± )25=
&$03,
,1752'8=,21(
/ RU] SHV 3
&
VWDW GHILQLW FRP O RUPDOL]]D]LRQ TXLQG PLVXUD
GHOO¶LQWHUD]LRQ FK O 7HUU HVHUFLW V RJQ PDVVD P SX HVVHU JLXVWLILFDWD
G XQ OHJJ SL JHQHUDO QRW FRPH /(** ' *5$9,7$=,21
81,9(56$/( FK YDO V VFDO FRVPLF LQWHUD]LRQ WU FRUS FHOHVWL! VXOOD
7HUU" )RU]" 3HVR#%$ P"&" QFK' V( VFDO" ORFDO' FRP' LQWHUD]LRQ' WU" GX'
TXDOXQTX' PDVVH$ DQFK' V' L) TXHVW* FDV*,+.- PRGXO* G+ WDO' IRU]" ULVXOWD
SUDWLFDPHQW' WUDVFXUDELO/ ULVSHWW0 D1 DOWU/2/ YHQWXD35464QWHUD]LRQ4 HVWHUQ/70 G4
FRQWDWW0 G4 QDWXUDHOHWWURPDJQHWLFD
8 /(**9 ': *5$9,7$=,219 81,9(56$/(
/; /HJJ< G= *UDYLWD]LRQ< 8QLYHUVDOH HVSULP> O¶LQWHUD]LRQ> FK> V?
PDQLIHVW@ WU@ GX> PDVVHA SRVW> DB XQ@ GLVWDQ]@ FK> V? SXC HVSULPHU> FRD E F G U HHJIK VSUHVVDGDOODUHOD]LRQH L M N N M L L L M N L N L M N U U U P P * )
&
&
−−
==
FKO7O VSULPO XQP IRU]Q VHPSUR DWWUDWWLYD VS GLFT DQFKT IRU]U FHQWUDOHV
HYLGHQ]LDWDGDW VHJQXZY [
/\ UHOD]LRQ] F^ GLF] FK] O\ )RU]\`_ SURSRU]LRQDOa Db SURGRWWc GHOOa
PDVVHd LQYHUVDPHQWe SURSRU]LRQDOe Df TXDGUDWg GHOOh GLVWDQ]D WUi Oj
PDVVjkjmlon VHPSUe DWWUDWWLYD VHJQp ³³q &Rr s
t
u
U LQGLFKLDPv Ow GLVWDQ]w WUD
Ox PDVVx`x SLy SUHFLVDPHQWx Ow GLVWDQ]w GHOOw PDVVw Pz GDOO{ PDVV{ P| }
HTXLYDOHQW~ D PRGXO GH YHWWRU~ U
&
G P G P FLR FR RULJLQ L P , WHUPLQ U U
&
YHUVRU FKUDSSUHVHQW O GLUH]LRQ YHUV G
U
&
3H WHQHU FRQW GH IDWW FK OD
IRU] VHPSU DWWUDWWLYD FLR P V DYYLFLQHUHEE P SHQVDW FRP RULJLQ
TXLQG ILVVR VQWURGXF ± ³ , IDWWRU G! SURSRU]LRQDOLWj" FK GHULY# GD
ULVXOWDW! VSHULPHQWD$! ULVXOW# HVVHU XQ# FRVWDQWH FLR% XWLOL]]DQG& PDVV
GLYHUV')( GLVWDQ]' GLIIHUHQW* WDO' IDWWRU' ULVXOW( VHPSU' O+ VWHVVR, V* FKLDPD
&RVWDQW- GL*UDYLWD]LRQ- 8QLYHUVDOH. F*/*QGLFDFR0 1 ' YDOH
2 2 343 .J P 1 *
==
⋅⋅
−−
⋅⋅
&RP5 DFFHQQDW6 V5 V7 YDOXW8 79 PRGXO6 GHOO8 : RU]8 G7 DWWUD]LRQ5
JUDYLWD]LRQDO; WUDGX; PDVV; G< .=?> RVW; DOODGLVWDQ]DG<A@CBB WURYLDPR
1 P .J .J P 1 ) D E F F F F G H I J4J
⋅⋅
==
⋅⋅
⋅⋅
⋅⋅
==
−−
DVVROXWDPHQWK WUDVFXUDELOK ULVSHWWL DDOIRU]M GN DWWUD]LRQK SXUK JUDYLWD]LRQDOHO
GRYXWDDOOD7HUUDP FLRQSRT/TRUU SHVU FKV YDOV W 1
6X SXY GLPRVWUDUZ FKZ O[ )RU]\ JUDYLWD]LRQDOH ] SL^ L_ JHQHUDO] XQ`
TXDOXQTXa IRU]b FHQWUDOadc FRQVHUYDWLYD 1Re VROf Pgih FRPSUHQVLELOj
DQFKj FKj XQg IRU]k FHQWUDOl Kk PRPHQWm QXOOm ULVSHWWm Dn SXQWm FXL
WHQGHo SHp FXq QRr DOWHUs O¶HYHQWXDOt PRPHQWu DQJRODUHo ULVSHWWu DOOu
