JournalofNeuroradiology(2014)41,153—167
Availableonlineat
ScienceDirect
www.sciencedirect.comREVIEW
Magnetic
resonance
features
of
pyogenic
brain
abscesses
and
differential
diagnosis
using
morphological
and
functional
imaging
studies:
A
pictorial
essay
Carmine
Franco
Muccio
a,
Ferdinando
Caranci
b,
Felice
D’Arco
b,∗,
Alfonso
Cerase
c,
Luca
De
Lipsis
d,
Gennaro
Esposito
a,
Enrico
Tedeschi
b,
Cosma
Andreula
eaUnitofNeuroradiology,DepartmentofNeuroscience,Hospital‘‘GaetanoRummo’’,Benevento,Italy
bUnitofNeuroradiology,DepartmentofAdvancedBiomedicalSciences,University‘‘FedericoII’’,Naples,
Italy
cUnitofNeuroradiology,DepartmentofNeuroscience,University‘‘SantaMariaalleScotte’’,Siena,Italy
dDepartmentofCriticalCareMedicine,Hospital‘‘Fatebenefratelli’’,Benevento,Italy
eUnitofRadiologyandNeuroradiology,AntheaHospital,Bari,Italy
Availableonline21June2014
KEYWORDS Cerebralabscesses; Pyogenicabscesses; Magneticresonance; PWI; DWI; MR-spectroscopy
Summary Theaimofthispaperistoillustratethepotentialofmagneticresonanceimaging (MRI)indiagnosis,differentialdiagnosis,treatmentplanningandevaluationoftherapy effec-tivenessofpyogenicbrainabscesses,throughtheuseofmorphological(orconventional)and functional(oradvanced)sequences.ConventionalMRIstudyisusefulfortheidentificationof lesions,todeterminethelocationandmorphologyandallowsacorrecthypothesisofnature inthemosttypicalcases.However,thedifferentialdiagnosisfromotherbrainlesions,such as non-pyogenicabscesses or necrotictumors (high-grade gliomas andmetastases) isoften onlypossiblethroughtheuseoffunctionalsequences,asthemeasurementofdiffusionwith apparent diffusioncoefficient(DWI-ADC),protonmagnetic resonancespectroscopy(1H-MRS)
andperfusionweightedimaging (PWI),whichcomplementthemorphologicalsequences and provideessentialinformationonstructural,metabolicandhemodynamiccharacteristics allow-inggreaterneuroradiologicalconfidence.ModerndiagnosticMRIofpyogenic brainabscesses cannotbe separated fromknowledge, integrationandproperuse ofthemorphological and functionalsequences.
©2014ElsevierMassonSAS.Allrightsreserved.
∗Correspondingauthor.UnitofNeuroradiologyUniversty‘‘FedericoII’’,viaPansini5,80131Naples,Italy.
E-mailaddress:darcofel@gmail.com(F.D’Arco).
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.neurad.2014.05.004
Introduction
Cerebralabscessisalocalizedinfectionofthecentral ner-voussystem (CNS).Itisformed byacentralnecroticarea surroundedbyanexternalwall(collagen,granulationtissue, macrophages,gliosis).
Abscesses account for 1—2% of brain occupying space lesionsinwesterncountriesand8%indevelopingcountries [1].Theyarefrequentinadultswhileinonly15—30%ofthe cases,theyinvolveyoungpatients(<15years)[2—5].
Pyogenic brain abscesses are not common, accounting for one third of all the cerebral abscesses [6]. They are causedbycerebral disseminationofbacteriacoming from neighbouringinfections (sinusitis,otitis,mastotiitis)or by hematogenousspreadofaremoteinfection(sepsis); how-ever, in approximately 40% of cases, the primary site of infectionremainsunknown.
OthercausesofcerebralbacterialdisseminationinCNS arecranio-facialtrauma(withpenetrationofforeignbodies orbonefragments),meningitisandneurosurgery(iatrogenic infections).
Clinicalfeaturesaredifferentaccordingtothesiteofthe abscess.Diagnosisischallengingandimaginghasaprimary role in differentiating brain abscesses from other lesions
that can have similar clinical spectrum. MR is the imag-ingmodalityofchoicefordiagnosisandfollow-upofbrain abscesses.
The aim of this paper is to analyze the role of combined use of morphological and advanced magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) techniques (diffusion weighted imaging—DWI/ADC; perfusion weighted imaging—PWI; spectroscopy—1H-MRS)inthediagnosis,differential
diagno-sis,treatmentplanningandfollow-upofpyogenicabscesses. Anextensivereviewoftheliteratureisalsoprovided.
Etiology
and
pathogenesis
Bacteriaresponsibleforbrainabscessescanbebothaerobic (mostfrequentlyStaphylococcus,Streptococcus and Pneu-mococcus)andanaerobic[7].Itisalsoimportanttohighlight thatoftentherearedifferentkindsofbacteriainvolvedin theformationofanabscess.
Themostcommonlocalizationofapyogenicabscessin the brain is the supratentorial region, in the subcortical whitematter,especially,iftheycomefromhematogeneous spreadofadistantinfection(Figs.1and4)[8,9].
Abscessessecondarytomiddle hear otitisaretypically locatedinthetemporallobeorinthecerebellum(Fig.2).
Figure 1 A—F: supratentorial pyogenic abscess in the gray-white junction: T1-weighted (A), T2-weighted (B), gadolinium-enhancedT1-weighted(Gd-MR)(C),DWI(b=1000)(D),ADC(E)andPWI mapofCBV(F)MRimages.Thecapsuleoftheabscess ishyperintenseinT1-weightedimage(A), partiallyhypointenseinT2-weightedimage (B)withsurroundingvasogenicoedema. Gd-MRimageshowsaring-enhancingmass.ThecentralcomponentofthelesionshowshighsignalintensityinDWIimage(D),and hypointensesignalinADCmap,findingsthatareconsistentwithrestricteddiffusion(ADC=0.440×10−3mm2/s).AtPWI,theCBV
Magneticresonancefeaturesofpyogenicbrainabscessesanddifferentialdiagnosis 155
Figure2 A—F:pyogenicabscessintherightcerebellarhemisphere:T2-weighted(A),T1-weighted(B)gadolinium-enhanced T1-weighted(Gd-MR)(C)magneticresonanceimages,DWI(b=1000)(D),ADCmap(E)andPWImapofCBV(F).Thecapsuleofthe abscessishyperintenseinT2-weightedimage(A),partiallyhyperintenseinT1-weightedimage(B)andshowsenhancementinGd-MR image.ThecentralcomponentofthelesionishyperintenseinT2-weightedimage,hypointenseinT1-weightedimageandshows highsignalintensityinDWIimage(D)andhypointensesignalinADCmap(E),findingsthatareconsistentwithrestricteddiffusion (ADC=0.610×10−3mm2/s).AtPWI,theCBVmap(F)doesnotshowevidenceofincreasedperfusioninthegadolinium-enhancing
rimofthelesion(rCBV=0.9).
