Il principio di offensività tra contrasti interpretativi e progetti di riforma
6
0
0
Testo completo
(2) FRQODFRQVHJXHQ]DFKHODPDQFDQ]DGLXQ¶RIIHVDDO EHQHSURWHWWRGHWHUPLQDO¶LQHVLVWHQ]DGHOUHDWRFRPHO¶DVVHQ]DGLXQRGHLUHTXLVLWLVWUXWWXUDOLDSSHQDULFKLDPDWL /DFRVWLWX]LRQDOL]]D]LRQHGHOSULQFLSLRGLRIIHQVLYLWjYLHQHULFDYDWD GDOODGLVWLQ]LRQHRSHUDWDGDJOLDUWH&RVWWUDSHQHHPLVXUHGLVLFXUH]]DPHGLDQWHDVVHJQD]LRQHGLGLYHUVLVFRSLFRQODFRQVHJXHQ]DFKHOD SXQL]LRQHGLXQUHDWRSHUPHUDGLVREEHGLHQ]DDOSUHFHWWRGHWHUPLQHUHEEHXQDXWLOL]]D]LRQHGHOODVDQ]LRQHFRQHVFOXVLYDIXQ]LRQHSUHYHQWLYDSURSULD GHOOHPLVXUHGLVLFXUH]]DHOLPLQDQGRODQHWWDGLVWLQ]LRQHRSHUDWDGDOOD&RVWLWX]LRQH GDOFRQWHQXWRGHOO¶DUWLFRORVXOO¶LQYLRODELOLWjGHOODOLEHUWjSHUVRQDOHXQDOLPLWD]LRQHGHOODTXDOHVDUHEEHLQDPPLVVLELOHSHUHIIHWWRGLSHQHDSSOLFDWH VHQ]DFKHYLVLDO¶HVLJHQ]DGLWXWHODUHXQRVSHFLILFRLQWHUHVVH 6XOODEDVHGLWDOLDUJRPHQWD]LRQLVLqTXLQGLHYLGHQ]LDWRFKH .
(3) . ,OSULQFLSLRGLRIIHQVLYLWjGHYHULWHQHUVLVWUHWWDPHQWHFROOHJDWRFRQTXHOORGLOHJDOLWjQHOVHQVRFKHO¶LQWHUHVVHRIIHVRGHYHFRVWLWXLUHXQHOHPHQWR WLSLFRGHOUHDWRHQRQGHYHHVVHUHXQGDWRHVWHUQRULFDYDELOHVRJJHWWLYDPHQWHGDOJLXGLFHVXOODEDVHGLFRQVLGHUD]LRQLVRFLDOLRPRUDOL ,OSULQFLSLRGLRIIHQVLYLWjVYROJHDOO¶LQWHUQRGHOSULQFLSLRGLOHJDOLWjXQDIXQ]LRQHJDUDQWLVWDIDFHQGRVuFKHO¶RIIHVDQRQFRLQFLGDFRQOD UHDOL]]D]LRQHGHOIDWWRWLSLFRPDFRQVHQWDGLVDOYDJXDUGDUHODUHDOWjGHOO¶RJJHWWRJLXULGLFRHGHOODVXDRIIHVD /DUHDOWjGHOO¶RJJHWWRHGHOO¶RIIHVDGHYRQRHVVHUHVDOYDJXDUGDWLIDFHQGRVuFKHOHIDWWLVSHFLHOHJDOLFRQWHPSOLQROHRIIHVHDGLQWHUHVVLSUHHVLVWHQWL FRVWLWX]LRQDOPHQWHJDUDQWLWLRQRQLQFRPSDWLELOLFRQOD&RVWLWX]LRQH 6HFRQGRDOWUL$XWRULLOSULQFLSLRGLRIIHQVLYLWjqGHVXPLELOHDOWUHVuVXOSLDQRGHOODQRUPD]LRQHRUGLQDULDGDOO DUW FRPPDFS'DHVVRGLVFHQGH QRQVROWDQWRO REEOLJRSHULOOHJLVODWRUHGLULFRUUHUHDOODVDQ]LRQHSHQDOHVRORTXDQGRYLVLDODQHFHVVLWjGLWXWHODUHXQEHQHJLXULGLFRPDDQFKHLOGRYHUH GHOJLXGLFHGLYHULILFDUHVHODIDWWLVSHFLHFRQFUHWDQRQVRORFRUULVSRQGDDTXHOODDVWUDWWDSUHYLVWDGDOODQRUPDLQFULPLQDWULFHPDLQWHJULDOWUHVuO¶RIIHVD OHVLRQHRPHVVDLQSHULFROR
(4) GHOO LQWHUHVVHWXWHODWR7DOHLPSRVWD]LRQHVLFROORFDQHOO RUELWDGHOODFGFRQFH]LRQHUHDOLVWLFDGHOUHDWRDOODTXDOHFRP¶q QRWRDGHULVFHJUDQSDUWHGHOODGRWWULQDHVHFRQGRFXLLOUHDWRLQFRQFUHWRqXQIDWWRXPDQRFRQIRUPHDGXQPRGHOORGHVFULWWRGDOO RUGLQDPHQWRH OHVLYRGLXQLQWHUHVVHSHQDOPHQWHSURWHWWR6HFRQGRTXHVWRLQGLUL]]RLQWHUSUHWDWLYRSHUWDQWRVHQ]DODOHVLRQHRDOPHQRODPHVVDLQSHULFRORGHOOR VSHFLILFRLQWHUHVVHWXWHODWRGDOODQRUPDLQFULPLQDWULFHLOUHDWRQRQVXVVLVWH&LzVLJQLILFDFKHQHOQRVWURRUGLQDPHQWRLOUHTXLVLWRGHOO