14
Veterinary Forensic Pathology
The Assessment of Injuries to Dolphins at Postmortem
Roger W. Byard, MBBS , MD , Catherine M. Kemper, PhD , Mike Bossley, PhD , Deborah Kelly, BVSc,
and Mark Hill, BVSc
C
ONTENTSINTRODUCTION
DOLPHINTRAUMAGROUP
ILLUSTRATIVECASES
MEDICOLEGALCONSIDERATIONS
PATHOLOGICALFEATURES
CAUSES OFDEATH
NECROPSY
CONCLUSIONS
REFERENCES
S
UMMARYInjury assessment of nonhuman subjects may be performed for a variety of reasons, most often in a forensic setting to prove or disprove human activity.
In Adelaide, South Australia, the killing of several dolphins from nearby water- ways prompted the formation of a multidisciplinary Dolphin Trauma Group,
415
From: Forensic Pathology Reviews, Vol. 4 Edited by: M. Tsokos © Humana Press Inc., Totowa, NJ
among whose aims was the performance of rapid biological and forensic assessments of dead local dolphins. Necropsy and wound evaluation by group members utilizing standard forensic techniques aimed at determining as quickly as possible causes of death, whether injuries were inflicted ante- or post- mortem, whether injuries were responsible for, or had contributed to, the fatal episode, and whether human intervention was responsible for the wounds. Esti- mation of the type and dimensions of possible weapons was also undertaken, as well as attempts to determine possible time frames for the injuries. This infor- mation was then passed on to investigating officers. A series of necropsy find- ings in seven dolphins investigated by the group (four Indo-Pacific bottlenose dolphins, one southern right whale dolphin, one short-beaked common dolphin, and one common bottlenose dolphin) is described in this chapter. Two deaths were caused by exsanguination from stabbing/spearing, two to the sequelae of entanglement with fishing gear, one to blunt craniocerebral trauma from a boat propeller injury, one to probable sepsis, and one remained undetermined. All cases had extensive histological assessment of tissues with retention of blood and tissues for future toxicological screening if required. Examination of the brain is undertaken by a neuropathologist when tissues are not putrefied. Blood spots are signed and sealed and transferred to Forensic Science South Australia for storage in case comparisons are subsequently required with blood and tis- sue on possible weapons. In this way, each dolphin has an extensive forensic evaluation to provide as much usable information to courts and prosecutors if legal proceedings are ever undertaken. The skeletons and life history samples are held in the collections of the South Australian Museum.
Key Words: Inflicted injury; marine mammal; dolphin; death; stabbing;
necropsy.
1. I
NTRODUCTIONThe accurate assessment of wounds is a fundamental requirement for practitioners of forensic medicine and pathology. Most cases require careful description, documentation, and photographic depiction of injuries so that they can be presented to courts and selected experts for subsequent explanation and evaluation. Although forensic analysis usually involves injuries to humans, there are situations where injuries to animals may require examination to assist in the determination of the cause of death and the likelihood of possible legal proceedings. The following chapter details a range of injuries encountered in a group of dolphins in South Australian waters, and discusses difficulties that may arise in evaluating mechanisms and manners of death in such animals, and the potential legal consequences of such assessments.
416 Byard et al.
2. D
OLPHINT
RAUMAG
ROUPFollowing a series of deaths of dolphins in South Australia owing to human activity, it was decided to formalize work being done in the investiga- tion of these fatalities by individuals from the South Australian Museum, the Department for Environment and Heritage, primary industries (fisheries), Forensic Science South Australia, the Australian Dolphin Research Foundation (ADRF), and private veterinary practice. A Dolphin Trauma Group was there- fore formed, the aim of which was to provide immediate biological and foren- sic assessment in cases of deaths of dolphins, particularly in the Port River area immediately adjacent to the South Australian state capital Adelaide, and to draw public attention to these events. The Port River estuary was the initial target site because it was an area frequented by groups of dolphins that had been the sub- ject of study by the ADRF for a number of years, including the use of photo- identification to establish individual identities.
Every dead dolphin found in this area that was reported to police, the Department for Environment and Heritage, or fisheries officers was evaluated by members of the group. Autopsies were arranged through the South Aus- tralian Museum, with processing of specimens and tissues through both the museum and Forensic Science South Australia. In addition, members of the group also conducted a number of examinations of injuries to other marine mammals, such as whales and seals. The details of selected cases examined by members of the group over the 5-year period from 1999 to 2004 are provided in the following section.
