AIDS Patients in the Intensive Care Unit
L. A
LVAREZ-R
OCHA, P. R
ASCADO-S
EDES, J. P
ASTOR-B
ENAVENT, F. B
ARCENILLA-G
AITEIntroduction
The first cases of acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) were reported in the summer of 1981, in American young homosexual males. Two years later, the virus responsible for the disease, known as human immunodeficiency virus (HIV-1), was identified. Although this agent causes the vast majority of cases, a variant of this virus (HIV-2) was later isolated in patients from or epidemio- logically linked to West Africa. From its onset, the epidemic of HIV/AIDS has shown continuous growth beyond all predictions. According to the Joint United Nations Program on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS), at the end of 1999, about 56 million people worldwide had been infected, of which, 20 million had died [1]. The problem is particularly worrying in developing countries, where 95% of the HIV-infected people live, especially in Sub-Saharan Africa, with a mean preva- lence of 8.8% in the adult population (it has been estimated that 25.3 million people infected by HIV were living in this area at the end of 2000). In contrast, in North America and Western Europe together, at the end of 2000 the infected population was 1.46 million. In addition, the development of preventive pro- grams and the availability of highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) in industrialized countries has determined a change in the pattern of the epidem- ic: not only is the growth of the epidemic slower but survival of infected patients is also increasing. In Spain, according to data from the Health Department (http://www.msc.es/sida), the infection rate has decreased from 187.6 per million in 1994 to 58.9 in 2000.
The HIV/AIDS epidemic is a major health problem, with high morbidity,
mortality, and costs produced by a chronic and ultimately fatal disease. It also
has a great socio-economic impact, since HIV infection affects mainly young
productive adults. Likewise, the disease affects individuals belonging to high
economic and educational classes, at least in the first stages, although later it
persists in the most-vulnerable classes. This epidemic has therefore led to a sig-
nificant reduction in life expectancy, even to the appearance of a negative demographic growth, and to an important decrease of the gross domestic prod- uct in countries with a greater incidence of the disease.
HIV/AIDS and the Intensive Care Unit
Patients with HIV infection are admitted to intensive care units (ICUs) for monitoring and vigilance, or for advanced life support; but a non-negligible number of patients can be admitted to these units due to causes unrelated to the infection. In the last 3 years, only 33% of HIV/AIDS patients were admitted to our unit due to conditions directly associated with the disease, while the other conditions were not associated (trauma, coronary syndromes, drug overdose, etc.) (unpublished data).
The presence of HIV-infected patients in ICUs varies widely depending on the area being considered and the type of hospital [2]. In some units, this group of patients can reach more than 33% of all admissions [3]. Overall, of all HIV-infect- ed patients admitted to a hospital, about 4%–12% will require ICU care [4, 5].
The improvement of preventive and therapeutic options has prolonged the life of HIV/AIDS patients, and has changed the spectrum of diseases that cause hospitalization. At the beginning of the epidemic, more than two-thirds of ICU admissions were due to respiratory failure, especially secondary to Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia (PCP) [6, 7]. However, in the last few years only 38%–49% of admissions were due to respiratory failure [3–5] (Table 1), and 37%–45% of these were caused by PCP [3–5, 8]. Bacterial pneumonia is becoming the leading cause of respiratory failure leading to ICU admission (47%–53%), but other etiologies, such as tuberculosis, toxoplasmosis, or Kaposi sarcoma (KS), still represent a significant minor proportion [3, 8]. Neurological problems (11%–27%), sepsis (10%–15%), and several types of cardiac manifes- tations (5%) are other frequent reasons for ICU admission [3–5, 8].
Toxoplasmosis is the major cause of cerebral dysfunction in this group of
patients (62% of cases of central nervous system disease in the series of
Casalino et al. [3]), although tuberculosis, cryptococcosis, bacterial meningitis,
cerebral lymphoma, or progressive multifocal leukoencephalopathy (PML) are
also reported with variable frequencies [9]. Sepsis and septic shock are mainly
of pulmonary origin and bacterial etiology [10, 11]. In the series of Rosenberg
et al. [11], pneumonia caused 65% of episodes of sepsis, and in 45% of infec-
tions a bacterial agent was identified, although in this study and in others, other
micro-organisms were found, such as P. carinii, Mycobacterium tuberculosis,
cytomegalovirus (CMV), Cryptococcus neoformans, and Toxoplasma gondii. The
most common cardiac manifestations in HIV/AIDS patients are pericarditis,
myocarditis, dilated cardiomyopathy, endocarditis, neoplasms, and cardiac drug toxicity [12]. Some of the most frequent infectious agents associated with cardiac disease are Staphylococcus aureus, Streptococcus viridans, Salmonella, M. tuberculosis, T. gondii, and C. neoformans, and the most common neoplasms are KS and lymphoma [3, 12].