RIIHVDQRQq FRQVLGHUDWRFRPHQHFHVVDULDPHQWHLQVLWRLQXQIDWWRFKHULSURGXFDOHQRWHGHVFULWWLYHSURSULHGLXQDILJXUDFULPLQRVDPDHVSULPHO HVLJHQ]DFKHWDOH IDWWRROWUHDSRVVHGHUHLFRQQRWDWLIRUPDOLWLSLFLVLSUHVHQWLDQFKHQHOFDVRFRQFUHWRHQRQXQLFDPHQWHLQDVWUDWWRFDULFRGHOVLJQLILFDWRLQIRU]DGHO TXDOHqDVVXQWRFRPHIDWWLVSHFLHSURGXWWLYDGLFRQVHJXHQ]HJLXULGLFKH3HUWDQWRO DUW FSLPSRQHVHFRQGRTXHVWRRULHQWDPHQWRXQDGXSOLFH YDOXWD]LRQHGHOIDWWR LQSULPROXRJRVXOODVXDFRQIRUPLWjDOWLSRGLUHDWR LQVHFRQGROXRJRVXOODVXDFDSDFLWjOHVLYDGHOEHQHRLQWHUHVVHSURWHWWR GDOODQRUPD(VWDWDLQIDWWLFULWLFDWDLQTXHVW¶RWWLFDO¶RS]LRQHHUPHQHXWLFDVHFRQGRODTXDOHTXHVWDQRUPDQRQFRVWLWXLVFHFKHLOFRQWUDOWDUHLQ QHJDWLYRGHOGLVSRVWRGHOO DUWFS6LqULOHYDWDLQSULPROXRJRO DQRPDOLDVXOSLDQRVLVWHPDWLFRGLXQDQRUPDHVDWWDPHQWHVSHFXODUHDGXQ DOWUD FKHVDUHEEHVWDWDGHWWDWDGDOOHJLVODWRUHDOVRORILQHGLSUHYHGHUHO DVVRJJHWWDELOLWjGHOUHVSRQVDELOHGHOIDWWRDGXQDPLVXUDGLVLFXUH]]DÊGHOWXWWR HYLGHQWHFRPHVDUHEEHVWDWRSLORJLFRDWDOILQHLQVHULUHTXHVW XOWLPDSUHYLVLRQHQHOcorpusGHOO DUWFS1RQVLFRPSUHQGHUHEEHLQROWUHSHUTXDOH PRWLYRLOOHJLVODWRUHDEELDXVDWRLOWHUPLQH³D]LRQH´DOO¶DUW FSHLOWHUPLQH³DWWL´DOO¶DUWFS0DDQFKHDYROHUULIHULUHFLzDGXQDLQFRQJUXHQ]D VXOSLDQRGHOODWHFQLFDOHJLVODWLYDQRQSXzVIXJJLUHFRPHGDTXHVWDWHVLGHULYHUHEEHURFRQVHJXHQ]HGHOWXWWRLUUD]LRQDOL6LQRWLLQIDWWLFRPHO¶DUW VLULIHULVFDDTXDOXQTXHUHDWRHGXQTXHDQFKHDOOHFRQWUDYYHQ]LRQLPHQWUHO¶DUWqWHVWXDOPHQWHDSSOLFDELOHHVFOXVLYDPHQWHDLGHOLWWL1HGHULYDFKH DWWLLGRQHLGLUHWWLLQPRGRQRQHTXLYRFRDFRPPHWWHUHXQDFRQWUDYYHQ]LRQHQRQULHQWUDQGRQHOO¶DPELWRGLDSSOLFDELOLWjGHOO DUWVRQRSHQDOPHQWH LUULOHYDQWLPHQWUHDWWLQRQLGRQHLGLUHWWLDFRPPHWWHUHXQDFRQWUDYYHQ]LRQHLQWHJUDQGRO¶LSRWHVLGLFXLDOO¶DUW FRPPDFSDSULUHEEHURODVWUDGD DOO LUURJD]LRQHGLXQDPLVXUDGLVLFXUH]]D'LTXLODYDORUL]]D]LRQHGHOGHWWDWRGHOO¶DUW FSLQWHUSUHWDWRQHOO¶RWWLFDGHOO¶DXWRQRPLDGHLVXRL FRQWHQXWLSUHFHWWLYLGDOODSURVSHWWLYDGHOWHQWDWLYRVLFFRPHYROWRDGHVFOXGHUHODSXQLELOLWjGLIDWWLVSHFLHGHOWXWWRFRQIRUPLDOWLSRPDLQLGRQHHD OHGHUHLOEHQHRLQWHUHVVHWXWHODWRGDOODQRUPD,QTXHVW¶RUGLQHGLLGHHVLqLQIDWWLVRWWROLQHDWRLQGRWWULQDHLQJLXULVSUXGHQ]DFRPHXQ¶D]LRQH DVWUDWWDPHQWHHIRUPDOPHQWHWLSLFDSRVVDQRQGLPHQRHVVHUHLQLGRQHDDOHGHUHO¶LQWHUHVVHSURWHWWR'RQGHO¶XOWHULRUHDVVHUWRVHFRQGRLOTXDOHOD QR]LRQHGLHYHQWRYDDQFRUDWDDOO¶RIIHVDGHOO¶LQWHUHVVHSURWHWWR,OFKHKDLQGXEELHULSHUFXVVLRQLVXOODWHPDWLFDLQHUHQWHDOO¶HOHPHQWRVRJJHWWLYRGHO UHDWR ÊQRWRFRPHLQVHGHGLLQWHUSUHWD]LRQHGHOGLVSRVWRGHOO DUWFSVLVLDDOXQJRGLEDWWXWRVHLOWHUPLQHHYHQWRFKHILJXUDLQTXHVWDQRUPDVLDGD .
