/HFLQTXHLQQRYD]LRQLULFKLDPDWHSUH¿JXUDQR±DOPHQRVXOODFDUWD±OD liberalizzazione di un settore a lungo rigidamente governato e al riparo dagli ³HQ]LPLGHOODFRQFRUUHQ]D´3XUWXWWDYLDLO³'HFUHWR%HUVDQL´FRQWLHQHDOFX- ne ambiguità, che sono state sfruttate dalle Regioni per limitarne la spinta ULIRUPDWULFH6HF¶qXQ¶HQIDVLVXOODOLEHUWjG¶LPSUHVDHODFRQFRUUHQ]DF¶qDQ- FKHXQIRUWHULFKLDPRDOODQHFHVVLWjGLJDUDQWLUHXQ¶HTXLOLEUDWDVWUXWWXUDGHO- ODUHWHGLVWULEXWLYDHDOO¶LPSRUWDQ]DGHOFRPPHUFLRGLYLFLQDWRVSHFLHQHOOH DUHHSHULIHULFKHHGHEROL3URSULRULFKLDPDQGRVLDTXHVWLXOWLPLDVSHWWLPROWH 5HJLRQLQHOO¶DWWXD]LRQHGHOOHQRUPHVWDWDOLKDQQRUHLQWURGRWWRYLQFROLDOOR VYLOXSSRGHOOHJUDQGLVWUXWWXUHGLYHQGLWD HVSHVVRDQFKHGLTXHOOHPHGLH FRQWUDULDOO¶LPSXOVROLEHULVWDGHO³'HFUHWR%HUVDQL´+DSHVDWRPROWRODVXD natura di provvedimento-delega, che ha lasciato troppa discrezionalità alle 5HJLRQL 5DYD]]RQL /HVSLQWHFRQWURULIRUPLVWHVLVRQRPDQLIHVWDWH JLjQHOODSULPDIDVHGLDSSOLFD]LRQHGHO'HFUHWRIUD H/H5HJLRQL KDQQROHJLIHUDWRLQULWDUGR &ULVWLQL HFLzKDFRPSRUWDWRXQEORFFR
delle autorizzazioni per grandi strutture di vendita superiore al limite di un DQQRSUHYLVWRGDOOHQRUPHQD]LRQDOL3HUGLSLVLqIDWWRDPSLRULFRUVRD una programmazione quantitativa – FRQWLQJHQWLVXOQXPHURGLVWUXWWXUHHROH VXSHU¿FLDXWRUL]]DELOL±FKHKDOLPLWDWRO¶HVSDQVLRQHGHOJUDQGHFRPPHUFLR proteggendo gli incumbents6RORWUH5HJLRQLLQTXHOODIDVHKDQQRDGRWWD- to una programmazione qualitativa che non tradisce gli sforzi riformatori GHOOHQRUPHVWDWDOL 3LHPRQWH(PLOLD5RPDJQDH0DUFKH 1HOFRPSOHVVR JOLVWXGLKDQQRHYLGHQ]LDWRFRPHQHOODSULPDIDVHSRVW%HUVDQLOH5HJLRQL GHO6XGDEELDQRSLRVWDFRODWRODOLEHUDOL]]D]LRQHDYDQWDJJLRGHOOHSLFFROH LPSUHVHJLjEHQSUHVHQWL )HUUXFFLH3RUFKHGGXDE ංඌൺൾ 1HOFRQODULIRUPDGHOWLWROR9GHOOD&RVWLWX]LRQHVLqDSHUWDXQDIDVH QXRYD DOOH5HJLRQLYLHQHDWWULEXLWDFRPSHWHQ]Desclusiva in materia di com- PHUFLRPHQWUHVSHWWDDOOR6WDWRTXHOODVXOODWXWHODGHOODFRQFRUUHQ]D0ROWH 5HJLRQLQHKDQQRDSSUR¿WWDWRSHUXQDVWUHWWDGHOOHQRUPHVXOFRPPHUFLRFRQ un ampio ricorso a vincoli quantitativi allo sviluppo delle grandi strutture di YHQGLWD DQWLFRVWLWX]LRQDOLSHUO¶$QWLVWUXVW 'RSRLOLWHQWDWLYLGLcontro-
riformaDO³'HFUHWR%HUVDQL´VLVRQRUD൵RU]DWL 9HQWXUD 6RQRGLYHQWDWL
