The first reports on Doppler recordings of blood velocity signals from the umbilical artery [1, 2] stim- ulated attempts to record blood flow in fetal vessels.
In 1979 Gill presented a method combining a quasi- real-time imaging and pulsed-wave Doppler technique for estimating the volume flow in the intraabdominal part of the umbilical vein [3]. The ultrasound system used (Octoson, Ultrasonic Institute, Millers Point, Australia) did not allow the recording of high blood velocities owing to the low repetition frequency of the Doppler ultrasound pulses (2 kHz) necessitated by the long distance between the ultrasound transdu- cers emerged in a water bath and the target vessel.
Eik-Nes et al. [4] applied the principle of intermit- tently using two-dimensional and pulsed-wave Dop- pler ultrasound by combining a linear array scanner and a 2-MHz Doppler velocimeter [4]. The two trans- ducers were mounted firmly to a unit with an inclina- tion of the Doppler transducer of 458 to the linear ar- ray transducer. By placing the linear array transducer on the maternal abdomen so it was parallel with a sufficiently long portion of the vessel of interest, in- sonation by Doppler ultrasound under a known angle (458) was achieved and thus the possibility of correct- ing the recorded mean blood velocity for the insona- tion angle (Fig. 11.1).
With the above arrangement, the Doppler transdu- cer could be located relatively close to the fetal body, and so a high repetition rate (9.75 kHz) of Doppler pulses could be used. This technique allowed veloci- ties up to 1.7 cm/s to be detected down to a depth of 6.5 cm [5], and the first recordings of blood velocity signals from the fetal descending aorta were obtained [4]. Unfortunately, during these first recordings a high-pass filter with a cutoff frequency of 600 Hz was employed, in agreement with the experience from Doppler recordings in the adult aorta, where it is nec- essary to eliminate disturbing low-frequency Doppler shift signals from the vessel walls. This technique caused an erroneous appearance of the fetal aortic velocity waveforms noted in the two first reports [4, 5] with only systolic velocities present. Today such wavefroms would be recognized as highly abnormal [6]. The estimated time-averaged mean velocity was also influenced by erroneous high-pass filtering of
Doppler signals; consequently, the calculated values of the volume flow cannot be considered reliable.
The Malmæ research group, at that time including Sturla Eik-Nes, evaluated and further developed the Doppler method for estimating fetal aortic blood flow. In an experimental study comparing the electro- magnetic and Doppler measurements of aortic flow in pigs, the artificial distortion of the aortic signals was recognized [7]. This discovery enabled correction of the original reports on fetal aortic flow and the recommendation of not using a high-pass filter with a cutoff frequency higher than 100 Hz.
For recording Doppler shift signals from the fetal descending aorta, a duplex system combining pulsed Doppler ultrasound and real-time imaging is necessary to localize the vessel and to precisely position the sam- ple volume. Duplex ultrasound systems employing a sector scanner are most often used for Doppler exam- inations of the fetal circulation. They are less suitable for fetal aorta examination owing to the difficulty of ensuring an acceptable (i.e., <608) insonation angle.
Figures 11.2±11.4 demonstrate the problems of obtain- ing a good image of a sufficiently long portion of the fetal descending aorta and at the same time an accept- able angle of insonation by Doppler ultrasonography.
Fetal Descending Aorta
Karel MarsÏl
Fig. 11.1. Doppler velocimetry of fetal descending aorta:
original method combining a linear array real-time scanner
and a 2-MHz pulsed Doppler instrument according to Eik-
Nes et al. [4]. The Doppler transducer is firmly attached to
the linear array transducer at an angle of 458 (a)
Thus for practical reasons, systems combining a linear array transducer and pulsed Doppler may be advanta- geous for recording signals from the fetal aorta. As the descending aorta is an easily identified large vessel with flow in the distal direction, color flow imaging does not provide substantial help to the operator.
Fetal Aortic Doppler Velocimetry
Aortic Flow Estimation
The combination of the linear array real-time scanner and pulsed Doppler was originally designed to esti- mate volume flow in the fetal aorta from the values of
time-averaged mean velocity and the aortic diameter [4]. For correct estimation of the mean velocity, proper location of a sufficiently large sample volume is necessary; hence the whole lumen of the vessel is insonated during both systole and diastole. Further- more, the insonation angle must be reliably con- trolled to enable correction of the recorded mean Doppler shift frequency. The use of a high-pass filter causes overestimation of the mean velocity. Unfortu- nately, because of the pulsatile character of the aortic flow and the changing velocity profile during the car- diac cycle, it is impossible to use a standard correc- tion factor.
The errors in the velocity measurement can be kept to a minimum by meticulous performance of the exam- ination by experienced operators who are aware of the problems noted above. Much greater risk of error is in- volved when measuring the aortic diameter because of the relatively low spatial resolution of the ultrasound scanners and dynamic diameter changes during aortic pulsations. Each error is squared in the calculation of the cross-sectional area of the vessel and thus has a sig- nificant impact on the resulting value of the calculated volume flow. The smaller the caliber of the vessel, the more significant the impact (Fig. 11.5).