(5) . LQWHQGHUVLLQVHQVRQDWXUDOLVWLFRRJLXULGLFR(YHQWRQDWXUDOLVWLFRqODPRGLILFD]LRQHGHOPRQGRHVWHUQRSHUHIIHWWRGHOODFRQGRWWDULOHYDQWHSHULO GLULWWR(YHQWRLQVHQVRJLXULGLFRqLQYHFHODOHVLRQHRODPHVVDLQSHULFRORGHOO LQWHUHVVHSURWHWWR$VRVWHJQRGLTXHVW¶XOWLPDFRQFH]LRQHVLIDULOHYDUH FRPHODIRUPXOD]LRQHGHOO DUWFSQHOGHILQLUHLOGRORVLDDVVROXWDPHQWHLQHTXLYRFDQHOO DWWULEXLUHDOUHTXLVLWRGHOO HYHQWRFDUDWWHUHGLDVVROXWD LQGHIHWWLELOLWjLQUHOD]LRQHDTXDOXQTXHWLSRORJLDGLUHDWR,OFKHDSSDUHLQFRQFLOLDELOHFRQODSUHVHQ]DQHOO RUGLQDPHQWRGLLQQXPHUHYROLILJXUHGLUHDWR SULYHGLHYHQWRLQVHQVRQDWXUDOLVWLFR LFRVLGGHWWLUHDWLGLSXUDFRQGRWWD VLSHQVLDGHVDLUHDWLRPLVVLYLSURSUL
(6) ,QUHOD]LRQHDGHVVLHVXODQGRGDOOD IDWWLVSHFLHTXDOXQTXHULIHULPHQWRDGXQULVXOWDWRGHOO D]LRQHRGRPLVVLRQHGDFXLODOHJJHIDFFLDGLSHQGHUHO HVLVWHQ]DGHOGHOLWWRQRQULVXOWHUHEEHPDL LQWHJUDWRLOSDUDGLJPDGLFXLDOO DUWFSDSUHVLGLRGHOO LPSXWD]LRQHVRJJHWWLYDGHOO LOOHFLWR 0DDSUHVFLQGHUHGDFLzRYHVLDFFHGDDOODWHVLVHFRQGRODTXDOHJLjVXOSLDQRRJJHWWLYRGHEEDFRQVLGHUDUVLQHFHVVDULDDLILQLGHOO LQWHJUD]LRQHGHJOL HVWUHPLGHOO LOOHFLWRODOHVLRQHGHOEHQHRGHOO LQWHUHVVHSURWHWWRGLYLHQHLQHOXGLELOHFRQFOXGHUHFKHHVVDGHYHQHFHVVDULDPHQWHULHQWUDUHQHOIXRFRGHOOD YRORQWjGRORVDGRYHQGRO HOHPHQWRVRJJHWWLYRLQYHVWLUHWXWWLJOLHOHPHQWLFRVWLWXWLYLGHOUHDWR,OVRJJHWWRGRYUjSHUWDQWRHVVHUHFRQVDSHYROHGL RIIHQGHUHFRQODSURSULDFRQGRWWDO LQWHUHVVHSURWHWWRGDOODQRUPD,QGXEELDPHQWHFLzLPSOLFDLQFRQFUHWRQRWHYROLGLIILFROWjLQTXHLFDVLLQFXLWDOH LQWHUHVVHQRQVLDGLDJHYROHLQGLYLGXD]LRQH&RQOHFRQVHJXHQWLSUREOHPDWLFKHLQWHPDGLHUURUHGRYHQGRVLDPPHWWHUHO HVFOXVLRQHGHOODSXQLELOLWjH[ DUWFRPPDFSODGGRYHLOUHRYHUVLLQHUURUHFLUFDOHFDUDWWHULVWLFKHGLOHVLYLWjGHOODSURSULDFRQGRWWDULWHQHQGRGLWHQHUHXQDFRQGRWWDGHOWXWWR LQRIIHQVLYDODTXDOHDEELDLQYHFHDUUHFDWRQRFXPHQWRDOEHQHRLQWHUHVVHWXWHODWR /H6H]LRQLXQLWH &DVV6H]8Q
(7) VLVRQRULFKLDPDWHDOSULQFLSLRDIIHUPDWRGDOODJLXULVSUXGHQ]DFRVWLWX]LRQDOHVHFRQGRLOTXDOHRYHODVLQJROD FRQGRWWDVLDDVVROXWDPHQWHLQLGRQHDDSRUUHDUHSHQWDJOLRLEHQLJLXULGLFLWXWHODWLYLHQHPHQRODULFRQGXFLELOLWjGHOODIDWWLVSHFLHFRQFUHWDDTXHOOD DVWUDWWDSRLFKpOHLQGLVSHQVDELOLFRQQRWD]LRQLGLRIIHQVLYLWjGLTXHVW XOWLPDLPSOLFDQRGLULIOHVVRODQHFHVVLWjFKHDQFKHLQFRQFUHWRO RIIHQVLYLWjVLD UDYYLVDELOHDOPHQRLQJUDGRPLQLPRQHOODVLQJRODFRQGRWWDGHOO DJHQWH,QGLIHWWRGLFLzODIDWWLVSHFLHYHUUHEEHDUHIOXLUHQHOODILJXUDGHOUHDWR LPSRVVLELOH,QTXHVWDSURVSHWWLYDVLFROORFDQRDQFKHYDULHSURQXQFHGHOOD&RUWHGLFDVVD]LRQHDGHVLQPDWHULDGLUHDWLGLIDOVR &DVV