Localizationofapyogenicabscessinthebasalgangliais pos-siblebutrare(Fig.3)[6].Furthermore,theabscessisoften anisolatedlesionbut,inimmunocompromised patients,it isfrequentthefindingofmultiplelesions(Fig.4).
Theearlystageofpyogenicinfectioninthebrainiscalled cerebritis,alocalizedandblurredareaofbrain inflamma-tion[10,74].Cerebritisleadstoacerebralabscessinmost ofthecases;thisevolutionconsistsoffourstages:
• earlycerebritis(firststage),fromthe1sttothe3rdday, characterizedbyaninflammatoryresponsewith predom-inanceofpolymorphonuclearleukocytes;
• latecerebritis(secondstage),fromthe4thtothe9thday, inwhichtheimmuneresponseismediatedbylymphocytes andmacrophages;centralnecrosisformationstartswith peripheral neoangiogenesis andpresence of fibroblasts; theneo-formedvesselshavenoblood-brainbarrier; • early encapsulation (third stage),from the 10thto the
13th day, in which there is formation of surrounding peripheralwallwithcentralnecrosis;
• latecapsulestage(forthstage):fromthe14thday, char-acterizedbya matureencapsulate brainabscesswitha widecentralnecroticarea.
Thepresenceofairintotheabscessisnotfrequentandis associatedwithClostridium,Klebsiella,Enterobacter, Pep-tococcusorPseudomonas[75,76].
Clinical
features
and
treatment
Pyogenic abscesses have non-specific symptoms. In early stages,headacheandfeverarethemostcommonsymptoms butthey arenot always present. Notably only 30—55% of patientshave bodytemperature above38.5◦C [11].Focal neurological signs are appreciable in 40—60% of patients depending on the site of the lesion [11]. Complications, notfrequentbutserious,areintraventricularruptureofthe abscessthatleadtodisseminationoftheinfectionandacute hydrocephalus(Fig.5),andduralsinusthrombosis.
There are two possible therapeutic choices in case of pyogenicabscess:medicalorsurgical.
The useofmedicaltherapyalonecan beconsidered in casesofanabscesswith<2.5cmmaximumdiameter, local-izationinnotcriticalareasforthebrainfunction, concomi-tantmeningitis/ependymitisandmultipleabscesses[11].
However, the medical treatment alone is often not enough to eradicate the abscess being necessary the
Figure3 A—N:pyogenicabscessinvolvingtherightnucleo-capsularregion,andfollow-upafterstereotacticneurosurgery aspi-rationandcontinuedantibiotictheraphy.Atclinicalpresentation,theabscessshowsringenhancementongadoliniumT1-weighted image(A),highsignalintensityonDWIimageofthecentralcomponent(B)andlowvaluesonADCmap(0.434×10−3mm2/s)
con-sistentwithrestricteddiffusion(C).Follow-up,afterstereotacticaspiration,showsreductioninthesizeoftheabscesscavityon gadolinium-enhancedT1-weightedimages(D),dishomogeneuspatternhyper-andhypointenseonDWI(E)withincreasedofADC values(1.03×10−3mm2/s)(F).Onemonth(G,H,I)and3months(L,M,N)follow-upstudies,duringantibiotictherapy,showfurther
decreaseinsizeoftheabscessonT1-weightedimages(G,L),lowsignalintensityonDWI(H,M)andhighvaluesonADCmap(I,N), suggestingresolutionoftheabscess(ADCvaluesatthelastfollow-up:1.51×10−3mm2/s).
Magneticresonancefeaturesofpyogenicbrainabscessesanddifferentialdiagnosis 157
Figure4 A—F:multiplepyogenic abscessesinimmunocompromisedpatient locatedatthegraymatterjunction:T2-weighted (A),T1-weighted(B)andgadolinium-enhancedT1-weighted(Gd-MR)(C)magneticresonanceimages,DWI(b=1000)(D),ADCmap (E)and1H-MRS(TE=144ms).ThecentralcomponentoftheabscessesshowsdishomogeneoushyperintensitysignalinT2-weighted
image(A).AtGd-MRimage,(C)therearesmalladjacentsatellitelesionsbyabscesses(arrows)andathickenedcapsuleonthegray matter(smallarrow).TheabscessesshowhyperintensesignalinDWI(D)lowsignalinADCmap(E),findingsthatareconsistentwith restricteddiffusion.The1H-MRS(F)fromtheabscesscavityshowsresonancerepresentingaminoacids(AA),lipids/lactate(Lip/L)
andacetate(Ac).
drainage of the necroticpart or the totalexcision of the mass[73].
Magnetic
resonance
imaging
MRI shows pyogenic abscessas a round/oval-shapedmass witha central areaof suppurative necrosis anda periph-eral capsule. The central necroticarea is hypointense to thecerebralwhitematteronT1-weighted(w)and hyperin-tenseonT2-wimages(Fig.6).However,thesefeaturesare notalwayspresent,beingpossible,insomecases,avariable T2signalintensity(Fig.4).
The external capsule appears typically as a complete hypointenseonT2-wandhyperintenseonT1-wimagesrim (Fig.6)[8,12,13].TheshortT1andT2oftherimseemto beduerespectivelytothepresenceofcollagen fibresand tomacrophagesreleasingfreeradicalswithaparamagnetic effect[13].Itisalsopossiblethattheexternalcapsuleshows a non-typicalsignal, being hyperintense onT2-w and iso-hypointenseonT1-wimages(Fig.2)[8,12,13].Conversely, thesurroundingvasogenicoedemaappearshypointenseon T1-wandhyperintenseonT2-wimages(Fig.6).After intra-venousinjection ofcontrastmediun(gadolinium),abscess showsatypicalperipheralthinandregular‘‘ring enhance-ment’’thatcorrespondstotheT2hypointenserim(Fig.6)
[12]. It is important to note that the peripheral contrast enhancementcanbestrongerintheportionoftheabscess closesttothegreymatter,becauseofthestronger inflam-matoryreactionduetothebiggervascularizationofthegrey matter[13].
