ARTICLE
IN
PRESS
JID:CLLC [mNS;April23,2021;6:41]
Case
Report
Black
Hairy
Tongue
After
Immune
Checkpoint
Inhibitors
in
NSCLC:
A
Case
Report
and
Review
of
the
Literature
Cristina
Cecchi,
Annapaola
Mariniello,
Simona
Carnio,
Marco
D.
Delcuratolo,
Silvia
Novello
Clinical
Practice
Points
•Immunecheckpointinhibitors(ICIs)areassociatedwith the development of unique immune-related adverse events(irAEs), which emerged primarily during post-marketingsurveillance.Oral irAEshavealreadybeen reported,withthemostcommonmanifestationsbeing mucositisandxerostomia.Ithasbeensuggestedthata T-cellactivation,similartothatobservedinautoimmune conditions,mayplayarole.
•Here,wereportacaseofblackhairytongue(BHT)ina patientreceivingfirst-linepembrolizumabforadvanced non–small-celllungcancer(NSCLC).AlthoughtheBHT wassymptomaticforburningmouthanddysgeusia,ICI usewascontinueddue to its clinicaland radiological benefit,whichpersistedforalongtime.
•BHTischaracterizedbyhypertrophyandlengtheningof thefiliformpapillae.Despitebeingararebenign condi-tion,itcanoftenresultinasignificantburdenonquality oflife.
•Manypredisposing factorshavebeen described,and cancer patients represent a population particularly at risk.Basedonthetemporalassociationandexcluding possible alternativecauses, weproposed that,in our patient, BHTwaslikely ICIrelatedthrough the devel-opmentofxerostomia,whichrepresentsakeyfactorin BHTpathogenesis.
•To the best of our knowledge,this is the first report ofBHTafterICIuse,suggestingthatitmayrepresent anatypicaloralirAE.Todate, theoralirAEshavenot been well explored, and further studies are needed to elucidate the underlying mechanisms and possi-bleassociationswithanti-tumorresponses,with signif-icant implications on prognosis and quality of life.In thepresentcontext,ourcaseemphasizestheneedto remainvigilantforatypicalandnewirAEs.
ClinicalLungCancer,Vol.000,No.xxx,1–4© 2021ElsevierInc.Allrightsreserved.
Introduction
Over the last decade, immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICIs) have emergedasa novelandeffective treatmentstrategythathas produced unprecedented results in several solid tumors, includ-ing non–small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC).1 In contrast to other anti-cancer therapies, ICIs are associated with the development of unique immune-related adverse events (irAEs).2 Whereas the mostcommonirAEs,suchasrash,diarrhea,arthritis,hepatitis,and endocrinopathies, werereportedinclinicaltrials,rareirAEshave
DepartmentofOncologyatSanLuigiGonzagaUniversityHospital,Universityof Torino,Turin,Italy
Submitted:Jan29,2021;Revised:Feb27,2021;Accepted:Mar18,2021;Epub:xxx Addressforcorrespondence:CristinaCecchi,DepartmentofOncologyatSanLuigi
Gonzaga UniversityHospital,UniversityofTorino, RegioneGonzole,10,10043 Orbassano,Torino,Italy.
E-mailcontact:annapaola.mariniello@unito.it
emergedduringpost-marketingsurveillance.3 DermatologicirAEs upontheuseof ICIsarefrequentandmayaffectqualityoflife.4 Oralmucosacanalsobeinvolved,withthemostcommon manifes-tationsbeingmucositis andxerostomia.Toourknowledge,black hairytongue(BHT)upontheuseofICIshasnotbeendescribedso far.Here,wereportacaseofICI-inducedBHTinapatientwith advancedNSCLC.
Case
Presentation
A68-year-oldmanwhowasaformersmokerwithapasthistory of type 1diabetes mellitus, tuberculosis, and myocardial infarc-tion was diagnosed with advanced NSCLC in December2019. Thediagnosticwork-uprevealedapoorlydifferentiatedcarcinoma atstageIIIb(T4N2M0).Themolecularprofilingshowed epider-malgrowthfactorreceptorwild-type,anaplasticlymphomakinase and c-ros oncogene 1 receptor tyrosine kinase non-rearranged,
1525-7304/$-seefrontmatter© 2021ElsevierInc.Allrightsreserved.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cllc.2021.03.008 ClinicalLungCancer 2021
1
Pleasecitethisarticleas:CristinaCecchietal,BlackHairyTongueAfterImmuneCheckpointInhibitorsinNSCLC:ACaseReportandReviewofthe Literature,ClinicalLungCancer,https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cllc.2021.03.008
Black
Hairy
Tongue
After
Immune
Checkpoint
Inhibitors
ARTICLE
IN
PRESS
JID:CLLC [mNS;April23,2021;6:41]
Figure1 BlackHairyTongue.
andimmunohistochemistryshowedaprogrammeddeathligand-1 tumorproportionscoreof100%(clone22C3).