(8) RGL VRVWDQ]HVWXSHIDFHQWL &DVV
(9) RGLSHFXODWRG¶XVR &DVV
(10) / DPSLRULFRQRVFLPHQWRGHOFDQRQHGHOO RIIHQVLYLWjGDSDUWHGHOODJLXULVSUXGHQ]DRUGLQDULDqVWDWRDXWRUHYROPHQWHDYDOODWRQRQFKpVWLPRODWRGDOOD &RUWHFRVWLWX]LRQDOHODTXDOHKDULSHWXWDPHQWHSUHVRSRVL]LRQHQHJOLXOWLPLYHQWLDQQLDIDYRUHGLXQDFRQVLGHUD]LRQHDOLYHOORLQWHUSUHWDWLYRGHO SULQFLSLRGLRIIHQVLYLWjFROOHJDWRDOO DUW FRPPDFS6XOODVSLQWDGHOODGRWWULQDSLVHQVLELOHFKHKDLQGLYLGXDWRLQSDUWLFRODUHQHOODGLVFLSOLQDGHL IDWWL³WHQXL´R³HVLJXL´XQSUREOHPDIRQGDPHQWDOHVLDSHUO LQWHUSUHWHFKHSHULOOHJLVODWRUHLOJLXGLFHGHOOHOHJJLFRQODleading decisionGHO KD HYLGHQ]LDWRSHUODSULPDYROWDLOUXRORGHOO HVLJXLWjTXDQWLWDWLYDFRPHLQGLFHGLLQRIIHQVLYLWjGHOIDWWRULPHWWHQGRDOJLXGLFHGLPHULWRO LQGLYLGXD]LRQH DOO LQWHUQRGHLUHDWLGLSHULFRORDVWUDWWRGHOODVRJOLDPLQLPDGLOHVLYLWjDOGLVRWWRGHOODTXDOHOHFODVVLFRPSRUWDPHQWDOLSHUODORURRJJHWWLYDWHQXLWj GLYHQJRQRLQLGRQHHDGRIIHQGHUHLOEHQHRLEHQLWXWHODWL7DOHSUHVDGLSRVL]LRQHGHOJLXGLFHGHOOHOHJJLQRQqULPDVWDLVRODWDDQ]LKDWURYDWRWHUUHQR IHUWLOHLQQRUPHLQFULPLQDWULFLSRVWHDWXWHODGLEHQLJLXULGLFLVXVFHWWLELOLGLHYROX]LRQHTXDOLO DUWFSRYYHURLQUHDWLDUWLILFLDOLFRPHTXHOOL WULEXWDULGHOODFXLORFX]LRQHDOWULPHQWLWURSSRDPSLDKDIRUQLWRXQ LQWHUSUHWD]LRQHUHVWULWWLYDQRQFRQWUDVWDQWHFRQODUDWLROHJLV$OODVWHVVDORJLFDVLq SRLLVSLUDWDOD&RUWHFRVWLWX]LRQDOHDQFKHLQVXFFHVVLYHVHQWHQ]HWUDFXLODQGHOLQPDWHULDGLSRVVHVVRLQJLXVWLILFDWRGLFKLDYLHJULPDOGHOOL ODGGRYHKDVWDELOLWRFKH “il principio di offensività opera su due piani, rispettivamente, della previsione normativa sotto forma di precetto rivolto al legislatore di prevedere fattispecie che esprimano in astratto un contenuto lesivo e dell'applicazione giurisprudenziale (offensività in concreto), quale criterio interpretativoapplicativo affidato al giudice, la norma censurata, nell'insieme degli elementi costitutivi che la compongono, vale a dire materialità della condotta incriminata e conseguente possibilità di condurre in sede di applicazione della norma un incisivo controllo circa la .