The presence of a satellite abscess(closely associated withaprimaryabscess)thatgivesapolylobateappearance tothemassisalsopossible(Fig.4)[14].
After surgical and/or medical therapy, the degree of masseffect,surroundingedema,andcontrastenhancement decreases slightlybut does notchange substantially com-paredwiththepre-treatmentstudies[15].
Advanced
MR
techniques
DWI-ADC, 1H-MRS and PWI, together with morphological
MRI,cangiveinformationabout structural,metabolicand hemodynamicfeaturesof abscesseshelpingindifferential diagnosis.
Diffusionweightedimaging
DWI gives a critical support in the diagnosis of cerebral abscesses.Apyogenic abscess is typicallyhyperintense in
Figure5 A—F: hydrocephalus followingintraventricular ruptureofpyogenic abscess: T2-weightedcoronal (A) andaxial (B), gadolinium-enhancedT1-weightedaxial(C)andcoronal(D)magneticresonanceimages,DWI(b=1000)(E),ADCmap(F).In T2-weightedimages(A,B),thelateralventriclesaredilatatedandthediluteintraventricularpusshowshypointesesignal(whitearrow) thatislessintenseinbrightnesscomparedwiththatofthecerebrospinalfluid(CSF)(blackarrows).Thediluteintraventricular pusisisointenseinT1-weightedimage(shortwhitearrow)(C),hyperintenseinDWI(shortblackarrows)(E)andlowvalueofADC (0.570×10−3mm2/s)onthemap.Gadolinium-enhancedT1-weightedcoronalimage(D)showsependymitisfollowingruptureof
abscess.
DWI,withlowvaluesonADCmaps(Figs.1,2and4)because ofthewaterrestrictioninthecentralnecroticarea contain-ingproteins,bacterialandcellulardebris[15—19].
ADCvaluesofthenecroticareainpyogenicabscessesare reportedinliteraturebetween0.28and0.73×10−3mm2/s
[8,20].However,thedifferentconcentrationofbacteriaand whitecells,thedifferentkindofbacteriainvolvedandthe immuneresponseofthehost canleadtoawiderrangeof
ADCvaluesinthecentralnecroticarea[21];indeed,there aresomecasesofpyogenicabscesseswithhighADCvalues inthepurulentarea[22].
DWIis alsouseful toimprovethediagnosisof an intra-ventricular rupture of a pyogenic abscess. The purulent fluid appears hyperintensein DWI withlow valueson the ADC maps in comparison with cerebrospinalfluid (Fig. 7) [23].
Figure6 A—C:cerebellarpyogenicabscess:T2-weighted(A),T1-weighted(B)andgadolinium-enhancedT1-weightedMRimages. InT2-weightedimage,(A)thecoreoftheabscessishyperintense(asterisk)andthehypointensesignalofthecapsule(whitearrow) iseaslydistinguishablefromperipheral vasogenicedemathatappears hyperintense(blackarrow). In T1-weightedimage after administratione.g.ofgadolinium(C)image,theabscessshowsanenhancedregularandthincapsule.
Magneticresonancefeaturesofpyogenicbrainabscessesanddifferentialdiagnosis 159
Figure7 A—F:intraventricular ruptureofpyogenic abscess:T1-weighted (A), T2-weighted(B)andgadolinium-enhanced T1-weighted(C)images,PWImapofCBV(D),DWI(b=1,000)(E),ADCmap(F)MRimages.AtPWI,theCBVmap(D)doesnotshow evidenceofincreasedperfusioninthegadolinium-enhancingrimofthelesion.Thecentralcoreoftheabscessshowshighsignal intensityinDWIimage(E),andhypointensesignalinADCmap(F),findingsthatareconsistentwithrestricteddiffusionthatextends intotrigoneofthelateralventricle(arrow),signofintraventricularruptureoftheabscess.
SomepaperssuggesttheusefulnessofDWIinthe follow-upofapyogenicabscessduringtreatment[15,24,25].The progressiveincreaseofADCvaluescouldbeanearlierindex of medical response to antibiotics earlier than the size reduction of the lesion and/or the presence of a gap in theperipheralrimenhancementthatarelatesignsofdrug response.HigherADCvaluesinthecentralareaarealso vis-ibleafter neurosurgical aspirationof the central necrotic area(Fig.3).Ontheother hand,constantlowADCvalues overtimewouldbeduetoanineffectivetherapy,andthe recurrenceoflowADCvaluessuggestsrecurrenceofactive disease.
MR-spectroscopy
MR-spectroscopy(1H-MRS)isanon-invasiveanalytical
tech-nique that has been used to study metabolic changes in normal and pathological tissues. Typically, the central necroticareaofpyogenicabscessesshowspeaks correspond-ing to lipids (0.8—1.2ppm), lactate (1.3ppm) and amino acids (0.9ppm), without peaks corresponding to normal spectrumofnervoustissue(suchasN-acetyl-aspartateand choline)[26,27].
Moreover,itispossibletofindpeaksofalanine(1.5ppm), acetate (1.9ppm) and succinate (2.4ppm) [26,27]. The
absence of choline is related to the lack of normal cell membranes,theabsenceofN-acetyl-aspartateisduetothe factthattherearenotfunctioningneuronsintotheabscess (Fig.4)[26].Presenceoflactate,acetateandsuccinateis probablyrelated to bacterial glycolysisand fermentation [27,28].Aminoacidsareproducedfromtheproteolysisdue to enzymes released by neutrophils [20,28—30] and they aretypicalin pyogenic abscesses butnot always present. Inacaseseriesof194patientswithpyogenicabscesses,Pal etal.foundthepresenceofaminoacidpeak(aloneor asso-ciatedwithotherpeaksdescribedabove)in80%ofpatients [31].