SLHQDPHQWHHYLGHQWLRSSRUWXQLWjHULVFKLGHO³IHGHUDOLVPRFRPPHUFLDOH´,OUL- spetto delle autonomie locali, la dialettica fra Stato e Regioni, la possibilità di legiferare a misura della propria storia e dei peculiari assetti insediativi regio- QDOLVRQRWXWWLDVSHWWLSRVLWLYLGHO³IHGHUDOLVPRFRPPHUFLDOH´0DF¶qDQFKH XQ¶DOWUDIDFFLDGHOODPHGDJOLD ODYXOQHUDELOLWjDLQWHUHVVLGLSDUWHODGL൶FROWj a mantenere salda la rotta della concorrenza nel commercio e la crescente dif- ferenziazione delle norme a scala regionale, che crea disparità di trattamento IUDLPSUHVHHFRQVXPDWRUL 9DUDOGR &ULVWLQL /XJOL *UHJRUL H0DULRWWL 9HQWXUD *UHJRUL
1HODIURQWHGHLWHQWDWLYLGLFRQWURULIRUPDGDSDUWHGHOOH5HJLRQLLO *RYHUQRqLQWHUYHQXWRQXRYDPHQWHQHOODGLVFLSOLQDGHOFRPPHUFLRDSSHOODQ- dosi al rispetto del principio della tutela della concorrenza, basilare anche in VHGHHXURSHD&RQLOGHFUHWROHJJH³%HUVDQL&LFDWUDOj´ '/FRQY / FDGHO¶REEOLJRGHLUHJLVWULDELOLWDQWLHGHOSRVVHVVRGLUHTXLVLWL SURIHVVLRQDOL VSHFL¿FL9HQJRQR HOLPLQDWH OH distanze minime fra attività
FRPPHUFLDOLGHOODPHGHVLPDWLSRORJLD±EDUULHUDDOO¶HQWUDWDFKHSHUPHWWHYD GL VIUXWWDUH UHQGLWH GL SRVL]LRQH ± QRQFKp L OLPLWL TXDQWLWDWLYL DJOL DVVRUWL- PHQWL'LYHQWDSRVVLELOHFRQVXPDUHSURGRWWLJDVWURQRPLFLSUHVVRJOLHVHUFL]L GL YHQGLWD 0D VRSUDWWXWWR VL ULEDGLVFH FRPH OH DWWLYLWj FRPPHUFLDOL QRQ SRVVDQRHVVHUHVXERUGLQDWHDOLPLWLULIHULWLD©TXRWHGLPHUFDWRSUHGH¿QLWHR FDOFRODWHVXOYROXPHGHOOHYHQGLWHDOLYHOORWHUULWRULDOHVXEUHJLRQDOHª DUW FRPPDOHWWHUDG GHOOD/ 9HQJRQRFRVuHVFOXVLLFRQWLQJHQWLGL VXSHU¿FLHLQWURGRWWLGDPROWH5HJLRQLDOORVFRSRGLOLPLWDUHO¶DYDQ]DWDGHOOH JUDQGLVWUXWWXUHGLYHQGLWDULWHQXWLGDOO¶$QWLVWUXVWOHVLYLGHOODFRQFRUUHQ]D )DWWRVDOYRTXHOOLULJXDUGDQWLLOVHWWRUHDOLPHQWDUHHGHOODVRPPLQLVWUD]LRQHGLDOLPHQWL HEHYDQGH
/HULWURVLHGHOOH5HJLRQLQHOO¶DSSOLFDUHOHQXRYHQRUPHUHVWDQRIRUWL6H si abbandonano i contingenti, vengono introdotti vincoli indiretti, che co- PXQTXHOLPLWDQRODFRQFRUUHQ]D$QFRUDXQDYROWDFLVLULFKLDPDDOO¶HTXLOL- brato rapporto fra diverse tipologie di vendita, obiettivo presente nelle norme GHO , YLQFROL GLYHQWDQR TXDOLWDWLYL PHQR HVSOLFLWL SDUDPHWUL]]DWL LQ EDVHDFRH൶FLHQWLGLLQFUHPHQWRGHOOHVXSHU¿FLGHJOLHVHUFL]LGLYLFLQDWRH GHLWHUULWRULXUEDQL]]DWL6LLQWURGXFRQRVSHVVRGLYLHWLDOO¶DSHUWXUDGLJUDQGL VWUXWWXUHGLYHQGLWDLQFHQWULDELWDWLDOGLVRWWRGLXQDFHUWDWDJOLDGHPRJUD¿FD e si facilitano le aggregazioni di strutture già attive nel mercato, misura che favorisce gli incumbents 9LYLDQR