(11) . sussistenza del requisito dell'offensività in concreto, mira a prevenire, sotto forma di reato di pericolo, la commissione di delitti contro il patrimonio, nel rispetto del principio di materialità e di offensività in astratto”. ,QXQRUL]]RQWHFRQFHWWXDOHDIILQHDTXHOORLQGLVDPLQDVLFROORFDO LQGLUL]]RHUPHQHXWLFRYROWRDYDORUL]]DUHODUDWLRGHOO LQFULPLQD]LRQH$QFKHTXHVWR RULHQWDPHQWRPXRYHGDOO HVLJHQ]DGLVRWWUDUUHDOO DUHDGHOODSXQLELOLWjLFGIDWWLLQRIIHQVLYLFRQIRUPLDOWLSR(GqVWDWRULOHYDWRLQGRWWULQDFRPHOH LSRWHVLIDWWXDOLGLVIDVDWXUDWUDWLSLFLWjHGRIIHVDQRQVLDQRFRQVHJXHQ]DGLXQ LPSHUIHWWDIRUPXOD]LRQHWHFQLFROHJLVODWLYDGHOODIDWWLVSHFLHEHQVuGHOOD WHQVLRQHWUDDVWUDWWH]]DQRUPDWLYDHFRQFUHWH]]DIDWWXDOH6LULWLHQHSHUzFKHQRQSRVVDHVVHUHWDQWRLOFRQFHWWRGLEHQHJLXULGLFRDULVROYHUHLSUREOHPL DSSOLFDWLYLSRVWLGDOOHLSRWHVLGLVIDVDWXUDTXDQWRORVFRSRGHOODQRUPD/HLSRWHVLIDWWXDOLGLGLVFUDVLDIUDWLSLFLWjHGRIIHVDQRQULHQWUDQRLQIDWWL VHFRQGRTXHVWDWHVLQHJOLVFRSLGLWXWHODGHOODGLVSRVL]LRQHLQFULPLQDWULFHSHUFXLODQRQSXQLELOLWjGHOVRJJHWWRSXzHVVHUHDIIHUPDWDPHGLDQWH XQ LQWHUSUHWD]LRQHWHOHRORJLFDGHOODQRUPD6LqLQWDOHSURVSHWWLYDDIIHUPDWRQHOODJLXULVSUXGHQ]DGLPHULWRFKHO LQWHUSUHWD]LRQHWHOHRORJLFDGHOOD IDWWLVSHFLHLQFULPLQDWULFHLQFHQWUDWDVXOODFRQVLGHUD]LRQHGHJOLVFRSLGLWXWHODSHUVHJXLWLGDOOHJLVODWRUHqSUHYLVWDGDOO DUWSUHOFKHHVSUHVVDPHQWH LPSRQHGLIDUHULIHULPHQWRDOO LQWHQ]LRQHGHOOHJLVODWRUH7DOHLQWHUSUHWD]LRQHLQGXFHQHLFDVLLQGLVDPLQDDGHVFOXGHUHODWLSLFLWjGHOIDWWRLQTXDQWRLO IDWWRLQRIIHQVLYRLQUHDOWjQRQqFRQIRUPHDOPRGHOOROHJDOHILQDOLVWLFDPHQWHLQWHUSUHWDWR6LWUDWWDFRPHVLYHGHGLXQGLYHUVRSHUFRUVRLQWHUSUHWDWLYR FKHFRQGXFHSHUzDJOLVWHVVLULVXOWDWL Tesi contraria al principio di offensività come elemento strutturale 1RQRVWDQWHTXHOODILQRUDSURVSHWWDWDVLDO¶RSLQLRQHSUHYDOHQWHLQGRWWULQDHLQJLXULVSUXGHQ]DQRQPDQFDQRWXWWDYLDDUJRPHQWLDVRVWHJQRGHOO¶RSSRVWD SRVL]LRQHVHFRQGRODTXDOHLOSULQFLSLRGLRIIHQVLYLWjQRQDYUHEEHFLWWDGLQDQ]DDOO¶LQWHUQRGHOQRVWURRUGLQDPHQWR ,QQDQ]LWXWWRO¶RELH]LRQHSLULFRUUHQWHDOODWHRULDUHDOLVWLFDFRPHVRSUDSURVSHWWDWDFRQVLVWHQHOULWHQHUHFKHO¶DIIHUPD]LRQHGHOODQRQSXQLELOLWjGHL IDWWLLQRIIHQVLYLFRQIRUPLDOWLSRULFKLHGHUHEEHLOULFRUVRDFULWHULH[WUDQRUPDWLYLHVWUDQHLFLRqDOODIDWWLVSHFLHOHJDOH 6LqLQIDWWLVRVWHQXWRFKHFRQVLGHUDUHODQHFHVVDULDRIIHQVLYLWjDOODVWUHJXDGLHOHPHQWRFRVWLWXWLYRGHOUHDWRHTXLYDOHDLQIUDQJHUHLOSULQFLSLRGL OHJDOLWjSHUFKpSRUWDDGDWWLQJHUHO¶RIIHVDQRQUHSHULELOHQHOODIDWWLVSHFLHOHJDOHGDFULWHULGLYDOXWD]LRQHH[WUDOHJLVODWLYLUHQGHQGRLOJLXGLFHDUELWUR GHOODUHVSRQVDELOLWjRGHOODLUUHVSRQVDELOLWjSHQDOHGHOO DJHQWH /DWHQVLRQHGHOVXGGHWWRSULQFLSLRULVSHWWRDTXHOORGLVWUHWWDOHJDOLWjSHUzQRQGHULYDWDQWRGDOIDWWRFKHLOJLXGLFHILQLVFHSHUULGLVHJQDUHODIDWWLVSHFLH DJJLXQJHQGRXQHOHPHQWRFRVWLWXWLYR TXHVWDVRUWDGLGHOHJDFRQIHULWDGDOOHJLVODWRUHDOJLXGLFHLQIDWWLKDXQDFRSHUWXUDOHJDOH DUW FRFS