1H-MRScouldbeusefulindistinguishingbetween
differ-entbacteriaresponsiblefortheabscessandinchoosingan appropriatetherapy[32].Therearethreedifferentspectra toconsider:
• type A: presence of lactate, amino acids, alanine, acetate,succinateandlipidsrelatedtothepresenceof obligateanaerobeswithorwithoutfacultativeanaerobes; • typeB:presenceoflactate,aminoacidsandoccasionally lipidsrelatedtoobligateaerobesandfacultative anaer-obes;
• typeC:presenceoflactatealone,associatedwith Strep-tococcusandwithtreatedabscesses.
After medical therapy, abscesses show a non-specific peakof lipids and lactate that are also present in cystic tumors[33,34]. Forthis reason,it is criticalto use spec-troscopybeforethemedicaltreatment[33].
Perfusionweightedimaging
Perfusionweighted imaging(PWI)is anMR techniquethat givesinformationaboutcerebral hemodynamics.Injection ofgadoliniumleadstoareductionofT2andT2*signalinthe tissue(becauseofamagneticsusceptibilityeffect)related tothevasculardensity[72].
Therearefew studiesabout PWIinpyogenic abscesses demonstratinglow perfusion(incomparisontothenormal white matter) in the abscess capsule (Figs. 1, 2 and 7). Erdoganetal.[35]describedfourpyogenicabscesseswith a mean cerebral blood volume (rCBV) in the capsule of 0.76±0.12.Muccioetal.[36]describedfiveabscesseswith ameanrCBVof0.72±0.08.Holmesetal.[37]studiedfour abscesseswithameanrCBVof0.79±0.18.Chanetal.[38] found a mean rCBV of 0.45±0.11. Finally, Chiang etal., usinga3Tscan,foundmeanvaluesofrCBVof0.94±0.09 in20pyogenicabscesses[51].
In only one paper, Harris at al [39] found rCBV values higherintheabscesscapsulethaninthenormalwhite mat-ter.
Itispossiblethatperfusionvaluesarerelatedtothestage ofthecapsule.Inearlystage,thevascularizationishigher thaninthelatestageinwhichthefibroblastsaredominant, soexplainingthedifferenceinrCBVvaluesbetweenauthors [40].
Differential
diagnosis
Thedifferentialdiagnosisbetweenpyogenicabscessesand otherbrain lesionswitha‘‘ring-like’’ enhancement,such as other kind of abscesses and necrotic tumors, is not always possible with MRI only. The features of the cap-sule,hypointenseonT2-wandhyperintenseonT1-wimages, witharegularcontrastenhancementareoften enough to distinguish an abscess from a necrotic tumor that show an irregular central cavity and ill-defined margins with nodules. However, the T2 hypointensity of the capsule and the regular contrast enhancement can be present in non-pyogenicabscesses(Mycobacteriumtubercolaris, Toxo-plasma,Aspergillus),insomecasesofnecrotictumorsandin lymphomas [8,12—14,41—45]. The spontaneous peripheral T1hyperintensityistypicalofpyogenicabscessesbutcanbe alsopresentinother lesions,suchasmasswithperipheral hemorrhagiccomponentor withcalcificwall(granulomas, multiple sclerosis plaques, primary brain tumors, metas-tases,non-pyogenicabscesses)[45,46].
InatypicalcasesinwhichtheabscesscapsuleshowsT2 hyperintensityandT1hypo/isointensity,differential diagno-siswithotherlesionsisverydifficultbyusingmorphological MRI,anditcanbeimprovedwithadvancedMRItechniques.
Necroticbraintumors
Necroticbraintumorscanbehigh-gradegliomas(HGGs)and metastases.TheyusuallyhaveaT2hypointenseperipheral
rimbutitisoftennotcompleteasinthepyogenicabscesses. After gadolinium injection, HGGs show non-homogeneous enhancementwithsomenodularareasofenhancement pro-truding in the central cavity (Fig.8). Metastases, on the other hand, canhave a regularrim of enhancement simi-larlytopyogenicabscesses(Fig.9).Asarule,necroticbrain tumorsarehypointense,in thecentralarea,in DWI(with highADCvalues)(Figs.8and9).However,DWI hyperinten-sityandlowADChavebeendescribedinnecroticmetastases from lung, breast, colorectal and testicular cancer, and in bladder transitional cell carcinoma; nevertheless, this seemstobeaveryrarefinding[44,47—49].
Furthermore,an intratumoralhemorrhagecan increase theDWIsignal[50]butthedifferentialdiagnosisiseasyon themorphologicalimagesinwhichbloodhastypicalsignal changesovertime.
On1H-MRS,presenceofaminoacids,acetateand
succi-nateistypicalforcerebralabscess[8,33].
Moreover, HGGs and metastases typically show an increaseofneoangiogenesiswithhighervaluesofrCBVthan abscesses in the periphery of the mass (Figs. 8 and 9) [35—39,51,52].
Finally, using susceptibility weighted imaging (SWI) (a new MR sequence enhancing the paramagnetic propriety of brain tissue), Toh et al. described a ‘‘double rim’’ hypointensitysign presentinmost oftheabscessesandin noneofthenecroticgliomas[70];thiscanbeanother use-fulsigninthedifferentialdiagnosisbetweenabscessesand necrotictumors.
Fungalabscesses
Fungalabscessesarequiterare[54]andtheycanshow,like pyogenicabscesses,a‘‘ring-like’’enhancementanda cen-tralhyperintenseareaonDWIwithlowADCvalues[53,55] (Fig.10).
Some fungal infections (i.e. aspergillosis) can invade brain vessels leading to hemorrhagic strokes that are extremely rarein pyogenic infections [57].The finding of hemorrhagic strokes in basalganglia and/or in thalami in a patient with a primary aspergillosis (lungs, paranasal sinuses,etc.)isstronglysuggestiveofcerebralaspergillosis. Sometimesthecentralcavityoffungalabscesseshas het-erogeneoussignalonT2-wimagesbecauseofthepresence ofhypointenseareaswithrestricteddiffusionandwithout contrastenhancement,representingzonesofactivefungal proliferations[8].
At1H-MRS,fungalabscessesshowpeaksoflipids,lactate
andaminoacidssimilarlytopyogenicabscesses.
Tuberculomaandtubercularabscesses
Tuberculoma typically shows a hypointense T2 peripheral rim and a ‘‘ring-like’’ contrast enhancement after injec-tion of gadolinium [58]. The centre of the lesion shows iso/hypointensity in T1-w images and variable T2 signal relatedtothepresenceofcaseousorliquefactivenecrosis [58,59].