3. I
LLUSTRATIVEC
ASESCase 1
The carcass of an Indo-Pacific bottlenose dolphin neonate (Tursiops adun- cus, South Australian Museum 03.001) was found floating in the Port River estuary near Adelaide. The calf had been recently born to one of the dolphins studied by the ADRF and had been photographed swimming with its mother in the days before its death (Fig. 1A). Necropsy revealed two significant and lethal injuries. The first was an irregular, deeply incised wound of the left side of the head running downward, and slightly posteriorly from behind the blowhole in front of the eye (Fig. 1B). The injury was approx 300 mm in length with vari- ably ragged and cleanly incised edges. It was associated with shattering of the underlying skull and facial skeleton with opening of the cranial cavity and exposure and loss of brain tissue. Recent hemorrhage into soft tissue and brain was demonstrated histologically. The second injury was an irregular, deeply
Veterinary Forensic Pathology 417
Fig. 1. (A) A young Indo-Pacific bottlenose dolphin calf who was seen swim-
ming with its mother near power boats was subsequently found floating with a
deeply incised lethal wound of the left side of the head. (B) The skull and facial
skeleton were shattered with exposure and loss of brain tissue. (Figure continues)
incised wound of the left side of the tail (Fig. 1C), 170 mm in length extending to a depth of 40 mm into underlying vertebral bodies. The injury ran downward and slightly posteriorly, roughly parallel to the major injury to the head and 55.5 cm behind. Fresh blood clots were present within the wound. Recent hemor- rhage was also confirmed histologically. Death was caused by severe cranio- cerebral trauma most likely inflicted by a boat propeller.
Case 2
The carcass of an adult male southern right whale dolphin (Lissodelphis peronii, 04.145), never previously stranded in South Australia, was found dead on Kangaroo Island about 100 km south of Adelaide. Reddish fluid initially thought to represent hemorrhage was emanating from the mouth (Fig. 2A) and what appeared to be a stab wound was present in the right flank. At necropsy, a “V”- shaped incised wound was present in the right flank, each arm of which measured 75 mm (Fig. 2B). The wound extended 40 mm into the epaxial muscles beside the
Veterinary Forensic Pathology 419
Fig. 1. (continued) (C) A parallel deep incised wound was also present on the
left side of the tail. Both of these injuries were thought to be caused by a boat pro-
peller.
420 Byard et al.
Fig. 2. (A) The head of southern right whale dolphin with purging of putrefac-
tive fluids initially thought to represent hemorrhage from trauma. (B) A “V”-
shaped incised wound was present in the right flank; this was found at necropsy
to be a nonlethal injury that only extended into the paravertebral epaxial muscles
and did not compromise major vessels or internal organs.
spine but did not involve any major vessels or organs. Examination of the stom- ach contents revealed that the animal had not fed on the day before death, and the presence of mesenteric lymphadenopathy raised the possibility of death resulting from infection. Advanced putrefaction had been responsible for the purging of fluids from the mouth and prevented further assessment. Death was attributed to natural causes and not to trauma. The lack of hemorrhage into tissues and the absence of a vital reaction would be in keeping with the wound being caused after death. The cleanly incised edges and lack of adjacent abrasions was against the wound being inflicted by another animal.
Case 3
The carcass of a juvenile Indo-Pacific bottlenose dolphin (T. aduncus, 03.085) was found dead on a beach south of Adelaide. Necropsy revealed an emaciated animal with braided fishing line wrapped around the tail associated with a 60-mm-deep wound extending into the underlying tissues (Fig. 3) associ- ated with acute and chronic inflammation and microabscess formation. Moving
Veterinary Forensic Pathology 421
Fig. 3. The tail of a juvenile Indo-Pacific bottlenose dolphin with braided fish-
ing line wrapped tightly around it. Movement of the animal’s tail while swimming
had caused the line to tighten and cut deeply into underlying tissues with result-
ant hemorrhage and abscess formation. The animal was emaciated, having been
unable to feed itself adequately.
the tail to swim would have caused the tightly wrapped mass of braided fishing line to saw deeper into the tissues. The extensive tissue reaction suggested that the twine had been in place for some time (weeks or probably months). The injuries would certainly have interfered with the animal’s ability to swim and forage, and death was likely caused by sepsis and/or exhaustion associated with cachexia owing to the effects of the tail wound.