(12) /¶DWWULWRGHULYDSLXWWRVWRGDOODFLUFRVWDQ]DFKHSXUSRWHQGRHVVHUHDGRWWDWDVRORQHOFDVRGLUHDWLGLGDQQRHGLSHULFRORFRQFUHWR FRVWUXLWLJLjLQ DVWUDWWRGDOOHJLVODWRUHLQWHUPLQLGLQHFHVVDULDRIIHQVLYLWj
(13) TXHVWDVROX]LRQHYLHQHVSHVVRLPSLHJDWDDQFKHULVSHWWRDLUHDWLGLSHULFRORDVWUDWWRR SUHVXQWRHDLUHDWLGLVFRSR ,QSDUWLFRODUHLOOLPLWHGLVFHQGHGDOIDWWRFKHO¶XWLOL]]RGHOODFRQFH]LRQHUHDOLVWLFDLQSUHVHQ]DGLXQUHDWRLQDVWUDWWRLQRIIHQVLYRFRPSRUWHUHEEHXQD VRUWDGLLQGHELWDDOWHUD]LRQHGHLFULWHULGLRSHUDWLYLWjGHOODWLSLFLWjFRVuFRPHGLVHJQDWDGDOOHJLVODWRUH HFLzSHUFKpQRQVRORVLDJJLXQJHUHEEHLO UHTXLVLWRDXWRQRPRGHOO¶RIIHVDDOEHQHJLXULGLFRWXWHODWRPDTXHVW¶DJJLXQWDILQLUHEEHSHUPDQLSRODUHDQFKHODVWHVVDWHFQLFDGLWXWHODHLOJUDGRGL RIIHVDSUHVFHOWLGDOOHJLVODWRUH,QVRVWDQ]DPHQWUHO¶DJJLXQWDGHOO¶RIIHVDDOO¶LQWHUQRGLXQUHDWRFRVWLWXLWRJLjDVWUDWWDPHQWHLQVLIIDWWLWHUPLQLPXWDOD VWUXWWXUDOHJLVODWLYDGHOODIDWWLVSHFLHUHQGHQGRHVSUHVVRFLzFKHqLPSOLFLWRSRQHQGRVLSHUzLQSHUIHWWDVLQWRQLDFRQJOLVFRSLGLWXWHODSHUVHJXLWLGDO .
(14) . OHJLVODWRUHDOFRQWUDULRO¶DJJLXQWDGHOO¶RIIHVDLQXQUHDWRJLjLQDVWUDWWRLQRIIHQVLYRLQFLGHVXOODVWUXWWXUDOHJLVODWLYDGHOODIDWWLVSHFLHLQVHUHQGRex novo XQHOHPHQWRDGGLULWWXUDGHOWXWWRHVWUDQHRDOODQRUPDFRQODFRQVHJXHQ]DFKHO¶DWWLYLWjGHOJLXGLFHILQLVFHSHUVRVWLWXLUVLDTXHOODGHOOHJLVODWRUH RSHUDQGRLQSUDWLFDVXOSLDQRGHOOHIRQWL 8QDVHFRQGDRELH]LRQHFKHVLVXROHSRUUHDOODWHRULDPDJJLRULWDULDqTXHOODSHUFXLODFRQFH]LRQHUHDOLVWLFDVLSRUUHEEHLQFRQWUDVWRDQFKHFRQLO VRWWRSULQFLSLRGLGHWHUPLQDWH]]DHWDVVDWLYLWj,QSULPROXRJRLQIDWWLHVLVWRQRDPSLVSD]LGLGLVFUH]LRQDOLWjQHOODLQGLYLGXD]LRQHGHOEHQHJLXULGLFR WXWHODWR3URSULRSHUFKpVLSDUODGLEHQHJLXULGLFRHQRQGLVFRSRGLWXWHODGHOODQRUPDODVXDLQGLYLGXD]LRQHULVFKLDGLHVVHUHWRWDOPHQWHVYLQFRODWDGD XQDFFRVWDPHQWRDOODIDWWLVSHFLHLQFULPLQDWULFHHTXLQGLLQVRVWDQ]DGLHVVHUHGHOWXWWRDUELWUDULD 6LqDOWUHVuULOHYDWRFKHO¶DUW FRPPDFSQRQFRQWULEXLUHEEHLQDOFXQPRGRDGLQGLYLGXDUHODQDWXUDGHJOLLQWHUHVVLWXWHODWLHSHUWDQWRTXHVWL XOWLPLVDUHEEHURLQGLVWLQJXLELOLGDJOLHOHPHQWLGHVFULWWLYLGHOODIDWWLVSHFLH,QILQHVLQHJDFKHODFRQFH]LRQHUHDOLVWLFDSRVVDIRUQLUHXQDLXWRGHFLVLYRDO JLXGLFHLQTXDQWRQRQVDUHEEHPDLDSSOLFDELOHDLUHDWLFGsenza offesa ULVSHWWRDGHVVLQRQHVVHQGRVWDWLLQRULJLQHFRQILJXUDWLGDOOHJLVODWRUHLQ WHUPLQLGLRIIHVDDGXQEHQHJLXULGLFRQRQVDUHEEHFRQVHQWLWRLQDOFXQPRGRXWLOL]]DUHLOUHDWRLPSRVVLELOHTXDOHFDQRQHHUPHQHXWLFRDOILQHGL ULOHJJHUHVLPLOLIDWWLVSHFLHLQWHUPLQLGLQHFHVVDULDRIIHQVLYLWj $VRVWHJQRGHOODWHVLLQHVDPHVLSRQHDQFKHXQUHFHQWHDUUHVWRGHOOD6XSUHPD&RUWHODTXDOHSRQHQGRVLLQFRQWUDVWRFRQXQtrend JLXULVSUXGHQ]LDOH SUHVVRFKpFRVWDQWHDIIHUPDFKH³nel nostro ordinamento penale non vige alcuna norma che consacri il cosiddetto principio di offensività, alla stregua del quale non sussisterebbe il reato se la condotta sia insuscettibile di ledere il bene protetto dalla norma incriminatrice” &IU&DVV &DVV