Various methods for measuring the diameter of the fetal aorta have been used: Averaging of measure- ments using calipers in ten subsequently frozen images of the aorta, M-mode recording, and time-dis- tance recording [8]. The resolution power of the time-distance recording has been improved and a special instrument developed (Diamove, Teltec, Lund, Sweden) that gives reliable measurements of the fetal aortic diameter [9]. It has been shown that recording changes in the fetal aortic diameter can provide an estimate of the changes in intrauterine blood pres- Fig. 11.2. Recording of fetal aortic velocities with a duplex
ultrasound system including a sector scanner and a pulsed and color Doppler mode. A good image of the fetal des- cending aorta is obtained. The insonation angle for Dop- pler ultrasound is close to 908, however, which gives no or low amplitude shift signals in the spectral Doppler mode and no color in the color Doppler mode
Fig. 11.3. Fetal descending aorta in an oblique projection illustrates the difficulty of obtaining a suitable angle of in- sonation for Doppler recording of aortic velocities with a duplex sector scanner
Fig. 11.4. Examination of the fetal descending aorta with a
linear array duplex system. The color Doppler box and the
pulsed Doppler beam are inclined; the insonation angle is
still high
sure. Hence this technique may have potential for re- search and clinical application [10].
The problems involved when estimating volume blood flow in the fetal descending aorta were elabo- rated in the paper by Eik-Nes et al. [11]. In a com- parative study mentioned above, good agreement was found between simultaneous flow measurements in pig aorta with an electromagnetic and Doppler ultra- sound method: correlation coefficient (r)=0.91 [7].
Similar good correlation was found for the descend- ing aorta of the fetal lambwhen comparing the Dop- pler ultrasonographic estimation of flow with electro- magnetic flowmeters (r=0.93) [12] or radionuclide- labeled microspheres (r=0.94) [13]. These results were obtained under experimental conditions. Similar accuracy might be achieved in the hands of experi- enced operators in carefully performed physiologic studies on human fetuses near term. There is little doubt, however, that the method of estimating vol- ume flow in the fetal aorta is open to overwhelming errors when applied in a clinical situation. Therefore the interest of clinicians and researchers has focused on waveform analysis of fetal aortic velocities.
Various ultrasound systems that allow estimation of the fetal aortic volume flow have been tested by us in vitro and in vivo ± one utilizing the time-domain prin- ciple (CVI-Q, Philips Ultrasound, Santa Ana, CA) [14, 15] and the other combining on-line the time-distance recording of aortic diameter using a phase-locked echo-tracking system with the 2-MHz pulsed Doppler estimation of mean blood velocity (Fig. 11.6) [16].
Power Doppler images of the fetal descending aorta were also used for measurement of the vessel diameter to be used together with the mean velocity for calcula- tion of volume flow [17]. All these methods necessitate further evaluation before possible clinical application.
Aortic Velocity Waveform Analysis
Several of the errors inherent in volume flow estima- tion are eliminated when waveform analysis of the maximum blood velocity is used: Uniform insonation of the vessel is not as critical as it is when perform- ing the mean velocity estimation, there is no influ- ence of high-pass filters (so long as the diastolic velo- cities exceed the cutoff frequency of the filter), the waveform indices are independent of the insonation angle, and values for the aorta diameter and fetal weight are not needed. On the other hand, waveform indices do not directly represent the blood flow, and the results should therefore be interpreted with care.
The waveform of the fetal maximum aortic veloc- ity is usually characterized by some of the waveform indices described elsewhere in this book (see Chap. 4). In hypoxic fetuses, similar to the umbilical artery waveform, diastolic velocities in the descend- ing aorta decrease and eventually disappear or even become reversed, a condition called absent or re- versed end-diastolic (ARED) flow. In 1984 Jouppila and Kirkinen [6] described the absence of diastolic velocity in the fetal descending aorta and called it a Fig. 11.5. Error in flow measurements due to errors when
measuring diameter of four vessels of different caliber. (Re- printed from [5] with permission)
Fig. 11.6. Simultaneous recording of blood velocity (upper tracing) and vessel diameter (lower tracing) from descend- ing aorta of a healthy 30-week fetus. (Reprinted from [84]
with permission)
total end-diastolic block; and in 1986 Lingman et al.
[18] reported the first four cases of reversal of di- astolic velocities in the fetal aorta. A semiquantitative method of assessing the waveform has been evolved for clinical use, four blood flow classes (BFCs) being defined to describe the waveform with emphasis on its diastolic part (Fig. 11.7) [19]: BFC 0 (normal), positive flow throughout the heart cycle and a normal PI; BFC I, positive flow throughout the cycle and a PI³mean+2 SD of the normals; BFC II, nondetectable end-diastolic velocity; BFC III, absence of positive flow throughout the major part of the diastole, re- verse flow during diastole. More recently, a method has been developed for computerized pattern recogni- tion of ten waveform types [20].
When evaluating the end-diastolic portion of the aortic velocity waveform, it is important for the op- erator to be aware of the risk of reporting a falsely absent flow. The combination of a high insonation angle and a high cutoff level of the high-pass filter included in the Doppler instrument eliminates Dop-
pler shift signals of considerably high amplitude. An example of this effect is presented in Fig. 11.8. Ob- viously, the recommendation not to use an insonation angle of more than 558 and a high-pass filter higher than 100 Hz [21] is valid not only for estimating mean velocity but also for waveform analysis.