Case 4
The carcass of a juvenile short-beaked common dolphin (Delphinus del- phis, 03.084) was found on a beach south of Adelaide. Necropsy revealed three curvilinear superficial abrasions on the under surface of the jaw (Fig. 4) asso- ciated with a linear mark behind the left eye. Whereas the features of these wounds were essentially nonspecific, the finding of interrupted circumferential markings under the jaw associated with a linear abrasion behind the eye would be in keeping with injuries from a large mesh net. Histological examination of tissues was complicated slightly by early tissue autolysis and putrefaction; how- ever, no significant underlying organic diseases were detected microscopically.
Although the cause of death remained undetermined, the absence of lethal trauma and organic disease with possible netting marks around the head made net entanglement a distinct possibility.
422 Byard et al.
Fig. 4. Three curvilinear, superficial wounds on the under surface of the jaw of
a juvenile short-beaked common dolphin, in keeping with injuries that could be
sustained from a large mesh net.
Case 5
The carcass of a male Indo-Pacific bottlenose dolphin calf (T. aduncus, M20749), aged approx 4 to 6 weeks old, was found on a beach near Adelaide.
Necropsy revealed a stab wound to the flank that had passed through the body incising the aorta (Fig. 5A,B). Based on the assessment of the wound, it was considered that the weapon used had been a single-edged blade approx 190 mm
Veterinary Forensic Pathology 423
Fig. 5. (A) A stabbed Indo-Pacific bottlenose dolphin calf with a vertical exit
stab wound present in the left flank. (B) Death had resulted from exsanguination
from damage to the aorta.
long and 22 mm wide. Death was caused by exsanguination from the stab wound to the flank (1).
Case 6
The carcass of an adult male Indo-Pacific bottlenose dolphin (T. aduncus, M21243) was found floating off the Adelaide coast. Necropsy revealed a single lethal stab wound to the ventral thorax that had penetrated the right ventricle of the heart and caused a left sided hemothorax (Fig. 6). Based on the assessment of the wound, it was considered that the weapon used had been a single-edged blade with a maximum width of 18 mm 85 mm from the tip. Death was caused by exsanguination from the stab wound to the thorax (2). Extensive sea lice damage to the epidermis suggested that the carcass had been floating in the water after death, rather than the animal dying from stranding on a beach.
Case 7
The carcass of a juvenile male common bottlenose dolphin (Tursiops truncatus, M22411) was found on a beach in southeastern South Australia. On external examination, it appeared to have been stabbed in the thorax (Fig. 7)
424 Byard et al.
Fig. 6. (A) A single lethal stab wound (arrow) to the ventral thorax of an adult
Indo-Pacific bottlenose dolphin. The two linear wounds further towards the snout
are probable rake marks from an attack by another dolphin, and the patchy areas
of superficial loss of epidermis are the result of sea lice activity after death. (Fig-
ure continues)Veterinary Forensic Pathology 425
Fig. 6. (continued) (B) The weapon had penetrated the sternum (arrowhead) and
(C) the right ventricle of the heart (arrowheads) and caused a left-sided hemothorax.
426 Byard et al.
Fig. 7. (A) An apparent lethal stab wound to the ventral thorax of a juvenile
common bottlenose dolphin. Dissection revealed that the wound was not lethal
and extended only into superficial tissues, not involving any major vessels or
organs. (B) Once overlying skin and blubber had been reflected, the shallow cav-
ity within muscle was revealed (arrowheads).
with a wound similar to that seen in Case 6. Necropsy, however, showed that the wound extended only into superficial tissues, had not involved major ves- sels or organs, and was inflicted postmortem. In this case death was not the result of trauma (2).
A summary of the features of the seven dolphin necropsies is given in Table 1.
4. M
EDICOLEGALC
ONSIDERATIONSThe penalty for killing a marine mammal in South Australia is a $30,000 fine or 2 years in prison (3). Given the significant consequences of such an act, cases have to be evaluated carefully in the knowledge that judicial outcomes will rely heavily on the quality of the medicolegal assessment. Similar penal- ties exist in other jurisdictions for killing dolphins, seals, and whales.
Veterinary Forensic Pathology 427
Table 1
Summary of the Features of Seven Dolphin Necropsies in South Australia