VWHVVu SXQWRo GHOFRUSu FXLv DSSOLFDWD &RQVLGHULDPw GXx PDVVx 0 x y x LQGLFKLDPw FRz U{
&
H| U}&
~ UDJJ ~ YHWWRU ~ FK LQGLYLGXDQ O SRVL]LRQ G ~P L SRVL]LRQ LQL]LDO $ ILQDO % ULVSHWW
D 0 , TXHVW PRG RULJLQ GH VLVWHP G ULIHULPHQW VXSSRQLDP G
WHQHUO ILVVR L WD PRG FRVWLWXLVF) ULIHULPHQW LQHU]LDOH 4XHVW LSRWHV
9DOXWLDP ODYRU IDWW GDOO )RU] *UDYLWD]LRQDOH TXDQG SDVVD GDOO SRVL]LRQ DOO SRVL]LRQ % &R GV
&
LQGLFKLDP O VSRVWDPHQW LQILQLWHVLP QH YHUVR GH PRW FLR GDD % FR UDJJL YHWWRU FK LQGLYLGX P QHOO JHQHULF SRVL]LRQ WU
FR U U
&
LQGLFKLDP!#"$ YHUVRUG" TXHVW% GLUH]LRQH& 0RYHQGRF" G%('
→
SH) XQ! VSRVWDPHQW! GV
&
"$ UDJJL! YHWWRU * + GLPLQXLVF SH) FXL VXELVF XQD YDULD]LRQ GU QHJDWLY% TXLQG" WHQHQG! FRQW! FK V G&
QH$ YHUV! QHJDWLY! SRVVLDP! VFULYHU V G&
, G U U U&
⋅⋅
- 4XLQG.==
⋅⋅
−−
==
⋅⋅
−−
==
⋅⋅
−−
==
⋅⋅
==
∫∫
∫∫
∫∫
∫∫
→
→
/ 0 1 0 2 2 3 4 4 3 5 6 7 5 6 8 9 : U U U GU P 0 * U U GU U P 0 * U U GU U U U P 0 * V G ) /&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
−−
−−
==
−−
−−
==
−−
==
−−
==
∫∫
∫∫
9 : ; ; ; ; < ; ; = < U U P 0 * U P 0 * U GU P 0 * U U GU P 0 * > ? > ? > ?6@ YHGA FRPA O¶LQWHJUDOA GLSHQGB VRODPHQWH GDC YDORUA UD E UF G &LH
VLJQLILFI FKJ OI )RU]K *UDYLWD]LRQDOLNM FRQVHUYDWLYD J TXLQGO SRVVLDPP
DVVRFLDUJ DQ HVVI XQI IXQ]LRQL VFDODUL (QHUJLK 3RWHQ]LDOL
*UDYLWD]LRQDOHR ODFXO YDULD]LRQJ SDVVDQGP GDS
→
→
% T GHILQLWDGDU V W X Y Z [ \ Y Z Z / 8 8 8
==
−−
==
−−
→
→
∆∆
6] GHY^ DQFK^ QRWDU^ FK^ TXDQW_ ULFDYDW_ QR` GLSHQG^ WDQW_ GDa IDWW_ FK^
b
VLc WHQXWc ILVVced IHUPD ^ FK^ O¶RULJLQ^ GHa VLVWHPf G] ULIHULPHQW_ VLD
ILVVDW_ L` 0g Pf SLXWWRVW_ GDOOc FRQILJXUD]LRQd FKd YHGdhid
b GLVWDQWj U 0 P $ % k U
&
l U&
0 P $ % U&
m n o p q r s tuLQGLSHQGHQWHPHQW FK VLDQR IHUP
L PRWR 3X HVVHU XWLO ILVVDU XQD
FRQILJXUD]LRQ G ULIHULPHQWR DOO TXDO DVVHJQDU YDORU GHOO¶(QHUJL
SRWHQ]LDO 6DU O FRQILJXUD]LRQ FK YHG O GX PDVV GLVWDQ] WDO
G QR LQWHUDJLUH FLR TXDQG U
→
→ ∞
∞
$ WDO FRQILJXUD]LRQH DWWULEXLDPYDORU 8
∞
∞
8WLOL]]DQG! O" UHOD]LRQ# SUHFHGHQW# GRY# FR$ $ LQGLFKLDP! OD
FRQILJXUD]LRQ# SH% FX& '# PDVVH VRQ(*) GLVWDQ]) LQILQLWD ! WDO# G" QR$
LQWHUDJLUH+,# FR$ - O" FRQILJXUD]LRQ# FRUULVSRQG. D/ XQ) JHQHULF) GLVWDQ])
U WUDO# PDVVH0 SRVVLDP! VFULYHUH
−−
∞
∞
==
−−
==
==
⋅⋅
−−
==
−−
==
−−
∞
∞
∞
∞
∞
∞
→
→
∞
∞
∫∫
∫∫
U P 0 * U P 0 * U GU P 0 * V G ) / U 8 1 1 2 1 3 1 3&
