+! %5775! c4*+>4())&;5! )(>),57(d! 5! ! 6,(775!

%(773c54(*),*5d! %+@@&5?+! '54&*(! 4*+4*&+! &7! 7(C5?(! '&*'+75*(B! %&! '+T

%(A&$&-&+$(!(!'+T'+?4*($>&+$(B!A*5!?+%+!(!'+$)($,)+!%&!,$3+4(*5B!A*5!)(>)+!

(!'+$)($,)+K!25!6,(>)&+$(!%(775!'&*'+75*&)=!D!&$A5))&!'($)*57(!$(775!A&7+>+A&5!

%&!:5;(77!4+&'<i!75!>,5!D!,$35$57&>&!'<(!>&!4+$(!5773,&-.)&*!%&!'&f!'<(!%(;(!

>4&(C5*(B! $+$! '(*'5! A+$%5-&+$&! +! C&,>)&A&'5-&+$&! (>)(*$(! 4(*! &7! >,+! >)(>>+!

4($>&(*+!(!4(*!7(!>,(!4*+4+>)(B!4&,))+>)+!>&!?,+;(!;(*>+!75!%&*(-&+$(!%(775!

+*8().&/,*&.! (! %(7! ),+*&*/+,8.&-*! %&! '&f! '<(! A5''&5?+! $(7! %&>'+*>+!

A&7+>+A&'+B!,$!*&'+$+>'&?($)+!%(77(!$+>)*(!>)(>>(!4*5)&'<(K!k57(!544*+''&+B!

'<(! %('&%(! %&! '+&$;+7C(*(! >(! >)(>>+! (! 75! 4*+4*&5! 4+>&-&+$(! ($,$'&5)&;5!

'+?(! >+CC())+! (! +CC())+! %(77(! 4*+4*&(! *&A7(>>&+$&B! A5! >e! '<(! 75! $+-&+$(! %&!

>4&(C5-&+$(!'<(!6,&!&$)(*;&($(!$+$!>&5!%,$6,(!6,(775!1,&.').!'<(!%&?+>)*5!

(! C&,>)&A&'5B! ?5! 4&,))+>)+! ,$! '&*'+75*(! (! 5,)+T*&A7(>>&;+! &$)*(''&+! %&!

./.8(1,2,+'9,*&.$(!()*(*/-'$'<(!&7!$+>)*+!'+$'($)*5*'&!>,7!*544+*)+!A*5!)(>)&!

(!4*+@7(?&B!>,77(!7+*+!54(*),*(B!;,+7(!&$%5C5*(K!

Q+$! 5! '5>+! C&=! $(7! 4*&?+! 45*5C*5A+! %&! >1',8$ *2$ P.'/*&B! '<(! %&>',)(! (%!

(>5?&$5! &! ;5*&! 4+>>&@&7&! 544*+''&! 577(! P,+.)+D.$ Q,1*/*2,+D.B! &7! )(?5! %(775!

'&*'+75*&)=B! +! ?(C7&+! 5$'+*5! %(7735,)+T*&A7(>>&;&)=! %(7! )(>)+! \(! %(7!

*5C&+$5?($)+]! A&7+>+A&'+B! '+?45*(! &$! ?5$&(*5! %()(*?&$5$)(P! 6,&! 75!

Riferimenti

Documenti correlati

Tale correzione avverrebbe nel corso del tempo, attraverso la ripetuta applicazione delle norme a diversi casi concreti e la definizione di criteri interpretativi, eccezioni,

L’attiva loro partecipazione al finanziamento dei piani autarchici sarà più che largamente assicurata dai forti bisogni di credito d’esercizio da parte delle imprese autarchiche,

[r]

240/2010 per il settore concorsuale 06/D2 – Endocrinologia, nefrologia e scienze della alimentazione e del benessere, Settore scientifico-disciplinare MED/13 – Endocrinologia,

u Nella seconda fase siamo stati impegnati in esperienze di osservazione attiva, visita e stage in tre ambiti della filiera e della gestione dell’ambiente e del territorio..

Francesco Leccese Tutor AUSL 5 Pisa:

Figure 15. A) Assembly of the SWCNT electrically-contacted glucose oxidase electrode. B) AFM image of the GOx recon- stituted on the FAD-functionalized SWCNTs (about 50 nm)

[r]