Three different kind of tuberculomas have been describedaccordingtoT2andADCfeatures[60]:
Magneticresonancefeaturesofpyogenicbrainabscessesanddifferentialdiagnosis 161
Figure8 A—F:glioblastomas:T2-weighted(A),T1-weighted(B)andgadolinium-enhancedT1-weighted(Gd-MR)(A)images,DWI (b=1000)(D),ADCmap(E) andmapofCBV(F).TheimagesshowalesionwithhyperintenseinT2(A)andisointenseinT1(B) capsule.AtGd-MRimage(C),thelesionshows arim-enhancing masswithirregularmarginssurroundingvasogenicedema.The centralcomponentofthelesionshowsiso-hyperintensityinDWI(D)andhighsignalintensityintheADCmap(E),findingsthatare consistentwithincreaseddiffusion.AtPWI,theCBVmap(F)showsincreasedperfusionintheGd-enhancingrimofthelesion.
Figure9 A—F:metastasisfromcoloncancer:T2-weigheted(A),T1-weighted(B)andgadolinium-enhancedT1-weighted(Gd-MR) (A)images,DWI(b=1000) (D),ADCmap(E)andmapofCBV(F).TheimagesshowalesionwithaT2-hyperintense(A)and T1-isointense(B)capsule.AtGd-MRimage(C),themetastaticlesionshowsarim-enhancingmasswithregularmargins.Thecentral componentofthelesionshowshypointensityatDWI(D)andhighsignalintensityintheADCmap(E),findingsthatareconsistent withincreaseddiffusion.AtPWI,theCBVmap(F)showsincreasedperfusionintheGd-enhancingrimofthelesion.
Figure10 A—D:multiplefungalabscessesinimmunocompromisedpatient:T2-weighted(A),Gadolinium-enhancedT1-weighted (Gd-RM)(B)images,DWI(b=1000)(C),ADCmap(D).AtGd-MRIimage(B),thelesionsshowrim-enhancingmasses.Thecentral componentofthelesions(arrows)showshighsignalintensityinDWIimage(C),andhypointensesignalinADCmap(D),findingsthat areconsistentwithrestricteddiffusion.
• typeI:hypointensecoreinT2(caseousnecrosis)withhigh ADCvalues(1.24±0.32×10−3mm2/s);
• typeII:slightlyhyperintensecoreinT2,withintermediate ADCvalues(0.80±0.08×10−3mm2/s);
• typeIII:stronglyhyperintensecoreinT2,withlowerADC values(0.74±0.13×10−3mm2/s),consistentwith
lique-factivenecrosis.
Furthermore, tubercolumas are often associated with tubercularmeningitisthattypicallyinvolvesbasalmeninges [59](Fig.11).
Tubercularabscessisrare,morecommonly in immuno-compromisedpatients[60,61].Itappearssimilartopyogenic abscessatMRI,andcanbesingleormultipleandoften mul-tiloculatewiththinandregularborders[8].Thecentralarea showslowADCvaluesasinpyogenicabscesses[8,58,60].1
H-MRSshowsonlypeaksoflipidswithoutanyotherpeak[8];
thisfindingseemstobeusefulinthedifferentialdiagnosis amongthesetwoentities.
PWIcandemonstratehighvaluesofrCBVinthe periph-ery ofthe mass,more similartothevaluesof HGGs than pyogenicabscesses[62].
Cerebraltoxoplasmosis
Cerebral toxoplasmosis is typical of immunocompromised patients.
MRIdemonstratesmultiplelesionsindifferentstagesof evolution(Fig.12),typicallylocatedinthesubcorticaland periventricularwhitematter,inthebasalgangliaand thal-ami (rarely in cerebellum) [63—65]. The presence of an eccentric area of contrast enhancement (‘‘eccentric tar-get sign’’) is a typical feature of cerebral toxoplasmosis (Fig.12CandF).The‘‘concentrictargetsign’’isarecently
Magneticresonancefeaturesofpyogenicbrainabscessesanddifferentialdiagnosis 163
Figure11 A—E:tuberculoma associatedwithtuberculum meningitis: T2-weighted(A), DWI(b=1000s/mm2)(B),
gadolinium-enhanced T1-weighted coronal (Gd-MR) (C) andaxial (D), ADC map (E) magnetic resonance images. The central part ofthe tuberculomas(groupII)showsmildlyhyperintensityinT2-weightedimage(whitearrowhead)(A),isointensityinDWI(B)andADC map(whitearrows)(E)withintermediateADCvalue(0.81×10−3mm2/sec).AtGd-MRIimages(C,D),thetuberculomasappears
asrim-enhancingmasswiththickmargins.Itisassociatedwithtuberculousmeningitisthattypicallyaffectsthebasalmeninges, andependymitisofthethirdventricle;therearealsotuberculousgranuloma(blackarrow)andothertuberculomasadjacenttothe basalsylvianfissure.
Figure12 A—F:multipleToxoplasmagondiiabscesses: T2-weighted(A,D),T1-weighted(B,E) andgadolinium-enhanced T1-weighted resonancemagnetic (Gg-MR) (C,F) images. Multiple supratentorial abscesses in various stages ofdevelopment with ‘‘starrysky’’appearanceandenhancingasymmetricnodules(‘‘eccentrictargetsign’’)(arrows)inGd-MRimages(C,F).Notealso theconcentricalternatingzonesofhypo-andhyperintensitiesinT2-weightedimages:‘‘concentrictargetsign’’(D)(arrowheads).
Figure13 A—F:Toxoplasmagondiiabscessinimmunocompromisedpatient:T2-weighted(A),T1-weighted(B)and gadolinium-enhancedT1-weightedmagneticresonance(Gd-MR)(C)images,DWI(b=1000)(D),ADC(E)andmapofcerebralbloodvolume(CBV) perfusionweightedimaging(PWI)(F).Thelesionshowsringenhancementwithextensiveperilesionalvasogenicoedema.Thecentre ofthelesionshowsisointensesignalinDWI(D),hyperintensesignalintheADCmap(E)reflectingincreaseddiffusion.AtPWI,the CBVmap(F)doesnotshowevidenceofincreasedperfusioninthecapsuleoftheabscess.