&
&
4XLQG465¶HQHUJL7 SRWHQ]LDO8 JUDYLWD]LRQDO8 GHOO7 FRQILJXUD]LRQ8 FK8
YHG8 GX8 PDVV897 GLVWDQ]7 : ; WU7 ORUR< UHODWLY797 OO7 FRQILJXUD]LRQ8 FK8
YHG8 O7 PDVV87 GLVWDQ]7 LQILQLW7 YDOH
,= VHJQ>@? ? FA GLFB FKB O¶HQHUJLC SRWHQ]LDOB GA XQC TXDOXQTXB
FRQILJXUD]LRQB FRDFE
≠≠ ∞
∞
G PLQRUB GA ]HURH &LIKJ FRHUHQWL FRMNO IDWWP FKLKNOVLVWHPQ QDWXUDOPHQWL L YROYL YHUVP OQ FRQILJXUD]LRQB GA PLQLPC HQHUJLC
SRWHQ]LDOH L GDWQ OQ QDWXUQRQ WWUDWWLYQ GHO IRU]Q JUDYLWD]LRQDOL SRUWQ OL PDVVL D
DYYLFLQDUVNTS /Q FRQILJXUD]LRQL GN PDVVLPQ HQHUJLQ SRWHQ]LDOLUJ TXHOOQ FRM OL
GXL PDVVL DGLVWDQ]DLQILQLWDH
6N RVVHUYN FKL PHQWUL OQWVRU]Q JUDYLWD]LRQDOLXJ LQYHUVDPHQWL SURSRU]LRQDOL
DOO¶LQYHUVP GHO TXDGUDWP GHOOQ GLVWDQ]Q WUQ OL PDVVHY O¶HQHUJLQ SRWHQ]LDOLZJ
SURSRU]LRQDOL DOO¶LQYHUVP GHOODGLVWDQ]D
U P 0 * 8U
==
1% /¶HQHUJL SRWHQ]LDO 8 XQ SURSULHW GHOO¶LQWHU VLVWHP P
QH VX FRPSOHVV QR SRVVLDP GLU TXDQW G WDO QHUJL FRPSHWD D XQD
PDVV TXDQW OO¶DOWUD 6SHVV SHU V SDUO G HQHUJL SRWHQ]LDO G XQD
PDVV VRJJHWW OO RU] WWUDWWLY GHOO¶DOWUD &L QR GH WXWW FRUUHWW P
JLXVWLILFDW GD IDWW FK L TXHVW FDV VRO XQ PDVV V PXRY FDXV GH
UDSSRUW WU O PDVV LQWHUHVVDW 0
>>>>
/! PDVV! FK" V# PXRY" DFTXLVWDXQ! HQHUJL! FLQHWLF! SUDWLFDPHQW" SDU# DOO! YDULD]LRQ" GHOO¶HQHUJL! SRWHQ]LDO"
GH$ VLVWHPDQH$ SDVVDU" GDXQDFRQILJXUD]LRQ" D% XQ¶DOWUD
& &$03' *5$9,7$=,21$/(
(VLVW(*),+ PRG- GLYHUV- P. PROW- LQWHUHVVDQW( G/ HVDPLQDU( O¶LQWHUD]LRQ(
WUDGX( PDVVH
/¶DVSHWW- IRQGDPHQWDO( GHOO. /HJJ( G/ JUDYLWD]LRQ( XQLYHUVDO(10 FK( V/
HVHUFLW. XQ. LQWHUD]LRQ243 GLVWDQ]D WU. GX( PDVV(65- WU. SL7 PDVV( FK(
SRVVRQ- HVVHU( WUDWWDW(8. GX(8. GXH9 VHQ]. FK( Y/ VL.:),+ FRQWDWW- GLUHWWR,;
FRQFHWW- G/ D]LRQ2<3 GLVWDQ]D QR+=0 VHPSU( ILVLFDPHQW( FRQYHQLHQW( L+
TXDQW- SUHVXSSRQ( FK( O. SHUWXUED]LRQ( V/ WUDVPHWW. ( JLXQJD
LVWDQWDQHDPHQWH9 FLR01. YHORFLW> LQILQLWD? ,+@+ DWXU. SHUA QHVV),+ VHJQDO( G/
TXDOXQTX( QDWXU. VLD V/ SURSDJ.B.DC XQ. YHORFLW> LQILQLW.B( O. PDVVLP. YHORFLWj
G/ SURSDJD]LRQ( G/E),+ VHJQDO(10 TXHOO. GH; UDGLD]LRQ(1( OHWWURPDJQHWLF. QH;
YXRW- F? 3XA HVVHU( DOORU. FRQYHQLHQW( DQDOL]]DU(F/G; IHQRPHQ- GHOOD
SURSDJD]LRQ( G/ WDO( SHUWXUED]LRQ( L+ PDQLHU. OHJJHUPHQW( GLYHUV. XWLOL]]DQG
-/G; FRQFHWW- G/ &$032 PROW- XVDW- QHOO¶HOHWWURPDJQHWLVPR
6XSSRQLDP- G/ HVHJXLU( ODVHJXHQW( VHUL( G/ HVSHULPHQW/H/SRWHWLFL?