(15) $OODVWUHJXDGLTXHVWDLPSRVWD]LRQHLFDVLGLHVLJXDRIIHVDDOEHQHJLXULGLFRYHQJRQRULVROWLGDOOD&RUWHFRQO¶DSSOLFD]LRQHGHOODVRODDWWHQXDQWHGHOOD SDUWLFRODUHWHQXLWjH[DUWQFS /DVWHVVD&RUWHFRVWLWX]LRQDOHLQSDVVDWRKDDIIHUPDWRFKH“l'offensività deve ritenersi di norma implicita nella configurazione del fatto e nella sua qualificazione di illecito da parte del legislatore, salvo talune ipotesi marginali ... nelle quali, a causa della necessaria astrattezza della norma, può verificarsi divergenza fra tipicità ed offesa” &RUWHFRVW
(16) ,QXQDSURVSHWWLYDde iure FRQGHQGRVLqVRVWHQXWRSLXWWRVWRFKHLOSULQFLSLRGLRIIHQVLYLWjGHYHHVVHUHLQWHVRFRPHVSLQWDSHULOOHJLVODWRUHDFRVWUXLUH IDWWLVSHFLHSHQDOLPRGXODWHLQPRGRGDDVVLFXUDUHFKHDOODORURUHDOL]]D]LRQHFRUULVSRQGDVHPSUHODOHVLRQHRODPHVVDLQSHULFRORGHOO LQWHUHVVH SURWHWWRHFRPHREEOLJRSHUO LQWHUSUHWHGLULFHUFDUHO¶RIIHQVLYLWjGHOODFRQGRWWDVRORODGGRYHULFKLHVWRGDOODIDWWLVSHFLHDVWUDWWD Tesi intermedia $VVDLGLIIXVHLQGRWWULQDVRQRLQROWUHOHSRVL]LRQLGLFRORURFKHGDXQODWRULWHQJRQRFKHLOQRVWURRUGLQDPHQWRUHFHSLVFDLOSULQFLSLRGLQHFHVVDULD RIIHQVLYLWj ULIDFHQGRVLHVVHQ]LDOPHQWHDOOHQRUPHFRVWLWX]LRQDOL
(17) GDOO¶DOWURODWRQHJDQRFKHO¶DUW FRPPDFSSRVVDULFRSULUHXQTXDOFKH VLJQLILFDWLYRUXRORQHOO¶DIIHUPD]LRQHGLWDOHSULQFLSLR7DOHGRWWULQDIRQGDPHQWDOPHQWHQHJDODSRVVLELOLWjGLDPPHWWHUHO¶HVLVWHQ]DGLXQRVFDUWRIUD WLSLFLWjHGRIIHVDDFDXVDGHOOHFRQVHJXHQ]HQHIDVWHFKHQHGHULYHUHEEHUR YLROD]LRQHGHOSULQFLSLRGLOHJDOLWjLQGHWHUPLQDWH]]DQHOO¶LQWHUSUHWD]LRQH GHOOHIDWWLVSHFLHHLQFHUWH]]DQHLFULWHULGLYDOXWD]LRQHGHOORVFDUWRIUDWLSLFLWjHGRIIHVD
(18) FLRQRQRVWDQWHHVVDDPPHWWHFKHVLDLQYHFHFRQILJXUDELOHXQ .
(19) . GLYHUVR³VFDUWR´QRQJLjIUDWLSLFLWjHGRIIHVDEHQVuIUD³WLSLFLWjUHDOH´H³WLSLFLWjDSSDUHQWH´,QTXHVW¶RWWLFDO¶HVHPSLRVFRODVWLFRGHOIXUWRG¶DFLQR G¶XYDQRQVDUHEEHGDFRQVLGHUDUVLXQIDWWRWLSLFRQRQRIIHQVLYREHQVuGRYUHEEHHVVHUHLQWHVRQHOVHQVRGLXQIDWWRVROWDQWRDSSDUHQWHPHQWHFRQIRUPH DOWLSROHJDOHGLIXUWR 6LDUJRPHQWDLQIDWWLFKHLQTXHVWRFDVRFRPHLQDOWULDQDORJKLODWLSLFLWjqVROWDQWRDSSDUHQWHSHUFKpQRQSXzVHULDPHQWHHVVHUHFRQVLGHUDWR FRQIRUPHDOODIDWWLVSHFLHXQIDWWRFRVuPDQLIHVWDPHQWHSULYRGHOO¶LGRQHLWjDSUHJLXGLFDUHJOLLQWHUHVVLWXWHODWL7XWWDYLDDQFKHTXHVWRPRGRGLUDJLRQDUH SUHVHQWDGHLOLPLWLLQIDWWLXQDYROWDFKHLOSUREOHPDLQWHUSUHWDWLYRVLVSRVWDGDOO¶RIIHQVLYLWjDOODWLSLFLWjULILXWDQGRFKHSRVVDHVLVWHUHXQIDWWRWLSLFR QRQRIIHQVLYR HVVHQGRO¶RIIHQVLYLWjLPPDQFDELOPHQWHFRQQDWXUDWDDOODWLSLFLWj
(20) PDDOWHPSRVWHVVRDPPHWWHQGRFKHSRVVDHVLVWHUHLOIDWWRQRQ RIIHQVLYRLQTXDQWRVROWDQWRDSSDUHQWHPHQWHWLSLFRDTXHVWRSXQWRULPDQHGDFKLDULUHDWWUDYHUVRTXDOLFULWHULODWLSLFLWjVLDUHDOHRVROWDQWRDSSDUHQWH ,QDOWULWHUPLQLXQDYROWDHOLPLQDWRLOSUREOHPDGHOO¶RIIHQVLYLWjQRQVLIDDOWURFKHVSRVWDUORVXOODWLSLFLWjLQWURGXFHQGRODFDWHJRULDGHOIDWWR ³DSSDUHQWHPHQWHWLSLFR´ PDVLqDSSHQDGHWWRVRSUDFKHQRQqFKLDURTXDOHVLDLOFULWHULRLQEDVHDOTXDOHLOIDWWRVLSXzFRQVLGHUDUHUHDOPHQWHWLSLFRR VROWDQWRDSSDUHQWHPHQWHWDOH