1HOODIDVHSLUHFHQWHGRSRLOLO*RYHUQRqLQWHUYHQXWRQXRYDPHQWH SHUULEDGLUHLOSULQFLSLREDVLODUHGHOODFRQFRUUHQ]DQHOVHWWRUHFRPPHUFLDOH 8QSULPRSDVVDJJLRFKLDYHVLqDYXWRFRQLO'/JV FKHUHFHSLVFH OD³'LUHWWLYD%RONHVWHLQ´ ർൾ YROWDDVHPSOL¿FDUHOHQRUPHHOH SURFHGXUH SHU O¶DFFHVVR DO PHUFDWR H OR VYROJLPHQWR GHOOH DWWLYLWj HFRQR- PLFKH,QSDUWLFRODUHSHUO¶DSHUWXUDGHJOLHVHUFL]LGLYLFLQDWRVLSUHYHGHOD 'LFKLDUD]LRQHG¶LQL]LRDWWLYLWj ൽංൺ FRQH൶FDFLDLPPHGLDWD. Si ribadisce, LQROWUHFRPHOHQRUPHFKHOLPLWLQRO¶DFFHVVRHO¶HVHUFL]LRGHOOHDWWLYLWjGHE- EDQRHVVHUHQRQGLVFULPLQDWRULHJLXVWL¿FDWHHFRPPLVXUDWHDXQRELHWWLYR GLLQWHUHVVHSXEEOLFR LQDJJLXQWDVLD൵HUPDFKHQHVVXQDDXWRUL]]D]LRQHSXz HVVHUHVXERUGLQDWDDOODGLPRVWUD]LRQH©GHOO¶HVLVWHQ]DGLXQELVRJQRHFRQR- PLFRRGLXQDGRPDQGDGLPHUFDWRRDOODYDOXWD]LRQHGHJOLH൵HWWLHFRQRPLFL SRWHQ]LDOLRH൵HWWLYLGHOO¶DWWLYLWj RDOODYDOXWD]LRQHGHOO¶DGHJXDWH]]DGHOO¶DW- WLYLWjULVSHWWRDJOLRELHWWLYLGLSURJUDPPD]LRQHHFRQRPLFDVWDELOLWLª DUW FRPPDOHWWHUDH GHO'/JV 8Q¶XOWHULRUHVSLQWDQHOODVWHVVDGLUH]LRQHqGDWDGDO³'HFUHWR6DOYD,WDOLD´ '/FRQY/ FKHROWUHDOLEHUDOL]]DUHJOLRUDULGLYHQ- dita per tutti gli esercizi commerciali, ha stabilito il principio della libertà di apertura di nuove strutture «senza contingenti, limiti territoriali o altri vincoli di qualsiasi altra natura, esclusi quelli connessi alla tutela della salute, dei ODYRUDWRULGHOO¶DPELHQWHLYLLQFOXVRO¶DPELHQWHXUEDQRHGHLEHQLFXOWXUDOLª DUWFRPPDGHOOD/ $TXHVWRSXQWRODOLEHUDOL]]D]LRQHQRQGRYUHEEHDYHUHSLRVWDFROL 3HO- OHJULQLH=DQGHULJKL ,QUHDOWjQRQVDSSLDPRFRPHWXWWRFLzVLDVWDWR H൵HWWLYDPHQWHDFFROWRLQVHGHUHJLRQDOH*OLDWWHJJLDPHQWLDQWLFRQFRUUHQ]LD- OLVHUSHJJLDQR,FRQWLQJHQWLHDOWULYLQFROLTXDQWLWDWLYLVRQRFKLDULPHQWUH TXHOOLTXDOLWDWLYLLQWURGRWWLGDOOH5HJLRQLQHOODIDVHUHFHQWHVRQRSLRSDFKL VRWWLOL (VVL ODYRUDQR VXO FRQ¿QH ODELOH IUD XQD UHJROD]LRQH FKH SHUVHJXH H൵HWWLYDPHQWH LQWHUHVVL SXEEOLFL H XQD UHJROD]LRQH FKH PLUD D FRQWUROODUH JOLHTXLOLEULIUDLPSUHVHRVWDFRODQGRLOSLHQRGLVSLHJDUVLGHOODFRQFRUUHQ]D
9LHQHPHQRO¶REEOLJRGHOODFRPXQLFD]LRQHGHOO¶DSHUWXUDHGHOVLOHQ]LRDVVHQVRGL