3RUWLDPI XQ3 PDVV3 PJ LKL,K SXQWM GHOOM VSD]LM FKN VXSSRQLDPM YXRWM
GO6O OWUN PDVVHP 3RWUHPMQM VVHUYDUN FKN WDON PDVVO ULPDQN LK TXLHWN LKQL,K D
TXDOXQTXN SRVL]LRQN OO VR SRQJDP 9HULILFDWM FLS VXSSRQLDPM GR ILVVDUOT
ULJLGDPHQWH LK L,KUO SRVL]LRQN TXDOXQTXN LK PRGM FKN QRK SRVVD
YLFLQDQ] G P SH HVHPSL QHOO SULP SRVL]LRQ L FX DYHYDP SRVW P
2VVHUYHUHP DGHVV FK O PDVV V PXRYHUj 3RVVLDP GHGXUU FK OD
SUHVHQ] G P K PRGLILFDW O SURSULHW GHOO VSD]L QH SXQW L FX K P
SULPDP QR V PXRYHYD DGHVV V PXRYH! " FDPELDW TXDOFRVD
4XHVW# SHUWXUED]LRQ$ GHOO% VSD]L% SURGRWW# G# P& V' GHILQLVF$
&$03( *5$9,7$=,21$/() G' P& * SURSUL+ JUD]L*-, WDO* &$03. IDUj
VHQWLU* O, VX, SUHVHQ],/,10 RJQ2 HYHQWXDO* DOWU, PDVV, PHVV, QHOO* VX*
YLFLQDQ]H3 DWWLUDQGRO, FR465748, FHUW,:9 RU]D; VDU< GXQTX*=574 FDPS% YHWWRULDOH
3RWUHPP+ IDU* XQ, PDSSDWXU# GHOO% VSD]LR DWWRUQ+ DP& PLVXUDQG+ ODIRU]D
FK*>* VV, HVHUFLW, VXOO, PDVV,@? PDVV, HVSORUDWULFH3 FK* VDU<A, WWUDWWLYD
UDGLDOH3 FLRq
,B VHJQ+DC ± C GLF* FK* O,E9 RU],GF DWWUDWWLYD DYHQG+ ILVVDW+ FRP* SRVLWLY+H2IB
YHUV+ UDGLDO* XVFHQWH
62 GHILQLVF* ,17(16,7$JLK (M &$032 O# )RU]# SHN XQLWO GLPDVVDP 1HB
FDV+ JUDYLWD]LRQDOH SRVVLDP+ GHILQLU*Q2IB &$03( *5$9,7$=,21$/R G2 XQD
PDVVD0 PHGLDQW*:2IB YHWWRUH
/DFX2S2QWHQVLWjYDOH
,O YHWWRUH *
&
TXQ# IXQ]LRQ$ GHU SXQWR3 RYYLDPHQW* GLSHQG* GDOOD
PDVV, H0VF LQYHUVDPHQW* SURSRU]LRQDO* DB TXDGUDW+ GHOO, GLVWDQ], G,HW GHB
SXQW+ L4 FX2 V2 YXRO* YDOXWDU*X2IB FDPSR ,4 RJQ2 SXQW+ GHOO+ VSD]L+ SRWUHPP+
PHWWHU* XQDHWLFKHWWDFK* UDSSUHVHQWD2IB YHWWRU* FDPS+ JUDYLWD]LRQDOH
Y U 0 * U U U P P * ) Y Z
&
&
==
(( ))
(( ))
U U U 0 * U * P ) U * [ \&
&
&
&
&
&
==
==
, &$03 XQ SURSULHW GHOO PDVV 0 FK O FUHD , TXHVW PRG
O PDSSDWXU GHOO VSD]L DWWRUQ SX HVVHU FDOFRODW SULRUL 1H
FDV JUDYLWD]LRQDO GLFLDP DQFK FK &$03 ( &216(59$7,92 GHULYD
GDXQDIRU]DFRQVHUYDWLYD
327(1=,$/ '( &$03 *5$9,7$=,21$/(
,QWURGRWW! " FRQFHWW G &DPSR# ULSUHQGLDP O$ GHILQL]LRQ% G GLIIHUHQ]$ G
HQHUJL& SRWHQ]LDO' 8U( UHODWLY&)&+* XQ& FHUW& FRQILJXUD]LRQH, 5LFRUGLDP- FK'
QH. FDV- L/ FX0 VRO- XQ& PDVV& V0 SRVV& PXRYHU' SRVVLDP- GLU' FK' O¶HQHUJLD
SRWHQ]LDO' GHOO& FRQILJXUD]LRQ'1' TXLYDO' DQFK' DOO¶HQHUJL& SRWHQ]LDO' GHOOD
PDVVDL/ PRYLPHQWR, $YHYDP- VFULWWR
' V' GLYLGLDP-20 YDU0 WHUPLQ0 SH354 RWWHQLDPR
/DTXDQWLWj
V0 GHILQLVF' 327(1=,$/6 GH7 &$032 FK' GHY'8' VVHU' FRQVHUYDWLYR(9' V0
LQGLF& FRQYHQ]LRQDOPHQW' FR/ : ; XQ< JUDQGH]]< VFDODU= IXQ]LRQ= GL
> ?