Figure14 A—F: neurocystercosis in colloidal-vesicular stage:T2-weighted axial (A) and coronal (B), T1-weighted axial (C), gadolinium-enhancedT1-weighted axial (Gd-MR) (D) and coronal (E) MR images, DWI (F). At Gd-MRimages (D, E) the lesion showsarim-enhancingmassandinT2-weightedimages thecapsuleishypointense(A,B).The MRimagesshowthescolexasa hypointenseeccentricnoduleinT2(blackarrows)andenhancednoduleinGd-MR(whitearrows).Thecentralpartofthelesion appearshypointenseinDWI(E),findingthatisconsistentwithincreaseddiffusion.
Magneticresonancefeaturesofpyogenicbrainabscessesanddifferentialdiagnosis 165 describedMRIsignonT2-weightedimagingwhichconsistsof
concentricalternatingzonesofhypo-andhyperintensities (Fig.12D).The‘‘concentrictargetsign’’seemstobemore specific thanthe ‘‘eccentric targetsign’’ in thediagnosis of cerebraltoxoplasmosisespeciallyin thecontext ofAIDS [56].
DWI canbe usefulfor differentialdiagnosis [36,58,67], since the centre of the toxoplasma abscess has a hypo/isointensesignal inDWIwithADCvalueshigherthan in pyogenic abscesses(Fig.13).On the contrary,PWI and
1H-MRSseemtobenotusefulindistinguishing
toxoplasmo-sis from a pyogenic abscess: PWI shows in both pyogenic abscessesandincerebraltoxoplasmosisareducedperfusion inthecapsule(Fig.13)withareportedrCBVmeanvalueof 0.84±0.07[66];1H-MRShaslowspecificitybecauseofthe
widerangeofpossiblepeaks[67,68].
Neurocysticercosis
MRfeatures ofneurocysticercosischange accordingtothe stage of cyst evolution. Cysts in the colloidal-vescicular stageshowhypointensecoreonT1-wandhyperintenseon T2-w images, with a T2 hypointense pseudo-capsule and peripheralenhancement,withasurroundingoedemaasin caseofpyogenicabscesses.Thescolexappearsasan eccen-trichypointensenoduleonT2-wimagesthatshowsintense contrast enhancement (Fig. 14). In contrast to pyogenic abscess,thecystincaseofneurocysticercosishashighADC values(Fig.14)[69].
PWI shows a reduction of rCBVand thus, is not useful in differentialdiagnosis withpyogenicinfection[77]. Itis importanttomentiontheintraventricularformof neurocys-ticercosisthathasarapidlyprogressivecourseanditisseen inmorethan54%ofpatientwithintracranialcysticercosis [69,71].
Conclusion
MRI is a useful tool for diagnosis, differential diagno-sis, treatment planning and follow-up of pyogenic brain abscesses. Particularly the combined use of morphologi-calandadvancedtechniquestogether,usingthedatafrom literature, is now critical in the diagnostic approach to abscess-likemassesinthebrain.
Disclosure
of
interest
Carmine F. Muccio, Ferdinando Caranci, Felice D’Arco, Alfonso Cerase, Luca De Lipsis, Gennaro Esposito, Enrico Tedeschi and Cosma Andreula declare that they have no conflictsofinterestconcerningthisarticle.
References
[1]OsenbachRK,LoftusCM.Diagnosisandmanagementofbrain abscess.NeurosurgClinNorthAm1992;3:403—20.
[2]CarpenterJ,StapletonS,HollimanR.Retrospectiveanalysisof 49casesofbrainabscessandreviewoftheliterature.EurJ ClinMicrobiolInfectDis2007;26:1—11.
[3]HakanT,CeranN,ErdemI,etal.Bacterialbrainabscesses:an evaluationof96cases.JInfect2006;52:359—66.
[4]KaoPT,TsengHK,LiuCP,etal.Brainabscess:clinicalanalysis of53cases.JMicrobiolImmunolInfect2003;36:129—36. [5]Seydoux C, Francioli P. Bacterial brain abscesses:
fac-tors influencing mortality and sequelae. Clin Infect Dis 1992;15:394—401.
[6]Nowak DA,RodickSO, TopkaH. Pyogenic brainabscess fol-lowing haematogenousseeding of a thalamichaemorrhage. Neuroradiology2003;45:157—9.
[7]GreenbergJO.Neuroimaging.2ndednItalia,Milano: McGraw-Hill;2001.
[8]LuthraG,PariharA,NathK,etal.Comparativeevaluationof fungal,tubercular,andpyogenicbrainabscesseswith conven-tionalanddiffusionMRimagingandprotonMRspectroscopy. AJNRAmJNeuroradiol2007;28:1332—8.
[9]OsbornA. Diagnosticimaging:brain.1st ednSalt LakeCity, Utah:Amirsys;2004.
[10]ParkerJrJC,DyerMC.Neurologicinfectionsduetobacteria, fungiandparasites.In:DorisRL,RobertsonDM,editors. Text-bookofNeuropathology.Baltimore:Williams&Wilkins;1985. p.632—70.
[11]Erdo˘ganE,CanseverT.Pyogenicbrainabscess.NeurosurgFocus 2008;24(6):E2.
[12]Schwartz KM, Erickson BJ, Lucchinetti C. Pattern of T2 hypointensity associated with ring-enhancing brain lesions can help to differentiate pathology. Neuroradiology 2006;48:143—9.
[13]HaimesAB,ZimmermanRD,MorgelloS,etal.MRimagingof brainabscesses.AJRAmJRoentgenol1989;152:1073—85. [14]FalconeS,PostMJ.Encephalitis,cerebritisandbrainabscess:
pathophysiologyandimagingfindings.NeuroimagingClinNAm 2000;10:333—53.
[15]Cartes-Zulmelzu FW, Stavrou Ioannis, Castillo M, et al. Diffusion-weighted imaging in the assessment of brain abscessestherapy.AJNRAmJNeuroradiol2004;25:1310—7. [16]Ebisu T, TanakaC,Umeda M, et al. Discriminationof brain
abscessfromnecroticorcystictumorsbydiffusion-weighted echoplanarimaging.MagnResonImaging1996;14:1113—6. [17]KimYJ,ChangKH,SongIC,etal.Brainabscessandnecrotic
or cystic brain tumor: discrimination with signal intensity on diffusion-weighted MR imaging. AJR Am J Roentgenol 1998;171:1487—90.