The appearance of the fetal aortic maximum veloc- ity waveform and the values of waveform indices are independent of the direction of insonation (i.e., up- stream or downstream). The position of the sample volume is important, as the waveform of aortic blood velocity changes with increasing distance from the heart. Recorded in the fetal thorax, the velocity wave- form of the descending aorta shows high pulsatility
Fig. 11.7. Blood flow classes (BFC) of fetal aortic wave- forms. BFC normal positive flow throughout the heart cycle and a normal pulsatility index, BFC I positive flow through- out the cycle and a pulsatility index³mean+2 SD of the normals, BFC II nondetectable end-diastolic velocity, BFC III absence of positive flow throughout the major part of di- astole or reverse flow during diastole
Fig. 11.8. Effect of insonation angle and high-pass filtering
of Doppler shift signals on the aortic velocity waveform of
a healthy fetus. Bottom: Combination of a high cutoff level
of the high-pass filter (200 Hz) and a high insonation angle
(608) erroneously eliminates the diastolic velocities and
gives the waveform a false pathologic appearance with a
high pulsatility index
with a low proportion of diastolic flow (Fig. 11.9); re- corded in the fetal abdominal aorta, the proportion of diastolic flow increases [22]. It is therefore crucial to standardize the site of recording; typically, in the thoracic aorta the sample volume is located just above the diaphragm.
Fetal Aortic Flow
in Uncomplicated Pregnancies
Blood flow in the fetal descending aorta is character- ized by high blood velocity ± higher than that found in adult descending aorta [23], and the waveform of the aortic velocity is influenced by the low vascular resistance in the placenta. In the uncompromised fe- tus during the second half of pregnancy, aortic dia- stolic velocity is present throughout the cardiac cycle, the proportion of diastolic flow being higher in the abdominal than in the thoracic descending aorta [22].
Consequently, the pulsatility index (PI) [24] and re- sistance index (RI) [25] are typically lower in the ab- dominal than in the thoracic fetal aorta. The narrow spectrum of Doppler shift signals recorded from the thoracic aorta during systole indicates a fairly flat flow profile. In the abdominal aorta, lower and more dispersed frequencies can be seen owing to the change of flow profile toward a more parabolic pat- tern.
The time-averaged mean velocity in the thoracic descending aorta does not change significantly during the third trimester (35.0Ô5.5 cm/s, meanÔSD) [26], the increase in the volume flow being related to the growing aortic diameter. The volume flow corrected for fetal weight was found to be stable during late pregnancy, the reports in the literature ranging from 206 to 280 ml´min
±1´kg
±1(Table 11.1). The mean
aortic PI was reported to range from 1.83 to 2.80 and to be rather stable until 36 weeks (Table 11.2). There- after a slight increase was observed toward term [22].
Concomitantly, a slight decrease in the volume flow was reported [26].
Estimation of flow at two levels of the fetal des- cending aorta and in the abdominal part of the umbilical vein enabled calculation of the percentual distribution of the aortic flow (Fig. 11.10). The pla- cental proportion of blood flow in the descending thoracic aorta related to the fetal weight diminished with increasing pregnancy length: At 28 weeks it was 59% and at term 33% [26]. This finding is in good agreement with the reports of other authors, who have described the umbilical venous blood flow to be 64% [44], 55% [31] or 54% [28] of the fetal aortic blood flow from 26 weeks onward. In fetal lambs 65% of the blood flow in the descending aorta was found to be directed to the placenta [45]. The de- crease in the placental proportion of the flow with the progression of pregnancy might be due to the changing ratio of fetal to placental weight [46].
The velocity waveform in the fetal aorta is subject to several influences, one of them being fetal heart function. In a study on exteriorized lambfetuses, a strong correlation was found between the rising slope of the velocity waveform and myocardial contractility (measured as dP/dt) in the left heart ventricle [47].
Interestingly, the next best correlation was found for the aortic PI.
Råsånen et al. [32] found in human fetuses a good correlation between the growth of the fetal heart, the lumen of the descending aorta, and aortic volume flow. The aortic velocity indices were independent of cardiac size and fractional shortening. The authors interpreted this finding as myocardial contractility that remained stable despite the changing peripheral vascular resistance so long as the changes of resis- tance remained within the normal range.