Tab. 1 – Indice ਏਃਓਅ del livello di regolamentazione nel settore distributivo in alcuni paesi europei, 1998 e 2013I
I2JQLLQGLFHSXzYDULDUHWUDXQPLQLPRGL DVVHQ]DGLUHJRODPHQWD]LRQH HXQPDVVLPRGL
PDVVLPDUHJRODPHQWD]LRQH II somma ponderata dei singoli indici parziali
Fonte HODERUD]LRQLVXGDWLඈർඌൾ
0HQWUH O¶LQGLFH GL UHJROD]LRQH HODERUDWR GDOO¶ඈർඌൾ JXDUGDQGR DOO¶HYR- luzione delle norme nazionali, registra la progressiva liberalizzazione del FRPPHUFLRLWDOLDQR WDE LOTXDGURQRUPDWLYRDOLYHOORUHJLRQDOHqDO-
TXDQWR YDULHJDWR 9LYLDQR KD FRQVLGHUDWR O¶HYROX]LRQH GHL YLQFROL DOO¶DSHUWXUDHGLTXHOOLJHVWLRQDOLLQWURGRWWLDVFDODUHJLRQDOHIUDH 5LVDOWDXQ¶LQL]LDOHDOWDHWHURJHQHLWjGHOOHQRUPHFRQPROWH5HJLRQLORQWDQH GDOORVSLULWRGHO³'HFUHWR%HUVDQL´ QHOWHPSRODYDULHWjVLDWWHQXDPDSXU VHPSUHVRQRQXPHURVHOH5HJLRQLFRQQRUPHSRFRFRQFRUUHQ]LDOL6XWXWWR FLzSHVDQRQRQVRORLQWHUHVVLLQWHUQLDOVHWWRUHFRPPHUFLDOHPDDQFKHVSLQWH FRQVHUYDWULFLSURYHQLHQWLGDOPRQGRLQGXVWULDOH 9LYLDQR
/D YLFHQGD GHOOD FRQWUDVWDWD OLEHUDOL]]D]LRQH GHO FRPPHUFLR LQ ,WDOLD GRSRLO UHQGHFKLDURLOSUREOHPDGHOFRQÀLWWRIUDVFDOHGHOODUHJROD]LR- QHJLjGLVFXVVRQHOFDSLWRORSUHFHGHQWHÊXQDV¿GDDOOLQHDUHLGLYHUVLOLYHOOL GLJRYHUQRDOSULQFLSLRGHOODWXWHODGHOODFRQFRUUHQ]D 3DPPROOLet al 0ROWH5HJLRQLODSHQVDQRGLYHUVDPHQWHGDOOR6WDWRHPROWHDPPLQLVWUD]LRQL FRPXQDOLDORURYROWDKDQQRSRVL]LRQLQRQFRQFRUGLFRQTXHOOHUHJLRQDOL $OGLOjGLWXWWRFLzOD¿JPRVWUDO¶H൵HWWRGLOXQJRSHULRGRGHOODOLEH- UDOL]]D]LRQH$VFDODQD]LRQDOHIUD HVLqUHJLVWUDWRXQVHQVLEL- OH DXPHQWR GHOO¶RFFXSD]LRQH PHQWUH OH LPSUHVH VRQR GLPLQXLWH LQGXFHQGRXQDPDJJLRUFRQFHQWUD]LRQHGHOPHUFDWR
Paesi Anno Indice Permessi Regole Protezione Orari di Controllo Promozioni/ totaleII avvio grandi sup. imprese vendita prezzi discounts
attività di vendita esistenti
Italia *HUPDQLD )UDQFLD Spagna « 5HJQR8QLWR « $FRQIURQWRFRQLSULQFLSDOLSDHVLHXURSHLO¶,WDOLDKDFRPXQTXHLOUHJLPHSLYLQFROLVWLFR
Fig. 1 – Trend imprese e addetti nel commercio al dettaglio in Italia, 1998-2015 (indici 1998 = 100) Fonte HODERUD]LRQLVXGDWLංඌඍൺඍ Imprese Addetti 9DULOHYDWRFRPHPLQRULEDUULHUHDOO¶HQWUDWDQHLPHUFDWLDEELDQRDYXWR LQL]LDOPHQWHXQH൵HWWRSRVLWLYRVXOOHLPSUHVHFKH¿QRDO±QHOFRP- PHUFLRVSHFLDOL]]DWR¿QRDO±VRQRDXPHQWDWH,Otrend poi si inverte, PDVRORGRSRLO LOFDORGLYHQWDVLJQL¿FDWLYR