3RVVLDP- GHILQLU' O& GLIIHUHQ]< G@ SRWHQ]LDOH WU& GX' SXQW0 GH. FDPS
-FUHDW- GDXQDPDVVDPHGLDQW' ODUHOD]LRQH
∫∫
⋅⋅
==
==
→
→
A B C A B B A 8 / ) GV 8&
&
==
⋅⋅
==
==
∫∫
B A A B C C B A U U 0 * V G P ) P ©8 P 8 8&
&
r
M
G
V G * 9 9 D E E D&
&
⋅⋅
==
∫∫
$QDORJDPHQW TXDQW IDWW SH O¶HQHUJL SRWHQ]LDOH V ILVVLDP ]HU LO YDORU G DOO¶LQILQLWR SRVVLDP GHILQLU SRWHQ]LDO L SXQW
TXDOXQTX GLVWDQ] GDOO PDVV FK FUH
FDPSR PHGLDQW OD UHOD]LRQH FK UDSSUHVHQW ODYRUR FDPELDW G
VHJQR GHOO IRU] JUDYLWD]LRQDO
SH XQLW G PDVV SH SRUWDU O PDVV HVSORUDWULF GD SXQW 3 GLVWDQ] GDOO PDVV FK FUH FDPSR DOO¶LQILQLW GRY SRWHQ]LDO !
" (# RYYLDPHQW XQDIXQ]LRQ VFDODU GHOSXQWR"
,$ TXHVW PRG SRVVLDP IDU XQ PDSS GHOO VSD]L DWWRUQ D% XQD PDVV & WWULEXHQG D% RJQ SXQW FRUULVSRQGHQW YDORU GH SRWHQ]LDO GHILQLW FRP L$ SUHFHGHQ] ' TXLQG G( FDPS YHWWRULDO SRVVLDP SDVVDU D) X FDPS VFDODUH (# RSSRUWXQ* VVHUYDU FK O )RU] *UDYLWD]LRQDOH )+
&
WU GX PDVV OFRUULVSRQGHQW (QHUJL 3RWHQ]LDO *UDYLWD]LRQDOH 8, VRQ- XQ.
SURSULHW/ G0 XQ. FHUW. FRQILJXUD]LRQH1 ,2 &DPS- *UDYLWD]LRQDOH *U
&
&
3 O¶DVVRFLDW465 XQ]LRQ 3 VFDODU 3 3RWHQ]LDOH 9U&
VRQ- LQYHF7 SURSULHW/ GHO
FDPSR
/. GHILQL]LRQ7 G0 SRWHQ]LDOH GDW4 SH8:9 2 FDV; JUDYLWD]LRQDOH<>= SHU? GH2
WXWW; JHQHUDO
3 3
SX? HVVHU
3
DSSOLFDW4 4 WXWW9@9 FDV9 G9 &$03A
&216(59$7,92 (B RSSRUWXQ; ID8 QRWDU
3 FK 3 9 2 FRQFHWW- GL &$032 SX? HVVHU 3 LQWURGRWW; WXWW 3 O 3 YROW 3 FK 3 V9 PDQLIHVW4 XQ4 LQWHUD]LRQ 3 4 GLVWDQ]4 WUD
GXC SURSULHWD GHOOE PDWHULE OE PDVVE GE FXFGF H &DPSI *UDYLWD]LRQDOHJ OE FDULFD
HOHWWULFDK GE FXFLF H FDPSI (OHWWULFI (OHWWURVWDWLFRJMF H 0RPHQWI 0DJQHWLFI GE FXFNF H
FDPSI 0DJQHWLFRO GHWWC 625*(17P '(Q &$032R 1RSTS HFHVVDULDPHQWC WXWWFNF V G * U 9 U
∫∫
∞
∞
⋅⋅
==
*
&
&
FDPS VRQ FRQVHUYDWLYL 3H HVHPSL &DPS 0DJQHWLF QR FRQVHUYDWLY
L WD
FDV SRWUHP DQFRU GHILQLU
FDPS YHWWRULDO P QR SRWUHP
DVVRFLDU D HVV XQ XQ]LRQ SRWHQ]LDO VFDODUH 9 RVVHUYDW FK VRO FL
FK SX HVVHU VRUJHQW G
FDPS SX HVVHU VX YROW LQIOXHQ]DW G
DQDORJ FDPSR SH HVHPSL XQ PDVV QR YHUU PD QIOXHQ]DW G &DPS HOHWWULF 0DJQHWLFR /¶XWLOLW GH FRQFHWW G &$032 H VRSUDWWXWW QH FDV G FDPS FRQVHUYDWLY G SRWHQ]LDO GH FDPSR FRQVLVW QH IDWW FK L JHQHUDO GDWD
XQ FHUW VRUJHQW GHO FDPSR PDVV FDULF HFF O VX GLVWULEX]LRQ
VSD]LDO JHRPHWUL IRUP GHOO VRUJHQWH QR VHPSU VLPPHWUL VIHULFD
VRSUDWWXWW QH
FDV HOHWWULF PDJQHWLFR SRVVLELO DWWUDYHUV O UHJRO
GHOO¶DQDOLV YDOXWDU SULRU
!