The nonsimultaneous measurements of pulsatile mean flow velocity and vessel diameter in the fetal des- cending aorta can be synchronized by transabdominal fetal electrocardiography (ECG) [48±50]. A more accu- rate estimation of the aortic flow is then possible, and the aortic stroke volume can be calculated. In the above studies, the stroke volume has been reported to range from 2.8 to 5.6 ml/min in the thoracic aorta and from 2.4 to 4.3 ml/min in the abdominal aorta of healthy third trimester fetuses. The relative stroke volume was found to be stable during the last trimester of ges- tation (1.7±2.1 ml´min
±1´kg
±1) [48, 50]. The method used for these examinations is laborious, mainly be- cause of the difficulty obtaining transabdominal fetal ECG signals of acceptable quality. To circumvent this problem, Tonge et al. [49] applied their experience from animal experiments and recommended that the Fig. 11.9. Doppler shift spectrum recorded from the tho-
racic descending aorta of a healthy fetus at 28 weeks' ges-
tation
Table 11.1. Reference values of the fetal aortic blood flow reported in the literature
Study Gestational
age (weeks) No. Volume flow
(ml´min
±1´kg
±1) Comment Thoracic descending aorta
Eik-Nes et al. [4] 32±41 26 191Ô12 Erroneous signal filtering
Griffin et al. [27] 28±40 75 246Ô30
van Lierde et al. [28] 37±40 20 216Ô24
MarsÏl et al. [29] 27±40 64 238Ô40
Erskine & Ritchie [30] 28±40 71 206Ô72
Lingman & MarsÏl [26] 27±36 21 238Ô46 Longitudinal study
37±38 21 221Ô41
39±40 21 213Ô37
Rasmussen [31] 29±40 58 234 (184±289)
Råsånen et al. [32] 40Ô 2.3 51 290Ô67
Cameron et al. [33] 28 9 143Ô34 Low values for unclear reason
36 13 149Ô45
Brodszki et al. [16] 28±31 20 213Ô77 Longitudinal study;
32±35 20 239Ô66 simultaneous automatic
measurement of the velocity and diameter
Abdominal aorta
Eldridge et al. [34] 18±40 18 184Ô20 Longitudinal study
Lingman & MarsÏl [26] 27±36 21 167Ô43 Longitudinal study
37±38 21 133Ô38
39±40 21 136Ô30
Mean valuesÔSD or range are given.
Table 11.2. Reference values of the fetal aortic pulsatility index reported in the literature
Study Gestational
age (weeks) No. of pregnan- cies
PI Comment
Griffin et al. [35] 24±42 98 1.83Ô0.29
Van Eyck et al. [36] 37±38 13 2.7Ô0.3 Mean velocity PI; state 1F
Jouppila & Kirkinen [37] 30±42 43 2.49 (1.94±3.10)
Lingman & MarsÏl [22] 28±40 21 1.96Ô0.31 Longitudinal study
Tonge et al. [38] 26±29 10 2.0Ô0.2
32±33 15 2.2Ô0.3
38±41 13 2.3Ô0.2
Arabin et al. [39] 20±40 137 2.56Ô0.47
Rasmussen [29] 29±40 58 1.83 (1.32±2.20)
Råsånen et al. [32] 40Ô2.3 51 2.07Ô0.44
ârstræm et al. [40] 25 22 1.81Ô0.19 Longitudinal study
40 22 1.95Ô0.30
Hecher et al. [41] 29±42 209 1.86 (1.49±2.24)
Ferrazi et al. [42] 26 1.86 Regression line based on
38 2.30 120 measurements
De Koekkoek-Doll et al. [43] 36±40 23 1.92Ô0.18 State 1F
PI, pulsatility index; mean valuesÔSD or range are given.
first derivative of the mean velocity and diameter wave- forms is used to synchronize heart cycles.
Intrinsic Influences on Fetal Aortic Flow and Flow Indices
Similar to other fetal vessels (e.g., the carotid artery [51]), a negative correlation has been found between the aortic PI and fetal heart rate, with correlation coefficients between ±0.43 and ±0.73 [22, 36, 43, 52].
This inverse relation was pronounced mainly during periods of behavioral state 2F in term fetuses [36].
In a series of studies, the Rotterdam research group reported a clear dependence of fetal aortic ve- locity waveform indices on fetal behavioral states in term pregnancies [36, 43] and on the fetal activity state during the early third trimester [52]. The values for the fetal aortic PI were higher during fetal quiet sleep than during active sleep, with decreased impe- dance and increased flow in fetal musculature.
All noncompromised fetuses perform periodic breathing movements, with contraction of the dia- phragm, expansion of the abdominal wall, and retrac- tion of the thorax during ªinspirationº and a return to the rest position during ªexpirationº [53]. Fetal breathing movements have a pronounced effect on blood circulation in the umbilical cord and the intra- fetal vessels [29]. The aortic blood flow velocity wave- forms exhibit modulation of their shape, with rhyth- mic oscillations in the amplitude of their peak veloci- ties and diastolic velocities. The end-diastolic veloci- ties sometimes eventually disappear during fetal ªin-
spiration.º The time-averaged mean velocity usually increases ± up to 40% ± during periods of fetal breathing movements [29]. Probably, the cardiac out- put also increases as a consequence of increased venous blood return to the fetal heart [54].
The above observation is important to consider when recording fetal aortic blood velocities: To obtain reproducible results, only Doppler traces recorded dur- ing periods without fetal breathing should be accepted for analysis. Fetal breathing movements can usually be recognized in the two-dimensional realtime image of the fetus, the aortic Doppler shift signals, or the Dop- pler traces of umbilical venous velocities.
Fetal Aortic Blood Flow During Labor
The fetal aortic volume blood flow has been shown to increase with progression of labor in a study in which the measurements were performed between contractions [55]. The increased fetal flow might be a phenomenon similar to the reactive hyperemia found in the uteroplacental circulation of experimental ani- mals between contractions [56]. In the study by Lind- blad et al. [55] there was no change in the aortic PI with advancing labor, and there was no difference be- tween patients with and those without ruptured membranes. Fendel et al. [57] measured the mean fe- tal aortic velocity during labor and found a decrease in the velocity during contractions. The aortic PI and RI remained unchanged.