[18]NoguchiK,WatanabeN,NagayoshiT,etal.Roleof diffusion-weighted echo-planar MRI in distinguishing between brain abscess and tumor: a preliminary report. Neuroradiology 1999;41:171—4.
[19]Desprechins B,Stadnik T, Koerts G, et al. Use of diffusion-weighted MR imaging in differential diagnosis between intracerebralnecrotictumorsandcerebralabscesses.AJNRAm JNeuroradiol1999;20:1252—7.
[20]MishraAM,GuptaRK,SaksenaS,etal.Biologicalcorrelatesof diffusivityinbrainabscess.MagnResonMed2005;54:878—83. [21]Hartmann M, Jansen O, Heiland S, et al. Restricted diffu-sionwithinringenhancementisnotpathognomonicforbrain abscess.AJNRAmJNeuroradiol2001;22:1738—42.
[22]Lee EJ, Ahn KJ, Ha YS, et al. Unusual findingsin cerebral abscess:reportoftwocases.BrJRadiol2006;79:e156—61. [23]RanaS,AlbayramS,LinDD,etal.Diffusion-weightedimaging
andapparentdiffusioncoefficientmapsinacaseof intracere-bralabscesswithventricularextension.AJNRAmJNeuroradiol 2002;23:109—12.
[24]DuprezTP,CosnardG,HernalsteenD.Diffusion-weighted mon-itoring of conservative treated pyogenic brainabscesses: a markerforantibacterialtreatmentefficacy.AJNRAmJ Neuro-radiol2005;26:1296—8.
[25]FanningNF, Laffan EE, Shroff MM. Serial diffusion-weighted MRI correlates with clinicalcourse and treatmentresponse
in children with intracranial pus collection. Pediatr Radiol 2006;36:26—37.
[26]GuptaRK,VatsalDK,HusainN,etal.Differentiationof tuber-colousfrompyogenicbrainabscesseswithinvivoprotonMR spectroscopyandmagnetizationtransferMRimaging.AJNRAm JNeuroradiol2001;22:1503—9.
[27]Grand S,Passaro G, Ziegler A,et al. Necrotictumor versus brainabscess:importanceofaminoacidsdetectedat1HMRS
spectroscopy.Initialresults.Radiology1999;213:785—93. [28]RémyC,GrandS,LaïES,etal.1HMRSofhumanbrainabscesses
invivoandinvitro.MagnResonMed1995;34:508—14. [29]MendzGL,MccallMN,KuchelPW.identificationofmethyl
reso-nancesinthe1HNMRspectrumofincubatedbloodcelllysate.
JBiolChem1989;264:2100—7.
[30]VajroP,SokalEM,MaddalunoS,etal.Brainabscessdueto Kleb-siellapneumoniaeinaliver-transplantedchild.TransplInfect Dis2009;11:341—5.
[31]PalD,BhattacharyyaA,HusainM,etal.InvivoprotonMR spec-troscopyevaluationofpyogenic brainabscesses:areportof 194cases.AJNRAmJNeuroradiol2010;31:360—6.
[32]LaiPH,LiKT,HsuSS,etal.Pyogenicbrainabscess:findings frominvivo1.5-Tand11.7-TinvitroprotonMRspectroscopy. AJNRAmJNeuroradiol2005;26:279—88.
[33]Lai PH, Ho JT, ChenWL, et al. Brain abscess and necrotic brain tumor. Discrimination with proton MR spectroscopy and diffusion-weighted imaging. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol 2002;23.:1369—77.
[34]KimuraT,sakoK,GotohT,etal.Invivosingle-voxelprotonMR spectroscopyinbrainlesionwithring-likeenhancement.NMR Biomed2001;14:339—49.
[35]ErdoganC,HakyemezB,YildirimN,etal.Brainabscessand cysticbraintumor:discrimination withdynamic susceptibil-itycontrastperfusion-weightedMRI.JComputAssistTomogr 2005;29:663—7.
[36]MuccioCF,EspositoG, BartoliniA, etal.Cerebralabscesses and necrotic cerebral tumours: differential diagnosis by perfusion-weightedmagneticresonanceimaging.Radiol Med 2008;113:747—57.
[37]HolmesTM,PetrellaJR,ProvenzaleJM.Distinctionbetween cerebral abscesses and high-grade neoplasms by dynamic susceptibility contrast perfusion MRI. AJR Am J Roentgenol 2004;183:1247—52.
[38]ChanJH,TsuiEY,ChauLF,etal.Discriminationofaninfected brain tumor from a cerebral abscess bycombined MR per-fusion and diffusion imaging. Comput Med Imaging Graph 2002;26:19—23.
[39]HarisM,GuptaRK,SinghA,etal.Differentiationofinfective from neoplasticbrainlesionsbydynamiccontrast-enhanced MRI.Neuroradiology2008;50:531—40.
[40]BrittRH,EnzmannDR,YeagerAS.Neuropathologicaland com-puterizedtomographicfindingsinexperimentalbrainabscess. JNeurosurg1981;55:590—603.
[41]Jinkins JR, Gupta R, Chang KH, Carbajal-Rodriguéz J. MR imagingofcentralnervoustuberculosis.RadiolClinNorthAm 1995;33:771—86.
[42]GuptaRK,RoyR.MRimagingandspectroscopyofintracranial tuberculomas.CurrSci1999;76:783—8.
[43]GuptaRK,RoyR,PoptaniH,etal.Fingerprintingof Mycobac-teriumtuberculosisinintracranialtuberculomasusinginvivo, ex vivo and in vitro proton spectroscopy. Magn reson Med 1996;36:829—33.
[44]Holtas S, GeijerB, Strombland LG, et al. A ring-enhancing metastasiswithcentralhighsignalondiffusion-weighted imag-ing and low apparent diffusion coefficients.Neuroradiology 2000;42:824—7.
[45]JanardhanV,SuriS,BakshiR.Multiplesclerosis:hyperintense lesioninthebrainonnon-ehancedasareasofT1shortening. Radiology2007;244:823—31.
[46]Osbron AG, Preece MT. Intracranial cyst: radiologic-pathologic correlation and imaging approach. Radiology 2006;239:650—64.
[47]Park SH, Chang KH, Song IC, et al. Diffusion-weighted MRI in cystic or necrotic intracranial lesions. Neuroradiology 2000;42:716—21.