According to the medical history and the clinical conditions (EasternCooperativeOncologyGroupperformancestatus1), first-line treatment with pembrolizumab 200 mg every 21 days was given,startingfromJanuary2020.InFebruary2020,dueto uncon-trolledpain,palliativeradiationtherapywasdeliveredontheright chestwall(20Gyin5fractions).Aftertwocyclesofpembrolizumab, the patient reported grade 1 mucositis (according to Common TerminologyCriteriaforAdverseEventsVersion5.0[CTCAE5.0]), associated with xerostomia and burning mouth, initially treated with bakingsodamouthwashesandnystatin,withoutsignificant improvement. The restaging CT scan,after four cycles, showed a partialresponse forshrinkage ofthe lunglesion andassociated lymphnodes.
In May 2020 (after five cycles, about 110 days after pembrolizumabstart),oralmucositisworsenedfromgrade2to3 (CTCAE5.0),forpersistingsymptomsofburningmouth, dysgeu-sia, and severe xerostomia. These symptoms partially interfered withfoodintake,butdidnotdeterminesignificantweightloss.At theobjectiveexamination,theonsetofblackdiscolorationonthe dorsumofthetongue,withhairyelevationofthefiliformpapillae, wasnoted(Figure1).
Diagnosis of BHTwas first madeby a dermatologist inJune 2020.AsecondodontostomatologyevaluationconfirmedBHTand suggestedapossibleassociationwithICI,notwithstandinga possi-bleroleofotherconcomitantmedications,whichincluded
panto-prazole, bisoprolol, candesartan/hydrochlorothiazide, manidipine, cardioaspirin, clopidogrel,simvastatin, fentanyl,paracetamol, and insulin.Good oralhygienewasrecommended,and other topical andsystemic treatmentsforBHTweretried(eg,miconazoleoral gel,fluconazole)withoutclinicalbenefit.
Inagreementwiththepatient,andinconsiderationofthe excel-lentradiological response, ICI usewascontinuedinspite of the qualityoflife(QoL)impairmentduetoBHTandxerostomia.Inthe subsequentmonths,theBHTseverityvaried,alternatingperiodsof remissionandexacerbation;thelattermostlyinthefirstdays follow-ing pembrolizumabinfusion. Ofnote, the patient also reported an immune-related thyroiditis, laboratory confirmed with anti– thyroid-stimulatinghormone receptorantibodies,whichoccurred alongwithBHTinMay2020andrequiredspecifictreatment.As ofJanuary2021,thepatient’slungdiseasewasstableandtherapy withpembrolizumabwasongoing,withtheBHTbeingmanaged withbakingsodamouthwashandgentlebrushingwithgauze.
Discussion
BHT,orlinguanigravillosa,isabenignrarecondition character-izedbyhypertrophyandlengtheningofthefiliformpapillae,witha blacktobrownishdiscolorationcommonlyontheposteriordorsal surfaceofthetongue.Intermsofpathogenesis,predisposing condi-tions,suchaspoororalhygieneanddrymouth,canleadtoa defec-tivedesquamationofthefiliformpapillae,collectingdebris,fungi, andbacteria,whichproducechromogenicporphyrins.5,6
2
ClinicalLungCancer 2021Pleasecitethisarticleas:CristinaCecchietal,BlackHairyTongueAfterImmuneCheckpointInhibitorsinNSCLC:ACaseReportandReviewofthe Literature,ClinicalLungCancer,https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cllc.2021.03.008
Cr
ist
in
a
C
ecchi
et
al
AR
TICLE
IN
PRESS
JID: CLLC [mNS; A pr il 23, 2021; 6: 41 ]Table1 ReportedCasesofBlackHairyTongueinCancerPatients
PatientAge (y);Sex Related Comorbidities Oncological Disease
OncologicalTreatment WhenBHTOccurred BHTTreatment;Outcome Ref.