Pathophysiologic Changes of Fetal Aortic Flow During Intrauterine Hypoxia
Blood flow in the fetal descending aorta supplies the placenta and lower body of the fetus, including kid- neys, splanchnic and pelvic organs, and lower ex- tremities. The major portion of blood in fetal des- cending aorta is directed to the placenta. Thus an in- crease in the resistance to flow in the placental vascu- lar bed can profoundly influence the flow not only in the umbilical artery but also in the descending aorta.
It would be reflected by typical changes of the veloc- ity waveform, (i.e., decreased or no diastolic velocity) (Fig. 11.11). Possibly, vasoconstriction in the lower fetal body, which is known to be one of the mecha- nisms involved in the centralization of flow during hypoxia, potentiates the effect on aortic velocity waveforms.
Doppler indication of increased resistance to flow in the fetoplacental circulation was found to be re- 100
50
0
%
28 32 36 40
0 50 100
%
Viscera
Placenta
Lower extr.
Weeks Distribution of Fetal
Aortic Blood Flow
Fig. 11.10. Distribution of the fetal aortic blood flow dur-
ing the third trimester of normal pregnancy. Blood flow in
the thoracic descending aorta corresponds to 100%. (Re-
printed from [26] with permission)
lated to the increased neonatal nucleated red blood cell counts that are considered a sign of intrauterine hypoxia [58]. Doppler results from the fetal descend- ing aorta, umbilical artery, and maternal uterine ar- teries were independent determinants of neonatal nu- cleated red blood cell count.
In an experimental study on the fetal lamb, in- creasing the placental and hind limbresistance by embolization with microspheres caused a progressive increase in the aortic flow PI [59]. In another study on pigs, the aortic PI, recorded by Doppler ultra- sonography, was shown to correlate with the total peripheral resistance calculated from the invasively measured blood flow and pressure (r=0.64±0.87) [60]. In the study by Adamson and Langille [59] the aortic PI reflected not only the vascular resistance but also the pulsatile flow and pressure pulsatility (Fig. 11.12). Thus an increasing fetal aortic PI should not be interpreted solely as an expression of increas- ing placental vascular resistance.
When studying the aortic blood velocity wave- forms of lambfetuses during experimental asphyxia, Malcus et al. [61] found a loss of aortic end-diastolic flow velocities, a significant increase in the PI, and a decrease in mean velocity. Concomitantly, increases in the diameter and mean velocity were recorded in the fetal common carotid artery [62], and there was a slight decrease in the carotid artery PI. These changes indicate a redistribution of flow, although the changes occurred as relatively late phenomena in the develop- ment of acute asphyxia.
An interesting observation on fetal aortic isthmus has been reported, based on animal experiments [63]
and human studies [64]. With increased resistance to flow in the placenta and fetal lower body, changes in the diastolic flow velocity occurred earlier in the aor- tic isthmus than in the descending aorta and umbili-
cal artery. In the sheep fetus during an acute increase in placental vascular resistance, delivery of oxygen to the brain was preserved despite a significant decrease in arterial oxygen content as long as net flow through the aortic isthmus was antegrade [65]. These reports offer an interesting possibility of closely following the process of centralization of flow. The suggested con- cept awaits evaluation in prospective clinical studies.
Fig. 11.11. Absence of end-diastolic velocity in the des- cending aorta of a growth-retarded fetus at 27 weeks' ges- tation
Fig. 11.12. Flow pulsatility index (P.I.), flow pulse ampli-
tude, and mean blood flow measured with an electromag-
netic flowmeter in the descending thoracic aorta of sheep
fetuses versus the vascular resistance of the lower body cir-
culation during progressive embolization of the hind limbs
and placenta. Solid circles show values obtained during an-
giotensin II infusion. (Reprinted from [59], with permission)
Clinical Studies
Fetal Cardiac Arrhythmias
Doppler recording of fetal aortic velocities provides important information of the hemodynamic conse- quences of fetal cardiac arrhythmias. Simultaneous detection of Doppler signals from the fetal abdominal aorta, reflecting ventricular contractions, and the in- ferior vena cava, reflecting atrial contractions, can fa- cilitate the classification of arrhythmias [66±68]. In most cases of fetal arrhythmia, the estimated aortic volume flow remains within normal limits, indicating the ability of the fetal heart to maintain cardiac out- put [67, 69]. Subnormally low values of aortic flow were found in fetuses with severe arrhythmias that caused heart failure [67]. In cases of bradyarrhyth- mias and tachyarrhythmias, a decrease in the aortic flow was observed when the fetal heart rate exceeded the limits of 50 or 230 bpm, respectively [69].
In fetuses with premature heartbeats, an increase in peak aortic velocities was observed with the first postextrasystolic beats [70]. Similarly, the peak systol- ic velocities are higher in fetuses with complete atrio- ventricular block than in those with regular sinus rhythm [67]. This finding, together with the above- described compensation for negative effects of cardiac arrhythmias on fetal cardiac output, indicates that the Frank-Starling mechanism is valid for fetal myocar- dium.