FDPS" YHWWRULDOH L RJQ SXQW GHOO VSD]LR
7DO &DPSR RSHUDWLYDPHQW GHILQLW" FRP O# )25=$ VXOO¶XQLW% GL
625*(17( O SRVVLDP SHQVDU & VLVWHQW LQGLSHQGHQWHPHQW GD
IDWW G
DYHU DOWU PDVV ' FDULFK ' TXDQW¶DOWUR QHOO VSD]L FLUFRVWDQWH 1H
FDV SR G FDPS FRQVHUYDWLYL XQ YROW QRW &DPS IXQ]LRQ GH SXQWR SRVVLDP YDOXWDU SRWHQ]LDO D HVV DVVRFLDWR , WD PRG SRVVLDP SULRU YDOXWDU
TXDO VDU O¶HQHUJL SRWHQ]LDO G XQ HYHQWXDO PDVV SRVW L
FHUW SXQW GH FDPS FDULF QH
FDV G &DPS (OHWWULF HOHWWURVWDWLFR( TXLQG DQFK
ODYRU HVWHUQ QHFHVVDUL) UHDOL]]DU XQ FHUW FRQILJXUD]LRQ G PDVV *
FDULFKH
)DFFLDP DQFRU ULIHULPHQW HVSOLFLW D
FDV JUDYLWD]LRQDO + ULIHULDPRF
L SDUWLFRODU D
&$03, *5$9,7$=,21$/- GHOO# 7HUUD. +/ VHQV0 GHILQLU1324
&DPS0 *UDYLWD]LRQDO1 GHOO/ 7HUUD5 VXSSRVW/ XQ/ VIHU/ G2 UDJJL0 687 59 5: ;
5DJJL< PHGL< GHOOD7HUUD= >@?3ACB D PE SHF SXQWG FKH VG WURYDQI DGLVWDQ]DJ
>>
5K GDL FHQWUI GHOOD7HUUDM 3RVVLDPI GLUH DOORUDFKHGL &DPSN *UDYLWD]LRQDOO
GHOOP 7HUUD Q GDWI GD R S R 5 U U U U 0 * U *
==
≥≥
&
&
&
5LVXOW XQ]LRQ GHOO GLVWDQ] GH SXQW L FX VL YXRO YDOXWDUH GDOOD
VXSHUILFL GH 7HUU 5 K O TXRW ULVSHWW DOO VXSHUILFL GHOOD
7HUUD V PLVXUDL
FK FRUULVSRQG D XQ
FFHOHUD]LRQ SURSUL O DFFHOHUD]LRQ G JUDYLW J
&
FK FRPSDU QHOO¶HVSUHVVLRQ GHOO )RU] 3HVR FK L UHDOW QR FRVWDQW
P GLSHQG GDOO TXRWD / )RU] 3HV 3
&
QR DOWU FK O¶LQWHUD]LRQ GH
&DPS GH 7HUU FR O PDVV P FLR O )RU] *UDYLWD]LRQDO WU O 7HUU
ODPDVVD FRQ U!#"%$
≅≅
5& '&RQVLGHULDP( DOORU) XQ) PDVV) * FK+ V, VSRVW- G-/.10 SXQW2 $ VXOOD
VXSHUILFL3 GHOO) 7HUU)4)6587:9 SXQW2;<- TXRW- K GDOO) 7HUUD' ,QGLFDQG( FR9 G=
>@?
PRGXO( GHOO( VSRVWDPHQW( LQILQLWHVLPR GV
&
QH
?
YHUV( G)BA
→
C3 FR9 *U>@?
PRGXO( O¶LQWHQVLWjD GH
?