61;male Notknown Lungcancer Erlotinib 28daftererlotinibbegan Drugwithdrawal;complete resolution
10
68;female Notknown Breastcarcinoma Doxorubicin,cyclophosphamide, anddocetaxel
Fewweeks(notspecified) Notreatment;completeresolution 11 57;female Notknown Breastcancer Cyclophosphamide,
5-fluorouracil,anddoxorubicin
60dafterchemotherapybegan Notreatment;completeresolution 12 75;female Diabetesmellitus Anaplastic
oligoastrocytoma
Temozolomide 9dafterchemotherapybegan Oralcareandbrushing;complete resolution
13
63;male Diabetesmellitus Glioblastoma Temozolomide 1dafterchemotherapybegan Oralcareandbrushing;complete resolution
13
79;male Diabetesmellitus LargeBcelllymphoma Rituximab,methotrexate, procarbazine,andvincristine
9dafterchemotherapybegan Oralcare;completeresolution 13 78;male Hypertension,
dyslipidemia, hypertrophic cardiomyopathy
LargeBcelllymphoma Rituximab,methotrexate, procarbazine,andvincristine
102dafterchemotherapybegan Oralcareandbrushing;complete resolution
13
73;female Appendicitis,lacunar cerebralinfarction,
cataract
LargeBcelllymphoma Rituximab,methotrexate, procarbazine,andvincristine
145dafterchemotherapybegan Oralcareandbrushing;complete resolution
13
68;male None Lungcancer Carboplatinandvinorelbine 15dafterchemotherapybegan Sodiumbicarbonatemouthwash; completeresolution. 14 Clinical Lung Cancer 2021
3
P lease cite this ar ticle as: C ristina Cecchi et al, Bl ac k Ha iry To n gu e After Immune Checkpoint In h ib ito rs in NSCL C: A Case Re p or t and R evie w of the Literatur e, Clinical Lun g Cancer , https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cllc.2021.03.008Black
Hairy
Tongue
After
Immune
Checkpoint
Inhibitors
ARTICLE
IN
PRESS
JID:CLLC [mNS;April23,2021;6:41]
BHTisaclinicaldiagnosis combiningdermoscopicevaluation and clinicalhistory.Despitetypicallyasymptomatic,BHTcanbe associated with gagging, nausea, dysgeusia, xerostomia, burning mouthsyndrome,andhalitosis,resultinginasignificantburdenon QoL,asinthepresentcase.5
Treatments include good oral hygiene, discontinuing habits predisposingtoBHT,andgentlebrushingorscrapingofthetongue. Antifungals, suchas fluconazole ornystatin, canalso beuseful.6 When considering the possible causesof BHT inthis case, our patientpresentedseveralacknowledgedriskfactors,suchasolderage (>60years),smoking,type1diabetesmellitus,andmalignancy.5,7
Infact,asshowninTable1,BHThasbeendescribedincancer patients, primarily after chemotherapy and/or other immune-suppressivetreatments.Ithasbeenreportedthatnumerous medica-tionscanalsopredisposetoBHT,includingantibiotics, anticholin-ergic,antipsychotics,andantihypertensiveagents.8Ourpatientwas onantihypertensivetreatment,butthishadbeenundertakenprior tothestartofimmunotherapy,andthepatienthadnoxerostomia or BHT.Basedonthetemporalassociation andexcluding possi-blealternativecauses,weproposethatinthiscaseBHTwaslikely associated with the useof ICIs, resultinginthe development of xerostomia.
In clinical trials, ICI-inducedoral effects have been reported, mainly consisting of grades 1 and 2 xerostomia observed in melanomapatientsreceivingnivolumab(6.5%)orpembrolizumab (3.5%).9Indeed,ithasbeensuggestedthatICIsmayinduce xeros-tomiaduetoanexcessiveT-cellactivation,similarlytothatobserved in autoimmune conditions.9 In its turn, dry mouth can predis-posetothedevelopmentofBHT.5,6Unfortunately,biopsywasnot performedinthepresentcase.Thedescriptionoftissue modifica-tionswouldhaveprovidedbetterinsightintotheBHTpathogenesis andpossiblyclarifiedthecausalrelationshipwithICIuse.