Fetuses with congestive heart failure caused by a cardiac arrhythmia sometimes require transplacental treatment with digoxin or antiarrhythmic drugs. In addition to the effect of treatment on heart rhythm, the improved performance of the fetal heart can be followed by serial measurements of fetal aortic vol- ume blood flow [71].
Fetal Anemia
In isoimmunized pregnancies the degree of fetal ane- mia can be determined by analyzing fetal blood sam- ples obtained by cordocentesis. It would facilitate their clinical management if these anemic fetuses could be identified with a noninvasive method. One of the early reports suggested that there was an in- verse correlation between the cord hemoglobin at birth and the time-averaged mean velocity and vol- ume blood flow recorded antenatally in the intraab- dominal portion of the umbilical vein using Doppler ultrasonography [72]. In the descending aorta of pre- viously untransfused isoimmunized fetuses, Right- mire et al. [73] reported an increased mean blood ve- locity and a negative correlation with the hematocrit of umbilical cord blood obtained by cord puncture under fetoscopic control. Their finding was confirmed by Nicolaides et al. [74], who related the values of mean aortic velocity to the hemoglobin deficit in blood samples obtained by cordocentesis. The find- ings of increased fetal aortic velocities in anemic fetuses (Fig. 11.13) are in accord with an increase in their cardiac output as a consequence of lowered blood viscosity, increased venous return, and cardiac preload. Doppler cardiac studies of anemic fetuses showed indications of increased cardiac output [76, 77]. After intrauterine transfusion, a decrease or even normalization of the mean velocity in the fetal aorta was observed [78]. In contrast to the changes in aortic time-averaged mean velocity seen with fetal anemia, there were no changes in the waveform in- dices.
Recently, it has been shown by Mari et al. [79] that Doppler examination of the fetal middle cerebral ar- tery can be used for clinical management of pregnan- cies with red-cell alloimmunization. The sensitivity of the middle cerebral artery velocimetry for detection of fetal anemia seems to be superior to that of the velocimetry of fetal descending aorta.
Fig. 11.13. Three-dimensional presentation of Doppler signals recorded from the descending aorta of a normal fetus (a) and an anemic fetus (b). Note the increase of velocity amplitudes and the right shift of the velo- city power in the anemic fetus.
(Reprinted from [75] with per- mission)
a b
Diabetes Mellitus
Serial Doppler examinations were performed in a group of 40 pregnant women with diabetes mellitus [80]. A high-volume blood flow in the fetal descend- ing aorta was found during the early third trimester;
near term, blood flow approached normal values. The PI in the umbilical artery and fetal aorta was within the normal range, so long as there were no signs of fetal growth retardation or hypoxia. Otherwise no flow variations specific for diabetic pregnancies were seen. Similar findings were also reported for pregnant women with gestational diabetes [81].
Intrauterine Growth Restriction
Intrauterine growth restriction (IUGR) can have vari- ous etiologies, restricted flow through the placental vasculature being the most common cause of this rel- atively frequent complication of pregnancy. As de- scribed above, the increased vascular impedance in the placenta is reflected in a changed blood velocity waveform in the descending fetal aorta, with a reduc- tion of diastolic velocities and a corresponding in- crease in PI [6, 19, 35]. These findings are similar to those reported for the umbilical artery of growth-re- tarded fetuses [82].
In a study that evaluated placental morphology in relation to intrauterine flow in IUGR fetuses, only the presence of placental infarction was significantly as- sociated with abnormal flow velocity findings in the fetal descending aorta (high PI, BFC I±III, low mean velocity) [83].
In the descending aorta of growth-retarded fetuses, low values were obtained for the time-averaged mean velocity and volume flow, though they did not differ significantly from those of controls [19]. This similar- ity was probably due to the already mentioned meth- odologic difficulty of precisely estimating volume flow. Using an improved technique combining an ul- trasonic phase-locked echo-tracking system for diam- eter measurement synchronized with a pulsed Dop- pler velocimeter [16], Gardiner et al. [84] found both the relative pulse amplitude, mean blood velocity, and volume flow to be significantly lower in the descend- ing aorta of growth-restricted fetuses than in the con- trols. Also, the aortic pulse waves of growth-restricted fetuses showed values significantly different from those in controls, reflecting the chronic ventriculovas- cular responses to increased placental impedance [85].
In severely growth-restricted fetuses developing signs of intrauterine distress, the aortic end-diastolic velocity disappears or even becomes reversed (BFC II and III; Fig. 11.7) [18]. An association has been found to exist between the degree of fetal hypoxia,
hypercapnia, acidosis, and hyperlactemia, as diag- nosed in blood samples obtained by cordocentesis from growth-restricted fetuses and changes in the mean fetal aortic velocity [86] and the velocity wave- form [87]. The aortic velocity waveform changes have been observed to precede the cardiotocographic changes, the median time lag being 2±3 days [19, 88], though the interval between the first blood velocity changes and the first changes in cardiotocographic tracings may be as much as several weeks [19, 89].