&DPS2 *UDYLWD]LRQDOH FK3 DEELDP( YLVW( HVVHU3
GLUHWW( YHUV( OD7HUUDE FLRF RSSRVW( DGV
&
E SRVVLDP( VFULYHUHG 3RLFKF K5&<<<<
H ULFRUGDQGI FKJ K4LNM O P≅
Q R SHSTR<<
U SRVVLDPV VFULYHUH W W W W W VHF P .J VHF P .J .J 1 P .J .J P 1==
⋅⋅
==
==
⋅⋅
⋅⋅
(( ))
(( ))
++
==
==
++
==
==
==
==
==
⋅⋅
==
∆∆
⋅⋅
==
−−
==
∆∆
++
++
++
++
→
→
∫∫
∫∫
∫∫
X X X X X Y Z Z [ \ Z Z ] [ \ Z Z \ Z Z ^ _ _ ^ 5 K 5 0 * P K 5 5 0 * P U 0 * P U GU 0 * P GU U * P V G U * P U 9 P 8 8 8 ` ` ` ` ` ` ` `&
&
&
&
K J P K 0 * P 5 K 5 0 * P 8 8 8 ab b b b b c d d c
==
⋅⋅
==
==
−−
==
∆∆
→
→
HVVHQG
YDORU GHOO¶DFFHOHUD]LRQ G
JUDYLWjVXOOD7HUUD
$EELDP FRV ULWURYDWR DWWUDYHUV O GHILQL]LRQ G &DPSR FK XQD
PDVV OORQWDQDQGRV G GDOO VXSHUILFL GHOO 7HUU DFTXLVW XQ (QHUJL
3RWHQ]LDO PJK &RUUHWWDPHQW RVVHUYLDP FK
∆∆
8→
→
>>
TXLQGD
)RU] GH &DPS K IDWW ODYRU QHJDWLYR / PDVV SRWXW VDOLU
VRO SHUFK TXDOFK DOWU )RU] HVWHUQ J K SHUPHVV G VROOHYDUVL
SHUFK SRVVHGHYDXQDFHUWD(QHUJLDFLQHWLFDFR! YHORFLWjYHUV O¶DOWR
&RQVLGHULDP XQ PDVV FK LQL]LDOPHQW V WURY " $# XQ GLVWDQ] PROW
JUDQG GDOO 7HUU WDO G QR! HVVHUQ LQIOXHQ]DWD TXLQG%! TXLHWH
,PSULPLDPRO FR!'&(! OHJJHU LPSXOV XQ FHUW YHORFLW) LQL]LDO YHUV O 7HUUD
L! PRG FK V VSRVW GDOO SRVL]LRQ G HTXLOLEUL H IDFFLDP L PRG FK VL
VSRVW* FR O VWHVV YHORFLWj ILQ D#+&(! SXQW, GLVWDQ] U GDOO 7HUUD &L
-VLJQLILFDFK ODPDVVDSDVVDGD&(! SXQW L! FX KD(QHUJLD3RWHQ]LDOH
8
∞
∞
./10 9∞
∞
2D# XQ SXQW L! FX SRVVLHG XQDFHUWD(QHUJLD3RWHQ]LDOH
8U./10 9U.
<<
TXLQG43 VXELVF XQ
∆∆
5<<
TXLQG/ )RU] GH &DPSR FRPSL6/DYRU 3RVLWLYR
& SRWUHPP FKLHGHU6 YDQWDJJL67 VFDSLW G FK VXELVF TXHVWD
YDULD]LRQ G (QHUJL SRWHQ]LDOH"8 5LFRUGLDP9 FK: O; PDVV; ; QGUHEE:
QDWXUDOPHQW< GDOO¶LQILQLW= D> SXQW=@? GLVWDQ]? UA SHUFKBC< YROYHUHEE< YHUV= XQD
VHF P J 5 J 5 0 * D E D E E
==
==
==
SRVL]LRQ PLQR (QHUJL 3RWHQ]LDO TXLQG G PDJJLR (TXLOLEULR 0XRYHQGRV
FDPS FRQVHUYDWLYR GRYUHEE QHFHVVDULDPHQW DFTXLVWDU
XQ FHUW (QHUJL &LQHWLF SDU DOO GLPLQX]LRQ GHOO¶(QHUJL 3RWHQ]LDOH 6 FL QR DYYLHQ VLJQLILF FK GHY VVHUF XQ¶DOWU )RU] HVWHUQ FDPS FK WUDWWLHQ O PDVV L PRG FK O VX FFHOHUD]LRQ VL QXOO FK TXLQG FRPSL /DYRU 1HJDWLY XQ RU]
UHQDQWH , /DYRU SRVLWLY GHO
FDPS SURSUL XJXDO D /DYRU QHJDWLY GHOO )RU] HVWHUQD 6
FRQVLGHULDP 6LVWHP ³0DVV FK FUH FDPS PDVV L PRW DJHQW
(VWHUQR SRVVLDP GLU FK O! )RU]! HVWHUQ! I!#"%$ /DYRU& QHJDWLY& VSHV'
GHOO¶HQHUJL! 3RWHQ]LDO' GHO6LVWHPD
(VLVW' XQ¶DOWU! 3URSULHW( GHOO! PDWHULD) O! &$5,&* (/(775,&$ FK
V RSSRUWXQDPHQW' VROOHFLWDWD V+ PDQLIHVW, FR- .-/, LQWHUD]LRQ
IRUPDOPHQW DQDORJDDTXHOOD*UDYLWD]LRQDOH0
/, &DULF, (OHWWULF, V+ PDQLIHVW, VRWW GX' IRUPH FRQYHQ]LRQDOPHQW
GHILQLW FRP &DULF! 3RVLWLYD TXHOO, GH1 3URWRQH2 &DULF! 1HJDWLYD TXHOOD
GHOO¶HOHWWURQH0 1H1 VLVWHP, ,QWHUQD]LRQDO V+ PLVXU! L$ &RXORP3 &E H4#5