VLRELHWWDSHUWDQWRFKHFRVuUDJLRQDQGRVLSUHIHULVFHDJJDQFLDUHODQRQSXQLELOLWjDGXQDHYDQHVFHQWHQR]LRQHGLWLSLFLWj ³DSSDUHQWH´IRUQHQGRXQDVROX]LRQHFHUWDPHQWHPHQRJDUDQWLWDGLTXHOODFKHDJJDQFLDODQRQSXQLELOLWjDGXQLVWLWXWRGLGLULWWRSRVLWLYR,QDOWUH SDUROHVLLQWURGXFHXQDQR]LRQH±TXHOODGLUHDWRRWLSLFLWjDSSDUHQWH±FKHQRQWURYDDOFXQULVFRQWURQRUPDWLYRULWHQHQGRODSUHIHULELOHDGXQD FRVWUX]LRQHFKHIRWRJUDIDFRQULJRUHJLXULGLFRHGLQWHUSUHWDWLYROHVLWXD]LRQLGLFRQIRUPLWjDOIDWWR D]LRQHLQLGRQHD
(21) PDQRQOHVLYHGHOO¶LQWHUHVVH WXWHODWR LPSRVVLELOLWjGHOO¶HYHQWRGDQQRVRRSHULFRORVR
(22) Progetti di riforma ,QXOWLPDDQDOLVLqGDVHJQDODUHFKHqLQDWWRXQSURJHWWRGLULIRUPDGHO&RGLFH3HQDOHHODERUDWRGDOOD&RPPLVVLRQHSUHVLHGXWDGD*LXOLDQR3LVDSLDLO TXDOH VXOODVFLDGHLSURJHWWL3DJOLDUR*URVVRH1RUGLR
(23) WUDO¶DOWURSUHYHGHODFRGLILFD]LRQHGHOSULQFLSLRGLRIIHQVLYLWj/¶DUWGHOSURJHWWRLQIDWWL VWDELOLVFHFKH nessuno sia punito per un fatto che non offenda beni giuridici di rilevanza costituzionale; nessuno sia punito per un fatto che in concreto non offenda i beni giuridici tutelati dalla norma incriminatrice; l’agente non sia punibile quando risultino la tenuità dell’offesa e l’occasionalità del comportamento. $EHQYHGHUHWDOHSURJHWWRQRQSXzFKHHVVHUHOHWWRFRPHODFRQIHUPDGHOO¶DWWXDOHDWLSLFLWjQRUPDWLYDGHOSULQFLSLRGLRIIHQVLYLWjHDOWHPSRVWHVVR GHOO¶HVLJHQ]DGLSRVLWLYL]]DUHOHLVWDQ]HGRWWULQDULHHJLXULVSUXGHQ]LDOLRUPDLGDWHPSRDIIHUPDWHVLVXOODVFHQDGHOGLULWWRSHQDOHVRVWDQ]LDOH. .
(24)
Documenti correlati
Proprio questo disincanto rende interessante l’analisi comparatistica. B) Abbiamo chiarito che in virtù della ricostruzione teorica liberale di J.S. Mill, nei sistemi di common
È vero, infatti, che quest’ultima rap- presentò un punto nevralgico, in relazione al quale l’obiettivo dei costituenti fu di ribaltare l’assetto precedente in ordine alla
Nel secondo caso, cioè richiedendo quale elemento strutturale del delitto di evasione il precipuo fine di guadagnare definitivamente la libertà personale, il fatto tipico non
La motivazione spiegava, tra l’altro, che quell’incriminazione non tutelava nessun bene giuridico (“non è tutelato alcun bene giuridico”: § 4) meritevole
153 Vedi MASTELLARINI, Sui fallimenti il peso dei mutui, in Il sole 24 ore del 31/10/06. 154 Il legislatore delegato non ha eccelso per la chiarezza espositiva perciò i
E tali considerazioni sono state applicate anche ad un secondo profilo di indagine, la potenziale destinazione all’alimentazione umana dell’acqua avvelenata. Se così non
Muovendo da queste premesse, allora, l’intervento della Corte costituzionale dovrebbe condurre a invalidare (anche) quelle norme sul concorso di persone che qualificano come
rilevanza della quantità e della tossicità delle piante ai soli fini della commisurazione della pena. Tuttavia, la tesi della bipartizione tra coltivazione domestica