Finally, during the first stage of the epidemic, the observed mortality among AIDS patients admitted to the ICU was high. Wachter et al. [6] and Schein et al.
[7] reported a mortality of 69% and 77% respectively, which increased to 87%
and 91% in patients who developed acute respiratory failure. These poor out- comes changed physicians’ attitudes to these patients, and it was thought that ICU admission was generally futile and mechanical ventilation was rarely indi- cated. This led to the search for new therapeutic options outside the ICU.
However, introduction of antiretroviral therapy and the availability of better options for prevention and management of opportunistic infection, especially PCP, with the use of co-trimoxazole and corticosteroids, have changed the prognosis and management of HIV/AIDS infection. In several recent series [3–5], in-ICU and in-hospital mortality among HIV/AIDS patients admitted to the ICU ranged between 21% and 24% and between 30% and 39%, respectively.
The 1-year survival was 27%–28% [3, 4, 13]. These rates are comparable to those observed in high-risk non-HIV-infected patients admitted to the ICU (severe sepsis, the elderly, patients needing cardiopulmonary resuscitation, bone mar- row transplantation recipients) [3]. According to these data, admission of HIV/AIDS patients to the ICU should not be considered futile, although more studies are needed to evaluate the impact of HAART.
We must bear in mind that the outcome varies with the cause of ICU admis- sion [3–5, 8, 10, 11]. In-hospital mortality is 44%–93% in patients admitted due Table 1. Reasons for intensive care unit (ICU) admission among HIV/AIDS patients
a% of Admissions
Respiratory failure 38.4–49.2
Neurological disease 11.1–26.8
Severe sepsis 10.2–58.1
Gastrointestinal bleeding 6.3–6.5
Cardiac disease 4.5–7.9
Drug overdose 2.3–5.3
Metabolic disturbance 1.6–1.7
Trauma 1.1–2.9
Miscellaneous 2–9.3
a
From references [4–6, 12]. The intervals are the extreme values reflected in the references
to severe sepsis/septic shock, 26%–46% in those with acute respiratory failure, 32%–41% in those with central nervous system dysfunction, and 6%–69% in those with cardiac involvement. Multiple risk factors have been identified in several studies, with independent association with mortality in HIV/AIDS patients admitted to the ICU (APACHE/SAPS scores, need for mechanical ven- tilation, and duration, diagnosis of PCP, patients coming from a hospital ward, serum albumin level less than 25 g/l, CD4+ count less than 50x10
6/l, function- al status, weight loss, HIV disease stage, duration of AIDS, etc.) [3–5, 8, 11]
(Table 2). As a general rule, as reported by Casalino et al. [3], short-term in-ICU and in-hospital outcome is determined by the severity of the acute disease and health status prior to admission, whereas long-term outcome depends mainly on those variables reflecting the stage of HIV infection. However, to date, no single factor or combination of factors has been able to reasonably predict after-ICU survival. For example, Nickas and Wachter [4] reported an in-hospi- tal mortality of 39% in a group of patients with very high mortality predicted on a theoretical basis (CD4+ cells count less than 50x10
6/l, serum albumin level less than 25 g/l, and mechanical ventilation). Therefore, caution must be used when evaluating these markers for a particular case.
Table 2. Factors influencing in-ICU/in-hospital mortality among HIV/AIDS patients admitted to the ICU (multivariate analysis)
aOdds ratio
Functional status (>2) 1.82
AIDS diagnosis in ICU 1.62
AIDS diagnosis prior to ICU 2.63
Time since AIDS diagnosis (>360 days) 1.91
Albumin level 0.39 per 10 g/l increase
Serum albumin <25 g/l 3.06
APACHE II score >17 3.41
APACHE III score >80 3.1
SAPS I score >12 1.62
Mechanical ventilation requirement 4.3–19.2
Acute respiratory distress syndrome in ICU 14.0
Bacterial cause of infection 1.3
Pneumonia 1.9
Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia diagnosis 2.4–4.5
a