The finding of ARED flow in the fetal aorta is as- sociated with an adverse outcome of the pregnancy [19, 90] and increased neonatal morbidity [91, 92].
Reverse flow during diastole identifies fetuses in dan- ger of intrauterine death. Perinatal mortality in cases with reverse flow is reported to be high ± in some se- ries as high as 100% [93]. The combination of ARED flow in the fetal descending aorta and pulsations in the umbilical vein seems to indicate a fetus with se- vere hypoxia and iminent heart failure [18].
Aortic Doppler Velocimetry as a Diagnostic Test of IUGR and Fetal Hypoxia
Several prospective studies on IUGR pregnancies have been performed to evaluate the predictive capacity of fetal aortic velocity waveforms with regard to birth weight, occurrence of fetal distress, and perinatal out- come. Tables 11.3 and 11.4 summarize results of some of the studies in terms of sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values. For the RI ra- tios between the common carotid artery and descend- ing thoracic aorta of small-for-gestational-age (SGA) fetuses redistributing their flow, a sensitivity of 94%
was reported for prediction of cesarean section for fetal distress [96]. It is obvious that in IUGR fetuses fetal aortic velocimetry is a better predictor of fetal health than fetal size, which is not surprising in view of the multiplicity of determinants of fetal growth.
The accumulated evidence suggests that, as is also the case for umbilical artery velocimetry, Doppler fe- tal aortic examination is better suited for use as a secondary diagnostic test in preselected high-risk pregnancies than as a primary screening test in a whole pregnant population [97]. In a prospective study of growth-retarded fetuses, Gudmundsson and MarsÏl [90] compared the predictive value of aortic versus umbilical artery velocity waveforms: The PI in the umbilical artery was found to be a slightly better predictor of fetal outcome than the aortic PI, though the BFC was similarly predictive in the two vessels.
Two longitudinal studies confirmed that the changes
in the umbilical artery PI preceded changes in the
thoracic aorta of IUGR fetuses [98, 99]. Doppler ex- amination of the umbilical artery is technically easier and can be done with less sophisticated and less ex- pensive instruments. Therefore for simple monitoring of fetal health in suspected cases of IUGR, umbilical artery Doppler velocimetry seems preferable. The in- vestigation of fetal aortic arterial waveforms might provide more detailed information on the circulatory adaptation and pathophysiologic mechanisms in the process of IUGR. It should be validated, however, in randomized clinical trials comprising management protocols based on the results from Doppler examina- tions of several vessel areas: uteroplacental circula- tion, umbilical artery, fetal aorta, and fetal cerebral vessels. Possibly such a concept can improve clinical decision making for preterm growth-restricted fe- tuses, a group usually posing a difficult problem for the clinician.
Follow-up Studies
It is of interest to follow the postnatal development of infants who suffered growth restriction and hypoxia in utero and to evaluate the possible predictive value
of Doppler fetal velocimetry with regard to long-term prognosis. The Malmæ group performed extensive so- matic, neurologic, and psychological investigations of 149 children at 7 years of age. All of them had been subjects for Doppler velocimetry of the descending aorta in utero and about half were SGA at birth. A univariate analysis showed that infants with abnormal intrauterine aortic blood flow had an increased fre- quency of minor neurologic abnormalities [100] and lower mean intelligence quotient [101] than infants with normal intrauterine hemodynamics. Logistic re- gression analysis revealed a statistically significant as- sociation between the aortic BFC and the neurologic [102] and intellectual [101] status at age 7 years (Ta- ble 11.5).
The above findings invite speculation as to whether an early intervention in cases of growth-re- stricted fetuses with an abnormal BFC might prevent not only fetal mortality but also some minor develop- ment deficits. Such management policy, however, en- genders the danger of iatrogenic prematurity. There- fore a protocol for management of preterm babies, based on the results of fetal velocimetry, should be tested in randomized clinical trials before adopting it in clinical practice.
Table 11.3. Diagnostic capacity of fetal aortic Doppler velocimetry with regard to the prediction of intrauterine growth restriction
Study No. of
pregnancies Prev
(%) Sens
(%) Spec
(%) PPV
(%) NPV
(%) Kappa
value Aortic PI
Gudmundsson and MarsÏl [90] 139 52 40 87 76 57 0.26
ARED flow
Laurin et al. [94] 159 47 50 97 67 93 0.48
Chaoui et al. [89] 954 ? 87 82 67 94 ±
Gudmundsson and MarsÏl [90] 139 52 87 61 46 93 0.38
Prev, prevalence; Sens, sensitivity; Spec, specificity; PPV, positive predictive value; NPV, negative predictive value; PI, pulsa- tility index; ARED flow, absent or reversed end-diastolic flow.
Definition of intrauterine growth retardation: reference 89: birth weight <5th percentile; references 90 and 94: birth weight £mean ±2 SD.
Table 11.4. Diagnostic capacity of fetal aortic Doppler velocimetry with regard to the prediction of operative delivery for fetal distress
Study No. of
pregnancies Prev
(%) Sens
(%) Spec
(%) PPV
(%) NPV
(%) Kappa
value Aortic PI
Arabin et al. [95] 171 ? 68 88 58 93 ±
Gudmundsson and MarsÏl [90] 139 34 62 87 71 81 0.50
ARED flow
Laurin et al. [94] 159 19 83 90 66 96 0.66
Chaoui et al. [89] 954 ? 88 82 85 95 ±
Gudmundsson and MarsÏl [90] 139 34 91 88 74 96 0.74
For explanation of abbreviations see Table 11.3.