[48]TungGA,EvangelistaP,RoggJM,etal.Diffusion-weightedMR imagingofrim-enhancingbrainmasses:ismarkedlydecreased waterdiffusionspecificforbrainabscess?AJRAmJRoentgenol 2001;177:709—12.
[49]DuyguluG, OvaliGY, CalliC,et al.Intracerebralmetastasis showingrestricteddiffusion:correlationwithhistopathologic findings.EurJRadiol2010;74:117—20.
[50]MoriH,Abe O,AokiS, etal.Hemorrhagic brainmetastases withhigh signalintensity ondiffusion-weighted MR images. ActaRadiol2002;43:563—6.
[51]ChiangIC,HsiehTJ,ChiuML,etal.Distinctionbetween pyo-genic brainabscessand necroticbraintumourusing 3-tesla MRspectroscopy,diffusionandperfusionimaging.BrJRadiol 2009;82:813—20.
[52]FertikhD,KrejzaJ,CunqueiroA,etal.Discriminationof capsu-larstagebrainabscessesfromnecroticorcysticneoplasmusing diffusion-weightedmagneticresonanceimaging.JNeurosurg 2007;106:76—81.
[53]Castro S, Bernardes I. Coccidioidal cerebral abscess with peripheral restricted diffusion. J Neuroradiol 2009;36(3): 162—4.
[54]KastrupO, WankeI,MaschkeM.Neuroimaging of infection. NeuroRX2005;2:324—32.
[55]Gaviani P, Schwartz RB, Hedley-Whyte T, et al. Diffusion-weighted imaging of fungal cerebral infection. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol2005;26:1115—21.
[56]MahadevanA,RamalingaiahAH,ParthasarathyS,etal. Neu-ropathologicalcorrelateofthe‘‘concentrictargetsign’’inMRI ofHIV-associatedcerebraltoxoplasmosis.JMagnResonImaging 2013;38(2):488—95.
[57]MiauxY,RibaudP,WilliamsM,etal.MRofcerebralaspergillosis inpatientwhohavehadbonemarrowtransplantation.AJNR AmJNeuroradiol1995;16:555—62.
[58]BatraA,Tripathi RP.Diffusion-weightedmagnetic resonance imaging and magnetic resonance spectroscopy in the eval-uation of focal cerebral tubercular lesions. Acta Radiol 2004;45:679—88.
[59]BernaertsA,VanhoenackerFM,ParizelPM,etal.Tuberculosis ofthecentralnervoussystem:overviewofneuroradiological findings.Neuroradiology2003;13:1876—90.
[60]Gupta RK, Prakash M, Mishra AM, et al. Role of diffusion weighted imagingin differentiationof intracranial tubercu-lomaandtuberculousabscessfromcysticercusgranulomas—a reportofmorethan100lesions.EurJRadiol2005.
[61]BarnesPF,BlochAB,DavidsonPT,etal.Tuberculosisinpatients withhumanimmunodeficiencyvirusinfection. NEnglJMed 1991;324:1644—50.
[62]BatraA,TripathiRP.Perfusionmagneticresonanceimagingin intracerebralparenchymaltuberculosis:preliminaryfindings. JComputAssistTomogr2003;27:882—8.
[63]NaviaBA, PetitoCK, GoldJK,et al.Cerebraltoxoplasmosis complicatingtheacquiredimmunedeficiencysyndrome: clin-icalandneuropathologicalfindingsin27patients.AnnNeurol 1986;19(3):224—38.
[64]RamseyRG,GeremiaGK.CNScomplicationsofAIDS:CTand MRfindings.AJRAmJRoentgenol1988;15:449—554.
[65]Chong-Han C, Cortez SC, Tung GA. Diffusion-weighted MRI of cerebral toxoplasma abscess. AJR Am J Roentgenol 2003;181:1711—4.
[66]BarceloC,CatalaaI,Loubes-LacroixF.InterestofMRperfusion and MRspectroscopy for thediagnostic ofatypicalcerebral toxoplasmosis.JNeuroradiol2010;37(1):68—71.
Magneticresonancefeaturesofpyogenicbrainabscessesanddifferentialdiagnosis 167 [67] ChinnRJ,WilkinsonID,Hall-CraggsMA,etal. Toxoplasmosis
andprimary centralnervous systemlymphomainHIV infec-tion: diagnosis with MR spectroscopy. Radiology 1995;197: 649—59.
[68] Gupta RK. Magnetic resonance spectroscopy in intracranial infection.In: Gillard JH,Waldaman AD,Barker PB,editors. Clinical MR neuroimaging. New York: Cambridge University Press;2010.p.426—51.
[69] Sinha S, Sharma BS. Intraventricular neurocysticercosis: a reviewofcurrentstatusand management issues. BrJ Neu-rosurg2012;26(3):305—9.
[70] Toh CH, Wei KC, Chang CH, et al. Differentiation of byo-genicbrainabscessesfromnecroticglioblastomawithuseof susceptibiliy-weightedimaging.AJNR2012;33(8):1534—8. [71] VandesteenL,DrierA,GalanaudD,Clarenc¸onF,etal.Imaging
findingsofintraventricularandependymallesions.J Neurora-diol2013;40(4):229—44.
[72]TokgozS, PaksoyY,Tokgoz H,DemirI,Mutler M. Perfusion-weighted cranial MR imaging findings in a patient with hemophagocytic lymphohistiocytosis. J Neuroradiol 2013; 40(4):307—10.
[73]DashtiSR,BaharvahdatH,SauvageauE,etal.Brainabscess formation at the site of intracerebral hemorrhage sec-ondarytocentralnervoussystemvasculitis.NeurosurgFocus 2008;24(6):E12.
[74]Enzmann DR, Britt RH, Placone R. Staging of human brain abscessbycomputedtomography.Radiology1983;146:703—8. [75]Domingo Z. Clostridial brain abscesses. Br J Neurosurg
1994;8:691—4.
[76]Liliang PC,LinYC, SuTM,et al.Klebsiellabrainabscessin adults.Infection2001;29:81—6.
[77]doAmaralLL,FerreiraRM,daRochaAJ,etal. Neurocysticer-cosis:evaluationwithadvancedmagneticresonancetecniques andatypicalforms.TopMagnResonImaging2005;16:127—44.