Ofnote,alongwithBHT,thepatientalsodeveloped immune-relatedthyroiditis.Smallretrospectiveserieshavesuggestedthatthe developmentofirAEscanpredictsurvivalbenefitincancerpatients receivingICIs.Infact,theimmunesystemactivationunderlyingthe observedirAEsmayalsoberesponsiblefortheanti-tumorresponse.2
Conclusion
AlthoughBHTisabenignconditionandtheoverallprevalence issmall,itmayconsiderablyaffectQoL.Cancerpatientsrepresenta
populationparticularlyatrisk,becauseofthefrequentlyassociated comorbidities,anti-cancertreatments,andthemalignancyitself.To thebestofourknowledge,thisisthefirstreportofBHTafterICI use,suggestingthatBHTmayrepresentanatypicaloralirAE.To date,theoraleffectsinducedbyICIshavenotbeenwellexplored, andfurtherstudiesarenecessarytoelucidatetheunderlying mecha-nisms and possibleassociation with anti-tumor responses,which havesignificantimplicationsregardingprognosisandQoL.Inthe presentcontext,wheretheuseofICIisrapidlyincreasing,ourcase emphasizestheneedtoremainvigilantfornewandatypicalirAEs.
Disclosure
S. Novello has received speaker bureau or advisor fees from Eli Lilly, MSD,Roche, BMS, Takeda, Pfizer, AstraZeneca, and BoehringerIngelheim.Theremainingauthorshavestatedthatthey havenoconflictsofinterest.
References
1.SrivastavaA,Al-ZubidiN,AppelbaumE,etal.Immune-relatedoral,otologic,and ocularadverseevents.AdvExpMedBiol.2020;1244:295–307.
2.RicciutiB,GenovaC,DeGiglioA,etal.Impactofimmune-relatedadverseevents onsurvivalinpatientswithadvancednon-smallcelllungcancertreatedwith nivolumab:long-termoutcomesfromamulti-institutionalanalysis.JCancerRes ClinOncol.2019;145:479–485.
3.FriedmanCF,SnyderA.Atypicalautoimmuneadverseeffectswithcheckpoint blockadetherapies.AnnOncol.2017;28:206–207.
4.LacoutureM,SibaudV.Toxicsideeffectsoftargetedtherapiesand immunother-apies affectingthe skin, oral mucosa, hair,and nails. AmJClin Dermatol. 2018;19:31–39.
5.Gurvits GE, Tan A. Black hairy tongue syndrome. World J Gastroenterol. 2014;20:10845–10850.
6.SchlagerE,StClaireC,AshackK,KhachemouneA.Blackhairytongue: predis-posingfactors,diagnosis,andtreatment.AmJClinDermatol.2017;18:563–569.
7.RohaniB.Oralmanifestationsinpatientswithdiabetesmellitus.WorldJDiabetes. 2019;10:485–489.
8.ThompsonDF,KesslerTL.Drug-inducedblackhairytongue.Pharmacotherapy. 2010;30:585–593.
9.JacksonLK,JohnsonDB,SosmanJA,MurphyBA,EpsteinJB. Oralhealthin oncology:impactofimmunotherapy.SupportCareCancer.2015;23:1–3.
10.JeongJS,LeeJY,KimMK,etal.Blackhairytongueassociatedwitherlotinib treat-mentinapatientwithadvancedlungcancer.AnnDermatol.2011.doi:10.5021/ ad.2011.23.4.526.
11.AlfreijatM.Tonguehyperpigmentationassociatedwithchemotherapy.J Commu-nityHospInternMedPerspect.2013.doi:10.3402/jchimp.v3i3-4.21047.
12.ParvaeiP,MortazaviH,BaharvandM,etal.SeverePigmentationofOralMucosa, SkinandNailsDuetoBreastCancerChemotherapy– CaseReport.Dentaland MedicalProblems.2015.
13.YamagishiY,MaruyamaK,KobayashiK,etal.Blackhairytongueafter chemother-apy formalignantbrain tumors. Acta Neurochir(Wien).2017.doi:10.1007/ s00701-016-3036-5.
14.SowML,MoukafihB,BaldeS,etal.Vinorelbineandcarboplatin-inducedblack tongue:Acasereport.Therapie.2020.doi:10.1016/j.therap.2019.05.006.
4
ClinicalLungCancer 2021Pleasecitethisarticleas:CristinaCecchietal,BlackHairyTongueAfterImmuneCheckpointInhibitorsinNSCLC:ACaseReportandReviewofthe Literature,ClinicalLungCancer,https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cllc.2021.03.008