Summary
A combination of real-time scanning and pulsed Dop- pler velocimetry is required for Doppler ultrasound velocimetry of the fetal descending aorta. A combined linear array real-time/pulsed Doppler method makes it possible to estimate fetal aortic volume flow. How- ever, the volume flow method is open to error and is therefore less suitable for application to the clinical situation. The waveform of the maximum velocities recorded from the fetal descending aorta reflects the impedance to flow in the placenta and the lower fetal body. The waveform is also influenced by other fac- tors (e.g., fetal heart function). The aortic waveform can be characterized by various indices (e.g., the PI and the RI). In a situation of increased peripheral vascular resistance, the aortic diastolic velocities de- crease and eventually disappear. In extreme cases re- versed flow during diastole can be detected. The find- ing of absent or reversed aortic flow is associated with an adverse outcome of pregnancy. For practical application, a semiquantitative method (blood flow classes) has been designed to evaluate fetal aortic velocity waveforms. The BFC method emphasizes especially the appearance of the diastolic part of the waveform. When recording fetal aortic Doppler sig- nals, caution must be taken to avoid periods of fetal breathing movements, which can profoundly influ- ence the shape of the waveform. The values of wave- form indices in the fetal aorta are also dependent on fetal heart rate and activity/behavioral states.
In uncomplicated pregnancies the velocity wave- form of the fetal descending aorta shows positive flow throughout the cardiac cycle, the proportion of dia- stolic flow being higher in the abdominal aorta than in the thoracic aorta. The PI values are stable during the last trimester of gestation, with a slight increase at term. The aortic mean velocity and the relative flow do not change significantly with gestational age
during late pregnancy. About 50%±60% of the flow in the thoracic descending aorta supplies the placenta.
In fetuses with a cardiac arrhythmia, aortic Dop- pler velocimetry can facilitate diagnosis of the ar- rhythmia, and the estimation of aortic flow can pro- vide an early indication of imminent heart failure. In anemic isoimmunized fetuses, the mean aortic veloc- ity is increased.
Clinical studies of pregnancies with IUGR showed that examination of fetal aortic velocity waveforms can be used for fetal surveillance. The develoment of fetal hypoxia is associated with typical changes of the waveform: increased PI and absence or reversal of diastolic flow. These changes usually precede other signals of fetal distress. The predictive capacity of fe- tal aortic velocimetry is comparable to that of umbili- cal artery velocimetry with regard to IUGR and the development of fetal distress. As is the case for um- bilical artery velocimetry, Doppler examination of the fetal descending aorta is suited for application as a secondary diagnostic test in high-risk pregnancies.
Changes in the intrauterine aortic waveforms have been shown to be significantly correlated to the peri- natal outcome and to the long-term postnatal neuro- logic and psychological development. Analysis of the fetal aortic flow velocity pattern can be applied, to- gether with examination of other vessel areas, for a more detailed study of redistribution of flow in the presence of fetal hypoxia. Clinical management proto- cols based on such a concept should be tested in pro- spective randomized trials.
References
1. FitzGerald DE, Drumm J (1977) Non-invasive measure- ment of human fetal circulation using ultrasound: a new method. BMJ 2:1450±1451
2. McCallum WD, Williams CB, Napel S, Diagle RE (1978) Fetal blood velocity waveforms. Am J Obstet Gynecol 132:425±429
3. Gill RW (1979) Pulsed Doppler with B-mode imaging for quantitative blood flow measurement. Ultrasound Med Biol 5:223±235
4. Eik-Nes SH, Brubakk AO, Ulstein MK (1980) Measure- ment of human fetal blood flow. BMJ 2:283±284 5. Eik-Nes SH, MarsÏl K, Brubbakk AO, Kristoffersen K,
Ulstein M (1982) Ultrasonic measurements of human fetal blood flow. J Biomed Eng 4:28±36
6. Jouppila P, Kirkinen P (1984) Increased vascular resis- tance in the descending aorta of the human fetus in hypoxia. Br J Obstet Gynaecol 91:853±856
7. Eik-Nes SH, MarsÏl K, Kristoffersen K, Vernersson E (1981) Noninvasive Messung des fetalen Blutstromes mittels Ultraschall. Ultraschall Med 2:226±231
8. Lindstræm K, MarsÏl K, Gennser G et al (1977) Device for monitoring fetal breathing movements. I. TD-re- corder: a new system for recording the distance be- tween two echo generating structures as a function of time. Ultrasound Med Biol 3:143±151
Table 11.5. Follow-up study on neurologic and intellectual performance of 149 children at 7 years of age
aVariable Relative
risk 95%
Confidence interval Significant Aortic BFC 3.64 1.25±10.54 contribution
to total IQ £85 Social group 2.82 1.12±7.07 Significant Aortic BFC 3.61 1.55±8.41 contribution
to minor neurologic dysfunction
IQ, intelligence quotient; BFC, blood flow class.
a