XQDGHOO 76 JUDQGH]] IRQGDPHQWDOL
/¶LQWHUD]LRQ WU, &DULFK (OHWWULFK SXQWLIRUP+ VFKHPDWL]]DE+18+ WDOL2 YLHQ
IRUPDOL]]DW, , WWUDYHUV XQ, )RU]D G+ GLUH]LRQ' UDGLDOH FK ULVXOWD
DWWUDWWLY! V' DYYLHQ' WU! FDULFK' G9 VHJQ& & SSRVW&:' UHSXOVLY! TXDQG&
VLPDQLIHVW! WU! FDULFK' GLXJXDO' VHJQR
7XWW FL; YLHQ VLQWHWL]]DWR QHOO, /HJJ' G9 &RXORP3 FK SX; HVVHU
IRUPDOL]]DWDQH1 PRG VHJXHQWH
GRY T< T= VRQ O GX FDULFK SXQWLIRUPL > ? O, GLVWDQ], WU, G+@1RUBAC WU,D+
ORU FHQWU+ QH1 FDV G+ FRUS+ FDULFK , VLPPHWUL, VIHULFD2E N F XQG FRVWDQWH
GLPHQVLRQDWDSRVLWLYDI 1HJ FDVK LL FXMNJH FDULFKH VLDQK QHJ YXRWK
U U U T T N ) O PRQO O P S T S U V
&
&
==
( ,03257$17( SUHPHWWHU
FK
SH PRPHQW F V ULIHULVF TXHOO FK
YHQJRQ GHWW ,17(5$=,21 (/(775267$7,&+( FLR WU FDULFK
LVWDQWDQHDPHQW IHUP P QR HFHVVDULDPHQW QR VRJJHWW D
DFFHOHUD]LRQH
, SDUWLFRODU V V YXRO LQGLFDU O )RU] FK O FDULF T HVHUFLW
VXOO FDULF T HQWUDPE SRVLWLY HQWUDPE QHJDWLYH F PHWWLDP L
VLVWHPDG ULIHULPHQW VROLGDO FR T T ! U
&
T ! )
&
GRY ! U&
"$#% UDJJL& YHWWRU' FK' LQGLYLGX( O( SRVL]LRQ' GHOO( FDULF(*) ULVSHWW&
DOOD+ /DIRU]D),.-0/
&
ULVXOWDSDUDOOHOD DU, -/&
' TXLQGL UHSXOVLYD 1H% FDV& L1 FX#2%' GX' FDULFK3 VLDQ4 GLVHJQ454 SSRVWR T6 U, -/&
),.-0/
&
T7 ODIRU]DULVXOWDDQWLSDUDOOHODU, -/&
' TXLQGL DWWUDWWLYD2YYLDPHQW' SH8 O( ,,,9 /HJJ: GHOO; 'LQDPLF; O; )RU]; FK: O; FDULF; T<
HVHUFLW= VXOO= FDULF= T> VDU? VHPSU: XJXDO:@: FRQWUDUL;@; TXHOO; FK: T>
HVHUFLW= VXOO= FDULF= T<BA FLRq
SHC FDULFK: GHOOD VWHVVD VHJQR E.F0G )
&
T> G F E U&
T< H I I H J F J J F J ) )&
&
==
3H FDULFK G VHJQ SSRVWR T )
&
T U
&
6SX DQFK GLPRVWUDU FK O )RU] (OHWWULF (OHWWURVWDWLF
&216(59$7,9$
&RP SH
FDV JUDYLWD]LRQDO SRVVLDP LQWHUSUHWDU O¶LQWHUD]LRQ WUD
FDULFKH QRQ FRP XQD LQWHUD]LRQ FDULFD FDULF P FRPH LQWHUD]LRQ
FDULF ± FDPSR
/ FDULF SHUWXUE O VSD]L FLUFRVWDQW FUHDQG &$03 (/(775,&2
(/(775267$7,&2 GHILQLW RSHUDWLYDPHQW FRP O )RU] FK DJLVF
VXOO¶XQLW G FDULFD SRVW QHOO VX YLFLQDQ]H &RQYHQ]LRQDOPHQW V
QGLFD
FRQ
DVVROXWDPHQW YHU VRO V T LQGLF XQ FDULF HVSORUDWULF L PRG VL GD
QR DOWHUDU VV VWHVV FDPS GHOO¶DOWU FDULF P QFK G SRWH LQGLYLGXDUQ O SRVL]LRQ PHGLDQW UDJJL YHWWRU , FDPS ULVXOW ! FDPS UDGLDO"
YHWWRU FDPSR ULVXOW GLUHWW# YHUV# O FDULF FK FUH LO
FDPS# V TXHVW$ QHJDWLY$ QHOYHUV#%# SSRVW# V TXHVW$ SRVLWLYD
&RQYHQ]LRQDOPHQW
&DPS (OHWWULF (OHWWURVWDWLF&" JHQHUDO&
FDPSR V
UDSSUHVHQW QHOO VSD]L DWWUDYHUV TXHOO FK V
GHILQLVFRQ /,1'('
') )25=$ FLR* GHOOH OLQ+ RULHQWDW FK UDSSUHVHQWDQ O WUDLHWWRUL
VHJXLW G XQ FDULF SRVLWLYD SRVW QH
&DPS VWHVVR 3XQW SH SXQW
9HWWRU &DPS# (OHWWULF#, WDQJHQW DOO OLQ+ G )RU]D 3HUWDQW O /LQ-
G
)RU] ULVXOWHUDQQ GLYHUJHQW
GDOO FDULFK SRVLWLY.. PHUJHQW
GDOO FDULFKH QHJDWLYH / 021 T U ) U (